In Re : Section 6a of the Citizenship Act 1955 Versus
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 17 October 2024
- Judge
- Justice D.Y. Chandrachud
- Neutral citation
- 2024 INSC 789
- Reported in
- [2024] 10 S.C.R. 961
- Result
- Reference answered
- Acts & sections
- Article 32 Constitution, Article 11 Constitution
Full judgment
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 961 : 2024 INSC 789 (Writ Petition (C) No. 274 of 2009) 17 October 2024
[Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud,* CJI, Surya Kant,* J.B. Pardiwala,* M.M. Sundresh, and Manoj Misra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the constitutional validity of s.6A of the Citizenship Act; does s.6A offend preambular values like fraternity; s.6A, if ultra vires Part II of the Constitution; does s.6A create an unreasonable classification which violates Art. 14; does s.6A suffer from manifest arbitrariness; does s.6A violate the rights provided to ‘indigenous’ communities u/Art. 29; s.6A, if ultra vires Art. 21; does s.6A violate the political rights of Indian citizens in Assam u/Art. 326; does the operation of s.6A cause ‘external aggression’ and ‘internal disturbance’, culminating in the invocation of Art. 355; does the Citizenship Act conflict with provisions of the Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam Act), 1950, if so, how can the two legislations be harmoniously interpreted; and does s.6A violate international laws. Headnotes† Constitutional validity of s.6A of the Citizenship Act Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – s.6A confering citizenship on a specific class of migrants from Bangladesh to Assam – Provision conferred deemed citizenship to immigrants who entered prior to 01.01.1966; and process of registration for immigrants who entered between the period of 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971 – However, immigrants who entered the State of Assam on or after 25.03.1971 not entitled to the protection conferred vide s.6A and consequently, declared to be illegal immigrants – Constitutional validity: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) s.6A is constitutionally valid – s.6A falls within the bounds of the Constitution and is a valid piece of *Author
962
legislation – It does not contravene the foundational principles of fraternity, nor does it infringe upon Arts. 6, 7, 9, 14, 21, 29, 326, or 355 – s.6A does not clash with the IEAA or established principles of international law – While the statutory scheme of s.6A is constitutionally valid, there is inadequate enforcement of the same, leading to the possibility of widespread injustice – Intention of s.6A, to restrict illegal immigration post-1971 has also not been given proper effect – s.6A has become redundant qua those immigrants who have entered the State of Assam on or after 25.03.1971 – In view thereof, directions issued in Sarbananda Sonowal’s case to be given effect to for deporting the illegal immigrants falling in the said category – Provisions of the Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Act, 1950 to be read into s.6A and be effectively employed for identification of illegal immigrants – Statutory machinery and tribunals tasked with the identification and detection of illegal immigrants or foreigners in Assam are inadequate to the legislative object of s.6A read with Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Act, 1950, Foreigners Act, 1946, Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964, Passport (Entry into India) Act, 1920 and Passport Act, 1967, thus, necessitates constant monitoring by this Court – Bench to be constituted to monitor the implementation of the directions issued. [Paras 387, 391, 392] – Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) s.6A not violative of Arts. 6 and 7 of the Constitution – s.6A does not violate Art. 29(1) of the Constitution – s.6A(3) cannot be held unconstitutional on the ground of temporal unreasonableness and s.6A(2) cannot be held unconstitutional for not prescribing a procedure for registration. [Para 125] – Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting): By applying the doctrine of temporal reasonableness, s.6A declared to be invalid with prospective effect – Immigrants migrated before 01.01.1966 and were granted deemed citizenship, and immigrants migrated between 01.01.1966 and 24.03.1971 and were granted citizenship to remain unaffected – Immigrants migrated between 01.01.1966 and 24.03.1971, and were detected as foreigners, and registered with authorities to be treated as Indian citizens after the expiry of 10 years after they were detected – Immigrants migrated between 01.01.1966 and 24.03.1971, who were detected as foreigners but did not register on time to lose eligibility for citizenship benefits – Immigrants whose applications and appeals pending to be governed by s.6A(3) – After the said judgment, no illegal immigrants in Assam to benefit from s.6A – Constitution of India – Arts. 6, 7, 9, 14, 21, 29, 326, or 355. [Paras 217, 218]
[2024] 10 S.C.R. Ethos of s.6A, aligned with fraternity Constitution of India – Fraternity – Preambular notion of fraternity – Meaning of ‘fraternity’ – Ethos of s.6A, if aligned with fraternity – Preambular value of fraternity, if applicable to the immigrants entering into the State of Assam under the aegis of s.6A: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Ethos underlying s.6A, align with the concept of fraternity – In the Indian constitutional context, fraternity assumes a dynamic and inclusive role, aligning with the broader goals of social justice, equality, and upliftment – Very scope of fraternity beyond just being an ideal in the Preamble was thus expanded to be a principle that would create checks and balances on the system of governance and state actions – Essence of fraternity, is fundamentally geared towards fostering interconnectedness among Indians and was envisaged to be a principle for uplifting marginalised sections of society – Petitioners approach to interpret fraternity in a highly restrictive manner, which allows them to choose their neighbours, cannot be accepted since it runs contrary to the very idea and ethos of fraternity envisaged by the Constituent Assembly and interpreted by this Court – Fraternity requires people of different backgrounds and social circumstances to ‘live and let live’ – Nomenclature of fraternity itself is self-explanatory to the extent that it exhibits the notion of inclusiveness and togetherness, as opposed to restricted applicability – Thus, it becomes imperative to refrain from employing this concept in a negative manner that selectively applies it to a particular segment while labelling another faction as ‘illegal immigrants’, solely based on the alleged unconstitutionality of s.6A. [Paras 106, 114, 115, 117, 118] Part II and s.6A Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Constitution of India – Part II – Arts. 6, 6A, 7 and 11 – s.6A, if ultra vires the Part II – s.6A, if violative of Arts 6, 7 and 11 – Parliament, if had the power to enact s.6A – s.6A, if contradicts s. 5 of the Citizenship Act, which requires every citizen to take an oath of allegiance – s.6A enabling dual citizenship, if unconstitutional for violating Art. 9 – Parliament, if had the competence to specify different conditions u/Art. 11.
964
Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) s.6A aligns with the fundamental purpose of Arts. 6 and 7, which was to extend citizenship rights to those affected by the country’s partition and is not contrary to them – Art. 6 does not prohibit the granting of citizenship after the cut-off date of 19.07.1948 – It only specifies the fulfilment of certain conditions, which, are also present in s.6A(3) – While s.6A(2) grants deemed citizenship without these conditions, the competence of Parliament to prescribe different conditions is well embedded in Art. 11 – Art.7 prohibits citizenship to people who remigrated to India, this is only a sub-class of people who have been granted citizenship by s.6A – Since s.6A grants citizenship even to people who migrated for the first time, the class of re-migrants is severable from this provision – Art. 11 confers overriding powers upon the Parliament to make laws even when they are against other provisions of Part II and that it grants the Parliament the power to make ‘any’ provision regarding citizenship and that this authority is not restricted by the provisions of Part II – Concept of dual citizenship means one has citizenship of two countries simultaneously – In India, such citizenship is restricted by Art. 9, and s. 9 of the Citizenship Act, and operate in different time spheres and in different fields – Even if it is assumed that s.6A grants dual citizenship, it does not run counter to Art. 9 which restricts a person possessing foreign citizenship from acquiring citizenship u/Arts. 5, 6, and 8 – However, s.6A does not grant citizenship under these provisions and is rather a separate method enacted by Parliament by virtue of its power u/Art.11 – Conflict between Art. 9 and s.6A, thus, does not arise at all – Further, s.6A also does not conflict with s. 9 because s.6A does not override the scheme of s. 9 and must be read complementarily thereto – However, s.6A, presumes the renunciation of previous citizenship – Furthermore, explicit lack of an oath of allegiance before the conferral of citizenship by s.6A does not absolve the immigrants covered under this provision from following the laws of the country, just as any other citizen of India – s.6A cannot be run down on the premise that it does not mandate an oath of allegiance. [Paras 132, 134, 135, 137, 141, 142, 144-146, 148, 149, 158, 159] – Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) s.6A not violative of Arts. 6 and 7, which prescribe cut-off date for conferring citizenship for migrants from East and West Pakistan at the commencement of the Constitution-26.01.1950 – s.6A confers citizenship from 01.01.1966 for those who migrated before that date – Those who migrated between 01.01.1966 and 24.03.1971,
[2024] 10 S.C.R. are conferred citizenship upon the completion of ten years from the date of detection as a foreigner – s.6A confers citizenship from a later date to those who are not covered by Arts. 6 and 7, thus, does not have the effect of amending Arts. 6 and 7 – Art. 11 is not a non-obstante clause – Legislative competence of Parliament to enact laws related to citizenship is traceable to Entry 17 List I and not Art. 11 – Provisions in Part II do not impact or limit the legislative competence of Parliament. [Paras 38, 42, 125] – Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting): s.6A is not similar in form and identical in spirit with Arts. 6 and 7 – Perusal of s.6A vis-à-vis Arts 6 and 7 respectively would reveal that despite a few similarities between the two, the crucial difference lies in the fact that in Art. 6, the onus of registration for a person seeking citizenship lies on that person and not on the State – All those persons who migrated to India from Pakistan after 19.07.1948, had to make an application before the commencement of the Constitution – Permit system which was introduced as per Art. 7 was also brought to an end in 1952 – Both these conditions-onus of registration as well as the specification of a cut-off date till which such applications could have been made are absent from the very scheme of s.6A – This glaring absence renders the scheme of s.6A arbitrary and as a result unconstitutional. [Para 212] s.6A vis-à-vis Art. 14 Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Constitution of India – Art.14 – s.6A vis-à-vis Art. 14 – s.6A, if creates an unreasonable classification which violates Art.14 – Plea that s.6A falls foul of Art.14 as it treats equals unequally; and that the selective application of s.6A solely to the State of Assam exhibits hostility against it in comparison to other states: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Since s.6A was predicated on the terms of the Assam Accord, it extended citizenship solely to immigrants in Assam because the Union of India had exclusively engaged in this accord with Assam – This serves as the basis of intelligible differentia vis-à-vis other States – s.6A duly considered the pertinent factors, notably that the Assam Accord pertained solely to the State of Assam – Since a piquant situation such as that in Assam did not exist in any of the other States, s.6A’s objective
966
did not extend to allowing such citizenship in these other States, thus, classification between the State of Assam and other States had a direct nexus with the object of the statute and classification was not ex-facie arbitrary – Striking down s.6A on the grounds of non-inclusion only of West Bengal would amount to allowing an under-inclusivity challenge in disguise, which, is not generally permitted – Thus, classification u/s.6A, not violative of Art.14 simply because it is applicable to the State of Assam alone – Thus, s.6A not ultra vires Art. 14. [Paras 189, 198, 203-205] – Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) Undocumented migrants could be registered as citizens u/s.5(1)(a) of the Citizenship Act before it was amended by the Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2003 to exclude ‘illegal immigrants’ – Thus, the claim of the petitioner that s.6A is unconstitutional because instead of preventing migration to Assam, it incentivizes migrants in other states to come to Assam to secure citizenship through s.6A, is erroneous – s.6A confers citizenship to migrants from Bangladesh to Assam before 25 March 1971 – s.6A satisfies the two-pronged reasonable classification test - Legislative objective of s.6A was to balance the humanitarian needs of migrants of Indian Origin and the impact of the migration on the economic and cultural needs of Indian States – Two yardsticks employed in s.6A-migration to Assam and cut-off date of 24 March 1971 are reasonable – Though other states share a longer border with Bangladesh, the impact of migration in Assam in terms of numbers and resources is greater – Cut-off date of 25 March 1971 is reasonable because the Pakistani Army launched Operation Search light to curb the Bangladeshi nationalist movement in East Pakistan on 26 March 1971 – Migrants before the operation were considered migrants of Indian partition – Both the yardsticks have a rational nexus with the object of s.6A – Also s.6A is neither under-inclusive nor over-inclusive. [Paras 75, 125] Constitution of India – Art. 14 – Right to equality – Reasonableness of classification – Yardsticks to check the reasonableness of classification – Qualifications regarding the yardsticks: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Art. 14 requires the legislature to treat equals equally, but it also allows for differential treatment if the characteristics of the classes differ – Art. 14 permits the legislature to classify individuals into different groups and apply distinct
[2024] 10 S.C.R. norms accordingly, and such classification must be reasonable – Yardsticks to check the reasonableness of classification is that the classification should not be based on arbitrary criteria and must instead be based on a logic which distinguishes individuals with similar characteristics – Thus, a classification is reasonable if it differentiates between similar and dissimilar elements, if such distinction is intelligible, and if the similarities and dissimilarities have nexus with the purpose of the statute – Qualifications regarding the yardsticks is that while establishing a nexus with the object of the statute is necessary, it is not essential to demonstrate that the classification was the optimal method to achieve the object in question, and when gauging the reasonableness of classification, the Court must adopt a pragmatic view and refrain from deeming a classification unconstitutional solely because it is marginally under-inclusive. [Paras 168-170, 177, 179, 180] – Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) Classification is constitutionally permissible, when two prong test that there must be an intelligible differentia between those forming a group and those left out; and the differentia must have a reasonable nexus with the object sought to be achieved, is satisfied – Court now, within the traditional two prong test has advocated for a more substantial inquiry that subsumes the following prongs which is the objective and the means – Determination of the yardstick for classification will help in the assessment of whether a provision is under-inclusive or over-inclusive – Yardstick must have a nexus with the object and must be in consonance with constitutional principles. [Paras 59, 68(c)] Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Over-inclusiveness and under-inclusiveness – Determination – s.6A, under-inclusive or over-inclusive : Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Classification u/s.6A, not violative of Art. 14 simply because it is applicable to the State of Assam alone – In adjudicating the validity of a statute, the concept of under-inclusiveness arises when classification within the law fails to encompass all individuals similarly situated with respect to the law’s intended purpose – Even if there are States that could share similar characteristics with Assam, comparison should be between two broad classes: Assam and the rest of India, rather than each individual constituent of these two classes – Since other States, in general, were not facing similar issues, unique political situation
968
created in Assam by the influx of immigrants, the differentiation in classes was reasonable – Hence, even if some States like West Bengal were placed similarly to Assam, that in and of itself would not lead to holding s.6A unconstitutional – Striking down s.6A on the grounds of non-inclusion only of West Bengal would amount to allowing an under-inclusivity challenge in disguise, which, is not generally permitted. [Paras 180, 203, 204] – Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) s.6A is neither under-inclusive nor over-inclusive – Over-inclusiveness and under-inclusiveness must be determined based on whether there are similarly situated persons/situations who or which have not been included or have been included based on the yardstick identified – Determination cannot be made with reference to the objective without reference to the yardstick – Doing so would limit the ability of the Legislature to identify the degrees of harm – Yardstick can be challenged where another yardstick affects or is related to the objective in a comparable manner – 6A would be under-inclusive only when all those who are similarly situated with respect to the object and on the application of the rational yardstick are not included – Provision would be over-inclusive only when those who are not similarly situated with respect to these two parameters are included. [Paras 75, 76] – Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Concurring) s.6A cannot be said to be violative of Art. 14 for being under-inclusive – Distinction drawn between the State of Assam and other states for the grant of citizenship to immigrants was on the basis of special circumstances prevailing in Assam at the time of enactment of s.6A – s.6A was a statutory codification of a political settlement reached between the Government and the people of Assam and thus, not violative of the equality clause enshrined u/Art.14 at the time of its enactment in 1985. [Paras 15, 207] Constitution of India – Art. 14 – Writ petition challenging constitutionality of s.6A – Maintainability u/Art. 14: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Art. 14 indicates that it confers individuals with equality before the law and is not restricted to mere equality for the benefits provided under law – Petitioner’s case that s.6A has singled out the State of Assam alone vis-à-vis other Indian States situated alongside the Bangladesh border and has curtailed the rights of only its original inhabitants – Petitioners’ assertion founded upon Art. 14 cannot be invalidated at a preliminary stage merely because they are seeking equality in regard to a restriction
[2024] 10 S.C.R. as opposed to a benefit – Thus, the objection regarding the maintainability of the petitioners’ claim u/Art. 14 rejected. [Paras 163, 164, 166] s.6A, if manifestly arbitrary Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Constitution of India – Art. 14 – Manifest Arbitrariness – s.6A, if manifestly arbitrary – Plea that there is no rationale for the cut-off dates-01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971, thus, manifestly arbitrary; that the process envisaged u/s.6A and the Citizenship Rules, 2009 for the migrants unreasonable and suffers from the vice of ‘manifest arbitrariness’; that s.6A offends Part II of the Constitution; and that the term ‘ordinarily resident’ in s.6A undefined and vague: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) s.6A does not suffer from manifest arbitrariness because there is application of mind behind the incorporation of the cut-off dates; the process u/s.6A is not arbitrary; s.6A does not violate Part II of the Constitution; and the term ‘ordinary residence’ is not vague enough to be void – Cutoff dates in s.6A not incorporated in a vacuous manner but were result of considerable deliberation and discussion, and also backed by well-considered rationale which does not militates against any constitutional values or the concept of constitutional morality – Instead, s.6A acknowledged the political and social realities of that period along with the impracticability of reversing the changes that had occurred – There are legibly delineated conditions and reasonable process envisaged u/s.6A and the Citizenship Rules, 2009 for migrants who came before 01.01.1966, as well as those who came on or after 01.01.1966 and before 25.03.1971 – s.6A conferred citizenship only upon certain immigrants who met certain specified conditions up to a particular cut-off date – Its aim was not only to legitimize the stay of a particular class of immigrants but also to facilitate the detection and deportation of others. [Paras 232, 234, 238, 243, 245, 273] – Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) s.6A suffers from the vice of manifest arbitrariness on account of the “systematic failure of the legislative vision – s.6A has acquired unconstitutionality subsequent to its enactment in 1985 by efflux of time and has thus become violative of Art. 14 for being temporally unreasonable – Efflux of time has brought
970
to light the element of manifest arbitrariness in the scheme of s.6A(3) which fails to provide a temporal limit to its applicability. [Paras 15, 208, 210] Constitution of India – Art. 14 – Manifest Arbitrariness – Relation between Art. 14 and arbitrariness – Constituents of manifest arbitrariness – Facets of the test of manifest arbitrariness – Extent of review under manifest arbitrariness – Elucidated. (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) [Paras 206-226] – (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) [Para 59] – (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) [Paras 171, 177, 179, 180] Vagueness in law Citizenship Act 1955 – s.6A – Term ‘ordinarily resident’ in s.6A, if vague – s.6A, if void for being vague : Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Term ‘ordinarily residence’ is not vague enough to be void. [Paras 267-273] Words and phrases – Vagueness in law – Meaning and explanation – Test for void-for-vagueness – Extent of review for the test of ‘void for vagueness’ – Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Vagueness is an inherent feature of language – Same intention can be expressed with a variety of words and expressions, and any given choice of words can relate to multiple different intentions – This problem is particularly exacerbated with vague terms – Most standards in law have some degree of open texture, and inevitably harbor some vagueness or multiple meanings – Vagueness in law, however, exists on a spectrum, and different scenarios necessitate different degrees of tolerance towards vagueness – Excessive vagueness in law can make the statute overbroad and might make the exercise of discretion a capricious exercise – At the same time, it might sometimes be desirable in the interest of justice to retain some open texture in statutes, to cover future eventualities that the legislature might not have anticipated but intended to address based on the overarching purpose of the law – In that sense, the sliding scale of vagueness in law determines whether the law is just and inclusive, or unjust and capricious – Vagueness needs to be viewed from the perspective of the authorities applying the
[2024] 10 S.C.R. impugned law; and the persons being regulated by the impugned law – Statute or its provision can be struck down for vagueness – Ordinarily, courts should endeavour to draw a demarcating line and infer some reasonable meaning from an impugned provision, rather than hastening to intervene and striking down the entire provision on the grounds of vagueness. [Paras 249, 251, 255, 263, 264] Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Phrase ‘ordinary resident in Assam’ under – Meaning – Discussed. (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) [Paras 268-273] s.6A vis-à-vis Art. 29 Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Constitution of India – Art. 29 – s.6A vis-à-vis Art. 29 – s.6A, if violative of the rights provided to 'indigenous' communities u/Art. 29: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) s.6A cannot be held to be violative of Art. 29 – Petitioners’ failed to show either an actionable impact on Assamese culture, or trace the cause of it to s.6A – On the contrary, s.6A mandates timely detection and deportation of illegal immigrants, a large portion of whom entered Assam post-1971 – It is the non-implementation of the statutory regime which is the cause of the petitioners’ concerns; their attack on the constitutionality of s.6A is misplaced – Also, s.6A does not compel pre-1971 immigrants to keep residing within the territory of Assam once they have obtained Indian citizenship, given that they would enjoy Art. 19(1)(e) rights like any other citizen of India. [Paras 298, 304] – Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) s.6A does not violate Art. 29(1) – Cultural and linguistic interests of the citizens of Assam are protected by constitutional and statutory provisions – Mere presence of different ethnic groups in a State not sufficient to infringe the right guaranteed by Art. 29(1) – Also the petitioners are unable to prove that the ability of the Assamese people to take steps to protect their culture, violated by the provisions of s.6A. [Paras 100-102, 125] – Held (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) By virtue of Art. 19(1)(e), s.6A does not compel pre-1971 immigrants to keep residing in the territory of Assam once they have obtained citizenship thereunder, said may be true for the immigrants belonging to the pre-1966 stream who
972
