Mohammed Ajmal Mohammad Amir Kasab @ Abu Mujahid v. State of Maharashtra

Court
Supreme Court of India
Date of judgment
29 August 2012
Judge
Justice Aftab Alam
Neutral citation
2012 INSC 357
Reported in
[2012] 8 S.C.R. 295
Result
Dismissed
Acts & sections
Section 164 CrPC, Section 366 CrPC
Subject
Criminal, Service

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

[2012] 8 S.C.R. 295 MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR ABU MUJAHID

KASAB @

v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA (Criminal Appeal Nos. 1899-1900 of 2011 etc.) AUGUST 29, 2012

[AFTAB ALAM AND CHANDRAMAULI KR. PRASAD, JJ.]

c

PENAL CODE, 1860:

ss. 302, 302 read with s.34 and s.302 read with ss.109, 120-B, 121, 121-A and 122 /PC and s.16 of Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 - 26111 (2008) terrorists' attack on Mumbai at targeted places by appellant (A-1) along with 9 D other terrorists (dead accused), in furtherance of a conspiracy to wage war against Government of India - 166 people killed and 238 injured - Trial court holding the appellant guilty of the offences charged and awarding him five death sentences - Convictions and sentences confirmed by High Court - Held: E On the basis of ocular evidence alone, the appellant personally and jointly with deceased accused-1 (DA-1) is directly responsible for killing 72 persons and causing injuries of various kinds to 130 persons - He was also found guilty along with other dead accused as a co-conspirator Conviction and sentences awarded by trial court and F confirmed by High Court are affirmed - As regards A-2 and A-3, when the attack on Mumbai took place, they were in custody of U.P. Police in connection with a different terrorist attack - Both the courts have analyzed the prosecution evidence in regard to A-2 and A-3 at great length and have G given very good reasons to hold the prosecution evidence unworthy of reliance with respect to such grave charges against the two accused - Both the courts have rightly

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

acquitted A-2 and A-3 of all the charges - Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 - s.16.

ss. 120-8, 121, 121-A and 302- Criminal conspiracy and conspiracy to wage war against Government of India 8 Terrorists' attack in furtherance of conspiracy to wage war against Government of India - 10 terrorists dividing themselves in 5 teams of 2 each and attacking at targeted places in Mumbai - Plea that appellant's case should be considered only with respect to the incidents in which he was C personally involved - Held: In view of the incidents at the venues of terrorists' attack and the conspirators across the border being in constant contact with terrorists, it is obvious that all the ten terrorists were bound together and each team was acting in execution of a common conspiracy - In view of the enormous evidence of all possible kinds including the D recoveries made, it is clear that the terrorists' attack on Mumbai was in pursuance of a larger conspiracy of which the appellant was as much part as the 9 dead accused and other wanted accused persons - The attacks at all the targets were integrally connected with each other and the appellant and his E deceased accomplice are as much part of the offences committed at other places as they are responsible for the offences committed by them directly - The most clinching evidence regarding conspiracy comes from recording of intercepted telephone calls between the terrorists and their coF conspirators and collaborator sitting in a foreign land, which in the light of all facts and circumstances of the case can only be Pakistan - Evidence Act, 1872 - s.10. ss.121, 121-A and 122 - "Waging war against the

G Government of India" - Conspiracy -Terrorists' attack on Mumbai - Expressions "offences against the State" and ''in like manner and by like means as a foreign enemy would do" - Connotation of - Held: The expression "Government of India''. as appearing in s.121, must be held to mean the State H or interchangeably the people of the country as the repository

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 297 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

of the sovereignty of India which is manifested and expressed A through the elected Government - It does riot matter that the target assigned to the appellant and DA-1 was a public building where they killed a large number of people - What matters is that the attack was aimed at India and Indians - It was by foreign nationals - People were killed for no other s reason than they were Indians - In case of foreigners, they were killed because their killing on Indian soil would embarrass India - The conspiracy, in furtherance of which the attack was made, was, inter alia, to hit at India; to hit at its financial centre; to try to give rise to communal tensions and c create internal strife and insurgency; to demand that India should withdraw from Kashmir; andto dictate its relations with other countries - It was in furtherance of those objectives that the attack was made, causing the loss of a large number of people and injury to an even greater number of people - D Nothing could have been more "in like manner and by like means as a foreign enemy would do" - Appellant has been rightly held guilty of waging war against Government of India and rightly convicted u/ss 121, 121-A and 122 - Death penalty for an offence u/s 121, upheld - International Law. SENTENCE/SENTENCING: Terrorists' attack on Mumbai - Trial court sentencing the appellant to death - High Court confirming the sentence Held: The case has shocked the collective conscience of F Indian people - It was a case of waging war against Government of India - The number of persons killed and injured is staggeringly high - The number of policemen and security forces killed and injured in the course of their duty by the appeJlant and his accomplice and 8 other co- G conspirators would hardly find a match in any other cases The offence committed by the appellant show a degree of cruelty, brutality and depravity as in very few other cases - The appellant and his co-conspirators used highly lethal weapons and explosives - It is a case of terrorists' attack from across H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A the borer - It has a magnitude of unprecedented enormity on

s

C

all scales - In terms of loss of life and property and, more importantly in its traumatizing effect, this case stands alone or at/east it is the vety rarest of rare to come before the Court since the birth of republic - Therefore, it should also attract the rarest of rare punishment - Appellant never showed any repentance or remorse, which is the first sign of any possibility of reform and rehabilitation - The only mitigating factor is appellant's young age, but that is completely offset by the absence of any remorse on his part and the resultant finding that in his case, there is no possibility of any reformation or rehabilitation - In the facts of the case, death penalty is the only sentence that can be given to the appellant - The convictions and sentences of the appellant passed by trial court and confirmed by High Court are affirmed. CONSTITUTION OF IND/A, 1950: Arts. 20(3), 21 of the Constitution and s.164, CrPC - Right against self-incrimination - Voluntaty confession - Held: Right against self-incrimination under Art. 20(3) has been statutorily incorporated in the provisions of ss.161, 162, 163 and 164 CrPC and the Evidence Act, as manifestations of enforceable due process, and thus compliance with statutoty provision is also compliance with constitutional requirements - Right against self-incrimination under Art. 20(3) does not proscribe vo/untaty statements made in exercise offree will and volition - Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - ss.161, 162, 163 and 164 - Evidence Act, 1872 - ss.25, 26 and 32. Arts. 21, 22(1), 39-A of the Constitution, and ss. 303 and 304 CrPC - Right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner - Held: Right of person accused of an offence to access to legal aid, to consult and to be defended by a legal practitioner arises when a person arrested in connection with a cognizable offence is first produced before a magistrate - It needs to be clarified that the right to consult and be defended

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 299 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA by a legal practitioner is not to be construed as sanctioning or permitting the presence of a lawyer during police interrogation, as the role of a lawyer is mainly focused on court proceedings - Accused would need a lawyer to resist remand to police or judicial custody and for granting of bail; to clearly explain to him the legal consequences in case he intended to make a confessional statement in terms of s. 164 CrPC, to represent him when the court examines the charge-sheet submitted by the police and decide upon the future course of proceedings and at the stage of the framing of charges; and, for the trial - The right to access to a lawyer flows from the provisions of the Constitution and the statutes, and is only intended to ensure that those provisions are faithfully adhered to in practice - Every accused unrepresented by a lawyer has to be provided a lawyer at the commencement of the trial to represent him during the entire course of the trial - Even if the accused does not ask for a lawyer or he remains silent, it is the Constitutional duty of the court to provide him with a lawyer before commencing the trial - But the failure to provide a lawyer to the accused at the pre-trial stage may not have the same consequence of vitiating the trial, unless it is shown that failure to provide legal assistance at the pre-trial stage had resulted in some material prejudice to the accused in the course of the trial - That would have to be judged on the facts of each case - In the instant case, there has been no violation of any of the rights of the appellant under the Constitution He was offered the services of a lawyer at the time of his arrest, and at all relevant stages in subsequent proceedings - The absence of a lawyer at the pre-trial stage was not only as per the wishes of the appellant himself, but this absence also did not cause him any prejudice in the trial -Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - ss. 303 and 304. Arts. 21, 22(1) of the Constitution and ss. 303 and 304 Cr.P. C. - Right of person accused of an offence to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner - Duty of Magistrate concerned - Held: The provisions of the CrPC and the

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2012] 8 S.C.R.

A Evidence Act fully incorporate the Constitutional guarantees,

s

c

and that the statutory framework for the criminal process in India affords the fullest protection to personal liberty and dignity of an individual, but the Court takes judicial notice that there is a great hiatus between what the law stipulates and the realities on the ground in the enforcement of the law - It is the duty and obligation of the magistrate to make the accused fully aware that it is his right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner and, in case he has no means to engage a lawyer of his choice, that one would be provided to him from legal aid at th<:) expense of the State - The right flows from Arts. 21 and 22(1) of the Constitution and needs to be strictly enforced - The Court, accordingly, directs all the Magistrates in the country to faithfully discharge the said duty and obligation and further make it clear that any failure to fully discharge the duty would amount to dereliction in duty and would make the Magistrate concerned liable to departmental proceedings - Administration of criminal justice - Judicial notice. CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, 1973:

S. 164 - Confessional statement - Held: In the instant case, the confession made by the appellant was voluntary The Magistrate gave sufficient time to the appellant to reflect and reconsider the matter, and cautioned him of the F consequences; and after satisfying herself that the appellant was making the statement on his own free will and volition, proceeded to record his statement u/s 164 - The statement was recorded in accordance with the procedure prescribed and there was no violation of any constitutional or legal right of the G appellant in recording the confession - In the instant case, to say that the confessional statement was intended to confirm the investigation is actually to blame the police for an excellent investigation - Further, police was fully justified in producing the appellant for confession only after completing its investigation - The Court is clearly of the view that the

MOHAMMEDAJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB@ABU 301 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

confessional statement recorded by the Magistrate is voluntary and truthful, except in so far as it relates to A-2 and A-3 - There was no violation of any constitutional and legal rights of the appellant in recording of the cofession - There is no reason for not taking the confession into consideration to judge the charges against the appellant - Investigation.

CRIMINAL TRIAL: Proceedings before trial court - Held: The manner in which the trial Judge conducted the trial proceedings and maintained the record, is exemplary - The Court seriously recommends that the trial court records of this case be included in the curriculum of the National Judicial Authority and the Judicial Authorities of the States as a model for criminal trial proceedings. MEDIA: Incidents relating to national security, and safety of public and security forces -26111 (2008) terrorists' attack on Mumbai - Security forces fighting terrorists - Live telecast by T. V. Channels - Held: Court can take judicial notice of the fact that terrorists' attacks at all the places, in the goriest details, were shown live on the Indian TV from beginning to end almost non-stop - The reckless coverage of the terrr>rists' attack by the channels gave rise to a situation where on the one hand the terrorists were completely hidden from the security forces and they had no means to know their exac. sition or even the kind of firearms and explosives they possessed and, on the other hand, the positions of the security forces, their weapons and all their operational movements were being watched by the collaborators across the border on TV screens and being communicated to the terrorists, thus, making the task of the security. forces not only Pxceedingly difficult but also dangerous and risky - Any attempt to justify the conduct of TV channels by citing the right to freedom of speech and

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2012] 8 S.C.R.

expression would be totally wrong and unacceptable in such a situation - The freedom of expression, like all other freedoms under Art. 19, is subject to reasonable restrictions An action tending to violate another person's right to life guaranteed under Art. 21 or putting the national security in jeopardy can never be justified by taking the plea of freedom of speech and expression - The shots and visuals that were shown live by TV channels could have been shown after all the terrorists were neutralized and the security operations were over - It must, therefore, be held that by covering live the C terrorists attack on Mumbai in the way it was done, Indian TV channels were not serving any national interest or social cause - On the contrary, they were acting in their own commercial interests putting the national security in jeopardy - Constitution of India, 1950 - Arts. 19 and 21 - Judicial notice.

The appellant-accused(A-1) in Crl. A. Nos. 1899-1900 of 2011 was one of the gang of 10, who, in furtherance of a sinister conspiracy hatched in Pakistan to wage war against the Government of India, struck terrorist attack on Mumbai at targeted places on 26.11.2008 at about 9.50 P.M. that lasted till 9.00 A.M. on 29.11.2008. In the said attack 166 people were killed and 238 were injured. Both the injured and the dead included police and security personnel as also foreign nationals, besides a large number of Indian citizens. The appellant and his accomplice deceased-accused-1 (D-A1) were apprehended by police; whereas the 8 other terrorists were killed in the operation which had been handed over to MARCOS (Naval) Commandos and National Security Guards. D-A1 was declared brought dead in the hospital. 35 other co-conspirators and collaborators (wanted accused) remained to be apprehended and brought to court. The prosecution case, as revealed from the investigation and the confessional statement of the appellant made u/s 164 CrPC, was that the appellant was imparted rigorous and extensive training in terrorist

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 303 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

activities by the members of Lashkar-e-Toiba and Jamatul- Cava in Pakistan. He was an active member of the group, who hatched the conspiracy in Pakistan to wage war against India by attacking her major cities. In furtherance of that conspiracy he and 9 other terrorists sailed from Karachi armed with sophisticated fire arms and explosives in huge quantity to strike attack on Mumbai. On the way, they captured and boarded an Indian fishing boat ('Kuber') and with the help of its navigator they reached near the shore of Mumbai, (where the appellant himself cut the neck of the navigator of 'Kuber' and hid his body in the engine room), and in an inflatable rubber speed-boat they reached the Mumbai shore near Badhwar Park at about 9.00 P.M. on 26.11.2008. PW-28 witnessed their arrival at the said place and time. They divided themselves into 5 groups of two each and headed for the assigned targets. ' The appellant and his accomplice (D-A1) hired a taxi for CST. On the way the appellant fixed a bomb under the seat of the driver. On reaching CST, they left the taxi. (Subsequently, the said taxi was blown up by the bomb blast at Vile Parle at 10.45 p.m. killing its two occupants, the driver and a passenger. It was witnessed by PWs. 490 and 491 who were injured in the incident). Following the appellant and D-A1, D-A4 and D-A 9 took a taxi from Badhwar Park for Leopold Cafe. (They also planted an ROX bomb in the taxi, which subsequently exploded in the Mazgaon area at about 10:30 PM killing its driver, and two passengers, and causing injuries to 19 people on the road). They were followed by D-A5 and D-A8 who went to Hotel Taj by taxi. After them, D-A2 and D-A3 went to Nariman House on foot. After these 8 terrorists had left, the remaining two, namely, D-A7 and D-A6 sailed the rubber boat to Nariman Point from where they walked into Hotel Oberoi. PW-29 noticed the said abandoned rubber boat. He along with others towed it to Badhwar Park and

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

A informed the Coast Guard about it.

C

The appellant and D-A 1, after entering CST, opened indiscriminate firing from their AK-47 rifles and hurled hand grenades leaving many dead and several injured including the police and RPF personnel. From there they went to Carna Hospital and killed and injured several persons there including the police personnel. They overcame any efforts by the police to stop them. After corning out from Carna Hospital they attacked the car meant for a high official of the State Government and injured its driver. Thereafter, they attacked a police Qualis and killed 3 senior Police Officers and three other occupants of the vehicle, and grabbed that vehicle. However, they were unable to go very far in the Qualis as one of its wheel was destroyed in the gunfire. They then commandeered a Skoda car from its occupants at gun point. They were driving the Skoda on Marine Drive when they were finally apprehended by police at Vinoli Chowpaty. In exchange of firing, DA1 and the appellant also received injuries. Both were taken to hospital, where DA1 was declared brought dead.

