Miniskar Harshitha v. The State of Telangana
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 13 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Juvvadi Sridevi
- Case number
- WP No. 23916 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED OF NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Section 151 CPC
Full judgment
13257 | IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) TUESDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE JUWADI SRIDEVI WRIT P
TION NO: 23916OF 2026
Between: Miniskar Harshitha, D/o.Miniskar Nageshwara Rao, Aged about 30 years, Occ ; Medical Practitioner/student, Fl/o.H.No.49-405-31K, Ring Road Padma Nagar Phase-ll Chinthal, Quthbullapur, Hyderabad. .....PETITIONER AND
. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Medical and Health
Department Secretariat building, Hyderabad. 2. The Kaloji NarayanaRao Health Sciences University, Rep by its Registrar, Warangal, Warangal District. 3. The Controller of Examination, The Kaloji Narayana Rao Health Sciences University Warangal, Warangal District. 4. The Kakatiya Medical College, Hanumakonda, represented by its Principal. 5. The Gandhi Medical College, Secunderabad, rep. by its Principal. .....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring action of the respondents Nos. 2 to 5 in withholding the original certificates such as Memorandum of Marks in MBBS, MBBS Degree Certificate, compulsory Rotatory lnturnship certificate, MBBS Permanent registration certificate, caste certificate, transfer certificate, Migration certificate, OBC Memorandum of Marks, ce(ificate, sSC date of birth certificate and
ssc
lntermediate Memorandum of Marks, Bonafide certificate, study certificate, conduct
certificate, Original Medical registration certificate issued by the Telangana State Medical council, submitted by the petitioner at the time of Admission into Post Graduation Degree Course MD, Geriatrics in Sth respondent college and re-allotted into 4th respondent college in MD Biochemistry in the MOPUP phase of counseling
and also to declare the letter No.3107/KNRUHS/Academic/AD-ll/2026
dated
17.04.2026 addressed to the Sth respondent college to collect Rs.50,00,000/- from
the petitioner for return of original certificates of the petitioner, as illegal, arbitrary, contrary to the orders passed by the Honourable High court in W.P.No.21137 of 2019 dated 24.01 .2020, and in violation of Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia and consequently direct the respondents to issue afore said orrginal certificates to the petitioner forthwith. ,
i.A.NO:1 OF 2026 Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavil filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondents to issue the original certificates such as Memorandum of Marks in MBBS, MBBS Degree Certificate, Compulsory Rotatory lnturnship Certificate, MBBS
Permanent registration certificate, caste certificate, transfer certificate, Migration certificate, OBC Certificate, SSC date of birth certificate and SSC Memorandum of
Marks, lntermediate Memorandum of Marks, Bonafide certificate, study certificate, conduct certificate, Original Medical registration certificate issued by the Telangana State Medical council, submitted by the petitioner at the time of Admission into Post Graduation Degree Course MD, Geriatrics in 5th respondent college, to the petitioner
by suspending the operation of the order No. 3107/KNRUHS/AcademiclA0-l'112026 daled 17.04.2026 issued by the 2nd respondent, pending disposal of the above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI A.PRABHAKAR RAO Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1, 4 & 5 : SRI R.NAGARJUN REDDY, AGP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 & 3 : SRI T.SHARAT, SC FOR KNRUHS The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE
AT HYDERABAD THE HO N'B LE SM T. JUS TICE JU
OF TELANGANA
WADIS RIDEVI
WRIT PETITI ON No .23916 of 2026 c.N. R.No .HBH c010492 't62026
130 c TOBER 2026 Between: Miniskar Harshitha .
. Petitioner
AND The State of Telangana and 4 others Respondents
:ORDE R: This Writ Petition is filed seeking the
following relief
"lolssue an appropriate writ. order or direction m.ore _pafticularty one in lhe nat:ure of Witi'Oi MANDAMUS declaring action of n"- nii"ra""ri" Nos.2 to S in withhotdiig the originat ,u,tiiiiitl,"-"rii a^s Memorandum ot Mirks in riaas nB:;;'";"sr";
Ceftificate. Computsory Rotatory irrciiiii i ifi c a t e. M B B S p e r m a'n e n t * g i il;t i o n ;;;:;; ;;;; : certificate, transfer ciftificate, " "u"1."-. ceftificate oBC ceftifrcate, ssc oit" MiSr;t;; ii "iiii ceftificate and SSC Memorandum of Uil*" lnte.rmediate Memorandum of ia,rf","' B;;Z:;;; ceftificate. study cerlifrcatu r;;;;,;';i;, Original Medrcal registration cenhcate "onJrit' issued bv the Tetangana State tiecticat p^etitioner at the time of "o"r"l' "'itiitiJi tl',liZ Air;;;o';"'ii,"", i"il, -ii Graduation Degree Course UO, Aeriatrics ii respondent coltege and re_altotted irto +;'r"ipinalnt college in MD Biochemtstry in me uopui"iia'JJ'o'r and atso to dectare ?guy2etlnO the tetter r.ug:1.0-715NRUHS/Academic/AD_l/2026 Ce
17.04 2026 addressed to the 5,. to.cotlect Rs.s0.O0 OOO/_ hom th"
,"iiirO"*
;r;;;;
;;;ti"';;;';";"itbZZ ;i;; petftioner the iriil,,t' Z:^?:::o Y,' dt.utuaty. contrary ^::l:!:?'?: to the orders passed bv ihe Honbte Hish courl in wpNoz,isi 2,4.01 2020. and in violation of Articb ti)rAZ'"it the Constitution of tndia and consequenuy direct the
"" iii,ri\*l.Z
lunrc.luwadr Sr oe\
\rp 23916 i026
respondenfs to issue aforesaid original pass . the petitioner forthwith and
ceftificates to
Heard Mr' A Prabhakar Rao' learned
petitioner, tt/lr. R.Nagarjun Reddy'
learned Assistant Government
Pleader for l\/edical, Health and appearing for respondent Nos
Senior Counsel for the
Family Welfare Department
l' 4 and 5 and tt/lr' T Sharat' learned
appearing Standing Counsel for KNRUHS'
for respondent Nos 2
and 3. Perused the record'
The case of the petitioner is that'
2025 'ank,she was allotted a
pursuant to her NEET-PG
seat in tr/l D Geriatrics in respondent
year 2025-26 No.5-college for the academic counseling vide allotment letter
during the first phase of
dated 14 122025' She ioined
the
and university course, paid the requisite college
fees and submitted
all her original certificates to respondent
No
including subsequent phases of counselling she 'was allotted a seat in M
5 During the
the tvlOP-UP phase'
D Biochemistry in respondent No 4-
college vlde allotment letter dated
16 022026 As such' respondent
No.5issuedacustodian/relievingcertificate,daledlT'02.2026. to health and personal of the petitioner is that owing Further case
reasons, she did not join the said
course Thereafter' she submitted
to respondent Nos2 representations, dated 24022026 requesting to waive off the
and 5'
penalty and return her original
lusticeluwad S. devi wp 23975 2A26
certificates. Vide letter, dated 17.04.2026, University directed respondent No.S_college
certificates, unress penarty amount of
respondent No.2_
not to return her original
Rs.50,00,000/_, in terms of
G.O lvls.No.107, dated 2Z.Og.2OZ2 is paid.
