Divisional Manager United India v. Shivanna @ Shivamurthy

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
4 November 2026
Judge
Justice Ravi V Hosmani
Case number
MFA No. 10034 of 2013
Result
ALLOWED
Acts & sections
Section 166 Motor Vehicles Act
Subject
Motor accident

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

-1HC-KAR

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 4TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.10034 OF 2013(MV-I)

BETWEEN: DIVISIONAL MANAGER UNITED INDIA INSURNACE CO LTD # 34/3, M M K COM0PLEX AKKAMAHADEVI ROAD P J EXTENSION DAVANAGERE - 577 002. …APPELLANT (BY SRI A N KRISHNA SWAMY, ADVOCATE) AND: 1.

SHIVANNA @ SHIVAMURTHY S/O HANUMANTHAPPA NOW AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS OCC: COOLIE R/O CHIKKAPURA VILLAGE CHITRADURGA TALUK - 577 501.

2.

S NAGAPPA S/O SIDDAPPA AGE: MAJOR OWNER OF TRACTOR & TRAILER R/O SADARAHALLY LAXMISAGARA POST CHITRADURGA TALUK - 577 501.

3.

SHIVANANDA S/O VEERAPPA

Digitally signed by ANUSHA V Location: High Court of Karnataka

-2HC-KAR

NOW AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS DRIVER OF TRACTOR AND TRAILER R/O CHIKKAPURA VILLAGE CHITRADURGA TALUK - 577 501. …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI B M SIDDAPPA, ADVOCATE FOR R2; R1 AND R3 NOTICE SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED) THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 16.09.2013 PASSED IN MVC NO.363/2008 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSION

JUDGE

&

ADDITIONAL

MACT,

CHITRADURGA,

AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.1,67,500/- WITH INTEREST @6% P.A FROM THE DATE OF PETIION TILL THE REALIZATION. THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR DISMISSAL, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI ORAL JUDGMENT Challenging judgment and decree dated 16.09.2013 passed by Addl. District & Sessions Judge & Addl. MACT., Chitradurga (Tribunal), in M.V.C.no.363/2008, this appeal is filed.

-3HC-KAR

2.

Sri

A.N.Krishna

Swamy,

learned

counsel

for

appellant submitted that appeal was by insurer challenging finding of tribunal on liability. 3.

Brief facts leading to appeal as per claimant were

that at 8:30 p.m. on 10.12.2007 claimant along with other coolies, as per instructions of owner, went to unload areca nut in tractor-trailer no.KA.16/F-1264-65. On return journey, they stopped at Bharamasagar for meals. Thereafter when claimant was standing on backside of tractor-trailer, driver drove it in reverse direction without any signal or noticing claimant. Tractor-trailer dashed against claimant resulting in injuries. Despite treatment at CHC, Hospital, Bharamasagara and later at Basaveshwara Hospital, Chitradurga, he did not recover fully and sustained loss of earning capacity. Claiming compensation, he filed claim petition under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (MV Act) against driver, owner and insurer of tractortrailer. 4.

Despite service of notice, driver of tractor-trailer did

not appear and was placed ex parte. Owner and insurer opposed claim petition on all available grounds. Based on

-4HC-KAR

pleadings,

tribunal

framed following

issues and recorded

evidence: i.

Whether the petitioner proves that he sustained injuries in the alleged RTA on 10.12.2007 at 8.30 p.m. in Bharamasagara, Chitradurga Taluk, due to rash and negligent driving of tractor-trailer bearing no.KA-16/T-1264-65 by its driver?

ii.

Whether petitioner is entitled for compensation? If so, at what quantum and from whom?

iii.

To what order or award?

5.

Claimant along with Dr.Ambarish deposed as PWs.1

and 2 and got marked Exs.P1 to 17. In rebuttal, official of insurer was examined as RW.1 and got marked Exs.R1 to 3. On consideration, tribunal held accident had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of tractor by its driver. Claimant had sustained injuries and was entitled for compensation assessed at Rs.1,67,500/- with interest at 6% per annum and held owner as well as insurer liable to pay same. Dis-satisfied with finding on liability, appeal was filed. 6.

It was firstly submitted that tribunal had, on an

earlier occasion, passed award dismissing claim petition against

-5HC-KAR

insurer and holding owner liable to pay compensation of Rs.59,400/-. Said award was questioned by claimant in MFA no.3161/2011. By judgment dated 08.12.2012, same was allowed and matter remitted back to tribunal. Thereafter impugned order was passed holding owner and insurer liable to pay compensation. It was submitted that consistent version of claimant in claim petition and in deposition was that accident occurred when claimant was standing behind tractor and driver reversed tractor without signal or noticing claimant same militated against contents of Ex.P4 wound certificate, Ex.P15 Discharge summary and Ex.R3 MLC Register Extract, which indicated that injuries were sustained due to fall from tractor. 7.

