Azmira Bibi @ Azmira Khatun v. Union of India and 4 ORS.

Court
Gauhati High Court
Date of judgment
10 November 2026
Bench
Justice Kalyan Rai Surana, Justice Pranjal Das
Case number
WP(C) No. 89 of 2017
Result
Disposed Of
Acts & sections
Article 226 Constitution
Subject
Family

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

Page No.# 1/13 GAHC010009672017

2026:GAU-AS:16520-DB

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) Case No. : WP(C)/89/2017 AZMIRA BIBI @ AZMIRA KHATUN W/O. SOHIDUR RAHMAN, D/O. AMZAD ALI, VILL. CHITAGURI, P.O. MAKRITHORA, P.S. GAURIPUR, DIST. DHUBRI, ASSAM.

VERSUS UNION OF INDIA and 4 ORS. REP. BY THE SECRETARY OF MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, GOVT. OF INDIA, NEW DELHI-1. 2:THE STATE OF ASSAM REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER and SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM HOME DEPTT. DISPUR GUWAHATI-6. 3:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER DHUBRI DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM. 4:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE B DHUBRI DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM. 5:THE OFFICER-IN-CHARGE GURIPUR POLICE STATION DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM

Page No.# 2/13

Advocate for the Petitioner : MR.M R Z CHOUDHURY, MS.S KAKATI,MD.H BHUYAN,MS.J BEGUM,MS.J H CHOUDHURY,MS.S BEGUM Advocate for the Respondent : , ASSTT.S.G.I.,GA, ASSAM

BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS

Advocate for the petitioner Advocate for the respondents

: Md. H. Bhuyan. : Mr. S. Chakraborty, CGC, : Mr. A.I .Ali, SC, ECI : Mr. J. Payeng, SC, FT, Border matters and NRC. : Mr. P. Sarmah, Addl. Sr. G.A.

Date on which judgment is reserved

: 21.07.2026

Date of pronouncement of judgment

: 11.11.2026

Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the judgment?

: No.

Whether the full judgment has been Pronounced?

: Yes.

JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV) (K.R. Surana, J) Heard Md. H. Bhuyan, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. Chakraborty, learned CGC; Mr. A.I. Ali, learned standing counsel for the ECI; Mr. J. Payeng, learned standing counsel for the FT matters and NRC;

Page No.# 3/13

and Mr. P. Sarmah, learned Additional Senior Govt. Advocate for respondent. 2.

By filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution

of India, the petitioner, namely, Azmira Bibi @ Azmira Khatun has assailed the impugned opinion dated 14.09.2016, passed by the learned Member, Foreigners’ Tribunal, 6th Dhubri at Bilasipara, in FT. Case No 6th, Dhubri 1-272/2016, arising out of Ref No.1509/D/07 and Tr. No.781/BLP/11, by which the petitioner was declared as an illegal migrant. 3.

On receipt of notice, the petitioner had entered appearance and

filed her written statement denying that she is a foreigner or illegal migrant and claimed to be an indigenous citizen of Assam by birth. The petitioner claimed that her father is Amzat Ali @ Amzat Ali Shekh and her grandfather is Noimuddin @ Noimuddin Shekh. She claims to born and brought up at villChataguri Pt-II under Bagribari P.S, in the district of Dhubri (now Kokrajhar). She claims that the name of her grandfather was enrolled in the voter’s list of 1961 and name of her grandparents were entered in the voter’s list of 1966 moreover, the name of her grandfather and grandparents were also entered in the NRC with legacy data. She claims that her grandfather had died in the year 1970 and accordingly, her grandmother namely, Jamiron Bewa appeared in the electoral roll of 1970 and her name also appears in the voter details of legacy data for the said year. The name of her father appeared in the electoral roll of 1997. The petitioner claimed that on 20.09.2002 she was married with Sahidur Rahman of Vill-Poyasti Salmara in the district of Dhubri by exhibiting a marriage Kabinnama and her name was enrolled in the voter’s list of 1997 at VillChataguri Pt-II under Bagribari P.S. However, against her name “D” mark was made. The petitioner in order to substantiate the linkage with her projected father has referred to the certificate issued by the Mahamaya VCDC. The

Page No.# 4/13

petitioner has stated that before the marriage her name was Azmira Khautun and after marriage was Azmira Bibi and accordingly, both are same person. In order to support her contention, the petitioner relies on the certificate counter signed by BDO, Mahamaya Block. 4.

In support of the stand taken in the written statement, the

petitioner has examined herself as DW-1 and she had filed her evidence-onaffidavit, wherein the reiterating the statements has exhibited the following documents:Ext.1 is the said NRC details. Ext.2 is the image of NRC. Ext.3 is said voter details 1961. Ext.4 is said image of Electoral Roll 1961. Ext.5 is certified copy of Electoral Roll 1961. Ext.6 is the said voter Details 1966 of her grandfather Ext.7 is voter Details 1966 of my grandmother. Ext.8 is said image of Electoral Roll 1966. Ext.9 is the said certified copy of Electoral Roll 1966. Ext.10 is the said voter details. Ext.11 is image of Electoral Roll of 1970. Ext.12 is the certified copy of Electoral Roll of 1970. Ext.13 is the said certified copy of Electoral Roll 1997. Ext.14 is the certified copy of Electoral Roll of 2005. Ext.15 is the certified copy of Electoral Roll of 2011. Ext.16 is her marriage Kabinnama. Ext.17 is certificate of Gaon Burah and Ext.18 is certificate of Mahamaya V.C.D.C.

