Madhav Tulshiram Shivbhakte v. The State of Maharashtra and Others
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 4 November 2026
- Case number
- WP No. 435 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED OFF
- Acts & sections
- Section 35 BNSS, Section 333 BNS, Section 109 BNS
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:54493-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 435 OF 2026 Madhav s/o. Tulshiram Shivbhakte Age : 21 years, Occ : Labour, R/o. Balirampur, Tq. & Dist. Nanded. ... PETITIONER VERSUS 1.
The State of Maharashtra, Through its Section Officer, Home Department (Special), Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.
2.
The District Magistrate, Nanded, Tq. & Dist. Nanded.
3.
The Superintendent of Jail, Central Jail, Harsool, Aurangabad Dist. Aurangabad. ... RESPONDENTS
... Mr.Shailendra S. Gangakhedkar, Advocate for the Petitioner Mrs.M.N.Ghanekar, APP for Respondent nos.1 to 3. ... CORAM
: SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE & VAISHALI PATIL-JADHAV, JJ.
RESERVED ON : 21.10.2026. PRONOUNCED ON : 04.11.2026
JUDGMENT [Per : Vaishali Patil-Jadhav, J.] : .
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard
finally at the admission stage with the consent of learned advocates for the parties. 2.
By this petition, the petitioner challenges the
detention order dated 29.01.2026 bearing No. 2026/RB1/Desk-2/T-4/MPDA/CR-11, passed by Respondent No. 2District Magistrate, Nanded, in exercise of the powers under Section 3(1) of the Maharashtra Prevention of Dangerous Activities
of
Dangerous
Persons,
Persons
Slumlords,
Engaged
Video in
Bootleggers, Pirates,
Drug-offenders,
Sand
Black-Marketing
of
Smugglers, Essential
Commodities, Illegal Gambling, Illegal Lottery and Human Trafficker Act, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as “MPDA”), and the confirmation order dated 27.03.2026 bearing No. MPDA-0226/CR-82/Spl-3B, passed by Respondent No. 1State Government, in exercise of the powers under Section 12(1) of the MPDA. By the impugned detention order, the petitioner is directed to be detained for a period of 12 months on the ground that the petitioner is a “dangerous person” within the meaning of Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA.
3.
The record reflects registration of seven (07)
criminal cases and two preventive actions taken against the petitioner. The reference chart showing the criminal record of the petitioner is reproduced hereunder : Sr. Police No Station
C.R. No.
Under Section
Date of filing
Date of arrest
Bail Date
Court Case No.
Present Status
1.
Nanded Rural
67/2023
457,380, 34 of IPC
07.02.2023
09.02.2023
17.05.2023
RCC No.523/24
Court pending
2.
Nanded 299/2023 Rural
160 of IPC
24.04.2023
24.04.2023
24.04.2023
RCC No.1707/23
Court pending
3.
Nanded 467/2023 452, 354Rural A, 506 of IPC
26.06.2023
27.06.2023
21.02.2024
RCC No.203/23
Court pending
4.
Nanded 645/2023 4/25 of Rural Arms Act
04.09.2023
04.09.2023
04.09.2023
RCC No.1532/23
Court pending
5.
Nanded 738/2025 4/25 Rural Arms Act
02.08.2025
02.08.2025
02.08.2025
RCC No.1451/25
Court pending
6.
Nanded Rural
1209/25
333, 352, 351 (2), 351 (3), 3 (5) BNS
18.12.2025
20.12.2025
20.12.2025
--
On investigation
7.
Nanded Rural
1210/25
109, 126 (2), 115 (2), 352, 351 (2), 352 (3), 189(2), 191 (2), 191 (3), 190 BNS 4/25 Arms Act
18.12.2025
19.12.2025
19.01.2026
--
On investigation
Preventive Action :Sr. No.
Police Station
Chapter Case No.
Section
Date
Present status
1.
Nanded Rural
24/2023
110 CrPC
19.03.2023
Closed
2.
Nanded Rural
287/2025
126 BNSS
04.08.2025
Closed
4.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submits that
out of the three recent crimes considered by the detaining authority for passing the impugned order, the petitioner was released on the very same day of his arrest in C.R. No. 738/2025, by serving a notice under Section 35(3) of the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, "BNSS, 2023"), and in C.R. No. 1209/2025. Furthermore, in C.R. No. 1210/2025, the petitioner was arrested on 19.12.2025 and was subsequently released on bail by the competent court on 19.01.2026, with certain conditions. Learned advocate submitted that the State did not move any application for the cancellation of bail in any of these cases, nor did the detaining authority record its subjective satisfaction as to why the conditions imposed by the courts or the immediate release on issuance of notice under Section 35(3) of the BNSS, 2023 were insufficient to prevent the alleged prejudicial activities of the petitioner. Learned advocate also submitted that there is an unexplained delay of more than one month in passing the impugned order, as the last crime was registered on 18.12.2025, the proposal was forwarded on 22.12.2025, but the order of detention was passed only on 29.01.2026.