D-A4 and D-A9 launched an attack on Leopold Cafe with grenades and gunfire from AK-47 rifles and left it within minutes, leaving behind 11 dead of whom 2 were F foreign nationals and 28 injured (of whom 9 were foreign nationals). They walked to Hotel Taj to join the other two terrorists, namely, D-A 5 and D-A 8. D-A 5 and D-A 8, on reaching Hotel Taj, first put one ROX bomb near a tree at a distance of about 50 metres G from the porch of the New Taj Hotel. This bomb did not explode and was recovered and seized along with the bomb planted by the Leopold-team under the Panchnarna Ext. no. 736. They then entered the hotel and started firing with their AK-47 rifles on burst mode. On the

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

fifth floor of the hotel they planted the second ROX bomb, A placing it under the central dome so as to cause maximum damage to the building. They took PW-184, PW-188, PW-224 and two others as hostages (all of whom escaped subsequently). Later, they were joined by 0-A 4 and 0-A 9. All the while, the terrorists had long B conversation with their collaborators and handlers on a mobile phone; these handlers were constantly urging them to throw grenades and to set fire to the hotel building. They gave a tough fight to the security forces till they were finally killed on the morning of November C 29, 2008. By that time, the four terrorists had killed 36 people (of whom 9 were foreign nationals) and caused injuries to 30 others (of whom 5 were foreign nationals). O-A2 and D-A3 had gone to Nariman House from Badhwar Park on foot. On reaching near Nariman House .. D they first planted an ROX bomb at Petrol Pump. From there they proceeded to Nariman House, where they planted the second ROX bomb near the staircase on the ground (parking level area). These bombs exploded causing considerable damage. From Nariman House E they made random firings in all directions and threw hand grenades at adjoining buildings, roads and lanes that resulted in death of two and injuries to several others. The two terrorists, 0-A 2 in particular, were in regular contact on the mobile phone with their handlers and F corroborators across the border. At one stage, the controllers even tried to use one of their hostages, (a Mexican citizen, later killed), as an intermediary in an attempt to start some sort of 'negotiation' with the Indian authorities.0-A 2 and D-A 3 were finally killed by security G forces in the night of November 28, 2008. But, by then, they had been able to kill 9 people (of whom 5 were foreign nationals) and injure 7 others. O-A7 and O-A6 entered Hotel Oberoi at about 21 :55

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

hours on 26.11.2008 and started firing indiscriminately from their AK-47 rifles. They fought the security forces till they were finally killed at about 7.00 AM on November 28, 2008. They left behind 35 people as dead (of whom 10 were foreign nationals) and 24 injured (of whom 7 B were foreign nationals).

On November 27, 2008, at 13:00 hours, PW-42 recorded disclosure statement of the appellant in the presence of PW-48 and two panch witnesses including PW-25, which led to the recovery of the Indian boat C ('Kuber') on the sea and the dead body of its navigator, a satellite phone, a GPS and a notebook in the said fishing boat. Respondents no. 1 and 2(A-2 and A-3 respectively) o in Crl. A. No. 1961 of 2011 also faced trial along with the appellant (A-1) in Crl. A. No. 1899-1900 of 2011, on the basis of conspiracy, on the same charges. The case of the prosecution was that A-2 prepared, by hand, maps of various places of Mumbai to facilitate the attack by the E terrorists and one such map was recovered from the trouser-pocket of D-A 1. A-2 was said to have handed over the said maps to A-3 in Nepal and the latter sent/ delivered those maps to the perpetrators of the crime in Pakistan. Further, A-2, in order to provide logistical F support to the terrorists landing in Mumbai, was stated to have made arrangements for his stay in South Mumbai. The trial court convicted the appellant (A-1) of the offences charged and awarded him 5 death sentences; G for offence punishable (i) u/s 1208 IPC read with s.302 IPC for conspiracy to commit murder; (ii) u/s 121 IPC for waging war against the Government of India; (iii) u/s 16 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967; (iv) u/s 302 IPC for committing murder of 7 persons; (v) u/s 302 H read with s.34 and s.302 IPC read with s.109 and 120-B

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

IPC. However, A-2 and A-3 were acquitted of all the charges. The High Court confirmed the death sentences of the appellant and also upheld the acquittal of A-2 and A-3. Crl. A. Nos. 1899-1900 of 2011 were filed as jail appeals against the conviction of the appellant and Crl. A. No. 196 of 2011 was filed by the State against acquittal of A-2 and A-3.

Dismissing the appeals, the Court HELD: (Per Aftab Alam, J.) 1.1. In regard to the CST episode, like all other parts C of the case, the prosecution has gathered a very large amount of evidence: ocular, forensic and of other kinds, e.g., CCTV recordings. They have documented practically every action and movement of the two killers (the appellant and D-A 1) from the point when DA-1 threw D the first hand grenade at the passengers on the platform till they went out of CST through the foot-overbridge on the side of platform no.1 of the local lines. On the basis of the ocular evidence alone (not taking into account for the moment the other evidences) the prosecution has E presented before the court a vivid and photographic (figuratively and actually) account of the CST events. [Para 103] [387-B-D] 1.2. PW-49 is the Informant in connection with the offences committed at CST. At the time of the assault on CST he was an Assistant Inspector of Police attached to the CST Railway Police Station situated within the premises of CST. On the night of November 26 and 27, he was on duty at the police station. At about 21.50 hours, while he was coming out of the PS, he heard the sound of firing from the main hall of the main line railway station. He proceeded to the main hall. Police Inspector 'SS' (one of the policemen killed in the attack), proceeded to the hall. On coming to the main hall PW-49 saw the two terrorists indiscriminately firing from AK-47 rifles at

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A the passengers sitting in the main hall. He was injured by the bullets of the terrorists. He intimated the railway police helpline about the assault by the terrorists and asked for additional force. He also intimated the Commissioner of Police, Railways, on his walkie-talkie. B His statement was recorded at the hospital and on that basis an FIR in regard to CST episode was registered. [Paras 105, 109 and 113] [388-E-H; 389-A; 390-A-G] 1.3. PW-54, PW-58, PW-59, PW-60, PW-62, PW-63 and PW-66 are the other policemen or members of RPF who C heard the explosion and firing from different places of their duty and tried to tackle the assailants and some of them were seriously injured. [Para 136] [397-F-G; 398-AC] 1.4. PW-65 was the railway announcer on duty at the D time of terrorists' attack on CST. At about 9.55 PM he heard a big explosion. He guessed that it was a bomb and looked outside the window of his cabin. He saw passengers from the main line hall running towards the local lines. Among them some were bleeding. Some E were trying to rescue others who were unable to flee or move on account of injuries. He saw two terrorists coming from the direction of platform no.7. Both were firing. He then gave a description of the two terrorists and identified the appellant as the person who loaded his F rifle sitting down on the floor of the main hall and who t~rew away his bag. He was then shown the identity card, Article 61. He identified the photograph as that of the taller terrorist who was accompanying the appellant. He was shown a black haversack, Article 219. He identified it as G the bag that the appellant had thrown away in the main hall of the local lines. [Para 116,117,118 & 120] [391-C, GH; 392-A-B, E-F] 1.5. The evidence of PWs 61 and 102 is extraordinary in that they did not only witness the incidents but also H made a visual record of the events by taking pictures of

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

the two killers in action and also of their victims. The A pictures taken by these two witnesses, without anything else, are sufficient to conclude the issue of identification of the appellant and DA-1 as the killers of CST. Both the witnesses are professional photographers working with a national newspaper. Both of them, caring little for their B own safety and displaying exemplary professionalism, followed the killers practically at their heels. Their ocular testimony together with the photographs taken by them provides a graphic picture of the carnage at CST. PW61 prepared a CD of the photographs from the memory c card, to produce in court. The print-outs were taken from the CD. [Paras 121,122 and 128] [392-G-H; 393-A-B; 395-

C] 1.6. PW-50 and his daughter, aged about 10 years, (PW-51); PW-52; PW-53; PW-86 and her h~usband PW-87; D and PW-88, are some of the passenger witnesses. They were in the main hall of the main lines waiting for their respective trains. They were jolted out of whatever they might be doing or thinking at that moment by the explosion of the first grenade thrown by DA-1 and from E that moment they watched, in abject horror, the appellant and his companion firing indiscriminately at the group of passengers in the main hall; DA-1 throwing the second grenade and. then the two moving around on the platforms in different directions until the spray of bullets F and the shrapnel from the exploding grenades hit them or one of their group. Some of them were injured in the incident. [Para 150-158] [404-C-E] 1.7. After coming out of CST, the appellant and DA-1 G entered Cama Hospital, and killed 16 persons and injured 17 persons in the hospital and while coming out of it. The killed and injured ones included the police personnel. The prosecution, with the aid of 11 eye-witnesses, namely, PWs 101,103;105,107,106,109,111,118, ~

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

A 138,128,141 has traced practically every step taken by the appellant and DA-1 from the moment they came out of CST, entered Cama hospital and eventually left the hospital. These were the witnesses who were either themselves injured by the two terrorists or their relatives B were either shot dead or injured by the terrorists. PW 118, an IPS Officer had an encounter with the two terrorists in the terrace of the hospital building. PWs 138, 128 and 141 were the other police personnel who saw the two terrorists, namely, the appellant and DA-1, who after c coming out of Cama Hospital shot dead a police officer who was directing the persons coming from CST not to proceed further but to go back. They tried to tackle the terrorists but were injured by them. [paras 159-188] [407A; 406-H; 414-A; 418-C]

1.8. PW-138 stated that he saw the appellant and DA1 firing at a white car with a red beacon and DA-1 also throwing a hand grenade towards the car. PW-139 was the driver of the said car who was injured by the bullets of the two terrorists. PW-139 also stated before the court E that he saw the two terrorists approaching the "High Rise Building" by taking cover behind bushes. At the same time, a police vehicle approached his vehicle and as soon as the police vehicle came close to the two terrorist, who were hiding in the bushes, they started F firing at the police vehicle. There was an exchange of fire from the police vehicle also and when firing from police vehicle stopped, the two terrorists went to the vehicle, pulled down bodies of its occupants and drove away in the said vehicle. [para 194-196] [419-8-C, E; 420-F-G]

1.9. PW-136 was one of the member of the police team in the Qualis which was attacked by the two terrorists and he was badly injured in the attack. As the two terrorists approached the vehicle, he kept on lying in the rear seat of the vehicle pretending to be dead. The H ta!!er one drove the vehicle while the shorter one

MOHAMMEDAJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB@ABU MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

occupied the other front seat. After sometime, he heard the sound of firing. The tyre of the vehicle was punctured. The vehicle stopped. The two terrorists left that vehicle and left in another car. PW-144, PW-147 and his wife were the three occupants of the white Skoda car that the appellant and DA-1 snatched at gun-point. [Paras 203, 206, 207, 208, 210, 213, 215, 216] [422-E; 424-C-F; 426-B-C] 1.10. PW-1, the Sub-Inspector of Police stated that on 26.11.2008, at about 22.00 hours, the Senior Police Inspector told him that terrorists had attacked some parts of South Mumbai and directed him to go to Vinoli Chowpaty along with members of the Crime Detection Branch and to do a nakabandi there by putting up barricades. Accordingly, he accompanied by 6 members of the Detection Branch, proceeded to Vinoli Chowpaty. On reaching there, they found API, PW-3, alongwith other police personnel already present there and barricades already put up. After some time, API, PW-2 (injured) and an ASI (killed), along with some other policemen, also arrived at the nakabandi. At about 00.30 hours they spotted a Skoda car on Marine Drive coming from South Bombay towards Chowpaty. Having been alerted in regard to the Skoda, all the policemen, including PW-1, signalled to the driver to stop the car. In the exchange of firing two policemen and both the terrorists were injured. All the injured were taken to hospital where DA1 was declared brought dead and the appellant was admitted in the hospital for treatment. Subsequently, one of the two policemen also died in the hospital. The FIR of PW-1 was recorded by PW-31 at 2.10 hours, giving rise to CR no. 305/2008 (later converted into DCB CID CR no. 182/2008). [Para 223-224, 228, 230 and 237] [429-E-H; 430-B; 431-D-H] 1.11. PW-2 was another member of the police team at Vinoli Chowpaty that took the appellant in custody. His

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A deposition was similar to that of PW-1. He was one of the two policemen who were injured by the bullets of the two terrorists. He survived whereas the other died subsequently in the hospital. PW-3 was another Assistant Police Inspector present at the nakabandi at B Vinoli Chowpaty on the direction of Senior Police Inspector. His narration of the occurrence was similar to that of PW-1 and PW-2. [Para 240, 241 and 245, 247] [433H; 434-A, 435-G-H] 1.12. All the witnesses (except those relating to the C Vile Parle and Mazgaon Taxi blasts) had a life and death encounter with the appellant and his associate, (D-A1) at close quarters. The physical appearance of the two terrorists .was etched on their minds. All the witnesses gave a detailed description of the two terrorists to the D court. They described them by their complexion, age, body-built and height, stating that one of them was tall and the other was short. All of them identified the appellant in court as the shorter of the two assailants. They also identified DA1 from the photograph on the fake E identity card, Article 61. They also stated before the court that they had identified the appellant in the test identification parades held. This Court accepts their testimony without any hesitation. [Para 263] [441-G; 442A-C]

1.13. On the basis of the ocular evidence alone, the appellant, personally and jointly with D-A 1, is directly responsible for killing at least 72 people and causing injuries of various kinds to 130 people. [Para 262] [441E-F]

1.14. Besides the depositions of the prosecution witnesses, the prosecution has an enormous volume of other evidence such as: articles recovered and seized from places through which the two terrorists passed, and the places where they stopped; the vehicles-they used H until they were finally caught; medical and forensic

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 313 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

reports, CCTV recordings, phone call records, Station Diary entries, police logs, etc. (Para 262] (441-D-E] 1.15. From the forensic evidence it further appears that of the 72 dead, at least 6 persons fell to shots fired by the appellant. Therefore, he is held guilty of multiple murders, murders with common intention and abetment, attempts to murder with common intention and abetment, abducting in order to murder, robbery with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt, and several other allied offences under the Penal Code, committing terrorist act u/s 16 of Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, as well as offences under the Explosives Act, 1884, Explosive Substances Act, 1908, and Arms Act, 1959. [Para 264] (442-D-E] OTHER INCIDENTS OF TERRORISTS' ATTACK: 2.1. The prosecution has documented the episodes at Leopld Cafe, Hotel Taj, Hotel Oberoi, and Nariman House, as well as Mazgaon Taxi Blast as exhaustively as it has documented the incidents at "CST", "Cam a Hospital", snatching of SKODA car and incident at Vinoli Chowpaty relating to the appellant and D-A 1. PWs 478, 479, 176, 179, 184, 224, 188,,239, 206, 255, 182,C-W 3, 239, 201, 202, 200, 212, 215, 250 and 208 are substantive witnesses of the incidents at these places. [para 304-308] [458-A-H; 458-A-B]

C

CONSPIRACY: 2.2. The suggestion that the appellant should only be held liable for acts committed by him in the company of the deceased accused(D-A1) based on the premise that the two were acting independently and separately from the other terrorists who, on arriving at Mumbai, went to four different targets, cannot be accepted. There is no basis for the assumption that the five pairs were not connected to each other by a common conspiracy and

