Madduri Shiva Shanker and 5 Others v. The Government of Andhra Pradesh and 4 Others
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 27 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Anil Kumar Jukanti
- Case number
- WP No. 15141 of 2005
- Result
- DISPOSED OF NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Section 151 CPC, Article 226 Constitution
- Subject
- Property & land
Full judgment
[ 33841 IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction) TUESDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR JUKANTI WP .Nos.15141 AND 15406 OF 2005
WP NO: 15141 OF 2005 Between:
1. Madduri Shiva Shanker, S/o.Late Sri M Papaiah, aged about 37 years, Occ: Agriculture 2. Madduri Radhakrishna, S/o. Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 34 years, Occ: Agriculture 3. Smt. M.shankaramma, W/O: Late Sri M.Papaiah Aged about 56 years, Occ: House Hold 4. M. Urmila, D/o. Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 35 years, Occ: House Hold 5. M.Laxmi, D/o. Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 30 years, Occ: House Hold 6. M.Vasantha, D/o. Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 27 yeats, Occ: House Hold All are R/o.H.No.4-31 , Chandanagar Village Ranga Reddy District. ...PETITIONERS AND
1. The Government Of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Khairatabad, HYd. 2. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its, Revenue Divisional officer, Chevella Division, Ranga Reddy District. 3. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its, Mandal Revenue Officer, Serilingampally Mandal Ranga Reddy District. 4. Ch.Rama Krishna, S/o.Sri Pentaiah, aged about 51 years, Occ: Contractor 5. Sri Bendapudi Sri Krishna, S/o.Satyanarayana, aged about 51 years, Occ: Contractor Both are R/o.H.No.23-26, Jyotinagar, R.C. Puram Medak District' ...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Cou( may be pleased
to issue a writ order or direction more particularly, one in the nature of writ of Certiorari, call for the records in case No.D5/430112004 on the file of 1st respondent,
and quash the order d1.5.3.2005 passed by 1st respondent in Case No.D5i430112004 as illegal, arbitrary and violation of Principles of natural justice and
against Article-30OA as illegal, arbitrary and violation of Principles of Natural Justice and against Art cle 300-A of Constrtution of lndia.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2022 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to permit the
petitioner to amend the affidavit by adding paragraphs 64 to 6E as under: "64. I submit that the genealogy of the petitioners family is as under: Madduri papaiah Lachamamma l\/adduri Seethaiah Madduri Sayanna 4, (Died issueless) IVladduri Anjaiah (Died issueless) t\/adduri Papaiah "iv 4' Madduri Madduri Madduri [\/adduri Madduri Madduri Shiva Shanker Radhakrishna Shankeramma Urmila Laxmi Vasanta (Petnr-No.1) (Petnr-No.2) (Petnr-No.3) (Petnr (Petnr (Petnr No.4) No.5) No.6) oners er to is as 68. I submit that originally our g reat-grandfather late Madduri papaiah was
the absolute owner in possession and enjoyment of all that land, among others the
land admeasuring Ac.0-21 gts in Sy.No.43 situated in Chandanagar village, Serilingampally lvlandal, Rangareddy District. I submit that after the demise of our g
realg randfather, I\,4adduri Papaiah, the said land was got mutated in the name of
our grandfather l\rladduri seethaiah which is evident from Khasra pahani for the year 1954-1955 and in Chesala Pahani for the years 1955-'1958; pahanies for the years
1975-76;'1985-86; and 1995-96; Adangal for the years 2OO-1 and 2OO3-2OO4 in which his name was shown in Pattadar/owner/possessor column. 1 submit that ever since the mutation our grandfather had been in absolute possession enjoyment. 6c I
submit that after the demise of our grandfather, as our senior father Madduri Sayanna died issueless, the land was mutated in favour of our father, Madduri Papaiah and eversince then he had been in absolute possession and enjoyment of
the land without any let or hindrance from any quarter. 6D I submit that on demise of our father on 13-05-2002, we the petitioners herein filed an application for mutation
of the names of the oetitioners in revenue record and the Mandal Revenue officer
after conducting due enquiry issued mutation orders for the above land along with the other land which he was holding during his life time. 6E I submit' that the allegation of the respondent No.4 before the respondent No.1, that our greatgrandfather had two wives and the name of his first wife is Smt. Madduri Yellarruna
is not correct. I submit that our great-grandfather, never married to anybody else except our great-grandmother, Smt.Madduri Lachamma. I submit that the respondent Nos.4 and Sfailed to produce any evidence in support of their contention.
