M/S Ellis Fashion Exports Private Limited v. M/S the Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Limited

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
2 November 2026
Judge
Justice Suraj Govindaraj
Case number
WP No. 5093 of 2025
Result
Partly Allowed
Acts & sections
Article 300A Constitution, Article 226 Constitution

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

-1HC-KAR

®

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 2ND DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ WRIT PETITION NO. 5093 OF 2025 (GM-RES) BETWEEN M/S ELLIS FASHION EXPORTS PRIVATE LIMITED A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956, HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT NO.29, WHITE HOUSE, 3RD FLOOR, ST. MARKS ROAD, BENGALURU 560 001, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR SRI. JITENDRA D MAJETHIA. AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS ... PETITIONER (BY SRI. RAJENDRA S., ADVOCATE)

AND 1. M/S THE BANGALORE METRO RAIL CORPORATION LIMITED REGISTERED OFFICE AT BMTC COMPLEX, 3RD FLOOR, K.H. ROAD, SHANTHI NAGAR, BENGALURU - 560 027. REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR. 2. ADDITIONAL CHIEF ENGINEER (CIVIL)/R5/P3 BANGALORE METRO RAIL CORPORATION LIMITED, REGISTERED OFFICE AT BMTC COMPLEX, 3RD FLOOR, K.H. ROAD, SHANTHI NAGAR, BENGALURU - 560 027. 3. GENERAL MANAGER, (LA AND A), BANGALORE METRO RAIL CORPORATION LIMITED, REGISTERED OFFICE AT BMTC COMPLEX, 3RD FLOOR, K.H. ROAD, SHANTHI NAGAR,

-2HC-KAR

BENGALURU - 560 027. …. RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. HARISH NARASIMHA MURTHY., ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3) THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF MANDAMUS OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT , ORDER OR DIRECTION, DECLARING THAT THE PROVISIONS OF THE WAY LEAVE POLICY OF THE RESPONDENTS PRODUCED AND MARKED AS ANNEXURE-C BEARING NO. BMRCL/LAQ/WLP/5132/2022-23 INCLUDING ITS UNILATERAL TERMINATION CLAUSE ARE UNCONSTITUTIONAL, INVALID AND UNENFORCEABLE AND ETC. THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS AND HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 17.08.2026, THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ

CAV ORDER 1.

The Petitioner is before this Court seeking for the following reliefs:

a. A writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order, or direction, declaring that the provisions of the Way Leave Policy of the Respondents produced and marked as Annexure-C bearing No. BMRCL/LAQ/WLP/5132/2022-23 including its unilateral termination clause are unconstitutional, invalid, and unenforceable. b. A writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order, or direction to the Respondents to provide, forthwith and on a permanent basis, an unrestricted 6 meter

-3HC-KAR

wide entry and a 6 meter wide exit to the Schedule Property from the northern side, free of cost, along with the necessary rights for the Petitioner to install and maintain essential utility connections (water, electricity, and sewage) on the relevant acquired land in favour of the Petitioner. c. A writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order, or direction to the Respondents to make good the loss as demanded under the legal notice of the Petitioner as per Annexure F dated 07/10/2024 and continue to pay such damages till such time the Respondents allow the Petitioner from getting accesses to schedule property as prayed for. d. Pass such other order/s including the award of costs, as this Hon'ble Court deems fit under the facts and circumstances of the case, in the interest of justice and equity.

2.

The Petitioner claims to be the absolute owner of the property

bearing

Bangalore

Mahanagar

Palike

Municipal No. 28/B, PID No. 57-137-28B, situated at Sarakki Industrial Layout, Bannerghatta Road, 3rd Phase, J. P. Nagar, Bengaluru, measuring 766.26 square metres. The property comprises a commercial building with a super built-up area of 21,839 square feet, consisting of the ground, first, second, third and fourth

floors.

According

to

Petitioner,

property originally had an independent and wide

-4HC-KAR

entry and exit on its eastern side, directly facing the main road. 3.

On 07.03.2017, Respondent No. 1, Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Limited (BMRCL), issued a letter informing the Petitioner that an extent of 152 square metres on the eastern side of the property would be acquired through the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Board (KIADB) for the construction of a metro station. The date 07.03.2017 is treated in this order as the date of acquisition of the said extent. Pursuant to the acquisition, a portion of the existing building was demolished and the metro station was constructed. The Petitioner contends that, in the course of these works, the entire access from the property to the main road was taken over, thereby leaving the remaining property without access.

4.

The Petitioner states that the property had been leased to M/s. GraphX Solution India Private Limited under a registered lease deed dated 01.07.2015. According to the Petitioner, the tenant was paying monthly

rent

of

Rs.12,01,145/-,

subject

to

an

escalation of 15% upon completion of every third year. The Petitioner further contends that, following the proposed demolition of a portion of the building

-5HC-KAR

and the consequent disconnection of the water, electricity and sewerage connections, the tenant vacated the premises in August 2019, and the demolition was carried out thereafter. Consequently, the property has remained vacant since August 2019, resulting in a continuing loss of rental income. 5.

The Petitioner also raises a dispute concerning the compensation paid for the acquired extent of 152 square metres. It is contended that compensation was paid only for 95.75 square metres, while compensation for the remaining 56.25 square metres was declined on the ground that the land constituted kharab land. The Petitioner challenged that decision in W.P. No. 4125/2023, in which this Court directed KIADB

to

take

steps

to

issue

necessary

corrections to a corrigendum so as to include the remaining extent of 56.25 square metres and make payment of compensation. 6.

On 15.04.2024, the Petitioner addressed a letter to BMRCL seeking access to the remaining property from the northern side through land acquired by BMRCL. The Petitioner sought a separate ingress and a separate egress, each measuring six metres in width, contending that such access was necessary

-6HC-KAR

having regard to the size and commercial use of the building and the number of persons using it. 7.

By its reply dated 28.06.2024, Respondent No. 2, the Additional Chief Engineer of BMRCL, informed the Petitioner that a combined access measuring six metres in width could be provided, subject to payment of the prescribed way-leave charges in advance and execution of a way-leave agreement for a period of ten years. The Petitioner did not accept the proposal.

8.

The Petitioner thereafter issued legal notices dated 05.10.2024 and 07.10.2024. In the notice dated 05.10.2024, the Petitioner contended that BMRCL had left the property without access to the main road and had unauthorisedly disconnected the water, electricity

sewerage

connections

during

construction of the metro station. The Petitioner further asserted that these acts had caused the tenant to vacate the premises and had resulted in financial loss. The Petitioner called upon BMRCL to provide a six-metre-wide entry and a six-metre-wide exit on the north-western side of the property, while reserving the right to claim damages.

-7HC-KAR

9.

By the subsequent legal notice dated 07.10.2024, the Petitioner quantified the loss of rental income and related amounts at Rs.11,30,36,834.57 as on the date of the notice. The Petitioner relied upon the rent payable under the registered lease deed, the stipulated escalation and the period during which the property remained vacant. A statement setting out the calculation of the rental loss and interest, together with a copy of the lease deed, was enclosed with the notice. The Petitioner called upon BMRCL to pay the amount claimed.

10. On 19.11.2024, BMRCL informed the Petitioner that a six-metre-wide entry and exit could be provided for a period of ten years and called upon the Petitioner to confirm in writing its acceptance of the applicable charges. By a reply dated 27.11.2024, the Petitioner disputed the demand for payment for the entire sixmetre width, relying upon Clause 4 of BMRCL's wayleave

policy,

under

which,

according

to

Petitioner, access up to 3.5 metres was to be provided free of cost. The Petitioner contended that BMRCL

could

not

demand

charges

for

access

necessitated by its own acts in blocking the existing ingress and egress. The Petitioner further maintained that, having regard to the size and commercial use of

-8HC-KAR

the property, permanent and unrestricted access was required and reiterated the request for a six-metrewide entry and exit from the northern side. 11. BMRCL responded on 23.12.2024, stating that the compensation already paid included compensation for the demolished building and that no further compensation was payable. It further stated that, following the demolition, the Petitioner had been permitted, upon request, to strengthen the floors extending from the line of acquisition towards the line of cut, at the Petitioner's own expense and without entitlement to compensation for such works. 12. BMRCL, while admitting that it demolished a portion of

building

after

taking

possession

of

acquired land, denied that it had disconnected the water, electricity and sewerage connections in the manner alleged by the Petitioner. It stated that the water

acquired

sewerage

portion

had

pipes

situated

within

been

closed

to

facilitate

construction of the metro station, as the property was lying vacant. According to BMRCL, there was consequently no need to restore those connections to

remaining

property.

It

also

disputed

Petitioner's claim that the tenant had vacated the

-9HC-KAR

premises or had been paying monthly rent of Rs.12,01,145/- with an escalation of 15% every three years. BMRCL contended that, if the Petitioner intended to lease the property, separate water and sewerage connections could have been obtained and that it could not be held responsible for the alleged loss of rental income. 13. With regard to access, BMRCL relied upon Clause 4 of its way-leave policy, stating that free access up to 3.5

metres

could

be

permitted

over

BMRCL's

property. It maintained that the policy did not extend to

providing

connections

water,

across

its

sewerage

or

electricity

property

that

Petitioner's demand for a six-metre-wide entry and exit was not permissible under the policy. BMRCL further contended that any right granted to the Petitioner to use its property for ingress and egress would be in the nature of a licence, subject to the applicable terms and conditions. It denied liability for the compensation and damages claimed by the Petitioner. 14. In

these

circumstances,

Petitioner

has

approached this Court seeking the reliefs set out in the petition.

- 10 HC-KAR

15.

Sri.S.Rajendra, learned counsel for the Petitioner would submit that:

15.1.

The

Petitioner

Bangalore

owns

Mahanagar

property

Palike

bearing

Municipal

No.

28/B, PID No. 57-137-28B, situated at Sarakki Industrial

Layout,

Phase,

P.

J.

Bannerghatta

Nagar,

Bengaluru,

Road,

3rd

measuring

766.26 square metres. The property comprises a commercial building with a super built-up area of 21,839 square feet, consisting of the ground, first, second, third and fourth floors. Before the acquisition, the property had a wide, independent access on its eastern side, directly facing the main road, with the entire frontage available for ingress and egress. 15.2.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that, by communication dated 07.03.2017, BMRCL informed the Petitioner that 152 square metres on the eastern side would be acquired through KIADB for construction of a Metro station. Following

acquisition,

road-facing

portion of the building was demolished and the Metro station was constructed. The Petitioner’s

- 11 HC-KAR

case is that the acquisition and construction blocked the entire former frontage and access to

main

property

road,

without

leaving

ingress

or

remaining

egress.

The

Petitioner further submits that access cannot be obtained through the Metro station. 15.3.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the effect assessed

of an acquisition must solely

by

reference

to

not

be

area

acquired. The effect on the remaining property is also relevant, particularly where the use of the acquired land affects the access, usability and commercial utility of the residual property. Payment of compensation for the acquired land and demolished structure does not, by itself, determine the separate question whether the remaining

property

has

been

left

with

reasonable and usable access. 15.4.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that

former

frontage

was

not

voluntarily

surrendered and that the Petitioner did not independently seek permission to use BMRCL’s land for an additional benefit. The land was compulsorily acquired by the State in exercise

- 12 HC-KAR

of its power of eminent domain. The need for alternative

access

arose,

according

to

Petitioner, because the Metro project removed the access previously available. The Petitioner therefore submits that its request should not be treated as an ordinary request for an additional facility or commercial advantage. 15.5.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the public purpose of the Metro project is not disputed. The issue is whether that purpose can be

achieved

foreseeable

while

effect

of

also

addressing

project

on

remaining property. The Petitioner does not seek to obstruct the project; it seeks an effective

means

of

continuing

to

use

property left after acquisition. 15.6.

Referring to the photographs produced before this Court, Learned Counsel submits that the Metro station abuts the Petitioner’s property and that the station wall blocks the eastern side that formerly provided direct access to the main road. The Petitioner relies on the photographs and site layout to contend that neither the former access nor an alternative access is

- 13 HC-KAR

available, his submission is that there is at present no Access to the property of the Petitioner. 15.7.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that, by

letter

dated

15.04.2024, the Petitioner

requested

access

from

northern

side

through land acquired by BMRCL. The request was for separate ingress and egress passages, each six metres wide, having regard to the size of the property, the commercial building and

movement

of

persons

vehicles

associated with its use. 15.8.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that, by communication dated 28.06.2024, BMRCL offered a single combined passage measuring six

metres

in

width,

subject

to

advance

payment of way-leave charges and execution of an agreement for ten years. The Petitioner did not accept the offer. BMRCL reiterated its position by communication dated 19.11.2024 and called upon the Petitioner to confirm acceptance Petitioner

of

submits

applicable that

a

charges.

single

The

six-metre

passage is not equivalent to two separate

- 14 HC-KAR

passages, each six metres wide, because the arrangements differ in width, configuration and the manner in which vehicles would enter and leave the property. 15.9.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that access must be assessed in the context of the building’s size and commercial use. The building has a super built-up area of 21,839 square feet and was leased to M/s. GraphX Solution India Private Limited under a registered lease deed dated 01.07.2015. The Petitioner submits that the building was being used commercially and generating rental income before the access and utility disputes arose. The requirements of such a

building

include

access

for

employees,

customers, visitors, service providers, delivery vehicles and the movement of goods, furniture, equipment

materials

required

for

maintenance and repairs. Pedestrian access, or a passage suitable only for limited vehicle movement,

would

not

necessarily

provide

effective access for the building’s intended use. 15.10. Learned

Counsel

for

Petitioner

further

submits that parking facilities have been made

- 15 HC-KAR

available for persons using the building. Those facilities cannot serve their intended purpose if vehicles cannot reach the property through a suitable passage. The width and configuration of access should therefore bear a reasonable relationship

to

property’s

dimensions,

location, commercial use and site conditions. The Petitioner submits that its request for separate six-metre-wide ingress and egress should be considered on its merits and not rejected

merely

by

reference

to

standard

categories in the way-leave policy. 15.11. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the adequacy of access also raises fire-safety and emergency-response concerns. Fire tenders and other emergency vehicles may need to approach the building. Suitability depends not only on the stated width of a passage but also on its turning radius, clear height, alignment, obstructions

ability

of

emergency

vehicles to reach the relevant part of the premises.

The

Petitioner

relies

on

approximate dimensions of passenger vehicles and larger vehicles, including buses, minibuses, goods trucks and fire tenders, to contend that a

- 16 HC-KAR

passage of limited width may not meet all the requirements of the property. Learned Counsel submits that these matters require technical assessment and cannot be resolved merely by referring to the minimum free-access width under the way-leave policy. 15.12. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that BMRCL’s policy regulates the use of its land, but does not, by itself, establish that every width permitted under the policy is suitable for every building. The technical adequacy of access and the financial terms on which it is provided are separate questions. The Petitioner’s case is that separate six-metre-wide ingress and egress are required for the effective use of the remaining property and should be assessed in light of the relevant site and safety requirements. 15.13. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner relies on Clause 4 of BMRCL’s way-leave policy, which, according to the Petitioner, provides for free access up to 3.5 metres for eligible properties. Learned Counsel submits that the policy must be

read

as

a

whole

applied

to

circumstances of this case. The provision for

- 17 HC-KAR

free access shows that the policy recognises the need to provide access to affected properties in at least some circumstances. BMRCL should therefore

consider

applies

whether

whether

provision Petitioner’s

circumstances justify a different or case-specific arrangement before demanding charges. 15.14. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that reliance on the 3.5-metre provision does not amount to acceptance of access limited to that width or of BMRCL’s offer of a combined sixmetre passage. The Petitioner maintains that the required access must be determined by reference

to

actual

site

conditions,

building’s commercial use and applicable safety requirements.

A

standard

width

may

be

adequate for some residential properties but, according

to

adequate

for

this

building.

Even

if

Petitioner,

may

substantial

policy

not

be

commercial prescribes

a

standard free width, the Court should consider whether that width is sufficient in this case and whether the policy permits a reasoned, casespecific arrangement.

- 18 HC-KAR

15.15. Learned

Counsel

for

Petitioner

further

submits that the policy provides for wider passages in the ranges of 3.5 to 7 metres, 7 to 12 metres and 12 to 20 metres, with charges calculated

at

different

applicable

guidance

percentages

value.

The

of

Petitioner

submits that these provisions recognise that access requirements vary, but that charging a landowner whose former access was removed through compulsory acquisition is arbitrary and causes prejudice. The Petitioner’s case is that BMRCL

must

reasonably

first

required

determine

provide

access effective

alternative access without charge, because the need for that access arose from the project. The

existence of charging

slabs

does not

remove the need to assess the suitability of the proposed arrangement or the reasonableness of the charges and conditions. 15.16. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that BMRCL requires advance payment of way-leave charges and an agreement for ten years. According to the Petitioner, the charges are calculated by reference to the guidance value notified by the State Government, with the

- 19 HC-KAR

applicable percentage depending on the width of the passage, and renewal charges are based on the guidance value prevailing at the time of renewal. The

Petitioner

contends

that

this

would impose a substantial financial burden on an owner who needs access only because the original

access

was

lost

through

a

public

project. Learned Counsel submits that BMRCL should not, in effect, charge rent for restoring access that the Petitioner previously enjoyed without charge, or use the acquisition-created need to derive a commercial benefit from the affected owner. 15.17. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that there is a material distinction between a person who voluntarily seeks to use BMRCL’s land for an additional benefit and an owner whose former access has been lost as a consequence of a public project. The Petitioner contends that ordinary licence charges may be relevant to the former situation but should not automatically apply where acquisition and construction have left the remaining property without access. The Petitioner further submits that BMRCL should not be permitted to take advantage of a

- 20 HC-KAR

situation caused by its own acquisition and construction activities. 15.18. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the former access to the Schedule Property was available

without

payment

of

way-leave

charges. Had the road-facing portion not been acquired, the Petitioner would, according to its case, have continued to enjoy that access. The Petitioner submits that compensation paid for the acquired land and demolished building does not include separately assessed compensation for the loss of access to the remaining property. It contends that the Respondents cannot treat alternative

access

as

a

new,

chargeable

privilege while leaving the loss of the former access unaddressed. The Petitioner submits that, at the least, any compensation properly payable for the loss of access should be considered

when

determining

cost

of

providing access on a continuing basis. The Petitioner characterises the proposed advance charges as expropriatory in their effect. 15.19. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner relies on Clause 3 of the way-leave policy, which is said

- 21 HC-KAR

to reserve to BMRCL the right to enter upon, pass through or use its land and to discontinue the way-leave facility without notice. The clause is

also

stated

to

exclude

liability

for

compensation or reimbursement and to impose no obligation to provide alternative access following submits

discontinuance. that

these

Learned

terms

do

Counsel

not

provide

adequate security or continuity for an owner who requires dependable access for the use of the property and for any tenant occupying the building. 15.20. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the risk of discontinuance is particularly serious where

Petitioner

is

required

to

make

substantial advance payment for a ten-year period. The payment obligation and BMRCL’s asserted power to discontinue access without notice or an alternative arrangement should be considered together. The Petitioner contends that this would place the owner in an unequal position and could leave the property without access even after payment. The Petitioner therefore challenges the policy insofar as it permits access to be made subject to conditions

- 22 HC-KAR

without adequate safeguards against leaving an affected property inaccessible. 15.21. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the way-leave policy, as applied to this case, is arbitrary

violates

Article

of

Constitution. The challenge is not merely to the use of standard categories or charges. It is that the policy and its application fail to account for relevant differences between properties and between the circumstances in which access is sought. A property with access from another road is not in the same position as a property whose only access has been blocked by a public project.

