Baldev v. State of Hp

Court
High Court of Himachal Pradesh
Date of judgment
28 October 2026
Judge
Justice Ranjan Sharma
Case number
CWPOA No. 5507 of 2019
Result
Disposed Off
Subject
Service

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA CWPOA No.5507 of 2019 Decided on: 28.10.2026

__________________________________________________________

Baldev

.....Petitioner Versus

State of H.P. and others

....Respondents

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge 1Whether approved for reporting? Yes

For the petitioner:

Ms. Shikha Chauhan, Advocate.

For the respondents:

Mr. Rahul Thakur, Deputy Advocate General, for Respondents No.1, 2 and 4-State. Respondent No.3 and Respondent No.5 stood already proceeded exparte, vide orders dated 29.09.2015.

Ranjan Sharma, Judge Petitioner

had

filed

No.2731 of 2015 before State

an

Original

Application

Administrative Tribunal;

and upon its abolition, the same has been re-transferred to this Court as CWPOA No.5507 of 2019, seeking the following reliefs:-

“7(a)

That the impugned termination order may kindly be quashed and set aside, being illegal and void; and

7(b)

That the respondents be directed to re-instate the services of the applicant with consequent benefits.”

Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

FACTUAL MATRIX:

2.

Grievance of

petitioner

that he was

appointed as Post-Graduate Teacher in the subject of English

by

School

Management

Committee,

due

selection by Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Padhar, District Mandi,

on

10.11.2014.

Pursuant

issuance

appointment letter, though the petitioner joined service

Government

15.11.2014

Senior

Secondary

Post-Graduate

School,

Teacher

Sarni

on

English

but

Respondents No.3 and 4 i.e. School Management Committee of Government Senior Secondary School, Sarni, Drang-II, District

Mandi,

have

issued

an

order

on

25.11.2014

[Annexure A-1], terminating the services of the petitioner as Post-Graduate Teacher [English] on the ground, that the petitioner does not fulfill the Educational Qualifications as prescribed in Recruitment Promotion Rules for the said post.

Petitioner has assailed the Termination Order dated

25.11.2014

[Annexure

A-1],

on

ground,

that

aforesaid order was passed in violation of the principles of natural justice and his services could not have been terminated

when,

his

recommended

Post-Graduate

Teacher

case

thereafter under

was he

duly was

considered,

appointed

Respondents

therefore, the Termination Order may be set aside, with

direction

re-instate

petitioner

service,

with

all consequential benefits. STAND OF AFFIDAVIT:

3.

RESPONDENTS-STATE

IN

REPLY-

Pursuant to issuance of Notice, Respondents-

State Authorities have filed Reply-Affidavit dated 09.11.2015 of Director of Higher Education, Himachal Pradesh, stating that services of petitioner were terminated on 25.11.2014,

he

did

not

possess

Minimum

Essential

Qualifications of M.A. in English, as required for the post of Post-Graduate Teacher, in accordance with the Rules. It is averred that School Management Committee had afforded an opportunity to the petitioner to produce the Educational Qualification Certificate of M.A. in English but since the petitioner had failed to establish his eligibility, therefore, the services of the petitioner were terminated by the Respondents in accordance with School Management Committee

Rules. REBUTTAL BY PETITIONER:

4.

Petitioner has filed a Rejoinder stating that stage

test

eligibility

petitioner

for

post was already over and the petitioner had successfully cleared the eligibility criteria and joined the service only

satisfying

competent

authority

therefore

termination of his services by Respondents No.3 and 4, were

without

any

competence,

authority

legal

sanction. 5.

Heard, Ms. Shikha Chauhan, Learned Counsel

for the petitioner and Mr. Rahul Thakur, Learned Deputy Advocate General, for the Respondents-State. ANALYSIS:

6.

Indisputably, the Respondents-State had notified

School

Management

[Annexure R-1].

Committee

on

17.07.2012

Clause-7 of the said Policy indicates that

Head of Institution shall give appointment to the candidates

verifying

Certificates

credentials,

including

per

Educational

Rules.

Perusal of Clause 8 of the SMC Policy provides that no ineligible candidate joins the Educational Institution. In terms of the School Management Committee Policy and the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Post-Graduate Teacher, since the petitioner did not possess the essential qualification of Master’s Degree i.e. M.A. in English,

therefore,

petitioner,

being

ineligible, has

neither any right nor locus to assail his Termination Orders dated 25.11.2014 [Annexure A-1]. Even, the plea of the petitioner that his services were terminated without affording an opportunity of hearing, will not come to the

aid of the petitioner, for the reason, that the Respondents had afforded an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner to produce

Eligibility

Educational

Qualification

Certificate of Master’ Degree-M.A. in English but since the petitioner failed to produce the required certificate, in accordance

with

requirement

SMC

Rules,

therefore,

services were validly dispensed with on 25.11.2014 [Annexure A-1]. Moreover, the claim of the petitioner for reinstatement is devoid of any merit, for the reason, that once the petitioner is ineligible for the post, therefore, an ineligible candidate alike the petitioner has no right to continue

service

permitting

ineligible

continue

shall

amount to perpetuating illegality and shall amount to fraud

public

employment,

which

impermissible.

Merely because the petitioner was allowed to participate in selection

process

was

appointed

had

joined

despite being ineligible for the post, then, the plea that the State Authorities could not have dispensed with his services, cannot come to the rescue of the petitioner, as no estoppel can be invoked against the Statutory Rules and the essential minimum qualification prescribed therein, which the petitioner does not possess. 7.

No other point was pressed/argued.

DIRECTIONS:

8.

Considering the matter in for

reasons

recorded

above perspective

hereinabove,

instant

writ petition, is dismissed, in the following terms:(i)

Termination

Orders

dated

25.11.2014

[Annexure A-1] is upheld; (ii)

Consequent

upon

upholding

termination of the petitioner, the claim for reinstatement

not

tenable;

is accordingly disallowed; and (iii)

Parties to bear their respective costs.

In aforesaid terms, the instant petition and all

pending

miscellaneous

application(s),if

any,

shall

also stand disposed of.

October 28, 2026 [Bhardwaj]

(Ranjan Sharma) Judge

Related judgments

More Himachal Pradesh High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.