Govind Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand

Court
High Court of Jharkhand
Date of judgment
24 September 2026
Bench
Justice Sri Ananda Sen, Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava
Case number
Cr.A(DB) No. 1520 of 2017
Result
Dismissed
Acts & sections
Section 313 CrPC, Section 302 IPC, Section 341 IPC, Section 161 CrPC
Advocates
Arvind Kr. Choudhary, Vishwanath Roy, J. Sri Pradeep Kumar Srivastava
Subject
Criminal, Family

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI Criminal Appeal (D.B.) No. 1520 of 2017

[Against the Judgment of conviction dated 28.07.2017 and Order of sentence dated 03.08.2017 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge-IV, Deoghar in Sessions Case No. 19/2016]

Govind Yadav, son of Taro Mahto, resident of Village – Dudhani, P.O. + P.S. – Kunda, District - Deoghar. … … Appellant Versus The State of Jharkhand … … Respondent ….. For the Appellant : Mr. Arvind Kr. Choudhary, Advocate For the Respondent: Mrs. Vishwanath Roy, Spl.P.P.

….. P R E S E N T SRI ANANDA SEN, J. SRI PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, J.

JUDGMENT Dated: 24th September, 2026 By Court:

2.

Heard learned counsel for the parties. Instant

criminal

appeal

is

directed

against

judgment of conviction dated 28.07.2017 and order of sentence

dated

03.08.2017

passed

by

learned

Additional Sessions Judge-IV, Deoghar in S.C. No. 19 of 2016, arising out of Deoghar Kunda P.S. Case No. 887 of 2015 corresponding to G.R. No. 2039 of 2015, whereby and whereunder, the appellant has been convicted for the offence under Section 302 of the I.P.C.

and

sentenced

to

undergo

Rigorous

Imprisonment of life along with fine of Rs. 10,000/with default stipulation.

Factual Matrix

3.

The factual matrix giving rise to appeal, as per written report of one Rajesh Kumar Yadav dated 29.09.2015 is that the informant’s sister Sila Devi, aged about 27 years (since deceased) was married with Govind Yadav (present appellant) about 10 years ago. It is alleged that out of their wedlock, they were blessed with two sons namely, Karan Kumar, aged about 7 years and Prince Kumar, aged about 3 years. It is further alleged that on 27.09.2015 at about 10:30 P.M., the present appellant returned to his home and started abusing and assaulting to his wife Sila Devi and pouring kerosene oil on her body set on ablaze. The informant came to know through telephonic message about the said incident from Guria Devi (gotni of the deceased) and immediately proceeded to his sister’s matrimonial home and brought her to Sadar Hospital, Deoghar for treatment. The deceased has also disclosed above incident before the police. Thereafter, in course of treatment, she died on 28.09.2015 at about 4:00 A.M. The informant has claimed that his brother-in-law has killed his wife by setting her on ablaze.

4.

On the basis of above information, FIR was registered being Deoghar (T) Khunda P.S. Case No. 887 of 2015 for the offences under Sections 341, 323, 302 of I.P.C.

5.

After conclusion of investigation, charge sheet was submitted against the sole accused for the aforesaid offences.

After

taking

cognizance,

case

was

committed to the court of Sessions, where S.C. No. 19/2016 was registered. The appellant denied from the charges and claimed to be tried.

6.

In

course

trial,

altogether

witnesses

were

examined by prosecution namely, P.W.-1 : Rajesh Kumar Yadav (Informant). P.W.-2 : Taro Mahto (father-in-law of deceased). P.W.-3 : Karan Kumar (son of the deceased). P.W.-4 : Kamdeo Yadav (brother of the appellant). P.W.-5 : Dr. Anil Kumar (conducted autopsy of the dead body of the deceased). P.W.-6 : Kalicharan Yadav (witness to the inquest report). P.W.-7 : Sudama Choudhary (first I.O. of this case). P.W.-8 : Sukhdeo Yadav (father of deceased). P.W.-9 : Asim Kamal Topno (second I.O. of this case). P.W.-10: Bhola Prasad Yadav (A.S.I. of Deoghar (Town) P.S. has recorded the dying declaration of deceased). Apart from oral testimony of aforesaid witnesses, following documentary evidences were also adduced:Exhibit-1

:

Signature of P.W.-1 Rajesh Kumar Yadav on Written complaint.