5.

The learned counsel for the petitioner by referring to the various

exhibits referred above has submitted that the petitioner has been able to show

Page No.# 5/13

and prove that she is the daughter of Amzat Ali @ Amzat Ali Sheikh and the name of her grandfather is Noimuddin Sheikh accordingly, it is submitted that exhibited documents were wrongly appreciated by the learned Tribunal which has vitiated the opinion. Accordingly, the learned counsel for the petitioner prays for setting aside the impugned opinion and to declare the petitioner not a foreigner. 6.

Per contra, the learned standing counsel for the FT and Border

matters has submitted that the petitioner is trying to connect her to one Amzat Ali whose name appears in the voter’s list of 1977. It is submitted that through Amzat Ali, projected father, the petitioner is trying to connect herself to Noimuddin Sheikh her projected grandfather. It is further submitted that existence of the projected father of the petitioner in the State of Assam is only from voter’s list of 1997 (Ext.13) and therefore, the existence of the projected father of the petitioner in the State of Assam is not available before the year 1971. It is also submitted that the marriage certificate would not have relied on by the learned Tribunal as the marriage disclosed in the Kabin Nama was held on 20.09.2002 and since it is not registered after 12 years and moreover, the author of the Kabin Nama was not examined though the entry in the Kabin Nama was made on 30.10.2014 which is about 12 years after purported marriage took place on 20.09.2002. Accordingly, the learned standing counsel for the FT and Border matters prayed for dismissal of this writ petition. 7.

The petitioner had also examined Amzat Ali @ Amzat Ali Sheikh,

her projected father as DW-2. He had reiterated the statement made by the petitioner in her evidence-on-affidavit and he had re-exhibited all the relating documents already exhibited by the petitioner. On a query of the learned Tribunal, the DW-2 had stated that he had put his signature on understanding

Page No.# 6/13

the contents. 8.

The petitioner had also examined one Zakir Hussain Mondal,

LDA at the office of the Election Officer, Dhubri, as DW-3, who had stated in his evidence-on-affidavit that he had brought the Electoral Roll of 1961, containing the name of Noimuddin Shekh, S/o. Kosimuddin, aged 30 years (Ext.5) and he had also exhibited the signature of the Election Officer, Dhubri [Ext.5(i)]. He had also brought the Electoral Roll of 1970, containing the name of Jamiron Bewa, W/o. Noimuddin, aged 36 years (Ext.12) and the signature of the Election Officer [Ext.12(i)]. On a query of the learned Tribunal, DW-3 had also stated that he had put his signature on understanding the contents of the affidavit. 9.

The petitioner had examined one Abdur Rahman Sk. as DW-4,

who is the Govt. appointed Muslim Marriage Registrar and Kazi at Panbari Rangamati, Dist. Dhubri, Assam. He had stated that on 20.09.2002, muslim marriage was held by executing marriage Kabin Nama between Sahidur Rahman, S/o. Md. Gyeas Uddin Shekh, village- Poyasthi Salmara, P.S. South Salmara, Dist. Dhubri, Assam; and Azmira Khatun, daughter of Amzat Ali of village- Chataguri, PS. Bagribari, Dist. Dhurbri, Assam, which was registered by his office vide No. 1053/2016, dated 30.10.2014. He had brought his office register and on being tallied, the contents of the same are found to be correct. He had exhibited the marriage Kabin Nama (Ext.16); his signatures [Ext.16(i) and 16(ii)]; seals [Ext.16(iii) and 16(iv)]; official round seal [Ext.16(v)]; and Marriage Registrar Seal [Ext.16(vi)]. On a query of the learned Tribunal, he had stated that he had put his signature on understanding the contents of the affidavit. Along with his evidence-on-affidavit, the DW-4 had also produced his licence under the Assam Moslem Marrriage and Divorce Act, 1935, dated 13.01.1992, issued by the Inspector General of Registration, Assam. The said

Page No.# 7/13

document contains counter signature by the learned Tribunal with an endorsement “compared with original copy, dated 14.06.2016”. 10.

The petitioner had also examined one Khushiman Barman, the

Gaonburah of Chataguri Part-II village under Bagribari P.S., Dist. Kokrajhar, BTAD, Assam as DW-5. He had exhibited his certificate dated 10.03.2016 (Ext.16); his signature and seal [Ext.17(i)]; official round seal [Ext.17(ii)]; and photo of proceedee Azmira Bibi @ Azmira Khatun [Ext.17(iii)]. On a query of the learned Tribunal, the said witness had also stated that he had put his signature on understanding the contents of the affidavit. 11.

