M/S United India v. Puttamma

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
27 October 2026
Judge
Justice Ravi V Hosmani
Case number
MFA No. 2873 of 2017
Result
ALLOWED
Acts & sections
Section 166 Motor Vehicles Act, Section 196 Motor Vehicles Act
Subject
Motor accident

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

-1HC-KAR

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 1265 OF 2014 (MV-I) C/W MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 2873 OF 2017 (MV-I) IN MFA No. 1265/2014 BETWEEN: PUTTAMMA W/O POOJARI DODDAIAH AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS R/AT CHANDANAMANE BIKKODU HOBI BELUR TALUK HASSAN DISTRICT PRESENTLY R/AT C/O GOVINDAIAH Digitally signed 2ND CROSS, CPC BOUNDARY by ANUSHA V BALEGADDHE, Location: High SAKALESHPUR TOWN Court of HASSAN DISTRICT.

Karnataka

…APPELLANT (BY SRI. ABHIJITH M.M., ADVOCATE) AND: 1.

MOHAN KUMAR S/O MOHAN KUMAR AGED ABOUT MAJOR R/AT NO.42, 1ST MAIN ROAD, 6TH CROSS, NARAYANAPPA GARDEN

-2HC-KAR

THAVAREKERE BANGALORE-560 029. 2.

THE BRANCH MNAGER UNITED INSURANCE CO. LTD., VENKATESHWAR BUIDLING B M ROAD, HASSAN-573 201. …RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI AM VENKATESH, ADVOCATE FOR R2; V/C/O/DATED 05.12.2017 - NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH) THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 06.11.2013 PASSED IN MVC NO.1234/2012 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE & JMFC, MACT, SAKLESHPUR, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION. IN MFA NO. 2873/2017 BETWEEN: M/S UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED VENKATESHWARA BUILDING B R ROAD, HASSAN-573 201. NOW REP.BY ITS REGIONAL OFFICE 6TH FLOOR, KRISHI BHAVAN NRUPATHUNGA ROAD BENGALURU-560 001 REP.BY ITS MANAGER. ...APPELLANT (BY SRI A M VENKATESH, ADVOCATE)

AND: 1.

PUTTAMMA W/O POOJARI DODDAIAH MAJOR

-3HC-KAR

R/AT CHANDRANAMANE BIKKODU HOBLI, BELUR TALUK HASSAN DISTRICT - 573 164. PRESENT ADDRESS:C/O GOVINDAIAH, 2ND CROSS CPC BOUNDARY, BALEGADDE SAKALESHPUR TOWN HASSAN DISTRICT. 2.

MOHAN KUMAR S/O MOHAN KUMAR NO.42, 1ST MAIN ROAD 6TH CROSS NARAYANAPPA GARDEN THAVAREKERE BENGALURU-560 029. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. ABIJITH M.M., ADVOCATE FOR R1; V/C/O/DATED 05.10.2026 - NOTICE TO R2 IS HELD SUFFICIENT) THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 06.11.2013 PASSED IN MVC NO.1234/2012 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND J.M.F.C,

SAKALESHPUR,

AWARDING

COMPENSATION

OF

RS.1,00,500/- WITH INTEREST AT 6% P.A. FROM THE DATE OF PETITION TILL REALIZATION. THESE APPEALS ARE COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI

ORAL JUDGMENT Challenging

judgment

and

award

dated

06.11.2013

passed by Senior Civil Judge & Member-MACT, Sakaleshpur in

-4HC-KAR

MVC

no.1234/2012,

no.1265/2014

is

these

filed

by

appeals

are

filed.

While

MFA

claimant

for

enhancement

of

compensation and MFA no.2873/2017 is by insurer challenging finding of Tribunal on liability.

2.

Sri Abhijith M.M., learned counsel for appellant in

MFA no.1265/2014 submitted that appeal was by claimant for enhancement of compensation. Brief facts leading to these appeals were that at 07:00 a.m. on 25.04.2012, when claimant was near

water

tank of Chandanmane

village,

rider

of

motorcycle no.KA-05-W-5230 rode it in rash and negligent manner and it dashed against her causing accident. Alleging that despite treatment, she did not recover fully and sustained loss of earning capacity, she filed claim petition against owner and United India Insurance Co.Ltd. under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (MV Act). On appearance, owner appeared and

stated

that

offending

motorcycle

was

insured

with

respondent no.2 and he was entitled for indemnification. Insurer opposed claim petition on all grounds including denying issuance

of

insurance

policy

and

stating

that

Insurance

-5HC-KAR

Company was unable to confirm issuance of insurance policy to motorcycle in question, based on particulars provided.