Exhibit-1/1

:

Signature

informant

on

inquest report. Exhibit-1/2

:

Signature of Kalicharan on inquest report

Exhibit 2

:

Written Report before P.S.

Exhibit-2/1

:

Endorsement on Written Report.

Exhibit-2/2

:

Registration of formal F.I.R.

Exhibit-3

:

Post mortem report.

Exhibit-4

:

Fardbeyan

Sila

Devi

in

handwriting of Bhola Prasad Yadav. Exhibit-4/1

:

Signature of Rajesh Yadav on the fardbeyan of deceased Sila Devi.

Exhibit-4/2

:

Endorsement on fardbeyan of Shila Devi.

Exhibit-5

:

Inquest report.

Exhibit-6

:

Charge sheet.

Exhibit-7

:

Application

second

investigating Officer before C.J.M. to include the fardbeyan of deceased in original record. Exhibit-8

7.

:

Fardbeyan of deceased Sila Devi.

No oral or documentary evidence has been adduced by the defence. The case of defence is denial from occurrence and false implication. In statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., the accused has pleaded

innocence. His brother-in-law Rajesh Kumar Yadav (Informant) has taken loan from the bank in the name of wife of this accused, but he failed to satisfy the loan amount and for re-payment of loan his wife was demanding money from him. Hence, she herself set on fire and died.

8.

As per trend of suggestion extended to witnesses, while cooking on kerosene stove, it burst accidently and deceased caught fire and died due to burn injuries.

9.

The learned trial court after appreciating the evidence adduced

by

prosecution

arrived

at

definite

conclusion about guilt of the appellant for causing murder of his own wife by setting her on ablaze by pouring kerosene oil and convicted and sentenced, as stated above, which has been assailed in this appeal. Submissions on behalf of the appellant

10. Learned counsel for the appellant has strenuously argued that the learned trial court has failed to properly appreciate the evidence of witnesses available on record. There is no eye-witness of occurrence, except P.W.-3, who is the son of the appellant and at the time of occurrence, he was merely about 7 years old

child.

The

alleged

dying

declaration

deceased is a doubtful document in the shape of

fardbeyan of the deceased, but no F.I.R. was lodged by

deceased.

The

authenticity

dying

declaration has also not been proved through cogent and reliable evidence. It is further submitted that after death of wife of the appellant, his both sons were taken away to their matrimonial uncle’s home, who happens to be informant of this case. The son of the appellant Karan (P.W.-3) was brought to court for testifying as a witness by the informant after tutoring him. Therefore, the testimony of P.W.-3 has wrongly been relied upon by the learned trial court as basis for conviction of the appellant. Rest of the witnesses of facts are hearsay and highly interested witnesses. The learned trial court has committed serious error of law while placing reliance upon such tainted testimony. The F.I.R. was also lodged after 24 hours of the death of deceased. No certificate of fitness has been issued by conducting doctor that the deceased was under fit condition

to

state

anything.