The petitioner has examined one Nurul Islam, Election Assistant

at the office of the Election Officer, Bilsaipara as DW-6. He had brought the record of the Electoral Roll 1966 (Ext.9) containing the names of Noimuddin Shekh, S/o. Kosimuddin, aged 40 years; and Jamiron Bibi, W/o. Noimuddin, aged 32 years. He had exhibited the signature of the Election Officer, Bilasipara [Ext.9(i)]. The said witness had exhibited the Electoral Roll of 1997 (Ext.13), where the voter is Amjat Ali Shekh, S/o. Noimuddin, aged 35 years. He had exhibited the signature of the Election Officer, Bilasipara [Ext.13(i)]. He had exhibited the Electoral Roll of 2011 (Ext.15), where the voter is Amjat Ali Shekh, S/o. Noimuddin, aged 49 years. He had exhibited the signature of the Election Officer, Bilasipara [Ext.15(i)]. On a query of the learned Tribunal, the said witness had submitted that he had put his signature after understanding its contents. 12.

On perusal of the records of the learned Tribunal, it is seen that

the learned Tribunal has not even referred to the 6 (six) other witnesses examined by the petitioner and the documents exhibited by them by producing the originals, which are referred to above.

Page No.# 8/13

13.

In a perfunctory and casual manner, the learned Tribunal has

discussed the evidence and given its reasons. Therefore, it would be appropriate to extract the scanned copy of that part of the opinion and make it a part of this order. This is the relevant portion of the order.

Page No.# 9/13

Page No.# 10/13

Page No.# 11/13

14.

From the scanned copy of the opinion of the learned Tribunal, as

referred above, it is apparent that by referring to the voter list of 1961 (Ext. 5) and the voter list of 1966 (Ext. 9), the learned Tribunal had recorded that the name of the purported grandfather of the petitioner, namely, Naimuddin Shekh is proved on record. Therefore, there appears to be no dispute with regard to the fact that Naimuddin Shekh is the grandfather of the petitioner. However, the entire evidence was rejected on the ground that the petitioner had not been able to prove that her purported father, Amjat Ali, is the son of her purported grandfather, Naimuddin Shekh. 15.

In this case, the petitioner, by examining the Gaonburah of

village- Chataguri Part-II, namely, Khushiman Barman, had made an effort to prove through the said Gaonburah that there was some minor discrepancy in the name of Amzat Ali and Amzat Ali Shekh. 16.

In her written statement as well as in her evidence-on-affidavit,

the petitioner had stated that her father name was Amzat Ali Sheikh and in the Electoral Roll of 1997 and 2005, the name of her father was recorded as Amjat Ali Sheikh and that as per exhibited Kabin Nama, she is the daughter of Md. Amzat Ali. As stated above, the petitioner had examined her projected father, Amzat Ali Sheikh, as DW-2. 17.

Under such circumstances, apart from examining herself, the

petitioner had examined 5 (five) other witnesses, whose names are referred hereinabove, this Court is of the considered opinion that the learned Tribunal had perfunctorily and casually passed the opinion by ignoring the evidence of DW-2 to DW-6, which are available at pages 87 to 90 for DW-2, pages 92 to 93 for DW-3, pages 94 to 97 for DW-4, pages 98 to 100 for DW-5, and pages 102 to 104 for DW-6.

Page No.# 12/13

18.

This appears to be a fit and proper case to hold that the learned

Tribunal has failed to take into consideration the evidence on record, which is found to have vitiated the impugned opinion. 19.

Accordingly, the impugned opinion dated 14.09.2016, passed by

the learned Member, Foreigners’ Tribunal, 6 th Dhubri at Bilasipara, in FT. Case No 6th Dhubri 1-272/2016, arising out of Ref No.1509/D/07 and Tr. No.781/BLP/11 is hereby set aside and quashed. 20.

The matter is remanded back to the learned Tribunal for passing

a fresh opinion after examining all the evidence and exhibited documents on record. 21.

The petitioner, namely, Azmira Bibi @ Azmira Khatun, who is duly

represented by her learned counsel, is directed to appear before the said learned Tribunal within the outer time limit of 04.12.2026 and by producing a certified copy of the order, await for any further order that may be passed by the said learned Tribunal. 22.

It is further provided that on the date of appearance of the

petitioner, she shall be ready and willing to take bail of such sum as may be deemed fit and proper by the learned Tribunal. It is provided that the bail so granted by the learned Tribunal shall be valid for a period of 30 (thirty) days from the date of the opinion that may be passed by the said learned Tribunal. 23.

This writ petition is allowed to the extent as indicated above.

24.

The parties are left to bear their own cost.

25.

The Registry shall expeditiously return back the Tribunal’s record

along with a copy of this order to be made a part of the records by the learned

Page No.# 13/13

Tribunal for future reference.

JUDGE

JUDGE.

Digitally signed by Champak Rajbongshi Date: 2026.11.11 17:13:31 +05'30'

Comparing Assistant

Private Secretary

Related judgments

More Gauhati High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.