Jagdish Chand v. The State of Hp and Others
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
- Date of judgment
- 7 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
- Case number
- CWP No. 5722 of 2026
- Result
- Disposed Off
- Advocates
- Rajiv Rai, Rajat Chaudhary, Dilip Sharma, Manish Sharma
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA CWP No.5722 of 2026 Decided on: 7th October, 2026 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jagdish Chand …..Petitioner Versus State of H.P. and Ors .....Respondents ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua Whether approved for reporting? 1 For the Petitioner:
Mr. Rajiv Rai, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Rajat Chaudhary, Assistant Advocate General for respondents No. 1 to 3. Mr. Dilip Sharma, Sr. Advocate, with Mr. Manish Sharma, Advocate, for respondent No.4. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge Petitioner and respondent No.4 are serving as Assistant
Professor
(Physics)
(College
Cadre)
in
the
respondent-Education
Department.
Respondent-State
issued
on
transferring
a
notification
17.04.2026
the
petitioner from Government Degree College, Solan to RKMV, Shimla vice respondent No. 4 who was brought in place of
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
petitioner from RKMV, Shimla.
Petitioner has grievance to
his transfer ordered vice-versa to respondent No. 4. 2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner alleges that
impugned
order has been issued on the basis of a D.O.
note. It was further submitted that though the petitioner has completed more than five years of stay at Government Degree
College,
Solan,
however,
petitioner
is
to
superannuate on 30.06.2027. As of now, just about nine months are left in his retirement. At the time of issuance of impugned notification, petitioner had about 18 months of service tenure left with him.
Pursuant to the interim order
passed in the writ petition on 21.04.2026, petitioner is presently
continuing to serve
at
Government
Degree
College, Solan. The said order is as under:“Mr. Pushpinder Jaswal, learned Additional Advocate General, accepts notice on behalf of respondents No.1 to 3. Notice be issued to respondent No.4, returnable for 21.05.2026, on taking steps within one week. List on 21.05.2026. Reply on behalf of the contesting respondents in the meanwhile. CMP No.8135 of 2026 Notice in above terms. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, though, the petitioner has completed his normal tenure at Solan, but, as the petitioner shall be superannuating in less than 1 ½ years, his transfer at this stage is not in terms of the transfer policy. In light of the contention of the petitioner that he has been transferring ignoring that the petitioner has left with less than 1 ½ years of service, till further orders, the operation of impugned transfer order qua the petitioner and the private respondent is hereby stayed. Petitioner shall be allowed to continue serve at Solan and the private respondent shall be instructed to serve at RKMV Shimla de-hors whether they have been relieved
or not. In other words, status quo ante, as it existed before the passing of impugned order dated 1704.2026, shall be maintained qua the petitioner and the private respondent. In the meanwhile, the petitioner may otherwise approach the Authority for his adjustment at some other station nearby to Solan.”
3.
Reply to the writ petition has been filed by
respondent No 4. Respondents No. 1 to 3- State, has not filed reply. Learned Assistant Advocate General, however, has placed on record office instructions dated 07.10.2026, placing on record incumbency positions of petitioner and respondent No. 4. Incumbency position of petitioner is as under:Sr. No.
Name of Institution
Date of joining
Date of relieving
Govt. College Sarkaghat, Mandi Govt. College Sanjauli Govt. College Solan Govt. College Sanjauli Govt. College Solan Govt. College Nerwa Govt. College Solan
11.06.1999
26.04.2006
29.04.2006 20.08.2009 21.09.2012 30.01.2016 12.04.2019 05.07.2021
18.08.2009 21.09.2012 30.01.2016 10.01.2019 03.07.2021 Till date
The above tabulation shows that most of his service career has been spent by the petitioner either at Solan or in Shimla. Incumbency position of respondent No. 4 is as under:Sr. No.