I submit that the findings recorded by the 2nd respondent and as confirmed by the first respondent are baseless, perverse and without any evidence. However, the respondent No.1 authority on an incorrect appreciation of questions of fact and law
erroneously passed order under challenge mechanically without any basis. Aggrieved by which the petitioners are constrained to approach this Hon'ble Court seeking appropriate reliefs. lt is not out of place to state here that in the report of the Mandal Revenue lnspector it is clearly mentioned that LRs of the deceased Madduri
Seethaiah S/o Late Madduri Papaiah and Madduri Papaiah S/o Late Madduri Seethaiah are the original pattadars of land in in the interest of justice and pass
l.A. NO: 2OF 2005(WPMP . NO: 19257 OF 2005) Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all
further proceedings in pursuance of the orders d1.5.3.2005 passed by the '1st respondent in Case No.D5/4301/2004, pending disposal of the above writ petition.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2005 (wv MP. NO: 2186 OF 2005) Between:
1. Ch.Rama Krishna, S/o.Sri Pentaiah, aged about 51 years, Occ: Contractor
2. Sri Bendapudi Sri Krishna, S/o.Satyanarayana, aged about 51 years, Occ: Contractor Both are R/o.H.No.23-26, Jyotinagar, R.C. Puram Medak District. ...PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS AND
1. Madduri Shiva Shanker, S/o.Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 37 years' Occ: Agriculture
2. Madduri Radhakrishna, S/o. Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 34 years, Occ: Agriculture
3. Smt. M.Shankaramma, W/O: Late Sri [\il,Papaiah Aged about 56 years, Occ: House Hold 4. M. Urmila, D/o. Late Sri IM.Papaiah, aged about 35 years, Occ: House Hold 5. lvl.Laxmi. D/o. Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 30 years, Occ: House Hold 6. M.Vasantha, D/o. Late Sri M.Papaiah, aged about 27 yeas, Occ: House Hold All are Rro.H.No.4-31, Chandanagar Village Ranga Reddy District ...RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS
7. The Government Of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by its Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Khairatabad, Hyd. 8. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its, Revenue Divisional Officer, Chevella Division, Ranga Reddy District. 9. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its, Mandal Revenue Officer, Serilingampally Mandal Ranga Reddy District. ..RESPONDENTS Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the interim order passed rn WPMP No, 925712005 in WP No. 1514112005 dt. 15-7-2005.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI B. NALIN KUMAR Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 3: GP FOR REVENUE Counsel for the Respondent Nos.4 and 5: SRI D. V.N. ACHARYA WP NO: 15406 OF 2005 Between: '1
. Madduri Shiva Shanker, S/o. Late Sri M. Papaiah, Occ: Agriculture,
2. Madduri Radhakrishna, S/o. Late Sri M. Papaiah, Occ: Agriculture, Both are Rlio.H.No.4-31, Chandanagar Vitlage Ranga Reddy District ...PETITIONERS AND '1
. The Government of Andhra pradesh, Rep. by its Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Khairatabd, Hyderabad.
2. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by its Revenue Divisional Officer, Chevella Division, R. R.District. 3. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by its [Vlandal Revenue Officer, Serilingampally Mandal, R.R.District. 4. Smt. K. Satya Sampuma, (Died as per LR R5), W/o. K. Madhava Rao, House Hold, Rl/o. MIG-1 5, Phase-ll, Madinaguda, Miyapur, Hyderabad-S00 050. 5. Jetti Vara Lakshmi, W/o. Srinivasa Chowdary, Hindu, aged about 52 years, Occ. House wife, Fl/o. B 3-36, Amritha Nilayam, MMTS Road, Huda Colony, Hyderabad 500 050.
Respondent No. 5 is brought on record as LR of the deceased Respondent No. 4 as per C.O.dt.12.02.2025 in lA Nos. 1120'18,212022. ...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to lssue a writ order or direction more particularly, one in the nature of Writ of Certrorari, call for the records in Case No.D5/43O'll2O04 on the file of '1st respondent,
and quash the order dt.5.3.2005 passed by 1st respondent in Case No.D5/4300/2004 as illegal, arbitrary and violation of Principles of Natural Justice and against Article -3004 of Constitution of lndia.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2005 (WPMP. NO: 19 5s8 0F 2005) Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased stay all further proceedings in pursuance of the orders dt. 5.3.2005 passed by the 1st respondent in case No.D5/43OO12004.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2005 (vw MP. NO: 2187 OF 2005) Between:
Smt. K. Satya Sampurna, W/o. K. Madhava Rao, aged about 65 years, House Hold, R/o. MIG-15, Phase-ll, Madinaguda, Miyapur, Hyderabad-S00 050.
...PETITIONERS/RESPONDENT AND
1. Madduri Shiva Shanker, S/o. Late Sri M. Papaiah, Occ: Agriculture, Ri./o.H.No.4-31 , Chandanagar Village Ranga Reddy District.
