Ajmal Ziauddin Sanai v. M/S Bajaj Electronics
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 8 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Moushumi Bhattacharya
- Case number
- ARBAPPL No. 123 of 2025
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
- Subject
- Civil
Full judgment
[ 3405 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
ARB ITRATION APPLICATION NO: 123 OF 2025 Between: Ajmal Ziauddin Sanat, Son of Late. Afzal Jalaluddin Sanai, Aged about 59 years, Occupation Business, Resident of H.No 32A MLA colony Road No. 12 Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500034, Telangana State ...Applica nt AND 1. Ivl/s Bayaj Electronics, having its registered office at having its corporate office at No 6-3-6661A1 lo 7 , 3'd Floor, Opposite Nims Hospital, Panjagutta lVlain road, Hyderabad- 500082 Represented by its Partner Karan Bajaj. 2. The Electronics [\/a rt lndia, having rts registered office at H.No.6-'l-9'1 , Shop No. 10, Ground Floor next to Telephone Bhavan Secretariat Road, Saifabad, Hyderabad- 500004. Also at. The Electronics Mart lndia, having its corporate office at M.No.6-3-666/A1 to 7, 1't floor, Opposite Nims Hospital, Panjagutta Main road, Hyderabad500082 ...Respondents Arbitration Application under Sub-Secs (5 & 6) of Section 11 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 read with Para (3)(i)(c) of Scheme for appointment of Arbitrators, 2006 praying that this Hon'bie Court may be pleased to appoint a sole arbitrator for the purpose of adjudicatron of all the disputes that have arisen between
the Applicant and the Respondent from out of and in relation to the deed dated 2806-20'18 between the Applicant and the Respondent.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Mr. Syed Hassan Bin Taher Counsel for the Respondents: Mr. Sunil B. Ganu, Senior Counsel representing Mr. Omar A Pasha The Court made the following: ORDER
rl IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA ARBITRATION APPLI cATroN NO.123 0F 2025 (cNR NO.HBHCOLO3229 6202sl DATE: O8.1O.2O26 RESERVED ON: O1. 10.2026
PRONOUNCED ON: 08. 1O.2O26 UPLOADED ON: O8. 1O.2O26
BETWEEN: Ajmal Ziauclclin Sanai
.Applicant AND
M/ s Bajaj Dlectronics and Anothcr Respondents
Mr. Sr ed Hassan Bin Taher , learncd counsel appearing for the applicant.
Mr. Sunil [3 Ganu, learned Senior Counsel representing Mr. Omar A pasha, Iearnr:i counsr:l appearing for thc respondents.
ORDER:
1.
The appllcant has sought for the appointment of an
Arbitrator to adjudicare the dispute arising out of ,a Lease Deed darecl 28.06 2018.
The applicant is the lcssor and the respondent No. i is the
lesser: irr respect of th c comme rcial propert]No. 1ilA, Valic,-r. Vicu., Banjara
Hiils, Hl,derabad
situated at Road
Arbitration Clause 13 of the Lease Deed contains an if a dispute arising Clause which provid es, inter atia' tlnat with the Lease Deed the parties out of or in connection
3.
between
is not resolved through mutual discussions days, one parry sha11 sen'e a Notice on
within thirty (30)
the other party and the
dispute sha11 be frnally settled by way of
Arbitration under the
provisions of The Arbitration and Conciliation
Act' 1996 (A&C
ActJ by a mutually agreed and jointly appointed failing which an arbitrator shall be appointed
arbitrator'
in accordance
with the A&C Act.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the applicant
submits that
the dispute arises out of Serial No'6 ('Lease Term') Schedule attached to the Lease Deed which
of the
stipulates a rental
period of 15 years, renewable every 5 (five) years
each, with a lock-in period after each term
for three terms
under the same
terms and conditions, from the rent commencement
date of 1"t
July, 2018 to 30th June, 2033
5.
Counsel submlts that the respondent No' 1 issued
a Notice
adhere to the of Intent to vacate on 07 '03 2025 and failed to No 6 of the Lease Term/ Lock-ln Period provided in Serial
submits that the Schedule to the Lease Deed' Counsel further Arbitration to the applicant accordingly issued a Notice invoking
I
address of the respondent No. 1 on 2l .O4.2025, nominating an
arbitrator
6.
The respondenl No. I however gave lu'o replies on
05.05.2025 and 15.05.2025, stating, inter alia. rhat the Lease Deed is closed and that the respondent No.I w'll continue to
occupy thr: prcmises until thc applicant returns the security dep, rsit of Rs.3 I .5O Iakhs.