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A that they were not acting in furtherance of a conspiracy that was keeping them bound together even after they had separated physically in order to execute their assigned roles under the conspiracy. Further, it would be wrong to proceed on such an assumption even without B taking into account the evidence of conspiracy that the prosecution has presented with reference to the other aspects of the case and the other venues of the terrorist attack. [para 267) [444-C-D, E-G]

C

2.3. Keeping in view the incident at the venues of the terrorists' violence, it cannot be said that the appellant and his dead accomplice (D-A 1), were acting separately and that their actions were not connected in any manner with the offences committed at the other places by the other 8 terrorists with whom they jointly made the sea journey to Mumbai's shore. It is significant to note that the nine dead accused could only be known by their respective names after the appellant identified them through photographs of their dead bodies. Further, the names of the four terrorists at Hotel Taj also came in the evidence of PW-224 and PW-242. Also the names of the terrorists who went to Hotel Oberoi and Nariman House came through in the transcripts of their intercepted phone calls, in which they are talking with their collaborators. It is obvious that all 5 teams were bound together and each team was acting in execution of a common conspiracy. [para 272 and 309) [446-D-F; 459C-D]

2.4. The landing site for the terrorists at Badhwar Park was selected with great care and the selection of the G targets for attack was made with even greater care. The attacks at all five targets appear to be integrally connected with each other and the appellant and DA-1 are as much part of the offences committed at the other places as they are responsible for the offences committed H by them directly. Therefore, it cannot be said that for the

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

purpose of the instant appeal, there is no need to go beyond the acts directly attributed to the appellant and his dead associate. [para 310 and 315) [459-E; 461-D-E] 2.5. The evidence of conspiracy brought on record may be broadly classified under three heads: (i) the confessional statement by the appellant; (ii) the objective findings in the vessel 'Kuber', the inflatable rubber dinghy, the different places of attack by the other groups of terrorists and the locations of bomb explosions in the two taxis; and (iii) the transcripts of the phone conversations between the terrorists and their collaborators and handlers from across the border. The evidence under any of these three heads is sufficient to bring home the charges relating to conspiracy against the appellant. [para 532) [595-C-D] 2.6. The phase of planning the attack and training for it, which form the core of the conspiracy, took place in Pakistan, and the terrorists, including the appellant, came to Mumbai in execution of the main objects of the conspiracy. The appellant was apprehended while he was on a killing spree in execution of the objects of the conspiracy and the transcripts of the phone conversation of the other terrorists, associates of the appellant and their foreign collaborators, relate to a time when the speakers were not only free but were actively involved in trying to fulfil the objects of the conspiracy. The transcripts are by no means any confessional statements made under arrest and they are fully covered by the provisions of s.10 of the Evidence Act. There is no reason not to take them into consideration in support of the charge of conspiracy against the appellant. [para 533) [597-A-C] State v. Nalini 1999 (3) SCR 1 distinguished.

C

=(1999) 5 sec 253 -

2.7. On the basis of the disclosure statement of the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A appellant recorded by PW-42 at 13.00 hrs on 27.11.2008, a search was mounted for "the abandoned Indian boat" ('Kuber') and it was found and brought to Sassoon Dock in Mumbai with the assistance of the Coast Guard. Two police officers, namely, PW-48 and PW-42, took the B appellant and the two witnesses of the disclosure statement Panchnama, namely, 'PAH' and PW-25, near a wooden boat brought from the sea that was anchored near the jetty. The appellant identified the wooden boat as "the Indian boat" in which he, along with his nine c associates, had approached the Mumbai shore and on which he had killed the 'Nakhva' of the boat, whose body he had kept in the engine room. The appellant then led the police team and the panchas to the engine room and showed them the dead body of the 'Nakhva' that was kept in the corner. The appellant then took out a satellite phone, a GPS and a notebook that were kept concealed under a wooden plank in the engine room on the left side of the dead body, and handed them to the police team. The note book contained, inter alia, entries regarding guard roster, phone numbers, satellite number, maps, E GPS, arms and ammunitions, and certain places in Mumbai. [para 318-325 and 329-334] [463-E; 465-D-G] 2.8. The Thuraya satellite phone and the GARMIN GPS recovered from 'Kuber', along with four other GPS F devices recovered from the other sites of terrorist violence, were sent for forensic examination to the United States Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) where the data stored in the GPS devices were analyzed by PW-152. The route shown on page No.36 of the annexure to his G report showed the intermediate waypoints stored by the user and those waypoints were between Karachi and Mumbai. The first waypoint was in the ocean of the Gulf of Karachi and the last waypoint was in Mumbai. He added that page No.38 of the annexure to his report H showed the track back route from Mumbai to the Gulf of

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 317 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Karachi. Page No.38 showed the waypoints of the journey A of the user from 'OCEN1' to 'OCENA'. He explained that 'OCEN1' was the coast of Pakistan and 'OCENA' was the coast of Mumbai. PW-161 explained that the 'OCENS' waypoints showed the route from south of Pakistan to south Mumbai. The JALA waypoints showed the route B from Gujarat to South Mumbai. [para 341-344] [471-H; 472A; 473-C-E; 474-D] 2.9. The other articles recovered from 'Kuber', namely, blankets, shawls and many other items of clothing contained the stains of sweat, saliva and other bodily C secretions which were subjected to DNA profiling and, excepting D-A2, D-A5, D-A7, D-A9, the rest of the six accused were connected with those articles. The appellant's DNA matched the DNA profile from a sweat stain detected on one of the jackets. [para 345] [474-D-F] D 2.10. PW-34 and another person ('PKN') witnessed the seizure of the rubber dinghy under Panchnama Ext. no. 162. From the seizure Panchnama it appears that 14 articles were seized along with the rubber dinghy. Of these, the Yamaha outboard machine that was fitted to the E rubber dinghy is of special significance for the case. From the evidence of PW-154, whose evidence was recorded through audio-video linkage while he was sitting in the office of the FBI at Los Angeles, USA, and PW-153 who was working as a Special Agent of FBI, the F prosecution has established that the Yamaha outboard machine fitted to the inflatable rubber boat, was exported to Pakistan. (para 346-349] (475-B-C-G; 476-F; 477-B] 2.11. At CST a piece of pink coloured foam was G found, which inseparably connects the appellant to the other eight terrorists. The pink foam runs like a thread through all the episodes and connecting them as integral pieces of one single, horrible drama. The pink foam pieces recovered from 'Kuber' and found in the bags that were picked up from CST, the terrace of the Cam a Hospital H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

building and the two bags containing unexploded IEDs found near Hotel Taj and seized under the Panchnama, Ext. no. 736, were sent for chemical examination at the Forensic Science Laboratory. PW-247, the forensic expert, deposed before the court that all the foam pieces B tallied with each other in respect of hue (appearance) and physico-thermal characteristics. He concluded that the source of all the foam pieces was the same. It is obvious that the foam was used to provide padding and cushion to the IEDs and the hand grenades kept in the bags so c as to prevent them exploding accidentally while the terrorists were carrying them on their person. [para 350, 352-359) [478-H; 479-A; 481-G-H; 482-A-C]

2.12. The most clinching evidence regarding conspiracy comes from the recordings of intercepted telephone calls between the terrorists and their coconspirators and collaborators sitting in a foreign land that, in light of the over all facts and circumstances of the case, can only be Pakistan. Unlike the appellant and his dead companion (D-A1), who were constantly on the move, the other terrorists had gone to Hotel Taj, Hotel Oberoi and Nariman House and were holed up there, even taking hostages for some time. From their respective positions they were in regular contact with their collaborators and were constantly receiving moral support, tactical advice and guidance from them by means of mobile phones. The phone calls made by the terrorists from Hotel Taj, Nariman House and Hotel Oberoi came to be noticed and were intercepted by a watchful member of the Anti Terrorist Squad i.e PW-242. At midnight of 26.11.2008, he received information that terrorists were making regular calls from mobile phone no.9910719424. PW 242 stated before the court that the first conversation recorded by him from that mobile number commenced at 01:04 hours on November 27, 2008, and the last call from that mobile number was recorded by him at 10:27 hours

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 319 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

of November 27, 2008. He stated that the conversation was being heard by him personally and being recorded on t~e hard disk of the computer simultaneously. He stated that, from the conversations made from mobile phone number 9910719424, he could make out that the callers from that phone were speaking from Hotel Taj. He named the said callers. He also named the two persons on the other end. In course of the night, PW 242 came across two other mobile phone numbers, 9820704561 and 9819464530. The first of these two was being used by the terrorists at Hotel Oberoi and the second by those at Nariman House. PW 242 intercepted and recorded the conversations made from those two phone numbers also. He stated that the interception of these calls by him commenced at 01 :04 hours on November 27, 2008, and the last call from one of these numbers concluded at 08:52 hours on November 28, 2008. The total recordings of intercepted phone calls were spread over 12 hours and 33 minutes. The CD recordings of the intercepted phone conversations were played in court on a laptop. Significantly, PW 242 told the court that all the calls from the said three mobile phones were made to a single number, 012012531824, which later investigation revealed to be the number of private Corporation based in New Jersey, USA, with the domain name Callphonex. [para 360-370] [482-E-F; 483-A-D; 484-D-H; 485-A-E]

c

2.13. PW-242 told the court that the collaborators of the terrorists appeared to be speaking from telephone number 012012531824. As the international code would indicate, the number was based in the US. Clarification about the number comes from the evidence of PW-156. G The evidence of this witness was recorded through audio-video linkage, through the Special Agent of FBI, PW-153. PW 156 stated before the court that he was the owner of International Connection Services (ICS) in New Jersey. Services of PW 156 were 'thus used by a bunch H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

of terrorists for the mass killing of innocent people. According to him, he realized that a false account was opened with him for unlawful purposes, only after the massacre in Mumbai. [para 371, 379-381) [485-F-H; 490E]

2.14. A great many mobile phones were collected and seized from the various places through which the terrorists had passed as also from the vehicles used by the appellant and his dead companion, for moving through the city, but out of these, 5 mobile phones were C relevant, 2 of which were recovered from Hotel Taj, 2 from Nariman House and 1 from Hotel Oberoi. The two phones that were recovered from Hotel Taj are mentioned in Exhibit nos. 749 and 760. Both were Nokia 1200. One of them, a Nokia 1200 phone had the IMEI No. D 353526025840890. It had a Sim card purchased from PW259, a retailer in Delhi, in the name of a fictitious person ('SP') and, on calls being made from this phone, the number that was displayed on the receiving phone would be 9910719424, the first number that had come to the E notice of PW-242. Two Nokia 1200 phones were also recovered from Nariman House and they found mention in Exhibit no. 771. One of them, a Nokia 1200 phone had the IMEI No.353526025842235. It had a Sim card belonging to 'GH', who was first taken hostage and was F later killed by the terrorists. It appears that the terrorists had taken away the mobile phone of 'GH', took out the Sim card from his mobile and put it in their own mobile phone. A call made through the Sim card of 'GH' would display this number on the receiving phone: 9819464530. G This was one of the two numbers that later came to the notice of PW-242. The fifth Nokia 1200 was recovered from Hotel Oberoi vide Ext. no. 790. Its IMEI number was 353526025933620. This mobile phone had a Sim card issued in the name of one of the victims killed by the H terrorists at Hotel Oberoi. It appears that her mobile

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 321 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

phone was also taken away by the terrorists at Hotel A Oberoi, who took out the Sim card from her mobile and used it to make calls from their own mobile. Any call made through the said Sim card would display the number 9820704561 on the receiving phone. This was the third number that had come to the notice of PW-242. [para 383- B 385] [491-A-H; 492-A-C] 2.15. It is thus clear that the terrorists at Hotel Taj were using a Sim card that was obtained in India under a fictitious name 'SP' on the basis of fake identity C documents. The terrorists at Nariman House and Hotel Oberoi used Sim cards snatched from their respective victims, which they used to make calls from their own mobile phones. From the materials brought on record, it is evident that all the five Nokia 1200 mobile phones were manufactured in China and were shipped to Pakistan. D Exhibit no. 606 is a communication dated February 12, 2009, authenticated by ACP, Enforcement Manager I Americas Nokia Inc. (PW-155) addressed to SA, of F.B.I. (PW-153). The mobile phones and the SIM cards have been produced by the prosecution, by means of which E the terrorists holed up in the places targeted by them were calling their collaborators across the border and also the medium through which the exact location of the collaborators was hidden. [para 386-388] [492-C-E; 494F~ 2.16. The attack on Mumbai, killing and wounding scores of innocent people was a wicked act, and the conversations between the terrorists and their collaborators while the attack was underway appear to G be its ugliest and most hateful part. Those conversations unveil warped minds conceiving perverted objectives and trying to realize those objectives through vicious and dastardly means. The conversation between the terrorists and the collaborators evidenced: (1) Exhortation to fight in the name of Islam against heresy, and the allurement H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

of martyrdom; (2) Deception that the terrorists were Indians and were venting the grievance of the Indian Muslims; also an attempt to involve Israel; (3) Rejoicing over the killing of the high police officers; (4) Advising the terrorists on tactics to deal with the security forces, who B were called in to neutralize them; (5) Killing of the hostages. The sum and substance of the transcripts of talks from Hotel Taj, Hotel Oberoi and Naiman House was exactly on the lines that the terrorists from Nariman House talked to India TV as the transcripts of those c interviews would indicate. The deception, the falsehood that the terrorists were Indian Muslims coming from Hyderabad and were connected with some fictitious organization called Mujaheddin, Hyderabad Deccan, is one of the most ominous and distressing part of the o conspiracy. If the appellant had not been caught alive and the investigating agencies had not been able to unravel the conspiracy fully and in all its devious ways, the terrorists might have passed as Indian Muslims which could easily evoke communal violence that would be E difficult to contain. The deception was ominous because it aimed at destabilising Indian society and its governments. [para 389,390, 392-400] [494-H; 495-A; 496B-E; 510-C-F; 511-B] 2.17. In view of the enormous evidence of all possible F kinds it is clear that the terrorist attack on Mumbai was in pursuance of a larger conspiracy of which the appellant was as much part as the nine dead accused and the other wanted accused. From the evidence on record it is further clear that the conspiracy did not stop with the G group of 10 terrorists leaving the Pakistani shore. It continued developing and growing even while the larger conspiracy was under execution. In course of execution of the larger conspiracy by the ten terrorists in Mumbai, they were being advised and guided to meet the H contingencies arising at those three different places.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 323 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Thus, newer conspiracies were being hatched even in A course of execution of the larger conspiracy and the conspiracies came to an end only when all the remaining eight terrorists were killed at the three places where they were holding up. [para 401] [532-C-F] WAGING WAR AGAINST GOVERNMENT OF INDIA:

3.1. The appellant has also been convicted on the charge of waging war against the Government of India and is awarded the death penalty u/s 121 IPC. In addition, he is separately convicted, u/s 121A IPC, for conspiracy C to commit offences punishable bys. 121 and s.122 IPC for collecting arms with intention of waging war against the Government of India, and given life sentences under these two Sections. [para 534] [597-D-F] 3.2. The offences concerning "waging war" are in Chapter VI of the Penal Code under the heading "OF OFFENCES AGAINST THE STATE". Section 121 uses the phrase 'Government of India' and it provides that whoever, wages war against the Government of India, or attempts to wage such war, or abets the waging of such war, shall be punished with death, or imprisonment for life and shall also be liable to fine. Section 121A makes a conspiracy to commit offences punishable by s.121 per se an offence punishable with imprisonment for life or for a period that may extend to 10 years. The explanation to the Section makes it clear that the offence is complete even without any act or illegal omission occurring in pursuance of the conspiracy. This Section uses the expression 'the Central Government or any State Government'. Section 122 similarly makes collection of arms witl:l intention of "waging war" per se an offence, regardless of whether or not the arms were put to actual use. This Section again uses the expression "Government of India". [para 540-542] [599-F-H; 600-A-F] 3.3. The expression "Government of India" is used

s

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

ins. 121 to imply the Indian State, the juristic embodiment of the sovereignty of the country that derives its legitimacy from the collective will and consent of its people. The use of the phrase "Government of India" to signify the notion of sovereignty is consistent with the principles of Public International Law, wherein sovereignty of a territorial unit is deemed to vest in the people of the territory and exercised by a representative government. Thus, the expression "Government of India", as appearing in s.121, must be held to mean the State or interchangeably the people of the country as the repository of the sovereignty of India which is manifested and expressed through the elected Government. [para 545-546) [601-G-H; 602-A-C]

3.4. The expression, "in like manner and by like means as a forei{j_n enemy would do" ( as explained in Navjot Sandhu) is very significant to understand the nature of the violent acts that would amount to waging war. In "waging war", the intent of the foreign enemy is not only to disturb public peace or law and order or to E kill many people. A foreign enemy strikes at the sovereignty of the State, and his conspiracy and actions are motivated by that animus. As explained in Navjot Sandhu, a "terrorist act" and an act of "waging war against the Government of India" may have some F overlapping features, but a terrorist act may not always be an act of waging war against the Government of India, and vice-versa. The provisions of Chapter IV of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act and those of Chapter VI of the Penal Code, including s.121, basically cover G different areas. [para 547-548 and 550) [602-G-H; 603-A; 604-F-G] State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu 2005 (2) Suppl. SCR 79 (2005) 11 sec 600- relied on

=

Mohd. Arif v. State of Delhi 2011 (8) SCALE 328-

referred to.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 325 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Report of Indian Law Commission with regard to Draft Panel Code in 1847 - referred to.

