Dr. K. Venkat Reddy v. The English and Foreign Languages University
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 29 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice E.V. Venugopal
- Case number
- WP No. 8401 of 2024
- Result
- DISPOSED OF NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Article 226 Constitution
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
[ 32ee ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) THURSDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE E.V. VENUGOPAL
WRIT PETITION NO: 8401 OF 2024 Between:
Dr. K. Venkat Reddy, S/o Late K. Papi Reddy Aged about 54 years, Occ professor, R/o 301 , Surya krishna Residency, Street No. 03, Kakatiya Nagar, Habsiguda, Hyderabad, Telangana ...PETITIONER AND
1. The English and Foreign languages University, Represented by its Vice Chancellor Osmania University Mina Road, Ravindra Nagar, Near Tarnaka Hyderabad. Telangana-500007 2. The English and Foreign Language University, Represented by its Registrar Osmania University Main Road, Ravindra Nagar, Near Tarnaka, Hyderabad Telangana -500007 ...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue any order, direction or Writ more particularly in the nature of Writ of 'Certiorari', to call for the records relating to and in connection with the lmpugned
Order No. EFLU/Admn/F.1772120211552d1.19.02.2021 and rejection orders in EFLU/Admn/F.1772120231771 dl.0711112023, issued by the 2nd Respondent and set
aside the same, by declaring them as illegal, unjust, arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia and consequently, direct the
Respondents to retransfer the Petitioner from Regional campus, EFL University, Shillong to EFL University, Hyderabad, with all service and monetary benefits and to
t-
pass such other order o, orders as this Hon',ble court may deem fit
and proper in the
circumstances of the cal;e Prayer is amende,d as per C.O dl2810412026inlA0212026 t.A. NO: 't OF 2024
PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedinthe be pleased to suspend affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may orderdatedlglozt2ol'.lvideNo.EFLU/Admn/F.No.1772120211552passedby Respondent No. 2 pending this Writ Petition' r.A. NO :2OF 2024
PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedinthe affidavitfiledinsupportofthepetition,theHighCourtmaybepleasedtodirectthe 0510212024 Respondents to recon:;ider the representation dt. 08/09/2023 and dl. pending this Writ Petitic n.
t.A NO: 3 OF 2024 Petition under seclion 1 51 CPC praying thal in the circumstances stated
in the
affidavitfiledinsuppor':ofthepetition,theHighCourtmaybepleasedtodirectthe RespondentstocontinttetopaythesalaryfromlglO2l2o2laspertheexistingscales pending this Writ Petitirtn.
Counsel for the Petiti,rner: SRl. POODATTU AMARENDER
counselfortheResp.rndents:SRIP'B.VIJAYKUMARREPRESENTING SRI.AVSLAXMI The Court made the f,rllowing: ORDER
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE E.V.VENUGOPAL No, WRIT ETITI (cNR NO. H8HC010163432O24)
Dated tL1.LO.2O26 Reserved on : 10.09.2025.
Pronounced on : -:'1.10.2025. Uploaded on : 30 .tO-2O26,
Between : Dr.K.Venkat ReddY.
... Petitioner. And
The English and Foreign Languages University and another.
... Respondents.
ORDER
The present writ petition is filed seeking the following relief :
"... to call for the records relating to and In connection with the
r:i"ttlo,l: impugneJ Order No.EFLU/AdmnlF't7721202U552, dt'79'02'.2021,and the l'" by issued dt' 07lLLl20Z3, ord.f, in EFLU/Admn/F.1772120231771 jside unjust' illegal' as the same, by declaring them and set .iir'ti..V, Oitiririnatory and violative of Article 14 and 27 of the Constitution of inOii u'n'O consequentiy, direct the respondents to retransfer the petitioner Hyderabad' iro, n.gLn.f Campus, efL University. Shillong to EFL. University' orders with all iervice and monetary benefits and to pass such other order or ai ifris non'Ute Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case...".
i.tp*0".t
2.
Heard Sri Poodattu Amarender, learned counsel for the
and Sri PB Vijay Kumar, learned senior counsel, representing learned counsel for the respondents.
petitioner
MTs AVS Laxmi'
wp 8401 2024
3.
