Chethan Kumar N v. The State of Karnataka
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 29 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice S Sunil Dutt Yadav
- Case number
- WP No. 28540 of 2023
- Result
- ALLOWED
- Acts & sections
- Section 13 PC Act
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
-1HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S SUNIL DUTT YADAV WRIT PETITION NO. 28540 OF 2023 (S-RES) BETWEEN:
Digitally signed by VIDYA G R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
1.
CHETHAN KUMAR N. S/O NARAYANASWAMY, AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, SENIOR HEALTH INSPECTOR, CMC, KOLLEGAL, R/AT DOOR NO.7/98, BASTHIPURA MAIN ROAD, RAMASWAMY LAYOUT, KOLLEGAL, CHAMARAJANAGR DISTRICT, PIN 571440.
2.
JAYALAKSHMI B. W/O H. N. SURESH, AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, SECOND DIVISION ASSISTANT, TMC, YALANDUR, R/AT DOOR NO.78/741, 14TH CROSS, MARUTHI NILAYA, NEAR NAIDU FARM, KOLLEGAL, CHAMARAJANGAR DISTRICT, PIN 571440.
3.
N MADESH, S/O LATE NARAYANA,
-2HC-KAR
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, SECOND DIVISION ASSISTANT, TMC, HANURU RA/T DOOR NO.129/3, S R ROAD, GUNDLUPETE, CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT, PIN 571111. 4.
MANIYA M. S/O LATE MADAIAH, AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS, BILL COLLECTOR, CMC, KOLLEGAL, R/A HANURU, AMBEDKAR NAGAR, HANURU TALUK, CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT, PIN 571439.
5.
NANJUNDA SHETTY S/O LATE RANGA SHETTY, AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS, BILL COLLECTOR, CMC, CHAMARAJANAGAR, R/AT BALEPETE, YELANDUR, CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT, PIN 571441. …PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. PAVANA CHANDRA SHETTY H., ADVOCATE) AND: 1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENMT, URBAN DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT, VIKASA SOUDHA,
-3HC-KAR
DR AMBEDKAR VEEDHI, BENGALURU 560001. 2.
DIRECTOR OF MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION, GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA, 9TH FLOOR, V. V. TOWERS, BENGALURU 560001.
3.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT, CHAMARAJANAGAR 571313.
4.
PROJECT DIRECTOR CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT, D. C. COMPOUND, CHAMARAJANAGAR - 571313.
5.
HANURU TOWN MUNCIPAL COUNCIL, HANURU TOWN, CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT-571313.
6.
Y GIRIRAJ, FATHER NAME NOT KNOWN, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS, WORKING AS A MANAGER, DISTRICT URBAN DEVELOPMENT CELL, D. C. OFFICE BUILDING, DOUBLE ROAD, CHAMARAJANAGAR DISTRICT, PIN - 571313.
7.
K SURESH FATHER NAME NOT KNOWN, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
-4HC-KAR
WORKING AS A REVENUE OFFICER, MYSURU CITY CORPORATION, NEW SAYYAJI RAO ROAD, MYSURU, PIN 570024. 8.
NANJUNDASWAMY FATHER NAME NOT KNOWN, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, WORKING AS COMMISSIONER, NANJANGUD CITY MUNCIPAL COMMISSION, NEAR NEHRU CIRCLE, NANJANGUD, MYSURU DISTRICT, PIN 571301. …RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. MAMATHA SHETTY, AGA FOR R1 AND R3; SMT. RUPA B.P., ADVOCATE FOR C/R2; R6, R7, R8 ARE SERVED) THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED
ORDER
AGAINST
THE
PETITIONERS
HEREIN
PASSED BY THE R2 DATED 04.12.2023 FROM SL.NO.2, 4 TO 7 IN ORDER BEARING ITS NO.280352/DMA/ENQ2/MYS/28/202020 PRODUCED AS ANNEXURE-A ORDER FOR DEMOTION IN RANK/STATUS OF THE PETITIONERS. THIS
PETITION,
COMING
ON
FOR
PRELIMINARY
HEARING, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S SUNIL DUTT YADAV
-5HC-KAR
ORAL ORDER
Issuance of notice as regards respondents No.4 and 5 is waived, in light of the memo filed by the petitioner stating that the said respondents are only pro-forma parties. 2.
The present petition has been filed by the
employees of respondent No.5 - Town Municipal Council, Hanuru Town, challenging the order
at Annexure-A,
whereby the Director of Municipal Administration which is a disciplinary authority by the impugned order had imposed the punishment after accepting the enquiry report as against the petitioners herein who are found at Sl.No.2 to 7 of the reduction to a lower stage in the time scale of pay. 3.
It is to be noticed that the petitioners would
contend that insofar as the employee who was the Chief Officer of the Town Municipal Council, who was imposed the punishment of compulsory retirement in a joint
-6HC-KAR
enquiry, the order at Annexure-A insofar as the said employee had been challenged in W.P.No.9429/2024 and the punishment imposed as against the said Chief Officer was set aside by the order dated 19.12.2024 passed in W.P.No.9429/2024
with
further
direction
to
respondents to reinstate the petitioner into service with arrears,
continuity
service
and
all
consequential
benefits. 4.
It is accordingly submitted that in light of one of
the delinquent employee of a joint enquiry having had the benefit of the enquiry report being set aside as well as penalty imposed being set aside on the basis of evidence available on record, the said benefit on principle of parity is required to be extended to the other co-delinquents. 5.