As

against

it

informant himself admits that he brought the injured Sila Devi under unconscious state at the hospital. Therefore, the dying declaration (Exhibit-4) relied upon by the prosecution is absolutely unreliable and cannot be made basis for conviction of the appellant. In view of above premises, it is submitted by learned

counsel for the appellant that the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence of the appellant is liable to be set aside and this appeal may be allowed. Submissions on behalf of State

11. Per contra, learned Spl.P.P. for the State controverting the aforesaid contentions raised on behalf of the appellant, has submitted that the learned trial court has very wisely and aptly appraised, appreciated, scanned and evaluated the oral and documentary evidence available on record. There is no reason to disbelieve the evidence of P.W.-3, who is none else but son of the appellant and sole eye-witness of this occurrence. The testimony of P.W.-3 goes to show that he is quite intelligent in answering the questions put by court and nothing has been elicited casting any doubt

on

his

presence

at

relevant

time

occurrence as an eye-witness of the occurrence. The defence has also failed to elicit any material showing that P.W.-3 was tutored in any manner to depose at

instance

informant,

even

having

no

knowledge about the occurrence. There is no legal impediment to accept the evidence of child witness. It does not suffer from any embellishment, tutoring or otherwise unreliable. A child being innocent and free from animosity is expected to speak truth and nothing

else. The dying declaration of the deceased (Exhibit-4) was also scribed by Bhola Prasad Yadav (P.W.-10) and signed by witnesses. On that basis, a sanha was entered, but the formal F.I.R. was lodged on the basis of written report of the informant. The overall episode proved

by

prosecution

leads

towards

single

conclusion about guilt of the appellant. The appellant has miserably failed to offer any valid explanation as to how and under what circumstances his wife caught fire and sustained 100% burn injuries at odd time of night about 10:30 P.M. The appellant himself in his statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. has admitted that there was some vehicle loan dispute taken by the informant in the name of appellant’s wife, which cannot be satisfied by informant and appellant’s wife was asking money from her husband / appellant, hence, she committed suicide, is also not believable story. Moreover, no bank loan document was brought on record as defence evidence to substantiate the above defence plea. The testimony of witnesses cannot be bruised aside simply on the ground that they are close relative of the deceased or interested witnesses unless

some

clinching

reasons

to

disprove

their

testimony has been brought on record. The learned trial

court

has

very

cautiously

scrutinized

evidence

witnesses

and

recorded

a

very

reasoned judgment holding the appellant guilty for the murder of his wife. There is no reason to take a different view on the grounds pointed out by the appellant. Therefore, there is no merits in this appeal, which is fit to be dismissed. Analysis, discussions and reasons

12. We have gone through the record of the case along with impugned judgment in the light of contentions raised on behalf of both side.

13. The only point for consideration in this appeal is as to “whether the judgment of conviction and sentence of the appellant passed by the learned trial court suffers from

any

serious

error

law,

calling

for

any

interference in this appeal?”

14. Before imparting our verdict on the above point, we have to take brief resume of ocular testimony of witnesses for proper appreciation of the case.

15. It is a case of gruesome murder by a husband of his own wife upon some quarrel between them in the night. The sole eye witness of the occurrence is P.W.-3 Karan Kumar, who was examined on 29.07.2016, just after 10 months of the occurrence, who has disclosed his age about 11 years. This witness was found competent to understand the questions put to him

reasonably

and

intelligently.

According

to

his

evidence, his mother has been died. In his own language, he has stated thus: “esjs firkth xksfoUn ;kno esjh eEeh 'khyk nsoh ds 'kjhj ij feV~Vh dk rsy fNM+d dj vkx yxk fn;k A

esjh eEeh

fpYykus yxh vkSj eSa Hkh fpYykus yxk ysfdu esjs firkth xksfoUn ;kno eq>s dqN djus ugha fn;s vkSj esjs firkth ogha cxy esa [kM+k gksdj eEeh dks tyrk ns[k jgsa FksA” He has further stated that his uncle Kamdeo Yadav and Saroj Yadav and aunt Guria Devi and Lalita Devi also arrived and dashed the door, which was opened then his mother while burning rushed outside the room and fell down on earth. Thereafter, his father fled away. His uncle and aunt extinguished

fire

and

maternal

his

uncle

aunt

Guria

through

Devi

informed

telephonic

his

message.