were conferred citizenship automatically, and thus became citizens of India for all purposes from the date of commencement of s.6A itself, the same does not hold true for the immigrants belonging to the 1966-71 category – In the absence of any temporal limit, within which all immigrants belonging to the 1966-71 category are to be detected, deleted and registered as citizens, the immigrants of this category are tethered to the territory of Assam, so as to satisfy the criteria of “ordinarily resident in Assam” on the date when they eventually happen to get detected. [Para 214] Substance of Art. 29(1) Constitution of India – Art. 29(1) – Protection of interest of minorities – Substance of Art. 29(1): Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Rights conferred by Art. 29(1) require that the State not to take any steps to erode a community’s culture, language or script; and concomitantly accords to such section of citizens the freedom and independence to preserve and conserve their culture, language and script, by themselves – Right u/Art.29(1) does not necessitate the Government to enact specific provisions for its enforcement and also does not altogether restrict the State from enacting regulations. [Para 295] Art. 21 and s.6A Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Constitution of India – Art. 21 – s.6A, if ultra vires Art. 21 – Plea that s.6A infringes upon the rights of the ‘indigenous’ Assamese community; that immigration led to the marginalization and disruption of their socio-economic aspirations; relying on Art.1 of ICCPR, their right of self-governance is being violated by s.6A; and inclusion of unidentified migrant population burdens country’s natural resources, hindering sustainable development: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) s.6A non-violative of Art. 21 – Petitioners not able to establish both a deleterious effect of s.6A on their indigenous communities as well as trace the cause of such effect to s.6A – As regards plea of self-governance, perceived right u/Art.1 of the ICCPR not enforceable through writ jurisdiction – More so, India’s explicit reservation is against its application in India, and it
[2024] 10 S.C.R. generally is applicable only to people under foreign domination – Assertion that immigration has impacted the self-governance of the original inhabitants of Assam, cannot be accepted – Furthermore, petitioners have not demonstrated how s.6A affects their right to govern themselves democratically – Mere fact that sub-class of immigrants whose status has been legitimised by s.6A also has access to these resources does not automatically imply a disruption of ecological balance or violation of the original inhabitants’ rights to resource usage – This conflates the idea of “unfair usage” with “more usage”- premise that cannot be accepted – Nation can accommodate immigrants and refugees, while simultaneously prioritizing sustainable development and equitable allocation of resources. [Paras 308-321] Aim of Art. 326 Constitution of India – Art. 326 – Aim and objective of Art. 326: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Objective of Art. 326 is to enfranchise people as opposed to disenfranchising them – Evident purpose of its inclusion was to bestow upon every individual citizen the right to exercise their vote and choose their elected representatives. [Para 335] Right of exclusion and Art. 326 Constitution of India – Art. 326 – Right of exclusion – Right u/Art. 326, if can be invoked to exclude certain individuals – s.6A, if violates the political rights of Indian citizens in Assam u/Art.326: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Art. 326 bestows upon individuals the right to vote and the right to be included in electoral rolls unless disqualified by the legislature or other constitutional provisions – It cannot be said that the influx of immigrants in the State of Assam has affected the right of the Assamese people to vote – Once deemed citizens by operation of s.6A, the erstwhile immigrants would enjoy equal rights as any other Indian citizen, including the right to vote, irrespective of the mode or time of acquisition of citizenship – Such constitutional rights cannot be summarily revoked or infringed upon – There has been no violation of the right of the petitioners u/Art. 326 as it merely grants them the right to vote and be included in the electoral rolls, which continues to
974
subsist to this day devoid of any interruption – Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A. [Paras 341-344] Elections – Adult suffrage – Background and evolution of – Stated. [Paras 325-330] s.6A vis-à-vis Art. 355 Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Constitution of India – Art. 355 – s.6A vis-a-vis Art. 355 – Operation of s.6A, if causes ‘external aggression’ and ‘internal disturbance’, culminating in the invocation of Art. 355: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) s.6A not contrary to Art. 355 – s.6A is limited in its ambit and does not by itself create unabated migration or legitimize its continuance – In fact, s.6A adopts a practical solution for the problem of incessant illegal immigration into Assam by devising an implementable solution keeping in mind India’s commitments, international relations and administrative realities – Migrants also need to satisfy certain conditions for invoking s.6A, apart from being persons of Indian origin and ordinary residents in India – s.6A addresses controlled and regulated form of immigration that would fall short of ‘external aggression’ – Migration legitimized by s.6A also does not constitute internal disturbance – s.6A was a crucial step in bringing quietus to the political upheaval in Assam and marked the culmination of various agitations surrounding illegal immigration and the rights of indigenous communities – Thus, s.6A does not cause ‘internal disturbance’. [Paras 364-367] – Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) Constitutional validity of a legislation cannot be tested for violation of Art. 355 – Art.355 was included in the Constitution as a justification for the exercise of emergency powers by the Union over States – Art. 355 as an independent ground for judicial review of legislative action is beyond the scope of the provision – An interpretation that a legislative enactment can be challenged for contravention of Art. 355 would lead to disastrous consequences – Reading the duty in Art. 355 into a right would effectively place the emergency powers with citizens and courts – Such a consequence would be catastrophic for the federal structure of the Constitution and would subjugate the constitutional status of States. [Paras 89, 90, 125]
[2024] 10 S.C.R. Sarbananda Sonowal’s case Citizenship – Illegal immigrants – Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India’s case on detection and deportation of illegal immigrants – Explanation: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Holding in Sarbananda Sonowal’s case that the term aggression in Art. 355 is of a wide import and can include unabated migration if it poses a threat to the security of the state, is concurred with – Thus, in such cases, the Union indeed bears a duty to protect the State from such unabated immigration that it amounts to external aggression or internal disturbance; and those statutes which violate this duty can be held unconstitutional. [Paras 356-361] Constitution of India – Art. 355 – Intention behind the inclusion of Art. 355 – Explained. [Paras 351-355] (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Citizenship Act vis-à-vis the IEAA Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Citizenship Act vis-à-vis the Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam Act), 1950-IEAA – IEAA, if applicable to the immigrants in Assam, to the exclusion of the Foreigners Act, 1946 – IEAA, if in conflict with the intent and aim of s.6A – Harmonious interpretation of two legislations: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) s.6A is not in conflict with a differently situated statute-IEAA – Instead, IEAA and s.6A can be read harmoniously along with other statutes – IEAA and Foreigners Act, 1946, seek to regulate the residence and departure of foreigners in India – To that extent, no conflict between the Statutes and both of them supplement and complement each other within the framework of s.6A – s.6A need not be construed in a restrictive manner to mean that a person shall be detected and deported only under the Foreigners Act, 1946 – If there is any other piece of legislation such as the IEAA, under which the status of an immigrant can be determined, no reason as to why such statutory detection shall also not be given effect to, for the purposes of deportation – Provisions of IEAA shall also be read into s.6A and be applied along with the Foreigners Act, 1946 for the purpose of
976
detection and deportation of foreigners – Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam Act), 1950 – Foreigners Act, 1946. [Paras 376-382] Interface with International Law Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – s.6A, if violative of international laws – Plea that since s.6A impacts the culture of original inhabitants, thus, violates Art. 27 of the ICCPR: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Art. 27 of the ICCPR restricts intervention in one’s culture – s.6A per se does not intervene in culture of Assamese people – Furthermore International law cannot trump domestic law – Thus, s.6A cannot be assailed on the ground of the perceived violation of Art. 27 of the ICCPR as well – Constitution of India – Art. 29 – International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. [Para 386] Temporal Unreasonableness Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A(3) – Temporal Unreasonableness – Absence of temporal limit on the applicability of s.6A(3), if renders the said provision manifestly arbitrary and thus violative of Art. 14 – Efflux of time, if has rendered s.6A temporally unreasonable and thus liable to be struck down in consequence of violation of Art. 14 – Placing temporal limitations on the period of applicability, if an objective implicit in the scheme of s.6A – s.6A, if suffers from manifest arbitrariness: Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) Principle of temporal unreasonableness cannot be applied to a situation where the classification is still relevant to the objective of the provision – Process of detection and conferring citizenship in Assam is a long-drawn out process spanning many decades – To strike it down due to lapse of time is to ignore the context and object of the provision. [Para 120] – Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) Absence of any temporal limits on the applicability of s.6A has the effect of rendering it manifestly arbitrary and constitutionally invalid – Although the mandate of timely detection and deportation of illegal immigrants was the fundamental premise on which the Assam Accord was signed, yet, this intention recorded in the
[2024] 10 S.C.R. Accord, was never translated statutorily, due to a faulty mechanism prescribed u/s.6A(3), either due to inadvertence or advertence of the legislature – s.6A has acquired unconstitutionality with the efflux of time – Efflux of time has brought to light the element of manifest arbitrariness in the scheme of s.6A(3) which fails to provide a temporal limit to its applicability – Neither s.6A nor the rules made thereunder prescribe any outer time-limit for the completion of detection of all such persons who belong to the 1966-71 stream and are eligible to avail the benefits of s.6A (3) – Absence of any prescribed time-limit for detection of foreigners of the 1966-71 stream has two-fold adverse consequences-it relieves the state from the burden of effectively identifying, detecting, and deleting from the electoral rolls, in accordance with law, all immigrants of the 1966-71 stream, and it incentivises the immigrants belonging to the 1966-71 stream to continue to remain on the electoral rolls for an indefinite period and only get themselves registered u/s.6A once detected by a competent tribunal – Thus, the manner in which the provision is worded, counter-serves the very purpose of its enactment, which is the speedy and effective identification of foreigners of the 1966-71 stream, their deletion from the electoral rolls, registration with the registering authority and conferring of regular citizenship – Working mechanism of s.6A(3) goes against its avowed objective – Mechanism prescribed for giving effect to s.6A is imbued with the idea of temporal limitations and in the absence of temporal limits on the period during which s.6A is made applicable, the provision counter serves the object it was enacted with – To allow s.6A to continue indefinitely for all times to come would tantamount to taking a reductive and one-sided view of the historical context in which s.6A came to be enacted, more particularly, that s.6A sought to achieve a delicate balance between two competing interests. [Paras 139, 140, 142, 143, 178, 208, 213, 215] Constitution of India – Art. 14 – Manifest arbitrariness vis-a-vis temporal unreasonableness – Explanation: Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) Even if a statutory provision fulfils the two-pronged test of reasonable classification and rational nexus with the object of enactment, it can still suffer from the vice of manifest arbitrariness and be violative of Art. 14 if the provision may lead to differential application on similarly situated persons – Manifest arbitrariness also encompasses the aspect of temporal unreasonableness that a statute may acquire with the efflux of time –
978
While the test of manifest arbitrariness entails a two-prong test which requires that first, there is a reasonable classification based on an intelligible differentia; and second that such classification has a rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved by such classification – Test of temporal unreasonableness, on the other hand, would involve a further examination into whether the said two prongs have continued to remain relevant with the passage of time – Test of temporal unreasonableness would require examining the provision in two different time frames-first, when the provision was enacted, and second when such provision comes to be challenged on the ground of temporal unreasonableness – Even if a provision passes the two prong test in the first time-frame, it may still fail the test in the subsequent time-frame if the efflux of time renders either the classification, or the object sought to be achieved by such classification, or both as arbitrary and thus violative of Art. 14 – This could be said to be the third prong in the test of manifest arbitrariness u/Art. 14 as envisaged by the doctrine of temporal unreasonableness. [Paras 171, 177, 179, 180] Words and phrases – Term temporal Unreasonableness – Meaning of. (per Pardiwala, J.) [Paras 129-130] Doctrines/Principles – Doctrine of temporal Unreasonableness – Meaning. (per Pardiwala, J.) [Para 130] Scope of Judicial Review u/Art. 14 Judicial Review – Scope of, u/Art. 14 – Grounds of unreasonable classification and arbitrariness – Two-prong test – Scope of judicial review of under-inclusive provisions – Elucidated. (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) [Paras 58-68] Limits to judicial review Judicial review – Concept of – Limits to judicial review – Judicial review of government policies – Validity of s.6A, hovering around foreign policy, if excluded from the purview of judicial review: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Judicial review of government policies encapsulates determining whether they infringe upon the fundamental rights of citizens, contravene constitutional provisions, violate statutory regulations, or display manifest arbitrariness, capriciousness, or mala fides – Focus of judicial scrutiny is limited
[2024] 10 S.C.R. to legality of the policy, excluding any evaluation of its wisdom or soundness – Court cannot compel the government to formulate a policy, evaluate alternatives or assess the effectiveness of existing policies – This constraint stems from the principle of separation of powers, where the Court lacks the democratic mandate and institutional expertise to delve into such matters – Thus, while the Court can invalidate a policy, it lacks the authority to create one – Court can check the constitutional validity of a policy, particularly so when it is elevated as an act of the Legislature – Challenge as regards the validity of s.6A, cannot be dismissed at the threshold, on the ground of judicial review – Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A. [Paras 53-55]– (per Pardiwala, J.) (Concurring) [Para 8] Applicability of doctrine of laches Doctrines/Principles – Doctrine of laches – Applicability, to writ petitions raising substantial questions – Writ petitions as regards constitutionality of s.6A raising significant public policy issues that involve ramifications for the original inhabitants of Assam, the rights of immigrants, and the security of the country – Writ petitions challenging the provisions introduced in 1985, filed after 27 years – Maintainability: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) While there has been a considerable delay in filing the instant writ petitions, the doctrine of laches cannot be applied strictly to disbar the petitioner’s claim at the threshold since the instant proceedings raise substantial questions that affect the public at large and the constitutional validity of a statutory provision – If decided otherwise, it would be creating an artificial deadline for important constitutional issues giving rise to an unfair principle of law in the realm of constitutional adjudication – Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A [Paras 75-76] – (per Pardiwala, J.) (Concurring) [Para 8] Limitation period for writs Constitution of India – Art. 32 – Writs under – Limitation period – Applicability of doctrine of laches: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Limitation Act, 1963, as also Supreme Court Rules, 2013 do not specify the limitation period for filing a writ – Though period is not specified, writ petition filed
980
belatedly after a considerable delay is barred by the operation of the doctrine of laches – Doctrine of laches is not an inviolable legal rule but a rule of practice that must be supplemented with sound exercise of judicial discretion – Doctrine of delay and laches is not to be ipso facto excluded where a breach of fundamental rights is alleged – Doctrine is not applicable when the claim affects the public at large as also in matters where the vires of a statute are challenged vis-à-vis the Constitution, else, time would run in favour of a constitutionally invalid statute, which cannot be allowed in the larger interests of justice and the transformative nature of the Constitution – Limitation Act, 1963 – Supreme Court Rules, 2013. [Paras 59, 60, 63-67] Legislative objective of s.6A Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Legislative objective of s.6A: Held: (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) Preamble to Citizenship (Amendment) Act 1985 by which s.6A was included states that the amendment was made for the “purpose of giving effect to certain provisions of the Memorandum of Settlement relating to the foreigners issue in Assam – Provisions of s.6A are traceable to the Assam Accord – s.6A was included with the objective of reducing the influx of migrants to India and dealing with those who had already migrated – Assam Accord was a political solution to the issue of growing migration from Bangladesh to Assam and s.6A was a legislative solution – s.6A must not be read detached from the previous legislation enacted by Parliament – s.6A is the legislation that balances the humanitarian needs of migrants of Indian Origin and the impact of such migration on economic and cultural needs of the Indian States. [Paras 69, 71] Scheme and mechanism of s.6A Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Scheme and mechanism of s.6A – Stated. (per Pardiwala, J.) [Paras 91-102] Legislative competence to enact s.6A Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Legislative competence to enact s.6A: Held: (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) Art. 11 gives the Parliament broad powers
[2024] 10 S.C.R. to enact laws on citizenship, notwithstanding any inconsistencies with any other provision in Part II of the Constitution – It grants the Parliament the power to make ‘any’ provision regarding citizenship – Thus, the Parliament indeed possesses the legislative power to enact laws concerning citizenship and that this authority is not restricted by the provisions of Part II of the Constitution. [Para 140-142] – (per Pardiwala, J.) (Concurring) [Para 11, 15] Object sought to be achieved by the prescription of two separate cut-off dates Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Object sought to be achieved by the prescription of two separate cut-off dates-01.01.1966 and 24.03.1971: Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) s.6A was enacted to give statutory effect to the political settlement arrived at in the form of Assam Accord – Object sought to be achieved by the prescription of two separate cut-off dates was adopting a humanitarian approach towards the immigrant population in Assam; and on the other, ensuring that large scale immigration does not result into the loss of culture, economy and the political rights of the people of Assam – Purpose behind the introduction of an additional cut-off date of 01.01.1966 and the corresponding concept of detection and deletion from the electoral rolls was to assuage the apprehensions of the protesting students – Intention of the legislature was to confer citizenship on the immigrants in a graded manner – To say that the sole object sought to be achieved by s.6A was to confer benefits on the immigrants alone would amount to taking a reductive view of the historical context in which the provision was enacted. [Paras 107-120] Onus of detection of foreigners of the 1966-71 stream lies on the State Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Onus of detection of foreigners of the 1966-71 stream, if lies on the State: Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) No provision which prescribes or provides for self- declaration/registration or voluntary detection as a foreigner within a given time period for availing
982
the benefit of citizenship by registration u/s.6A (3) – Mechanism of implementation of s.6A is set into motion with the first step of reference of a suspected foreigner to the foreigner’s tribunal – As soon as a reference is made to the tribunal, the onus is on the suspected person to either establish that he or she is an Indian citizen, or to establish that he or she is an immigrant eligible to avail the benefit available u/s.6A – It appears as illogically unique that a person wanting to avail the benefit of citizenship by registration u/s.6A(3) has to await identification as a suspicious immigrant and subsequent reference to the tribunal – No plausible reason why it should be impermissible for him or her to set the mechanism of s.6A into motion by voluntarily choosing to get detected as a foreigner of the class specified in s.6A, or to make an application for conferment of citizenship – Statutory scheme of s.6A(3), which does not envisage voluntary detection at the option of the immigrant, marks a clear departure, for no intelligible reason, from the prevalent scheme noticed under the rest of the Citizenship Act – Thus, there is no discernible reason why the mechanism prescribed u/s.6A does not require, or at the very least, permit an immigrant to come forward and make an application to avail the benefit. [121-128] Damage caused by the scheme of s.6A Citizenship Act, 1955 – s.6A – Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – Damage caused by the scheme of s.6A: Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) Absurd and faulty mechanism has been prescribed u/s.6A – s.6A owing to its inherent problems of absence of temporal limit as to the period of application, and shifting of the onus of identification and detection of an immigrant as a foreigner on the State, has indeed resulted in the influx and continued presence of illegal immigrants into the State of Assam, to this date – Legislature instead of providing for a one-time process to avail the benefits of s.6A to all those who are eligible has instead provided a process where each immigrant of the 1966-71 category has to be first identified and then referred to the foreigner’s tribunal – Tribunal is then required to determine in each individual case whether the person referred is an illegal migrant, his date of entry in Assam, whether he is entitled to any benefits u/s.6A – More than 38 years having elapsed since s.6A came into effect, with the benefit of retrospect, s.6A, which was meant to dispel and discourage incoming illegal
[2024] 10 S.C.R. immigrants, turned out to be a beacon for the illegal immigrants from Bangladesh to come into Assam, by taking advantage of the poor mechanism which is prone to open abuse – Provision has far exceeded the time-limit within which it should have been made applicable, and has become vulnerable to misuse owing to the inherent arbitrariness – Assam Accord was a one-time political settlement, arrived at in the specific context of widespread violence and agitation in Assam – Extraordinary conditions existing in the years 1979-85 cannot provide a permanent and perennial ground for continuation of a manifestly arbitrary provision, which is uncertain and indeterminable owing to its sui-generis mechanism. [Paras 182, 189, 190, 195, 211] Doctrine of Prospective Overruling Doctrines/Principles – Doctrine of prospective overruling – Application of – s.6A, if unconstitutional with prospective effect: Held: (per Pardiwala, J.) (Dissenting) : This Court has been endowed with the power to mould the relief so as to do complete justice in a given situation, and to avoid the possibility of chaos and confusion that may be caused in the society at large – In the instant case, a number of immigrants who came into the State of Assam from Bangladesh, have already been conferred with citizenship u/s.6A – Unconstitutionality of s.6A is attributable to the efflux of time – s.6A being manifestly arbitrary, temporally unreasonable and, demonstrably unconstitutional cannot be allowed to continue for all times to come – Thus, s.6A declared as unconstitutional with prospective effect – This would ensure that the benefit which has already been derived by the immigrants in Assam is not taken away, more particularly when the challenge to s.6A has been made after a considerable delay. [Paras 205, 206] Assam accord Assam accord – Salient features of the Assam Accord – Stated. (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) [Paras 90, 187-189, 200] – (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) [Paras 69-71] – (per Pardiwala, J.) [Paras 73-79] Citizenship Citizenship – Meaning of – Modes of acquiring citizenship – Indian vis-à-vis foreign jurisdiction – Elucidated. (per Surya
984
Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) [Paras 3-16] Citizenship – Legal regime under the Citizenship Act, 1955 governing migrants – Legal regime governing migrants from East and West Pakistan to Assam – Discussed. (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) [Paras 45-57] Constitution of India – Arts. 5 to 11 – Citizenship under – Legislative scheme on citizenship – Elucidated. (per Surya Kant, J.) (for himself and for M.M. Sundresh and Manoj Misra, JJ.) [Paras 3-16] (per Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI.) (Concurring) [Paras 14-19] Case Law Cited In the Judgment of Surya Kant, J: Assam Sanmilita Mahasangha v. Union of India [2014] 14 SCR 744 : (2015) 3 SCC 1; Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India [2005] Supp. 1 SCR 472 : (2005) 5 SCC 665; State (NCT of Delhi) v. Union of India (2018) 8 SCC 501; L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India [1997] 2 SCR 1186 : (1997) 3 SCC 261: 1997 SCC (L&S) 577; Bennett Coleman & Co. v. Union of India [1973] 2 SCR 757 : (1972) 2 SCC 788; A.L. Kalra v. Project & Equipment Corporation [1984] 3 SCR 646 : (1984) 3 SCC 316; Hindi Hitrakshak Samiti v. Union of India [1990] 1 SCR 588 : (1990) 2 SCC 352; Fertilizer Corporation Kamgar Union v. Union of India [1981] 2 SCR 52 : (1981) 1 SCC 568; A. K. Roy v. Union of India [1982] 2 SCR 272 : (1982) 1 SCC 271; Directorate of Film Festivals v. Gaurav Ashwin Jain [2007] 5 SCR 7 : (2007) 4 SCC 737; Union of India v. S. L. Dutta [1990] Supp. 3 SCR 173 : (1991) 1 SCC 505; State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal [1987] 1 SCR 1 : (1986) 4 SCC 566; Jacob Puliyel v. Union of India [2022] 3 SCR 471 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 533; Gaurav Kumar Bansal v. Union of India [2014] 7 SCR 725 : (2015) 2 SCC 130; Shri Sitaram Sugar Co. Ltd. v. Union of India [1990] 1 SCR 909 : (1990) 3 SCC 223; Santosh Singh v. Union of India [2016] 5 SCR 761 : (2016) 8 SCC 253; Ashwani Kumar v. Union of India [2019] 12 SCR 30 : (2020) 13 SCC 585; Sanjeev Coke Mfg. Co. v. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. [1983] 1 SCR 1000 : (1983) 1 SCC 147; Rustom Cavasjee Cooper (Banks Nationalisation) v. Union of India [1970] 3 SCR 530 : (1970) 1 SCC 248; Maharashtra State Board of Secondary & Higher Secondary Education v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar
