Mamidi Nagaraju Sagar v. The State of Telangana
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice J Sreenivas Rao
- Case number
- CRLP No. 11123 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED OF NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Section 482 CrPC
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
[ 3303 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO CRIMINAL P ETITION NO : 11123 0F 2026 Between:
Mamidi Nagaraju Sagar, S/o. NXranthi Kumar, aged about 45 years, ^ Occ.Business, R/o. H.No. 3-5-56/2918, Road No.1/A, Krishna Nagar, Mouia Ati, Medchal/Malkajgiri Dist ...Petitioner/Accused No.1
AND
1. The State of Telangana, rep its public prosecutor, High Court, Hyderabad 2. Mamidi Laxmi Sagar Sangeetha Laxmi, Wo. Mamidi Nagaraju Sagar, aged about 37 years, Occ. Household, Caste.Uppara/Sagara, presently residlng at.i.l4-2971513, Chilkalguda, Secunderabad, native: H.N-o.e_S_S6l2gtB', Colony, Moula Ali, Kapra Mandal, Medchal/Malkajgiri Dist
Kil;;;N;g;.
...Respondents Petition under Section S28 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of criminar petition, the High court
may be preased to quash
the proceedings in c.c.No 1478 ot 2023, il Addr Junior civir Judge-cum-Vr Magistrate of First crass, Uppar, at Medipaily, Medchar/Markajgiri
Addr Judiciar
Dist registered U/sec
498-4 and 506 of lPC, sec 3 of D.p.Act, dated. 15-9-2023, incruding
the appearance of
the petitioner/Accused No.1 .
I.A. NO: 2 OF 2 026 Petition under section 482 of cr.p.c praying that in the circumstances Memorandum of Grounds of criminar petition, the High court may stay of all further proceedings in c.c.No 1479 ot 2023, on the fire
stated in the
be preased to grant
of I Addr Junior civir
r!t!].!F-r
!FE7
Judge-cum-Vl Addl Judiciar Metropolitan Magistrate of First crass, Uppal,
at Medipafiy,
Medchal/Malkajgiri Dist registered U/sec 498-4 and 506 of rpc,
Sec 3 of D.p.Act, dated: 15-9-2023, incruding the appearance of the petitioner/Accused no.1
ti the
disposal of the Main Quash petition in the interest of the justice
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum
criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of sri Brahmadandi counsel representing sri B siva prasad, Advocate for the petitioner Rao Veeramarra, Additionar pubric prosecutor on beharf
The Court made the following ORDER:
of Grounds of
Ramesh, senior
and sri Jithender
of the Respondent No,1_state.
IN TIIE HIGH COTJR'I'FOR'tI{I] S
.tA]'E OF TELANGANA
AI' IIYI)ERAI}At) .I'HE
HONOURAI}I,E SRI JT,STIC}, J.SREI]NIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETI'I'ION No.lll23 of 2026 CNR No. H BHC0 10470072026 Datc:28.10.2026 Be tween
Mamidi Nagaraju Sagar ..
Pctitioner/Acc used No. I
ANI) -['he
State o1- 1-elangana and anothcr ..Respondents
ORDER I'his Crirninal Pctition is irlcd b1' thc pctitio ner/acc u sed No.I sceking to quash thc proccedings in ('.C. No.l478 of 2023 on thc
lllc oj' the Il Additional Jur.rior' ('ir il J Lrclgc-cLrrn-Vl Additionat Judicial Magistratc of First Class. [Jppal at Medipatly. Medchal Malkajgiri District, for the ofl-ences under Sections 498-A and 506 ol-thc Indian Penal ('ode. 1860 (lbr short'thc IPC')and Section 3 of the Dowry Prohibition Act. I 96 I (for short 'the D.P. Act').
).
Mr.Brahrnadandi Ramcsh. lcarncd Senior ('orrnscl,
rr'prescnting Mr.[].Siva Prasad, icarncd counscl lbr thc pctitioncr,
submitted that pursuant to the order. dated 16.07.2026, the leamed counsel lbr I rc pctitionet on record sent notice to respondent \o 2
by rvay of speed post with acknou'ledgement due and the said notice vu'as re'tumed with a postal endorsernent "Refused, returned to scndor" and ll lcd proof o1- scrvicc vizle Merno in USR No.9'1347
ol 2026 on 01.08.2026. As per Scction 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, retusal is deemed to be served. Hence, this Court is not having an1 option cxcept to procced with the matter in accordance
with law
3.
Heard Mr.tlrahmadandi Rarresh. learned Senior Clounsel,
rcprescntins. ivlr.ll.sira Prasad. learned counsel tbr the petitioncr.
and Mr.Jithendar Rao Veeramalla. learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for respondent No. 1-State
'1,
[-carned counsel fbr thc petitioner submitted that the learned
Magistrate took cognizance against thc petitioner for the of'fences under Sections 498-A and 506 ol'the IPC and Section 3 ofthe D P.
Act. on 2-l.Cr9.l()21 and issued sumrrons. without recordirrg satistaction arrd r,,'ithout assigning any reasons and the satne IS contrary to the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Sunil Ilharati Mittal v. Central Bureau of
-
Investigationr and F'akhruddin Ahmad v. State of Uttaranchal and anothe12.
5.
'Ihe said submission has not been opposed by the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor.