It was further submitted that the in-camera statements of witnesses A and B are mechanical and were recorded on 19.12.2025, when the petitioner was already in police custody, which completely negates the alleged apprehension of the witnesses, and that the alleged acts are individual in nature and do not amount to a breach of public order. Learned advocate lastly submitted that the detention order is liable to be quashed and set aside and prayed for the release of the petitioner. 5.
Per contra, learned APP while supporting the
impugned
order
submitted
that
the
petitioner
is
a
“Dangerous Person” within the meaning of Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA, as he has committed serious offences under the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, "IPC", Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (for short, "BNS, 2023") and the Arms Act, 1959. His activities have created a reign of terror in the Nanded Rural area, and people are afraid to give statements against him openly. It was submitted that grant of bail does not preclude or invalidate the exercise of powers under the MPDA. The detaining authority was aware of the bail orders but found them insufficient to prevent the petitioner from acting in a prejudicial manner. After considering the gravity
of
the
petitioner's
criminal
activities,
the
in-camera
statements of confidential witnesses were recorded and duly verified. The incidents occurred at public places, involved threats and violence, and directly disturbed public order. Learned APP lastly submitted that the detaining authority has passed the detention order after applying its mind
to
the
entire
record
and
that
the
subjective
satisfaction of the detaining authority is based on cogent material, and prayed for dismissal of the petition. 6.
Heard
learned
Advocate
Mr.
Shailendra
S.
Gangakhedkar for the petitioner and learned APP Ms. M.N. Ghanekar for the respondents. With the assistance of the learned advocates, we have perused the petition, the affidavit-in-reply, citations and the record. 7.
The detaining authority, while passing the
impugned detention order, has mainly relied upon three offences, i.e., C.R. No.738/2025 registered on 02.08.2025 under Sections 4/25 of the Arms Act, 1959,
C.R.
No.1209/2025 registered on 18.12.2025 under Sections 333, 352, 351(2), 351(3), 3(5) of the BNS, 2023, and C.R. No. 1210/2025 registered on 18.12.2025 under Sections
109, 126(2), 115(2), 352, 351(2), 352(3), 189(2), 191(2), 191(3), 190 of the BNS, 2023 and Section 4/25 of the Arms Act, 1959, all registered with Nanded Rural Police Station, Nanded,
along
with
two
in-camera
statements
of
confidential witnesses "A" and "B", to declare the petitioner a “Dangerous Person”. 8.
Admittedly, three offences have been considered
for passing the detention order against the petitioner, out of which, C.R. No.738/2025 is under Sections 4/25 of the Arms Act, 1959, wherein, it is alleged that, while patrolling at night the police received information that the petitioner was standing on the road with a weapon. Thereafter, the police went to the spot and seized the iron dragger in presence of two witnesses and filed the abovementioned F.I.R. In C.R. No.1209/2025, it is alleged that the brother of the petitioner had committed murder of the brother of the complainant and thereafter, the brother of the petitioner was released on bail and the complainant filed a complaint that the petitioner and his brother are threatening
them
for
withdrawing
the
complaint
by
entering into their house.
In C.R. No.1210/2025, it is alleged that the complainant was driving the auto rickshaw and one of his friend Gujjar was traveling by his auto-rickshaw towards his home. When they reached Zilla Parishad School, Balirampur, the petitioner and other accused persons started verbally abusing the complainant and there was some scuffle between Gujjar and some other accused persons. The allegation towards the petitioner is only that he, his wife and mother-in-law verbally abused the complainant and gave slaps and punches. 9.
All of these offences are individual in nature, in
between two private parties and, society as such is not involved in any of the offences. In F.I.R. No.1210/2025, other accused persons were found with deadly weapon. However, there is nothing on record to show that other accused were also dealt with similar preventive action as that of the petitioner. Moreover, it was revealed that the other associates of the present petitioner had created an atmosphere of terror. It appears that the aforesaid incident was individual in nature and for that purpose the petitioner was arrested and thereafter released on bail.
10.
So far as, the statements of secret witnesses are
concerned, both of them appear to be stereotype in nature wherein general criminal behaviour of the petitioner is discussed. Moreover, on going through those statements, it is clearly evident that though the same took place at public place, there was no deterrence to the public at large. The incidents described, even if accepted at face value, appear to be incidents affecting law and order, but not public order. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ameena Begum Vs. The State of Telangana and Ors. reported in 2023 INSC 788, has discussed the distinction between "law and order" and "public order" stating that the difference between the two is of degree and impact. An act may affect the law and order but not public order. It is only when the act affects the community at large or the even tempo of life of the people that it becomes a public order issue. The statements of confidential witnesses in the present case do not establish that the petitioner's activities had caused an impact on the public order. 11.