2. Madduri Radhakrishna, S/o. Late Sri M. Papaiah, Occ. Agriculture, Fi/o.H.No.4-31, Chandanagar Village Ranga Reddy Distrlct. ...RESPONENTS/PETITIONERS
3. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, Rep. by its Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Khairatabd, Hyderabad. 4. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by its Revenue Divisional Officer, Chevella Division, R.R.District. 5. The Go,uernnrent of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by its l,/andal Revenue Officer, Serilingampally lvlandal, R.R.District. ...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 15'l CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the interim order passed in WPIr/P No. 19958/2005 in WP No. 154OO12O05 dl. 15-7-2005
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI K. ARAVIND GOUD Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 3: GP FOR REVENUE Counsel for the Respondent No.4: SRI K. CHAITANYA Counsel for the Respondent No.5:--The Court made the following: ORDER
HIGH COURT FO R THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR JUKANTI WRIT PETIT ION Nos.1514l & 15406 OF 2OOs (CNR.Nos.HBHCO lO2 L34O2OO5 & HBHCO 1 0286392OOS )
DATE OF ORDER:27. 10.2O26 Reserved on: 30.06.2026
Pronounced on 27.tO.2026 Uploaded on 28.10.2026
W.P.No.15141 of 2OO5 Betwee n:
Madduri Shiva Shanker and 5 o[hers Petitioners
And 'l'he Government of Andhra Pradcsh, rcp. by its Joint Collector', llanga Rcddy I)rstrict, Khairatabad and 4 othcrs . Respondents
COMMON ORDER: W.P.No.15141 of 2005 is filecl with the follou'ing prayer: " . to issue a wr-it. order or drrection more particularly, one in the nature of Writ of Certiorari, call for the records in case No.D5/4301/2004 on the frle of l",respondent. and quash the order dt.5.
3-2005 passed by l"' respondent in
Case
No.D5/a3O I /2004 as illcgal. arbitrary' :rnd violation of Principlcs r.lf natural justicc and against Article 300A of Constitution of India, and pass such other order or orders ..."
2.
W.P.No.15406 of 2005 is filed with the following prayer
"... to issuc a writ. order or direction more
particularly, one in the natll re oI Writ of Certiorari , call for the records in Oase No.l)5/4301/2004 on the h1e of l",respondcnt, and quash the order dt.5-
3-2005 passed by ln rcspondcnt in
Case
lA(..i
.,\ t, \os r: ].1
& 5J0ar 01 1005
No.l)5,'4300/2004 as illegaJ, arbitrarl, and violation of Principics of Natural Justice ald agarnst Artrcle 300 q ol (lonstitution of India and pass ..."
3.
Heard Ms. Prathvusha Boppanna, learned counsel for
petitioners. Mr. G.Umesh, learned counsel appearing for Mr DVN Acharya, learned counsel for unofficial respondent Nos.4 &
5 and learned. Assistant Government Pleader for official respondent s
4.
lt is subrnitted bv learned counsel for petitioners (in
W.P.No. 15I 41 oi 2005) that petitioners are absolute owners and
possessors of lar-rd in Sy.No.43, admeasuring 21 guntas situated
at Chandanagar Village, Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District. It is further submitted that petitioners inherited the subject property from their father after the demise of their fore-
father Madduri Papaiah and succeeded to the property. It is also
submitted t hat the)' have been in effective possession and enjoyment of tl-re sard property without any interruption or hindrance
4.1. It rs subrnitted by learned counsel for petitioners (in W.P.No. 1502t6 of 2005) that petitioner No.1 and others are
absolute owners and possessors of land in
Sy.No.43,
admeasurinll 21 guntas srtuated at Chandanagar Village,
JAK,J
wPNos l5l,ll & 15406o12005
Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District. It is further
submitted that petitioners inherited the sub.ject property from their father after the demise of their fore-father Madduri Papaiah
and succeeded to the property. It is also submitted that they have been in effective possession and enjoyment of the said property without any interruption or hindrance. In both the writ
petitions, challenge is laid to the order of the Joint Collector on similar grounds.
5.
For convenience, facts in W.P.No.15141 of 2OO5 are being
referred
6. It is submitted that they approached respondent No.3 i.e., Mandal Revenue Officer (MRO) for mutation of their names in revenue records by frling an application under ROR Act. That the
MRO conducted elaborate enquiry and was pleased to issue
mutation proceedings, granted pattadar passbooks and title deeds in their favour vide proceedings No.B/343/2OO3, dated 13.05.2003.
7. It is submitted that unofficial respondent Nos.4 & 5 tried to interfere with the properties of petitioners, that their father filed a suit bearing OS No.540 of 1995 on the file of learned
.l
JAK,J
wPNoi l5lrl& 15{06 of2005
Principal .Junior Civii Judge, West & South, Ranga Reddy District, seeking perpetual injunction and that the said suit was dismissed. It is pointed out that aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed in OS, petitioners' father preferred an appeal vide
A.S.No.94 of 1999 on the file of ill Additional District Judge,
Fastrack Court, Ranga Reddy District and that the first appeal was also ctismissed.