Thereafter, maternal uncle Rajesh Yadav arrived on a vehicle

and

his

mother

was

brought

to

Sadar

Hospital, Deoghar, but in the morning at about 4:00 A.M., she died. The

learned

trial

court

has

also

recorded

demeanour of this witness in following words “lk{kh U;k;ky; esa lk{; nsrs le; jks jgk gS vkSj mlds vkWa[k ls iwjk vkWlw py jgk gSA” This witness has further categorically stated that in his parental home, there is sewing machine, T.V., Gas Cylinder and other utensils, electricity connection is also in the house. There is no kerosene stove in his house and in case of non-availability of gas, food are

cooked on mud stove through fire wood and cow dung cake etc. No question has been asked by defence to demolish his testimony as stated above. He

has

simply been suggested by the defence that his mother caught fire due to accidental burst of kerosene stove, which has been denied and again reiterated that there was gas connection and fire wood fuel was also used.

16. P.W.-1 Rajesh Kumar Yadav is the informant-cumbrother of the deceased. He was informed through telephonic message by Guria Devi in the night of 27.09.2015 that his sister has been set on ablaze by his

brother-in-law

by

pouring

kerosene

oil.

He

immediately rushed to matrimonial home of his sister and found that she was lying on a cot under burn condition,

although

she

was

breathing.

He

immediately brought her to Sadar Hospital, Deoghar where her treatment was started and A.S.I. Bhola Prasad Yadav has recorded her statement, but she could not be saved and died in the morning at about 4:00 A.M. The statement of his sister was recorded by A.S.I. Bhola Prasad Yadav also bears his signature marked Exhibit-1. His father has also put his LTI. He has further proved his signature and signature of witness Kali Charan Yadav on inquest report as Exhibit-1/1 and Exhibit-1/2 respectively. He further

proved the written report, which was scribed by his friend Rakesh Roshan on 29.09.2015, which bears his signature and marked as Exhibit-2. In his cross-examination, he admits that he was busy in getting treatment of his sister and after her death, in her post-mortem. He brought her dead body to her matrimonial home. Thereafter, lodged this case. There is nothing in his cross-examination to rebut his aforesaid testimony. He has denied the suggestion of defence that his sister caught fire accidently during cooking and he has falsely implicated his brother-in-law.

17. P.W.-2

Taro

deceased

and

Mahto

is

father

father-in-law

present

appellant.

According to his evidence, at the time of occurrence, he was not present in the house, rather was working in

School.

When

he

returned

to

home,

he

was

informed that Sila Devi has caught fire while cooking due to bursting of kerosene stove. This witness has been declared hostile by the prosecution. He has denied the suggestion of prosecution that in order to save his son, he has given false evidence. To a court question, he has stated that when his daughter-in-law’s

body

caught

fire

after

stove

bursting, his son was at home at that time, but

instead of taking her to the Hospital for treatment, he left her burning and fled from the house.

18. P.W.-4 Kamdeo Yadav is the brother of the appellant. According to his evidence, on the date of occurrence, he was sleeping in his room after taking dinner. Thereafter, he heard sound of bursting stove and reached towards the courtyard of his house then saw his sister-in-law Sila Devi was burning. He raised alarm, but door of the room of Sila Devi was burning. He raised alarm to broke open the door and saw Sila Devi was lying on earth sustaining burn injuries. He further admits that he did not bring Sila Devi to Hospital and also denied any statement before police. Therefore, this witness has also been declared hostile by prosecution. After drawing attention to his statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C., this witness was suggested that he has given false evidence with a view to save his own brother, which was denied.