Name of Institution
Date of joining
Date of relieving
Govt. College R/Peo Kinnaur, RKMV College Shimla Govt. College Solan RKMV Shimla Govt. College Solan RKMV Shimla
21.12.2009 10.08.2013 09.11.2016 03.07.2020 19.04.2026 23.04.2026
08.08.2013 08.11.2016 03.07.2020 18.04.2026 22.04.2026 Till date
The
table
above
makes
it
evident
that
respondent No 4 has also served most of his service career either at Shimla (RKMV) or in Solan. 3(i)
Learned senior counsel for respondent No. 4
submits that respondent No. 4 belongs to Palampur, but his family resides at Solan; Respondent No. 4’s serving
as
lecturer
at
GSSS
Dharampur,
wife
is
Solan;
Rrespondent No. 4's children are also studying in school in Solan.
That respondent No. 4 on 04.10.2025 was
diagnosed with ligament tear “Anterior Cruciate Ligament” of ‘left knee accompanied by mild bone contusions, joint effusion
& popliteal cyst’, and has been undergoing
regular
check-ups
and
treatment
from
PGIMER,
Chandigarh. Medical prescription slips/treatment record up till the month of February 2026 has been placed on record alongwith reply filed on 09.07.2026. 3(ii)
Learned senior counsel for respondent No.4 has
opposed the writ petition, primarily relying upon Narender Bhota vs. State of HP and others 2, Shabnam vs. State of HP and others3 and Kripa Ram vs. State of
CWP No 1420 of 2023, decided on 28.03.2023 CWP No 2624 of 2022, decided on 18.09.2022,
HP and others4. It has been submitted that petitioner is holding Class-I post, therefore, norms laid down by the respondent-State in Comprehensive Guiding Principles 2013 to exempt Class-III and Class-IV employees having less than two years of service prior to their date of retirement from transfer, are not applicable to him; Petitioner has completed much more than normal tenure at his current place of posting, the ground of impugned order having been issued on the basis of DO note is
also not
available to him; Having completed his normal tenure at his present place of posting, it is not for the petitioner to complain as to on whose request his transfer order came to be issued. 4.
From the incumbency positions of petitioner
and respondent No. 4 placed on record by the respondentState, it becomes quite clear that both of them probably have been beneficiaries of DO notes in the past, and
have
managed to remain posted either in Solan or in Shimla. Respondent No. 4, save and except for his initial period of service at Government College, Rekong Peo, Kinnaur, has only served in two colleges till date, that is, either RKMV, Shimla, or Government Degree College, Solan.
CWP No. 2026 of 2019, decided on 21.11.2019
Respondent
No. 4, though has endeavoured to make out a case that on account
of injury suffered by him in October 2025 he
needs to undergo regular check-ups at PGI, Chandigarh, and for that reason had requested the State to transfer him to Solan, and accordingly, his request was accepted and he was transferred under the impugned order vice petitioner at Solan. However, there is no document/ certificate on record to reflect that on account of such injury, petitioner is required to be posted at Solan, or even to the effect that he is still undergoing regular check-ups from PGI, Chandigarh. Even assuming that respondent No. 4 is still taking regular treatment from PGI, Chandigarh, then also his posting at Solan or Shimla will not make any difference in that regard. Apparently, the only reason for respondent No. 4's strong desire to remain at Solan appears to be his family residing at Solan. Be that as it may, respondent No. 4 is holding Class-I post and belongs to State Cadre. He does not enjoy a vested right to remain posted only in Solan and Shimla, which he has managed to do till now. Therefore, insofar as respondent No. 4's posting is concerned, the issue is left for appropriate decision by respondent No. 1. Respondent No. 1 is directed to consider the case of transfer of respondent no.4 again. Fresh order in respect of transfer of respondent
No.4 be
passed keeping in view all relevant factors
including his incumbency position as also genuineness or otherwise of medical
issues raised by him in the reply. The
order in this regard be passed within two weeks i.e. by or before 26.10.2026. Though in view of incumbency position of petitioner, this Court would have interfered in respect of posting of the petitioner to a place other than Solan or Shimla, and would have directed respondent No. 1 to consider posting the petitioner to a place other than Solan or Shimla, however, taking note of the fact that petitioner is due to superannuate on 30.06.2027, only on account of impending retirement of the petitioner, this recourse is not adopted. With the above observations, this writ petition is disposed of. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also to stand disposed of.
October 07, 2026 R.Atal
Jyotsna Rewal Dua Judge