M/S Royal Sundaram General Insurance Co LTD v. Smt Kiran Devi
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 6 November 2026
- Bench
- Justice Anu Sivaraman, Justice T.p.vivekananda
- Case number
- MFA No. 4505 of 2020
- Result
- DISMISSED
- Subject
- Motor accident
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 PRESENT THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN AND THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.P.VIVEKANANDA MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.4505 OF 2020 C/W MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.6056 OF 2021 (MV-D)
IN MFA No.4505/2020 BETWEEN: M/S. ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., (FORMERLY KNOWN AS ROYAL SUNDARAM ALLIANCE INSURANCE CO., LTD.,) PRESENTLY HAVING ITS DIVISIONAL OFFICE AT NO.30 3RD FLOOR, JNR CITY CENTER RAJA RAM MOHAN ROY ROAD SAMPANGIRAMA NAGAR BANGALORE 560 027 REPRESENTED BY MANGER Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
…APPELLANT (BY SRI: RAVI S. SAMPRATHI, ADVOCATE) AND: 1.
SMT. KIRAN DEVI W/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
2.
KUM. POOJA KUMARI D/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 16 YEARS
3.
MASTER PRINCE KUMAR S/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 13 YEARS
4.
KUM. KUSHI KUMAR D/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 10 YEARS
5.
KUM. ALKA KUMARI D/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 07 YEARS RESPONDENT NOS.2 TO 5 ARE MINORS, REPRESENTED BY NATURAL GUARDIAN AND MOTHER RESPONDENT NO.1
6.
SRI. VISHWANATH YADAV S/O LATE SURAJ YADAV AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
7.
SMT. GHANGHARI DEVI W/O VISHWANATH YADAV AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS SINCE DEAD REPRESENTED BY HER LRs
7(A). LAKSHMAN YADAV S/O VISHWANATHA YADAV AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS 7(B). SHEO SHANKAR YADAV S/O VISHWANATHA YADAV AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS 7(C). ASHHAYLAL YADAV S/O VISHWANATHA YADAV AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS ALL ARE RESIDING AT KENCHANAHALLI NELAMANGALA TALUK BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT-562 123
NATIVE ADDRESS OF THE ABOVE RESPONDENTS: DAMODARPUR (DITTO) BHOJPUR, BIHAR-502 166 8.
SRI. R. VIJAYAN S/O RAJAMANI MAJOR NO. 15/27, SIVADI KATTUVALAVU SIVAI PO, DHARAMAPURI DISTIRCT TAMILNADU-636 807 …RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI: K V NAIK, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R6 & R7 (A TO C); [R2 TO R5 ARE MINORS REP. BY R1]; R8 IS SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED) THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 05.03.2020, PASSED IN MVC NO.342/2019, ON THE FILE OF THE IX ADDITIONAL SMALL CAUSES JUDGE AND ACMM, COURT OF SMALL CAUSES AND MEMBER, MACT-7, BENGALURU, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.87,87,220/- ALONG WITH FUTURE INTEREST AT THE RATE OF 6 PERCENT P.A., FROM THE DATE OF PETITION TILL REALIZATION OF ENTIRE AMOUNT.
IN MFA NO.6056/2021 BETWEEN: 1.
SMT. KIRAN DEVI W/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
2.
KUMARI. POOJA KUMARI D/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS
3.
MASTER PRINCE KUMAR S/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 14 YEARS
4.
KUMARI. KUSHI KUMAR D/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 11 YEARS
5.
KUMARI. ALKA KUMARI D/O LATE RAMESH YADAV AGED ABOUT 08 YEARS (SINCE THE APPELLANT NOS.2, 3, 4 & 5 ARE MINORS, THEY ARE REP. BY THEIR MOTHER SMT. KIRAN DEVI)
6.
SRI. VISHWANATH YADAV S/O LATE SURAJ YADAV AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
7.
