Ganesh Naik v. The State by Karnataka
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice Mohammad Nawaz, Justice B.pramod
- Case number
- CRL.A No. 1149 of 2019
- Result
- DISMISSED
- Acts & sections
- Section 302 IPC, Section 313 CrPC
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
-1HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 PRESENT THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ AND THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1149 OF 2019 (C)
BETWEEN: GANESH NAIK AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS S/O. BAJJA NAIK OCC: COOLIE R/O. BOMMENAHALLI TANDA VILLAGE DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DISTRICT-577 514 …APPELLANT (BY SRI VEERESHA E., ADVOCATE) Digitally signed by SHARADAVANI B Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
AND: THE STATE BY KARNATAKA BY MAYAKONDA POLICE STATION MAYAKONDA DAVANAGERE DISTRICT-577 34 REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT BUILDING BENGALURU-560 001 …RESPONDENT (BY SMT. SOWMYA R., H.C.G.P.)
-2HC-KAR
THIS
CRL.A.
IS
FILED
U/S.374(2)
CR.P.C
BY
THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANT PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT OF CONVICTION DATED 24.05.2019 AND ORDER OF SENTENCE DATED 25.05.2019 PASSED BY THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT
AND
SESSIONS
JUDGE,
DAVANAGERE
IN
S.C.NO.91/2017 - CONVICTING THE APPELLANT/ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 302 OF IPC. THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT
ON
07.10.2026,
THIS
DAY,
THE
COURT
PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ and HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD CAV JUDGMENT (PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD)
The present criminal appeal is preferred by the appellant/accused challenging the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 25.05.2019 passed by the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Davanagere, in S.C. No.91/2017, whereby the appellant/accused was convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, 'IPC') and
-3HC-KAR
sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs.30,000/- (Rupees Thirty Thousand only). 2.
Heard
Sri.
Veeresha
E,
learned
counsel
appearing for the appellant and Smt. Sowmya R, learned HCGP appearing for the respondent-State.
Perused the
entire material available on record. 3.
It is the case of the prosecution that on
27.02.2017 at about 9.00 a.m., in a vacant place situated in front of the house of PW.8 at Bommenahalli Village, the accused picked up a quarrel with his mother Shantibai (hereinafter referred to as 'the deceased') over her refusal to affix her signature to the documents. When the deceased refused to accede to his demand, the accused allegedly pulled her saree and assaulted her on the head with an iron rod. The deceased, who was undergoing treatment at C.G. Hospital, Davanagere, succumbed to the injuries on 01.03.2017 at about 7.36 p.m. Thus, the accused committed the murder of the deceased.
-4HC-KAR
4.
The first informant, PW.8 gave a complaint on
27.02.2017 that his parents were working as coolies. In his grandfather's name Bacha Naik, they had 3/4th acre of land. Accused wanted it to be changed to his name to clear a loan and to sell the same, wanted signature of his mother and there was galata by the accused and the deceased. The accused wanted the land to himself and was forcing the deceased to sign the document. Further, it is stated that on 27.02.2017 he got a call around 10.30 a.m. from one Mr.Sathish Naik who had informed that on 27.02.2017 at about 9.00 a.m., when he was in front of the house of the deceased, the accused came with an iron rod and was quarrelling with the deceased. He saw that the accused was abusing the deceased with filthy language and the deceased requested her husband to call Sharada Bai, wife of the accused as the accused was drunk. When the deceased was going, the accused caught hold of her saree and pulled it and assaulted her with an iron rod, resulting in bleeding injuries. The deceased cried out of
-5HC-KAR
pain and the accused informed that as the deceased did not sign the papers, he had threatened to kill the deceased. Thereafter, he and husband of the deceased took her to the Chigateri Hospital. 5.
Based on the information furnished by PW.8,
the police registered a criminal case and upon completion of the investigation, filed a charge sheet against the accused. 6.
To
examined
prove
charge,
witnesses
as
PWs.1
prosecution to
23,
has
marked
documents as Exhibits P1 to P33 and the material objects as MOs.1 to 4. In the statement recorded under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., the accused denied all the incriminating evidence appeared against him. The trial Court after considering the evidence of PWs.8 and 10 who are the eyewitnesses and also the evidence of PW.11, and other documents,
convicted
accused
for
offence
punishable under Section 302 of IPC. Being aggrieved by
-6HC-KAR
the same, the accused is before this Court in the present criminal appeal. 7.