8. It is subrnitted that during the pendency of appeal suit, respondent Nos.4 & 5 approached the revenue authorities by way of an appeal challenged the mutation proceedings passed by
respondent No.3, dated 13.05.2003. That the proceedings of MRO were set aside by respondent No.2 and that an ex parte order was lrassed in File No.Cl392l/2003, dated 19.06.2004.\t
is further submitted that a revision was preferred under Section
9 of Andhra Pradesh Rights in Lald and Pattadar Passbooks Act, 7971 That respondent No.l herein without verifying the records anrl rvithout application of mind, passed orders dated
05.03.2005, b1 considering the order of appellate Court in A.S.No.94 of 1999, dated 18.01.2005.
9.
It is submitted that a second appeal was preferred by the
unsuccesshrl altpellalts (i.e., the petitioners, herein) ald was
JAK.J
WPNos lJ14l & lJ,loo of2001
dismissed by a learned Single Judge of this Court and that a
review is pending. Learned counsel requested this Court that review in second appeal be heard along with these writ petitions.
10. Mr. M.S.Chandresh, learned counsel for petitioners 1n W.P.No.15141 of 2005 (counsel for review petitioners
1n
S.A.No.450 of 2005) tried to impress upon this Court that review I.A.No.2 of 2Ol7 (S.A.M.P.No.805 of 2017) in S.A.No.45O of 2O05 be heard
1. On the other hand, it is the case of the unofficial
respondents that petitioners are trying to claim the title to the
subject property having lost before all the Forums and are not entitled for any relief. It is also submitted that the order of the
Joint Collector does not need interference as it is based on the judgment and decree in A.S.No.94 of 1999, dated 18.01.2005,
which stood confirmed by the learned Single Judge in second appeal. It is also pointed out that the Special Court under A.P. Land Grabbing (Prohibition) Act has also held that petitioners in W.P.No.15406 of 2O05 to be land grabbers. Hence, the claim of
the petitioners being devoid of merits, writ petitions deserves to be dismissed.
JAK.J
w P :,Jos l5l{lA 15106ofl005
12. The present writ petitions are filed challenging the order of Joint Collector dated 05.03.2005, wherein Joint Coilector dismissed the revision. It is reflected in the order that A.S.No.94
of 1999 was dismissed and the order of RDO dated 19.06.2OO4 was well founcled.
13. The following is the relevant portion of the order of Joint Collector: ''l'hc above t\ .o cases are common in view of same lald and the similar parties are involved in these t\\'o cases. therefore are dealt commonly. The brief facts of the case are that one Sn Madduri Seetaiah Pattadar of lald in Sy.No.43' extent 0-21 guntas
died leaving behind two sons (1).Anjarah. t'2).Papaiai. Anj aiah died issueless and Papaiah died leavrng behind his wife, two sons and three daughters as LRs. The wife and daughters submir-ted no objection through Affrdavits to grart succession in respect of the lalds in favour of sons of Late Papaiah and accordingly the Mandal Revenue Ofhcer, Serilingampally gralted successlon. Against these orders two separate appeals were hled before the Revenue Drvisiona.l Ofhcer, Chevella Division alongwith a copy of registered sale deed No.729 11964 rvhich shows that one Sri Madduri Venkatswamy S/o Veeraiah had sold an extent of 0-027 guntas of land out of 0-21 glrntils in Sy.No.43 of Chandanagar Village to one Smt. I)o'inenr Sampurna W/o D. Sharathchandra Babu the sard Smt. D. Sampurna in document No.730/1964 purchased arother extent of 0-28 g!ntas in Sy.No.44 of Chandanaga_r Village from the Pattadars making a total of O-35 guntas and made out plots of different sizes. One of such plots al extent lf 523 Square Meters in Plot No.A-4 was sold out to Sri K.Gopalakrishnaiah through registered ciocumr:nt No.I752/1,967., and the said
JAK.J W P Nos.l5l1l & 15406 of2005
K.Gopalakrishnaiah gifted the said plot to Smt.K.Satya Sampurna. Similarly, Smt.Devineni Sampurna sold out arrother plot of an extent of 523 Square Meters in Plot No.A-3 out of the said Sy.Nos.43 and 44 through reglstered document No.17561 7967 to Sri Papi Reddy Venkateshwar Rao S/o Appalaswamy. In turn the LRs of Sri P.Venkateshwar Rao sold out the said land in two
parts through document No.89i 1/1988 and 8912 / 1988 to Sri Ch.Ramakrishna and Sri G.Srikrishna. Thus executant of the original sale deed No.729 I 1964 was no other than one Sri Venkatswamy one of the legal heirs of original Pattadar i.e., Madduri Sayanna. The family tree brought on record shows that Madduri Sayanna was having two wives (1). Yellamma. (2).La-xmamma. Venkatswamy S/o Veeraiah is the grand son of Smt. Yellamma the first wife of original Pattadar and Sri Papaiah S/o Seetatah is the grarrd son of Smt.La:rrnamma the second of wife of original
Pattadar. Sri Venkatswamy got a share of O-07 guntas in Sy.No.43 under a oral family settlement and sold away his sha_re in the year, 1964 itself. A copy of tJ:e order under appeal before the Revenue Divisional Offrcer, Chevella showed the name of Venkatswamy as Pattadar in respect of Sy.Nos.84 and 89, as such it is evident that he is one of the LRs. of the original Pattada-r. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Serilingampally ought to have seen the
family tree before passing sanctioning the succession. Therefore, the Revenue Divisional Officer, Chevella Drvision found that O-07 guntas sold out by Veeraswamy should have been deleted from the total extent of Sy.No.43 before passing succession order. Further, the Revenue Divisiona-l Officer, Chevella modified the order under appeal to an extent of O-03 guntas in Sy.No.43 alld allowed the appeal. Assailing the same, the present revision is filed. The matter was taken-up for enquiry and notices issued to both the parties, fixing a date of headng on |4-O9-2OO4. The matter was posted from time to
JAK,J
w P \os l5l1l & li40o ot2005
tinre and hnally having come up today for consideration, this court made the following
ORDER: Pemsed the material papers placed before tJlis corrrt and also verihed the lou,er court records. The corrnsel for appellant absent. The counsel for respondent absent. Respondent present and sul)mltted a Xerox copy of decree in A.S.No.94 of 19')9, Dated: I8-01-2005 passed by the Court Of 3.d AdCitional District And Sessions Judge, Ranga Redd1. District in which the appeal of the petrtioners is lound devoid of merits and ttre same is dismissed.