Likewise,

needs

of

a

small

residential property may differ from those of a substantial commercial building. The location, dimensions, frontage, intended use, number of occupants,

vehicle

requirements

movements,

availability

of

safety

alternative

access are all relevant considerations. 15.22. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that a uniform policy may provide an administrative framework, but its application must comply with constitutional requirements. If the policy

- 23 HC-KAR

does not permit meaningful consideration of an affected property’s circumstances, or if BMRCL refuses

to

consider

relevant

factors

when

deciding the Petitioner’s request, the resulting decision may be arbitrary even if the policy serves a legitimate administrative purpose in general. The Petitioner contends that BMRCL has

not

adequately

explained

why

requested arrangement is unsuitable, why a combined

six-metre

passage

would

be

sufficient, or why the policy must be applied without modification in the circumstances of this case. 15.23. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that BMRCL has treated the way-leave policy as inflexible and has declined to consider the particular consequences of its acquisition and construction

activities.

The

Petitioner

accordingly challenges the policy at Annexure-C as unconstitutional, ultra vires, invalid and unenforceable to the extent that it fails to provide for fair, case-specific consideration of the circumstances pleaded, permits access to be denied or discontinued without adequate safeguards,

allows

a

time-bound,

- 24 HC-KAR

chargeable arrangement to be imposed without adequately addressing the loss of the access previously enjoyed. The Petitioner seeks a declaration to that effect and a consequential writ of mandamus directing the Respondents to provide the access claimed in the writ petition. 15.24. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the loss of access has affected the Petitioner’s ability to use the property for commercial purposes.

According

to

Petitioner,

tenant, M/s. GraphX Solution India Private Limited, vacated the premises in August 2019 following

proposed

demolition

interruption of utility services, and the building has remained vacant since then. The absence of effective access has impaired occupation, delivery of goods, maintenance, emergency response and the ability to lease the premises. Learned Counsel submits that the practical effect of the denial of access must be assessed in the context of the building’s established commercial use. 15.25. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the Petitioner does not contend that Article

- 25 HC-KAR

19(1)(g) guarantees every property owner the precise width of access preferred by that owner. The submission is that the State and its instrumentalities must consider the effect of their actions on the ability to use property for lawful commercial purposes. Where a public project

removes

former

access,

authority must consider whether the alternative arrangement is reasonable and effective. The Petitioner contends that the failure to do so in the present case infringes Article 19(1)(g). Learned Counsel further submits that the public purpose of the Metro project does not answer the separate question whether the remaining property

can

still

be

used

lawfully

effectively for commercial purposes. 15.26. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner also relies on Article 300A of the Constitution. The Petitioner acknowledges

that

acquisition

was

undertaken for a public purpose, but submits that the Court should consider the substance and effect of the action, rather than only the formal extent of the land acquired. According to the Petitioner, the use made of the acquired land has deprived the remaining property of the

- 26 HC-KAR

access required for its effective enjoyment. The consequences for the residual property must therefore

be

considered

compensation

for

separately

land

from

structure

actually acquired. 15.27. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the Petitioner does not seek to treat every inconvenience caused by a public project as a constitutional violation. Its case is that the loss is substantial: the former access has been blocked,

alternative

access

remains

disputed, and the proposed arrangement is subject

to

charges

conditions

that,

according to the Petitioner, do not secure dependable access. The Petitioner submits that compensation for the acquired land cannot automatically extinguish every separate claim arising from the effect of the acquisition on the remaining property. The access dispute must be determined on its own facts and under the applicable law. 15.28. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner further relies on Article 21 in relation to the safety of persons who

may

occupy

or

use

commercial

- 27 HC-KAR

building. The Petitioner submits that the access arrangement should not be treated solely as a dispute about licence charges. Its adequacy also affects emergency response and the safety of persons within the premises. In particular,

Petitioner

permanent

submits

that

unrestricted

requested

access

under

prayer (b) a six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre egress from the northern side, is relevant to fire safety and emergency response and thus to the life and liberty of persons using the building of the Petitioner. 15.29. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the Respondents’ offer of a single passage, of which 3.5 metres is free and anything above that width is chargeable, would not provide adequate access for fire tenders and other emergency vehicles. An emergency at the Schedule Property could also pose a risk to the adjoining

Metro

station,

its

operations,

commuters and members of the public. The Petitioner submits that access must therefore be

assessed

by

reference

to

actual

emergency-access requirements of the building

potential

consequences

for

- 28 HC-KAR

adjoining solely

Metro

by

infrastructure,

reference

to

a

rather

than

nominal

width

prescribed by policy. These considerations are relied upon in support of the specific mandamus sought under prayer (b). 15.30. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the claim for damages under prayer (c) has two components:

(i)

past

Annexure-F

dated

losses

quantified

07.10.2024;

in (ii)

continuing damages arising from the ongoing deprivation of effective access. The past claim relates to the period up to the date of the legal notice and is based on rental income said to have been lost after the tenant vacated the building.

The

Petitioner

submits

that

proposed subsequent reconnection of water, electricity and sewerage facilities does not extinguish the accrued claim, because proposed restoration of those utilities neither reverses past rental loss nor remedies the continuing access problem. 15.31. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that continuing damages are claimed for the period after 07.10.2024, for so long as the Schedule

- 29 HC-KAR

Property

remains

commercial

use

incapable

of

effective

occupation

because

adequate ingress and egress have not been provided. The Petitioner seeks damages until the permanent and unrestricted access claimed under prayer (b) is provided. The claim for past damages and the claim for continuing damages thus relate to distinct periods. The Petitioner submits that both are covered by prayer (c), subject to adjudication on the pleadings and material on record. 15.32. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that

property

Solution

was

India

leased

Private

to

M/s.

Limited

GraphX

under

a

registered lease deed dated 01.07.2015, at a monthly

rent

of

Rs.12,01,145/-,

with

an

escalation of 15% upon completion of every third year. The Petitioner contends that the tenant

vacated

in

August

2019

after

demolition and disconnection of utility services, and that the premises have remained vacant since then. By legal notice dated 07.10.2024, the Petitioner quantified rental loss and related amounts at Rs.11,30,36,834.57 and enclosed a statement calculating the claimed loss and

- 30 HC-KAR

interest by reference to the lease deed. Learned Counsel submits that the claim is based on identifiable contractual and financial records and should be assessed in light of those records. 15.33. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that, by communication dated 23.12.2024, BMRCL stated that the compensation paid included compensation for the demolished building and that no further compensation was payable. BMRCL also stated that the Petitioner had been permitted, at its own expense, to strengthen the floors from the line of acquisition towards

line

of

cut,

without

entitlement

to

compensation for those works. The Petitioner submits that these statements do not resolve the separate issues concerning loss of access to the remaining property, interruption of utilities,

adequacy

of

proposed

alternative

passage, or the terms governing its continued use. 15.34. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner refers to the separate dispute concerning compensation for the 152 square metres acquired. The Petitioner

- 31 HC-KAR

submits that compensation was paid for only 95.75 square metres and that compensation for the remaining 56.25 square metres was refused on the ground that the land was classified as kharab land. The Petitioner challenged that refusal

in

W.P.

No.

4125/2023.

In

that

proceeding, this Court directed KIADB to take steps to issue a corrigendum containing the necessary corrections, including the remaining extent of 56.25 square metres, and to make payment of compensation. Learned Counsel submits that this dispute is distinct from the access grievance and that the circumstances demonstrate

need

to

consider

Petitioner’s claims fairly. 15.35. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that

compensation

dispute

access

dispute must be kept distinct. The former concerns payment for the land acquired; the latter concerns the loss of access to the remaining property and the conditions on which alternative access is offered. Resolution of the compensation dispute would not, by itself, resolve

access

issue.

Conversely,

access claim should not replace consideration of

- 32 HC-KAR

whether

directions

concerning

remaining 56.25 square metres have been complied with. 15.36. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that prayer (b) seeks substantive and prospective relief by way of a mandamus directing the Respondents

to

provide

permanent

unrestricted access to the remaining Schedule Property, comprising a six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre egress from the northern side, together with the necessary rights to install

maintain

water,

electricity

sewerage facilities. The Petitioner submits that this relief is intended to secure access and enable the property’s use and

occupation.

Compensation

land

for

acquired

demolished structure does not, by itself, satisfy this separate claim. 15.37. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that prayer (c) seeks monetary relief for the losses quantified in Annexure-F dated 07.10.2024 and continuing damages until the access sought under

prayer

concerns

loss

(b)

is

of

provided. rental

The

claim

income

- 33 HC-KAR

consequential losses said to arise from the continued

deprivation

of

access

to

remaining property. The Petitioner submits that it is not a claim for duplicate compensation for the acquired land or demolished structure. An order

providing

access

may

remove

continuing impediment to use of the property, but

would

not,

by

itself,

determine

extinguish losses accrued before provided.

The

Petitioner

or

access is

accordingly

seeks

separate consideration of the monetary relief under prayer (c), in addition to the access relief under prayer (b). 15.38. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the central issue is not merely the amount of way-leave charges. It is whether the remaining property was left without access as a result of

public

proposed

project

solution

reasonable.

The

is

whether

adequate, Petitioner

BMRCL’s

lawful

seeks

an

arrangement that accounts for the physical configuration

of

site,

building’s

commercial use, the movement of vehicles and goods, applicable safety requirements and the need for continuity of access. The Petitioner

- 34 HC-KAR

maintains its request for separate six-metrewide ingress and six-metre-wide egress. 15.39. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the Petitioner is also willing, if effective and dependable

access

cannot

reasonably

be

provided, for BMRCL to acquire the remaining portion

of

property

upon

payment

of

appropriate compensation. This is advanced as an alternative and not as an admission that acquisition

of

remaining

necessary.

The

primary

relief

property

is

remains

provision of effective access on lawful and reasonable

terms.

The

alternative

is

put

forward because the Petitioner does not wish to remain indefinitely dependent on a licence that may be discontinued under the terms of the policy. 15.40. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner accordingly submits

that

Respondents

should

be

directed to provide permanent and unrestricted access to the Schedule Property in the manner sought under prayer (b), including a six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre egress from the northern side, together with the necessary

- 35 HC-KAR

utility

rights.

The

Petitioner

also

seeks

adjudication of its claim for past and continuing damages under prayer (c), and a declaration that

Annexure-C,

way-leave

policy,

is

unconstitutional, invalid and unenforceable to the extent pleaded, or, alternatively, a direction requiring BMRCL to apply the policy fairly and give a reasoned decision after considering the particular circumstances of the case. If effective access cannot reasonably be provided, the Petitioner seeks consideration of acquisition of the remaining property in accordance with law. 16.

Sri.Harish Narasimha Murthy, learned counsel for BMRCL, would submit that:

16.1.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that BMRCL is a joint venture company in which

State

Government

Government

each

hold

50%

Central of

shareholding. It was established to implement the Bangalore Metro Rail project, a major urban infrastructure transit

for

project

providing

benefit

Bengaluru.

of

rapid

mass

citizens

of

- 36 HC-KAR

16.2.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that BMRCL formulated the Way Leave Policy after due consideration to provide access where acquisition for the Metro project leaves a property without access. The policy recognises a right of necessity by providing free access up to 3.5 metres, while requiring payment for any additional width. The Respondents submit that the policy establishes a fair and transparent mechanism that balances access to affected properties

with

public

interest

operational requirements of the Metro project. 16.3.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the writ petition is not maintainable and that the Petitioner is estopped from challenging the Way Leave Policy. The Petitioner’s letter dated 31.07.2024 is said to record willingness to pay the applicable way-leave licence charges for access beyond the free entitlement of 3.5 metres. The Respondents contend that, having expressed cannot

such

willingness,

approbate

reprobate

subsequently challenging the policy.

Petitioner by

- 37 HC-KAR

16.4.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the Petitioner has no vested right to demand free access of 12 metres. BMRCL is prepared to provide 3.5 metres of access free of charge under the policy and to consider an additional five metres, subject to compliance with the policy and payment of the prescribed licence fee. The Respondents submit that no access beyond the additional five metres can be considered and that the Petitioner is bound by the policy. According to the Respondents, the Petitioner cannot challenge the policy merely on the basis of its own assertions, particularly when the different rates for different widths of access were prescribed after due consideration by BMRCL, which has the relevant technical expertise and personnel.

16.5.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the Petitioner’s claim for damages and further compensation raises disputed questions of fact that cannot appropriately be determined in

proceedings

under

Article

of

Constitution. The Respondents contend that the Petitioner should approach the competent Civil Court to seek damages, compensation or a

- 38 HC-KAR

declaration

of

easementary

rights,

where

evidence can be led. Learned Counsel submits that such claims cannot be adjudicated merely by filing a writ petition. 16.6.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the acquisition was carried out under the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Act, 1966 (“KIAD Act”). A sum of Rs.4,01,44,404/was paid to the Petitioner as compensation for the acquired land and building. According to the Respondents,

Petitioner

accepted

that

compensation in respect of the acquisition and cannot claim further compensation on account of

same

acquisition.

Learned

Counsel

further submits that the compensation was calculated

at

together

with

200%

of

solatium

market

value,

interest,

in

accordance with the Right to Fair Compensation

Transparency

in

Land

Acquisition,

Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. 16.7.

On this basis, the Respondents contend that BMRCL is entitled to levy licence charges for access beyond the free 3.5-metre entitlement

- 39 HC-KAR

and that such charges are neither unreasonable nor arbitrary. 16.8.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents admits that 152 square metres of the Petitioner’s property was acquired. The boundaries of the acquired land were recorded as follows: East— road; West—remaining portion of Property No. 28/B; North—property of Prema Raghu N. V.; and South—property of Madhusudhan P. Patel. Learned Counsel submits that the acquired land lies on the eastern side and now forms part of BMRCL’s property.

16.9.

It is also admitted that BMRCL demolished a portion of the building after taking possession from

Special

Land

Acquisition

Officer

(“SLAO”), and that compensation was paid for the demolished portion. 16.10. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the land over which access is sought belongs to BMRCL and is required for its Metro infrastructure.

The

Petitioner

has

no

independent right to use that land apart from the benefit available under the Way Leave Policy.

According

to

Respondents,

- 40 HC-KAR

access permitted under the policy is not a vested right and remains subject to BMRCL’s discretion. This, he submits, is why the policy reserves the right to cancel the permission to use

BMRCL’s

land.

Learned

Counsel

nevertheless submits that, if the Petitioner pays the prescribed licence fee, BMRCL would not cancel the licence and would enter into renewal agreements from time to time, so long as the applicable fee continues to be paid. 16.11. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that

Petitioner’s

request

for

water,

electricity and sewerage connections through BMRCL’s land from the northern side is not covered by the Way Leave Policy. BMRCL therefore denies that it is obliged under the policy to provide those connections. However, he submits that in response to the Petitioner’s representation,

a

joint

inspection

was

conducted on 28.03.2025 in the presence of the Tahsildar,

BMRCL’s

Assistant

Engineer

Legal Advisor. 16.12. During the inspection, locations for laying the electricity,

sewage

water

lines

were

- 41 HC-KAR

marked, as shown in Annexure-R2 to the objections.

Learned

Counsel

submits

that

BMRCL is willing to permit the water line, sanitary line and electricity line to be laid at the marked locations. 16.13. Learned Counsel for the Respondents further submits that BMRCL is willing to provide an additional five metres of access, over and above the free 3.5-metre passage, subject to compliance with the Way Leave Policy and payment

of

Respondents

prescribed

maintain

that

amounts.

The

BMRCL

not

is

obliged to provide the 12 metres of access sought by the Petitioner and that any additional access

beyond

free

entitlement

is

conditional on payment under the policy. 16.14. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that BMRCL is not aware of the terms of the alleged lease of the property to M/s. GraphX Solution India Private Limited or the rent payable

under

Respondents

it.

In

contend

that

any

event,

lease,

amount of rent and the tenant’s decision to

- 42 HC-KAR

vacate are matters between the Petitioner and the tenant and do not concern BMRCL. 16.15. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that, if this Court were to hold the Way Leave Policy invalid, the Petitioner could not rely on that policy to claim even the free 3.5-metre passage. The Respondents contend that the Petitioner would then have to approach the competent

Civil

Court

establish

an

easementary right, including any claim based on easement of necessity. Such a claim, they submit,

requires

evidence

cannot

be

determined in the present writ proceedings. 16.16. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the land on the northern side of the Petitioner’s

property

is

also

required

for

BMRCL’s infrastructure project. The acquired property was required for construction of the Jayadeva

Hospital

Metro

Station

on

Bannerghatta Road, which serves thousands of Metro users in the area. The Respondents maintain that the acquisition and construction of the station were lawful and proper and

- 43 HC-KAR

cannot

be

challenged

in

present

Respondents

proceedings. 16.17. Learned

Counsel

for

accordingly submits that the applicable licence charges are authorised by the Way Leave Policy and are not arbitrary. BMRCL is willing to provide free access up to 3.5 metres, consider an additional five metres subject to payment and compliance with the policy, and permit the laying of water, electricity and sewerage lines at

locations

marked

during

joint

inspection. The Respondents contend that the claims for damages, further compensation and easementary rights involve disputed questions of fact that should be pursued before the competent

Civil

Court.

On

these

grounds,

Learned Counsel prays that the writ petition be dismissed. 17.

Heard

Sri.S.Rajendra,

learned

counsel

for

Petitioner and Sri.Harish Narasimha Murthy, learned counsel for BMRCL, and perused papers. 18.

The points that would arise for consideration are as follows:

- 44 HC-KAR

(i)

Whether the writ petition is maintainable in its present form, having regard to the Respondents’ objections concerning the disputed questions of fact, the availability of a civil remedy and the alleged estoppel arising from Petitioner’s communication dated 31.07.2024?

(ii)

Whether the Petitioner has established grounds for declaring the impugned Way Leave Policy bearing No. BMRCL/LAQ/WLP/5132/2022-23, including its unilateral termination clause, unconstitutional, invalid unenforceable, as sought under prayer (a) of the writ petition?