Tho case of the petitioner, as narrated in the writ aFfidavit, in
brief, is that the petitioner was appointed as a Reader in the Centre for Training and [)evelopment, CIEFL, Hyderabad, pursuant to a specific recruitment pro:ess vide Advertisement No.28/2003 and against a post attached to thr: Hyderabad Campus, on 05.07.2006, i.e., prior to the commencement of the English and Foreign Languages University Act, 2006.
The post was linked to the specialized Depaftment/Centre in which the petitioner was sr:lected and which was located only at Hyderabad. The main grievance of the petitioner is that despite being protected under Section 4(v) of
the EFL Universty Act,2006 by virtue of his pre-existing service conditions
under the CII:FL By-laws, the respondent University purported to transfer/relocate him from Hyderabad to Shillong Campus by order No.EFLU/AdmnlF:.No.77721L552, dated L9.02.202L, invoking Regulation 17(k),
which was incorl)orated in 2016-17, i.e. subsequent to the appointment of the
petitioner. The petitioner's specific case is that the CIEFL By-laws did not confer power upon the Vice-Chancellor to effect an inter-campus transfer and
that the subseq rent statutory/regulatory provisions could not be invoked to alter the service :onditions protected under Section 4(v) of the Act.
(a) Tho contention of the petitioner is that the impugned transfer was not a mer.e routine transfer but, in substance, a permanent relocation of
the petitioner along with his post from Hyderabad to Shillong and to a
EW,J Wp a4OL2O24
Departmenthavingadifferentareaofspecialization,notwithstandingthathe was selected for his specific expertise in Training and Development' The
university has not demonstrated any legally sustainable administrative necesslty warranti ng such relocation/transfer'
(b)Thepetitionerfurthersubmitsthatthetransferwaseffected without prior notice, consultatlon or opportunity and without consideration
of
the peculiar circumstances of his case, including his long and unblemished service,specialisedacademicresponsibilities,ongoingsupervisionofresearch scholars and the serious medical difficulties placed before
the University' The
petitionerhadalsomaderepresentationsseekingreconsideration,whichwere not taken into consideration by the respondents'
(c) Accordingly, the petitioner filed W'P'No'4773 of 2021 before this Court, ventilating his grievance against his transfer from Hyderabad
Campus to
ShillongCampusalongwithhispostcontendingthatthesaidtransferwould result in his permanent relocation to the Department of Education'
where he
hasnorequisiteexpertiseorspecialization'However,thisCourt'videitsorder
dated04.0s.2023disposedofthesaidwritpetitionholdingthatthoughthe petitioner was initially appointed as a Reader in 2006, he was subsequently promoted as Professor with effect from 10'07'2017 under the
new Regulations
and therefore, could not rely upon the erstwhile Regulations
to contend that
Regulation 17(k) was inapplicable to him' The Court
accordingly held that
Wp 8401-2024
Regulation 17(k) empowered the Vice-Chancellor to transfer the petitioner from
one place to a tother. However, having regard to the petitioner's health condition and hi:; status as a single parent, the Court directed the University to
reconsider his request for transfer From Shillong to Hyderabad on medical
grounds. Pursuant to the order of the learned Single Judge in W.P'N0.4773 oF 2021, the petitioner submitted a representation dated 08.09.2023 seeking his
transfer back to Hyderabad. Pursuant to the above orders the Executive Council considered and examined the representation dated 08.09.2023 of the
petitioner seekirg transfer from the Regional Campus, EFL University, Shillong
to
EFL ljniversity, Hyderabad and vide Memorandum
No.EFLU/Admn ll=.177212023177L, dated 07.11.2023 rejected
the said
representation folding that the request for transfer could not be acceded to and was not feirsible on administrative grounds. The petitioner submits that
the impugned r()jection fails to adequately consider the statutory protections available to hint, as well as his medical and family circumstancet, which warrant reconsic eration of the matter.
(d) Th,-, petitioner subsequently filed WA No.1136 of 2023 challenging the orders of the learned Single Judge in WP No.4773 of 202L, which was subsequently wthdrawn. The Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court, while disposing of the said writ appeal, observed that the petitioner would challenge
the rejection onJer dated 07.17.2023 and that the petitioner is at liberty to
wp 84Ol-2O24
t
challenge the competency of the University in transferring him before the appropriate forum.