Sinilarly the common order of the Revenue
Dir isional Officer, Chevella Division, Dated: l9-062Ot)4 in File No.C/3414 /2OO3 and Cl392r/2OO3 is also lbund to be well founded. In result the revision
is rlismissed."
14. On a perusal of the Joint Collector's order, it is apparent that in spite of notices to both the parties and a date being fixed
for hearing and the matter being posted on many occasions, counsels were absent. It was only then the order was passed by
the Joint Collector, taking into consideration the judgment and
decree in A.S.No.94 of 1999, dated 18.01.2005 and after considering the order of RDO, dated 19.06.2004
15. It is observed from the record that petitioners have not succeeded in their attempts before the revenue authorities. They
have knocked the doors of the High Court by availing the remedies lmder iaw by preferring a second appeal against the
JAKJ W P Nos 15141 & 15406 of20o5
judgment arrd decree in A.S.No.94 of 1999. The second appeal came to be dismissed by a learned Single Judge of this Court.
16. Petitioners are now setting up a claim that they are in possession of the property and that respondent No.1 has not appreciated the facts on record properly, by placing relialce on
the revenue records, writ petitioners have set up a cha_l1enge to the order of Joint Collector.
17. Copies of revenue records are pressed into service ald reliance is placed on them. I.A.No. I of 2022 is filed to amend the
affidavit by adding paragraph Nos.6A to 6tr and copies of revenue records are arrnexed as documents to the LA.No.1 of 2022.
18. A counter affidavit is filed by the counsel for respondent No.5 (Smt. Jetty Vara Lakshmi, W/o Jetty Srinivasa Choudary) opposing the amendment on the ground that it is filed alter IT
long years and the amendment would cause prejudice to have and the amendment is permitted would go against the f,rnding of
Joint Collector and RDO which are based on record. Hence, amendment deserves to be dismissed.
JAK,J
W P N_os l5l4l & 15106 of2005
19. Additionai material documents are pressed into service by respondent No.5 on 29.06.2026 vide USR No.3 of 2026 i.e., the order of the special Court under AP Lald Grabbing (Prohibition)
Act, dated 30.06.2009 wherein the petitioner Nos.1 & 2 in W.P.No.15141 of 2005 are appellants and one Kode Satya Sampurna is the respondent in LGA No.lO of 2OO7 (appellant in
LGA No.16 of 2OO7 is one Kode Satya Sampurna and respondents are petitioner Nos.1 & 2 in W.P.No.15141 of 2005,
which is also clecided on 30.06.2009). It is observed from the
judgment in LGOP No.255 of 2003 filed by Kode Satya Sampurna against Madduri Shiva Shanker and Madduri Radha
Krishna, the Special Tribunal held that the petitioner was the absolute owner of Plot No.A4 admeasuring 622 Sq.yards 1n Sy.Nos.43 &, 44 at Chandanagar Village and the respondents were held to be land grabbers
20. This Court is not inclined to delve into the aspects decided in LGOP and further adjudicated in LGA No.lO of 2OO7 along with the other LGA i.e., LGA No.16 of 2OO7.It is observed that LGA No.10 ol 2OO7 filed by Madduri Shiva Shanker and Madduri
Radha Krishna was dismissed. LGA No.16 of 2OO7 filed seeking compensation was dismissed as the Kode Satya Sampurna did
JAK.J
WPNos l5l4l & 15406of2005
not depose about the aspect of entitlement to compensation in her evidence. The order under challenge before this Court is that of the Joint Collector
21. It is observed from the record that second appeal arises out of O.S.No.54O of 1995 filed for perpetual injunction in respect of land admeasuring Ac.0.21 guntas of agricultural land
in Sy.No.43 at Chandanagar Village, Serilingampally Mandal' Plaintiff was one Mr. Madduru Papaiah and the writ petitions are filed by legal heirs/ representatives of Mr. Madduru Papaiah
in respect of the very sarne property, who also continued their battle in the first appeal and the second appeal.