3.5. In the case in hand, the primary and the first offence that the appellant and his co-conspirators committed was the offence of waging war against the Government of India. It does not matter that the target assigned to the appellant and DA-1 was CST Station (stated to be no more than a public building) where they killed a large number of people. What matters is that the attack was aimed at India and Indians. It was by foreign nationals. People were killed for no other reason than they were Indians; in case of foreigners, they were killed because their killing on Indian soil would embarrass India. The conspiracy, in furtherance of which the attack was made, was, inter alia, to hit at India; to hit at its financial centre; to try to give rise to communal tensions and create internal strife and insurgency; to demand that India should withdraw from Kashmir; and to dictate its relations with other countries. It was in furtherance of those objectives that the attack was made, causing the loss of a large number of people and injury to an even greater number of people. Nothing could have been more "in like manner and by like means as a foreign enemy would do". [para 551] [604-H; 605-A-D] 3.6. The transcripts of the conversations between the terrorists and their collaborators across the border, the passages of the appellant's confessional statement made before the magistrate stating about instructions given by wanted accused no. 1, wanted accused no. 2, and others in connection with the main purpose of the attack and a number of passages from the transcripts of conversations between the terrorists and their collaborators across the border would show that the attack was clearly an enemy action. [para 552] [605-E-G] 3.7. On a careful consideration of the materials on

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A record this Court has no hesitation in holding that the appellant has been rightly held guilty of waging war against the Government of India and rightly convicted u/ ss 121, 121A and 122 of the Penal Code. [para 553] (605H; 606-A]

Due Process:

4.1. There is no doubt that the right to silence and the right to the presence of an attorney granted by the Miranda decision to an accused as a measure of C protection against self-incrimination have no application under the Indian system of law. The US Supreme Court has clearly acknowledged and pointed out that the measures to protect the accused against selfincrimination evolved by it under the Miranda rules were D already part of the Indian statutory scheme. [para 450 and 453] (557-B-C; 558-C] Miranda v. Arizona 384 US 436 (1966) - held inapplicable

Sarwan Singh v. State of Punjab 1957 SCR 953 1957 SC 637 (644) - referred to.

=AIR

4.2. A bare reference to the statutory provisions namely, ss.161(2), 162(1), 163 and 164 CrPC read with ss. F 25,26, 27 and 32 of the Evidence Act would show that those provisions are designed to afford complete protection to the accused against self-incrimination. It is thus clear that the protection to the accused against any self-incrimination guaranteed by the Constitution is very G strongly built into the Indian statutory framework and there is absolutely no reason to draw any help from the Miranda principles for providing protection against selfincrimination to the accused. The right against selfincrimination under Art. 20(3) of the Constitution of India does not exclude any voluntary statements made in H exercise of free will and volition. The right against self-

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 327 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

incrimination under Art. 20(3) is fully incorporated in the A provisions of the CrPC (s.161, 162, 163 and 164) and the Evidence Act, as manifestations of enforceable due process, and thus compliance with these statutory provisions is also equal compliance with the Constitutional guarantees. [para 454, 455 and 468] [558- 8 D; 559-C-D; 566-D-E] 4.3. It is significant to note that the law of the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002 (POTA) is a major departure from the common criminal law process in this country. One can almost call the POTA and a few other C Acts of its ilk as exceptions to the general rule. In the severe framework of the POTA, certain constitutional safeguards are built into s.32, and to some extent in s.52, of the Act. But the mainstream criminal law procedure in India, which is governed by the CrPC and the Evidence D Act, has a fundamentally different and far more liberal framework, in which the rights of the individual are protected, in a better and more effective manner, in different ways. It is, therefore, incorrect to say that what is said in the context of the POTA should also apply to E the mainstream criminal law procedure. [para 465] [565D-F] 4.4. It is incorrect to say that Art. 22(1) of the Constitution merely allows an arrested person to consult F a legal practitioner of his choice and the right to be defended by a legal practitioner crystallizes only at the stage of commencement of the trial in terms of s.304 CrPC. Art.22(1) was a part of the Constitution as it came into force on 26.1.1950. Code of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 that substituted the Code of 1898, came into G force on 1.4.1974. It incorporated the constitutional provisions regarding the protection of the accused against self-accusation. The CrPC also had a provision in s. 304 regarding access to a lawyer. The Constitution and the body of laws comprise an organic structure H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

developing and growing like a living organism. Art. 39A came to be inserted in the Constitution by the Constitution (42nd Amendment Act, 1976) with effect from 3.1.1977 as part of the 'Directive Principles of the State Policy'. In furtherance to the ideal of Art. 39-A, Parliament 8 enacted the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, that came into force from 9.11.1995. All this development clearly indicates the direction in which the law relating to access to lawyers/legal aid has developed and continues to develop. It is now rather late in the day to C contend that Art. 22(1) is merely an enabling provision and that the right to be defended by a legal practitioner comes into force only on the commencement of trial as provided u/s 304 of the CrPC. [para 469-470, 471,473 and 475] [566-G-H; 567-8-D; 568-8-C, F; 569-D-E]

State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar 1952 SCR 284

=AIR 1952 SC 75 - relied on. 4.5. The obligation to provide legal aid to the accused as soon as he is brought before the magistrate is very E much part of our criminal law procedure, but for reasons very different from the Miranda rule, aimed at protecting the accused against self-incrimination. And it cannot be accepted that any failure to provide legal aid to the accused at the beginning, or before his confession is F recorded u/s 164 CrPC, would inevitably render the trial illegal. [para 464] [565-8-C] Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Jugal Kishore Samra 2011 (7) SCR 889 = (2011) 12 SCC 362 Poolpandi v. Superintendent, Central Excise 1992 (3) SCR 247 = (1992) G 3 SCC 259; Nandini Satpathy v. P. L. Dani 1978 (3) SCR 608 = (1978) 2 SCC 424; D.K. Basu v State of West Bengal 1996 (10) Suppl. SCR 284 = (1997) 1 SCC 416; Karlar Singh v. State of Punjab 1994 (2) SCR 375 = (1994) 3 SCC

569 - referred to.

MOHAMMEDAJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 329 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

4.6. It can also not be said that providing a lawyer at A the stage of trial would provide only incomplete protection to the accused in case the accused had already made a confession u/s 164 CrPC. The object of the criminal law process is to find out the truth and not to shield the accused from the consequences of his B wrongdoing. A defense lawyer has to conduct the trial on the basis of the materials lawfully collected in the course of investigation. The true test to judge the Constitutional and legal acceptability of a confession recorded u/s 164 CrPC is whether or not the confession is voluntary. If a c doubt is created regarding the voluntariness of the confession, notwithstanding the safeguards stipulated in s. 164 it has to be trashed; but if a confession is established as voluntary it must be taken into account, not only constitutionally and legally but also morally. o [para 466-467] [565-G-H; 566-A-C] 4.7. The provisions of the CrPC and the Evidence Act fully incorporate the Constitutional guarantees, and that the statutory framework for the criminal process in India affords the fullest protection to personal liberty and E dignity of an individual, but the Court takes judicial notice, that there is a great hiatus between what the law stipulates and the realities on the ground in the enforcement of the law. The abuses of the provisions of the CrPC are perhaps the most subversive of the right to F life and personal liberty, the most precious right under the Constitution, and the human rights of an individual. Access to a lawyer is, therefore, imperative to ensure compliance with statutory provisions, which are of high standards in themselves and which, if duly complied G with, will leave no room for any violation of Constitutional provisions or human rights abuses. [para 476] [569-F-H; 570-A-B] 4.8. The right to access to legal aid, to consult and to be defended by a legal practitioner, arises when a H

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2012] 8 S.C.R.

person arrested in connection with a cognizable offence is first produced before a magistrate. Accordingly, it is the duty and obligation of the magistrate before whom a person accused of committing a cognizable offence is first produced to make him fully aware that it is his right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner and, in case he has no means to engage a lawyer of his choice, that one would be provided to him from legal aid at the State expense. The right flows from Arts. 21 and 22(1) of the Constitution and needs to be strictly enforced. This Court accordingly, directs all the magistrates in the country to faithfully discharge the said duty and obligation and further make it clear that any failure to fully discharge the duty would amount to dereliction in duty and would make the concerned magistrate liable to departmental proceedings. [para 484] [573-E-H] Hussainara Khatoon (IV) v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar 1979 (3) SCR 532 (1980) 1 sec 98; Khatri (II) v. State of Bihar 1981 (2) SCR 408 (1981) 1 SCC 627- relied on.

=

=

4.9. However, it needs to be clarified that the right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner is not to be construed as sanctioning or permitting the presence of a lawyer during police interrogation. According to our F system of law, the role of a lawyer is mainly focused on court proceedings. The accused would need a lawyer to resist remand to police or judicial custody and for granting of bail; to clearly explain to him the legal consequences in case he intended to make a confessional statement in terms of s.164 CrPC; to G represent him when the court examines the chargesheet submitted by the police and decides upon the future course of proceedings and at the stage of the framing of charges; and beyond that, of course, for the trial. It is thus to be seen that the right to access to a lawyer in this H country is not based on the Miranda principles, as

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

protection against self-incrimination, for which there are more than adequate safeguards in Indian laws. The right to access to a lawyer is for very Indian reasons; it flows from the provisions of the Constitution and the statutes, and is only intended to ensure that those provisions are faithfully adhered to in practice. [para 485] [574-A-D] 4.10. Every accused unrepresented by a lawyer has to be provided a lawyer at the commencement of the trial, engaged to represent him during the entire course of the trial. Even if the accused does not ask for a lawyer or he remains silent, it is the Constitutional duty of the court to provide him with a lawyer before commencing the trial. Unless the accused voluntarily makes an informed decision and tells the court, in clear and unambiguous words, that he does not want the assistance of any lawyer and would rather defend himself personally, the obligation to provide him with a lawyer at the commencement of the trial is absolute, and failure to do so would vitiate the trial and the resultant conviction and sentence, if any, given to the accused. [para 487] [574-FH; 575-A]

C

Suk Das v. UT of Arunachal Pradesh 1986 (1) SCR 590

=(1986) 2 sec 401 - relied on.

4.11. But the failure to provide a lawyer to the accused at the pre-trial stage may not have the same consequence of vitiating the trial. It may hav11 other consequences like making the delinquent magistrate liable to disciplinary proceedings, or giving the accused a right to claim compensation against the State for failing to provide him legal aid. But it would not vitiate the trial unless it is shown that failure to provide legal assistance at the pre-trial stage had resulted in some material prejudice to the accused in the course of the trial. That would have to be judged on the facts of each case. [para 488] [575-B-C]

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

4.12. In the instant case, the appellant was arrested on November 27, 2008, at 10.45PM. At the time of his arrest the appellant stated that he was a Pakistani national and he did not have any friend or relative in India. PW-48, accordingly, made a note in "the Record of B Formalities to be Followed at the time of Arrest" that intimation of his arrest could not be given to anyone h::i India but information about his relatives was being procured for giving intimation to them (in Pakistan). He also noted in the Arrest Panchnama that the appellant c belonged to an economically weaker section. The note in "the Record of Formalities" states that the appellant refused the offer of legal aid made to him. From the records, it is evident that the appellant was offered a lawyer at the time of his arrest by the police officer making the arrest. He declined the offer. He then wrote a letter to the Pakistani High Commission asking to be provided with a lawyer. He made a similar request in a second letter that was handed over to the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. In the second letter, there is an assertion that he did not want to be represented by an Indian lawyer. It E is thus clear that, in his mind, the appellant was still at war with India, and he had no use for a lawyer from the enemy country. Moreover, the negative assertion that he did not want an Indian lawyer itself implies that he had received offers of legal counsel. But those offers were not F acceptable to him. The appellant's refusal to accept the services of an Indian lawyer and his demand for a lawyer from his country cannot be anything but his own independent decision. He was acting quite independently and, in his mind, he was a "patriotic" Pakistani at war with G this country. [para 489, 494 and 495] [575-D-G; 579-B-F] 4.13. On March 23, 2009, the appellant finally asked for a lawyer, apparently convinced by then that no help would come from Pakistan or anywhere else. He was H then immediately provided with a set of two lawyers. In

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 333 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

the facts of the case, this Court is firmly of the view that A there has been no violation of any of the rights of the appellant under the Indian Constitution. He was offered the services of a lawyer at the time of his arrest and at all relevant stages in the proceedings. The absence of a lawyer at the pre-trial stage was not only as per the B wishes of the appellant himself, but this absence also did not cause him any prejudice in the trial. [para 496-497] [579-F-H; 580-A] Zahira Habibullah Sheikh (5) v. State of Gujarat 2006 (2) C (2006) 3 sec 374 T. Nagappa v. Y.R. SCR 1081 Muralidhar 2008 (6) SCR 959 (2008) 5 SCC 63, Noor Aga v. State of Punjab 2008 (10) SCR 379 (2008) 16 sec 417, NHRC v. State of Gujarat (2008) 16 SCC 497; Jayendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra 2009 (8) SCR 591 (2009) 7 SCC 104; and G. Someshwar Rao v. Samineni 0 Nageshwar Rao 2009 (11) SCR 676 (2009) 14 SCC 677; Behram Khursheed v. State of Bombay (1955) 1. SCR 613 and Olga Tellis v. Bombay Municipal Corp. 1985 (2) Suppl. SCR 51 (1985) 3 SCC 545; Se/vi and others v. State of Karnataka 2010 (5) SCR 381 (2010) 7 SCC 263; State of E Bombay v. Kathi Kalu Oghad [1962] 3 SCR 10 - cited.