(e) The petitioner further submits that the impugned action is without jurisdiction, contrary to the statutory saving provision, contrary to the governing CIEFL By-laws, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the
constitution and was made without application of mind. The respondents under the guise of administrative exigency cannot exercise a power which they
do not possess or defeat the statutory protection attached to the petitioner's pre-existing service conditions.
(0
Accordingly, the petitioner seeks to
set aside the
transfer/relocation order dated 19.02.2021 and the consequential rejection
memorandum dated 07.1L.2023 and a consequential direction to restore/retransfer him to the EFL University, Hyderabad Campus, together with consequential service benefi ts,
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the controversy in
the present writ petition is not merely with regard to the transfer of the petitioner on administrative grounds, but essentially concerns the competence
and authority of the respondent University to effect an inter-campus transfer from Hyderabad to shillong. It is submitted that the petitioner was appointed under the erstwhile GIEFL in the year 2006, prior to the commencement of the English and Foreign Languages University Act, 2006 and his pre-existing service
wp-8a0l-202'1
conditions are p-otected under section 4(v) of the said Act. Learned counsel
would submit thet the GIEFL By-laws governing the petitioner did not confer any power upon the competent authority to transfer him from one campus to another and th(:refore, such power could not subsequently be assumed by invoking Regulation 17(k) of the University. According to him, the statutory protection under Section 4(v) cannot be defeated by resorting to a subsequent
regulation. It is further submitted that the impugned action is not a routine transfer, but am{)unts to a permanent relocation of the petitioner along with his post from Hyderabad to Shillong and to a Depaftment having a different area of specialisation.
(a) Le;rrned counsel submits that the respondents have not demonstrated arty legally sustainable administrative exigency warranting such relocation and trat the expression "administrative exigenry" cannot confer a power which is otherwise not vested in the authority. Learned counsel further
submits that the consequential rejection of the petitioner's representation is vitiated by non-application of mind, particularly when the specific issue relating
to the competertce of the University to efFect the inter-campus transfer was raised before the respondents. It is also submitted that the Hon'ble Division Bench, while permitting withdrawal of the earlier writ appeal, had left it open to
the petitioner to question the competency of the University to transfer him
from Hyderaba<l to Shillong. An administrative or statutory authority js
Wp A4Ol -2024
required to reconsider a matter pursuant to a judicial direction and it must
applyitsmindtotherelevantfactsandCircumstancesandtakeareasoned decision. A mere rejection on the premise of "administrative grounds", without disclosing the specific reasons or circumstances warranting such rejection, would not demonstrate proper application of mind, particularly where the court
hasspecificallydirectedreconsiderationoftherequest.Itis,therefore, submitted that the general proposition that transfer is common and inevitable
intheservicehasnoapplicationwheretheverySourceandextentofthe power to transfer are under challenge. Learned counsel accordingly submits
thattheimpugnedaction,beingWithoutauthorityoflawandcontrarytothe statutory protection available to the petitioner, is liable to be intefered
with in
exercise of the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the constitution of India.
(b)Thelearnedcounselforthepetitionerrelieduponthedecisionof
the Hon'ble Apex Couft rendered in Prof'V'S'S'Sastry Vs' Ministry of Human Resource Developmen! Government of India, New Delhi and
othersl.
5.
Per contra, learned Senlor Counsel appearing for the respondents
submits that the impugned transfer is an administrative decision taken exigencies of service and in exercise of the power vested in the
in the
Vice-chancellor
under Regulation 17(k) of the University Regulations' It is contended
' 2008 scc online AP 128
that
Wp-840I-2024
transfer is an incidence of service and that an employee has no vested right to
insist upon cont nuation at a particular place of posting, unless such right is conferred by a statutory provision or the applicable service conditions. The
mere tact that the petitioner was initially appointed against a post at Hyderabad does not confer upon him an indefeasible or continuous right to remain posted al Hyderabad without any transfer.
(a) Lezrrned Senior Counsel further submits that the petitioner, having subsequently been promoted as Professor under the University Regulations, cannot selectively rely upon the erstwhile CIEFL By-laws so as to
claim immunity 'rom the service regime governing the employees of the EFL
University. The transfer from Hyderabad to Shillong is only an inter-campus transfer within l:he same University and does not result in any change of employer, post, pay, seniority, tenure or other substantive service benefits of
the petitioner. The order merely alters the place of posting and does not affect any accrued or s rbstantive service right of the petitioner.
