Bikram Chatterji & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 23 July 2019
- Judge
- Justice Arun Mishra
- Neutral citation
- 2019 INSC 799
- Reported in
- [2019] 9 S.C.R. 289
- Result
- Dismissed not complying condition order
- Acts & sections
- Section 12 Consumer Protection Act, Article 32 Constitution
- Subject
- Service, Property & land, Consumer
Full judgment
[2019] 9 S.C.R. 289
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS.
v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (Writ Petition (C) No. 940 of 2017) JULY 23, 2019
[ARUN MISHRA AND UDAY UMESH LALIT, JJ.] Housing: Housing projects – By a Group of companies – Proposing to construct approximately 42,000 flats – The projects were registered under RERA – Booking of flats by various home-buyers during the years 2010-2014 – Standard Form of Allotment-cum-Flat Buyers Agreement stated that delivery of possession within 36 months – Builder got the land from Noida and Greater Noida Authorities on paying 10% of the land price – Builders also took loans from the Banks for the project on mortgaging the land with the Banks – Home-buyers paid the amount from 50% to 100% abiding by the payment schedule – Builders failed to deliver the flats within 36 months – They did not pay the balance amount towards the land to the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities and also failed to repay the loans taken from the Banks – Some of the consumers filed consumer complaint under Consumer Protection Act – Bank, for recovery of the loan, filed company petition under s.7 of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) appointed Interim Resolution Professional (IRP) and declared Moratorium restricting institution of any suit against the corporate debtor – Thereupon writ petitions u/Art.32 were filed by home-buyers – Several orders by Supreme Court giving the builder opportunity to go ahead with project work and complete the same – Orders were not complied by the builder – Forensic audit of the companies of the builder directed by the Court – Court directed freezing of individual accounts of the Directors of all the 40 companies and also directed attachment of the properties in the individual names of the Directors – Held: The Noida and Greater Noida Authorities were grossly negligent in reviewing and monitoring progress of the project and in collusion with the builders, failed to take action for non-payment of its dues – They illegally permitted
the builders to sub-lease the land – The officials of Authorities have acted in clear breach of public trust and have failed to act as per statutory mandate, Regulations and terms of the Lease Deed – The mortgage of the land with the Bank was without obtaining clear NOC which was a condition precedent for creation of Mortgage – Thus, no mortgage in the eye of law has been created – Moreover, the money borrowed from the Bank was not utilized for the project and the same was diverted for creation of other assets – The Bank also failed to check whether the money, in fact was required for the project and used for the same – Therefore, the Banks and the Authorities can realize their money only from those assets and from the Guarantors and not from investment of home buyers – There has been blatant violation of provisions of RERA – In the circumstances of the case, principle of ‘fraud vitiates’ is attracted and such transaction would become unenforceable and would be against the public trust doctrine – It is bounden duty of court not only to save the home-buyers but also to ensure that they are not cheated – Therefore, the registration of the builder companies under RERA is cancelled – The Lease-Deeds in favour of the Companies are also cancelled – Construction work in the projects is handed over to NBCC – Rights of the lessee shall vest in the Court Receiver – Real Estate Regulation and Development Act, 2016 – Uttar Pradesh Industrial Area Development Act, 1976. Doctrines/Principles: Principle of ‘fraud vitiates’ – Applicability of. Doctrine of ‘public trust’ – Applicability of.
Issuing directions, the Court HELD : 1.1 In the instant matter, the question of larger public importance is involved. A large–scale cheating has taken place and middle and poor class home buyers have been duped and deprived of their hardearned money and lifetime. By the Amrapali Group, the buyers’ money which has been obtained has not been invested in the construction activities, rather it has been diverted to a great extent. Money obtained from the banks has also not been invested in the projects and has been diverted elsewhere to acquire other assets. This is not only with respect
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
to the Amrapali builders that projects have not been completed as reflected in the affidavits of Noida and Greater Noida Authorities. More than 70% of the projects have not been completed which were initiated way–back in the year 2008–09 and were supposed to be completed within 3 years. [Para 69] [531-F-G]
1.2 If the real estate business has to survive in India, it has to be answerable to the public and has necessarily to uphold the trust reposed in builders/promoters. They have been paid huge amounts not only by the home buyers but also, they have to pay a huge amount for the public land given to them on lease by Noida and Greater Noida Authorities for construction of houses. The land has been given to them by the authorities on a concessional basis by making payment of 10% amount at the time of allotment. The builders have to be accountable to public/home buyers as well as the authorities and bankers. It is a matter relating to housing needs dealing with shelter place, such an activity is of the public importance as the real estate sector plays a pivotal role in the fulfilment of needs of housing infrastructure. [Para 73] [532-F-H] 2.1 It is apparent from the report of the forensic audit submitted by Forensic Auditors that there is a serious kind of fraud played upon the buyers in active connivance with the officials of the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities and that of the banks. The money of the home buyers has been diverted. The Directors diverted the money by the creation of dummy companies, realizing professional fees, creating bogus bills, selling flats at undervalue price, payment of excessive brokerage, etc. They have obtained investment from J.P. Morgan in violation of FEMA and FDI norms. The shares were overvalued for making payment to J.P. Morgan. It was adopted as a device for siphoning off the money of the home buyers to foreign countries. In view of the huge money collected from the buyers and comparable investments made in the projects, there was no necessity to obtain a loan from banks. The amount so obtained was not used in the projects. The mortgage deeds in favour of the banks were not permissible due to non-payment of dues of the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities. The Noida and Greater Noida Authorities issued
conditional NOCs. to create mortgages subject to payment of dues which were not paid. They issued such NOCs in collusion with builders. It was incumbent upon the bankers also to obtain clear unconditional NOCs. which were not obtained and to ensure that the dues were paid to Noida and Greater Noida authorities. They permitted diversion of money immediately after sanctioning of the loan and also in day to day transactions of Amrapali group of companies. [Para 146] [580-D-H; 581-A] 2.2 No accounts were prepared w.e.f. the years 2015-2018 and money withdrawn was diverted during the said period. The Statutory Auditor, failed in duty and was part of fraudulent activities as found in the Forensic Report. The money obtained from banks was diverted to unapproved uses such as for the creation of personal assets of Directors, creation of assets in closely held companies by the Directors along with their partners and relatives, for personal expenses of Directors, to give advances without carrying interest for several years. There was total non– monitoring by the bankers. The money laundering was resorted to by Amrapali Group/ Directors. [Para 147] [581-B-C] 2.3 The statement filed on the expenditure of Rs.10,000 crores is nothing but a scrap of paper not supported by the books of account, supporting documents. It has to be outrightly rejected as there is an attempt made on siphoning off, apparent from the report of the Forensic Auditors also. [Para 142] [578-F-G] 2.4 The diversion of huge amount of Rs. 2,996.20 crores has been rightly detected on Forensic Audit. The Forensic Auditors have given the details in their report along with reasons. As to other amounts with respect to advances which are recoverable, the explanation that there is a surrender of shares etc. is not supported by books of accounts. There is no basis to contend so. No proper explanation has been given on behalf of Amrapali Group. The finding as to the diversion of home buyers’ funds is based on the figures worked on the basis of minute accounting as reflected in the auditors’ report. There is no proper answer to each and every entry which have been gone into by the Auditors. General and broad submissions have been made which are flimsy and have no legs to stand. [Paras 143, 144 and 145] [579-F-H; 580-A-B]
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
3.1 The public trust doctrine imposes on the State and its functionaries a mandate to take affirmative action for effective management, and the citizens are empowered to question its ineffectiveness. The land of the farmers had been acquired for the purpose of housing and infrastructure needs, by the State Government and handed over to the concerned authorities for construction. They are bound to ensure that builders act in accordance with the objective behind the acquisition of land and the conditions on which allotment had been made. It was a duty of concerned officials; they are not only enjoined to ensure that the rights of the home buyers are protected but also the interests of the authorities; and bankers. The public authorities are duty– bound to observe that the leased property is not frittered away along with the money of the home buyers. Affirmative action was clearly enjoined upon them not only under the statutory provisions of various enactments but also under the public trust doctrine. [Para 73] [533-A-D]
Noida Entrepreneurs Association v. Noida & Ors. (2011) 6 SCC 508 : [2011] 8 SCR 25 ; Natural Resources Allocation, In re, Special Reference No.1 of 2012 (2012) 10 SCC 1 : [2012] 9 SCR 311 ; Association of Unified Tele Services Providers & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. (2014) 6 SCC 110 : [2014] 9 SCR 780 – relied on. 3.2 In the instant case, it is apparent that there are colossal dues of Noida and Greater Noida Authorities. There were several defaults in making the payment of the premium amount, lease money, even the money payable to the farmers as compensation for land acquisition has not been paid by the builders, though the builder has realised from home buyers the amount payable to authorities of Noida and Greater Noida as a component of the price payable by them. [Para 76] [535-F-H; 536-A] 3.3 The transfer of the plot by the lessee was only on fulfilment of certain conditions. The dues of lessor towards the cost of land were to be cleared in accordance with the schedule of payment. It was specifically provided in lease deed condition No.(ii)(c) that the lessee shall use the allotted plot for construction
of group housing/flats/plots. Condition No.(ii)(c)(iii) deals with the part transfer of the plot. It lays down normally the permission for part–transfer of the plot shall not be granted under any circumstances. The lessee shall not be entitled to complete the transaction for sale, transfer, assign or otherwise part with possession of the whole or any part of the building constructed thereon before making payment according to the schedule specified in the lease deed of the plot to the lessor. By way of sub–lease of the plot, the transfer of plots could not have been made by the lessee. The lessee was required to start construction within 12 months from the date of possession. The date of execution of lease deed was to be treated as the date of possession. The lessee was required to complete the construction of minimum 15% of the total FAR of the allotted plot as per the approved layout plan and get occupancy/completion certificate within 3 years from the date of execution of the lease deed. Cancellation of lease deed was also provided in the case of violation of directions, or rules, regulations or in case of the default on the part of the lessee for breach or violation of terms and conditions of the registration/allotment/lease and/or non–deposit of allotment amount. [Paras 78, 80 and 81] [536-E-F; 538-D-F; 540-B-D] 3.4 The lease deed/allotment was to be governed by the provisions of the U.P. Industrial Area Development Act, 1976 and by the rules and/or regulations made or directions issued under the Act. The lessor w as required to monitor the implementation of the project. In larger public interest the lessor was also given a right to take back possession of the land/building by making payment at the prevailing rate. [Para 82] [541-C-E] 3.5 Once the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities knew very well that there were defaults, they could not have allotted further land to the Amrapali group without insisting for payment of its dues. Secondly, it was not open to the authorities to permit the sub–leases of plot of land executed by builders, thereby allowing the leaseholder to earn a huge amount without making payment of the amount due to them. The officials of the authorities have acted in clear breach of public trust. They have permitted the defaulting leaseholders to earn the amount by sub–leasing
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
its land of which dues had not been cleared. Thus, apparently, the officials of the authorities acted clearly in collusion with the builders and overlooked the interest of the Authorities and home buyers while permitting the sub–leases of plot of land to be granted. The action of the officials of the authorities has the effect of causing unjust enrichment of builder from the land held by the concerned authorities. It was wholly an illegal exercise permitted. [Para 77] [536-B-D]
3.6 The leases had been granted by Noida and Greater Noida Authorities subject to the provisions contained in U.P. Industrial Area Development Act, 1976. Section 13 of the U.P. Industrial Area Development Act, 1976 deals with imposition of penalty and mode of recovery of arrears, which states that where any transferee makes any default in the payment of any consideration money or instalment thereof or any other amount due on account of the transfer of any site or building by the Authority or any rent due to the Authority in respect of any lease or where any transferee or occupier makes any default in payment of any amount of fee or tax levied under the Act, in addition to the amount of arrears, a further sum not exceeding that amount shall be recovered from the transferee or occupier by way of penalty. Under Section 13– A, any amount payable to the Authority under Section 13 shall constitute a charge over the property and may be recovered as arrears of land revenue or by attachment and sale of property in the manner provided under the provisions of Uttar Pradesh Municipal Corporations Act, 1959 (Act no.2 of 1959). Section 14 provides for the resumption of any site or building and forfeiture of whole or any part of the money if any paid in respect thereof. [Para 95] [549-B-E] 3.7 Public trust doctrine requires an affirmative action, which was envisaged not only statutorily but under the Scheme also. The Authorities were required to ensure that projects were completed within the stipulated period, otherwise, the very purpose of the grant would stand frustrated and colossal loss of public money. Amrapali Group did not pay even the amount due to be paid to the landowners on the part of land acquisition, it did not pay premium annual lease amount interest to Authorities.
They have violated every condition, but still, Authorities were bent upon to condone everything. This reflects absolute dereliction of duty cast upon the Authorities. [Para 96] [550-B-C] 3.8 Thus, the officials of the Noida and Greater Noida authorities have acted clearly in a breach of public trust and apart from that, they have failed to act as per the statutory mandate, the regulations and the terms of the lease deed. [Para 78] [536-E-F] 4.1 With respect to the creation of mortgage deed in favour of bankers etc., Noida Authority has submitted that every mortgage permission is granted by the Noida Authority to the individual company of Amrapali group wherein a provision is made that Noida Authority has first charge/priority over all other charges including those created in favour of banks and financial institutions. One of the conditions on which permission to mortgage was that permission to mortgage was to be effective on making full payment of the premium and up to date annual lease rent of group housing plot and after execution of the sub– lease deed in favour of the allottee of the dwelling unit, the allottee/ sub–lessee was to be governed by the terms and conditions of allotment/lease deed of the plot to be executed and sub–lease deed to be executed in favour of the allottee/sub–lessee. Since at no point of time, payment of premium due had been made and up to date annual lease rent had not been paid, no mortgage could have been created in favour of the bank in view of specific condition. [Paras 83 and 84] [542-B-C; 543-C-E] 4.2 In order to create a mortgage, it was necessary to obtain clear NOC in order to create effective mortgage deed. As that has not been done so far, no mortgage in the eye of law has been created in favour of the bank. It was not open to the bankers to mortgage the land in view of the conditional permission to create mortgage, the mortgage created in violation of condition cannot be said to be effective in accordance with law as the land was owned by the concerned authorities and the lessees had right to mortgage only subject to fulfilment of conditions imposed by the lessor/authorities. [Para 84] [543-F-G]
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
4.3 Issuance of conditional NOC was with ulterior motive, there was no reason to issue such a conditional permission, subject to which mortgage could have been made. They could not have issued any conditional permission for creation of a mortgage also without payment of amount due, permission has been issued obviously for being misused, in collusion with the officials of the bank and Authorities. It was incumbent upon the concerned authorities not to issue such an NOC for a mortgage and it was incumbent upon the bank officials in order to create a valid mortgage to ascertain from the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities that the condition imposed by them as condition precedent to create a mortgage had been fulfilled and to obtain clear NOC. But that is how in illegal manner the public money is obtained from banks for the purpose of construction activity and then it was not used for that purpose, and there was a diversion of money. [Para 85] [544-B-E]
4.4 The banks not only have failed to ensure that mortgage was effected in accordance with the law, but also they have failed to check whether money was in fact, required for the projects and was used for purpose it was lent. Money borrowed from bank, in fact, was not required for completion of these projects as the money paid by the buyers was enough for that purpose, but that was also diverted and the money obtained from the banks was also not utilised for the purpose it was taken and it was well within the knowledge of the bankers and Authorities that the funds were being diverted, but they remained mute spectators. It has been observed in extensive detail in the forensic audit report that the Banks did not monitor utilisation of funds and acted as a mute spectator to diversion which was almost happening evidently in all banking transactions. [Paras 85 and 86] [544-G-H; 545-A-C]
4.5 There was negligence on the part of Bank of Baroda and merely proceeding before the Court to recover the amount is not going to serve the purpose. More so, in view of the finding of the Forensic Audit that there was no necessity of obtaining the loan from the Bankers as Amrapali Group had sufficient money from the home buyers, which has also been diverted and has not been utilised in the construction activities. Other assets have
been created with the help of the same and the borrowings have been used in order to siphon off the money by making payment of some unusual amount not only to J.P. Morgan, but also to IPFII Singapore in violation of the FEMA Rules and FDI Rules as found by the Auditors in the respective cases. [Para 93] [548-D-F]
4.6 The Noida and Greater Noida Authorities and the Bankers have permitted diversion of funds of home–buyers and the possession of other assets by Amrapali Group. The buyers’ money had been diverted, which was meant for construction on payment of dues of Authorities in case they were paid timely by the Amrapali Group to the Authorities and to the Banks substantively liability would have been cleared. But by their inaction and rather conniving, the buyers were cheated by the Amrapali Group. [Para 97] [550-D-E]
4.7 Whatever complete/incomplete structures are there, the Authorities are claiming that buyers have no right and they have the first charge on the structure as they have to recover the amount, only thereafter if anything is left out, can be paid to the buyers. In case the submission is accepted, it would amount to playing further fraud upon the fraud. It was incumbent upon the Authorities as well as the Banks to prevent the fraud. Now, if Banks, as well as the Authorities, are permitted to recover the amount from the home–buyers’ investment, in that case, it would be equally unjust and would be against the conscience of the law and nothing would be left for buyers not even a brick and the structures have come up by investing their money. Law never permits unjust gain based upon fraud. The principle “fraud vitiates” is clearly attracted and such a transaction would become unenforceable and would be against the public trust doctrine. Therefore, it is the bounden duty of the Court to act as parens patria not only to save the home–buyers but also to ensure that they are not cheated. [Para 97] [550-F-H; 551-A-B] 4.8 The kind of fraud that has taken place not only in Amrapali Group of Companies but at large as more than 70 percent of the various projects have not come up, is alarming to the Courts to take affirmative steps with the direction to prevent such frauds, restore the money of home–buyers and to punish incumbents
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
responsible for such act. At the same time to ensure that buildings are completed. [Para 98] [551-C-D]
4.9 In the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, it has to be secured and recovered by way of selling other attached properties and the one, which have been created out of the diverted funds of the home–buyers and property of guarantors etc. The banks’ borrowings have to be taken care of in a similar manner. The money payable to the Authorities had been diverted and huge amount of buyers’ money had not been invested in the projects neither any part of the money of bank borrowings, in fact, were spent in the construction as found by the Forensic Auditors. The promoters are held accountable for the diversion of the money paid by the buyers as component of price of flats even on account of payment to Authorities. [Para 123] [567-D-F] 4.10 The stand of the Noida is clear that without payment of land dues no mortgage could be effected. Thus, in fact in the eye of the law no mortgage could be created as there was no permission to mortgage unless the dues were paid and thus the bank could not have mortgaged the property before clearance of the dues of the Noida Authority, and secondly, the mortgage was permissible for the purpose of financing the investment in the project. As a matter of fact, when this was the stipulation, it was the banker’s duty to ensure that money made available was invested in the project. [Para 126] [568-E-F] 4.11 The Forensic Auditors’ report makes it apparent that Bankers have failed to ensure and oversee that the money was invested in the projects. It was diverted elsewhere as rightly found by the Forensic Auditors. Thus, no charge can be said to have been created by bank loans on the projects as the money, in fact, it has not been used in the projects as such home buyers cannot be saddled with liability and also the projects. The money borrowed from banks was used to create other assets worth thousands of crores. Thus, the banks can realise their money from those assets and from guarantors and not from the investment of home buyers, not from the buildings in which loans granted by banks have not been invested. Home buyers are not direct party to the bank loan, thus it was the duty of the bankers
and Noida authorities, if they wanted to impose their charge, to ensure that no fraud takes place and money is invested in the projects for the purpose for which it has been taken not only the money paid by the home buyers but obtained from the banks and due to be paid to Noida authorities, is not usurped illegally by promoter/builder. Though it was realised as part of the component of the price of flat from the home buyers, by the promoters/ builders its illegal diversion was permitted by Amrapali Group in connivance with the officers of the authorities and the bank. Thus, the very condition of investment in the project by bankers, subject to which the mortgage was permissible, had been violated. Thus, it cannot be said that any charge of the banks has been created on the projects. The charge would be on the property which has been purchased/created by dubious methods. It would be inequitable to fasten the charge against the investment made by the home buyers whereas they have not been benefited and rather have been cheated by the promoters for which bankers, as well as authorities, have to share the blame. [Para 127] [568-G-H; 569-A-E] 4.12 Though the home buyers may not be a secured creditor, they have a right to be treated in accordance with the law, fairly and they cannot be subjected to a fraudulent action by the promoters, that too in connivance with the bankers and officials of the Noida and Greater Noida authorities. [Para 128] [569-F-G] 4.13 No doubt about it as submitted on behalf of Amrapali group of companies, that the provisions of RERA are for protecting the interests of promoters also. No doubt about it that the RERA intends to protect the interests of the promoters and home buyers both. However, in the instant case, we have given the opportunity to the promoters to deposit the 10% of the amount in December 2017 and January 2018 but orders have met with non–compliance with all impunity. Thereafter on the assurance of the Amrapali Group that it would undertake the construction work and a joint plan was submitted after great wastage of time and energy and then order dated 17.5.2018 was passed that was also not complied with. It was passed on a condition that a sum of Rs.250 crores to be deposited which was also not deposited by the Amrapali group to show its bona fide. The Group never
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
intended right from the beginning to complete the construction work, has been rightly observed by Forensic Auditors. Thereafter, we have assigned the work to the NBCC. But at the same time, the effort has been made by Amrapali Group/ its Directors to sell the property which has been created by diversion of home buyers’ funds. Incorrect facts have been stated and suppressions have been made in various affidavits filed in this Court that the certain properties are not encumbered. Various applications are being filed one after the other by the encumbered holders with respect to several properties that they have the charge over the said property. [Para 129] [570-A-E]
4.14 That apart, several attached properties have been put to sale by DRT under the orders of this Court. In most of the cases, no buyers have turned up and/or the price offered by forming a cartel are too low. The property cannot be sold at throw away price. Amrapali group is instrumental in not allowing the properties to be sold. There appears to be some invisible hand holding buyers out and even the bankers are not coming up to finance the purchasers, is the genuine grievance pointed out at the Bar. Be that as it may. Entire gamut of facts indicates the contumacious conduct of Amrapali Group, proper and correct disclosures on oath have not been made, even encumbrances are not being specified clearly in spite of repeated orders. They have sold several valuable properties during pendency of petitions as pointed out by the Forensic Audit Report. In the aforesaid circumstances, under the provisions of the RERA their interest cannot be protected. [Para 130] [570-E-H; 571-A]
4.15 Considering the serious kind of fraud unearthed on the forensic audit, formation of dummy companies, violation of norms of foreign investment, violation of FEMA, siphoning off the money of home buyers, making payment of dividend without profits and a methodology had been devised of valuing the shares on an unreasonable higher basis so as to siphon out the money of the home buyers to J.P. Morgan etc. The creation of a large number of assets with the help of money of the home buyers. Right from 2015, no construction activity has taken place. Account books had not been maintained and money has been transferred
continuously. No audit was made. Money was taken out from banks, and fake purchases have been made. Thus, they are not at all entitled for any indulgence under the provisions of the RERA. In view of their unholy conduct, defying description, their contumacious fraudulent conduct totally disentitles them and they are required to be dealt with as sternly as possible so as to make it exemplary one that such fraudulent actions do not recur in future, in real estate business in India. [Para 130] [571-A-D] 4.16 There was no force majeure condition or any legal impediment and as such the period from 2011 to 2015 cannot be treated as a moratorium period vis-à-vis the dues of Noida and Greater Noida authorities. The submission made as to the farmers’ agitation etc. is too vague and 30% of the projects have come up; whereas 70% have not yet come up, out of the projects in Noida and Greater Noida alone. [Para 141] [577-F-G] 5.1 The Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Bill, 2013 (RERA) was intended to standardise business practices and transactions in the real estate sector. It intends to ensure consumer protection. It intends to regulate transaction related to both residential and commercial projects. It is apparent from the aims and objectives of RERA that the Act ensures greater accountability towards consumers and significantly reduce fraud and delays. Accountability standards have been laid down where duties cast upon promotors as well as the effort has been made to make consumer also responsible. [Paras 104 and 105] [554-F; 557-E] 5.2 In view of the provisions of the RERA Act, in the instant case, it was necessary to deposit the amount in the account. A blatant violation of the provisions of RERA has been done by the Amrapali Group. Since RERA contemplates timely completion of projects once registration has been granted under Section 5 and extension of registration under Section 6, it is only in the event of force majeure in case there is no default on the part of the promoter, registration can be extended in aggregate for the period not exceeding one year. Force majeure shall mean a case of war, flood, drought, fire, cyclone, earthquake or any other calamity caused by nature. The registration granted under
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Section 5 is valid for a period declared by the promoter. [Paras 109 and 110] [559-G-H; 560-A-B]
5.3 Section 7 provides that the Authority may on receipt of a complaint or suo motu or on the recommendation of the competent authority revoke the registration granted under Section 5 in case promoter makes default in doing anything required by or under the Act or the rules or the regulation made thereunder; the promoter violates any of the terms of approval given by the competent authority; the promoter is involved in any kind of unfair practice or irregularities. It is also independently provided that in case the promoter indulges in any fraudulent practices, the registration can be revoked. Upon revocation of the registration, the promoter shall be debarred from accessing the website in relation to that project under Section 7(4)(a). Under Section 7(4)(b), the Authority shall facilitate the remaining development works to be carried out in accordance with provisions of Section 8. [Para 110] [560-B-D] 5.4 It is clear that RERA intends for completion of the project in case any fraud is committed by the promoter and the activity is not completed, the home–buyers cannot be left in lurch, allowing the prayer on behalf of Bankers as well as by the Authorities would amount to unfair treatment of home buyers in the facts of this case. It is too late for them to submit that home buyer has no rights in the teeth of the provisions contained in the RERA, which intends to prevent fraud. [Para 111] [562-B] 5.5 Once registration lapses on non–completion of project within the time stipulated or it is revoked the consequence ensue as enumerated in Section 8 of RERA, the Authority is enjoined upon the duty to consult with the appropriate Government to take such action as it may deem including the carrying out of the remaining development works by competent authority or by the association of allottees or any other manner as may be determined by the Authority. The development work has to be completed and cannot be left in between. [Para 112] [562-C-D]
5.6 As per the provisions of Section 11, the promoter shall be responsible to obtain the completion certificate or the
occupancy certificate. He shall also be responsible for providing and maintaining the essential services on reasonable charges, till taking over of the maintenance by the association of the allottees. The promoter shall enable the formation of an association or society or co–operative society or federation of allottees. He shall pay all outgoings until he transfers the physical possession to the allottee. After he has executed an agreement for sale for any apartment, plot or building, he may not mortgage or create a charge on such an apartment, plot or building and if any such mortgage or charge is made or created then notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, it shall not affect the right and interest of the allottee. [Para 113] [562-H; 563-A-C] 5.7 It is apparent that after the transfer of conveyance deed, the title vests in the allottee and of the common area in the association of the allottees or the competent authority as the case may be. No title remains with the promoter. In case promoter fails to complete or is unable to give possession of an apartment, plot or building, he shall be liable on demand to the allottees. In case the allottee wants to withdraw from the project, without prejudice to any other remedy available, the promoter has to return the amount received in respect of that apartment, plot, building with interest in this behalf including compensation in the manner as provided under the Act. [Paras 116 and 117] [564-E-G] 5.8 It is apparent that RERA intends protection of home– buyers and aims at completion of the buildings. The buildings have to be completed. The task has already been assigned to NBCC by the Court for completion of buildings as the promoters/ builders have failed to complete the building within the time fixed and the time which could have been extended. Now, more than 10 years have passed and buyers were given the assurances that they would get flats within three years period by the promoter/ builder. The maximum time fixed in RERA has also expired and extension could not have been beyond 1 year. It is clear that common areas as provided under Section 17 have to be ultimately handed over to the Association of Allottees or the Competent Authority as the case may be. Thus, any sub–lease, alienation or
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
transfer affected by the promoter of the common areas as defined in the RERA and otherwise reserved under the plan shall be void and inoperative. [Paras 120 and 121] [566-F-H; 567-A]
5.9 The contention on behalf of the Bank is that the agreement of promoter/builder with home buyers is unregistered as such, no right has been created in the immovable property in view of the provisions contained in section 49 of the Registration Act. The contention ignores and overlooks the provisions of RERA which intends to prevent such frauds on home buyers and ensure completion of projects and that of the agreement between promoters and buyers. There are various rights under the agreement as well as under the RERA. The agreement entered into at the time of allotment is the basis of the investment in the projects made by home buyers, it cannot be said to be a scrap of paper. It is their valuable investment which is required to be protected and cannot be permitted to be taken away by builder or secured creditors in an illegal manner. The provisions of section 17 of the Registration Act no doubt provide that a document of title requires compulsory registration, no doubt registered document has to be executed that also has to be taken care of by the Court so as to protect the interest of home buyers. [Para 132] [571-G; 572-A-B] 5.10 The two expressions of the provisions of Section 11(4)(g) of RERA Act are significant. Firstly, which the promoter has collected from the allottees. Secondly “which are related to the project”. In the instant case dues of the Noida/Greater Noida authorities have been collected from the allottees by the promoters but the authorities have permitted diversion of said amount by not taking any action in view of the chronic default right from the beginning. Though they knew that the promoter had booked the flats, even the permission to grant sub–lease of the plot had been granted in totally illegal manner without payment of dues of premium and lease rent etc. Conditional permission to the mortgage was issued without payment of the premium lease money etc. so as to perpetuate the fraud being done by the promoters. The mortgage created ought to have been objected in view of the conditions subject to which it could have been done.