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

Davis v. United States 512 US 452 (1993); Berghuis, Warden v. Thompkins 130 S.Ct. 2250 (2010); Dietrich v. R. [1992] 177 CLR 292; R. v. Sinclair [2010] 2 S.C.R. (Canada) 31 O; Sa/duz v. Turkey (2009) 49 EHRR 19; Ambrose v. Harris (Procurator Fiscal, Oban) (Scotland) [2011] UKSC 43 and McGowan, (Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh) v. B (Scotland) [2011] UKSC 54- cited.

Time allowed to the lawyer for preparation:

4.14. The counsel was appointed on 16.4.2009 to represent the appellant and on his application dated 21.4.2009, the court allowed him 8 days' time, which cannot be said to be unreasonable. From the chart

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

showing not only the day-to-day developments in the trial but also giving details of the hours of the court proceedings on each day, it is evident that the counsel for the appellant was allowed ample time for preparation. It would be pertinent to note that the counsel for the B appellant before the trial court never complained about not being given sufficient time. It is also evident that, in the course of the trial, when the counsel for he appellant requested for adjournment for cross-examination of some important witnesses, the court accommodated him on c most occasions. Therefore, it cannot be said that the defence was not allowed sufficient time for preparation of the case and that denial of sufficient time vitiated the trial. [para 500-503] [581-D-G; 582-A-C]

Ranchod Mathur Wasawa v. State of Gujarat 1974 ( 2) D SCR 72; and Owais Alam v. State of U.P. Criminal Appeal No.284 of 1968, decided on December 17, 1968 - cited

CONFESSION:

5.1. It is pertinent to note that though the appellant was produced before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate on 17.2.2009, the Magistrate after satisfying herself that the appellant was willing to make the confessional statement voluntarily and not under any pressure, coercion or allurement by police or anyone F else, gave him 24 hours time to reflect further on the matte and remanded him to judicial custody. When the appellant was brought back to the Magistrate on 18.2.2009, she had another long interaction with him and cautioned him of the consequences of his statement by G saying that he should make the statement only if he wished to do so. The appellant said that he was aware of the consequences and he wanted to make the confession. The Magistrate again gave him a period of 48 hours for further reflection and to reconsider the matter H with a composed mind. When the appellant was

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 335 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

produced before the Magistrate on 20.2.2012, she again A followed the procedure and after satisfying herself that the appellant was willing to make the statement on his volition proceeded to record his statement u/s 164 CrPC. The statement was completed on 21.2.2009 in accordance with the procedure prescribed. [para 10-15] [353-D; 354- B A-G; 355-A-G] 5.2. From the text of appellant's confession, it is impossible to hold that the confession is not voluntary and is liable to be thrown out for that reason. However, the censure regarding the mentions of the other two C accused in the confessional statement is quite justified, and the references to accused 2 and 3 at three places in the confessional statement is highly unsatisfactory. The reference to their destination being Malabar Hills when DA-1 and the appellant were caught at Vinoli Chowpaty D is equally vague, and that also is perhaps mentioned to establish a connection with the alleged maps prepared by accused 2 and 3. But so far as the rest of the very detailed confession is concerned, there is absolutely no reason to doubt that it was made voluntarily and without E any influence or duress from any external agency. [para 516] [587-G-H; 588-A-C] 5.3. The detailed references by the appellant to his parents and a larger number of his relatives, their F addresses and the mobile phone numbers of some of them, and his references to the different places in Pakistan, appear to be directed against the Pakistani authorities. In the statement that he made before the magistrate on February 20, 2009, the appellant was G making it clear that he was a Pakistani by birth and by citizenship, and was making assertions that no one could deny. [para 517] [588-0-G] 5.4. As to his knowing the names of many people in Lashkar-e-Toiba, their respective positions in the hierarchy H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

and their roles in the organization, again there is nothing unusual about it. It is to be noted that the appellant was not a mercenary hired for the operation. He was a highly committed and devoted member of the organization and, therefore, there is nothing strange or wrong in his B coming to know many people in the organization during the course of his training. Further, it is to be kept in mind that his being caught alive was not part of the plan of the handlers. Further, to say that the confessional statement was intended to confirm the findings of the police c investigation is actually to blame the police for an excellent investigation. If the confessional statement confirms the findings of the investigation that should go to the credit of the investigation, and it cannot be said that the confessional statement was recorded to confirm the police investigation. [para 519] [589-E-G; 590-A-C] 5.5. Finalli, the production of the accused before the magistrate on February 17, 2009, even though he had expressed his willingness to make the confessional statement in early December, 2008, is equally legitimate E and understandable. The police could not afford to lose custody of the appellant at that stage, as it was essential in connection with their investigation, which was still incomplete to a very large extent at that time. Once the appellant was produced for recording of the confession F u/s 164 CrPC, the law ordained the magistrate to send him to judicial custody and not back on police remand. In those circumstances, the police was fully justified in producing the appellant for confession only after completing its own investigation, when it no. longer G needed the appellant in its custody. [para 520] [590-D-F]

5.6. The proof of the voluntariness and the truthfulness of the confessional statement comes directly from the appellant's own statements. On February 18, 2009, when the appellant was brought before the

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 337 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

magistrate, she asked him when he first felt like making A a confession, to which he had replied that the thought of making the confession came to him when he was arrested by the police; he then added that he had absolutely no regret for whatever he had done. At another stage in the proceedings, the magistrate once again B asked why he wished to make the confessional statement, to which he replied that he wanted to set an .example for others to follow and to become Fidayeen like him. It is thus clear that he was not making a confessional statement from any position of weakness or c resignation, or out of remorse. He was a hero in his own eyes, and in those circumstances it is not possible to hold that the confession was not voluntary. It may further be noted that he did not say that the statements made therein were untrue in any manner. [para 521] [590-G-H; 0 591-A-C] 5.7. It needs to be noted that, in the course of the trial, after 58 prosecution witnesses had been examined and the next witness, a Police Sub-Inspector was about to enter the witness box on July 20, 2009, the appellant, after consulting his counsel, said that he was accepting his guilt. The Special Public Prosecutor objected to entertaining any plea of guilty at that stage, on the grounds that the stage of s. 229 CrPC was already over. The court, however, rightly overruling the objection, allowed the appellant to make a statement, which was recorded after giving him due caution. Though structurally and sequentially the statement made in the court is completely different from the confessional statement made before the magistrate, it has broadly the same contents. It is true that in the confessional statement he presents himself as the central figure in almost all the episodes while in the statement before the court he appears to be perceptibly retreating to the background. The lead role and the overt acts are

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A attributed to others rather than to himself. Significantly, however, as regards his joining of Lashkar-e-Toiba, the formation of the conspiracy, the preparation and training for the attack on Mumbai, as well as the identities of the men in the organisation, there is hardly any omission in B the appellant's statement made in the court. Further, in the statement to the court, though there is mention of the hand-prepared maps, there is no mention of their source. There is no reference to accused nos. 2 and 3 as the maker and the deliverer (respectively) of those maps. c [para 522-524] [591-D-H; 592-C-G] 5.8. The trial court, of course, did not accept the statement that was sought to be made as the plea of guilty because it was a very diluted and partial admission of only some of the charges. It, accordingly, proceeded with D the trial. While dealing with the statements made by the appellant, it may also be noted that, finally, in the statement recorded u/s 313 of the CrPC, he denied the entire prosecution case and also retracted his two previous statements. It is evident that by the time the E statement u/s 313 was recorded towards the end of December 2009, the Jihadi sheen had worn off and the desire to live was exerting its pull on the appellant. [para 527 -528] [593-D-F] 5.9. Therefore, the appellant's confessional statement made before the magistrate cannot be eschewed completely from consideration. This Court is clearly of the view that the confessional statement recorded by the magistrate is voluntary and truthful, except insofar as it G relates to the other two accused, namely accused 2 and 3. There was no violation of any Constitutional or legal right of the appellant in the recording of the confession. Therefore, there is no reason for not taking the confession into consideration to judge the charges against the appellant. [para 529 and 532] [594-A-B; 595H B]

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 339 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA SENTENCE:

6.1. There was no lowering of the standard of fairness and reasonableness in the appellant's trial and it, therefore, follows that no mitigation in punishment can be asked for on that score. [para 558] [607-D-E]

6.2. As to the charge of waging war against the Government of India and the appellant being personally responsible for the killing of 7 people, including the navigator of Kuber, those are fully in accord with the findings of this Court, arrived at independently and, C therefore, the High Court was quite justified in taking those facts into account for determining the punishment for the appellant. [para 560] [608-A-B] 6.3. The actions of the appellant and the offences D committed by him must be judged as expressions of his free will, for which he alone is responsible and must face the punishment. It cannot be said that the appellant was a mere tool in the hands of the Lashkar-e-Toiba. He joined the Lashkar-e-Toiba around December 2007 and E continued as its member till the end, despite a number of opportunities to leave it. This shows his clear and unmistakable intention to be a part of the organization and participate in its designs. Even after his arrest he regarded himself as a "watan parast", a patriotic Pakistani at war with this country. Thus, there is no question of F his being brain-washed or acting under remote control or acting like an automaton. During the hearing of the instant appeal, this Court has been able to make a fair assessment of the appellant's personality. It is true that he is not educated but he is a very good and quick G learner, has a tough mind and strong determination. He is also quite clever and shrewd. Unfortunately, he is wholly remorseless and any feeling of pity is unknown to him. He kills without the slightest twinge of conscience. [para 562-563] [609-E-H; 610-A-B]

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

6.4. The saddest and the most disturbing part of the case is that the appellant never showed any remorse for the terrible things he did. The judge trying him had occasion to watch him closely and has repeatedly observed about the lack of any remorse on the part of B the appellant. The High Court, too, has noticed that the appellant never showed any remorse for the large-scale murders committed by him. This forecloses the possibility of any reform or rehabilitation of the appellant. The alternative option of life sentence is thus c unquestionably excluded in the case of the appellant and death remains the only punishment that can be given to him. [para 564] [610-D-G; 611-A-B] 6.5. In Machhi Singh this Court observed that though the "community" revered and protected life because "the D very humanistic edifice is constructed on the foundation of reverence for life principle" it may yet withdraw the protection and demand death penalty. The Court enumerated the kinds of cases in which protection to life may be withdrawn and there may be demand for death E penalty. The instant case would not only satisfy all the conditions laid down in Machhi Singh for imposition of death sentence but also present several other features that could not have been conceived of by the Court in Machhi Singh. Every single reason that this Court might F have assigned for confirming a death sentence in the past is to be found in this case in a more magnified way. [para 567 and 569] [612-B; 614-D-E]

=

Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab 1983 ( 3) SCR 413 G (1983) 3 SCC 470; and Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab 1980) 2 sec 684 - relied on

6.6. In the instant case, the following features are worth noticing:

(i) This case has the element of conspiracy as no

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 341 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

other case. The appellant was part of a conspiracy A hatched across the border to wage war against the Government of India and lethal arms and explosives were collected with the intention of waging war against the Government of India. The conspiracy was to launch a murderous attack on Mumbai B regarding it as the financial centre of the country; to kill as many Indians and foreign nationals as possible; to take Indians and foreign nationals as hostages for using them as bargaining chips in regard to the terrorists' demands; and to try to incite c communal strife and insurgency; all with the intent to weaken the country from within. [para 570) [614F-G] (ii) The case presents the element of previous planning and preparation as no other case. For D execution of the conspiracy, the appellant and the 9 other dead accused, his accomplices, were given rigorous and extensive training as combatants. The planning for the attack was meticulous and greatly detailed. The route from Karachi to Mumbai, the E landing site at Mumbai, the different targets at Mumbai were all predetermined. The nature of the attack by the differeytt teams of terrorists was planned and everyone ,was given clear instructions as to what they 'were supposed to do at their F respective targets. All the terrorists, including the appellant, actually acted according to the previous planning. A channel of communication between the attacking terrorists and their handlers and collaborators from across the border, based on G advanced computer technology and procured through deception, was already arranged and put in place before the attack was launched. [para 571] [614-H; 615-A-D]

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

(iii) This case has the element of waging war against the Government of India and the magnitude of the war is of a degree as in no other case. And the appellant is convicted on the charge, among others, of waging war against the Government of India. [para 572] (614-D-E] (iv) This case has shocked the collective conscience of the Indian people as few other cases have. [para 573] [615-E]

C

(v) The number of persons killed and injured is not only staggeringly high but also as in no other or in extremely few cases. Out of 166 people killed and 238 injured, at least 7 were killed by the appellant personally and 72 were killed by him in furtherance of the common intention he shared with D-A-1 and the rest were victims of conspiracy to which he was a party along with 9 dead accused and 35 other accused who remained to be apprehended. [para 57 4] [615-F-G; 616-A] (vi) The number of policemen and members of security forces killed and injured in course of their duty by the appellant and his accomplice DA-1 and the eight (8) other co-conspirators would hardly find a match in any other cases. [para 575] [616-B] (vii) The offences committed by the appellant show a degree of cruelty, brutality and depravity as in very few other cases. [para 577] [616-E]

(viii) The appellant, as also the other 9 terrorists, his co-conspirators, used highly lethal weapons such as AK-47 rifles, 9 mm pistols, and grenades and ROX bombs. [para 578] (616-F] (ix) The loss of property caused by the attack being

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 343 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA over Rs.150 er. is colossal, again of a scale as in no A other case. [para 576] [616-E] (x) The appellant never showed any repentance or remorse, which is the first sign of any possibility of reform and rehabilitation. [para 580] [617-A]

(xi) This is a case of terrorist attack from across the border. It has a magnitude of unprecedented enormity on all scales. The conspiracy behind the attack was as deep and large as it was vicious. The preparation and training for the execution was as C thorough as the execution was ruthless. In terms of loss of life and property, and more importantly in its traumatizing effect, this case stands alone, or it is at least the very rarest of rare to come before this Court since the birth of the Republic. Therefore, it should D also attract the rarest of rare punishment. [para 581] [617-A-B] 6.7. The only mitigating factor is the appellant's young age, but that is completely offset by the absence of any E remorse on his part, and the resultant finding that in his case there is no possibility of any reformation or rehal:>ilitation. [para 582] [617-D]

=

Mohd. Mannan V. State of Bihar 2011 (5) SCR 518 (2011) 5 SCC 317; Swamy Shraddananda (2) v. State of F Karnataka 2008 (11) SCR 93 (2008) 13 SCC 767; (iii) Santosh Kumar Satishbhushan Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra 2009 (9) SCR 90 (2009) 6 SCC 498; Mohd. Farooq Abdul Gafur v. State of Maharashtra (2009) 11 SCALE 327; Rameshbhai Chandubhai Rathod v. State of G Gujarat (2009) 5 SCC 740; (vi) Rameshbhai Chandubhai (2011) 2 Rathod (2) v. State of Gujarat 2011 (1) SCR 829 SCC 764; (vii) Mui/a and another v. State of Uttar Pradesh 2010 (2) scR 633 (2010) 3 sec 508; (viii) Dilip 'Premnarayan Tiwari v. State of Maharashtra 2009 (16) SCR H

= =

=

=

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

=

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

(2010) 1 SCC 775; (ix) RS Budhwar v U0/ 1996 (2) Suppl. SCR 528 (1996) 9 SCC 502; and (x) State of Maharashtra v. Bharat Chaganlal Raghani 2001 (3) SCR 840 (2001) 9 sec 1 - distinguished