Learned
counsel
for
appellant/accused
argued that: i. PWs.8 and 10 are interested witnesses and there are contradictions in their evidence. ii. PW.11 who had informed PW.4 had turned hostile. iii. There are contradictions of timing in the evidence of eyewitnesses. iv. Motive is not proved and PW.12 did not support the case of the prosecution. v. PW.8 in his evidence had deposed that there was no blood on the MO.1-iron rod and saree. vi. The learned counsel has relied on judgments passed in Rajakhan
vs.
State
of
Chhattisgarh,
2025 INSC 167, Govind vs. State of Haryana, in Crl.A.No.5641/2024
and
Gautam
Satnami
State of Chhattisgarh in Crl.A.No.1782/2026.
vs.
-7HC-KAR
8.
Per contra, learned HCGP contends that:
i. PWs.8 and 10-eyewitnesses, though they are relatives, their evidence cannot be brushed aside as they were present at the time of assault. ii. PW.13-doctor who conducted the postmortem, corroborates the evidence of PWs.8 and 10. iii. PW.14-doctor of CG Medical Hospital, has given evidence in support of prosecution. iv.
Further,
PW20-doctor
who
had
treated
deceased has also given evidence supporting the prosecution. PW15, Doctor of SS Hospital, has given evidence supporting the case of prosecution and has stated that the deceased had expired on 01.03.2017. v. PW.7-panch witness to Ex.P8-photograph though turned hostile supports seizure of MO.1-iron rod. vi. The prosecution has proved the case beyond doubt and the order of conviction passed by the trial court is just and proper.
-8HC-KAR
9.
Having
considered
contentions
of
appellant and the respondent, the following point arises for consideration of this Court: "Whether the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence passed by the learned Trial Court suffer from any illegality or infirmity warranting interference by this Court?"
10.
The prosecution has examined PW.1, who is an
inquest Pancha to Ex. P1.PW.1, Manjunaik, the son of CW5, has stated that it had been 8 months since Shantabai had died and that; he had seen the body with an injury on the left side of the head. 11.
PW.4 is the complainant-son of the deceased,
the first informant, who has stated that accused and deceased are brother and sister and there was dispute in respect
of
land.
When
he
had
gone
for
work
on
27.02.2017, he got a call around 10.30 am from one Satish Naik-PW.11 stating that the accused had assaulted the deceased with an iron rod and she was taken to the
-9HC-KAR
CG Hospital, Davanagere and asked to come over. He has also mentioned that due to the land dispute the accused scolded the deceased by using filthy language and he had stated that he would commit her murder. 12.
PW.5-uncle of the accused denied statement
made before the police. PW.6-Pancha of seizure mahazar denied notice and seizure of MO.1, and has turned hostile. PW.7- pancha to Ex. P8-photograph, has stated that he is in a rented house situated near the house of the accused and he is his uncle. He states that Ravi Naik, deceased and PW.8 were there. Though he has turned hostile, in the cross- examination, he has admitted that the accused was carrying MO.1-iron rod.
13.
PW.8-eyewitness states that the accused and
his wife were brother and sister and there was dispute with regard to the land as the accused wanted to sell the land and his wife had objected to it. The accused had come to their house and was carrying the iron rod and
- 10 HC-KAR
asked his wife to sign the papers and abused the deceased in filthy language and pulled her saree. When he had requested to call the wife of the accused and when she was on the way, accused followed her and assaulted on her head with M.O 1 and thereafter, she was taken to the hospital for treatment. It was PW.11 who had called the ambulance. In the
course of cross-examination, the
defense has elicited that the houses of the deceased and the accused were situated at different places. Further, they have also elicited that due to the assault, blood had fallen on the saree.
14.
PW.10
is
wife
of
PW.4,
who
is
eyewitness. She has stated that on the date of incident, her father-in-law and deceased were in the house and the accused came to the house of the deceased holding an iron rod threatening the deceased that because she is not signing the paper, he is unable to sell the property and the deceased had informed the accused to call the person who
- 11 HC-KAR
is purchasing the property. During that time, the accused had abused the deceased in filthy language and forced the deceased to sign the papers. At that time, her father-inlaw had said to the deceased to get the wife of the accused and when she was proceeding, the accused assaulted the accused with iron rod and the deceased fell on the ground and thereafter, the deceased was taken to the hospital for treatment. 15.
