Express Newspapers PVT. LTD. & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.

Court
Supreme Court of India
Date of judgment
5 November 1985
Judge
Justice A.P. Sen
Neutral citation
1985 INSC 238
Reported in
[1985] SUPP. 3 S.C.R. 382
Result
Disposed off
Acts & sections
Article 239 Constitution, Article 14 Constitution, Article 19 Constitution, Article 32 Constitution
Subject
Property & land

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

EXPRESS NE.l/SPAPERS PVT, LTD. & ORS. Vo

UNION OF INDIA & ORS,

OCTOBER 7, 1985/NOVEMBER 5, 1985

[A.P. SEN, E.S. VE.NKATARAMI1111 MD R.B. MISRA, JJ.]

Articles 32 & 226 - Executive action challenged on grounds of violjitions of Art. 14, 19(l)(a) & (g) by writ petition Maintainability of - Issues pertaining to civil rights arising out of contracts between parties - Whether can be decided on mere affidavits. lleld: Filing of civil proceedings only remedy - Civil Procedure Code, s.9. Articles 19(1) (a) and (2) - Freedon, guaranteed under Whether comprehends freedom of press. - Violation of such freedom - How to be determined.

Articles 239(1), 53(1), 72,77, 240 & 298 - Lt. Governor of Delhi - Whether successor of the former Chief Commissioner of Delhi - Whether has power to deal with allotment/lease etc. of lands falling ··1ithin Union Territory of Delhi and which is under control and adm:f.nistration of I.and & Development Officer and vests in Govt. of India, ~dnistry of works & Rousing - Govt. of Part 'C' States Act 1951, sec. 21, Proviso, Authentication (Orders & Other Instruements) Rules 1958, Govt. of India (Allocation of Business) Rules 1961 & General Clauses Act 1897, s.18. Local Authorities -

Delhi Development Act, 1957 ss.53(3)(a), 12(4), 14,41 and 2{d) - Construction of a building - Permission obtained from competent authority under the Act - whether i t will prevail notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith in any other law. Delhi Municipal Corporation Ac~ 1957 ss .343, 344 and 481 read with Delhi Nunicipal Corporation (Buildings) Bye-laws 1959 Bye-laws 25(2) - (IV-B), 21(1), 22(V) and 2(33) - Show cause notice for taking action u/ss.343 & 344 - Validity of Permission already granted by competent authority under Delhi Development Act 1957 to raise the structure and acted upon Whether raising cf structure can be questioned under ss.343, 344 - Applicability of bye-laws - Hei~ht of builoing - Restriction of

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.r.

- How to be decided - Construction of press building with increased FAR of 360 with double basement for installation of printing press - Validity of - Master Plan aad Town Planning Whether construction legal and . in compliance with terms and conditions of lease deed - Notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease - Validity of. Specific Relief Act 1963, ss. S,6 and 9 - Perpetual lease granted to a private limited company by government for construction of building - Provisions in lease deed for Govt. 's right of re-entry in case of breach of lease terms - Whether lessor can enforce that right by resort to summary procedure Recourse to Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1971 - When arises - ·Public Premises (E••iction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1971, _ss.2(3), and (g) and 5. Government hrants Act 1895, s.3 - Effect of.

Administrative Law - Mala Fides - Allegations of - Misuse of Power in bad faith for collateral purpose - \Jhether amounts to mala fide Pxercise of power - Burden and nst,.i:e of proof Allegations tc be definite, specific and not v_ague - Court to accept them as true, if not controverted on affidavits. Doctrine . of ultra vires - Scope of - Fraud on power Meaning of - Exercise of power in good faith and misuse in bad faith - Distinction between.

Doctrine of Promissory Estoppel - Applicability of Whether applicable against government - Limitations - What are. The Central Government had i::I. the year 1949 demarcated the press area along the Bahadur Shah Zafar Msrg, New Delhi. It consisted of plots Nos. l to 10 known as Press Enclave as a C011111ercial complex. These plots were alloted to various newspapers like the Indian Express, Times of India, Patriot, National Herald, etc. Petitioner No.1, Expr""s Newspapers Private Ltd,, eggaged in the business of printing and publishing a national newspaper, Indian Express (Delhi Edition), was alloted plot nos. 9-10 Bahadur Shih'> Zafar Marg, New Delhi by an indenture st}led as an "agreement for lease" executed on Msy 26, 1954 between the petitioner and the Secretary (Local self-government) to the Chief Commissioner of Delhi by the orders and directions of the President of India for the construction of a four storeyed building meant to be used for a newspaper.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

At the time of construction of buildings in the press area there were no restrictions as to the Floor Area Ratio (FAR) permissible along the Bahsdur Shsh Zafar Marg and the only restriction on cons_truction of building in that area was that the allottees of the plots should construct buildings up to a height of 60 feet. The Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. was allowed to build upon the entire area of plots Nos. 9 and 10 with a ground coverage of 100%, that is, edge to edge, a structure with a mln1nnmi of five storeys including the ground floor for the purpose of installation of a printing press for publication of a Hindi newspaper. This permission was granted in response to the plans subnitted by the Express Newspapers Pv.t. Ltd. and approved in writing by the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi acting for and on behalf of the lessor, that is, the Union of India. During the preliminary work of construction by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. an underground sewer line was found to be running diagonally across plot nos. 9 and 10. It was agreed between the parties vide lease agreement dated November 19, 1957 that in view of the underground drain running through the plots, the Express Buildings would be constructed only to the East of the drain till the drain was diverted. In effect, an area of 2740 square yards to the West of the drain hsd to be left open as residual plot of the land out of a total area of 5703 square yards. The Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. constructed the old Ezpress Building to the East of the sewer line with an FAR of 260 with reference to the entire plot leased to it i.e. plots Nos. 9 and 10 altho1J8h the building occupied only half of the area. On March 17, 1958 another perpetual lease was executed by Assistant Secretary (LSG) to the Chief Comnissioner, Delhi by the order and direction of the President of India demising on behalf of the Union· of Indi!' in perpetuity the ~ land described therein in consideration of pa)'lllellt of a premium and yearly rent. Likewise, the earlier agreement dated November 19, 1957 so also the supplementary agreement of May 26, 1954 were also executed by the said Officer in the a.,.., lll81Uler. Both the agreements stipulated that the rules, regulations and bye-laws of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi relating to buildings which may be in force from time to time shal~ be conformed to by the lessee. On November 6, 1959 all functions relating to administration of leases of Government lands in Delhi were transferred from the Chief Comnissioner .of Delhi (LSG) to the Ministry of Works & Housing.

In the year 1977, petitioner No.l, the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd., approached the Municipal Corporation of Delhi for

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.l.

shifting the sewer line outside plots Nos. 9 and 10 and also moved the lessor; the Union of India, Ministry of Worka and Housing for grant of requisite sanction to conatruct the new Express Building with an FAR of 400. The Chief Engineer, Delhi Water Supply and Sewage Disposal Undertaking granted approval to the diversion of the sewer line at the cost of petitioner 11o.1. Thereafter, petitioner No.l, informed the Ministry of Workll and Housing about the aforesaid approval granted by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and requested the Miniatry for advice on the FAR permissible for the said building. The matter wu proceaeed in the Ministry of Workll and Hou.dog at varioua ·level.II ad ultimately on October 21, 1978, tbe Vice-Chainllll, Delh1 Development Authority took the foll.owing deciaione1 (a) to smalgR!!l!!te plots Noa.9 and 10. and taking into account the existing built-up area would permit the FAii. of 360 overall; (b) to allow the reaidual area of plota Noe. 9 and 10 to be built in line with the Times of India and ShR!!I!! Building; (c) to ucl11de the buement from the calculationa of the FAii. provided the basmente are uot uaed for office purposes; (d) to penoit parking on the service road in the 11111111er aa it waa for the other buildioga in thia line. The Vice-<:hairman further directed that the aforeaaid order waa to be treated u one under special appeal. He accordiogly gave inatruction for iaauing 'No Objection' to petitioner No.l for conatruction on the residual area and to make a reference to the Government of India asking for confirmation of the action proposed in view of the order of the Minister for Works and Housing to clear the cases illllediately and to obtain his !!. ~ ~ sanction. On November 4, 1978 tbe Joint Director (Buildings), Delhi Development Authority iasued a "No Objection Certificate" to the petitioners and the Ministry of Works and Housing granted its !!. ~ ~ approval on November 24, 1978. Thereafter, petitioner No.l constructed its new Express Building. On February 17, 1980, respondent No.2 Jagmohan assumed office as the Lt. Governor of Delhi and on the same evening, be s1111111Dned the Comnissioner of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and called for the files relating to the construction of the new Express Building at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi. On the next day, the necessary files were made available. On February 20, 1980, some important files of the Delhi Development Authority relating to the Express Buildings were sent to respondent No.2. On February 29, 1980, respondent No.2 through the Colllllissioner Municipal Corporation of Delhi caused the loclr.s of the office and cupboards of the Zonal Engineer (Building) to be brolr.eil open to

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

take away the files relating to the new Express Building. On March l, 1980 respondent No.2 convened a press conference in which he handed over a press release alleging (i) that the new Express Building put up by the petitioners was in contravention of law in several respects; (ii) that he had ordered an inquiry to be made by a conmittee of three of his subordinate officials and (iii) that the new Express Building might have to be demolished. On the same day, although the relevant files had been removed from his office, the Zonal Engineer (Buildings), City Zone, Municipal Corporation of Delhi served a notice on petitioner No.l, to show cause why action should not be taken for demolition of the Express Buildings under as. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957. On March 4, 1980, a second press releas~ was issued from the Raj Nivas, to justify th<.! action of respondent oo.2 in initiating the inquiry. The issue of show cause notice again figured in a third press release dated March 8, 1980. The Ministry of Works and Housing also submitted the files relating to the construction of the New Express BuUding to respond~t No.2 on March 7, 1980. On March 10, 1980 the Engineer Officer in the Land and Develop11ent Office under the Ministry of Works and Housing also issued a notice to the petitioners to show cause "!thin 30 days as to why the property should not be re-entered under clause 5 of the perpetual lease on the grounds: (i) that the construction of the New Expresa Building waa without permission from the lessor under the terms of lease; (ii) that the pla.ns were not submitted for the sanction under the terms of lease by the lessor; and (iii) that the plans were in contravention of cl.2(5) and 2(14) of the lease deed. On March 12, 1980 at a specially convened Press Conference, respondent No.2 released the report of the Comnittee of his subordinates which substantiated the view of respondent No.2 and also found that petitioner No.l was liable to pay Ra.35 la.ca as conversion charges. The petitioners .:hallenged the validity of the aforesaid notices before the Supreme Court under Art.32 of the Constitution on the grounds: (i) That the Lt.Governor appointed by the President under Art. 239(1) of the Constitution is an Administrator and he discharges such functions as are entrusted to him by the President of India and in the absence of a notification under Art. 239(1), the Lt. Governor cannot usurp the functions of the Union of India in relation to the properties of the Union: (ii) that the W.eutenant-Governor is not a successor of the Chief Coumissioner of Delhi. There was no notification issued by the President under Art. 239(1) of the Constitution for two

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I.

-

.,

'

the conferral of any power on tbe Lt. Governor to administer the lease in question; (iii) that it is inconceivable that after October 1, 1959 when the administrative control over the Land & Development Officer wss transferred from tbe Delhi Administration to the Minis try of Works & Housing and by virtue of a notification issued under Art. 299(1) the Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing wss made the competent authority to act for the President with regard to any contract, grant or assurance or property of the Union, tbe Lt.Governor could still arrogate to himself the powers of the Union of India, Min.i.s try of Works & Housing in relation to the lease; (iv) that respondent No.2, Jagmohan, is actusted with personal biaa against the Indian Express which had published an article in the Indian Express in April 1977 with regard to his role during the period of Emergency in Turkman Gate dem:ilitions. The proposed action of re-entry by the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of works & Housing at tbe instance of the Lt. Governor of Delhi is an act of politir.al vendetta. The impugned notices have been issued with an evil eye and an unequsl hand and with a deliberate design to compel tbe petitioners to close down the Express Group of Newspapers in general and the Indian Express in particular. The said notices are ex-facie illegal and without jurisdiction and are contrary to factusl and legal provisions. The arbitrary and discriminatory initiation of executive action under the guise of alleged infraction of the terms of the lease and/or the Master Plan of Delhi and or tbe lllllnicipal building bye-laws is violative of the petitioners' fundamental rights under Arts.14, 19(l)(a) and 19(l)(g) of the Constitution; (v) that the impugned notice issued by the Zonal Engineer (Building) City Zone, Municipal Corporation of Delhi dated March 1, 1980 was illegal and void as be did not apply his llind at all to the question at issue but ..,rely issued tbe 181111! at the instance of respondent No.2. The construction of the said building was not without or contrary to the sanction referred to in s.336 or in contravention of any of the provisions of the Act or bye-laws made there.under; (vi) that the erection of the double basement or a working platform in a printing press like the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. is a compoundable deviation from the sanctioned plan and the insistence of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi to .demolish the same suffers from the vice of hostile discrimination. (vii) that the construction of· the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 wss in conformity with clause 2.(5) of the perpetual lease dated March 17,1958 inasnuch as it wss with the express sanction of the lessor i.e. the Union of India. In terms of the Govern...nt of India (Allocation of Business) Rules, 1961 as well

I!

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 S.C.R,

ea Ulldar a notification issued Ullder Art.299(1), the Ministry of Worka & Housing with the Minister at the head waa and is the ultimate authority re1ponsible to deal with the property of the Union 8Dd to enter into all contractual obligations relating thereto. The Minister had not only full authority, power 8Dd juri1diction to grant permis1ion to the petitioner• to construct the new Ezpress Building with an increued FAR of 360 with a double basement for the installation of the printing prea1, but the action taken by the then Government waa in good faith after tsking into consideration all the circumstance• attendant at all levela. (viii) tl!llt there could be no objection to the construction of the new Ezpreas Building with an increaaed FAR of 360 as it allond the residual area of plota Noe. 9 and 10 to be built in line vith other building• along the Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg. Furthar, the llu ter Plan for Delhi aubaequently approved by the Central Government in the year 1962 doe• not mention the preas area on the Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg comprising of the preH enclave• Although specified u a C011111ercial area, it ia not liated in the li1t of "already built-up ~rcial areaa" beca111e it relates to the walled city of old Delhi. The Zonal development plan for D-II ar,.. within vbich the preH plota are located alao perlllitted an FAR of 400 for the prees area in the Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg. Therefore, all that the then Minister for Worka & llouaing did wea to rutore to the petitioner& the right that they acquired under the perpetllll leue dated March 17, 1958 i.e. to he treated a1iM alongwith other plot-bolder• in that area and a denial of •uch equal terms would be oppoaed to the principle& of equality besid~• being violative of Art.14 of the Constitution. (ix) That ~be Ezpreaa Building at 9-10 Babadur Shah Zafar Marg forms the nerve-centre of the Ezprea• Group of Newspapers as the ed1 to rials and the leading articles of the Indian Ezpress are sent out and the e41tor1al policy laid down from Delhi office to ten centres all over India· In this factual background, the impugned notices have a direct impact on the freedOll of the press and being in excess of governmental authority and colourable exercise of statut11ry powers, are liable to be struck down as offending Art.19(l)(a) read with Art.14 of the Constitution. (x) that the lessor i.e. the Union of India ie estopped by the doctrine of promissory estoppel 8Dd cannot therefore go back upon all assurances given and actions taken by the previous government, particularly When the petitioners had acted upon the decisions so reached aDd had constructed the new Ezpreas Building with a coat of approximately Rs.1.30 crorea by February 1980 which at present would coat more than Rs.3 crorea.

.

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.o.I.

It..,.. contended on~ of respondent No.l, the Union of India; (1) · that the right to occupy the land leased for the construction of a building for inatallation of a printing press ia not within Art. 19(l)(a) nor within Art. 19(l)(g) wt llUCb a right ia derived fran a grant or contract; (2) That the right arising out of a statute or out of a contract cannot be a fund&B lllelltal right itself. Once ·a contract ia entered into or a grant ia · made, the rights snd · obligationa - of the parties are not governed by Part III of the Constitution but by the terms of the docrnnent et.bodying the contract or the grant, snd any cmplaint about its breach cannot be a matter· for grant of a writ, direction or order under Art. 226 of tbe Constitution, much less under Art.32, snd since the petitioners are seeking to enforce a contractual right, it cannot be decided on a petition under Art• 32 of the Constitution. (3) That the content of Art. 19(l)(g) of the Constitution 1'0U1d not include the right '1hich ia. guaranteed· by other cJsuses of Art.19 (4). That. the argument of the petitioners thst ·the. 'bodldfng in ·.question is necessary for rmming .the press and any statutory or executive action to pull it d0>1n or forfeit the lease 1'0U1d directly :IJDpinge on the right of freedan of speech and expression under Art. 19(1)(g) ia loibolly · misconceived inasmuch as every activity thst may be necessary for exercise of freedom of speech · and expression or .thst may facilitate such exercise or make it meaningful snd effective c:amiot be elevated to the status of a furularnental right. (5) That the right to the land and the right to construct bo11ldfngs thereon for rmming a printing press are not derived fran Art. 19(1) (a) but spring fr= the terms of the grant of such 1anda by the Goverm.ent under the provision& of the Goveniment Grants Act, 1895 snd regulated by other k..s governing the subject viz. ·the Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Master Plan and the Zonal Develoµnent Plan framed thereunder, the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 and the Delhi Municipal Corporation · (Bnfldfng) Bye-Ia..s,. 1959 '1hich regulate construction of boifldfngs in the Union Territory of Delhi irre6pective o~ the purpose for '1hich the boifldfng is constructed. (6) That the right to run a_ press may be a . fimdamental right guaranteed under Art. 19(1)(a) · or Art. 19(l)(g) lxlt the right to use a particular 1:>11Jd1ng for rmming a press ia altogether another thing inasmuch as no particular building is equally fit for the running of the press and the person ·desiring to run a . press or already running the press is at liberty to acquire another suitable bnlldfng for that purpose. Further, even i f the- lxlildings in question '1ere necessary for the enjoYlllellt of the rights under Art.19(1)(a) or- -- li Art. 19(l)(g) 'a right to_ use a particular bo1lldfng does not

"

- -

•

--------- -------~---------------'------

C

5UPJ.<EME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 S.C.R.

become an integral part of the right to freedom of speech and expression' or the 'right to carry on any trade of business in printing and publishing a newspaper' and clearly therefore the petitions under Art. 32 are not maintainable. (7) That even on a question of fact, the direct impact of the impugned notices will not be on the double basement wherein printing press is installed but will be wholly or in part on the two upper storeys which are not intended to be wred in relation to the press or for publication of the intended Hindi newspaper but only for the purpose of letting out the same for profit; the only other possible effect may be the removal of the upper basement which the petitioners call a working platform which has been constructed in violation of the building regulations. (8) That there was no :Imminent danger of demolition of the Express Building nor was the impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 issued by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office, a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease. It was merely a notice of an exploratory nature requiring the petitioners to show cause why the lease should not be forfeited under cl.5 of the lease-deed for alleged breaches of els. 2.(5) and 2(14) ther~f. The Petitione!:s should have therefore entered appearance before tbe Land & Development Officer and showed cause against the action proposed. It was only if the Land & Development Officer was not satisfied with their explanation, that he would put up the papers before the Lt. Governor for necessary action. It would then be for the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing to decide whether or not the lease should be forfeited under cl.5 of the lease-deed. (9) That the impugned notice by the Engineer Officer purporting to act on behalf of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing was not based either on the report of the Three-Menber Canmittee obtained by the Lt.Governor or on the basis of any comnunication from him, (10) That the Lt.Governor had no powers in ~elation to the properties of the Union and, therefore, the Union of India is not bound by the acts of the Lt. Governor. The Lt. Governor had no power in relation to the lease and, therefore, he could not usurp to himself the powers and functions of the Union of India in relation to the lease deed. However the Lt.Governor as the Administrator had to keep himself informed and cannot be said to have acted mala fide merely because of any possible personal malus animus on his part, i f the quality of the action was itself in complete accord with the law. (11) That the Government itself was in possession of relevant records and applied its mind to them and the impugned notice issued by the Engineer Officer who was empowered to act on behalf of the President under Art.299(1) of the Constitution

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.o.I.

having been authenticated in the manner required by Art.77(3), it lllUSt be deemed to be the deeision of the President on the advice of the Council of Ministers. as enjoined by Art. 74(2) and the Court was precluded from making any investigation into tbe circumstances attendant thereto. (12) That it was the respondent No.2 to meet the charges of malafides levelled against him. On behalf of

respondent No.2, the Lt.Governor of Delhi, it

was argued: (1) That the Administrator appointed by the President

under Art.239(1), as amended by the Seventh Amendment, could be called by any designation, that the Chief Coumissioner of Delhi continued to be the Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi under Art.239(1) after November l, 1956 when the Government of Part C States Act, 1951 was replaced by s.130 of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956 and that he functioned as such till September 6, 1966 since the Delhi Administration Act, .1966 continued to use the nomenclature of Administrator appointed by the President under Art.239(1). It was for the first time on September 7, 1966 that the Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi who used to be designated as the Chief Coumissioner was re-designated as the Lt.Governor. (2) that the Lt.Governor was successor of the Chief Coumissioner and, therefore, . all the powers exercisable by the Chief Coaloissioner in relation to the lease vested in him· (3) That the Lt. Governor was the alter ego of the President in relation to such territory which he is called upon to administer on behalf of the President. One of the primary functions of the Lt. Governor, as the Administrator, was to be aware of facts brought to his knowledge and therefore respondent No.2 could not have turned a blind eye to the action of Sikander Bakht, the then Minister for Works & Housing in making a highly fraudulent, illegal and improper grant of sanction to petitioner No. l, the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to build the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360. (4) That the Lt. Governor as the appointed agent or nominee of the President was entitled to act on behalf of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing in relation to the lease and therefore, be was well within his rights (a) in calling for and making perusal of the respective files from the Ministry of Works & Housing, Delhi Development Authority and the Municipal Corporation of. Delhi pertaining to the construction of the Express Building with an increased FAR of 360; (b) in constituting a Three-Melllber Coaloittee to .inquire into the circumstances

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3

s.c.R.

relating to the grant of sanction by the then Miniater of Works & Housing and to take necessary stepa as regards the unauthorised construction of the new Express Building; and (c) in forwarding the report of the Tbree-tlember Comittee to the concerned authority, me•ntng the Minister for Works & Housing for taking necessary steps. (5) that the transfer of administrative control of the L & D 0 on October l, 1958 to the Ministry of Works & Housing did not diVe&t the Chief Commiasioner of hia contractual powers given under the lease and be alone represented the lessor i.e. the Union of India and not the Ministry of Works & Housing (6) That being the Lt. Governor of Delhi, be was responsible for the admi.n!.stration of the Union Territory of Delhi and, as such, he was acting within his power to direct all the authorities concerned to prevent violation of laws by any person or inatitution. He further asserted that he, as the Lt. Governor of Delhi, was fully competent to appoint the Inquiry Conaittee under the Comnisaioner of Inquiry Act, 1952. (7) that the Union of India or the Lt. Governor of Delhi never intended to inflict a reprisal on the petitioners for the independent stand of the nelOSpapers they publish. (8) that the respondents had no personal animosity towards the Express Group of Newspapers and the criminal complaint for defamati@ was instituted by respondent No.2 because the Indian Express was guilty of fabricating and publishing falae, motivated, s<;andslous stories about respondent No.2 and others. (9) That be bad not ordered the issuance of the notice in question and that the Lend & Development Officer was an authority independent of the administrative control and supervision of the Lt. Governor, As regards the impuged show cause notice issued by the Zonal· Engineer (Building) City Zone, Municipal Corporation of Delhi, it was asserted that the same bad been issued by the Municipal Coi:poration of Delhi in exercise of its statutory powers under ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act after verification of the allegations. (10) That the perpetual lease-deed dated March 18, 1958 governs the relationship effectively between the Union of India and the Lt. Governor on the one band and the pet:itioners on the other i.e. the contractual relationa between the parties. (11) That the sewer, according to the terms of the lease-deed, could not be diverted without the consent of the Chief Comnissioner and the approval of the Minis try of Works & Housing was a nullity being without juriadiction and legal competence. (12) that for the c011111ercial user of the residual ares to be kept as 'green' it is only the Chief Commissioner (Lt. Governor) who could give

,_

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v.

u.o.r.

sanction to construct for the c0111Dercial user at the residual ares; the petitioners were liable to pay c011111ercial realization changes; and (13) that it is for the Chief Comnissioner (Lt. Governor) to decide if the breaches were remediable or aa to the nature of the remedies required for the breach. Since the breaches are not remediable breaches, the impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 issued by the Engineer Officer, L & D 0 for re-entry upon the land on forfeiture of the leaae for breach of the conditions waa valid and proper. Counsel for respondent No.4, Municipal Corporation of Delhi, urged (l) that the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. have no right to construct the upper basement particularly when the Corporation refused to accord sanction to it and that, in any event, it was not such an unsvoidsble necessity as to break the law; and (2) that even if some receiving floor may perhaps be neces8"1')' to receive the printed newspapers from the machine, it would be achieved by locating the machines on a suitable pedestal or by laying the floor of the basement in such a manner as to discharge the newspaper on the ground floor; and (3) that under the Master Plan and the Building Bye-laws, not more than one basement is permissible and that any basement more than one will have to be reckoned for the purpose of FAR. Counsel for respondent No.5 Land & Development Officer contended (l) that under the terms of the leaae deed of 1958, previous consent of either the President of India or the Chief Comnissioner (Lt. Governor) or such officer or body as the lessor (President of India) or the Chiaf Comnissioner of Delhi authorised was necessary for building activity on the residual area of the plots (2740 sq. yards). The Ministry of Works & Housing did not represent the lessor or the Chief Comnissioner. ; and (2) that the Land & Development Officer is not a functionary under the Ministry of Works & Housing. He is the officer appointed on behalf of the lessor to administer the leaae. At no 11tage the petitioners approaehed the office of Land &Development for permission to construct on the residual area of 2740 sq.yards to the west of the pipe-line and no approval wss obtained from the office of L & D O for construction of a building in contravention of clauses 2(5), (9) and (14) of the leaae. The so-called permissions and approvals obtained by the petitioners have no legal competence or authority under the terms of the lease-deed

SUPREME COL'RT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 S.C.R.

which governed the relationship between the petitioners and respondent no.l.

