Agustin Hansdak v. The State of Jharkhand
- Court
- High Court of Jharkhand
- Date of judgment
- 2 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice Deepak Roshan
- Case number
- C.Rev. No. 100 of 2026
- Result
- Allowed
- Advocates
- Amit Kr. Tiwari, Oishi Das
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI Civil Review No. 100 of 2026 ---------
Agustin Hansdak, Aged about 50 years, Son of Late Charles Ilachand Hansdak, Resident of Rajbandh, P.O.: Rajbandh, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 2. Benjamin Hansdak, Aged about 49 years, Son of Late Ruben Hansdak, Resident of Kurmahat, Ρ.Ο.: Kurmahat, P.S.: Saraiyahat, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 3. Sukhu Hembrom, Aged about 48 years, Son of Charan Hembrom, Resident of Kachua, P.O.: Nonihat, P.S.: Hansdiha, 4. Lobin Hembrom, Aged about 59 years, Son of Late Lalu Hembro, Resident of Mohalla: Karharbil, P.O.: Shiv Pahar, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 5. Sonot Besra, Aged about 53 years, Son of Late Somai Besra, Resident of Mangurdih, P.O.: Lakra Pahari, P.S.: Jama, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 6. Lukhin Hembrom, Aged about 51 years, Son of Late Choto Hembrom, Resident of Village: Ramkhari, P.O.: Goasol, P.S.: Masalia, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 7. Ramesh Murmu, Aged about 49 years, Son of Late Mangal Murmu, Resident of Village: Jugidih, P.O.: Purana Dumka, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 8. Surendra Murmu, Aged about 47 years, Son of Late Moti Lal Murmu, Resident of Village: Bhaluksundia, P.O.: Sapchala, P.S.: Masalia, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 9. Noyan Murmu, Aged about 55 years, Son of Ramai Murmu, Resident of Village: Jhopa, P.O.:Koraiya, P.S.: Dumka (M), 10. Mritunjay Marandi, Aged about 57 years, Son of Late Hilar Marandi, Resident of Village: Ranipahari, P.O.: Masalia, P.S.: Kathikund, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 11. Sonamati Marandi, Aged about 60 years, Wife of Nand Kumar Hembrom, Resident of Mohalla: Karharbil, P.O.: Shiv Pahar, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 12. Raj Vivekanand Marandi, Aged about 43 years, Son of Paul Marandi, Resident of Bandorjori, P.O.: Bandarjori, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 13. Nayantara Hansdak, Aged about 51 years, Son of Pradeep Tirkey, Resident of Lal Pokhra Champa, P.O.: Dumka G.P.O., P.S.: Dumka Sadar, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 14. Shankar Hembrom, Aged about 56 years, Son of Late Govind Hembrom, Resident of Bhangahir, P.O.: Ranga Mission, P.S.: Gopikandar, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 15. Precilla Hansdak, Aged about 53 years, Wife of Rabilal Marandi, Resident of Balijore, P.O. & P.S.: Kathikund, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 16. Manoj Kumar Hembrom, Aged about 52 years, Son of Late Sukumar Hembrom, Resident of Village: Anand Pahari, P.O. & P.S.: Masalia, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 17. Nicolas Hansdak, Aged about 51 years, Son of Munsi Hansdak,
Resident of Rajbandh, P.O.: Rajbandh, P.S.: Dumka (M), 18. Satyender Murmu, Aged about 50 years, Son of Rasik Murmu, Resident of Village: Bagdaha, P.O.: Bagdaha, P.S.: Palojori, District: Deoghar, State: Jharkhand. 19. Shankar Hansdak, Aged about 60 years, Son of Late Budhan Hansdak, Resident of Village: Simra, P.O.: Dhamnicata, P.S.: Jarmundi, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 20. Pramod Kumar, Aged about 52 years, Son of Late Kedar Nath Sah, Resident of Nonihat, P.O.: Nonihat, P.S.: Hansdiha, 21. Manoj Kumar Hembrom, Aged about 44 years, Son of Hari Das Hembrom, Resident of Village: Lakra Pahari, P.O.: Bhurkunda, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 22. Sunil Kumar Murmu, Aged about 41 years, Son of Late Sugda Murmu, Resident of Village: Maniamore, P.O.: Mohanpur, P.S.: Mahagama, District: Godda, State: Jharkhand. 