Divisional Controller Ksrtc v. Smt B J Shanthakumari
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 29 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Geetha K.B
- Case number
- MFA No. 6597 of 2024
- Result
- ALLOWED
- Acts & sections
- Section 173 Motor Vehicles Act
- Subject
- Motor accident
Full judgment
-1HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B. MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 6597 / 2024 (MV-I) C/W MFA CROSS OBJECTION NO. 20 OF 2025 (MV-I) IN MFA NO. 6597/2024: BETWEEN: 1.
DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER KSRTC PUTTUR DIVISION, PUTTUR, DAKSHINA KANNADA NOW REPRESENTED BY MANAGING DIRECTOR KSRTC BENGALURU CENTRAL OFFICE K.H. ROAD, SHANTHINAGAR DOUBLE ROAD BENGALURU-560 027 REP. BY CHIEF LAW OFFICER. …APPELLANT (BY SRI. RAJASHEKAR S., ADVOCATE) AND:
1.
SMT. B.J. SHANTHAKUMARI W/O R. PRATHAP KUMAR AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS R/AT BHUVANAGIRI KUSHALNAGAR KODAGU-573116.
2.
T NATESH MAJOR KSRTC BUS DRIVER R/AT VIDYANAGAR KUSHALNAGAR, MADIKERI
-2HC-KAR
KODAGU-573 116. …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. JAGADISH BALIGA, ADVOCATE FOR R1; V/O DATED 15.01.2025, NOTICE TO R2 DISPENSED WITH) THIS MFA IS FILED U/S. 173(1) OF MV ACT, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 07.03.2024 PASSED IN MVC NO.99/2022 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE AND MACT, KODAGU, AT MADIKERI, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.16,88,711/WITH INTEREST AT 9 PERCENT P.A. FROM THE DATE OF PETITION TILL REALIZATION. IN MFA.CROB NO. 20/2025: BETWEEN: 1.
SMT. B.J. SHANTHAKUMARI AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS, WIFE OF R. PRATHAP KUMAR, RESIDING AT BHUVANAGIRI, KUSHALANAGAR-571 234, KODAGU DISTRICT.
...CROSS OBJECTOR (BY SRI. JAGADISH BALIGA N., ADVOCATE) AND: 1.
SRI. T. NATESH AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS KSRTC BUS DRIVER, RESIDENT OF VIDYANAGAR, MADIKERI-571 201, KODAGU DISTRICT.
2.
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER, KSRTC, PUTTUR DIVISION, PUTTUR-574 201,
-3HC-KAR
DAKSHINA KANNADA. ...RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. RAJASHEKAR S., ADVOCATE FOR R2; V/O DATED 07.07.2025, NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH) THIS MFA CROB IS FILED UNDER ORDER XLI RULE 22(1) OF THE CPC, 1908 READ WITH SECTION 173(1) OF MOTOR VEHICLE ACT, 1988 AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 07.03.2024 PASSED IN MVC NO.99/2022 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE AND MACT, KODAGU, MADIKERI, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CALIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION. THIS APPEAL AND MFA CROB, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM:
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
ORAL JUDGMENT MFA No.6597/2024 is filed under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, ‘M.V. Act’) by the appellant/respondent
No.2-KSRTC,
challenging
the
quantum of compensation awarded in the judgment and award dated 07.03.2024 in MVC No. 99/2022 on the file of the I Additional District Judge & MACT, Kodagu at Madikeri (in short, ‘the Tribunal’).
-4HC-KAR
2.
MFA CROB No.20/2025 is filed by the claimant
not satisfied with the compensation awarded in the aforesaid case. 3.
The parties would be referred with their ranks,
as they
were before the Tribunal for the sake of
convenience and clarity. 4.
The case of the claimant before the Tribunal in
nutshell is that on 25.02.2022 at 07:40 a.m. when she was traveling in KSRTC bus bearing Reg.No.KA-19/F-3242 near Kaman gate near Madikeri-Mysuru highway, the rear tyre of the bus suddenly exploded and burst and because of that the claimant sustained grievous injuries and hence, undertook treatment in District Hospital, Madikeri from 25.02.2022 to 02.03.2022. The claimant is working as a qualified staff Nurse at KIMS, Madikeri and getting salary of `25,000/- per month, thus claiming compensation from the respondents, who are the driver and the KSRTC. 5.
After framing issues, recording evidence and
hearing arguments, the Tribunal came to the conclusion
-5HC-KAR
that the claimant has suffered injuries in the road traffic accident
and
thus,
entitled
for
compensation
of
`16,88,711/- under the following heads: Sl. No.
Particulars
Amount
Towards pain and suffering & loss of amenities in life Towards medical expenses Towards conveyance Towards Boarding and Lodging charges Towards Food, nourishment and attendant charges Towards loss of future earning capacity due to permanent disability Towards loss of earning during laid off period Towards Attendant expenses for present and future Total compensation amount
6.
`3,00,000/`775/`10,000/`10,000/`20,000/`9,99,936/`2,48,000/`1,00,000/`16,88,711/-
Challenging the said quantum, the KSRTC is
before this Court and not satisfied with the quantum of compensation, the claimant is before this Court in the Cross-Objection. 7.
Heard the arguments of both sides.
8.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
Sri S Rajashekar would submit that the cross-examination of the claimant establishes that she continued her job in
-6HC-KAR
the hospital and getting the same salary as she was earning before the accident. Thus, there is no functional disability to the claimant. The tribunal has added 40% future prospects to the income of the claimant, which is not required in the case of present nature as the claimant continued
her
job.