Obviously, it was done by Amrapali Group in connivance with officials of Authorities including the bankers. Thus when the authorities have themselves permitted fraudulent action money has been diverted, which has been paid by home buyers for payment to Authorities also, as premium was component of price and as bankers have also permitted diversion of loan amount, mostly on same day, it cannot be said in the facts of the case, that any amount of the bankers or that of authorities remains invested in the project. The sine qua non is the expression “which are related to the project” would mean that that amount recoverable from the allottee is the one which has been invested in the project. A third person can be held liable for the money payable to secured creditors in case it has been invested in the project, in case it has not been spent in constructions, same cannot be permitted to be realised from the project/home buyers, the investment of home buyers cannot be frittered away and to fasten liability upon the innocent buyers/allottees in that event would tantamount to perpetrating yet another fraud on them. Accountability, as per law, has to be fastened on promoters/builders and all concerned. It would amount to total deprivation of money of home buyers without any fault on their part or legal liability. It would amount to fastening liability upon them once over again by misuse of the process of law. The provisions of the first and second charge cannot come to the rescue of Authorities/Bankers. Under Section 11(4)(g) the promoter has to pay all outgoings which he has collected from the allottees, the payment of outgoings includes land cost, ground rent, charges for water or electricity, maintenance charges etc. As per the proviso to Section 11(4)(g), the promoter shall continue to be liable, even after the transfer of the property, to pay such outgoings and penal charges, if any, to the authorities. Outgoings which have been collected by the promoter can be and have to be recovered in the facts and circumstance of the case from them as intended by section 11(4)(g) of RERA. [Para 133] [572-E-H; 573-A-E] 5.11 The Bank’s plea is that the provisions of section 11(4)(h) of RERA provides that the promoter, after he executes an agreement for sale for any apartment, plot or building, cannot mortgage or create a charge on such an apartment, plot or
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
building, as the case may be, and if any such mortgage or charge is made or created then it shall not affect the right and interest of the allottee who has taken or agreed to take such apartment, plot or building, as the case may be. The provision has a non– obstante clause. As the provision has given an overriding effect by non–obstante clause, the provision is no help to the banks as the agreement had been by promoters with home buyers entered into earlier in point of time to the creation of the mortgage. There could not have been any mortgage created subsequently and even if validly created, it would not affect the right and interest of the allottee as intended by RERA. Thus, the right and interest of the allottee are safeguarded by virtue of the provisions contained in section 11(4)(h). As the project was pending, the provision intends to confer a right on the allottee and save the allottees and also their interests from such liability. Even if the provision is held not applicable on the ground that RERA came into force later, since there was no valid mortgage as held by this Court, it was incapable of affecting the right or interest of the allottee. Had it been ensured that the money due to Noida and Greater Noida authorities was paid by the promoters to the authorities, the fraud of siphoning of money would not have taken place to the extent it has been done. Moreover, the money borrowed from banks has not been invested in the projects. In fact, projects required no funding. It would be iniquitous to charge the allottees with the bankers’ money. Thus, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, it is held that rights or interests of the allottees are not at all affected by the mortgage created by the bankers or by the dues of the Noida or Greater Noida authorities. [Para 134] [573-F-H; 574-A-D]
5.12 Section 4(2)(1) of the RERA requires the promoter to disclose the prior encumbrance. Therefore, the RERA contemplates the creation of encumbrance even before the project is registered and such a plot can be offered to allottees. Basically, a declaration is required under section 4(2)(l)(A) that the land is free from all encumbrances or as the case may be, details of the encumbrances, if any, on such land, should be disclosed. The intention is that the allottee should know about
the encumbrance if any. The provision does not espouse the cause of the bank in any manner whatsoever. [Para 135] [574-E-F] 5.13 It is not correct that in view of the provision of section 19(4) of RERA, the right of the allottees is restricted to only receiving the compensation from the promoters. The provisions of Section 8 of the RERA which provides for completion of the development projects by the competent authority or by the association of allottees or in any other manner, as may be determined and the association of allottees shall have the first right of refusal for carrying out the remaining development work is the wholesome provision contained in the second proviso to section 8. To claim compensation is at the option of the allottee if the allottee wants to go out. That is an additional right, not the only right conferred under the RERA. He cannot be left in lurch but is entitled to claim the refund if he so desires. It is his option to claim the refund along with interest and compensation which is to be determined under the RERA. The rights of the allottees are not restricted to only receiving the compensation. [Para 136] [574-G-H] 5.14 As regards the plea that the RERA recognises and protects interests of the lenders and does not in any manner take away rights under any of the existing statutes such as T.P. Act, Debt Recovery Tribunal Act, SARFAESI Act, it is apparent from a perusal of RERA, which is a special Act, that certain rights have been created in favour of the buyers. The provisions of RERA have to prevail. When it comes to the question of protection of rights of buyers even if RERA had not been enacted, under aforesaid laws in the facts of the case, a different view could not have been taken. However, there is no dispute that the bankers would have the right to recover their dues. The provisions of RERA are beneficial to the home buyers and are intended to insulate them from fraudulent action, ensures completion of the building and it is the duty of the court to protect and ensure the home buyers’ interest and at the same time to hold them responsible for the duties enjoined upon them under the said statute. The home buyers are not observed from the discharge of their liability if any. At the same time, they have the right of
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
enforcement of their right for compensation due to undue delay in completion of the project. [Para 137] [575-D-F]
5.15 In case the authorities are making allotment of plots at a paltry sum of 10% and giving the builders 8 years period to make payment of premium with a moratorium of 2 years then the period runs to 10 years and the project is to be completed within 3 years. It is clear that the authorities have to be very vigilant for securing their interests otherwise in every case even if the promoter has completed the project and realised the charges from the home buyers and has not deposited the amount due to the authorities, in case no action is taken by the Authorities, can it be taken after 10 years against home buyers. The authorities have to blame themselves for their inaction and have to wait for the realisation of dues by sale of other properties and as against guarantors etc. The projects have to be completed as mandated by Section 8 of RERA. [Para 139] [576-C-F]
5.16 No part of the building can be directed to be demolished. Buildings have to come up and completed even the ones which are at the nascent stage as mandated by RERA. No doubt about it that in case of failure to pay the dues the onus of payment of land dues has to be passed on to the buyers on pro– rata basis but in the instant case they have already paid the substantial amounts, huge amount has been permitted to be diverted by the authorities and bankers as such they have to wait for recovery and cannot act in a manner further detrimental to the interests of the home buyers. [Para 140] [577-B-C]
5.17 There is duty enjoined under the RERA, there has to be a Central Advisory Council as well as the role of the State Government is not ousted in order to protect against such frauds. The Central Government and the State Government are directed to take appropriate steps on the time–bound basis to do the needful, all other such cases where the projects have remained incomplete and home buyers have been cheated in aforesaid manner, it should be ensured that they are provided houses. [Para 141] [578-C-D]
6. As the basic obligations have not been complied with by the promoters, they cannot also be entitled to FAR. In the instant case, there is serious kind of fraud by the promotors as such they cannot be said to be entitled to avail the FAR to utilise it or to alienate and more so when they have failed to complete the projects and pay the dues. [Para 122] [567-B] 7.1 There appears to be non-issuance of the completion certificate, whereas the buildings are being occupied, completion certificate is directed to be issued. This Court has to monitor the payment of dues of the Authorities and Banks and that outstanding are not going to create hurdle in the execution of the registered document/conveyance deed in favour of home buyers. It has to be executed by the concerned Authorities as well as by the Court Receiver and by the home buyers. The amount which is due on the part of home buyers has to be deposited in the account, which has been opened, in the UCO Bank by this Court. It has to be utilised firstly for the purpose of completion of the buildings and for providing other facilities and the home buyers of incomplete projects also have to deposit the outstanding amount on their part in the aforesaid account opened in the UCO Bank and out of that amount, it has to be disbursed as per the orders to be passed by this Court for the purpose of construction and outstanding if any, shall be used for the purpose of payment of compensation to home buyers for the period of delay as per the agreement or as may be determined ultimately and other dues. [Para 124] [567-F-H; 568-A-B] 7.2 In the facts and circumstances of the case, it would be absolutely improper for the Authorities to deny issuance of occupancy or completion certificate, especially on the ground of non–payment of dues. The facts indicate that 9000 families are residing for the last several years out of the sheer necessity of shelter place and they have not been provided with electricity connections and other facilities due to non–issuance of occupancy certificate by the concerned authorities. Most of them have paid the entire amount to the builders. The payment to be made to concerned Authorities had also been collected by the builder from home buyers as component of price of flat, but has not been
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
deposited with the concerned Authorities and the home buyers’ money had been diverted, which was more than the dues of the Authorities and the Banks taken together. Had timely action been taken by the Authority, no amount could have been diverted and the position would have been different as it stands today. The concerned Authorities have to issue occupancy certificate as well as completion certificate with respect to the projects in which home buyers residing without insisting for the payment of their dues. This Court has to monitor the payment of the dues to the Authorities as well as the Bankers, from guarantors and other proprietors. The innocent buyers cannot be made to suffer for no fault on their part. [Para 101] [553-C-E]
7.3 Once Authorities have allowed 9000 home-buyers to occupy the premises without terminating the lease on the ground that occupation is illegal. Obviously, builders have put them in possession, they are not the encroachers and they have invested their valuable saving and have no other shelter place to live. They cannot be deprived of their houses and cannot be left without basic necessities of life like water, electricity, etc. The concerned Authorities are responsible to provide electricity, water, and all other basic amenities to buyers as they have the right to occupy the premises. In the peculiar facts of the case, the Court has directed the Authorities to provide basic necessities forthwith. The Central Government and Government of Uttar Pradesh are also directed to ensure that everything is done to protect the interest of the home-buyers without obliging the builders. Obliging the builders by making certain concessions by the Government would amount to perpetrating further fraud and unjust enrichment of builder. The case poses challenge to the law enforcement agencies to act in tandem to book such culprits. [Para 102] [553-E-H; 554-A] 7.4 It is also apparent from the provisions of the Act of 1976 as well as RERA and also the case set up by the Authorities that partial occupation certificate can also be issued. The completion certificate can be issued partially also as per the provisions of Uttar Pradesh Apartment (Promotion of
Construction, Ownership, and Maintenance) Act, 2010. [Para 123] [567-C-D] 8.1 Because of the failure on the part of the Builders to fulfil the obligations towards the buyers and the serious kind of fraud which has been played by them upon the home buyers, the registration of Amrapali group of companies under the Real Estate Regulation and Development Act, 2016 deserves to be cancelled. [Para 148] [581-D-E] 8.2 Because of the gross violations of the conditions of lease deeds executed by the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities in favour of Amrapali group of companies with respect to various projects, the lease deeds are liable to be cancelled and the rights thereupon shall vest in the Court Receiver. [Para 149] [581-E-F] 8.3 The criminal cases have also been registered by the police. The Court proposes to monitor the progress of the investigation. For violations of FEMA and FDI norms, the Enforcement Directorate is directed to make investigation in accordance with the law and submit reports quarterly to this Court. Money laundering aspect is also to be looked into by concerned authorities. [Para 151] [582-B] 8.4 It has been found in the Forensic Audit Report that there are several recoverable from various companies as well as from individuals, Directors and other incumbents. It is directed that as per the findings recorded by the Forensic Auditors, the money be deposited in this Court on a time–bound basis and other needful be done as observed by the Auditors. As the Court has approved the report, let the concerned companies/ Directors/ individuals take steps in compliance with the observations and findings made by Auditors to refund the amount and or to do needful as suggested within one month. [Para 152] [582-C-D] 8.5 It has also beem found that non–payment of dues of the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities and the banks cannot come in the way of occupation of flats by home buyers as money of home buyers has been diverted due to the inaction of Officials of Noida/ Greater Noida Authorities. They cannot sell the buildings
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
or demolish them nor can enforce the charge against homebuyers/ leased land/ projects in the facts of the case. Similarly, the banks cannot recover money from projects as it has not been invested in projects. Homebuyers money has been diverted fraudulently, thus, fraud cannot be perpetuated against them by selling the flats and depriving them of hard–earned money and savings of entire life. They cannot be cheated once over again by sale of the projects raised by their funds. The Noida and Greater Noida Authorities have to issue the Completion/ Part Completion Certificate, as the case may be, to execute tripartite agreement and registered deeds in favour of the buyers on part–completion or completion of the buildings, as the case may be or where the inhabitants are residing, within a period of one month. [Para 153] [582-E-G]
8.6 The home buyers are directed to deposit the outstanding amount under the Agreement entered with the promoters within 3 months from today in the Bank account opened in UCO Bank in the Branch of this Court. The amount deposited by them shall be invested in the fixed deposit to be disbursed under the order of this Court on phase–wise completion of the projects/work by the NBCC. The percentage of profit of NBCC is fixed at 8 percent. As it is a Government Undertaking, NBCC has to ensure that DPR is prepared reasonably and the work to be completed as expeditiously as possible. [Para 154 iii and 125] [583-D; 568-B-C]
8.7 The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India is directed to initiate the appropriate disciplinary action against Mr. Anil Mittal, CA for his conduct as reflected in various transactions and the findings recorded in the order and his overall conduct as found on Forensic Audit. Let appropriate proceedings initiated and concluded as early as possible within 6 months and a report of action taken to be submitted to this Court. [Para 154 vii] [583-F-G]
8.8 Concerned Ministry of Central Government, as well as the State Government and the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, are directed to ensure that appropriate action is taken as against leaseholders concerning such similar projects at Noida and Greater Noida and other places in various States,
where projects have not been completed. They are further directed to ensure that projects are completed in a time–bound manner as contemplated in RERA and home buyers are not defrauded. [Para 154 ix] [584-B-C] 8.9 Shri R. Venkataramani, Senior Advocate is appointed as the Court Receiver. The right of the lessee shall vest in the Court Receiver and he shall execute through authorized person on his behalf, the tripartite agreement and do all other acts as may be necessary and also to ensure that title is passed on to home buyers and possession is handed over to them. [Para 154 x] [584-D] 8.10 The Court also directs Noida and Greater Noida Authorities to execute the tripartite agreement within one month concerning the projects where homebuyers are residing and issue completion certificate notwithstanding that the dues are to be recovered under this order by the sale of the other attached properties. Registered conveyance deed shall also be executed in favour of homebuyers, they are to be placed in the possession and they shall continue to do so in future on completion of projects or in part as the case may be. The Noida and Greater Noida Authorities are directed to take appropriate action to do the needful in the matter. The Water Works Department of the concerned area and the Electricity Supplier are directed to provide the connections for water and electricity to home buyers forthwith. [Para 154 xi] [584-E-G] Case Law Reference
[2011] 8 SCR 25
relied on
Para 73
[2012] 9 SCR 311
relied on
Para 74
[2014] 9 SCR 780
relied on
Para 75
CIVIL ORIGINAL/APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Writ Petition (Civil) No. 940 of 2017. (Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India)
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
With
Writ Petition (C) Nos. 947, 971, 942, 1041, 1018, 1116, 1144, 1156, 1206, 1242 of 2017, 8, 58, 21, 52, 91, 56, 57, 74, 134, 131, 160, 164, 182, 199, 226, 245, 281, 306, 298, 246, 267, 288, 460, 353, 378, 742, 829, 1397 of 2018, S.L.P.(C) No. 1879 of 2018, SMC (Crl.) No. 4 of 2018. Maninder Singh, Vikramjit Banerjee, ASGs, Ms. V. Mohana, Vikas Singh, Gaurav Bhatia, M. G. Ramachandran, Shyam Divan, Ms. Vibha Datta Makhija, Krishnan Venugopal, K. S. Namdar, S. B. Upadhyay, V. K. Shukla, Debal Kr. Banerji, Ms. Geeta Luthra, P. N. Mishra, Rakesh Khanna, Siddartha Dave, K. K. Rai, Rakesh Munjal, Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Nikhil Nayyar, V. Shekhar, Sr. Advs., Biswajit Dubey, Uday Khare, Ms. Ruchi Choudhary, Ms. Ashita Chawla, Ms. Srideepa Bhattacharyya, Aditya Marwah, Ms. Surabhi Khattar, Manpreet Lamba (for M/s. Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas), Vibhu Shanker Mishra, Mukul Singh, B. V. Balramdas, Ms. Ankita Sharma, Ms. Nikita Capoor, Prashant Singh, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Raj Bahadur, Vikrant Yadav, Mrs. Misha Rohatgi, Ekant Luthra, Nakul Mohta, Lalit Mohan, Johnson, Manoj Singh, Abhishek Sharma, Utkarsh Jaiswal, Himanshu Shekhar Tripathi, Rohitash Kumar Sharma, Gaurav Goel, Paras Choudhary, Vishal Gupta, Arpit Rai, Aviral Kashyap, Ms. Akansha Goyal, Rishi Matoliya, Ms. Sumati Sharma, Kumar Mihir, Ms. Shayaree Basu Mallik, Sukant Vikram, Hitesh Kumar Sharma, S. K. Rajora, Rajesh Kumar Gupta, Krishnam Mishra, Param K. Mishra, Nishant Kumar, Ms. Anisha Upadhyay, Shashank Singh, Rohit Pandey, Ms. Yamini Raman Acharya, Varad Dwivedi, Ms. Manju Jetley, Balraj Dewan, Vishnu Sharma, Sourav Roy, Ms. Anupama Sharma, Prashant Kumar, Ashutosh Kumar, Gaurav Majumder, Abhay Kumar, Alok Kumar Aggarwal, Ms. Anushruti, Ms. Pavni Poddar, Ms. Gauri Goburdhan, Ms. Shivani L. Lohiya, Ms. Asmita Nanda, Sahil Modi, Ms. Anshul Duggal, Pranav Vashishtha, Kushagra Nigam, Ms. Kritika Singh, Gaurav Goel, Manoj Singh, Altamish Siddiki, Abhishek, Prateek Yadav, Anshul Duggal, Niraj Gupta, Fuzaail Khan, J. Abbas, Ms. Shefali Jain, Mrs. Anushree Gupta, Prakash, Umair Ahmad Siddiqui, Mohd. Waqous, Zeeshan Khan, Kabir Dixit, S. S. Ray, Manmeet Singh, Anugrah Robin Frey, Ankrit Gupta, Ms. Rakhi Ray, S. K. Pandey, Anshul Rai, Chandrashekhar A. Chakalabbi, Awanish Kumar, Ramkrishna Veerendra (for M/s. Dharmaprabhas Law Associates), Mohd. Ehraz Zafar, Divyam Dhyani, Vivek Narayan Sharma, Abhishek Aggarwal, Atul Sharma, Manmeet Singh, Mishra Saurabh, Anshuman
Dwivedi, M. L. Lahoty, Paban K. Sharma, Anchit Sripat, Himanshu Shekhar, Sukant Vikram, Joby Varghese, Arif Eqbal, Abhinav Ankit, Ms. Indrani Mukherjee, Ms. Tatini Basu, Ms. Rajkumari Banja, Nitin Bajpai, Syed K. Ali, Rohit Sharma, Atul Agarwal, Rounak Nayar, Anshul Chowdhary, Kumar Dushyant Singh, Shadan Farsat, Ms. Jahnavi Sindhu, Ms. Shruti Narayan, Ranjan Kumar Pandey, Sandeep Bist, Ram Krishna, Anuj Tiwari, Shikhar Srivastava, Ritwik Sahah, K. K. Bhatt, Ms. Khushboo Khauja, Ms. Shobha Gupta, Joyshree Barman, Tahir Ashraf Siddiqui, Amit Goel, Ms. Ruchi Goel, Ashwani Bhardwaj, Ali Chaudhary, Azeem Kalebude, Jamnesh Kumar, A.D.N. Rao, A. Venkatesh, Rahul Mishra, Rohit Kumar Singh, Ms. Stuti Mishra, Ms. Prerna Mehta, Ms. Gargi Khanna, Rajul Shrivastav, Mohit D. Ram, Ms. Suman Tripathy, Pran Prasoon, R. P. Goyal, Naresh Kaushik, Manoj Joshi, Rahul Kaushik, Vardhman Kaushik, B. Purushothama Reddy, Rahul Sharma, Omung Raj Gupta, Devik Singh, Lakshay Juneja, Ms. Lalita Kaushik, Ms. Priyanka Das, Somiran Sharma, Ms. Sheena Taqui, Ms. Ragini Pandey, Gudipati G. Kashyap, Ms. Apoorva Pandey, Ms. T. Archana, Rajinder Wali, B. K. Satija, Anurag Tandon, Ms. Sonam Gupta, Kumar Sudeep, Somesh Chandra Jha, Ms. Neha Chaudhary, Sunil K. Khatri, Ms. Shaila Arora, Badri Prasad Singh, Arvind Kumar, Manish S. Verma, Ms. Astha Sharma, Shivam Sharma, Ms. Dimple Nagpal, Abhigya, Ms. Sunita Yadav, Ms. Sheetal Rajput, Vivek Narayan Sharma, Pragyan Mishra, Ms. Mohika Jain, Mohd. Zaheb Husain, Dr. Shesh Main Pandey, Rajeev Kumar Jha, Satyabrata Panda, Shashwat Panda, Manoranjan P., Tejaswi Kumar Pradhan, Dinesh K. Garg, Abhishek Garg, Dhananjay Garg, Deepak Mishra, Ramdhir Kumar Sinha, Vijay Kumar, Thomas Oommen, Aniruddha P. Mayee, Vivek Srivastava, Ravi Bhushan Upadhyay, Gajanand Kirodimal, Ms. Anisha Mathur, Saarthak Bansal, Ms. Manju Jetley, Mrs. Veera Kaul Singh, Ms. Vijaya Singh, Ms. Akansha Singh, Ms. Aishwarya Mishra, T. K. Joseph, P.K. Jayakrishna, Sandeep Jha, Ram Ekbal Roy, Binay Kr. Das, Manoj Sharma, Kapil Kaushik, Roopansh Poorohit, E.R. Sumathy, Ms. Savita Aggarwal, Ms. Kapnana Kalra, Sanjay Kumar Visen, Ms. Ritu Rastogi, Ms. Sasmita Tripathy, Sanjeev Singh, Ms. Anandita Singh, Ms. Amisha Agarwal, Dushansho Polo, Ms. Pallavi Pratap, Ms. Shikha Shrivastav, Ms. Shweta M., Ms. Neena Singh, Nitin Jain, Aneesh Mittal, Abhishek Agarwal, Atul Sharma, Arunav Tewari, Ms. Mona K. Rajvanshi, Aneesh Mittal, Ms. Shreya Sharma, Manish Kumar Saran, Sukant Vikram, R. Sathish, Mrs. Indra Sawhney, Amit Pawan, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal, Prithvi
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Pal, Shishir Pinaki, Shovan Mishra, Raj Kamal, D. K. Sharma, Maheen Pradhan, Varun Tyagi, Siddhant Sharma, Mayank Sharma, Mrigank Prabhakar, Ms. Jyoti Sharma, Gopal Jha, Binay Kumar Das, G. Balaji, A. P. Mohanty, P. K. Pattnaik, Raghavendra Shukla, Robin Singh Solanki, Kumar Mihir, G. C. Tyagi, Kailash Prashad Pandey, Ashok Kumar Singh, Ms. Jasmine Damkewala, Ms. Sangeeta Singh, Prakash Ranjan Nayak, Suchit Mohanty, Mrs. Vandana Kaushal Nee Mohanty, Sibo Sankar Mishra, Ms. E. R. Sumathy, Dr. Alok K. Sharma, Naresh Kumar, Ravindra Kumar, Rabin Majumder, Akhilesh Kumar Pandey, Abhimanyu Bhandari, Ms. Nattasha Garg, Somesh Tiwari, Naveen Kumar, T. Mahipal, Ms. Atishi Dipankar, Ajit Sharma, Satish Pandey, Shashank Singh, Krishanu Mishra, Param Kumar Mishra, Kabir Dixit, Aishwarya Sinha, Ms. Priyanka Sinha, Alok Kumar Singh, Gaurav Goel, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Jaibir Singh Nayar, Akash Nayar, Ms. Sucharita Ganguly, Siddhartha Jha, Ms. Rashmi Singh, Ashwani Bhardwaj, Tahir Ashraf Siddiqui, Kaushal Yadav, Sanand Ramakrishnan, Ritesh Agrawal, Raj Kamal, Mrs. Anil Katiyar, R. R. Rajesh, Raj Bahadur, Gaurav, Sanjeev Bhatnagar, M. K. Verma, Prakash Kumar Singh, Pawanshree Agrawal, Dharmendra Kumar Sinha, Ms. Astha Sharma, S. K. Verma, Ms. Prerna Mehta, Ms. Amita Singh Kalkal, Divyakant Lahoti, Dr. Shashwat Bajpai, Sharad Agarwal, Rohit Amit Shekdhar, Abhinav Shrivastava, Rahul Gupta, Ms. Sana Kamra, S.S. Ray, Vaibhav Gulia, Ms. Praveena Gautam, Aman Gupta, Dhananjay Garg, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal, Pawan Bhushan, Talha Abdul Rahman, Kunal Mimani, Ms. Vishrutyi Sahni, Dheeraj Nair, Ms. Sonam Gupta, Smarhar Singh, Virender Goswami, Gautam Narayan,. Ms. Soni Singh, Shamik Saha, Manu Nair, Kuber Dewan, S.S. Shroff, Pradeep Misra, Daleep Dhyani, Suraj Singh, Ms. Pallavi Pratap, Avneesh Arputham, Ms. Anuradha Arputham, Sureshan P., Badri Prasad Singh, Aakarshan Aditya, Somesh Chandra Jha, Ms. Sujata Kurdukar, Roopansh Purohit, Gautam Das, Lalit Rana, C.M. Gopal, Sunil Kumar Sethi, Ms. Subasini S., Ms. Kamakshi S. Mehlwal, Ms. Charu Mathur, Anil Kumar Mishra-I, Aditya Jain, Ms. Indra Sawhney, Mohit D. Ram, Ashwani Kumar Upadhayay, Prashant Kumar Umrao, Veer P. Singh, Raghvendar Shukla, R.D. Upadhyay, Sumit Sinha, Ms. Payal Kakra, Sushant Chaturvedi, Ajay Pratap Singh, Ms. Anindita Pujari, Ms. Arti Singh, Ms. Pooja Singh, Kumar Dushyant Singh, Mrs. Gargi Khanna, Ranjan Kumar Pandey, Mishra Saurabh, Mrinal Harsh Vardhan, Abhimanue Shrestha, Anoop Prakash Awasthi, Ms. Anannya Ghosh, Brijesh Kumar Tamber,
Ms. Shobha Gupta, Sanjay Kumar Visen, Sudhansu Palo, Abhitosh Pratap Singh, Mrs. Swarupama Chaturvedi, Ms. Aparna Trivedi, Ms. Hima Lawrence, Vikram, Anurag Rana, Ms. Nikita Tyagi, Ravindra Sadanand Chingale, Brijesh Panchal, Vinod Yadav, Sudhir Naagar, Mushtaq Ahmad, Ms. Suruchii Aggarwal, Ms. Abhigya, B. K. Satija, S.R. Setia, Vikram Patralekh, Ms. Kriti Sondhi, Braj Kishore Mishra, M/S Vibhu Shanker Mishra And Co., Ms. Puja Sharma, Anup Kumar Mishra, Balwinder Singh Suri, Ms. Garima Sharma, Ms. Srishti Gupta, Ms. Aaryav Mehra (for M/s. Kings and Alliance LLP), Ambhoj Kumar Sinha, P. K. Jayakrishnan, M/S. V. Maheshwari & Co., Manoj Saxena, Nitish Massey, Mrs. Mona K. Rajvanshi, Sibo Sankar Mishra, Ram Lal Roy, Abhishek Rajput, Praveen Jain, Annam D. N. Rao, Shri Gaichangpou Gangmei, Ms. Dharitry Phookan, B. Krishna Prasad, Radhakanta Tripathy, Ms. Chandan Ramamurthi, Joby P. Varghese, Nikilesh Ramachandran, Ms. Roohina Dua, Ejaz Maqbool, Kaushik Choudhury, Kedar Nath Tripathy, E. C. Vidya Sagar, Rajesh Kumar Gupta, Alok Kumar, Somya Yadava, Snigdha Singh, Ashutosh Jain, Chirag Babbar, Ketul Hansraj, Balaji Srinivasan, Aneesh Mittal, Ms. Shreya Sharma, Abhijit Sengupta, Kumar Neeraj, Mrs. Lalita Kaushik, Arun K. Sinha, Raj Singh Rana, Pankaj Kumar Singh, Anupam Dwivedi, Ms. Bharti Tyagi, Chandan Kumar, Somiran Sharma, Ms. Arti Singh, Prasenjit Keswani, Kabir Shanker Bose, Raghvendra Pratap Singh, Ankit Anand, Arvind Gupta, Dr. Sumant Bharadwaj, Ms. Mridula Ray Bharadwaj, Rakesh Kailash Sharma, Ms. Tamanna Goyal, Ms. Iti Aggarwal, Chander Prakash (for M/s. D.S.K. Legal), Binay Kumar Das, Chandan Kumar, Ms. Rituraj Choudhary, Tarun Vaid, Siddharth Bansal, Shekhar Kumar, K. Paari Vendhan, Ms. Vandana Sehgal, Ms. Gunjan Ahuja, Abhinav Shrivastava, Somanatha Padhan, Sarvam Ritam Khare, Sanjay Kumar Dubey, Arvind Kumar, Anil K. Chopra, Neeraj Shekhar, Ms. Charu Ambwani, Rajesh Mahale, Vishal Gupta, Ravinder Kumar, Advs. for the appearing parties. Applicant-in-person. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
ARUN MISHRA, J. 1. These writ petitions pertain to the projects of various companies of Amrapali Group in the Noida and Greater Noida.
2. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that in 2011 in Noida and Greater Noida various real estate projects for housing were started.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
In the various projects, the Amrapali Group of Companies proposed to construct approximately 42,000 flats. Various brochures were published and it was assured that the delivery of possession shall be made in 36 months and other world-class amenities were also promised.
3. Various home buyers booked their apartments during the period 2010-2014. The buyers signed the Standard Form of Allotment-cumFlat Buyers Agreement and even after payment of 40 to 100 percent of total consideration, they are faced with the threat of forfeiture of huge booking amount. The agreement contained specific terms as to interest. Under Clause 14 of the agreement, the builder authorised itself to finance loan from any financial institution by way of mortgage/charge/ securitization of receivable of the land and flats and the allottees will have no objection in this regard. Clause 15 also authorised the builder to keep full authority over the flat depriving the allottees of any lien or interest despite payment of entire amount thereof. 4. The builder under Clause 19(a) was obliged to complete the flats of M/s. Amrapali Centurion Park Private Limited within 30 months from the date of commencement of excavation/signing of the agreement, which may vary for plus/minus 6 months. Under Clause 19(c), builder fixed a paltry sum of Rs.5 per square feet super area per month for the period of delay, which would include any/all damages, compensation, claims for delayed possession. 5. The buyers invested their life savings and some of them had obtained the loan from the Bank. Most of the buyers have made the payment to the extent of 50 percent to 100 percent abiding by the payment schedule. The dreams of the buyers of obtaining house were given serious jolts when M/s. Amrapali Silicon City Private Limited and M/s. Amrapali Centurian Park Private Limited, respondent Nos.3 and 4 herein respectively were found in serious breach of their obligation to deliver the flats within 36 months. They did not pay the amount either to the Noida or Greater Noida Authority and also to the Banks. Several revised dates of possession were fixed unilaterally, but they failed to deliver the flats. The Amrapali Group has failed to comply with its obligation under the subvention scheme, the tenure of which was approved by the bank/ financial institution. The builder had failed to comply with the abovementioned scheme as the buyer making the payment of EMIs to the banks, thereby causing a double loss. Some of the consumers approached the National Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission (for
short, ‘the NCDRC’) by filing Consumer Complaint No.213 of 2017 under Section 12(1)(c) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. 6. The Bank of Baroda had filed Company Petition No. (IB)121(PB)/2017 before the National Company Law Tribunal (for short, ‘the NCLT’) under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 for triggering the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process in the matter of M/s. Amrapali Silicon City Private Limited, respondent No.3. The NCLT appointed the Interim Resolution Professional (in short, the ‘I.R.P’). Moratorium was also declared thereby restricting the institution of any suits against the corporate debtor including execution of any judgment, decree or order; transferring, encumbering, alienating or disposing of by the corporate debtor any of its assets or any legal interest therein; and any action to foreclose, recover or enforce any security interest created by the corporate debtor in respect of its property under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (for short ‘the SARFAESI Act’). The order of NCLT has a direct bearing on the home buyers of M/s. Amrapali Centurian Park Private Limited, respondent no.4, which is virtually owned by M/s. Amrapali Silicon City Private Limited with 98.84 percent shareholding. Both the companies are run by the almost same set of Directors including Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma and Mr. Shiv Priya. Thus, in order to secure the interest of home buyers, in the instant petitions under Article 32, a plethora of intervention applications have been filed. 7. It is submitted on behalf of petitioners that home buyers have put their lives at stake by paying their lifetime savings and hard-earned money in the purchase of flats. As such, they cannot be categorised as ordinary financial creditors to rank pretty low in the order of priority under Section 53. Corporate builder heavily counts upon the home buyers as stakeholders to sustain in the market. Section 53 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 is irrational and violates the rights of the home buyers guaranteed under Article 21 as by subjecting the home buyers to the liquidation proceedings of discriminatory nature. The very survival of home buyers has been seriously jeopardised. Not only they are going to lose the entire money with accrued interest, but they also become financially crippled for all time to come even close to the dream of a new home, let alone purchase it. There is no equal protection under
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. The moratorium imposed by NCLT directly affecting not only the home buyers of M/s.Amrapali Centurion Park Private Limited, but also similarly situated lakhs of home buyers in various other projects. They cannot be deprived of their legal rights. Similar plight has been averred by the other buyers in the other several projects.
8. The matter projects the issue of larger public interest. The real estate business has developed and it mainly survived by the money invested by the buyer for the purchase of the house. They have the right to obtain houses. The facts of the instant case project that Noida and Greater Noida have allotted huge plots to the builders by charging a sum of approximately 10 percent and in most of the cases, thereafter no money has been paid. The large number of projects which have come up not only in Noida and Greater Noida, but most of them have not been completed by the builders/promoters and they have siphoned buyers’ money in large scale. No action has been taken by the Noida and Greater Noida Authorities against builders for cancellation of leases due to violation to fulfil their obligation. Bankers have financed to builder certain loan on the condition to invest in the projects, but they have also permitted the money to be used as for other purposes as apparent from the report of the Forensic Audit in the instant case which had been submitted by Auditors - Mr. Pawan Kumar Aggarwal and Mr. Ravinder Bhatia. The facts which are projected in the Forensic Auditor Report speaks for itself. 9. Before we consider the Forensic Audit, it would be appropriate to refer to certain orders which were passed from time to time by this Court. This Court on the application filed by petitioner - Bikram Chatterji, passed an order on 22.11.2017, directing builder to deposit 10 percent of the dues to Noida Authorities. This Court also directed that the phase in respect of which Occupancy Certificate and No Objection Certificate, if granted, the possession of flats shall be handed over to the respective flat buyers. Liberty was granted to flat owners to complete the finishing work. Thereafter, an order was passed on 31.1.2018, requesting the builder to deposit amount as ordered on 17.11.2017. It was also pointed that in several places firefighting devices were not installed though the places were occupied by thousands of families of Phase-I of Silicon City of Amrapali in Sector 76, Noida. Directions were issued to do the needful. We also directed to submit the proposal within one week with
respect to all the projects, which were incomplete. On 22.2.2018, the following order was passed by this Court: “Applications for impleadment(s) is/are allowed to the extent of intervention only.
IN W.P.Nos.160,91,164 of 2018 AND D. NO. 6636 OF 2018 Issue notice on the petition as well as on the prayer for interim relief returnable within two weeks. Dasti, in addition, is also permitted. IN W.P.(C) Nos. 942/2017 AND 8 OF 2018
Heard learned senior counsel for the parties. Pursuant to the order passed on 21.02.2018, Mr. Ranjit Kumar, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Gaurav Bhatia and Alok Aggarwal, appearing on behalf of the promoters of Amrapali Group has produced a compilation ‘A’ before this court on behalf of the said promotors disclosing the particulars of the on-going projects, stages of the work vis-a-vis the towers involved, the likely time to complete the remaining works and the cost of construction therefor. Mr. Ranjit Kumar, learned senior counsel, has in particular drawn the attention of this court at pages 4 & 5 of the compilation ‘A’ which deal with 19 towers as mentioned therein of Amrapali Leisure Valley Developers Pvt. Ltd. (Leisure Park). In the chart, on these two pages of the compilation amongst others the number of units, saleable area, the proposed/likely time to complete the finishing work, the total balance amount payable by the home buyers and the total expenditure to be incurred in completing the work, have been indicated. As this chart reveals the likely time to complete the work and to deliver possession in accordance with the law, ranges from 3 to 15 months. According to the respondent, an amount of Rs.87.28 crores is required to complete the finishing works in fairness as mentioned therein. When enquired by this court as to the guarantee for the implementation of the arrangements proposed for all practical purposes, Mr. Ranjit Kumar, on instructions, has submitted that to ensure that the works are completed by the time as proposed 12
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] developers in addition to the Galaxy group have given their letters to collaborate with the respondent promoters for the said purposes as testified by the documents available in compilation ‘B’. Learned counsel appearing for the home buyers, however, have expressed some reservation contending that the arrangements as proposed do not inspire confidence in view of the past experience and have pleaded that unless the 13 developers who undertake to collaborate with promotors of Amrapali Group are tied down with necessary conditions, the very executability of the project would be doubtful. To this Mr. Ranjit Kumar, learned senior counsel has urged that adequate undertakings would be given by the promoters of Amrapali Group as well as the other developers. Having regard to the rival submissions made and the attendant facts and circumstances and also considering the predominant interest of the home buyers, we are of the view that it would be in the fitness of things to permit the promotors of Amrapali Group to immediately start the finishing work as proposed in the units of the towers as listed at pages 4 & 5 of Compilation ‘A’ on the basis of the arrangements as proposed. In order to examine the bonafide of the proposal and the progress of the works that would be achieved, list these matters on 27th March at 2 P.M. By then the promotors of Amrapali Group would furnish to this court complete details of the proposals in all respects made by the collaborators/developers and ensure completion of the projects/finishing work as indicated in chart. We part with the belief that the respondents-developers would be true to their assurances to this court and also to the home buyers. Needless to say that all promotors of Amrapali Group shall furnish their undertaking by 7th March 2018. Further orders in this regard, as considered necessary, would be passed on the next date i.e. on 27.03.2018. In response to the prayer made on behalf of the developers that the insolvency proceedings before the NCLT ought to be stayed, we on this stage leave the parties to make the appropriate prayer as advised before the said Forum.”
10. Keeping in view the predominant interest of the home buyers, vide above order we directed the Amrapali Group to complete the projects and the finishing work as assured, but it was not done as apprehended by the home-buyers. This Court vide order dated 15.3.2018, directed to submit a joint proposal with respect to providing project wise information of the stages of various building. Thereafter, on 27.3.2018, learned senior counsel appearing for Amrapali Group stated that they are ready to undertake the completion of the projects of Amrapali Group and we requested the I.R.P. of Amrapali Group not to proceed any further, in view of the assurances given by the Amrapali Group to undertake works. This Court on 10.5.2018 has passed an order for installation of lifts in the Towers and also to make certain lifts functional. We also asked the promoters/ developers to submit the statement of the total price of the flats, the total amount paid to the builder by the flat buyers, the total amount spent by the builder on the construction and how the remaining part of the money paid by buyers has been utilised. It also transpired from documents that money had been transferred to certain other companies, thus, this Court has asked for the details of the composition of the transferee company including the names of the Director and for what purpose money was transferred and how it is to be retrieved and how projects are to be completed. 11. On 17.5.2018, this Court passed the following order: “1. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. Pursuant to our request made to the learned counsel, they have sat together and a joint statement has been filed for containing the proposal for completion of the various projects. A joint meeting had been conducted between the lawyers representing the buyers and builder of Amrapali Group and the representatives of Greater Noida and Noida. The proposals are in the form of four baskets with independent timelines and the co-developers had been chosen to undertake the completion of the projects and remaining work at the site. The independent proposals given by Amrapali along with the proposed codeveloper had been placed before the concerned lawyers representing the flat owners in those projects and lawyers of Noida and the representatives of Greater Noida and broad consensus has been reached.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] 3. The following are the basket-wise proposals:
FIRST BASKET I. SAPHIRE – PHASE-I IN NOIDA : In relation to Saphire Phase-I, consisting of 1033 units, the time given is of 10+2 months for completion of the project.
II. SAPHIRE-PHASE-II : It consists of 1308 units and the time sought for completion of the project is 12 to 15 months. The promoter of the Saphire Phase I & II projects is M/s. Amrapali Saphire Developers Pvt. Ltd. The developer chosen by the promoter is M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd. With respect to Saphire Phase II project, as agreed to by the promoter, the relevant agreements entered into with codevelopers to be placed within one week. The documents shall be filed afresh, even if the same had been filed earlier, duly supported by an affidavit. Let the undertaking of concerned promoter/co-developer be also placed on record within seven days.
III. LEISURE PARK : This project comprises of 2993 units. There are three categories of this project, namely: i) The first category comprises of the following 19 towers with 1665 units and the time limit of 15 months is fixed : 1. E1 2. E2 3. E3 4&5. E4 (Two Towers) 6. B2 7. B3 8. B4 9. B5 10. A1 11. A2 12. A3 13. A4 14. A5 15. A6 16. F1 17. F2 18. F3 19. F4 ii) The second category comprises of 3 towers, i.e., towers C1, C2, and F5. There are 411 units and time limit, as agreed to for completion is up to 22 (twenty-two) months.
(iii) The third category (River view) comprises of 7 towers, i.e., D1 to D7. There are 917 units in this category and time, as agreed to for completion is 29 (twenty-nine) months.
The co-developer of the first basket is M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd.
SECOND BASKET PRINCELY ESTATE :
The promoter of the project is M/s. Amrapali Princely Estates Pvt. Ltd. There are 1919 units. Out of these, minor work is required to be carried out in 1600 units, possession of which have already been handed over to buyers and some work remains in three other towers, being towers N, O and P, which comprise 319 units. Time agreed for completion of same is 12 months and it has been proposed that M/s. Kanodia Business Pvt. Ltd. will be the co-developer. It is also agreed to that as there is no water tank, no lift in three towers, i.e., N, O & P, the work of water tank and lifts in these towers shall be completed within six months from today.
As the inhabitants are already occupying certain portion up to the fifth floor, let arrangements be made, as agreed to, for water tank on a priority basis. Adequate provision for electricity connection shall also be made within three months from today. We defer the order with respect to Amrapali Silicon project, as agreed to. THIRD BASKET
Amrapali-the promoter has proposed certain projects in category-A, namely, Zodiac, Platinum, Titanium and Eden Park in this basket. The promoter of the Zodiac is M/s. Amrapali Zodiac Developers Pvt. Ltd., whereas the promoter of Platinum and Titanium is M/s. Ultra Home Construction Pvt. Ltd. and of Eden Park, the promoter is Amrapali Eden Park Developers Pvt. Ltd. The following agreement has been reached with respect to the aforesaid category ‘A’ projects : A.1. ZODIAC : Zodiac comprises of 2230 units. It is agreed that the work in the said units shall be completed within 12 months. The co-
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] developer is M/s. India Infoline Limited (IIFL) & M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd.
A.2. PLATINUM & TITANIUM : (a) Platinum comprises of 888 units, and (b) Titanium comprises of 54 units. The work in the said units shall be completed within 7 months. The codeveloper being M/s. IIFL or M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd.
Let the requisite undertaking by the concerned promoter and co-developer be filed within seven days in this Court. A.3. EDEN PARK :
Eden Park comprises of 316 units. The work shall be completed within 7 months. The co-developer is M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd. Let the promoter and co-developer to file a requisite undertaking within 7 days from today.
CATEGORY B PROJECTS : The following are category ‘B’ projects : B.1. CENTURIAN : A. CENTURIAN PARK:
Centurian Park comprises of low rise 600 units. The work shall be completed within 10 months. B. TERRACE HOMES : Terrace Homes comprises of 3481 units. The work shall be completed within 21 months.
C. TROPICAL : Tropical comprises of 1240 units. The work shall be completed within 30 months.
D. O-2 Valley : O-2 Valley comprises of 800 units. The work shall be completed within 12 months.
The proposed promoter is M/s. Amrapali Centurian Park Pvt. Ltd. and co-developer is M/s. IIFL.
It appears that earlier M/s. Sahi Developers Pvt. Ltd. was appointed as co-developer under a Joint Development Agreement. There is some interse dispute with respect to the work undertaken by the said codeveloper and the promoter. Be that as it may. The co-developer M/s. Sahi Developers Pvt. Ltd. to file the details of the investment made by it in the projects. Let the promoter also file a reply to the same and appropriate orders would be passed by this Court with respect to the interest of M/s. Sahi Developers Pvt. Ltd. However, we permit the new codeveloper M/s. IIFL to be appointed for the said project so that owing to the interse dispute between the promoter and co-developer, the project may not be delayed. B.2. GOLF HOME :
This project consists of two parts : (i) Golf Homes; and (ii) Kingswood. (i) Golf Homes :
Golf Homes consists of 4210 units. The work shall be completed within the period of 6 months to 22 months and possession shall be handed over as soon as the project is completed. (ii) Kingswood : Kingswood comprises of 1596 units. The work shall be completed within nine months to 22 (twenty-two) months.
The promoter of Golf Homes and Kingswood projects is M/s. Amrapali Smart City Developers Pvt. Ltd. and the co-developer is M/s. IIFL. B.3. TECH PARK :
Tech Park project is located in Greater Noida. The promoter is M/s. Ultra Home Construction Pvt. Ltd. and the co-developer is M/s. IIFL The work shall be completed within the time limit of 18-24 months.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] PROJECT COSMOS KOCHI :
In COSMOS KOCHI, the project at Kochi, the time limit for completion is fixed from 9 to 18 months. The promoter of the Vananchal ‘Kochi’, the project is M/s. Ultra Home Constructions Pvt. Ltd. In VANANCHAL CITY, Ranchi project also, the promoter is M/s. Ultra Home Constructions Pvt. Ltd.
The co-developer for both the Vananchal projects is M/s. IIFL. FOURTH BASKET I. DREAM VALLEY :
The promoter of Dream Valley is Amrapali Dream Valley Pvt. Ltd. This project comprises of Dream Valley Villa and Enchante, with respect to which proposal has been filed. a) Dream Valley (Villa): This project comprises of 379 units. The work shall be completed within 6-15 months in a phasewise manner.
b) Dream Valley-2 (High Rise): This project comprises of 8302 units. The work shall be completed within 9-35 months. c) Enchante: This project comprises of 1508 units. The work shall be completed in a phase-wise manner within 42 months.
The co-developer is M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd. Requisite undertaking by the promoter and the codeveloper shall be filed within seven days. II. LEISURE VALLEY :
a) Leisure Valley Villas – which comprises of 887 units, the work shall be completed within 6-15 months. b) Verona Heights & Jaura Heights – comprise of 4964 units and the work shall be completed within 42 months.
c) Adarsh Awas Yojna - comprises of 1904 units and the work shall be completed within 30 to 42 months. The promoter of the projects is M/s. Amrapali Leisure Valley Pvt. Ltd. and the co-developer is M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd.
III. HEARTBEAT CITY 1 & 2 :
a) In a Heartbeat City-1 project, the number of units is 759 plus shops. The time limit is 10-18 months; and
b) In a Heartbeat City-2 project, the number of units is 1217 plus shops. The time limit is from January 2020 to December 2020. The promoters of these projects are M/s. Pebble Prolease Pvt. Ltd. and M/s. Three Platinum Softech Pvt. Ltd. The codeveloper is M/s. Galaxy Dreamhome Developers Pvt. Ltd.