(iii) Whether the Petitioner is entitled to a writ of mandamus under prayer (b), directing the Respondents to provide, permanently and free of cost, an unrestricted sixmetre-wide ingress and a separate sixmetre-wide egress to Schedule Property from the northern side, together with the necessary rights to install and maintain water, electricity and sewerage connections over the relevant acquired land; and, in particular, whether the Respondents can restrict such access to the arrangement contemplated under the impugned Way Leave Policy and subject any additional access to licence charges and time-bound conditions? (iv) Whether the compensation paid in respect of the acquired land and demolished

- 45 HC-KAR

structure precludes the Petitioner from pursuing its distinct claim for damages arising from the alleged loss of access to the remaining Schedule Property? (v)

Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the monetary relief sought under prayer (c), namely, recovery of the amount of ₹11,30,36,834.57 claimed under Annexure-F dated 07.10.2024 continuing damages until the access sought under prayer (b) is provided; and whether such relief can appropriately be adjudicated in present writ proceedings, having regard to Respondents’ objections concerning disputed facts, causation and the alleged loss of rental income?

(vi) What order? 19.

This Court answers the above points as follows:

20.

Answer to Point No. (i): Whether the writ petition is maintainable in its present form, having regard to the Respondents’ objections concerning the disputed questions of fact, the availability of a civil remedy and the alleged estoppel arising from Petitioner’s communication dated 31.07.2024?

20.1.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, Shri S. Rajendra, submits that the Petitioner does not challenge the acquisition of its land or the

- 46 HC-KAR

public

purpose

grievance

is

of

that

Metro

project.

The

acquisition

construction of the Metro station have left the remaining Schedule Property without access. The challenge is directed against the conditions imposed by BMRCL for providing access to the property. The Petitioner seeks relief under prayers (a) and (b) of the writ petition. 20.2.

The

Petitioner

submits

that

its

refusal

to

execute the proposed way-leave agreement does not amount to refusal to cooperate with BMRCL. Its letter dated 31.07.2024 expressed willingness to pay the applicable charges for additional

access

but

did

not

amount

to

acceptance of the Policy or its conditions. The Petitioner disputes the financial burden imposed and the absence of any assurance that access would continue. Reliance on Clause 4 of the Way

Leave

Policy

does

not

amount

to

acceptance of access limited to 3.5 metres or of BMRCL’s proposal for a combined six-metre passage. 20.3.

The Petitioner submits that the dispute is not confined to way-leave charges. The principal

- 47 HC-KAR

issue

is

whether

remaining

property

BMRCL

can

without

leave

access

as

a

consequence of a public project and then insist on access only on the terms of its Policy. The Petitioner relies on Articles 14 and 300A of the Constitution and also invokes Articles 19(1)(g) and 21. 20.4.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents, Shri Harish Narasimha Murthy, submits that BMRCL is a joint venture of the State Government and

Central

Government,

established

to

implement the Bengaluru Metro Rail project, which serves an important public purpose. 20.5.

The Respondents raise three objections to maintainability.

First,

dispute

involves

questions of fact, including the alleged loss of rental income and the claim for damages, which require determination by a civil court. Second, the Petitioner has an alternative remedy before the civil court by way of a suit for easement of necessity. Third, the Petitioner’s letter dated 31.07.2024, expressing willingness to pay the applicable way-leave charges, precludes it from

- 48 HC-KAR

challenging the Policy under the principle of approbation and reprobation. 20.6.

The Respondents further submit that, if the Policy is set aside, the Petitioner must establish its right to an easement before the competent civil court. They also rely on the court fee paid in the writ petition and contend that the acquisition

construction

of

Metro

station were undertaken for a public purpose and should not be questioned. 20.7.

The

Petitioner

does

not

challenge

acquisition or the construction of the Jayadeva Hospital Metro Station. It accepts that the project serves a public purpose. The validity of the acquisition and construction is therefore not in issue in this writ petition. 20.8.

The writ petition seeks three distinct forms of relief: 20.8.1.

Prayer (a) challenges the validity of the Way Leave Policy, including its unilateral termination clause.

20.8.2.

Prayer

(b)

seeks

permanent

unrestricted

access

to

Schedule

- 49 HC-KAR

Property, comprising a six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre egress from the northern side, together with the necessary

rights

relating

to

utility

connections. 20.8.3.

Prayer (c) seeks the amount claimed in the legal notice dated 07.10.2024 and continuing

damages

until the

access

sought under prayer (b) is provided. 20.9.

The maintainability of the writ petition must be examined separately in relation to each relief.

FIRST

OBJECTION:

DISPUTED

QUESTIONS

OF

FACT 20.10. Article 226 of the Constitution empowers the High Court to issue writs for the enforcement of fundamental rights and for any other purpose. The existence of disputed questions of fact does not,

by

itself,

bar

exercise

of

writ

jurisdiction. The Court must examine the nature of the dispute, the facts requiring determination and the relief sought. 20.11. In Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks [(1998) 8 SCC 1] and Radha

- 50 HC-KAR

Krishan Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh [(2021) 6 SCC 771], the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the availability of an alternative remedy is not an absolute bar to the exercise of writ jurisdiction. The Court must determine

whether

particular

claim

is

appropriate for consideration under Article 226. 20.12. BMRCL

is

a

public-sector

joint

venture

established to implement the Metro project. The impugned Policy governs the conditions on which affected property owners may obtain access

over

land

under

its

control.

The

challenge concerns the exercise of public power and raises an issue under Article 14. The objection to jurisdiction cannot be sustained merely because the dispute concerns land or access. 20.13. In relation to prayer (a), the principal issue is the legal validity of the impugned provisions of the Way Leave Policy. The Policy is a written instrument issued by BMRCL. Its terms and legal effect can be examined on the basis of the record. The constitutional validity of the Policy

- 51 HC-KAR

is a matter for the Constitutional Court and cannot be determined by a civil court. 20.14. In relation to prayer (b), BMRCL admits that 152 square metres of land on the eastern side were acquired, that the acquired portion is under its control and that part of the building was

demolished

following

acquisition.

BMRCL’s proposal to provide access from the northern side also establishes that access over land under its control forms part of the dispute. These matters can be considered on the basis of the pleadings, admissions, correspondence and other documents on record. 20.15. These

admissions

do

not,

by

themselves,

establish the precise access to

which the

Petitioner is entitled. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to a six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre egress, whether those dimensions are legally required and whether access must be provided free of charge are matters to be determined under the point concerning prayer (b). For the present point, it is sufficient that the claim for access can be examined in writ proceedings.

- 52 HC-KAR

20.16. BMRCL disputes the lease in favour of M/s. GraphX Solution India Private Limited, the rent payable, the tenant’s departure and the alleged loss of rental income. These matters principally concern prayer (c). A dispute over the amount or cause of the alleged loss does not prevent the Court from examining the legal validity of the Policy or the claim for access. 20.17. BMRCL has not identified any specific factual dispute concerning prayers (a) and (b) that necessarily requires oral evidence before those claims can be considered. The objection based on disputed questions of fact is therefore rejected insofar as it concerns prayers (a) and (b). The monetary claim under prayer (c) is considered separately under Point No. (v). SECOND OBJECTION: AVAILABILITY OF A CIVIL REMEDY 20.18. The Respondents contend that the Petitioner must institute a civil suit for an easement of necessity. The availability of a civil remedy does not automatically oust the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226. The question is

- 53 HC-KAR

whether

nature

of

relief

sought

warrants consideration in writ proceedings. 20.19. Prayer (a) challenges the validity of a Policy issued by

a

public body on constitutional

grounds. A civil suit for an easement would not resolve

that

challenge.

The

Petitioner’s

grievance concerns not merely the existence of a right of passage but also the conditions imposed by BMRCL for providing access under its

Policy.

The

constitutional

challenge

is

therefore appropriate for consideration by this Court. 20.20. BMRCL itself relies on the Policy as the basis for offering access over land under its control. It also states that the Policy recognises access where a property has been left without an outlet.

This

establishes

that

dispute

concerns, at least in part, the terms on which BMRCL proposes to provide access under its own Policy. 20.21. The correspondence shows that the parties have not reached an agreement on those terms. BMRCL offered a combined six-metre passage subject to charges and a time-limited

- 54 HC-KAR

agreement.

The

Petitioner

sought

separate

ingress and egress and disputed the proposed conditions.

BMRCL’s

subsequent

position

regarding free access and additional access on payment is considered under the point dealing with prayer (b). 20.22. The history of the dispute also does not warrant rejection of the writ petition. BMRCL informed the Petitioner in 2017 that land would be acquired for the project. The demolition of part of

building

is

admitted.

The

parties

exchanged correspondence concerning access in 2024, followed by the present writ petition in 2025.

This

history

does

not

require

Petitioner to pursue a civil remedy before the Court considers prayers (a) and (b). 20.23. The objection based on the court fee paid in the writ petition is also untenable. The issue is whether the reliefs sought are appropriate for consideration under Article 226, not whether the court fee is lower than that payable in a civil suit. 20.24. The objection that the Petitioner must first institute

a

civil

suit

for

an

easement

of

- 55 HC-KAR

necessity is therefore rejected insofar as it concerns prayers (a) and (b). This conclusion does not determine the nature or extent of any easementary

right

or

precise

access

arrangement to which the Petitioner is entitled. Those issues fall for consideration under the point dealing with prayer (b). THIRD OBJECTION: ESTOPPEL ARISING FROM THE LETTER DATED 31.07.2024 20.25. The Respondents contend that the Petitioner expressed

willingness

in

its

letter

dated

31.07.2024 to pay the applicable charges for access beyond 3.5 metres and cannot now challenge the Policy. 20.26. A statement of willingness to pay for access on proposed terms does not amount to acceptance of the validity of every provision of the Policy. The

Petitioner

challenges,

among

other

matters, the Policy’s termination clause and the conditions

imposed

for

access.

The

Respondents have not established that the Petitioner expressly accepted those provisions or abandoned its right to challenge them.

- 56 HC-KAR

20.27. The

principle

against

approbating

reprobating prevents a party from accepting and obtaining a benefit under a transaction while challenging that same transaction to secure

an

application

inconsistent requires

advantage.

acceptance

Its

of

transaction and the benefit flowing from it. A mere expression of willingness to proceed on proposed

terms

does

not

satisfy

that

requirement. 20.28. BMRCL’s own case is that access would be provided only after the agreement was signed and the required payment was made. It does not contend that the Petitioner signed the agreement,

obtained

access

under

it

or

otherwise received any benefit under the Policy. The Petitioner’s willingness to pay for additional access

therefore

does

not

amount

to

acceptance of the Policy as a whole. 20.29. The subsequent correspondence confirms that no final agreement was reached. The Petitioner sought access on 15.04.2024, did not accept BMRCL’s

proposal

subsequently

dated

objected to

28.06.2024

charges

- 57 HC-KAR

conditions

in

its

27.11.2024.

The

communication

correspondence

dated

does

not

establish that the dispute was settled or that

Petitioner

unequivocally

abandoned

its

challenge. 20.30. The Respondents have also not established that they changed their position to their detriment in reliance on the letter dated 31.07.2024. Their case is that access was not provided because the Petitioner did not sign the agreement. This does

not

establish

estoppel

against

Petitioner. 20.31. The objection based on estoppel is therefore rejected. The letter dated 31.07.2024 does not preclude the Petitioner from challenging the Policy. 20.32. The

Respondents’

objections

must

be

considered separately in relation to the reliefs sought. Prayer (a) raises a constitutional issue concerning the validity of a Policy issued by a public body. Prayer (b) concerns access to the remaining property and can be considered on the basis of the pleadings, admissions and documents on record. The disputed claim for

- 58 HC-KAR

damages under prayer (c) requires a separate assessment

of

facts

of

whether

monetary relief can properly be granted in writ proceedings. 20.33. This Court accordingly answers Point No. (i) by rejecting the objection to maintainability insofar as

it

concerns

prayers

(a)

(b).

The

availability of a civil suit for an easement of necessity does not require the Petitioner to pursue that remedy before this Court considers those prayers. The Respondents have also failed

to

31.07.2024

establish

that

estops

letter

dated

Petitioner

from

challenging the Policy. 20.34. The maintainability and merits of the monetary claim under prayer (c) are left for separate consideration under Point No. (v).

21.

Answer to Point No. (ii): Whether the Petitioner has established grounds for declaring the impugned Way Leave Policy bearing No. BMRCL/LAQ/WLP/5132/2022-23, including its unilateral termination clause, unconstitutional, invalid and unenforceable, as sought under prayer (a) of the writ petition?

- 59 HC-KAR

21.1.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, Shri S. Rajendra, challenges the Way Leave Policy at Annexure-C.

He

submits

that

Policy

prescribes different charges for passages of different widths—3.5 to 7 metres, 7 to 12 metres and 12 to 20 metres. This recognises that access requirements vary. The Petitioner submits that BMRCL must consider the actual need for access and the circumstances that created it, rather than apply the charging schedule

without

adequate

regard

to

individual case. 21.2.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the Policy requires ten years’ charges to be paid in advance and calculates renewal charges by reference to the guidance value then prevailing. These conditions impose a substantial burden on an owner who requires access because the original frontage was acquired for the Metro project.

The

applicant

Petitioner

seeking

distinguishes

additional

access

an for

convenience from an owner whose existing access

was

lost

through

acquisition.

The

Petitioner had direct access from the main road before

acquisition

submits

that

- 60 HC-KAR

compensation

for

acquired

land

demolished portion of the building did not separately compensate for the loss of access to the remaining property. 21.3.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner challenges Clause 3, which permits BMRCL to discontinue access without notice, compensation, refund or an alternative route. The Petitioner submits that these conditions make access uncertain even after substantial advance payment. Where BMRCL controls the only effective route, the power to withdraw access should be subject to safeguards, including notice, reasons and a suitable alternative arrangement. The Petitioner states that it declined to sign the proposed agreement because of its terms, not because it was unwilling to cooperate.

21.4.

On

Article

14,

Learned

Counsel

for

Petitioner submits that the Policy does not adequately distinguish owners who have other access from those whose only access was lost through acquisition. Nor does it sufficiently account for differences between properties, including the needs of a substantial commercial

- 61 HC-KAR

building.

The

challenge

is

not

merely

to

standard categories or charges, but to their application without fair consideration of the affected

owner’s

circumstances.

Learned

Counsel also relies on Article 300A and submits that

effect

of

acquisition

on

remaining property must be considered, rather than only the area acquired. Article 19(1)(g) is relied on in relation to lawful commercial use, but the Petitioner

does not claim that

it

guarantees the precise width of access sought. Article 21 was referred to in connection with fire safety. 21.5.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents, Shri Harish Narasimha Murthy, submits that the Policy was framed after due consideration to provide access where acquisition for the Metro project has left a property without an outlet. It recognises a right of necessity by allowing a passage up to 3.5 metres free of charge and prescribing According

charges to

for

additional

Respondents,

width. Policy

provides a fair and transparent system that balances property owners’ needs with public

- 62 HC-KAR

interest and the operational requirements of the Metro project. 21.6.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the Petitioner has no vested right to demand 12 metres of free access and must comply with the Policy if it seeks additional access.

The

Respondents

rely

on

compensation paid for the acquisition, said to have been calculated at 200% of market value, together with solatium and interest under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land

Acquisition,

Rehabilitation

Resettlement Act, 2013. They contend that charging for additional access is not arbitrary. The Respondents further submit that the land belongs to BMRCL, access is permitted at its discretion,

termination

provision

protects BMRCL’s control over its land. They state that, if charges are paid, BMRCL will not cancel the arrangement and will renew it from time to time. 21.7.

Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the rates for different widths were fixed after

due

consideration

by

a

competent

- 63 HC-KAR

authority with the technical expertise required for the Metro project. The Respondents contend that the Court should not interfere merely because the Petitioner considers the charges excessive. They also argue that, if the Policy is invalidated, the Petitioner may lose even the benefit of the free 3.5-metre passage and may have to establish an easement before a civil court. The alternative-remedy objection has been considered under Point (i). 21.8.

This point concerns prayer (a), which seeks a declaration that the Way Leave Policy, including its

unilateral

termination

clause,

is

unconstitutional, invalid and unenforceable. The challenge must be decided on the grounds pleaded and the terms of the Policy. The Court does not sit in appeal over every policy choice made by a public authority, nor is it required to decide in the abstract whether a particular percentage of guidance value is the correct charge. The question is whether the challenged provisions are fair and lawful when applied to an owner whose access or frontage was lost through BMRCL’s acquisition for the Metro project.

- 64 HC-KAR

21.9.

The

Policy

is

dated

07.07.2022.

BMRCL

acquired the relevant land on 07.03.2017, and the Petitioner states that the tenant vacated in August 2019 and that part of the building was demolished thereafter. The Policy was issued after the events giving rise to this dispute, but BMRCL has applied it to the Petitioner and relied

on

it

in

its

correspondence

submissions. Its validity must therefore be considered on its merits. 21.10. On account of the very date of the Policy it could be held that the Policy dated 07.07.2022 could not be made applicable by BMRCL to the relevant

land

acquired

on

07.03.2017.

However, since BMRCL has in fact made the Policy applicable to the Petitioner and has relied upon it in its correspondence and submissions, this Court proceeds to decide the challenge to the Policy on merits and considers all the other arguments

addressed

by

respective

counsels. 21.11. The

opening

paragraphs

of

Policy

acknowledge that acquisition for the Metro project has, in some cases, left the remaining

- 65 HC-KAR

buildings or sites without access because their entire

frontage

was

acquired.

They

also

recognise that acquisition of only part of a property may affect direct access from the existing road to the remaining land. The Policy states that access in such cases may be unavoidable because of the nature and extent of the Metro alignment. BMRCL thus recognises that the project itself may create the need for access over its land. The issue is whether the terms prescribed to address that need are fair and lawful. 21.12. Clause 1 of the Way Leave Policy is reproduced below: 1. Way leave facilities on BMRCL land involve limited use of land by a party for a specified purpose like passage etc. without conferring upon the party any ownership or right of possession or occupation of the land and without in any way affecting the BMRCL's title, possession, control and use of the land.

21.13. Clause 1 defines a way-leave facility as limited use of BMRCL land for a specified purpose, without transferring ownership, possession or occupation.

The

Petitioner

does

not

claim

ownership of the land over which access is

- 66 HC-KAR

sought. Its case is that the conditions imposed on access must nevertheless be fair where the property has been left without access because of the Metro project. 21.14. Clause 2 is reproduced below: 2. The requests/applications for granting way leave facilities shall be considered with due regard to the circumstances of each case. Some such circumstances may be :(a) Non-availability of any other means of access to properties / houses/places of business. (b) Non-feasibility of provision of water supply, electricity, sewerage etc. from any other direction. (c) Other means of access are available, but not enough to meet the requirements of the applicant

21.15. Clause 7 is reproduced below: 7. Way leave facilities should not be granted as a matter of routine, but only after consideration of case on merits after site inspection. Special care should be taken to see that the way leave facility doesn't in any way impinge on the safety & security of metro operations & BMRCL property.