(b) It ir; further submitted that the protection afforded under Section 4(v) of the EFL University Act, 2006 to the existing service conditions of the employees is sut)ject to the provisions of the said Act. Such saving provision
cannot be construed as creating an absolute bar against transfer or as overriding the statutory and regulatory powers vested in the Vice-Chancellor.
Se(ion 4(v) anc Regulation 17(k) are required to be read harmoniously, so.
EW,J Wp 8401-2024
that the petitioner's accrued service beneflts remain protected, while the administrative power to determine the place of posting, in accordance with the exigencies of service, continues to operate.
(c) It is also submitted that the transfer was necessitated by administrative requirements at the Shillong campus, where the petitioner's experience and expertise were considered relevant to the academic and administrative needs of the university. Appropriate arrangements were made
in respect of his responsibilities at Hyderabad. However, despite the transfer order, the petitioner did not report at shillong and remained absent without authorisation, which lead to initiation of disciplinary proceedings. It is further
submitted that the personal and medical circumstances relied upon by the petitioner were duly considered, but the material available in the service and leave records did not substantiate the extent of the difficulties pleaded by him. His request for re-transfer to Hyderabad was also considered by the competent
authority/Executive council and was declined on administrative grounds.
(d)Learnedseniorcounselfurthersubmittedthatthepetitionerhas
no vested right to remain posted at Hyderabad, as neither his original appointment nor the applicable service conditions stipulated any permanent place of posting. Regulation 17(k) expressly empowers the vice-chancellor to
transfer an employee from one place to another and the Coordinate Bench has already upheld the university's competence to transfer the petitioner, observing
Wp_A401 2024
: l0
that his subseqrtent promotion as Professor was governed by the EFLU Rules and Regulations The transfer from Hyderabad to Shillong was therefore within
the University's administrative authority and cannot be interfered with in the absence of an\/ statutory or contractual prohibition or any demonstrated arbitrariness.
(e) Lelrned senior counsel further submits that there is neither any allegation nor any material on record to establish mala fides, incompetence on
the part of the competent authority, violation of any statutory provision, or alteration of the petitioner's substantive service conditions. The decision regarding the suitable place of posting falls essentially within the administrative
domain of th€ University and absence of any demonstrated illegality, arbitrariness, ma/a fides or violation of statutory or constitutional rights, does not warrant interFerence by this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India. The petitioner cannot seek judicial interference me'ely on the basis of personal preference or dissatisfaction with
the place of posting. It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned transfer order and the rubsequent decision of the University are neither illegal nor arbitrary and thirt the writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
(D
Lelrned senior counsel, appeared for the respondents, relied
upon the followirg decisions :
w p-84O1-2024
:11 :
(ii)
South India Corporation (P) Ltd.,-Vs. Secretary, Board of Revenue Trivandrum and another'. Chandavarkar Sita Ratna Rao Vs. Ashalata S. Guram3.
(iii) (iv)
Union of India and others Vs. S.L.Abbasa. State of U.P. and others Vs.Gobardhan Lals.
(i)
(v)
Gujarat Electricity Board and another Vs' Atmaram Sungomal Poshani6.
(vi) (viii) (ix) (x) (xi) (xii)
Shilpi Bose (Mrs.) and others Vs. State of Bihar and otherc7. State Bank of India Vs. Anjan Sanyal and otherss. Public Services Tribunal Bar Association Vs. State of U'P' and anothere. Jawahartal Nehru Universaty Vs. Dr.K.S.lawatkar and otherc10. Roshan Lal Tandon Vs. Union ofIndiall. State ofJ&K Vs. Triloki Nath Khosa and othersl2.
Union of India and another Vs. D'P.Singh and otherc with Union of India and another Vs. Amit nai and othercr3' (xiv) State of Himachal Pradesh and others Vs. Rai Kumar and
(xiii)
others with Anurag Sharma and others Vs. State of Himachat Pradesh and othersto.
This Court heard the rival submissions advanced on either side
and perused the material placed on record. The controversy falls for consideration primarily with reference to the competence and source of
'?
