Lakhan Singh Baghel v. Shivnarayan Vishvakarma
- Court
- High Court Of Chhattisgarh
- Date of judgment
- 11 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Shri Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal
- Case number
- MAC No. 297 of 2023
- Result
- DISPOSED OFF
- Acts & sections
- Section 173 Motor Vehicles Act
- Subject
- Motor accident
Full judgment
Digitally signed by
BHOLA BHOLA NATH KHATAI NATH KHATAI Date: 2026.10.14 10:37:54 +0530
CGHC010068632023
2026:CGHC:44085
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR MAC No. 297 of 2023 1 - Lakhan Singh Baghel S/o Late Bhakla Singh Baghel Aged About 42 Years R/o Village - Bhilai - 03, World Bank Colony, Charaunda Bhilai, Police Station - Bhilai, Tahsil Patan, District Durg (C.G.) 2 - Laxmin Bai W/o Lakhan Singh Baghel Aged About 39 Years R/o Village - Bhilai-03, Warld Bank Colony, Charaunda, Bhilai, Police Station - Bhilai, Tahsil - Patan, District - Durg (C.G.) ... Appellant(s) versus 1 - Shivnarayan Vishvakarma S/o Mangal Wisvakarma Aged About 27 Years R/o Village Chacheriya, Ward No. 05, Post Ketar, Police Station - Bhavnathpur, Tahsil - Baligarh, District Garhwa, Ketar (Jharkhand) (Driver Of The Vehicle Trailer No. NL-01-N-8016) 2 - Mehta Transport Logistic Transport Private Limited R/o - T. C. P. Get, Kohima (Nagaland) Pin No. - 797001, (Owner Of The Vehicle Trailer No. NL-01-N-8016) 3 - Branch Manager New India Insurance Company Limited, Branch Office - Rama Trade Centre, 2nd Floor, In Front Of Rajiv Plaza, Old Bus Stand, Police Station - Civil Line, Tahsil And District - Bilaspur (C.G.) (Insurer Of The Vehicle Trailer No. - NL01-N-8016) ... Respondent(s)
For Appellants : For Respondent : No.1 For Respondent : No.3
Mr. Anand Kesharwani, Advocate Mr. Priyanshu Yadav, Adv., on behalf of Mr. Vikash Pandey, Advocate Mr. Azad Siddiqui, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal Order on Board (12.10.2026) 1. This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
has been preferred by the appellants/claimants seeking enhancement of the amount of compensation, challenging the impugned
award
dated
24.11.2022,
passed
by
6 th
Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Bilaspur (CG), in Claim
Case
No.548/2019,
whereby
Claims
assessed the total compensation at ₹11,70,680/- and, after deducting 25% towards contributory negligence attributed to the deceased, Vivek Baghel, who died in a motor accident on 08.04.2019, awarded a sum of ₹8,78,010/- in favour of the claimants. 2. Learned
counsel
appearing
for
appellants/claimants
submits that the Tribunal has erroneously attributed 25% contributory negligence to the deceased, Vivek Baghel, who was riding the motorcycle, despite there being no evidence to substantiate such a finding. It is further submitted that the eyewitness, Kamlesh Kumar, who was travelling as a pillion rider on the motorcycle, has supported the case of the
claimants, which is also corroborated by the charge-sheet. Therefore, learned counsel prays that the finding of the
attributing
25%
contributory
negligence
to
deceased be set aside. 3. Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants further submits
that the Tribunal has committed a manifest error in assessing the monthly income of the deceased at ₹7,200/-, which is even lower than the minimum wages payable to an unskilled labourer at the relevant time. It is also contended that the amount awarded towards loss of consortium is inadequate and requires enhancement. Accordingly, learned counsel prays that the appeal be allowed and the compensation awarded by the Tribunal be suitably enhanced in accordance with law. 4. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.