21.16. Clause 12 is reproduced below: 12. In cases not covered by the above way leave policy, a decision shall be taken with the approval of the Managing Director.

- 67 HC-KAR

21.17. Clauses 2, 7 and 12 require BMRCL to consider each application on its merits, including the availability or adequacy of other access and the feasibility of utility connections from another direction. Clause 7 requires a site inspection and protection of Metro operations and BMRCL property. Clause 12 permits the Managing Director to decide cases not covered by the Policy.

These

provisions

recognise

that

individual circumstances matter, but do not by themselves

resolve

challenge

to

mandatory termination and charging provisions. 21.18. Clause 3, including the termination provision challenged by the Petitioner, is reproduced below: 3. In genuine and unavoidable cases, way leave facility may be allowed, if feasible and for the developments coming up on this property, after execution of proper agreement. Land cannot be given on lease/license in such cases and only permission / leave is to be granted for a limited use which is to be specified in detail in the agreement. To avoid any misunderstanding on this score, the agreement should not use terms like ‘Lease/License and Rent/License fee etc.’ but only permission and way leave. The agreement should also clearly stipulate that the Metro Rail Administration retains full rights to enter upon, pass through or use the land, or to

- 68 HC-KAR

discontinue the way leave facility at any time, without any notice to the party. In the event of the way leave facility being discontinued with, the BMRCL will not be liable to pay any compensation or reimburse any amount to the party, nor to provide any alternative arrangement for access etc., In such a case, any installations like underground pipelines etc., put up by the party are liable to be removed/shifted by the party at his/its own cost.

21.19. Clause 3 permits BMRCL to discontinue access at

any

time

without

notice.

It

excludes

compensation, reimbursement or refund and does not require BMRCL to provide alternative access. It also places on the user the cost of removing

or

shifting

installations,

including

underground pipelines. The issue is whether these terms are fair and lawful when applied to an owner whose original frontage and access were lost through acquisition for the Metro project. 21.20. Clause 4 is reproduced hereunder for ease of reference: 4. The following amount shall be charged by BMRCL on the party requesting for the way leave, for different activities It shall be made clear in the agreement that these charges are subject to

- 69 HC-KAR

revision and the revised rates shall be applicable when the agreement is revised. Item

Type of way leave

1(a)

Passage/pathway on/across BMRCL land (up to 3.5 metres wide) for vehicular access. (If property became landlocked, with no other access as on the date of acquisition of the land) Passage for vehicles, scooters etc. (i.e., between 3.5–7 metres wide)

1(b)

1(c)

Passage for vehicles, scooters etc. (i.e., between 7–12 metres wide)

Way leave charges Free of cost

3% of the guidance value notified by the State Government per annum. Way leave agreement shall be entered into for 10 years and way leave charges shall be paid upfront for the 10-year period. Renewal of agreement after 10 years will be at 3% of the then prevailing guidance value per annum. 6% of the guidance

- 70 HC-KAR

1(d)

Passage for vehicles, scooters etc. (i.e., between 12–20 metres wide)

value notified by the State Government per annum. Way leave agreement shall be entered into for 10 years and way leave charges shall be paid upfront for the 10-year period. Renewal of agreement after 10 years will be at 6% of the then prevailing guidance value per annum. 10% of the guidance value notified by the State Government per annum. Way leave agreement shall be entered into for 10 years and way leave charges shall be paid

- 71 HC-KAR

2(a)

Electric lines (domestic purpose/service line) crossing for individual houses, shops etc. (both underground and overhead)

2(b)

Water/sewage/effluent pipeline crossing for individual up to 300 mm diameter. Electrical crossings by State Electricity Boards and Central Agencies.

2(c)

upfront for the 10-year period. Renewal of agreement after 10 years will be at 10% of the then prevailing guidance value per annum. Rs. 25,000/per annum. Way leave agreement shall be entered into for 10 years and the charges for 10 years shall be paid upfront. Renewal of this agreement will be at the discretion of BMRCL for another 10 years with a 50% increase in charges. Same as item 2(a). Same as item 2(a).

- 72 HC-KAR

2(d)

2(e) 2(f)

Open drains and overground water/sewage/oil/gas/effluent pipelines by private parties (including public sector undertakings). Underground oil/gas/pipelines. Underground/overhead electrical crossing other than covered under item 2(c); underground cables and alignment in favour of the Department of Telecommunications/BSNL/other telecom operators. This includes laying of Optic Fiber Cable (OFC). If electrical cable/pipeline is to be laid parallel to the BMRCL alignment in BMRCL land.

Same as item 2(a).

Same as item 2(a). Same as item 2(a).

(a) Up to a length of 250 metres: Rs. 25,000/- per annum. (b) Beyond 250 metres: Rs. 100 per running metre per annum. Way leave agreement shall be entered into for 10 years and way leave charges shall be paid upfront for the 10-year period. Renewal of this agreement will be at the discretion of BMRCL for

- 73 HC-KAR

another 10 years with a 50% increase in charges.

Note: i) Acquired land means land which is acquired /purchased / surrendered for the Bangalore Metro Rail Project, from the party seeking way leave permission. ii) Way leave charges will be calculated based on the guidance value as on the date of original application for way leave facility by the applicant. iii) Way leave charges shall be remitted upfront for a block period of 10 years for all the way leave permissions.

21.21. Clause 9 is reproduced below: 9. In all cases of way leave facility granted, proper agreement should be executed Agreement should provide for remittance of way leave charges upfront on signing of the agreement and revision by way leave charges from time to time, as provided in the policy.

21.22. Read together, Clauses 4 and 9 and Note (iii) provide free vehicular access up to 3.5 metres for a qualifying landlocked property, while wider passages attract charges based on the guidance value, payable ten years in advance. Since the first 3.5 metres is free, the charges under items 1(b) to 1(d) are leviable only for the width over and above 3.5 metres. The

- 74 HC-KAR

Policy also prescribes charges for specified utility crossings. The question is whether this structure fairly accounts for an owner who requires

replacement

access

because

original frontage was acquired for the Metro project. WHETHER ACCESS IS MERELY A DISCRETIONARY BENEFIT 21.23. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the land belongs to BMRCL and that wayleave

access

is

granted

at

its

discretion.

BMRCL’s ownership is not disputed. However, ownership alone does not permit a public body to impose arbitrary conditions on access to a property. 21.24. The Petitioner’s case is that BMRCL’s acquisition for the Metro project removed the direct access or

frontage

of

property,

leaving

remaining property dependent on way-leave access. The Petitioner belongs to the class of owners whose access was lost in this manner. Clause 4 recognises the special position of a property that became landlocked and had no other

access

on

date

of

acquisition,

- 75 HC-KAR

providing free access up to 3.5 metres. Clauses 2 and 7 require individual consideration of applications, site

inspection and

regard

to

Metro safety. The validity of the challenged termination and charging provisions must be assessed against this context. THE TERMINATION PROVISION AND ARTICLE 14 21.25. Article 14 requires public authorities to act fairly and not arbitrarily. Clause 3 permits BMRCL to discontinue access at any time without notice. It does not require reasons or specify the circumstances in which termination may take place. It also excludes compensation or refund and provides no alternative access. 21.26. Read with Clause 4, which requires ten years’ charges in advance for wider passages, Clause 3 permits BMRCL to discontinue access after receiving advance payment without refunding any part of it. The owner must also bear the cost of removing or shifting installations. 21.27. These terms are inconsistent with the Policy’s requirement for individual consideration before access is granted. Although Clauses 2 and 7

- 76 HC-KAR

require BMRCL to consider the circumstances of

property

Metro

safety,

Clause

permits access to be withdrawn without notice, reasons or safeguards. 21.28. BMRCL must be able to discontinue a way-leave facility for reasons relating to safety, security or Metro

operations.

The

defect

lies

in

unrestricted power conferred by Clause 3 and the absence of safeguards against arbitrary termination. The provision is therefore arbitrary under Article 14 insofar as it permits access to be

withdrawn

without

notice,

refund

or

alternative access in the circumstances of the Petitioner’s case. 21.29. BMRCL’s assurance that it will not cancel access if charges are paid and that the arrangement will be renewed from time to time does not cure

defect.

That

assurance

is

not

contained in the Policy. Its validity must be assessed by the power Clause 3 confers, not by an assurance about how BMRCL expects to exercise it. THE CHARGING PROVISIONS AND ARTICLE 14

- 77 HC-KAR

21.30. The Petitioner does not contend that BMRCL can never charge for the use of its land. The challenge is to applying the prescribed charges to

replacement

access

required

in

circumstances identified above. 21.31. Clause

prescribes

charges

according

to

passage width. It does not distinguish between an applicant seeking additional access for other reasons

replacement recognises

an

owner

access. that

who

Although

existing

access

requires Clause

may

be

insufficient, the charging provisions do not adequately account for the circumstances that necessitate replacement access. 21.32. The width of a passage may affect the use of BMRCL land and Metro operations. However, applying the same charging structure without accounting for the reason access is required places an arbitrary financial burden on the Petitioner. 21.33. BMRCL relies on the compensation paid for the acquired land and demolished structure. That payment does not, by itself, establish that the separate charging conditions for replacement

- 78 HC-KAR

access are fair. The scope of compensation and its relationship to the claim for loss of access fall for consideration under Point (iv). 21.34. The requirement to pay ten years’ charges in advance further aggravates the burden. The charges are linked to the guidance value, and renewal

charges

are

based

on

value

prevailing at the time of renewal. Read with Clause 3, the Policy requires a substantial advance payment for access that may be discontinued without notice or refund. 21.35. The Court does not question the technical competence of the officers who fixed the rates or revised the percentages. The constitutional defect lies in the charging structure and its failure to account for the circumstances in which replacement access is required. 21.36. BMRCL’s submission that the Petitioner has no vested right to 12 metres of free access concerns the width and form of access sought. That issue falls under Point (iii). The present issue is the validity of the charging provisions.

- 79 HC-KAR

ARTICLE

300A

AND

THE

ULTRA

VIRES

CHALLENGE 21.37. Article 300A provides that no person shall be deprived of property except by authority of law. The acquisition in this case was undertaken under law and is not challenged in this petition. The present issue concerns the

conditions

imposed on access to the remaining property. The loss of access affects its practical use and is relevant to the assessment of the Policy. 21.38. The finding rests principally on Article 14. Article 300A reinforces the need to consider the effect of the Policy on the use of the remaining property, but does not, by itself, establish a right to a passage of any particular width. 21.39. The Petitioner also challenges the Policy as ultra

vires.

However,

neither

party

has

identified the specific statutory provision under which the Policy was framed or the statutory limit that it is alleged to exceed. No separate finding is made on that ground.

- 80 HC-KAR

ARTICLE

19(1)(G)

AND

THE

RESPONDENTS’

OBJECTION 21.40. Article 19(1)(g) protects the right to practise a profession or carry on an occupation, trade or business, subject to constitutionally permitted restrictions. The Petitioner does not claim that this provision guarantees access of the precise width sought. The finding on the challenged provisions therefore rests on Article 14. 21.41. BMRCL submits that invalidating the challenged provisions may deprive the Petitioner of even the free 3.5-metre passage. This objection does not justify retaining provisions that impose arbitrary conditions. The Policy’s provision for free access up to 3.5 metres in qualifying cases is not itself under challenge. 21.42. For the reasons stated above, THIS Court answers Point No. (ii) by holding that the Petitioner has established grounds for declaring the following provisions of the Way Leave Policy unconstitutional, invalid and unenforceable in their application:

- 81 HC-KAR

21.42.1. Clause 3, insofar as it permits BMRCL to discontinue access at any time without notice and excludes refund or alternative access upon discontinuance. 21.42.2. The charging provisions of Clause 4, namely items 1(b), 1(c) and 1(d), and items 2(a) and 2(b) relating to electricity lines and water or sewage pipelines serving the remaining property, read with

Note

(iii),

Clause

9,

requirements for payment of ten years’ charges

in

advance

revision

or

renewal of charges by reference to the prevailing guidance value. 21.43. The

declaration

does

not

invalidate

remainder of the Way Leave Policy. 22.

Answer to Point No. (iii): Whether the Petitioner is entitled to a writ of mandamus under prayer (b), directing the Respondents to provide, permanently and free of cost, an unrestricted six-metre-wide ingress and a separate six-metre-wide egress to the Schedule Property from the northern side, together with the necessary rights to install and maintain water, electricity and sewerage connections over the relevant acquired land; and, in particular, whether the Respondents can

- 82 HC-KAR

restrict such access to the arrangement contemplated under the impugned Way Leave Policy and subject any additional access to licence charges and time-bound conditions? 22.1. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the Petitioner owns Municipal No. 28/B, PID No. 57-137-28B,

Sarakki

Industrial

Layout,

measuring 766.26 square metres. The property contains a commercial building with a super built-up area of 21,839 square feet, comprising the ground floor and four upper floors. Before acquisition, the property had a full and wide entry and exit on the eastern side facing the main road, and the entire frontage served as access.

On

07.03.2017,

BMRCL,

through

KIADB, acquired 152 square metres on the eastern side. 22.2. Learned Counsel submits that the road-facing portion of the building was demolished and the Metro station was constructed. The acquisition took away the frontage and former access, leaving

remaining

property

without

effective ingress or egress. The photographs and site layout are relied on to show that the Metro station now abuts the property and that

- 83 HC-KAR

no other access is available. The Petitioner did not voluntarily surrender the frontage; the land was acquired in exercise of the State’s power of eminent domain. 22.3. Learned Counsel submits that the effect of acquisition cannot be assessed only by the area taken. The use made of the acquired land may affect access to, and the practical use of, the remaining

property.

Compensation

for

acquired land and demolished structure does not, by itself, resolve whether the remaining property has reasonable and usable access. The request

is

for

a

replacement

necessary

by

Metro

additional

facility

route

project,

sought

made

not

merely

an for

convenience. 22.4. Learned Counsel submits that, by letter dated 15.04.2024, the Petitioner sought a separate six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre egress from the northern side. BMRCL’s replies dated 28.06.2024 and 19.11.2024 offered a combined

six-metre

passage,

subject

to

advance way-leave charges and a ten-year agreement. By letter dated 23.12.2024, BMRCL

- 84 HC-KAR

stated that free access was available only up to 3.5 metres. Before this Court, BMRCL has offered 3.5 metres free and a further five metres on payment. None of these proposals provides the separate entry and exit lanes sought. 22.5. Learned Counsel submits that the Schedule Property

is

a

large

commercial

building

previously leased to M/s GraphX Solution India Private Limited. The Property would once again have to be let out, and its use involves employees, providers,

customers, vehicles,

visitors,

deliveries,

service

goods

maintenance. Pedestrian access alone would not be adequate. Access must be suited to the building’s size, layout and lawful commercial use, including access to its parking facilities and the movement of goods and materials. 22.6. Learned

Counsel

further

submits

that

fire

tenders and other emergency vehicles must be able to reach the building. Adequacy depends not only on nominal width but also on turning radius,

clear

height,

alignment

obstructions. The Policy’s minimum free width

- 85 HC-KAR

cannot replace a site-specific assessment or override applicable safety requirements. A fire in the building may also pose a risk to the adjoining Metro station and its commuters. The Petitioner relies on Article 21 in support of the need for safe access. 22.7. Learned Counsel submits that Clause 4 of the Way Leave Policy provides free access up to 3.5 metres for qualifying landlocked properties, but that width cannot be treated as sufficient in every case. The Petitioner does not contend that Article 19(1)(g) guarantees any particular width of access. Its submission is that the State and its instrumentalities must not disregard the effect of their actions on the lawful use of the remaining property. The Petitioner seeks a proportionate arrangement that permits the Metro

project

to

continue

while

restoring

effective access. 22.8. Learned Counsel submits that prayer (b) seeks permanent

access

comprising

a

six-metre

ingress and a separate six-metre egress from the northern side, together with the right to install

maintain

water,

electricity

- 86 HC-KAR

sewerage lines over the relevant land. The width and configuration must be assessed in relation to the property’s size, shape, use and applicable safety and operational requirements. 22.9. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that BMRCL admits acquisition of 152 square metres on the eastern side of the Petitioner’s property. The acquired land is bounded by the road to the east, the remaining portion of Property No. 28/B to the west, the property of Prema Raghu N. V. to the north and the property of Madhusudhan P. Patel to the south. BMRCL admits that the acquired portion is now its property and that part of the building was demolished after possession was taken through the Special Land Acquisition Officer, for which compensation was paid. 22.10. Learned Counsel submits that BMRCL is not obliged to provide twelve metres of free access. It is willing to provide 3.5 metres free under

Policy

a

further

five

metres

on

payment. BMRCL contends that the northern land is also required for Metro infrastructure

- 87 HC-KAR

and that the Petitioner has no vested right to twelve metres of free access. 22.11. On utility connections, Learned Counsel for the Respondents initially submits that the Policy does not cover water, electricity and sewerage connections

through

BMRCL

land.

BMRCL

nevertheless states that a joint inspection was held on 28.03.2025 in the presence of the Tahsildar and BMRCL’s Assistant Engineer and Legal Advisor, and that locations for electric, sewage and water lines were marked. The plan is produced as Annexure-R2. BMRCL is willing to permit the lines at those points, subject to the Policy and payment of applicable charges. It also states that it is willing to provide an additional five metres of access over and above the free 3.5 metres on the same conditions. The Petitioner has throughout sought separate ingress and egress, each six metres wide. ISSUES AND MATERIAL FACTS 22.12. Point (iii) concerns the relief sought under prayer

(b):

permanent

free

access

comprising a six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre

egress

from

northern

side,

- 88 HC-KAR

together with the right to install and maintain water,

electricity

questions

are

what

sewerage

lines.

access

reasonably

is

The

required, whether BMRCL may confine the Petitioner to its standard Policy arrangement, and on what terms replacement access and utility routes must be provided. The validity of

relevant

charging

termination

provisions has been considered under Point (ii). 22.13. The material facts are substantially undisputed. BMRCL admits that 152 square metres of the eastern, road-facing portion were acquired, that the land is now BMRCL property, and that part of the building was demolished. The correspondence records the Petitioner’s request for separate six-metre entry and exit lanes on 15.04.2024; BMRCL’s proposals for a combined six-metre

passage

on

28.06.2024

19.11.2024, subject to advance payment and a ten-year

agreement;

its

letter

dated

23.12.2024 referring to free access of 3.5 metres; and its offer before this Court of 3.5 metres free plus five metres on payment. None provides the separate lanes sought.

