Additional Chief Excise and Taxation v. Mohinder Singh
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
- Date of judgment
- 6 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Ranjan Sharma
- Case number
- COPC No. 77 of 2026
- Result
- Disposed Off
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA COPC No. 77 of 2026 In CWP No. 17952 of 2025 Decided on:06.10.2026.
________________________________________________________
Devesh Kumar & Others
...Petitioners
Versus Mohinder Singh
...Respondent
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge 1Whether approved for reporting?
For the petitioners:
Mr. Varun Chandel, Additional Advocate General.
For the respondent:
Mr. Narender Advocate.
Guleria,
Ranjan Sharma, Judge
Petitioners,
being
authorized
signatories
of Excise Department have invoked the contempt jurisdiction of this Court, alleging non-compliance of the order dated 29.12.2025 [Annexure CP-1], by Respondent-Mohinder Singh.
The operative part
of the order dated 29.12.2025, reads as under: On
request
learned
Senior
Counsel for the petitioner(s) as also learned Advocate General, the hearing of this case is being deferred by six weeks, but, with the direction that in the interregnum, the earlier order passed by this Court is modified to the
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
effect that the petitioner(s) shall continue to pay the current licence fee in terms of the conditions
allotment
vends
petitioner(s) and the arrears, if any, shall be cleared before 31.01.2026. The arrears shall also include the fee etc., for the period quo which the dispute has been raised by the petitioner(s)
before
this
Court.
It
goes
without saying that the deposition of this amount
shall
be
construed
protest
shall
abide
be
under
by
final
adjudication of the writ petition. Besides this, it is further clarified that if the petitioner(s) do not clear the arrears by 31.01.2026, then, the State shall recover the same alongwith interest @ 6% simple interest, as from the date due, because, the benefit of deferred payment is being given to the petitioner(s) by this Court. It also goes without saying that if the current licence fee i.e., payable by the petitioner(s) is not paid by the petitioner(s) in
garb
this
order,
then,
also
Department shall be at liberty to proceed against the petitioner(s) in accordance with law. It is further observed that the pendency of these petitions shall not come in the way of the State in considering the issues which have been raised by the petitioner(s) before this Court, sympathetically.
2.
Learned State Counsel submits that the
order
29.12.2025
[Annexure
CP-1]
has
not
been
complied
with
by
Respondent-
Mohinder Singh, as the license fee, in terms of the condition of allotment of vends and the arrears payable therefrom have not been deposited by the said Respondent before 31.01.2026. Learned State Counsel submits that the Status of Outstanding License Fee, is enclosed as Annexure CP-2 whereas, Respondent-
Mohinder
Singh,
was
in
arrears
of License fee amounting to Rs.1,89,37,424/- as on 31.01.2026. In these circumstances, the instant petition was filed with prayer to initiate contempt proceedings Singh,
for
against
Respondent-Mohinder
non-compliance
order
29.12.2025 [Annexure CP-1]. 3.
Instant petition [COPC No. 77 of 2026]
was listed before a Coordinate Bench of this Court on 10.03.2026. 3(i)
Upon
13.08.2026,
service,
when,
matter
Learned
was
listed
on
Counsel
for
Respondent prays for directing the Petitioner(s)State
file
fresh
status
outstanding
dues.
In
addition,
other
pleas
were
raised
giving
reasons for not remitting the License Fee as per the specified conditions. It is admitted the passing of the order dated 29.12.2025 [Annexure CP-1], with the plea, that the respondent was mandated to clear the arrears of License Fee by 31.01.2026 and for failure to deposit License Fee before 31.01.2026, the State Authorities were to recover the same alongwith interest @ 6% from the due date with liberty
against
with
law.
petitioner-department
Respondent Learned
maintainability
herein
Counsel
in
accordance
objected
contempt
proceed
petition,
being
premature, as the writ petition [CWP No. 17952 still
2025]
pending.
accompanying In
this
applications
backdrop
instant
were
petition
was opposed by Respondent. 4.
Matter was listed on 14.09.2026, when,
Learned Counsel for the Respondent herein, has pointed
out
that
a
similar
Contempt
Petition
No. 80 of 2026 has been dismissed by a Coordinate
Bench of
this
Court
on
28.07.2026,
being
not
maintainable. 5.
Faced with the above situation, matter
was listed
on 22.09.2026, when, Learned State
Counsel prays for adjournment so as to enable him to have an update as to whether any steps have been taken for recovering the amount from the Respondent or not. 6.
Upon listing of the matter on 30.09.2026,
Learned
State
Instructions
Counsel
has
placed
30.09.2026,
on
record
alongwith
communication dated 29.09.2026 sent by Deputy Commissioner [Excise] Kullu, to Commissioner State Taxes and Excise, Shimla, indicating the action taken against Respondent- Mohinder Singh for the recovery of pending License Fee, in following terms:“Exn-KUL -Excise-/232/2026-27-3657 O/o Deputy Commissioner, Excise, Kullu, District Kullu (H.P.) Dated 29.09.2026 To The Commissioner State Taxes & Excise, Himachal Pradesh, Shimla -9 Subject:
COPC No. 77 of 2026 in CWP No. 17952/2025 titled as Shri Devesh
Kumar and others versus Mohinder Singh Respected Sir, Kindly refer to the subject cited above.
