Baldev v. State of Hp
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Ranjan Sharma
- Case number
- CWPOA No. 5507 of 2019
- Result
- Disposed Off
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA CWPOA No.5507 of 2019 Decided on: 28.10.2026
__________________________________________________________
Baldev
.....Petitioner Versus
State of H.P. and others
....Respondents
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge 1Whether approved for reporting? Yes
For the petitioner:
Ms. Shikha Chauhan, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Rahul Thakur, Deputy Advocate General, for Respondents No.1, 2 and 4-State. Respondent No.3 and Respondent No.5 stood already proceeded exparte, vide orders dated 29.09.2015.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge Petitioner
had
filed
No.2731 of 2015 before State
an
Original
Application
Administrative Tribunal;
and upon its abolition, the same has been re-transferred to this Court as CWPOA No.5507 of 2019, seeking the following reliefs:-
“7(a)
That the impugned termination order may kindly be quashed and set aside, being illegal and void; and
7(b)
That the respondents be directed to re-instate the services of the applicant with consequent benefits.”
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
FACTUAL MATRIX:
2.
Grievance of
petitioner
that he was
appointed as Post-Graduate Teacher in the subject of English
by
School
Management
Committee,
due
selection by Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Padhar, District Mandi,
on
10.11.2014.
Pursuant
issuance
appointment letter, though the petitioner joined service
Government
15.11.2014
Senior
Secondary
Post-Graduate
School,
Teacher
Sarni
on
English
but
Respondents No.3 and 4 i.e. School Management Committee of Government Senior Secondary School, Sarni, Drang-II, District
Mandi,
have
issued
an
order
on
25.11.2014
[Annexure A-1], terminating the services of the petitioner as Post-Graduate Teacher [English] on the ground, that the petitioner does not fulfill the Educational Qualifications as prescribed in Recruitment Promotion Rules for the said post.
Petitioner has assailed the Termination Order dated
25.11.2014
[Annexure
A-1],
on
ground,
that
aforesaid order was passed in violation of the principles of natural justice and his services could not have been terminated
when,
his
recommended
Post-Graduate
Teacher
case
thereafter under
was he
duly was
considered,
appointed
Respondents
therefore, the Termination Order may be set aside, with
direction
re-instate
petitioner
service,
with
all consequential benefits. STAND OF AFFIDAVIT:
3.
RESPONDENTS-STATE
IN
REPLY-
Pursuant to issuance of Notice, Respondents-
State Authorities have filed Reply-Affidavit dated 09.11.2015 of Director of Higher Education, Himachal Pradesh, stating that services of petitioner were terminated on 25.11.2014,
he
did
not
possess
Minimum
Essential
Qualifications of M.A. in English, as required for the post of Post-Graduate Teacher, in accordance with the Rules. It is averred that School Management Committee had afforded an opportunity to the petitioner to produce the Educational Qualification Certificate of M.A. in English but since the petitioner had failed to establish his eligibility, therefore, the services of the petitioner were terminated by the Respondents in accordance with School Management Committee
Rules. REBUTTAL BY PETITIONER:
4.
Petitioner has filed a Rejoinder stating that stage
test
eligibility
petitioner
for
post was already over and the petitioner had successfully cleared the eligibility criteria and joined the service only
satisfying
competent
authority
therefore
termination of his services by Respondents No.3 and 4, were
without
any
competence,
authority
legal
sanction. 5.
Heard, Ms. Shikha Chauhan, Learned Counsel
for the petitioner and Mr. Rahul Thakur, Learned Deputy Advocate General, for the Respondents-State. ANALYSIS:
6.
Indisputably, the Respondents-State had notified
School
Management
[Annexure R-1].
Committee
on
17.07.2012
Clause-7 of the said Policy indicates that
Head of Institution shall give appointment to the candidates
verifying
Certificates
credentials,
including
per
Educational
Rules.
Perusal of Clause 8 of the SMC Policy provides that no ineligible candidate joins the Educational Institution. In terms of the School Management Committee Policy and the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Post-Graduate Teacher, since the petitioner did not possess the essential qualification of Master’s Degree i.e. M.A. in English,
therefore,
petitioner,
being
ineligible, has
neither any right nor locus to assail his Termination Orders dated 25.11.2014 [Annexure A-1]. Even, the plea of the petitioner that his services were terminated without affording an opportunity of hearing, will not come to the
aid of the petitioner, for the reason, that the Respondents had afforded an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner to produce
Eligibility
Educational
Qualification
Certificate of Master’ Degree-M.A. in English but since the petitioner failed to produce the required certificate, in accordance
with
requirement
SMC
Rules,
therefore,
services were validly dispensed with on 25.11.2014 [Annexure A-1]. Moreover, the claim of the petitioner for reinstatement is devoid of any merit, for the reason, that once the petitioner is ineligible for the post, therefore, an ineligible candidate alike the petitioner has no right to continue
service
permitting
ineligible
continue
shall
amount to perpetuating illegality and shall amount to fraud
public
employment,
which
impermissible.
Merely because the petitioner was allowed to participate in selection
process
was
appointed
had
joined
despite being ineligible for the post, then, the plea that the State Authorities could not have dispensed with his services, cannot come to the rescue of the petitioner, as no estoppel can be invoked against the Statutory Rules and the essential minimum qualification prescribed therein, which the petitioner does not possess. 7.
No other point was pressed/argued.
DIRECTIONS:
8.
Considering the matter in for
reasons
recorded
above perspective
hereinabove,
instant
writ petition, is dismissed, in the following terms:(i)
Termination
Orders
dated
25.11.2014
[Annexure A-1] is upheld; (ii)
Consequent
upon
upholding
termination of the petitioner, the claim for reinstatement
not
tenable;
is accordingly disallowed; and (iii)
Parties to bear their respective costs.
In aforesaid terms, the instant petition and all
pending
miscellaneous
application(s),if
any,
shall
also stand disposed of.
October 28, 2026 [Bhardwaj]
(Ranjan Sharma) Judge