Allowing the writ petitions,

BEW : By the Court (Per A.P. Sen, E.S. Venkatsramiah & R.B. Misra, J.)

C

(l) The writ petitions under Art.32 of the Constitution 11118t succeed and are allowed with costs. The notice issued by the Engilleer Officer, Land & Development Office dated March 10, 1980 purporting to act on behalf of the Government of India, Ministry of Works & Housing requiring the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to show cause why the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing should not re-enter upon and take possession of plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi together with the Express Buildings built thereon, under cl.5 of the indenture of lease dated llar<!h 17, 1958 for alleged breaches of cls.2(5) and 2(14) thereof, and the earlier notice dated March l, 1980 isaued by the Zonal Engineer (Building), City Zone, Municipal Corporation, Delhi requiring them to show cause why the aforeaaid buildings should not be demolished under ss.343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, are quashed. It is declared that the construction of the new Express Building on the residual portion of 2740 square yards on the western side of plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for installation of a pr1nting press for publics tion of a Hindi daily newspaper was with tile permission of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry <>f Works & Housing and did oot constitute a breach of clauses 2(5) and 2(14) of the lease-deed. [554 E-11; 555 A] (2) The Lt. Governor failed to make a distinction in this case between the power with respect to the subject 'Property of the Union and the revenue therefrom' which is in Entry 32 of List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution and the general powers of admin!stration entrusted to him under Article 239 of the Constitution as the administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi. The property in question is a part of the estate of the Central Government. Mere nearness to the seat of the Central

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I.

Government does not clothe the Lt. Governor of Delhi· with my power in respect of the property of the Central Government. He can discharge only those powers which are entrusted to him by the Constitution and the laws. It is also not correct to claim that all the powers of the former Chief Commissioner of Delhi have devolved on the Lt.Gov"rnor and continue to vest in him. [556 B-il)

l(i) Freedom of the press ill comprehended within the right to freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Art.19(l)(a). The freedom of thought and expression, and the freedom of the press are not only valuable freedoms in tbemaelves but are basic to a democratic foilJ of Government which proceeda on the theory that problems of the Government can be solved by the free eitchsnge of thought and by public discuaaion of the various issues facing the nation. It ia necessary to emphaaize and one 1111St not forget that the vital importUJ.ce of freedom of speech and expression involves the freedom to dissent to a free democracy like ours. Democracy relies on the freedom of the press. It is the inalienable right of everyone to c011111ent freely upon any matter of public importsnce. This right ia one of the pillars of individusl liberty-freedom of speech, which Supreme Court haa always unfailingly guarded. Howsoever precious and cherished the freedom of speech is under Art.19(l)(a), this freedom. is not akolute and unlimited at all times and under all circumstances but is subject to the restrictions contained in Art.19(2). That 1111St be so because unrestricted freedom of the preaa and is wholly free from restraints, amounts to uncontrolled licence which would lead to disorder and anarchy and it would be hazardous to ignore the vital importsnce of our social .and national interest in public order and security of the State. [474 C-il; 475 0-G) l(ii) The extent of permissible limitations on this freedom are indicated by the fundamental law of the land itself viz. Art.19(2) of the Constitution. But, permissible restrictions on any fundamental right guaranteed under Part Ill of the Constitution have to be imposed by a duly enacted law and 1111St not be excessive i.e. they llBlSt not go beyond what is necessary to achieve the object of the law under which they ai:e sought to be imposed. The power to impose restrictions on fundamental

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

rights is essentially s power to 'regulate' the exercise of these rights. In fact, 'regulation' and not extinction of thst which is to be regulated is, generally spesking, the extent to which petmissible restrictions may go in order to satisfy the test of ressonsbleness. The test laid down by the Supreme Court is whether the direct and imnediste impact of the impugned action is on the freedan of speech aDd expression guaranteed under Art.19(l)(a) which includes the freedan of the press.

In the instant case, the very threat is to the existence of a free and illdependent press. The impugned notices of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease aDd of the threatened demolition of the Express Buildings are intended and meant to silence the vioce of the llldian Express. lt must logically follow that the impugned notices constitute a direct and imnediate threat to the freedan of the press and are thus violative of Art.19(l)(a) read with Art.14 of the Constitution. lt must accordingly be held that these petitions under Art.32 of the Constitution are maintainable. [475 H; 476 A-C; 477 D-E]

Bemiett ColEllan & Co. & Ora. v. Union of lDdia & Ora. [1973] 2 s.c.R. 757 followed.

Jlalll!sh 'l'happar v. State of Madras [1950] s.c.R. 594, Sakal Papers (P) Ltd. v. Union of lDdia [1962] 3 s.c.R. 842 and Express Beimpapers (P) Ltd. & Anr. v. Union of lDdia & Ors. [1959] s.c.R. 12 at 120 relied upon.

The correctness of the landmark decision in Maneka Gandhi's case and the innovative construction placed on Art .14 in the three cases of Royapps, Maneka Gandhi and International Airport Authority (supra), which have evolved new dimensions in judicial process, is no longer open to question. [472 C-D] Haneta Gandhi v. Unial1 of India [1978] 2 s.c.R. 621, E.P. Boyappa v. State of Tallil Nadu & Anr. [1974] 2 s.c.R. 348 llaneka

Gandhi v. Union of lDdia (supra) and llmans llayaram Sbetty v. lnternstioDal Airport Authority of India Ltd. & Ors. [1979] 3

s.c.R. 1014 affirmed.

All lDdia Bank lllllpl.oyees' Association V• Natioaal lnduatrial Tribunal & Ors. (1962] 3 s.c.R. 269 referred to.

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.!.

(3) Even in cases involving purely contractual iaaues, the settled law is thst where statutory provisions of public law are involved, writs will issue. [484 A) (4) (i) Section 2 of the Goverment Granu Act, 1895 excludes the operation of the Transfer of Property Act, 1892 to Government grants. Section 3 declares tbat all proviaiona, any such grant or transfer aa aforesaid ahsll be .valid and shell take effect according to their tenor, notwithatsnding any rule of law, statute or enactment of the Legialature to the contrary. A aeries of judicial decisions hsve determined the overriding effect of s.3 making it amply clear that a grant of property by tbe Government partakes of the nature of law since it overrides even legal provisions which are contrary to the tenor of the docUMllto [478 D-E] (4)(ii) There can be no doubt whatever on a true construction of the impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 that the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office purporting to act on behalf of the leasor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing served a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of leaae under cl.5 of the leue-deed. There was no question of the said notice being construed to be of an exploratory nature. Since reapondent No.2 is not the successor of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi nor haa any function in relation to the lease, there ia no warrant for the suggestion thst prior approval of the Lt. Governor io a condition precedent to the right of the leasor i.e. the Union of India to exercise its right of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease under cl.5 of the lease-deed. [480 B-D] 4.(iii) The Express Newapapera Pvt. Ltd. having acted upon the grant of permission bY the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing to construct the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 together with a double basement was clearly not an unsuthorized occupant within the meaning of s.2(g) of the Act. The Express Buildings constructed by Expreaa Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. with the sanction of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing on ploto Noa. 9 and 10 Bahadurshah Zafar Marg demised on perpetual lease by registered lease-deed dated March 17, 1958 can, by no procP.sa of reasoning, be regarded as public premises belonging to the Central Government under s.2(g). That being so, there is no question of the lessor applying for eviction of the Express Newapapers Pvt.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

Ltd. under 5.5(1) of the Public Premises (Eviction of unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971 nor has the Estate Officer any authority or jurisdiction to direct their eviction under sub-s.(2) thereof by sumnary process. Due process of law in a case like the present necessarily implies the filing of suit by the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministty of Works & Housing for the enforcement of the alleged right of re-entry if any, upon forfeiture of lease due to breach of the terms of the lease. However, the Government has the power to take recourse to the provisions of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971 where admittedly there is unauthorized construction by a lessee or by any other person oL Government land which is public premises within the meaning of s.2(e) and such person is in unauthorized occupation thereof. [484 E-F; 485 A-DJ Biahan Das & Ors. v. State of Punjab & Ors. [1962] 2 s.c.R. 69 aff~rmed.

Wazir a.and v. State of H.P. [1955] l s.c.R. 408 & II.am Prasad Narayan Sabi v. State of Bihsr [1953] s.c.R. 1129 relied upon.

State of Orissa v. II.am <llandra Dev A.l.R. 1964 S.C. 685 criticised.

5(i) Under the Constitution of India, Delhi became a Part 'C' State w.e.f. Janusry 26, 1960 and it was provided by Art. 239(1) that a State specified in Part 'C' of the First Schedule shall be administered by the President acting to such extent as he thinks fit through a Chief Camnissioner or Lt. Governor to be appointed by him. [491 E-FJ

Art. 239(1) of the Constitution differed from the provision contained in s.94(3) of the Government of India Act, 1935 to the extent that the appointment of a Chief Commissioner or Lt. Governor as an Administrator irrespective of the designation and entrustment of powers, functions and duties to him by the President, were not to be in his discretion but had to be exercised on the advice of the Council of Ministers. Except for this, s.94(3) of the Government of India Act, 1935 and Art.239(1) of the Constitution as enacted were identical in respect of the provisions for the administration of Delhi as a Chief

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I.

Comnissioner's province under the 1935 Act and as a Part 'C' State under the Constitution, by the Governor-General under s.94(3) and under Art. 239(1) by the President acting to such extent as he thought fit, through the Chief Comnissioner or. the Lt. Governor as an Administrator irrespective of the deaignation. [491 H; 492 A-BJ

JI

5(ii) Art. 239(1) of the Constitution was amended by the Constitution (7th Amendment) Act, 1956 w.e.f. November 1, 1956 and for the words 'through a Chief Comnissioner or a Lt. Governor to be appointed by him' in Art.239(1) as originally enacted, the words substituted are 'through an administrator appointed by him with such designation as he may specify'. Therefore, the Administrator appointed by the President under Art. 239(1) whether with the deaignation of the Chief Comnissioner or of the Lt. Governor could exercise only such powers, functions and duties as were entrusted to him by the President i.e. there have to be specific entrustment of powers by the President under Art.239(1). From November 1, 1956 Part 'C' States ceased to exist by virtue of the Seventh AmendDmt and in their place Union Territories were substituted in the First Schedule to the Constitution, including the Union Territory of Delhi i.e. the territorie~ which iumediately before the COlllllf!Ilcement of the Constitution were comprised in the Chief Comnissioner's ;;>rovince of Delhi. [493 A-B; D-E; 493 F-G] 5(iii) On October 1, 1959 decision was taken by the Government of India to transfer the administrative control of the office o:': Land & Development Officer, New Delhi from the Delhi Administration to Ministry of Works, Housing & Supply w.e.f. October 1, 1959. This decision was duly cOlllllllnicated to the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi and to the Land & Development Officer, New Delhi. The President of India on February 1, 1966 issued an order under Art.299(1) of the Constitution which inter alia directed that in the case of Land & Development Office (1) all contracta and assurances of property relating to matter falling within the jurisdiction of Land & Development Officer, (2) all contracta, deeds and other instrumenta relating to and for the purpose of enforcement of the terms and conditions of the sale/lease-deed of the government property in Delhi/New Delhi, etc. made in exercise of the executive power of the Union may be executed on bis behalf by the Land & Development Officer. Therefore, neither the Chief

Ii

Jl

SUPREME COUltT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

Commissioner nor the Lt• Governor had anything to do with the Office of the Land & Development or the administration of nazul. lands 1.n the Union Territory of Delhi after October 1, 1959. They have not been conferred any authority by the President under Art. 299(1) to enter into any contracts made in the exercise of the executive power of the Union or to act 'on behalf of' the President in relation to auch contract or assurance of property i.e. to act on behalf <>f the President for the enforcement of the terms and cond!tions thereof, There is also no notification under Art. 239(1) by the President vesting Chief Commissioner or the Lt. Governor with any power, functions and duty in relation to the property of the Union Territory of Delhi. [495 C-il; F~; E; 497 A..JI]

5(iv) It would therefore, appear that the territory of Delhi as a Part State under the First Schedule to the Constitution was a separate and distinct constitlitional entity as from that of a Chief CommiHioner Province under the Government of India Act, 1935, and this ia equally true of the Union Territory of Delhi. It must logically follow that with the transformation of the territory of Delhi from a Chief Comniaaioner's Province under s.94(3) of the Government of India Act, 1935 into that of a Part 'C • State under the Constitution and after the Seventh Amendment into the Union Territory Delhi, the office of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi disappeared and that of an Administrator appointed by the President under Art.239(1) with such designation as he may specify, came into existence. The necessary concomitant is that the Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi derived only such powers, functions and duties aa were entrusted to him by the President under Art.239(1). [501 C-E]

•c•

5. (v) There was no Order in Council issued by the GovernorGeneral under s.94(3) of the Government of lod1a Act, 1935 nor any order issued by the President under Art. 239(1) of the Constitution investing the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi to deal with the property of the Union. The matters relating to the property of the Union of India are included in the executive power of the Union under Art.53 of the Constitution read with Art.298 which expresHly provides that the executive power of the Union shall extend to the acquisition, holding and disposal of

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.r.

•

property and the making of contracts for any purpose. Such executive power of the Union is vested in the President under Art.53(1) and shall be exercised by him either directly· or through officers subordinate to him in sccordance with the Constitution. All executive actions of the Government of India shall be expressly taken in the name of the President under Art.77(1). Under cl.(2) thereof, orders and other instruments made and executed in the nsme of the President shall be authenticated ·as may be specified in rules to be made by the President i.e. in the manner specified under the Authentication (Orders and other Instruments) Rules, 1958 framed under Art. 72(2). In terms of the Government of India (Allocation of Business) Rules, 1961, all matters relating to the property of the Union, allotment of Governm£nt lands in Delhi, administration of Government estates under the control of the Ministry of Works & Housing and the administration of the Land & Development office, are matters exclusively vested in the Ministry of Works & Housing vide Entries 1, 6 and 23 ( 1) in the Second Schedule under the bead 'Ministry of Works & Housing'. In the light of the said directive, as further confirmed by the constitutionally enacted regulations, the power over the allotment of nszul lands, administration of leases in Delhi and the control and administration of Land & Developlllellt office in particular and the property of the Union in general are subjects vest.ed solely under the control of the Ministry of Works & Housing. In the premises, by such transfer of authority, the Chief Commissioner of Delhi and necessarily his successor, the Lt. Governor, became bereft of his powers to control and administer the lease and any attempt by respondent No.2 to set up a claim that the Lt. Governor is the authority empowered to administer the lease is wholly frivolous and untenable and must be rejected. [502 F; 503 A-C; E-G] llobd. llaqbool Dallloo v. State of J - & laahldr

[1972]

s.c.&. 1014 & Edvard Milla eo. Ltd. Beawar & Ora. v. State of Ajller & A.Dr. [1955] 1 s.c.&. 735 distinguiohed.

6(i) The impugned notices dated March 1, 1980 and March 10, 1980 were not issued bona fide in tbe ordinsey course of official buoiness for implementation of the law or for securing justice but were actusted with an ulterior and extraneous purpose and thus were wholly mala fide and politically motivated. [519 CJ 6(11) iraud on power voids the order if it is not exercised bona fide for the end design. There is a distinction

R

SUPRENE COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

between exercise of power in good faith and misuse in bad faith. 'lbe former arises when an authority misuses its power in breach of law, say, by taking into account bona fide, and with best of intentions, sane extraneous matters or by ignoring relevant matters. That would render the impugned act or order ultra vires. It would be a case of fraud on powers. The misuse in bad faith arises when the power is exercised for an improper motive, say, to satisfy a private or personal grudge or for wreaking vengeance of a Minister. A power is exercised maliciously if its repository is motivated by personal animosity towards those who are directly affected by its exercise. Use of a power for an 'alien' purpose other than the one for which the power is conferred is mala fide use of that power. Same is the position when an order is made for a purpose other than that which finds place in the order. The ulterior or alien purpose clearly speaks of the misuse of the power. [507 F-ti] 6(iii) It is not for the parties to say what is relevant or not. The matter is one for the Court to decide. Mala fidea on the part of the Government in power or its functionaries would be sufficient to invalidate the impugned notices. [505 F] 6(iv) The petitioners have alleged several facts imputing improper motives which have not boon specifically denied and there is only a bare denial with the assertion that the facts are not relevant, Mere denial of allegations does not debar the courts fran inquiring into the allegations. It is quite evident that no action was contemplated against the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. by any of the respondents prior to February 17, 1980. Respondent No.2upon assumption of bis office as the Lt. Governor of Delhi on that day !mediately set on a course of action against the Indian Express which culminated in the issue of the impugned notices. It cannot be doubted that bis initiative to call for the files from the Municipal Corporation relating to the construction of the new Express Building was an action of his own not provoked by anyone, much less at the instance of respondent No.l, the Union of India, Ministry of. Works & Housing. The sequence of events set in motion imnediately after his assumption of office as the Lt. Governor demonstrate the extent to which and the keenness with which be pursued the matter. It would appear that the entire administrative machinery was geared into action by respondent no.2 and he 'activated' the taking of steps culminating in the issue of the impugned notices. [509 A-B; 515 A-BJ

EXPRESS NEWSPAPJ!RS v. U.O.l.

6(v) The dominant purpose which actuated respondent no.2 in initiatillg governmental action was not so much for implementation of the provisions of the Master Plan or the Zonal Development Plans framed under the Delhi Development Act or the observ8IICe of the relevant Municipal Bye-laws under the Delhi Municipal r.orporation Act, but to use these provisions for an 1alien' purpose and in bad faith i.e. for demolition of the Express Bni l dings with mark of retribution or politiC'll vendetta for the role of IDdiBn Express during the period of Emergency and thereafter and thereby to bring about closure of tbe Indian Express. (512 D-E) 6(vi) It was somewhat strange that tbe Land & Development Officer who was a minor fllllCtiODarY of the Ministry of Works & Housillg should have filed counter supporting the action of respondent no.2. There is no doubt that the Land & Development Officer deliberately made an inaccurate statement that be is not under the sclmfnistrative control of the Ministry. [516 B)

a

6(vii) The contention that there was no :lmninent danger of demolition of the Express Buildillg nor was the impugned notice by the Engineer Officer a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease, is against the very terms of the impugned notice. There is a categoric avel'lllent tbat tbe grant of sanction by the then MiDister for Works & Housillg was illegal, improper and irregular. It is therefore futile to contend that tbe impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 was not a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease but merely a notice of an exploratory nature · requiring Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to show cause why the lease should not be forfeiture under cl.5 of the lease-deed. [518 C-E]

c.s. ~jee & Ora. Vo A.Po State Jload Transport Corporation

[1964] 4 s.c.R. ·330 relied upon• S. Pratap Singh v. State of Punjab (1964] 4 S.C.R. 733 & General •ss"Ehly of Free a.urcb of Scotland Vo Overta1m L.R. (1904] A.c. 515 relied upon.

Short Vo Poole Corporatico L.R. [1926] Cb,D, 66 1 . Lazarus Estates Ltd. v. Beaaloy [1956] 1 Q.B. 702 at pp.712-13, Dr. Baa Hpoohar Labia V• State of Bihar & Ors. [1966) l· S,C,R, 708 & State of Punjab v. llmojilal & Ora. [1971] 2 s.c.R. 550 relied

upon. J1ar1m <>-rtcals Ltdo & Aur. Vo 7be Canpany 1-

[1966] Supp. s.c.R. 311 relied upon.