SMT. GHANGHARI DEVI SINCE DEAD BY HER LRs
7(A). LAKSHMAN YADAV S/O VISHWANATHA YADAV AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS R/AT DAMODHARPURA (DITTO) BHOJPUR, BIHAR-502 166 7(B). SRI. SHEO SHANKAR YADAV S/O VISHWANATHA YADAV AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS R/AT DAMODHARPURA (DITTO) BHOJPUR, BIHAR-502 166 7(C). SRI. ASKHAYLAL YADAV S/O VISHWANATHA YADAV AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS R/AT DAMODHARPURA (DITTO) BHOJPUR, BIHAR-502 166 ALL ARE RESIDING AT KENCHANAHALLI
NELAMANGALA TALUK BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT-562 123 ...APPELLANTS (BY SRI: K V NAIK, ADVOCATE) AND: 1.
ROYAL SUNDARAM ALLIANZ INSURANCE CO. LTD NO.132, BALAJI SOVEREIGN 2ND FLOOR, BRIGADE ROAD NEAR BRIGADE TOWERS BENGALURU-560 025 REP. BY ITS MANAGER
2.
SRI. R. VIJAYAN S/O RAJAMANI NO. 15/27, SIVADI KATTUVALAVU SIVAI PO, DHARMAPURI DISTIRCT TAMILNADU-636 807 ...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. RAVI S. SAMPRATHI, ADVOCATE FOR R1; VIDE ORDER DATED 23.07.2026, NOTICE TO R2 IS DISPENSED WITH) THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 05.03.2020 PASSED IN MVC NO.342/2018 ON THE FILE OF THE IX ADDITIONAL SMALL CAUSES JUDGE AND ACMM, COURT OF SMALL CAUSES, MEMBER, MACT-7, BENGALURU (SCCH-7), PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION. THESE APPEALS, HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 25.09.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, T.P.VIVEKANANDA J., PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN and HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.P.VIVEKANANDA
CAV JUDGMENT (PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.P.VIVEKANANDA)
MFA.No.4505/2020 is filed by the insurer challenging
judgment
and
award
dated
05.03.2020
in
MVC.No.342/2019 passed by IX Additional Small Causes and Addl. MACT, Bangalore (SCCH-7). The said appeal is only
confined
to
challenge
to
quantum
of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal. MFA.No.6056/2021 is filed by the claimants being not satisfied with the compensation awarded by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment and award and the prayer is for enhancement of compensation. 2.
With the consent of learned counsels appearing
for the respective parties, both the appeals are heard and considered together by this common judgment. 3.
The facts leading to the claimants approaching
the MACT are that, on 01.12.2018 Mr.Ramesh Yadav who
is the husband of the first claimant was proceeding in a motor bike bearing registration No.KA-52-J-4267 along with his daughter-claimant No.2. Claimant No.2 was the pillion rider. Near KMC Glass Factory at Tumkur Road, they met with an accident on account of rash and negligent driving by the driver of lorry bearing registration No.TN29-BC-7701. Due to the serious impact of the injuries, Mr.Ramesh Yadav succumbed to the injuries at the accident spot. 4.
The wife, children and parents of the deceased
have approached the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Bangalore, seeking compensation of Rs.3 Crores for the death of Mr.Ramesh Yadav. 5.
The claim of the claimants before the Tribunal
was that Mr.Ramesh Yadav was a businessman and was earning Rs.30,00,000/- per annum. In support of their claim,
produced.
documents
at
Ex.P.14
Ex.P.15
registration
is
to
Ex.P.19
were
certificate
of
establishment, Ex.P.16 is the agreement, Ex.P.17 is the income tax returns for the years 2014-2015 to 2019-2020.
Claimant No.1 was examined as P.W.1. P.W.7 who is the Manager of Kavi Protein and Feeds Private Limited was examined to establish that the deceased Mr.Ramesh Yadav was providing man power and was a labour contractor of the said Company. The agreement between the Company and Mr.Ramesh Yadav were produced. The copies of the registration certificates, Bank statements and other related documents concerning the contract between the Company and Mr.Ramesh Yadav were produced. 6.