22. The judgment in A.S.No'94 of 1999 was challenged by way of a second appeal bearing S.A.No 45O of 2005, which was d.ismissed on merits. The contention that order of Joint Collector
has considered the judgment in A'S.No.94 of 1999 cannot be
found fault with. The order of the Joint Collector was also records that the order of the RDO is well founded' This Court has perused the judgment and decree in A.S.No'94 of 1999 and a judgment in second appeal of the learned Single Judge'
t2
JAK,J
$ P \os I5l.1l& ltl06ol2005
23. It is trite law that when a Court of competent jurisdiction in a second appeal, after considering the judgment and decree in appeal suit and a-lso on the basis of evidence adduced before the
trial Courls (in rvhich writ petitioners herein are the appellants), holds thal plaintiff was not entitled for the relief of perpetual injunction anC that plaintiff failed to establish iawful possession of the plaint schedule property, this Court cannot delve into the
aspect of possession being pressed into service on the basis of the revenue records and the challenge to the order.
24. It is also observed from the record that petitioners' father initiated the legal battle in respect of the very same property in another forum by filing a suit bearing O.S.No.540 of 1995 for
perpetual injunction (i.e., in respect of land to an extent of Ac.0.21 guntas in Sy.No.43, situated at Serlingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District).
25. Pending the suit, the plaintiff died (petitioners' father), writ petitioners continued the legal battle as
legal
heirs/repre.senratives. The dispute ultimately landed before this
Court in the form of a second appeal bearing S.A.No.450 of 2005
and the,v suflered an order in the second appeal. Legal heirs/represent atives of plaintiff Madduru papaiah, continued
l3
]AK,J
w PNos.1514l & 15406 oi200J
the battle on the different platform, have also challenged the order of Joint Collector in the year 2005 by filing writ petitions. Parallel proceedings in respect of the same property were being pursued although on different grounds.
26. Be that as it may, a learned Singie Judge of this Court, vide judgment dated 07.10.2015 dismissed the second appeal and at paragraph No.17, held as follows "17. Tlire law is well settled that the entries in revenue records do not confer or take away the existing title. Therefore, in the light of the evidence and more parLicularty, the fact that the name of the grandfather of the sole plaintiff is also Papaiah artd that he is the ancestor of Venkat Swamy (DW3), the mere mention of the name of Papaiah in the earliest records does not advance the case of the plalntiffs any further. Therefore, the entries in exhibits Al to A2O, the copies of the revenue records, showing the name of either Papaiah or the names of Papaiah arrd his brother Anjaiah are not by themselves sufficient to come to a safe conclusion that the plaintiff is in exclusive law{u1 possession of the entire extent of Ac.O.27 guntas, i.e., the suit schedule property, more parLicularly when the said land, as per the evidence brought out on record, is a fa-llow land and is not under cultivation even as per the version of PW3, the Village Assistant. Having alalyzed the evidence and examined it in juxtaposition with the facts, this Court is satisfied that the courts below are justifred in holding that the plaintiff had failed to establish his lawfu1 possession over the entire plaint schedule property aind that therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled to a perpetual injunction as prayed for in respect of ttte entire plaint schedule property and that the frndings of the courts below well supported by valid and cogent reasons do not call for any interference in this second appeal."
JAI(J
w P Nos l514l & 15406 of2005
. It is apparent from the judgment in the second appeal that
plaintiff failed to establish lawful possession over the entire
plaint schedule property and was not entitled for perpetual lnJunctron, as prayed for,
1n
respect of the suit schedule
property.
28. After the second appea-1
was
dismissed,
a revlew
application bearing Review I.A.No.2 of 2Ol7 (S.A.M.P.No.805 of 2017) was fiied under Section 1 14 of C.P.C. and Order 47 and
Rule 1, 4 and 5 of C.P.C. for reviewing the judgment and decree dated 07.10.2015 in S.A.No.450 of 2005. A learned Single Judge on 14.11.2018 dismissed the review petition filed and the order
is as follovus "On O8.11.2018, Sri G. Dhananjai, learned counsel, submitted that the revicw petitioners have taken av.a). the bundle from him with no objection vakalat arld that he is no longer appearing for the review petitioners. On that day, neither the counsel engaged by the petitioners entered appearaice nor thr: petitioners were present before this Court. Hence, this Court directed to post the application on 13.1 1.2018 under the caption 'for dismrssal by pr:nting the narnes of the review pelitioners in the ca -rse l1st,
On I3.11.2018, when the matter was listed, the names of the review petitioners were not listed in thc calrse list. Therefore, this Court directed the Registrl, to follow the directions in the order, dated 08 1 I .2018, and list the matter todav under the sirne captron .
