A. Shekhar Babu v. Mr. M. Prem Kumar
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 27 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice C.V. Bhaskar Reddy
- Case number
- CC No. 2584 of 2023
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
- Subject
- Civil
Full judgment
[ 32e6 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD TUESDAY, THE TWENry SEVENTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE C,V. BHASKAR REDDY CONTEMPT CASE NO: 2584OF 2023 Contempt Case filed under Sections 10 to 12 of Contempt of Courts Act, 1971
to punish the respondents for wilfully, intentionally, deliberately, disobeying and
violating the Orders of the High Court dated 09.11.2023 passed in W.p.No.31 181 of 2023.
Between:
1. A. Shekhar Babu, S/o A. Murli Krishna Aged About 47 yearc, Occ: Business Rl/o Flat No.401, Lotus Abhaya, Plot No.548. Phase Vl KPHB Colony, Kukatpally, Hyderabad
2. A. Ravindra Babu, S/o A. Murli Krishna Aged About 49 years, Occ: Business Rl/o Lotus Enclave, Plot No.614 and 615, Phase Vl, KpHB Colony, Kukatpally,
Hyderabad
3. A Vishwa Murthy, S/o Late A. Ramadas Aged about 68 years, Occ: Service R:/o Plot No.680, Vivekananda Nagar Colony, Kukatpally, Hyderabad
4. A. Mohan Rao, S/o Late A. Ramdas Aged about 66 years, Occ: Service Rl/o Flat No.S-1 , Plot No.582, Vivekananda Nagar Colony, Kukatpally, Hyderabad
5. M. Appa Rao, S/o M. Venkataratnam aged about 62 years, Occ: Business R/o Flat No.201, Lotus Aditya, PIot No.538 and 544, Kukatpally, Hyderabad 6. Smt. M Seeta Devi, W/o M. Uma Maheswara Rao Aged about 59 years, Occ: Business R/o Flat No.401, Lotus Aitya Plot Nos.538 and 544 phase lV, KpHB Colony, Kukatpally, Hyderabad 7. M.N. Venkateshwara Rao, S/o M. Subba Rao Aged 57 years Occ: Business Rl/o Flat No.302, Shanti Apartments, Bhagya Nagar Colony, Kukatpally, Hyderabad 8. B. Parameswra Rao, S/o B. Krishna Rao Aged about 57 years, Occ: Business Rl/o Plot No.454, Vivekananda Nagar Colony, Kukatpally, Hyderabad
...Appellant AND Mr. M. Prem Kumar, Circle lnspector of Police, Miyapur Police Station, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State
...Respondent
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI M A K MUKHEED Counsel forthe Respondent: SRI MOHD. IMRAN KHAN, ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT ITYDERABAD THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.BHASKAR REDDY CONTEMPT CASE No.2584 of 2o23 (CNR No.HBH cOLos95222O23l
DATE:27.LO.2O26
Pronounced orr: 27.10.2026
Reserved on: L9.08.2026
Uploaded o* 27.LO.2O26 Between: A.Shekhar Babu and Scven others Petitioners AND
Mr M.Prem Kumar Circ:lc Inspector of Po[ce, Miyapur Policc Station, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana ...Respondent/ Contemnor ORDER
This Contempt Case is {iled by Lhe petitioner under Sections 10 to
I2 of tht: Corltelnpt of Courts Act, 1971 {for short, "the Aot, 197i"), alleging willful and deliberate disobedrence of the order dated 09.11.2023 passed by thls Court in W.P.No.31187 of 2023.
2.
Irr W.P.No.3118l of 2023, this Court passed the following interirn
order on 09.I1.2023
"
Notice before admission
Learned Assstant Couerntnent I'Leader Jor Hotne takes nottce fc:r respondent Nos. L to 4 and seeks time to get inslructtons.
