Gimageria Welfare Primary Teachers Training Institute and Anr v. State of West Bengal and ORS.

Court
Calcutta High Court
Date of judgment
13 November 2026
Judge
Justice Amrita Sinha
Case number
WPA No. 31691 of 2026
Result
DISPOSED

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

13-11-2026 Item No.2

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

Subrata Bhattacharyya

Appellate Side

AR(C)

Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction

WPA No.31691 of 2026 Gimageria Welfare Primary Teachers’ Training Institute & Anr. -vsThe State of West Bengal & Ors. Mr. Biswarup Bhattacharya Mr. Rahul Kumar Singh Mr. Rajdeep Pramanik

…for the petitioners

Mr. Billwadal Bhattacharyya, Sr. Adv. Mr. Parashar Baidya …for the University Ms. Asha G. Gutgutia

…for NCTE

Mr. Ajit Kumar Mishra, AGP Mr. Madhu Jana Mr. Ankit Kumar Mishra

…for the State

1. The first petitioner claims to be a self-financed Institute imparting B.Ed course to the students. The second petitioner claiming to be the assistant secretary represents the Institute. 2. The petitioners are aggrieved by the act of Baba Saheb Ambedkar Education University publishing a list of colleges non-eligible for renewal of affiliation under the University for the academic session 2026-27. The petitioner Institute has been incorporated in the said list. 3. The note of the University preceding the list mentions that the enlisted colleges are not able to meet the expected criteria and hence are found ineligible for affiliation (renewal) and therefore are not allowed to admit the students in B.Ed course for the session 2026-28. The colleges have been

directed to immediately overcome their deficiencies to make themselves eligible for admission in the session 2027-29. 4. There are 205 colleges mentioned in the list published by the University which are ineligible for renewal of affiliation for the academic session 2026-27/28. 5. The petitioners allege that the particular reason or ground on which the Institute has been found to be

ineligible

for

renewal

affiliation

and

admission of students has not been disclosed. For non-disclosure of the reason of ineligibility, the bar to take admission ought to be set aside. The affiliation of the Institute ought to be renewed. 6. The petitioners submit that a show cause notice was issued by the University on August 29, 2026 pointing out certain deficiencies. The Institute was permitted 21 days’ time to file response to the show cause which the Institute filed before the Registrar (Acting) of the University. The petitioners allege that no decision has yet been taken by the University on consideration of the reply to the show cause. 7. The University published a notice for admission in the B.Ed. programme. The petitioners not being aware of the fate of their reply to the show cause are not in a position to take admission in the Institute because of the bar imposed by the University. Until and unless affiliation of the Institute is renewed, the Institute will not be in a position to take admission of the students. 8. It has been submitted that the University ought to have

taken a

decision

after considering

response given by the petitioners. 9. A supplementary affidavit has been filed by the

petitioners wherein it has been mentioned that a further surprise inspection was conducted in the Institute on October 6, 2026 and the members of

inspecting

team

were

satisfied

with

performance of the Institute. 10.

The petitioners pray for a direction upon the

University to allow the Institute to take admission in the B.Ed course for the session 2026-28. 11.

The submission and prayer of the petitioners

have been vehemently opposed by the learned senior counsel representing the University. It has been submitted that there are glaring deficiencies that

were

detected

at

time

surprise

inspections on July 29, 2026 and October 6, 2026. The University cannot permit the Institute to take admission of students till the deficiencies are cured. 12.

It has been submitted that the Institute has

been allowed time to rectify the deficiencies for taking admission in the future academic year. 13.

Learned senior counsel representing the

University has drawn attention of the Court to a communication dated May 18, 2026 made by the Chairman, Sikkim Students Welfare Board, HRDD, Sikkim addressed to ADG (Law & Order), West Bengal Police Directorate complaining against illegal practice by B.Ed/D.El.Ed institutions in West Bengal. 14.