23. Murari Chandra Manjhi, Aged about 54 years, Son of Gopi Chandra Manjhi, Resident of Village: Nonihat, P.O.: Nonihat, P.S.: Hansdiha, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 24. Kartik Dehri, Aged about 43 years, Son of Late Raghu Pujhar, Resident of Village: Bhangahir, P.O.: Ranga Mission, P.S.: Gopikander, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 25. Dinesh Kumar Murmu, Aged about 43 years, Son of Naren Murmu, Resident of Village: Bhangahir, P.O. & P.S.: Masalia, 26. Dhananjay Kumar, Aged about 57 years, Son of Late Sitaram Mandal, Resident of Village: Domnadih, P.O. & P.S.: Jarmundi, 27. Anand Antony Besra, Aged about 57 years, Son of Late Girish Besra, Resident of Village: Mohanpur, P.O. & P.S.: Ramgarh, 28. Minu Marandi, Aged about 58 years, W/o John Besra, Resident of Village: Mohanpur, P.O. & P.S.: Ramgarh, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 29. George P. Hembrom, Aged about 53 years, Son of Parta Hembrom, Resident of Village: Saharjori, P.O.: Barmasia, P.S.: Barmasia, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 30. Meena Nazrita Tudu, Aged about 54 years, Wife of William James Tudu, Resident of Village: Ahrichuan, P.O.: Rajdaha, P.S.: Gopikander, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 31. Neelu Nalini Tudu, Aged about 51 years, Wife of George P. Hembrom, Resident of Village: Saharjori, P.O.: Barmasia, P.S.: Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 32. Xavier Ashish Hembrom, Aged about 55 years, Son of Parta Hembrom, Resident of Village: Saharjori, P.O.: Barmasia, P.S.: Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 33. Hupni Ujjwalata Hansda, Aged about 60 years, Wife of Palu Hembrom, Resident of Village: Kendpahari, P.O.: Pattabari, P.S.: Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 34. Aruna Jacinta Hembrom, Aged about 54 years, Wife of Late Bertie Hembrom, Resident of Village: Kushbona, P.O.:
Kolhabadar, P.S.; Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 35. Paulina Soren, Aged about 54 years, Wife of Sri Kima Kisku, Resident of Village: Gaipathor, P.O.: Rajdaha, P.S.: Pakuria, District: Pakur, State: Jharkhand. 36. Sylvester Soren, Aged about 50 years, Son of Lawrence Soren, Resident of Village: Kushbona, P.O.: Kolhabadar, P.S.: Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 37. Asha Rani Hansdak, Aged about 53 years, Wife of Late Panchan Murmu, Resident of Village: Mohul Pahari, P.O.: Mohul Pahari, P.S.: Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 38. Marcella Soren, Aged about 60 years, Son of Late Laurence Soren, Resident of Village: Babupur, P.O.: Makra Pahari, P.S.: Jama, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 39. Ram Dulari Kumari, Aged about 62 years, Wife of Suresh Prasad Raut, Resident of Village: Sirsanath, P.O.: Lilatari, P.S.: Jama, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 40. Mistri Hembrom, Aged about 55 years, Son of Late Mangal Hembrom, Resident of Village: Khejuria, P.O.: Dhamnilata, P.S.: Jarmundi, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 41. Veronica Murmu, Aged about 50 years, Wife of Pritam Marandi, Resident of Village: Golpur, P.O.: Jaruwadih, P.S.: Masalia, 42. Veronica Murmu, Aged about 50 years, Son of Late Panu Paulus Murmu, Resident of Guhiajori, P.O.: Guhiajori, P.S.: Dumka (M), 43. Sunemi Soren, Aged about 57 years, Wife of Alfred Marandi, Resident of Mudayam, P.O.: Gujisimal, P.S.: Shikaripara, 44. Rajesh Tudu, Aged about 48 years, Son of Chunda Tudu, Resident of Village: Chandopani, P.O.: Telia Chowk, P.S.: Mufsil Dumka, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 45. Stensheela Lilawati, Kisku, Aged about 66 years, Wife of Pores Tudu, Resident of Village: Chirapather, P.O.: Benagadia P.S.: Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 46. Elbina Kisku, Aged about 58 years, Wife of Subodhan Soren, Resident of Village: Barapathar, P.O.: Kurudih, P.S.: Gopikandar, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 47. Piyush Murmu, Aged about 59 years, Son of Late Bansi Murmu, Resident of Village: Mohulbina, P.O.: Koraiya, P.S.: Madhuwadih, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 48. Kanchan Pauria, Aged about 53 years, W/o Parimol Kumar Hembrom, Resident of Village: Dondia, P.O.: Khairbani, P.S.: Jama, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 49. Manajer Tudu, Aged about 52 years, Son of Gopal Tudu, Resident of Village: Balijor, P.O.: Gujisimal, P.S.: Shikaripara, ....Petitioner(s) Versus 2.
