Abdul Rehman Antulay v. Union of India and ORS. ETC.

Court
Supreme Court of India
Date of judgment
17 April 1984
Judge
Justice D.A. Desai
Neutral citation
1984 INSC 85
Reported in
[1984] 3 S.C.R. 482
Result
Dismissed
Advocates
Writ Petition, Mtirli Bhandare, Govindtfas, Ms-. Bina Gupta, Bhardwaj, Singh, Ashok Desai, Amare'wra Nath Sen, H.S.K

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

•

'·

A

AjlDUL REHMAN ANTULAY

v.

'

UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. ETC.

B

'

,.. . .,., .A..

[AMARENDRA NATH SEN AND D.A. DESAI, JJ.] .

April 17, 1984 .·

~

#

.

·constitution ·of India Ari. 1'41--i>uty of all courts to follow d~cision of the Supreme Court;

c

S~preme Court Rufes-Whether Supreme Court cafl. entertain writ petition

aiafnst its own .ofder anti i;tdgmfnt.

·

.

ORJGIN,l.L & CRIMINAL APPELLATE . JURISDICTION : Writ Petition (Cr!) No. 708 of !934. ·

D

'(Under Article· 32 of the Constitution of India) And Spe~ial Leave Petitiob (Cr!) Nos. 1949·50 of 1984

E

(From the Judgment and Order dated 13.3.84 and 16,3.84 of the Bombay High Court in Speciat'Case Nos. 24/82 & 3/83)

Mtirli Bhandare;Govindtfas, Ms-. Bina Gupta, H.R: Bhardwaj and ·

PP. Singh for the petitioner.

'

R.am Jethma/ani, Ashok Desai and Ms. Rani Jethmalani for • the _respondents. The Order, 'of the Court was delivered by

G

H

AMARE'WRA NATH SEN, J. There· is' no merit in this Writ Petition. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. , In inY view, the writ petition challenging the validity of the order and judgment passed by this Court ·as nullity or otherwise incorrect ·cannot be entertained. "t wish to make it cleat that the ·dismissal of this writ petition will not prejudice the right of the petitioner, to approach the Court with an appropriate review petition or to file any other application which be may be entitle<! in law to file. .

.

,.,_

•

A.R. ANT1JLAY v. UNION (Desai, J.) DESAI, J.

I broadly agree with the. conclusion recorded by

A

my br9ther.

' ')r

'"

The learned Judge in deciding the S.L.P (Crl) Nos. 1149-50/ 1984 has followed the decision of this Court: The learned Judge · was perfectly justified and indeed it was the duty of th.e learned Judge to follow the decision of this Court ·which is binding on · him.·

B

Special 'leave petitions are dismissed.

Petitions dismissed. •

H.S.K.

•

• •

. {

c

Related judgments

More Supreme Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.