Learned Additional Government Advocate would
submit that the said assertion of the petitioners is a matter of record and in fact as per the order in W.P.No.9429/2024, the penalty imposed as against the
-7HC-KAR
Chief Officer has been set aside and accordingly, it is submitted that the Court may pass appropriate orders. 6.
Perused the order passed in W.P.No.9429/2024.
It is not in dispute that the enquiry was a common enquiry. Insofar as the evidence available pertaining to Sri. Murthy, the Chief Officer, the Co-ordinate Bench has examined in detail the evidence on record and has set aside the order of penalty. The relevant observations made by the Co-ordinate Bench on the merits of the matter are found at para-34, which reads as follows: " 34. Conclusions: 1.
Violation
procedure:
The
penalty
compulsory retirement imposed on the petitioner contravenes Rule 8(vi) of the Karnataka Civil Service Rules,
(Classification, 1957.
This
rule
Control,
and
stipulates
Appeal)
that
such
penalties are to be reserved for cases involving proven
charges
corruption
or
misconduct
supported by substantial evidence. 2. Absence of Corruption Charges: The charges against the petitioner relate solely to the issuance
-8HC-KAR
e-katha
certificates
without
adequate
verification of record conversion orders and layout plans. No allegations or evidence were presented that
could
constitute
corruption
or
"criminal
misconduct" as defined under Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. 3.
Lack
Substantiated
Evidence:
The
disciplinary enquiry failed to present credible or verifiable
evidence
demonstrating
that
petitioner’s actions caused any financial loss to the State or involved unapproved layouts. The assertion of revenue loss remains unsupported by documentary proof. 4. Inadequate Justification for Recovery: The directive to recover Rs. 4,43,170/- with 8% interest from the petitioner is baseless, as neither the rationale for this calculation nor supporting records have been provided. 5.
Petitioner’s
Procedures:
The
Compliance
petitioner
with
Legal
provided
detailed
explanations and supporting documents, including prior conversion orders and technical approvals, which demonstrated that the issuance of e-kathas adhered to legal and procedural norms. The
-9HC-KAR
Disciplinary
Authority
failed
to
rebut
these
explanations or present counter-evidence. 6. Non-Reliance on Critical Report: Although a financial loss report prepared by the Deputy Commissioner
(DC)
was
referenced
by
respondents, it was not introduced or relied upon during the enquiry proceedings, undermining the credibility
and
admissibility
findings.
Compounding the procedural deficiency is the fact that the report has not been produced before this Court, thereby rendering it impossible for judicial scrutiny
or
evaluation
its
contents
and
authenticity. 7. Retaliatory Proceedings: The initiation of departmental
proceedings
appears
to
be
retaliatory, following the petitioner’s challenge to a transfer order and the initiation of contempt proceedings against senior officials. This points to potential
malafide
intent
and
abuse
administrative power. 8. Failure to Follow Procedural Fairness: The disciplinary process lacked procedural fairness, as evidenced by speculative findings unsupported by verifiable evidence and the absence of a clear basis for penalty imposition.
- 10 HC-KAR
9. Legal Unsustainability of the Penalty: The impugned
penalty
compulsory
retirement,
coupled with the financial recovery directive, is legally
unsustainable
due
to
lack
substantive evidence and procedural deficiencies. 10. Failure of Disciplinary Authority to Rebut Evidence: Despite the petitioner's provision of
robust
counter-evidence,
Disciplinary
Authority failed to effectively challenge or rebut these claims. The lack of any meaningful effort to address or discredit the petitioner's documentary submissions reflects a procedural oversight that significantly
weakens
credibility
authority's stance. 11. Inquiry Officer’s Omission to Address Crucial Explanations:
The Inquiry Officer inexplicably
neglected
address
to
explanations
and
petitioner's
key
evidence
during
proceedings. This omission amounts to a failure to conduct a fair and impartial assessment of the facts
and
constitutes
a
procedural
defect
undermining the findings of the inquiry. The Disciplinary Authority disregarded the petitioner’s explanation, failing to provide reasoned findings or
cogent
justifications
for
rejecting
petitioner's evidence. Such disregard contravenes
- 11 HC-KAR
principles of procedural fairness and due process, which mandate that decision-making authorities meaningfully engage with the submissions and evidence of the accused. 12. Necessity to Set Aside Penalty: In view of the aforementioned points, the order of compulsory retirement is disproportionate and lacks legal justification. The imposition of penalties without due process and substantiation undermines the principles of justice and fairness, warranting the setting aside of the impugned order. 13. The Appellate Authority (Respondent No. 1) failed to adequately consider or address the detailed explanations and evidence submitted by the petitioner in response to the charges. Instead, the authority mechanically affirmed the order of compulsory
retirement
without
providing
any
independent analysis or reasoned justification for rejecting
petitioner's
submissions.
This
perfunctory approach violates principles of natural justice and due process, rendering the appellate decision legally unsustainable."
7.
Taking note of the stand of the respondents and
also the fact of the joint enquiry, the order at Annexure-A
- 12 HC-KAR
insofar as the petitioners, requires to be set aside by taking
note
observations
made
in
W.P.No.9429/2024. 8.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The
impugned order at Annexure-A insofar as it concerns petitioners herein is set aside. Accordingly, the penalty imposed against the petitioners of reduction to lower stage in time scale of pay is set aside. 9.
Respondents are directed to re-instate the
petitioners forthwith into service, with arrears, continuity of service and all consequential benefits. The compliance of the order is to be completed within a period of four (4) weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of the order. Accordingly, the petition is allowed.
Sd/(S SUNIL DUTT YADAV) JUDGE MCR