Amol Jyotiram Gambhire v. The State of Maharashtra and Others
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 4 November 2026
- Case number
- WP No. 851 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED OFF
- Acts & sections
- Section 35 BNSS, Section 129 BNSS, Section 3 BNS
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:54485-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 851 OF 2026 Amol S/o Jyotiram Gambhire Age : 26 years, Occ : Labour, R/o. Sikandarpur, Tal. Dist. Latur (Presently detained at Central Jail, Harsul Road, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar) ... PETITIONER VERSUS 1.
The State of Maharashtra, Through the Secretary, Home Department (Special), Government of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, Mumbai-400 032.
2.
The District Magistrate, Collector Office, Latur Tq. & Dist. Latur - 413 512
3.
The Superintendent of Central Jail, Harsul Road, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar ... RESPONDENTS
... Mr. A. U. Chandel, Advocate for the petitioner Mr. G.A. Kulkarni, APP for Respondent nos.1 to 3. ... CORAM
: SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE & VAISHALI PATIL-JADHAV, JJ.
RESERVED ON : 28.10.2026. PRONOUNCED ON : 04.11.2026
JUDGMENT [Per : Vaishali Patil-Jadhav, J.] : .
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard
finally at the admission stage with the consent of learned advocates for the parties. 2.
By this petition, the petitioner challenges the
detention
order
dated
20.02.2026
No.2026/MAG/MPDA/Desk-2/Pol-1/WS-25,
bearing passed
by
Respondent No. 2- District Magistrate, Latur, in exercise of the
powers
Prevention
under of
Section
Dangerous
3(1)
of
Activities
the
Maharashtra
of
Slumlords,
Bootleggers, Drug-offenders, Dangerous Persons, Video Pirates, Sand Smugglers, Persons Engaged in BlackMarketing of Essential Commodities, Illegal Gambling, Illegal Lottery and Human Trafficker Act, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as “MPDA”), as well as the approval order dated 27.02.2026 and the confirmation order dated 12.05.2026 bearing
No.
MPDA-0226/CR:123/Spl-3B,
passed
by
Respondent No. 1- State Government, in exercise of the powers under Section 12(1) of the MPDA. By the impugned detention order, the petitioner is directed to be detained for a period of 12 months on the ground that the petitioner is
a “dangerous person” within the meaning of Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA. 3.
The record reflects registration of fifteen (15)
criminal cases and four preventive actions taken against the petitioner. The reference chart showing the criminal record of the petitioner is reproduced hereunder : Sr. No
Police Station
Crime No.
Section
1.
Latur Rural
204/2015
2.
Shivajinagar, Latur
3.
Registratio n Date
Date of arrest
Date of Bail
Court Case no Status of & Date. case
IPC 341, 22.09.2015 02.10.2015 324, 323, 504, 506, 34
13.10.2015
RCC No.632/2015 dated 30.10.2015
pending before Court
202/2015
IPC 356, 28.10.2015 29.01.2016
01.02.2016
RCC No.131/2016 dated 30.03.2016
pending before Court
Latur Rural
266/2015
IPC 394, 26.11.2015 26.11.2015 341, 34
30.11.2015
RCC No.42/2016 dated 28.01.2016
pending before Court
4.
MIDC, Latur
215/2016
IPC 327, 15.06.2016 16.06.2016 341, 323, 504 and 34
27.07.2016
RCC No.150/2017 dated 17.03.2017
pending before Court
5.
Vivekanand Chowk, Latur
163/2016
IPC 324, 15.12.2016 02.01.2017 363, 341, 435, 427, 323, 504, 506, 34
23.03.2017
STCC No.203/2017 dated 13.04.2017
pending before Court
6.
Vivekanand Chowk, Latur
459/2017
IPC 324, 08.10.2017 22.06.2018 323, 34
--
RCC No.839/2017 dated 14.12.2017
pending before Court
7.