The aforesaid period wherever fixed includes the period of mobilization and reflects the outer limit. Let undertaking of promoter and developer be filed within seven days with respect to all the projects. 4. It is apparent from the admission made by the promoter that the money to the extent of Rs.2765 crores, out of the six projects in question, has been transmitted to other projects. Though we were inclined to direct the promoter to deposit the said amount in this Court, we are not doing this at this juncture, because of the singular reason that the various promoters of the projects have shown their willingness to complete these projects by engaging the services of the co-developer. It is made clear that co-developer is the agent of the promoter. No right or interest shall accrue to the co-developer and liability towards the buyer shall remain with the promoter. 5. At this stage, we deem it appropriate to direct that an escrow account has to be opened. The said account has to be opened in the UCO Bank, Supreme Court Branch, situated in the premises itself. At this juncture, we deem it appropriate to direct the promoters to deposit a sum of Rs.250/- crores (Rupees Two Hundred Fifty Crores) in the said escrow account, and money shall be deposited on or before 15th June 2018. 6. A proposal has also been submitted on behalf of the promoters of the aforesaid projects to sell some of the unencumbered property, details of which have been given at page 28 of the affidavit dated 16.5.2018. Out of the aforesaid proposal, we find that the properties mentioned at serial
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] numbers 11 and 15 are of high value. The unlaunched part of M/s. Amrapali Leisure Valley Pvt. Ltd., land of project is in Greater Noida, is held on the basis of the leasehold interest from the Greater Noida Industrial Authority, the realizable value is shown to be is Rs.917.29 crores (Rupees Nine Hundred Seventeen Crores Twenty Nine Lakhs). There is no bank loan but however, there appear to be some dues to the Greater Noida Authority on this particular property. The distress sale value is shown at Rs.491 crores (Rupees Four Hundred NinetyOne Crores). The property mentioned at serial number 15 is a part of the unlaunched property of Amrapali Centurion Park (Commercial) held on a leasehold basis from the Greater Noida Industrial Authority and its distress value is Rs.246 crores (Rupees Two Hundred Forty-Six Crores). 7. There are some other commercial properties, which are in the form of hotels and other commercial properties comprising of malls, etc. and those can also be sold for completion of projects. As and when a concrete proposal is submitted before us for sale, the same shall be considered and appropriate orders would be passed in this regard. However, the amount of Rs.250 crores (Rupees Two Hundred Fifty Crores) has to be deposited by 15th of June, 2018 without fail, in the escrow account to be opened with the UCO Bank of this Court. 8. There are certain outstanding dues of the buyers. It would be open to the buyers to deposit the said amount in the said escrow account. However, as soon as the projects are completed, we propose to give them reasonable time to deposit the outstanding dues. As soon as the promoter and co-developer are in a position to hand over the possession, the buyers shall have to deposit the outstanding amount in the escrow account to be opened in the UCO Bank, within three months time from the date of issuance of offer of possession. 9. We also propose to form a Committee to submit periodical reports of the progress of the construction, to this Court, consisting of the following members:
i. Architect of the developer; ii. Structural Engineer of the developer;
iii. Chartered Accountant appointed by the developer; as well as – iv. Architect of buyers v. Structural Engineer of buyers
vi. Chartered Accountant appointed by the buyers and apart from the above members, we appoint Mr. M.L. Lahoty, learned Advocate, as a member of the said Committee, so as to coordinate the effective functioning and to submit an appropriate periodical report in this Court. We appoint one nominee each of Greater Noida and Noida Authority, to be the member of said Committee. 10. There are certain unsold units in the various projects that have to be firstly adjusted by making swapping as agreed to, after that the remaining available units may also be permitted to be sold. In this regard, a proposal would be submitted as and when swapping process is completed and the details of property to be sold and amount of offer by the prospective buyers, be indicated by this Court. The proposal will be submitted for consideration so that appropriate orders may be passed by this Court. Let the Committee constituted by us also to supervise the swapping part. 11. Eight weeks’ time is granted to the buyers for the purpose of applying for swapping and decision shall be taken within 15 days from the date of application for the purpose of swapping is filed before the promoters. In case there is any difficulty in swapping, the Committee is authorized to take care of the grievances and to guide the promoters as well as the buyers. 12. As there are certain dues of Noida and Greater Noida Authorities and that of the secured creditors and operational/ unsecured creditors, let the proposal be submitted by the promoters in this regard, on or before 07.07.2018. We also place on record that approximately a sum of Rs.4,300-4,900/crores will be required for completion of the various projects as pointed out by promoters. 13. There are certain ‘C’ category projects. With respect to those projects also, as they are not taken care of during
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
swapping or there may be certain buyers not willing for swapping or certain amount may be required to be refunded to the buyers, who are not intending to purchase now and not opting for swapping or/and is not feasible, to take up those projects. The promoter shall also file its proposal with respect to such buyers who want their money to be refunded. Let that proposal be also filed after swapping is done indicating therein as to how many persons require to refund the money. The buyers in ‘C’ category projects only who are intending to obtain a refund, may also submit their proposal to the concerned promoter in the meantime, within one month from today.
14. The promoters with respect to Silicon Valley have applied for connection for electricity, sewerage, and water, as per the order passed by this Court on 10.5.2018. The aforesaid order is carried out punctually. The promoters of Silicon Valley has undertaken to make the payment of dues onwards.
15. The joint statement that has been filed has been signed in the Court by the learned counsel for the promoters as well as by learned counsel for the authorities and the flat buyers, is placed on record and made part of this order as “Annexure-A”.
16. The aforesaid Committee constituted by us is also requested to evaluate the work undertaken by M/s. Sahi Developers Pvt. Ltd. so far and submit a report in the 1 st week of July 2018.
17. Let nominations be made by the developers, flat buyers and authorities within seven days from today, under intimation to this Court.
18. The matter has been heard in part and requires a further hearing. List on 18.7.2018 at 2.00 p.m. 19. It is agreed to, that with respect to essential amenities, the order passed by this Court on 10.5.2018 shall also apply to Silicon City Phase I project and in case inhabitants are there in some towers, the same shall apply to Silicon City Phase-II project also.” The aforesaid order was passed on the basis of the joint proposal, which was in the form of four baskets with independent timelines, submitted in this Court.
12. It was also mentioned in paragraph 4 of the above order that admission has been made by the promoters/builders that the money to the extent of Rs.2,765 crores, out of six projects has been transferred to other projects. Though we were inclined to direct the promoter to deposit the said amount in this Court, we refrained from directing as the willingness to complete the projects was shown by engaging services of codevelopers and builder assured that it would undertake the work. It was proposed to sell certain unencumbered properties of Amrapali Group for payment of these projects, however, this Court directed to deposit an amount of Rs.250 crores in the escrow account to be opened in the UCO Bank, Supreme Court Branch on or before 15.6.2018. This order was again not complied with and the work was not undertaken and inability was shown to deposit the amount in the escrow account as ordered. When the case was listed on 18.7.2018 in this Court, learned counsel appearing on behalf of promoters was to place progress report, but in order to wriggle out of the compliance of order, totally a different stand was taken in this Court and it was stated that a notice dated 13.7.2018 has been issued by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, which was placed on record, indicating that a High-Level Committee has been created by the Government of U.P. to redress the issues of home buyers and the affected parties of incomplete/stalled house projects in the Noida/ Greater Noida/Yamuna Expressway under the Chairmanship of Secretary, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs. It was submitted on behalf of Amrapali Group that a meeting was held today and prayed that something concrete is likely to happen within ten days. We deferred the hearing up to 1.8.2018. However, at the same time, we directed the builder to file the accounts with effect from 1.4.2008 till date under the certificate of Chartered Accountant and also a list of all assets in a sealed cover in this Court. As a matter of fact, there was no compliance of the order dated 17.5.2018 of this Court, but the totally indifferent stand was taken so as to wriggle out of their obligation under said order was passed by this Court on the basis of the joint statement. 13. This Court has passed an order on 1.8.2018, wherein it was observed that in order to scuttle the hearing in this Court, it was stated that the meeting was held on the very same day. The order passed by this Court on 17.5.2018 to deposit Rs.250 crores had not been complied with. There was also an admission made by Amrapali Group that there was a diversion of more than Rs.2,765 crores from six projects. This
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
Court observed that money could not have been diverted. That would prima facie tantamount to a criminal breach of trust. We directed that the individual bank accounts of the Directors of all the 40 companies be frozen and ordered attachment of the properties in the individual names of Directors and also put a restriction on the alienation of the properties in the names of individual Directors etc. Following order was passed by this Court:
“1. On 17.5.2018, we have passed a detailed order in these cases after hearing learned counsel for the parties for several days. We need not reiterate the directions, statements, representations made to this Court and the orders which we have passed. Order dated 17.5.2018 is clear in this regard. As per the order passed by this Court, certain obligations were imposed and certain directions were issued which were to be complied with by the group of companies as well as the co-promoters, etc., as mentioned in the aforesaid order. The compliance has not been reported an effort was made to wriggle out of order passed on 17.5.2018. 2. When the matter was taken up on 18.7.2018, compliance of the order was not reported and on the other hand, a letter dated 13.7.2018 signed by Mr. Akhil Saxena, Deputy Secretary to the Government of India, was placed on record. The letter is extracted hereunder : “No.D.17024...sic Government of India Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi Dated July 13, 2018 Meeting Notice Subject: Meeting to discuss the issues of homebuyers and affected parties of Noida/Greater Noida/Yamuna Expressway scheduled to be held on 18.07.2018 at 11:00 A.M. - 1.00 P.M. - regarding.
The undersigned is directed to state that a High-Level Committee has been constituted by the Government of UP to redress the issues of homebuyers and affected parties of incomplete/stalled housing projects in the Noida/Greater Noida/
Yamuna Expressway under the Chairmanship of Secretary, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs.
2. In this regard the Chairman of the Committee and Secretary MoUHUA will hold a meeting with the developers/promoters (Amrapali Group Jaypee Infratech Limited, Three C Group of Companies and Unitech Limited) on 18 July, 2018 at 11:00 A.M. - 1:00 PM in Room No.123-C, Conference Room, 1st Floor, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi. You are requested to kindly make it convenient to attend the meeting personally. You may also bring the details of the housing projects promoted by your company along with your specific plans as to how earliest you can deliver the flats/houses to the home buyers who have made payments towards the same to your company. 3. A line in confirmation on email, housingministry@gmail.com will be highly appreciated. Sd/(Akhil Saxena) Deputy Secretary to the Govt. of India Tel No.23062280 To 1. Shri Shiv Priya, ED, Amrapali Group, C-56/40 Sector-62, Noida-2301307. 2. Shri Nirmal Singh, Three C Group of Companies, Tech Boulevard Central Block, Plot No.6, Sector 127, Noida-201307.
3. Shri Manoj Gaur, Jaypee Infratech Limited, Sector 128, Noida-201304 (U.P.), India. 4. Dr. Ramesh Chandra, Chairman, Unitech Limited, 6, Community Centre, Saket, New Delhi-110017. Copy to :
1. Sr.PPS to Secretary, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs. 2. PPS to Additional Secretary (Housing), Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs. 3. PS to Economic Adviser (Housing), Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] 4. Deputy Secretary (Housing), MoHUA Sd/(Anil Saxena) Deputy Secretary to the Govt. of India Tel. No.23062280" 3. In order to scuttle the hearing in this Court on 18.7.2018 on which the case was listed, it was reported to us that meeting was held on that very day which was presided over by the Secretary, Ministry of Housing, who is the Chairperson of the Committee and Secretary MoUHUA. Thereafter, pursuant to the said meeting it was stated today that NBCC India Limited, a Government of India enterprise, has invited “Expression of Interest” for joint development in real estate with respect to the development of residential and commercial real estate projects in Delhi and NCR region, inclusive of the Amrapali Group for which we have already passed orders on 17.5.2018. 4. In case the Committee constituted by the Government of Uttar Pradesh wanted to take up the matter of Amrapali Group in view of the order dated 17.5.2018, it was necessary for them to seek the express permission from this Court, as this Court was in seisin of the matters, before transacting any business in this regard. But that has not been done and when the order of this Court stands, it was not at all appropriate or permissible to take up the matter by the Committee and intermeddle with the order passed by this Court when the matter is pending in this Court. The action has a clear effect on rendering order passed by this Court ineffective. In the circumstances, we deem it appropriate to direct the presence of the Secretary to the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs and the Chairman of the NBCC India Limited and to file their affidavit in this Court and produce entire record so as to show how they have convened the meeting and acted in the manner in the matter pending in this Court, without permission of this Court before dealing with the matter of Amrapali Group. Let them be present before this Court tomorrow, i.e., on 2.8.2018, at 2.00 p.m. to explain their stand.
5. Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma, Chairman and Managing Director (CMD) of Amrapali Group of Companies were personally present
in this Court. He has stated that there are 40 companies in the Amrapali Group of Companies. They are as follows: 1. Ultra Home Pvt. Ltd. 2. Amrapali Silicon City Pvt. Ltd. 3. Amrapali Zodiac Developer Pvt. Ltd. 4. Amrapali Sapphire Developer Pvt. Ltd. 5. Amrapali Princely Estate Pvt. Ltd. 6. Amrapali Eden Park Developer Pvt. Ltd. 7. Amrapali Smart City Developer Pvt. Ltd. 8. Amrapali Smart City Pvt. Ltd. 9. Amrapali Leisure Valley Pvt. Ltd. 10. Amrapali Leisure Valley Developer Pvt. Ltd. 11. Amrapali Centurian Park Pvt. Ltd. 12. Amrapali Dream Valley Pvt. Ltd. 13. Amrapali Homes Project Pvt. Ltd. 14. Hi-Tech City Developer Pvt. Ltd. 15. Sangam Coloniger Pvt. Ltd. 16. Shalimar Coloniger Pvt. Ltd. 17. Amrapali Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. 18. Amrapali Aerocity Pvt. Ltd. 19. Amrapali Mahi Developer Pvt. Ltd. 20. Amrapali Buddha Developer Pvt. Ltd. 21. Amrapali Hospitality Pvt. Ltd. 22. Amrapali Biotech Pvt. Ltd. 23. Amrapali Health Care Pvt. Ltd. 24. Amrapali Hospitality Pvt. Ltd. 25. Amrapali Power & Cement Pvt. Ltd. 26. Stunning Construction Co. Pvt. Ltd. 27. Kapila Build Home Pvt. Ltd. 28. Gaurisuta Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. 29. Gaurisuta Infra Solution Pvt. Ltd. 30. MSB Software Pvt. Ltd. 31. MVG Techno Consultant Pvt. Ltd. 32. Noida Text Fab Pvt. Ltd. 33. Navodya Properties Pvt. Ltd. 34. AHS Joint Venture 35. Amrapali Homes 36. Amrapali Grand 37. HIMS Pvt. Ltd.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] 38. Amrapali Spring Valley Pvt. Ltd. 39. Amrapali Patel Platinum 40. Amrapali Media Vision Pvt. Ltd. 6. The order passed by this Court of depositing 250 crores of rupees has not complied. There is an admission already made by Amrapali Group that there was a diversion of more than 2765 crores of rupees from six projects to other projects. In the circumstances, we direct the Bank accounts of all the aforesaid 40 companies be frozen forthwith. We forthwith attach the entire immovable properties of these 40 group of companies. They shall not be entitled to deal with the same in any manner whatsoever without the express permission of this Court. 7. There was a diversion of the funds, prima facie it is apparent that when the money was paid by the buyers for the purpose of investment in the particular project, it could not have been diverted. That would prima facie tantamount to a criminal breach of trust. We are not expressing any final opinion in this regard at this moment. However, at the same time, we propose to take a call on this after hearing the parties on this aspect. However, so as to further ascertain the extent of internal and external diversion from all the projects. The names of all the Chartered Accountants of all the aforesaid 40 companies be disclosed to us and their reports from 2008 till today be placed on record by tomorrow. 8. The individual Bank accounts of the Directors of all the 40 companies are also freezed and they shall not be entitled to operate the same with immediate effect. Let details of all Bank accounts be furnished by tomorrow of companies and their Directors and of personal accounts of Directors. The properties in the individual names of the Directors are also attached and the same shall not be disposed of or alienated in any manner without the express order of this Court. 9. Let the matter be listed tomorrow, i.e., on 2.8.2018 at 2.00 p.m. Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma, Mr. Shiv Priya and Mr. Ajay Kumar of Amrapali group of companies to remain personally present in this Court tomorrow, along with the aforesaid officials.” 14. It was stated by Secretary, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs that he was not aware of the order passed by this Court on
17.5.2018, appointing promoters and time frame and stated that he never intended to violate the order passed by this Court. On 2.8.2018, we have recalled the order dated 17.5.2018, considering the dubious and unfair conduct of the Amrapali Group of Companies and on each and every day they have been shifting their stand. Earlier, they have filed affidavits making certain representations and now want to wriggle out of it. Following order was passed on 2.8.2018, recalling the order dated 17.5.2018: “1. Pursuant to the order passed yesterday, i.e., on 1.8.2018, Mr. Durga Shankar Mishra, Secretary, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, has stated that a Committee has been constituted by the Government of Uttar Pradesh under his chairmanship to look into the problems of three lakhs home buyers of Noida, Greater Noida, and Yamuna Expressway. The Committee has been constituted so as to take a policy decision so as to solve the problems of the home buyers. On 25.6.2018, the first meeting of the then Chief Executive Officers (CEOs) of the Noida and Greater Noida, real estate representatives, etc. was held and thereafter, second meeting was held on 10.7.2018, which was attended by 32 persons, inter alia including certain representatives of the Flat Owners Welfare Association, Joint General Manager, ICICI Bank, AGM of the Bank of Baroda, General Manager of HDFC Bank and Chairman of CREDAI had also attended the meeting. Thereafter, no meeting of the Committee has been held. However, a discussion with the Chairman of representatives of the four builders, i.e., Amrapali Group, Jaypee Infratech Ltd., Three C Group and Unitech Limited was held on 18.7.2018, along with details of the housing projects promoted by their companies and with the specific plans as to how earliest they could deliver the flats/houses to the home buyers who have made payments towards their companies. It was also stated by the Secretary that he was not aware that this Court has passed an order on 17.5.2018 appointing promoters etc. and the time frame within which the projects have to be completed. He has also stated that he never intended to violate the orders passed by this Court. The statement made by Mr. Mishra is placed on record. 2. It was also submitted that NBCC issued advertisement on 30.7.2018 and the Chairman of the NBCC has informed us that the said advertisement was not issued specifically for Amrapali Group of companies. Similar advertisements have been issued
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] earlier too. However, it was stated by the Chairman that they are ready to undertake the Amrapali Group projects and to complete them, after making the detailed study of the stage and investment which is required to be made in the projects that are incomplete. 3. Pursuant to the directions issued by the Court, Amrapali Group has placed on record the account numbers and other details of 38 of Amrapali Group of companies only, but not that of the personal accounts and the accounts in names of its Directors, as per the order passed by this Court on 1.8.2018. They have furnished the details of 38 companies out of 40. They are contained in Annexures marked as X-1 and X-2.
4. We direct the Registry to apprise the concerned Banks along with the text of the order and the account numbers so furnished. Let the copy of the order be sent to the Banks for its due compliance. 5. It was stated that the personal Bank accounts in the names of the Directors of aforesaid 40 companies are in the process of compilation and that the account numbers shall be furnished to this Court by Monday, i.e., 6th August 2018. On the account number being furnished, the Registry is directed to intimate the order to the said Banks also regarding the order passed by this Court on 1.8.2018. 6. Two applications, i.e., I.A.Nos.82917/2018 and 92775/2018 in W.P.(C)No.942/2017 have been filed by the Amrapali Silicon City Flat Owners Welfare Society and Heartbeat City for modification of order dated 17.5.2018. It was also pointed out that one of codeveloper, IIFL, has backed out, thus, it was not possible to comply with the order dated 17.5.2018 and same requires modification. The sum of Rs.250 crores has also not been deposited. An application has been filed so as to waive that requirement also. When we see the conduct of the promoter on the various stages, it is apparent that on 18.7.2018 on behalf of the promoter it was stated before us that the Committee has been constituted by the Government of Uttar Pradesh under the Chairmanship of the Secretary, Ministry of Housing & Urban Affairs, as such we should wait for the outcome of same. Yesterday, i.e., on 1.8.2018 it was stated before us that NBCC is now considering to take over the entire project of Amrapali Group as it has issued an advertisement
for the purpose and as such the Court should stay in our hands. In the circumstances, it is apparent that the Amrapali Group does not intend to abide by order dated 17.5.2018 and its conduct is dubious. Thus, we have no hesitation in recalling the order dated 17.5.2018 permitting Amrapali Group to complete the projects. We hereby recall the order entrusting the project to the Amrapali Group of companies for completion, along with co-promoters, and we place it on record that the conduct of Amrapali Group of companies is wholly unfair and on each and every date they have been shifting their stand before us and it was absolutely improper on their part to do so. They have violated our order also. They have earlier filed affidavits making certain representations and now want to wriggle out of that. Be that as it may. We recall the order dated 17.5.2018 under the aforesaid circumstances. 7. In the circumstances, as the Chairman of the NBCC is present before us and has shown willingness to undertake the projects, the matter cannot be left at that. Let the NBCC complete the projects, let it undertake the study and work out the details. Though the time of 45 days was prayed, considering the urgency of the matter, we grant 30 days’ time, as the people are deprived of basic necessities of life, and they are residing in some incomplete buildings. We appreciate the gesture of the Chairman of NBCC, who has assured us to complete the projects as may be directed and to submit a proposal in this Court within 30 days. Let a proposal be submitted in 30 days before us. 8. In the circumstances, we direct the promoters and also request Mr. M.L. Lahoty and two other representatives to be nominated by home buyers to assist and submit the details and all requisite documents to the Chairman, NBCC as also to the Chairman of the Committee. Noida authority and Greater Noida authority shall also furnish to them all the documents which are in their possession. Let promoter, Noida authority, Greater Noida authority and buyers furnish all the documents/pleadings they have submitted to this Court, within three days from today. 9. We also place on record the appreciation to the offer made by the Chairman, NBCC, and also by Mr. Mishra, Chairman of the Committee. Let them make an endeavour to form policy and to solve problems of other groups of companies also. However, the
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] matters are pending in the Court, they have to appraise this Court of their proposals and only thereafter to take steps in this regard. 10. Mr. Anil Mittal, the Chartered Accountant of Anil Ajay & Company, who is the statutory auditor for most of the companies, is present in the Court. Similarly, Mr. Ravi Kapoor, the Chartered Accountant of Serva Associates is also present in the Court. It is pointed out that the information furnished by them is contained on page 6 and 7 of the compilation Annexure X-1. It is stated by Mr. Anil Mittal that his engagement as statutory auditor has begun in the year 2008 and continued up to 2015. He was the auditor from 2008 and has also stated before us that after 2015 no papers have been given to him. It was stated by Mr. Gaurav Bhatia, learned counsel, that at present S.N. Dhawan & Company is doing the audit of the Company. 11. Since we find that various documents have been placed on record indicating transfer/diversion of the fund by the Amrapali Group itself, the Amrapali Group has admitted that out of the six projects, there was transfer/diversion of Rs.2765 crores. Though it was submitted that the amount was transferred to other projects, in our opinion, this was clearly diversion of funds. The amount given by the home buyers for the completion of their projects/ houses could not have been diverted before the completion of the projects. We request the auditors to find out how much money has been so transmitted/diverted to other projects and how it has been used. Let projectwise information of all projects be furnished. The Amrapali Group of Companies shall furnish the requisite information and documents and shall cooperate with the statutory auditors. Let the auditor certify how much money has been diverted from which project and how it has been used in other projects, including the projects of Heartbeat city. The internal auditor is requested to assist Mr. Anil Mittal in this regard. 12. It was stated before us that the bank accounts of Amrapali Healthcare Pvt. Ltd. have also been frozen and it is necessary to run the hospital to keep the accounts operational. Considering the fact that the hospital requires money on a day-to-day basis, we order de-freezing of account of Amrapali Healthcare Pvt. Ltd. only. However, at the same time, we direct that let the details of the bank account(s) of it be placed before us right from 2008 till
date. Interim order dated 1.8.2018 to continue unless otherwise ordered. 13. For the purpose of assessing the proposal to be submitted by the NBCC and to pass requisite orders in this regard, we fix the hearing on 4.9.2018 at 2.00 p.m. Let the aforesaid reports be submitted by Mr. Anil Mittal and Mr. Ravi Kapoor, Chartered Accounts before 4.9.2018. For further order of other IAs. and arrangement of funds to be provided to NBCC and regarding furnishing of accounts, let matters be listed on 8.8.2018 at 2.00 p.m. Personal presence of Secretary, Housing and Urban Affairs and Chairman, NBCC, is dispensed with.” 15. There are various order sheets indicating how the wrong and incomplete information had been submitted on behalf of Directors of Amrapali Group of Companies.
16. The National Building Construction Corporation Ltd. had been appointed by this Court to complete the construction vide order dated 12.9.2018. 17. Vide order dated 8.8.2018, this Court had directed the Directors of various companies including the Managing Directors to file affidavits regarding immovable properties and moveable properties and their valuation. We had earlier asked the statutory auditors of Amrapali group of companies to conduct the audit. However, it was pointed out on 4.9.2018 that there was the necessity of appointing independent auditors so as to conduct a forensic audit. On 6.9.2018 this Court directed the forensic audit. Following order was passed on 4.9.2018 : “We have heard learned counsel for the parties. A proposal has been submitted by the NBCC in the booklet form. Let it be placed on record along with an affidavit of a responsible officer of the NBCC. Let a copy of the same be circulated to the learned counsel appearing for the parties. Let Amrapali Group of Companies file a response to the NBCC’s proposal for completion of the project. We have heard Sh. Gaurav Bhatia about the property which can be sold. He has attracted our attention to the affidavit of Shri Anil
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] Kumar Sharma in terms of the Court’s order 10.5.2018 filed with respect to I.A. No. 7366 of 2018 in W.P. No. 942 of 2017.
He has submitted that Saleable Area Commercial is described at page 20 of the affidavit. The value is given as per the development model, not the Distress Sale Value. Let Distress Sale Value be also stated on affidavit and with respect to the fact that what are the encumbrances and also the dues of Noida/Greater Noida Authorities as against the property as mentioned at page 20 of the affidavit.
He has also attracted our attention to the list of encumbered property on page 27 of the affidavit and list of unencumbered property on page 28.