PW.11 informed PW.4 about the incident and in
the cross-examination, he has turned hostile and it is elicited that the lawyer who is representing the accused is his uncle. 16.
PW.12 is the agreement holder of the land and
he admits that Ex.P13 was executed by the accused, his wife and children but the deceased had not signed the agreement. However, he denies the execution of Ex. P15. The said witness has turned hostile,and it is elicited that
- 12 HC-KAR
on 20.04.2015, accused had executed the agreement in his favor. 17.
PW.13
is
doctor
who
conducted
postmortem. The following external injuries were found on the body of the deceased: "A surgically sutured wound measuring 05CMx0.5 CM skull deep (known after removal of sutures) with intact suture material (Catgus) is present over the left parietotermporal part of the scalp, which is obliquely placed."
The doctor has given the opinion that the deceased died due to "COMA" consequent upon head injury sustained. In his evidence he has stated that he did not notice blood stain on the MO1. 18.
PW.14 is the doctor who gave first aid and
referred the deceased to a higher hospital. In Ex.P21, there is a mention of history of assault by the accused. 19.
PW.15 is the doctor/professor, at S S Hospital,
Davanagere,
who
has
stated
that
on
01.03.2017,
- 13 HC-KAR
deceased was admitted to the hospital with history of assault, and that the patient was unconscious. The deceased sustained head injury due to which she suffered brain hemorrhage and was discharged against medical advice. 20.
PW.20 is the doctor working in C T Central
Hospital, Davanagere. He has deposed that the deceased took first aid treatment in CG Hospital, Davanagere and the said C G Hospital referred the deceased to their hospital
for
further
treatment.
The
deceased
had
undergone CT scan, and it is noticed that the deceased sustained left posterior frontal and temporal bone region parachymalhaematoma, Sub archanold hemorrhage with pneumocephalus and mild cerebral oedema. The deceased was treated and neuro surgeon’s opinion was taken. 21.
PW.17 is the Police Constable who apprehended
the accused. PW.18 is another Police Constable who submitted FIR to the Magistrate and submitted one more
- 14 HC-KAR
requisition to add offence under Section 302 of IPC. PW.19 is the Head Constable who collected MOs.1 and 2 and submitted them to FSL. 22.
PW.21 is the ASI, who registered the FIR.
PW.22 is the police officer who had investigated the matter initially and sent a note to add Section 302 of IPC. PW.23 is the CPI who filed the investigation. 23.
The prosecution case rests primarily on the
direct evidence of eyewitnesses, PWs.8 and 10, which is corroborated by the medical evidence on record. Both PWs.8 and 10 have categorically deposed that the accused came to the house of the deceased armed with an iron rod and assaulted the deceased. Their ocular testimony finds corroboration in the medical evidence of PW.13, the doctor, who has opined that the death was due to "coma consequent upon head injury sustained". Thus, the ocular evidence is consistent with the medical evidence on record
- 15 HC-KAR
and clearly establishes the homicidal nature of the death. 24.
Further, the prosecution has established that
there was a dispute between the accused and the deceased in respect of the land and that the accused and his family members, except the deceased, had executed Ex.P15 in favor of PW.12. A perusal of page No.5 of Ex.P13, the Agreement Deed, clearly discloses that the said document bears the signatures of PW.12, the accused and his family members, except the deceased. The fact that the deceased had not signed the said agreement and that there was a quarrel between the accused and the deceased in this regard clearly establishes the motive for the commission of the offence. 25. On careful appreciation of the evidence of eyewitnesses PWs.8 and 10, it is clearly established that the accused came to the house of the deceased armed with an iron rod marked as M.O.1. The fact that the
- 16 HC-KAR
accused had come armed with a deadly weapon, coupled with the dispute arising out of the deceased's refusal to sign the document, clearly establishes his premeditated intention to assault the deceased. The minor discrepancies in the testimony of PWs.8 and 10 are neither material nor sufficient to discredit their
otherwise
consistent and
trustworthy evidence. Such discrepancies do not go to the root of the prosecution case and cannot be a ground to discard their ocular testimony. Further, Ex.P19, the postmortem report, establishes that the injuries sustained by the deceased were consistent with the assault by an iron rod such as M.O.1 and were sufficient to cause death. The ocular testimony of PWs.8 and 10 thus finds material corroboration in the medical evidence on record. We are therefore of the considered opinion that the prosecution has established the involvement of the accused in the commission
of
offence
and
that
minor
discrepancies pointed out by the defence do not create any reasonable doubt regarding the prosecution case.
