Mallarapu Rebecca v. The State of T.S
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 27 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice J Sreenivas Rao
- Case number
- CRLP No. 17664 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED OF NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Section 528 BNSS
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
I3303 I IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD TUESDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO CRIMINAL PETITION N O: 17664 OF 2026 Between: Mallarapu Rebecca, D/o Ir/.Arlanikya Rao, Aged about 35 years, Occ Teacher, R/o H.no 3-192/1, Street no 1, IVlailikarjuna nagar, Irrrailapui, Ivledcnat Markajgiri District ... Petitioner/Accused
AND
No. 2
The State of T.S, through public prosecutor, High court of Telangana. ... Res ponde nUCom pla ina nt
Smt. Gandam Rani Lincoln, W/o Gandam Abraham Lincoln, Aged about years, Occ Head Mistress, R/o H.no 12_1_157.1t1, Blue Eye NTodel School, Shanthi nagar, North Lalaguda, Secunderabad_5Oo0l 7
...Respondent/De_facto Complainant
Petition under section 528 of BNSS, 2023 praying that in the circumslances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of crimrnar petition, the High court pleased to quash the c.c. No. 8755 of 2020 pendrng before on
may be
the fire of XII ADDL.
chief lvletropolitan Magistrate, at IVanoRanjan comprex, Hyderabad District, as agarnst the petitione r/Accused no 2.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS, 2023 praying that in the circumstances stated in the lVlemorandum of Grounds of criminal petition, the High courl may be
pleased to stay all further proceedings in the C C No. 8755 of 2020 registered for the offences Urs. 498-A 494.427 IPC and 4 sectron of D.P. Act pending before on the file
of Hon'ble Xlll ADDL. Chief Ir,4etropolitan Magistrate al Mano Ranjan Complex, Hyderabad District as against the petitio n e r/Accused Nos 2 pending disposal of above cnminal petition
This Petitron coming on for hearrng. upon perusing the l\,4emorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the argumenls of Srr M lvlanisha. Advocate for lhe Petitioner and the lVlr Jrthendar Rao Veeramalla, Additional Pub ic Prosecutor on behalf
ofthe Respondent No.1 and of None appeared forthe Respondent No. 2. The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION No.17664 o12026 CNR.No. H8HC010737802026 Date:27.10.2026 Between:
Mallarapu Rebecca ..Petitioner/accused No.2
AND The State ofTelangana and another ..Respondents
ORDER This Criminal Petition has been filed by the petitioner, seeking
to quash the proceedings in C.C.No.8755 of 2020 on the fi1e of the
XIII Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Manoranjan, Hyderabad District, registered for the offence punishable under Section 498 (A), 494,427 read with 34 ofthe Indian Penal Code, 1860
(for short, 'IPC') and Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961.
2.
Heard Ms. M.Manisha, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Mr.Jithendar Rao Veeramalla, Iearned Additional Public Prosecutor for respondent No. 1
3.
With the consent of both the leamed counsel, the critninal
petition is disposed o1'at the admission stage on the ground that even accorcling to the ieamed counsel fbr the petitioner, the matter before
the learned
'l
rial Cloun has not nped fbr the trial yet ln vieia' of the
same. llot cc irr re spcct o1' respondent No .2idefacto complainant is r
disper sed rvilh
1.
Llpon pcrusal o1' the record,
it reveals that the learned
Magi:tratc. u'ithor.rt recording satisfaction and without assigntng any reasons. Iia: taken cogtrizance against the petitioner and issued summons mechanically and passed cryptic docket order. Thereflore, cognizance rrrdet' passed b1, the leamed Magistrate is liable to be quashed
5.
Learncd Additional I'ubhc Prosecutor has not opposed the
submissions nradc b,v the leamed counsei for the petitioner
6.
Having consirleled the submissions made by the respective
paftics ancl a f-r ei' pcrusal ot' lhe material al'ailable on record, it reveals
that the learne'c'i Nlagistlatc has taken cognizance, without recording satistirctro. unrl
'^
irh.ur assi,qning any reasons against the accused and
not a,elrinsr the orli,nccs. tlrr.ough
the co-qnizance. order.
.