Leat-ned counsel for the petitioners is permitted to take out personal notice ta respol.tdeat rvos.s to 7 bll Registered Post utth Ackruoutledgment Due and rtle prooJ of seruice before the nexl date of listing'
'l'l'e clse oJ the pe'tittoners is that theg are absolute o1t)ners and possessors of Gokul Plot Nos 62' 63,73 and 74 altogether 7O0 square aards in S!1.No.73 Paft situated at Hdfeezpet Village, Seilingampallg Mandal' sale
Ranga Recid/ D$trict, hautt"Lg purchase'| the' same through reEisteted deed beaing dacument No.1g19 of 2OO9' dated 13 03.2009 It is the further propertA'
case oJ the petlltoners tlLat when the dtsputes arose ouer the sclid the ftLe thel) were constrarnecl to tnstitute a suiL uide O S rVo' 1285 of 20A9 on
cohtest' the of the VIII Aclditional Senior Ciuil Judge, Ranga Reddy and aftPr has said. suit u,as decreed ln favour oJ the petitioners and the said nrdgment
as on r,ot been suspended blJ qna apPellate Court and the same is tr' force case of the petitiorlers that uhen respondent Nos 5 ta todclA. It is the
further
7 are rnterfenng uith thetr peqceJut possesslon euen after a decree' theg .,1)ere cansrratnecl to J'ile W.P.N}.17228 of 2A19 Qnd thts Court hd"s granted tntenm ord.ers Ln IA.No.1 of 2019' 'ditecting respandent Na'lthe' Statton House Officer, MtAapur Potice Stdtion to provide police aid to the
petitioners
agclinst reqtondent Nos.s to 7 and their henchmen for implementation of qieultlce pennanent tnJunction order grantecl in O'S'No 1285 of 20A9'' The oJ the pet..trcners is that euen after recetpt of the orders of this Court in
W.P.No.172),8 of 2A19, respontlent No4 tn actiue conntuance luth respondent Nos.5 to 7, is making efforts,o dispossess them frotn the subiect properlA, LDhich action on the pdrt of respondent No'4 not onlll amounts to uiotation oj the Court order anci also qmounts to intetference o'f edminrstrat:'on a,f Justice
.
h'r tht: saLd ci.rcumstances' respondent No 4 the StQtion House Offcer, Miyapur Paltce Sta,tion, Ranga Reddy Distict, shall appear before this Coutt on the next date of heanng and explain the reosons for not prouiding th'e police atd to the petitioners ds per the directions issued bu this 19. Courl in I. A No. i of 2019 in W.P.No' 17228 of 2019' dated 20 06 '2A L.$t at'L 07.12.2023. "
3.
Mr.M.A.K. Mukheed, learned counsel appearing for the petrtioners
submitted that the petitioners are the absolute owners and possessors of Gokul Plot Nos.62, 63,73 and 74, admeasuring a total extent of 700
square yards in Sy.No.78 (part), situated at Hafeezpet Village, Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, having purchased the same under registered sale deed bearrng Document No 1919 of 2009,
dated 13.03.2009. He submitted that the peLitioners instituted O.S-No.1285 of 2OO9 and obtained a decree of permanent injunctron on
21,10.2013, which was aflirmed in A.S.No.322 of 2013, uide judgment d,ated. 24 .06.2019. He further submitted that the application seeking
suspension of the decree il S.A.No.348 of 2079 was dismissed by this
Court on 03.l2.2olg. Learled counsel further submitted that, despite
the decrce of permanent injunction, I) Snnivas Rao and others continued to interfere with the petitioners' peaceful possession and enjoyment of the subject property, compelling them to approach this
Court by filing W.P.No. 17228 of 2019. This Court, uide order dated
2}.o8.2olg in LA.No.1 of 2019, directed the Station House Officer, Miyapur Police Station, to provide police aid for implementation of the decree of permanent injunction. However, the police authorities failed to
provide cfft:ctive assistance in tcrlns of thc said order and, lnstead, allegedly facilitated the interference of D. Srinivas Rao and others with
the subject property. Learned counsel also submitted that when the petitioners lodged a complaint on O7 1 1.2023 regarding the continued
construction acti\'1t]- over the subject property, the respondent failed to
take effective action, compelling the petitioners to institute W.P.No.31181 of 2023. This Court, uide order dated 09.11.2023, dirccted the Statron IIor.rsr: Officcr, Miyapur Policc Statron, to appcar
and explain the reasons for not providing pohce aid in terms of the
earlier order dated 20.O8.2O19. It is further sr-lbmitted that notwithstandinq thr: aforesatd orders and the notir;e dated 13.11.2023 issued to the rt'spontlcnt. the respon(lent failed ro take e[:cctive stcps to
protect the petitioncrs' property and permitted the construction activity of D. Srinivas Rao and others to continue. karned counsel contended
that the conduct of the respondent demonstrates wilful and delibt:rate disobedrence o[ the orders of this Court and interference with the
administration of justice. He, therefore, prayed that the rcspondent be held guilty of contempt and punished in accordance wrth law.