Another
ground
is
regarding
the
non-
consideration of bail orders. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of Ameena Begum (supra) has observed as under:
“It is pertinent to note that in the three criminal proceedings where the Detenu had been released on bail, no applications for cancellation of bail had been moved by the State. In the light of the same, the provisions of the Act, which is an extraordinary statute, should not have been resorted to when ordinary criminal law provided sufficient means to address the apprehensions leading to the impugned Detention Order. There may have existed sufficient grounds to appeal against the bail orders, but the circumstances did not warrant the circumvention of ordinary criminal procedure to resort to an extraordinary measure of the law of preventive detention. 52. In Vijay Narain Singh vs. State of Bihar, Hon’ble E.S. Venkataramiah, J. (as the Chief Justice then was) observed: 32. ...It is well settled that the law of preventive detention is a hard law and therefore it should be strictly construed. Care should be taken that the liberty of a person is not jeopardised unless his case falls squarely within the four corners of the relevant law. The law of preventive detention should not be used merely to clip the wings of an Accused who is involved in a criminal prosecution. It is not intended for the purpose of keeping a man under detention when under ordinary criminal law it may not be possible to resist the issue of orders of bail, unless the material available is such as would satisfy the requirements of the legal provisions authorising such detention. When a person is enlarged on bail by a competent criminal court, great
caution
scrutinising
the
should
be
exercised
in
validity
of
an
of
order
preventive detention which is based on the very same charge which is to be tried by the
criminal court.” (emphasis supplied)
12.
Applying the above principles to the facts of the
present case, it emerges that in Crime No.738/2025 and Crime No.1209/2025, the petitioner was not arrested and was only served with notice under Section 35(3) of the BNSS, which shows that the detaining authority did not find it necessary to arrest the petitioner and detain him to prevent
the
further
illegal
activities.
In
Crime
No.1210/2025, the petitioner was arrested on 19.12.2025 and was released on bail by the competent Court on 19.01.2026 by imposing certain conditions. The detaining authority while passing the impugned order, has merely noted the fact of the petitioner’s release on bail without adverting to the bail order or examining the sufficiency of the conditions imposed therein. There is no discussion in the detention order as to why the conditions were insufficient to restrain the petitioner from acting in a manner prejudicial to the public order. There is nothing on record to show that the petitioner has violated bail conditions or the State has filed any application for cancellation of bail. This indicates that the remedies
available under the ordinary criminal law were not resorted to by the authorities to deal with the situation, and instead, the extra ordinary power of preventive detention was invoked. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Shaik Nazneen Vs. State of Telangana and others reported in (2023) 9 SCC 633, has observed that if the detenu is a menace to society, the prosecution can seek cancellation of his bail and/or move an appeal to the Higher Court. Seeking shelter under the preventive detention law is not the proper remedy. 13.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Rekha Vs.
State of Tamil Nadu reported in (2011) 5 SCC 244, has held that preventive detention is a serious encroachment on personal liberty, and the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority must be based on cogent and relevant material. The Court further observed that if the ordinary criminal law is sufficient to deal with the situation, the detention order is liable to be quashed. 14.
In the instant case, the detaining authority has
failed to record any valid reason as to why the ordinary penal provisions under the BNS, 2023 were inadequate to prevent the petitioner's alleged activities. The reliance on a
case where the petitioner was in judicial custody for a long period and the non-consideration of bail conditions indicate that the authority mechanically applied its mind without examining the actual gravity and impact of the incidents. This failure shows the non-application of mind while arriving at the subjective satisfaction by the detaining authority. The material relied upon is insufficient to categorize the petitioner as a "Dangerous Person" within the meaning of the MPDA Act. 15.
We are, therefore, of the considered view that
the detention order and the subsequent approval and confirmation orders are unsustainable and are liable to be quashed and set aside. Accordingly, we pass the following order: ORDER (i)
The Writ Petition is allowed.
(ii)
The
detention
order
dated
29.01.2026
No.2026/RB-1/Desk-2/T-4/MPDA/CR-11,
bearing
passed
by
Respondent No. 2- District Magistrate, Nanded and the confirmation order dated 27.03.2026 bearing No. MPDA0226/CR-82/Spl-3B, passed by Respondent No. 1- State Government, are hereby quashed and set aside.
(iii)
The Petitioner- Madhav S/o Tulshiram Shivbhakte
shall be released forthwith, if not required in any other offence. (iv)
Rule is made absolute in the above terms.
[VAISHALI PATIL-JADHAV] JUDGE
[SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE] JUDGE
SGA