~

R

SUPREME COURT REPORTo

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

Judicial Review of Administration Action, 4th Edn. pp.335-36 and by Prof. De. Smith and H.w.R. Wade's Administrative Law, 5th Edn. pp.42, 348 and 369 referred to. 7(i) The construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 for starting a Hindi Newspaper and the installation of the printing press in double basement waa allowed by the Delhi Development Authority, in accordance with the provisions of the Master Plan. [520 HJ

.8

7(ii) The Press Enclave on Bahadurshah Zafar Marg otherwise known as the Mathura Road Comercial Complex is not a 'development area 1 i.1.thin the meaning of s.2(3) of the Delhi Development Act, 1957. The Master Plan does not prescribe any FAR for the press enclave situate on Mathura Road ccmnercial area nor does such area fall within the 1already built-up ccmnercial areas' aa def:l!led in the Maater Plan i.e. commercial area falling within the walled city of Old Delhi. Apparently, the contention that the FAR of no commercial area in Delhi can exceed 400 is wholly misconceived inasmuch as the Master Plan in express terms permits FAR of the commercial areas in Minto Road and Ranjit Singh Road at 400. The Zonal Development Plan for the D-lI uea approved by the Central Govemment in November 1966 mentions four ccmnercial areas, namely (1) Asaf Ali Road commercial area (2) Minto Road ccmnercial area (3) Mathura Road commercial area, and (4) Circular Road ccmnercial area (opposite Ramlila Grouwl). Although in the Zonal Development Plan for D-11 area, Asaf Ali Road comnercial area is described as fully developed with no room for expanaion, the FAR of which is admittedly 400, there could be still a further increase in Fil aubject to payment of premium. This could only be uwler the provisions of the Zonal Development Plan for D-II area and therefore it lllllSt logically follow that the FAR prescribed in the Zonal Development Plan fo~ Mathura Road c<>mMrcial area where ·the preaa enclave ie aituate ie 400. 'lbe presa area 1a not far from Asaf Ali Road c:amiercial area. lt not only falls in the aame D-lI area but is treated aa part of a complex of four commercial areas in the Zonal Development Plan for D-II area. Thia preas area is not even deacribed aa fully coamercialized· lf FAR 400 ia prescribed and al.lowd for Aaaf At! Road ccmnercial area which is fully developed, it could not poasibly be :lmpemiasible for the press area vbicb although fully commercialized waa still not fully developed. [520 D; 524 c-E; 526 D-G] 7(iii) The floor area ratio or FAii. ia the restriction on the llllllber of floors in a building with refere11Ce to the plot area. Where FAR ie not apecified in the Muter Plan which

EXPRESS N~'WSPAPERS v. l.).O.I.

admittedly is the case in regard to press area on Bahsdurshah Zafar Marg, the only bye-law applicable would be bye-laws 21 and 22. Bye-law 21(1) restricts the height of a building to 70 feet. This height is to be measured from the centre of the adjacent portion of the 'nearest street'. Admittedly as is clear from the sanction plan, the height of the new Express Building is about 47 feet. The adjacent portion which is the service road is on level with the plinth of the additional construction. Taking Mathura Road as the 'nearest street', the level of Mathura Road stretches from 2 ft. to 5 ft. higher than the plinth level of the additional construction. In any view of the matter, the additional construction could therefore be permissible if it did not exceed a height of 63 feet. This is because of bye-law 21(1) and also because of FAR with which is linked the ground floor cover'l-ge is not specified in the Master Plan. In order to avoid congestion the ""'xinnnn height is further restricted under bye-law 22 in proportion to the width of the abutting street. In the instant case, Mathura Road which is the abutting street measures in width 150 feet. This is apart from the immediately abutting service road which, even if reckoned as an abutting street, is 63 feet in width. Therefore, applying bye-law 22(4) read with bye-law 21(1), it is the service road of the street that governs the height of the buildings in the press area as well as the number of floors, the miniuaJm floor height being already specified in bye-law 19. The ~estriction on the height of buildings is therefore governed by the width of the street subject to the maximum height of 70 feet and this is the measure adopted where FAR for a particular area. is not specified in the Master Plan. [529 C, E-F; 530 A-{;; F-11; 531 A) 7(iv) Bye-law 25(2)(IV-ll) only applies to "already built up commercial areas as indicated in the Master Plan such other areas as may be declared as commercial areas by the appropriate authority from time to time.• The list of already build-up commercial areas as defined in the Master Plan admittedly does not include the press area on th" Mathura Road. At the time of coustruction of buildings in the press area, there were also no restric.tions as to the FAR along the Mathura Road and the only restriction on construction of such buildings was that the allottees of the plots in the press area shodd construct buildings upto a height of 60 ft. [533 E-F) 7(v) It lllUSt therefore be held that the permissfon granted by Sikander Bakht, the then Minister for Works & Housing for the construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement ior installation of the printing press was not in violation of the Master Plan for Delhi or the Zonal De\relopment Plan for D-II area or the Delhi Municipal Corporation

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

(Buildings) Bye-laws, 1959 inasmuch as ex facle by-law 26 read with 25(2)(IV-B) was not applicable tothe press area on the Matlura lload. Admittedly, the Master Plan does not prescribe any FAR for the Press enclave. The Zonal Development Plan for the first time prescribed FAR for the four c011111ercial areas for general business and C0111Dercial areas. All these C0111Dercial areas fall within D-Il area for which the Zonal Development Plan prescribes an FAR of 400. (535 E-F] B(i) The non-obstante clause in section 53(A)(i) of the Delhi Development Act clearly gives an overriding effect to the sanction granted by the Delhi Development Authority for the construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 and a double basement for installation of printing presa or the working platform. The effect of grant of such permission by the Authority was to modify the sanctioned plans of the Municipal Corporation to that extent. That apart the term "development" as defined in section 2(d) of the Act includes the carrying <>ut of builclinga •• •• •••• in, on, over or under land in any building etc. and la wide enough to include the structures in question. As the Authority approved each of these structures for which the impugned show cause notice under ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 had been issued by the Zonal Engineer (Buildings), City Zone, Municipal Corporation, it is clear that he had acted beyond his authority and power. (537 A-C) 8(11) There is no diapute that all the structures are below the ground. The main purpose of the upper basement i.e. a working platform measuring 6000 sq.ft. was meant to work the printing press. If the upper basement ·or the working platform constructed by the Expreaa Newspapers Pvt. ,Ltd. is demolished, the installation of the printing press itself in the lower basement with the sanction of the Delhi Development Authority under the appropriate statutory provision would be nullified and the Ezpreas Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. would not be in a poaition to operate the printing presa at all. Without the water storage tank the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. would not get tl.e completion certificate and it is difficult to understand how the underground tunnel passage, to connect the old and new Express Building would cause traffic hazard. At ey rate, such minor deviation would not result in a demolition of the Express Buildings. The manner in which the impugned notice was got iasued by the Municipal Corporation at the direction of respondent no.2 shows that it was done with an ulterior purpose, The illegality of the action is writ large and the manner in which it was done creates a ground for belief that the action was motivated. [538 C-EJ

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I.

B(iii) It is evident from page 16 of the Printed Master Plan and the zonal Development Plan for D-11 area at pages 935 and 936 that semi-basement, meaning a second basement is permissible under the Master-Plan as well as the ZOnsl Development Plan. The Bye-laws of the Delhi Municipal Corporation do not prohibit second basement and on the contrary bye-law 54 usea the term 'basements', Moreover, double basements have, in fact, been permitted in the case of many hoteis by the Delhi Development Authority. [543 B-ll) B(iv) lt is difficult to conceive how the huge printing press with a height of 24 ft. could be placed on a pedestal or be laid on the floor of the basement in such a manner as to discharge the newspapers on the ground floor. lt is COlllllOn ground that there is a working platform in all the other printing presses in the same line of buildings like that of the Times of lndia, the National Herald, Patriot and the old Indian Express Building. In all these buildings, the printing presses are installed in the lower basement and there is an over-hanging platform in the printing press in each of the buiidings to receive the printed material. Therefore, there is no justification of the working platform. If the Municipal Bye-laws do not permit the construction of a double basement then they would be clearly violative of Art.14, 19(l)(a) and 19(l)(g) of the Constitution. [543 F-il; 544 A) 9(i) The basic principle of eatoppel is that a person who by some statement or representation of fact causes another to act to his detri..,nt in reliance on the truth of it is not allowed to deny it late?, even though 1.t is wrong. Justice here prevails over truth. Estoppel is often described as a rule of evidence, but more correcUy it is a principle of law. As a principle of common law it applies onfy to representations about past or present facts• But there is also an equitable principle of promisSOl:Y estoppel' which can apply to public authorities. [545 E-F)

~·

9(11) In public law, the most obvious limitation on the doctrine of estoppel is that it cannot be evoked so as to give an overriding power which it does not in law possess. In other worda, no estoppel can legitimate action which is ultra vires. Another limitation is that the principle of estoppel does not operate at the level of Government policy. Es toppels have however been allowed to operate against public authority in minor matters of formality where no question of ultra vires arises. [548 A-C] In the instant case, the then Minister for Works & Housing actad within the scope of his authority in granting permission of

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(1985] SUP~.3 s.c.R.

the lessor i.e. the Onion of Inclis, Ministry of Works & Housing to the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to construct new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for installation of a printing press for publication of a Hindi newspaper under the Rules of Business framed by the President under Art.77(3). Therefore, the doctrine of ultra vires does not come into operation. In view of this, respondent no. l the Union of India is precluded by the doctrine of promissory estoppel from questioning the authority of the Minister in granting such pei:miasion. In that view, the successor Government was clearly bound by the decision taken by the Minister particularly when it had been acted upon. [548 0-F] Robertson v. Hinl.Jlter of Peuaiona L.R. [1949] I K.B. 227, 1laion of IDdia i Ora v. HI• lndo-Afghan AgeDcies Ltd. [1968] 2 s.c.R. 366 & Century SpimWlg & llanufacturing Ltd. & Anr • .,. Ullia81>agar llmlicipal eoi-u & Anr. [1970] 3 s.c.R. 854, HI•· llotilal Padapat Sugar Mills Co. (P) Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradeah & Ora. [1979] 2 s.c.R. 641 & Jit Ka Shiv~ & ors. v. State of ll8ryana &Anr. (1980] 3 s.c.R. 689 referred to.

eo.

Marltiae IU.ec. Co. Y• r.eneraJ Dair1e8 Ltd. [1937] A.c. 610 P.C. & Sout:lreod-ol>-5ea Corporation v. llodgren (V:lckforcl) Ltd. (1962] 1 Q.B. 416 distinguished. Judicial Review of Administrative Action 4th Edn. p.103 by Prof. De Smith & Administrative Law 5th Edn. p.232 by Prof. H.W.R. Wade, relied.upon.

(10) The Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. are liable to pay conversion charges in terms of cl.2(7) of the lease-deed and it is directed that the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing shall enforce its claim for recovery of conversion charges by a duly constituted suit or by making a law prescribing a forum for adjudication of its claim. It is also directed that the Municipal Corporation of Delhi shall colllpOund the construction nf the double basement of new Expreas Building, the excess basment beyond the plinth limit and the underground passage on payment of the usual CCllllpOsition fee. [555 B-<:]

l(i) The material available is sufficient to hold that the impugned noticea suffer from arbitrariness and non-application of llind. They are violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. Hence they are liable to be quashed. It is not necessary therefore to ezpresa any opinion on the contentions based on Article 19(l)(a) of the Constitution. (556 F]

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.r.

l(ii) The said notices were issued by the authorities concerned muler the Pressure of the second respondent. 'lbe question whether the notices should be issued o" not doea not appear to have been coosidered iDdependently by the concerned administrative authorities before issuing then. [555 F] l(iii) The Lt. Governor failed to make a distinction between the power with respect to the subject 'Property of the Union and the revenue therefran' which is in Entry 32 of !J.st I of the Seventh Schedule to the Coostitution and the general powers of administration entrusted to him muler Article 239 of the Constitution as tche Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi. The property in question is a part of the estate of the Central Government. Mere nearness to the seat of the Central Government does not clothe the Lt. Governor of Delhi with any p?Wer in respect· of the property of the Central Government. Be can discharge only those powers which are entrusted to him by the Coostitution and the laws. Moreover, all the powers of the former Chief Cooloissioner of Delhi have not devolved on the Lt. Governor and continue to vest in him. [ 556 B-D] 2(i) The question arising out of the lease, auch as, whether there has been breach of the covenants muler the lease, whether the lease can be forfeited, whether relief against forfeiture can be granted etc. are foreign to the scope of Article 32 of the Coostitution. lhey cannot be decided just on affidavits. These are matters which should be tried in a regular civil proceeding. One should remember that the property belongs to the Union of India and the rights in its cannot .be bartered away in accordance with the sweet will of an officer or a Minister or a Lt. Governor but they should be dealt with in accordance with lsw. At the same time a person who has acquired rights ill such property cannot also be deprived of then except in accordance with law. The stakes in this case are very high for both the parties and neither of then can take lsw into his own hands. [556 H; 557 A-BJ

2(ii) No opinion is expressed on the rights of the parties wider the lease and all other questi.oos argued in this case. They are left open to be decided in an appropriate proceeding. It io however, open to both the parties if they are so advised to take such fresh action as may be open to them in lsw on the basis of all the relevant facts including those which existed before the :Impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 was issued by the Engl neer Officer of the Land and Development Office to vindicate their respective rights in accordaw::e with lsw. This order is made without prejudice to the rights of the Union Government to

SUPRfilJE COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

compound the breaches, if any, comnitted by the lessee and to regularise the lease by receiving adequate premium therefor from the lessee, if it is permissible to do so. [557 C-E]

2(iii) It is open to the Delhi Municipal Corporation to examine the matter afresh independently and to take such action that may be open to it in accordance with i.aw. The Delhi Municipal Corporation· may, if so advised instead of taking any further action against the petitioners permit the petitioners to compound the breaches, if any, comnitted by them in accordance with law. [557 E-F]

Per Misra, J. l(i) The impugned notices threatening re-entry and demolition of the construction are invalid and have no legal value and must be quashed for reasons detailed in the two judginents. [557 H]

l(ii) The other questions involved in the case are based upon contractual obligations between the parties. These questions can be satisfactorily and effectively dealt with in a properly instituted proceeding or suit and not by a writ petition on the basis of affidavits which are so discrepant and contradictory. [558 A-BJ 2. The right to the land and to construct buildings thereon for running a business is not derived from Article 19(l)(a) or 19(l)(g) of the Constitution but springs from the terms of contract between the parties regulated by other laws governing the subject, viz., the Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Maater Plan, the Zonal Development Plan framed under the Delhi Municipal Bye-laws, 1959 irrespective of the purpose for which the buj]dings are constructed• 'Whether there has been a breach of the contract of lease or whether there has been a breach of the other statutes regulating the construction of buildings are the questions which can be properly decided by taking detailed' evidence involving exmnlnstion and cro•s-examination of witnesses. [558 B-D] ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Writ Petition Nos.535-539 of 1980. AND Review Petition No. 670 of 1985 (Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India) F.s. Nariman, P.H. Parekh, Arun for the Petitioners.

Jately and Pinski Misra

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.I. [A.P. SEN, J. J

Lal Narayan Sinha, M.M. Abdul Khader, Miss A. Subhaehini, c.v. Subba Rao and p,p, Singh for Respondent No.l.

Dr. L.M. Singhvi, Miss A. Subhashini and Roshan Lal Tandon for Respondent No. 2. Dr. L.M. Singhvi

and Miss

A. Subhashini for Respondent

No. 5. IJr, L.M. Singhvi, Miss A. Subhashini and Abishek Manu Singhvi for Respondent No.6.

The following Judgments were delivered by SEN, J, These petitions under Art. 32 of the constitution are by petitioner no.l, the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd., which is a company incorporated under the companies Act, 1956 engaged in the business of printing and publishing the national newspaper the Indian Express'(Delhi Edition) from the Express Buildings at 9-10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi, held on a perpetual, lease from the Union of India under a registered indenture of lease dated March 17, 1958. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of petitioner no.2, the Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) Pvt. Ltd. of which petitioner no.3 Ram Nath Goenka is the Chairman of the Board of Direc tors • Pe ti tioner no"' Nihal Singh was the then Editor-in-chief of the Indian Express and petitioner no.5 Romesh Thapar was the Editor of the Seminar published from the Express Buildings. Respondent no. l is the Union of India, no.2 is Jagmohan, Lt. Governor of Delhi, no.3 the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, no.4 the Zonal Engineer (Buildings), n.o.5 the Land & Development Officer, etc. The petitioners challenge the constitutional validity of a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease issued by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office, New Delhi dated March 10, 1980 purporting to be on behalf of the lessor i.e. the Government of India, Ministry of Works & Housing, New Delhi. The said notice required petitioner no.l, .the Express Newspapers Pvt.r.td., New Delhi to show cause why the Union of India should not re-enter upon and take possession of the demised premises i.e. plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg together with the Express Buildings built thereon under cl.5 of the aforesaid indenture of lease dated. March 17, 1958 for the alleged breach of els. 2(14) and 2(5) of the lease-deed. They also challenge the validity of an earlier notice dated March l, 1980 issued by the Zonal Engineer (Buildings), Municipal Corporation, City Zone,

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

Delhi to petitioner no.l, the Express Newspapers Pvt.Ltd., New Delhi to show cause why the aforesaid buildings being llilauthorized should not be demolished under ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957.

The petitioners allege thst the impugned notices of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease and of threatened demolition of the Express Buildings at Bahsdurshsh Zafar Marg, New Delhi which constitute the nerve centre of the newspaper the Indian Express which has the largest combined ~irculation among all the daily newspapers in India and is published simultaneously from eleven cities in the country, are wholly mala fide and politically motivated. They further allege thst the impugned notices constitute an act of personal vendetta against the Express Group of Newspap<1rs in general, and Ram Nath Goenka, chairman of the Board of Directors in particular, and are violative of Arts. 14, 19(l)(a) and 19(l){g) of the Constitution. We are informed thst a teleprinter is installed at the Express Buildings at Bahsdurshah Zafar Marg from where the Delhi edition of the Indian Express is published and the editorials, editorial policies and leading articles are transmitted to ten cities all over India from where the other editorials of the Indian Express are published simultaneously every day, namely, Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Bombay, Chandigarh, Cochin, Hyderabad, Madras, Madurai, Vijayawada and Vizianagaram.

The issues raised in this case are far-reaching in significance to the maintenance of our federal structure of · Govertllllent. It necessarily involves a claim by the Lt. Governor of Delhi that he hss the power and authority to administer properties of the Union of India within the Union Territory of Delhi which he is called upon to adlllinis ter • The questions presented are whether the Lt. Governor of Delhi could usurp the functions of the Union of India, Ministry of Works& Rousing and direct an investigation into the affairs of the Union of India i.e. question the legality and propriety of the action of the then Minister for Works & ·Housing in the previous Government at the Centre in granting permission to the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to construct the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for installation of a printing press for publication of a Hindi Newspaper on the western portion of the demised premises i.e. plots nos. 9 and 10, Babadutshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi with the Express Buildings built thereon.

The Lt. Governor asserts that he has the power and authority to adlllinister the properties·of the Union of India in the Union Territory of Delhi. The further question is whether the

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

grant of sanction by the then Minister for Works & Housing and the consequential sanction of building plans by him of the new Express Building was contrary to the Master Plan and the Zonal Development Plans framed under the Delhi Development Act, 1957 and the llllnicipal bye-laws, 1959 made under the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 and therefore the lessor i.e. the Union of India hsd the power to issue a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease under cl. 5 of the indenture of lease dated March 17, 1958 and take possession of the demised premi91'S together with the Express Buildings built thereon and the Municipal Corporation had the authority to direct demolition of the said buildings as unauthorized construction under ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957. The ultimate question is whether the threatened action which the petitioners characterise as arbitrary, illegal and irrational was violative of Art. 19(l)(a) read with Art. 14 of the Constitution. History of the matter

FACTS OF l'llE CASE

The facts are somewhat involved and present a feature which is r.ather disturbtng. It would be convenient to set forth the facts relating to the impugned notices. Put very briefly, the essential facts are these. On February 17, 1980, respondent no.2 Jaguxihsn assumed office as the Lt. Governor of Delhi. That very evening which was a Sunday, he summoned the Colllllissioner of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and called for the files relating.to the construction of the new Express Building at Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi. On the next day i.e. on the 18th mrning, the files relating to the grant of sanction for the construction of the same were made available to him. On February 20, 1980, some important files of the Delhi Development Authority relating to the Express Buildings were sent to respondent no.2. On February 29, 1980, respondent no.2 through the Comnissioner, Municipal Corporation of Delhi caused the locks of the office and cupboards of the Zonal Engineer (Building) to be broken open to take away 'the files relating to the new Express Building. J;mmediately thereafter i.e. on March l, 1980 respondent no.2 convened a press conference in which he handed over a press release alleging that the new Express Building put up by the petitioners was in contravention of law in several respects. The press release stated inter alia that :

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(1985) SUPP.3 s.c.R.

l. The government had been receiving complaints that additional space was sanctioned to the Indian Express Buildings in total disregard of tbe provisions of the Master Plan, zonal. regulations and Municipal Corporation bye-laws. 2. The Lt. Govemor had ordered an inquiry into the grant of sanction of the building plans in January 1979 by the Municipal Corporation for the construction of the new F.xpress Building and had entrusted the inquiry to a Buildiug and had entrusted the inquiry to a committee of three of his subordinate officials.

3. The committee had been asked to sub:nit its report within three days and the authorities of the DDA and the MCD had been separately directed to extend all co-.iperation to the commi.ttee and made available all relevant files and connected papers. 4. The Commissioner of the MCD had been separately advised to take inmediate action in regard to the unauthorized deviations made from the sanctioned plan in the construction of the new Express Building. The Lt. Governor also held out a threat at the press conference that the new Express Building might have to be demolished. The holding of the press conference was broadcast over ~he All India Radio within an hour and within two hcurs the Delhi Doordarshan telecast the same and read out the contents of the press release. It also exhibited the film both of the press conference as well as of the new Express Building. On the same day i.e. on March l, 1980, although the relevant files had been removed from his office, the Zonal Engineer (buildings). City Zone, Municipal Corporation served a IlOtice on petitioner no.l the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to show cause why action should not be taken for demolition of the Express Buildings undP.r ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957. It reads as under "Number 79/B/ua/cz/80'/;/.III

Dated 1.3.1980.

You are hereby informed that on your property situated at Bahadurshah Zafar Marg bearing nwnbers 9 & 10, you

have

started

unauthorized

construction

of

excess

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

basement beyond sanction and construction of upper basement without sanction as sJ-.own red in the sketch below. Therefore, I, L.S. Pal, Zonal Engineer (Buildin3) as authorized by the Comnissioner under D.M.c. Act, 1957 vide s. 49 to serve upon you notice and call upon you to appear in my office within three days of the receipt of this notice during office hours with all relevant records and documents relating to the above constructi.on to explain as to why· under sub-clause I of clause 343 as .to issuing for demolitl.on of unauthorized construction should not be issued. Please further note under sub-clause I of clause 344 you are ordered to stop construction work on this land failing which under sub-clauses 2 and 3 action will be taken against you and the construction will be demolished at your risk and cost.

C

Sd/(L.s. Pal) Zonal Engineer (Bldg.) Office Address : City Zone, Municipal Corporation, Delhi.

Served on : M/s. Indian Express Newspepers (P) Ltd. 9/10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, Delhi ...

Three days after i.e. on March 4, 1980, a second press release

was issued from the Raj Nivas, the official residence of respondent no.2. It was sent by a special courier to all newspaper offices to justify the action of resp.ondent no.2 in initiating an inquiry and the mode that had been prescribed for holding the inquiry. It stated "In regard to the unauthorized deviations fro:n the sanctioned plan and construction of about 23,000 sq.ft. in the lower basement and upper basement, the spokesman indicated that the show cause notice had been issued by the Corporation authorities. Further action would be taken in the light of the reply received by the party concerned."

ll

Jl

Again, the issue of the show cause notice figured in the third press release dated March 8, 1980 wherein under the heading "Additional Cons true tion in the Indian Express Buildings" the above extract was repeated verbatim· Respondent no.2 in his counter had asserted that the show cause notice was issued by the Coomissioner in accordance with his statutory functions after verification of the allegations. However, it is asserted that respondent no.2 being responsible for administration of the Union Territory of Delhi was obliged to ask all the authorities concerned

l!

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

to

prevent violation

of

lease

by any

person or

institution. Whereaa the files of the Corporation were SU11111>Jned by respondent no.2 before the press conference on March 1, 1980, the files of the Ministry of Works &Housing were summoned by him in the first week of March 1980. It is admitted by the Ministry of Wcoks & Housing that the said files were made available to respondent no.2 on March 7, 1980. On March 7, 1980, the Land & Development Officer acting as part of the overall plan of respondent no. 2 issued a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of the lease signed by the Engineer Officer in the Land & Development Officer under the Ministry of Works & Housing purporting to act for and on behalf of the President of. India under clause XIX of the agreement of lease alleging that there were breaches in contravention of cl· (ll) of the agreement for lease dated May 26, 1954. This notice was later withdrawn because it was realized that forfeiture of the lease had to be with reference to the registered indenture of lease dated March 17, 1958 and not under cl. XIX of the agreement for lease of 1954. On March 10,1980, the Engir.eer Officer in the Land & Development Office issued a notice in supersession of the said notice dated March 7, 1980 in these terma : No. L.II 10(2)/76 Government of India Mirdstry of Works & Housing Land & Development Office, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi, dated the 10.3.80. To The Manager, Express Newspapers Ltd., Post Box No. 751, Express Building, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.

l

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.)

Sub: Premises situated at plot nos. 9 &10 ,Delhi Mathura Road, New Delhi.

Dear Sir, I am to inform you that you have started the cons true tion of additional block on the land to be kept open without taking the permission from the lessor under the terms of lease, nor the plans were submitted by you for the sanction under the terms of lease by the lessor for the construction of multistoreyed building over open plot which is in contravention of clause 2(14) and 2(5) of the lease-deed. You are, therefore, hereby requested to show cause within 30 days from the date of receipt of this letter to why .the property should not be re-entered under clause 5 of the perpetual lease. Please take notice that if no satisfactory cause is shown within the stipulated period as referred to above, action t.o re-enter upon the premises will be taken against you without any further reference to you.

This is in supersession of this office letter of even no. dated 7.3.1980. Yours faithfully,

Sd/-(R. S •.Sibal) Engineer Officer For & on behalf of the President of India. Tele: 388727."

'

On March 12, l980·at a specially convened press conference

respondent no.2 released the report of the cODlllittee of his subordinates. The comnittee in its . report substantiated the allegations which respondent no.2 had aired at his press conference on March l, 1980 and through the press release dated March 4, 1980 and among other findings recorded that the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. was liable to pay Rs.35 · lakhs as conversion charges. From the report it appears that the Land & Development Officer hsd been functioning in close coordination with respondent no.2 as is evident from the following extract from the report of the Three"*"1nber Comnittee:

· "The representative of· Land & Development Officer who was present at the site was directed by the Comnittee

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

to take measurement of the new constructions. But the measurement could not be completed before the CollllJlittee left the site. Therefore. the representative of Land & Development Officer was aSked to complete the measurement by 10. 3.1980."

It is clear that there had been no application of mind by the

Engineer Officer in issuing the show cause notice.