Hence, the present writ
petition
4.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
respondents have no authority to withhord
the originar ce(ificates of
the petitioner towards recovery of the penarty. seats allotted to the petitioner were
not go waste. He further
submits that imposing such a huge penalty,
particularly when the
course, is illegal and arbitrary. He
further submits that the petitioner has
appeared for NEET_pG 2026
and requires her originar certificates to formalities. He further submits that
comprete the admission
the petitioner is required to
submit her original certificates on or before further delay in release of the petitioner,s irreparably prejudice her academic
He submits that the
subsequenfly allotted to other
meritorious candidates and therefore did
petitioner did not join the allotted
submits that the
03.11.2026 and that any
original certificates would
career. Therefore, he prayed this
Court to declare the letter, dated 12.04.2026, Rs.50,00,000/- on the petitioner as illegal
imposing a penalty of
and arbitrary and direct
l!stic: luvvad sr dev !p 239i6 2016
responclent No 5 to forthwith return
the petitioner's original
certificates On the other hand, learned Assistant
tr/edical Health and Family welfare respondent Nos 1, 4 and 5 and
Government Pleader for
Department appearing for
learned Standing Counsel for
KNRUHS appearing for respondent
Nos 2 and 3 opposed for the
same
lt is not in dispute that the petitioner submitted
her original
the time of admission certificates to respondent No 5 at
to the IM D
Geriatrics course and the said
certificates are presently in the
original certificates' custody of respondent No 5 The petitioner's personal and academic documents'
merely on the ground of any outstanding petitioner has violated any undertaking
beinq the
cannot be withheld
liability Even if the
or rule or instructions' etc '
to the the proper remedy, if any, available
appropriate proceedings, for recovery accordance with Iaw However' retention
respondents is to pursue
of the amounts due in of the petitioner's original
certificatesaSsecurityforrecoveryofsuchamountsis impermissible Therefore' this Court that the petitioner is entitled to cert ficates
ls of the considered ooinion
the immediate return of her original
lustrce luwadrSndevr
wp-23916,2026
7.
and considering For the foregoing discussion
petitioner is required to submit
her original certificates on or
$11.2026 in the NEET-PG 2026
before
counselling process' this Writ
respondent Petition is disposed of, directing original certificates ie , Memorandum
No 5 to return the
of Marks in MBBS' MBBS
Rotatory Degree Certificate, Compulsory MBBS Permanent registration
that the
lnternship Certificate'
certificate' caste certiflcate' transfer
OBC Certificate' certificate, Migration certiflcate'
certificate and SSC Memorandum
SSC date of birth
of tVlarks' lntermediate
certificate, study certificate' Memorandum of Marks' Bonaflde by registration certificate issued conduct certificate, Original Medical
to the the Telangana State Medical council' 17.10.2026.lt is made clear that
respondent Nos2 and 5 are
proceedings' liberty to initiate appropriate for recovery of amounts' if any'
petitioner by at
in accordance with law'
due from the petitioner' No costs'
Pending miscellaneous applications'
if any' shall stand
closed SD/. K.V.O. NARSI BABU ASSISTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// SECTION OFFICER
To
ThePrincipalsecretary,MedicalandHealthDepartmentSecretariatbuilding'
State of Telangana at HYderabad. Warangal' ine-Cegistai fatoii ttlarayanaRao Health Sciences University' Warangal District
3. The Controller of Examination, The Kaloji Narayana Rao Health Sciences University Warangal, Warangal District. 4. The Principal, Kakatiya Medical College,, Hanumakonda. 5. The Principal, Gandhi Medical College, Secunderabad. Two CCs to GP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH AND FAIUILY WELFARE, High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT] One CC to SRI A.PRABHAKAR RAO, Advocate IOPUCI One CC to SRI T.SHARAT, SC FOR KNRUHS (OPUC) 9. Two CD Copies
T
S
SA
C.C.TODAY
HlGH COURT
DATED: 1311012026
ST,crG 1 E
( f,
(
o o
l5 $Ei 2r2$
ORDER -i\r i<1r:T c, j-)
WP.No.23916 of 2026
DISPOSING OF THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
\e
<0
+,