1963 scc online sc 19
t (tgAO) a Supreme Court Cases 447 n
1199314 Supreme Court Cases 357 'u lzoo+; t t scc +oz (t989) z scc ooz 1991 supp.(2) scc 656
'(2ool) 5 scc 5oE lzoo:; + scc to+ 'o (1989) I scc 679 " AIR 1967 sc lE89 '' (1974) I scc t9
e
'3 LPA Nos.726&
'1 CA Nos.9746 & 9741
of2}ll
power
wp_8401_2024
i12 l
of the respondont-University to effect the petitioner's inter-campus transfer, rather than merely on the general proposition that transfer is an incidence of servrce.
While it is well settled proposition that an employee ordinarily has no
vested right to continue at a particular place of posting and that a transfer made by the cornpetent authority in administrative exigencies cannot ordinarily
be interFered wi:h in judicial review, such power must necessarily be traceable
to a valid statulory or service provision and exercised in conformity with the conditions governing the employee's service.
(a) In the present case, the petitioner was appointed under the erstwhile CIEFL prior to the commencement of the EFL University Act, 2006
and therefore the protection, if any, extended to his pre-existing service conditions under Section 4(v) of the Act assumes significance. Therefore, the issue to be detr:rmined is whether Regulation 17(k), read in the context of Section 4(v) anc the petitioner's pre-existing service conditions, conferred any
power on the ccmpetent authority to effect the transfer of the petitioner from Hyderabad Camgrus to Shillong Campus. Administrative exigency, past practice
or cbnvenience may furnish the platform for a transfer, but cannot, by themselves, creete a power which is otherwise not vested in the authority. At
the same time, the petitioner cannot claim an absolute immunity from transfer merely by reasorr of his initial appointment at Hyderabad. The legality of the impugned actior must, therefore, be examined by determining whether the
EW,J Wp-8401 2024
: 13:
power oF transfer existed, whether it validly operated upon the petitioner's service conditions and whether its exercise was consistent with the governing
statutory and regulatory framework. Subject to the existence of such power,
the assessment of administrative requirements and academic deployment would ordinarily fall within the domain of the University, unless the exercise of power is shown to be arbitrary, without authority, contrary to the governing framework, or vitiated by non-application of mind.
(b) At this juncture it is relevant to extract Regulation 17(k) and Section 4(v) of the EFL University Act, 2006 hereunder :
"section 4 of the EFLU Act, 2006 : Dissolution of the Central Institute of English and Foreign Languages, Hyderabad Society and transfer of all the On and Establishment of the University properties and effect commencement of this Act :
of
(i)
:
The society known as Central Institute of English and Foreign
Languages, Hyderabad Society, shall be dissolved, and all properties, movable or immovable, and all rights, powers and privileges of the said Society shall be transferred to and vest in the University and shall be applied to the objects and purposes for which the University is established;
(ii) All debts, liabilities and obligations of the said Society shall be transferred to the University and shall thereafter be discharged and satisfied by iu
(iii) All references in any enactment to the said Society shall be constituted as references to the University;
(iv) Any will, deed or other document, whether made or executed
before or after the commencement of this Act, which contains any bequest, gift or trust in favour of the Said Society shall be construed as if the University was therein named instead of the Society;
Wp 8401 2024
(v) Surject to the provisions of this Act, every person employed immediately bef:re the commencement of this Act in the Central Institute of English and Forerign Languages, Hyderabad, shall hold such employment in the University by thr: same tenure and on the same terms and conditions and with the same rights and privileges as to pension and gratuity as he would have held under the (lentral Institute of English and Foreign Languages, Hyderabad, if this Act had n(,t been passed. Regulation 17 of EFLU Act, 2006: Powers of the Vice-Chancellor:
I.