The recital of these events clearly shows that reapondent no.2 displayed great zeal in causing a probe into the manner in which sanction was granted by the then Minister for Works & Housing for the construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for installation of a c printing press and the entire administration was geared into action with lightning speed so as to ensure that some action or other was taken against the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. This is evident from the fact, for instance, that he gave the Thre~ber CollllJlittee only thtee days to examine questions which, if they were properly scrutinized, would require inspection of the records from the year 1949 onwards of at least D six agencies viz. Ministry of Works & Housing, Land & Development Office in the Minis try of. Works & Housing, New Delhi Municipal Comnittee, Municipal Corporation of Delhi, Delhi Water Supply and Sewage Disposal Undertaking and the Union of India. He not only constituted a colllllittee of subordinates to go into the affairs of the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing but also procured E the files of the Central Government. The Ministry of Works ~. Housing apparently made available to the said Colllllittee all the relevant files of the Government pertaining to the new Express Building. There was no confidentiality maintained. Without the express authorization of the Government of India, respondent no.2 published the minutes of the proceedings of the Government. After F the suhnission of the report by the Three-Member Colllllit.tee, he on March 14, 1980 addressed a letter to the then Minister for Works & Housing to the effect :

<Xl!IFIDENTW. D.O.No.60/LG/80 March 14, 1980.

Dear Shti P.C. Sethi,

I am enclosing, for your information, a copy of the Enquiry Report in respect of the Indian Express Building. Some action msy H bcessary at the Ministry's end.

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.I. [A.P. SEN, J.J

I am seeking legal opinion to ascertain as to what action can be taken at this stage to salvage the situation created by irregularities and illegalities committed in this case. I will write to you further in the matter. With kind regards,

Yours sincerely, Sd/- (Jagmohan) Shri P.c. Sethi, Minister for Works & !lousing, Nirmlin Bhawan, New Delhi.

Encl: Enquiry Report" From the tenor of the letter is difficult to imagine that the Lt. Governor could address such a letter to a Union Minister. On the same day, the Lt. Governor also ruidressed to a letter on similar terma to the Vice-Chairman, Delhi Development Authority and the Comnissioner, Municipal Corporation of Delhi.

Execution of agreement for lease dated May 26, 1954: Allotment of plots nos. 9 & 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg to Express Newspapers Pvt.Ltd.

By an indenture styled as an 'agreement for lease'

executed

on May 26, 1954 between the late Feroze Gandhi, Managing Director, Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. of the one part and the Secretary (Local Self ,Government) to the Chief Commissioner of Delhi 'by the orders anci directions of the President of India' of the other part, the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. were allotted plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg in terms of the intended lease entered into between the parties on November 17, 1952, pursuant to the allotment of the said plots to the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. for construction of a four-storeyed building meant to be used for a newspaper, installation of a printing press therefore on the ground floor with residential accommodation for the staff on the top. Incidentally, the Central Government had in the year 1949 demarcated the press area along the Bahadurshah Zafar Marg consisting of 10 plots nos. l to 10 known as the Press Enclave as a cODDD.ercial complex for allotment to the press viz. to various newspapers like the Indian Express, Times of India, Patriot, National Herald etc. These other

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

newspapers like the Times of India, Patriot, National Herald were also granted similar plots on the same conditions and were allowed to build on the entire area of their respective plots without any restrictions whatsoever. The petitioners case is that the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. was first allotted plots no.l and 2 but later at the request of Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, the Prime Minister of India, it accepted instead plots nos. 9 and 10 as the Govermnent required plots nos. 1 and 2 for construction of the Gandhi Memorial Hall known as the Pearey Lal Bhawan. Preliminary work of construction of the Express Buildings Discovery of underground sewer line: Execution of fresh lease agreement dated November 19,1957. While the preliminary work of construction was started by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. on the basis of the aforesaid agreement, an underground sewer line was found be running diagonally across plots nos. 9 and 10. Thereupon, the parties entered into negotiations for modification of the said agreement. It was agreed between the parties that in view of the underground drain running through the plots, the Express Buildings would be constructed only to the east of the drain and in such a way as to leave the drainage system unaffected i.e. till the drain was diverted. The Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. was thus disabled from building on a substantial part of the land allotted to it until the underground drain was realigned outside the boundary of the two plots. In effect, an area of 2740 square yards to the west of the drain had to be left open as residual plot of the land out of the total area of 5703 square yards. The agreement was embodied in a document styled as a lease agreement executed between the parties on November 19, 1957 so as to protect the underground sewage drain and restrict the construction of the building to the ea~t of the drain. On April 11, 1956, J.N. Ambegaokar, Under Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Works & Housing addressed a letter to the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to the followi0g effect:

"I am directed to state that the allotment of land to the Indian Express Newspapers on the Delhi Ma thura Road, New Delhi, has been revised on the following basis: (i) 2965 sq. yards to the east of pipe line @ as. 1,25,000 per acre plus 2-1/2% annual ground

I

'

EXPRESS t<'EWSPAPERS v. U,Q,I, [A.P. SEN, J.]

\

rent thereon; (ii) 2740 sq. yards to the west of the pipe line @Rs. 36,000 per acre plus 2-1/2% per acre annual ground rent thereon. In addition to the premium as indicated above, .the following amount should also be recovered : (a) 50% of the ground rent of Rs. 2424 (@ 2-1/2% of the total premium of Rs.96,955) per annum for the period from 17 .11.1952 the date of original allotment to 14.1.1956 - Rs. 3838, (h) an advance ground rent for 1-1/2 years @ Rs. 2424 per annum - Rs. 3636." The revised allotment was subject, among others, to the following conditions : "The area of the west of the pipe line as mentioned in para l(ii) of this letter should be maintained as an open space i.e. as lawns, paths or parking ground. The lessor shall have the right to construct and maintain another sewer line along this land, if necessary." The letter went on to say that necessary instructions had been issued to the Chief Commissioner of Delhi in that behalf with a request that the Exp~ess Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. should get in touch with the Land & Development Office, New Delhi for taking possession of the land. It would appear from the letter that the Ministry of Works & Housing permitted the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to construct on plots nos. 9 and 10 to the east of the sewer line with a corresponding reduction in the amount of 'premium and

ground rent for the area west of the sewer line as compared to

the amount chargeable to the area east of the sewer line. Execution of the indenture of lease dated March 17, 1958 and the terms thereof. By a registered indenture of lease dated March 17, 1958 executed between the President of India of the one part and the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. of the other part, the Chief Commissioner of Delhi 'under the instruction of the Government of India relating to the disposal of building sites in the new Capital of India' demised on behalf of the Union of India in perpetuity the nazul land described therein in consideration of payment of a premium of Rs.96,955 admeasuring 1.179 acres of thereabout being plots nos; 9, 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg on payment of the yearly rent Rs.1212 stipulated therein for the period November 17, 1952 to January 14, 1956 and thereafter @

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 $,C.R.

Rs. 2424 per annwn. The lease-deed inter alia provided as per

cl.2(4) that the lessee shall keep tathe---.atisfaction of the Chief Col!lldssioner the area to the west of the sewer line running diagonally on plots nos. 9 and 10 from north-west to south-west admeaauring 2740 sq. yards as green i.e. as open space on which no building activity was permitted. The petitioner were charge premiwn at two different rates of the leasehold premises. The premiwn charged was at Rs.36,000 per acre for the area west to the sewer line and for tlie remaining portion, i.e. to the east of the sewer line on which construction of the building was permitted, the price of the land was fixed at Rs.l,25,000 per acre. It may be mentioned that the above perpetual lease was executed by Assistant Secretary (Local Self Government) to the Chief Col!lldssioner, Delhi by the oraer and direction of the President of India. Likewise, the earlier agreement dated November 19, 1957, s.o also the supplementary agreement of May 26, 1954 to which we shall presently refer, were executed by the said officer in the same manner. Both the agreements stipulated (under clause V of both) that the rules, regulationa and bye-laws of the Municipal corporation of Delhi rt!lating to bulldings which may be in force from time to time shall be conformed by the lessee. On November 17, 1964, a supplemental lease was executed between the President of India and the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. allowing the permanent change of user in respect of one lac square feet of the total accommodation of one and a half lac square feet i.e. two-third of the total acc011100dation in the Express Buildings for general office use, comnercial or otherwise, i.e. allowing the petitioners to sub-let upto 2/3rd of the floor area of the Express Buildings in lieu of payment of a awn of Rs.2,23,875 by them to the Union of India, the lessor, as an additional premiwn and in conaideration of their covenant to pay additional ground rent of Rs.5,746.88p. per annwn for the land demised over and above the rent reserved by the perpetual lease. Th~ recital in the deed was to the effect :

"The lessor doth hereby permit the lessee to use l,00,000 (one lac) sq.feet out of the total accollllllOdation of l,50,000 (one and a half lac) sq.ft. in the said Express Newspaper Building for general office use comnercial or otherwise, excluding coomercial ventures like hotel, cinema, restaurant etc. and subject to ·the other provisions and conditions mentioned in clause 7 of the said lease.

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U<O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

Provided further that the lessee shall all along continue to use least 50, 000 (fifty thousand) sq .feet of the accommodation in the said Express Newspaper Building for the use of press/presses, office/offices of its newspaper, publications and

at

other ventures." And that

"And this indenture further witnesseth that in consideration of the premises, the lessee doth hereby covenant to the lessor that the lt!ssee will pay an additional ground rent of Rs. 5746.88p. per annum as and from the 15th day of January 1960 over and above the ground rent reserved under the said principal lease to be paid by equal half-yearly payments from the 15th day of July each year as provided in the said principal lease-deed."

C

The effect was that the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing permitted permanent change of user of the existing Express Building by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. in respect of 1,00,000 sq.ft. of total accommodation. and it was permitted to let out 75,000 sq.ft. of the surplus accommodation with them to the State Trading Corporation for a period of 3 years from February 1, 1960 @Rs.60 per month per 100 sq.ft. with liberty to the State Trading Corporation to sublet any part of. the area over and above its own needs. At the time of cons true tion of buildings in the press area, there were no restrictiona as to the FAR permissible along with Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, also known as the Mathura Road Commercia: Complex, and the only restriction on conatruction of buildings in that area was that the allottees of the plots in the press area should construct buildings upto a height of 60 feet. Under the agreememt of lease dated May 26, 1954, the Express Newspapers l'vt· Ltd. was allowed to build upon the entire area of the plots in question being plots nos. 9 and 10 with a ground coverage of 100% i.e. edge-to-edge, a structure with a minimum of five storeys including the ground floor for the purpose of installation of a printing press for publication of a Hindi newspaper. This permission was granted il\ response to the plana submitted by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. and approved in writing by the Chief Commissioner of Delhi acting for and on bahalf of the lessor i.e. the Union of India. Such plana as

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

C

approved permitted construction by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. of a building on the entire area of plots nos. 9 and 10 with 100% ground coverage in conformity with the said agreement. Pursuant thereto, the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. constructed the old Express Building to the east of the sewer line with an FAR of 260 with reference to the entire plot leased to it i.e. plots nos. 9 and 10 although the building occupied only half of the area. After completion of the old Express Building to the east of the sewer line on March 14, 1958, the perpetual lease was executed on March 17, 1958, as already stated. The aforesaid supplemental lease was also executed on November l, 1964 permitting change of user i.e. enabling the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to sublet two-third of the accOUJmOdation available with it. At no stage did the Central Government go back upon their solemn comnibnent embodied in the agreement of lease dated May 26, 1954 under which the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. was entitled to construct a four storeyed Express Buildil18 on the entire area of plots nos. 9 and 10. They continued to recognize the right of the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to revert to the terms and conditions thereof as soon as the obstacle to further construction thereto that had been discovered, unknown to the parties that there was an underground sewage drain running through plots nos. 9 and 10 diagonally, was removed. In particular, they continued to recognize the right of the petitioners to build on the land kept as open space to the west of the sewer line, once the drain was diverted. This would be evident from the two facts : l. The Union of India being the lessor left with the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. the area to the west of the drain on a reduced premium because it had to be kept as an open space for protection of the drain. And 2. While nazul plots that are to be left open are valued at Rs • 4840 per acre and ground rent is assessed accordingly, the area to the west of the drain was assessed at Rs. 36,000 per acre implying thereby that it was not an area to be kept vacant in perpetuity. Constitutional Instruments relating to property of the Union in the Union Territory of Delhi.

EXPRESS Nll'WSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

On November 3, 1958 the President of India in exercise of his powers conferred by cl.2 of Arr.. 77 of the Constitution issued

the Authentication (Orders and Other Instruments) Rules, 1958 relating to, and dealing with, the conduct of business of the Government of India. In terms of the said Rules all Secretaries of the Ministries concerned were authorized to authenticate documents on bahalf of the government of India. On November 6, 1959 all functions relating to administration of leases of Government lands in Delhi were. transferred .from the Chief Conmissioner of Delhi (Local Self Government) to the Ministry of Works & Housing. On Janwn-y 18, 1961 the President in exercise of the powers under Az t. 77(3) of the Constitution made the Government of India (Allocation of Bµsiness) Rules, 1961. Rule 2 provided that the business of the Government of India shall be transacted in the Ministries, Departments, Secretaries and Offices specified in the First Schedule to the Rules. Rule 3 laid down that the distribution of subjects among the departments shall be as specified in the Second Schedule. Rule 4 enjoined that the President may on the advice of the Prime Minister allocate the business of the Government of India among Ministers by assigning one or more departments to the charge of a Minister. The Minis try of Works, Housing and Supply is specified in the First Schedule at serial no .19. Under the Second Schedule, the distribution of subjects in the Ministry of Works, Housing and Supply is allocated. Entries 1, 6 and 23 (a) and (1) come under the Ministry of Works, Housing and Supply and read as under : "l. Property of the Union (not being railway, naval, mill tary or air force works or being the property of the Department of Atomic Energy) except (i) butldings, the construction of which has been financed otherwise than from the civil works budget and (ii) buildings, the control of which has at the time of construction or subsequently, been permanently made over by the Ministry of Works, Housing and Supply to another Ministry."

"6, Allotment of Government lands in Delhi," "23. Administration of the Ministry and attached and subordinate organisations, namely :(a) Central Public Works Department;

**

**

**

(1) Land & Development Office."

**

**

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

In terms of the aforesaid Entries 1, 6 and 23 (a) and (1), all matters relating to the properties of the Union including allocation of Government lands in Delhi and the administration of the Land & Development Office were exclusively vested in the Ministry of Works, Housing and Supply, later the Ministry of Works & Housing.

Under Art. 299(1) of the constitution, the President issued a notification No. GSR 585 dated February 1, 1966 supersession of the earlier notification no. 1161 dated December l, 1958. The Land & Development Officer under Entry XXI, Item 7 was authorized to execute contracts assurance of property relating to matters falling within the jurisdiction of the Land &Development Office. The relevant Entry reads : "7. Iu the case of Land &Development Office

u

(i) All contracts and assurances of property relating to matters falling within the jurisdiction of Land & Development Officer; (ii) all contracts, deads and other instruments relating to or for the purpose of enforcement of the terms and conditions of the sale/ lease-deeds of the Government Built Property in Delhi/New Delhi;

(iii) auctioneering agreements, bonds of auctioneers and security bonds for the due performance of works by the auctioneers." However, by an overriding provisions contained in Entry XII, it was laid down thst 'notwithstanding the previous authorizations, any contract or assurance of property relating to any matter whatsoever may be executed by the Secretary, Special Secretary, Additional Secretary, Joint Secretary or Deputy Secretary to the Central Government in the appropriate Ministry or Deparbnent'. In terms .of the allocation of Business Rules of the Government of India, the Minis try of Works & !lousing was the appropriate authority for dealing with matters relating to lease of Government lands and in terms of the aforesaid notification no. GSR 585 issued under Art.299(1), the Secretary, Additional Secretary, Joint Secretary, Deputy Secretary and Under Secretary in the Ministry of Works & Housing were authorized to execute such contracts in the name of the President of India. It cannot therefore be doubted thst the Ministry of Works & !lousing with

j

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, J.]

the Minister at the head was and is the ultimate authority responaible for the following items of work, viz. "Property of the Union, Town & Country Planning, Delhi Development Authority, Master Plan of Delhi, Administration of Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Land & Development Office dealing with administration of nazul lands in the Union Territory of Delhi". The Ministry of Works & Housing was and also is the ultimate authority in respect of the powers, functions and duties of the Delhi Development Authority as well as the Municipal corporation of Delhi, including that of the Delhi Water Supply and Sewage Disposal Committee of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi ••

Statutory changes subsequently brought about in Delhi· It is common ground that the Delhi Development Act, 1957 is the paramount law on the subject viz. implementation of the Master Plan, Zonal Development Plan and Building Regulations, and overrides the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957. The Delhi Development Act came into force on December 30, 19.57. The provisions of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act were brought into force on different dates. S. 2 which is the definition clause, Chapter 11 relating the constitution of the Corporation and some other provisions were brought into force w.e.f. January 2, 1958, s. 512 on February 15, 1958 and the remaining provisions including Chapter XIV relating to building regulations were brought into force on April 7, 1958 •. On September 10, 1962 the Central Government approved the Master Plan for Delhi, prepared by the Delhi Development Authority under s. 7 of the Delhi Development ACt. The Master Plan makes specific regulations for comnercial areas and especially for already built-up comnercial areas i.e. walled city of Old Delhi. But the press area on the Mathura Road Comnercial Complex although specified as a commercial area is not Us ted in the list of already built-up comnercial areas which relate to the walled city of Old Delhi. On November 26, 1956 the Central Government approved the Zonal Development Plan for D-11 area prepared by the Delhi Development Authority under s.8 of the Act within which the press plots are located. It provided for an FAR of 400 for the press area in the Bahadurshah Zafar Marg.

c;

The material on record discloses that the construction of the new I>xpress Building with an incresed FAR of 360 with a

SUPREME COUR:r REPORTS

(1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

II

C

double basement was in conformity with els. 2(5) and 2(i4) of the perpetual lease-deed dated March 17, 1958 inasmuch as it was with the express sanction of the lessor i.e. the Union of India. It is also quite clear that Sikander Bakht, the then Minister for Works & Housing was th1.rughout guided by the officials of the Ministry particularly the Secretary, Ministry of Works & !lousing, who was the competent authority to act for the President with regard to any contract, grant or assurance of property of the Union relating to any manner whatsoever in relation thereto by virtue of the notification issued by the President under Art. 299(1) and further that the grant of such parmission was after the matter bad been dealt with at all levels and was in conformity with the orders of the then Vice-<:bairman, Delhi Developnent AUthority dated October 21, 1978 as one under 'special appeal'. After the formation of th" Janata Government at the Centre on March 22, 1977 the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. moved for the reiooval of the legal impedim2Ilt for the construction of the Express Building to the west of the sewer line first by moving the Municipal Corporation of Delhi for shifting of the sewer line outside plots nos. 9 and 10 and secondly, by moving the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works &Housing for grant of r-,quisite sanction to construct the new Express Building with an FAR of 400. On October 7, 1977 it wrote a letter to the Chief Engineer, Delhi Water Supply & Sewage Disposal Undertaking, Municipal Corporation of Delhi to inquire whether it was possible to realign the underground sewer line so that it would run outside their premises and were duly informed that the sewer line could be so shifted. Aecordingly on October 25, 1977 the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. addressed a letter to the Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing saying that additional construction on the western portion of plots nos. 9 and 10 leased out was possible after the sewer line shifted and that they were in need of a larger amount of because they wanted to start a Hindi newspaper and were also in need of an additional basement where the printing press would be located. It was pointed out that because of the underground sewer line running across these plots, no construction could be undertaken above the sewer line as they had to leave a safety distance of 25ft. parallel to the same and thus the built-up area available to them was almost reduced to half i.e. 2963 sq. yards while other presses in the area like the Times of India, National Herald, Patriot etc. were able to build over the entire extent of their respective plots. It accordingly requested the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing for permission to construct on the open space aclmeasuring

~

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

2740 sq.yards on the western side of plots nos. 9 and 10 indicating the permissible built-up area as also the terms on which the additional space could be so utilized. A copy of the letter was marked to the Land & De•elopment Office, Ministry of Works ~ Housing. On November 3, 1977 the Secretary instructed the Joint Secretary to call a representative of the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. and the Land & Development Officer and evolve a solution. The Joint Secretary (Delhi Division) directed the Under Secretary (Land Division) to do the needful, Incidentally, the Ministry has two separate divisions, the Delhi Division and the Land Division, both working under the control of the Joint Secretary (Delhi Division). Delhi Division deals with matters pertaining to the Delhi Development Authority and Urban Development while the Land Division deals with matters relating tc> allotment of government lands and administration of lease. It follows that the Delhi Division was competent to deal with matters relating to construction of the new Express Building including the pennissible FAR and the grant of permission to the lessor under the lease and the question of payment of additional premium etc. had to be dealt with by the Delhi Division.

Accordingly, on November 14, 1977, R.K. Mishra, General Manager and authorized representative of Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. waited on the Under Secretary, (Land Division), Ministry ·Of Works & Housing and was verbally informed that the requisite permission of the lessor could be sought after the building plans were approved by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and it was then that they should seek the approval of the lessor and at that time the Ministry would intimate what additional premium, i f any, was payable. The Under Secretary also recorded a note to that effect. Thereafter on December 7, 1977 petitioner no.3 Ram Nath Goenka addressed a letter to Sikandar Bakht, the then Minister for Works & Housing drawing his attention to the aforesaid meeting where the representative of Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. had been intimated that they should first submit their building plans to the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and thereafter seek permission of the lessor which would advise them of the amount of premium payable for the change of user. He requested the Minister to issue necessary instructions directing that the plots in the press area should be treated as commercial complex which entitled the plot-holders to build over the entire area of the respective plots subject to the restriction of a height of 60 ft. as stipulated in 1951 without any restriction as to the area of various floors. There followed a meeting in the Ministry of Works & Housing on December 20, 1977 when the General Manager of Indian

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] sUPP.3 s.c.&.

Express and an official of the Delhi Development Authority were present and the extent of FAR permissible was specifically discussed. This was followed by a letter of the General Manager dsted December 23, 1977 to the Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing iµ which he referred to the meeting where it was felt that although the press area was not expressly mentioned in the Master Plan, it would still fall under the general description of 'other comnercial areas' where only an FAR of 300 was permissible and that it would be so despite the fact that no such limitation existed when the press complex was established. He referred to the letter of Ram Nath Goenka dsted December 7, 1977 to the Minister wherein permission to build on the entire area of the plots in question was sought. A copy of the letter was endorsed to the Minister. On December 30, 1977 the Chief c Engineer, Delhi Water Supply & Sewage Disposal Undertaking wrote a letter to R.K. Mishra, General Manager, Indian Express stating . that it would cost Rs. 2.5 lakhs to divert the sewer line and that the completion of work would take about five months after the deposit was made. This was in reply to the letter sent by Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. on October 12, 1977. Accordingly, the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. on December 31, 1977 wrote to the Deputy Secretary, Ministry of Worl-.s & Housing that the limicipal Corporation of Delhi i.e. the Delhi. Water Supply & Sewage Disposal Undertaking had indicated that the undergro"und drain could be shifted so that it would run outside the lease hold premises and therefore there should be no objection to the cons true tion of the new Express Building, and requested the Ministry for advice on the FAR permissible for the said building.

According to the note recorded by the Minister on the margin of the letter of petitioner no.3 Ram Nath Goenka dated December 7, 1977, instructions were to be issued to the Delhi Developnent Authority to examine the question. On January 7, 1977 J.B.D'Souza, Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing recorded a detailed note and put it up to the Minister. It appears that he discussed the case with the Minister on the 7th and explained to him that the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. had already used up an FAR of 260 with reference to their leasehold premises i.e. plots nos. 9 and 10 although they had occupied about half of the land with their building. It was recorded in the note that the assertion that others in the press area had an FAR of 500 was not factually correct. Maxinrum FAR for all the press plots was 300 and below except in the case of Times of India where it was 304 and the National Herald where it was 306. 3. According to him, the effect of allowing the petitioners to erect similar building on

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

the other half would mean a rise of FAR from 300 to 400. Perhaps an increase from 260 to 360 should be permitted if the need for starting a newspaper in Hindi was really genuine. The portion to the west of the sewer line was kept as open and was being used for parking of cars, and these would have to be parked out on the road, apart from the extra parking need that the additional construction would give rise to. The Minister asked the Secretary to discuss the matter with Petitioner no.3 Ram Nath Goenka and arrive at a suitable solution. As a result, the Secretary noted as below : "I find it difficult to recommend the FAR requested by Shri Goenka, as this will inevitably lead to requests from"other plot-holders, including the Times of India, to use up their entire· land area for building upto 60 feet, which will mean in effect a rise of FAR from 300 to 400. The effect on parking and other requirements may not be acceptable.

r

At the same time it is undeniable that Shri Goenka is unable to retrieve from his tenants a considerable part of his existing building, and i f his needs of starting a newspaper are really genuine~ some considerable concession will be needed. Perhaps an increase from 260 to 360 should be permitted; with the extra .basement area the firm will build this should give i t nearly 50,000 extra sq.feet of area."