It is very much relevant to mention that in Sunil Bharati Mittal
v. Central Bureau of Investigation I the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the order of issuing process to accused to face criminal trial is a serious issue. Such summoning cannot be done on mere asking and
the Court has to record reasons for summoning a person. In GHCL Employees Stock Option Trust v. India Infoline Limilet, the
Hon'ble Apex Court found fault with the order of the Magistrate in
issuing summons when the Magistrate has not recorded his satisfaction about the prima facie case against the accused. In Chief
Enforcemnet Officer v. Videocon International Limitei, the Hon'ble Supreme Court while discussing the expression 'cognizance' held that in criminal law 'cognizance' means becoming aware of and the word used with respect to Court or a Judge initiating proceedings
in respect ofan offence. Taking cognizance would involve application
of mind by the Magistrate to the suspected commission of an offence. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sunil Bharati Mittal's case (Supra), further heid as follows:
"Sine Qua Non for taking cr.tgnizance of the offence is the application of mind by the Mctgistrale ctnd his satisfaction thet the qllegations, if prr.tved,
(2015) 4 scc 609 (2013) 4 scc so5 'z lzoos; z scc +sz
\touli co stitutt on oflctrce It i.s. thereforc, imperatiye that on a tontplttint or on a poltce reporl, lhe Magistrata is bound trt consider the uue\uon at ro thetht'r tht runtc discloses comntissiott of an ,ffinte and is rcquiretl to jornt such an opinion in thls respect. Wen he does so and LlecLtlet io rs.ir? /rro( r\J. itc' .sh,,tll be :uid ttt havt' taken cogntzance At the .\tagc 01 tuking cctgniLutca, the only consiclerution before the Court |en'tuins r,t co sidt'r lLt.ltLiolt.tlt vltthcr thL' materiol ttn which the t)ro\ccutiotl prapos.'.\ lo l)toscutte tlt accusetl brings out u prima fucie ((l5t t)t' llol '
\n Fakhrttddin Ahmad v. State of (Jttaranchal and anothera,
it is held as lbllows: '\'etcrthele;.;. il is t|cll seltled lhdt bcfore u Mogistrate cctn be stttl r,t lr,rvt' tuken Loqnt:dnct of at offence, it i5 imPerali\'( that he nrust hqtt, taken notict' oJ lhe uccLtsllons etnd ttpplictl his mind to the ttllcgations nnde in lht cotnpl nt or in the police report or th" inlornr,tttort rcceictl .fntn .t \our(e other tfuut a Jtolicc reporl, as Lhe cetL,ttid| bc. uncl the nateriul fiLcd therewith. It needs little empha.sis thttt it i\ onl,. then rhe l[qgi.\tatc upplies his mintl cmtl is satisrted that lll., al/tgalnns, i/ prot'cd, :.'rtr.rld const ute ut ttlfcnce and decides to inltiur. lro('re(litgt ttguitsr lhc alltged olfendcr, lhot it can be posittvel-v stutcd thLrt ha hus takcn ct)gttizttnce o/ the qfence Cognizance is il
rcqtrd tr; thi ol.fenct otll ot lhe ollentler."
9.
ln view of tht-' obser\ ations and directions of the Hon'ble
Supre rne Cou r-t i n the j udgments refeffed to supra, the act of issuing
process ol srLmmoning tlte accused to face criminal lrial is a serious issue and such orders directing surnmons to a person to face criminal
trial cannot be on the basis of cryptic orders and it should be an order reflcctins apl)lication of rnind by' the Presidin,e Of1'lcer while taking cognizance arld issuing Process
' (2OO8) 17 SCC 157
10. For the foregoing reasons and in view of the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgments cited supra, and
without going into the other grounds, this Court is of the considered view that the cognizance order is liable to be quashed and accordingly quashed. The leamed Magistrate is directed to take cognizance afresh and to proceed with the matter, in accordance with 1aw.
1. Accordingly, the criminal petition is disposed of. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed. SD/- MOHD. ISMAIL DEPUTY REGISTRAR
i
/ffRUE COPY//
\
SECTION OFFICER To,
. The Xll Additional Chief lVletropolitan tvlagistrate, at Manoranjan' Hyderabad District.
2ThestationHouseofficer,LallagudaPoliceStation'HyderabadDistrict. 3. Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State of Telangana' at Hyderabad (OUT)
4. One CC to Sri. tvl lvlanisha, Advocate [OPUC]
5 Two CD CoPies DL/GNK
d
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2711012026 1 T E STAI E
:)
;.D
ii ,-.r
[ 5 NI\J 2[28
i).-..t
\\..L
<.
0rspRtc ,t 1:)
.' :1:
ORDER
CRLP.No.17664 of 2026
DISPOSING OF THE CRIMINAL PETITION
(,
oq ,,)
yL
vz 6}
.E