Based on the oral and documentary evidence
produced, the Tribunal by placing reliance on Ex.P.17income tax returns for the year 2018-2019 considered the annual income after deduction of tax in a sum of Rs.5,81,150/-, which comes to Rs.48,429/- per month. Since, the deceased was aged 40 years 11 months as on the date of the accident, the Tribunal has added future prospects at 25% of the income and thus, the total income of
deceased
was
considered
at
Rs.60,536/-
(Rs.48,429/- + Rs.12,107/-). Accordingly, the Tribunal has calculated the loss of dependency at Rs.87,17,220/-
(Rs.60,536/- x 1/5 = Rs.48,429/- x 12 x 15). In addition, the Tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs.15,000/- under the head loss of estate, Rs.15,000/- under the head funeral, obsequies ceremony and conveyance and Rs.40,000/- is awarded under the head loss of consortium. In all, the Tribunal has awarded compensation of Rs.87,87,220/-. 7.
We have heard the learned counsel for the
appellants/claimants in both the appeals and learned counsel appearing for the Insurer. 8.
It is the submission of Sri Ravi S.Samprathi,
learned counsel appearing for the Insurer that the Tribunal has seriously erred in considering the gross income of the deceased as reflected in the income tax return for the year 2018-19. However, the average income of the deceased preceding 3 years should have been considered.
9.
In support of the said contention, the learned
counsel has relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Rashmirekha Tripathy and Another Vs. The Branch Manager (Legal Claims),
Sriram General Insurance Company Limited and Others1. The learned counsel takes us through paragraph Nos.19 & 20 of the said judgment, which reads as follows: "19. When it comes to self-employed/individuals carrying out their own business, in our view, the average of the income specified in the ITRs of up to the previous three years is to be taken as a reference point for assessment of annual income from their business. There may also be a scenario where only one or two ITRs have been filed. Given such scenarios and the fluctuation of income in these professions, surrounding circumstances are also to be taken into consideration. These would include: a) The nature of the business (including geographic location, category etc.); b) Growth pattern of the business and impact of death on the business; c) Potential growth of business (for instance certain businesses are capital intensive at the outset and are profitable at scale/in the future); d) Negative income (certain businesses may require losses in the initial years, which may not reflect true financial standing); and e) Any other relevant factor relating to the business. 20. The date when the ITRs are filed would also become a relevant consideration, as there may be scenarios where inflated income is showcased after death/injury. In these circumstances, the surrounding factors of the business would become more relevant. However, if sufficiently supported by financial statements, such ITRs may also be taken into consideration."
10.
On the other hand, Sri. K.V.Naik, learned
counsel appearing for the claimants submits that the income tax returns for the assessment year 2018-19
2026 SCC Online SC 1256
discloses the gross annual income of the deceased in a sum of Rs.6,27,181/- and after standard deductions, the total income was shown as Rs.5,81,150/- and the total tax payable was only Rs.29,592/-, however, the excess tax amount of Rs.50,122/- was paid and thus, the deceased assessee has received refund Rs.20,530/- and accordingly, his submission is that the taxable income should be Rs.6,01,680/- (Rs.5,81,150 + Rs.20,530/-).
11.
It
is
his
further
submission
that
compensation awarded under the head loss of consortium in a sum of Rs.40,000/- in respect of seven claimants is grossly insufficient and contrary to the judgments of the Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
cases
of
National
Insurance Co. Vs. Pranaya Sethi and Others2 and Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd., Vs. Nanuram @ Chuhruram And Others3 and thus, he concludes his submission requesting this Court to reassess and enhance the compensation.
(2017) 16 SCC 680 (2018) 18 SCC 130
12.