4.
Per contra. Sri Mohd. Imran Khan, Iearned Additronal Advocatc
General appearlng for the respondent, relying upon thc counter-affidavit
filed by the respondent, submitted that the allegations mzrde against the
respondent arc farlse and that thcrt: is no urlful disobedience of the orders of this Court. It rs further submitted that the respondent was noL
the Station House Oflicer of Miyapur Police Statron when the order
dated 20.O8.2079 was passed rn W.P.No.l7228 o[ 2019. Sri S.Venkatcsh workccl as thc: Station I-louse Officer from 10.09.2018 to
06.72.2O21, lollowed by Sri N. Trrupathr Rao from t)6.12.2O21 to
26 .06.2023 , whereas the respondent assumed charge on I3.O7 .2023.
Therefore, ttre respondent had no prior knowledge of the earlier order
directing provision of police aid. It is further submitted that the respondent neither extended police assistance to D. Snnivas Rao and
others nor encouraged them to interfere with the petitloners' possession. Upon physrcai verihcation of the subject property, the respondent noticed that there was no room or compound wall on the
Iand and that the property was covered with blue-coloured galvanised sheets. It is further submitted that when the petitioners approached the
respondent on 07.11.2023 and brought the earlier order to his notice,
the respondent was occupied with election duty. However, on 09.1I.2023. the respondent visited thc subject propcrty along with hrs
staff and the petitioners, noticed that construction activitl was irr progress and instructed the persons present at the site to stop the
work. He further submitted that the respondent appeared before this Court on 07.12.2023 in connection with W.P.No.31181 of )O23 and erplained the circumstances relating to the dispute. It is contended that the respondent had not encouraged or assisted the alleged construction
activity and that the allegations of wilful disobedience were unfounded. He also submitted that the respondent had tendered an uncondi.tional
apolory to this Court for any inadvertent failure on his part to comply
with its direclions, while reiterating that he had no intention to disobey
the orders of thrs Court. 1Ie, therefore, requested thls Court to accept the unconditional apologr and close the Contempt Case'
5.