6.
tlaving considercd thc rir al suLrtrissions rnade b1' thc
rcspective parties and upon pcrusal of the rnaterial available on record, it reveals that the learned Magistrate on 23.09.2023 without recording satisf-action and w'ithout assigning an\ rcasons had takcn cognizance and issued surnrnons to the petitioner. Therelbre, the docket order dated23.09.2023 passed by the leamed Magistrate is liablc to bc quashcd.
1.
It is very much relevant to mention that in Sunil Bharati
Mittal (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the order of issLring proccss 1o accuscd to lacc clirttittal trial is a scrioLts issLtc Such sumrnoning cannot be done on nlere asking and the Coun has
to record reasons for summoning a person. ln GHCL Fimployees Stock ()ption J'rusl \" lndia Infoline
Limitedr, thc Flon'ble Apcx CoLrrt tbund lault with the ordcr o1' the Magistrate in issuing surrlrnons when the Magistrate has not {l0IiJ I SC( 60() (1U08) l7 SCC 157 (l0ll) a SCC 505
\
recorded his satisl-action about lhe prima Jacie case against the
accused. ln Chief Enforcement Officer v. Videocon
International Limitctla, the lton'ble Supreme Courl ',vhile discussing the erpression 'cognizance' held that in crirninal law
'cognizattce' tneans becoming aware of and the wold used with rcspcct to Ctrurt or a Judge initiating proceedings in rcspect o1'an oll-ence
. laking cognizancc ri'otrld inrolre application o1'rnind b1
the Magistrare 1tl the suspected commission of an offence. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sunil Bharati Mittal's case .supra, firrther hcld as lirllou.s:
'Sine Qua Non fbr taking cognizance of' the oI}'ence is the application of rnind by the Magistrate ancl
his satisluction that thc allcsittiot.ts. il' proved. u'ould cons:itt,1c un ollctrcc. lt is. tltcrclbrc. ir.npcrative thitt on
a cornplair.tl or or1 a policc rcport, the Magistratc- is bound to consider the question as to whethcr the sauc disclr)ses commission of an off-ence and is reqr-rired to
firrrl srrch un opinion irt tl.ris rcspcct. Whcn he docs so and ilccidcs t() issuc pr'()ccss. he shall bc said to have taken crrgnizance. At the stage of taking cognizance, the on11, considcration befbre the Court retnains to consider
judiciousll' whether the material on which the pr()sccuri()n l.rr()p()\cs t() pr'()sccLrtc thc acctrsecl brit.tgs rlltt .t l)ril .l l:re ic .lr'C ()t t'lr)1.
' 12008 : scc ]9l r
-
J
-
8. ln Fakhruddin Ahmad (supra), it is held as tbllows: "Nevertheless. it is wcll scttlcd that befbre a Magistrate can bc said to have takcn cognizance ol- an ofl'cnce, it is in.rpcrativc that he mr"rst have taken noticc
ol' the accLrsatious and applicd his rr-rind to the allegations rnade in the cornplaint or in the policc report or the infbrrnation received fiom a source othcr
than a police report, as the case rnay be, and the material flled thercwith- It neecls little err.rphasis that it
is only when thc Magistratc applics his mind and is
satisllcd that thc allcgations. il' provcd. would constitute an o11'ence and dccides to initiate proceedings against the alle-ged ot'l'ende r. that it can bc
positively statcd that hc lras takcn cognizrncc ol'the otlL'ncc. (-'ognizancc is irr rcgarcl to thc ol'tcncc and not the ofl'ender."
9.
ln view of the observations and directions of the Ilon'ble
Supreme Court in thc jLrdgrrcnts rct-errcd to supra, the act 01issuing process for summoning an accused to face a criminal trial is a serious issue and such ordcrs directing the issuancc ot'surnrrons I
to a pe[soll to l'acc crirninal tt ial cxnnot bc passcd otl thc basis olcr)'ptic orders and it should be an order ret)ecting due application o1' rnind by the Prcsiding Oftrcer while taking cognizance and
rssl ng procc ss
\
l0
I'or th.' lbrcgoing rcasons ancl in vieu' of thc principles laid
down by the tlon'ble Apex Court in the judgments cited suprct, and
without going into the other grounds. this Courl is ol the considcrccl ricw that thc cognizance order dated 23.09.2023 ln
C.C. No.1178 o1'2023 on the fllc o1'the Il Additional Junior Cit'il Judge-cum-VI Additional Judicial Magistrate of F-irst Class, Uppal at Mediparly-. N'lt'dchal IValka.igiri t)istrict. is liable to be quashed and accorrlinqlv c1r-rashcd,
'Ihe learncd Magistrate is directed to
take cognizance afresh and to proceed with the matter in accordance with law
I
l.
Accordinglr'. the crirninal petition is disposed of
Pending rriscellancous applications, if any, shall stand c loscd
SD/. K. VANI ASSISTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY'
/b-
SECTI ON OF FICER
To, '1
\/
. The Il Addl Junior Civil Judge-cum-Vl Addl Judicial Magistrate of First class, Uppal, at Medipally, Medchal/Malkajgiri
2. The Station House Officer, Women Police Station, Uppal (Rachakonda), Rachakonda Com m issionerate.
3. Two CCs to PUBLIC PROSECUTOR High Cou( for the State of Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT] 4. One CC to SRl. B SIVA PRASAD Advocate [OPUC] 5. Two CD Copies
BA/(iNK
I
l ,l
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2811012026
ORDER GRLP.No.11123 ot 2026 ( o+ o o
1r'- S IA r€
0 3 N 0v 2 026 .1,
* D Fs, ,/\T c\'cQ *
DISPOSING OF THE CRIMINAL PETITION
d Irt
lu