Mahesh Kumar Rathi, v. The State of Telangana,
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 5 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice B.vijaysen Reddy
- Case number
- WP No. 33318 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED OF NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Article 226 Constitution
Full judgment
[ 3183 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD (SPecial Original Jurisdiction) MONDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.VIJAYSEN REDOY WRIT PETITIO N NO: 333 18 0F 2026
Between: Rathi' Occ Chartered Mahesh Kumar Rathi', Age.60 years S/o Ranchod Das n""orntrnt Rlo.4-7-102, Esamia Bazar, Koti, Hyderabad Sreekanth Kulkarni' Occ Service' 2 Smt. Sarwade Vaishali,, Age. 50 years, w/o Flat No.27, TSR Nagar, Meerpet, Ranga Reddy District' r/o H No 4-4-1 ' Flat No BJ Nandlal Totla,, Age. 87 years, s/o Gangaram Totla' 2'l , Dilshad Plaza, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad' Laxminivas Kishan Lahoti' Occ' 4 Hari Kishan Lahoti, , Age. 66 years, S/o errin".., r/o. H.No.4-4-1 , Flai No B-23, Dilshad Plaza' Sultan Bazar'
Hyderabad.
Sharma' Occ House wife' Smt. Sandhya Devi,, Age. 56 years, w/o Bhagwandas Hyderabad Jo. ff .No.+-+-r, Flat No-.8-33, bilshad Plaza, Sultan Bazar' R/o 15-26. Jitesh H. Thakar, ' Age. 67 years, S/o Harish Ch ' Occ Business 307/ 1 , 3rd floor, Kishangun.l, Hyderabad' Occ Service R/o' 7. Khemchand Daga,, Age 50 years, s/o Shankarlal Daga' n r.lo.+-+-r, Ftat-No.C-2e, Dilshad Plaza, Sultan Bazar' Hyderabad' Das Heda' Occ' 8. Smt. Tara Devi Heda, , Age 64 years' w/o late Purshotham Bazar' H No a-"+ t f tat No D-13' Dilshad Plaza' Sultan
- iou." wife, R/o.
,
Hyderabad.
w/o. Jugal Kishore Totla' Occ House L Smt. Sharada Devi Totla, , Age 59 years' Gunj, Jain Bhavan, Gowliguda cheman'
wife, r/o. H.No.1 5-2-169i1 7o,"Maha;aj Hyderabad.
Totla' Occ' House wife' r/o' 10.Smt. Leela Devi Totla,, Age. 60 years, w/o Gopal Gowliguda Cheman' H.No. 1 5-2-1691170, MahLai Gunj' Jain Bhavan' Hyderabad.
Malani,, Age. 46 years, s/o. Sampath Kumar Malani, Occ Business, R/o. Ftat No.32, D-Block, H.No.4-4-1 , Flat No.D-24, Dilshad Plaza' Sultan Bazar, Hy'derabad. 12. Unesh Daga,. Age. 28 years, s/o. Karnidan Daga, Occ. Service RA). Flat No 32' D-Block, H.No.4-4-1, Flat No.D-32, Dilshad Plaza, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad'
1 1 . Narayandas
13. Amrit Doshi, , Age. 33 years, s/o. Surendra Kumar Doshi, Occ Business Rio'
H.No.4-5-896/4, Kruparambagh, Badichowdi, Hyderabad 14.Sri. Vimal Kumar Gaggar,, Age.69 years. S/o. Sri Prabhudayal Gaggar, Occ Business Occ. Business, R/o.D-43, Dilshad Plaza, 4-4-1, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad-50001 2, Telangana. 15.Sri Vishnu Das Bhutada, , Age. 61 years S/o. Sri Mohan Lal Bhutada, Occ Business, R/o. Flat No.D-1 1, 4-4-1lDl11 Kanda Swamy Lane, Dilshad Plaza, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad-500095. 16. Bhagwandas Sharma, , Age. 68 years S/o. Ramanoj Sharma. R/o.4-4-1 Dilshad Plaza, Sultan Bazar Hyderabad. 17. Ramesh Kumar Toshniwal, , Age. 55 years S/o. Jai Prakash Toshniwal, Occ Business Rlo.4-4-118,132139, Dilshad Plaza Sultan Bazar' Hyderabad. 18. Sunita Bohra,, Age. 39 years W/o. Anil Kumar Bohra, Occ Housewife Rlo.4-4-1'
Dilshad Plaza, Sultan Bazar Hyderabad, Telangana. lg.Jayshree Rathi, , Age.56 years, W/o. Pradhyuman Rathi, Occ Housewife R/o.45-573, Flat No.204. Acropolis Tulip Apts., Badichowdi, Hyderabad. 20. Ramanuj Sharma, , Age. 87 years S/o. Govind Ramji Sharnra No 4-4-1lB-11' Dilshad Plaza Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad. 21 . Sri. Surender Kumar Doshi,, Age. 58 years, S/o.Shree Chand Doshi, Occ. Business, R/o.4-5-896, Krupamrambagh, Badichowdi Hyderabad' TG.