Having considered the rival snLrmissions and perused the
material on recorcl, the question that arises for consideration is
whether
the respondent has wiifully and deliberately disobeyed the orders
o1 this
Court so as to attract the provisions of the Act, 797I and' if so' whether the unconditional apologr tendered by him deserves to be accepted'
6.Thematcria]onrecorddisclosesthatthepetitionerspulchased the subject property under registered sale deed bearing Document No.1919 of 2009, dated 13.03 2OO9 They instituted a suit uide o.S.No'l2S5ot2oogandobtainedadecreeofpermanentrnjunctionon 21.1,O.2O73. The said decree was af{irmed in A S No 322
of 2013' which
was dismissed on 24.06.2019. The applicatron hled seeking suspension
ofthedccreeinS.A.No.348of2oTgwasdismissedbythisCourton 03.12.2O7(). Thereafter, rt'hen the petltioners complained
of interfercnce
u'ith their possession, this Court, uide order dated 20'08 2019 in I.A.No.1 of 2079 in W.P.No 17228 of 2O!9, drrected the Station
House
Ofhcer, Miyapur Police Statlon, to provrde police aid for lmplementation
of the d er:ree ol permanent rnjunction' The petitioners subsequently approached this Court in W P No 31 1 81 of 2023, alleging that
the police
authorities had failed to provide the required assistance despite their complaint dated 07 112023 Upon considering the grievance raised
by
the petitioners, tJlis Court, uide order dated 09.11.2023, specifrcally directed the Station House Ofhcer, Miyapur police Station, to appear
and explain the reasons for not providing police aid in terms of the earlier order dated 20.08.2019. The direction was j.ssued after taking
note of the history of the dispute and the petitioners, grievance regarding the alleged failure of the police authorities to protect their possession. The respondent, in his counter-afhdavrt dated 04.O3.2024.
admitted that tl:e petiLioners approached him on OT .17.2023 and informed him about the order dated 20.08.2019. He sought to explain
his failure to provide immediate assistance by stating that he was occupied with electlon duty on that day. He further stated thar he
visited the subject property along with his staff and the petitioners on 09.11.2023 and instructed the persons present at the site to stop the
construction activity. The respondent also stated that he had no knowledge of the earlier order until rt was brought t.o hts notice by the
petitioners. However, the absence of prror knowledge of an order cannot
justify inaction after the order has been brought to the notice of the officer concerned. Once the respondent was inforrned of the subsrsting
direction for providing police aid, it was incumbent upon him to examine the order and take appropriate steps in accordance wilh 1aw to
ensure its implementation. The respondent's own counter-afhdavit establi.shes that he was aware of the earlier order on 07 .11 .2023. The
subsequent direcLion issued by this Court on 09.11.2023 also required.
him to explain the failure to provide police explanation that hc visrted the properry
aid The respondent's
and stopped the construction
in the light of the nature of the mere the material placed before this court A
activiry is requued to be considered
earlier direction and
assertion of har,rng visited the site
would not establish compliance with
a <lirection lo provide effective police aid for subsisLing decree of permanent injunction
implementatron of a
The pelitioners on the other
hand, consistentlY comPlained of conlinued
interference with their
authorities to provide effective possession and failure of the police issued to the respondent also protection . The nolice dated 13 112023 to seek implementation of the indicates that the petitioners continued orders of this Court' The respondent's assessed noL nrerelv on the trasis
explanation must' therefore' be
of his assertion that he visited the
property, but aiso with reference to whether to implement the directions brought
7.
effective steps were taken
to his notice'
In the circumstances, the respondent cannot
merely by referring to the pendency
avoid responsibility
of rhe second appea} or by asserting
continued for several years' that the dispute between the parties had Court does not The pendency of proceedings before a competent
authoriseapoliceoftlcertorlisregardasubsistingjurlicialdirection.The orders in Ibrce required to act in accordance with the respondent was
and could noL substltute his own assessment of directions issued b5' this court
the dispute for the
8.
It is well settled that the jurisdiction of this Court under the
Contempt of Courts Act, 7921 , is intended to uphold the
majesty of law
and ensure compliance with the orders passed by this Court.
A public
ofhcer, entrusted with tie responsibility of implementing judicial directions, is under an obligation to ensure t1 at such
directions are
complied with in letter and spirit. Any delitrerate failure
such oLrligation undermines the authority of the court
to discharge
and interferes
with the administration of justrce. In the present case, the petitioners obtained a decree of permalent injunction in O.S.No.12g5
of 2009,
which was afhrmed in A.S.No.322 of 2013. The application suspension of the decree in S.A.No.34g of 2079 was
seeking
dismissed by this
Court on 03 -l2.2olg . Thereafter, this Court, utd.e ord,er 20.OA.2Ol9 in i.A.No.I of 2Ol9 in W.p.No. 172 28 ot
d.ated.