In
this connection, it is submitted that a letter NO. COPC 77/2026 dated 24.09.2026 was received in this office from the Additional Advocate General, State of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla, requesting compliance with the directions/orders passed by
Hon’ble
High
Court
submission
requisite information. Accordingly, the Assistant State Tax and Excise Officer (ASTEO), Excise Circle Manali, was directed to furnish the latest status regarding the Licence Fee of the respondent/licensee.
As per
the report submitted by the ASTEO, Manali, dated 29.09.2026 and the records available in this office, the position is as under: 1.
The
respondent/licensee
was
excise
licensee of Unit No. 8, Aleo, for the excise year 2025-26. 2.
The respondent has deposited the entire licence fee in respect of the Country Liquor Licence amounting to Rs.154,03,884/-
3.
In respect of the IMFL Licence against the total licence fee of Rs.8,04,24,124/- the respondent/license
has
deposited
7,17,39,906/- leaving a balance amount of Rs.86,84,218/- which remains payable for the financial year 2025-2026. 4.
In compliance with the directions of this Hon’ble Court contained in the order dated
29.12.2025, the interest payable on account of delayed/default payment of the licence fee has been calculated by the ASTEO, Manali, is Rs.4,11,207/-, as on 28.09.2026. 5.
Accordingly, an amount of Rs.86,84,218/towards the outstanding licence fee and Rs.4,11,207/- towards interest aggregating
Rs.90,95,425/-
[Rupees
Ninety
Lakh
Ninety Five Thousand Four Hundred and Twenty Five only], remains due and payable by the respondent/licensee. 6.
outstanding
The
license
fee
amounting
to Rs.86,84,218/- Rupees Eighty Six Lakh Eighty
Four
Thousand
Two
Hundred
Eighteen only] was declared recoverable under Section 73 of the Himachal Pradesh Land
Revenue
Act,
1954
on
23.05.2026 and a red entry was made accordingly.
Sincere efforts are being made
recover
outstanding
revenue
for
protecting the Government exchequer and safeguarding the revenue due to the State. The above facts are submitted for your kind perusal
further
necessary
action,
please. Yours faithfully, Sd/Deputy Commissioner [Excise], Kullu, District Kullu, (H.P.)
7.
Heard
Mr.
Varun
Chandel,
Additional
Advocate General for the petitioners and Mr. Narender Guleria, Advocate, for the Respondent-herein ANALYSIS:
8.
Considering the factual matrix this Court
is of the considered view that instant contempt petition, alleging non-compliance of the orders dated 29.12.2025 [Annexure CP-1], is not maintainable, at this stage, for the reason, firstly, the order dated 29.12.2025 [Annexure CP-1] was a conditional order directing the Respondent to deposit current License fee alongwith arrears by 31.01.2026, failing which the State was given the liberty to recover the same alongwith interest @ 6% simple interest from due date; and secondly, in case, the Respondent did then,
not
deposit
in
such
an
interest
Petitioner(s)-State were
petitioners-department
amount
alongwith
eventuality,
Taxation Department
arrears
alongwith
interest
interest,
rights
Excise
&
safeguarded,
enabling
recover
said
in
accordance
with
law; and thirdly, there is neither any
intentional
disobedience
any willful nor
on
part
the Respondent herein; and fourthly, the remedy
contempt
is
fifthly,
material
Instructions
petitioner-State
not
a
substitute
for
execution;
on
record
including
30.09.2026
indicate
that
Authorities
have
already
made
efforts towards recovery of the arrears alongwith interest from the Respondent herein by making process under Section 73 of Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act on 23.05.2026 and pending arrears have been declared as arrears of land revenue;
sixthly,
once
petitioner(s)-State
had
unilaterally initiated action for recovery of arrears alongwith interest therefore, question of violation of orders
cannot
sustain,
as
petitioner(s)-State
Authorities cannot approbate and reprobate; and seventhly, order dated 29.12.2025 [Annexure CP-1] was passed in Writ Petition No. 17578 of 2025 and in accompanying CMP as an interim measure and aforesaid writ petition as well as application
is
pending
rights
parties
shall
be
adjudicated in the main proceedings; and in these circumstances,
non-compliance
does
not
appear
to be willful and intentional, in view of the effortssteps already initiated by the Petitioners - State Authorities
against
Respondent
as
referred
to above; and lastly, in a similar Contempt Petition i.e. COPC No. 80 of 2026, a Coordinate Bench of this Court had dismissed a similar petition on 28.07.2026, as not maintainable, as the PetitionerState therein, had already taken recourse to the legal remedy in accordance with law; and even the orders dated 28.07.2026 passed in COPC No.
2026
had
attained
finality
despite
opportunity Learned State Counsel, has not been able to establish that orders passed in identical contempt petition has been taken in appeal or has been set-aside or modified and having failed to assist this Court, therefore, the only inference is
that the
order
28.07.2026
in
another
COPC No. 80 of 2026 had attained finality.
9.
In view of the above discussion and for
reasons recorded hereinabove, the present petition is not maintainable and resultantly, the same is dismissed. 10.
Sequel to the dismissal of instant petition,
notice
issued
against
Respondent
is
discharged. 11.
However,
it
is
made
clear
that
petitioners-State Authorities shall be at liberty to recover arrears of License Fee, alongwith interest, from Respondents herein, by taking recourse to such
legal
remedy,
as
available
them,
in
accordance with law hereinafter. 12.
Resultantly,
instant
proceedings
are
closed.
(Ranjan Sharma) Judge October 6, 2026 [tm]