3.

Based on pleadings, Tribunal framed following

issues: 1. Whether the petitioner proves that she sustained injuries due to the accident alleged to have taken placed on 25.04.2012 at about 7:00 a.m. Chandan House, near water tank and that the said accident occurred due to the rash and negligent riding of the Bike bearing no. KA-05W-5230 by its rider? 2. What was the age, occupation and income of the injured person at the time of accident? 3. Whether the respondent no.1 proves that the driver of the offending vehicle having valid and effective driving licence at the time of accident? 4. Whether the petitioner is entitled for compensation? If so, to what amount? And from whom? 5. What award or order?

4.

Claimant examined herself and Dr.Sreeranga N., as

PWs.1 and 2 and got marked Exhibits P1 to P18. There was no rebuttal evidence.

5.

On

consideration,

Tribunal

held

accident

had

occurred due to rash and negligent riding of motorcycle by its rider and by stating that photocopy of insurance policy was

-6HC-KAR

produced by claimant and no contrary evidence was led by insurer held owner and insurer jointly and severally liable to pay compensation of Rs.1,00,500/- with interest at 6% p.a. from date of petition till deposit. Dissatisfied with same, appeal was filed.

6.

It was firstly submitted, as on date of accident,

claimant was aged 40 years earning Rs.6,000/- per month as Coolie, who sustained fracture of left ankle assessed by PW.2 to have resulted in 23% of permanent physical disability. It was submitted that Tribunal erroneously under assessed monthly income at Rs.3,750/- and disability at 10% and granted inadequate compensation. It was submitted that even award of Rs.5,000/- towards attendance and other incidental expenses as against 24 days of in-patient treatment, Rs.20,000/towards pain and suffering and Rs.5,000/- only towards medical expenses was on lower side and sought enhancement. It was submitted, failure to award any compensation towards future medical expenses for removal of implants as well as towards loss of amenities and loss of income during laid-up

-7HC-KAR

period was also erroneous. On above grounds, sought for allowing appeal.

7.

Sri AM Venkatesh, learned counsel for appellant in

MFA no.2873/2017 submitted that appeal by insurer was on solitary ground that appellant was not insurer of offending vehicle at time of occurrence of accident. Insurance Company had verified policy particulars produced and was unable to confirm issuance of policy. It was stated that review petition on said contention and same having been dismissed, appeal was filed. It was submitted that learned Single Judge of this Court in Oriental Insurance Co.Ltd. v. N.S. Devaraja & Ors. reported in ILR 1997 Kar 1061, under similar circumstances referring to various decisions had held, when Insurance Company had denied issuance of policy to offending vehicle, burden would lie on claimant or owner to establish issuance of policy. Merely on ground that insurer did not lead any evidence would not be a ground for fastening liability on insurer. It was submitted that said ratio would squarely apply and sought for allowing appeal.

-8HC-KAR

8.

On quantum, it was submitted that Tribunal had

awarded just compensation and there would be no justification for enhancement.

9.

In reply, learned counsel for claimant sought to rely

upon decision of this Court in National Insurance Co.Ltd. v. Raju & Ors. [2018:KHC-K:330] to contend that this Court had held even if policy produced by claimant was alleged to be a fake policy, insurer cannot escape liability without leading evidence and therefore, direction for pay and recover was passed. It was submitted that claimant would be satisfied if there is modification to said extent.

10.

Heard

learned

counsel,

perused

impugned

judgment, award and record.

11.

From above and since claimant as well as insurer

are in appeals following points would arise for consideration:

(i)

Whether Tribunal was justified in holding insurer liable

to

pay

compensation

in

absence

of

material to establish appellant as insurer of offending vehicle?

-9HC-KAR

(ii) Whether claimant is entitled for enhancement of compensation as prayed?

Reg.Point no.1: 12.

To

establish

actionable

negligence

against

owner/insurer, claimant sought to rely on FIR, complaint, spot mahazar, seizure mahazar, Motor Vehicle Inspector's Report, charge sheet and MLC Intimation marked as Exs.P1 to P4, P6 and P17 respectively. Perusal of said records would indicate that rider of motorcycle was implicated for causing accident due to rash and negligent riding. Perusal of FIR and charge sheet do not indicate that owner/rider was implicated for offence under Section 146 read with Section 196 of MV Act. However, perusal of claim petition reveals that claimant had mentioned duration of insurance coverage in cause-title of claim petition. In written statement filed by owner, in para 4, he admits insurance coverage by insurer and prays for indemnification. Perusal of written statement filed by insurer reveals a specific assertion that it is unable to confirm issuance of insurance policy to motorcycle no.KA-05-W-5230 with a plea that in case of failure to establish policy, insurer would not be liable.