C

On January 18, 1978, the Minister for Works & Housing concurred with the views of the Secretary and ordered as below:

"I agree. In the circumstances stated, 'A' above is the farthest we should accommodate. May process further accordingly."

The Ministry of Works & Housing by letter dated February 2, 1978 conveyed to the Vice-Chairman, Delhi Development Authority the decision of the Union of India to permit the petitioners to build with an FAR of 360 as below "It has been decided that FAR in this case may be increased up to 360 so that with the extra basement area the firm would have an additional built-up area of nearly 50,000 sq.feet. You are requested to take necessary actio~ in the matter."

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 S.C.R.

Copies of this letter were endorsed to the Town & Country Planning Organisation and Officer Inchrage, Master Plan in the Delhi Development Authority. The Additional Secretary, (Master Plan), Delhi Development Authority however maintained that the FAK permissible for the press area was only 300 with 80% ground coverage, 70~ on the first floor and 50 % on the second, third and fourth floors. Another letter dated March 6, 1978 was addressed by petitioner no.3, Ram Nath Goenka, to the Minister in which he reiterated the earlier request made by him for allowing the •petitioners to build on 100% of the plinth area, only with the height restriction of 60 feet. It stated that the Minister had informed him that an order allowing the petitioners to build upto an FAR of 360 had already been passed and further construction beyond it would be sanctioned later. lnmediately thereafter the Ministry of Works & Housing took a decision adverse to the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. On April 15, 1978, P.B. Rai, TCP.:.II put up a note objecting to the Government decision to increase the FAR to 360 on the ground that it was in total contravention of the Master Plan and would have serious implications. It is a long note, relevant part of which may be extracted : "As per Master Plan, FAR 300 in commercial areas does not exist for any area in Delhi whatsoever."

further stated that such a decision to permit construction upto an. FAR of 360 would not be implemented by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi as their existing bye-laws and rules permitted construction upto 300 only and added that the rules and bye-laws should not be modified for one particular case or building or for one particular commercial area.

He

Upon the receipt of the TCP-II 's note, the Joint Secretary (Delhi Division) on May 6, 1978 directed the Deputy Secretary to put up a clear note for obtaining the orders of the Secretary Ministry of Works & Housing and the Minister because the petitioners wanted to build the 100% coverage, while the TCP-II's note showed that the permissible FAR was 300. Accordingly, the Under Secretary put up a detailed note on May 8, 1978 explaining the various view points, bye-laws etc. and recommended reduction of FAR to 300. On the same day, the Deputy Secretary marked the file to the Joint Secretary. On May 18, 1978, the Joint

EXPRESS NEWSPAPE).{S v. U.o.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

Secretary, (Delhi Division) pointed out that the petitioners were not happy with FAR 360 against their original demand of 500 and they now wanted FAR 430.67 while the maximum FAR permissible was 300 as pointed out by the Secretary (Master Plan), Delhi Development Authority. He therefore recommended restriction of the FAR to 300 as per the bye-laws of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and the Secretary endorsed the said recommendation. Therefore, the Minister approved of the restriction of the FAR to 300. On May 19, 1978, M.N. Buch, Vice-Chairman,' Delhi Development Authority wrote to the Joint Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing stating that the Government's decision of FAR 360 was "totally unacceptable and added that 'making of exceptions of this nature was precisely the stick with which the Delhi Development Authority was beaten' for its own office building i.e. Vikas Minar which far exceeded FAR 400 and was in breach of all buHding bye-laws. He accordingly suggested that FAR 300 might be permitted with the condition that necessary parking facilities would have to be provided. On May 24, 1978, the Deputy Secretary recorded a note directing that further action to implement the said decision of the Minister to restrict the FAR to 300 may be taken by the Land & Development Officer. On June 9, 1978, the Deputy Secretary, Delhi Development Authority informed the Vice-Ghairman of the decision of the government restricting the FAR to 300.

It appears that the case was revived on July 14, 1978 when Sikandar llakht, Minister for Worka & Housing wanted to know after some representative of Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. had visited his office, if the press ares and the FAR therefor were mentioned in the Master Plan and whether or not the FAR achieved for the Express Buildings was 500, it would not operate for fresh construction in the press area for which the FAR was not to exceed 300. A meeting was fixed to discuss the matter in the room of the Minister on August 18, 1978 and the following note was recorded by D'Souza, Secretary in the Ministry of Works & Housing regarding the discussions : "The JS(D), the Vice-Chairman, DOA and I met the Minister today and explained the undesirability of allowing the Indian Express Higher FAR than already proposed in this case, particularly the repercussions it would have on the othe.r occupants of plots on this roacl. The Vice-Chairman suggested

SUPREMI:: COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

another possibility, namely, allotting to the Indian Express some other land where it could put up a building. The Vice-Chairman said he would get in touch with Shri Goeiika and put this proposition to him." The Minister agreed with the Vice-Chairman's, suggestions."

On October 21, 1978, M.N. Buch, Vice-Chairman, Development Authority took the following decisions :

Delhi

"(a) to amalgamate plots nos. 9 and 10 and taking into account the existing built-up area would permit on FAr of 360 overall;

(b) to allow the residual area of plots nos. 9 and 10 to be built. in line with the Times of India and Shama building; (c) to exclude the basement from the calculations of the FAR provided the basements are not used for office purposes;

(d) to permit parking on the service road in the same manner as it was for the other buildings in this line, adequate parking facilities would also have to be provided in the set back of approximately half portion of the line which has been suggested by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. in the drawings."

He further directed that the aforesaid order was to be treated as one under special appeal. He accordingly gave instructions for issuing 'no objection' to the Express authorities for construction on the residual area and to make a reference to the

Government of propo"sed.

India asking for

confirmation of

The Vice-Chairman in his

the

action

order mentioned that the

Minister for Works & Housing had ordered that the cases should be cleared immediately and his ex post facto sanction obtained by

the Delhi Development Authority. - - - On November 4,

1978, R.D. Gohar, Joint Director (Buildings),

Uelhi Development Authority addressed a letter to the petitioners

to the effect : "The plans submitted by you have been examined. I am ti

directed to inform you that there is no objection to

<:Xl'KESS NEWSPAPE!{l) v. u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, .J.j

amalgamation of plots nos. 9 and 10 and allowing an overall FAR of 3.6 taking into account the existing FAR. In that case the existing building line of the adjoining plots shall have to be maintained. The basemen< has been excluded from the calculation of the FAR and the installation of Press Machinery like any other service machinery is permitted. The parking on the service road is permitted in the same manner as it is for other buildings in this lirte. However, adequate parking facility shall have to be provided in the open area which may be so planned to make usable for parking purposes." On the detailed examination of the lay-out plan, he observed that as per FAR of 360 construction was permitted on 1,84,886.07 sq.feet as against the existing FAR covering an area of 1,29,028 sq.feet i.e. the overall ground coverage now permitted was 13.81% i.e. 37904.92 sq. feet. The petitioners were directed to submit the plans to the concerned authorities for approval. A set of plans as submitted by the petitioners and examined 'as per norms' was enclosed. On November 17, 1978, the Vice-Chairman, Delhi . Development Authority addressed a letter to the Ministry of Works & Housing reconnnending extension of FAR from 300 to 360. On November 24, 1978 the Government of India, Ministry of Works & Housirig addressed the following letter to the Vice-Chairman, Delhi Development Authority

'B

C

"No .K-12016/Z/78-DDA Government of India. Ministry of Works & Housing (Nirman Aur k."BB Mantralya)

r' New Delhi, the 24th November, 1978. To The Vice-chairman. Delhi Development Authority, Vikas·Minar, New Delhi. Sub: Plots nos. 9 and 10, llahadurshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi.- Request for additional Coverage.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

Sir, With reference to your D.O. Letter No. PA/VC/78/874 dated 17.11.78 and in supersession of this Ministry's letter of even number dated 9.6.1978, I am directed to say th;lt, as proposed by

ll

you, the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. may be allowed to construct on the residual plot on the basis of an FAR 360 for the whole plots. Yours faithfully, sd/- (V.S. Katara) Joint Secretary to the Government of India.

Copies of the letter were endorsed to the Coumissioner, Municipal Corporation of Delhi, Land & Development Office, Town & Country Planning Organisation and Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. This was followed by a clarificatory letter from the Ministry of Works & Housing to the Vice-Chairman dated December 1, 1978 that the FAR 360 allowed excludes the entire area of basement as per the provisions of the Master Plan. The permission granted by the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing for the construction of new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 as accorded by Sikandar Bakht, the then Minister for Works & Housing was acted upon by the petitioners by cons true ting the four-s toreyed new Express Building by the end of February, 1980. As already stated, this was done with the sanction of the Delhi Development Authority and the Municipal Corporation of Delhi.

Pleadings of the Parties

r. Petitioners' Case

In the facts and circumstances hereinbefore adumbrated, the petitioners pleaded inter alia that : 1. The proposed action of re-entry by the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing at the instance of the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi is meant to be a.n act of political vendetta. The impugned notices have been issued with an evil eye and an unequal hand and with a deliberate design to compel

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

the petitioners to close down the Express Group of Newspapers in general and the Indian Express in particular. The said notices are ex facie illegal and without jurisdiction and are contrary to the factual and legal provisions. The arbitrary and discriminatory initiation of executive action under the guise of alleged infraction of the terms of the lease and/or the Master Plan of Delhi and/or the municipal building bye-laws is violative of the petitioners' fundamental rights under Arts. 14, 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. 2. The construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 was in conformity with clause 2(5) of the perpetual lease dated March 17, 1958 inasmuch as it was with the express sanction of the lessor i.e. the Union of India. The grant of permission by Sikandar Bakht, the then Minister for Works & !lousing to sanction the construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 was in accordance with the Master Plan, after M.N. Buch, Vice-Chairman, Delhi Development Authority by his order dated October 21, 1978 as "one under special appeal" under the Master Plan, Chapter 11, Part A, Zoning Regulations, Item 13, Use Zone - C-2, at p.50 directed that plots nos. 9 and 10 at Bahadurshah Zafar Marg leased to the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. should be 'amalgamated together into one plot and taking into account the existing buHt-up area occupied by the old Express Building built on the eastern portion of the underground sewage drain with an FAR of 260, the construction of the new Express ·Building on the western portion thereof after removal of the sewer line with an overall FAR of 360 was permissible'. 2. The then Minister for Works & Housing was throughout guided by the officials of the Ministry, particularly the Secretary, Ministry of Works & !lousing, who was the compet~nt authority to act for the President with regard to any contract, grant or assurance of property of the Union relating to any matter whatsoever in relation thereto by virtue of the notification issued by the President under Art. 299(1). In terms of the Government of India (Allocation of Business) Rules, 1961 as well as und~r

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

the aforesaid notification under Art.299(1), the Ministry of Works & Housing with the Minister at the head was and is the ultimate authority responsible to deal with the property of the Union and to enter into all contractual obligations in relation thereto. The Minister had not only full authority, power and jurisdiction to grant permission to the petitioners to construct the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for the installation of the printing press, but the action taken by the then government was in good faith. after taking into consideration all the circumstances attendant at all levels. 3. After the shifting of the underground sewer line outside the leasehold premises at the cost of the petitioners to the tune of Rs. 6 lakhs and on payment of the supervision charges to the Municipal Corporation amounting to Rs. 25,000, there could be no objection to the construction of the new Express lluilding with an increased FAR of 360 as it allowed the residual area of plots nos. 9 and 10 to be built in line with the Times of India, National Herald, Patriot and other buildings along the Bahadurshah Zafar Marg. At the time of the grant of plots nos. 9 and 10 to the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd., there were no restrictions as to the FAR in the construction of buildings along the Bahadurshsh Zafar Marg. Further, that the Master Plan for Delhi subsequently approved by the Central Government in the year 1962 does not mention the press area on the Bahadurshah Zafar Marg comprising of the press enclave. Although specified as a coumercial area, it is not listed in the list of "already built-up commercial areas" because it relates to the walled city of Old Delhi. The zonal development plan for D-II area within which the press plots are located permitted an FAR of 400 Jor the press area in the Bahadurshah Zafar Marg. In short, the submission is .that all that the then Minister for Works & Housing did was to restore to the petitioners the right that they acquired under the perpetual lease dated March 17, 1958 i.e. to be treated alike all other plot holders in that area and a denial of such equal terms would be opposed to the principles of equality besides being violative of Art. 14 of the Constitution.

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

4. The lessor i.e. the Union of India is estopped by the doctrine of promissory estoppel. and cannot therefore go back upon all assurances given and actions taken by the previous government, particularly when the petitioners had acted upon the decisions so reached and had constructed the new Express Building with a cost of approximately Rs.1.30 crore by February 1980 which at present would cost more than Rs. 3 crores. In substance, the petitioners contend that where permission of the lessor i.e. the Union of India has been granted in relation to any property of the Union under a lease by the authority competent i.e. the Ministry of Works & Housing, it is not competent for the successor government to treat such permission as being non est and to proceed as if no such permission or-sanction had been granted. 5. The impugned notice issued by the Zonal Engineer (Building), City Zone, Municipal Corporation of Delhi dated March 1, 1980 upon the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to show cause why the Express Buildings should not be demolished under as. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 was illegal and ineffective inasmuch as the construction of the sald building was not without or contrary to the sanction referred to in s. 336 or in contravention of any of the provisions of the Act or bye-laws made thereunder. The threat to demolish the second basement especially when similar double basement/platform exists in other newspaper buildings in the press area such aq the Times of India, National Herald, Patriot etc. along the Bahadurshah Zafar Marg was violative of Arts. 14 and 19(1)(a) of the Constitution. The denial of the respondents to allow such a double basement to be constructed by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. in the new Express Building clearly infringes the petitioners' right to free speech and expression guaranteed under krt. 19(1)(a) which includes the freedom of the press as otherwise the printing apparatus installed in the lower basement would be rendered incapable of operation and is. therefore a ~qua ~ for the printing and publication of the Indian Express. 6. The erection of the double basement or a working

platform in a

printing

press

like

the

Express

I)

SUPl®IE COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. is s compoundable deviation from the sanctioned plan and the insistence of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi to demolish the same suffers from the vice of hostile discrimination. Even assuming that the llllilicipal bye-laws do not permit the construction of a double basement in the press area along the Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, such bye-laws would 8IJl)unt to an unreasonable restriction on the right to carry on the business of printing and publishing the newspaper and thus offends Art. 19(l)(g) of the Constitut;l.on. 7. Respondent No.2 Jagioohsn, Lieutenant-Governor of Delhi, cannot usurp the functions of the Union of India in relation to the property of the Union in the Union Territory of Delhi, and that the Lieutenant Governor ia not a successor of the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi. There wss no notification issued by the. President under Art. 239(1) of the Constitution for the conferral of any power on the Lieutenant-Governor to adioinister the lease in question. No doubt, by virtue of the notification issued by the President on September 7, 1966 under Art. 239(1), the LieutenantGovernor has, subject to the like control by the President, the same powers and functions as well as exercisable by the Chief cOIIlllissioner with power to administer the property of the union. There is, admittedly, no such notification issued by the President under Art. 239(1) vesting either the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi or the Lieutenant-Governor with sny such power.• 8. In sny event, i t is inconceivable that after October 1, 1959 when the administrative control over the Land & Development Officer was transferred from the llelhJ. Administration to the Ministry of Works & Housing and by virtue of a notification issued under Art. 299(1), the Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing was made the competent autl\ority to act for the President with regard to any contract, grant or assurance of property of the Union, the LieutenantGovernor could still arrogate to himself the powers of the Union of India, Minis try of Works & Housing in re la tion to the lease.

I

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

9. It is alleged that respondent no. 2 Jagmohau is actuated with personal bias against the Indian Express and had filed a criminal complaint against the Chief Editor of the Indian Express and some of the officers of the Express Group of Newspapers for having published an article in the Indian Express in April 1977 with regard to his role during the period of Fmergency in Turkman Gate demolitions. The Express Group of Newspapers, particularly the Indian Express, had during the period of Fmergency and imnedia tely thereafter openly criticized the high handed actions of respondent no.2 Jagmohan who was the then ViceChairman of the Delhi Development Authority for which he was later indicated by the Shah Comnission of Inquiry. 10. The Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. contend that they having approached the Central Government for exercise of its powers under s.41 of the Delhi Development Act, 1954 for the issue of necessary directions as regards the permission to build the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for the installation of the printing press which became necessary due to want of any provision in that behalf in the Master Plan and the Zonal Development Plan in regard to the press enclave and the Central Government having issued directions under the relevant provisions, in terms of s. 53(3A) of the Act, the sanction of the plan by the Delhi Development Authority by its letter November 4, 1978 pursuant to such directions and its authentication of the building plans approvii:g the portions objected to by the Municipal Corporation, Delhi, overrides and makes irrelevant any other sanction granted by the Municipal Corporation subject to any qualification. 11. The impugned notice issued by the Zonal Engineer (Building), City Zone, Municipal Corporation of Delhi dated March 1, 1980 was illegal and void as he did not apply his mind at all to the question at issue but merely issued the same at the instance of respondent no.2. Further, the impugned notice issued by th~ Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office dated March 10, 1980 purporting to act on bahalf of the lessor i.e. the Union of India was factually and

u

SUPl\EME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

legally not a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of the lease as contemplated by els. 5 and 6 of the lease-deed, based as it was on non-existent ground. Although the lease-deed permits remedy of any breach of any of the terms thereof, the opportunity to effect such a remedy has not been, and as indeed it is clear, it is not intended to be, granted to the petitioners and instead, there is a threat of re-entry upon the leasehold premises upon forfeiture of the lease.

n. Bespondents Case

lJ

Ii

l. Respondent No.2·Jagmohan, Lt. Governor of Delhi filed a counter on behalf of all the respondents asserting that the perpetual lease-deed dated March 18, 1958 was executed on behalf of the lessor by the Assistant Secretary to the Department of Local Self Government 'under the administrative control of the Chief Comnissioner/Lt. Governor of Delhi'; that the demise land is nazul land vested in the President of India, for the management, control and disposal of which the Land &Development Officer in the Department of Local Self Government, was created; and that as a matter of fiscal policy, the administrative control of the Land & Development Office, New Delhi was transferred from the Delhi Administration to the Ministry of Works, Housing and Supply w.e.f. October 1, 1959. It was asserted that this transfer was 'purely on fiscal grounds' and did not divest the Chief Commissioner/Lt. Governor of his contractual powers, ~iven to him by the parties to the lease-deed, as the representative of the President of India and the Head of the Local Self Government. It was averred that according to cl.2(14) of the perpetual lease-deed the land to the west of the sewer line was to be kept as an "op~n space" i.e. as lawns, paths or parking grounds to the satisfaction of the Chief comnissioner and only the lessor or the Chief Commissioner had the right to interfere with the maintenance of this area and that too only for the purpose of laying a new sewer line along the existing one. According to cl.2(9) thereof, no excavation in the demise premises should be made without the written consent of the Chief Commissioner/Lt. Governor of Delhi. Admittedly,

EXPRESS fil.'WSPAPERS v. u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, J.]

no permission from the Chief Commissioner/Lt. Governor pursuant to els. 2(9) and 2(14) was obtained by the petitioners. It was further asserted that the sewer line, according to the terms of the lease, could not be diverted by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi at the cost of the petitioners without the consent of the Chief Commissioner /Lt. Governor. The petitioners had no right under the lease to change the character of this land which was to be maintained and by suppression of material facts obtained permission to build thereon sanction of building plans from authorities which they knew, under the terms of the lease was not permissible. 2. In refuting the allegations made by the petitioners that Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office had at the instigation of the Lt. Governor issued the impugned notice for forfeiture of the lease, respondent no.2 asserted that he had not ordered the issuance of the notice in question and that the Land & Development Officer was an authority independent of the administrative control and supervision of .the Lt. Governor. It was asserted that the impugned show cause notices were issued by authorities ·which are independent of the authority of Lt. Governor or by autonomus local bodies. It was asserted The impugned >how cause notice by respondent no.5, the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office was issued only after he came to know through Press Reports of certain serious violations of the lease-deed by the petitioners. The show cause notice by respondent no.; was issued in exercise of powers under cl.4 of the perpetual lease-deed dated March 17, 1958 for violation of els. 2(5), 2(9) etc. As regards the impugned show cause notice issued by the Zonal Engineer (Building), City Zone, Municipal Corporation of Delhi, it was ·asserted that the same had been issued by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi in exercise of its statutory powers under ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act after verification of the allegations. 3. Respondent no.2 has sought to disown all responsibility for the issuances of two impugned show cause notices but asserted that being the Lt. Governor of Delhi, he was responsible for the administration of

I!

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

the Union Territory of Delhi and as such he was acting within his powers to direct all the authorities concerned to prevent violation of laws by any person or institution. He further asserted that he, as the Lt. Governor of Delhi, was fully competent to appoint the Enquiry Coom1ttee under the Coom1ssion of Inquiry Act, 1952. It was denied that the Union of India or the Lt. Governor of Delhi intended to inflict a reprisal on the petitioners for the independent state of the newspapers they publish. It was added : "The respondents while welcoming, creative and constructive criticism of Government policies and actions only expect a minimum standard of decency and fairness from the Press." 4. It was alleged that the petitioners indulged in all sorts of "Distortions and fabrications in criticising the policies and actions of the Union of India and the Lt. Governor" and despite all this, respondent no. 2 had taken an indulgent view of these delinquencies except when "he had to file a criminal complaint against Express Newspapers Pvt· Ltd." to uphold his self-respect and dignity", and some of the petitioners have been summoned to stand their trial by a Court of competent jurisdiction. It is not disputed that respondent no.2 had filed a criminal complaint in Criminal Case No. Nil of 1979 in the Court of the Learned Metropolitan Magistrate, New Delhi against petitiooer no.4 for having coom1tted alleged offences punishable under ss. 500, and 501 of the Indian Penal code, 1860 for having published a news item regarding the active role played by him in the demolition of houses near Turkman Gate in Delhi , which rendo>red thousands of persons destitutes and hom.,less which became the subject of an enquiry by the Shah Coomission during the Emergency. Respondent no.2 makes a special pleading of the demolition of the Turkman Gate operation during the Emergency by him as ViceChairman of the Delhi Development Authority which he styled as a clearance operation undertaken for the resettlement of the vast multitude of poor people. who were vie t1ms of exploitation at the hands of vested hands and compelled to live in sub-standard human living conditions of dirt and squalor stating that the

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, J.]

clearance operation was undertaken for improving the

standard of living of the poor and their resettlement. While admitting that he had filed a criminal complaint against the Editors, Printers and Publishers of the Indian Express for defamation, he denies that the respondents had any personal animosity towards the Express Group of Newspapers and asserted that the criminal complaint for defamation was instituted because the Indian Express was guilty of fabricating and publishing false, motivated scandalous stories about respondent no.2 and others.

5, Respondent no. 2 controverted that the contractual relations between the parties were governed by the lease agreement dated May 26, 1954 which was modified and superseded by the subsequent lease agreement dated November 19, 1957, since this had also been substituted by the registered perpetual lease dated March 17, 1958 which alone, according to him, governed the relationship effectively and legally between the Union of India and the Lt. Governor of Delhi on the one hand and the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. on the other. It was denied that the Deputy Secretary, Ministry of Works & llousing, Government of India had any jurisdiction or authority to permit diversion of

the sewer line as he was not authorized to represent

the Central Government for the purpose of administration of the lease and, therefore, any attempt on the part of the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to rely upon the agr~ement of 1954 or on the subsequent agreement of 1957 to justify the action of the Municipal Corporation' of Delhi in shifting the sewer line beyond the leasehold premises was an exercise in futility. It was asserted that cl. 2(5) of the perpetual lease could not be availed of by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. in the absence of a permission granted by representative of the lessor, meaning .the Chief Commissioner/Lt. Governor or the Land & Development Officer and, therefore, the removal of the sewer line itself was illegal and did not create any right in the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd.

to raise any construction on the land to the west of the old sewer line which was to be kept as "green". It

was denied that by virtue of the transfer of functions relating

to

administration

of

leases

executed on

ll

SUPREl'iE COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

bahalf of the Union of India, the Chief Commissioner/ Lt. Governor was divested of all the powers conferred

on him by the various clauses of the lease-deed. It was asserted that the transfer of the functions was only an administrative measure to achieve the desired fiscal discipline in the matter of administration of properties of the Union of India. Even after the transfer of functions to the Land & Development Officer, it was said that all lease agreements are being referred to the Lt. Governor of Delhi for exercise of powers conferred on him in the lease agreement. It is then said that "It is also denied

that the Ministry of Works &

Housing, as such represents the lessor. It is the Land

& Development

Officer,

the respondent

no.5,

who

represents

the lessor (President of India) for the execution of the leases and their administration under

Art.299(1) of the Constitution. Statutory Bodies like the llu.'licipal Corporation of Delhi, the Delhi Development Authority, the Urban Arts Commission etc. had no power under the perpetual l:oase-deed of 1958 to vary or waive tre conditions of the lease." Upon this basis, respondent no.2 asserted that the so-called permission obtained by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. from the Ministry of works & Rousing was void, illegal and without jurisdiction and, therefore, a nullity in law.