7.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent
No. I / lcssee submits that the respondent No. 1 issued the Notice
of Intent to vacate indicating that the Lease Deed had expired in 20211. ri'ithout any further rene$,al thereafter. Scnior Counsel
furtl-rer submits thar the Lease Deed is unre.gistered and insulficient.ly stamped. Hence, in the facts and circumstances of the case. there is no valid Lease Deed at all.
8.
It is aLso submitred that Serial No.6 of the Schedule to the
Lease Deecl merkes it clear that the applicant see,ks to loist a Ieasc in perpetuitl. on the respondent No.1.
9.
i have considered thc submissions made on behalf of the
applicant/ lr:ssor, rr.ho seeks the appointment of an arbitrator,
and Lhc respondent No. 1/lessee, who disputes the very nature of Lh c. Lease Dce d.
-
10. At the very outset, it should be pointed out that Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent No'l
has taken a fair
stand and has made his submissions in accordance
with the
law cited on the subject' I 1.
From the documents, it is evident that the Arbitration
Agreement contained
in Clause 13 of the Lease Deed is an
independent agreement which can survive on its
own despite
the alleged expiry of the Lease Deed in 2023 Section
i 1(6A) of
theA&CActprovidesthattheCourt,whileconsideringany application under sub-sections (4), (5) or (6)' sha1l be confined to the examination of the 'existence' of an arbitration agreement'
12. Further, the interpretation of Serial No'6 of the Schedule to the Lease Deed is a matter within the domain of arbitration' namely, whether the respondent No'1/lessee should be bound
by the lock-in period contained in Serial No'6 of the Schedule'
It is also settled law that the alleged infirmity of the Lease Deed itself, by virtue of being unregistered or insufhciently stamped' is a matter which can be adjudicated by an arbitrator'
13. It is evident liom the rival submissions and the material onrecord.thatthereisaliveandsubsistingdisputebetweenthe parties which squarely falls within Serial No 13 (the Arbitration
J
Cl:rrise ol the l-easc Deed). The dispute is evident from the
respondent No. I's rwo replies to the applicant,s Notice of lnvocation. While the applicant claims substantral amounts by wav of vearlv escalatrons, monthl!. rents and the lock-in period,
the respondent No.I disputes the conrinuation of the Lease Decd and clemands refund of the security deposit.
14. The existence of thc dispute between the parties is dirt'cr1r'relatable to and ariscs out of the Lease Dced. The facts
further shos, that the applicant has establisht:d a case for app()inlment of an arbitraror under secrion 1l((r) of the A&C Act.
15. In vit:',r, ol the above, this Court finds it zLppropriate to allos, the Arbitration Application and appoint an arbitrator in ternrs of the Arbitration Clause executed between the partres.
16. In view of the submissions made by counsel appearing for the:rpplicant and Senior Counscl appearing for the respondent No.1. Sri Justicc L. Narasimha Redd1,, lletired Chief Justice of
I)atnrr F{igh Court. H.No.2-2 23l3l3, Durgabar Deshmukh Colonr, NezLr O.U. Campus, Bagh Amberpet, I{yderabad _ 5000 13. Mobile No 9,140621406, is hereby appo;nted
Sole.\rbirraror to adjudicate the disputes
as the
between the parties.
-
The parties sha11 appear before the learned Arbitrator on of this order' The 24.10.2026 at 11.00 A M along with a coPY
learned Arbitrator shall thereafter proceed
with the Arbitral
Proceedings in accordance with law'
17. The parties are at liberty to raise all the contentious issues before the learned Arbitralor' The fee ol
the Arbitrator as
well as the other terms and conditions' sha11 be settled
by the
parties in consultation with the Arbitrator so appointed'
1ti. Arbjtration Application No 123 of 2025' along with al1 connected applications, is accordingly allowed' SD/- M. VIJAYA BHASKER JOINT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER To,
1. Sri Justice L. Narasimha Reddy, Retired Chief Justice of Patna High Court, H.No.2-2-25t313, Durgabai Deshmukh Colony, near O.U Campus, Bagh Amberpet, Hyderabad - 5000'13, tt/lobile No.9440621406 (By Special Messenger)(Along with a Copy of affidavit and material papers)
2. One CC to Mr. Syed Hassan Bin Taher, Advocate [OPUC] 3. One CC to Mr. Omar A Pasha, Advocate [OPUC]
4 Two CD Copies t"
lilA,
w
KAIV/GNK
HIGH COURT
DATED: 08t1012026
(o -+ ..) :) J
ARBAPPL.No.123 of 2025
ALLOWING THE ARBITRATION APPLICATION
1'1
\
L
li lL.
z
lE 0cT 2[m t Or-
ORDER
q
1i1E s
C)
t i'AT Ct{