- 17 HC-KAR
26.
The contention of the appellant that PWs.8 and
10 are interested witnesses is untenable. Mere relationship of PWs.8 and 10 with the deceased is not a sufficient ground to discard their evidence. It is beneficial to refer to the Apex Court judgment in the case of Dalip Singh and Others vs. State of Punjab AIR 1953 SC 364, where the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that - "The testimony of an eyewitness cannot be thrown out or labeled as inherently untrustworthy simply because they are related to the deceased or injured party."
27.
In the present case, the occurrence having
taken place near the house of the deceased, the presence of PWs.8 and 10, who are the husband and daughter-inlaw
of
deceased
respectively,
at
scene
of
occurrence was natural in the ordinary course of events. Merely because the said witnesses are related to the deceased, their testimony cannot be discarded on that ground alone, particularly when their presence at the
- 18 HC-KAR
scene of occurrence is natural and their evidence is otherwise credible and trustworthy.
28.
Further, in the present case, the evidence of the
eyewitnesses is cogent and reliable, and no material discrepancies are forthcoming. Minor discrepancies, if any, do not affect the credibility of their testimony.
29.
In
view
of
foregoing
discussion,
contention of the accused regarding the partisan nature of the witnesses is, by itself, not a sufficient ground to discard their testimony, particularly when the evidence of the eyewitnesses finds corroboration from the other evidence adduced by the prosecution.
30.
The evidence on record finds corroboration from
the other material evidence placed on record, particularly the medical evidence. Further, the testimony of PW.12 is relevant insofar as he admits the execution of Ex.P13 and acknowledges that the said document does not bear the signature of the deceased. These aspects of his testimony
- 19 HC-KAR
are required to be considered in conjunction with the other evidence on record while assessing the evidentiary value of Ex. P13.
31.
The contention of the learned counsel for the
appellant/accused that there were no blood stains on the MO.1 does not hold water as it is not a sharp weapon and by use of the MO.1- iron rod, the deceased has sustained injury to the head, which is a vital part, due to which she was under coma and has succumbed to the same.
32.
Learned counsel for the appellant has placed
reliance on the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rajakhan v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2025 INSC 167; Govind
v.
State
of
Haryana,
Criminal
Appeal
No.5641/2024; and Gautam Satnami v. State of Chhattisgarh,
Criminal
Appeal
No.1782/2026,
in
support of the proposition that recovery of incriminating articles, by itself, cannot form the sole basis for conviction
- 20 HC-KAR
in
absence
of
other
reliable
and
corroborative
evidence.
33.
In the present case, the voluntary statement of
the accused was recorded as per Ex. P27 and the said accused has stated that he has thrown the M.O.1, which was the iron rod, in the back portion of his house. M.O.1 was produced by the accused and the Panchanama was also conducted as per Ex. P27. As stated supra, though the M.O. 1 which is the iron rod has been recovered, there is also the ocular testimony of PWs 8 and 10 which finds corroboration from the other evidence available on record.
34.
The
evidence
of
PWs.8
and
10,
when
appreciated in conjunction with the other corroborative material on record, establishes the guilt of the accused beyond
reasonable
doubt.
The
conviction,
therefore,
cannot be assailed merely on the ground of alleged infirmities in the recovery. The said principle has also been reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rakesh and
- 21 HC-KAR
Another v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another, reported in (2021) 7 SCC 188, wherein it was held that recovery of the weapon used in the commission of an offence is not a sine qua non for conviction when credible and trustworthy eyewitness evidence is available. In the present case, the conviction is not founded solely on the recovery of the weapon but is principally based on the reliable ocular testimony of PWs.8 and 10, which finds corroboration
in
other
evidence
on
record.
Consequently, the judgments relied upon by the appellant, which deal with the insufficiency of recovery as the sole basis for conviction, are distinguishable on facts and do not advance the case of the appellant.
35. In view of the aforesaid discussion and upon reappreciation of the evidence and perusal of the material on record, we are of the considered opinion that the impugned judgment and sentence of the learned Trial Court
do
not
suffer
from
any
infirmity
warranting
- 22 HC-KAR
interference by this Court. Hence, we proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The appeal is dismissed.
Sd/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ) JUDGE
Sd/(B.PRAMOD) JUDGE Bsv/Mkm