[2024] 10 S.C.R. Sheth [1985] 1 SCR 29 : (1984) 4 SCC 27; Tilokchand Motichand v. H. B. Munshi [1969] 2 SCR 824 : (1969) 1 SCC 110; Aflatoon v. Lt. Governor of Delhi [1975] 1 SCR 802 : (1975) 4 SCC 285; Narayani Debi Khaitan v. State of Bihar 1964 SCC OnLine SC 1; Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India [1979] 3 SCR 1014 : (1979) 3 SCC 489, Shri Vallabh Glass Works Ltd. v. Union of India [1984] 3 SCR 180 : (1984) 3 SCC 362; Daryao v. State of U.P. [1962] 1 SCR 574 : 1961 SCC OnLine SC 21; Amrit Lal Berry v. CCE [1975] 2 SCR 960 : (1975) 4 SCC 714; Tukaram Kana Joshi v. MIDC [2012] 13 SCR 29 : (2013) 1 SCC 353; Vidya Devi v. State of Himachal Pradesh [2020] 1 SCR 749 : (2020) 2 SCC 569; Kashinath G. Jalmi (Dr) v. The Speaker [1993] 2 SCR 820 : (1993) 2 SCC 703; Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India [2018] 7 SCR 379 : (2018) 10 SCC 1; Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala [1973] Supp. 1 SCR 1 : (1973) 4 SCC 225; Nandini Sundar v. State of Chhattisgarh [2011] 8 SCR 1028 : (2011) 7 SCC 547; Akbar Khan Alam Khan v. Union of India [1962] 1 SCR 779 : AIR 1962 SC 70; State v. Syed Mohd. Khan [1962] Supp. 3 SCR 288 : 1962 SCC OnLine SC 2; Nagpur Improvement Trust v. Vithal Rao [1973] 3 SCR 39 : (1973) 1 SCC 500; Subramanian Swamy v. CBI [2014] 6 SCR 873 : (2014) 8 SCC 682; State of M.P. v. Bhopal Sugar Industries Ltd [1964] 6 SCR 846 : (1964) 6 SCR 846; Clarence Pais v. Union of India [2001] 2 SCR 43 : (2001) 4 SCC 325; State of W.B. v. Anwar Ali Sarkar [1952] 1 SCR 284 : (1952) 1 SCC 1; John Vallamattom v. Union of India [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 638 : (2003) 6 SCC 611; Transport & Dock Workers Union v. Mumbai Port Trust [2010] 14 SCR 873 : (2011) 2 SCC 575; State of Kerala v. N.M. Thomas [1976] 1 SCR 906 : (1976) 2 SCC 310; Ramesh Chandra Sharma v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2021] 6 SCR 219 : (2024) 5 SCC 217; Roop Chand Adlakha v. DDA [1988] Supp. 3 SCR 253 : (1989) Supp. 1 SCC 116; D.S. Nakara v. Union of India [1983] 2 SCR 165 : (1983) 1 SCC 305; State of Gujarat v. Shri Ambica Mills Ltd [1974] 3 SCR 760 : (1974) 4 SCC 656; State of T.N. v. National South Indian River Interlinking Agriculturist Association [2021] 7 SCR 479 : (2021) 15 SCC 534; State of Uttar Pradesh v. Deoman Upadhyaya [1961] 1 SCR 14 : 1960 SCC OnLine SC 8; Charanjit Lal Chowdhury v. Union of India 1950 SCC Online SC 49; ; Superintendent & Remembrancer of Legal Affairs v. Girish Kumar Navalakha [1975] 3 SCR 802 : (1975) 4 SCC 754; Javed v. State of Haryana [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 947 : (2003) 8 SCC 369; Basheer v. State of Kerala [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 580 : (2004) 3
986
SCC 609; Subramanian Swamy v. Raju [2014] 9 SCR 283 : (2014) 8 SCC 390; Council for Civil Service Union v. Minister for the Civil Service 1985 AC 374; Shri Ram Krishna Dalmia v. Shri SR Tandolkar [1959] 1 SCR 279 : 1958 SCC OnLine SC 6; Gopi Chand v. Delhi Administration [1959] Supp. 2 SCR 87 : 1959 SCC OnLine SC 29; Mohd. Hanif Quareshi v. State of Bihar [1959] 1 SCR 629 : 1957 SCC OnLine SC 17; Bhagwati Saran v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1961] 3 SCR 563 : 1961 SCC OnLine SC 170; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhopal Sugar Industries Ltd. [1964] 6 SCR 846 : 1964 SCC OnLine SC 121; Ameerunnissa Begum v. Mahboob Begum [1953] 1 SCR 404 : (1952) 2 SCC 697: Ram Prasad Narayan Sahi v. State of Bihar [1953] 1 SCR 1129 : (1953) 1 SCC 274; Shayara Bano v. Union of India [2017] 9 SCR 797 : (2017) 9 SCC 1; Harakchand Ratanchand Banthia v. Union of India [1970] 1 SCR 479 : (1969) 2 SCC 166; Arunachal Pradesh v. Khudiram Chakma [1993] 3 SCR 401 : 1994 Supp. 1 SCC 615; Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Shri Raj Narain [1976] 2 SCR 347 : 1975 Supp SCC 1; EP Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu [1974] 2 SCR 348 : (1974) 4 SCC 3; Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India [1978] 2 SCR 621 : (1978) 1 SCC 248; State of Andhra Pradesh v. McDowell [1996] 3 SCR 721 : (1996) 3 SCC 709; Joseph Shine v. Union of India [2018] 11 SCR 765 : (2019) 3 SCC 39; Cellular Operators Assn. of India v. TRAI [2016] 9 SCR 1 : (2016) 7 SCC 703; J.S. Luthra Academy v. State of Jammu and Kashmir [2018] 10 SCR 1098 : (2018) 18 SCC 65; Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd. v. Union of India [2019] 17 SCR 331 : (2020) 17 SCC 324; Vivek Narayan Sharma (Demonetisation Case-5 J.) v. Union of India [2023] 1 SCR 1 : (2023) 3 SCC 1; K.S. Puttaswamy (Privacy-9J) v. Union of India [2015] 9 SCR 99 : (2017) 10 SCC 1; State of Punjab v. Amar Nath Goyal [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 549 : (2005) 6 SCC 754; Union of India v. Parameswaran Match Works [1975] 2 SCR 573 : (1975) 1 SCC 305; Indian Social Action Forum v. Union of India [2020] 4 SCR 903 : (2021) 15 SCC 60; Nisha Priya Bhatia v. Union of India [2020] 10 SCR 596 : (2020) 13 SCC 56; Shreya Singhal v Union of India [2015] 5 SCR 963 : (2015) 5 SCC 1; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Baldeo Prasad [1961] 1 SCR 970 : (1961) 1 SCR 970; Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab [1994] 2 SCR 375 : (1994) 3 SCC 569; Federation of Obstetrics & Gynaecological Societies of India (FOGSI) v. Union of India [2019] 7 SCR 12 : (2019) 6 SCC 283; Seksaria Cotton Mills Ltd. v. State of Bombay [1953] 1 SCR 825 : (1953) 1 SCC 561; K.A. Abbas v. Union of India
[2024] 10 S.C.R. [1971] 2 SCR 446 : (1970) 2 SCC 780; Smt. Shanno Devi v. Mangal Sain [1961] 1 SCR 576 : (1961) 1 SCR 576; Premium Granites v. State of T.N. [1994] 1 SCR 579 : (1994) 2 SCC 691; Ahmedabad St. Xavier’s College Society v. State of Gujarat [1975] 1 SCR 173 : (1974) 1 SCC 717; State of Karnataka v. Associated Management of Medium Primary and Secondary Schools [2014] 5 SCR 1104 : (2014) 9 SCC 485; State of Bombay v. Bombay Education Society [1955] 1 SCR 568 : (1954) 2 SCC 152; D.A.V. College v. State of Punjab (1971) 2 SCC 269; S. P. Mittal v. Union of India [1983] 1 SCR 729 : (1983) 1 SCC 51; M. C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath [1996] Supp. 10 SCR 12 : (1997) 1 SCC 388; Natural Resources Allocation, In re, Special Reference No. 1 of 2012 [2012] 9 SCR 311 : (2012) 10 SCC 1; N.P. Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency [1952] 1 SCR 218 : AIR 1952 SC 64; Jyoti Basu v. Debi Gosal [1982] 3 SCR 318 : AIR 1982 SC 983; Shyamdeo Prasad Singh v. Nawal Kishore Yadav [2000] Supp. 2 SCR 668 : (2000) 8 SCC 46; Krishnamoorthy v. Sivakumar [2015] 4 SCR 987 : (2015) 3 SCC 467; People’s Union for Civil Liberties v. Union of India [2013] 12 SCR 283 : (2013) 10 SCC 1; Rajbala v. State of Haryana [2015] 12 SCR 1106 : (2016) 2 SCC 445; Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India [2023] 9 SCR 1 : (2023) 6 SCC 161; Inderjit Barua v. Election Commission of India AIR 1984 SC 1911; Extra-Judicial Execution Victim Families Assn. v. Union of India [2016] 4 SCR 909 : (2016) 14 SCC 536; State Trading Corpn. of India Ltd. v. CTO 1963 SCC OnLine SC 3; State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal [1987] 1 SCR 1 : (1986) 4 SCC 566; Shri Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of India [1993] 1 SCR 480 : AIR 1993 SC 1267; Indra Sawhney v. Union of India [1992] Supp. 2 SCR 454 : AIR 1993 SC 477; AIIMS Students’ Union v. AIIMS [2001] Suppl. 2 SCR 79 : AIR 2001 SC 3262; Indian Medical Association v. Union of India [2011] 6 SCR 599 : AIR 2011 SC 2365; Izhar Ahmed Khan v. Union of India [1962] Supp. 3 SCR 235 : AIR 1962 SC 1052; Lakshmi Charan Sen v. A.K.M. Hassam Uzzaman [1985] Suppl. 1 SCR 493 : (1985) 4 SCC 689 – referred to. Länsman v Finland (511/92); Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia, Communication No. 760/1997 (25 July 2000); Lubicon Lake Band v. Canada, Communication No. 167/1984 (26 March 1990), U.N. Doc. Supp. No. 40 (A/45/40) at 1 (1990); Rakhim Mavlonov and Shansiy Sa’di case (Mavlonov v. Uzbekistan), Communication No. 1334/2004, UN Doc. CCPR/C/95/D/1334/2004 (2009); Perez v. Bromwell, [1958] 356 US 44, 46; Igartua De La Rosa v. United
988
States [2000], 80 F.3d 29, (1st Cir. 2000); Thomas Bonham v. College of Physicians [1610], 8 Co. Rep. 107 77 Eng. Rep. 638; Marbury v. Madison [1803], 5 U.S. 137 (1803); Lorenzo v. McCoy, 15 Phil 559 (Philippines Supreme Court); South Carolina v. Katzenbach 383 U.S. 301 (1966) – referred to. In the Judgment of Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI Assam Sanmilita Mahasangha v. Union of India [2014] 14 SCR 744 : (2015) 3 SCC 1; Kulathil v. State of Kerala [1966] 3 SCR 706 : AIR 1966 SC 1614; Izhar Ahmed v. Union of India [1962] Supp. 3 SCR 235 : 1962 SCC OnLine SC 1; State of UP v. Shah Mohammed [1969] 3 SCR 1006 : (1969) 1 SCC 771 [5]; National Human Rights Commission v. State of Arunachal Pradesh [1996] 1 SCR 278 : (1996) 1 SCC 742; Committee for Citizenship Rights of the Chakmas of Arunachal Pradesh v. State of Arunachal Pradesh [2015] 9 SCR 1020 : (2016) 15 SCC 540; Shah Muhammad Anwar Ali v. State of Assam 2014 SCC OnLine Gau 103; Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India [2024] 2 SCR 420 : 2024 INSC 113; Shri Ram Krishna Dalmia v. Shri SR Tandolkar [1959] 1 SCR 279 : 1958 SCC OnLine SC 6; Moorthy Match Works v. CCE [1974] 3 SCR 121 : (1974) 4 SCC 428; State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar [1952] 1 SCR 284 : (1952) 1 SCC 1; EP Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu [1974] 2 SCR 348 : (1974) 4 SCC 3; Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Seheravardi [1981] 2 SCR 79 : (1981) 1 SCC 722; State of Andhra Pradesh v. McDowell [1996] 3 SCR 721 : (1996) 3 SCC 709; Shayara Bano v. Union of India [2017] 9 SCR 797 : (2017) 9 SCC 1; Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India [2018] 7 SCR 379 : (2018) 10 SCC 1; State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh [2024] 8 SCR 1321 : 2024 INSC 562; Kerala Hotel and Restaurant Association v. State of Kerala [1990] 1 SCR 516 : (1990) 2 SCC 502; Joseph Shine v. Union of India [2018] 11 SCR 765 : (2019) 3 SCC 39; Nagpur Improvement Trust v. Vithal Rao [1973] 3 SCR 39 : 1973 1 SCC 500; Arun Kumar v. Union of India [2006] Suppl. 6 SCR 290 : (2007) 1 SCC 732; G Sadasivan Nair v. Cochin University of Science and Technology [2021] 9 SCR 752 : (2022) 4 SCC 404; State of Tamil Nadu v. National South Indian River Inter-linking [2021] 7 SCR 479 : (2021) 15 SCC 534; State of Gujarat v. Ambica Mills [1974] 3 SCR 760 : (1974) 4 SCC 656; Basheer v. State of Kerala [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 580 : (2004) 3 SCC 609; Gauri Shanker v. Union of India [1994] Suppl. 3 SCR 244 : (1994) 6 SCC 349; Anant Mills v. State of Gujarat [1975] 3
[2024] 10 S.C.R. SCR 220 : (1975) 2 SCC 175; Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India [2005] Supp. 1 SCR 472 : (2005) 5 SCC 665; Naga People’s Movement of Human Rights v. Union of India [1997] Suppl. 5 SCR 469 : (1998) 2 SCC 109; Madhyamam Broadcasting Limited v. Union of India [2023] 10 SCR 595 : (2023) SCC OnLine SC 366; SR Bommai v. Union of India [1994] 2 SCR 644 : 1994 3 SCC 1; Ahmedabad St. Xavier’s College Society v. State of Gujarat [1975] 1 SCR 173 : (1974) 1 SCC 717; Father W Proost v. State of Bihar [5J] [1969] 2 SCR 73; DAV College, Bhatinda v. State of Punjab [1971] Supp. 1 SCR 677; Jagdev Singh Sidhanti v. Pratap Singh Daulta [1964] 6 SCR 750; Supriyo Chakraborty v. Union of India [2023] 16 SCR 1209 : 2023 INSC 920; Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India [1978] 2 SCR 621 : (1978) 1 SCC 248; Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala [2018] 9 SCR 561 : (2019) 11 SCC 1; State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial [1971] 1 SCR 734 : (1970) 2 SCC 417; TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka (2002) 8 SCC 481; Motor General Traders v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1984] 1 SCR 594 : (1984) 1 SCC 222; Rattan Arya v. State of Tamil Nadu [1986] 2 SCR 596 : (1986) 3 SCC 385; Malpe Vishwanath Acharya v. State of Maharashtra [1997] Supp. 6 SCR 717 : (1998) 2 SCC 1; JK Cotton Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd. v. Union of India [1988] 1 SCR 700 : AIR 1988 SC 191 – referred to. Missouri Kansas & Texas Railway v. May 194 US 297, 269; Williums-Yulee v. The Florida Bar, 575 US (2015) – referred to. In the Judgment of Pardiwala, J. Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India [2005] Supp. 1 SCR 472 : (2005) 5 SCC 665; Naga People’s Movement of Human Rights v. Union of India [1997] Supp. 5 SCR 469; Somaiya Organics (India) Ltd. & Another v. State of U.P. & Another [2001] 3 SCR 33 : (2001) 5 SCC 519; Synthetics and Chemicals Ltd. v. State of U.P [1989] Suppl. 1 SCR 623 : (1990) 1 SCC 109; Independent Thought v. Union of India [2017] 13 SCR 821 : (2017) 10 SCC 800; Modern Dental College and Research Centre and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors. [2016] 3 SCR 579 : (2016) 7 SCC 353; Satyawati Sharma v. Union of India [2008] 6 SCR 566 : (2008) 5 SCC 287; Malpe Vishwanath Acharya v. State of Maharashtra [1997] Supp. 6 SCR 717 : (1998) 2 SCC 1; State of M.P. v. Bhopal Sugar Industries Ltd [1964] 6 SCR 846 : 1964
990
SCC OnLine SC 121; Rattan Arya and Ors. v. State of Tamil Nadu and Ors. [1986] 2 SCR 596 : (1986) 3 SCC 385; State of Assam v. Moslem Mandal 2013 SCC OnLine Gau 1; Shayara Bano v. Union of India [2017] 9 SCR 797 : (2017) 9 SCC 1; Cellular Operators Assn. of India v. Telecom Regulatory Authority of India [2016] 9 SCR 1 : (2016) 7 SCC 703; Joseph Shine v. Union of India [2018] 11 SCR 765 : (2019) 3 SCC 39; Narottam Kishore Deb Varman v. Union of India [1964] 7 SCR 55; H.H. Shri Swamiji of Shri Amar Mutt v. Commr., Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Deptt [1980] 1 SCR 368 : (1979) 4 SCC 642, Motor General Traders v. State of A.P. [1984] 1 SCR 594 : (1984) 1 SCC 222; I.C. Golak Nath v. State of Punjab [1967] 2 SCR 762 : AIR 1967 SC 1643, Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala [1973] Supp. 1 SCR 1 : (1973) 4 SCC 225; State of UP v. Synthetics and Chemicals Ltd. [1980] 2 SCR 531 : (1980) 2 SCC 441 – referred to. Books and Periodicals Cited In the Judgment of Surya Kant, J: T. S. MURTY, Assam, The Difficult Years: A Study of Political Developments in 1979- 83, Himalayan Books, 1983; Begum Aizaz Rasul, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 7, 08.12.1948; Z. H. Lari, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 7, 08.12.1948; Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 7, 08.12.1948; PASCUAL GISBERT, Fundamentals of Sociology, Orient Longman, 1973 (3rd ed.), 342; BRONISLAW MALINOWSKI, A Scientific Theory of Culture and Other Essays, The University of North Carolina Press, 1944, 67; Govind Ballabh Pant, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 7, 08.12.1948; K. Santhanam, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 7, 08.12.1948; ORNIT SHANI, How India Became Democratic: Citizenship and the Making of the Universal Franchise, Cambridge University Press, 2017; M. Thirumala Rao, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 11, 22.11.1949; Brajeshwar Prasad, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 8, 16.06.1949; Hriday Nath Kunzru, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 11, 22.11.1949; Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 11, 25.11.1949; B.R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 8, 02.06.1949; Alladi Krishnaswamy Ayyar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 11, 23.11.1949; Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9,
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 03.08.1949 and 04.08.1949; H.V. Kamath, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 02.08.1949; Nehru-Liaquat Pact of 1950; ARISTOTLE, Politics, Book III, Benjamin Jowett (trans.), Batoche; Books, 1999, R. D. Masters (ed.), J. R. Masters (trans.), New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1978; ULRICH PREUSS, The Ambiguous Meaning of Citizenship, University of Chicago Law School (2003); STEPHANIE DEGOOYER ET AL, The Right to Have Rights,Verso Books, 2018; ROMILA THAPAR ET. AL., On Citizenship, Aleph Book Company, 2021; KANGNI KPODAR, Citizenship and Growth, IMF eLibrary; JAMES BROWN SCOTT, Nationality: Jus Soli or Jus Sanguinis, American Journal of International Law, 1930, 24(1), 60; ACQUISITION OF CITIZENSHIP - AĠENZIJA KOMUNITÀ MALTA; DAVID FITZGERALD, Nationality and Migration in Modern Mexico, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2005; STEYN, The Constitutionalisation of Public Law, 1999, 4, 6, 13-14; A. W. BRADLEY & K. D. EWING, Constitutional and Administrative Law, Pearson Longman, 2007; H. BARNETT, Constitution and Administrative Law, Cavendish, 2006; LAURENCE H. TRIBE, American Constitutional Law, Foundation Press, 2000; EDWARD GAIT, A History of Assam, Thacker, Spink & Company, 1906; MANOR DIN: ARUPJYOTI SAIKIA ON HOW THE BURMESE INVASION OF ASSAM TRANSPIRED DOWN TO EARTH; SANGEETA BAROOAH PISHAROTY, Assam: The Accord, the Discord, Penguin Random House, 2019, 221; ARUPJYOTI SAIKIA, The Quest for Modern Assam, Penguin Random House, 2023, 25; Ministry of External Affairs Annual Report (1943-44), para 15, ANTARA DATTA, Refugees and Borders in South Asia: The Great Exodus of 1971, Routledge, 2015; Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 11, 25.11.1949; DR. BABSAHEB AMBEDKAR WRITINGS AND SPEECHES, Dr. Ambedkar Foundation, Vol. 1, 57; GEORGES LEFEBVRE, The Coming of the French Revolution, R. R. Palmer (trans.), Princeton University Press, 1973; THE NEW ENCYCLOPAEDIA BRITANNICA: MACROPAEDIA (Encyclopaedia Britannica Inc.), 1974; JEREMIE GILBERT AND DAVID KEANE, Equality versus fraternity? Rethinking France and its minorities, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 2016, 14 (4), 901 and 902; Decision 99-412 DC of June 15, 1999, Rec. 71 (European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages), para 10; R. K. Sidhwa, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 11.08.1949; Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 10.08.1949; Alladi Krishnaswamy Ayyar and H. N. Kunzru,
992
Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 12.08.1949; K. M. Munshi, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 3, 29.04.1947; Nationality Law of People’s Republic of China, 1980, Article 9; Japan’s Nationality Law, 1950, Article 11; Kuwait, Ministerial Decree No. 15 of 1959 Promulgating the Nationality Law, Article 11; The Oxford Handbook on Indian Constitution, Oxford University Press, 2016, 940; H.L.A. HART, Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals, Harvard Law Review, 1958, 71(4), 607; B. K. MILLER, Constitutional Remedies for Underinclusive Statutes: A Critical Appraisal of Heckler v. Mathews, Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, 1985, 20, 86; Bholanath Sen, Lok Sabha Debate (CAB, 1985), 20.11.1985 – referred to. In the Judgment of Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI BR Ambedkar in Constituent Assembly Debates (10 August 1949); B Shiva Rao, The framing of India’s Constitution: Select Documents (Part II), 472; B Shiva Rao, The framing of India’s Constitution: Select Documents (Part II), 473; B Shiva Rao, The framing of India’s Constitution: Select Documents (Part II), 683; The emergence of Documentary Identities in Post-Colonial India, 1950-67 (2016), History Faculty Publications 129; BN Rao, Memorandum on the Union Constitution and Draft Clauses (May 30 1947); Ad-hoc Committee on Citizenship (12 July 1947); Draft Constitution of India, 1948; P Ramanatha Aiyar, Advanced Law Lexicon (6th Edition Volume 2 D-1) 1587, Citizenship Bill, Parliamentary Debates, New Delhi, 3 December 1955, p.1176; Shri RK Choudhuri (Assam), Parliamentary Debates: Official Report (Volume 1, 1950), 318; Shri Gopalaswami to the question from Dr Deshmukh, Parliamentary Debates: Official Report (Volume 1, 1950), 336; Arupjyoti Saikia, The Quest for Modern Assam, (Penguin and Allen Lane) 455; M Rafiqul Islam, A Tale of Millions: Bangladesh Liberation War, 1971 (Bangladesh Books International); Report of Governor of Assam Lt. Col S.K Sinha dated 8.11.1998; W.N Hohfeld, Fundamental Legal Conceptions as applied in Judicial Reasoning and other legal essays, (W.W. Cook ed., Yale University Press, 1919); Anil Roychoudhury, National Register of Citizens 1951, (Vol 16, Issue no. 8, 21 Feb 1981); Justice GP Singh, Principles of Statutory Interpretation (15th edition, Lexis Nexis), Yasmin Khan, The Great Partition: The Making of India and Pakistan (Penguin India) – referred to.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. In the Judgment of Pardiwala, J. Myron Weiner, The Political Demography of Assam’s AntiImmigrant Movement, 9, POPUL. DEV. REV., 283 (1983); Arupjyoti Saikia, Quest For Modern Assam: A History; Uddipan Dutta, The Role of Language Management and Language Conflict in the Transition of Post-Colonia Assamese Identity, (2012); Assam Tribune, Nov. 12 1972; Times of India, Nov. 13 1972; Dainik Asam, Oct. 4, 1972; Times of India, Oct. 6, 1972; Times of India, Oct. 7, 1972; SANGEETA BAROOAH PISHAROTY, ASSAM: THE ACCORD, THE DISCORD; Report of the Non-Official Judicial Inquiry Commission on the Holocaust of Assam Before During and After Election 1983; Order of R.K. Trivedi, Chief Election Commissioner, India, Annexure F, 201 (Jan. 7, 1983); Report of the Non-Official Judicial Inquiry Commission on the Holocaust of Assam Before During and After Election 1983, Note Submitted by S.L. Khosla, Chief Electoral Officer, Assam to R.V. Subramaniam, Advisor to Governor, Assam, Annexure E, 193 (Sept. 29, 1982); Lok Sabha Debates, Statement of A.K. Sen, Minister of Law and Justice on Statutory Resolution Regarding Disapproval of Representation of the People (Amendment) Ordinance and Representation of the People (Amendment) Bill., at cols. 190–93, (Jan. 23, 1985); Assam Tribune, K.C. Khanna, Minefield of Uncertainties: The Assam Accord and After; Times of India, (20 August 1985); MANI SHANKAR AIYAR, RAJIV GANDHI’S INDIA: A GOLDEN JUBILEE RETROSPECTIVE, NATIONHOOD, ETHNICITY, PLURALISM AND CONFLICT RESOLUTION, (Atlantic Publishers 1998); Dr. Bhupendra Nath & Dilip C Nath, The Change of Religion and Language Composition in the State of Assam in Northeast India: A Statistical Analysis Since 1951 to 2001, 5 INT. J. SCI. RES. PUB. 2, (2012); Nandita Saikia, William Joe, Apala Saha & Utpal Chutia, Cross Border Migration in Assam during 1951-2011: Process, Magnitude, and Socio-Economic Consequences, Report submitted to ICSSR 38, (2016); Govt. of Assam, White Paper on Foreigner’s Issue; Session No. 136, Rajya Sabha Deb., Statement of Shri. Baharul Islam on The Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 1985; SANGEETA BAROOAH PISHAROTY, Assam: The Accord, The Discord; Liaqat A. Khan, Temporality of Law, 40 MCGEORGE L. REV. (2016); Cross Border Migration in Assam During 1951-2011: Process, Magnitude, and Socio-Economic Consequences by Dr. Nandita Saikia & Dr. William Joe; The Hindu Bureau – referred to.
994
List of Websites In the judgment of Surya Kant, J: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/citizenship/; https://www. doi.gov/oia/islands/american-samoa; https://www.elibrary.imf. org/view/journals/022/0056/001/article-A014-en.xml; https:// komunita.gov.mt/en/services/acquisition-of-citizenship/; https://globalresidenceindex.com/citizenship-by-investment/; https://www.downtoearth.org.in/interviews/governance/manordin-arupjyoti-saikia-on-how-the-burmese-invasion-of-assamtranspired-93414; https://www.mea.gov.in/Images/attach/ amb/Volume_01.pdf; https://static.mygov.in/saas/s3fs-saas/ assam/mygov_149761430071181.pdf; https://pmindiaun. gov.in/pageinfo/ODY3#:~:text=Article%201%3A%20The%20 Go – referred to. List of Acts In the Judgment of Surya Kant, J: Voting Rights Act of 1965; Citizenship Act, 1955; British Nationality Act, 1981; Representation of the People Act, 1983 (c. 2), Acts of Parliament, 1983 (United Kingdom); Immigration Act, Acts of Parliament, 1971 (UK); Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019; Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Act, 1950; Limitation Act, 1963; West Pakistan (Control) Ordinance; Chhattisgarh Police Act, 2007; Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985; Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964; Foreigners Act, 1946; Passport (Entry into India) Act, 1920; Passport Act, 1967; Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010; Information Technology Act, 2000; Life Insurance Corporation Act, 1956; Income Tax Act, 1961; Patents Act, 1970; Government of India Act, 1935; Representation of People Act, 1951; Representation of People Act, 1918; Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunals) Act, 1983; Citizenship Rules, 2009; Citizenship (Amendment) Rules, 2024; Citizenship (Amendment) Rules, 2013; Supreme Court Rules, 2013; Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Rules, 2011; Dadra and Nagar Haveli (Citizenship) Order, 1962; Goa, Daman and Diu (Citizenship) Order, 1962; Chandernagore (Merger) Act, 1954; Citizenship (Pondicherry) Order, 1962; Sikkim (Citizenship) Order, 1975; Special Courts Bill, 1978; The Constitution (Thirteenth) Amendment Bill, 1962.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. In the Judgment of Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI Citizenship Act 1955; Foreigners Act, 1946; Assam Official Language Act 1960; Citizenship (Amendment) Act 1985; Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964; Passport Act 1967; Government of India Act 1935; Pakistan (Control) Act 1949; West Pakistan (Control) Ordinance 1948; Pakistan (Control) Repealing Act 1952; Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2003; Foreigners Order 1948; Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Act 1950; Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunals) Act 1983, Passport (Entry into India) Act 1920 ; Assam Disturbed Areas Act 1955; Representation of the People Act 1951; Constitution (Twenty-second Amendment) Act 1969; Assam Official Language Act 1960; Code of Civil Procedure 1908; Code of Criminal Procedure 1973; Registration of Foreigners Act 1939; Influx from Pakistan (Control) Repealing Act 1952; Citizenship Rules 1956; Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunals) Rules 1984; Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and Issue of National Identity Cards) Rules 2003; Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and Issue of National Identity Cards) Amendment Rules; Citizenship Rules 2009; Registration of Foreigners Rules 1939. In the Judgment of Pardiwala, J. Citizenship Act 1955; Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation, 1873; Charter Act, 1833; Assam Company Act, 1845; Government of India Act, 1935; Indian Independence Act, 1947; Pakistan (Control) Act, 1949; Pakistan (Control) Repealing Act, 1952; Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964; Foreigners Act, 1946; Bangladesh, Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunals) Act, 1983; Citizenship (Temporary Provisions) Order, 1972; Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1939; Registration of Foreigners Act, 1939; Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985; Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 1985; Citizenship Rules, 1956; Citizenship Rules, 2009; Citizenship (Amendment) Rules, 2013; Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947; Bhopal State Agricultural Income Tax Act, 1953; Passports Act, 1967; Pakistan (Control) Repealing Act, 1952; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Act, 1950 .