Adrninistrative.
a) To supervise the conduct and work of the staFf oF the University an(l for that purpose to exercise such disciplinary control as may be necessary.
b) To sanction all kinds of leave to members of the staff, research fell)ws etc.
c) To arrange at his/her discretion outside visits for the members to edtrcational centres in India for educational purposes.
d) To act as controlling officer in respect of journeys performed by the members of the staff and act as his/her own controlling offi:er in respect of journeys performed by him in connection with the affairs of the University,
e) To permit at his/her discretion in special cases and for reasons to be recorded in writing officers and members of staff to draw actlral expenses Incurred by them while on tour.
f) To ,:llow mileage allowance by a route other than the shortest. g) To rlecide the shoftest of two or more routes. h) To rnake temporary and ad-hoc appointment of teachers.
i) To r:reate temporary posts on sanctioned scales of pay in Group C and D and to fill such posts for period not exceeding six months in each case.
j) To yrermit retention of lien on a post under the University. k) To transfer an employee from one place to another.
l) To s;anction grant and to permit acceptance of honorarium. m) To lvithhold increments.
Wp_A4O |
:15:
Evv,J -2024
n) To allow an employee to count extraordinary leave for increments up to 2 years. o) To grant subsistence allowance to an employee. p) To order destruction of records, as per weeding rules.
c) Order sale, by auction or othenarise in the interest university of unserviceable stores or perishable articles. II.
of the
Financial : a) To arrange to prepare budget estimates. b) To re-appropriate funds from one head of appropriation to another.
c) Subject to availability of budget provision, the estimates as approved by the Executive Council' i.
To disburse salaries and allowances and stipends to the
ii.
To incur expenditure of a contingent or miscellaneous nature on:
employees of the Universlty, Research Fellows and other persons engaged in the programme of the University'
1.
Electricity, Water and Gas Charges.
2. Freight Charges. 3. Demurrage/Wharfage charges.
4. Hire oF the office furniture, fans, heaters, cookers, clocks, etc' 5. Maintenance and upkeep of Vehicles.
6. Rent, Rates and Taxes. 7. Postage, TelePhone and Telegrams. B.
Contingent paid staff.
9. Supply of liveries, badges and payment of washing allowances' 10.
Repairs to, erection of and removals of machinery (where expenditure is of a capital nature).
11.
Incurring legal exPenses.
12.
Petty works and special repairs to buildings, etc.
13.
Ordinary repairs and maintenance of buildings etc'
Evv,J Wp_8401_2024
: 16 :
L4.
Lo:al purchase of stationery, printing etc.
15.
Filtures and furniture.
16.
Bolks and periodicals.
77.
To purchase working stores, offlce equipment, computers calculating machines etc.
18.
To sanction the installation of office and residential telephones.
19.
Bicycles.
20.
To sanction fixed recurring charges of a contingent character.
2L.
Pu 'chase of Motor Vehicles.
22.
Exllenditure not included in any of the above categories.
iii.
To sanction permanent advances.
d) To open bank accounts in the name of the University in such barrks as are approved by the Executive Council, and to operate the account i.e., to say
i) ii)
Pay in all money received by the University and for that purpose endorse all cheques, drafts, bills etc. To draw cheques in the name of the University.
e) To sanction increments, TA, and other advances etc., to em ployees oF the University according to rules.
f) To sanction advance of pay and TA to any officer under transfer. g) To sanction advance for the purchase of conveyance. h) To vary the terms of repayment of advance.
i) To pay salaries on the last working day of the month if the first day of the following month is a holiday or as per the practice of the University.
j) Povrer in regard to writing off the irrecoverable value of Stores, casr and Stamps etc. Provided trat (1) the loss is not due to theft or fraud and (2) it does not disclose a defect of system or serious negligence on the part of some individual employees of the university which might possibry cail for disciprinary action.
Wp 8,101 2024
il7 i
III.
Disciplinary :
To impose all penalties on teachers and non-teaching employees laid down in the terms and conditions of service."
(c) The Office Order No.CIEFL/Admn./F127212006160, dated 05.07.2006, indicates that pursuant to the recommendation of the Selection Committee made at its meeting held on 16.06.2006 and approved by the Board
at its 114th meeting held on 05.07.2006, the petitioner, Dr.K.Venkat Reddy, was appointed as a Reader in the Centre for Training and Development at the
Institute, in the pay scale of Rs.12,000/- - Rs.18,300/-, with an initial pay of Rs.12,000/- per month. The order stipulated that he would be on probation for
one year from the date of joining and that his service would be governed by
the rules of the Institute.