22.Narendra Kumar Doshi, , Age.60 years S/o. Shree Chand Doshi, Occ. Business R/o.3-4-173. Flat No.201 , Baglingampally Kachiguda, Hyderabad. PETITIONERS AND
1. The State of Telangana,, rep. by its Principal Secretary, tr,,4unicipal Administration and Urban Development Department, Secretariat. Hyderabad. 2. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation,, rep.by its Commissioner, Tank Bund Road, Hyderabad. 3. The Zonal Commissioner, GHMC,, Khairatabad Zone, Hyderabad
4. The Deputy Commissioner, GHMC, Circle No.35, Khairatabad, Hyderabad. 5. JNTUH University College of Engineering, Science and Technology, Hyderabad,
lndLrstrial Consultancy Services (lCS), rep.by its Chief Coordinator, ICS Kukatpally, Hyderabad-500 085, Telangana State.
...RESPONDENTS
praying that in. the Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia court may be pleased toto circumstances stated in tne affiJavit filed therewith, the High the nature of Writ of issue a writ, order or. Uit""tion' more particularly one in the
"
herein in not conducting Mandamus, declaring tne action of iespondent No.s-J'NITU a detailed, report of the field inspection and structurai stability iest and in not submitting piaza situated at H No 4-4-1 ' Sultan Bazar' Hyc'l5 abad' same for the building oifsnal 21-08-2026' as prr.rrnt to the reqiuisition ,uJ" Ly respondent No.2-GHMC dated respondent ["i"g iil"grr, arbitraiy, and without any basis and consequently' to direct the
No.5herein,throughitslndustrialConsultancyServices'toinspectthesaidbuildingand report of the same to ,."".trin itt struciural satety anO stability and submit a detailed issued by Respondent R;.;;;J.;t No.2_GHMC in ier.s of the [etter dated 21-08-2026 No.2
t.A. NO :1OF 2026
PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesStatedinthe
may be pleased 10 direct ,the affidavii iited in support of the petitioni tfrl iign Court test of the building L.po"O""t No.5 to conduct aiieta inspection a-nd structural stability report of the a detailed submit O-i-rJn"Jpf".r, H.No.4-4-1 , Srrtrn Su"'' Hyderabad and tetter dated 21-08-2026 issued bv ;;il1" iesponoent ruo.z_ oHrrac, aswritper petition Respondent No.2, pending disposal of the Counsel for the Petitioner(s): Sri' Rohan Aloor Counsel for the Respondents No' 1: Gp For Mcpl Admn Counsel for the Respondents No' 2 to 4: Sri M Arun
Urban Dev
Kumar' SC for GHMC
Counsel for the Respondents No' 5: SRI MR' Peri Prabhakar' The Court made the following: ORDER
Sc for JNTU
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYOERABAD
HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE B. VIJAYSEN REDDY WRIT PETITION No.33318 OF 2026 C NR. No. HBHC0 1 0682482026
Date: 05.'10.2026 Between: Mahesh Kumar Rathi and others Pe tition ers
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Municipal Administration and Urban Deveropment Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, and others. .. Respondents
ORDER:(ORAL) Heard Mr. A. Giridhar Rao, learned Senior Counsel, appearing
for Mr. Rohan Aloor, learned counsel for the petitioners; Mr. M Arun Kumar, learned Standing Counsel for GHMC, appearing for
respondent Nos.2 to 4; and Mr. Peri Prabhakar, learned Standing
Counsel appearing for respondent No.5, and perused the material available on record
2. The limited grievance of the petitioners is that respondent No.5
- JNTUH is not conducting the field inspection and structural stability