996
List of Keywords Constitutional validity of s.6A of Citizenship Act; Preambular values like fraternity; Unreasonable classification; Manifest arbitrariness; Rights provided to ‘indigenous’ communities u/Art. 29; Political rights of Indian citizens in Assam u/Art. 326; ‘External aggression’ and ‘internal disturbance’; Harmonious interpretation of two legislations; Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord; Deemed citizenship to immigrants who entered prior to 01.01.1966; Process of registration for immigrants; Illegal immigrants; Principles of fraternity; Directions issued in Sarbananda Sonowal’s case; Deporting the illegal immigrants; Identification of illegal immigrants; Identification and detection of illegal immigrants or foreigners in Assam; Fraternity; Preambular notion of fraternity; Meaning of ‘fraternity’; Essence of fraternity; Principle for uplifting marginalized sections of society; Notion of inclusiveness and togetherness; Safeguarding community’s endogamous way of life; Disenfranchising; Dual citizenship; Competence to specify different conditions u/Art. 11; Concept of dual citizenship; Renunciation of previous citizenship; Oath of allegiance; Oath of allegiance before conferral of citizenship; Treats equals unequally; Selective application; Ex-facie arbitrary; Two-pronged reasonable classification test; Humanitarian needs of migrants of Indian origin; Impact of the migration on economic and cultural needs of Indian states; Rational nexus; Under-inclusive; Over-inclusive; Right to equality; Reasonableness of classification; Yardsticks to check reasonableness of classification; Marginally under-inclusive; Rationale for cut-off dates-01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971; Constituents of manifest arbitrariness; Relation between Art. 14 and arbitrariness; Facets of test of manifest arbitrariness; Extent of review under manifest arbitrariness; Vagueness in law; Extent of review for test of ‘void for vagueness’; ‘Ordinary resident in Assam’; Actionable impact on Assamese culture; Protection of interest of minorities; Marginalization and disruption of their socio-economic aspirations; Right of self-governance; Inclusion of unidentified migrant population burdens country’s natural resources, Sustainable development; Right of exclusion; Right u/Art. 326, if can be invoked to exclude certain individuals; Adult suffrage; Federal structure of Constitution; Constitutional status of States; Detection and deportation of illegal immigrants; Intention behind inclusion of Art. 355; International law cannot trump domestic law; Limits to judicial review; Judicial review of government policies; Scope of
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
judicial review; Grounds of unreasonable classification; Scope of judicial review of under-inclusive provisions; Limitation period for writs; Applicability of doctrine of laches; Transformative nature of Constitution; Equitable allocation of resources; Right of Assamese people to vote; Government policies hovering around foreign policy; Effectiveness of existing policies; Modes of acquiring citizenship. Case Arising From CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (C) No. 274 of 2009 (Under Article 32 of The Constitution of India) With Writ Petition (Civil) No. 916 of 2014, Writ Petition (Civil) Nos. 470 and 1047 of 2018, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 68 of 2016, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 876 of 2014, Writ Petition (Civil) Nos. 449 and 450 of 2015 and Writ Petition (Civil) No. 562 of 2012 Appearances for Parties R Venkataramani, Attorney General, Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, K M Nataraj, A.S.G., Ardhendumauli Kumar Prasad, Tapesh Kumar Singh, Saurabh Mishra, Amit Anand Tiwari, A.A.Gs., Devajit Saikia, Amit Kumar, K N Balgopal, Gurminder Singh, Adv. Gen./Sr. Advs., Shyam Divan, Vijay Hansaria, Kamal Nayan Choudhury, Sanjay Hegde, Kapil Sibal, Ms. Indira Jaising, Salman Khurshid, Sanjay R Hegde, Anupam Lal Das, Chander Uday Singh, Ms. Malvika Trivedi, P V Surendranath, Dr. Manish Singhvi, Ajay Tewari, Colin Gonsalves, Sr. Advs., Somiran Sharma, Udayaditya Banerjee, Ms. Kavya Jhawar, Sudipto Sircar, Ms. Anshula Laroiya, Adith Deshmukh, Arpit Jacob Varaprasad, Ms. Shristi Borthakur, Dhrubajit Saikia, Ms. Aadya Malik, Suryanusen Gupta, Manish Goswami, Navneet Gautam, Rongon Choudhury, Rishab Sharma, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal, Anjani Kumar Mishra, Fuzail Ahmad Ayyubi, Shivendra Singh, Bikram Dwivedi, Puneett Singhal, Sanjeev Chaudhary, Somesh Chandra Jha, Anas Tanwir, Mrigank Prabhakar, Ms. Sakshi Banga, Gautam Prabhakar, Sunil Murarka, Partha Sil, Tavish Bhushan Prasad, Ms. Sayani Bhattacharya, Joydeep Mukherjee, Abhiraj Choudhary, Syed Shahid Rizvi, Mansoor Ali, Bilal Mansoor, S. Islam, Imtiyaz Ali, Mukul Kumar, Anish Roy, Mrs. Rekha Pandey, Mrs. Shraddha Deshmukh, Shuvodeep Roy, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Kanu
998
Agrawal, Ms. Ruchi Gour Narula, Ms. Diksha Rai, Ms. Sneha Kalita, Chitvan Singhal, Ms. Sonali Jain, Abhishek Kumar Pandey, Raman Yadav, Kartikay Aggarwal, Gaurang Bhushan, Abhishek Kumar Pandy, Dr. Reeta Vasishta, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Mrs. Mrinal Elkar Mazumdar, Anil Hooda, Rajesh Singh Chauhan, P Nayak, Madhav Sinhal, Kritagya Kait, Tanmay Mehta, Rohit Khare, Akshay Nain, Deepayan Dutta, Saurabh Tripathi, Arijit Dey, Ms. Apurva Sachdev, Ms. Atiga Singh, Nizam Pasha, Gautam Bhatia, Mustafa Khaddam Hussain, Ms. Rupali Samuel, Ibad Mushtaq, Ms. Sumedha Ray Sarkar, Paras Nath Singh, Ms. Akanksha Rai, Ms. Lubna Naaz, Mohammad Wasim, Rohin Bhatt, Ms. Tehsheena Z Hussain, Sadeeq Sherwani, Ms. Gurneet Kaur, Arkam Pasha, Syed Ashhar, Adeel Ahmed, Abdur Rehman Sikdar, Raja Chatterjee, Ms. Taqdees Fatima, Piyush Sachdev, Md Sharuk Ali, Ms. Anupama Gupta, Ms. Riya Dutta, Ms. Sana Parveen, Ms. Lilly Biswas, Rahul Pratap, Anirudh Singh, Ms. Aparna Bhat, Ms. Bidya Mohanty, Ms. Karishma Maria, Mrinmoy Dutta, Amjid Maqbool, Ankit Yadav, Ms. Sujal Gupta, Shailendra Slaria, Ms. Prakriti Rastogi, Tarun Mehra, Gajjala Bhaskar, T. Mahipal, Biju P Raman, Subhash Chandran K R, Sawan Kumar Shukla, Mrs. Lekha Sudhakar, John Thomas Arakal, Ms. Krishna L R, Shadan Farasat, Mehmood Pracha, Syed Ali Ahmad, Syed Tanweer Ahmad, Syed Miran Ahmad, S S Bandyopadhyay, Ankit Verma, S Kundu, Abhaya Nath Das, Mrs. Barnali Basak, N D Kaushik, V K Shukla, Ms. Riya Soni, Satish Kumar, Dr. Vivek Sharma, Ms. Krishna Sarma, Navnit Kumar, Pardeep Kumar (for M/s. Corporate Law Group), Gaurav Dhingra, M.C. Dhingra, A.K. Singh, Mrs. Arna Dass, Mahender Ram, Joginder Kumar, Rishabh Kumar Singh, Lohit Kumar Bimal, Mrs. Palolavi Parmar, Pradeep Misra, Daleep Dhyani, Manoj Kumar Sharma, Suraj Singh, Bhuwan Chandra, Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, Debojit Borkakati, Mohit D. Ram, Sidhant Kumar, Sahil Tagotra, Manyaa Chandok, Ms. Ishita Deswal, Ms. Abhivyakti Banerjee, Ms. Sushma Suri, Ms. Astha Sharma, Srisatya Mohanty, Ms. Anju Thomas, Sanjeev Kaushik, Ms. Mantika Haryani, Shreyas Awasthi, Himanshu Chakravarty, Ms. Ripul Swati Kumari, Bhanu Mishra, Ms. Muskan Surana, Ms. Lihzu Shiney Konyak, Ms. Anvita Dwivedi, Ms. G. Indira, G. N. Reddy, Shantwanu Singh, Ms. Pragya Singh, Akshay Singh, Ashok Kumar Singh, Saket Singh, Mrs. Sangeeta Singh, Mrs. Niranjana Singh, Siddhesh Shirish Kotwal, Ms. Ana Upadhyay, Ms. Manya Hasija, Tejasvi Gupta, Pawan Upadhyay, T.illayarasu, Ms. Prachi Mishra, Sumeer Sodhi, Chaitanya
[2024] 10 S.C.R. Sharma, Ms. Shreya Singh, V. K. Sidharthan, D. S. Mahra, Gopal Singh, Merusagar Samantaray, Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Ms. Hemantika Wahi, Anuvrat Sharma, Anando Mukherjee, C. K. Sasi, Ms. Meena K Pouiose, Ms. Liz Mathew, Abhinav Mukerji, Mrs. Bihu Sharma, Ms. Pratishtha Vij, Mohit Prasad, Aditya Pratap Singh, Priyanshu Malik, Sunny Choudhary, K.N. Mishra, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Raavi Sharma, Ms. Yamini Singh, M/s. K J John And Co, Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, Karun Sharma, Ms. Rajkumari Divyasana, Avijit Mani Tripathi, Shaurya Sahay, Aditya S. Pandey, Himanshu Sehrawat, Ms. Rekha Bakshi, Sandeep Kumar Jha, V. N. Raghupathy, Manendra Pal Gupta, Ms. K. Enatoli Sema, Ms. Limayinla Jamir, Amit Kumar Singh, Ms. Chubalemla Chang, Prang Newmai, Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Ms. Devyani Bhatt, Ms. Shubhangi Agarwal, Apurv Singhvi, Milind Kumar, Ms. Ranjeeta Rohatgi, Kuldip Singh, Ajay Pal, Mayank Dahiya, Ms. Sugandh Rathor, Shashi Shekhar Kumar Prasad, Raghvendra Kumar, Anand Kumar Dubey, Ms. Harsha Sharma, Simanta Kumar, Devvrat Singh, Jainendra Kumar, Maneesh Pathak, Nishant Verma, Kailas U More, Mrs. Nirmala D Borade, Narendra Kumar, Sabarish Subramanian, Ms. Devyani Gupta, Vishnu Unnikrishnan, C Kranthi Kumar, Naman Dwivedi, Danish Saifi, Ms. V Keerthana, Ms. Tanvi Anand, B. Balaji, Dr. Joseph Aristotle S., Sri Harsha Peechara, Duvvuri Subrahmanya Bhanu, Ms. Pallavi, Ms. Kriti Sinha, Akshat Kulshreshtha, Rajiv Kumar Choudhry, Mrs. Swarupama Chaturvedi, Siddharth Sangal, Ms. Nilanjani Tandon, Ms. Richa Mishra, Ms. Harshita Agrawal, Chirag Sharma, Parijat Sinha, Abhimanyu Tewari, Ms. Eliza Bar, Harsh Parashar, Mahfooz Ahsan Nazki, Dr. P.N. Mishra, Mrs. Hardeep Kaur Mishra, Praveen Mishra, Mohit Chaudhary, Ms. Puja Sharma, Kunal Sachdeva, Ms. Madhuri Jain, Prakhar Mithal, Ms. Srishti Bajpai, Aashish Arya, Anubhav Singhal, Ms. Sagrika Arya, Sanand Ramakrishnan, Rajeev Mishra, Madan Mohan Bora, Praveen Swarup, Ms. Rashmi Singhania, Ms. Bharti Tyagi, Vikash Kumar, M.R. Shamshad, Syed Shahid Husain Rizvi, Ms. Rubina Jawed, S Islam, Arijit Sarkar, Zeeshan Rizvi, Ms. Nabeela Jamil, Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, Dhawal Uniyal, Abhishek, Ashwani Kumar Dubey, Avijit Roy, M/s. Corporate Law Group, Satya Mitra, Ms. Hetvi Patel, Mohan Pandey, Shibashish Misra, Krishna Dev Jagarlamudi, Pashupathi Nath Razdan, Ms. Maitreyee Jagat Joshi, Astik Gupta, Ms. Akanksha Tomar, Argha Roy, Gaurav Kumar, Advs. for the appearing parties.
1000
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court
Judgment Surya Kant, J. (On Behalf of Himself, M.M. Sundresh J. and Manoj Misra, J.) Table of Contents* A. BACKGROUND.....................................................................
B. TERMS OF REFERENCE.....................................................
D. ISSUES.................................................................................
C. CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES......................................
E. ANALYSIS............................................................................. I.
Prefatory challenges.......................................................... i.
ii.
Judicial review...........................................................
(a) Concept of judicial review.................................. (b) Limits to judicial review.................................... Delay and maintainability of the writ petitions..........
(a) Limitation period for writs..................................
(b) Applicability of doctrine of laches to the present case...................................................................
II. Challenges regarding constitutionality..............................
(a) Meaning of ‘fraternity’.......................................
iii.
iv.
v.
The preambular notion of fraternity........................... (b) Ethos of Section 6A is aligned with fraternity....
Part II and Section 6A................................................
(a) Section 6A and Articles 6, 7 and 11 of the Constitution.......................................................
(b) Section 6A and dual citizenship.........................
Article 14 and classification under Section 6A.........
(c) Section 6A and the oath of allegiance..............
(a) Maintainability under Article 14......................... (b) Section 6A vis-à-vis Article 14............................
* Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1001
vi.
Manifest arbitrariness............................................... 109 (a) Relation between Article 14 and arbitrariness
(b) Constituents of manifest arbitrariness................
(c) Facets of the test of manifest arbitrariness........
(d) Extent of review under manifest arbitrariness...
(e) Cut-off dates in Section 6A.................................
(f)
Process prescribed under Section 6A............... 121
(g) Section 6A and Part II of the Constitution........ 126 (h) ‘Ordinarily resident’ in Section 6A..................... 126 vii.
Article 29 and Section 6A......................................... 139 (a) Background of Article 29.................................. 140 (b) Standing under Article 29(1).............................. 142 (c) Substance of Article 29(1)............................... 146 (d) Section 6A vis-à-vis Article 29.......................... 149
viii. Article 21 and Section 6A........................................ 153 (a) ‘Marginalization’ of a community...................... 153 (b) Right of self-governance.................................. 154 (c) Right of sustainable development.................... 156 ix.
Article 326 and Section 6A...................................... 158 (a) Background and evolution of adult suffrage..... 159 (b) Aim of Article 326............................................. 162 (c) Right of exclusion and Article 326..................... 164
x.
Article 355 and Section 6A...................................... 168 (a) Intention behind Article 355.............................. 170 (b) Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India........... 172 (c) Section 6A vis-à-vis Article 355......................... 175
F.
xi.
Citizenship Act vis-à-vis the IEAA............................ 177
xii.
Interface with international law................................. 181
CONCLUSIONS AND DIRECTIONS.................................... 182
1002
1.
The present batch of matters involve the constitutional validity of Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, 1955 (Section 6A). This provision was incorporated in 1985 to establish a framework and to delineate criteria for granting Indian citizenship to migrants who entered Assam before 25.03.1971. Briefly put, the provision created categories for the conferment of citizenship to immigrants who entered Assam – (i) deemed citizenship to immigrants who entered prior to 01.01.1966; and (ii) the process of registration for immigrants who entered between the period of 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971. However, by omission, no protection was granted to those entering Assam after 25.03.1971, thereby rendering their presence in India illegal and liable for deportation under other existing legislation. Expressing their anxiety over the problems that have been posed by the influx of immigration from Bangladesh into Assam, which the Petitioners contend have been compounded and legitimized by Section 6A, the present action has been brought before this Court.
2.
Citizenship and its penumbral dimension are at the core of the present challenge. Thus, before analyzing the challenges regarding the constitutionality and the scheme of citizenship under the Constitution of India and the Citizenship Act, 1955, (Citizenship Act) we shall endeavour to explore the jurisprudential scheme and framework of citizenship globally as well as in India. A.
BACKGROUND
Meaning of citizenship 3.
Jurisprudentially, the term ‘citizenship’ is an abstract concept which has carried various interpretations that have evolved over time.1 In ancient Greek society, philosophers like Aristotle distinguished citizens from other members of society – such as residents, children, slaves, and the elderly. According to Aristotle, citizens were individuals who held judicial or legislative authority within a state.2 Hence, society was divided into citizens and mere subjects, where being a citizen was a matter of privilege. Called the ‘republican model’, this was also seconded by other philosophers such as Tacitus, Cicero, Machiavelli,
Citizenship, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/citizenship/.
Aristotle, Politics, Book III, Benjamin Jowett (trans.), Batoche Books, 1999, 53.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1003
Harrington and Rousseau.3 With the growth of the Roman empire, the notion of ‘citizen’ was broadened to encompass individuals in conquered territories. This eventually transformed the meaning of citizenship, where instead of granting access to political office, the term ‘citizen’ meant acquiring legal status of being part of a community and receiving protection under law. 4.
Over time, the term citizenship thus moved from the ‘republican model’ to a ‘liberal model’, which diluted the status of citizenship from a political privilege to a more egalitarian right based upon the similarity of legal status shared by a common populace.4 The meaning of citizenship in India
5.
In the domestic context, citizenship was ascertained by a 9-Judge Bench of this Court in State Trading Corpn. of India Ltd. v. CTO,5 as the ‘right to have rights’.6 It was held that citizenship is the pre-requisite that leads to gaining legal status and other socio-political rights in a country. However, although there is broad consensus on the fundamental concept of citizenship,7 the specific rights and privileges associated with citizenship vary from one jurisdiction to another. Additionally, countries differ in the mechanisms and criteria for acquiring citizenship. These variations reflect the unique historical, cultural, and legal contexts of each nation.
6.
In India, various rights are exclusively conferred upon citizens. These include the right to vote, the right to move freely, the right to form unions, the right to hold public office, the freedom of speech and expression, equality in public employment, etc. However, there are certain rights that are also made available to non-citizens, including the right to equality before the law, the prohibition of forced labour, etc. Additionally, the category of Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) represents a unique position within the spectrum of citizenship and
Citizenship, supra note 1; Rousseau, J.J., 1762, On the Social Contract with Geneva Manuscript and Political Economy, R. D. Masters (ed.), J. R. Masters (trans.), New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1978, Chapter 15.
Ulrich Preuss, The Ambiguous Meaning of Citizenship, University of Chicago Law School (2003).
1963 SCC OnLine SC 3, para 13.
Stephanie DeGooyer et al, The Right to Have Rights,Verso Books, 2018, 7; Romila Thapar et. al., On Citizenship, Aleph Book Company, 2021, 35.
Perez v. Bromwell [1958] 356 US 44, 46
1004
non-citizenship since they have more rights than non-citizens (such as a lifelong visa for visiting India) but have fewer rights in comparison to citizens (such as the absence of the right to vote). 7.
The bundle of rights accompanying ‘citizenship’ differs in other countries. For instance, in the United Kingdom, the British Nationality Act, 1981 creates six different classes of people: British Citizen, British Overseas Territories Citizen, British Overseas Citizen, British Subject, British National (Overseas), and British Protected Person. These classes are based on varying levels of association with the United Kingdom and its overseas territories, former colonies, and protectorates; and they carry different sets of rights. For instance, while British citizenship bestows the right to vote, it is also available to some Commonwealth citizens.8
8.
Similarly, Mexico establishes two distinct categories of “national” and “citizen”.9 A citizen is defined as a national who is 18 years of age and has an “honest way of life”.10 Once a national becomes a citizen, they get the right to vote, the right to assembly, the right to join the army, etc.11 Hence, while nationals and citizens can live in Mexico, only citizens get the extra right to vote. The situation is also similar in the United States of America (USA). Here, the residents of certain territories like American Samoa are only granted nationality and not citizenship of the USA. Like Mexico, such nationals can reside freely in the USA but cannot vote or hold certain elected offices.12 Further, while the residents of some other territories, like Puerto Rico, are granted citizenship, they still do not get the right to vote.13
9.
The trans-national comparison examined above aids us by providing three definite conclusions. First, globally, citizenship can be conceptualized as the right to be a member of a society. In that sense, citizenship is essential to one’s identity since it determines whether that person would be perceived as an alien or as ‘one of us’. This is particularly true given the historical context of the partition
Representation of the People Act, 1983 (c. 2), Acts of Parliament, 1983 (United Kingdom), Section 4; Immigration Act, Acts of Parliament, 1971 (UK), Section 2.
Constitution of Mexico of 1917, First Title, Chapter II & IV.
Id, Article 34.
Id, Article 35.
American Samoa, U.S. Department of the Interior, https://www.doi.gov/oia/islands/american-samoa.
Igartua De La Rosa v. United States [2000], 80 F.3d 29, (1st Cir. 2000).
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1005
and subsequent relations among the nations and people in our subcontinent. In addition to such identification by fellow members of society, citizenship is also a key determinant in enabling an individual to achieve their aims and objectives; since citizenship grants access to certain exclusive rights in society. Additionally, citizenship provides a sense of belongingness and esteem, apart from furthering the selfactualization needs of individuals. Collectively, citizenship provides an ‘identity’ to individuals, which has a significant impact on the quality of their lives and their individual psyche. 10. Second, beyond the conceptual understanding that citizenship grants an assemblage of certain rights in a community, the rights that may be conferred depend on the municipal policies of that country. While some countries like India reserve the right to vote exclusively for citizens, countries like the United Kingdom also extend it to Commonwealth citizens. Further, countries such as the USA do not bestow the right to vote even to some citizens. 11. Third, most nations have multiple classes of citizenship or nationality instead of a rigid dichotomy of citizens and non-citizens. In addition to this division, countries also have categories such as overseas citizens, nationals, subjects, etc. However, while the basket of rights differs inter-se such categories, citizenship is generally the highest basket a person can be classified under. Hence, though citizenship is one sub-set among many possible ways of being a member of a polity, it is the most significant one. Nonetheless, reality is often more nuanced, with numerous exceptions, caveats, entrenched inequalities and discriminatory legal regimes. 12. The conditions to acquire citizenship also vary across jurisdictions. Given that the Petitioners are challenging a specific mode of conferment of citizenship, it would be helpful to understand the manner in which citizenship is conferred both across the world and under our constitutional scheme. This will help us trace whether Section 6A is merely an aberration that does not fit into our domestic conceptualization of conferring citizenship or if it is another piece of a much more complicated puzzle. Modes of acquiring citizenship 13. Broadly, there are three approaches for granting citizenship: (i) jus soli, i.e., on the basis of birth within that particular country;
1006
(ii) jus sanguinis, i.e., citizenship by blood/descent; and (iii) through special recognition by law, such as citizenship by registration, naturalization, incorporation of a foreign territory, etc. Globally, countries have adopted different models for constructing their citizenship regimes. While most countries in North America follow a jus soli regime, a majority of European nations follow a jus sanguinis regime. In contrast, Australia and the African nations follow a mixed regime.14 14. There are varied academic perspectives deliberating as to the reasons why a country chooses one mode of conferring citizenship over another. As per one perspective, countries that wish to grant citizenship to immigrants who do not have familial links in the country choose the jus soli model.15 However, from another perspective, the choice of mode is often based on the significance of ethnicity for the citizen’s identity resulting in adoption of a jus sanguinis model. Hence, if a nation emphasizes ethnic continuity through descent and lineage, it tends to choose the jus sanguinis model over the jus soli model. However, where the cultural identity is tied to the territory of the nation, the jus soli model is preferred.16 Beyond these considerations, citizenship models can also be justified on the basis of inter-state relations (by which citizenship is granted based on historical links or treaties between nations),17 or on economic considerations (which are instantiated by countries that allow citizenship by investment).18 15. While providing an exhaustive account of all academic perspectives is neither feasible nor necessary for the current discussion, it is evident that various policy reasons inform the selection of one citizenship pattern over another. There is no single policy that universally dictates the framing of citizenship laws; rather, diverse considerations, including historical, cultural, economic, and political factors, influence the formulation of citizenship regimes.19 Even
Kangni Kpodar, Citizenship and Growth, journals/022/0056/001/article-A014-en.xml.
IMF
eLibrary,
https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/
Id.
James Brown Scott, Nationality: Jus Soli or Jus Sanguinis, American Journal of International Law, 1930, 24(1), 60.
This is particularly demonstrated by European states like the United Kingdom as discussed earlier, which, due to its historical ties extends citizenship to some individuals from Commonwealth countries.
Acquisition of citizenship - aġenzija komunità malta, https://komunita.gov.mt/en/services/acquisition-ofcitizenship/.
David Fitzgerald, Nationality and Migration in Modern Mexico, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2005, 31(1), 172.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1007
though a uniform citizenship policy across the world could eliminate statelessness and multiple citizenships, the varying basis of granting citizenship is unavoidable because each country has its own unique policy considerations and political milieu. Since there is no single universally suitable model, no mode of granting citizenship can be called an aberration or an anomaly. Citizenship is purely a creation of law, which, in turn, is an instrument of policy based on different prevailing circumstances of each country. While some nations insist on connections in terms of descent and territory, some even grant citizenship for purely economic reasons.20 16. Further, since the policy reasons underlying a citizenship regime are bound to remain in flux, constitutions around the globe are wary of setting citizenship norms in stone. For instance, a country’s demographic pattern might change, it might want to effect inter-state arrangements, it might be engaged in a war, there could be international treaties granting rights to certain classes of people, etc. Therefore, rather than imposing rigid norms on citizenship, it is desirable for constitutions to grant the government the flexibility to determine laws regarding membership in the country’s community. For this, either the constitutions such as the Australian Constitution, remain silent on the conditions of acquiring citizenship, or they prescribe the overarching norms for the time being and give the power to make and change specific conditions to the Parliament.21 Citizenship under the Constitution of India 17. In India, the approach of prescribing wide-ranging norms for citizenship was adopted at the commencement of the Constitution. Since the country was required to have norms for determining who could be a member of its community, the Constitution prescribed certain transitional conditions within Part II and made them subject to any laws that Parliament may make later.22 Prescribing such norms in the Constitution was all the more critical because the country had undergone two significant changes: first, there had been a complete
Citizenship by Investment Countries & Programs List in 2024, Global Residence Index, https:// globalresidenceindex.com/citizenship-by-investment/.
Constituição da República Federativa do Brasil, Article 22; Grundgesetz für die Bundesrepublik, Article 18; Constitution of Kenya, Article 18.
Constitution of India, Article 11.
1008
metamorphosis from a ruled territory to an independent nation; and second, there was the partition of the country, and some of its territories that were hitherto a part of it were declared a separate nation. After the creation of an independent India and the demarcation of its territory being complete, the next logical question of who an Indian was, emerged. Since the Parliament itself was nascent, the Constituent Assembly chose to incorporate transitionary norms of citizenship in the Constitution itself, instead of keeping the question of who an Indian was unsettled till later. 18. In this context, the Constitution came to incorporate the provisions now enshrined in Part II of the Constitution. Articles 5 to 10 prescribed the overarching norms of citizenship at the time of the commencement of the Constitution, while Article 11 granted Parliament the power to make any law regarding citizenship. 19. Hence, the scheme of citizenship provided under the Constitution comprises broadly of the following provisions: “5. Citizenship at the commencement of the Constitution — At the commencement of this Constitution, every person who has his domicile in the territory of India and— (a)
who was born in the territory of India; or
(b)
either of whose parents was born in the territory of India; or
(c)
who has been ordinarily resident in the territory of India for not less than five years immediately preceding such commencement, shall be a citizen of India.”