The communication specifically mentions

about inspection team by the Board of Sikkim in various colleges in the State of West Bengal for approval of scholarships for SC-ST students. During inspection, the Sikkim authority found that several colleges in this State do not have proper infrastructure and certified faculty to run the

course. 15.

It

has

members

been

have

found

been

that

appointed

some

faculty

in

different

institutions for the same position simultaneously. The Sikkim authority found several malpractices which are flourishing in the State of West Bengal. 16.

The attention of the police has been drawn

to the allegations of nexus between several private colleges, HRDD officials and NCTE. Such practice has been found to have affected the entire education system of this State. 17.

The Sikkim authority opined that the illegal

practice is destroying the credibility of the teacher education

and

misleading

thousands

unemployed youth who obtained their degrees. 18.

A request has been made by the Sikkim

authority to intervene in the matter and to order for high-level inquiry by the Department of Higher Education along with NCTE Eastern Regional Committee into the functioning of B.Ed/D.El.Ed colleges in the State of West Bengal which are running without fear. 19.

In response to such communication, the

authorities in the State of West Bengal including the Higher Education Department took up the issue

and

conducted

surprise

inspections

to

ascertain the genuinity of the allegations made in the complaint by the Sikkim Board. 20.

The University has also relied upon an order

dated July 31, 2026 passed by this Bench in WPA No.19240 of 2026 in the matter of Sanjana Mandal & Anr. v. The State of West Bengal & Ors. wherein the Court expressed displeasure about the activity of the B.Ed self-financed colleges and opined that the colleges are only concerned about their finance

and hardly take care of the academic career of the students. 21.

The Court expressed opinion that the Higher

Education Department of the State and NCTE ought to keep regular checks over the self-financed colleges to ascertain as to whether education is at all imparted in the colleges or they are merely functioning for the purpose of generation of revenue. 22.

The Court directed the Secretary, Higher

Education Department to constitute a special team consisting of competent officers to investigate and ascertain the status and functioning of the selffinanced B.Ed colleges in the State. 23.

NCTE was also directed to constitute a

separate team to inspect each and every selffinanced B.Ed colleges in the State to ascertain the mode and manner of their functioning. 24.

Learned counsel for NCTE submits that the

Institute ought to follow the provisions of law for renewal

affiliation

and

for

admission

students. 25.

Upon hearing submissions made on behalf

of the parties and on perusal of the documents placed before this Court, the Court is of the considered

opinion

petitioners

to

that

permit

prayer

Institute

to

take

admission of the students in the current academic session

cannot

be

allowed.

The

same

is

particularly because of the several deficiencies that have been pointed out by the University. 26.

Till the deficiencies are rectified and the

University

is

satisfied

with

infrastructural

facilities

regard

to

Institute

for

imparting education to students, the affiliation of

the college ought not to be renewed. If the deficiencies are not rectified, then the students who will take admission in the course will be the worst sufferers. 27.

The petitioners contend that they have

already given a detailed response to the show cause notice dealing with the deficiencies pointed out. 28.

The competent authority of the University is

directed to take a decision on the response given by

petitioners

upon

giving

reasonable

opportunity of hearing to the petitioners to place documents in support of their stand. 29.

Only if the University is satisfied that the

Institute would be in a proper position to impart education to the students, the University may take a decision to renew the affiliation of the Institute. 30.

A decision shall be taken by the competent

authority of the University in accordance with law at the earliest but positively within a fortnight from the date of communication of this order. 31.

If

infrastructural

University

is

satisfied

with

facility

Institute

for

functioning as B.Ed college, then the University may take a decision to extend the time period for taking admission in the current academic session. 32.

The writ petition is disposed of.

33.

All parties are to act on the server copy of

this order duly downloaded from the official website of this court. 34.

Certified server copy of this order, if applied

for, shall be made available to the parties.

[Amrita Sinha, J ]

Related judgments

More Calcutta High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.