Today, despite listing the matter under the same czrption after printing -tlre names of the revieu,
JAK,J
w P Nos 15141 & 15,106 of2005
petitioners in the cause list, yet again there is no representation for the review petitioners. Review petitioners are cal1ed absent.
In the result, the Review Petition is dismissed for default. As a consequence, SAMp.No.8O6 of 2OlZ
hled in the review petition shall also starrd
dismissed.
29. After the dismissal of review petition preferred i.e., LA.No.2 of 2077, I.A.Nos.1 and 2 of 2023 werc filed by the petitioners. It
is trite to take note of the order passed in I.A.Nos.1 and 2 of 2023 In S.A.No.450 of 2OO5 on 10. 1O.2023, by a learned Single Judge of this Court. The order reads as follows: "I.A.No.l of 2023 This application is filed to condone the delay of 777 days in resubmitting I.A.Sr.No.97468 of 201g in I.A.No.2 of 2Ol7 (SAMP Review MP.No.805 of 2Ot7 in S.A.No.450 of 2OO5). The reasons mentioned for condonation of delay are not satisfactory. Accordingly, the application is
dismissed.
I.A.No.2 of 2()23
This application is filed to restore the Review
I.A.No.2 of 2077 (S.A.M.P.No.805 of 2Ot7) by settrng aside tJle dismissal order dated 14.11.2018 passed in the Review C.M.P. and to give an opportunity to argue the same. In view of dismissa.l of I.A.No.1 of 2023, LA.No.2 2023 of is also stands dismissed."
30. In view of dismissal of LA.No.l of 2023, which is filed to condone the delay of 777 days in resubmitting I.A.SR.No.9746g of 2OI8 in I.A.No.2 of 2017, LA.No.2 of 2023, which was filed to
restore the review I.A.No.2 of 2OI7 (S.A.M.p.No.gOS of 2017) was
JAK,] W P Nos 1514l & 15406 012005
also dismisseci,
as
such, this Court cannot consider the
contentions put forth that revieu, petition be heard
31. lt is t:-ite to extract the relevant paragraphs of the lalr, laid down bv the Apex Court in Vadigala Prabhakar Rao u, State
of A.P. (reported in 2026 SCC Online SC 815). The Hon'ble Apex Court surnmarized the larv on revenue entries and their
effect on the cluestion of title. The following is the releva-nt portion of the Hon ble Apex Court judgment: "16. Let us summarise the precedents on Revenue Errlries and their legal effect on the question of title: 16.1 Entnes in Revenue Records or Jamabandi ser', e onll' a "hscal purpose", Their primary function is to enable the person whose name is mutated in the records to pay the land revenue in question. 16..2 -{ Revenue Record is not a document of title and does not confer any olvnership or title upon the person whose narne appeaJs in it. Further, mutation
does ni)t create o.r extinguish title and has absolutely no presumptive value regarding tit1e.
16.3 The mere acceptance of municipal or agricultr.rral taxes, or the granting of a bank loan based on these records, does not stop the State from chatlengrng the ownership of the land. 16.4 \\'hile they do not prove Lit1e, Revenue Records
can raise a presumption regarding possession. M:rintenance artd custody of Revenue Records is the exclusivt domain of the Patwari, and it is not uncommon that Revenue Records are often tinkered u:d br him to suit the exigencies. 16.5i Stra,v or solitary entries recorded for a single year do not raise a presumption of rights and cal-rl-rot I)e relied upon against a long, consistent coulse o1'revenue entries in favour of another party. 16.,5 Tht: creation of fabricated records in collusion acls as a camouflage to defeat the legal rights of the
t7
IAK.J
WPNos 15141 & l5r0o of 2005
actual tiller, and the Government is not bound by
tiem."
32. On a perusal of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court, it is apparent from the contents of paragraph Nos.16.2 and 16.4 that revenue records do not confer any ownership nor
they are documents of title. It is also trite to take note of the observation that revenue records can raise a presumption regarding possession
33. O.S.No.540 of 1995 was filed in respect of land admeasuring Ac.O.21 guntas of agricultural land in Sy.No.43 at Chandanagar Village, Serilingampally Manda, seeking the relief
of perpetual injunction. The relief sought by the plaintiff i.e., father of the petitioners herein was negatived and even in the second appeal, the petitioners suffered an order in respect of the subject property.
34. In other words, contentions advanced on behalf of the petitioners' that they are in possession by virtue of the entries in revenue records cannot be countenanced in the light of the judgment in second appeal.