Furthermore,
the
compensation
awarded by the Tribunal on all other heads is excessive. 9.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
claimant
Sri Jagadish Baliga would submit that as per the evidence of the doctor, there is 45% disability to two limbs i.e. to both legs and the claimant is not in a position to work as she was working earlier and the disability would become more by the lapse of time. Hence, the disability of the claimant shall be taken at 45% and not 15%. The job of the claimant was not permanent. She got appointment only on contract basis. Hence, prayed for enhancement of the compensation.
-7HC-KAR
10.
Having heard arguments of both sides, verifying
the appeal papers and the trial Court records, the point that arises for consideration is: "Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal requires modification?"
11.
Finding of this Court is in Affirmative for the
following:
REASONS 12.
The facts established before the trial Court are
that the claimant was the inmate of KSRTC bus bearing Reg.No.KA-19/F-3242 on the date of road traffic accident and because of the accident, she sustained Bilateral fracture of Talus of both legs and Medial Malleolus fracture of feet procedure. She was admitted to the hospital on 25.02.2022 and discharged on 02.03.2022. The claimant was working as Staff Nurse in KIMS Hospital, Madikeri, wherein she has taken treatment as inpatient. Her appointment order as per Ex.P.9 establishes that her job
-8HC-KAR
was on contract basis and was getting salary of `25,000/-, which includes `200/- professional tax. The disability Certificate is also issued by the same hospital as per Ex.P.11. The evidence of PW.1 establishes that she was inpatient in the hospital only for 6 days. She admitted in her cross-examination that even now she continued her job in the same hospital and getting the same salary. She has deposed that she took rest for 10 months, but document is not produced in that regard.
13.
PW.2 in his evidence has stated that before the
accident, the claimant was working in their hospital but now she is not coming to the hospital. However, in the cross-examination he admitted that he is not having any document to show that she is not attending the hospital and he is not having any information on that point. According to him, the injury is Grade-4-injury type 4 Haw kins-Talus fracture and it is grievous in nature and
-9HC-KAR
because of that the blood circulation at Talus bone would stop and that would increase the disability in future.
14.
Considering the evidence of PWs.1 and 2, the
Tribunal held that the claimant continued her job. Even then, the Tribunal has taken the income of the claimant at `24,800/- per month and added 40% future prospects to it and assessed the disability at 15%.
15.
As per the evidence of PW.1, she is working
directly under the Medical Dean and her appointment is based on contract basis. Ex.P.9 also speaks the same. Under these circumstances, the job of the claimant is not permanent. The doctor has not deposed that she requires rest for 10 months. But it is only the claimant has deposed that she has taken rest for 10 months. But she has not produced any document to prove that she has taken rest for 10 months and started going to the job only 10 months after the accident. Hence, the compensation awarded
- 10 HC-KAR
under the head 'loss of earning during laid-up period' at 10 months of salary is exorbitant.
16.
The
Tribunal
has
awarded
compensation
towards 'attendant charges' at `1,00,000/-. However, the claimant is attending her job and she does not require any attendant. Hence, 'attendant charges' at `1,00,000/- for present and future is exorbitant. The Tribunal has further awarded compensation towards conveyance at `10,000/-. The compensation awarded under the head 'pain and sufferings' & 'loss of amenities in life' is also on higher side. Hence, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is to be modified completely.
17.
In the evidence, the doctor deposed that there
is Medial Malleolus fracture of both legs, Type-4 Haw kinsTalus fracture. The doctor has not produced the document to support that the fracture is of Type-4 Haw kins to the claimant. The X-ray or any other relevant document is not produced to substantiate the aforesaid contention. As per
- 11 HC-KAR
the evidence of the claimant she continued her job. There is no such diagnosis in the wound certificate and discharge summary.
18.
Thus, the disability assessed by the Tribunal at
15% is proper. However, adding future prospects at 40% is not correct. Hence, towards 'loss of future earning capacity due to disability', the claimant is entitled to `7,14,240 `7,14,240/ 14,240/- (`24,800/- x 12 x 16 x 15%).
19. 'pain
The claimant is entitled to `50,000/- towards
and
suffering';
towards
'loss
of
amenities',
`50,000/- and towards 'medical expenses' to `775/- as per
the
bills
produced
by
the
claimant.
Towards
'conveyance, food, nourishment and attendant charges', `20,000/- and towards 'loss of income during laid-up period' `99,200/- (`24,800/- x 4).
- 12 HC-KAR
20.
Thus,
the
claimant
is
entitled
for
total
compensation of `9,34,215/- instead of `16,88,711/awarded by the tribunal under the following heads: Sl. No.
Particulars Towards loss of future earning capacity due to disability. Towards pain and suffering. Towards loss of amenities. Towards medical expenses. Towards conveyance, food, nourishment and attendant charges. Towards loss of income during laid-up period Total compensation
21.
Amount `7,14,240/`50,000/`50,000/`775/`20,000/`99,200/`9,34,215/-
Hence, this Court passes the following: ORDER
a.
MFA No.6597 of 2024 filed under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is allowed in part;
b.
MFA.CROB No.20/2025 filed by the claimant is dismissed;
- 13 HC-KAR
c.
The claimant is entitled for compensation of `9,34,215/- instead of `16,88,711/- as awarded by the Tribunal;
d.
The Tribunal has awarded interest @ 9% which is exorbitant. Always bank rate of interest is to be awarded. Hence, claimant is entitled for interest @ 6% per annum from the date of petition till date of realization;
e.
No order as to costs;
f.
Draw modified award accordingly;
g.
The amount in deposit be transmitted to the Tribunal;
h.
Registry to transmit TCR to the Tribunal forthwith.
(GEETHA K.B.) JUDGE SPV CT:SM List No.: 1 Sl No.: 21