Let affidavit be filed specifically stating with respect to the nature and extent of encumbrances with respect to encumbered property and how much is the amount due and what are the documents executed.
With respect to list of the unencumbered property also mentioned at page 28 there are certain dues of Noida/Greater Noida Authority that may be clearly specified and let affidavit also specifically state that these properties are otherwise unencumbered properties. Affidavit in detail be filed in this regard too.
With respect to the audit, the accounts for three years have not been made available to statutory Auditor as pointed out by Mr. Anil Mittal of Anil Ajay & Co., appointed by this Court. Mr. Maninder Singh learned senior counsel has urged that there is the necessity of appointing independent auditors so as to conduct a forensic audit. He has prayed for time to suggest the names in this regard. It was also pointed out by the learned counsel appearing for the Bank of Baroda that certain audit exercise has been undertaken on behalf of the Bank of Baroda with respect to the transaction entered into with Bank of Baroda which was the subject matter of other proceedings. Let the names of Auditor be suggested so as to conduct a deep and pervasive forensic audit of the Amrapali Group of Companies.
Suggestions be made on the next date of hearing.
Mr. Shyam Diwan and Mr. Siddharth Luthra learned senior counsel have pressed I.A. Nos. 124711-124712 of 2018 and I.A. No. 36562 of 2018. These I.As are to be considered after forensic Audit is concluded and a report is received. List on 6th September 2018.”
18. This Court appointed Mr. Ravi Bhatia of M/s. Bhatia & Co. and Mr. Pawan Kumar Aggarwal of M/s. Sharp & Tannan Company to conduct the forensic audit, which was ordered to be conducted with effect from the year 2008 till date, to be completed within two months. On 12.9.2018, a list of properties was submitted which was to be sold by the Debt Recovery Tribunal, Delhi, (DRT) and the details of properties, title deeds and maps were to be submitted to the DRT. This Court directed statutory Auditor, Mr. Anil Mittal, to hand over the original records of Amrapali group of companies vide order dated 12.9.2018. This Court also directed remaining records from 2008 till date, be handed over within 10 days. Amrapali group of companies were also directed to hand over the documents required by the forensic auditors. The matter was taken up by this Court on 26.9.2018. Considering the non-cooperation of the Directors, the following order was passed by this Court on 26.9.2018 : “Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
It was pointed out by Mr. M.L.Lahoty, learned senior counsel that there are certain existing Directors, namely, Mr. Anurag Sanghai, Mr.Vinay Vishal and Mr.Sankalp Shukla, particulars of their properties, etc. have not been filed as ordered by this Court and there are several other existing or former directors whose names have not been disclosed. Let the names of all the directors be disclosed without remiss before the next date fixed along with details of asset etc. as already ordered by this Court. It was also pointed out by Mr. Lahoty in I.A. No.116688/2018 that ‘O’ 2 valley particulars have not been disclosed by the group of companies. Let reply to the said I.A be filed by the Amrapali Group of companies and details of ‘O’ 2 Valley be also disclosed. It was also pointed out that DRT has initiated the proceedings and has directed the production of the original documents, sanctioned plans and other relevant documents available with Amrapali Group of Companies. It was also submitted that valuation has also been
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] ordered. We direct the Amrapali Group of companies and the Directors viz. Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma, Ms. Shiv Priya, and Mr.Ajay Kumar to submit Maps clearly delineating an unencumbered portion of their properties and other details which have been asked by the DRT. Let them be present before the DRT on each and every date until and unless it is specifically dispensed with by the DRT. Let the order of DRT be complied with by the Amrapali Group of the company before 4.10.2018.
With respect to the handing over the documents by the Statutory Auditors as well as by the Amrapali Group of companies, we note it regrettably that order passed by this Court has been violated and the documents have not been handed over in spite of clear and categorical direction to hand over the documents to forensic auditors within ten days. However, it was pointed out by Mr. Gaurav Bhatia, learned counsel that statutory auditors are going to hand over the document, etc. w.e.f. 2008 to 2015 by tomorrow to the forensic auditors. Let all the necessary documents which may be in possession of Amrapali Group of companies in addition to statutory auditors be also handed over from 2008-2015 and also all the papers of Amrapali Group of companies 2015-2018 by tomorrow. We make it clear that the documents with respect to 2015-2018 shall be handed over by the Amrapali Group companies along with all the original documents necessary to do audit shall be handed over to the forensic auditors by tomorrow. Let account books in whatever status they are, at present, be also handed over.
We request the forensic auditors to send their representative on the next date of hearing to apprise us of compliance of this order.
Before IRB certain proceedings are pending for recovery of dues and inter alia, there are dues of Bank of Maharashtra, etc also as pointed out including that of Bank of Baroda. Let the details of all the outstanding dues of secured and unsecured creditors project-wise and in total be submitted in this Court in a tabular form. Let total outstanding dues be stated, including that of Noida and Greater Noida authorities supported by affidavit. Mr. Anoop Kumar Mittal, Chairman of the NBCC and Ms. Pinky Anand, ASG are present. It was pointed out on behalf of the
NBCC that detailed project report has to be prepared of Group A Project within 30 days and Group B and C Projects within 60 days. It was also pointed out that tenders may be permitted to be floated by NBCC Group A and B projects. The NBCC is permitted to float the tenders and also to go ahead with the preparation of the DPRs and also to submit detailed proposals, terms, and conditions in this Court as prayed by them. Existing architects of Amrapali Group of Companies to ensure cooperation with the NBCC. Non-cooperation shall be viewed seriously by this Court. Let DRT go ahead with the process of finding out the encumbrances. We also permit the Bank of Maharashtra and all other such creditors who may have a charge on the unencumbered property to state their claim before DRT. Let reply be filed in IA No.139255/2018, 117300/2018,95140/2018, 135446/2018, 138400/2018.
All applications for impleadments to the extent of intervention are allowed. List on 9.10.2018.”
19. On 9.10.2018 when despite the orders dated 12.9.2018 and 26.9.2018, orders were not complied with, records were not handed over and there was utter violation of orders passed by this Court, we directed the Police to seize all the documents and to hand them over to the Forensic Auditors from the possession of 46 companies and their Directors. We directed all the Directors to surrender their passports and hand them over to the Police. The observations made by this Court were being misused by Amrapali group of companies, “No coercive action will be taken by any authority with respect to the building where completion is going on under the order passed by this Court”. As observed on 27.3.2018, we clarified that the observations did not deal with any police investigation in any criminal case or in FIR which may have been registered with the Delhi Police, EOW, to make investigation in any case which is required to be made. Police was free to make an investigation. On 10.10.2018 this Court directed the concerned police officers to seal all the seven premises situated at Noida and Greater Noida. On 11.10.2018 certain directions were issued so as to facilitate the forensic audit. After audit work was over for the day, on a prayer
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
made by learned counsel on behalf of the three Directors of Amrapali group of companies, they were permitted to stay overnight in Hotel Park Ascent but they shall not be allowed any access to the mobile phone or the facility of telecommunication without permission in writing of the police. This Court also directed issuance of a formal notice on the suo moto contempt.
20. On 24.10.2018 the forensic auditors were present. They have disclosed as to diversion of funds of more than Rs.100 crores to a firm known as GauriSuta Infrastructures Pvt. Ltd. in which Ashish Jain and Vivek Mittal were the Directors. They are stated to be the relatives of the Statutory Auditors. We directed the personal presence of Chander Wadhwa, CFO of Amrapali group of companies on the next date. On 26.10.2018 the Forensic Auditors submitted an interim report. It was pointed out that the tally data of 23 companies, reserves and surplus figures as appearing in the tally data does not reconcile with the reserves and surplus as appearing in the last signed financials. The difference has also been pointed out in a tabular form. There were several advances, investments, utilisations, advances made to suppliers and payments made to Mr. Anil Sharma and Mr. Shiv Priya, Directors of the company for professional charges, etc. It was also pointed out that in spite of repeated reminders, groupings have not been supplied. Grouping is a process to indicate the process between the stage of trial balance, balance sheet, and profit and loss account. All files had not been handed over and Mr. Anil Mittal, the Statutory Auditor had sent one file late in the evening. This Court ordered that in case documents were not handed over, the same shall be viewed seriously and the incumbents punished suitably. The last opportunity was granted to hand over the requisite documents to the Forensic Auditors. We directed Statutory Auditors to comply with the requisition made by the Forensic Auditors. It was also noted by this Court that a sum of Rs.242.38 crores had been handed over to Gaurisuta Infrastructure Private Ltd., Vidhyashree Buildcon Private Ltd., Mannat Buildcraft Private Ltd. This Court observed in para 5 thus : “5. It has also been pointed out by Shri Pawan K. Aggarwal in his report that so far with respect to four companies, namely, Gaurisuta Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., Vidhyashree Buildcon Pvt. Ltd., Mannat Buildcraft Pvt. Ltd. And Jhamb Finance & Leasing Pvt. Ltd., only it has been noticed that a sum of Rs.242.38 crores has been
handed over to them and in most of these firms Shri Ashish Jain and Shri Vivek Mittal are the Directors. Beside, it was stated before us by Shri Anil Mittal, statutory auditor, that his nephewVivek Mittal joined as a Director on the request made by Shri Chander Wadhwa, CFO, to create a company and he has in turn asked Shri Ashish Jain, an employee of his client, to join as another Directory of at least 10 companies, created at the request of the CFO and Amrapali Group of Companies. It is a shocking state of affairs that the statutory auditor himself was responsible for the creation of companies in an aforesaid manner. Shri Anil Mittal has also stated before us that he was aware that the money was flowing to the said companies through bank statements. However, on a specific query made by this Court to him, he has admitted that this fact of flow of money was not reflected in the audit report, which was signed by him in the audited Balance Sheet, in spite of knowing the fact that money has flown out of the accounts of the Amrapali Group of Companies to aforesaid companies.” About the creation of companies consisting of his nephew as Director on the request made by Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO for asking Ashish Jain, an employee of his client, to join as another Director. The Company agreed at the request of the CFO and Amrapali group of companies. 21. Since the CFO did not reply to the questions put by the Forensic Auditors to him, his conduct has been noted by this Court thus:
“6. We regretfully also note the conduct of the CFO, who is personally present before us today. His questions and answers have been placed on record by Shri Pavan K. Aggarwal, Forensic Auditor, along with his report and today we find that Shri Chander Wadhwa has contradicted his version which he had made to the Forensic Auditor. He has apologized for making wrong statements to the Forensic Auditor and has assured us that in future he will render all cooperation to the Forensic Auditors rightly, honestly and diligently. He has admitted today that there was appointment order as CFO and there was an authorization in writing issued to him for dealing with the banks. He has virtually contradicted the entire statement which he had made and has feigned ignorance to the Forensic Auditors. Be that as it may. We give him the last
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] opportunity to come out clean and live up to the reputation of a profession of a Chartered Accountant. Let him cooperate with the Forensic Auditors, supply entire information correctly, truly and diligently. In case any remiss is found, it is made clear not only to him but also to the statutory/internal auditors that we will be compelled to take appropriate action as against them in the aforesaid factual situation, including the one for the professional misconduct.” 22. It was further pointed out by the forensic auditors that there were 23 more groups of companies to whom money had been diverted and these companies had been created by Amrapali group of companies. This Court directed disclosure of these companies in the order dated 26.10.2018 thus: “7. Shri Pavan K. Aggarwal has also pointed out to us that there are 23 groups of companies to whom the money has been diverted and these companies have been created. Let the names of the companies be disclosed to the Amrapali Group of Companies and we direct the police to seize all the documents of these 23 companies to which money has been diverted and be handed over to the Forensic Auditors. 9. We also direct the Directors of other 23 companies, which have been identified so far by the Forensic Auditors, to file their detailed affidavits in this Court, disclosing the amount received by them, dates of receipt, for what purpose and how it is utilized and invested by them.” 23. We had also directed Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO to file affidavit pointing out appointment order, authorisation, authority to sign any voucher and his entire role in the organisation thus: “13. Let Shri Chander Wadhwa, CFO, file his affidavit in this Court placing the appointment order; authorization made to him from time to time; his authorization letters; details of attendance, if any, at the Board meetings; authority to sign any voucher; and his entire role which he has performed in the organization. Besides, it was also stated by Shri Chander Wadhwa, CFO, that he was one of the Directors of the Amrapali Development UK Ltd. and Saffron LLP, Delhi. Let the details of the Articles of Association
of these companies be placed on record and the present composition of the Directors and the entire transactions be disclosed on affidavit, along with the documents of these companies and returns, if any, which have been filed, be also handed over to the Forensic Auditors and affidavit be filed in this Court in this regard.
14. It was also stated by Shri Chander Wadhwa that his nephew is one of the Directors in M/s. Rinku Computech, one of the shareholders of the Amrapali Biotech India Pvt. Ltd. His disclosure on affidavit be also made by Shri Chander Wadhwa.”
24. We also issued other directions to ensure that laptops and computers were made available to forensic auditors. On 31.10.2018 this Court noted that certain transactions of Amrapali group to Zodiac/J.P. Morgan, Mauritius/Singapore by the creation of various companies. We directed the bank statement of J.P. Morgan from 2008 till date to be filed. With respect to the money received from the Indian companies and in particular from Amrapali group of companies, all monetary transactions of J.P. Morgan, Mauritius and Singapore with Amrapali group of companies be disclosed with details on affidavit. We directed the Amrapali group of companies/statutory auditors as well as Anil Mittal, Ravi Kapoor and S.N. Dhawan and CFO to disclose the names of all the companies in which their family members or acquaintance were included as Director and all the transactions inter alia family members and relatives. It was also pointed out by Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO that though his salary was Rs.15,000 per month, a car worth Rs.43 lakhs was given to him by the company in lieu of his services. It was also pointed out that an amount of Rs.2 crores has been paid on account of Chander Wadhwa’s tax liability by Amrapali group of companies. Further directions were also issued to make the disclosures. This Court has noted the conduct of non-compliance of the order vide order dated 13.11.2018 thus: “4. This Court has drawn suo moto contempt on 12.10.2018 and that is listed on 20.11.2018. In spite of the aforesaid observation made in the order dated 26.10.2018, still there is gross disobedience of the directions issued by this Court and in the affidavit filed in compliance of the order dated 26.10.2018, the various disclosures as ordered have not been made. Besides that, there is a failure to hand over to the forensic auditors, the relevant material as pointed out by them.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] 5. The names of all the related companies have also not been disclosed with which the transactions have taken place. No such statement has been made categorically in terms of the order passed by this Court on 31.10.2018 and absolutely vague averments have been made. This tantamount to deliberate noncompliance of the orders of this Court despite several opportunities having been granted. 7. An affidavit has also been filed by Mr. Anil Sharma of Amrapali Group of Companies in which names of the companies which were ordered to be disclosed have not been disclosed and no statement has been made as ordered on 31.10.2018. It is a gross violation of the orders passed by this Court. There are certain averments in the affidavit which shows that certain properties have been sub-leased, out of Dream Valley, Centurian Park, Amrapali Leisure Valley. The subleases have been created. Full disclosures have not been made as to subleasing since earlier affidavits were contrary to it, it was shown as unencumbered property. we direct the Directors of Amrapali Group of Companies to disclose entire transaction and relevant documents as well as Greater Noida Authorities to file the documents about sub-leases, who is holding the land as on today, its considerations, how it has been used, how much consideration was received and where the amount is lying, and the sub-lease deeds be also placed on record. We order that there shall not be any further alienation of the subleased property by anyone. 8. Statements of various bank accounts have also not been furnished besides other particulars. Learned counsel has again surprisingly prayed for three weeks’ further time to furnish the details though sufficient time had been given. No direction is being complied with. The Directors are filing the affidavit on each and every date making improvement as the forensic audit progresses. They are not making full disclosures and concealing the facts and have not mentioned in the affidavit what they are ordered to do. It is clear that they are obstructing the course of justice to the best of their ability. This state of affairs cannot be continued any further. For non-compliance of the directions issued from time to time, we have already drawn suo moto contempt and as subsequent orders
have also been violated. For the purpose of taking the contempt proceedings to further logical end, before this Court passes any further order, we give an opportunity to the Amrapali Group of Companies and Directors to furnish their reply as to why they should not be punished for the contempt and the violation of the order passed by this Court from time to time by November 19, 2018. The case will be taken up for considering non-compliance of the order and for filing the wrong affidavits before this Court, on 20.11.2018 along with the suo moto contempt that has been registered vide order dated 12.10.2018. 9. We have two affidavits. One of Anil Mittal and another of Chander Wadhwa. Both are passing liability on each other for creating certain additional companies. None want to own the responsibility. We require Amrapali Group of Companies and their Directors to file a reply to the affidavit, filed by their CFO Chander Wadhwa and Anil Mittal. Let the copies of affidavits of Chander Wadhwa and Anil Mittal be furnished to the Advocate on Record, Amrapali Group of Companies. Let para-wise and point-wise reply be submitted as to what has transpired in the Court, as recorded in order-sheets, including what they have stated in their affidavits. 12. It was also pointed out that Computech Pvt Ltd. is in possession of a substantial amount. The forensic auditors are in the process of examining the details. However, at this juncture pursuant to findings of forensic auditors, it was pointed out by Mr. Vikas Singh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Chander Wadhwa, CFO that a sum of Rs.7.58 crore from Rinku Computech Private Limited and Rs.4.1 crore is lying with Chander Wadhwa, said amount is out of the transactions with the Amrapali Group of Companies. He has volunteered to deposit the amount within three weeks from today. Let it be deposited in the account opened with the Registrar of this court, within three weeks. 14. From the forensic auditors’ report, it is prima facie clear that Amrapali Healthcare Private Limited, as pointed out in Annexure 11 is created out of funds belonging to the Amrapali group. That is extracted hereunder:
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] Annexure-11 Amrapali Healthcare Private Limited (As per Audited financials 2015-16) Details of Asset Sl. No. 1.
Asset Land
Book value 0.53
2.
Building
4.43
(Figures in crore) Address Amrapali Hospital P2, NH-34 Omega 1, Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh-201310 Amrapali Hospital P2, NH-34 Omega 1, Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh-201310
Date of transaction Area (sq. meters)Constructed areaSl. No. 1.
2. 3.
Shareholder’ Name Ultra Home Constructions Private Limited Swapnil Shikha Suvash Chandra Kumar Total
% holding
No. of shares
99.89 %
93,85,260
0.03 %
2500
0.08%
7500
100 %
93,95,260
* In FY 2016-17 the shares of Ultra Homes Construction Pvt. Ltd. are transferred in the name of Gaurisuta Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Details of Inter Corporate Deposits Sl. No. Name of company 1. Ultra Home Construction Private Limited 2. Others
Amount 5.36
(figures in crore)
0.32
List of Present Directors Sl. No. Name 1. Swapnil Shikha 2. Suvash Chandra Kumar
Begin Date 27/11/2012 27/11/2012
It has also been pointed out that this hospital is, in fact, owned to the extent of 99.89 percent by Ultra Home Constructions Pvt Ltd. and funding has been made by the said company. It is one of the companies out of the Amrapali Group of Companies involved in the case. Thus, it is apparent that this property has to be sold as it has been purchased out of money of buyers, in order to make available the money for the construction of the buildings. 17. It is a case where we find ourselves in a situation that the money of Greater Noida and Noida Authorities has not been paid, buyers have also been duped. Other financial institutions have not been paid. Construction has not been completed. Money paid by buyers has been diverted for the creation of various companies and assets have been created. All these assets are accountable and have to be sold as it is not the independent investment made by these directors. It is a patent and blatant fraud which appears to have been played, the way in which the money has been transacted and creation of companies has taken place in connivance with the CFO, statutory auditors. It was also pointed out that there are various related companies in which money has been transferred. We restrain all monetary transactions out of bank accounts or any kind of alienation of the property held by the related group of companies where the money has been siphoned and has been used for the creation of the assets. Any transfer made in any manner shall be illegal, void and inoperative. 20. It is also necessary in order to find out the actual amount invested in building activities, out of the funds collected. It also appears that certain companies were created only for the purpose of purchasing raw materials. Whether actual transactions of purchase have taken place is required to be ascertained. Let all the vouchers of the purchase, Bills, orders, etc., which are in possession of Amrapali Group of Companies and the estimates of various raw materials for each and every building without which
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] construction of a building is not possible to be undertaken to be positively handed over to the forensic auditors within a week. We also request the forensic auditors to propose how the actual valuation of the buildings constructed so far by the Amrapali Group of Companies on the spot can be made so as to ascertain the actual investments made and extent of diversion. Let the estimate and quantities of the bills be also furnished by Amrapali Group to the forensic auditors along with the names of all the suppliers and mode of payment. They may also collect information/documents from suppliers.” Certain directions were also issued to DRT to make the valuation to sell the property. Other facts were also noted. 25. On 20.11.2018 this Court had noted non-compliance of various orders passed by this Court from time to time. Various sub-leases had also been created. We issued the directions vide order dated 20.11.2018 as under: “3. It appears that various sub-lessees have been created. It was informed to us by the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the Amrapali Group of Companies that certain structures have been raised by the sub-lessees. We have asked them to disclose all the information on affidavit, but the order still remains uncomplied. Various directions in this regard have been issued in paragraph 7 of the order dated 13.11.2018. There are various other directions issued time to time also and compliance thereof is still wanting, though time fixed is over. 4. In the circumstances, we give one last opportunity to the Amrapali Group of Companies, particularly to all the Directors of the company and also those who have filed a reply in the Suo Motu Contempt. They have to file their further affidavits in compliance with the aforesaid directions as to what they have done and to make the disclosure as envisaged in various orders.” We had also directed that any non-cooperation with the Forensic Auditors shall be viewed seriously. Statements of accounts of banks were also ordered to be issued by the banks. In order dated 5.12.2018 this Court observed that let the Amrapali group of companies and their Directors Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO and Mr. Anil Mittal to explain as to why criminal action be not initiated against them on the basis of
affidavits, various documents and the statements made in this Court on various dates and why their conduct as projected in the case be not reported to the ICAI to inquire. We directed the production of details of immovable properties as well as the movables etc. This Court also noted that DRT has pointed out that there was non-cooperation and noncompliance on the part of Amrapali group of companies. It was also pointed out to this Court that certain buyers/companies who have booked the flats by making payment of a paltry amount for the purchase of several flats/plots, did not appear to be genuine buyers. We have directed the Forensic Auditors to look into this issue. We also directed all the Directors of companies, their relatives, family members, Mr.Chander Wadhwa, CFO and statutory auditors who were in receipt of money of home buyers, to deposit the same in this Court. The last opportunity was given to do so. 26. On 12.12.2018 in para 4 we have observed thus:
“4. Pursuant to our order dated 05.12.2018, Mr. Adhikari Devi Prasad, Mr. Bhuvan Pant, Mr. Prasanna Kumar Rout, Mr. Jagannath Sharma, Mr. Tarun Kumar Sharma, and Mr. Sunil Kumar and also Mr. Anil Sharma, Director, Amrapali Group of Companies are present in the Court. We generally asked them how the accounts for the period 2015 to 2018 were prepared by them and submitted in the Court. They have stated that it was based on tally data which was given to them. In addition, Mr.Prasanna Kumar Rout, who worked as an Accountant with Amrapali Sapphire, stated that he made the entries up to August 2018 in the tally data on the basis of the documents/vouchers which were made available to him. Mr.Jagannath Sharma, who is a Chartered Accountant and partner in L.D.R. Company stated that they have prepared the balance sheet on the basis of the tally data provided to them for the years 2015 to 2018. However, when cross-checked with the Forensic Auditors, the Court was informed that the data from 2015 to 2018 has not been made available fully to them. It was also pointed out that there should be supporting documents/material to make these entries other than the Bank statement when these statements have been prepared that should also be clarified by Amrapali Group and supplied to the Forensic Auditors.”
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
We also directed details of unsold apartments and flats of the projects to be submitted in this Court. It was also pointed out that the methodology has been adopted by creating sub-leases as a mode of siphoning off the amount of the buyers. This Court noted the following facts and issued the requisite directions:
“8. Mr. Lahoty, the learned counsel, also pointed out that the methodology which has been adopted for creating the subleases was, by and large, a mode of siphoning the amount. He has given the following details as Annexure E, which is extracted below:-
“CREATION OF SUB-LEASES I. Amrapali Centurian Park: (Current Status: 228646 Sq. Mts.)
As per the lease deed, Lessor here is Greater Noida Authority 1. Lessee here is Amrapali Centurian Park Pvt Ltd (Total Area – 2,72,916 Sq Mts) 2. Sub- Lessee of Amrapali Centurian Park here are:
o Hawelia Builders Pvt. Ltd (Hawelia Valenova Park – 14920 Sq Mts) o DSD Homes Pvt Ltd (Novena Green – 14760 Sq Mts) In DSD Homes, Mr. Nishant Mukul (brother in law of Chairman Mr. Anil Sharma) Ex-Director of Amrapali Group was also a director.
o Elegant Infracon Pvt Ltd (Elegant Villa Phase I, III, & IV 14590 Sq Mts) In the Elegant Infracon following are consortium partners with shareholding: Vidhyashree Buildcon Pvt Ltd (26%) Nishant Creation Pvt Ltd (19%) Anjali Buildcon Pvt Ltd (20%) Agrawal Associates (Promoters) Ltd (5%) Elegant Infracon Pvt Ltd (19%) Stunning Construction Pvt Ltd (11%) Vidhyashree Buildcon is one of the companies as mentioned in an order dated 26.10.2018 page 13, point 5, to whom sum of Rs.242.38 crores has been handed over. Mr. Pankaj Jain (current
director of Amrapali Group) was also a director in Vidhyashree Buildcon Pvt Ltd. Sushma Bajaj & Kulbhushan Bajaj (Current directors of Amrapali Group) are also directors in Nishant Creation Pvt Ltd.
Mukesh Kumar Roy (DIN: 2175661) who is presently director of Amrapali Group (listed in 46 companies LA Residentia) is also director of Anjali Buildcon. In Anjali Buildcon Mr. Sanjiv Kumar (DIN: 03136323) is also one of the directors, who is the director of New Tech La Palacia to whom Shri Balaji Hi-Tech Construction Pvt Ltd (A sublessee of Amrapali Dream Valley) has further transferred the sub-lease of said project. Stunning construction is one of the Amrapali Group Company listed in 46 companies.