In para 79, it is averred

"With reference to para 27(b), it is denied that the Land & Development Officer is merely a functionary under the Ministry of Works & Reusing. Ile is, in fact, the officer appointed on bahalf of the lessor (President of India/The Chief Corunissioner of Delhi)

under the terms of the lease for the execution of

management of the lease-deeds, it is submitted that the permission referred to by the petitioners was neither applied for and obtained nor granted under clause 2(5) of the lease-deed. The so-called permission,

in any case, was not addressed to be

petitioners but to respondent no.6.·

EXPRESS Nl:.'WSPAl'ERS v. u.o.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

6. After referring to the grant of permission by the Ministry of Works & Housing and the Delhi Development Authority, respondent no.2 averred in para 89 : "With reference to para 28(4) and (c) it is denied that the breach complained of was capable of remedy. As already stated, the so-called permission obtained by the petitioners did not amount to any valid permission under the terms of the perpetual lease-deed dated March 18, 1958. It: is submitted that: the petitioners were bound to apply to the cowpetent authority and obtain prior approval of the lessor before coornenclng construction and the petitioners knew who the cowpetent: autbority was. The petitioners did not make any appllcati<>n uoder any of the tetlllll of the lease-deed before cmmitting the breach of the

lease-deed. (Emphasis supplied)

The aforesaid averments clearly bring out the stand of

respondent no.2 that he alone and not the Ministry of Works ~ Housing was competent to act on behalf of the

lessor i.e. the Union of India and this is brought out in the averment which immediately follows:

"It is further submitted that for any breach of clauses (3), (9) and (10) of clause 2 of the leasedeed, it was for the Chief Commissioner of Delhi to decide i f the breaches are remediable and the nature of the remedies required for the breach. If the breaches were net remediable to the satisfaction of

the Chief Commissioner of Delhi,

he could order

removal or demolition of the construction complained

of. Modification of the layout plan, conversion of the land use and violation of the FAR prescribed under the Master Plan and the Municipal Bye-laws are not remedi-

able breaches." 7. Respondent no.2 has specifically

denied that the

FAR for D-2 area which includes the Press Enclave is

400, and asserted that for built up areas which include partly built-up areas, the FAR under the Municipal Building Bye-laws is only 300. It was

II

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 S.C.R.

then asserted thst the FAR for D-2 area being 300, according to the Municipal Building Bye-laws and the Master Plan for Delhi, the question of issue of direction by the Central Government under s.41 of the Delhi DevelojXDl!nt Act does not arise. Even then, it was said thst the Vice-Chairman of the Delhi Development Authority (M.N. Buch), in view of this legal position expressed the view in his note dated October 21, 1978 that the case of the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. should be treated as an isolated case to ·bring it at par and allow the FAR of 360 overall. Acco,:ding to him the reason for this as indicated in the note was thst the order of Shri Sikander Bakht, Minister for Works & Housing "for imnediate clearance of the case and for obtaining his ex-post-facto sanction''.. Respondent No.2 denied that the letters referred to in para 30(h) and (i) of the petition could be construed as directions of the Central Government to the Delhi Development Authority under s. 41 of the Delhi Development Act. Instead of being such a direction, the Annexure 21 was a clarification of letter dated November 25, 1978 stating thst FAR 360 was allowed excluding the basen.ent. Annexure 22 was said to be a sanction letter issued by respondent no.l on January 9, 1979 in respect of building plans submitted by the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. before respondent no.3. Even Annexure 20 which is a letter dated November 24, 1978 from the Ministry of Works & Housing, it was said was not a permissipn under s. 41 of the Delhi Development Act as it gives the ex-post-facto sane tion of the proposal of the Delhi Development Authority permitting FAR 360 for the Express Ne'wspapers Pvt. Ltd. It was then added : "With reference to para 30(j), it is denied that the actions taken by the Ministry of Works & Housing and the Delhi Development Authority constituted a restoration of the rights of the petitioners under the lease agreement of 1954, as the agreement of 1954 was inadmissible being non-existent and inoperative after its substitution by the agreement of 1957 as per perpetual lease-deed dated March 18, 1958, it was asserted that the petitioners could construct on the residual area of plots nos. 9 and 10 only in

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS V• u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, J.]

accordance with the terms and conditiona of the lease-deed of 1958 and subject to the provisions of the Master Plan and the Municipal Bye-laws. It was asserted that the lease deed of 1958 envisaged compliance with the Municipal Bye-laws for any future conatructions/additions in plots nos. 9 and 10."

8. It will be seen that the points sought to' be made out by respondent no.2 in his counter-affidavit are : (a) At present the perpetual lease-deed dated March 18, 1958 governs the relationahip effectively between the Union of India and the Lt. Governor. on the one hand and the petitioners on the other i.e. the contractual relationa between the parties. (b) The tranafer of administrative control of the L & D 0 on October 1, 1959 to the Ministry of Works & Housing did not divest the Chief Commissioner of his contractual powers given under the lease and he alone represented the lessor i.e. the Union of India and not the ~dnistry of Works & Rousing. ( c) The sewer, according to the terma of the lease-deed, could not be diverted without the consent of the Chief Commissioner (Lt. Governor) and the approval of the Ministry of Works & Rousing was a nullity being without jurisdiction and legal

competence.

(d) For the commercial user of the residual area to be kept as 'green', it is only the Chief Commissioner (Lt. Governor) who could give sanction to construct for the commercial user at the residual area; the petitioners were liable to pay commercial realization charges. ( e) The Lt. Governor was a successor of the Chief Commissioner and, therefore, all the powers exercisable by the Chief Commissioner in relation to the lease vested in him· (f) It is for the Chief Commissioner (Lt. Governor) to decide if the breaches were ren.ediable or as to the nature of

the

remedies

required

for

the

breach.

Ii

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

ll

According to him, the breaches are not remediable breaches and, therefore, the impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 issued by the Engineer Officer, L & DO for re-entry upon the land on forfeiture of the lease for breach of the condiUons was valid and proper. (the leamed Attorney-General has throughout in the course of his ar8'..ilts on behalf of respondent oo. l, the Union of India maintained that the Lt· Governor of Ilelbi has DOthing to do with the lease and that wherever the of the Chief ec-tssiooer of Delhi appears, it should be scored out fl'llll the lesse-deed.)

(Emphasis supplied) 9. One S. Rangaswami, Additional Land & llevelo1111ent Officer, Ministry of Works & Housing filed a separate counter-affidavit supporting the stand of the Lt. Governor. It was averred in para 3 :

"The petitioners during the year 1977 applied to the Ministry of Works & Housing for permission to construct on the residual area of 2740 square yards in plots nos. 9 and 10. The petitioners have placed reliance on the letters dated June 9, 1978 from Shri L. N. Sukwami and dated 24th November 1978 from Shri V. S. Ka tara in the Minis try of Works & Housing and claimed that these two letters constituted permission

to build on the residual area of plots nos. 9 and 10. I am advised to state that under the terms of the lease deed of 1958, previous consent of either the President of India or the chief Commissioner (Lt. Governor) or such officer or body as the lessor (President of India) or the chief Commissioner of Delhi authorised was necessary for building activity on the residual area of the plots (2740 sq. yards). 1'be M1nistry of Works & llousing did oot represent the lessor or the chief ccwnfsst.ooer. •

10. It is somewhat strange that Land & Develo1111ent Officer, who is the last functionary in the Ministry of Works & Housing should challenge the very authority and power of the Minis try of Works & Housing to administer the lease on behalf of the President of India. He has also averred in para 5 :

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

"The impugned show cause notice of 10th March 1980 was issued to the petitioners under cl. 6 of the perpetual lease for violation of sub-clauses (5) and (14) of clause 2 of the lease-deed. The Land & llevelop!lent Officer is oot a flmcticoory nod& th:! Ministry of llo<lw 6' !lousing. He is i:he officer appointed on behalf

of the lessor to administer the lease. At no stage the petitioners approached the office of Land & Development

for

permission

to

construct

on

seen many

twi:s ts

and

turns.

the

residual area of 2740 sq. yards to the west of the pipe-line and no approval was obtained from the office of L&DO for construction of a building in contravention of clauses 2(5), (9) and (14) of the lease. The so-celled pamissions and approvals obta!Ded by the petltimiem have no iegal validity oo the short gr"""1:! of 1Bck of legal CO'lljl2t:ence or authority under the tezm6 of the lease-deed whlch governed the relationship bet:ween the petitiooers and re.spoodent no. l." (Emphasis supplied) The case has

The hearing

commenced on April 27 , 1982. and was concluded on September 22, 1983 with intermittent breaks. I regret to say that the ambivalent attitude adopted by respondent no.1 the Union of India and the hostility of respondent no.2 prolonged the hearing which lasted as many as 43 days. This has resulted in a colossal waste of public money and valuable time of the court. On April 29, 1982 when Shri Nariman, learned counsel for the petitioners- had concluded his arguments for the day. Shri Parasaran, the learned Solicitor General made a statement that he wanted to obtain instructions as to whether the impugned notices issued by the Zonal Engineer (Building), Municipal Corporation of Delhi dated March 1, 1980 and by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office, dated March 10, 1980 for the forfeiture of the lease of plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg granted by the Government of India in favour of the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. and the threat to re-enter upon the leasehold premises with the new Express Building built thereon and for removal of the

unauthorized structures should be enforced or not. In the facts and circumstances of the case, we must say that the request for adjourmnent by the learned Solicitor General was reaso!lB.ble and

was not opposed by' the learned counsel for the petitioners. We accordingly adjourned the hearing of the Writ Petitions till August 3; 1983 to enable· respondent no.1 the Union of India to

II

SUP!®IE COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

take a decision in the matter. On August 23, 1982 the matter. was taken up in Chambers when the learned Solicitor General mad~ a statement that the Writ Petitions would have to be heard on merits, meaning thereby that the lessor i.e. the Union of India were not prepared to reconsider the matter. The learned Solicitor General Later ~1.thdrew from the case. The strange phenomenon when the hearing was resumed on November 4, 1982 of the Union of India speaking through the voice of learned counsel for respondent no.2 was irore than we could permit. We sent for Shri L.N. Sinha, the learned Attorney General and he rightly objected to anyone speaking on bahalf of the Union of India. We directed the learned Attorney General to appear and assist the C.ourt. During the pendency of the proceedings, Shri Sinha demitted his office and Shri Parasaran was appointed to be the Attorney General. The Union of India engaged Shri Sinha as its counsel and he continued to represent respondent no.1. We are grateful to learned counsel for the parties who dealt with all aspects of the various constitutional issues and other questions of great public importance with their usual industry and have supplemented their arguments by filing written subnissions. Learned counsel for respondent no. l has throughout been emphatic in contending that respondent no.2 was a complete stranger to the lease and he did not represent the lessor, the Union of India. Strangely enough, Dr. Singhvi continued to appear not only for respondent no.2 the Lt. Governor but also for respondent. no.5 the land & Development Officer who is a minor official in the Mini~try of Works & Housing. When we repeatedly enquired from lMrned counsel for respondent no.l as to the right of respondent no.5 to be represented by another counsel when he was appearing for the Union of India, he asserted that Dr. Singhvi had no right to represent respondent no.5 Land & Develo~nt Officer as he was appearing for reepondent no. l and he wss not bound by his submissions. Again, there was a rather distrubing feature. Submissions at the bar by learned counsel for the respondents were not in consonance with the stand taken in the original affidavit filed by respondent no.2 on behalf of all the respondents. Further, the respondents have been filing different affidavits from time to time to suit their purposes as the hearing progressed and it was difficult to reconcile the conflicting averments made in these subsequent affidavits. It is somewhat unfortunate that the Government should have embarked upon this course of action.

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS V• U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.J

At the resumed hearing on November 4, 1982, we took on record the further affidavits filed by respondent no.2 dated July 29, 1982 with certain deletions. In trying to meet the allegations made against him, respondent no.2 cast aspersions on Sikandar Bakht, the then Minister for Works & Housing. It was averred : "llut if Ram l<ath Goenka approached the then Minister of Worlw & Housing, Shri Sikandar Bakht and the latter misusing his authority aru! exercising blatant favouritism pressurised the officers of the Delhi Development Authority, Delhi Municipal Corporation and of his own Ministry to do totally illegal acts, thereby giving huge financial benefits to his political assocl.ate aru! friend Ram Nath Goenka, there are no mala fides. If the statutory provisions unalterable thrOugh an executive action, of the Delhi Mas.ter Plan, Zoning Regulations and Municipal Bye-laws are ruthlessly violated, there are no mala fides. If expert advice of the Town & Country Planning Organisation is deliberately attacked, which, in fact, makes it quite clear that E'AR 300 does not exist in any area in Delhi and that FAR and coverage are prescribed for the locality as a whole and. not fot individual building, there are no ma1a fides. And if senior officers are sent to an l.nfluentWli\iSinessman to mollify him end in the event of not being mollified, the illegal and irregular concessions asked for are granted ·without even taking the trouble of amending the law of the statutory provisions, there are no mala_ fides, according to the writ petitioners."

On the same day i.e. on ~ovem.ber 4, 1982, ~e sent for Shri L.N, Sinha, the then Attorney-General and drew his attention to the averments made by respondent no. 2 1n the fresh affidavit alleging that the orders passed by the then l'd.nister for Works & Housing were illegal, improper and irregular. We felt that it was highly improper for respondent no.2 to have made suCh extreme allegations against the then Minister for Works & Housing and against the previous Government in power~ Accordirigly, we called upon respondent no. l Union of India to clarify its stand with regard to the following aspects 1. The authority of respondent nc.2 to wake allegatlons of fraud, misuse of pwers aud misdemeanours against the functionaries of the Union cf India including the Minister, Works & Housing.

(1985] SUPP.3 s.c.a.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

2. The stand of respondent no.l, Union of India, to the case of the petitioners without adopting the counter affidavit of respondent no.2. ll

3. The specific reply, if any, of the Union of lndia, to the allegations of mala fides made by the petitioners against the Government of India in paras 9(b), 11 and 12 of the Writ Petition. 4. What is the reaction of the Union of India to the averments in the counter-affidavits of respondent no.2 and the affidavit of respondent no. 5 that the Minis try of Works & Housing Joes not represent the lessor and that respondent no.5, the Land & Development Officer alone represents the lessor. And 5. Whether a successor government was not bound by the acts of the duly constituted previous government ?

Instead of cou.'j>lying with the directions, respondent no.l through the affidavit of M.K. Mukherjee, Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing dated November 16, 1982 purported to raise certain additional issue : 1. I am advised to say that the orders passed by Shri Sikandar Bakht, the then Minister for Works & Housing were clearly illegal, improper and irregular. 2. The powers and functions assigned to the Chief Commissioner of Delhi under the lease-deed were exercisable by the Lt. Governor by virtue of the notification issued by the President dated September 7, 1966 under Art. 239(1) of the Constitution. 3. The Land & Development Officer as well as the Chief Engineer in the office of the Land & Development Officer were both empowered to take action of the lease-deed and therefore the Engineer Officer was authorized by the lessor i.e. the Union of India to issue

the

impugned

show

cause

notice

as

he

was

competent to do so under cl. 5 of the lease-deed having been empowered to act on behalf of the President under Art. 299(1). The said show cause notice was issued on the basis of which a press report &S per the orders recorded on the file of the Land & Development Officer and not at the instance of the Lt. Governor.

EXi'RESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J .. ]

4. The order of M.N; Buch, the then Vice-Chancellor of the ODA dated October 21, 1978 was without any legal authority or sanction and the said order was passed by him in clear violation of the procedure laid down in s. 11A(2) of the Delhi Development Act, inasmuch as no relaxation of the permission for FAR for the D-II area could be made which was tantamount to a modification of

the

Master

Plan~

The

said

decision

cannot be

implemented by the MCD because it would require modification of their existing bye-laws, which cannot be done for a particular case or building or for oae particular commercial area.

It is then averred 1 "I say that the counter-affidavit filed by respondent no. 2 be read as part and parcel of this counter-affidayit.

I am advised to categorically deny any allegation of fides, design or animosity on the part of respondent no.las alleged."

mala

The respondents have also placed on record two affidavits of M.N. Buch and H.R. Ailawadi, both of whom became Vice-Chairmen, Delhi Development Authority. Ailawadi in his affidavit avers that the demised land is a nazul land which vested in the President of India. For management, control and disposal of such lands, Land & Development Office in the Department of Local Self Government was created. As a matter of fiscal policy, the administrative control of the Land & Development Office, Delhi was transferred from the Delhi Administration to the Ministry of Works, Housing & Supply w.e.f. ·October 1, 1959. He asserts that this transfer wao on administration and fiscal grounds and did not divest the Chief Commissioner of the powers given to him by the parties under the lease as the representative of the President of India. He further avers that the sewer line, according to the terms of the lease, could not be diverted without the consent of the Chief Commissioner (Lt.Governor). As regards the sanction, he asserts that M.N. Buch in fact had no authority to sanction the building plans in the instant case and that the Additional Secretary, Master Plan, had raised certain objections to the building plans and no decision on these objections was taken and then adds : "Shri Buch contrary to all the views expressed by

himself, the Ministry of Works & Housing, Office of L&DO and TCPO passed the following orders."

SUPIU;ME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

This is followed by the terms of the order J.n question passed by M,N, Buch. He then avers : "Under clause 2(5) of the perpetual lease-deed only the lessor or the Chief Conmissioner of Delhi could permit construction on the residual area of plots nos. 9 and 10. The Vice-Chairman, DDA had no authority under the terms of the lease •to permit an additional construction on these plots. No objection certificate, therefore, issued to the funicipal Corporation of Delhi and to M/s Express Newspapers Ltd. by the DOA on 4.11.1979 was without jurisdiction and a nullity. The Ministry of Works & Housing could not have also permitted any construction at the residual area. Only the Chief Commissioner of Delhi or the Officers authorized by the President of India under Art. 299 of the Constitution were cq_mpetent to grant such permission. The Vice-chairman, DOA or the Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Works & Housing were not authorized by the President in exercise of powers under Art. 299 to administer the lease-deed.

The direction of Shri Buch to treat his order as one under special appeal was without jurisdiction and, therefore, a nullity. The procedure prescribed for special appeal waa totally disregarded. No resolution of the DOA was adopted in this regard and as a matter of practice and rule, special appeal cases are decided only by means of resolution of the author.tty. The decision of Shri Buch waa in violation of the provisions of the Delhi Development Act, Master Plan and funicipal Bye-laws."

He then questioned the validity of the sanction to the building plan granted by the funicipal Corporation of Delhi and

asserts :

I

"Sanction of the building plans by the MCD violated the following statutory provisions : (a) FAil. : According to the funicipal Bye-laws, FAR for a built area could not exceed 300. The Press area being a built up area, permission to build up to FAR to 360 was violative of the funicipal Building Bye-laws.

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS V• U.Q.I. [A.P. SEN, J.)

(b)Coverage According to the Master Plan and building bye-laws, which were in force prior to 24.12. 76, coverage for different floors of a five storey building was as under Ground floor First Second Third Fourth

..

..

80% 70% 50% 50% 50%

He then refers to the amended rule dated 24.12. 76 which· prescribed for all conmercially developed areas, including offices, coverage of 25% · and asserts that the press area i~ covered by the amendment. He also asserts that even the earlier rule was violated by allowing 75.43% on the first floor and 77.5% coverage on the second and third floors. Further he states that for comnercial areas, parking has to be done within the plots and within the covered area. In the present case, no proyision was made for parking of the vehicle within the plot and then adds : "In the Municipal Bye-laws, there is no provision for waiving, relaxing and modifying the rules referred to abbve. The sanction was, therefore, accorded illegally and under undue pressure from vested interests ... ~n his counter-affidavit, M.N. Buch avers in para 3 that he had not authorized respondent no. 2 or anyone else to swear an affidavit on his behalf and, therefore, he was not bound by the same. According to him, the area in question was not a "develo!'ll"nt area" within the meaning of sub-s.(3) of s. 12 of the Delhi Development Act and as such, question of according any permission/approval by the Delhi Development Authority or by any of its officers did not arise. As regards the communication dated November 4, 1978 issued under the signature of R.D. Gohar, the then Joint Director (Building) of the Delhi Develo!'ll"nt Authority, i t could not, in his opinion, be treated to be a permission/sanction accorded under any statutory rule or regulation or Bye-law. According to him, i t was as a matter of fact a formal correspondence in response to a reference made in that behalf by the Ministry of Works & Housing and its gist and essence W<tS that the petitioners could submit plans to the concerned authorities for approval, if they so chose and that was

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

why, the set of plans as submitted by them, was returned and no

plans were ever approved.

On the contrary,

the plans were

returned

for submission to the appropriate authority for approval. AB regards a number of communications from the Mini"try

of Works & Housing to him, as the then Vice-Chairman, M.N. Buch contended that he had no ac:cess to the records of the Delhi Developnent Authority and due to non-availability of the records, it was difficult for him to say anything specifically about the same. In substance, the contentio'l of Buch is that the area in question was not a duly notified "develoµnent area" and aF such,

j)

question of granting any permission either by the Delhi lJevelopnent Authority or by him as the Vice-Chairman did not arise and that no sanction or approval of the building plans, as alleged or otherwise, was accorded by him as such. The point of FAR raised in the petition was, according to him, not at all relevant fo< a just and proper decision of the case. He further stated that a perusal of the records would reveal that nowhere in any of the communications had he stated that any building plan had been sanctioned or approved. On the contrary, he had made it clear that "It is for the Municipal Corporation of Delhi to examine the building plans in the light of the Building Bye-laws already sanctioned by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi. In other words, neither the Delhi Developnent Authority nor he as the Vic!!-Chairman had anything to rlo with the sanction/approval of the building plans in the instant case."