19. P.W.-5 Dr. Anil Kumar has conducted autopsy on the dead body of the deceased and found following:External Findings :– Rigor mortise present in all limbs,

both

eyes

closed,

mouth

partially

open,

blackish skin of face and burn face and hair, bandage on whole body after removal of bandage burn skin on

whole body found with blackish colour and redish brown colour skin on chest, public region both legs and neck (burn about 100%). Internal

Findings

:–

Brain

and

meaninges

contested and intact, neck – blackish particle found in trachea, lungs – congested, heart – blood in all chamber, liver – intact and pale, Spleen – Intact and pale, both kidney intact and pale, stomach contain about 200 ml. of gastric fluid, intestine – contain some gases, urinary bladder – empty, Uterus – non gravid. Time elapse since death – within 12 to 24 hours. He has opined that the cause of death was due to hypovolemic shock caused by burn by fire. This

witness

has

identified

post-mortem

report and his signature on post-mortem report and the post-mortem report has been marked as Exhibit3.

20. P.W.-6 Kalicharan Yadav. He is witness of inquest report, who has admitted his signature on inquest report prepared on 28.09.2015.

21. P.W.-7 Sudama Choudhary is the first I.O. of this case. According to his evidence on 29.09.2025, he was handed over the investigation of this case. In course of investigation,

he

has

recorded

statement

informant and proceeded to the place of occurrence at Village – Dhudhnia, where he recorded the statement of witnesses Karan Kumar Yadav, Kamdeo Yadav and Taro Mahto. Witness Taro Mahto (P.W.-2) has stated before him that his son Govind Yadav set on ablaze to his own wife by pouring kerosene oil, due to which, she

sustained

severe

injuries

and

in

course

treatment at Sadar Hospital, she died. The place of occurrence is the house of the accused Govind Yadav made of mud situated in Village Dhudhnia having its main door towards west fitted with a wood door. There are two rooms after entrance from the door. In the inside room, there was a cot, a T.V. was on table and odour of Kerosene oil and burn clothes were coming from the room. Govind Yadav was arrested. He was also interrogated, but no satisfactory explanation was given by him. The attention of this witness has been drawn towards the statement of witness Kamdeo Yadav (P.W.-4), who has stated before him that his brother Govind Yadav frequently used to assault his wife and on the date of occurrence, after hearing cries of his wife, he came out and saw the flash light in the room of his brother. The door was not opened; then he dashed the door and broke open the same then his brother Govind Yadav fled away and his wife Sila Devi

came out in burning condition and fell down on earth. Thereafter, telephonic message was given to Rajesh Kumar Yadav, who arrived at the place of occurrence and brought the injured Sila Devi to Sadar Hospital, Deoghar, but she died. This witness has also received a fardbeyan of Sila Devi

(deceased),

her

inquest

report,

dead

body

challan. The fardbeyan of deceased was recorded by A.S.I. Bhola Prasad Yadav on 27.09.2015 at Sadar Hospital, Burn Ward, Bed No. 3, which is marked Exhibit-4 and signature of Rajesh Yadav as Exhibit4/1. He has handed over the charge of investigation to Asim Kamal Topno on 19.10.2015.

22. P.W.-8 Sukhdeo Yadav is the father of the deceased. He also appears to be hearsay witness and came to know about the occurrence from his son and also went to Sadar Hospital.

23. P.W.-9 Asim Kamal Topno (2nd I.O.) has deposed that on 19.10.2015, he was posted as Officer-in-Charge of Kunda

Police

Station

and

received

charge

investigation of this case. In course of investigation, he

had

gone

Thereafter

through

obtained

previous

Post-Mortem

investigation.

Report

deceased and finding sufficient evidence submitted charge sheet against the accused on 24.12.2015. He

has further stated that on 02.01.2016, he filed an application along with charge sheet for enclosing the fardbeyan of the deceased recorded by A.S.I. Bhola Yadav under S.D. No. 20/2015 dated 29.09.2015 marked Exhibit-7.