Having heard the submissions of the learned
counsel for the appellants in both the appeals and considering the contentions advanced, we are of the opinion that no reassessment of compensation under the head loss of dependency is required in as much as the finding and calculation made by the Tribunal at paragraph Nos.22 to 24 is just and proper requiring no interference. 13.
The submission of the learned counsel for the
insurer is that the average of the income tax returns filed preceding 3 years of the date of accident is to be considered in the light of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to supra is not seriously appealed to us. In as much as the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed in paragraph No.19 of Rashmirekha Tripathy’s case (stated supra) that in cases where only one or two ITRs are filed, the fluctuation of income in the profession, surrounding
circumstances
have
to
be
taken
into
consideration for arriving at the loss of dependency. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has also noticed that the nature of business, growth pattern of the business, potential growth
of the business, negative
income and other relevant
factors relating to business shall be considered. 14.
In the present case, on perusal of Ex.P.17-
income tax returns, we find that the claimants have produced the income tax returns from the assessment year 2014-2015 till assessment year 2019-2020. The graph of earning of the deceased is upward and there is no fluctuation of the income earned by the deceased. Taking note of the observations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid judgment, it cannot be said that there is fluctuation in the income, therefore, ITRs of preceding 3 years to be considered. In fact, ITRs of the assessment year 2019-2020, which was filed after the death of Mr.Ramesh
Yadav
discloses
that
income
of
Rs.6,29,710/-, which was in respect of the year at which Mr.Ramesh Yadav died. Since, there is no fluctuation in the income of the deceased, the contention of the insurer that the ITRs of preceding 3 years should be taken for assessing the loss of dependency is liable to be rejected. Accordingly, we hold that the Tribunal has not committed
any error in considering the income as disclosed in the returns
filed
for
assessment
year
2018-2019.
Consequently, we also reject the contention of the claimants that the claimants are entitled for reassessment of compensation for the loss of dependency. We find that the loss of dependency assessed by the Tribunal is just and proper and adequate. 15.
We see considerable force in the submission of
the learned counsel for the claimants that the Tribunal has grossly erred in awarding compensation of Rs.40,000/towards loss of consortium to seven claimants. Claimant No.1 is the wife, claimant Nos.2 to 5 are the children, claimant No.6 is the father and claimant No.7 is the mother. It is brought to our notice that claimant No.7 Smt.Ghanghari Devi died during the pendency of this appeal. Therefore, it is only claimant Nos.1 to 6 who are entitled
for
compensation
under
head
loss
of
consortium. The accident is of the year 2018. In terms of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pranaya Sethi’s case, the loss of consortium is required to be
awarded in respect of each of the claimants at Rs.40,000/. Therefore, the claimants are entitled for compensation of Rs.2,40,000/-
(Rs.40,000/-
x
claimants).
The
compensation awarded under the heads loss of estate and loss of funeral expenses is just and proper requiring no interference. 16.
In the result:
(i)
MFA.No.4505/2020 filed by the insurer is dismissed.
(ii)
MFA.No.6056/2021 filed by the claimants is allowed-in-part.
(iii)
The impugned judgment and award dated 05.03.2020 in MVC.No.342/2019 passed by IX Additional
Small
Causes
and
Addl.
MACT,
Bangalore (SCCH-7), is modified by granting additional compensation of Rs.2,00,000/-. The entitlement,
apportionment,
release
compensation
of
deposits
ordered
by
and
Tribunal is undisturbed. (iv)
On account of grant of additional compensation of Rs.2,00,000/-, it is needless to observe that the claimant Nos.1 to 6 are equally entitled for
the compensation of Rs.40,000/- each towards loss of consortium. (v)
It may not be out of context to clarify here that an account of death of claimant No.7, claimant No.6 is entitled for the compensation awarded in favour of deceased claimant No.7.
(vi)
No order as to costs.
Sd/(ANU SIVARAMAN) JUDGE
Sd/(T.P.VIVEKANANDA) JUDGE
PB