It is rather pertinent to observe that in his counter-affidavit Buch does not explain the implications of his specific order as the Vice-Chairman dated October 21, 1978 for amalgamation of plots nos.9 and 10 and permitting construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for installation of the printing press, directing that it was not merely a conmunication from the Vice-chairman,

Delhi Developnent Authority to the Ministry of Works & Housing but per se it was an order passed by M.N. Buch as Vice-chairman, Delhi Developnent Authority and he concludes by observing :

"The Minister, Works & Housing had discussed the case with me and ordered that the case should be cleared

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, J.]

immediately and his ex-post-facto sanLtion obtained. On this basis, we may issue cleaiancP. to the Express Authorities and also make a reference to the Government of India asking for confirmation of the action taken. 'The orrier should be treated as an order under Special Appeal'," A perusal of the counter-affidavit of M.~. Buch bears out that the maker of an inotrument is not always its best interpreter. Nothing really turns on the aforesaid two affidavits of M.N. Buch and H.R. Ailawadi, the then Vice-Chairman of the Delhi Development Authority which was just a belated attempt of the respondents to support the action of respondent nv.2 in initiating the proceedings which culminated in the issue of the impugned notices. The respondents have been shifting their rtand from stage to stage. Upon these pleadings, arise may be formulated :

the point£ for det<>rmination that

1. Whether the impugned notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office, Ministry of WorkE & Housing dated ~iarch 10, 1980 requiring Express Newspapers Pvt. l,td. to show cause why the lessor i.e. the Union of India should not re-enter upon and taken possession of plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg together with the Express Buildings built thereon and the impugned notice of the Zonal Engineer (Buildings), Municipal

L

Corporation, City Zone, Delhi to show cause why the new Express building, particularly the double

basement, where the Express Newspaper• Pvt. Ltd. have installed the printing press with the working platform which was a necessa:&:')' appurtenance to the installation of the printing press expressly sanctioned by the then Minister for works & Housing as well as by M.N. Buch, the then Vice-Chairman, DDA in conformity with Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Master Plan and under ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, were violative of the petitioners' right to freedom of press guaranteed by Art. 19(l)(a) read with Art. 14 of the Constitution and therefore a petition under Art. 32 was maintainable. 2. Whether the construction of the new Express Building on the residual area of 2740 square yards to

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(1985] SUPP.3 S.C.R.

the west of sewer-line after its removal on plots nos. 9 and lO without the permission of the Lt. Governor or of the Land & Development Officer by the petitioners with an increased FAR 360 con.stituted s bruch of clauses 2(5) and 2 (14) which entitled the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office. Ministry of Works & Housing to issue the iuq>llgned show" cause notke dated March 10, 1980 of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease and the Union of India to re-ent..r upon and take possession of plots 9 and 10, llahadurshah Zafar Marg, together with the Express Buildings thereon. 3, (a) Whetber under the Master Plao, development of the Mathura Road commercial area was totally prohibited on FAR uceeding 300 i.e. whether such area does fall within the expression 'already buil~ commarcial area' or whether ..he Huter Plao doea not refer to the Matbura Road commercial atea nor doea such area fall within the expression 'already built-up cOlll!lercial area' i.e. the area falling within the walled city of Delhi. (b) Whei:her the pet'llitced uaes in the use-Zone C-II viz. the zone in which the press area falls do not exclude 'newspaper and printing press' except only if such user is allowed by a competent authority after special appeal that newspaper and printing presses are permitted to be installed. 4. Whether the Ministry of Works & Housina with the Minister at the head was and is the ultimate authority responsible for the following items of work.a 'Property of the Union, Town and Country Plaoning, ' Delhi Development Authority, Master Plan of Delhi, Adminiatration of the Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Land ' Development Office dealing with the administration of nazul i..nds in the Union Territory of Delhi. If that be so, whether the orders passed by Sikaudar llakht, the then Minieter for Works & Housing granting permission to che petitioners to construct the new Express Building with an increased FAR 360 on an area of 2740 square yards to the west of plots nos. 9 and 10 was illegal, in.proper and irregular. S. Whether the decision taken by the then Minister for Works & Housing for perlllitt1ng construction of the new

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 with a double. basement for the installation of the printing press wae in coofol"llli ty with the recomoenda ti on of M.N. lluch, the then Vice-<:hainnan, Delhi Developinent Authority and had been r~.ached after the matter had been de.alt with at all levels in the Minis try of Works & Housing was binding upon the successor Government i.e. the Union of India as also the Ministry of Works & Housing and the petitioners having acted in the faith of such assur.ance and constructed the new Express Building thereon at a cost of nearly Rs.2 crores, the respondents particularly respondent no. l, the Union of India, was precluded bY the doctrine of promissory estoppel from chal:lenging the validity of the permission granted by the then Minister for Works & Housing. If that be so, whether the present govermnent is bound to honour all assurances given by or on bahalf of the Union of India, Minis try of Works & Housing by the then Minister. 6. Whether the Lt. Governor of Delhi has any function in relation to the lease being a successor of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi. If that be so, whether the Lt. Governor of Delhi could have set up a threeman Committe~ to inquire into and report on the alleged breaches coami tted by the petitioners in the cons true tion of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 or the double basement for installation of the printing press, contrary to the sanction plan .and the building bye-laws of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi. If that be so, whether the Engineer Officer, Land & llevelopnent Office could have acted on the press report of the news cooference held by the Lt. Governor and on its basis issue the impugned show cause notice dated March 10, 1980.

7. Whether the respondents are right in contending that the alleged breach comitted by the petitioners in not obtaining t.he previous permission of the Lt. Governor as required by els. 2(5) and 2(14) was not remedial and therefore the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing could direct removal or demolition of the cons true tion complained of.

ll

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

8. Whether the notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease issued by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office, New Delhi dated March 10, 1980 purporting to be on behalf of the lessor i.e. the Union of lndia, Ministry of Works & Housing, and that of March 1, 1980 issued by the Zor.e.l Engineer (Building), Municipal Corporation, City Zone, Delhi, were wholly mala fiJ~ and politically motivated. For a proper appreciation of the points involved, it is necessary to set out the material clauses of the indenture of lease-deed dated March 17, 1958. Clause& 2(5), 2(14), 4, 5 and 6, insofar as material, run as follows :

"2(5). The lessee will not without the previous consent in writing of the Chief Commiesl.oner of Delhi or of such officer or body as the lessor or the Chief Commissioner of Delhi may authorize in this behalf make any alterations in or additions to the building erected on the said demised premises so as to affect any of the architectural or structural features thereof or suffer to be erected on any part of the said demised premises or any building other than and except the building erected thereon at the date of these presents." "2.(14). The lessee shall keep to the entire satisfaction of the said Chief Comdssioner the area co the west of the pipeline adr.ieasuring 2740 sq.yards (which area for clarity's sake is delienated on the plan hereto annexed and thereon shown in yellow) as an open space, that is, as lawns, paths or parking

grounds."

"4. If there shall at any time have been in the opinion of the Lessor or the Chief Comdssioner of Delhi whose decision shall be final, any breach by leo1ee or by any person claiming through or under him of any of c;

the covenants or conditions contained in sub-els.

(5) ...... of cl.2 and if the said intended lessee shall neglect or fail to remedy any such breach to the satisfaction of the Chief Comdssioner of Delhi within seven days from the receipt of a notice signed by the Chief Conmissioner of Delhi requiring him to remedy such breach it shall be lawful for the officers

i

~

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

of the C:U.ef Comnissioner of Delhi to enter upon the premises hereby demised and (a) to remove or demolish any alterations on or additions to the buildings erected on the said premises without the previous consent in writing of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi or duly authorized officer as aforesaid ••••••• and it is hereby expressly declared that the liberty hereinbefore given is not to prejudice in any way the power given to the President of India by els. 4 and 5 hereof. 5. '" ••••••• (I)f there shall have been in the opinion of the Lessor or the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi whose decision shall be finsl, any breach by the Lessee or by any person claiming through or under him of any of the covenants or conditiorts hereinbefore contained and on his part to be observed or performed then and in any such case it shall be lawful for the lessor or any person or persons duly authorized by him notwithstanding the waiver of any previous cause or right of re-entry upon any part of the premises whereby demised or of the buildings thereon in the name of the whole to re-enter and thereupon this demise and everything herein contained shall cease and determine and the Lessee shall not be entitled to any compensation whatsoever, nor, to the return of any premium paid by him •• 6. "No forfeiture of re-entry shall be effected except as herein provided, without the -permission of the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi, and the Chief Comnissioner shall not permit such forfeiture or re-entry until the Lessor has served on the lessee a notice in writing :

(a) specifying the particular breach complained of (b) if the breach is capable of remedy, requiring the Lessee to remedy the breach and the Lessee fails within a resonsble time from the date of se!:Vice of the notice to remedy the breach, if it is capable of remedy, and in the event of forfeiture or re-entry the Chief Commissioner may in his discretion relieve against forfeiture on such terms and conditions as he thinks proper.

SUPREME 60URT REPORTS

!1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

'Die Acta

We may then refer to the relevant provisions of the Delhi Development Act, 1957 which is parmoount law on the subject and overrides the provisions of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957. The word 'Building' is defined in section 2(b) as including any structure or erection or part of a structure or erection which is intended to be used for residential, industrial, COlllllercial or other purposes, whether in actual use or not; And the term 'building operations as defined in section 2(c) includes rebuilding operations, structural alterations of or additions to buildings and other operations normally undertaken in connection with the construction of buildings. In section 2(d) the term 'development' is defined with all its grammatical variations to mean the carrying out of building, engineering, mining or other operations in, on, over or under land or the making of any material change in building or land and includes redevelopment. The expression 'development area' is defined in section 2(e) to mean any area declared to be the development area under s\lb-s.(l) of s.12.

Under the scheme of the Act, the predominant object and purpose for which the Delhi Development Authority is constituted under s.3(1) is to secure the planned development of Delhi. This hes to be achieved by the preparation of Master Plan under s.7(1) and Zonal Development Plans under s.8(1). Under s.3(3)(a) the Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi shall be the Chairman ex-t>fficio of the Delhi Development Authority. Under s. 6 the Authority is charged with the duty to promote and secure the development of Delhi according to plan. The l'iaster Plan as enjoJ.ned under s. 7(2)(a) defines the various zones into which Delhi may be divided for the purpose of development and indicates the manner in which tne land in each zone is proposed to be used (whether by the carrying out thereon on development or otherwise) and the stages by which any such development shell be carried out; and by cl. (b) thereof serves as a basic pattern of framework within which the zonal development plans of the various zones may te prepared. s. 12(1) provides that as soon as may be after the COlllilencement of this Act, the Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, declare any area in Delhi to be a development area for the purposes of this Act. After the commencement of the Act, s. 12(3) enjoins that no development of land shall be undertaken or carried out in any area by any person or body (ineluding a department of government) unless, -

-•

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.J

(i) " where that area is a development area permission for such development has been obtained in writing from the Authority in 'accordance with the provisions of this Act, i.e. according to the Master Plan and the Zonal Development Plans;

(ii) where that area is an area other than a development area, approval of, or sanction for, such development has been obtained in writing from the local authority concerned or any officer or authority thereof empowered or authorized in this behalf, in accordance with the provisions made by or under the law governing such authority or until such provisions have been made in accordance with the provisions of the regulations relating to the grant of permission for development made under the Delhi (Control of Building Operations) Act, 1955, and in force illlllediately before the conmencement of this Act:"

It is cOlllIOOn ground that the Press Enclave on the Mathura Road ColllOOrcial Complex has. not !Y.en declared under s. 12(1) to be a development area for pµrposes of the Act. S.14 provides that after the coming into operJtion of any of the plans in a zone no person shall use or permit to be used any land or building in that zone otherwise than in conformity with s4ch plan. S.29(1) makes it a penal offence to undertake or carry out development of any land in contravention of the Master Plan or Zonal Development Plans or without the permission, approval or sanction referred to in s. 12 or in contravention of any condition subject to which such permission, approval or sanction has been granted. S.53(3) is important for our purpose and it reads :

53(3): "Notwithsµmding anything contained in any such other law I (a) when permission for development in respect of any

land has been obtained under this Act such development shall not be deemed to be unlawfully undertaken or carried out by reason only of the fact that perod,ssion, approval or sanction required under such other law for such development' has not been obtained; (b) when permission for which development has not been obtained under this Act, such development shall not be deemed to be lawfully undertaken or carried out by

SUP.REME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

reason only or the fact that permission, approval or sanction required under such other law for such develo(lllent has been obtained." The words 'such other law' in s. 53(3) obviously refer to the non-obstante clause in sub-s. (2) which reads :

53(2):" ... The provisions of this Act and the rules and regulations made thereunder shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any other law." i.e. the provisions of the Act have a overriding effect over the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957. The Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 provides inter alia by s. 332 that no person shall erect or comnence to erect any building, or execute any of the works specified in s. 334 except with the previous sanction of the Comnissioner, nor otherwise than in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter (Chapter XVI) and of the bye-laws made under this Act in relation to the erection of buildings or execution of works. S.334(1) provides that every person who intends to carry on any work of the type indicated e.g. in addition to or alterations in any building or the repairs or alterations of the kind specified shall apply for sanction by giving notice in writing of his intention to the Commissioner in such form and containing such information as may be prescribed by bye-laws Mde in that behalf. s. 336(1) provides that the Commissioner shall sanction the erection of a building or the execution of a work unless such building or work would contravene any of the provisions of sub-s(2) of that section. Sub-s.(2)(a) provides for one of the grounds on which sanction of building or work may be refused viz. where such building or work or the use of the site for the building or work would contravene the provisions of any bye-law made in that behalf or of any other law made in such other law. Sub-s. (3) provides that the Commissioner shall colilllUnicate the sanction to the person who has given the notice; and where he refuses sanction on any of the grounds specified in sub-s.(2) or under s. 340 he shall record a brief statement of his reasons for such refusal and communicate the refusal alongwi th the reasons therefor to the person who has given the notice. s.343(1) provides inter alia that where the erection of any building or

·execution of any work has been comnenced, or is being carried on, l!

or has been completed without or contrary to the sanction referred to in s. 336..... The Comnissioner may in addition to

-

liXPRESS NEWSPAPERS V• U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

,•

any other section that may be taken under the Act, make an order directing that such erection or work shall be demolished. Proviso thereto enjoins that no such order of demolition shall be made unless a person has been afforded a reasonable opportunity of showing cause by a notice in writing as to why such order shall not be made· Sub-s.(2) provides that the person aggrieved may prefer an appeal against an order of demolition passed under sub-s.(l) to the District Judge. Sub-s.(3) confers power on the District Judge to order stay of demolition. Sub-s.(5) thereof provides that the order made by the District Judge on appeal and subject only to such order, the order of demolition made by the Connnissioner shall be final and conclusive. Likewise s. 344(1) provides that where the erection of any building or execution of any work has been commenced or is being carried on but has not been completed, without or contrary to the sanction referred to in s. 336 or in contravention of any conditions subject to which sanction has been accorded or any contravention of any of the provisions of this Act or bye-law made thereunder, the Connnissioner may by order require the person at whose instance the building or work has been commenced or is being carried on to stop the same forthwith. The remaining sub-sections of s•344 are, slmilar to those as contained in s.343. I may now proceed to deal with the questions that have been raised· Maintainability of the Writ petitions Wider Art. 32 of the Constitution.

The contention that these petitions are not maintainable under Art.32 of the .Constitution leaves me cold. Some of the crucial questions that arise have been formulated hereinbefore. These are: (1) Whether the impugned notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease dated March 10, 1980 issued by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office under cl.5 of the lease-deed and that of the Zonal Engineer (Building), City Zone, Municipal Corporation, Delhi dated March 1, 1980 to show cause why the Express Buildings should not be demolished as unauthorized construction un•ler ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 were arbitrary and irrational without any factual basis and were therefore violative of Art. 19(l)(a) read with Art. 14 of the Constitution. (2) Whether the Lt. Governor was a successor of the Chief Comnissioner of Delhi in terms of the lease-deed and whether by virtue or the notification issued by the President under Art. 239(1) of the Constitution, he could exercise any power in relation to lease of Government lands in the Union Territory of Delhi. (3) Whether under the paramount law

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

i.e. the Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Master Plan for Delhi and the Zonal Development Plan for D-Il area, the permissible FAR prescribed for buildings constructed in the Press Enclave on the Mathura Road Comnercial Complex was 400. And ( 4) Whether the new Express Building constructed with an increased FAR of 360 with a double basement for installation of the printing press for publication of a Hindi newspaper, with the permission of the lessor, the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing, constitutes a breach of the Master Plan or the Zonal Ile'lelopment Plans or clauses 2(5) and 2(14) of the lease-deea. These questions which obviously arise on these petitions under art. 32 of the Constitution and any direction for quashing the impugned notices

must

necessarily

involve

determination

of

these

questions. I regret that my learned brother Venkata1'amiah, J. proposes to express no opinion on the questions on which, in my view, the Writ Petitions turn. The question at the very threshold is: Whether these petitions under Art. 32 are maintainable. Learned counsel appearing for the Union of India raised a preliminary objection which he later developed as his main argument in reply. First, there was in the present case no question of infraction of the freedom of the press comprehended within ·the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Art. 19(l)(a) but the enforcement of the Master Plan for IJelhi and the Zonal Development Plan framed under the Delhi Development Act, 1957 and the Delhi Municipal Corporation (Building) Bye-laws, 1959 may at the most amount to a restriction on the fundamental rights of the petitioners to carry on their business guaranteed under Art. 19(1)(g). Secondly, the right to occupy the land leased for the construction of a building for installation of a printing press is not within Art.19(l)(a) nor within Art. 19(l)(gJ. but such a right is derived from a grant or contract. Such a right is certainly not within the content of Art.19(l)(a) or Art. 19(l)(g). It is argued that the right arising out of a statute or out of a contract cannot be a fundamental right itself. Once a contract is entered into or a grant is made, the rights and

obligations of the parties are not governed by Part III of the Constitution, but by the terms of the document embodying the contract or the grant, and any complaint about the breach of the same, cannot be even a matter for the application for the grant

of a writ, direction or order under Art. 226 of the Constitution, much less under Art.32. These contentions plausible though i t may

seem

at

first

blush,

are,

on

closer

scrutiny,

nor

well-founded. They ignore the true object and purpose for which

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

the grant was made, namely, for the construction of a building or installation of a printing press for publication of a newspaper and the direct and immediate effect of the impugned notices for re-entry upon forfeiture of lease and the threatened demolition of the Expre•s Buildings built on the leasehold premises under cl.5 of the lease-deed for alleged breach of els. 2(5) and 2(14) thereof and wrder ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi )hinicipal Corporation Act, 1957 when the said buildings had been constructed with the permission of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing, and in conformity with the Master Plan and the Zonal Development Plan for D-ll area· as well as with the sanction of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and therefore must amount to a violation of the freedom of speech and expression enshrined in Art. 19(l)(a). I am not impressed at all with the submissions of learned counsel for respondent no .1 that the forfeiture of lease or the threatened demolition of the Express Buildings does not touch upon the right guaranteed under Art. 19(l)(a) as the petitioners can still shift the printing press to an alternative accommodation. It is argued by learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that the main thrust of the impugned notice of re-entery dated March 10, 1980 by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office purporting to act on bahalf of the lessor, the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing under cl.5 of the indenture of lease dated March 17, 1958 requiring the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to show cause why the Union of India should not re-enter upon and take possession of plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg together with the Express Buildings ,built thereon for alleged breach of els. 2(5) and 2(14) of the lease-deed and that of the earlier notice dated March 1, 1980 issued by the Zonal Engine-er (Building), City Zone, lilnicipal Corporation, Delhi requiring them to show cause why the aforesaid buildings should not be demolished under ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 waa a direct threat on the freedom of the press guaranteed under Art.19(l)(a) of the Constitution. He contends that the impµgned notices were intended and meant to bring about a closure of the Indian Express and not so much for the professed enforcement of laws governing building regulations the Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Master Plan for Delhi and the Zonal Development Plan for D!.ll area for the Muthura Road Commercial Complex framed thereunder or the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, i957 and the Delhi Municipal Corporation (Building) Bye-laws, 1959. He further contends that the respondents cannot be_ permitted to traverse beyond the

C

.E

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 S.C.R.

pleadings of the parties as contained in the counter affidavit of respondent no.2 filed on behalf of the respondents and the supplementary affidavit of M.K. Mukherjee, Secretary, Ministry of Works & Housing, or the terms ·of the impugned notices. In an attempt to justify the illegal, arbitrary and irrational governmental and statutory action which was wholly mala fide and politically motivated, he particularly drew our attentioii'"tO the terms of the impugned notice issued by the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office dated March 10, 1980 which purport to forfeit the lease under cl. 5 of the lease-deed. On two grounds, namely: ( 1) The additional cons true tion of tile new Express Building by Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. on the western portion of plots nos. 9 and 10 i.e. the land to be kept open as 'green', was without taking permission of the lessor under the terms of the lease-deed. And (2) The building plans were not submitted for sanction of the lessor under the terms of the lease and thus there was contravention of els· 2(5) and 2(14) of the lease-deed. He also pointed out that the impugned notice of the Zonal Engineer (Building), City Zone, Municipal Corporation, Delhi dated March 1, 1980 was on t~e ground that the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. had started unauthorized construction of excess basement beyond sanction and construction of upper basement without sanction as shown in red in the sketch plan annexed thereto and that these were therefore unauthorized constructions liable to be demolished u~der ss. 343 and 344 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957. According to the learned counsel, the impugned notices were based on grounds which were factually incorrect. Learned counsel further pointed out that the impugned notice of the Engineer Officer nowhere suggests that the construction of the said building with an increased FAR of 360 was in breach of the Master Plan or the Zonal Development Plan for D-II area framed under the Delhi Development Act or of the Building Bye-laws made under the Delhi Municipal Co1·poration Act, 1957. The contention is that the said building with an increased FAR of 360 together with a double basement for installation of a printing press for the publication of a Hindi newspaper was with the expres1 sanction of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing accorded to the ExpreH Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. which had duly submitted the building palns for grant of requisite sanction. In the premises, it ia submitted that each of the a true tures was cons true ted w1 th the express sane ti on of the lessor, and the Delhi Development Authority granted under the Ualhi Development Act, 1957 which was the paramount law on the subject. It i1 urged that the re-entry upon forfeiture of lease

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS V• u.o.r. [A.F. SEN, J.]

or the threatened demolition of the new Express Building with the double basement where the printing press is installed for publication of the Hindi newspaper Jansatta will result in snuffing out the Indian Express as a newspaper altogether although it has the largest. combined net sales among all daily newspapers in India. The learned counsel particularly emphasized the fact that the Express Buildings at 9-10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg from the nerve-centre of the Express Group of Newspapers in general and the Indian Express in particular as the teleprinter is installed therein. we are informed that the editorials alld the leading articles of the Indian Express are sent out and the editorial policy laid down from the Delhi office to ten centres all over India. As already stated, the Indian Express as a newspaper is simultaneously published from Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Bombay, Chandigarh, Cochin, Delhi, Ryderabad, ~iadras, Madurai, Vijaywada and Vizianagaram. In this factual background, the learned counsel contends that the impugned notices have a direct impact on the freedom of the press and being in excess of governmental authority and colourable exercise of statutory powers, are liable to be .struck down as offendit16 Art. 19(1)(a) read with Art. 14 of the Constitution. Re contends that the test laid down by this Court in Bennett Colemau & Co. & Ors. v. Union of lDdia & Ors. [1973] 2 s.c.R. 757, is whether the direct· and immediate impact of the impugned action is ~n the frePdom of speech and expression guaranteed under Art. 19(1)(a) which includes the freedom of the press. According to him, that test. is clearly fulfilled in the facts and circumstances of the present case. In my considered view, the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners must prevail. I regret my inability to accept the contention to the contrary advanced by learned counsel appearing for respondent no.l indicated above that the petitioners are seeking to enforce a contractual right and therefore the questions raised cannot be decided on a petition under Art.32 of the Constitution, It is urged that the content of the fw!damental rights guaranteed in Part III of the Constitution demarcate the area within which the jurisdiction of the Court under Art. 32 can operate and thet it is not permissible for the Court to enlarge upon its jurisdiction by a proce&& of judicial interpretation. Placing reliance on certain observations of Ayyangar, J, in All Illdia llllllk Employees' Auociation Vo National hldustr1al Tribunal & Orso [ 1962] 3 s.c.R. 269, and of Chandrachud and Bhagwati, JJ, in Malleka Gandhi v. 1Jll1on of lDdiA [1978] 2 s.c.R. 621, it is urged that the content of Art. 19(1)(a) of the Constitution would not include

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

ti

C

the right which is guaranteed by other clauses of Art.19. According to the learned counsel it must therefore logically follow that what facilitated the exercise of a fundamental right did not for that reason become a part of the fundamental right itself. lie read out different passages from the judgments of Bhagwati, J. in E.P. lloyappa v. State of Tamil lladu & [1974 J 2 s.c.a. 348, llaneka Gendb1 v. Union of India (supra) and l!alllana nsyaraa Sbetty v. Int.ematiooal Airport Authority of India Ltd. & Ors·, (1979] 3 s.c.l\. 1014, and endeavoured to show, to use his own language, that "inspite of some literal flourish in the language here and there, they did not and could not depart from the ambit of Art. 14 which deals with the principle of equality embodied in the Article". He was particularly critical of the decba of lihagwati, J. in International Airport Authority's case that "arbitrarineas was the anti thesis of Art. 14"' and comnented that this would mean that all govermnental actions which are not supportable by law were ~~violative of Art. 14. I am afraid, it is rather late in the day to question the correctness of the landmark decision in llaneka Gaodhi 's case and the innovative construction placed by l!hagwati, J. on Art. 14 in the three cases of lloyappa, llaneka Gendb1 and Int.ematiooal Airport Authority

Aor.,

(supra), which have evolved new dimensions in judicial process.