3/Insurance Company opposes the submissions made on behalf of the appellants and submits that the FIR and the statement of the eyewitness, Kamlesh Kumar, establish that three persons were travelling on the motorcycle, thereby exceeding its permitted seating capacity, and that they were returning after celebrating a birthday party. It is further submitted that the persons travelling on the motorcycle were under the influence of alcohol and that Kamlesh Kumar has admitted that the deceased, Vivek Baghel, had the last opportunity to avoid the accident. Therefore, the finding
recorded
by
attributing
25%
contributory
negligence to the deceased is justified and does not warrant any interference by this Court. Learned counsel further submits that, considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is just and proper and does not call for any enhancement. 5. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.1 also submits
that the award passed by the Tribunal is just and proper and does not warrant any interference by this Court. 6. Heard
learned
counsel
for
parties,
considered
their
respective submissions and perused the record of the case with due care. Contributory Negligence 7. As regards the finding of contributory negligence, Kamlesh
Kumar (AW-2) has been examined as an eyewitness to the accident. However, neither the driver nor the owner of the offending trailer has been examined as a witness. The person who lodged the FIR, namely, Manish Diwakar, has also not been examined. The basis on which it was stated in the FIR that the offending vehicle was stationary at the time of the accident is not clear from the evidence on record. It is, however, evident that the eyewitness, Kamlesh Kumar and one Aryan were travelling on the motorcycle along with the deceased.
Thus,
three
persons
were
travelling
on
motorcycle,
exceeding its permitted seating capacity, and they were returning after celebrating a birthday party. The eyewitness, Kamlesh Kumar, has also admitted that the deceased had the last opportunity to avoid the accident. Further, the accident occurred during daytime, and the motorcycle collided with the trailer from behind. 8. Having considered the aforesaid facts and circumstances,
together with the evidence available on record, this Court finds no error in the finding recorded by the Tribunal attributing 25% contributory negligence to the deceased, who was driving the motorcycle. Accordingly, the said finding does not warrant any interference by this Court. Quantum of Compensation 9. As
regards the quantum of compensation, although the
claimants have contended that the deceased was earning ₹15,000/- per month by working as a driver, neither any documentary evidence nor driving licence (D.L.) has been produced to substantiate the said claim. The accident occurred on 08.04.2019, and the minimum wages payable even to an unskilled labourer at the relevant time were ₹8,400/- per month. Accordingly, this Court considers it appropriate to reassess the monthly income of the deceased at ₹8,400/-.
10. The deceased was unmarried, aged about 20 years and a non-
salaried person. There are two claimants i.e. the parents of the deceased. 11. Considering the date of accident, the age of the deceased and
the number of claimants, this Court finds that the addition towards future prospects at the rate of 40%, the deduction of 50% (1/2) towards personal and living expenses, and the multiplier of 18 applied by the Tribunal are just, proper and in accordance with the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. However, the compensation awarded under the conventional heads requires reconsideration in accordance with the applicable legal principles. 12. Thus, in light of the aforesaid discussion and the judgments of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Company Ltd. V. Pranay Sethi1, Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation
&
Ors2
and
Magma
General
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram & Ors 3, the compensation is recomputed as under:Sl. No.
Heads
Income
2.
Future prospects
3.
Deduction
(2017) 16 SCC 680 (2009) 6 SCC 121 (2018) 18 SCC 130
Compensation Compensation awarded by the awarded by Court 7,200x12 =86400
this
8,400 x12 =1,00,800
(+)40% (i.e.34,560) (+)40% (i.e.40,320) = 1,20,960 = 1,41,120 (-) 1/2 =60,480
(-)1/2 = 70,560
4.
Multiplier
(x) 18 =10,93,680
(x) 18 =12,70,080
5.
Funeral Expenses
16,500
15,000
6.
Loss of Estate
16,500
15,000
7.
Loss of Consortium
44,000
80,000
Total
(40,000 x 2) Rs. 11,70,680/-
Rs. 13,80,080/-
13. In view of the aforesaid analysis, the total compensation
is
reassessed at ₹13,80,080/-. However, in view of the finding of 25% contributory negligence attributable to the deceased, as affirmed hereinabove, the claimants shall be entitled to 75% of the reassessed compensation, which comes to ₹10,35,060/-. 14. Accordingly, after adjusting the amount of ₹8,78,010/- already
awarded by the Tribunal, the appellants/claimants shall be entitled to an additional compensation of ₹1,57,050/-. The aforesaid additional compensation shall carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition before the Tribunal till its actual realisation. The remaining terms and conditions of the impugned award shall remain unaltered. 15. Consequently, the appeal is partly allowed, and the impugned
award stands modified to the extent indicated hereinabove. 16. The Registry is directed to communicate the claimants in
writing “the enhanced/additional amount” in this appeal as against the award made by the concerned Tribunal. The said
communication be made in Hindi Deonagri language and the help of paralegal workers may be availed with a co-ordination of Secretary, Legal Aid of the concerned area wherein the claimants reside. Sd/(Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal) Judge