Gandhi Chowk, Latur
523/2017
IPC 324, 17.11.2017 20.12.2017 323, 504, 506, 34
--
RCC No.42/2018 dated 22.01.2018
Pending before Court
8.
Gandhi Chowk, Latur
94/2018
IPC 341, 21.03.2018 22.03.2018 326, 323, 504, 34
27.03.2018
RCC No.363/2018 dated 21.07.2018
Pending before Court
9.
Vivekanand Chowk, Latur
159/2018
IPC 341, 19.05.2018 22.06.2018 323, 504, 506, 34
--
10.
Gandhi Chowk, Latur
78/2019
IPC 394, 25.02.2019 25.03.2019
02.07.2019
RCC no.604/2019 dated 27.08.2019
pending before Court
11.
Latur Rural
118/2020
IPC 142 15.06.2020 15.06.2020
15.06.2020
SCC no.884/2020 dated 22.06.2020
pending before Court
12.
Shivajinagar, Latur
45/2021
IPC 307, 18.01.2021 30.03.2021 384, 452, 141, 147, 148, 149 r/w Sec. 135 of Maharas htra Police Act
Anticipatory bail granted
SC no.63/2021 dated 25.05.2021
pending before Court
13.
Latur Rural
259/2021
IPC 307, 04.11.2021 04.11.2021 323, 506
29.04.2022
SCC no.02/2022 dated 01.01.2022
pending before Court
14.
Latur Rural
NC No.320/20
BNS 115(2), 352, 351(2), 351(3)
17.09.2024
--
--
--
15.
Latur Rural
249/2024
BNS 109, 126(2), 351(2), 351(3)
16.11.2024 09.12.2024
11.03.2025
RCC no.84/2025 dated 24.01.2025
pending before Court
--
RCC Pending no.1554/2018 before dated Court 24.08.2018
Preventive Action :Sr. No.
Police Station
C.R. No.
Under Section
1.
Latur Rural
01/2022
110(e)(g) CrPC
2.
Latur Rural
MAGCR 73/2019
56 (b) Maharashtra Police Act (Externment)
3.
Latur Rural
455/2016
107 CrPC
4.
Latur Rural
01/2025
129 BNSS
4.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submits
that: i)
The inordinate and unexplained delay in passing the
detention order after the alleged prejudicial activities and recording of the in-camera statements shows that there was no pressing urgency or imminent threat warranting the petitioner’s preventive detention. ii)
The Detaining Authority has failed to apply its mind
to the fact that the petitioner was not arrested and was only served a notice under Section 35 of the BNSS on 26.09.2025 in Crime No. 204/2025, which is the sole crime upon which the impugned detention order is passed. iii)
The in-camera statements of Witnesses "A" and "B"
are stereotyped, vague and lack material particulars. Furthermore, the incidents narrated therein are individual in nature and, at the most, amount to a "law and order"
issue, failing to demonstrate any disturbance to "public order" as required under the MPDA. Learned advocate lastly submitted that the detention order is liable to be quashed and set aside and prayed for the release of the petitioner. 5.
Per contra, learned APP while supporting the
impugned order submitted that: i)
The petitioner is a "Dangerous Person" within the
meaning of Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA Act, as he has committed serious offences under Chapter XVI and XVII of the IPC and Chapter VI of the BNS, 2023. His dangerous activities have created constant fear and terror among the citizens in the jurisdiction of Latur Rural Police Station and adjoining
areas
thereby
causing
prejudice
to
the
maintenance of public order. ii)
There is no delay in passing the detention order or in
completing the mandatory statutory requirements. The entire process from the submission of the proposal to the final confirmation by the State Government was completed strictly within the stipulated timelines. iii)
The Detaining Authority was aware that the petitioner
was released on serving a notice under Section 35(3) of the
BNSS. The said notice was placed before the Detaining Authority. Merely because the petitioner was released on notice does not negate the threat to public order, nor does it bar the issuance of a detention order. Learned APP lastly submitted that the detaining authority has passed the detention order after applying its mind to the entire record and recording the requisite subjective satisfaction, and prayed for dismissal of the petition. 6.