(d) By proceedings No.EFLU/1307i20151365, dated 24.07.2015, the petitioner was promoted from Associate Professor to Professor pursuant to the recommendations of the Selection Commiftee, as approved by the Executive
Council at its 20th meeting held on the same date. The promotion order stipulated that his service would be governed by the University's rules and
regulations applicable to teaching employees and the relevant UGC/Government of India regulations and orders concerning the Career Advancement Scheme.
(e) In W.P.No.4773 of 2021, filed by the petitioner challenging his transfer from Hyderabad to Shillong, a Coordinate Bench of this Couft, by order
EVV.J
Wp-8401 2024
18:
dated 04.08.20i13, held that the University had the power to transfer the petitioner and tlrat the decision had been taken by the Executive Council on administrative grounds. However, having regard to his medical condition and
his responsibilities as a single parent, the Court directed the University to reconsider his request for retransfer to Hyderabad.
(f)
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner submitted a representation dated
08.09.2023, citirg his history of two surgeries for cervical disc prolapse, partial impairment of his left hand, diabetes and hypetension. The Executive Council,
by proceedings \o.EFLU/Admn . lF.l772l2123177 7, dated 07.I1.2023, rejected
the request on administrative grounds. The proceedings, however, did not specify the partir:ular administrative considerations that guided such a decision.
(g) Thr:reupon, the petitioner filed W.A.No.1L36 of 2023 however, subsequently, hr: sought permission to withdraw the appeal. By order dated
12.12.2023, the Division Bench of this Court dismissed the appeal as withdrawn, granting liberty to the petitioner to challqnge the rejection order and the University's competence to transfer him from Hyderabad to Shillong.
(h) Thrr petitioner thereafter submitted a representation dated 05.02.2024 to th3 Vice-Chancellor, seeking recall of hls transfer. He contended
that his origina appointment as Reader in the Centre for Training and Development a: the erstwhile CIEFL, Hyderabad, was pursuant to Adveftisement Nrl.28 of 2003 and that the post was carnpus-specific and non-
"i
Wp A4Ol 2024
: 19:
transferable. Relying on Section 4(v) of the English and Foreign Languages University Act, 2006, the relevant CIEFL By-laws and the judgment dated 12.03.2008 in W.P.No.10846 of 2007, he claimed protection of his pre-existing service conditions. He also referred to the liberty granted in W.A.No.1136 of 2023 and alleged that the transfer was motivated by personal animosity.
(i)
By proceedings dated 04.03.2024, the University rejected the said
representation, stating that the legality of the transfer and the alleged nontransferable nature of the post had already been considered in W.P.No.4773 of
2OZl. It further stated that transfer was an incidence of service, the original appointment order did not restrict the petitioner's posting to Hyderabad and
that his subsequent promotion as Professor was governed by the University's applicable regulations. The University also denied that personal malice had motivated the transfer and stated that the petitioner was at liberty to seek appropriate judicial redressal.
0)
The judgment dated 12.03.2008 in W.P.No.10846 of 2007, relied
upon by the petitioner, concerns the protection afforded under Section 4(v) of
the English and Foreign Languages University Act, 2006, to the tenure and terms and conditions of service of employees of the erstwhile CIEFL, subject to
the provisions of the Act. However, that judgment, having arisen in the context of the transitional provisions governing the tenure of the ViceChancellor, does not, by itself, establish that the petitioner's post was nor_'l-
wp-E401-2024
transferable. The petitioner's claim must therefore be examined with reference
to his original irppointment order, the recruitment notification, the relevant CIEFL By-laws, applicable service rules and the rejection of the petitioner's claim by the Uni'/ersity.
(k) It is not in dispute that the petitioner was appointed as a Reader in the Centre for Training and Development of the erstwhile CIEFL, Hyderabad, by order dated (15.07.2006 and that the order stipulated that his service would be governed by :he rules of the Institute. Section 4(v) of the Act preserves the
tenure and terrrs and conditions of service of employees of the erstwhile institution, subj()ct to the provisions of the Act. Regulation 17(k), which empowers the \/ice-Chancellor to transfer employees, must likewise be read subject to the governing statute and any binding conditions of service. Though
transfer is ordin;lrily an incidence of service and an employee has no absolute right to remain ert a pafticular place of posting, this principle does not dispense
with the requirement that the transfer must be authorized by law and consistent with irpplicable statutory protections, while also taking into account
any compelling :ircumstances warranting protection of the employee against such transfer.