- 89 HC-KAR

22.14. BMRCL has not identified another effective route into the Schedule Property. Its own proposals to provide access over land under its control support the conclusion that the property has lost its former access and requires a replacement route. BMRCL has admitted that the land on the northern side belongs to it, and it is from that land that it proposed to provide 3.5 metres free and a further five metres on payment. There is no dispute as to BMRCL’s ownership of that land. ENTITLEMENT TO REPLACEMENT ACCESS; WHY IT MUST BE FREE AND PERMANENT 22.15. The Petitioner previously had direct access from the main road on the eastern side. That frontage was acquired and the road-facing part of the building was demolished for the Metro project. The remaining property thereby lost its former access. The Petitioner seeks to replace access

lost

construction,

through not

acquisition

merely

to

improve

convenience. 22.16. BMRCL’s ownership of the land proposed for the replacement route entitles it to protect its

- 90 HC-KAR

property and the safe operation of the Metro. It does

not,

remaining

by

itself,

property

answer may

be

whether left

without

effective access after the project took away the former route. The Policy itself recognises that acquisition

may

leave

a

property

without

access. In the circumstances of this case, replacement access is necessary to make the remaining

property

reasonably

usable.

The

source of the Petitioner’s entitlement is the admitted fact that BMRCL, by its acquisition and construction of the Metro station, closed the existing access and left the remaining property without access. Having deprived the Petitioner of its access, BMRCL is bound to provide replacement access, and it is therefore unnecessary to examine whether an easement of necessity is made out. 22.17. Under

Point

provisions

(ii),

relevant

charging

Policy’s

unilateral

termination provision have been held invalid and unenforceable insofar as they apply to owners whose access was lost through BMRCL acquisition

who

require

replacement

access. BMRCL cannot rely on those provisions

- 91 HC-KAR

to

require

advance

payment,

agreement,

renewal

at

a

ten-year

revised

rates

or

discretionary withdrawal of access in this case. 22.18. Compensation demolished resolve

for

structure

separate

acquired does

not,

question

land

by

itself,

of

access.

Compensation is considered under Point (iv). For present purposes, payment of acquisition compensation is not a sufficient reason to require the Petitioner to pay again for the route made necessary by the acquisition. 22.19. The Policy’s free-access provision recognises the distinction between replacement access made necessary by acquisition and additional access sought for convenience. However, the standard

width

conclusively

of

determine

3.5

metres

what

this

cannot property

reasonably requires. The need for replacement access will continue for as long as the Schedule Property requires it. A ten-year permission subject to renewal and revised charges would leave use of the property dependent on periodic approval and expose the Petitioner to the risk of losing access. No sufficient reason has been

- 92 HC-KAR

shown for imposing that uncertainty. Access must therefore be permanent and continue in perpetuity,

subject

safeguards

that

to

law

protect

reasonable

Metro

operations

without defeating the right granted. WHETHER SEPARATE SIX-METRE INGRESS AND EGRESS ARE JUSTIFIED 22.20. The Petitioner seeks a six-metre ingress and a separate six-metre egress. BMRCL has offered a combined six-metre passage and later offered 3.5 metres free plus five metres on payment, making 8.5 metres in total. The question is whether the proposed arrangement provides safe, reasonable and dependable access for a large commercial building, including two-way vehicle movement, deliveries, movement of goods and access by emergency services. 22.21. An owner cannot insist on a width merely because it is preferred. The width must bear a reasonable relationship to the size and use of the property, site configuration and applicable safety and operational requirements. However, a

standard

conclusive

width

in

where

a

policy

Policy

cannot

itself

be

requires

- 93 HC-KAR

individual consideration. Clause 2 identifies inadequate

alternative

access

as

relevant;

Clause 7 requires consideration of the merits after site inspection; and Clause 12 provides for cases not covered by the Policy to be decided with the Managing Director’s approval. 22.22. The Schedule Property contains a commercial building with a super built-up area of 21,839 square

feet

facilities.

over

Its

five

floors

parking

use

involves

employees,

customers,

service

providers,

deliveries,

maintenance

movement

of

goods.

A

pedestrian route or a single narrow passage does not, without more, establish adequate access. BMRCL

has not

produced material

showing that separate lanes are unnecessary or that

a

lesser

configuration

would

provide

equivalent and dependable access. 22.23. The dimensions of ordinary vehicles illustrate the practical issue but do not determine the technical requirement. A bus or goods truck may

be

about

2.5

to

3.5

metres

wide,

depending on the vehicle, and mirrors require additional clearance. Fire engines vary in size

- 94 HC-KAR

and need sufficient clear width and turning space. Actual requirements depend on vehicle dimensions,

turning

radius,

clear

height,

alignment, surface and obstructions. No sitespecific technical report on these matters has been identified in the material before the Court. 22.24. Separate

ingress

egress

reduce

likelihood that entering and exiting vehicles will obstruct one another. In a single passage, a vehicle breakdown or obstruction may prevent both entry and exit and delay emergency access. Separate lanes do not eliminate every risk, but they provide a more dependable arrangement. 22.25. BMRCL’s proposals have varied: a combined six-metre

passage

in

letters

dated

28.06.2024 and 19.11.2024; 3.5 metres free in the letter dated 23.12.2024; and 3.5 metres free plus five metres on payment before this Court. These proposals show the widths BMRCL was willing to offer under its Policy. 22.26. The joint inspection dated 28.03.2025 is relied on in relation to locations marked for utility lines. The record does not establish that BMRCL

- 95 HC-KAR

assessed the width and configuration needed for

vehicular

movement,

access,

emergency

including access

two-way

risk

of

obstruction. Nor has it explained why separate entry and exit lanes cannot be accommodated. 22.27. BMRCL’s

statement

that

it

was

willing

to

provide five metres in addition to the free 3.5 metres does not establish that the Petitioner abandoned the claim for separate six-metre lanes. The Petitioner did not accept that offer, and no document records any reduction in the request.

The

Petitioner’s

letter

dated

15.04.2024 sought separate six-metre entry and exit lanes, and its reply dated 27.11.2024 maintained that request while disputing the charges. The Petitioner continues to seek the same

relief.

In

any event, one

combined

passage of 8.5 metres is not equivalent to two separate six-metre lanes. 22.28. BMRCL

submits that the northern

land is

required for infrastructure. The Metro’s public purpose and operational requirements must be respected. However, BMRCL has not identified a particular plan, structure, operational need or

- 96 HC-KAR

safety constraint that would be affected by the access sought. Nor has it explained why the land it is willing to use for an 8.5-metre passage cannot accommodate separate entry and exit lanes. 22.29. The Policy contemplates passages wider than 3.5 metres, with categories for widths of 3.5–7 metres,

7–12

metres

12–20

metres.

BMRCL has described the request as a total width of twelve metres. The Policy therefore does

not

treat

impermissible.

that

The

width

issue

as

is

inherently

whether

configuration is justified on the facts and whether

BMRCL

properly

considered

circumstances. The charging provisions cannot defeat the relief for the reasons given under Point (ii). BUILDING

REGULATIONS,

ZONING

AND

DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL 22.30. The Petitioner relies on Bangalore Mahanagara Palike Building Bye-laws, 2003, of which Byelaw 9.2, read with Table 6, and Bye-law 9.10 link plot coverage and Floor Area Ratio (FAR) for commercial buildings, among other things,

- 97 HC-KAR

to plot area, development-area classification and road width. The Petitioner submits that replacement access must permit lawful and effective use of the existing building under applicable building regulations. 22.31. Bye-law 9.2, Table 6, and Bye-law 9.10 of the Bangalore Mahanagara Palike Building Byelaws, 2003, are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 9.2 Exterior open spaces/ setbacks, coverage, floor area ratio, numbers of floors and heights The setbacks required on all the sides of building/s, maximum plot coverage, maximum FAR, maximum number of floors, maximum height of buildings that are permissible for different dimensioned sites and widths of roads are set out in Tables 4, 5 and 6 given below.

TABLE 6 (Bye-law 9.2 and 9.10) COVERAGE AND FAR FOR RESIDENTIAL, COMMERCIAL, PUBLIC AND SEMI-PUBLIC, TRAFFIC & TRANSPORTATION, AND PUBLIC UTILITY BUILDING Public & Semi Plot Residential

Commercial

Public T&T &

Road width

Public Utilities

(Mtrs)

Area in Sq. mtr. Plot

F.A.R.

Plot

F.A.R.

Plot

F.A.R.

- 98 HC-KAR

Cove-

Max.

Cove-

Max.

Cove-

rage

rage

rage

Max.

Max.

Max.

Max.

A – INTENSELY DEVELOPED AREA Upto 240

65%

0.75

65%

1.00

60%

1.00

Upto 6

60%

0.75

60%

1.00

55%

1.00

Over 6 upto 9

60%

1.00

60%

1.25

50%

1.00

Over 9 upto 12

60%

1.00

60%

1.25

50%

1.25

Over 12 upto 15

60%

1.25

55%

1.50

45%

1.25

Over 15

Over 240 Upto 500 Over 500 Upto 750 Over 750 Upto 1000 Over 1000

B – MODERATELY DEVELOPED AREA Upto 240

65%

1.00

65%

1.25

60%

1.00

Upto 9

60%

1.25

60%

1.50

55%

1.25

Over 9 upto 12

60%

1.25

60%

1.50

50%

1.25

Over 12 upto 15

60%

1.50

60%

1.75

50%

1.50

Over 15 upto 18

60%

1.75

55%

1.75

45%

1.50

Over 18

Over 240 Upto 500 Over 500 Upto 750 Over 750 Upto 1000 Over 1000

C - SPARSELY DEVELOPED AREA Upto 240

65%

1.00

65%

1.25

60%

1.25

Upto 9

60%

1.25

60%

1.50

55%

1.50

Over 9 upto 12

60%

1.50

60%

1.75

50%

1.50

Over 12 upto 15

Over 240 Upto 500 Over 500

- 99 HC-KAR

Upto 750 Over 750 60%

1.50

60%

1.75

50%

1.80

Over 15 upto 18

60%

2.00

55%

2.00

45%

1.80

Over 18

upto 1000 Over 1000

Note 1: The dimensions in British system if any, adopted for the dimensions of plots may be interpreted as follows in Metric system and set backs may be applied accordingly. 20’-0” – 6.0 m 30’-0” – 9.0 m 40’-0” – 12.0 m 50’-0” – 15.0 m 60’0” – 18.0 m 80’-0” – 24.0 m Note 2 : The open spaces to be provided shall conform to the height necessary to consume the permissible FAR. Note 3: (a) The front and rear set backs shall be with reference to the depth of the site. (b) The left and right set backs shall be with reference to the width of the site. (c) If the height of a building exceeds 9.5 metres, the set backs to be provided shall be higher of the set backs specified in tables 4 and 5. Note 4 : Building lines have been prescribed to certain roads by the Bangalore Development Authority in Table 33 of the Zoning Regulations. This table is appended as Schedule X to these byelaws. In such cases, the front set back or the building line which is higher of the two shall be provided. Note 5 : In the case of corner sites both the sides facing the road shall be treated as front side and regulations applied accordingly to maintain the building line on these roads and to provide better visibility.

- 100 HC-KAR

Note 6 : In the case of a building facing more than two roads, the plot should be considered as corner plot taking two wider roads into consideration. Note 7 : In the case of sites facing roads both in front and rear, both the sides facing roads should be treated as front and other two sides not facing roads should be treated as right and the setbacks be applied accordingly. Note 8 : In case where the plinth of the building is not parallel to the property line, the setbacks shall not be less than the specified setbacks at any given point on any side. Note 9 : In case of irregular plots the set-backs are to be calculated according to the depth or width at the points where the depths or widths are varying. Average set-backs shall not be considered in such cases. Note 10 : The left and right set-backs may be interchanged by the Authority in exceptional cases due to existing structures like; open well and also considering the topography of the land. However, this shall be resorted to by the Authority only as an exception. Note 11: Set-backs should be provided in the owner’s plot. Public open space or conservancy should not be considered as set-backs. Note 12: In case of two or more buildings proposed on a single site, the set-backs shall be applied by considering them as a common building. In such cases, the distance between the two buildings shall be minimum of half the height of the taller building. Note 13: For plots with an area of more than 750 sqm. bell mouth entrance shall be provided.

- 101 HC-KAR

Note 14: The front set back mentioned above are minimum. The building shall be shifted back to the building lines, if any declared by any competent authority. 9.10 Limitations of floor area and covered area 9.10.1 The coverage, and FAR, for different sizes of plots with reference to existing road width as limiting factor are given in the table No.6 for various types of buildings like residential, commercial, public and semi-public, etc. The local planning area of Bangalore City is divided into A, B & C areas by the Bangalore Development Authority for the purpose of regulating building constructions as under:A: Intensely developed area. B: Moderately developed area. C:– Sparsely developed area . Note: (1) A map showing the details of A, B and C areas is available in the office of the Bangalore Development Authority, Bangalore. A copy of this map is appended to these bye-laws. Note: (2) When two sides of the same road are included in two different areas like: A and B or A and C, then both the sides shall be treated as intensively developed area (‘A’ area) up to one property depth. Note: (3) When two sides of the same road are included in two different areas like: B and C, then both the sides shall be treated as moderately developed area (‘B’ area) up to one property depth. 9.10.2 In respect of the following buildings, the maximum coverage shall be as prescribed below.

- 102 HC-KAR

Building Permissible maximum coverage a. Hospital 25% b. Health centre/nursing home 33.33% c. Nursery school/primary school 33.33% d. Secondary school 30% e. College 25% 9.10.3 (a) The floor area of a building shall be the aggregate area of the floors of all parts of the building including thickness of walls, parking area, staircase rooms, lift rooms, ramps, escalators, machine rooms, balconies, ducts including sanitary ducts, water tanks, lobbies, corridors, foyers and such other parts provided for common service. (b) The floor area ratio shall exempt the floor area used for the following purposes, namely:- (i) parking space (ii) staircase rooms (iii) lift rooms (iv) ramps (v) escalators (vi) machine rooms (vii) open balconies (viii) ducts including sanitary ducts and (ix) water tanks. (c) Parking area shall be exempted to the extent required for the building. (d) The area covered by the following structures on the roof are exempted from the floor area upto fifteen percent of the area of the roof over which they are erected, namely:- (i) staircase rooms (ii) lift machine rooms (iii) pent house (iv) water tanks (v) equipments for ventilation, air conditioning and similar services. (e) Lobbies, corridors provided in the plan shall be considered for F.A.R. (f) The nomenclature of certain roads may differ with those mentioned in the District Maps of the Revised C.D.P. In such cases, the location of the site may be considered to determine the land use. Note : One penthouse only is permissible for a building. The area of the penthouse with staircase room shall be limited to 19 sq.mtrs. If this limit is

- 103 HC-KAR

exceeded, the structures shall be considered for reckoning the FAR. 9.10.4 When sites do not face the roads of required width noted against each, then the FAR applicable to the corresponding width of roads shall apply. 9.10.5 When a site faces wider road than the one prescribed against it, the FAR shall be restricted only to the limit prescribed for the area of that particular site. 9.10.6 When coverage is less than the maximum prescribed in Table 6, floors and height beyond the limits indicated in table 5 may be permitted to utilise the full FAR subject to the provision of minimum set backs prescribed in Tables 4 and 5, whichever is applicable. 9.10.7 The set-backs and coverage shall be determined irrespective of the width of the road.

22.32. The schedule of the property in question as per the lease deed is as under:SCHEDULE All that piece and parcel of premises having a super built-up area of 21,839 sq. ft. consisting Stilt + 3 floors + terrace, situated at Plot no 28/ B, Bannergahatta Main Road, Sarakki Industrial Area, JP Nagar, Phase III, Bangalore – 560076

22.33. A perusal of the above would indicate that the super built-up area consists of stilt + three floors + terrace. The said building has been put to commercial use. The National Building Code,

- 104 HC-KAR

2016 determines the access required for a building in order to provide a No-objection Certificate by the fire and emergency services. The

fire

emergency

services

have

themselves not fixed any particular width of the road, nor does the building bylaws or the zonal regulation fix such width. 22.34. Regulation

4.6,

which

is

applicable

regulation in relation thereto is reproduced hereunder for ease of reference: 4.6 For high rise buildings and special buildings (see Part 4 'Fire and Life Safety' of the Code), the following additional provisions of means of access shall be ensured: a) The width of the main street on which the building abuts shall not be less than 12 m and one end of this street shall join another street not less than 12m in width. b) The road shall not terminate in a dead end; except in the case of residential building, up to a height of 30 m. c) The approach to the building and open spaces on all its sides shall be not less than 6 m in width, and a turning radius of minimum 9 m shall be provided for fire tender movement of fire tenders weighing up to 45 t. The same shall be hard surface capable of taking the mass of fire tender, weighing up to 45 t minimum. For heavier fire tenders, the minimum width, turning radius and the hard surface capable of taking the fire tender loads shall be as per the requirement laid down by the Fire Department. The layout for the open space for fire tender movement

- 105 HC-KAR

shall be done in consultation with the Chief Fire Officer of the city, which shall be kept free of obstructions shall be motorable. The compulsory open spaces around the building shall not be used for parking. d) The main entrance to the plot shall be of adequate width to allow easy access to the fire engine and in no case shall it measure less than 6 m. The entrance gate shall fold back against the compound wall of the premises, thus leaving the exterior accessway within the plot free for movement of fire tender. If the main entrance at the boundary wall is built over, the minimum clearance shall be 4.5 m.

22.35. A

perusal

of

above

regulation

would

indicate that other than a high-rise building or special building, the width of the main street on which the building abuts shall not be less than 12 meters and one end of the street shall join another street not less than 12 meters in width. In the present case, what was requested for by the Petitioner was 6 meters separate ingress and 6 meters separate egress which is in tune with the requirement of Regulation 4.6 of the National Building Code. 22.36. Clause (ix) of Regulation 3.16 of the Zonal Regulations of the Revised Master Plan 2015, is reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:

- 106 HC-KAR

ix. Areas which fall within 150m radius from the metro terminals shall be eligible for a maximum FAR of 4 for all permissible uses, irrespective of the FAR applicable for the respective uses in the respective tables. However, this will be applied only after the completion of the metro stations and also the same to be confirmed by the BMRCL. Till such time the existing regulations shall apply.

22.37. The

above

Clause

IX

of

Regulation

3.16

provides for any building which falls within a distance

of

meters

from

outer

boundary of the metro station/terminals to be eligible for a maximum FAR of 4 for all permissible applicable

uses, for

irrespective

of

respective

uses

in

FAR

respective tables of the zoning regulation. Admittedly,

property

of

Petitioner

abutting the metro railway station is definitely within 150 meters, and therefore would be eligible to a FAR of 4. Thus, apart from the construction which has already been put up, the Petitioner would be entitled to put up construction to an extent of 4 times the area of the property. 22.38. If the area of 766.26 sq. mt. represents the plot area before acquisition of 152 sq. mt. by BMRCL, the residual plot area would be 614.26

- 107 HC-KAR

sq. mt. The total permissible floor area at FAR 4 would then be 2,457.04 square meters or approximately

26,447

square

feet.