It is also urged that the argument of learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners that the building in question is neceasary for running the press and any statutory or executive action to pull it down or forfeit the lease would directly impinge on the right of freedom of speech and expression under Art. 19(l)(a) is wholly misconceived inasmuch as every activity that may be necessary for exercise of freedom of speech and expression or that may facilitate such exercise or make it nieaningful and effective cannot be elev11ted to the status of a fundamental right as if it were part of the fundamental right to free speech and expression. It is further urged that the right to the land and the right to construct buildings thereon for running a printing press are not derived from Art. 19(l)(a) but spring from the terma of the grant of such lands by the Government under the provisions of the Government Grants Act, 1895 and regulated by other laws governing the subject viz. the Delhi Development Act, 1957, the Master Plan and the Zor.al Developmen:t Plans framed thereunder, the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, and the Delhi Municipal Corporation (Building) Bye-laws, 1959 which regulate construction of buildings in the Union Territory of Delhi irrespective of the purpose for which the building is constructed. It is also urged that even on a question of fact,

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

the direct impact of the impugned no.tices will not be on the double basement wherein printing press is installed but will be wholly or in part on the two upper storeys which are not intended to be used in relation to the press or for pui>lication of the intended Hindi Newspaper but only for the purpose of letting out the same for profit; the only other possible effect may be the removal of the upper basement which the petitioners call a working platform which has been constructed in violation of the building regulations. Learned counsel for respondent no. l, the Union of India accepts that the right to carry on the business of printing and publication of a newspaper and installation of a printing press for that purpose is undoubtedly a fundamental right guaranteed both under Arts. 19(l)(a) and 19(l)(g) but the right to occupy the land or construct suitable structures thereon for the business of a printing press on .such land is not within Art. l'9(l)(a) nor within Art. 19(l)(g). If it were, the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act or the Delhi Development Act, and the Master Plan or the Zonal Development Plan and the Building Bye-laws would be totally ineffectual. Such restrictions cannot be placed even though in the interest of ·the general public as they would not fall within Art.19(Z). If, in respect of the building in question, the right to occupy such land is to be considered as comprehended in the right of freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by Art.19(l)(a), then inevitable consequence would be that neither the provisions of the Delhi Development Act nor the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act nor the Master Plan or the Zonal Development Plans or the Building Bye-laws would be applicable so as to control the building activities of the petitioners. It is said that the irresistible conclusion, therefore, ought to be that the fundamental right of freedom of speech and expression of a person under Art.19(l)(a) cannot extend to the continued occupation of a place where such right is derived from a grant or contract. Such a right is certainly not within the content of Art.l9(l)(a) or Art• 19(l)(g). I t is accordingly argued that the right arising out of a statute or out of a contract cannot be a fundamental right itself. Orice contract is entered into or a grant is made, the rights and obligatioIUl of the parties are not governed by Part III of the Constitution, by the terms of the document embodying the contract or the grant, and any complaint about the breach of the same, cannot be even a matter for application for grant of a writ, direction or order under Art. ZZ6 of the Constitution much less under Art. 3Z. In substance, the su'cmission is that the right to run a press may be a fundamental right guaranteed under Art. l9(l)(a) or Art.

II

ll

))

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

19(l)(g) but the right to use a particular building for running a press is altogethP.r another thing inasmuch as no particular building ~s eo.ually fit for the runniu.g cf the press and the person desiring to run a press or already running the press is at liberty to acquire another suitable building for that purpose. Further, even if the buildings in question were necessary for the enjoyment of the rights under Art. 19(l)(a) or Art.19(l)(g), a right to use a particular building does not become an ' integral part of the right to freedom of speech and expression' or ·the 'right to carry on any trade or J>usiness in printing and publishing a newspaper' and clearly therefore the petitions under Art. 32 were not maintainable. I am afral.d, the contentions are wholly misconceived and cannot be accepted. Here, the very threat is. to the existence of a free and independent press. It is now firmly established by a series of decisions of this Court anj is a rule written into the Constitution that freedom of the press is comprehended within the right to freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Art. 19(1)(a) and I do not wish to traverse the familiar ground over again except to touch upon certain landmark decisions. In llomeah 'J:bappar v. State of Madras, [1950] s.c.R. 594,· the Court observed that the Founding Fathers realized that freedoms of speech and of the press are at the foundation of all democratic organizations, for without free political discussion no public education, so essential for proper functioning of the processes of popular Government, is possible. In Sakal Papers (P) Ltd. v. Union of Ind1a1(1962] 3 s.c.R. 842, the Court reiterated : "That the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Art. 19(l)(a) of the Constitution includes the freedom of press i.e. the freedom of propagation of ideas, and that freedom is ensured by the freedom of circulation. Liberty of circulation is as essential to that freedom as the liberty of publication. Central to the concept of a free press is freedom of political opinion and at the core of that freedom lies the right to criticiae the Government, because it is only through free debate and free exchange of ideas that Government remains representation to the will of the people and orderly change ia effected. When avenues of political expression are closed, Government by consent of the governed would soon be foreclosed· Such freedom ie the foundation of free Government of a free people. Our Government aet up being elected limited end

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U,O,J., [A.P. SEN, J.]

responsible we need requisite freedom of any animadversion for our social interest which ordinarily demands free propagation of views. Freedom to think as one likes and to speak as one thinks at·e as a rule indispensable to the diacovery and separate of truth and without free speech, discussion cay be futile."

llomesh Thappar's case was cited with approval in Expreaa llewapapera (P) Ltd. & Anr. v. Union of India & Ora. (1959] .s.c.R. 12@ 120, There is in the Express Newspapers 1 case an elaborate discussion of the freedom of the press at PP• 118-128 of ~he Report. The Express Newspapers' case and also the case of Sakal Papers were cited with approval by the Court in Bennett Coleman. The principle ie too well-settled to need any more elaboration. I would only like to stress that the freedom of thought and expression, and the freedom of the press are not only valuable freedoms in themselves but are basic to a democrstic form of Government which proceeds on the theory that problems of the Government can be solved by the free exchange of thought and by public discussion of the various issues facing the nation. It is necessary to emphasize and one must not forget that the vitdl importance of freedom of speech and expression involves the freedom to dissent to a free democracy like ours. Democracy relies on the freedom of the press, It is the inalienable right of everyone to comment freely upon any matter of public importance. This right is one of the pillars of individual liberty-freedom of speech, which our Court has always unfailingly guarded. I wish to add that however precious and cherished the freedom of speech is under Art.19(l)(a) 1 this freedom is not absolute and unlimited at all ti'UeS and under all circumstances but is subject to the restrictions contained in Art. 19(2), That must be so because unrestricted freedom of speech and expression which includes the freedom of the press and is wholly free from restraints, amounts to uncontrolled licence which would lead to disorder and anarchy and it would be hazardous· to ignore the vital importance of our social and national interest in public order and security of the State.

In Bennett Co1-'a case the Court indicated that the extent of permissible limitations on this freedom are indicated by the fundamental law of tha land itself viz. Art. 19(2) of the Constitution. It was laid down that permiseible restrictions on

&llPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

any fundamental right guaranteed under Part III of the Constitution have to be imposed by a duly enacted law and must not be excessive i.e. they must not go beyond whar. is necessary to achieve the object of the la~ under which they are sought to be impoaed. "The power to impose restrictions on fundamentai rights is essentially a power to 'regulate' the exercise of those rights. In fact, 'regulation' and not extinction of that which is to be regulated is, generally speaking, the extent to which permissible restrictions may go in oraer to satisfy the test of reasonableness." The Court also dealt with the extent of permissible limitations on the freedom of speech and exprP.ssion guara."lteed under Art.19(l)(a). The test laid down by the Court in lleunett coleman's case is whether the direct and inmediate impact vf the impugned action is on the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Art. 19(l)(a) which includes the freedom of the press. It was observed that the restriction on the number of pages, a restraint on circulation and a restraint on advertizements would affect the fundamental right under Art.19(1 )(a) on the aspects of propagatl.on, publication and circulation of a n•'WSpaper. In repelling the contention of the learned Additional Sollcitor~neral that the newsprint policy did not violated Art. 19(l)(a) as it does not direct and immediately deal with the right mentioned in Art. 19(l)(a), the Court held that the test of pith and substance of the subject-matter and of direct and incidental effect of legislation are relevant to questions of legislative competence but they are irrelevant to the question of infringement of fundamental rights. The true test, according to the Court, is whethP.r the effect of the impugned action is to take away or abridge fundamental rights. It was stated that the word 'direct' would go to the quality or character of the effect and not the subject catter and the restriction sought to be imposed by the impugned newsprint policy was, in substance, a newspaper control i.e. to control the number of pages or circulation of dailies or newspapers and such restrictions were clearly outside the ambit of Art. 19(2) of the Constitution and therefore were in abridgement of the right of freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Art. 19(l)(a), and it added : "The ·Newsprint Control Policy is found to be newspaper control order in the guise of framing an Import Control Policy for newsprint. This Court in the Bank Nationalisation case (supra) laid down two tests. First it is not the object of the authority making the law impairing the right of the

r

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, J.]

citizen nor the form of action that determines the invasion of the right. Secondly, it i• the effect of the lsw and the action upon the right which attracts the jurisdiction of the court to grant relief. The direct operation of the Act upon the rights forms the real test.

••• No lsw or action would state in words that rights o): freedom of speech and expression are abridged or

taken away. That is why Courts have to protect and guard fundamental rights by considering the scope and provisions of the Act and its effect upon the fundamental rights." We have only to substitute the word 'executive' for the word 'lsw' and the result is obvious. Here, the impugned notices of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease and of the threatened demolition of the Express Buildings are intended- and meant to silence the voice of the Indian Express. It must logically follow that the impugned notices constitute a direct and imnediate threat to the freedom of the press and are thus violstive of Art. 19(l)(a) read with Art.14 of the Constitution. It must accordingly be held that these petitions under Art. 32 of the Constitution are maintainable.

The Government Grants Act, 1895 : Section 3: Purport & Effect of: Whether the notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease was valid and enforceable due to non-compliance of clsuse 6 thereof. It is coonnon ground that the perpetual lease was a Government grant governed by the Crown Grants Act, 1895, now known as the Government Grants Act. The Act is an explsnatory or declsratory Act; Doubts having arisen as to the extent and operation of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and as to the power of the Government to impose limitations and restrictions upon grants and other transfers of land made by it or under its authority, the Act was passed to remove such doubts as is clear from the long title and the preamble. The Act contains two sections and provides by s.2 for the exclusion of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and, by s.3 for the exclusion of, any rule of lsw, statute or enactment of the l.egislsture to the contrary. Ss.2 and 3 read as follows : "2. Transfer of Property Act, 1882. no: to apply to Government grants-

I!

Nothing in the Transfer of Prope1·ty Act, 1882, contained shall apply or be deemed over to have applied to any grant or other transfer of land or of any intereot therein heretofore made or hereafter to be made by or on behalf of the government to, or in favour of, any person whomsoever; but every such grant and transfer shall be cons trued and take effect as if the said Act had not been passed." "3. Goverment grants their tenor-

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.a.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

to

take

effect accordiDg to

All provisions, restrictions, conditions and limitations over contained in any such grant or transfer as aforesaid shall be valid and take effect according to their tenor, any rule of law, statute or enacbnent of the Legislature to the contrary notwithstanding." It is plain upon the terms that s.2 excludes the operation of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 to Government grants. While s. 3 declares that all provisions, restrictions, conditions and limitations contained over any such grant or transfer as aforesaid shall be valid and shall take effect according to their tenor, notwithstanding any rule of law, statute or enactment of the Legislature to the contrary. A series of judicial decisions have determined the overriding effect of s.3 making it amply clear that a grant of property by the Government partakes of the nature of law since it overrides even legal provisions which are contrary to the tenor of the document. Learned counsel appearing for res~ondent no. l, the Union of India, fairly conceded that the impugned notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease dated March 10, 1980 issued by the Engineer Officer, L&DO purporting to be on behalf of the lessor i.e. the Uriion of India under cl. 5 of the indenture of lease dated March 17, 1958 was invalid and had no le;;al effect since there was non-compliance of the mandatory requirements of cl.6 thereof. But as a very astute counsel he sought to evolve an argument contrary to the stand taken in the counter-affidavit filed by respondent no.2 on behalf of all the respondents and the supplementary affidavit of M.K. Mukherjee, Secretary, Ministry of Works & Houaing that the 'breach was irremediable' and therefore the lessor i.e. the Union of India acting through the Land & Development Officer (L&OO) was entitled to serve a notice under

EXPRESS NEwSPAPERS v. u.o.r. [A.P. SEN, J.]

cl.5 for re-entry upon forfeiture of lease. He contended that the impugned notice was, in reality, not a notice of forfeiture under cl.5 of the lease-deed but it was merely of an exploratory nature to afford petitioner no.l Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. to have its say before the L&DO as to whether the construction of the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 was in violation of the Master Plan or the Zonal Development Plans or. the building bye-laws i.e. contrary to the terms of the lease, and that it was for the L&IJO to be satisfied as to whether there wa" a breach of the terms of els. 2(14) and 2(5) of the lease and that in the e-vent of his reaching that conclusion, to proceed to serve the lessee with a notice of re-entry uppn forfeitu~e of lease under cl.5 learned counsel appearing for respondent no.5 L&DO has

placed before us a detailed note explaining the prevailing practice followed by the L&DO in such case. The meaning and significance of the note !s that the show cause notice under cl.5 served by the L&IJO is merely a preliminary step affording the lessee an opportunity to settle tile terms and conditions with the wncurrence of the Ministry of works & Housing, offered by the· lessor for condonation of such breacn. In the "event the lessee fails to comply with such terms, the L&DO withdraws the terms

offered and then calls upon the lessee to remove or remedy the

misuse or breach within 30 days. If there is failure on the part of the lessee to remedy such breach within the tim.e allowed, the L&OO processes the case for exercie,:e by the lessor i.e.. the Union of Ind~a of its rights to re-enter upon forfeiture of lease under

cl. 5 of the lease-deed. It ie said that according to the prevailing practice in respect of such leases i.e. pre 1959

leases of the kind held by petitioner no. l Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd., the approval of th~ Lt. Governor is considered a condition precedent to a final order of re-entry which is served on the lessee after such approval is accorded by the Lt. Governor.

In terms of

the order of re-entry the lessee is

requested to hand over possession peacefully to the L&DO within a reasonable tin..e. However, if the lessee does not hand over possession voluntarily in pursuance of L&OO' s letter, the L&DO

files an application under s. 5(1) of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971. Under s.8 of the Act the Estate Officer has the same powers that are vested in the

Civil Court under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, in trying a suit in respect of matters mentioned therein. The Estate Officer has to form an opinion that the lessee was in unauthorized

occupation of any public premises and that he should be evicted whereupon the Estate Officer issues a notice under s.4 by calling upon all persons concerned to show cause why an order of evictlon

SUPREME COu'llT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

should not be passed. Under s.9 of the Act the person aggrieved has the remedy of an appeal to the District Judge and thereafter he may move the High Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution. I am not at all impressed by any of these submissions advanced on behalf of the respondents. There can be no doubt whatever on a true construction of the impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 that the Engineer Officer, Land & Development Office purporting to act on bahalf of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works &Rousing served a notice of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease under cl.5 of the lease-deed. There was

C

no question of the said notice being construed to be of an exploratory nature. The note prepared by the L&DO is nothing but an afterthought. In the view that I take that respondent no.2 is not the successor of the Chief Conmissioner of Delhi nor has any function in relation to the lease. There is no warrant for thE::

suggestion that prior approval of the Lt. Governor is a condition precedent to the right of the lessor i.e. the Union of India to exercise its right to re-entry upon forfeiture of lease under

cl.S of the lease-deed.

There are two decisions of this Court which appear to be contradictory. In Bisban Das & Ors. v. State of Punjab & Ors. [1962] 2 S.C.R. 69, a Constitution Bench of this Court speaking through S.R. Das, J. in somewhat simil"r circumstances allowed the petition under Art.32 of the Constitution directing restoration of possession to the lessee who had been dispossessed from land granted by the Government by display of f0rce. What had happened was this. One Ramjidas built a dharamsala, a temple and shops appurtenant thereto with the joint family funds on Government land with the permission of the Government. After his death the other members of the family who were in management and possession of those properties were dispossessed by the State Government of Punjab at the instigation of ,a member of the ruling Congress party. The petitioners applied to the Punjab.High Court for issue of appropriate writs under Art.226 of the Constitution but the petition was dismissed in limine on the preliminary ground that the matter involved disputed questions of fact. An appeal under cl.10 of the Letters Patent was also dismissed on the same ground. The petitioners then moved this Court under Art.32. The State Government sought to justify the action on the ground that the petitioners were merely trespassers as the land

on which the dharamsala stood belonged to

the State,

and

the

respondents were entitled to use the minimum of force to eject the trespassers. It was also contended that there was a serious

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J. J

dispute on questions of fact between the parties and also whether the petitioners had any right or title to the subject matter in dispute and therefore proceedings by way of a writ were not appropriate in the case inasmuch as the decision of the Court would amount to a decree declaring a party's. title and ordering restoration of possession. The Court repelled both the contentions as unsound and held that the petitioners had made out a clear case of violation of their fundamental rights. As to the contention that the petitioners were mere trespassers, tl)e Court held that the admitted· position was that the land belonged to the State; with the permission of the State, Ramjidas on behalf of the joint family firm of Faquir Chand Bhagwan Das built the dharamsala, temple and shops and managed the same during his lifetime. After his death the petitioners, other members of the joint family continued in possession and management. On this aJmitted position, it was held that the petitioners could not be held to be mere trespassers in respect of thP. dharamsala, temple and shops; nor could it be held that the dharamsala, temple and shops belonged to the State irrespective of the question whether the trust created was of a public or private nature, and it was observed : "It is, therefore, impossible to hold that in respect of the dharamsala, temples and shops, the State has acquired any rights whatsoever merely by reason of their being on the land belonging to the State. If the State thought that.the constructions should be removed or that the condition as to resumption of the land should be invoked, it was open to the State to take appropriate legal action for the purpose."

As to the second contention, the Court observed : "It was enough to say that they are bona fide in possession of the constructions in question and could not be removed except under authority of law. The respondents clearly violated their fundamental rights by depriving them of possession of the dharamsala by

executive orders." The Court accordingly quashed the orders and issued a writ of mandamus directing restoration of the property. The Court felt its duty to pass strictures against the Government : ''We feel it our duty to say that the executive action .taken in this case by the State and its officers is destructive of the basic principle of the rule of law.

Ii

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

The facto and the position in law thus clearly are (1) that the buildings constructed on this piece of Government land did not belong to Government, (2) that the petitioners were in possession and occupation of the buildings and (3) that by the virtue of enactments binding on the Government, the petitioners could be

dispossessed, if at all, only in pursuance of a decree

of a Civil Court, obtained in proceedings properly initiated. In these circumstances the action of the Government in taking the law into their hands and dispossessing the petitioners by the display of force, exhibits a callous disregard of the normal requirements of the rule of. law apart from what might legitimately and reasonably be expected from a Government functioning in a society governed by a Constitution which guarantees to its citizens against arbitrary invasion of the executive of peaceful possession of property." The Court also adverted to the earlier decision in Wa.zir Chand v. State of H.P., [1955] l s.c.R. 408, where it was held that the State or its executive officers cannot interfere with the rights of others unless they can point to some specific rule of law which authorises their acts, and to Baa Prasad Narayan Sabi V• State of Bi.bar, [1953] s.c.R. 1129, where the Court said that nothing is more likely to drain the vitality from the rule of law than legislation which singles out a particular individual from his fellow subjects and visits him with a disability which is not imposed upon the others, and concluded : "We have here a highly discriminatory aod autocratic act which deprives a person of the possession of property without reference to any law or legal authority. Even if the property was trust property it is difficult to see how the Municipal Comnittee, Barna.la, can step in as trustee on an executive determination only. The reasons given for this extraordinary action are, to quote what we said in Sabi 's case (supra), remarkable for their disturbing implications•" In the later case of State of Orissa V• Baa Chandra Dev,

A.I.R. 1964 s.c. 685, Gajendragadkar, J. delivering the judgment

of the Constitution Bench observed :

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. U.O.I. [A.P. SEN, J. J

"Oridinarily, where property has been granted by the State on condition which make the grant resumable, after res1DDption it is the grantee who moves the Court for appropriate relief, and that proceeds on the basis that the grantor State which has reserved to itself the right to res...e may, after exercising its right, seek to recover possession of the property without filing a suit." All that the Couri. laid down was that the existence of a eight is the foundation for a petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution. In that case, certain ex-zamindars of Ganjam district were holding Govermnent Lands appurtenant to their office as Muthadars and were· dispossessed therefrom upon resumption of their Muthas. The Court held that the lands were held by the ex-zamindars as service tenures which.were resumable at the will of ·the Govermnent. The parties were at issue on the question about the character of the grant under which the predecessors of the ex-zamindars were originally granted the lands in question. The Orissa High Court held that it was not possible for it to decide the important question of title involved in proceedings under Art. 226 but that such a kind of title could only be decided in a properly conatituted suit but nevertheless were inclined to the view that the right to recover possession vesting in a person who had been in possession prior to such dispossession which was implicit in s.9 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 would be enforced by a petition under Art. 226. The view of the High Court was obviously not sustainable. At the hearing, counsel for the respondents sought an adjournment on the ground that the respondents had in the meanwhile filed a suit against the State Govermnent and further that the parties were negotiating for a settlement. It appears "that the <;ourt rejected the prayer for adjournment saying that no useful purpose would be served by granting any further time and thereafter entered upon I the pierits. lt held that merely because a suit under s. 9 of the Specific Relief Act would have been competent, no right can be claimed by the respondents merely on the ground of their possession under Art. 226 unless "their right to remain in possession was established against the State Govermnent. There is no reference to the earlier decision of the Constitution Bench in Bisban Das' case nor does the judgment lay down any contrary principle. It seems to me that the observations of Gajendragadkar, J. were merely in the nature of obiter in . _ Cllaadra Dev's case and nothing really turns on the observations made by him. The decision in RRW'bandra Dev's case appears to be in per incuriam..

Ii

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[1985] SUPP.3 s.c.R.

Even in cases involving purely contractual issues, the settled law is that where statutory provisions of public law are involved, writs will issue: lid. Bani£ v. State of Assaa,[1970] 2

s.c.a. 197. ll

For the sake of completeness, I wish to clear the ground of a possible misconception. Learned counsel appearing for respondent no .1 the Union of India while contending that the impugned notice dated March 10, 1980 was of an exploratory nature, fairly conceded that the lessor i.e. the Union of India lllllSt enforce its right of re-entry upon forfeiture of lease under cl. 5 of the lease-deed by recourse to due process of law and wanted to assure us that there was no question of marching the army or making use of the demolition squad of the Delhi Development Authority or the Municipal Corporation of Delhi in demolishing the Express Buildings. As we felt that there was •ome ambiguity in the expression 'due process of law', we wanted a categorical answer whether by this he meant by a properly constituted suit. Without meaning any disrespect, the learned counsel adopted an ambivalent attitude saying that the due process may not only consist in the filing of a suit by the lessor or re-entry upon forfeiture of the lease but that in the case of lease of Govermnent lands, the authorities may also take recourse to the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971. I have no doubt in my mind that the learned counsel is not right in suggestion that the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Minis try of Works & Housing can in the facts and circumstances of the case, take recourse to the summary procedure under that Act. The Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. having acted upon the grant of permission by the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing to construct the new Express Building with an increased FAR of 360 together with a double basement was clearly not an unanthorized occupant within the meaning of s.2(g) of the Act which runs as under "2(g) "unauthorized occupation", in relation to any public premises, means the occupation by any person of the public premises without authority for such occupation, and includes the continuance in occupation by any person of the public premises after the authority (whether by way of grant of any other llklde of transfer) under which he was allowed to occupy the premises has expired or has been determined for any reason whatsoever."

-

EXPRESS NEWSPAPERS v. u.o.I. [A.P. SEN, J.]

The Express Buildings constructed by Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. with the sanction of the lessor i.e. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing on plots nos. 9 and 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg demised on perpetual lease by registered lease-deed dated March 17, 1958 can, by no process of reasoning, be regarded as public premises belonging to the Central Govermnent under s. 2(e). That being so, there is no question of the lessor applying for eviction of the Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. under s.2(1) of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971 nor has the Estate Officer any authority or jurisdiction to direct their eviction under sub-s.(2) thereof by summary process. Due process of law in a case like the present necessarily implies the filing of suit by the lessor Le. the Union of India, Ministry of Works & Housing for the enforcement of the alleged right of re-entry, if any upon forfeiture of lease due to breach of the terms of the lease. Nothing stated here should be construed to mean that the Govermnent has not the power to take recourse to the provisions of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971 where admittedly there is unauthorized construction by a lessee or by any other person on Govermnent land which is public premises within the meaning of s. 2 ( e) and such person is in unauthorized occupation thereof. The constitutional position of the Lieutenant Governor : Whether the Lieutenant-Governor is the successor of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi· One of the most crucial issues on which long and erudite arguments were advanced by learned counsel for the parties, turned on the question as to whether the Lt. Governor was a successor of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners contended that the Lt. Governor cannot usurp the functions of the lessor i.e. the Union of India or the Chief Commissioner of Delhi in relation to the lease in question. It is urged that the Union Territory of Delhi which first became a Part 'C' State under the Constitution, was an entirely new constitutional entity and therefore the office of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi ceased to exist. It is further urged that the Lt. Governor appointed by the President under Art. 239(1) of the Constitution is an Administrato

Related judgments

More Supreme Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.