“6. Rights of citizenship of certain persons who have migrated to India from Pakistan — Notwithstanding anything in article 5, a person who has migrated to the territory of India from the territory now included in Pakistan shall be deemed to be a citizen of India at the commencement of this Constitution if— (a) he or either of his parents or any of his grand-parents was born in India as defined in the Government of India
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
Act, 1935 (as originally enacted); and (b)(i) in the case where such person has so migrated before the nineteenth day of July, 1948, he has been ordinarily resident in the territory of India since the date of his migration, or (ii) in the case where such person has so migrated on or after the nineteenth day of July, 1948, he has been registered as a citizen of India by an officer appointed in that behalf by the Government of the Dominion of India on an application made by him therefor to such officer before the commencement of this Constitution in the form and manner prescribed by that Government: Provided that no person shall be so registered unless he has been resident in the territory of India for at least six months immediately preceding the date of his application.” “7. Rights of citizenship of certain migrants to Pakistan — Notwithstanding anything in articles 5 and 6, a person who has after the first day of March, 1947, migrated from the territory of India to the territory now included in Pakistan shall not be deemed to be a citizen of India: Provided that nothing in this article shall apply to a person who, after having so migrated to the territory now included in Pakistan, has returned to the territory of India under a permit for resettlement or permanent return issued by or under the authority of any law and every such person shall for the purposes of clause (b) of article 6 be deemed to have migrated to the territory of India after the nineteenth day of July, 1948.” “8. Rights of citizenship of certain persons of Indian origin residing outside India — Notwithstanding anything in article 5, any person who or either of whose parents or any of whose grand-parents was born in India as defined in the Government of India Act, 1935 (as originally enacted), and who is ordinarily residing in any country outside India as so defined shall be deemed to be a citizen of India if he has been
1009
1010
registered as a citizen of India by the diplomatic or consular representative of India in the country where he is for the time being residing on an application made by him therefor to such diplomatic or consular representative, whether before or after the commencement of this Constitution, in the form and manner prescribed by the Government of the Dominion of India or the Government of India.” “9. Persons voluntarily acquiring citizenship of a foreign State not to be citizens — No person shall be a citizen of India by virtue of article 5, or be deemed to be a citizen of India by virtue of article 6 or article 8, if he has voluntarily acquired the citizenship of any foreign State.” “10. Continuance of the rights of citizenship — Every person who is or is deemed to be a citizen of India under any of the foregoing provisions of this Part shall, subject to the provisions of any law that may be made by Parliament, continue to be such citizen.” “11. Parliament to regulate the right of citizenship by law — Nothing in the foregoing provisions of this Part shall derogate from the power of Parliament to make any provision with respect to the acquisition and termination of citizenship and all other matters relating to citizenship.” Legislative scheme on citizenship 20. Exercising the power granted by Article 11 of the Constitution, the Parliament enacted the Citizenship Act, which expanded on the conditions prescribed by the aforementioned provisions of the Constitution. The key provisions that provided the conditions for citizenship under the Act are set out below: “3. Citizenship by birth ― (1) Except as provided in sub-section (2), every person born in India―
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
(a) on or after the 26th day of January, 1950, but before the 1st day of July, 1987; (b) on or after the 1st day of July, 1987, but before the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2003 (6 of 2004) and either of whose parents is a citizen of India at the time of his birth; (c) on or after the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2003 (6 of 2004), where― (i) both of his parents are citizens of India; or (ii) one of whose parents is a citizen of India and the other is not an illegal migrant at the time of his birth, shall be a citizen of India by birth. (2) A person shall not be a citizen of India by virtue of this section if at the time of his birth― (a) either his father or mother possesses such immunity from suits and legal process as is accorded to an envoy of a foreign sovereign power accredited to the President of India and he or she, as the case may be, is not a citizen of India; or (b) his father or mother is an enemy alien and the birth occurs in a place then under occupation by the enemy.” “4. Citizenship by descent ― (1) A person born outside India shall be a citizen of India by descent, ― (a) on or after the 26th day of January, 1950, but before the 10th day of December, 1992, if his father is a citizen of India at the time of his birth; or (b) on or after the 10th day of December, 1992, if either of his parents is a citizen of India at the time of his birth: Provided that if the father of a person referred to in clause (a) was a citizen of India by descent only, that person shall not be a citizen of India by virtue of this section unless― (a) his birth is registered at an Indian consulate within one
1011
1012
year of its occurrence or the commencement of this Act, whichever is later, or, with the permission of the Central Government, after the expiry of the said period; or (b) his father is, at the time of his birth, in service under a Government in India: Provided further that if either of the parents of a person referred to in clause (b) was a citizen of India by descent only, that person shall not be a citizen of India by virtue of this section, unless― (a) his birth is registered at an Indian consulate within one year of its occurrence or on or after the 10th day of December, 1992, whichever is later, or, with the permission of the Central Government, after the expiry of the said period; or (b) either of his parents is, at the time of his birth, in service under a Government in India: Provided also that on or after the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2003 (6 of 2004), a person shall not be a citizen of India by virtue of this section, unless his birth is registered at an Indian consulate in such form and in such manner, as may be prescribed, ― (i) within one year of its occurrence or the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2003(6 of 2004), whichever is later; or (ii) with the permission of the Central Government, after the expiry of the said period: Provided also that no such birth shall be registered unless the parents of such person declare, in such form and in such manner as may be prescribed, that the minor does not hold the passport of another country. (1A) A minor who is a citizen of India by virtue of this section and is also a citizen of any other country shall cease to be a citizen of India if he does not renounce the citizenship or nationality of another country within six months of attaining full age.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
(2) If the Central Government so directs, a birth shall be deemed for the purposes of this section to have been registered with its permission, notwithstanding that its permission was not obtained before the registration. (3) For the purposes of the proviso to sub-section (1), any person born outside undivided India who was, or was deemed to be, a citizen of India at the commencement of the Constitution shall be deemed to be a citizen of India by descent only.” “5. Citizenship by registration ― (1) Subject to the provisions of this section and such other conditions and restrictions as may be prescribed, the Central Government may, on an application made in this behalf, register as a citizen of India any person not being an illegal migrant who is not already such citizen by virtue of the Constitution or of any other provision of this Act if he belongs to any of the following categories, namely: ― (a) a person of Indian origin who is ordinarily resident in India for seven years before making an application for registration; (b) a person of Indian origin who is ordinarily resident in any country or place outside undivided India; (c) a person who is married to a citizen of India and is ordinarily resident in India for seven years before making an application for registration; (d) minor children of persons who are citizens of India; (e) a person of full age and capacity whose parents are registered as citizens of India under clause (a) of this sub-section or sub-section (1) of section 6; (f) a person of full age and capacity who, or either of his parents, was earlier citizen of independent India, and is ordinarily resident in India for twelve months immediately before making an application for registration; (g) a person of full age and capacity who has been registered as an Overseas Citizen of India Cardholder for
1013
1014
five years, and who is ordinarily resident in India for twelve months before making an application for registration. Explanation 1.―For the purposes of clauses (a) and (c), an applicant shall be deemed to be ordinarily resident in India if― (i) he has resided in India throughout the period of twelve months immediately before making an application for registration; and (ii) he has resided in India during the eight years immediately preceding the said period of twelve months for a period of not less than six years. Explanation 2.―For the purposes of this sub-section, a person shall be deemed to be of Indian origin if he, or either of his parents, was born in undivided India or in such other territory which became part of India after the 15th day of August, 1947. (1A) The Central Government, if it is satisfied that special circumstances exist, may after recording the circumstances in writing, relax the period of twelve months, specified in clauses (f) and (g) and clause (i) of Explanation 1 of sub-section (1), up to a maximum of thirty days which may be in different breaks. (2) No person being of full age shall be registered as a citizen of India under sub-section (1) until he has taken the oath of allegiance in the form specified in the Second Schedule. (3) No person who has renounced, or has been deprived of, his Indian citizenship or whose Indian citizenship has terminated, under this Act shall be registered as a citizen of India under sub-section (1) except by order of the Central Government. (4) The Central Government may, if satisfied that there are special circumstances justifying such registration, cause any minor to be registered as a citizen of India. (5) A person registered under this section shall be a citizen of India by registration as from the date on which he is so registered; and a person registered under the provisions
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1015
of clause (b)(ii) of article 6 or article 8 of the Constitution shall be deemed to be a citizen of India by registration as from the commencement of the Constitution or the date on which he was so registered, whichever may be later. (6) If the Central Government is satisfied that circumstances exist which render it necessary to grant exemption from the residential requirement under clause (c) of sub-section (1) to any person or a class of persons, it may, for reasons to be recorded in writing, grant such exemption.” “6. Citizenship by naturalization ― (1) Where an application is made in the prescribed manner by any person of full age and capacity 3[not being an illegal migrant] for the grant of a certificate of naturalisation to him, the Central Government may, if satisfied that the applicant is qualified for naturalisation under the provisions of the Third Schedule, grant to him a certificate of naturalisation: Provided that, if in the opinion of the Central Government, the applicant is a person who has rendered distinguished service to the cause of science, philosophy, art, literature, world peace or human progress generally, it may waive all or any of the conditions specified in the Third Schedule. (2) The person to whom a certificate of naturalisation is granted under sub-section (1) shall, on taking the oath of allegiance in the form specified in the Second Schedule, be a citizen of India by naturalisation as from the date on which that certificate is granted.” “7. Citizenship by incorporation of territory ―If any territory becomes a part of India, the Central Government may, by order notified in the Official Gazette, specify the persons who shall be citizens of India by reason of their connection with that territory; and those persons shall be citizens of India as from the date to be specified in the order.” 21. To understand the interplay of the norms prescribed by Part II of the Constitution and the provisions of the Citizenship Act, a brief overview of the different conditions is set out in the table below:
1016
Condition on birth
Condition on residence
Condition on descent
Condition of registration
Other conditions
Ref.
Citizenship by Birth (Jus Soli) Born before Had domicile 26.01.1950. in India at the commencement of Born in the Constitution. India. Born on/ after 26.01.1950 but before 01.07.1987.
-
-
Is not barred by Article 7.23
Article 5(a)
-
Parents must not be covered by Section 3(2).24
-
-
Section 3(1)(a)
-
Either parent is a citizen of India at the time of birth.
-
-
Section 3(1)(b)
Born in India. Born on/ after 01.07.1987 but before 03.12.2004.25 Born in India.
Born on/ after 03.12.2004. Born in India.
Parents must not be covered by Section 3(2). Both parents are citizens of India, or one parent was a citizen of India, and the other was not an illegal immigrant at the time of birth.
Section 3(1)(c)
Article 7 bars citizenship if a person has re-migrated to India from Pakistan without permit for resettlement or permanent return.
Section 3(2) applies if either parent possesses immunity like foreign envoy and is not a citizen of India/ Either parent is an enemy alien and person was born at enemy territory.
The condition is before commencement of Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2003, which came into force on 03.12.2004, https://egazette.gov.in/WriteReadData/2004/E_1031_2011_005.pdf.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1017
-
Parents must not be covered by Section 3(2).
-
-
Citizenship by descent (Jus Sanguinis) Born before Had domicile Either parent 26.01.1950. in India at the was born in commencement of India. Born the Constitution. outside India. Born on/ after 26.01.1950 but before 10.12.1992.
Born outside India.
Article 5(b)
Father was a citizen of India at the time of birth.
Registration with the Indian consulate is required if the father is a citizen of India by descent only and was not in service of the government of India.
-
Section 4(a)
-
Either parent Registration was a citizen with the Indian of India at consulate is the time of required if birth. either parent is a citizen of India by descent only and was not in service of the government of India.
-
Section 4(b)
-
Either parent Compulsory was a citizen registration is of India at required with the time of the Indian birth. consulate.
The parents shall declare that the minor does not possess a passport of another country.
Section 4(b)
Born outside India.
Born on/ after 03.12.2004.
Is not barred by Article 7.
-
Born outside India.
Born on/ after 10.12.1992 but before 03.12.2004.
-
1018
Citizenship by registration
-
-
Is ordinarily residing outside India (India as defined in Govt. of India Act, 1935, hereinafter “Undivided India”)
Person/ Either parent/Any grandparent was born in Undivided India.
-
Ordinary resident26 Person/ Must be in India for seven Either parent compulsorily years before was born in registered. making the Undivided application for India or registration. territories that became part of India after independence. -
Compulsory registration with diplomatic/ consular representative of India.
Must be compulsorily registered.
-
Article 8 and Section 5(5)
Person who is not a minor must take the oath of allegiance.
Section 5(1)(a) and Section 5(2)
Person must not be an illegal immigrant Spouse must be a citizen of India. Person who is not a minor must take the oath of allegiance.
Section 5(1)(c) and Section 5(2)
Person must not be an illegal immigrant Ordinary residents Person/ outside Undivided Either parent India or was born in Undivided India or
Must be compulsorily registered.
Person who is not a minor must take the oath of allegiance.
Section 5(1)(b) and Section 5(2)
Here specifically, ordinary resident means a person who: (i) has resided in India throughout the period of twelve months immediately before making an application for registration; and (ii) has resided in India during the eight years immediately preceding the said period of twelve months for a period of not less than six years.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1019
-
-
territories that became part of India after independence. -
territories that became part of India after independence. Parents are citizens of India.
Person must not be an illegal immigrant. Must be compulsorily registered.
Person must be a minor child.
Section 5(1)(d)
Person must not be an illegal immigrant -
-
Parents are Must be registered compulsorily under S. registered. 5(1)(a) or naturalised under S. 6 as citizens of India.
Person must be of full age and capacity27 Person must take the oath of allegiance
Section 5(1)(e) and Section 5(2)
Person must not be an illegal immigrant Ordinary resident in India for 12 months before making an application for registration.
Person/ Must be either of compulsorily the parents registered. was earlier a citizen of independent India.
Person must be of full age and capacity. Person must take the oath of allegiance.
Section 5(1)(f) and Section 5(2)
Person must not be an illegal immigrant
As per Section 2(4): “a person shall be deemed to be of full age if he is not a minor and of full capacity if he is not of unsound mind.”
1020
-
-
-
Must be compulsorily registered.
Person must be registered as an Overseas Citizen of India Cardholder for five years.
Section 5(1)(g) and Section 5(2)
Person must be of full age and capacity Person must take the oath of allegiance Person must not be an illegal immigrant Citizenship by naturalization -
Had domicile in the territory of India at the commencement of the Constitution.
-
-
Is not barred by Article 7.
Article 5(c)
-
Must apply to the govt. for getting the certificate of naturalisation
Is of full age and capacity
Section 6(1) and Third Schedule
Was ordinarily residing in India for at least five years before the commencement of the Constitution. Was residing in India/was in service of the government of India/both for twelve months before making the application.
Is not an illegal immigrant Takes oath of allegiance
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1021
-
During the 14 years preceding the 12 months mentioned above, the person has resided in India/ has been in the service of the government for an aggregate of 11 years.
Is of a good character and adequately knows languages specified in the Eighth Schedule Is not a subject/ citizen of a country where Indian citizens are barred from becoming subjects/ citizens Person undertakes to renounce previous citizenship if Indian citizenship is granted.
After getting citizenship, intends to reside in India/ work with the government of India or an international organization of which India is a member or a society/company/ body of persons established in India.
Citizenship by incorporation of territory -
-
-
-
The person Section 7 must be connected to the territory that is incorporated in India and is extended Indian citizenship by the Government of India. The person must fulfil the conditions prescribed by the governmental order granting citizenship.
1022
22. Apart from these general norms, the Constitution also prescribed citizenship norms for immigrants to and from Pakistan. For this, Article 6 provided citizenship to people who migrated from Pakistan if: (i) such person/either of their parents/ grand-parents were born in undivided India; (ii) if such person was an ordinary resident since the date of their migration; and (iii) such person was registered as a citizen of India if such migration was after 19.07.1948. As a corollary, Article 7 prohibited citizenship to people who migrated from India to Pakistan after 01.03.1947 and then sought citizenship after re-migrating to India, unless they came back under a permit for resettlement or permanent return. Similar to these provisions is Section 6A, which provides a framework addressing the conferment of citizenship to migrants entering the State of Assam based on their date of entry.28 23. Section 6A, which is presently under challenge, was inserted into the Citizenship Act, via Act 65 of 1985 and came into force with effect from 07.12.1985. This provision created special conditions for the citizenship of migrants who entered into Assam in accordance with certain cut-off dates. As per the provision, first, those who entered Assam from Bangladesh prior to 01.01.1966 were deemed to be Indian citizens, and second, those who entered into Assam between the period of 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971 were conferred citizenship based on the fulfilment of specific procedures and conditions. Those who entered Assam after 25.03.1971 have been denied citizenship by implication. 24. To analyze this provision comprehensively, it is imperative to go through Section 6A and the language it employs. Section 6A, as it was added in 1985 to the Citizenship Act reads as follows: “6A. Special provisions as to citizenship of persons covered by the Assam Accord – (1) For the purposes of this section
We are also apprised of the fact that Parliament has promulgated the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019, and more recently on 11.03.2024 the Government of India has notified the Citizenship (Amendment) Rules, 2024. However, we are not dealing with these provisions given that neither of the parties relied upon these provisions over the course of the proceedings before us. Additionally, some of these provisions had not yet been notified as of the date of reserving these judgments. In any case, these provisions are not germane to the controversy at hand, and a challenge to these amendments is already sub-judice before another bench of this Court.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
(a) “Assam” means the territories included in the State of Assam immediately before the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985; (b) “detected to be a foreigner” means detected to be a foreigner in accordance with the provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 (31 of 1946) and the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 by a Tribunal constituted under the said Order; (c) “specified territory” means the territories included in Bangladesh immediately before the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985; (d) a person shall be deemed to be Indian origin, if he, or either of his parents or any of his grandparents was born in undivided India; (e) a person shall be deemed to have been detected to be a foreigner on the date on which a Tribunal constituted under the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 submits its opinion to the effect that he is a foreigner to the officer or authority concerned. (2) Subject to the provisions of sub-sections (6) and (7), all persons of Indian origin who came before the 1st day of January, 1966 to Assam from the specified territory (including such of those whose names were included in the electoral rolls used for the purposes of the General Election to the House of the People held in 1967) and who have been ordinarily resident in Assam since the dates of their entry into Assam shall be deemed to be citizens of India as from the 1st day of January, 1966. (3) Subject to the provisions of sub-sections (6) and (7), every person of Indian origin who― (a) came to Assam on or after the 1st day of January, 1966 but before the 25th day of March, 1971 from the specified territory; and (b) has, since the date of his entry into Assam, been ordinarily resident in Assam; and
1023
1024
(c) has been detected to be a foreigner; shall register himself in accordance with the rules made by the Central Government in this behalf under section 18 with such authority (hereafter in this sub-section referred to as the registering authority) as may be specified in such rules and if his name is included in any electoral roll for any Assembly or Parliamentary constituency in force on the date of such detection, his name shall be deleted therefrom. Explanation ― In the case of every person seeking registration under this sub-section, the opinion of the Tribunal constituted under the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 holding such person to be a foreigner, shall be deemed to be sufficient proof of the requirement under clause (c) of this sub-section and if any question arises as to whether such person complies with any other requirement under this sub-section, the registering authority shall, ― (i) if such opinion contains a finding with respect to such other requirement, decide the question in conformity with such finding; (ii) if such opinion does not contain a finding with respect to such other requirement, refer the question to a Tribunal constituted under the said Order hang jurisdiction in accordance with such rules as the Central Government may make in this behalf under section 18 and decide the question in conformity with the opinion received on such reference. (4) A person registered under sub-section (3) shall have, as from the date on which he has been detected to be a foreigner and till the expiry of a period of ten years from that date, the same rights and obligations as a citizen of India (including the right to obtain a passport under the Passports Act, 1967 and the obligations connected therewith), but shall not entitled to have his name included in any electoral roll for any Assembly or Parliamentary constituency at any time before the expiry of the said period of ten years.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
(5) A person registered under sub-section (3) shall be deemed to be a citizen of India for all purposes as from the date of expiry of a period of ten years from the date on which he has been detected to be a foreigner. (6) Without prejudice to the provisions of section 8― (a) if any person referred to in sub-section (2) submits in the prescribed manner and form and to the prescribed authority within sixty days from the date of commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985, a declaration that he does not wish to be a citizen of India, such person shall not be deemed to have become a citizen of India under that sub-section; (b) if any person referred to in sub-section (3) submits in the prescribed manner and form and to the prescribed authority within sixty days from the date of commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985, or from the date on which he has been detected to be a foreigner, whichever is later, a declaration that he does not wish to be governed by the provisions of that sub-section and sub-sections (4) and (5), it shall not be necessary for such person to register himself under sub-section (3). Explanation. ― Where a person required to file a declaration under this sub-section does not have the capacity to enter into a contract, such declaration may be filed on his behalf by any person competent under the law for the time being in force to act on his behalf. (7) Nothing in sub-sections (2) to (6) shall apply in relation to any person― (a) who, immediately before the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985, is a citizen of India; (b) who was expelled from India before the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985, under the Foreigners Act, 1946. (8) Save as otherwise expressly provided in this section, the provisions of this section shall have effect notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force.”
1025
1026
25. A preliminary perusal of this provision and its associated rules contained in the Citizenship Rules, 2009, indicate various timelines and effects, resulting in the conferment of differing degrees of rights and obligations to immigrants entering into the State of Assam. These aspects are delineated below in a tabular format for greater ease of understanding. This tabular presentation aims to provide a structured overview of the different elements pertaining to immigrant entry into Assam, thereby aiding comprehension of the nuances involved. Right granted
Conditions
Procedure established
Immigrants before 01.01.1966 Condition of birth or descent
Sub-section (2) grants deemed citizenship. Such immigrants are considered citizens from 01.01.1966
As per sub-section (2), the deemed citizens are those persons who came to Assam before 01.01.1966, along with those who were included in the electoral rolls in 1967 and had to have been persons of ‘Indian origin.’
Since sub-section (2) grants The term ‘persons of deemed citizenship, it does Indian origin’ has been not provide for a procedure d e f i n e d u n d e r s u b - for registration. section (1) (d) to mean that (i) the individual himself; or (ii) either of his parents; or (iii) any of his grandparents were born in undivided India.
Condition of residence
Sub-section (2) requires these individuals to have been ordinarily resident in the State of Assam.
Immigrants between 01.01.1966 to 25.03.1971 Right granted
C o n d i t i o n o f b i r t h o r Procedure for citizenship descent by registration
Sub-section (3) grants citizenship by registration (the process is summarized in the last column)
In similar parlance with Step 1: Declaration as a sub-section (2), persons foreigner must be of ‘Indian origin’.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1027
For the first ten years Condition of residence after registration, Sub-section (3) also persons will have stipulates that the persons the same rights and who entered into Assam obligations as citizens between 01.01.1966 and of India except for 25.03.1971 must have inclusion in any been ordinarily resident electoral rolls (This in Assam. also includes the right to obtain a passport). Condition of detection Upon the expiry of these 10 years from the date of detection, these individuals will be deemed to be Indian citizens.
These individuals should be detected as foreigners under sub-section (3).
The very first step under sub-section (3) is that the individual in question should have been detected to be a foreigner. The opinion of a Tribunal constituted under the Foreigners (Tribunals) O r d e r, 1 9 6 4 , w o u l d be sufficient proof to establish detection as a foreigner.
Step 2: Registration The term ‘detected to T h e r e a f t e r, p e r s o n s be a foreigner ’ has can register themselves been defined to be through Form XVIII read in accordance with in Schedule I to the the provisions of the Citizenship Rules, 2009, Foreigners Act, 1946 with the registering and the Foreigners authority of the (Tribunals) Order, 1964 concerned district within t h r o u g h a Tr i b u n a l 30 days from the date of constituted under the detection or 30 days from said Order. the appointment of such registering authority. Condition of registration
Citizenship Act, 1955, Section 6A(4).
Rule 19, Citizenship Rules, 2009.
After being detected to be a foreigner, such persons should also register themselves (procedure summarized in the next column)
The registering authority may also, for reasons recorded in writing, extend the period of 30 days up to 60 days.30 Additionally, a person who has been declared as a foreigner by the Foreigners Tribunal prior to 16.07.2013 and who has not yet registered due to non-receipt of the order of the Foreigners Tribunal
1028
or on account of refusal by the registering authority may within thirty days from the date of receipt of such order or, from the date of publication of the notification dated 16.07.2013, make an application for registration vide Form XVIII to the registering authority of the concerned district.31 Immigrants on or after 25.03.1971 Section 6A does not prescribe the start date for the conferment of citizenship to these individuals beyond the date of 25.03.1971.
Section 6A does not prescribe any conditions in this regard. By implication, the provision declares the entry of an immigrant after 25.03.1971 as illegal.
Concomitantly, Section 6A does not prescribe any procedure as it intends to deny citizenship to those immigrants who entered after 25.03.1971.
(i)
Sub-section (6) allows immigrants to opt-out of being conferred Indian citizenship. Under sub-section (6)(a), deemed citizens are granted the option of declaring that they do not wish to be a citizen of India. If they choose to declare so, they will thereafter not be deemed to be Indian citizens under sub-section (6)(a). Further, under sub-section 6(b), individuals detected as foreigners can choose not to register themselves in accordance with the procedure laid down in sub-section (3). Consequently, these individuals will not be conferred citizenship. The persons who choose to renunciate their citizenship under sub-section (6) must declare the same vide Form XXI to the concerned District Magistrate of the area where such a person is ordinarily resident.32 This Form XXI is provided in Schedule I of the Citizenship Rules, 2009.
(ii)
Sub-section (7) provides that Section 6A would not apply to persons who were Indian citizens prior to the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985 or, on the contrary, to persons who were expelled from India prior to the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1985 under the Foreigners Act, 1946.
Rule 2A, Citizenship (Amendment) Rules, 2013.
Rule 22, Citizenship Rules, 2009.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1029
(iii) Lastly, sub-section (8) is the non-obstante clause in this provision, which states that this section would have effect irrespective of anything contained in any other law for the time being in force. 27. Having understood the interplay between the modes of citizenship, as conferred by the Indian Constitution, the Citizenship Act and the provision of Section 6A itself, we will now examine the genesis of this controversy, the contentions put forth by the parties and the key issues that demand scrutiny. B.
TERMS OF REFERENCE
28. The first writ petition before this court in the present matter was filed in 2009 by Assam Public Works, an NGO, seeking the deletion of illegal migrants from electoral rolls in Assam and the updation of the National Register of Citizens (NRC), 1951. Thereafter, in 2012, the Assam Sanmilita Mahasangha and other organisations challenged the constitutionality of Section 6A on the grounds that it was discriminatory, arbitrary, and illegal. Following this, a 2-judge bench of this court started monitoring the NRC updation process. This Court, vide judgement dated 17.12.2014 in Assam Sanmilita Mahasangha v. Union of India,33 framed 13 questions regarding the constitutionality of Section 6A as arising from the abovementioned writ petitions and referred them for adjudication by a Constitution Bench. For reference, the questions as they were framed are put forth hereinbelow:
"i.
Whether Articles 10 and 11 of the Constitution of India permit the enactment of Section 6A of the Citizenship Act in as much as Section 6A, in prescribing a cut-off date different from the cut-off date prescribed in Article 6, can do so without a “variation” of Article 6 itself; regard, in particular, being had to the phraseology of Article 4(2) read with Article 368(1)?
ii.
Whether Section 6A violates Articles 325 and 326 of the Constitution of India in that it has diluted the political rights of the citizens of the State of Assam;
Assam Sanmilita Mahasangha v. Union of India (2015) 3 SCC 1, para 33.