Heard
learned
Advocate
Mr.
Ajaysingh
U.
Chandel for the petitioner and learned APP Mr. G.A. Kulkarni for the respondents. With the assistance of the learned advocates, we have perused the petition, the affidavit-in-reply, citations and the record. 7.
The detaining authority, while passing the
impugned detention order, has mainly relied upon one offence, i.e., C.R. No.204/2025 registered on 12.09.2025 under Sections 118(1), 115(2), 351(2), 351(3), 352 read with Section 3(5) of the BNS, 2023, registered with Latur Rural Police Station, Latur, along with two in-camera
statements of confidential witnesses "A" and "B", to declare the petitioner a “Dangerous Person”. 8.
The record shows the following chronology: the
only crime considered for passing the detention order was registered on 12.09.2025. The confidential statement of witness "A" was recorded on 08.11.2025, and the statement of
witness
"B"
was
recorded
on
13.11.2025.
After
completion of the confidential inquiry, on 22.12.2025, the Police Inspector of Police Station Latur Rural, Dist. Latur, submitted the proposal to the Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Latur Rural. The Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Latur Rural forwarded the proposal to the Superintendent of Police, Latur on 02.01.2026. The Sub-Divisional Police Officer verified the statements of witnesses "A" and "B" on 30.01.2026. Thereafter, the Superintendent of Police, Latur forwarded the said proposal to the Detaining Authority on 02.02.2026 and the Detaining Authority passed the detention order on 20.02.2026. 9.
As the last offence considered was registered on
12.09.2025 and the detention order was passed on 20.02.2026, i.e., after a delay of more than five (5) months
from the last crime, there is an absence of any live link between the material considered by the Detaining Authority as being prejudicial to the maintenance of public order and the
subjective
satisfaction
reached
by
the
Detaining
Authority that the activities of the petitioner were indeed prejudicial to the maintenance of public order. Moreover, the said delay is unexplained. There is no sentence in the affidavit-in-reply of the Detaining Authority explaining the reasons for the delay caused in passing the detention order from the date of the last registered crime which is considered for passing the detention order. 10.
A profitable reference can be made to the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Smt. Hemlata Kantilal Shah Vs. State of Maharashtra and another, reported in (1981) 4 SCC 647, wherein it is held that, "delay ipso facto in passing an order of detention after an incident is not fatal to the detention of a person, for in certain cases delay may be unavoidable and reasonable. What is required by law is that the delay must be satisfactorily explained by the Detaining Authority." Thus, in our considered view, the inordinate and unexplained delay in the passing of the detention order has
snapped the live link between the prejudicial activities alleged against the petitioner and the rationale of clamping the detention order. 11.
Admittedly, the detention order rests upon one
crime i.e., C.R. No.204/2025 and two in-camera statements of confidential witnesses “A” and “B”. The facts of C.R. No. 204/2025 disclose that the complainant was sitting with his friend at Hanuman Chowk, Sikandarpur, when the petitioner and one another, in an intoxicated state, demanded him money for liquor and on refusal, the petitioner assaulted him with kicks and fists, while the coaccused hit him with a brick. The said incident is an individual dispute between private persons arising out of a demand for money for liquor. It does not disclose any act which affected the community at large or disturbed the even tempo of public life. At its highest, it may amount to an offence affecting law and order, but the material does not demonstrate that it was an act prejudicial to the maintenance of “public order”. 12.
So far as the two in-camera statements are
concerned, witness “A” alleges that about two months prior
to the recording of his statement, while he was returning from his agricultural field along with labourers, the petitioner and his associates demanded money for liquor and, on refusal, the petitioner took out a sickle, threatened him and forcibly took ₹800 from his pocket. Witness “B” alleges that about three months prior to the recording of his statement, while he was returning to Sikandarpur from Latur, the petitioner and two unknown persons intercepted his motorcycle, demanded money, and on refusal the petitioner took out a knife, caught hold of his collar and assaulted him with kicks and fists. Both statements are in general and stereotyped language. They refer to incidents without exact dates, and largely narrate the petitioner’s alleged general criminal behaviour. Though the incidents are said to have occurred at or near public places, the statements do not contain material particulars to show that the public at large was affected or that the even tempo of community life was disturbed. 13.
As observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Ameena Begum Vs. State of Telangana reported in 2023 INSC 788, the distinction between “law and order” and
“public order” is one of degree and impact. An act may affect law and order and yet not public order; it is only when the act affects the community at large or the even tempo of life of the people that it assumes the character of a public order issue. In the present case, the statements do not establish that the petitioner’s activities were prejudicial to the maintenance of public order so as to justify his preventive detention. 14.
The record further discloses that on 12.03.2025,
the Police Inspector, Latur Rural Police Station, on the report of the Assistant Police Inspector, Latur Rural Police Station, submitted a request letter to the Executive Magistrate,
Latur,
seeking
permission
to
initiate
proceedings under Section 129 of the BNSS, and Chapter Case No.01/2025 under Section 129 of the BNSS came to be initiated against the petitioner. However, neither the detention order nor the affidavit-in-reply discloses the status or outcome of the said proceedings, nor is there any explanation as to why the said less drastic statutory proceeding was not taken to its logical conclusion or why it was considered insufficient in curbing the prejudicial activities of the petitioner.
15.
Before passing the order of detention, the
Detaining Authority must keep in mind that the recording of subjective satisfaction by the Detaining Authority in an order of preventive detention is a sine qua non for passing a valid order of preventive detention. This Court is well aware of the position of law that, while deciding the validity of an order of preventive detention, this Court cannot decide whether there was adequacy of material before the Detaining Authority. This Court can only examine whether there was material before the Detaining Authority and whether the Detaining Authority has recorded subjective satisfaction that the grounds provided in the statute for passing an order of detention exist. The order of preventive detention is an order of a very drastic nature. The result of passing an order of preventive detention is to deprive the detenu of his liberty without trial. Therefore, an order of preventive detention cannot be passed in a casual manner. Passing of an order of preventive detention involves careful application of mind and recording of subjective satisfaction on the basis of the material on record that the grounds of detention provided by the statute exist.
16.
In our view, in the instant case, there has been
an inordinate delay from the last crime registered till the passing of the detention order which has snapped the live link between the prejudicial activities of the petitioner and the rationale of clamping the detention order on him. The sole crime and the two in-camera statements, even if accepted at their face value, disclose incidents individual in nature and, at the highest, affecting law and order, but not public order. The record further shows that Chapter Case No.01/2025 under Section 129 of the BNSS was initiated against the petitioner, but its status or outcome is not placed on record and the Detaining Authority has not explained why the said less drastic proceeding was insufficient. In the sole crime relied upon, the petitioner was not arrested and was only served a notice under Section
35(3)
of
the
BNSS
on
26.09.2025,
as
the
authorities did not find it necessary to arrest him. These circumstances clearly show that the Detaining Authority did not apply its mind to the relevant material and recorded subjective satisfaction mechanically. As a result, the detention order has ceased to be preventive, as it should be
in law, and has instead become punitive and must therefore be struck down. 17.
For the foregoing reasons, we pass the following
order :ORDER (i)
The Writ Petition stands allowed.
(ii)
The
detention
order
dated
No.2026/MAG/MPDA/Desk-2/WS-25,
20.02.2026
bearing
passed
by
Respondent No. 2 - District Magistrate, Latur, the approval order dated 27.02.2026 and the confirmation order dated 12.05.2026
bearing
No.
MPDA-0226/CR:123/Spl-3B,
passed by Respondent No. 1- State Government are hereby quashed and set aside. (iii)
The Petitioner- Amol S/o Jyotiram Gambhire shall be
released forthwith, if not required in any other offence. (iv)
Rule is made absolute in the above terms.
[VAISHALI PATIL-JADHAV] JUDGE
[SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE] JUDGE
DDC