The State of Jharkhand. The Secretary, Planning -cum- Finance Department, Govt. of Jharkhand, At: Project Bhawan, Dhurwa, P.O. & P.S.: Dhurwa, District: Ranchi, State: Jharkhand.
3.
The Secretary, School Education & Literacy Department, Govt. of Jharkhand, At: Project Bhawan, Dhurwa, P.O. & P.S.: Dhurwa, District: Ranchi, State: Jharkhand. 4. The Director, Primary Education. School Education & Literacy Department, Govt. of Jharkhand, At: Project Bhawan, Dhurwa, P.O. & P.S.: Dhurwa, District: Ranchi, State: Jharkhand. 5. The Deputy Commissioner, Dumka, P.O. & P.S.: Dumka, 6. The District Superintendent of Education, Dumka, P.O. & P.S.: Dumka, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 7. Matal Hembrom, Aged about 60 years, Son of Late Lal Hembrom, Resident of Sungaphalan, P.O.: Kolha Badar, Via: Shikaripara, P.S.: Shikaripara, District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 8. Holodi Soren, Aged about 52 years, Wife of Mahender Murmu, Resident of Village: Samlapur, Ρ.Ο.: Babangama, P.S.: Sarath, District: Deoghar, State: Jharkhand. 9. Prabhas Kumar Choudhary, Aged about 64 years, Son of Ram Narayan Prasad Choudhary, Resident of Mohalla: Shiv Pahar, P.O.: Shiv Pahar, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. 10. Bilwasini Murmu, Aged about 58 years, Wife of Samuel Marandi, Resident of Village: Bartali, P.O.: Gando, P.S.: Dumka (M), District: Dumka, State: Jharkhand. ....Respondents/Opposite Parties ---------
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN ---------
For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. Amit Kr. Tiwari, Advocate For the Respondent(s) : Mrs. Oishi Das, A.C. to A.G. ---------
02/Dated:-02.11.2026
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that this
review application has been preferred for correction in Paragraph Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 6 of the order dated 01.05.2026 passed in W.P.(S) No.6687 of 2025 with analogous cases as the same requires necessary correction in view of the fact that the case number which has been mentioned in paragraph Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 6 i.e., W.P.(S) No. 89 of 2021 and analogous cases dated 07.12.2023 and also the order passed in W.P.(S) No.3759 of 2020 dated 05.12.2022, were initially passed in the first round of litigation; accordingly, paragraph Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 6 of the order dated 01.05.2026 may be modified by incorporating W.P.(S) No.5897 of
2014 with analogous cases passed on 27.11.2025 in place of W.P.(S) No. 89 of 2021 with analogous cases and W.P.(S) No. 3759 of 2020 with analogous cases. 2.
Learned counsel for the respondents does not have any
objection because it is a typographical error in giving the case number. 3.
Accordingly, paragraph Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 6 of the order
dated 01.05.2026 passed in W.P.(S) No.6687 of 2025 with analogous cases, is hereby modified and shall henceforth be read as under: “2. At the outset, learned counsel for the respective petitioners jointly submits that the issues involved in these cases have already been decided by this Court in W.P.(S). No. 5897 of 2014 and analogous cases, vide judgment rendered on 27.11.2025. Accordingly, they submit that these instant writ applications may be disposed of in the line of the said judgment. 3. Learned counsel for the respondents very fairly submits that supplementary counter-affidavit has been filed and if the case of the petitioners is on similar footing with that of the petitioners of W.P.(S). No. 5897 of 2014 and analogous cases, they may approach the concerned respondents for consideration of their cases. 4. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, all these writ applications stand disposed of in the line of same finding what has been given by this Court in W.P.(S). No. 5897 of 2014 and analogous cases. .... .... 6. The respondents are directed to extend the similar benefits what has been given to the petitioners of W.P.(S). No. 5897 of 2014 and analogous cases, vide judgment rendered on 27.11.2025, within a period of 12 weeks from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order.”
4.
With the aforesaid modifications, the instant review
application stands allowed. Pending I.A., if any, also stands closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.) NOVEMBER 2, 2026 vikas/-
uploaded 07/11/2026