The

construction which has been put up now, being 21,839 square feet, the Petitioner would, on this calculation, be entitled to put up an additional construction of approximately 4,608 square feet. Alternatively, if the area of 766.26 sq. mt. represents the plot area remaining after acquisition of 152 sq. mt. by BMRCL, the total extent area of the property being 766.26 sq. mt., the Petitioner would be entitled to put up 766.26 into 4, i.e., 3,065.04 square meters or approximately

32,992

square

feet.

The

construction which has been put up now, being a super-built up area of 21,839 square feet, the Petitioner would be entitled to put up an additional construction of approximately 11,153 square feet. 22.39. As per the Schedule to the Lease Deed, the property consists of stilt + 3 floors + terrace. In terms of the zonal regulation, the height of the building would vary on the ground coverage permissible,

taking

into

account

FAR

applicable. The FAR in the present matter being

- 108 HC-KAR

assumed at 4, the total permissible floor area would be approximately 32,992 square feet if the plot area is 766.26 sq. m. after acquisition, or approximately 26,447 square feet if the said extent

represents

plot

area

before

acquisition of 152 sq. m. by BMRCL. The actual permissible construction would be subject to verification

of

plot

area

available

for

development, the applicable Zonal Regulations and the area of the existing construction counted for FAR purposes. 22.40. The FAR being 4, the road access that would have to be provided to the said building would have to be commensurate with the FAR as per the zonal regulation so as to make available the incentive of 4 FAR being achieved by the land user. Though the FAR is required to be provided by a different authority, namely the local planning authority and the BMRCL has nothing to do with it, it is required for BMRCL to make

achievement

of

incentive

of

additional FAR possible. 22.41. Hence,

taking

into

consideration

requirement of the National Building Code, the

- 109 HC-KAR

minimum width of the road which is required to be provided is 12 meters. It may be for achieving the larger FAR, there may be a higher road width which is required to be provided. That would have to be ascertained during the course of trial and cannot be done in this writ petition. What this Court can only direct is the provision of the minimum width of the road as required under the National Building Code. If the Petitioner has any further grievance relating to the width of the road, then the same would have to be agitated before the Civil Court and proper reliefs would have to be sought for. 22.42. On the present record, separate six-metre ingress and egress provide a more reasonable and dependable arrangement than a single combined passage. They address the separate needs of entering and leaving traffic, reduce

likelihood

of

obstruction

improve

access for emergency vehicles. BMRCL has not established

that

arrangement

would

interfere with an identified Metro requirement or that a lesser configuration would provide adequate access. Separate six-metre ingress

- 110 HC-KAR

and egress are therefore justified on the facts of this case. FIRE SAFETY, EMERGENCY ACCESS AND THE ADJOINING METRO STATION 22.43. The building’s size and commercial use make emergency

access

relevant.

The

Petitioner

submits that fire tenders must be able to reach the building and that a fire could affect the adjoining Metro station, its operations and commuters. 22.44. The approximate dimensions of buses, trucks

fire

engines

do

not,

by

themselves,

establish the prescribed minimum width for this site. The applicable requirement depends on the relevant building and fire-safety standards and the site-specific circumstances. Clause 4.6 of Part 3 of the National Building Code of India, 2016,

prescribes

certain

means

of access to

requirements

high-rise

for

special

buildings. 22.45. The Metro station and its commuters must be protected. The station is on the eastern side, where the former frontage was acquired, and

- 111 HC-KAR

requested

replacement

access

on

northern side over land admitted to be held by BMRCL. BMRCL has not identified a specific security or operational risk arising from the proposed

northern

access.

It

may

impose

reasonable safeguards consistent with law, but those safeguards must not narrow, obstruct or withdraw the access granted without lawful justification. WATER,

ELECTRICITY

AND

SEWERAGE

CONNECTIONS 22.46. BMRCL submits that the Policy does not cover utility connections through its land. However, the Policy’s introduction refers to way-leave requests for underground water-supply and sewerage

pipelines

electrical

telecommunication lines. Clause 2(b) identifies the feasibility of providing water, electricity and sewerage from another direction as a relevant consideration. Items 2(a) and 2(b) of the charging table prescribe charges for electric service lines and water and sewage pipelines. The

Policy

therefore

contemplates

such

- 112 HC-KAR

installations, although it prescribes charges for them. 22.47. The Petitioner does not ask BMRCL to supply these services; it seeks the right to install and maintain

its

own

connections

across

relevant land. BMRCL states that locations for water, sanitary and electric lines were marked during the joint inspection on 28.03.2025 and that it is willing to permit the lines at those points. This

is

inconsistent

with

its

initial

position that the lines cannot be provided under the Policy and confirms that installation is feasible in principle, subject to appropriate alignment and safeguards. 22.48. For the reasons given under Point (ii), the relevant charging provisions cannot be applied to make the necessary replacement utility routes chargeable in this case. The Petitioner must bear the cost of installing and maintaining the lines and any charges payable to the relevant service providers. The lines shall be laid at the points marked during the joint inspection and shown in Annexure-R2, or at such

other

points

as

may

be

marked

in

- 113 HC-KAR

accordance with the operative order. BMRCL shall not obstruct the authorised lines except in accordance with law and that order. 22.49. Water and sewerage pipes passing through the acquired

portion

were

closed

during

construction and the replacement utility lines have not yet been installed and commissioned. Merely marking their locations does not secure the Petitioner’s ability to install and maintain them. The Petitioner must have the right to route the necessary lines through the relevant land, subject to applicable technical and safety requirements. BMRCL need not supply the services

or

installing,

bear

costs

of

operating

or

water

sanitation

obtaining,

maintaining

connections. 22.50. Access

to

is

closely

connected with the right to life and human dignity under Article 21. Electricity is also necessary for the ordinary and lawful use of a modern commercial building. Where the need to route utility lines arises from acquisition and construction for the Metro project, BMRCL must not impose conditions that leave the remaining

- 114 HC-KAR

property without a practical means of obtaining essential

services

merely

to

protect

its

administrative or commercial interests.

APPLICATION OF THE POLICY AND BALANCE OF INTERESTS 22.51. BMRCL appears to have treated the Policy’s standard widths and charges as controlling. Yet Clause

requires

consideration

of

circumstances of each case, Clause 7 requires consideration

on

merits

after

site

inspection, and Clause 12 provides for cases not covered by the Policy to be decided with the Managing Director’s approval. A case like this in which the entire road frontage has been acquired

remaining

commercial

property has been left without effective access requires individual assessment. 22.52. BMRCL’s positions have differed: it says the Policy does not cover utility lines but offers to permit them at marked points; it says the northern land is needed for infrastructure but has offered a passage of 8.5 metres; and its

- 115 HC-KAR

access proposals have varied in width and configuration. These changes have not been accompanied by a reasoned explanation of what the property requires or why separate sixmetre lanes cannot be provided. 22.53. The relief must respect the public purpose of the Metro project. The Court does not direct the return of acquired land or alteration of the Metro station, nor does it transfer BMRCL’s ownership or control of its land. The direction is confined to replacement access and necessary utility routes over land held by BMRCL. BMRCL may protect its infrastructure and operations through reasonable measures consistent with this order, but the public purpose of the project does not justify leaving the remaining property without

effective

access

where

no

specific

operational or safety impediment has been demonstrated. 22.54. BMRCL’s offer of 3.5 metres free plus five metres on payment does not resolve the issue. A combined passage of 8.5 metres is not equivalent to separate six-metre ingress and egress, which together provide twelve metres,

- 116 HC-KAR

approximately 40 feet. Nor does an assurance that access will not be cancelled while charges are

paid

remove

or

payment

conditions

time

limit,

renewal

burden

found

inapplicable under Point (ii). NATURE OF THE RIGHT AND IMPLEMENTATION 22.55. Replacement access cannot be made subject to a

ten-year

revised

agreement,

way-leave

periodic

charges

or

renewal,

discretionary

withdrawal. It must continue in perpetuity, subject to law. BMRCL cannot withdraw, curtail or obstruct it merely at its discretion or because a fixed term has expired. Any lawful restriction must be supported by a genuine requirement consistent with law and must not defeat the right granted. Since the access is free and in perpetuity, the question of termination of the way-leave does not arise. 22.56. Permanent and free access does not transfer ownership or possession of BMRCL’s land to the Petitioner and does not create a public road. The route is for the Petitioner and persons lawfully using the Schedule Property to enter and leave, and for authorised utility lines to

- 117 HC-KAR

pass.

No

construction

other

than

that

reasonably required for the access surface and utility lines is permitted. Clauses 5 and 11 of the Policy continue to apply to the extent consistent with this order. BMRCL may take reasonable measures to protect Metro safety, security and operations, provided they do not narrow,

obstruct

or

render

ineffective

access granted. 22.57. The alignment of the two six-metre lanes shall be marked on land held by BMRCL on the northern side. It must avoid third-party land and interference with the Metro station and its operations. Utility lines shall be laid at the points marked on 28.03.2025 and shown in Annexure-R2, or at such other points as are agreed or determined under the operative order. Either party may approach this Court for directions

on

a

genuine

implementation

dispute. Such an application shall not reopen the entitlement to replacement access, its free and permanent character, or the separate sixmetre widths determined under this Point, subject

only

to

determination

by

committee mentioned below. Whether separate

- 118 HC-KAR

six-metre width ingress and egress can be provided shall be determined by a committee to be constituted by the Managing Director of BMRCL, comprising concerned officers having the requisite technical expertise, after notice to the Petitioner and having regard to the building bye-laws,

zonal

requirements

regulations,

fire

nature

of

force

construction. Only if the committee records in writing, with reasons, that separate ingress and egress cannot be provided, BMRCL shall provide a single access of at least 40 feet (about 12.2 metres) for both ingress and egress. 22.58. This Court answers Point No. (iii) by holding that the Petitioner is entitled to a writ of mandamus under prayer (b). BMRCL shall provide, free of cost and on a permanent basis, over land held by BMRCL, a six-metre-wide ingress and a separate six-metre-wide egress to the Schedule Property from the northern side;

if

committee

referred

to

above

records, with reasons, that separate ingress and egress cannot be provided, BMRCL shall instead provide a single access of at least 40 feet (about 12.2 metres) for both ingress and

- 119 HC-KAR

egress. The access shall continue in perpetuity and shall not be withdrawn, curtailed, made subject to renewal or obstructed at BMRCL’s discretion. This direction is subject to law and to reasonable safeguards for Metro safety, security

operations,

provided

those

safeguards do not defeat or materially impair the access granted. 22.59. BMRCL shall permit the Petitioner to install and maintain water, electricity and sewerage lines at the points marked during the joint inspection on 28.03.2025 and shown in Annexure-R2, or at such other points as are marked under the operative order. The Petitioner shall bear the costs of installing and maintaining the lines and any applicable charges payable to the relevant service providers. BMRCL shall not rely on the charging provisions or fixed-term conditions of the Way Leave Policy to deny, charge for or interrupt the replacement access and utility routes granted under this Point. 22.60. The exact alignment and marking shall be settled under the operative directions, on land held by BMRCL and without encroachment on

- 120 HC-KAR

third-party land or interference with the Metro station. Any dispute concerning implementation may be brought before this Court in accordance with the operative order.

23.

Answer to Point No. (iv): Whether the compensation paid in respect of the acquired land and demolished structure precludes the Petitioner from pursuing its distinct claim for damages arising from the alleged loss of access to the remaining Schedule Property?

23.1. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the compensation paid for the land and building acquired by BMRCL does not automatically extinguish every separate claim arising from the effect of the acquisition on the remaining property. The compensation was paid for the property taken over for the Metro project. Prayer allegedly

(c),

by

caused

contrast,

concerns

by

resulting

losses loss

of

effective access to the property left with the Petitioner. The two claims must be considered separately.

- 121 HC-KAR

23.2. Learned Counsel submits that, when only part of a property is acquired, the effect on the remainder must also be considered. Adequate ingress and egress are necessary for the effective use of a commercial building by its owner, tenants, employees, customers and other lawful users. The Petitioner’s case is that its former access from the eastern side, facing the main road, was entirely lost when the land was

acquired

Metro

station

was

constructed, leaving the remaining building without effective access and causing the tenant to vacate. 23.3. Learned Counsel submits that compensation for the acquired land and demolished structure is distinct from losses caused by the deprivation of access to the remaining property. Payment for what was taken does not, by itself, settle the consequences for what remained. 23.4. Learned Counsel also refers to the dispute concerning

compensation

for

acquired

extent of 152 square metres. Compensation was paid for 95.75 square metres, while the remaining 56.25 square metres were treated as

- 122 HC-KAR

kharab land. The Petitioner challenged that treatment in W.P. No. 4125/2023, in which this Court directed KIADB to take steps to issue a corrigendum including the remaining extent and to pay compensation. Learned Counsel submits

that

this

proceeding

concerns

a

separate issue from the claim arising from loss of access. 23.5. Referring to BMRCL’s letter dated 23.12.2024, Learned Counsel submits that the statement that compensation included the demolished building does not answer the claims concerning loss of access, interruption of utility services or loss of rental income. Nor does the statement that the Petitioner was permitted to strengthen the remaining floors at its own cost resolve whether the building could be accessed and used. 23.6. Learned prayer

Counsel (c)

is

compensation

accordingly

submits

not

a

claim

for

for

acquired

that

duplicate land

or

demolished structure. It is a separate claim for losses suffered because the remaining property could not be accessed and effectively used.

- 123 HC-KAR

Acceptance of acquisition compensation does not, by itself, bar consideration of that claim. 23.7. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the acquisition was carried out under the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Act, 1966, and that BMRCL paid Rs.4,01,44,404/as compensation for the acquired land and building. The Petitioner accepted that amount and, according to BMRCL, cannot seek further compensation arising from the acquisition. 23.8. Learned Counsel submits that compensation was calculated at 200% of the market value, together with solatium and interest, under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in

Land

Acquisition,

Rehabilitation

Resettlement Act, 2013. BMRCL relies on the amount paid to support its position that no further compensation is payable and that it may levy charges for access beyond the free width permitted under its Way Leave Policy. 23.9. Learned Counsel further relies on BMRCL’s letter dated 23.12.2024, which states that the compensation included the demolished building

that

Petitioner

was

permitted

to

- 124 HC-KAR

strengthen the remaining floors at its own cost, without any right to compensation. QUESTION FOR DETERMINATION AND SCOPE OF THIS POINT 23.10. The question under this Point is limited to whether the compensation paid for the acquired land and demolished structure, by itself, bars the Petitioner from pursuing a distinct claim for losses allegedly caused by the acquisition and the resulting loss of access to the remaining Schedule

Property.

This

Point

does

not

determine whether the Petitioner has proved its entitlement

to

amount

claimed

in

Annexure-F. That issue falls for consideration under Point (v). WHETHER THE COMPENSATION PAID BARS A SEPARATE CLAIM 23.11. BMRCL states that it paid Rs.4,01,44,404/- as compensation

for

acquired

land

building, including the demolished structure, and relies on its assertion that the award included 200% of market value, solatium and interest. The purpose for which compensation

- 125 HC-KAR

was assessed is material. BMRCL has not shown that the amount included a specific assessment of losses arising from the loss of access to the remaining

property,

interruption

of

utility

services or loss of rental income. 23.12. The substantial amount paid does not, by itself, establish

that

every

consequence

of

acquisition was assessed or compensated. The acquired land and demolished structure are distinct from the remaining property and the impairment of its use. If the loss of access is established, it concerns the use and utility of the property left with the Petitioner, rather than the value of the property acquired. 23.13. The Petitioner’s case is that it formerly had independent and complete access from the eastern side facing the main road and lost that access after the acquisition and construction of the Metro station. It alleges that the remaining building was left without effective ingress and egress. Whether the loss of access caused the tenant to vacate, whether other circumstances contributed to the vacancy, and whether any

- 126 HC-KAR

resulting rental loss is legally recoverable are matters reserved for Point (v). 23.14. Compensation for acquired land does not itself provide access to the remaining property. Nor does it establish, that the loss of use or rental income was included in the award. BMRCL has not identified a settlement or release by which the Petitioner relinquished claims concerning access,

interruption

of

utilities

or

loss

of

income. On the material placed before this Court,

acceptance

of

acquisition

compensation does not, by itself, dispose of those distinct claims. 23.15. The effect of acquisition on the remaining property must be considered separately from the value of the property taken. The public purpose of the Metro project and the payment of compensation for the acquired property do not,

by

themselves,

answer

whether

remaining property was left without effective access or whether any resulting loss has been addressed in accordance with law. 23.16. Article 300A of the Constitution is relevant to the extent that it protects against deprivation

- 127 HC-KAR

of property except by authority of law. It does not, by itself, establish an entitlement to every consequential loss claimed by an owner. It reinforces, however, that the effect of public action on private property must be considered in accordance with law and cannot be treated as immaterial merely because compensation has been paid for the property acquired. STATUTORY COMPENSATION AND THE HEADS OF LOSS 23.17. BMRCL has referred to both the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Act, 1966, and

Right

to

Fair

Compensation

Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. The present Point does not require the Court to determine the complete statutory basis of the acquisition or reopen the acquisition award. It requires the Court to distinguish the compensation actually paid from the losses now claimed. 23.18. Section 28 of the 2013 Act is reproduced hereunder for easy reference:

- 128 HC-KAR

28. Parameters to be considered by Collector in determination of award.–In determining the amount of compensation to be awarded for land acquired under this Act, the Collector shall take into consideration— firstly, the market value as determined under section 26 and the award amount in accordance with the First and Second Schedules;

secondly, the damage sustained by the person interested, by reason of the taking of any standing crops and trees which may be on the land at the time of the Collector's taking possession thereof; thirdly, the damage (if any) sustained by the person interested, at the time of the Collector's taking possession of the land, by reason of severing such land from his other land; fourthly, the damage (if any) sustained by the person interested, at the time of the Collector's taking possession of the land, by reason of the acquisition injuriously affecting his other property, movable or immovable, in any other manner, or his earnings; fifthly, in consequence of the acquisition of the land by the Collector, the person interested is compelled to change his residence or place of business, the reasonable expenses (if any) incidental to such change; sixthly, the damage (if any) bona fide resulting from diminution of the profits of the land between the time of the publication of the declaration under section 19 and the time of the Collector's taking possession of the land; and

- 129 HC-KAR

seventhly, any other ground which may be in the interest of equity, justice and beneficial to the affected families.

23.19. Section 28 identifies matters to be considered when

determining

compensation,

including

damage caused by severance of the acquired land from other land and damage caused where the acquisition injuriously affects other property or earnings. The provision may therefore be relevant to the distinction between the value of the land acquired and consequential loss. 23.20. The amount paid at 200% of market value, together with solatium and interest, does not by itself establish that the Petitioner was compensated for every consequence of the acquisition. The amount may be relevant to the acquisition claim, but its magnitude does not prove that the separate losses now claimed were included or that the Petitioner agreed to relinquish any distinct remedy available under law.