2019, directed the
Station I{ouse Officer, Miyapur police StaLion, lo provrde police implementation of the decree of permanent injunclion.
aid for
Despite the
subsistence of the said order, the petitioners were constralned
approach this Court once again by filing W.p.No.311g1 complaining of continued interference with their possesslon of the police authorities to provide effective assistance.
to
of 2023,
and failure
This Court, upon
considering the circumstances ancl the history of the
dispute, passed
order dated 09.1I.2023, directing the Statjon House
Olficer, Miyapur
Police Station, to appear before this court and
exprarn the reasons for
failure to provide police aid in terms of the earlier
order. The
respondent, who had assumed charge on l3'O7 2023' aclmitted in his counter-affid.avit that the petiLioners brought the earlier order to his
notice on 07.71.2023. Thus, from the date on which the order was
broughttohisnotice,therespondentwasfullyawareofthesubsisting judicial direction and was required to take effectrve steps to ensure its implementation. The explanation offered by the respondent that he was occupied wrth election duty on 07 .L7.2023 and subsequently vrsited the
subject propert-v on 09.11.2023 does not absolve him of his obligation
to comply with the orders of this Court I Iis conduct has to be considered in the context of the contlnuing grievance of the petitioners'
the subsistrng decree of permanent injunction and the spectfic directions issued by this Court. The respondent, being a responsiLrle police officer, was expecled to act promptly and effectively to ensure compliance with rhe judicial directions and to prevent interference with the peLitioners' Possession.
g.
Upon careful consideration of the materiai on record, the
submissions of learned. counsel and t1.e explanation offered by the respondent, this Court holds that the respondent has wi1fu11y and deliberately disobeyed the orders of this Court, thereby commltting civil contempt under the Act, 1971
.
10. Though the responclent has tendered an unconditional apolory' having regard to his conduct, failure to provrde effecttve police aid
despite the directions of this Court and the repeated approaches mad.e
by the petiLioners, tllis Court is not inclined to accept the apologz. As a
police ofhcer, the respondent was duty-bound to ensure compliance
with the orders of this Court, and his wilful disobedience warrants appropriate punishment to uphold the authority ofjudicial orders.
1.
Having regard to the nature and gravit-v of the disobedience and
the circumstances of the case, this Court is of the considered view t].at
a sentence of srmple imprisonment coupled wrth a fine would meet the ends ofjustice.
).2. In tJle result, this Contempt Case is allowed. The respondent is found guilty of civil contempt and is sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of four (04) weeks ancl to pay a hne of Rs.2,000/- (Rupees Two Thousand only). In defauit of pa1ment of fine, he shal1 undergo simple imprisonment for a further period of two (02) weeks. Having regard to the remedy available under Section 19 of the
Act, 1971, the sentence imposed upon the rcsportdr:nt shall remai.n suspended for a period of two (02) weeks from the date of this order.
Upon expiry of the said period, if no order suspending the sentence is
obtained from the competent Court, the respondent shall surrender before the Ilegistrar (Judicial-I) of this Court to unclergo the senrence imposed upon him. In tlre event of his failure Lo surrender, the Registrar
(Judicial-l) shall take steps in accord'ance with law to give effect to the sentence,
As a sequel. miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand closed
SD/. N. SRIHARI DEPUW REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY//
,ueSEGTION OFFTCER
To,
1. One CC to Sri tr4 A K Mukheed, Advocate IOPUCI the State of Telangana at 2, Two CCs to Advocate C"n"r.it, High Court for Hyderabad [OUTI 3. Two CD CoPies
ABK/GNK
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2711012026
9 STAre: oA
k
q
ORDER
o
iJ
CC.No.2584 ol 2023
2 $ ocl 2026 .:
* o {s
ALLOWING THE CONTEMPT CASE
n
\ [o
pa
.:()