Krishna Kumar Shandilya v. Subhash Chand Sinha

Court
High Court Of Chhattisgarh
Date of judgment
12 October 2026
Judge
Justice Shri Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal
Case number
MAC No. 1452 of 2023
Result
DISPOSED OFF
Acts & sections
Section 173 Motor Vehicles Act
Advocates
H.A.P.S. Bhatia, Mohd, Azad Siddiqui
Subject
Motor accident

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

CGHC010260362023

2026:CGHC:44167

NAFR

PRASHANT DEWANGAN Digitally signed by PRASHANT DEWANGAN Date: 2026.10.15 17:52:40 +0530

HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR MAC No. 1452 of 2023 1 - Krishna Kumar Shandilya, S/o Sukal Ram, Aged About 48 Years (Father Of Deceased), R/o Village - Rajpur, P.O. - Dongardula, Tehsil - Nagri , District - Dhamtari , Chhattisgarh. (Claimant) 2 - Smt. Anita Bai W/o Krishna Kumar Shandilya Aged About 39 Years (Mother Of The Deceased), R/o Village - Rajpur, P.O. Dongardula, Tehsil - Nagri , District - Dhamtari , Chhattisgarh. (Claimant) 3 - Sourabh S/o Krishna Kumar Shandilya Aged About 18 Years (Brother Of The Deceased) R/o Village - Rajpur, P.O. - Dongardula, Tehsil - Nagri , District - Dhamtari , Chhattisgarh. (Claimant) 4 - Satendra Kumar S/o Krishna Kumar Shandilya Aged About 16 Years (Brother Of The Deceased), Minor Being Represented By His Natural

Guardian

(Father)

Appellant

No.

(Krishna

Kumar

Shandilya), R/o Village - Rajpur, P.O. - Dongardula, Tehsil - Nagri , District - Dhamtari , Chhattisgarh. (Claimant) ... Appellants versus 1 - Subhash Chand Sinha, S/o Lt. Durgu Ram Sinha, Aged About 56 Years, Caste - Kalar, R/o Village And P.O. - Farsiyaan, Tehsil - Nagri, District - Dhamtari, Chhattisgarh. (Driver) 2 - Savita Sahu D/o Hulaarsingh Sahu, Aged About 41 Years R/o Sidhharth Chowk Raipur, P.S. - Raipur, Tehsil And District Raipur, Chhattisgarh. (Owner)

3 - Branch Manager, The Oriental Insurance Company Limited, M.B. Trade Centre, Near Ghadi Chowk, Dhamtari, P.O. , P.S., Tehsil And District - Dhamtari, Chhattisgarh. (Insurance Company) ... Respondent(s) For Appellants : Mr. H.A.P.S. Bhatia, Advocate For Respondents No.1 and 2 : Notice unserved For Respondent No.3 : Mr. Mohd. Azad Siddiqui, Advocate Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal Judgment on Board (13/10/2026) 1.

Heard on admission.

2.

Admit.

3.

With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the case is heard finally.

4.

This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short the "Act of 1988") has been preferred by the appellants/claimants seeking enhancement of the amount of compensation,

challenging

impugned

award

dated

08/05/2023, passed in Claim Case No. 70/2022, whereby the learned

Claims

has

awarded

a

total

sum

of

Rs.10,55,880/- as compensation for the death of Deepesh Shandilya, who died in a road accident which took place on 31/01/2022. 5.

Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the 10% compensation

has

been

deducted

towards

contributory

negligence on the ground that on the motorcycle three persons were traveling which runs contrary to the decision of the

Supreme Court in the matter of Mohammed Siddique & another v. National Insurance Company Limited & others, therefore, the 10% contributory negligence be waived. He would also submit that the Claims Tribunal erred in assessing income of the deceased Rs.8,000/- per month which should be Rs.9,280/- per months as per Chhattisgarh Minimum Wages Notification isued by the office of the Labour Commissioner, Chhattisgarh. It is submitted that the learned Claims Tribunal has awarded inadequate amounts under the conventional heads. Learned counsel further submits that no amount has been awarded towards consortium by the learned Claims Tribunal, which is also payable to the claimants. It is, therefore, prayed that the instant appeal be allowed and the compensation awarded by the learned Claims Tribunal be suitably enhanced. 6.

