Bhagwan Sahay and Others v. Dhandev(since Deceased Through Lr's Geeta Devi) and Others
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
- Date of judgment
- 30 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Bipin Chander Negi
- Case number
- FAO No. 337 of 2018
- Result
- Dismissed
- Advocates
- Dalip Singh Kaith
- Subject
- Civil, Motor accident
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA FAO(MVA) No.337 of 2018. Date of Decision: 30th October, 2026.
Bhagwan Sahay and Ors.
.....Appellants.
Versus
Dhandev (since deceased) through LRs Geeta Devi & Ors. …..Respondents. Coram The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge. Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Appellants:
Mr. Dalip Singh Kaith, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Nishant Khidtta, Advocate, for respondents No.1(a) to 1(c) and 2. Mr. Raman Sethi, respondent No.3.
Advocate,
for
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge (oral). The present appeal has been preferred against the impugned judgment dated 21.05.2018, passed by the learned
Motor
Accident
Claims
Tribunal-II,
Shimla,
whereby the claim petition preferred by the present appellants has been dismissed on account of the fact that the claimants/appellants have failed to prove rashness and negligence of respondent No. 2, i.e., driver of the vehicle in question. 2.
As
per
claimants/appellants,
Anand
Kumar, his sister Archana Sharma, brother-in-law Anand
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? YES
Swarup, and Ms. Narvada Devi were travelling in an Alto taxi bearing registration No.HP-01A-8448 from Shimla to Naina
Devi
on
08.03.2014.
When
taxi
reached
Ghambrola Pul, it went off the road, as a result of which Ms. Narvada Devi succumbed to her injuries on the spot. The accident, as per the claimants, had occurred on account of the rash and negligent driving on the part of the driver-Kamlesh Kumar. 3.
Per contra, the case of respondent No.1
(owner) and respondent No. 2 (driver) is that the accident had occurred on account of a hit by a truck, which was coming from behind, and the driver (respondent No.2Kamlesh Kumar) was not at fault at the time of the accident. 4.
One of the present appellants, namely Shri
Bhagwan Sahay, had appeared as a witness during the trial as PW-3. According to him, the deceased was his sister, who had died in the motor accident on 08.03.2014. The said individual had further stated that the accident in question had occurred due to the rash and negligent driving on the part of respondent No.2, i.e., driverKamlesh Kumar. The FIR, Ex.PW-3/A, had been tendered
in evidence by the said Shri Bhagwan Sahay. Reference of the FIR had been made in the claim petition. 5.
ASI Rajinder Singh had appeared as a witness
during trial as RW-5. On account of him being posted in PS Sadar, Bilaspur in the year 2014, he had investigated
matter
in
pursuance
of
FIR
Ex.PW-3/A.
After
completion of investigation, the case file had been handed over by the said ASI Rajinder Singh to Inspector/SHO, PS Sadar, Bilaspur, who prepared the untraced report Ex.RW4/A. During his testimony, ASI Rajinder Singh had deposed that he had prepared a spot map Ex. RW-5/A. He had further deposed that the accident had occurred on account of some unknown truck hitting the Alto taxi in the case at hand from behind, as a result of which the taxi went off the road. Since the driver of the unknown truck could not be found, therefore, an untraced report had been filed. In his cross-examination, he had categorically stated that since no rash and negligent act of driving had been found qua respondent No.2, i.e., driver Kamlesh Kumar, hence no case had been registered against the said individual. 6.
The Criminal Ahlmad of the Court of Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur, one Shri Mukesh Garg, had appeared and deposed at trial as RW-4. He had tendered
the copy of FIR as Ex.RW-4/A and had also tendered a copy of the statement of the complainant, Ex.RW-4/B. He further categorically deposed that till his examination on 28.10.2017, no objections had been filed against the untraced report. 7. Motor
In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the Accident
Claims
Tribunal-II,
Shimla
correctly
concluded that both the parties have placed reliance on the FIR and the untraced report submitted by PS Sadar, Bilaspur. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-II correctly observed
that
though
PW-2
Anand
Kumar,
whose
statement FIR Ex. PW-3/A had been registered, in his deposition before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-II had deposed a different version of the accident in the case at hand, yet he had not opted to file any objections before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur where the police had filed the untraced report. Along with the untraced report, a mechanical report had also been filed wherein it has been mentioned that the Alto car in question was pressed, thereby showing that the taxi was struck by the truck from behind. 8.
Once the FIR in the case at hand is being
relied upon by the claimants/appellants, hence they cannot
be permitted to turn around and contend to the contrary that the contents contained therein have not been proved. 9.
In this respect, reliance has correctly been
placed upon the judgment of the Apex Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Premlata Shukla and Ors., 2007 ACJ 1928.
Relevant extract whereof stands
reproduced in the impugned judgment.
For the aforesaid reasons, the present appeal
is dismissed being devoid of any merit, so also the pending application(s), if any.
(Bipin Chander Negi) Judge 30th October, 2026 (Gaurav Rawat)