It was submitted that though on an earlier occasion

taking note of claimant's version that he was working as coolie and accident occurred while in course of employment had held liability of insurer would be under Workmen's Compensation Act (WC

Act),

under

impugned

award,

tribunal

erroneously

observed that insurer would be liable, regardless of whether claimant sustained injuries while standing behind tractor or while travelling on tractor, which would not be justified.

-6HC-KAR

9.

Further, a tractor when attached with trailer would

be a goods vehicle and no other passenger than driver would be permitted to travel on tractor (tractor engine). In absence of any explanation about discrepancy in police investigation records and claimant's version vis-a-vis contents of wound certificate, discharge summary and MLC register extract, claimant would have to be held to have approached tribunal with unclean hands and claim petition was liable to be dismissed. On said ground sought for allowing appeal. 10.

Respondent

unrepresented.

Sri

BM

no.1-claimant Siddappa,

learned

is

served, counsel

for

respondent no.2 - owner would oppose appeal. 11.

It was submitted that there was no dispute about

both tractor and trailer being covered under insurance policy issued by appellant herein and being current as on date of accident. There was also no dispute about driver of vehicle holding valid and effective driving licence. It was submitted that claimant had consistently stated that he was an employee and travelling as a loader/unloader. Since separate and additional premium was collected to cover risk of employee, tribunal

-7HC-KAR

rightly held insurer liable to pay compensation. There was admission by insurer that claimant was employee. Therefore, fastening of liability on insurer by tribunal was justified and sought for dismissal. 12.

Heard learned counsel, perused impugned award

and record. 13.

From

above

and

since

insurer

is

in

appeal

specifically on ground of inconsistency about manner of occurrence of accident and for avoidance of liability on ground of violation of terms and conditions of policy, point that would arise for consideration is: Whether tribunal was justified in holding claimant entitled for compensation from insurer? 14.

In order to establish actionable negligence against

driver, owner and insurer of offending vehicle, claimant relied on police investigation records. Ex.P1-FIR is registered on a complaint filed three days after date of accident. In complaint claimant stated that he had travelled on tractor-trailer as per instructions of owner to unload areca nut and in transit, vehicle

-8HC-KAR

had stopped for meals. Thereafter when claimant was standing behind tractor trailer, driver reversed vehicle without noticing claimant, trailer hit claimant and he sustained injuries. Ex.P2charge

sheet

would

reflect

same

version.

Ex.P3-spot

panchanama would also be on similar lines. In order to establish injuries and disability, claimant relied on discharge summary, disability certificate, evaluation reports, medical bills, x-rays and case sheet, etc. Ex.P4-wound certificate, Ex.P7discharge summary and Ex.P15- case sheet would however paint a different version. They would record in history of injuries as 'fall from tractor'. There is no mention in any of them that claimant sustained injuries due to fall from trailer or for that matter fall from tractor trailer. There does not appear to be any confusion or usage of word 'tractor' in wider meaning to cover both tractor and trailer. Neither in his claim petition nor in his examination in chief, claimant has offered any explanation that usage was in wider sense. In case claimant sustained injuries due to fall from tractor trailer, as rightly submitted by owner of tractor trailer, insurer may have found it difficult to avoid liability. If claimant had sustained injuries due

-9HC-KAR

to fall from tractor i.e. tractor engine, since no other person than driver would be entitled to travel on tractor, same would be violation of terms and conditions of insurance coverage and though insurer would be liable to pay compensation to claimant in first instance, it would be entitled to recover it from owner. But instant case reveals two very different versions, one about claimant sustaining injuries while standing behind vehicle and vehicle reversing and hitting him where he would be a pedestrian and other would be as inmate. 15.

As

noted

above,

discrepancy

has

not

been

explained. Therefore, when difference in version about manner of occurrence would make a large difference on aspect of liability, absence of explanation would invite adverse inference. In view of above, point for consideration would have to be answered in negative. 16.

Consequently, following: ORDER i.

Appeal is allowed.

ii.

Judgment and award dated 16.09.2013 passed

by

Additional District

and

- 10 HC-KAR

Sessions Judge and AMACT, Chitradurga in MVC no.363/2008 is set aside. iii.

Claim petition is dismissed.

iv.

Amount in deposit is ordered to be released

in

favour

of

appellant

electronically.

Sd/(RAVI V HOSMANI) JUDGE

HNM,YKL List No.: 1 Sl No.: 4

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.