=

=

6.8. Death as a penalty has been held to be constitutionally valid, though it is indeed to be awarded in the "rarest of rare cases when the alternative option (of life sentence) is unquestionably foreclosed". In the facts of the instant case, the death penalty is the only sentence that can be given to the appellant. The C convictions and sentences of the appellant passed by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court are affirmed. [para 585-586] (618-D-F-G] Crl. A.No. 1961 of 2011

7. When the attack on Mumbai took place on 26.11.2008, A-2 and A-3 were in custody of U.P. Police in connection with a terrorist attack on RPF camp at Rampur. The trial court and the High Court have E considered the evidences relating to A-2 and A-3 in far greater detail. Both the courts have analysed the prosecution evidence in regard to the two accused at great length and have given very good reasons to hold the prosecution evidence unworthy of reliance to level such grave charges against the two accused. This Court F is in full agreement with the reasons assigned by the trial court and the High Court and both the courts have rightly acquitted the two accused of all the charges. The view taken by the trial court and the High Court is not only correct but on the facts of the case, that is the only G possible view. [para 593 and 596] [619-H; 620-A; 620-E-

G] MEDIA

8.1. From the transcripts it is evident that the

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

collaborators were watching practically every movement A of the security forces that were trying to tackle the terrorists under relentless gun fire and throwing of grenades from their end. The Court can also take judicial notice of the fact that the terrorists attacks at all the places, in the goriest details, were shown live on the B Indian TV from beginning to end almost non-stop. All the channels were competing with each other in showing the latest developments on a minute to minute basis, including the positions and the movements of the security forces engaged in flushing out the terrorists. The c reckless coverage of the terrorist attack by the channels thus gave rise to a situation where on the one hand the terrorists were completely hidden from the security forces and they had no means to know their exact position or even the kind of firearms and explosives they possessed 0 and on the other hand the positions of the security forces, their weapons and all their operational movements were being watched by the collaborators across the border on TV screens and being communicated to the terrorists.In the instant appeals, it E is not possible to find out whether the security forces actually suffered any casualty or injuries on account of the way their operations were being displayed on the TV screen. But it is beyond doubt that the way their operations were freely shown made the task of the security forces not only exceedingly difficult but also F dangerous and risky. [para 402-404) [534-A-F] 8.2. Any attempt to justify the conduct of the TV channels by. citing the right to freedom of speech and expression would be totally wrong and unacceptable in such a situation. The freedom of expression, like all other freedoms under Art.19, is subject to reasonable restrictions. An action tending to violate another person's right to life guaranteed under Art. 21 or putting the national security in jeopardy can never be justified by taking the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

A plea of freedom of speech and expression. The shots and visuals that were shown live by the TV channels could have also been shown after all the terrorists were neutralized and the security operations were over. [para 405-406] [534-G-H; 535-A] 8.3. It must, therefore, be held that by covering live the terrorists attack on Mumbai in the way it was done, the Indian TV channels were not serving any national interest or social cause. On the contrary they were acting C in their own commercial interests putting the national security in jeopardy. [para 406] [535-B] CRIMINAL TRIAL: 9. In the instant case, the trial Judge is a true flag 0 bearer of the rule of law in this country. The manner in which he conducted the trial proceedings and maintained the record is exemplary. This Court seriously recommends that the trial court records of this case be included in the curriculum of the National Judicial E Authority and the Judicial Authorities of the different States as a model for criminal trial proceedings. [para 603] [622-F-G] Per Chandramauli Kr. Prasad, J. (Concurring)

Hardly one come across a case, where court does not resort to "certain probability" as working substitute for proof beyond all reasonable doubt. However, the instant case is an exception. From the evidence, oral and documentary, it can be said that "absolute certainty" G may not necessarily be a myth or fake in all cases and can be a reality. Certainly, the planning and conspiracy to commit the crime were hatched in Pakistan, the perpetrators of crime were Pakistanis, trained at different centres in that country, and the devastation which took H place at various places in the city of Mumbai, were

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 34 7 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA executed by the appellant in furtherance thereof. [para 45] [650-0-F]

E.L. Dorado theory of "absolute proof" - referred to. Case Law Reference:

2006 (2) SCR 1081

cited

para 409

(2008 (6) SCR 959

cited

para 409

2008 (10) SCR 379

cited

para 409

2008 (16) sec 497

cited

para 409

2009 (8) SCR 591

cited

para 409

2009 (11) SCR 676

cited

para 40

1985 (2) Suppl. SCR 51

cited

para 409

1978 (3) SCR 608

referred to

para 412

384 us 436 (1966)

held inapplicable

para 412

1981 (2) SCR 408

relied on

para 413

2005 (2) Suppl. SCR 79

relied on

para 414

1994 (2) SCR 375

referred to

para 414

1996 (10) Suppl. SCR 284

referred to

para 415

2010 (5) SCR 381

cited

para 415

[1962] 3 SCR 10

cited

para 432

512 us 452 (1993)

cited

para 439

130 S.Ct. 2250 (2010)

cited

para 440

[1992] 177 CLR 292

cited

para 441

[2010] 2 S.C.R.(Canada) 310

cited

para 441

(2009) 49 EHRR 19

cited

para 441

c

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

(2011) UKSC 43

cited

para 441

[2011) UKSC 54

cited

para 441

1992 (3) SCR 247

referred to

para 443

2011 (7) SCR 889

referred to

para 443

1957 SCR 953

referred to

para 452

1952 SCR 284

relied on

para 471

1979 (3) SCR 532

relied on

para 477

1986 (1) SCR 590

relied on

para 487

Criminal Appeal No.284 of 1968 decided on December 17, 1968

cited

para 499

(1969) 1 SCR 32

cited

para 499

1974 (2) SCR 72

cited

para 499

1999 (3) SCR 1

distinguished para 533

2011 (8) SCALE 328

referred to

para 539

1980) 2 sec 684

relied on

para 565

1983 (3) SCR 413

relied on

para 566

2011 (5) SCR 518

distinguished para 583

2008 (11) SCR 93

distinguished para 583

2009 (9) SCR 90

distinguished para 583

(2009) 11 SCALE 327

distinguished para 583

(2009) 5 sec 740

distinguished para 583

2011 (1) SCR 829

distinguished para 583

2010 (2) SCR 633

distinguished para 583

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 349 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 2010 (2) SCR 633

distinguished para 583

2009 (16) SCR 322

distinguished para 583

1996 (2) Suppl. SCR 528

distinguished para 583

2001 (3) SCR 840

distinguished para 583

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos. 1899-1900 of 2011. From the Judgment & Order dated 21.02.2011 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Confirmation Case No. 2 of C 2010 along with Criminal Appeal No. 738 of 2_01 O along with Criminal Appeal No. 606 of 2010 in Session Case No. 175 of 2009.

WITH

Criminal Appeal No. 1961 of 2011. T.P. (Crl.) No. 30 of 2012. Raju Ramachandran, Gopal Subramanium, Gaurav E Agrawal, Rishad A. Chowdhury, Syed Burhanur Rahman, Shankar Narayanan, Syed Mehdi Imam, Ujjawal D. Nikam, Sanjay V. Kharde, Sachin J. Patil, Preshit Surshe, Shankar Chillarge, Devansh Mohata, Anand Varma, Yakshay Chheda, Lakshmeesh Karnath, Nishi! Agrawal, Asha G. Nair, M.S. Khan, B.S. Billowria (for D.K. Garg), Gaurav Bhatia for the appearing F parties. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by AFTAB ALAM, J. 1. The appellant, Mohammed Ajmal G Mohammad Amir Kasab @ Abu Mujahid (hereinafter referred to as. 'the appellant' or as 'Kasab'), who is a Pakistani national, has earned for himself five death penalties and an equal number of life terms in prison for committing multiple crimes of a horrendous kind in this country. Some of the major charges H

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

against him were: conspiracy to wage war against the Government of India; collecting arms with the intention of waging war against the Government of India; waging and abetting the waging of war against the Government of India; commission of terrorist acts; criminal conspiracy to commit murder; criminal conspiracy, common intention and abetment to commit murder; committing murder of a number of persons; attempt to murder with common intention; criminal conspiracy and abetment; abduction for murder; robbery/dacoity with an attempt to cause death or grievous hurt; and causing explosions punishable under the Explosive Substance Act, 1908. He was found guilty of all these charges besides many others and was awarded the death sentence on five counts, life-sentence on five other counts, as well as a number of relatively lighter sentences of imprisonment for the other offences. 2. Apart from the appellant, two other accused, namely Fahim Ansari and Sabauddin Ahamed, both Indian nationals, were also arraigned before the trial court and indicted on the same charges as the appellant. 3. At the end of the trial, however, the appellant was convicted and sentenced to death as noted above (vide judgment and order dated May 3/6, 2010 passed by the Addi. Sessions Judge, Greater Mumbai in Sessions Case No. 175 of 2009). The other two accused were acquitted of all charges. The trial court gave them the benefit of the doubt as regards the charges of conspiracy and abetment of other offences by conspiracy, and further held that the prosecution completely failed to establish those other charges that were made directly against them. 4. The judgment by the trial ~ourt gave rise to a reference to the Bombay High Court under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), registered as Confirmation Case No. 2 of 2010. In addition to the reference, two appeals also

MOHAMMEDAJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB@ABU 351 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] came to the High Court from the judgment and order passed A by the trial court, one by the appellant against his conviction and sentences (Criminal Appeal No. 738 of 2010) and the other by the State of Maharashtra against the acquittal of the other two accused (Criminal Appeal No. 606 of 2010). The High Court, by its judgment and order dated February 21, 2011, confirmed B the death sentences given to the appellant by the trial court and dismissed both the appeals. The High Court upheld the judgment and order passed by the trial court in all material aspects: it sustained the appellant's conviction and confirmed the punishments given him by the trial court, but at the same c time it did not interfere with the acquittal of the other two accused. 5. From the judgment of the High Court two appeals have come to this Court: one is a jail appeal by Kasab and the other is by the State of Maharashtra. The State's appeal seeks to D challenge the acquittal of the other two accused by the trial court and affirmed by the High Court. The other two accused are impleaded in the State's appeal as Respondents No. 1 and 2. Kasab was unrepresented in the appeal preferred by him from jail and this Court, therefore, appointed Mr. Raju E Ramachandran, senior advocate, assisted by Mr. Gaurav Agrawal, to represent him. He was thus able to get legal assistance of a standard and quality that is not available to a majority of Indian nationals approaching this Court against their conviction and sentence. 6. We may also state here that since it is a case of death sentence, we intend to examine the materials on record first hand, in accordance with the time-honoured practice of this Court, and come to our own conclusions on all issues of facts and law, unbound by the findings of the trial court and the High Court. 7. According to the prosecution, a sinister conspiracy was hatched in Pakistan and in furtherance of that conspiracy a savage attack was unleashed on Mumbai by a team of ten

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

terrorists, including Kasab, who landed on the city's shores via the Arabian Sea. The attack began on November 26, 2008 at about 9.15 PM and it ended when the last of the attackers, who was holed up in Hotel Taj Mahal Palace, was killed by Indian security forces at about 9.00 AM on November 29. The brutal B assault left Mumbai scarred and traumatized and the entire country shocked. The terrorists killed one hundred and sixty-six (166) people and injured, often grievously, two hundred and thirty-eight (238) people 1. The loss to property resulting from the terrorist attack was assessed at over Rupees one hundred c and fifty crores (Rs. 150 Cr.). The dead included eighteen (18) policemen and other security personnel and twenty-six (26) foreign nationals. The injured included thirty-seven (37) policemen and other security personnel and twenty-one (21) foreign nationals. Of those dead, at least seven (7) were killed by the appellant personally, seventy-two (72) were killed by him in furtherance of the common intention he shared with one Abu Ismail (deceased accused no.1) and the rest were victims of the conspiracy to which he was a party along with the nine (9) dead accused and thirty-five (35) other accused who remain to be apprehended and brought to court2 • 8. The case of the prosecution is based, of course, on investigations by the police, but a good deal of it also comes from the confessional statement of the appellant recorded under Section 164 of the CrPC. The confession of the appellant may F be broadly divided into two parts, one relating to the conspiracy, planning and preparation for the attack, and the other relating to the actual attack on Mumbai, in execution of the conspiracy of which the appellant along with his "buddia" 3 , the accomplice

1.

A complete list of people killed and injured is appended at the bottom of the Judgment as Schedule No.1, forming part of the Judgment.

2.

A complete list of the accused in three categories, i.e., (i) the three who faced the trial, (ii) the nine who died in course of commission of the crimes and (iii) the thirty five (35) who remain to be apprehended is appended at the bottom of this judg111ent as Schedule No.II, forming part of the judgment.

3. A term used by the appellant; vernacular adaptation of buddy.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 353 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] Abu Ismail, was a part. So far as the attack on Mumbai is A concerned, every statement made by the appellant is corroborated over and over again by objective findings and evidences gathered by the prosecution. But the conspiracy and the preparation for the attack took place in Pakistan and, therefore, it was impossible for any agency of this country to B make investigations in regard to that part of the case. Nevertheless, the investigators have been able to gather extensive material to corroborate even that part of the appellant's confession.

9. It would thus be convenient to present the case of the prosecution by beginning with the appellant's confessional statement.

c

THE RECORDING OF THE CONFESSIONAL STATEMENT:

10. The appellant was brought before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Mumbai, on February 17, 2009, to make his confessional statement. The Chief Metropolitan Magistrate referred him to Mrs. Sawant-Wagule, Addi. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, 3rd Court, Esplanade, Mumbai, before E whom he was presented for recording his confessional statement in CR No. 198/08 of Detection of Crime Branch, Mumbai (one of the twelve (12) cases registered in connection with the offences committed by the invading group of terrorists) at 10.45 AM on the same day. 11. Mrs. Sawant Wagule proceeded to take his statement very slowly and with great circumspection. First of all, she had the appellant completely insulated from the police. She explained to him that from that point he was in her custody and not in the custody of the police. She asked him whether he was ill-treated G or abused by the police in any manner and why he wanted to make the confessional statement. To her first question the appellant replied in the negative, and as for the reasons for him making a confession he said he would explain everything when

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2012] 8 S.C.R.

his statement was recorded in detail. The magistrate further satisfied herself that the appellant was willing to make the confessional statement voluntarily and not under any pressure, coercion or allurement by the police or anyone else. Nonetheless, she did not take his statement on that day but told him that she wanted him to reflect further on the matter, for which purpose she was giving him 24 hours' time. She then remanded him to judicial custody where he was not accessible to the police or any other agency.

12. When the appellant was brought back to her on C February 18 at 11 AM, she had another long exchange with him. In the preliminary exchanges on the previous day she had found that the appellant had no difficulty in following or speaking in Hindi; thus, the interaction between the magistrate and the appellant took place, in question and answer form, in simple, D everyday spoken Hindi. The magistrate, having satisfied herself that the police had no contact with the appellant in the past 24 hours, began by telling the appellant that she had no concern with the offences for which he was arrested or any connection with the police that had arrested him. She explained to him that E he was under no compulsion to make the confessional statement and further, that whether he made the confessional statement or not, he would not be handed back to the police. She confirmed once again that the appellant wished to make the statement of his own volition and not under any influence.