test of the subject building, namely, "Dilshad Plaza", situated at
tsVR,J
WP.No.33318 2026
H.No.4-4-1, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad, and
is also not submitting a
detailed report regarding the safety and structural subject building, pursuant to the requisition
stability of the
made by respondent No 2 -
GHN/C vide letter dated 21 .08'2026'
3. The documents placed on record by the
proceedings have been initiated under the
petitioners reveal that
provisions of the Greater
Hyderabad tvlunicipal Corporation Act, 1955
(for short 'GHI\/C Act')'
pursuant to a complaint s-ubmitted by the residents the subject building alleging that the subject
building is in a dilapidated
and dangerous condition. Consequently, notice rhe GHN/C Act, dated 22'05'2026, was
and neighbours of
under Section 459 of
issued to the owners/occupiers
of the building
4. lt is stated that the Executive Engineer-ll' Khairatabad GHI\iC, vlde letter No. Nil/E-ll/Circle-35/Khairatabad 2026-27, datecj 2,1 .08.2026, addressed
Zone'
ZonelGHIt/C/
to respondent No.5, requested
respondentNo.5toconductfieldinspectlonandstructi:ralstabilitytest Pursuant to the of the subject building and submlt a detailed report'
said request, respondent No 5 raised an invoice R.s..17,7001 towards consultancy charges for the
for a sum of
preliminary site visit of
the subject building and a further sum of Rs 1'77'0001 towards
I]VR,J
\\'l'].No 1331E 2026
consultancy charges for conducting its structural stability test' and that the said amounts have been paid by the GHMC'
5,. Learned Standing Counsel appearing for respondent No 5
submitted that pursuant to the request made by the GHMC' a preliminary inspection of the subject building has already been done
6. ln view of the above, the writ petition is disposed of, directing respondent No.5 to expedite the process of conducting the inspection
and structural stability test of the subject -building, namely'
'Dilshad
Plaza situated at H.No.4-4-1, Sultan Bazar, Hyderabad, and submit a detailt.,d report within a period of three (03) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. There shall be no order as to costs ,As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending
in this writ petition stand closed /TTRUE COPY//
SD/- MOHD ISMAIL DEPUTY REGISTRAR
G SECTION OFFICER
To,
and Secretary Municipal Administration P rincrpal The The State of Telangana Secretariat, HYderabad uiurn O"u"toP,rlent DePartment , Tank UrO"r"ouO Municipal Corporation " ioGrea The The Commissioner'
Bund Road, HYderabad '
3. The Zonal Commissioner, GHMC,, Khairatabad Zone, Hyderabad' 4. The Deputy Commissioner, GHMC, Circle No.35, Khairatabad, Hyderabad' 5. JNTUH University College of Engineering, Science and Technology, Hyderabad-'
lndustrial Consuttancy Servicei (lCS), rep.by its Chief Coordinator, ICS
Kukatpally, Hyderabad-S00 085, Telangana State' 6. One CC to SRl. ROHAN ALOOR Advocate IOPUCI
T,TwoCCstoGPFoRMCPLADMNURBANDEVHighCourtfortheStateof Telangana, at HYderabad [OUT] 8. One CC to Sri IV Arun Kumar, SC for GHMC [OPUC] 9. SRI MR. Peri Prabhakar, Sc for JNTU [OPUC] 10. Two CD Copies
DA TKS
w
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0511012026
.a 1r\ STArE o
)c
li i-l
$B
l,rl
ORDER
[tI 2[m
\'2. i\'-
\..
''i.
WP.No.33318 of 2026
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
_t\
\.b
^-!fiI ru\
ff"t.
.1.