Capt. George A.E Paul v. Commodore Madhava Rao
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice P.sam Koshy, Justice Laxmi Narayana Alishetty
- Case number
- CC No. 78 of 2025
- Result
- CLOSED NO COSTS
Full judgment
[ 3304 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY CONTEMPT CASE NO: 78 OF 2025
Contempt Case under Sections 10 lo 12 of Contempt of Courts Act 1971 to
punish the respondent herein for violation and willful disobedience of the order dt. 03-09-2024 in W.A.No. 597 of 2016.
Between: Capt. George A.E Paul, S/o. VDF Paul Aged about 56 Years. Fi/o.Tirumalagiri, Secunderabad. ...PETITIONER AND
1. Commodore Madhava Rao, Bharath Dynamics Limited, Bhanur Medak District Rep by its Chairman and Managing Director
2. Sri L. Kishan, General Manager/ Executive Director (Unit Head), Bharath Dynamics Limited Bhanur, Medak District. 3. Biplab Sinha, Deputy General Manager/ Additional General Manager (P and A) Bharath Dynamics Limited, Bhanur, Medak
...Respondents Counsel for the Petitioner : Sri Thalluri Niranjan Prasad Counsel forthe Respondents : Ms. V. Uma Devi The Gourt made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HON' BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P .SAM KOSHY AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUST ICE LAXMI NARAY ANA ALISHETTY
CONTEMPT CASE No.78 of2025 (CNR No. HBHCOr00052 12025) Datedz28.l0.2026 Between: Capt. George A.E.Paul
...Petitioner and
Commonrlore Madhava Rao and 2 others. .. . Respondents
ORDER: G'er rtrc Lt<ttt bte rhe Acring ChiefJ strce p.Sant KathN)
Learned counsel Sri Thalluri Niranjan prasad appears for
the
petitioner
I-earned counsel Ms. V.tJrna Devi appears lor the rcspondents through video conferencing
2.
'l'he present contempt case is one which has been fi1ed alleging
rvillul non-cotnpliance of the order dated 03'09'2024 passed in W.A.No.597 o1'2016.
3.
It would be relevant at this juncture to refer to the operative
portion of the order passed in the writ appeal, which reads as uuder: Accordingly. the Writ Appeat is allowed b)' setting aside the ordcr dateti I I 04.2016 passed irr W I'No 6753 of 2000 by the learned iingte.lrdg" and also ihe ptrnishtncnt imposed by the 3'd respondent is agaiirst th"'oppellant vide proceedings dated 26 02'2000 and appellant entitled to alt tlle consequential benefits No costs' Miscellaneous petitiolts, if any, pending shall stand closed "
'8.
Non-cornpliance of this order led to fiting of the present contempt case
4.
ln the contcrnpt case, the respondents/contemnors have come up
with a countcr affidavit. The respondents/contemnors have also filed a statement shou'ing the comparison bct\T een the pctitioner and
similarly
placed pcrsons in the departrrent in the coursc of showing due colnpliance ol the order passed by this court' It has been brought
to the
notice ol this court that an amount of Rs'4,4 I , 146/-' which
is an
additional arnount lorvards compliance of the order passed
by this court'
has been paid to the petitioner by way of a demand 28.04.2025. A copy of the said demand draft is court. !vhich is taken on record.
draft dated
produced before this
J
5.
Learned counsel lor the petitioner submits thal the calculation
made bl the department is erroneous and the comparison draw.n also is
not correct. as the petitioner being an Ex-serviceman cannot be conrpared with a regular employee of the departtnent.
6.
All said and done, this court is seized of rhe contolnpt
proceedings alleging non-compliance of the order to the extenr ol.the punishment order of stoppage of two incrernents with cumulativc efI'ect being ser aside. The nature of compliance ."vhich this court Lrnder the contempr .iurisdiction can look into is rvhether the punishrnent ordcr having been set aside, the petitioner has been granted the benefits o1.the
two increments along with the consequential benefits. The clepartment has done the calculation. which according to the petitioner is erroneous.
7.
ln the opinion of this court. all that this court as ol'nou nccds to
look into is rvhether the order has been complied uith or not and rvhether there is a wilful disobedience or non-cornpriance ol the
order.
Having gone through the counter alfidavit filed by, the department and also the comparative statement submitted by the departrnent. we arc
of
the considered opinion that substantial compliance has. in lact. been
made. Insofar as the contempt proceedings are concernecl. substantial
compliance also is sulficient to drop the contempt proceedings. Ifat all there is any calculation error or a mistake committed by the department
in the course ol drawing comparison, the petitioner would be at liberty
to approach thc departrnent showing the actual way as to how the calculation ought to havc been done and the respondents/contemnors shall duly consider the sarne and take appropriate decision immediately
on the petitioner submitting the objections to the paymcnts nrade and compliancc shown by the departrnent
8.
-l'he
contenrpt casc, with the afot'esaid liberty. stands closed. The
rcspondents shall stand discharged lrour the contelnpt proceedings.
Misccllanoous applications pcnding, ifany, shall stand closed SD/- A.V.S. PRASAD
DEPUW REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY//
€ SECTION OFFICER
To
1. One CC to Sri Thalluri N iranjan Prasad, Advocate (OPUC) 2. One CC to Ms. V. Uma Devi, Advocate (OPUC) 3. Two CD Copies MvjiGNK
Srrc,.
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2811012020
ORDER
CC.No. 78 oI2025 R
.:F i,
o
to
0 4 r;!1' 21126
*o
CLOSING THE CC
(?Lrt\c, gt \rol tL
I jp''i.-