35. Having perused the materia-l on record and having considered the entire factua,l matrix of the case, this Court is of
I8
JAK.J W P Nos l5lr I & 15406 of200t
the opinion that the order of the Joint Collector does not necessitato interference
36. This Court neither can ignore nor substitute the finding rendered by the learned Single Judge in the judgment in second appeal whrch is the competent Court to render a finding on the aspect of possession in a suit filed for perpetua_i injunction. Any
tinkering or observation on the aspect of possession will have an effect on the judgment in second appeal, which is impermissible
under law. The relevant portion of the judgment of the second appeal is extracted and is as follows: "FIar ing analyzed the evidence and examined it in
juxtaposition with the facts, this Court is satisfied thrlt the courts below are justifred in holding that thr: plzuntrff had failed to establish hrs lau{ul possession over the entire plaint schedule property and that therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled to a pel'pctual injunction as praved for in respect of the enr ire plaint schedule property and that the hndings of thc courts below well supported by vatid ald cogent reasons do not call for any interference in this second appeal."
. On the aspect of the submission advanced that the first
respondent has not given any opportunity for advancing the arguments is untenable. In this aspect, it is trite to take note
that the respondent No.1 in his order, dated 05.03.200S, recorded as follo$-s:
l9
JAK,] W P Nos l5l4l & It406 of2005
"The matter was taken-up for enquiry and notices issued to both the parties, fi,xing a date of hearing on I4-09-2OO4. The matter was posted from time to time and frnally having come up today for consideration, this court made the fo1lowing."
38. It is also recorded in the order by the respondent No.1 that the counsel for appellalt was absent and counsel for respondent
was a-lso absent. It is apparent from the order of the Joint Collector that the counsel for appeilant and counsel for respondent were absent and the matter was posted from time to
time. Hence, the contention that an opportunity was not granted
is devoid of merits. This Court, having perused the material on record, is not inclined to show any indulgence in the contention advanced that no opportunity was granted by respondent No.1
39. It is observed from the order in LGA No.10 of 2OO7 that respondent No.5 in W.P.No.15406 of 2005 (Kode Satya Sampurna) was held to be the absolute owner of the subject property which fell for consideration before the Land Grabbing Tribunal and petitioner Nos. 1 & 2 were held to be land grabbers.
40. On a perusal of the entire material on record, it is obviously apparent that the dispute pertains to the subject property which is said to have been partitioned into three shares
JA};J
!l P \os 1i]lL& 15.106of2005
arnongst Venkata Swamy, Anjaiah and Papaiah and they were enjoying their shares. Papaiah is the plaintiff in the suit who was
sought th e relief of perpetual injunction against defendants (defendalts
etre
respondents in this writ petition bearing
No.15141 of 2005), after the dismissai of the suit, an appeal was
preferred and on the death of the plaintiff, the petitioners who are the leeal heirs/ representatives continued the battle. in the second appeal, respondent Nos.4 & 5 in this writ petition are arrayed
AS
respondents i.e., Ch.Ramakrishna and Bendapudi
Srikrishna (K.Arjun Kumar is also arrayed as a respondent in the seconcl appeal)
4L
On a conspectus of the entire facts, it is apparent that the
dispute is in respect of the title to the subject property being claimed bv t he parties herein in these writ petitions and the same needs to be adjudicated by a competent Court.
42. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Sohan Lal a. Union of India (reported rn (1957) 1 SCC 439) held that proceedings under
Article 22(t ol the Constitution of India are not the appropriate forum for resolving serious disputes concerning questions of fact
and title to property. Investigating these claims is the proper function o1' a (livil Court in a regularly constituted suit, rather
ll
A(..1
$ :,\L\ i 1L ( LiJri(,,r1 ln(r:
than of a court exercising the prerogative to issue writs. Parties are at liberty to invoke remedies as available under iaw'
43. For reasons aforesaid, writ petitrons stand disposed of No order as to costs SD/. C.DEEPIKA ASSISTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// SECTION OFFICER To,
The Joint Collector, The Government Of Andhra
Pradesh' Ranga Reddy
District, Khairatabad, HYd.
2.
The Revenue Divisional Officer, The Government
of Andhra Pradesh'
3.
The lrilandal Revenue Officer, The Government
of Andhra Pradesh'
Chevella Division' Ranga Reddy District
Seiitingampatty Mandal Ranga Reddy District' Advocate[OPUC] 4. One CC to Sri B. Nalin Kumar, One CC to Sri K. Aravind Goud, Advocate [OPUC] High Court for the- State of Telangana' at 6 Tw-o CCs to GP for Revenue' Hyderabad [OUT] Advocate[OPUC] 7 One CC to Sri D.V.N. Acharya, One CC to Sri K. Chaitanya, Advocate [OPUC]
I
o TJ PB
. Two CD CoPies
q"
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2711012026
(
1 r{E
STAr
a-
ORDER
c()
't,
0 6 Nov 2u6
5.
WP.Nos.15141 AND 15406 OF 2005
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITONS WITHOUT COSTS
{? o6
lrrlz
aF
>..,
C)