- 10 HC-KAR

13.

In course of trial, claimant produced photocopy of

proposal form along with photocopy of RC book of offending vehicle. While passing impugned award, Tribunal observed that while claimant produced photocopy of insurance policy and RC book and insurer did not lead evidence to hold insurer jointly and severally liable to pay compensation. A bare perusal of document produced by claimant would reveal that it is only a 'proposal form' dated 30.04.2012 and not insurance policy. Apart from above, proposal form is dated 30.04.2012, when accident in question occurred on 25.04.2012.

14.

In NS Devaraja's case (supra) referring to earlier

Division Bench decisions, this Court had held fastening of liability on insurer on sole ground that it did not lead evidence to establish non-issuance of policy would not be justified as no party could be called upon to establish negative. Though in Raju's case (supra), this Court held insurer liable to pay compensation to claimant in first place and thereafter recover it from insurer and that was case where insurer taking contention of fake policy and would not be parallel on facts to instant case. In view of above, point no.1 is answered in negative.

- 11 HC-KAR

Reg.Point no.2: 15.

On quantum, though as on date of accident,

claimant stated that she was 40 years of age working as Coolie and earning Rs.6,000/- per month, there was no material to establish

income.

In

absence,

Tribunal

was

justified

in

assessing it notionally. But notional income for year 2012 being Rs.7,000/-, same ought to have been considered. There is no dispute about claimant having sustained fracture of bimalleolar of left ankle. To establish permanent physical disability and loss of earning capacity, claimant examined PW.2. PW.2 doctor stated that there were restriction of movements of limb and disability

was

assessed

at

23%.

Considering

nature

of

occupation and extent of disability, assessment of loss of earning capacity at 10% by Tribunal would appear justified. Multiplier applicable corresponding to age of claimant would be '15'. Thus, compensation towards future loss of income would be: Rs.7,000/- X 12 X 15 X 10% = Rs.1,26,000/-.

16.

Medical evidence would indicate that claimant took

in-patient treatment for a period of 24 days. Considering same,

- 12 HC-KAR

award of Rs.5,000/- only towards attendance and other incidental expenses would be grossly on lower side and is enhanced to Rs.15,000/-. Claimant sustained fracture of bimalleolar of left ankle, which is to a structural bone. Considering same, award of Rs.20,000/- towards fractural injury and Rs.3,000/- towards other injury under pain and suffering would be inadequate. It would be appropriate to enhance it to Rs.40,000/-. Tribunal has awarded Rs.5,000/towards medical expenses. Since there is no contention towards proof of medical expenses by production of bills and taking note of fact that claimant has taken treatment in Government Hospital, award would to be justified. In course of his deposition, PW.2 stated about implants in situ. For removal, claimant would require to undergo surgery. PW.2 has also stated about correctional procedures. In view of above, it would be appropriate to award Rs.20,000/- towards future medical expenses. Since claimant has sustained physical disability, loss of amenities is assessed at Rs.30,000/-. Normally fractures take about 3 months to heal. Considering this as period of layoff, claimant is awarded Rs.21,000/- (Rs.7,000/- X 3). Thus, claimant is held entitled for total compensation of

- 13 HC-KAR

Rs.2,52,000/-. Same shall carry interest at 6% p.a. from date of claim petition till deposit. Point no.2 is answered partly in affirmative as above.

17.

Consequently following: ORDER

(i)

MFA no.2873/2017 filed by insurer is allowed;

(ii)

Judgment and award dated 06.11.2013 passed by Senior Civil Judge & MemberMACT, Sakaleshpur in MVC no.1234/2012 is modified holding owner liable to pay compensation to claimant and dismissing claim petition against insurer.

(iii)

MFA no.1265/2014 filed by claimant is allowed in part;

(iv)

Compensation awarded by Tribunal at Rs.1,00,500/-

is

enhanced

to

Rs.2,52,000/- with interest at 6% p.a. from date of claim petition till deposit;

- 14 HC-KAR

(v)

Amount in deposit in insurer's appeal is ordered to be refunded to appellantinsurer by electronic means.

Sd/(RAVI V HOSMANI) JUDGE

AV List No.: 1 Sl No.: 21

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.