1030
iii.
What is the scope of the fundamental right contained in Article 29(1)? Is the fundamental right absolute in its terms? In particular, what is the meaning of the expression "culture" and the expression "conserve"? Whether Section 6A violates Article 29(1)?
iv.
Whether Section 6A violates Article 355? What is the true interpretation of Article 355 of the Constitution? Would an influx of illegal migrants into a State of India constitute “external aggression” and/or “internal disturbance”? Does the expression “State” occurring in this Article refer only to a territorial region or does it also include the people living in the State, which would include their culture and identity?
v.
Whether Section 6A violates Article 14 in that, it singles out Assam from other border States (which comprise a distinct class) and discriminates against it. Also, whether there is no rational basis for having a separate cut-off date for regularizing illegal migrants who enter Assam as opposed to the rest of the country; and
vi.
Whether Section 6A violates Article 21 in that the lives and personal liberty of the citizens of Assam have been affected adversely by the massive influx of illegal migrants from Bangladesh.
vii.
Whether delay is a factor that can be taken into account in moulding relief under a petition filed under Article 32 of the Constitution?
viii. Whether, after a large number of migrants from East Pakistan have enjoyed rights as Citizens of India for over 40 years, any relief can be given in the petitions filed in the present cases? ix.
Whether Section 6A violates the basic premise of the Constitution and the Citizenship Act in that it permits Citizens who have allegedly not lost their Citizenship of East Pakistan to become deemed Citizens of India, thereby conferring dual Citizenship to such persons?
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1031
x.
Whether Section 6A violates the fundamental basis of Section 5(1) proviso and Section 5(2) of the Citizenship Act (as it stood in 1985) in that it permits a class of migrants to become deemed Citizens of India without any reciprocity from Bangladesh and without taking the oath of allegiance to the Indian Constitution?
xi.
Whether the Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Act, 1950 being a special enactment qua immigrants into Assam, alone can apply to migrants from East Pakistan/Bangladesh to the exclusion of the general Foreigners Act and the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 made thereunder?
xii.
Whether Section 6A violates the Rule of Law in that it gives way to political expediency and not to Government according to law?
xiii. Whether Section 6A violates fundamental rights in that no mechanism is provided to determine which persons are ordinarily resident in Assam since the dates of their entry into Assam, thus granting deemed citizenship to such persons arbitrarily?” 29. An application was then moved seeking this Court’s directions regarding the children who had been excluded from the final NRC list despite their parents having been included. Vide order dated 06.01.2020, this Court noted the then Attorney General’s assurance that such children would not be separated from their parents and would not be sent to detention centers in Assam.34 In this context, it is also relevant to note that the final draft of the NRC list was published on 30.07.2018, whereby over 40 lakh persons out of 3.29 crore applicants stood excluded. The final NRC list was published on 13.08.2019, whereby over 19 lakh persons out of 3.29 crore applicants stood excluded. 30. This Court, vide order dated 10.01.2023, viewed that the one main issue that arises for consideration is - “Whether Section 6A of
Re: Section 6A of the Citizenship Act 1955, W.P (C) No. 274/2009.
1032
the Citizenship Act, 1955 suffers from any constitutional infirmity.” Subsequently, vide order dated 20.09.2023, the present matter was titled ‘In Re: Section 6A of the Citizenship Act 1955’. 31. We now turn to the submissions made by the parties in support of their respective stance on the matter. C.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioners’ submissions 32. Mr. Shyam Divan, Mr. Vijay Hansaria and Mr. K.N. Choudhury, Learned Senior Advocates, appeared for the Petitioners. Their contentions are detailed hereinbelow: i.
The Petitioners argued that the operation of Section 6A violates the preambular values enshrined in the Constitution. They urged that the Constitution upholds national fraternity, not global fraternity and that the presence of Bangladeshi immigrants in Assam poses a threat to the unity and integrity of the country.
ii.
They contended that Section 6A, which grants citizenship to immigrants, contradicts Articles 6 and 7 of the Constitution, which prescribe a different regime for granting citizenship to people who migrated to Pakistan or who migrated to India from Pakistan. Instead, they argued that the Parliament ought to have passed a constitutional amendment in this regard. The Petitioners also claimed that while Article 11 and Entry 17 of List I grant the Parliament the authority to alter these constitutional provisions, it does not include the power to override other provisions of Part II.
iii.
The Petitioners further contended that Section 6A violates Article 9 of the Constitution and Section 9 of the Citizenship Act, as it allows dual nationality by not requiring immigrants to renounce their previous citizenship.
iv.
They contended that Section 6A contradicts Section 5(2) of the Citizenship Act, which mandates every citizen to take the oath of allegiance.
v.
The Petitioners argued that Section 6A violates Article 14, treating equals unequally by applying the provision only to Assam without any intelligible differentia. They asserted that
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1033
this geographical basis lacks justification. The Petitioners further urged that Section 6A goes against the principles of democracy, federalism, and the rule of law, being susceptible to being struck down on grounds of ‘manifest arbitrariness.’ They also highlighted the lack of rationale in the cut-off dates and the absence of a mechanism to determine ‘ordinary residence.’ vi.
The Petitioners claimed that Section 6A infringes on Article 21 by impinging upon the rights of the indigenous Assamese community and violating their right to self-governance under Article 1 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). They contended that the inclusion of an unidentified migrant population burdens the country’s natural resources, which goes against sustainable development mandated under Article 21.
vii.
The Petitioners further urged that the demographic shift due to the influx of migrants from East Pakistan threatens Assamese culture and breaches Article 29(1).
viii. They asserted that Section 6A violates the voting rights of the Assamese people under Article 326 and has led to the marginalisation of their political rights. ix.
The Petitioners contended the violation of Article 355 on the ground that the continued presence of millions of Bangladeshi immigrants has precipitated violent ethnic clashes amounting to ‘external aggression’ and resulting in ‘internal disturbance’. They argued that, consequently, it becomes the duty of the Union to undertake necessary measures to protect the state of Assam.
x.
The Petitioners also argued that the Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Act, 1950 applies exclusively to the immigrants in Assam.
xi.
The Petitioners finally asserted that the writ petitions remain maintainable and should not be dismissed on the basis of delay. They contended that Section 6A can still be invoked and, therefore, constitutes a continuous wrong, providing a fresh cause of action. They argued against the application of the doctrine of laches, emphasizing that substantial questions of law are at the core of this case.
1034
Respondents’ submissions 33. Mr. R. Venkataramani, learned Attorney General, Mr. Tushar Mehta, Learned Solicitor General, Mr. Kapil Sibal, Ms. Indira Jaising, Mr. Sanjay Hegde, Ms. Malvika Trivedi, Mr. P.V. Surendranath Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Shadan Farasat, Dr. Vivek Sharma, Mr. Mehmood Pracha and Mr. Syed Shahi Rizvi appeared for the Respondents. Their contentions have also been summarized hereinbelow: i.
At the very outset, it is the Respondents’ assertion that this Court should refrain from delving any further into the matter on account of the issues raised in the context of foreign policy. They contend that foreign policy is traditionally excluded from the purview of judicial review.
ii.
The Respondents countered the Petitioners’ claims, emphasizing that Section 6A, introduced in 1985, has faced challenge after a considerable delay of 27 years, invoking the doctrine of laches to argue against the removal of rights established during this period. They further urged that even if the damage may be construed to be continuing, it does not give a fresh cause of action to file the petition after an inordinate delay.
iii.
Regarding the term fraternity, the Respondents argued that it encompasses equal regard among individuals, preventing societal division into distinct groups. The Respondents further asserted that Section 6A reinforces the idea of fraternity, in the absence of which society would be broken into a division between ‘others’ and ‘us’.
iv.
Addressing concerns about Articles 6 and 7, the Respondents argued that the cut-off dates align with the permit system and are not violative of the Constitution. They asserted that Article 11, in conjunction with Entry 17 of List I of the Seventh Schedule, grants Parliament the power to legislate on citizenship, superseding other provisions in Part II of the Constitution.
v.
The Respondents contended that Section 5(2)’s provision for the oath of allegiance is immaterial to Section 6A and is inconsequential.
vi.
Article 14, according to the Respondents, can only be invoked by those seeking benefits for similarly situated individuals,
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1035
which the Petitioners do not claim. The Respondents argued that a statute cannot be struck down as violative of Article 14 merely because it does not include all relevant classes, as the Parliament can decide the degrees of harm it wants to legislate. They further asserted that there is an underlying rationale for the cut-off dates and that the objective behind Section 6A and the Assam Accord reflects the constitutional tradition of accommodating differences through asymmetric federal arrangements. vii.
The Respondents maintained that Article 21 protects the Assamese community and the rights of foreigners affected by Section 6A. They argued that the provision is not violative of Article 21 as it is a lawfully established procedure.
viii. Dismissing claims of cultural change, the Respondents argued that demographic shifts attributed to Section 6A are unrelated, emphasizing Article 29(1)’s endeavour to promote multiculturalism rather than cultural exclusivity. They also strived to underscore that accepting the Petitioner’s arguments would lead to cultural exclusivity, which is not constitutionally permissible.
ix.
Regarding the right to vote, the Respondents countered the Petitioners, stating that Section 6A confers citizenship upon the immigrants. Therefore, citizenship rights, including voting, would naturally flow.
x.
They further distinguished the decision of Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India,35 asserting that its ratio was based on classification under Article 14, and not Article 355. They contended that fulfilling the duty under Article 355 justified enacting Section 6A to address ‘internal disturbance’.
xi.
The Respondents lastly argued for harmonizing domestic law with international norms, asserting that the prohibition of statelessness is a recognized international norm and rendering Section 6A unconstitutional would risk statelessness for the immigrants, justifying the provision’s validity.
Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India (2005) 5 SCC 665
1036
D.
ISSUES
34. Although the reference to this Court is simple, being one of the factors in determining the constitutional validity of Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, this issue can be broken down into several constituent questions for this Court’s determination. I.
Prefatory issues
a.
Does the power of judicial review extend to analysing the constitutionality of Section 6A?
b.
Whether the present petitions are barred by delay and laches?
II.
Challenges regarding constitutionality
c.
Does Section 6A offend preambular values like fraternity?
d.
Is Section 6A ultra vires Part II of the Constitution?
e.
Does Section 6A create an unreasonable classification which violates Article 14?
f.
Does Section 6A suffer from manifest arbitrariness?
g.
Does Section 6A violate the rights provided to ‘indigenous’ communities under Article 29?
h.
Is Section 6A ultra vires Article 21 of the Constitution?
i.
Does Section 6A violate the political rights of Indian citizens in Assam under Article 326?
j.
Does the operation of Section 6A cause ‘external aggression’ and ‘internal disturbance’, culminating in the invocation of Article 355?
k.
Does the Citizenship Act conflict with provisions of the Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam Act), 1950? If so, how can the two legislations be harmoniously interpreted?
l.
Does Section 6A violate international laws?
E.
ANALYSIS
35. Before examining the contentions of the parties on the merits of the core issue challenging the constitutional validity of Section 6A, it is incumbent first to address the prefatory issues arising from the Respondents’ contentions on the maintainability of the present petition.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1037
Prefatory challenges i.
Judicial review
36. At the very outset, the Respondents asserted that this Court should refrain from delving further into the matter, as the petition raises issues hovering around foreign policy, a domain traditionally excluded from the purview of substantive judicial review. Consequently, they argued that the Petitioners are barred from challenging Section 6A. 37. The Petitioners, on the other hand, contended that Section 6A merely being a provision of the statute, it does not fall beyond the purview of judicial review. It is, thus, important for us to discuss and demarcate the principles and scope of judicial review in the instant case. (a)
Concept of judicial review
38. The principle of judicial review finds its roots in common law. It can effectively be traced back to Chief Justice Coke’s ruling in Thomas Bonham v. College of Physicians,36 wherein it was asserted that common law had the authority to oversee Acts of Parliament and empowered the courts to invalidate an enactment conflicting with common right and reason. This principle entails subjecting all laws to scrutiny against a higher law, typically embodied in a constitution. 39. This principle originated in the Supreme Court of the United States during the landmark case of Marbury v. Madison.37 In that decision, the Court asserted its authority by deeming the concerned legislation unconstitutional, thereby constraining the powers of Congress. The Court therein held that: "Thus, the particular phraseology of the Constitution of the United States confirms and strengthens the principle, supposed to be essential to all written Constitutions, that a law repugnant to the Constitution is void, and that courts, as well as other departments, are bound by that instrument.” [Emphasis supplied]
Thomas Bonham v. College of Physicians [1610], 8 Co. Rep. 107 77 Eng. Rep. 638.
Marbury v. Madison [1803], 5 U.S. 137 (1803).
1038
40. The essence of our constitutional system is rooted in the concepts of constitutionalism and judicial review, which comprise three essential elements: first, the presence of a written Constitution establishing and constraining government organs; second, the Constitution serving as a superior law or standard by which the conduct of all organs is assessed; and third, the provision for sanctions to prevent, restrain, and if necessary, annul any violation of superior law. The third element, which seeks to safeguard superior law, is through judicial review. Despite the expansive powers granted to legislatures, they operate within the confines set by the Constitution. In a democratic nation governed by a written constitution, supremacy and sovereignty reside in the Constitution. However, the duty of protecting the rights given under the Constitution falls to courts through judicial review, making them, in the process, the ultimate arbiter of constitutional interpretation.38 41. Constitutional courts, equipped with the powers of judicial review, function as custodians of justice, ensuring effective safeguard of citizens’ rights. Embedded in Article 13 of our Constitution, judicial review is recognized as a basic feature of our constitutional framework.39 It gives the Court the authority to scrutinize any violation of constitutional mandates by state organs. As articulated by Lord Steyn, the justification for judicial review arises from a combination of principles, such as the separation of powers, the rule of law, and the principle of constitutionality.40 42. The power of judicial review does not undermine the doctrine of separation of powers. Instead, it fosters it by ensuring a system of checks and balances to prevent constitutional transgression by any organ of the state. Separation of powers should be seen as a connection or link, rather than as a limitation or impediment; allowing the Court to ensure that the constitutional order prevails.41 43. In the present case, the Respondents urged that the matter entails policy considerations, and hence, the Court should not step into it.
State (NCT of Delhi) v. Union of India (2018) 8 SCC 501
L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997) 3 SCC 261: 1997 SCC (L&S) 577.
Steyn, The Constitutionalisation of Public Law, 1999, 4, 6, 13-14.
A. W. Bradley & K. D. Ewing, Constitutional and Administrative Law, Pearson Longman, 2007; H. Barnett, Constitution and Administrative Law, Cavendish, 2006; Laurence H. Tribe, American Constitutional Law, Foundation Press, 2000.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1039
44. It is pertinent to iterate the language under Article 13(2) of the Constitution, which states that: "(2) The State shall not make any law which takes away or abridges the rights conferred by this Part and any law made in contravention of this clause shall, to the extent of the contravention, be void.” The word “law” in Article 13 includes within its ambit, “any Ordinance, order, bye-law, rule, regulation, notification, custom or usage having in the territory of India the force of law”. 45. Upon a perusal of the above, it becomes clear that though the term ‘policy’ is not expressly mentioned in Article 13, it becomes justiciable if it takes the shape of a law.42 In the event such a law is deemed void due to a violation of any fundamental rights outlined in Part III of the Constitution, it cannot be protected merely for being legislative policy. This view has been elucidated in A.L. Kalra v. Project & Equipment Corporation,43 wherein objections were raised on the grounds that the Court could not review the statute, as it entailed policy considerations. However, this Court, having taken these contentions into consideration, held that a legislative policy taking the concrete shape of a statute could be tested on the anvil of violation of fundamental rights. 46. It is, therefore, abundantly clear that courts possess the authority to scrutinize whether legislative or executive actions contravene the Constitution, and the designation of a decision as a policy choice does not serve as a fetter to the exercise of this judicial power. This aligns with the principle of separation of powers, which bestows upon the judiciary the authority to serve as a guardian against the actions of the legislature and executive, intervening to safeguard the interests of citizens when necessary. (b)
Limits to judicial review
47. However, concurrently, it is imperative to acknowledge and respect the domain of the legislature and executive within the framework of the separation of powers. While the courts are entrusted with the
Bennett Coleman & Co. v. Union of India (1972) 2 SCC 788
A. L. Kalra v. Project and Equipment Corporation (1984) 3 SCC 316
1040
authority to maintain checks and balances on the other branches concerning the constitution and other legal provisions, they are not empowered to supplant the legislature by delving into additional facets of policy decisions and governing citizens in its stead. This sentiment resonated in Hindi Hitrakshak Samiti v. Union of India, wherein it was held that: "8. It is well settled that judicial review, in order to enforce a fundamental right, is permissible of administrative, legislative and governmental action or non-action, and that the rights of the citizens of this country are to be judged by the judiciary and judicial forums and not by the administrators or executives. But it is equally true that citizens of India are not to be governed by the judges or judiciary. If the governance is illegal or violative of rights and obligations, other questions may arise but whether, as mentioned hereinbefore, it has to be a policy decision by the government or the authority and thereafter enforcement of that policy, the court should not be, and we hope would not be an appropriate forum for decision.” 44 [Emphasis supplied] 48. Similar views were echoed in Fertilizer Corporation Kamgar Union v. Union of India,45 where a 5-judge bench of this Court affirmed that, in accordance with the principle of separation of powers, the authority of the Court is confined to assessing whether legislative or executive actions comply with the law, without delving into judgments on their wisdom. Consequently, while the Court possesses the jurisdiction to interpret the law and scrutinize the legality of policy decisions, it is not empowered to substitute its discretion for that of the legislature or executive, nor to speculate on the appropriateness of such decisions.46 The courts do not operate as advisors to the executive in matters of policy formulation, a prerogative rightfully within the executive’s domain.
Hindi Hitrakshak Samiti v. Union of India (1990) 2 SCC 352, para 8.
Fertilizer Corporation Kamgar Union v. Union of India (1981) 1 SCC 568, para 35.
A. K. Roy v. Union of India (1982) 1 SCC 271, para 51
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1041
49. Similarly, it is imperative to emphasize that courts also lack the authority to intervene in policy matters when based on the premise of policy errors or the availability of ostensibly superior, fairer, or wiser alternatives. The Court cannot do a comparative analysis of policy to determine which would have been better. As summarized by this Court in Directorate of Film Festivals v. Gaurav Ashwin Jain:47 “16. […] the scope of judicial review when examining a policy of the Government is to check whether it violates the fundamental rights of the citizens or is opposed to the provisions of the Constitution, or opposed to any statutory provision or manifestly arbitrary. Courts cannot interfere with policy either on the ground that it is erroneous or on the ground that a better, fairer or wiser alternative is available. Legality of the policy, and not the wisdom or soundness of the policy, is the subject of judicial review”. [Emphasis supplied] 50. This is particularly true for complex areas requiring empirical knowledge, data inputs, and technical expertise,48 such as matters involving economic policy, 49 scientific policy, 50 or international relations.51 Complex social, economic, or commercial issues require a trial and error approach, the weighing of different competing aspects, and often intricate factual studies.52 Such matters raise complicated multi-disciplinary questions that do not fall within the legal domain, are irreducible to one answer, and require adjustment of priorities amongst different stakeholders.53 51. Since courts are not equipped to evaluate such factual aspects, they cannot be allowed to formulate policy. In contrast, the legislature has the correct institutional mechanism to deliberate on various considerations, as it facilitates decision-making by democratically
Directorate of Film Festivals v. Gaurav Ashwin Jain (2007) 4 SCC 737, para 16.
Union of India v. S. L. Dutta (1991) 1 SCC 505, para 18.
State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal (1986) 4 SCC 566, para 34.
Jacob Puliyel v. Union of India, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 533, paras 91 and 93.
Gaurav Kumar Bansal v. Union of India (2015) 2 SCC 130, para 9.
Shri Sitaram Sugar Co. Ltd. v. Union of India (1990) 3 SCC 223, para 56.
Santosh Singh v. Union of India (2016) 8 SCC 253, paras 23 and 24.
1042
elected representatives who possess diverse tools and skill sets to balance social, economic, and political factors.54 Such policy matters thus ought to be entrusted to the legislature. This principle is succinctly encapsulated by Sanjeev Coke Mfg. Co. v. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd.,55 in which a 5-judge bench of this Court held that: "Scales of justice are just not designed to weigh competing social and economic factors. In such matters legislative wisdom must prevail and judicial review must abstain.” 52. Furthermore, the Courts are not tasked with assessing the efficacy of policies. A policy may successfully achieve the objectives outlined in legislation, or it may possess limitations hindering the full realization of its aims. Regardless, the Court cannot sit in judgment over policy to determine whether revisions may be necessary for its enhancement. This has also been authoritatively elucidated by an 11-judge bench of this Court in the case of Rustom Cavasjee Cooper (Banks Nationalisation) v. Union of India:56 "63. This Court is not the forum in which these conflicting claims may be debated. […] The Parliament has under Entry 45, List I the power to legislate in respect of banking and other commercial activities of the named banks necessarily incidental thereto: it has the power to legislate for acquiring the undertaking of the named banks under Entry 42, List III. Whether by the exercise of the power vested in the Reserve Bank under the pre-existing laws, results could be achieved which it is the object of the Act to achieve, is, in our judgment, not relevant in considering whether the Act amounts to abuse of legislative power. This Court has the power to strike down a law on the ground of want of authority, but the Court will not sit in appeal over the policy of the Parliament in enacting a law. […]” [Emphasis supplied]
Ashwani Kumar v. Union of India (2020) 13 SCC 585, paras 25 and 26.
Sanjeev Coke Mfg. Co. v. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. (1983) 1 SCC 147, para 20.
Rustom Cavasjee Cooper (Banks Nationalisation) v. Union of India (1970) 1 SCC 248, para 63.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1043
53. In summary, the judicial review of government policies encapsulates determining whether they infringe upon the fundamental rights of citizens, contravene constitutional provisions, violate statutory regulations, or display manifest arbitrariness, capriciousness, or mala fides.57 The focus of judicial scrutiny is limited to the legality of the policy, excluding any evaluation of its wisdom or soundness. The Court cannot compel the government to formulate a policy, evaluate alternatives or assess the effectiveness of existing policies. This constraint stems from the principle of separation of powers, where the Court lacks the democratic mandate and institutional expertise to delve into such matters. Thus, while the Court can invalidate a policy, it lacks the authority to create one. 54. However, to reiterate, while the Court cannot look into the aforementioned aspects, the Court can check the constitutional validity of a policy, particularly so when it is elevated as an act of the Legislature. 55. The present challenge concerns checking the validity of Section 6A, a statutory provision. We are, therefore, of the firm view that the Respondents’ plea regarding foreclosing the Petitioners’ challenge at the threshold, on the grounds of judicial review, cannot be accepted. ii.
Delay and maintainability of the writ petitions
56. In addition to the grounds of non-justiciability, the Respondents also protested against the maintainability of the writ petitions on account of inordinate delay and laches. They argued that while the subject provision was introduced in 1985, the writ petitions challenging the same have been filed after a long period of 27 years. Applying the doctrine of laches, the Respondents argued that the writ petitions must be held to be non-maintainable since the rights created during these 27 years cannot now be taken away. In support of their contentions, the Respondents have cited, inter alia, a 5-judge bench decision of this Court in Tilokchand Motichand v. H. B. Munshi,58 and urged that even if it is assumed that Section 6A violates the fundamental
Maharashtra State Board of Secondary & Higher Secondary Education v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth (1984) 4 SCC 27
Tilokchand Motichand v. H. B. Munshi (1969) 1 SCC 110.
1044
rights of the Petitioners, it cannot be declared unconstitutional at this belated juncture. 57. Per contra, the Petitioners argued that inter partes, the question regarding maintainability has already been decided by this Court in Assam Sanmilita Mahasangha v. Union of India (supra). Hence, they contended that the writ petitions cannot be considered to have been filed after a delay. Alternatively, they urged that delay, per se, would not be fatal to their claim because the doctrine of laches is not applicable when substantial questions of law are involved. In the instant case, since the dispute involves questions like the security of the state, the rights of Assamese people under Article 29, the discrimination against the State of Assam, etc., the petitions should not be barred at the threshold on the grounds of delay. 58. The primary issue to be determined, therefore, is whether the current writ petitions should be dismissed outright due to delay without delving into the merits of the Petitioners’ claims. (a)
Limitation period for writs
59. In India, the Limitation Act, 1963 sets out the maximum period within which suits, appeals, and applications must be filed before the court. Cases brought after this prescribed period are typically barred due to delay unless the court decides to condone the delay. However, it is important to note that the Limitation Act, 1963 does not apply to writ proceedings and, therefore, does not specify a particular time limit within which a writ needs to be filed.59 Similarly, though the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 specify the time limit for certain petitions that the Limitation Act, 1963 does not cover (such as Special Leave Petitions),60 these Rules too do not specify the limitation period for filing a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. 60. However, while such a period is not prescribed by the Limitation Act, 1963, or the Supreme Court Rules, 2013, a writ petition filed belatedly after a considerable delay is barred by the operation of the doctrine of laches.61 The said doctrine of laches is a common
Tilokchand & Motichand v. HB Munshi (1969) 1 SCC 110, para 9.
Supreme Court Rules, 2013, Order XXI Rule 1.
Aflatoon v. Lt. Governor of Delhi (1975) 4 SCC 285, para 11; Narayani Debi Khaitan v. State of Bihar, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 1, paras 8 and 13.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1045
law principle disallowing a claim because it has been brought to the court after an unreasonable lapse of time. It is based on the maxim ‘vigilantibus non dormientibus jura subveniunt’, which means that the law assists those who are vigilant with their rights and not those that sleep thereupon. Hence, even in the absence of the prescription of a statutory time limit for its filing, a claim that has been filed after a significant delay can be rejected at the threshold by invoking this doctrine. 61. Indeed, the laches principle bears similarities to the Limitation Act, 1963, as both are founded on similar policy considerations. A claim brought after considerable delay may not be entertained because third-party rights may have been established during this time-lapse, and it would be unjust to prejudice innocent parties due to the tardiness of the claimant.62 Additionally, considering a delayed claim could be unfair to the opposing party, as they may have lost access to crucial evidence needed to defend against the claim. Reopening the case after a significant delay could thus place the opposing party at a disadvantage, potentially resulting in an unjust or inaccurate outcome. Moreover, it is essential to put a time limit on proceedings to provide certainty and prevent confusion from cases being in perpetual flux. It is also important to deny a delayed claim to encourage parties to be more diligent when enforcing their rights. 62. While the doctrine of laches serves similar underlying purposes as the Limitation Act, 1963, it is less rigid in its application. Unlike the aforementioned Act, which prescribes specific time periods for filing claims, there is no fixed timeframe under the doctrine of laches. Instead, each case is evaluated based on its unique facts and circumstances. In the context of writ petitions, Hidayatullah, C.J., in Tilokchand Motichand (supra), held that while there is no upper or lower time limit for entertaining writ petitions, the Court shall consider whether the delay was avoidable and whether such delay affects the merits of the case. Similarly, in Shri Vallabh Glass Works Ltd. v. Union of India,63 it was held that the Court must consider the conduct of the parties, the change in circumstances, and the prejudice that would be caused to the other party or the general public.
Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (1979) 3 SCC 489, para 35.
Shri Vallabh Glass Works Ltd. v. Union of India (1984) 3 SCC 362, para 9.
1046
63. Hence, it is settled law that the doctrine of laches is not an inviolable legal rule but a rule of practice that must be supplemented with sound exercise of judicial discretion. While Courts must ordinarily apply this doctrine in light of the policy reasons discussed before, the doctrine allows the Court to conduct an individualized analysis of each case and entertain claims in the competing interests of justice, even when the claim may be delayed and third-party rights may have been created.64 64. We may, however, hasten to clarify that the doctrine of delay and laches is not to be ipso facto excluded where a breach of fundamental rights is alleged. The 5-judge benches of this Court in Narayani Debi Khaitan v. State of Bihar,65 Daryao v. State of U.P.,66 and Tilokchand Motichand (supra), and a 3-judge bench in Amrit Lal Berry v. CCE,67 have reiterated that even in such like cases the court must see the effect of laches. However, that being said, there may be instances where considerations of justice demand that the court adjudicate on the merits of a case rather than summarily dismissing it based solely on procedural grounds such as delay.68 65. One such factual circumstance is when the claim affects the public at large. In Kashinath G. Jalmi (Dr) v. The Speaker,69 this Court analyzed several precedents (including Tilokchand & Motichand (supra)) and differentiated them by holding that the doctrine of laches cannot be used to expel a claim that is made on behalf of the public. Judicial discretion, while applying this doctrine, must always be governed by the objective of promoting the larger public interest; and if a claim affects the public at large, the Court should go into the merits of the case.70 Where it is found that denial of consideration on merits is likely to affect society in general and can have a cascading effect on millions of citizens, the Court will carve out an exception and proceed to decide the lis on merits.
State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal (1986) 4 SCC 566, para 24.
1964 SCC OnLine SC 1, para 8.
Daryao v. State of U.P., 1961 SCC OnLine SC 21, para 23.
Amrit Lal Berry v. CCE (1975) 4 SCC 714, paras 16 and 23.
Tukaram Kana Joshi v. MIDC (2013) 1 SCC 353, paras 12 - 15; Vidya Devi v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2020) 2 SCC 569, para 12.12.
Kashinath G. Jalmi (Dr) v. The Speaker (1993) 2 SCC 703, paras 28 and 30.
Id, paras 34 and 35.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1047
66. Another vital circumstance where the doctrine of delay and laches would not be applicable strictly is in matters where the vires of a statute are challenged vis-à-vis the Constitution. This Court has, in the due course of time, accepted the idea of transformative constitutionalism, which conceptualizes the Constitution not as a still document cast in stone at the day of its formation but as a living and dynamic body of law, capable of constant updation and evolution as per changing societal mores. Should this Court deny a constitutional challenge solely based on delay, it would effectively establish an arbitrary cut-off beyond which laws could no longer be re-examined in light of changing circumstances. Such a rigid approach cannot be countenanced as changing societal circumstances sometimes necessitate a reconsideration of the status quo—even when the challenge is brought after a considerable lapse of time. 67. To instantiate, a Constitution Bench of this Court in Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India,71 held Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 to be ultra vires of the Constitution, regardless of the fact that the provision was a part of the statute for over a century. The Court took note of the norms of contemporary society and declared them to be unconstitutional. If the doctrine of laches were to be applied strictly, time would run in favour of a constitutionally invalid statute, which cannot be allowed in the larger interests of justice and the transformative nature of the Constitution. (b)
Applicability of doctrine of laches to the present case
68. Adverting to the facts of the case, it seems that the two mitigating circumstances mentioned above are directly attracted. 69. First, the Petitioners have raised various substantial questions that affect the public at large, including the erosion of the culture of indigenous communities, discrimination against the State of Assam, and the larger perceived threat to the security of the country from immigration. Therefore, instead of being an in personam dispute between two individuals, the questions raised by the Petitioners directly or indirectly affect a large citizenry. 70. The question regarding the constitutionality of Section 6A raises significant public policy issues that involve ramifications for the original
Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018) 10 SCC 1
1048
inhabitants of Assam, the rights of immigrants, and the security of the country. Hence, foreclosing such questions at the threshold on the grounds of technicality of delay would lead to an unjust outcome. Instead, considering it has been a long-standing issue and because any resolution will affect millions of individuals, a compelling policy rationale exists to adjudicate the matter on its merits and settle the issue conclusively. 71. Second, since the controversy pertains to the constitutionality of a statutory provision, the doctrine of laches ought not to be applied strictly to bar the claim at the very threshold. As discussed in paragraph 66, such constitutional adjudication cannot be made subject to any straitjacket rule of limitation. Challenges regarding the constitutionality of a statute require the Court to take a liberal approach and permit a certain amount of flexibility. A contrary approach would set a wrong precedent and act as a bar against challenging anachronistic laws that might no longer align with the ideals of constitutionalism. This would constitute an unsound legal principle since oppressive laws should not persist solely because they have been tolerated by society for a certain period. 72. Since the challenge in these cases relates to the constitutional validity of Section 6A, its consideration on merits ought not to be precluded on the grounds of delay. We reiterate that the doctrine of laches cannot be applied strictly. Whatever may be the ultimate view on the claims of the Petitioners, they are able to persuade us to examine the perceived harms, such as cultural erosion, the threat to the state’s security, damage to natural resources, etc., which cannot be strictly limited to a particular time-frame and could have occurred even after a lapse of time from the enactment of the impugned provision. In other words, even if Section 6A may not have been constitutionally invalid from the beginning, it might have incurred such invalidity subsequently. Hence, instead of closing the present challenge at the threshold, we shall proceed to analyse the merits of these claims to find out whether Section 6A has become ultra vires the Constitution with the passage of time and due to systematic failure of the legislative vision. 73. The Petitioners, however, may not be correct in contending that the issue of delay between the same parties was previously settled by the reference order dated 17.12.2014.72 At the outset, we must note
Assam Sanmilita Mahasangha, supra note 33.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1049
that the claim inter se the parties must not be construed strictly in constitutional adjudication such as the present one, since much larger questions of public importance are under consideration. Furthermore, it is imperative to note that a reference order does not represent a conclusive decision. Hence, the aforementioned contention of the Petitioners otherwise suffers from a factual error as the reference order cannot be construed as a final expression of views by this Court on any of the issues. 74. That apart, and as has been noted previously, instead of conclusively deciding the question of delay, this Court framed one of the specific questions as to whether delay should be considered for moulding appropriate relief. Thus, while the Court discussed the principle of delay in challenging the vires of Section 6A, it left the question open to be dealt with by a larger bench. 75. To conclude, while there has undoubtedly been a considerable delay in filing the instant writ petitions, the doctrine of laches cannot be applied strictly to disbar the claims at the threshold. This is so because the present proceedings raise substantial questions that affect the public at large and the constitutional validity of a statutory provision. If we were to decide otherwise, we would be, in essence, creating an artificial deadline for important constitutional issues. This would give rise to an unfair principle of law in the realm of constitutional adjudication. 76. We thus conclude that the Petitioners’ claim overcomes the preliminary hurdles, and cannot be dismissed at the threshold on the grounds of lack of judicial review or doctrine of laches. ******* Challenges regarding constitutionality 77. Prior to examining the contentions articulated by the parties on the constitutionality of the provision and engaging in a discussion on the various legal issues involved, it is imperative to trace the history of this matter and have a holistic understanding of how the provision, Section 6A, came into being. This historical context sheds light on Assam’s evolving dynamics and challenges, which were marked by partition decisions and the subsequent establishment of regulatory frameworks governing movement and citizenship. 78. Before we begin our discussion on the political history of Assam, it is crucial to emphasize that this serves as a broad overview based
1050
on the material cited by both parties. It is not to be construed as an exercise of determining the factual veracity of competing versions of historical narratives and is not strictly germane to our legal analysis. It merely serves as a contextual background for those who might be unfamiliar with the origins of Section 6A and the present issue. 79. The region, known today as Assam, has historically been inhabited by diverse ethnic and linguistic communities. Throughout the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, it was predominantly governed by the Ahom political authority, albeit with a brief period of Mughal rule. Subsequently, like numerous other regions across the nation, it came under British colonial administration in 1826.73 80. Prior to the beginning of the British colonial era, several parts of Assam fell under the dominion of the Burmese for a brief duration, during which the region underwent significant changes in its political and economic landscape. This period witnessed a substantial exodus of people from the valley, seeking refuge in the bordering towns of Bengal and other adjacent territories.74 However, there was soon a change of hands in terms of control over these regions after the First Anglo–Burmese War.75 By the middle of the nineteenth century, most of the Brahmaputra valley of Assam had fallen under British rule, and the East India Company assumed control over Assam. In 1874, a distinct province of Assam, administered by a Chief Commissioner, was established by amalgamating Goalpara, Cachar, Garo, Khasi and Jaintia Hills, and Naga Hills, with its capital at Shillong.76 81. Thereafter, in 1905, as part of the British partition of the Bengal Province, Assam became a constituent of the East Bengal region, with Dhaka serving as its capital, which is often regarded as the inception of friction between the Assamese and Bengali communities.77 82. Initially, during the partition deliberations, Assam was intended to be amalgamated with Bengal. However, this proposal encountered
Edward Gait, A History of Assam, Thacker, Spink & Company, 1906.
Manor Din: Arupjyoti Saikia on how the Burmese invasion of Assam transpired down to Earth, https:// www.downtoearth.org.in/interviews/governance/manor-din-arupjyoti-saikia-on-how-the-burmeseinvasion-of-assam-transpired-93414.
Sangeeta Barooah Pisharoty, Assam: The Accord, the Discord, Penguin Random House, 2019, 221.
Arupjyoti Saikia, The Quest for Modern Assam,Penguin Random House, 2023, 25.
Sangeeta Barooah Pisharoty, supra note 75.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1051
significant opposition from political leaders in Assam, who opposed the integration. They perceived the proposed amalgamation as another attempt to subject Assam to Bengali dominance, resulting in their opposition to the British tendency to treat Assam as an extension of Bengal.78 83. This period also witnessed first-hand, the blending of communities and groups between the two regions. Unlike present-day India, which has linguistically organised states, the then-eastern front of British India witnessed numerous culturally divergent communities living together. The population of Sylhet in modern-day Bangladesh, for example, was then comprised of Bengali-speaking as well as Assamese-speaking people. This was representative of the fact that unlike the western border, in the eastern border, issues of culture and language were more at play. 84. After this period of unrest, the Nehru-Liaquat Pact of 1950 was signed between India and Pakistan, symbolising their mutual commitment to safeguard minorities and their interests in both nations. This period also denoted the Constitution of India coming into force, which contained a part prescribing different modes of citizenship, as already elucidated in paragraphs 19 and 21. In line with this, the Citizenship Act was enacted, empowering the Central Government to declare law on citizenship or nationality, the details of which have also been dealt with elaborately in the same. 85. Parallelly, in 1948, a permit system was instituted between West Pakistan and India vide the West Pakistan (Control) Ordinance, and subsequently, in 1952, a formal passport and visa system was introduced along the eastern border.79 Until then, border traffic was almost entirely unregulated on the eastern borders. The span from 1960 to 1985 was marked by significant political turmoil, civil unrest, and violence in the country’s northeastern parts. 86. Amidst these developments, the NRC was initially prepared exclusively for the state of Assam in 1951. It intended to identify illegal immigrants entering the state from Bangladesh, utilizing data from the 1951 Census.
Id, 231.
Ministry of External Affairs Annual Report (1943-44), para 15.
1052
87. However, the scenario changed dramatically on 25.03.1971, when Pakistan initiated ‘Operation Searchlight’ to quell the Bengali nationalist movement in East Pakistan. The following day, on 26.03.1971, Bangladesh declared independence from Pakistan, triggering the Bangladesh Liberation War. Following these developments, in December 1971, India joined the war against Pakistan. While immigrants from East Pakistan (present-day Bangladesh) had been migrating to India since 1948, the wars of 1971 led to an influx of immigrants from Bangladesh into the State of Assam and other Indian states.80 88. Soon, there was anxiety surrounding the issue of electoral rolls in the Northeast region, fueled by concerns revolving around the influx of refugees from erstwhile East Bengal into Assam.81 During this period, the Assam Students Union (AASU) and the All Assam Gana Sangram Parishad (AAGSP) grew in popularity in the region. Thereafter, in 1979, the draft electoral rolls prepared for the bye-elections in the Lok Sabha Constituency of Mangaldoi in Assam revealed the names of numerous Bangladeshi immigrants. This led the AASU and AAGSP to launch a 6-year-long agitation, now known as the ‘Assam Movement’, fearing that Bangladeshi immigrants would overwhelm the indigenous population of Assam.82 During this period, political tensions escalated, marked by fierce debates and demonstrations concerning the influx of immigrants into Assam. Simultaneously, there were counter-demonstrations in Bengal, expressing solidarity with the Bengali-speaking communities in Assam. These events had a detrimental impact on the economy and trade in Assam, and eventually, in 1981, the President’s rule was imposed in the State. 89. In 1983, after more than a year of President’s rule, the Union of India decided to hold elections, despite a breakdown in negotiations over electoral roll revisions and escalating student-led protests.83 However, these aspirations came to an end with the occurrence of the Nellie Massacre on 18.02.1983, resulting in a devastating
Antara Datta, Refugees and Borders in South Asia: The Great Exodus of 1971, Routledge, 2015.
Sangeeta Barooah Pisharoty, supra note 75, 27.
Arupjyoti Saikia, supra note 76, 549.
Id, 566.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1053
massacre of people with severe casualties. It is believed that factors contributing to the tragedy included administrative failure, warnings of potential clashes being ignored, and underlying land-related tensions. The Nellie Massacre marked a turning point, transforming the once-peaceful student protests into a violent agitation that garnered national and international attention. Thereafter, in 1984, negotiations between the Centre and AASU stalled, but in January 1985, the then Prime Minister expressed a willingness to resolve Assam’s disputes, leading to the repeal of contentious laws and concessions to calm the agitations.84 90. The student-led Assam Movement finally came to an end on 15.08.1985, with the signing of a Memorandum of Settlement known as the ‘Assam Accord’ between the Central Government and the leaders of AASU and AAGSP. The Assam Accord declared 01.01.1966 as the base date for the detection of illegal immigrants and created three classes of immigrants: first, those who came before 01.01.1966, including those in the electoral list of 1967; second, those who came between 01.01.1966 and 24.03.1971; and third, those who came on or after 25.03.1971. The first class of persons were to be regularized under the Assam Accord, while those belonging to the second class were to be detected as foreigners, and their names were to be deleted from electoral rolls. It was further provided that their names would be restored after the expiry of ten years from their detection. The third class of persons, i.e., those who came on or after 25.03.1971, were to be detected and expelled as per the Assam Accord. Subsequently, Section 6A was inserted into the Citizenship Act through an amendment to give effect to the provisions of the Assam Accord. 91. However, despite the enactment of Section 6A, the influx of illegal immigrants into the State of Assam from Bangladesh was stronger than ever. In 1998, the then Governor of Assam submitted a report to the then President of India highlighting the threat posed by large-scale migration from Bangladesh into Assam. Currently, there exist thousands of migrants who have been accorded citizenship under Section 6A and have been residing in the State of Assam for several years. Conversely, there are also hordes of immigrants
Sangeeta Barooah Pisharoty, supra note 75, 184.
1054
who have entered and continue to enter the State of Assam illegally. Thus, there presently exist two sets of immigrants who need to be bifurcated and treated differently—one set who will be conferred citizenship in accordance with the auspices of Section 6A and the other set who are illegal immigrants. 92. Having dealt with this historical and political context, and with this background, it is now pertinent to peruse the issues invoking constitutional challenge against the validity of Section 6A. iii.
The preambular notion of fraternity
93. The Petitioners seek to enforce the preambular notion of ‘fraternity’. They have urged that the idea of fraternity, as encapsulated in the Constitution of India, is to be interpreted in the context of the unity and integrity of the nation. They argued against a global/transnational construction of the term, wherein the notion of fraternity is extended beyond the citizens of India. They asserted that the constitutional mandate in the Preamble pertains to fraternity amongst citizens and that this notion of fraternity might be destroyed when a legislative enactment such as Section 6A threatens to destroy the cultural demography of that citizenry. The Petitioners further contended that the influx of immigrants from Bangladesh into the State of Assam has jeopardized the very ideal of fraternity in India. 94. Contrarily, the Respondents submitted that the term fraternity means individuals having equal regard for each other and preventing relationships from being confined to specific clans. The Respondents stated that Section 6A reinforces the idea of fraternity, in the absence of which, society would be broken into a division between ‘others’ and ‘us’. 95. Having bestowed our consideration to the contentions set out by the parties, we must examine the meaning of the term fraternity and determine whether Section 6A violates or enforces the idea of fraternity. (a)
Meaning of ‘fraternity’
96. As articulated in the Preamble, the term ‘fraternity’ embodies a sense of collective brotherhood amongst all Indians. It serves as a critical element for national unity and social cohesion. Fraternity assumes
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1055
paramount significance in reinforcing the ideals of equality and liberty, both of which are integral facets of the Preamble.85 97. In order to have a holistic understanding of what fraternity as an ideal encompasses, it is integral to examine the meaning of ‘fraternity’ as envisaged by the drafters of the Constitution, as well as in terms of other jurisdictions which also employ the notion. Delving into the Constituent Assembly Debates would not only shed light on the ambit of fraternity but would also reveal a consensus that the principles of equality, liberty and fraternity are to be perceived as an indivisible whole. 98. The word ‘fraternity’ was initially not included as a part of the Objectives Resolution, which had been proposed by Jawaharlal Nehru on 13.12.1946 and thereafter adopted by the Constituent Assembly on 22.01.1947. In fact, this very resolution provided the basis for the inclusion of the Preamble to the Constitution of India. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, however, emphasized the significance of adding the term fraternity into the Preamble, defining it to mean a sense of shared brotherhood among all Indians, and highlighted that it was imperative for national unity and social solidarity.86 In pursuance thereto, Dr. Ambedkar stated as follows: "What does fraternity mean? Fraternity means a sense of common brotherhood of all Indians— if Indians being one people. It is the principle which gives unity and solidarity to social life. It is a difficult thing to achieve. The sooner we realise that we are not as yet a nation in the social and psychological sense of the world, the better for us. For then only we shall realise the necessity of becoming a nation and seriously think of ways and means of realising the goal.” [Emphasis supplied] 99. Dr. Ambedkar introduced the term ‘fraternity’ into the preambular values of the Constitution with the objective of advancing his vision of democracy and eradicating the issues posed by caste distinctions. His vision encompassed fostering a societal framework characterised
Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 11, 25.11.1949.
Id.
1056
by shared interests and interconnectedness amongst all Indians. Notably, neither the deliberations within the Constituent Assembly nor Dr. Ambedkar’s conceptualisation of fraternity suggests any inherent restriction of this principle to a specific community or segment of citizens. Instead, it was conceived as a concept intended to cultivate a sense of brotherhood amongst all individuals within society. 87 Dr. B.R. Ambedkar elucidated this core idea of fraternity in the following words: “…What is your ideal society if you do not want caste is a question that is bound to be asked of you. If you ask me, my ideal would be a society based on Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. And why not? What objection can there be to Fraternity? I cannot imagine any. An ideal society should be mobile, should be full of channels for conveying a change taking place in one part to other parts. In an ideal society there should be many interests consciously communicated and shared. There should be varied and free points of contact with other modes of association. In other words, there must be social endosmosis. This is fraternity, which is only another name for democracy. Democracy is not merely a form of Government. It is primarily a mode of associated living, of conjoint communicated experience. It is essentially an attitude of respect and reverence towards fellowmen.” [Emphasis supplied] 100. The idea of fraternity was therefore envisioned as a deep sense of well-being for others and understood as essential to counterbalance individualism, thereby preventing anarchy and sustaining moral order in society. It emphasized that a thriving democracy could be achieved through fraternity, which enabled the notions of liberty and equality to support each other rather than undermine one another. Further, it gave rise to the belief that the ideals of equality, liberty and fraternity could not be divorced from each other, as equality and liberty without fraternity would result in the supremacy of the few over the many.88
Dr. Babsaheb Ambedkar Writings and Speeches, Dr. Ambedkar Foundation, Vol. 1, 57, https://www.mea. gov.in/Images/attach/amb/Volume_01.pdf.
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, supra note 85.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1057
101. During the deliberations of the Constituent Assembly, the concepts of equality, fraternity, and liberty were perceived as constituting a trinity, forming the very bedrock of democracy. The notion of equality was afforded considerable impetus on account of the prevailing graded inequality within Indian society, characterized by affluence for some and abject poverty for many. Recognizing that various approaches might not eliminate disparities in social and economic aspects of the citizens’ lives, they formulated the principle of “one man, one value”, intending to create a level playing field for all.89 However, the framers believed that equality devoid of liberty could lead to the forfeiture of individuality. Moreover, they recognized that in the absence of fraternity, the harmonious coexistence of liberty and equality would not be inherent or natural, necessitating external enforcement measures.90 102. The genesis of the very notion of fraternity can be traced back to the French ideal of fraternity or fraternité, originating from the French Revolution and intricately connected with the principles of liberty and equality. This period in French history reflected a marked shift from feudalistic societies governed by hereditary status to a society aspiring to be a democratic ideal. This evolution was recognised as not just a political concept but as a period that emphasised collective rights over the individual.91 103. The emergence of fraternity as a concept in the French context began to see recognition with the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen, which prescribed communal participation in contrast to individual rights in the interests of society. This was, in essence, a clarion call for the notion of fraternity, though it had not been fully articulated at that point in time.92 It was only with the emergence of the Third Republic and the formation of the Paris Commune in 1871 that fraternity was articulated more clearly and reflected the people’s need for a society based on collective welfare and shared interests. The Constitution of the Third Republic then included and recognised the principles of liberty, equality and fraternity as cornerstones of
Id..
Id.
Georges Lefebvre, The Coming of the French Revolution, R. R. Palmer (trans.), Princeton University Press, 1973.
Id.
1058
French society. In this context, fraternity was not restricted to the idea of social cohesion but also extended to ensuring the dignity of each individual in a manner in which national unity and integrity were fostered. The evolution of fraternity, from a mere idea encompassing social values into a principle now embedded into the fabric of a nation’s identity, is indeed fascinating.93 104. Within the French context, fraternity transcended mere brotherhood, expanding to encompass a collective sense of solidarity among citizens. This journey of fraternity from a mere idea into a fundamental value shows the deeply entrenched political and social transformation that occurred in France. Fraternity, therefore, came to be understood as a sense of collective consciousness that unified individuals in their need for an equitable society. 105. Although fraternity is embedded in the constitutional fabric of both India and France, the manner in which they have come to be construed inherently differs. A nuanced differentiation can be discerned by examining them through the lenses of French and Indian perspectives. In the French context, the principle of fraternity was initially envisaged to symbolize a commitment towards the collective well-being of citizens and to showcase a bond that unified them in their aspirations for a just society. However, over time, the notion of fraternity in France came to be somewhat eclipsed by equality, which was perceived to be paramount, with a heightened emphasis on individual rights.94 Conversely, in India, fraternity was perceived by the Constituent Assembly, as seen in Dr. Ambedkar’s speeches, as a means to realize equality and uplift marginalised groups. The divergence in the interpretation of the term fraternity by these two nations in relation to equality is thus distinctly evident.95 106. In the Indian context, the meaning of fraternity has thus entirely diverged from the French sense of the term and is intricately woven into the fabric of fostering social solidarity, uplifting marginalised groups, and achieving a more equitable society. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s introduction of the term ‘fraternity’ into the constitutional Preamble
The New Encyclopaedia Britannica: Macropaedia (Encyclopaedia Britannica Inc.), 1974.
Decision 99-412 DC of June 15, 1999, Rec. 71 (European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages), para 10.
Jeremie Gilbert and David Keane, Equality versus fraternity? Rethinking France and its minorities, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 2016, 14(4), 901 and 902.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1059
reflects a deliberate intention to use this principle as a means to promote unity and brotherhood.96 In light of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s persistent efforts towards eradicating caste discrimination, his subsequent advocacy for fraternity among individuals appears to mirror his commitment to inclusivity. Unlike some Western perspectives, where fraternity may be overshadowed by an emphasis on individual rights, in India, fraternity is distinctly perceived as a vital instrument for realising equality and harmonising the diverse segments of society. It serves as a conduit for transcending societal disparities and working towards collective well-being.97 Therefore, in the Indian constitutional context, fraternity assumes a dynamic and inclusive role, aligning with the broader goals of social justice, equality, and upliftment. (b)
Ethos of Section 6A is aligned with fraternity
107. Having examined the contentions presented by the Petitioners, it is imperative to scrutinize whether the preambular value of fraternity would be applicable to the immigrants entering into the State of Assam under the aegis of Section 6A. 108. In this regard, it would be apposite to consider whether such preambular values are justiciable in the first place. In the landmark case of Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala,98 this Court affirmed that while the Preamble may be employed to interpret ambiguous provisions of the Constitution, it, by itself, is not enforceable in a court of law. Indeed, our current comprehension of the preamble is evident. It serves as a tool for interpreting the Constitution and guiding our trajectory. However, akin to the Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP), it was not envisaged as being directly enforceable. Nevertheless, the discourse on ‘fraternity’ holds relevance in the current context and will undeniably shape our interpretation of the pertinent laws at hand. 109. At this juncture, it would be essential to take into consideration the evolution of the principle of fraternity in terms of judicial construction to get a complete understanding of the meaning and scope of fraternity
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, supra note 85.