Learned counsel appearing for Respondent No. 3/Insurance Company submits that the learned Claims Tribunal, after duly appreciating the oral and documentary evidence available on record, has rightly awarded the compensation and deducted 10% of the compensation towards contributory negligence. It is further submitted that the compensation awarded by the learned Claims Tribunal is just and proper and does not warrant any interference by this Court.

7.

I have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their rival submissions made herein-above and went through the records with utmost circumspection.

8.

Admittedly,

Claims

has

deducted

10%

compensation towards the contributory negligence on the ground that on the motorcycle three persons were traveling, however, the said finding of the Claims Tribunal runs contrary to the decision of the Supreme Court in the matter of Mohammed Siddiue (supra) and also by this High Court in the case of

Kaliram Sahu & Ors. Vs. Chamanlal Dewangan &

Ors, reported in 2014 (1) CGLJ 431 holding that three persons were riding a motorcycle is not sufficient for contributory negligence unless it is established that it contributed to the accident. 9.

Admittedly, in the instant case, at the time of accident, three persons were traveling on the motorcycle. However, no evidence on record to show that any wrongful act on the part of the driver of the motorcycle along with the deceased persons contributed to the accident. In the absence of any evidence in this regard and in the light of the aforesaid judgments, the riders of the motorcycle cannot be held guilty of contributory negligence.

10. Learned Claims Tribunal assessed the monthly income of the deceased to be Rs.8000/-, however, in the opinion of this Court, as per the Chhattisgarh Minimum Wages Notification issued by the Office of Labour Comissioner, Chhattisgarh, the monthly income of the deceased should be Rs.9,280/-. Further, on the basis of the documents available on record, the learned Tribunal has held that the deceased was unmarried aged about 20 years at the time of the accident. Having regard to the

number of claimants (4), the Tribunal has added 40% towards future prospects, deducted ½ (half) towards the personal and living expenses of the deceased, and applied the multiplier of ‘18’. The aforesaid assessment, in the opinion of this Court, is just and proper and does not warrant any interference. 11. However, under the conventional heads, the learned Claims Tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs. 45,000/-, whereas the claimants

are

entitled

to

Rs.2,09,000/-

towards

other

conventional heads. To this extent, the impugned award warrants modification. 12. Thus, in light of the aforesaid discussion and in light of the judgments of the Supreme Court rendered in the matters of National Insurance Company Ltd. V. Pranay Sethi 1, Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Ors 2 and Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram & Ors3, this Court is computing the compensation as below:Sr.

Heads

No.

Compensation awarded

Income

by

Compensation the awarded

Court

Rs. 8,000/-

Rs.

by

9280x

this

=

1,11,360/2.

Future

(+)40% (i.e. Rs. 2400) (+)40%

prospect

=

10400/-

x

1,24,800/(miscalculated)

(2017) 16 SCC 680

(2009) 6 SCC 121

(2018) 18 SCC 130

(i.e.

Rs.

12= 44,544) = 1,55,904/-

3.

Deduction

(-) 1/2 (i.e. 62,400) = (-) 1/2 (i.e. 77,952) = 62,400/-

77,952/(x) 18 = 14,03,136/-

4.

Multiplier

(x) 18 = 11,23,200/-

5.

Deduction

(-) 1/10 (i.e. 112320) Nil

(contributory = 10,10,880/negligence) 6.

Other

Rs.

45,000/- Rs. 2,09,000/-

conventional (15,000+15,000+

(16,500+16,500+44,0

heads

15,000)

00 x 4)

Total

Rs. 10,55,880/-

Rs. 16,12,136/-

13. In view of the aforesaid analysis, the amount of compensation of Rs.10,55,880/- awarded by the Claims Tribunal is enhanced to Rs.16,12,136/-.

Hence,

Rs.10,55,880/-,

after

appellants

deducting

are

entitled

held

amount for

of an

additional amount of Rs.5,56,256/-. The additional amount of compensation shall carry interest @ 6% per annum from filing of the claim application before the Claims Tribunal till its realization. Rest of the conditions of the impugned award shall remain intact. 14. In the result, the appeal is partly allowed and the impugned award is modified to the extent as indicated herein-above. 15. The Registry is directed to communicate the claimants in writing “the enhanced amount” in this appeal as against the award made by the concerned Tribunal. The said communication be made in Hindi Deonagri language and the help of paralegal workers may be availed with a co-ordination of Secretary, Legal Aid of the concerned area wherein the claimants resides.

Sd/(Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal) Judge Prashant

Related judgments

More Chhattisgarh High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.