24. P.W.-10 A.S.I. Bhola Prasad Yadav. According to his evidence, on 27.09.2015, he was posted at Deoghar (Town) P.S. on that date at about 11:40 P.M., at Burn Ward Bed No. 3 of Sadar Hospital, Deoghar, he recorded

fardbeyan

injured

Sila

Devi

in

presence of her brother Rajesh Kumar Yadav, which bears the right thumb impression of Sila Devi. He has proved the fardbeyan in his own handwriting, marked as Exhibit-8. On the basis of above fardbeyan of the injured, Deoghar (Town) S.D. Entry No. 20/2015 dated 29.09.2015 was made and forwarded to Kunda Police Station. In his cross-examination, this witness admits that in the fardbeyan of injured Sila Devi, he has not obtained signature of conducting doctor, nurse or compounder, although the Doctor was present in his Chamber. He has only obtained the signature of Sukhdeo Yadav and Rajesh Yadav. He has denied the suggestion of defence that the deceased had died on the spot itself and he has prepared this fardbeyan of

the deceased under conspiracy with the informant. No such statement was ever recorded by him and this fardbeyan is forged document.

25. We have given anxious consideration to the oral as well as documentary evidence available on record as discussed above.

26. It is admitted fact that the deceased has died due to severe burn injuries sustained all over her body on chest, public region both legs and neck inside her room. The presence of appellant and his son (P.W.-3) at the relevant time of occurrence is also not disputed. Moreover, the present appellant has in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. has admitted that due to dispute of loan transaction taken in the name of his wife by her brother (informant), she herself set on ablaze.

It further

transpires

that

other

eye-

witnesses of this case namely, Taro Mahto (P.W.-2) and Kamdeo Yadav (P.W.-4) have been turned hostile, but the evidence of Investigating Officer (P.W.-7) clearly explains the contradictions appearing in the evidence

aforesaid

witnesses,

wherein

Kamdeo

Yadav (P.W.-4) has stated that in the night while he was sleeping he heard crying sound of his sister-inlaw, then reached towards the room of his brother, door was not opened and it was burning, then he

dashed the door and saw Sila Devi was lying on earth sustaining burn injuries. In this background, the testimony of P.W.-3 although, who happens to be child

witness

circumstances,

has

given

under

vivid

which

description

occurrence

took

place, he clearly states that his father scolded him while he was intervening and stated in clear terms that his father poured kerosene oil on the body of his mother and lite match stick due to which she caught fire and sustained burn injuries. Although, the dying declaration of deceased (Exhibit-4) is alleged to be recorded in the shape of fardbeyan of the injured, but the same appears to have been registered as Sanha i.e. of 29.09.2015 that was also not certified by any conducting Doctor that the injured was under fit mental and physical condition to state anything. The said Sanha was also attached with charge sheet for the first time as admitted by P.W.-9. Therefore, the veracity of the alleged dying declaration appears to be doubtful and no blind reliance can be placed upon it.

27. We have further noticed that even if the purported dying declaration (Exhibit-4) scribed by P.W.-10 may be excluded from consideration, there are sufficient unimpeachable evidence showing the culpability of the appellant in commission of murder of his wife, as

discussed above. We further find that the learned trial court has meticulously considered all the aspects of the case while arriving at conclusion about guilt of the appellant. We do not find any valid reason to take a different view from that of the learned trial court. The grounds of objection on account of interestedness or relative witnesses against the impugned judgment taken by the appellant do not appear to be legally sustainable. The delay in lodging the F.I.R. is also not inordinate and properly explained.

28. In view of above discussions and reasons, we do not find

any

merit

impugned sentence

in

this

appeal.

judgment

conviction

appellant

is

Accordingly, and

hereby

order

upheld

and

confirmed and this appeal is dismissed.

29. Pending I.A., if any, stand disposed of. 30. Let a copy of this judgment along with trial court record

be

sent

back

to

court

concerned

immediately for information and needful.

(Ananda Sen, J.)

(Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, J.) Jharkhand High Court, Ranchi Dated, the 24 t h September, 2026. Sunil /N.A.F.R. Uploaded on 29/09/2026

Related judgments

More Jharkhand High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.