Id.
Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) 4 SCC 225
1060
as it stands today. The Preamble to the Constitution provides us insight into the values that embody the Constitution. The Preamble declares India to be a sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic, and republic and secures justice, equality, liberty, and fraternity for all its citizens. Though the Preamble does not grant any substantive rights and is not enforceable in courts, a plethora of cases have engaged with the Preamble and considered it to be a guiding light in interpreting the provisions of the Constitution. 110. Judicial precedents discussing fraternity will aid us in understanding whether fraternity remains to be seen as a beacon promoting togetherness amongst diverse groups or whether it has become more restrictive in its scope over time. This Court has dealt with the idea of fraternity or, at the very least, referred to it in a myriad of case laws. It has consistently held that the term ‘fraternity’ means a sense of common brotherhood of all citizens.99 This Court has also often reiterated that the ideals of liberty, equality, and fraternity should not be treated as separate entities instead, should be viewed as a trinity that secures empowerment and political justice for all citizens. Additionally, fraternity was interpreted as a principle that afforded the means to achieve national unity and the dignity of the individual.100 111. This Court in Indian Medical Association v. Union of India,101 addressed multiple petitions that had been filed challenging the exemptions provided under law, which allowed a private, non-aided educational institution to admit the children of army personnel exclusively. While examining the constitutionality of the challenged provision, the Court highlighted the significance of access to education as a means to foster fraternity and further promote social cohesion and unity. In the cited case, the Court determined that the restrictive admission policy was an impediment to achieving fraternity in society. Although not spelt out explicitly in the judgment, it is clear that the Court understood fraternity as encouraging the intermixing of people and one which discourages exclusivity or endogamous social structures.
Shri Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of India, AIR 1993 SC 1267, para 109.
100 Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, AIR 1993 SC 477, para 412; AIIMS Students’ Union v. AIIMS, AIR 2001 SC 3262, para 58. 101 Indian Medical Association v. Union of India, AIR 2011 SC 2365.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1061
112. It was, however, in the seminal case of Nandini Sundar v. State of Chhattisgarh102 that this Court, in the course of addressing issues pertaining to the appointment of Special Police Officers (SPOs) for the Salwa Judum in Chhattisgarh, extensively dealt with the aspect of fraternity. For context, the Salwa Judum was a militia formed and deployed to counter Maoist activities in the State of Chhattisgarh. This case brought to the fore several constitutional principles, including the ideals of fraternity, equality, the right to life, and personal liberty. This Court held that Section 9 of the Chhattisgarh Police Act, 2007 which allowed for the appointment of SPOs, violated the Constitution and delved into the relevance of the constitutional principle of fraternity. 113. In the aforesaid case, the Court interpreted fraternity as a safeguard against unchecked state power and an essential pillar for responsible governance. The Court held that state actions that de-humanized citizens violated the constitutional objective of the welfare of all citizens and would be wholly against the idea of dignity and fraternity, as enshrined in the Preamble to the Constitution. The Court further went on to underscore the significance of fraternity in shaping economic policies and stated thus:103 “The primary task of the State is the provision of security to all its citizens, without violating human dignity. This would necessarily imply the undertaking of tasks that would prevent the emergence of great dissatisfaction, and disaffection, on account of the manner and mode of extraction, and distribution, of natural resources and organization of social action, its benefits and costs.” [Emphasis supplied] 114. The very scope of fraternity beyond just being an ideal in the Preamble was thus expanded to be a principle that would create checks and balances on the system of governance and state actions. 115. Having examined the notion of fraternity from various perspectives, it can be deduced that the essence of fraternity, therefore, is 102 Nandini Sundar v. State of Chhattisgarh (2011) 7 SCC 547 103 Id, para 25.
1062
fundamentally geared towards fostering interconnectedness among Indians and was envisaged to be a principle for uplifting marginalised sections of society. 116. Consequently, it might be antithetical to the essence of fraternity to deploy this inclusive constitutional value in a way which deliberately excludes large swathes of the population, who have been duly conferred citizenship through procedure established by law, from the protection of constitutional rights. In fact, our understanding of fraternity, as also applied by this Court in Indian Medical Association v. Union of India (supra), is that it encourages, if not compels, people to fraternise and intermingle with people dissimilar to them. 117. In many ways, the Petitioners want fraternity to be interpreted in a highly restrictive manner, which allows them to choose their neighbours. Since this approach runs contrary to the very idea and ethos of fraternity that was envisaged by the Constituent Assembly and as subsequently interpreted by this Court, it cannot be accepted. Our reading of the Constitution and precedents is that fraternity requires people of different backgrounds and social circumstances to ‘live and let live’. The nomenclature of fraternity itself is selfexplanatory to the extent that it exhibits the notion of inclusiveness and togetherness, as opposed to restricted applicability. Thus, it becomes imperative to refrain from employing this concept in a negative manner that selectively applies it to a particular segment while labelling another faction as ‘illegal immigrants’, solely based on the alleged unconstitutionality of Section 6A. 118. In this light, when faced with the dilemma of disenfranchising millions or safeguarding a community’s endogamous way of life, this Court would certainly be compelled by the principles of fraternity to prioritize the former. Thus, in our considered view, the Petitioners contentions in this regard deserve to be rejected. iv.
Part II and Section 6A
(a)
Section 6A and Articles 6, 7 and 11 of the Constitution
119. The Petitioners argued that our Constitution exhaustively addresses the conferment of citizenship to individuals who migrated from present-day Bangladesh and that the Parliament cannot legislate
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1063
to the contrary without amending the Constitution. They asserted that Articles 6 and 7 prescribe a different regime for granting Indian citizenship to individuals who migrated from India to Pakistan or from Pakistan to India. They argued that ‘Pakistan’ encompasses Bangladesh, as it is a successor state to Pakistan, thus binding Parliament to the cut-off date of 19.07.1948 stipulated in Article 6 of the Constitution. Since these are constituent provisions and the Parliament enacted Section 6A through its ordinary legislative power, it could not have prescribed a different cut-off date in this Section for granting citizenship to immigrants from Bangladesh. The Petitioners further claimed that Parliament should have sought a constitutional amendment instead. Consequently, they contended that Section 6A is unconstitutional for being in conflict with Articles 6 and 7. 120. Per contra, the Respondents put forth a different view. They urged that Section 6A does not violate Articles 6 and 7 because these Articles operate in different contexts, both in terms of time and geography. They provided additional context on the cut-off dates prescribed in Articles 6 and 7, asserting that these dates were a remnant of the permit system, which never applied to East Pakistan. Referring to the Constituent Assembly Debates, the Respondents also demonstrated that it was never intended for these provisions to apply to East Pakistan. Further, they argued that the spirit and intent behind Section 6A align with those of Articles 6 and 7 and that striking down Section 6A would not serve the objectives of these Constitutional provisions. 121. The Respondents further argued that even if it is assumed that Section 6A conflicts with Articles 6 and 7, Article 11 of the Constitution is a non-obstante provision that grants Parliament the power to make laws regarding citizenship and that the other provisions of Part II of the Constitution cannot derogate from this power. In this regard, they relied upon Izhar Ahmed Khan v. Union of India,104 where it is held that the Parliament can make a valid law even when it is against such provisions. This power is supplemented by Entry 17 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution, which also empowers Parliament to legislate on the subject of citizenship.
104 Izhar Ahmed Khan v. Union of India, AIR 1962 SC 1052.
1064
122. The Petitioners refuted this plea, asserting that while Article 11 and Entry 17 of List 1 confer power upon Parliament, they do not include the authority to supersede other provisions within Part II of the Constitution. They interpreted Article 11 as a residual clause, empowering Parliament to enact laws that do not contravene other provisions within Part II. They argued that even if Article 11 admits multiple interpretations, the Court should adopt the construction that promotes harmony with the rest of the Constitution. 123. Considering these rival submissions, the issue that arises for consideration is whether Section 6A is violative of Articles 6 and 7 of the Constitution, and whether the Parliament had the power to enact Section 6A. 124. As we have specified previously in paragraphs 19 and 22 of this judgement, Article 6 specifies the conditions for granting citizenship to people who have immigrated to India from Pakistan. 125. The language of Article 6 unambiguously suggests that there exist two sets of conditions under this provision: for persons who migrated before 19.07.1948, and for those who migrated after this date. In terms of the former, Article 6 prescribes two further conditions: first, is the condition of birth/descent, mandating that such an individual, or either his parents or his grandparents must have been born in India; and second, is the condition of residence, prescribing that such an individual must have been a resident of India since migration. A third set of conditions is also prescribed for the people who migrated after 19.07.1948. This condition pertains to registration, which requires such individuals to have been registered as Indian citizens by an officer appointed for this purpose by the Government of India. 126. As a corollary to Article 6, and as previously discussed in paragraphs 19 and 22 above, Article 7 prescribes the condition for granting citizenship to people who migrated to Pakistan. 127. Thus, Article 7 mandates that a person who migrated to Pakistan after 01.03.1947 cannot claim Indian citizenship unless they fulfil three conditions: first, the person must have returned to India; second, such return must have been under permit for resettlement or permanent return; and third, that person must satisfy the conditions prescribed in Article 6 for a person migrating to India after 19.07.1948. 128. At this juncture, we may hasten to add that these conditions under Articles 6 and 7 covered both East and West Pakistan. This is
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1065
visible from these provisions’ text, which explicitly states “territory now included in Pakistan”. Since Pakistan, at the time of the commencement of the Constitution (i.e., 1950), included both East and West Pakistan, creating any artificial distinction would militate against the text of these provisions. Accordingly, the Respondents’ contention that these Articles would not cover East Pakistan cannot be accepted. 129. While the Respondents have cited the speeches of various members of the Constituent Assembly to argue that Articles 6 and 7 were not intended to apply to East Pakistan, we cannot use the opinion of individual members of the Constituent Assembly to negate the text of the Constitution, which, by itself, is the best manifestation of the Assembly’s intention. While the usage of such external aid might have been possible had the text been ambiguous, it cannot be used in the present context because Articles 6 and 7 leave no room to doubt that that they extend to both East and West Pakistan. 130. Having delineated the scope and ambit of these provisions, it is pertinent to comprehend the criteria outlined in Section 6A for bestowing citizenship upon immigrants from former East Pakistan, which was summarized previously in paragraph 25 of this judgement. 131. A perusal of these different conditions reflects various points of congruency between Section 6A and Articles 6 and 7. First, Section 6A prescribes that the immigrant must have been of Indian origin, defined in Section 6A(1)(d) to mean the person/either of whose parents/grandparents were born in undivided India. Hence, similar to Articles 6 and 7, the condition of birth/descent is present. Second, similar to Article 6, which does not stipulate the condition of registration before 19.07.1948 but necessitates it thereafter, Section 6A also lacks a requirement for registration before the specified cut-off date (i.e., 01.01.1966) but imposes it afterwards. Finally, mirroring the provisions of Articles 6 and 7, Section 6A(2) and (3) introduce the condition of residence, mandating that the immigrant must have resided in India since their immigration. 132. Furthermore, Section 6A aligns with the fundamental purpose of Articles 6 and 7, which was to extend citizenship rights to those affected by the country’s partition. Articles 6 and 7 aimed to safeguard the rights of individuals who were previously Indian citizens but
1066
found themselves residing in a foreign territory due to the political circumstances surrounding migration.105 Akin to this, Section 6A is also based on the same underlying policy reason of granting citizenship to the people of Indian origin migrating from Pakistan due to political disturbances in a foreign territory. Accordingly, Section 6A is aligned with the Constitutional philosophy of Articles 6 and 7 and is not contrary to them. 133. Regardless of these similarities, Section 6A diverges from Articles 6 and 7 in terms of the cut-off dates. As discussed earlier, Articles 6 and 7 prescribe the cut-off dates of 19.07.1948 and 01.01.1947, respectively. However, Section 6A prescribes two different cutoff dates: 01.01.1966 and 25.03.1971. Immigrants who entered Assam before 01.01.1966 are granted deemed citizenship, and immigrants who entered Assam between these two dates are granted citizenship once they fulfil certain conditions. Immigrants entering Assam on or after 25.03.1971 are not granted citizenship and are impliedly declared to be illegal immigrants who must be detected and deported. 134. The Petitioners’ contention that Section 6A is unconstitutional as it prescribes different dates in comparison to Articles 6 and 7 cannot be accepted because Article 6 does not prohibit the granting of citizenship after the cut-off date of 19.07.1948. It only specifies the fulfilment of certain conditions, which, as mentioned above, are also present in Section 6A(3). While Section 6A(2) grants deemed citizenship without these conditions, the competence of Parliament to prescribe different conditions—which will be analyzed in detail in the later part—is well embedded in Article 11. 135. Similarly, while Article 7 prohibits citizenship to people who re-migrated to India, this is only a sub-class of people who have been granted citizenship by Section 6A. Since Section 6A grants citizenship even to people who migrated for the first time, the class of re-migrants is severable from this provision. As will be discussed in the following paragraphs, the Parliament was competent to specify different conditions for this sub-class also.
105 R. K. Sidhwa, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 11.08.1949.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1067
Whether the Parliament had the competence to specify different conditions under Article 11 136. There is no quarrel among the parties that the Parliament has the power to enact laws on citizenship. This power is provided by Entry 17 of List 1 of the Seventh Schedule, which reads “Citizenship, naturalisation and aliens”. Further, the present situation is also covered by Entry 19, which reads, “Admission into, and emigration and expulsion from, India; passports and visas”. However, the parties are discordant to the extent of such power and whether law made by the Parliament can derogate from Article 6 and other provisions of Part II. 137. In this regard, it is pertinent to consider the objective and scope of Article 11 of the Constitution, which provides Parliament with the power to make laws on any matter relating to citizenship. Upon perusal of the text of Article 11, which was reproduced before in paragraph 19 of this judgement, two important considerations come to light. First, the phrase “Nothing in the foregoing provisions of this Part shall derogate” clearly fortifies that Article 11 confers overriding powers upon the Parliament to make laws even when they are against other provisions of Part II. 138. This was also duly acknowledged by a 5-judge bench of this Court in Izhar Ahmed Khan (supra), where it was explicitly noted that Article 11 grants Parliament the sovereign right to make laws on citizenship and that such laws cannot be impeached on the ground that they go against Articles 5 to 10 of the Constitution. 139. Incidentally, the overriding effect of Article 11 is also clearly established by various speeches in the Constituent Assembly. They highlight that the provisions of Part II were only meant to enact the law on citizenship for the time being at the commencement of the Constitution and the Parliament was empowered to enact provisions in the future, including making altogether new provisions. 106 As discussed in paragraph 16 earlier, this is consistent with the global practice of laying down only overarching principles of citizenship
106 Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 10.08.1949; Alladi Krishnaswamy Ayyar and H. N. Kunzru, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 12.08.1949; K. M. Munshi, Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 3, 29.04.1947.
1068
in the Constitution and empowering the Parliament to define the specifics through statutes. 140. From the phrase “Nothing in the foregoing provisions of this Part shall derogate”, the judicial pronouncement of this Court in Izhar Ahmed Khan (supra) and the accompanying speeches in the Constituent Assembly, we can appropriately conclude that Article 11 gives the Parliament broad powers to enact laws on citizenship, notwithstanding any inconsistencies with any other provision in Part II of the Constitution. 141. The second important aspect of Article 11, which lends support to this conclusion, is that it grants the Parliament the power to make ‘any’ provision regarding citizenship. A critical amendment to the text of the draft Article 11 further fortifies this conclusion. Initially, the draft Article granted Parliament the power to make ‘further provisions’. However, during a session of the Constituent Assembly on 29.04.1947, the President of the Assembly argued that the word ‘further’ might imply that Parliament should only make provisions in continuation of other Articles in Part II. Consequently, the word ‘further’ was replaced with ‘any’. This amendment highlights the framers’ intention to afford Parliament nearly unrestricted flexibility in crafting laws pertaining to citizenship. 142. Based on the analysis presented in this section, it can be concluded, and we hold so, that the Parliament indeed possesses the legislative power to enact laws concerning citizenship and that this authority is not restricted by the provisions of Part II of the Constitution. (b)
Section 6A and dual citizenship
143. The Petitioners, having not limited their contentions to the violation of Articles 6 and 7, also urged that since the immigrants did not renounce their citizenship before they were granted Indian citizenship, Section 6A enables dual citizenship and is therefore unconstitutional for violating Article 9. While the Respondents have not directly addressed this issue, it is vital to provide a comprehensive analysis for the sake of completeness. 144. The concept of dual citizenship means one has citizenship of two countries simultaneously. Across the world, there are various countries
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1069
like China,107 Japan,108 Kuwait,109 etc. that prohibit dual citizenship. Internationally, too, several countries have come together at various points to counter multiple citizenships. For instance, European nations that were members of the Council of Europe entered into the Convention on the Reduction of Cases of Multiple Nationality and on Military Obligations in Cases of Multiple Nationality, 1963, which, inter alia, provides that a person acquiring an additional nationality shall lose their previous nationality. Similarly, countries that were a part of the League of Nations (including India) entered the Convention on Certain Questions Relating to the Conflict of Nationality Law, 1930, to establish a commitment to abolishing dual citizenship. 145. In India, such citizenship is restricted by Article 9 of the Constitution and Section 9 of the Citizenship Act. Article 9 states that no person shall be granted Indian citizenship by Articles 5, 6, and 8 if such person has voluntarily acquired citizenship of a foreign state. As a corollary to this, Section 9 of the Citizenship Act provides: “Termination of citizenship — (1) Any citizen of India who by naturalisation, registration or otherwise voluntarily acquires, or has at any time between the 26th January, 1950 and the commencement of this Act voluntarily acquired, the citizenship of another country shall, upon such acquisition or, as the case may be, such commencement, cease to be a citizen of India: Provided that nothing in this sub-section shall apply to a citizen of India who, during any war in which India may be engaged, voluntarily acquires the citizenship of another country, until the Central Government otherwise directs. [Emphasis supplied] 146. While both Article 9 and Section 9 seemingly restrict dual citizenship, they operate in different time spheres. As was held by this court in Izhar Ahmed Khan (supra), while Article 9 contemplates the denial of Indian citizenship to a person who had acquired foreign 107 Nationality Law of People’s Republic of China, 1980, Article 9. 108 Japan’s Nationality Law, 1950, Article 11. 109 Kuwait, Ministerial Decree No. 15 of 1959 Promulgating the Nationality Law, Article 11.
1070
citizenship before the Constitution came into force, Section 9 deals with the acquisition of foreign citizenship after the commencement of the Constitution. 147. However, while they operate in different time spheres, a common theme that runs across both these provisions is the restriction on dual citizenship. Using these provisions, the Petitioners have urged that since Section 6A does not mandate the express renunciation of the immigrants’ previous citizenship before granting them Indian citizenship, Section 6A runs counter to these two constitutional and statutory provisions. 148. At the outset, even if it is assumed that Section 6A grants dual citizenship, it does not run counter to Article 9. We say so for the reason that these two provisions operate in different fields. As discussed above, Article 9 restricts a person possessing foreign citizenship from acquiring citizenship under Articles 5, 6, and 8. However, Section 6A does not grant citizenship under these provisions and is rather a separate method enacted by Parliament by virtue of its power under Article 11. The question of conflict between Article 9 and Section 6A, therefore does not arise at all. 149. Further, Section 6A also does not conflict with Section 9 because Section 6A does not override the scheme of Section 9 and must be read complementarily thereto. In case an immigrant who has been granted citizenship by Section 6A is found to have dual citizenship, Section 9 can always be invoked to hold that such person has ceased to be an Indian citizen. By virtue of Section 9(2), read with Rule 40 of Citizenship Rules, 2009, the Central Government will determine the question of such acquisition of foreign citizenship as per the detailed procedure prescribed under Schedule III of the aforementioned Rules.110 Since Section 6A is not a safe harbor from Section 9 and is rather subject to the scheme of restricting dual citizenship, it is not in conflict with Section 9 of the Citizenship Act. 150. However, Section 6A, by operation of law, presumes the renunciation of previous citizenship. As was discussed before in paragraph 25, Section 6A(2) and 6A(3) grant citizenship to immigrants, with a
110 Akbar Khan Alam Khan v. Union of India, AIR 1962 SC 70, para 5; State v. Syed Mohd. Khan, 1962 SCC OnLine SC 2, para 6.
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1071
possibility of opting out of such citizenship by filing prescribed forms. If such forms are not filed, and the immigrants choose to retain Indian citizenship, the presumption is that the person is an Indian citizen only and has foregone their previous citizenship. For this, an analogy can be drawn with the foreign territories incorporated in India after independence, for which India passed various legislations that granted Indian citizenship without mandating the explicit renunciation of their previously acquired foreign citizenship.111 These legislations provide Indian citizenship by default and an opt-out mechanism similar to Section 6A. In the event the person does not opt-out, the law presumes renunciation of previous citizenship. 151. Globally as well, various jurisdictions have held that citizenship can be lost through implied renunciation. For instance, Article 13 of the Constitution of Panama explicitly provides implied renunciation of citizenship. In the USA, Section 349 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, 1952, provides for the automatic termination of citizenship when specific actions are taken. Similarly, in the case of Lorenzo v. McCoy,112 the Supreme Court of the Philippines held that express renunciation is not necessary for the forfeiture of one’s citizenship, and it could be terminated by the actions. 152. Similarly, by electing not to opt-out, immigrants involved in the present context are presumed to have implicitly renounced their previous citizenship as per the law. However, it is essential to acknowledge that this presumption regarding renunciation of citizenship is not definitive and is rebuttable. As elaborated earlier, if an individual is found to have voluntarily availed themselves of the benefits of foreign citizenship despite not opting out of Indian citizenship, such a person would fall under the purview of Section 9 of the Citizenship Act, allowing authorities to revoke their Indian citizenship and face consequential deportation. 153. Therefore, based on the aforementioned reasons, we are of the considered opinion that the framework outlined by Section 6A is that an individual falling under Sections 6A(2) and 6A(3) can only
Dadra and Nagar Haveli (Citizenship) Order, 1962; Goa, Daman and Diu, the Goa, Daman and Diu (Citizenship) Order, 1962; Chandernagore (Merger) Act, 1954, Section 12; Citizenship (Pondicherry) Order, 1962; Sikkim (Citizenship) Order, 1975.
112 Lorenzo v. McCoy, 15 Phil., 559 (Philippines Supreme Court).
1072
assert Indian citizenship. Such individuals are presumed to have relinquished their previous citizenship. If authorities have reasons to believe that the previous citizenship is still being exercised, they are empowered under Section 9 of the Citizenship Act and associated rules to take steps to revoke the Indian citizenship of the delinquent individuals. Consequently, it can be deduced that Section 6A does not contradict Section 9 of the Citizenship Act, and we declare so. (c)
Section 6A and the oath of allegiance
154. The Petitioners also contended that Section 6A contradicts Section 5 of the Citizenship Act (Section 5), which requires every citizen to take an oath of allegiance. 155. The Respondents refuted this argument by asserting that the failure to take the oath was inconsequential, and as such, an oath was not mandated for them. 156. A bare reading of Section 5(2) reflects that it requires the oath of allegiance specifically to be taken by persons who seek citizenship under Section 5(1), which, as summarized previously in paragraph 21, provides citizenship by registration upon making an application to the Central Government. 157. Hence, Section 5(2) requires an oath for a specific mode of acquisition of citizenship. Similarly, under the Citizenship Rules, 2009, the oath is limited to certain modes, such as citizenship by registration under Section 5, citizenship by naturalization under Section 6, etc. Since Section 5(2) does not mandate the oath for every form of citizenship, the immigrants cannot be said to have violated Section 5 by not taking the oath. Likewise, it is difficult to hold that the immigrants have contravened any constitutional provision, as the Constitution does not explicitly mandate an oath for citizenship. 158. Moreover, the absence of such an oath does not absolve the immigrants from their obligation to respect the law and order of India. Even when such oath is not taken before acquiring citizenship, every citizen has to compulsorily abide by the norms of the Constitution, statutory laws, and other rules and regulations. We need not further emphasise that once the immigrants have become Indian citizens by operation of Section 6A, they are regulated by the Constitution of India, the laws framed under it and the values enshrined within
[2024] 10 S.C.R.
1073
them. Hence, the explicit lack of an oath of allegiance before the conferral of citizenship by Section 6A does not absolve the immigrants covered under this provision from following the laws of our country, just as any other citizen of India. 159. Hence, on account of the above-stated reasons, Section 6A cannot be run down on the premise that it does not mandate an oath of allegiance. v.
Article 14 and classification under Section 6A
160. In addition to the numerous other grounds, the Petitioners have vehemently contended that Section 6A falls foul of Article 14 as it treats equals unequally. They argued that the selective application of Section 6A solely to the State of Assam exhibits hostility against it in comparison to other states. They contended that since the issue of illegal immigration from East Pakistan was also prevalent in States like West Bengal or, rather, was significantly greater in comparison, hence singling out Assam is unconstitutional. The Petitioners further argued that such recourse is unjustifiable and that geographical considerations could not be the determining factor for applying laws differently. In support of their contention that the classification under Article 14 has to be on a reasonable basis and based on lawful object, the Petitioners cited, inter alia, Nagpur Improvement Trust v. Vithal Rao113 and Subramanian Swamy v. CBI.114 161. In response, the Respondents have first contested the maintainability of the Petitioners’ plea by asserting that Article 14 can only be invoked by individuals who are alleged to have been unfairly excluded from benefits granted to others and not by those singled out and subjected to restrictions alone. It is the Respondents’ case that Article 14 ensures equality in benefits provided but not in liabilities imposed. Given that the Petitioners’ claim falls into the latter category, the Respondents contended that the same would not be maintainable. Second, the Respondents argued that a statute cannot be struck down as violating Article 14 merely because it does not encompass all classes, as the Parliament wields discretion in legislating for
113 Nagpur Improvement Trust v. Vithal Rao (1973) 1 SCC 500 114 Subramanian Swamy v. CBI (2014) 8