Rs 46 Crs (Approx) amount which is to be paid by sublessee/s II. Amrapali Dream Valley: (Current Status: 260307) As per the lease deed, Lessor here is Greater Noida Authority.
1. Lessee here is Amrapali Dream Valley Pvt Ltd (Total Area – 354298 Sq Mts) 2. Sub- Lessee of Amrapali Dream Valley Pvt Ltd here are:
o M/s Shri Balaji Hi-Tech Construction Pvt Ltd (Total Are – 12479 Sq Mts) o M/s K.V. Developers Pvt Ltd (Total Area – 19986 Sq Mts) o M/s J.M. Housing Ltd (Total Area – 33537 Sq Mts) o M/s Samridhi Reality Homes Pvt Ltd (Total Area – 27989) o Sum Total Area is 93991 Sq Mts Shri Balaji Hi-Tech Construction Pvt Ltd one of Amrapali Group company (Sr.53 Page 2913 of an affidavit by Mr. Anil Sharma as Affidavit Submitted in terms of order dated 26.09.2018, 31.10.2018. submitted on 12.11.2018, where Mr. Ajay Kumar & Mr. Mukesh Kumar Roy were directors. Shri Balaji Hi-Tech Construction Pvt Ltd has further transferred the sub-lease to a new company namely New Tech La Palacia
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] Pvt. Ltd, which has applied for a revised sanction plan dated 21.01.2013 and it’s not yet approved. (page 18 of GNOIDA affidavit) In New Tech La Palacia Mr.Sanjiv Kumar (DIN: 03136323) is a director who is also a director of Anjali Buildcon (one of the shareholders of Elegant Infracon Pvt. Ltd. who is sub-lessee of Amrapali Centurian Park.
Rs. 91.89 Crs (Approx) amount which is to be paid by sublessee/s III. Leisure Valley: (Current Status: 396124.20 Sq. Mts As per the lease deed, Lessor here is Greater Noida Authority.
1. Lessee here is Amrapali Leisure Valley Pvt Ltd (Total Area – 419519.20 Sq. Mts.) 2. Sub- Lessee of Amrapali Leisure Valley Pvt Ltd here are: a. M/s Start Landcraft Pvt. Ltd. (Total Are – 23395 Sq Mts)
Rs.3.2 Crs. (Approx) amount which is to be paid by sublessee/s” 9. We have directed Mr. Anil Sharma, Director of Amrapali Group of Companies and other Directors to explain the sub-leases and place the documents regarding the creation of subleases on record. Mr. Anil Sharma stated before us that approximately a sum of Rs.66 Crores has been received by the creation of these subleases and that amount has been accounted for in the accounts of concerned Amrapali Group of Companies. With respect to the money utilization in an aforesaid manner, companies, names of Directors, relationship and activity made by sub-lessee so far, let details be filed on an affidavit. We also request the Forensic Auditors to look into this aspect and submit a report before us on the next date of hearing along with other aspects mentioned in the above-quoted details filed on behalf of the flat buyers.” 27. The directions were also issued to DRT to make a further valuation of Tech Park (Hotel) in Greater Noida. On 25.1.2019 we issued certain directions. On 11.2.2019 we directed M/s. J.P. Morgan to disclose the names of the investors and beneficiaries who invested in the Mauritius Fund which had invested in Amrapali INR Rs.85 crores. On 14.2.2019, dues were pointed out against individuals and Directors also. Against
Directors there was a report of loans and advances to the extent of Rs.161.51 crores as noted in the order. We issued certain directions with respect to M/s. Golf Link City Projects Private Ltd. as well as M/ s. Royal Golf Link City Projects Pvt. Ltd. We directed Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma to deposit an amount; whereas the non-compliance made by Amrapali was also pointed out by the buyers which had been noted. As inability was expressed on behalf of M/s. J.P. Morgan to explain valuation report dated 23.10.2013 submitted by Mr. Sudit K. Parikh & Co., Chartered Accountants, they were ordered to explain the valuation report on the basis of which Rs.140 crores had been withdrawn by M/s. J.P. Morgan. It was also pointed out in this connection that the shares of Amrapali Zodiac were ultimately purchased for Rs.140 crores by M/s. Neelkanth and M/s. Rudraksha Forensic auditors pointed out that two persons namely Chandan Kumar, is a peon of Mr. Anil Mittal, statutory auditor and was working in his office and one is Vivek Mittal, nephew of Mr. Anil Mittal, who was doing petty jobs of sub-contractors, getting a monthly income of Rs.15,000. They were stated to be Directors in the companies, i.e., M/s. Neelkanth and Rudraksha. They were not having any capacity to give Rs.140 crores to M/s. J.P. Morgan. This Court has noted the facts thus: “As inability was expressed on behalf of M/s. J.P. Morgan as well as other counsel to explain the report dated 23.10.2013 submitted by Mr. Sudit K. Parikh & Co., Chartered Accountants. In the circumstances, so as to find out the basis of the valuation, it is necessary to call Mr. Sudit K. Parikh [Address : Ballard House, 2nd Floor, Adi Marzban Path, Ballard Pier, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001] to explain the valuation report on the basis of which Rs. 140 crores had been withdrawn by M/s. J.P. Morgan. Let the Registry send a communication to Mr. Sudit K. Parikh to appear before this Court on the next date of hearing. It was pointed out that shares of Amrapali Zodiac were ultimately purchased for Rs.140 crores by M/s Neelkanth and M/s Rudraksha. It is pointed out by forensic auditors that there are two persons, namely, Chandan Kumar, who is a peon of Mr. Anil Mittal, Statutory Auditor, and working in his office and another one is Vivek Mittal, who is the nephew of Mr. Anil Mittal, and is doing petty jobs of sub-contractors and having a monthly income of Rs.15,000/-. It is stated by the learned counsel appearing on
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
behalf of M/s J.P. Morgan that in one company, Chandan Kumar and Atul Mittal were Directors. M/s Neelkanth and M/s Rudraksha are the private limited companies in which the abovementioned persons are named as Directors. They are not having the capacity to give an amount of Rs,140 Crores to be paid to M/s J.P. Morgan.
This is a serious kind of fraud apparent from the aforesaid facts. On being asked, Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma has shown reluctance to disclose about Atul Mittal, who was the Director of M/s Rudraksha along with Chandan Kumar. It is apparent that it was not a fair transaction of sale. That fact is required to be gone into. Let Mr. Anil Mittal and Directors of Amrapali Zodiac and Mr. Anil Sharma explain the situation by filing their personal affidavits from where the money came to be paid to M/s J.P. Morgan, who managed the money and how the companies were framed and for what purpose.”
28. On 28.2.2019, this Court considered IA No.35430/2019 filed by Deputy Commissioner of Police, EOW, Delhi Police, seeking permission to take into custody various Directors namely Anil Kumar Sharma, Shiv Priya, and Ajay Kumar. This Court has passed the following order: “I.A.No. 35430 of 2019 This application has been filed by the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Economic Offences Wing, Delhi Police, seeking permission to arrest and take into custody various Directors, namely, Anil Kumar Sharma, Shiv Priya, and Ajay Kumar. They are presently in the custody of Noida Police vide our order dated 11.10.2018. We make it clear that the Delhi Police is free to arrest/take into custody any or all the other Directors of Amrapali group of companies. Any order passed by this Court, in this case, shall not come in their way to do so. Let the Police investigate the entire gamut of the scenario of the various projects, as projected in this case and various orders passed and investigate the entire matter. Prima facie, we find that the case requires serious investigation in the facts projected by the Directors, CFO, and the statutory auditors. The Police are directed to investigate the role of Mr. Anil Mittal, Statutory Auditor, and Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO as well. The
Police may interrogate them and find out their criminality, if any, in the matter. Let various order sheets of this Court as well as the affidavits of Mr. Chander Wadhwa and Mr.Anil Mittal and Directors of Amrapali Group of Companies indicating the operational methods of diversion of funds and creation of companies be also furnished to the Deputy Commissioner forthwith. The application is allowed.”
This Court also issued other directions with respect to the persons who were called by the Forensic Auditors but did not report. Other directions were also issued. 29. On 9.4.2019 we requested the parties to address this Court how to protect the interests of the buyers so that they can get a clear title after completion of the projects. In view of the dues of Noida and Greater Noida authorities and other secured creditors, such as banks, etc. how to work out equities in the circumstances and requested the parties to address this Court. Amrapali group of companies to address how much investment they have made in the project and what they have done with the money of the buyers and to inform us as to diversion of the money of home-buyers, how to secure it and why they should not be suitably dealt with in accordance with law for what they have done. In view of the aforesaid facts projected in various affidavits of the Directors and the interim report of forensic auditors. This Court listed the case for hearing on various issues. We have heard Forensic Auditors, Mr. Krishnan Venugopal, learned senior counsel and Mr. M.L. Lahoty, learned counsel, on 30.4.2019. Thereafter, we further heard the matter on 1.5.2019. They concluded the arguments. Mr. C.A. Sundaram learned senior counsel was also heard and the learned counsel on behalf of Bank of Maharashtra and Bank of Baroda as well as Ms. Geeta Luthra and Mr. Gaurav Bhatia, learned senior counsel on behalf of Amrapali group. On 2.5.2019 and on 8.5.2019 certain directions were issued. On 10.5.2019 arguments were further heard and the case was reserved for orders. SUBMISSIONS
30. Mr. M.L. Lahoty, learned counsel appearing on behalf of 49,575 home buyers submitted that under section 8 of the Real Estate Regulation and Development Act, 2016 (for short, ‘the RERA’) and also in view of the provisions contained in sections 13 and 14 of the U.P. Industrial
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
Area Development Act, 1976 (for short, ‘the Industrial Development Act’), the lease deeds granted by Noida and Greater Noida authorities were ordered to be cancelled. In the lease deed also, there is a specific stipulation as to cancellation clause in case of cancellation and imposing penalty and for such other actions against the builder in case of default. Home buyers further submitted that after payment of first 10% of the lease premium, Amrapali Group has not paid any of the 20 half-yearly instalments from 2010 onwards. The Noida and Greater Noida authorities have been liberal, and not taking any stringent action against Amrapali Group which had been mandated by virtue of the provisions contained in the lease deed. The dues of Noida and Greater Noida authorities cannot be treated at par with the dues of home buyers. Home buyers further submitted that so far as the dues of the banks are concerned, they are not placed on any better footing and Forensic Auditors in their report have stated that but for the connivance of the bank officials, the act of money siphoning on such large scale would not have taken place. Banks have failed to monitor utilisation of the borrowed funds and they acted as mute spectators to the diversion of funds by Amrapali Group of Companies, its Directors and officials. Mr. Lahoty, on behalf of home buyers further submitted that the Reserve Bank of India has issued Master Circulars from time to time since 2014 onwards as to the obligations of the Banks and specifically directed that banks must necessarily monitor the ‘end use’ of the loans granted by them and call for periodical reports thereof. In the case of diversion and siphoning of loan funds, banks must invariably take action against defaulters. Reliance has been placed on RBI’s Master Circulars of July 2009, 2014 and 2015. In case after the cancellation of the leases, they are not able to construct, they may enter into an arrangement with any reputed builder like NBCC or L&T, etc. A roadmap thereof need be drawn to be monitored by a Monitoring Committee which duly represents the interest of the home buyers, may also be directed to be constituted which will not only oversee the work but also oversee the construction activities and also submit a report to this Court so that the needs of the home-buyers are finally achieved. A further audit of connected companies may be ordered. Bank accounts with Bank of Baroda are operationalised towards maintenance and electricity as families are residing in 21 Towers have been regularly depositing the electricity and other dues in their accounts which have become defunct after the discharge of IRP vide order dated 8.8.2018 passed by this Court. The amount be utilised for pending bills from August
to October 2018 towards electricity and maintenance services by nominating a Joint Signatory in place of IRP. 31. Mr. Krishnan Venugopal, learned senior counsel appearing for home-buyers has urged that there is the distinction between mortgage and charge as a mortgage involves the transfer of interest, whereas, in case of a charge, there is no transfer of interest. He has further urged that non-production of relevant documents despite the court order, leads to a presumption of an adverse inference. As Amrapali Group has failed to comply with the court’s order, an adverse inference may be drawn against them. He has also pressed into service public trust doctrine and submitted that the State or the public authority which holds the property for the public or which has been assigned the duty of grant of largesse, etc. acts as a trustee, and therefore, has to act fairly and reasonably, promote public good and public interest. Public trust doctrine is a part of the law of the land. The doctrine is a facet of Article 21 of the Constitution. The action has to be bona fide. Public property cannot be transferred to private property in case it affects the public interest. General welfare and common good are to be kept in view by the public authorities exercising public power and discharging public duty. 32. Mr. Krishnan Venugopal, learned senior counsel further urged that in view of the findings recorded by the Forensic Auditors, section 8 of the RERA has to be invoked. He further submitted that even though Amrapali was defaulting on payments of lease rents, authorities continued to allot further plots to them. The first lease had been granted on 1.5.2007 and the last on 30.7.2010. Despite default, they continued to issue permission to mortgage/NOCs for that purpose between 24.12.2009 and 27.2.2013, in spite of the fact that there was no payment of premium and advance annual lease rent up to date. The authorities have acted in breach of clause 7 of the conditions of the lease deed, they failed to monitor the progress of the project to protect the interest of the public. 33. In reference to banks, Mr. Venugopal submitted that banks were giving loans to finance Amrapali, in spite of the fact that they were diverted to other accounts and not utilised for construction. Banks do not even have effective mortgages because of NOCs. clearly, state that they would become effective only when Amrapali makes up to date payment of the premium and advance annual lease rent, and under the conditional NOCs., the banks were required to obtain confirmation from the authorities as to payment of premium and lease money for the
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
mortgage to become effective. The banks have not handed over copies of mortgage deeds despite orders. Moreover, the banks have a second charge after all dues of the Noida and Greater Noida authorities are realised. The authority’s ownership rights over the plots are paramount. The public sector banks are also subject to public trust doctrine to the extent that they are custodians of public funds and are beneficiaries of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertaking) Act, 1970 and Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertaking) Act, 1980 passed in pursuance of the Directive Principles under Article 39(b) and (c) of the Constitution. The facts demonstrate the collusion between Amrapali Authorities and the banks. The home buyers who invested their hard-earned money, cannot be cheated and deprived of their money as well as their houses. Authorities cannot seek to recover any additional amount from the home buyers. They must be directed to complete the construction by realising only the remaining dues from home buyers under their agreements with Amrapali, by selling off unsold inventory of flats, etc. available with it and by selling off excess land allotted to Amrapali. The Committees of home buyers must be set up for each project to monitor the quality and progress of the construction as well as the costs involved so as to ensure that contractors do not engage in fraud or inflate construction costs in the course of completing the projects.
34. On behalf of the home buyers Association, it was submitted that by promoters of the real estate sector in India from 2008-2009, home buyers have been promised the houses of which they have been deprived of on a large scale in spite of the fact that they have paid a substantial amount of money. Construction has not progressed and money has been diverted elsewhere. There is a charge of the money of the home buyers must be treated as the highest priority. They have paid towards dues of Authorities also which amount has been diverted. Banks and authorities have failed to discharge their duties. Banks have granted loans to the projects in some cases which were not sanctioned even on the date of grant of loan. For example, Phase III of Amrapali Adarsh Awas Yojana Project. Banks have released the complete payment amounts to the builder without the construction having been reached even 10 to 20%. As such lending was not permissible. The current scenario is that the construction of the various projects is stalled and the home buyers are without any hope of the promised homes. Certain incumbents who have taken loan are compelled to repay the loan and
money has been siphoned out. As such appropriate relief be granted to home buyers in view of the facts found in the report of the Forensic Auditors. 35. On behalf of the home buyers, reliance has been placed on the provisions contained in section 4(5) of the U.P. Apartments (Promotion of Construction, Ownership, and Maintenance) Act, 2010 (for short, the ‘U.P. Apartments Act, 2010’). It is provided that the completion of the construction works of a building as a whole or the completion of an independent block of such building, as the case may be. The completion certificate can be issued for the blocks which have been completed. Noida and Greater Noida authorities are not issuing NOC for the reason that payment of land dues has not been made by the builder, for which authorities are also responsible. The non-payment of dues by the builder should not come in the way as more than 9000 home buyers are already residing in the buildings. Most of them have paid the entire amount to the promoter. Others are waiting for the completion of buildings. 36. On behalf of Noida Authority, learned senior counsel submitted that public trust doctrine is not attracted to the facts in the instant case as there is no breach of trust. The decision to transfer lease at 10% was the carefully thought out policy of Noida approved by the State Government. It was applied uniformly to all and not restricted only to the Amrapali Group. It was submitted that allotment of group housing plots is made by Noida authority in accordance with the prevailing policies and rates which have kept changing with times. In 2007, the allottees were required to pay 10% of the total premium of the plot as reservation money, before formal allotment letter was issued. Then, a further amount of 30% had to be paid within 60 days from the time of allotment. Thus, 40% premium was required to be paid. Balance 60% had to be paid in eight half-yearly instalments along with interest. 37. It was further submitted on behalf of the Noida Authority that primarily on account of the global recession in the world economy, in the year 2008 a decision was taken to revise the rate of allotment money to 10%. Thus, the total sum of 20% was to be paid before handing over possession. In the year 2009, the rate of allotment money along with registration money was revised to 10% of the total premium for the possession to be handed over. However, steps were taken to provide (i) facility of re-scheduling of payments in case the allottees intended to complete his project as per agreed policy; (ii) to exit the project; (iii)
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
moratorium of two years on payment of balance premium; (iv) facility of sub-division of plots of area larger than 10 acres so as to make the larger projects financially viable.
38. It was also submitted on behalf of Noida Authority that after 2005, a total of 114 plots had been allotted to various group housing societies. 81 have been handed over the possession on payment of 10% of the total premium. 29 projects, out of these 81, have been completed. Out of other 33 allotted earlier, 11 had been completed, and 7 have obtained part-completion certificates. Noida Authority, being a responsible public organisation, has been diligent in pursuing Amrapali Group, it has not taken the drastic recourse of terminating the lease deed as that would entail demolition of the existing structures as per the provisions of the lease deed. In terms of the lease, home buyers have no title or legal rights to possession of the flats they are occupying. As the projects have been completed to some extent, it would have been unfair to leave the home buyers in the lurch. The occupancy certificate is issued in accordance with the provisions of the New Okhla Industrial Development Area Building Regulations, 2010 (for short, ‘the Regulations of 2010’). Clause 20.0 of the Building Regulations requires the allottee to submit a notice of completion of the building, inter alia, with a structural safety certificate, NOCs from the Fire Department, Explosives department and Environment department. No building erected, re-erected, can be occupied in whole or in part unless occupancy certificate is issued by the CEO of the Authority as per clause 20.1.1 of the Regulations. The lessee/promoter is entitled to allot the dwelling unit on a sub-lease basis. However, he has to make the payment of premium of the plot to Noida authority when permission to transfer built-up flats or part with possession of the whole or any part of the building which has been constructed is granted. The physical possession of flats can be given to home buyers only after execution of sub-lease deed and sale deed has also to be registered before actual physical possession of the flat is handed over as required under the provisions of Registration Act, 1908. The declaration required to be made under section 12 of the U.P. Apartments Act, 2010 is also to be filed.
39. It was further urged on behalf of the Noida Authority that the Noida Authority had the first charge including those created in favour of banks and financial institutions. The mortgage could have been effected in favour of Banks/financial institutions recognised by the RBI, National
Housing Bank, HUDCO, New Delhi and the charge of such institution shall be the second charge on the dwelling units, thus, being financed. The permission to mortgage shall be effective only on making full payment of premium and up to date annual lease rent of group housing society. An intimation shall be given to the Authority about the creation of the charge by way of mortgage. The mortgage permission shall be granted as per the terms of the lease only on payment of dues of authorities. 40. It is submitted that it is open to the authority to cancel or terminate the lease. In the case of misrepresentation, suppression or violation of the conditions of lease and in the case of default and at the time of cancellation, an amount equivalent to 25% of the total premium of the plot shall have to be forfeited and possession of plot shall have to be resumed by Noida Authority with structure thereon. In the instant case, no dues certificate had not been issued by the Noida authority nor any sub-lease deed has been executed. The possession by various home buyers in respect of constructed flats is contrary to the provisions of the lease deed. The builder could not have handed over the possession. Any occupation of flats by the home buyers without compliance of mandatory provision of occupancy certificate and without payment of statutory dues, both to Noida Authority and to the Collector of Stamps and without execution of tripartite sub-lease deed may not be termed as legal and as such which could have resulted in their eventual eviction. 41. It was further submitted on behalf of the Noida Authority that pursuant to order dated 27.11.2017 passed by this Court, on depositing 10% of the dues to issue completion certificate such NOC could not be issued and the order passed by this Court has not been complied with by builder/promoter as such possession could not be handed over. In spite of reiterating the aforesaid direction of this Court on 31.1.2018, it has not been complied with by the promoter/leaseholder. It is submitted by the Noida Authority that its dues to Amrapali group exceed Rs.2191.38 crores till 30.4.2019. It is in public interest to ensure payment of premium/ lease money with penal interest etc. so that the development of the various projects at Noida is not impeded. Prayer has been made that in whatever manner practicable and by whatever scheme this Court may think fit and proper, aforesaid dues of the authority may be secured and ordered to be recovered. 42. On behalf of Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority, it was submitted that its dues were Rs.3,234.71 crores as on 15.1.2019
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
in respect of 5 group housing plots of Amrapali group. These dues inter alia comprise of the amounts payable against the premium plus the penal interest for default, additional compensation and interest thereon, the lease rent and interest thereon and time extension charges for each of the five plots. Title in the flats can pass only by way of execution of a registered instrument. However, before that procedural requirements pointed out on behalf of the Noida Authority have to be complied with. Once completion certificate is issued, the rights in the flat will pass on to the flat buyers and then they would contend that the dues of the authority should be recovered from the builders who have defaulted in making payment and not the flat buyers. On the basis of that privity of contract, they would contend that the liability to make payment of the premium and other dues payable to Greater Noida authority, by lessee/builder is between them and they are not parties to the lease deed.
43. It is further submitted on behalf of Greater Noida Authority that even with regard to the issuance of completion certificate for a part of the projects, the existing policy is that against the part-payment received, completion certificate would be issued in the same proportion minus 10%, so that the financial interest of the authority is protected. Therefore, sub-lease deeds too would be executed up to 90% of the proportion in which part-payment has been received. It was further submitted by the Greater Noida Authority that section 19(10) of RERA also provides for taking over of physical possession after issuance of completion certificate. The provisions of the U.P. Apartments Act, 2010 are also similar as well the provisions in the lease deed. 44. It is further submitted on behalf of Greater Noida Authority that FAR admissible is 02.75 only and not 3.50. The differential FAR of 0.75 is not purchasable. The calculations made by Amrapali based on FAR of 3.50 is itself wrong. FAR has not yet been purchased by Amrapali group by depositing the charges and submission of consent of two-thirds of the apartment owners. Under section 4(2)(1)(D) of RERA, 70% of the amount received from home buyers is to be put in a separate account to be maintained in a scheduled bank and is to be used towards construction and land cost. The land dues payable to Greater Noida authority constitute an encumbrance as provided in section 4(1)(b) of the U.P. Apartments Act, 2010. As per section 11(4)(c) of RERA, it is the duty of the promoters to certify that all dues and charges have been paid. Thus, it follows that money received from the flat buyers is to be
spent on construction and payment of land dues. Therefore, payment of land dues cannot be denied to it. Land dues are in the nature of public money. Amrapali group is bound to pay it. The amount is payable in instalments as such same is interest bearing for availing the facility of payment in instalments as such the land cost payable increases. In case of default, penal interest follows. There was no order passed by the Allahabad High Court for staying construction on the leased plots. Amrapali Group was in possession of the allotted land and was proceeding with the construction. For 4 years, it has prayed for zero periods of interest to which the group is not entitled. It would lead to unjust enrichment by Amrapali as they have realised dues from home buyers and have not paid to the Authority. The order passed by the NGT with respect to Okhla Bird Sanctuary case was not applicable to the land in question. The dues payable to the authority are recoverable as the arrears of land revenue. The authority has the first charge. The permission to the mortgage was conditional one, it has not been complied with, in particular, conditions B, C and D. The mortgage had to be renewed every year and is subject to the payment of land premium, etc. The Greater Noida authority has written numerous letters to Amrapali group of companies to make the payment of its dues. In the case of Unitech, yet another Group, the Authority has cancelled the allotment which was questioned in this Court. As the cancellation of the allotment in case of Amrapali could have led to greater complications as construction had commenced with third-party interest created. It would have opened floodgates to litigation. As such cancellation of lease deeds was not resorted to. 45. Ms. Geeta Luthra and Mr. Gaurav Bhatia, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of Amrapali group of companies, have urged that Amrapali group started its activities in the name of M/s. Ultra Home Construction Pvt. Ltd. in the year 2003 with the purpose of providing low-cost housing to projects in Indirapuram (Ghaziabad) Noida, Lucknow, Indore, Bhilai, and more than 15,000 flats were handed over by the developers to flat owners in 5 different housing projects in Indirapuram and Greater Noida. The balance sheets of Amrapali group of companies at 2007-08 shows that it had carried forward the money earned by the company to launch the projects after 2009-10 upon allotment of plots by Noida and Greater Noida authorities in their respective areas. Immediately after the allotment of land, the work was started and the Allahabad High Court quashed acquisition. It had to be stopped as per the order passed
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
by the Allahabad High Court. When in 2016 Amrapali group again started to infuse capital and manpower, proceedings were initiated in NCLT by Bank of Baroda as against Amrapali Silicon City Pvt. Ltd. and M/s. Ultra-Home Constructions Pvt. Ltd. There were legal impediments/force majeure conditions in completing the projects within the period given in the flat buyer agreement. The Allahabad High Court finally decided the matter in Gajraj Singh & Ors. v. State of U.P. on 21.10.2011. The Patwari Village issue was pending before this Court till 2015. On 14.5.2015 this Court finally decided the matter in the case of Savitri Devi v. State of U.P. It was an order passed by the National Green Tribunal with respect to Okhla Bird Sanctuary which also hindered the work. Higher compensation was ordered to be paid by the Allahabad High Court in 2011. The period of litigation ought to have been treated as zero periods for the purpose of payment of dues by Noida and Greater Noida authorities. Amrapali Silicon City was affected on account of litigation and land acquisition issues. The work of Leisure Valley, Dream Valley, and Leisure Park were also affected. There was an issue of the approach road with the farmers with respect to Sapphire Housing Project. Other projects were also affected due to farmers’ agitation, want of proper roads, etc. The authority was required to give electricity, sewer and water connections. Proper facilities were not extended timely.