(l)
Tho University's administrative requirements may justify a
transfer where :he power to effect such transfer lawfully exists. However, administrative e>:igency cannot independently confer a power that is othenrui+se
Wp 8401-2024
i2li
unavailable or override an applicable statutory restriction. The earlier
order
dated 04.08.2023 in w.P.No.4773 of 2021 and the subsequent order dated 12.12.2073 in w.A.No.1136 of 2023 must also be kept in view. The
present
challenge must be examined within the scope of the liberty granted by the Division Bench, without reopening any issue that has attained finality under the earller judicial order.
(m) As regards the rejection of the petitioner's representation dated 08.09.2023, the Executive council rejected his request for retransfer by proceedings dated 07.11.2023 stating that the request was not feasible on
administrative grounds. while the assessment of administrative requirements ordinarily falls within the university's domain, the authority was required to undeftake a genuine reconsideration of the petitioner's request in the light of
the earlier judicial direction, which specifically referred to his medical condition and family circumstances.
(n) The absence of specific administrative reasons in the rejection proceedings raises a question as to whether the petitioner's representation was
meaningfully reconsidered. His medical condition and responsibilities as a single parent were relevant factors, though they did not confer an automatic
right to retransfer. However, the' reasoning underlying the rejection of the petitioners' request on medical grounds does not appear to be reasonable' Nor can the rejeetion be justified merely on the grounds that the petitioner had not
, 71 .
Wp 8401_2024
availed of medical leave or had submitted claims for relatively small amounts,
particularly wherr prolonged sickness was not pleaded. The decision ought to
have been bas:d on relevant material and a proper assessment of the circumstances placed before the competent authority. Further, the absence of
medical leave or the relatively low amounts claimed towards medical reimbursement c:ould not, by themselves, establish that the petitioner was not
suffering from chronic ailments. His medical condition was required to be assessed on the basis of the relevant medical records and other material.
(o) Tho adequacy of the reasons must, howqver, be assessed with reference to the complete record, including the materials considered by the Executive Council. The legality of the original transfer order dated L9.02.2021
and the validity r>f the subsequent rejection proceedings dated 07.11.2023 are separate issues. The former concerns the source and extent of the University,s power to transfe'the petitioner, while the latter concerns compliance with the earlier judicial di-ection and the fairness of the decision-making process. The
former must be tested against the governing statute and applicable service conditions, while the latter must satisfy the requirements of lawful, fair and reasoned adminisrtrative decision-making. In that view of the matter, when the
rejection of the p'etitioner's request is examined, it is apparent that authorities did not give mindful consideration to the grievance of tle
petitioner.
a,
Wp A4O1-2O24
(p) In the above Circumstances, since the competent authority's proceedings dated 07.11.2023 do not demonstrate meaningful reconsideration oF the petitioner's medical condition and family circumstances, or compliance
with the earlier judicial directions, the rejection order warrants reconsideration. Accordingly, the University authorities are directed to reconsider the petitioner's represenbation and pass a reasoned order after examining the relevant medical
records, family circumstances and administrative requirements stricfly in accordance with law within 90 working days from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order.
7.
With the above observations and directions, the present writ
petition is disposed of. No order as to the costs.
8.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, stands
closed.
SD/- MOHD. ISMAIL DEPUW REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// SE
To,
N OFFICER
'1. The Vice Chancellor Osmania University, English and Foreign languages University, Mina Road, Ravindra Nagar, Near Tarnaka nyOJraO-aO.
Telangana-500007 2. The Registrar osmania University, English and Foreign Language University, Main Road, Ravindra Nagar, Near Tarnaka, Hyderabad Telangana _500007 3. One CC to SRl. POODATTU AMARENDER, Advocate tOpUCl 4. One CC to SRl. A V S LAXM|, Advocate tOpUCl 5. Two CD Copies DAN
K
L
HIGH COUR'I'
DATED: 29111t12026
EI ATE OA
ORDER
ca
$?.
N$\
o
WP.No.8401 of 2024
DISPOSING CIF THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
? caP(elb\4,
-*(et"
i DES rL\
I
A
I