- 130 HC-KAR

RELEVANCE OF THE WAY LEAVE POLICY AND ACCEPTANCE OF COMPENSATION 23.21. The

Way

acquisition

Leave may

Policy

leave

a

recognises property

that

without

adequate access and provides a mechanism for considering access in such circumstances. This supports the conclusion that access to the remaining

property

is

a

distinct

matter

requiring consideration. The Policy’s existence does not, by itself, establish the Petitioner’s entitlement

to

damages

or

amount

recoverable. 23.22. The Petitioner’s acceptance of Rs.4,01,44,404/is not disputed. However, BMRCL has not identified any release or settlement showing that the Petitioner relinquished its separate claims concerning access, utility services or loss of rental income. Acceptance of compensation for the acquired land and building does not, without more, establish that the Petitioner agreed to make no further claim for the effect of the acquisition on the remaining property. 23.23. The Petitioner’s continued access grievance and

separate

proceedings

concerning

- 131 HC-KAR

compensation for part of the acquired extent are consistent with its maintaining distinct claims. The finding under this Point rests principally on the purpose of the compensation paid and the absence of material showing that the consequential losses were included in or settled by that payment. SEPARATE

PROCEEDING

CONCERNING

56.25

SQUARE METRES 23.24. The dispute concerning the remaining 56.25 square metres is separate. The Petitioner states that compensation was paid for 95.75 square metres out of the 152 square metres acquired and that the balance was treated as kharab land.

In

W.P.

No.

4125/2023,

directed KIADB

to

take

this

steps to

Court

issue

a

corrigendum including the remaining extent and to pay compensation. Compliance with those

directions

amount,

if

any,

remaining payable are not determined under this Point. Nothing in this finding alters the directions in that proceeding. 23.25. The extent for which acquisition compensation was paid is a separate issue from whether the

- 132 HC-KAR

compensation

for

acquired

land

building bars the claim arising from loss of access to the remaining property. The answer to the latter question does not depend on the final outcome of the former. EFFECT

OF

THE

STATEMENT

CONCERNING

STRENGTHENING OF THE BUILDING 23.26. BMRCL’s letter dated 23.12.2024 states that the Petitioner was permitted to strengthen the remaining floors at its own cost and without any right to compensation. That statement concerns work on the remaining structure. It does not establish that effective access was provided or that loss of use and rental income was included in the acquisition compensation. No finding is made under this Point concerning the cost or adequacy of the strengthening work. 23.27. This Court answers Point No. (iv) by holding that the compensation paid for the acquired land and demolished structure does not, by itself, preclude the Petitioner from pursuing a distinct

claim

for

losses

caused

by

- 133 HC-KAR

acquisition and the resulting loss of effective access to the remaining Schedule Property.

24.

Answer to Point No. (v): Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the monetary relief sought under prayer (c), namely, recovery of the amount of ₹11,30,36,834.57 claimed under Annexure-F dated 07.10.2024 and continuing damages until the access sought under prayer (b) is provided; and whether such relief can appropriately be adjudicated in the present writ proceedings, having regard to the Respondents’ objections concerning disputed facts, causation and the alleged loss of rental income? 24.1. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the Schedule Property bearing Municipal No. 28/B,

PID

Industrial

No.

57-137-28B,

at

Sarakki

Layout,

Bannerghatta

Road,

3rd

Phase, J.P. Nagar, Bengaluru, measures 766.26 square metres and comprises a commercial building with a super built-up area of 21,839 square feet, extending from the ground floor to the fourth floor. 24.2. Learned Counsel submits that, before the Metro project, the property had access from the eastern side facing the main road. By letter dated 07.03.2017, BMRCL indicated that 152

- 134 HC-KAR

square metres on the eastern side would be acquired

through

Karnataka

Industrial

Areas Development Board (KIADB) for the Metro station. The Petitioner’s case is that the acquisition and subsequent construction took over the former frontage and deprived the remaining property of effective access. 24.3. Learned

Counsel

further

submits

that

electricity, water and sanitation connections serving

Schedule

Property

were

disconnected in 2019 in connection with the Metro construction. The property had been leased to M/s GraphX Solution India Pvt. Ltd. under

a

01.07.2015,

registered recording

lease

deed

monthly

dated

rent

of

₹12,01,145 and contractual escalation of 15% every three years. The Petitioner asserts that the tenant vacated in August 2019 because effective access and essential services were unavailable,

that

property

has

consequently remained incapable of effective commercial use. 24.4. Learned Counsel submits that compensation paid for the acquired land and demolished 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 135 HC-KAR

structure does not necessarily compensate for the separate effect on the remaining property. Of

square

metres

identified

for

acquisition, compensation is said to have been paid

for

95.75

square

metres,

while

remaining 56.25 square metres were treated as kharab

land.

The

issue

concerning

remaining extent is the subject of W.P. No. 4125/2023. The Petitioner submits that the acquisition compensation issue is distinct from the loss allegedly caused to the remaining property by deprivation of access and essential services. 24.5. Learned Counsel submits that, by request dated 15.04.2024, the Petitioner sought replacement access from the northern side over land held by BMRCL, comprising a separate six-metre-wide entry and a separate six-metre-wide exit. By letters

dated

28.06.2024

19.11.2024,

BMRCL offered a combined six-metre passage subject to upfront way-leave charges and a ten-year agreement. The Petitioner disputes those

conditions

replacement

access

because

arose

from

project. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

need

for

Metro

- 136 HC-KAR

24.6. Learned Counsel relies on the registered lease deed as a relevant basis for assessing rental loss. By legal notice dated 07.10.2024, the Petitioner

claimed

Annexure-F

compensation

until

₹11,30,36,834.57 also

sought

effective

under

continuing access

essential services were provided or restored. 24.7. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that access and utility lines over land acquired for the Metro project are governed by BMRCL’s Way Leave Policy. BMRCL relies on the Policy provisions

concerning

permitted

widths,

charges and licence conditions, and on its offers of a combined six-metre passage subject to the terms set out in its letters dated 28.06.2024 and 19.11.2024. 24.8. Learned Counsel submits that, by letter dated 23.12.2024, BMRCL stated that pipes passing through the acquired portion had been closed during construction because the property was vacant, and that separate utility connections could

be

obtained.

BMRCL

disputes

responsibility for the alleged loss of rental income and contests the dates, circumstances 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 137 HC-KAR

and causal connection relied upon by the Petitioner. 24.9. Learned Counsel for the Respondents further submits

that

claim

raises

disputed

questions concerning the acquisition award, the date

responsibility

for

utility

disconnections, the date and reason for the tenant’s departure, the rent payable from time to time, the period of any loss, mitigation and the computation of damages. BMRCL contends that those issues require evidence and should be determined in a civil suit. 24.10. The issues for determination are: 24.10.1. whether payment of compensation for the acquired portion, by itself, bars a separate claim for consequential loss allegedly

suffered

by

remaining

property; 24.10.2. which aspects of the dispute can be determined in these writ proceedings; 24.10.3. whether the precise amount and period of any recoverable rental loss should be 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 138 HC-KAR

left

to

a

competent

civil

court

for

determination on evidence. 24.11. The Court has considered the claim in the context of its findings under Point Nos. (ii), (iii) and (iv). The issues must be kept distinct. The legality of BMRCL’s approach to replacement access and utility services is one matter. Whether

acquisition

award

included

compensation for the particular consequential loss now alleged is another. Whether, for what period and in what amount the Petitioner in fact suffered recoverable rental loss attributable to the acts or omissions complained of is a further, evidentiary question. 24.12. The findings under Point Nos. (ii) and (iii) determine

legal

position

governing

replacement access and utility connections in the circumstances of this case. The identified provisions of the Way Leave Policy cannot be relied upon to impose the impugned charges or time-limited conditions on an owner whose former

access

acquisition

or

was

lost

through

construction,

BMRCL’s BMRCL

is

required to provide the replacement access and 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 139 HC-KAR

utility arrangements directed in this judgment. Those findings and directions remain operative irrespective of the forum in which the precise monetary loss is assessed. 24.13. The Court rejects BMRCL’s broad proposition that payment of compensation for the acquired land

demolished

structure,

by

itself,

necessarily bars a separate claim arising from the effect of the acquisition and Metro works on the remaining property. The acquired land and the remaining property are distinct subjects of potential injury. The fact that compensation was paid for the former does not, without examination of the award and its component heads, establish that loss of access, severance, injurious affection, loss of earnings or rental loss concerning the remaining property was also assessed and compensated. 24.14. Section 28 of the Right to Fair Compensation

Transparency

in

Land

Acquisition,

Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, and 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, illustrate the legal distinction between the value of the land acquired and certain consequential injuries 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 140 HC-KAR

to other property or earnings. The Court does not decide in these writ proceedings which statutory regime governs the acquisition or whether a particular head was payable under that regime. The relevant factual question is what the acquisition award actually assessed and paid. That question must be answered by examining

complete

materials,

payment

award,

records

valuation

related

proceedings. 24.15. The registered lease deed is relevant evidence of the parties’ contractual arrangement and may

provide

an

important

measure

when

assessing loss. It does not, by itself, prove that rent at the stated rate was payable or received throughout every month claimed; that the tenant vacated for the reason alleged; that the premises could not otherwise have been let; or that all loss during the period was caused by BMRCL. Those matters must be considered with the tenancy records, termination and handover documents,

rent-payment

evidence,

utility

records, evidence concerning access, and any attempts to re-let the property. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 141 HC-KAR

24.16. The precise date on which each utility service was disconnected must be established from the relevant records. The date on which the tenant vacated, the reason for its departure and the period for which rent would otherwise have been payable must likewise be proved. The rent applicable from time to time must be calculated by reference to the complete lease deed, including its escalation provisions and any relevant period,

variation, credit

or

termination, other

rent-free

adjustment.

These

matters bear directly on causation, the period of

loss

amount,

if

any,

legally

recoverable. 24.17. The

same

compensation

applies

to

issue.

Whether

acquisitionthe

award

included compensation for severance, injurious affection, loss of earnings, rental loss or any overlapping head cannot safely be determined by a general assertion from either side. The award and supporting valuation record must be examined. If any payment is shown to cover the identical loss for the identical period, it must be accounted for to prevent double recovery. If no such overlap is established, the 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 142 HC-KAR

mere

payment

of acquisition

compensation

cannot defeat a distinct claim. 24.18. The Court is satisfied that the Petitioner has raised a substantial grievance concerning the consequences of a public infrastructure project and BMRCL’s handling of the resulting access and utility problem. The record warrants the findings elsewhere in this judgment concerning BMRCL’s application of the Way Leave Policy, the need for effective replacement access and

obligation

to

address

continuing

impairment of the remaining property. BMRCL’s conduct, as analysed under Point No. (vi), merits the Court’s express disapproval for the reasons recorded there. 24.19. However, the existence of a public-law wrong or the establishment of the Petitioner’s right to effective access does not permit the Court to presume

every

monetary

claim.

element Article

of

pleaded

permits

consequential relief where appropriate, but it does not require the Court to conduct a full civil trial within writ proceedings. Where damages depend

on

contested

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

evidence

about

- 143 HC-KAR

contents of an acquisition award, dates of disconnection, the tenant’s departure, the rent payable over time, mitigation, causation and the extent of any overlap, a trial is the appropriate means of resolving those issues. 24.20. The Court therefore distinguishes the matters that

can

properly

be

decided

in

these

proceedings from those that cannot. This Court can determine the legality of the impugned Policy provisions as applied to the Petitioner, the Petitioner’s entitlement to the replacement access and utility-related relief directed under Point No. (iii), and the legal proposition that payment for the acquired portion does not automatically extinguish a distinct claim for consequential loss to the remaining property. It can also record its disapproval of BMRCL’s handling of the grievance, award costs where justified, and issue directions governing future cases. 24.21. This Court cannot, on the present record and without a trial, finally determine the precise commencement date of rental loss, the date on which the tenant vacated, whether the tenant 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 144 HC-KAR

left for the reasons alleged, the rent legally payable in each month, the extent to which the property could have been re-let, the effect of intervening circumstances, the contents and effect of the acquisition award, or the precise amount of recoverable loss. Those questions require production and testing of evidence, including cross-examination where necessary. 24.22. The Court does not accept BMRCL’s submission insofar as it seeks to use the existence of disputed facts to defeat the Petitioner’s publiclaw challenge or the relief concerning access and utility services. Nor does the Court accept that

payment

of

acquisition

compensation

automatically bars the Petitioner from pursuing a separate claim. The proper consequence of

factual

disputes

is

that

precise

monetary claim must be left to a competent civil court, rather than being quantified finally in these writ proceedings. 24.23. The Petitioner shall accordingly have liberty to institute an appropriate civil suit before the competent court for recovery of rental loss and other consequential damages, if so advised and 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 145 HC-KAR

in accordance with law. The civil court shall determine, on the evidence adduced by the parties,

whether

to

what

extent

Petitioner suffered loss attributable to BMRCL’s acts or omissions; the relevant period of loss;

effect

of

acquisition

award

compensation already paid; the rental terms and escalation applicable from time to time; mitigation and other relevant circumstances; interest thereon, and the final amount, if any, payable. The Petitioner though shall be entitled to the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act, 1963 for the time spent in prosecuting this writ petition. The loss complained of is a continuing cause of action, which shall be treated as continuing until the access is made available

water,

electricity

sewerage facilities are restored. 24.24. For that purpose, the Petitioner may rely on the registered

lease

deed

dated

01.07.2015,

Annexure-F dated 07.10.2024 or any other document that would reflect the rentals that the Petitioner would have secured, which it has now lost out on, the acquisition award and payment

records,

utility

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

construction

- 146 HC-KAR

records, tenancy and handover documents, correspondence, and such other admissible evidence as may be available. BMRCL shall be at liberty to raise all legally available defences concerning

causation,

proof,

quantum,

mitigation and overlap, except that the general proposition

that

acquisition

compensation

automatically bars a distinct consequential-loss claim stands rejected for the reasons stated above. All questions requiring evidence shall be decided by the trial court independently in accordance with law. 24.25. The trial court shall not treat the observations in this judgment concerning the legal distinction between

acquisition

consequential

loss

Petitioner

already

has

as

compensation

a

finding

proved

that

precise

amount claimed; the observation is only limited to the fact that the Petitioner would be entitled to losses caused by the deprivation of access, in addition to the acquisition compensation, the existence and extent of such losses not having been

determined

or

proved

in

these

proceedings. Equally, the Petitioner shall not be required to establish the legal validity of the 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 147 HC-KAR

Policy provisions afresh as determined in this judgment,

or

replacement

entitlement

access

to

utility-related

directions granted herein. The trial court shall determine the factual issues and monetary consequences

on

evidence

before

it,

consistently with the binding findings of this Court. 24.26. The Court expresses no final view on whether the entire sum of ₹11,30,36,834.57 claimed under Annexure-F is recoverable, nor on the exact

amount

of

continuing

or

other

consequential damages. No monetary decree for

that

sum

is

passed

in

proceedings.

This

observation

ensure

claim

that

is

these is

writ

made

to

adjudicated

on

complete evidence and that BMRCL has a fair opportunity to contest the factual basis and calculation. 24.27. Accordingly, Point No. (v) is answered partly in favour of the Petitioner. BMRCL’s contention that payment of compensation for the acquired portion, without examination of the award and

relevant

heads

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

of

compensation,

- 148 HC-KAR

automatically

defeats

claim

for

consequential loss is rejected. The precise claim for

rental-based

compensation

other

damages is reserved for determination by a competent civil court on evidence. The findings and directions under Point Nos. (ii), (iii) and (iv) remain unaffected.

25.

Answer to Point No. (vi): What order?

BMRCL’S STAND AND THE APPLICATION OF ITS OWN POLICY 25.1. The Petitioner contends that BMRCL treated its Way Leave Policy as rigid, asserted that it was bound by the Policy, and failed to consider the particular

circumstances

property.

The

Court

of

records

Petitioner’s

following

further observations. 25.2. The

Policy

itself

provided

mechanisms

for

considering cases on their individual merits. Clause

required

circumstances

of

consideration each

case;

of

Clause

contemplated a decision on the merits after site inspection;

and Clause 12

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

provided for a

- 149 HC-KAR

decision, with the approval of the Managing Director, where the Policy did not cover the case. 25.3. The present case concerned a property whose eastern frontage had been acquired for the Metro

project,

leaving

remaining

commercial building without any access. The need for a permanent replacement route and associated

utility

connections

called

for

a

reasoned, site-specific assessment. Although a joint inspection was later conducted and points were marked for utility lines, the separate sixmetre-wide ingress and egress sought by the Petitioner was not provided and no reasons are placed on record, except to contend that it cannot be provided. BMRCL cannot justify its stand merely by referring to standard widths and charges prescribed by the Policy when the Policy

itself

contemplated

consideration

of

individual circumstances. 25.4. BMRCL’s positions were also inconsistent. It relied on the Policy to contend that access was governed licence

by

its

conditions,

discretion while

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

its

prescribed own

Policy

- 150 HC-KAR

recognised the special position of properties left without access. It initially maintained that the Policy did not cover the provision of utility lines, yet subsequently identified points at which those lines could be laid. It asserted that the relevant

land

was

required

for

Metro

infrastructure, but also offered access over that land, though on conditions disputed by the Petitioner. 25.5. Its proposals shifted from a combined sixmetre-wide

passage

to

an

arrangement

involving 3.5 metres free of charge and a further

five

metres

on

payment.

Neither

proposal

addressed

Petitioner’s

distinct

request for separate six-metre-wide entry and exit passages. Further, BMRCL relied on an assurance that access would not be cancelled if charges were paid, while maintaining that its Policy’s power of discontinuance must remain available. These positions reveal the absence of a consistent and reasoned approach to the particular problem before it. BMRCL also did not adequately address the applicable building byelaws and fire-safety requirements relied upon by the Petitioner. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 151 HC-KAR

25.6. BMRCL’s stand placed the practical and financial burden of resolving the access problem on the Petitioner, although the need for replacement access arose from the Metro project. The Petitioner’s refusal to accept terms requiring advance

payment

a

time-limited

agreement cannot, in the circumstances found under Point Nos. (ii) and (iii), be treated as a sufficient answer to the failure to provide effective replacement access. RELIANCE ON ACQUISITION COMPENSATION TO ANSWER THE DISTINCT LOSS OF ACCESS 25.7. A further feature of BMRCL’s stand is its reliance on compensation paid for the acquired land and demolished structure as though that payment necessarily answered the grievance concerning access to the remaining property. As explained under Point No. (iv), these are distinct matters. Compensation for the land and building acquired does not, by itself, establish that the effect on the remaining property, including deprivation of effective access and loss of use, was assessed and compensated. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 152 HC-KAR

25.8. BMRCL did not identify a specific assessment showing that the compensation already paid included the separate loss now in issue. Nor did it show that the Petitioner had settled or relinquished the distinct claim arising from the effect of the acquisition on the remaining property. The

Court does not reopen the

adequacy of compensation for the property acquired. The criticism is that BMRCL relied on that payment as a complete answer to a different grievance without addressing whether

two

matters

were

in

fact

assessed

separately. INCONSISTENT

POSITION

CONCERNING

THE

TENANT AND THE VACANCY OF THE PROPERTY 25.9. BMRCL’s letter dated 23.12.2024 presents an inconsistency

requiring

comment.