46. It was further submitted on behalf of Amrapali Group that a High-Power Committee has been constituted by the State of U.P. A sum of Rs. 2,715 crores are to be paid to the authorities including the interest and purchasable FSI costs. The outstanding of banks is Rs.985 crores. It was submitted that the projects are viable in case some relief is granted towards land dues of authorities and dues of the banks. The joint inspection indicated that substantial construction had been carried out. The cost of construction to complete the launched projects, as per NBCC is Rs.6827 crores; whereas the cost as per Amrapali group is Rs.5630 crores. Calculation of NBCC is wrong. The projects are divided into 3 categories: (i) where the allottees were living; (ii) advanced stage of construction; and (iii) work is at a nascent stage. The amount defaulted by buyers is Rs.511 crores, total receivables from them are Rs.5,332 crores. The encumbered and unencumbered assets can be sold to complete the project. The valuation worked out by the DRT comes to Rs.7,353 crores considering the maximum permissible FAR of 3.50. The order may be passed in respect of amounts due from Raipur and Bhubaneswar Housing Board which are recoverable from them to
deposit in Court. Certain suggestions have also been made on behalf of Amrapali group for arranging the required funds. That home buyer may be directed to pay the cost. Unsold inventory of the launched projects on sale would generate Rs.1,922 crores. In case of any shortfall, there can be a sale of unencumbered assets of the company. Reputed builders may be engaged for undertaking the construction of the various projects. Amrapali has spent Rs.10,630 crores as against Rs.11,652 crores received from home buyers. As per the affidavits dated 16.5.2018 and 3.12.2018, the total cash outflow is Rs.395 crores utilised by the group in the creation of assets whose current valuation as per DRT is Rs.1200 crores. The Noida and Greater Noida authorities have partial registration policies as provided in Building Regulations and the Act and an appropriate Committee may be constituted for supervision. Amrapali group shall extend all help in the building of the projects. 47. With respect to the report of the Forensic Auditors, it has been submitted that there is no undervaluation in booking the flats. The value of flats depends upon the situation etc. as the flats were booked at different times, they have different prices as per the prevailing market. In certain cases, the customers took possession of various Towers in partially unfinished conditions and managed the pending work by themselves. In some projects, lifts were installed by the customers’ associations. In some other cases, interiors of the flats were finalised by the customers themselves. Amrapali group reduced the value of such flats in their books accordingly. 48. With respect to other amounts recoverable from KMPA/ relatives/Directors, as per the affidavit submitted by Shiv Priya on 20.11.2018, Rs.4.3 crores were paid towards his taxes. The same has been adjusted against the salary due of Rs.4.4 crores from various Amrapali group of companies. Salary of Rs.1.6 crores is recoverable by Shiv Priya from Amrapali group of companies. As per the affidavit of Mr. Ajay Kumar, Rs.1.21 crores were paid by the company towards his taxes out of his outstanding salary up to 31.3.2015. Though his salary for the financial years 2016-18 is still to be mentioned in the books of accounts on account of his due salary. A sum of Rs.25 lakhs has been paid by him to Ultra Home Construction Pvt. Ltd.; in addition, a sum of Rs.25 lakhs paid to Yogesh Chand is duly debited in his ledger and as mentioned in his affidavit.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
49. With respect to Amrapali Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., it was submitted that an advance to Directors of Rs.113.54 crores was used by the Directors to purchase shares of Ultra Home Construction Pvt. Ltd. Ideally, the shares should have been issued in the name of Amrapali Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. The money moved from Amrapali Infrastructures Pvt. Ltd. to Ultra Home Construction Pvt. Ltd. Precast Factory’s valuation is Rs.179 crores. Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma has surrendered the shares in favour of Amrapali Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. to the extent of INR 73.2 crores. Mr. Shiv Priya has surrendered the shares in Amrapali Infrastructure Pt. Ltd. during 2018-19 of Rs.35.1 crores.
50. With respect to Amrapali Hospitality Services Pvt. Ltd., it was submitted that the company gave Rs.6.62 crores to Directors as advances out of which Rs.6.55 crores were given to Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma and his family. In the financial year 2017-18, Rs.2.25 crores were used by Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma for payment of housing loan of Jay Pee Green Property. Rs.1.25 crores were deposited with this Court by way of Demand Draft, Rs.0.85 crores were paid to settle the bank loan of Leisure Valley Villa and Rs.0.5 crores were transferred for payment of TDS liability of Amrapali hospital. 51. With respect to Hi-Tech City Developers Pvt. Ltd., the Auditor’s report indicates that a sum of Rs.4.24 crores was given as an advance to Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma in 2009-10 which was used by him for purchasing shares of Ultra Home Construction Pvt. Ltd. Ideally, the shares should have been issued in the name of Amrapali group of companies. No transfer of money was there. Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma had surrendered shares in favour of Amrapali Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., during the year 2018-19 but this has not been reflected in the books of the company. With respect to cash in hand, there is no consistency in the report of the auditors. Only Rs.9 crores were available in cash in various group companies. The entire amount was spent on payment of wages due to various labours at different times. With respect to other recoverable advanced to various parties amounting to Rs.234.31 crores, the details are not available in the report. These advances are against genuine business transactions. There is a possibility that such expenses have not been booked and squared off. 52. With respect to the diversion of home buyers amount to the extent of Rs.3,500 crores and bogus billing of Rs.1500-1600 crores, out of the total amount received from home buyers of Rs.11,652 crores
would leave INR 6,652 crores for carrying out the existing construction at sites. The total sum available for construction purposes comes to Rs.4,352 crores, after deducting the amount of payment to the authorities and banks of Rs.1,000 crores and Rs.1,300 crores respectively. With respect to non-genuine purchases from suppliers, though a sum of Rs.554 crores was given to the income-tax authorities, on appeal the error had been corrected by the income-tax authorities. There was an error in the report of the forensic auditors. The report of the forensic auditors as to non-existing companies is also not correct. It is further submitted that Gaurisuta Infrasolution Pvt. Ltd., which manufactures PVC doors and windows had business transactions with Amrapali group, payment/ advances were made to them. It is a fact that parties are related. It does not mean that all transactions are dubious. Law does not prevent such transactions. The short term and long-term loans to third parties were not for diverting loan funds and home buyer funds to group companies. 53. With respect to Auditors’ list of 27 companies formed for the purpose of routing the cash of the companies, were formed before demonetisation. With respect to J.P. Morgan Property Mauritius Company-II, Amrapali Zodiac Developers Pvt. Ltd. transferred money to another company to buy-back stake in J.P. Morgan but did not do it directly as share buy-back rules did not permit such transactions. It may be maximum violations of the Companies Act but is not a diversion of money. With respect to FEMA, it is submitted that again it is a violation of ECB guidelines but again it was not a case of diversion of money. Money was needed for construction, therefore, arrangement with J.P. Morgan was made. 54. With respect to doubt of Forensic Auditors as to the genuineness of interest paid by Amrapali Silicon City Pvt. Ltd. to IPFFI and claiming interest @ 17% which is very high, it was submitted that rate of interest depends upon the money lending transactions and is not illegal or prohibited in law. 55. With respect to charging for professional services and fee by Directors, it was stated that a person rendering professional services should have a membership of professional bodies and have some certificate of practice. A lot of companies pay a professional/consulting fee to outsiders to assist them in their business. Amrapali group has also paid salaries and consultation fees to Directors as they were providing
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
their expertise and skill. Ultimately prayer had been made to evolve some mechanism for completion of housing projects.
56. On behalf of Royal Golf Link City Projects Pvt. Ltd., it is submitted that a loan of Rs.50 crores or Rs.48,52,05,100 was paid by Ultra Home Constructions Pvt. Ltd. to Royal Golf. Interest @ 9% amounting to Rs.5,83,42,977 has been paid to Ultra Home. Subsequently, the agreement has been entered into to repay Rs.50,46,78,022 by 31.3.2017 or in lieu thereof 30 Villas have to be allotted by Royal Golf to Ultra Homes. This Court has attached 30 Villas allotted to Ultra Home. It is ready to give 30 Villas by 30.4.2021 or to refund the amount of Rs.48,46,78,022 in 4 equal quarterly instalments in full and final settlement of all claims of Amrapali group. 57. On behalf of Bank of Baroda, it has been submitted that Forensic Auditors have made adverse comments without any basis. Bank of Baroda had deployed suitable methods to monitor the utilisation of funds. No diversion of funds was permitted by Bank of Baroda. Monitoring of the loan was done and before sanction of the loan, the net worth of the promoters/Directors of ASCPL was ascertained. Bank of Baroda relied upon a letter dated 29.7.2010 from Noida to ASCPL. The term loan agreement was executed amongst ASCPL, Bank of Baroda, Bank of Maharashtra and Oriental Bank of Commerce “Consortium” for a term loan of Rs.300 crores. After execution of due documents and deeds of corporate guarantee issued in favour of Bank of Baroda, corporate guarantees were submitted by Ultra Homes Construction, Jotindra Steels and Tubes Ltd. along with Vidhyashree Buildcon. Pvt. Ltd. RoC search report of guarantors was also obtained. NOC of Noida dated 21.2.2012 for mortgaging the project site to procure a term loan from the consortium was also obtained. A detailed project report was issued by Solomon Consulting Pvt. Ltd. There was the appointment of independent lender’s Engineer and thereafter accounting was done, postdisbursal of loan by Bank of Baroda. The money was released on the basis of lenders Engineers advice of Rs.49 crores out of Rs.55 crores. Thus, there was no lack of due diligence and considering the progress of construction, steps had been taken by the Bank of Baroda to protect its interests after the account became NPA. Active steps were taken to recover the amount. The similar mechanism had been adopted for Amrapali Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. With respect to Ultra Homes Construction Pvt. Ltd., also a loan of Rs.75 crores was sanctioned out
of which Rs.65.84 crores were disbursed for the construction and development of an Integrated Information Technology Park, (IT Park), Hotel, Commercial complex, service apartments and residential complex on Plot No.59, Sector Knowledge Park-V, Greater Noida, which were executed by Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma, Mr. Ajay Kumar, Mr. Shiv Priya and Mr. Madan Mohan Sharma. Amrapali Zodiac Developers Pvt. Ltd. was granted a loan of Rs.75 crores. It was not utilised for payment of the cost of land or for payment of construction cost. The amount has been repaid and the account has been closed. The money may have been routed through various suppliers and contractors. The remittance of money is nothing but an example of due conduct of business. With respect to the release of the corporate guarantee of M/s. Jotindra Steel and Tubes Pvt. Ltd., it is submitted that they were unable to infuse share capital as required and seemed unable to do so in the future as well. The shares due to M/s. Jotindra Steel and Tubes Pvt. Ltd. were also allotted to M/s. Ultra-Homes Construction Pvt. Ltd. Thus, the Bank of Baroda granted the request for release of the corporate guarantee in favour of M/s. Jotindra Steel and Tubes Pvt. Ltd. Amrapali group had the right to mortgage the property as per the mortgage deed. There was no bank charge on the property mortgaged by Amrapali group. As per clause 15 of the mortgage deed, the buyer shall have no right after paying all amounts. The developer shall continue to have full authority over the flat unless a registered deed is executed in favour of the allottee. It is also submitted that the home buyers are not secured creditors. The home buyers were to acquire the premises on sub-lease basis which was never intended or stated anywhere that a sale would take place. The allottee shall not have any lien or interest on the flat unless sub-lease deed is executed. Therefore, they are not secured creditors, they have no right, title or interest or lien on the basis of allotment from flat buyer agreement. It is further submitted that the agreement does not create any rights in praesenti with a promise to enter into a future agreement. It does not create any right, title, interest or claim in the immovable property. In the absence of registration of document under the Registration Act, no rights are created in the immovable property in question under section 49 of the Registration Act. 58. With respect to RERA provisions, it has been submitted by Bank of Baroda that section 11(4) of RERA deals with the interaction between repayment to secured creditors and rights of allottees. Subsection (h) of section 11(4) states that the promoter shall not create a
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
mortgage or charge after an agreement to sell has been executed. Therefore, the promoter is permitted to create such mortgage or charge prior to the execution of an agreement to sell. Section 4(2)(1) of RERA requires the promoter to disclose the prior encumbrance to the real estate authority. Under section 34(b) it is required to publish and maintain a website of records. Section 19(4)(1) of RERA provides that if the promoter fails to complete or is unable to give possession of an apartment, plot or building, the rights of allottees are restricted to receive the compensation from the promoter. The rights of allottees under section 19 of RERA can be contrasted with the right of the mortgagee who secured creditors under section 58 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. The RERA is restricted to protect the rights and interests of the allottees from the promoters and developers. RERA recognises and protects the rights of the lenders and does not in any manner take away any right under the existing statutes like the T.P. Act, SARFAESI, etc. RERA has not brought any change in the nature of the rights of home buyers. The Bank is entitled to receive its money along with interest in the event of failure to repay by builder/ promoter.
IN RE: FORENSIC AUDITORS 59. The Forensic Auditors have submitted their report running into eight volumes. It has been observed that the Amrapali Group was started in 2003 by Mr. Madan Mohan Sharma. Later on, it was managed by his son Mr. Anil Sharma. He gradually expanded his team and Mr. Shiv Priya, Mr. Ajay Kumar, Mr. Nishant Mukul, Mr. Chander Wadhwa, Mr. Mohit Gupta, Mr. Adhikari Das, and others joined in. By 2010, the Amrapali Group was leading real estate development firms, promising to offer luxury and comfort. In the beginning, the Amrapali Group has constructed and completed certain projects and earned the goodwill of the general public in the real estate business. The Amrapali Group used unfair means to promote themselves. It made false promises to lure the public to invest in its projects, purposefully delayed construction, cheated home-buyers for the title of flats and trapped home-buyers in rental returns. The Amrapali Group floated several companies. The public invested their hard earned money in Amrapali projects and the shareholders used these funds to infuse capital in other companies/ entities. Home buyers were cheated by making false promises/claims for example selling of flats which were not even part of the master plan of projects or unapproved in the master plan, double booking of the same
flat by different customers. The homebuyers funds were diverted to other companies/directors through payment of professional fees, by way of booking of bogus bills of Rs.837 crores, by selling flats as undervalued prices in book and received differential market value in cash, by paying commission and brokerage on bogus booking of flats and by way of granting inter-corporate deposits of Rs.3,000 crores to related entities and Rs.500 crores to unrelated entities/trusted partners for ultimately diverting funds to unapproved uses. SUMMARY OF REPORT OF FORENSIC AUDIT
60. The summary of report submitted by Forensic Auditors in the Court is as under: 1. Brief Introduction
Amrapali Group started its operations in the year 2003 in Delhi. It was started by Mr. Madan Mohan Sharma who managed it for a brief period. Thereafter the operations of the Group were managed by his son - Mr. Anil Sharma. Gradually, he expanded his team and Mr. Shiv Priya, Mr. Ajay Kumar, Mr. Nishant Mukul, Mr. Chander Wadhwa, Mr. Mohit Gupta, Mr. Adhikari Das and other trusted partners/executives joined in. The Group was into the business of construction of residential complexes, townships, offices, commercial complexes. The Group built good reputation in the public and launched several projects in various cities in India. By 2010, the Group was a leading real estate development firms in India and particular in North India, promising to offer luxury and comfort in every project that it takes up. Subsequently, Mr. Mahender Singh Dhoni became brand ambassador of the Group. To achieve good standing in the eyes of public, the Group used unfair means to promote themselves. The Group made false promises to lure public to invest in its projects, purposefully delayed construction, cheated homebuyers over title of flats, trapped homebuyers in rental returns, sold flats at exorbitantly low prices and recovered market price in cash from them, among other unfair means adopted by them. The Group floated several companies through its directors, staff, trusted partners which were incorporated solely to divert homebuyers funds. The Group collaborated with external parties like JP Morgan in contravention
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] of FEMA and distributed returns along with principal amount, even though it did not book gains within the business of the company. Similarly, it collaborated with several other third parties and invested in other projects and built a cycle of returns in the form of unaccounted cash. The Group treated moneys received from home buyers as its own capital and used this money for investing in exclusively personal purposes, for example in constructing Amrapali hospital, hotels, malls, making movies etc. The Group booked bogus expenses and routed funds to trusted partners. The Group also used homebuyers funds for building personal properties, investment in mutual funds, expenses in daughter’s wedding, purchase of luxury cars, watches, building luxurious houses for directors etc. The Promoters diversified to different verticals i.e. Education, Entertainment (in making movies), FMCG, infrastructure, Shopping Malls, technology parks, hotel etc. from the diverted Home Buyers funds. The Promoters didn’t invest any paisa in such verticals and the whole empire was created out of the diversion. The Promoters created a web of more than 150 companies (Page No. 16-19 Volume I) for routing the funds and creating assets. About 100 Companies were under the supervision and control of promoters used mainly for the purpose of diversion of funds. The Directors and Shareholders of these Companies were benami and were the trusted junior employees of promoters. CFO and the Statutory Auditors. It is observed that the Company, i.e. management, CFO, the Statutory Auditors and key managerial persons deliberately and for reasons best known to them did not prepare the accounts till 31st March, 2018 or thereafter as nobody wanted to let anybody know where the funds moved from 31.3.2015 onwards. In absence of Book of Accounts, we are constrained to report that the management deliberately withdrew the Bank Balances for making payments to some person and brought down the huge bank balance to negligible amount. The management has diverted the Home Buyers’ funds from one Company to another Company in a very clever, pre-planned and clandestine manner. The management could not have done this without the full support of its CFO and the Statutory Auditors. As
per the submissions made, many companies were controlled by CFO and the Statutory Auditors to which huge funds have been transferred. It can therefore, be easily said that both CFO and the Statutory Auditor were Master Mind behind these types of planning for diversion and the misuse of funds. It may be important to mention here that funds were transferred from one Company to another and to third and to fourth and so on thereby absolutely confusing any person to find out the real trail where the money has gone, since there are more than 100 Companies through which these funds have been routed over the period. 2. HISTORY OF ALLEGATIONS
Bank of Baroda and several other banks filed a petition before NCLT under section 7 of the Code for triggering Corporate Insolvency Resolution process in the matter of Amrapali Group Companies. Homebuyers filed petition seeking construction and possession of around 42000 flats booked in Amrapali Group
On 6th September 2018, Supreme Court appointed Mr. P K Aggarwal and Mr. Ravi Bhatia as joint forensic auditors to audit into the matter. ACCOUNTING PACKAGE The group was using Tally till March, 2015 for all of its group companies. In April 2015, it introduced Far Vision an ERP which was not implemented properly. The opening balances were not properly entered. In November 2016, the group left half way Far vision and started recording partial transaction in tally. To avoid the traceability, of the transactions, the Promoters and CFO and Adhikari (G.M Accounts) recorded the financial transactions up to March 2015 in Accounting Package tally, then shifted to FARVISION from April 2015 and continued till March
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
2016, and thereafter partially recorded transaction in tally and a for a few companies in FARVISION and thereafter in tally. This was intentionally plan. The companies of the group stopped getting the annual accounts prepared and filing returns to Roc and Income tax.
3. Auditors
The Following Firms carried out the Audit of the Group Companies during the period: Anil Ajay & Co. BSR & Co. Deloitte Haskins & Sells SN Dhawan & Co. Chander Wadhwa & Associates Manoj Usha & Co. Agarwal Seth & Co. Kumar Chopra & Associates
4. Non genuine purchases from suppliers Purchase bills have been accounted for in the books of accounts without receipt of physical goods and purchase bills have been accounted for of suppliers who do not exist. There was an Income Tax search and seizure on 9th September, 2010 and 7th August, 2013. During the search held on 7th August, 2013, it was held by the Income Tax Authorities that purchases are being made from bogus suppliers without receiving the goods physically. The total amount of purchases from such suppliers as observed by the Income Tax department amounted to Rs.842.42 Crores approximately.. In order to confirm the genuineness of these suppliers and a few other suppliers we have sent written communication/ letters by speed post to them in order to confirm the transactions with the Amrapali Group of Companies. Most of these letters have been received back with the remarks “No such firm exists at the specified address”. In addition to above, there is no system of calling quotations for purchases and there is no internal control with respect to inventory.
We have spotted out further certain non-genuine supplies as per details given below: (i) M/s B S Promotors
There have been sales to M/s B S Promoters amounting to Rs. 21.15 Crores during the period 2013-16 from one Company of Amrapali Group and the same goods were re-purchased into another Company of Amrapali Group at a margin of 5% approximately. These transactions seem to be mere accommodation entries, where all purchase/ sales are recorded on a single day only. Further, it was also explained that M/s B S Promotors have made the sales against Bank Letter of Credit which has been discounted by them from their bankers. This seems to be a case of manipulation with the banks also since there is no movement of goods but entries within the Amrapali Group only. Further, it is observed the balance outstanding of INR 5.11 Crores due to the B S Promotors as on 31st March, 2016, has been adjusted against payment made by home buyers directly to the B S Promotors and by allotting a flat to M/s B S Promotors. However, the authorized representative of the B S Promotor has refuted this fact vehemently and asserted that it has not received any payment from the home buyers of the Amrapali Group, nor it has received any flat. Thus, the flat allotted to B S Promoters on paper needs to be attached and put to sale. Moreover, a sum of INR 1.06 crores as 5% of the margin earned by M/s B S Promoters needs to be recovered from him as they have neither received goods nor supplied any good and only acted as Billing agent for which they need not be claiming INR 1.06 crores as their margin. (ii) Kanodia Cements
While scrutinizing the purchase bills of this supplier it was noted that the slips of Weigh Bridge in the case of purchase of Bajri trucks show time interval of 4-5 Minutes only. This doesn’t seem to be possible that a full truck of Bajri takes only 4-5 minutes to enter into the site and come back on the weigh bridge again with empty truck in 4-5 minutes. No satisfactory explanation has been furnished by the management regarding this issue. Sample of such instances have been enclosed below:
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
6524 HR74A-5331
Net weight Date in Kg 30,720 2/3/2015
Time of Gross Weight 18:31
Time of tare weight 18:36
5 Min
6477 HR74A-3499
32,120 2/3/2015
18:34
18:39
5 Min
6437 HR74A-5331
29,230 23/2/2015 18:08
18:12
4 Min
6435 HR74A-8194
31,020 23/2/2015 17:55
18:00
5 Min
6429 HR74A-8194
30,640 22/2/2015 15:50
15:55
5 Min
6289 HR74A/5331 29,150 17/2/2015 15:08
15:13
5 Min
6291 HR74A/8194 30,240 17/2/2015 15:00
15:05
5 Min
6250 HR74-9144
30,710 12/2/2015 18:25
18:30
5 Min
6176 HR55T/5754
30,090 15/2/2015 15:54
15:58
4 Min
6265 HR74A-8194
29,490 15/2/2015 15:52
15:56
4 Min
6179 HR74A-1620
28,270 8/2/2015
16:39
16:43
4 Min
6261 HR74A-8194
30,930 14/2/2015 17:32
17:36
4 Min
6220 HR38T-2855
33,780 8/2/2015
15:43
15:48
5 Min
6227 HR74A-5331
29,290 9/2/2015
15:09
15:13
4 Min
6172 HR55T-5896
29,640 7/2/2015
16:56
17:00
4 Min
6210 HR74A-8194
29,560 7/2/2015
16:59
17:02
3 Min
6169 HR55T 5896
30,910 6/2/2015
15:32
15:36
4 Min
6170 HR55T 8339
31,270 6/2/2015
15:35
15:37
2 Min
6263 HR74A 1680
30,090 14/2/2015 19:09
19:13
4 Min
Challan Truck No. No.
Time taken
As these bills of Kanodia Cements are prima facie held to be bogus, the entire sum of INR 11.69 Crores booked as purchases from Kanodia Cements should be recovered from them or from the Management for inflating their purchase by debiting bogus invoices.
Bogus expense and cash surrendered in income tax search Cash has been surrendered by the Amrapali group in the first Income Tax search conducted on 9th September, 2010. No source of this cash has been explained by the management. According to the Balance sheet of Amrapali Sapphire Developers Private Limited examined by us, cash surrendered is shown as miscellaneous income in the profit and loss account during 201011 amounting to Rs.1.39 Crores.
It is further submitted that in the second search conducted by Income tax Authorities on 7th August, 2013, the Amrapali group had surrendered an additional income of Rs.125 crores. Both these facts clearly depict that Amrapali group was having inflow of unaccounted cash collected from either the Home Buyers or collected cash from Bogus purchases made or by advancing money to various parties and taking cash from them. While scrutinizing the Audited Financial Statements of the Companies for the Financial Year 2013-14, it is observed that no additional income has been shown. There is only jugglery of accounting transactions where sales have been shown by way of part completion method and the relevant cost is also debited to this part completion sale by changing the Accounting Method which was being followed by the Amrapali Group of companies in the earlier years. This method of accounting was changed for 2 financial years only i.e. for Financial Year 2012-13 and Financial Year 2013-14. This method was changed just to make adjustment in accordance with the letter of surrender. In fact, there is no surrender of additional income, it only amounts to preponement of sale being shown in these years instead of it in the later years. Cash has also been surrendered in the first search conducted on 9th September, 2010 and no source of this cash has been explained by the management. This clearly explains that there was flow of un-accounted cash from various sources to the Amrapali Group of Companies. A note was also stated in the Audited Financial Statements for the financial year 2010-11 as follows: “Note 6 (A) During the F.Y. 2010-11 Income Tax Search & Seizure operation conducted by the Income Tax Department on the company and company has surrendered a total income of Rs. 13,893,500 i.e. Rs. 10,043,500 for the F.Y. 2009-10 and Rs. 3,850,000 for the F.Y. 2010-11. Accordingly, the total income includes the above said income.” Thus, it is can be easily inferred that the company has been regularly taking cash from its various home buyers but not recording these cash entries in the Books of Accounts. (Volume –I Page No. 205)
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] It is unclear how the surrender of Rs.125 crore made during the Financial Year 2013-14 has been accepted by the Income Tax Authorities. In fact, no additional income has been shown on this search. Moreover, against the additions relating to Bogus Purchases made in the Assessment order for the Financial Year 2013-14, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeal), Central Circle has deleted all these additions.
We are informed by the management that no further appeal has been preferred by the department before the Income tax Appellate Tribunal as they have no idea of the same so far.
The bills booked and payments made were just accommodation entries. Many of the parties are not traceable and when we requested the Amrapali Group Management to produce the persons/entities to ascertain the veracities of the claims, they didn’t co-operate.
It appears Prima-Facie that the bogus invoices were booked and cash was taken from these parties. We are of the opinion that if we confront the recipient of the purported charges then last recipient would flatly deny. It is pertinent to note that Shri Ajay Kumar Aggarwal of BSBK Group in a statement recorded under section 132(4) of the Income Tax Act has admitted that he provided accommodation/bogus bills. Till the date of writing this report the amount so identified for bogus bills is Rs.837.2 crore. Further, the supplies by Jotindra Steel and Tubes and Mauria Udyog Ltd, having common directors with Amrapali Group Companies, are prima-facie bogus by nature and are under examination amounting to Rs.450 crore. (Refer Annexure No. S 4 Page no 2827 Supplementary report).
Land Development Charges A sum of Rs.7.3 crore has been debited to this account on 31st March, 2013 for which the supporting relevant documents are not made available to us for our verification. This amount needs to be recovered from the Directors as there is no supporting evidence or voucher and it is just a book entry.
Total bogus expenses as on date of report have been ascertained to be Rs. 842.42 crore. Double booking of expense
It has been observed that brokerage amounting to Rs 0.25 crore was paid twice; once to HDFC Realty and again to Mr. Alok Ranjan c/o SSS Enterprises on account of same flat bookings in Amrapali Sapphire Developers Private Limited during the FY 201910. Mr. Sanjay Kumar, proprietor of SSS Enterprises has already conveyed to GM Finance of Amrapali Group by way of speed post that fake bill for brokerage has been raised under his name by Mr. Alok Ranjan. This amount of Rs.0.25 crore should be recovered from Alok Ranjan/ the Management for booking of double expense. (Volume 1 – Page no 213) Unsupported Cash Payments
The Company has made unusual cash payments by transferring the cash to the site cash during the financial year 2016-17 by way of vouchers which are not supported/authenticated by the site cash in charge. It seems that all these entries have been manipulated to use the cash to decrease the balance as on 08/11/ 2016 being the date of demonetization. Some instances are as under: Financial Year
Particulars
Amount
30/04/16
Wages Paid
2,754,350
31/05/16
Wages Paid
2,637,050
30/06/16
Wages Paid
2,655,900
31/07/16
Wages Paid
2,645,450
31/08/16
Wages Paid
2,643,950
30/09/16
Wages Paid
2,659,450
31/10/16
Wages Paid
2,683,350
30/11/16
Wages Paid
1,259,630
06/06/16
Transferred to site cash
3,000,0000
12/05/16
Transferred to site cash
4,100,000
The above are only from one company which is tip of the iceberg and actual amounts may be much higher.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] Further cash payments are being made to number of parties amounting to Rs.20,000 or less which are not supported by payee’s receipts on daily basis. Thus, these payments are not genuine. (Volume I- Page 223) It is observed that the cash balance available on 8th November 2016 was partly deposited into bank and huge amounts were not deposited into bank and was used for payments to staff, suppliers, vendors etc. It is worthwhile to mention that it was not permitted to use Specified Bank Notes (SBN-500, 1000 denomination Notes) for making payments to these parties.
Further there has been an Income tax Survey on 17/11/2016. We understand Income Tax Authorities have recorded the statement of Directors and also taken the Inventory of Cash in hand as on that date. A copy of the statement recorded and detail of inventory of Cash in hand is not made available to us.
Gold bar purchased from Yashika Diamonds It has been observed that the Group Companies purchased Gold bar, other forms of gold worth Rs.5.88 crore. The same has been booked as festival expenses. This does not seem to be a normal business transaction but in the nature of personal expenses. Thus, this amount should be recovered from the management of the company.
5. Negligence and non- monitoring by bankers In view of our detailed report attached, we wish to submit here that the whole process of transfer of funds from one Company to another Company to a third Company and so on and so forth on the same dates would not have been possible without active support by the Bankers. The Bankers, in our opinion, turned a Blind Eye to the various transfer of funds from one account to another for reasons best known to them. They didn’t inquire the huge transfer of funds from various accounts which were being routed every day. Had they been slightly more vigilant to monitor and control transfer of funds, the Management would have not dared to launder the money from one Company to another according to their whims and fancies and the Bankers are solely responsible for the negligence on their part.
Banks did not do any monitoring that whether the funds disbursed were used for approved purposes or not. The loan sanctioned as term loan were diverted on the very same day of receipt. The land payment were not paid etc. Bank of Maharashtra – Term Loan has been released by transferring the amount to the Current account during the financial year 2009-10 to 2012-13. There has been no monitoring by the bank to ensure the end use of utilization of the funds. This amount was paid from the Current account for other than business activities of this Company.
It is observed that there was no monitoring done by the officials of Bank of Maharashtra, Andhra Bank and other banks by releasing of term loan to the Company. Even basic checks as required by the Bank were forgone and not ensured by the Bank Officials regarding the end utilization of the term loan funds for the purpose for which they were granted. It seems that the Bank officials overlooked all these important aspects and granted these loans to them without going into any technical requirements as relating to release of Term Loan facilities to a borrower. The banks acted as mute spectator to unapproved diversion which was almost happening evidently in all banking transactions. Optionally Convertible Debentures ICICI Prudential Asset Management Company Limited had given a sum of INR 74 crores approximately on account of debentures issued by Amrapali Sapphire Developers Private Limited during the financial year 2011-12. These debentures carried interest rate @ 17% Per annum. There has been a gross non-compliance of Investors cumshareholders agreement dated 16th Day of December, 2010 with respect to following: a. Non appointment of directors b. Non operation of bank account by joint signatory of investor c. Non utilization of funds as per clause no. 7.5 of Investment cum Shareholders Agreement dated 16th December, 2010.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] d. Sale of flats at less than Rs 3,420 per square feet of saleable area and many other clauses of this agreement neither followed nor ensured by the Investor. It is very clear that a Debenture Subscription Agreement and Investment cum Shareholders Agreement both dated 16 th day December, 2010 were merely sham documents which were never complied with and both i.e. Amrapali group of Companies and ICICI Prudential Asset Management Company Limited were in connivance with each other in diversion of funds for non-specified purposes. Foreign investment The company has received the sum of Rs. 140 Crores during the financial year 2012-13 from IPFFI Singapore PTE Limited under Foreign Direct Investment Scheme. As per FEMA rules this amount was to be invested in Real Estate construction projects only. The amount received in Axis Bank of Rs.85 Crores was transferred to Amrapali Centurian Park Pvt. Ltd. (ACPPL) as under: On 7.8.2012 Rs.5 Crores On 8.8.2012 Rs.50 Crores On 18.8.2012 Rs.30 Crores ————————— Total = Rs. 85 Crores
————————
ACPPL on receiving Rs.85 Crores, allotted Equity Shares worth Rs. 85 lakhs to ASCPL and balance Rs.84.15 Crores were treated as Share Premium Account. There is no Valuation Report available as to how this share premium of Rs. 84.15 Crores has been calculated. This transfer of fund by ASCPL to ACPPL is absolutely violative of FDI Rules and Agreement.
The Second amount received in BOB Escrow Account was transferred from 8.8.2012 to 28.9.2012 on various dates in the Account of BOB, Sansad Marg Branch, and New Delhi and also used for payment of Term Loan Instalments of OBC and Bank of Maharashtra for repayment of their Term Loan instalments.
It will therefore, be observed from the above, that the Company (ASCPL) did not use money for the project for which it was received from IPFII Singapore but transferred Rs.85 Crores to Amrapali Centurian Park Pvt. Ltd. and Rs.55 Crores to repay Bank Loan Instalments and Repay the outstanding creditors provided for in the books and standing in the books. The said payments made by ASCPL are, therefore, in contravention of FDI norms and rules and for which the money was brought in India. Moreover, ASCPL has paid interest of Rs.58.81 Crores @ 17% (which is a highly abnormal rate) so far to IPFII, Singapore during the last 3 years. - Year 31.3.2013 Rs.14.41 Crores Paid - Year 31.3.2014 Rs.22.20 Crores Paid - Year 31.3.2015 Rs.22.20 Crores Paid ————————
Total = Rs.58.81 Crores ———————— a)
It is very clear that all such violations are being made with the knowledge of the IPFII Singapore and they are in Connivance with the ASCPL.
b)
As per Schedule 4 of the agreement CCD’s (Compulsory Convertible Debenture) were subject to the following terms and conditions.
1) On expiry of 5 years from the date of allotment, the CCD shell be fully monetarily and compulsorily converted into class B shares of the company 2) The CCD’s shall be converted into such number of class B shares arrived that by dividing the aggregate face value of CCD’s by Rs.2,734.30.
But these CCD’s were not converted into class B shares as per agreement but entered into another agreement to extend the term of CCD’s from 5 years to 7 years. By this way , The fund has continued to be a creditor otherwise
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] after conversion to equity, it will not be eligible for interest and principal.
Current liabilities not payable Security deposits from contractors and intercorporate deposits accepted from non group companies are in the nature of unsecured loans. There have been no business transactions with the company except movement of funds. The list of such liabilities is under preparation which are not payable. Inter-corporate deposits accepted by the Group are Non-Interestbearing unsecured loans. There are no business transactions with these companies. It is not understood as to why a person will give interest free loans without any considerations. Thus, we are of the view that these are accommodation entry only in lieu of consideration given to them indirectly by the management.
Hence, we are of the view that all the aforesaid amounts are not payable.
In our opinion, this is a case of Money Laundering as the generic term of Money Laundering is defined to describe the process by which Criminals disguise the original ownership and control the proceeds of the criminal conduct by making such proceeds to have derived from a legitimate source.
Money Laundering is the process of concealing the origin of money obtained illegally by passing it through a complex sequence of Banking transfers or commercial transactions. The main process is accounting for the proceeds without raising the suspicion of law enforcement agencies. In the instant case too, Amrapali Group of Companies have defied all laws to transfer small and big amounts from one account to another to a third and so on and so forth on a single day with the connivance of the Bank officials and financial institution officials and thereby Committed act of Money Laundering on a large scale.
6. Lands allotted to consortium and flats sold to homebuyers Several companies were formed with consortium partners which were just dummy companies and were part and parcel of Amrapali group. To comply with the condition of minimum 3 partners, these companies were created in the names of office boys and peons.
Technically the allotments at the initial stage itself were void abinitio. In most of the companies, the amount received from homebuyers was sufficiently more than the amount spent on construction and for payment of land. Had the promoters paid amount received from homebuyers to the authorities on time there would not have been any liability of land dues. Further there was no need to avail any loan from banks, Private equity funds as well as from investors. The sole objective of taking loan was to divert the funds to other ventures to create assets in the name of family members, make movies, to satisfy the ambitious desires of family members and to build hospital. Villas were bought at tourist destinations for fun at the expense of middle class and low income group peoples abodes. Many parties joined them in the looting of hard earned money of homebuyers to take their share of the cake in the form of unbelievable return on investment, profits, land, FSI and flats and facilities at throwaway prices. Bogus expenses were booked and the promoters were having no fear of the law of the land. They could execute many transactions of transfer of properties, booking of expenses, funds transfer, even when the petition was accepted and was pending for disposal before the Honourable Supreme Court. Companies in which land was allotted to consortium partners are as under: Amrapali Leisure Valley Pvt Ltd Amrapali Centurian Park Pvt Ltd Amrapali Homes Amrapali Grand Amrapali Eden Park Developers Pvt Ltd -Iftikar Ahmed and Rakesh Mahajan jointly hold 49% in the said company (i) There is no substance in the nature of transactions carried on by the company. The funds are merely routed from one entity to another for hidden objective.
(ii) Banks were financing not the construction activity but loans and advances to third parties. (iii) Mr. Rakesh Mahajan and Mr. Ifthikar Khan were grossly involved in the wrongdoings in the company’s project and
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
equally conspired in the delay and diversion of home buyers funds and they being 49% shareholders and active directors in the company should be held responsible for the deficit in completion of the project amounting to Rs.20 crore.
Further, Amrapali Infrastructure had given an advance of Rs.1.5 crore to Nirala Infracity Ajmer Pvt Ltd - a project controlled by Rakesh Mahajan and Iftikar Ahmed. This amount is recoverable from Nirala Infracity Ajmer Pvt Ltd.
7. Companies created solely for the purpose of routing funds The intention of Amrapali Group was to divert funds to other projects/income sources in the name of family members of the promoter and the trusted employees, friends of the promoters as well of the executives, auditors and their relatives. For this purpose, several companies were incorporated for routing funds. These companies did not have any material transaction as per the main object for which they were incorporated and did not have business since their incorporation. These companies did not have any employees also. These companies are shell companies used only to route interest free funds from one company to another. List of such companies identified so far is as under: a) Jhamb Finance & Leasing Private Limited - The company didn’t have any operations/income/expenses except for FY 201415 and had only movement of funds from one related party/ interested party to the other. It means the company was used merely for routing the funds and not for doing any business. Since incorporation, loans (liability) and loans & advances (asset) increased as under, without booking of any expense/income: As on 1st April 2014
Loans (liability) Loans & advances (asset) Amount (RS. ) Amount (RS. ) 83,00,000 1,12,39,917
1st October 2014 31st March 2015 31st March 2016 31st March 2017
35,33,00,000 312,93,32,906 859,77,32,906 877,57,22,906
34,67,39,917 313,11,55,392 863,58,50,776 883,24,00,776
It is pertinent to note that starting from the FY 2015-16, the loans given and taken increased three folds without having any corresponding increased on the income and assets side on account of interest. Whereas starting from FY 2015-16, the employees started leaving the organization and the construction at sites was at standstill. The directors in the company are having no knowledge or an iota of idea about the transactions carried out. The company’s operation were under the controlled and supervision of CFO Chander Wadhwa. Further, it received Rs.18.95 crore from Suspense- unidentified persons/parties and paid Rs.24.41 crore to Suspense- unidentified persons/parties, leaving balance payable of Rs.5.46 crore to Suspense- unidentified persons/parties. The said transactions of Rs.18.95 crore details were not made available to us. b) Gaurisuta Infrastructure Private Limited – It lent and received funds from several parties without doing any business. Details of Rs.25 crore received from third parties are as under: S.no. Name of party
Amount
Since date
Ams Powertonic Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
07-05-2012
Anuj Buildcon Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
10-05-2012
Asv Garments Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
07-05-2012
Bij Buildcon Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
10-05-2012
Carona Infra Projects Pvt. Ltd. 2,20,00,000
Charuvilla Apartment Behl
8,31,000
Received on various dates From 16-052013 to 16-092014 08-07-2011
Financial World Pvt. Ltd
57,00,000
11-07-2012
Function Distributors Pvt. Ltd. 50,00,000
03-08-2012
Green Value Agro Farm Pvt. Ltd Infotech India Pvt Ltd
01-08-2012 & 03-08-2012 03-07-2012
30,00,000 1,00,00,000
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
Kabir Enterprises Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
06-06-2012
Ladli Ji Enterprises Pvt Ltd
2,00,00,000
15-05-2012
Leisure Buildcon Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
25-04-2012
M/S Naksha Properties Pvt.Ltd
84,00,000
19-04-2012
M/S Shravni Infrastructre
3,20,00,000
M/S Soulful Heart Solutions
22,00,000
Ram Rahim Trading Co. Limited
70,00,000
Received on various dates From 19-042012 to 11-072013 Received on various dates From 19-042012 to 17-072013 01-08-2012 & 02-08-2012
Randhir It Solutions Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
07-05-2012
Rayan Garments Pvt Ltd
1,40,00,000
R N Sangahi
24,37,480
26-04-2012 & 07-05-2012 11-04-2011 ; 02-07-2011 & 18-12-2012
S A Corrugators Pvt Ltd
20,00,000
01-08-2012
Sadbhavana Properties Pvt Ltd 4,00,00,000
08-06-2012
SpbPropcorn Pvt. Ltd.
50,00,000
25-04-2012
40,00,000
25-04-2012
Technicare Biomed India Pvt Ltd Utkarsh Properties Solution
28,00,000
26-04-2012 ; 16-09-2014 & 17-092014
Vendure Agents Pvt Ltd
50,00,000
01-08-2012
Zarf Infra. Development Pvt Ltd
1,45,00,000
Zoom Building Materials Pvt Ltd TOTAL
1,00,00,000
Received on various dates From 26-042012 to 04-082012 10-05-2012 & 11-05-2012
25,08,68,480
The above companies were used for the purpose of money laundering and required a detailed investigation. Further the amount as shown above is not payable to the party as indicated against. None of the parties as above has lodged any claim so far therefore it strengthens our charge.
As on 31st March 2017, the company is having interest free loans and advances amounting to Rs.703 crore without any movement with a paid up share capital of merely Rs.0.01 crore and the directors are employees and junior employees of statutory auditors. The company is used as a conduit in diverting home buyer funds to Amrapali Healthcare (Noida Hospital) and buying shares in different group companies from the funds of home buyers. The entire shareholding should be attached and be made up for sale.
c) Neelkanth Buildcraft Private Limited - It was formed in the year 2013 having a capital of Rs.0.01 crore for the specific purpose of buying shares from JP Morgan. Mr Chandan Kumar, director of Neelkanth Buildcraft Private Limited is an office boy in the office of Statutory Auditor of Amrapali Group, Mr Anil Mittal and the other director Mr Vivek Mittal is nephew of Statutory Auditor Mr Anil Mittal & does small time jobs. d) Stunning Construction Private Limited – The Company is holding 19.75 % shareholding in LA Residentia Developers Pvt. Ltd. is a consortium partner in the project since beginning. LA Residentia project has 3200 flats LA Residentia should surrender either 19.75% of land or 632 flats. It was formed only for payment of Statutory dues of Amrapali Group of Companies, its directors and their relatives including senior employees of the Amrapali Group of Companies. The company was under the direct control of CFO Chander Wadhwa and Company Secretary Pankaj Mehta. The amount of taxes paid by the company on behalf of promoters, directors, executives and their family members is Rs.17.43 crore (net) and gross up is Rs.24.9 crore is recoverable from promoters, directors, executives and their relatives. e) Kapila Buildhome Private Limited – The company did not undertake any business. A sum of Rs.392.68 Crores was advanced as loan or advances to the various group Companies. Further, it accepted non-interest bearing inter corporate deposits from
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.] non group companies with whom no other transactions were undertaken. We are of the view that these are accommodation book entries only in lieu of consideration given to them indirectly by the management. List is as stated hereunder: Name Ample Hotels and Resorts Justify Vanijya Private Limited Ladli ji Enterprises Private Limited Madhav Fincap Private Limited Pan Realtors Private Limited Total
Amount In Date of Acceptance Rs. 20,000,000 20/04/12 4,000,000 22/06/12 5,900,000 25/04/12 15,000,000 100,000,00 144,900,00
24/04/12 23/08/10
The above companies were used for the purpose of money laundering and required a detailed investigation. Further the amount as shown above is not payable to the party as indicated against. None of the parties (except PAN Realtors that also when we requested them otherwise they were silent for last 8 Years) as above has lodged any claim so far therefore it strengthens our charge. f) Rudraksh Infracity Private Limited- Shri Chandan Kumar, an office boy and employee of CA Anil Mittal, Statutory Auditor and Shri Atul Mittal, relative of CA Anil Mittal were inducted in the board. The basic purpose of this Company was only for money laundering and was incorporated to receive Funds from Mannat Buildcraft Private Limited. After receiving money (Rs.25 Cr.) from Mannat Buildcraft Private Limited, the same was transferred to J.P. Morgan Investments for purchase of Equity Shares of Amrapali Zodiac Private Limited at an exorbitant price. There are no transactions before or after these transfers of money and the same have been camouflaged to make it look with business transactions on the basis of the Valuation Report.
It was also observed that there are no transactions at any date during the period but the bank account has only been used for diversion of funds.
g) Mannat Buildcraft Private Limited - Shri Pankaj Mehta is Company Secretary of Amrapali group of Companies and now Partner of Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO in Saffron Consultants LLP and Mr. Ashish Jain who is also Partner of Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO in Saffron Consultants LLP, were inducted in the board. The basic purpose of this Company was only for money laundering (Rs.120 Cr.) and was incorporated to receive Funds from Amrapali Zodiac Developers Private Limited. The whole racket of money laundering and receiving money from these Companies i.e. Mannat Buildcraft Private Limited, Rudraksh Infracity Private Limited and Neelkanth Buildcraft private Limited are the brain child of Mr. Chander Wadhwa, CFO and Anil Mittal, Statutory Auditor of Amrapali Group of Companies. Both these Companies are controlled by both of these persons and had been formed only for this Money Laundering Business. There are no transactions before or after these transfers of money and the same have been camouflaged to make it look with business transactions on the basis of the Valuation Report. h) Amrapali Magadh Developers Pvt Ltd - The company has not carried out principal business activities. There is no bank account. The purpose of creating the company is not clear. The shareholders paid the share application money in cash. The company is a dormant company & did not have any significant transaction. i) Amrapali Mahi Developers Pvt Ltd - The company received share capital in cash and all the expenses were paid in cash only. Mr. Mahendra Singh Dhoni, husband of Ms. Sakshi Singh Dhoni (director of company) was the brand ambassador of Amrapali group and have carried out a number of transactions with respect to endorsement of Amrapali group’s projects. He entered in agreements with other group company. j) Amrapali Spring Valley Pvt Ltd- the company is created for diversion of funds and Rs.186 crore was diverted from Amrapali Smart City Pvt Ltd to buy shares of Ultra Home Construction Pvt Ltd and shareholders are promoter directors without doing any investments.
BIKRAM CHATTERJI & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. [ARUN MISHRA, J.]
Most of the above companies will qualify to be NBFC, which was reported neither by the management nor by the statutory auditors (except Jhamb Finance & Leasing Pvt Ltd). It is recommended that RBI shall investigate the affairs and compliances of the above companies.
Amrapali Media Vision Pvt Ltd was also incorporated with a purpose to route funds for making movies to satisfy the ambitious desires of directors/family members. Most of the marketing and advertisement business of the group companies was given to the company with a profit margin on the cost. The group could have done this advertisement directly. But because there was need to make movies, the funds were diverted to the company directly in the form of loan as well by availing the services indirectly from these companies. The Company was freely availing funds of homebuyers from other group Companies in the form of ICD and spent it on making movies.
Hawthrone Intellect Management Solutions Pvt Ltd – Company was providing Management Consultancy Services (Recruitment Services) and taking nominal professional fee. In turn, the Company has incurred more expenses in the last few years on account of Salary, Wages and other administrative expenses thereby resulting in net loss to the Company which has accumulated to INR 2.33 Crores as on 31.03.2015.
All these entries seem to be in nature of dubious entries and no voucher are available. This amount of loss of 2.33 Crores needs to be recovered from the Directors as they have wiped of the amount of the Home Buyers funds diverted as Home Buyers Money to the Company. Apart from the above companies, there were several companies which were incorporated by employees, auditors of Amrapali group. Shareholding as well as investment/assets of these companies shall be attached
8. Companies created for building assets The following companies were created by the Group for building assets from homebuyer funds without contribution of any rupee by promoters and their relatives. The shareholding is held by the
group companies and/or by shell companies and/or the trusted partners including individuals. Ultra Home Construction Pvt Ltd- Shareholders did not bring capital of their own, but used funds of home buyers in other entities/ projects to pay for allotment of shares in UHCPL. Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma was allotted shares at premium for an amount of Rs.22,82,40,810 on 4th Nov 2010 and Rs.25,84,05,470 on 2nd March 2011 by adjusting receipts from Amrapali Infrastructure Ltd which further received from Amrapali Sapphire Developers Pvt Ltd, which received from homebuyers. Few instances are hereunder: Received in Amrapali Sapphire Developers Pvt Ltd primarily from home buyers INR 5.47 crore as on 4th March 2010 INR 1.90 crore on 5th and 6th March 2010 INR 1.13 crore on 8th March 2010
Transferred to Amrapali Infrastructure Ltd
Transferred to Ultra Home Construction Pvt Ltd
INR 2 crore on 5th March 2010 INR 2 crore on 8th March 2010 INR 2 crore on 9th March 2010
INR 2 crore on 5th March 2010 INR 2 crore on 8th March 2010 INR 2 crore on 9th March 2010
Amrapali Homes Projects Private Limited –It has been observed that Mr. Prem Mishra was given INR 12.40 crore (under several ledgers) for purchase of land since 1st April 2008, out of which INR 10 crore are still receivable from him. The project was sold by Prem Mishra to various parties and received amount in his name. We are yet to complete the audit of Prem Mishra in Indore project. The company transferred funds to and fro with several parties which do not have any substance. It has several small and big debit balances as on date. Amrapali Biotech India Pvt Ltd – Land & Building, Plant & machinery, a factory at Rajgir (Bihar)
Amrapali Healthcare Pvt Ltd – Hospital at Noida Noida Texfab Pvt Ltd – Amrapali International Institute of Hotel management, Noida Neelkanth Buildcraft Pvt Ltd – bought shareholding from JP Morgan in Amrapali Zodiac developers Pvt Ltd.
MVG Tec