BMRCL

disputed the Petitioner’s assertion concerning the tenant’s departure, while also stating that the property was vacant and that the pipes had been closed because there was no need to restore services to a vacant property. Those positions

are

difficult

to

reconcile.

The

inconsistency is relevant to the adequacy of 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 153 HC-KAR

BMRCL’s response to the grievance, although it does not, without trial, conclusively establish the date or reason for the tenant’s departure or the precise amount of rental loss. 25.10. The registered lease deed dated 01.07.2015 predates the present dispute and records the agreed

rent

escalation.

BMRCL’s

correspondence did not provide a consistent or reasoned answer to the Petitioner’s case that the interruption of access and essential services had impaired the use of the property. This inconsistency assessment

is of

relevant BMRCL’s

to

handling

Court’s of

grievance. The precise tenancy facts and their monetary

consequences

remain

open

for

determination on evidence in the civil suit. RELIANCE ON A CIVIL SUIT FOR AN EASEMENT OF NECESSITY 25.11. BMRCL also submitted that, if the Petitioner required more access than the Policy allowed, it should institute a civil suit for an easement of necessity

that

this

Court

intervene

in

writ

proceedings.

should

not

However,

BMRCL’s own Policy recognises the need to 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 154 HC-KAR

consider access where acquisition leaves a property

without

effective

access.

BMRCL

cannot rely on the Policy framework while declining to address the consequences of its acquisition

construction

in

a

manner

consistent with that framework. 25.12. The availability of a civil remedy is relevant to the limits of relief that may be granted in writ proceedings. It does not remove this Court’s jurisdiction to examine whether BMRCL applied its Policy lawfully and fairly. The Court has considered

maintainability

objection

separately and rejected it insofar as it concerns the public-law challenge and the prayers for replacement access and utility-related relief. The monetary claim, by contrast, involves disputed facts requiring trial and is therefore left open to the competent civil court. THE CUMULATIVE EFFECT OF BMRCL’S CONDUCT 25.13. The above features must be viewed together with the findings under Point Nos. (ii), (iii) and (iv). The former frontage and access were lost in connection with the Metro project. The grievance

concerning

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

access

utility

- 155 HC-KAR

arrangements remained unresolved despite the Petitioner’s representations and the later joint inspection.

When

Petitioner

sought

replacement access, BMRCL’s proposals were conditional and did not address the distinct request for separate entry and exit passages. BMRCL did not produce a reasoned, site-specific assessment

explaining

why

requested

arrangement could not be accommodated, and continued to rely on Policy conditions found unenforceable as applied to the Petitioner. 25.14. The Court recognises the public importance of the Metro project and BMRCL’s responsibility to protect its land,

infrastructure,

safety and

operations. The relief granted does not require alteration

of

Metro

station,

return

of

acquired land or surrender of BMRCL’s control over

its

property.

It

requires

workable

replacement access and routes for utility lines, subject to reasonable safeguards consistent with this order. No specific operational or safety requirement

has

been

established

on

material before the Court that justifies leaving the remaining property without effective access 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 156 HC-KAR

or making replacement access dependent on the impugned charges. 25.15. A public authority is expected to deal fairly, consistently

proactively

with

persons

affected by its projects. Its Policy should assist it in identifying and resolving the consequences of acquisition, not become a reason to avoid doing so. BMRCL’s failure to make effective use of the case-specific mechanisms in its Policy, its inconsistent positions, and its insistence that

Petitioner

securing

should

bear

replacement

burden

access

of

materially

contributed to the continuation of the dispute. DISAPPROVAL

OF

BMRCL’S

CONDUCT

AND

AWARD OF COSTS 25.16. The Court’s disapproval is not based merely on the fact that BMRCL has failed in its defence. A public authority is entitled to contest a claim

protect

operational

its

property

interests.

This

legitimate

case,

however,

involves more than an ordinary disagreement over

interpretation

of

a

policy.

The

cumulative record shows that BMRCL failed to address

a

foreseeable

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

consequence

of

its

- 157 HC-KAR

acquisition, did not provide an effective solution for a prolonged period, relied on compensation for the acquired land as a complete answer to a distinct

grievance,

adopted

inconsistent

positions concerning the tenancy and vacancy of the premises, and sought to place the burden

of

resolving

resulting

access

problem on the Petitioner. 25.17. The Petitioner was compelled to approach this Court to secure relief concerning access and essential services necessary for the effective use of the remaining commercial property. The prolonged

failure

to

provide

a

reasoned

resolution, despite the mechanisms available under BMRCL’s own Policy, materially added to the burden of the proceedings. The Court considers that a declaration and directions for access should be accompanied by an award of costs reflecting its disapproval of the manner in which BMRCL dealt with the grievance. 25.18. In these circumstances, an award of costs is justified.

The

amount

must

reflect

prolonged and avoidable nature of the dispute, the need for the Petitioner to institute and 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 158 HC-KAR

prosecute these proceedings to secure effective relief, and the failure of a public authority with

requisite

technical

administrative

capacity to resolve the problem through a fair and lawful application of its own Policy. The award

is

intended

to

mark

Court’s

disapproval of that conduct and to meet, in part, the burden of litigation imposed on the Petitioner. It is distinct from any rental loss or consequential damages that may be established in the civil suit. 25.19. Having regard to the cumulative circumstances, this Court directs Respondent No. 1, BMRCL, to pay costs of ₹10,00,000 (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) to the Petitioner. The costs shall be paid within eight weeks from the date of this order. CLARIFICATION 25.20. The

above

observations

are

confined

to

BMRCL’s handling of the Petitioner’s request and the positions taken in these proceedings. They do not question the public purpose of the Metro project or BMRCL’s authority to protect its property and operations by lawful means. The criticism concerns the failure to address 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 159 HC-KAR

fairly and consistently the consequences of the project for the remaining Schedule Property, and the resulting need for judicial intervention. BEFORE PARTING: DIRECTIONS FOR FUTURE CASES 25.21. Before

parting,

this

Court

considers

it

necessary to set out directions for BMRCL to follow in future cases involving acquisition of private land for Metro projects, particularly where the acquisition or construction may affect access to or the ordinary use of the remaining

property.

demonstrates

that

The

present

case

consequences

of

acquisition cannot be assessed by considering only the extent of land taken over. The effect on the remaining property must also receive due attention. 25.22. Whenever BMRCL proposes to acquire land or undertake construction that may affect access to, or the ordinary use of, the remaining property,

it

shall

identify

likely

consequences for that property at the planning and implementation stages. The assessment shall, as relevant to the site, consider existing 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 160 HC-KAR

ingress and egress, access for vehicles and emergency services, the availability of water, electricity

sanitation,

any

other

essential facility that may be affected by the proposed works. 25.23. Where the proposed acquisition or construction is likely to leave the remaining property without access or effective access or essential services, BMRCL shall, as far as practicable, inspect the site, consult the affected owner and consider a workable access

arrangement or

services

before are

existing

disrupted.

The

assessment and proposed solution shall be recorded in writing. The purpose is to identify

address

consequences

for

remaining property in a timely manner, rather than leave the owner to seek a remedy after deprivation has occurred. 25.24. While considering a request for replacement access, BMRCL shall distinguish between a request

for

additional

or

more

convenient

access and a request made necessary because the original access or frontage has been lost owing

to

its

acquisition

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

or

construction

- 161 HC-KAR

activities. Such a request shall not be rejected merely

by

referring

to

standard

widths,

charging slabs or licence conditions under the Way Leave Policy. BMRCL shall consider actual site conditions, the use and configuration of the remaining

property,

availability

of

alternative

access,

relevant

safety

operational requirements, applicable building bye-laws, the National Building Code, Fire and Emergency Services requirements and other applicable

regulatory

requirements.

The

decision shall state reasons for accepting or rejecting the requested arrangement. 25.25. BMRCL shall give due effect to the provisions of its Way Leave Policy that require consideration of individual circumstances, site inspection and a

decision

on

merits,

including

procedure for cases not specifically covered by the Policy. The Policy shall be applied as a framework for fair decision-making and not as a reason to avoid examining the consequences of BMRCL’s own acquisition or construction. The provisions declared invalid or unenforceable in this judgment shall not be applied to owners whose original access or frontage has been lost 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 162 HC-KAR

because of BMRCL’s acquisition for the Metro project. 25.26. Where utility routes are likely to be affected, BMRCL shall coordinate, as necessary, with the relevant service providers and the affected owner to identify a workable arrangement for continuity or restoration of essential services at

earliest,

without

any

delay.

Where

replacement utility routes are required over land held by BMRCL, the proposed alignment, responsibilities

for

installation

maintenance, and applicable service-provider charges

shall

be

clearly

communicated.

Administrative or contractual conditions shall not be imposed in a manner that defeats the practical provision of essential services. 25.27. If BMRCL considers that effective replacement access

cannot

reasonably

or

lawfully

be

provided, it shall communicate its reasons to the affected owner and consider, in accordance with applicable law, whether acquisition of the remaining property or another lawful solution is appropriate. An owner whose property has been left without access or effective access 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 163 HC-KAR

shall not be kept indefinitely in uncertainty while the authority neither provides a workable solution nor takes a reasoned decision on the available alternatives. 25.28. BMRCL shall ensure that decisions concerning replacement access and essential services are communicated

within

a

reasonable

time,

supported by recorded reasons, and identify the steps required for implementation. Any genuine technical or operational restriction relied upon shall be identified with sufficient clarity to permit the affected owner to understand the basis of the decision and, where appropriate, challenge it in accordance with law. 25.29. The Managing Director of BMRCL shall issue appropriate

internal

instructions

to

concerned officers to ensure compliance with these

directions

findings

in

this

judgment. The instructions shall make clear that the consequences of acquisition for the remaining property must be considered at the planning and implementation stages; requests for replacement access must receive individual consideration;

03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

provisions

declared

- 164 HC-KAR

invalid or unenforceable in this judgment must not be applied to the class of owners covered by the declaration. The instructions shall be issued within four weeks from the date of this order. 25.30. These directions do not prevent BMRCL from acquiring land for a lawful public purpose, protecting its property or imposing reasonable measures necessary for Metro safety, security and operations. They require that such powers be

exercised

fairly,

consistently

in

accordance with law, with due regard to the consequences for the remaining property of persons affected by acquisition. The public purpose of the Metro project and the rights of affected owners must be addressed together; the former does not justify ignoring the latter. 25.31. In view of the reasons and the answers given above, this Court passes the following: ORDER (i)

The writ petition is allowed in part, in terms of the declarations and directions set out below. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 165 HC-KAR

(ii)

It is declared that the following provisions of the Way Leave Policy of BMRCL bearing No. BMRCL/LAQ/WLP/5132/2022-23

dated

07.07.2022 (Annexure-C) are unconstitutional, invalid

unenforceable

as

against

Petitioner and any owner of land whose direct access

or

frontage

was

lost

because

of

acquisition by BMRCL for the Metro project: a.

provision

in

Clause

permitting

BMRCL to discontinue a way-leave facility at any time without notice, together with provisions excluding compensation, refund or

alternative

access

upon

such

discontinuance; and b.

the charging provisions in Clause 4 for passages wider than 3.5 metres, namely rows 1(b), 1(c) and 1(d), and rows 2(a) and 2(b) relating to electricity lines and water or sewage pipelines serving the remaining property, read with Note (iii), Clause 9 and the requirements for ten years’ upfront payment and revision or renewal

of

charges

by

prevailing guidance value. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

reference

to

- 166 HC-KAR

c.

This

declaration

is

confined

to

provisions identified above and the class of owners described. The remainder of the Way

Leave

Policy

is

not

invalidated.

BMRCL may impose lawful and reasonable safeguards

for

property,

Metro

protection

safety,

of

security

its

operations, subject to this order. (iii)

A writ of mandamus is issued to Respondent Nos. 1 to 3, directing them as follows: a.

within four weeks from the date of this order, BMRCL shall depute officers to mark on the ground, after reasonable notice to the Petitioner and jointly with the Petitioner’s representative, an ingress six metres wide and a separate egress six metres wide on the northern side of the Schedule Property over the adjoining land held by BMRCL. Whether separate ingress and egress can be provided shall be determined, within the same period, by a committee

to

be

constituted

by

Managing Director of BMRCL comprising concerned officers having the requisite 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 167 HC-KAR

technical expertise, after notice to the Petitioner

having

regard

to

building bye-laws, zonal regulations, fire force requirements and the nature of the construction;

only

if

committee

records in writing, with reasons, that separate ingress and egress cannot be provided, BMRCL shall mark and provide instead a single access of at least 40 feet (about 12.2 metres) for common ingress and egress. If the Petitioner does not attend after notice, BMRCL may mark the access in the Petitioner’s absence, record the action taken and provide a copy to the Petitioner; b.

Within eight weeks from the date of this order, BMRCL shall provide and hand over to the Petitioner, on a permanent basis, free of cost and without an agreement for a fixed term, the ingress and egress so marked.

The

access

shall

not

be

withdrawn, curtailed, obstructed or made subject to renewal or payment of wayleave charges at BMRCL’s discretion; 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 168 HC-KAR

c.

BMRCL

shall

permit

Petitioner

to

install and maintain water, electricity and sewerage lines to the Schedule Property over the land held by BMRCL on the northern side, at the points marked at the joint inspection of 28.03.2025 (AnnexureR2), or, where those points cannot be used because of the marking of the strips, at other points marked by BMRCL for that purpose, without way-leave charges. The Petitioner shall bear the cost of laying and maintaining the lines and charges payable to service providers; and d.

The

access

persons

is

for

lawfully

using

Petitioner and

Schedule

Property. It does not create a public road or general right of access for third parties. BMRCL may adopt reasonable measures to protect Metro safety, security and operations, provided such measures do not narrow, obstruct or render ineffective the access directed above. (iv)

It is declared that payment of compensation for the land acquired and structure demolished 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 169 HC-KAR

does not, by itself, bar a distinct claim for consequential loss suffered by the remaining property.

Whether

included

compensation

acquisition for

loss

of

award access,

severance, injurious affection, loss of earnings, rental loss or any overlapping head shall be determined by the competent civil court upon examination of the complete award, valuation materials and payment records. Any proven overlap shall be accounted for to prevent double recovery. (v)

No monetary decree is passed in these writ proceedings

in

respect

₹11,30,36,834.57

made

of

under

claim

for

Annexure-F

dated 07.10.2024, or for continuing rental loss or other consequential damages. The Petitioner is at liberty to institute an appropriate civil suit before the competent court, if so advised and in accordance with law. Though the Petitioner shall be entitled to the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act, 1963 for the time spent in these proceedings, the cause of action shall be treated as continuing until the access is made available

water,

sewerage facilities are restored. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

electricity

- 170 HC-KAR

(vi)

In any suit instituted by the Petitioner, the competent civil court shall determine on the evidence: a.

the date or dates of disconnection of electricity, water and sanitation services

whether

disconnections

were

attributable to the Metro works or BMRCL; b.

the date and reason for the tenant’s vacation;

c.

the rent legally payable from time to time under the registered lease deed dated 01.07.2015,

including

contractual

escalation and any relevant adjustment; d.

whether and to what extent the Petitioner suffered rental loss or other recoverable damage

caused

by

BMRCL’s

acts

or

omissions; e.

the period of any recoverable loss and the effect

of

any

intervening

mitigation; 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

cause

or

- 171 HC-KAR

f.

heads

of

compensation

actually

included in the acquisition award and any overlap with the claim; g.

interest;

h.

All such factual and monetary issues are left open for determination at trial.

(vii) The Petitioner may rely in the civil suit on the registered

lease

deed

dated

01.07.2015,

Annexure-F dated 07.10.2024, the acquisition award

payment

records,

utility

construction records, tenancy and handover documents, correspondence, and any other admissible evidence. BMRCL shall be at liberty to raise all legally available defences concerning causation,

proof,

quantum,

mitigation

overlap, subject to the findings of law recorded in

this

judgment.

The

trial

court

shall

independently assess the evidence and shall not treat this judgment as having established the precise amount of rental loss. (viii) If BMRCL elects not to provide the replacement access directed under clause (iii), or maintains that such access cannot lawfully or feasibly be 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 172 HC-KAR

provided, it shall take appropriate steps under applicable law to acquire the balance property. Any acquisition, valuation and payment of compensation

shall

follow

applicable

statutory procedure. The current value of the balance

property

any

acquisition

compensation are not determined in these writ proceedings.

Merely

deciding

to

initiate

acquisition proceedings or taking preliminary steps shall not satisfy the direction to provide effective access or, by itself, determine any monetary

claim

reserved

for

civil

trial.

Acquisition of the balance property shall not negate

claim

of

Petitioner

for

compensation for rental loss already incurred or continuing, and other consequential damages. (ix)

BMRCL

shall

pay

Petitioner

costs

of

₹10,00,000 (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) within eight weeks from the date of this order. These costs are distinct from, and shall not be treated as a determination of, the rental loss or consequential damages reserved for civil trial. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 173 HC-KAR

(x)

The stand of BMRCL, as recorded in this order, is deprecated for the reasons set out under Point No. (vi).

(xi)

BMRCL shall file a memo of compliance in this Court, with a copy to the Petitioner, within two weeks after expiry of the period for handing over the ingress and egress. The memo shall state the dates on which the access was marked and handed over and the steps taken to facilitate the utility lines.

(xii) Either

side

directions

if

may a

apply

genuine

to

this

Court

for

difficulty

arises

in

carrying out the directions concerning access or utility lines, including a difficulty concerning the land over which the strips are to be marked or their length along the boundary. This liberty does not authorise reopening of the monetary issues reserved for civil trial. (xiii) Pending interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed of. Any interim order in force stands merged in this order. (xiv) Though the writ petition is disposed of by this order, relist the matter on 22.01.2027 for the 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

- 174 HC-KAR

Managing

Director

of

BMRCL

to

report

compliance.

This Court has been assisted by Ms. Harshada R.B., Law Clerk, in reviewing this judgment. 03/11/2026, 16:40, Bengaluru

(SURAJ GOVINDARAJ) JUDGE PRS, List No.: 1 Sl No.: 45

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.