13. The appellant told her his name and gave his address of a place in Pakistan. She asked him about his education and where, when and how he was arrested by the police. She asked him why was he ~rough! to her and in reply he said that he wanted to make a confessional statement. She asked for which G offence he wanted to make confession. He replied that on November 26, 2008, he and his accomplices made a Fidayeen attack on Mumbai city and he wanted to make a confession about the attack and the conspiracy behind it. She asked when he felt like making a confession. He told her that the thought of H making the confession came to him when he was arrested by

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 355 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] the police. He added that he had absolutely no regret for A whatever he had done. He wanted to make the confession to set an example for others to become Fidayeen like him and follow him in his deeds. The magistrate cautioned him by saying that he should make the statement only if he wished to do so. She further cautioned him by saying that any confessional B statement made by him would be taken down in writing and it would be used as evidence against him and that might lead to his conviction. The appellant said he was aware of the consequences. The magistrate again asked him whether the police had given any inducement to him to make the c confessional statement, such as by offering to make him an approver. He replied in the negative. She then asked if he needed an advocate while making the confession. Once again, he answered in the negative. 14. Even after this lengthy and detailed interaction, the D learned magistrate did not take his confession on that day but gave him a period of 48 hours for further reflection, telling him that during that period he would not be in police custody but would be kept in jail in her custody. She advised him to reconsider the matter with a composed mind. She then E remanded him to judicial custody with the direction that he be produced before her on February 20, 2009, at 11 AM. 15. The appellant was produced before the magistrate as directed, on February 20 at 10.40 AM. The magistrate repeated F the entire gamut of explanations and cautions at the end of which the appellant said that he still wanted to make his confession. It was only then did the learned magistrate proceed to record the statement made by the appellant under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The statement could G not be fully recorded on February 20 and it was resumed on February 21 at 10.40 AM. On that date, the recording of the statement was completed. The learned magistrate has maintained a meticulous record of the proceedings before her on all those dates, duly signed by the appellant. After recording H

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

his statement, she also gave such certificates as required under sub-section 4 of Section 164 CrPC. 16. Coming now to the main body of the confessional statement, it is in the form of a statement made by the appellant with only minimal interjections by the learned magistrate. She occasionally asked the appellant to clarify the meaning of some uncommon words or code words used in the conspiracy. The appellant's statement, made before the magistrate over two days, is long and rambling, at points repetitive and full of seemingly superfluous details that would appear quite unnecessary if one is to take a limited view of the case and judge the culpability of the appellant only on the basis of the events in Mumbai. To that end, it would be quite simple and convenient to give a brief summary of the appellant's confessional statement. But such an approach will not do justice to the case and we intend to take a look at the full statement of the appellant with all its repetitions and details. We do so to be fair to both the prosecution and the appellant. The details given by the appellant have a bearing on the prosecution case, according to which conspiracy, conspiracy to wage war against India and waging war against India are some of the main crimes in the case, and the details given by the appellant throw a great deal of light on the commission of those crimes. Further, the details in the appellant's statement are relevant to the submission that the confessional statement is not truly voluntary but that the appellant was manipulated into making that statement. It is submitted on behalf of the appellant that no accused making an admission of his guilt would refer to those unnecessary details and that the great detail of the confessional statement only shows that it was not the appellant but the prosecution that was speaking through his mouth. We, therefore, scan the confession as it is, in full, unabridged and unadorned. THE KASAB NARRATIVE:

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 357 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.]

Family background:

17. The appellant started by giving his name as Mohammed Ajmal Mohammad Amir Kasab. He was born on September 13, 1987. He lived in Pakistan where his address was village Faridkot, tehsil-Dipalpur, district Okara, Punjab province, Pakistan. He attended the Urdu-medium Faridkot Government Primary School up to class 4. He lived in the village with his Abbu Mohammad Amir Shaban Kasab, his Ammi Noor-e-Elahi, younger brother Munir and younger sister Surraiya. He gave his father's mobile phone number. He had an elder sister and an elder brother, both of whom were married. The sister lived with her husband at a village in Pathankot, district Okara, and the brother lived in Lahore with his wife. He gave the names of the spouses of the elder sister and the elder brother and their respective add r,esses. 18. After the immediate family he gave the names of his three paternal uncles, elder to his father, and their sons, who lived in village Mohammad Var Chishti, Pathankot, district Okara, Pakistan. He also named a fourth patern·a1 uncle, " younger to his father, who lived with the appellant's father. •

C

I

'

19. He then gave the names of his Mamoon (mother's brother) and his three sons and a daughter and their address; and the name of his Khaloo (mother's sister's husband), his address and mobile phone number.

20. He gave the name of another sister of his mother whom he called 'Mamo' and her address.

21. He had two paternal aunts who were married. He gave their names 'and their addresses. He said that his Mamoon and Mousi (mother's brother and sister) had grown-up children. 22. Kasab added that his house at Faridkot had been taken by his father who earned his livelihood by plying carts. Kasab was fond of watching TV and Hindi movies; he named a number of popular Indian films that he had seen many times.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

He was in the habit of chewing tobacco. He was good friends with the village doctor, Mazhar, who had a dispensary near Faridkot bus stop.

23. After dropping out of school in the year 2000, Kasab B and his friend Dittu started working as labourers in Faridkot. In 2001, he and his Abbu went to Lahore in search of employment. In Lahore he lived with his father and uncle, Ghulam Rasool, in a house they rented from Haji Qamar. He gave the detailed address of the house. On his father's instructions, Kasab started working as a labourer at "Mazdooron Ka Adda". He C worked there for about five years. In the year 2005, his father and uncle returned to their village. Kasab continued to stay in Lahore alone, living in rented accommodation. During this period he used to visit his village home. On one such visit, he quarreled with his Abbu over the money earned by him. After D the quarrel he left the home and started living at Ali Hajveri Dargah in Lahore. Kasab's friend Shafique got him a job in Welcome Tent Service. He gave the full address of the establishment, the name of its owner and the mobile phone numbers of the owner and his son. He added that the owner of E the establishment used to call him "Balka". It was here that Kasab met and befriended Muzaffar Lal Khan, who also worked there.

Induction into Lashkar-E-Toiba, Indoctrination and F Training for "Jihad": 24. In November 2007, Kasab and Muzaffar Lal Khan went to Rawalpindi in search of better employment and took rented accommodation in Bangash Colony. It was here, around the month of December, that they saw members of Lashkar-e- Toiba G going from door to door under the name of Jamaat-ul-Oava, collecting hides of goats sacrificed on Eid-uz-Zoha. They were asking people to donate the goat hides to help achieve independence for Kashmir. Kasab and his friend developed great respect for those people. They thought that those people H were fighting for the liberation of Kashmir and they, too, should

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 359 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] do something for their people. When they were working at Sarai Alamgir members of Jamat-ul-Dava were organising camps at different places where they would go to listen to their speeches. He explained that after Lashkar-e-Toiba was banned in 2002, it started its activities in the name of Jamatul-Dava. At this time, Kasab and Muzaffar Lal Khan first thought of undergoing training for Jihad. 25. In December 2007, they took the address of the office of Lashkar-e-Toiba from a moulvi and reached its office at Raja Bazar, Rawalpindi. He added that the office was near Bangash Colony. There were two persons in the office who asked them the purpose of their visit. They replied that they wanted to undertake Jihad. The office people took their address in full and asked them to come the following day, with their clothes and other belongings. They returned the following day. On that day, a person in the office gave them a slip of paper with "OauraE-Suffa, Markaz-e-Toiba, Muridke"written on it. He gave them directions for fy'luridke and told them to go there. They left for Muridke and, after traveling by bus for six hours, they reached Muridke bus stand. From there, they walked for about a kilometer and a half to reach the camp site. To the person there, they showed the letter and said that they had come for Daurae-Suffa. After subjecting them to a search, he took them inside the office. There they showed the letter to a person called Fahadullah (wanted accused No. 8). He wrote down their names and addresses and admitted them for the training. 26. Daura-e-Suffa training lasted twenty one (21) days. There were thirty (30) other boys, apart from Kasab and his friend, doing the training. During this, they were first converted from Sunni (sect of Islam) to Ahl-e-Hadis and were given lessons in the Hadis (a study of the things said by the Prophet Muhammad and descriptions of his daily life). An Ustad conducted physical exercises. Besides, they were given lectures and lessons on Jihad. In those sessions Fahadullah and Mufti Sayeed (wanted accused No. 13) were the Ustad. The training took place between December 2007 and January 2008. In the

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A course of the training, Ustad Abu Kata (wanted accused No. 5) introduced them to Hafiz Sayeed, the Ameer of Lashkar-eToiba (wanted accused No. 1), Operational Commander Zakiur-Rehman Lakhvi (wanted accused No. 2), Area Commander Abu Al-Kama (wanted accused No. 4), Muzzamil alias Yusuf B (wanted accused No. 6), Training-in-charge Abu Umar Sayeed (wanted accused No. 18) and Abu Hamza (wanted accused No. 3). Kasab added that Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi was known as 'Chacha' and Lakhvi. At that time Kata told them that Abu Umar Sayeed arranged the training camps of Lashkar-e-Toiba.

c

[At this point the learned magistrate interrupted him to ask the meaning of the word Ameer. He said it meant leader].

27. Kasab said that Ameer Hafiz Sayee<;I exhorted them by saying that all Mujahedeens must fight for the independence D of Kashmir; Zaki-ur-Rehman announced that the time had come for Jihad, adding that their orgainsation had been fighting in Kashmir for the last fifteen (15) years but the Hindustani Government was not allowing Kashmir to be independent. It had, therefore, become necessary to fight a war against E Hindustan to capture Kashmir. Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi asked them if they were ready to wage the war. They all said they were ready for the war. At that time, Abu Al-Kama told them that they had to attack the major cities of Hindustan; that they would wage war against Hindustan from within, so that it is weakened from F the inside. He added that anyone who would die in this war would go to paradise. In response, Kasab and all his associates said that they were ready to launch an attack on Hindustan. 28. In February 2008, they were selected for Daura-eAmma training. Ustad Fahadullah gave them a letter saying G "Bhai Vasool Daura-e-Amma", and sent them to Mansera Markaz Aksa. They traveled for twelve (12) hours by bus to reach Mansera bus-stand from where they had to walk into the hilly region. There, at the entrance to the camp they were subjected to a search. They showed Fahadullah's note to the H person at the gate and were allowed into the office. The person

MOHAMMEDAJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB@ABU 361 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] in the office wrote down detailed information concerning them in a register. After staying there for the day, they were taken to Buttel village in a van. From there the driver of the van led them to the top of the hill on foot - a walk of about thirty (30) minutes.

29. In this second training of twenty-one (21) days they did physical exercises and practiced running and climbing over mountains. They were also given training in dismantling and assembling 'Ka/ashan', rifles and pistols and taught how to fire these weapons.

[Here the magistrate asked him the meaning of 'Kalashan'. He said 'Kalashan' meant AK 47 rifle].

C

The Saving of Muzaffar:

30. During this training, Muzzafar's elder brother came and took him from there.

Further Training:

31. Kasab told the magistrate that after the Daura-e-Amma training a Mujahid could go home if he so wished; alternatively, he could remain for three months of 'Khidmar. [The magistrate asked him what 'Khidmar meant, to which he replied that it meant keeping watch on the new Mujahids who came for training, preparing food for them in the kitchen and generally looking after them]. 32. He said that he remained to do 'Khidmar of the Mujahedeens. The 'Ustad' for the trainees who came there during Kasab's 'Khidmar were Abu Abdul Rehman (wanted accused No. 9), Yusuf (wanted accused No. 15), Abu Anas (wanted accused No. 10) and Abu Bashir (wanted accused No. 11). Kasab did 'Khidmar during March, April and May, 2008. 33. Kasab's 'Ustad', Abu Abdul Rehman, then asked him to go along with the other 'Mujahedeens' to the office of

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

Lashkar-e-Toiba at Model Town, District Okara for 'Daura-e-

Khassa'. As instructed, they went to Mansera bus-stand in the 'Lashkar-e-Toiba' van. After traveling from there by bus for twelve (12) hours they reached Lahore Lorry Adda (bus-stand). From there they went to Okara bus-stand by bus and, after B walking for about one kilometer, they reached the office of 'Lashkar-e-Toiba' near a Masjid at the corner of a lane in Model Town. They told the people there that they had come to obtain the note for 'Daura-e-Khassa'. After making inquiries of them and after making verifications on the telephone, the person present there wrote a letter saying "Bhai Vasool". He stamped this with the flag of the 'Lashkar-e-Toiba' and gave it to them. He also gave them the address of the 'Lashkar-e-Toiba' training camp at Muzzafarabad.

c

34. All of them travelled 16/17 hours in a bus to D Muzzafarabad. Kasab added that Muzzaffarabad is in POK. From there they walked for about an hour and, passing through a 'Lashkar-e-Toiba' hospital called Neelam Dariya, they reached Sevai Nala. At that place there were 10/12 houses and a masjid of Lashkar-e-Toiba and the settlement was called E 'Baitul Mujahedeen'. They gave the Rukka (chit) to a person called Sayeed and entered the training camp, which was also called 'Maskar Aksa'. The camp was situated on Chehalbandi Hills of Muzzaffarabad. There was high security in this training camp and restrictions on moving in or out of the camp without F the permission of the 'Ustad'. Abu Muavia (wanted accused No. 28) was the 'Ustad' of this training, which was conducted in the months of May, June and July, 2008. 35. Kasab told the magistrate that this training was of two G and a half months in course of which they were turned into solid 'Jihacfls'. They were given lessons in Hadis, Namaz and Quran. In addition, they were taught to dismantle and assemble Kalashans and many kinds of rifles and pistols, and to fire from those weapons, to operate rocket launchers and the use of hand grenades. They were also given training in the use of

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 363 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] satellite phones, GPS systems and map-reading. The physical exercise comprised staying without food for 60 hours while climbing mountains with heavy loads on the back. He added that the training was very arduous, so much so that ten (10) Mujahedeens fled the training camp. Abu Muavia and Abu Hanzala (wanted accused No. 31) were the 'Ustad' for this Daura. 36. During that training, a person unknown to Kasab visited the camp. At that time, Ameer Hafiz Sayeed, Zaki-UrRehman Lakhvi and Kata were present there. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed and Zaki-Ur-Rehman Lakhvi embraced the visitor, and 'Ustad' Abu Muavia and Abu Hanzala saluted him in soldier style. Kata introduced him to the trainees as Major General Saab (wanted accused No. 20) adding that the persons who were giving them training were his men. Major General Saab asked them their names and inquired about their training. He asked whether they had any complaints. They all answered that they had none. Major General Saab left after talking to them for about an hour. [At this point, the magistrate asked Kasab for the name of Major General Saab. He said they were not told his name] 37. Kasab said that after completion of the training his 'Ustad' Muavia gave him Rupees one thousand and three hundred (Rs.1,300/-) and asked him to go home and then to Ameer Hafiz Sayeed's office at Baitul Mujahedeen.

C

Preparation for attack on India: 38. Kasab stayed at his village for one week and then, towards the end of July, 2008, he reached the office of Hafiz Mohammad Sayeed at Baitul Mujahedeen. From there 'Ustad' Muavia took him to Selection Point at Sevai Nala, where 20/ 22 Mujahedeens like him were already present. Also present were Ameer Hafiz Mohammad Sayeed, Muzammil, Abu Hamza, 'Ustad' Muavia, Kata and Abu Al-Kama. The

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A Mujahedeens were shown a CD on the laptop demonstrating how Salauddin had made a 'Fidayeen' attack in Kashmir. Thereafter, Abu Al-Kama explained to them in detail how 'Fidayeen' attacks were made in Kashmir.

39. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed selected them and gave them new names. He named Kasab 'Abu Mujahid' and lmran Babar from Multan of Punjab region 'Abu Aqsa'; Nasir of Faisalabad was named 'Abu Umar' and Nazir Ahmed 'Abu Omair'; Hafiz Arshad of Multan Road, Punjab, was called Abdul Rehman C 'Sada' alias Hayaji; Abdul Rehman (Chhota) of Multan Road, Arabwala, was called 'Saqib'; Soheb from Narowala, Shakkar Garh, Punjab, was given the name 'Abu Soheb'. Some other colleagues of Kasab, who came from different places in Pakistan and whose names he did not recall but whom he identified with reference to the places from which they came, D were similarly given pseudonyms by Hafiz Sayeed. 40. On the same day in the evening they were taken to the office of Baitul Mujahedeen.

41. The fifteen (15) selected persons then left for Markaze-Toiba, Muridke, for the Daura-e-Ribat training. In this session, which lasted one month, they were given intelligence training, such as gathering knowledge about the target, keeping watch on him, following him and dodging if someone were to follow them. Kasab described one of these tricks to the magistrate, F telling her that if they suspected that they were being followed, they would switch on the indicator light on the right and then suddenly take a left turn. That is how they would find out if they were being followed. They learnt how to use fake identities while

on a mission. Training in-charge Abu Sayeed gave special G attention to this training. He would frequently come to them and make queries about the training. 42. During the training two of Kasab's colleagues, Nasad and Abu Muavia, left the camp and went away.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 365 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] 43. Abu Kafa and lmran (wanted accused No. 12) were the Ustad of this Dauara. During this training, Major General Saab came there twice. He watched them train and encouraged them. The Daura was completed ih the end of August, 2008. At that time Muzammil alias Yusuf and Abu Al-Kama had also come there. Major Saab asked them if they could swim, to which they answered in the affirmative. Then Major Saab asked Kafa to give them marine training. Kafa said he would do so. 44. A few days later, in September, 2008, Kafa took them to Karachi by train. There they were lodged in a house in Azizabad mohal/a. It was there in the month of September, 2008, that Ramzan started. Kafa took all the thirteen (13) Mujahedeens to the creek from where they all sailed to the sea at Karachi on two small boats. Here, they were put on a boat with an engine attached to it. On that boat a person called Hakim Saab (wanted accused No. 14) gave them three days' marine training. During the marine training they were taught to read and use maps, to fathom the depths of the sea, to use GPS for marine-ways, to cast fishing nets and to sail.

[At this point the magistrate asked Kasab why they were taught to cast fishing nets. He replied that in order to deceive the naval officers of the enemy they would say they were fishermen]. 45. After the marine training, Kafa took them back to Baitul Mujahedeen. There, Ameer Hafiz Sayeed and Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi asked them about the marine training. 46. Three days later, Ameer Hafiz Sayeed and Zaki-urRehman Lakhvi sent six (6) Mujahedeens from among them (whose names Kasab told the magistrate) for a 'Fidayeen' attack in Kashmir. On the following day, Abu Hamza introduced three men to their group: Ismail Khan from Dera Ismail Khan, Punjab, Fahadulla, and Javed from Okara, Punjab. Hafiz Sayeed named them Abu Ismail, Abu Fahadullah and Abu Ali. Abu Hamza told the group that these three were 'Fidayeens'

C

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

like them; they had also taken training like them and they were also going with them to carry out the attack on Hindustan. 47. On the thirteenth (13th) Roza Hafiz Sayeed, Zaki-ur· Rehman Lakhvi, Muzammil alias Yusuf, Al Kama, Abu Hasan, Abu Kafa and Abu Umar Sayeed called them into the office of Baitul Mujahid. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed addressed them there. He said that the time for 'Jihad' had come and they were now required to consider how best to launch the attack on Hindustan. After him Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi spoke and said that the economic strength of Hindustan lay in Bombay and it was therefore necessary to direct the attack on Bombay. He added that they had taken good marine training and hence they would attack Bombay from the sea route. Major General Saab also came to this meeting. He embraced Ameer Hafiz and Zaki-urRehman Lakhvi and they talked to each other at some distance from the rest of the group. After a while they came to the group and Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi said that Major General Saab wanted to see their preparedness. Immediately, each of them was given a 'Kalashan' and a loaded magazine. Major General Saab asked Ameer Hafiz to have the targets fixed at which AmeerHafiz directed Kafa to fix ten (10) targets. Major General Saab said that when he shouted "fire" they should fire a single shot and when he shouted "fire" twice they were to make 'rapid firing'.

48. All of them took position. Major General Saab watched them taking position and then he shouted "fire". Each of them fired a single shot. Except lmran Babar, everyone shot the target. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed rebuked lmran Babar severely. Major General Saab, too, told lmran Babar to practice shooting G properly. Major General Saab then asked everybody to take position. They all resumed position and Major General Saab shouted "fire" twice. All of them emptied their magazines. Major General Saab then walked upto the targets and inspected them closely. He asked who had fired at (target) No.4. Kasab said it was he. Major General Saab complemented him saying that

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 367 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] he had destroyed the target entirely. He told the others that they had to destroy the target fully using minimum bullets and then, pointing at Kasab, he told the others that this is the way firing should be done. He then left and went away.

49. Then Kafa introduced them to a person called Zarar Shah (wanted accused No. 7). Kasab and Ismail asked him about Zarar Shah, at which he told them that Zarar Shah and Ibrahim were the Ameerof the media wing of their organization. Zarar Shah was a computer expert. He could use computer technology to make a call from Pakistan appear, deceptively, as if it was being made from some other country. Zarar Shah and Ibrahim had set up a high technology media room. In this room they had collected maps, CDs and other information concerning the major cities of every country in the world on the basis of which they selected the targets and advised Zaki-urRehman Lakhvi.

C

50. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed and Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi then divided the ten (10) 'Mujahedeens' into five (5) 'buddiyas'. [The magistrate asked what a 'Buddiya' was. Kasab said 'Buddiya' meant a pair].

51. The Buddiyas were: 1. Kasab & Ismail Khan; 2. lmran Babar & Nasir; 3. Soheb & Nazir Ahmed; 4. Hafiz Arshad alias Hayaji & Javed; and 5. Abdul Rehman (Chhota) & Fahadullah. 52. Then, Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi told them that on the twenty-seventh (27th) Roza they were to go and make the "Fidayeen" attack on Bombay. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed said to them that for going from Karachi to Bombay, a Hindustani boat would have to be hijacked and they would go to Bombay by that Hindustani boat. He added that the "maali ha/at" of Hindustan was based on "videshi sai/aniyon". Therefore, in order to weaken the "maali ha/at" of Hindustan it was necessary to attack, among other places, those places frequented by "videshi sai/aniyon ".

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

[At this point the magistrate interrupted to ask the meanings of "maali halal" and "videshi sailani". Kasab translated the two expressions as "money power" and "foreign tourists'].

53. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed told them that they would fire from B "Kalashan" while also throwing hand grenades at VTS, Malabar Hill, Taj Hotel at Colaba, Leopold Hotel, Oberoi Hotel and Nariman House Building where Israelis stayed in Bombay. He added that while firing they should specially target the Americans, the British and the Israelis because those people had greatly oppressed the Muslims. At VTS there would be a C very large crowd and while firing there they should not think of whether their targets were Muslims or Hindus. They should just open 'brush fire' without any thought as to who they targeted. However, while firing at the hotels they should take care that no Muslim was killed in their attack. Then, Zaki-ur-Rehman D Lakhvi asked the two "buddies" who were assigned the attack on the Taj Hotel and the Oberoi Hotel to set the two hotels on fire and to cause damage to them on a large scale. Zaki-urRehman Lakhvi said that before launching the attack they must fix the ROX bombs around their targets. The bomb blasts would E cause traffic jams and slow down the movement of the police coming to the rescue, and would thus make it easier for them to kill the policemen, besides many other people. 54. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed fixed the time for the attacks at F 7.30 PM. When Kasab asked why the attack should take place at that particular time, Hafiz Sayeed explained that this was the time when the targeted places would be most crowded, and insisted that the attack must take place at 7.30 PM. Kafa told them that the ten (10) "Mujahedeens", would be given ID cards G with fake Hindu names and that they would go to Hindustan with those fake ID cards. On the way, they would also tie sacred threads around their wrists like Hindus do. When Ismail asked about the need for ID cards and threads, Kafa replied that with those ID cards nobody could stop them and they would be H easily successful in their mission. And the threads on their

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 369 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] wrists would deceive the police.

55. Continuing his story, Kasab told the magistrate that at that meeting they decided that he and Ismail would begin firing at VTS to make piles of dead bodies. From VTS they would go to Malabar Hill and start firing there. Hafiz Arshad and Javed B would do the firing at Hotel Taj; Fahadullaah and Abdul Rehman (Chhota) at Hotel Oberoi; lmran Babar and Nasir at Nariman House; while Soheb and Nazir would begin firing at Hotel Leopold and then join Hafiz Arshad and Javed at the Taj Hotel. Further, while going to VTS he would plant an ROX bomb under the driver's seat in the taxi; Nazir Ahmed and Javed would C similarly place the bombs in the taxis they would hire to Leopold Hotel and Taj Hotel respectively. The taxis used by them would thus explode at some other place and no one would have any clue regarding how they came and where they came from. The Buddiyas at Nariman House, Oberoi Hotel and Taj Mahal Hotel D would talk to the media and falsely tell them that they had taken some people hostage and (on that strength) would ask the Hindustan Government to allow Kashmir to be free. They would deceive the media into believing that they were Hindustani Muslims in large numbers and would thus generate fear. 56. Ameer Hafiz said Abu Hamza would teach them how to plant ROX bombs and how to cause blasts. 57. Ameer Hafiz Sayeed, Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi, Muzammil alias Yusuf, Abu Al-Kama, Abu Umar Sayeed, Kata, F Abu Hamza and Zarar Shah then took the ten (10) "Mujahedeens" to a big hall. In that hall there were two or three TVs. Zarar Shah told them that this was the control room of the media wing. Zarar Shah showed them the different roads of Bombay and their different targets on a big TV screen. He G showed VTS and Malabar Hill to Kasab and Ismail Khan on a CD. He also gave them detailed information about the roads leading to VTS and Malabar Hill. Kata used Google Earth on a laptop to show them how to go from Badhwar Park in Mumbai

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

to VTS and from VTS to Malabar Hill. Kafa also showed them some maps that were drawn by hand and told them that Fahim Ansari and Sabauddin Ahmed in Hindustan (Accused 2 &3) had prepared those maps and sent them from there. He said that with the help of those maps they would easily reach the places targeted by them. Having told them how the maps were obtained, Kafa explained the maps to them. Kasab asked where Sabauddin and Fahim were. Kafa said both of them were arrested in Hindustan. Kasab asked why they were arrested, to which Kafa replied that they were arrested in connection with an attack made on a police camp at Rampur in India. Then, on the basis of one of the maps, he explained how long it would take them to go from Badhwar Park to VTS and from there to Malabar Hill. Kafa told them that Cooperage Ground and Azad Maidan fall on the way to VTS and told them to mention those places to the taxi driver. Kafa gave similar information to the other "Buddiyas" on the basis of the CD, Google Earth and the maps sent by Sabauddin and Fahim. 58. On the day of the fifteenth (15th) Roza, Abu Hamza and Kafa took the ten (10) Mujahedeens to the hills of Muzaffarabad. There they practiced how to take position and fire with Kalashans. They were also taught how to make the tiffin bomb from ROX, how to fix a blast timer into it and how to set off the bomb. At that time, on the instructions of Ameer Hafiz Sayeed, Abu Hamza and Kafa gave more firing practice to lmran Babar. 59. The same night they returned to Baitul Mujahedeen.

60. On the day of the sixteenth (16th) Roza, Kafa asked them to shave and cut their hair. They were given new clothes, shoes and socks. On Kafa's instruction they cut off the labels of the new clothes. Kafa also gave them watches set to Indian time. On the same day, Kafa had their photographs taken. 61. On the day of the seventeenth (17th) Roza, Kafa took them to Karachi city by train and there they went to a house in

MOHAMMEDAJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 371 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] Azizabad mohalla. Lying in the house was an Urdu magazine called "Taibat" that featured the names of the six (6) "Mujahedeens" who had gone on the Kashmir Mission and been martyred there. Kasab asked Kafa about them. Kafa said that their colleagues had become martyrs in the encounter with the Hindustani army and that Allah would rest their souls in heaven.

62. On the day of the eighteenth (18th) Roza, Kafa brought ten (10) timers and explained to them how to fix a battery in the timer and how to set the time. On Kafa's instructions they C affixed their names on one timer each, after which Kafa took the timers back from them. At that time, according to the plan, Kafa also gave all of them ID cards with their Hindu names. Kasab's ID card showed him as Sameer Choudhary son of Dinesh Choudhary of Arunodaya Degree College, Bangalore. lsmail's ID card described him as Naresh Verma son of Vilas D Verma of Arunodaya Degree College, Hyderabad. All the ID cards were of Arunodaya College. Kasab listed the different fake Hindu names given to the rest of his colleagues. 63. Kafa took them back to the Karachi harbour and they stayed on the sea for one day. On that expedition, Hakim Saab taught them how to dismantle, assemble and run a small inflatable boat. He showed them how to take out the sea valve and sink a boat. He explained to them about "tul" and "chourai".

[Here the magistrate asked him to explain "tul" and "chourai". He explained that "tuls" were the vertical and "chourais" were the horizontal lines on a map]

64. On the twentieth (20th) day of Roza, Lakhvi came there and said that the work had been stopped for some time. At this Kasab said to Lakhvi that there was no need for them to wait. He could make their mission successful, according to the plan, and there was no need for him to worry. Kasab further said that he had longed for it for so many years and asked Lakhvi not to create any obstructions. At this, Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi started

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

laughing and said that he knew from the beginning that he was a firm "Jihadi", but he asked him to wait for some time. The next day Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi left, though the Mujahedeens continued to stay in the Azizabad house. During those days lmran Babar would make them repeat the names on their ID cards. Of them, lmran Babar alone was properly educated and he could, therefore, read and write English. 65. They celebrated 'Ramzan Eid' in the Azizabad house. During this period Abu Hamza taught them how to plant a bomb under the seat in a moving car and gave training to Kasab, Javed and Nazir Ahmed on how to plant a bomb under the (driver's) seat while sitting in the back seat of the car. They were in the Azizabad hous!:l for almost a month and a half. On November 18, Kafa left, taking Nasir and .Nazir Ahmed with him.

Arming for the Invasion:

66. On November 21 they were driven from Azizabad in a car to a house near a creek. Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi, Zarar Shah, Abu Hamza, Kafa, Nasir and Nazir Ahmed were already present there. Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi had made Ismail Khan the 'Amee!' of the mission. In the house near the creek there were a number of boxes containing the 'goods'. Those boxes were opened in their presence and all the 'goods' were handed over to Ismail. The 'goods' were Aslaha, barood (explosives) and eatables. [The magistrate asked what "Aslaha" is. Kasab replied: weapons].

67. Abu Hamza had explained to Ismail how the "Aslaha" and "Barood" were to be distributed. Ismail noted down all the instructions in his diary and took all the articles in his possession. Thereafter Abu Hamza gave Kasab and Ismail Rupees ten thousand and eight hundred (Rs.10800=00) in Indian currency. They divided it between themselves. All the

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 373 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] other 'buddies' were also given Indian money. Then Zarar Shah gave each of them a mobile phone. Ismail asked which place the numbers belonged to. Zarar Shah replied that those numbers were of Hindustan. He added that they had obtained the SIM cards from Hindustan by tricking some people there. He added that the SIM cards would get activated on reaching Bombay. He asked them to use the phones on reaching Bombay. Kasab asked about the numbers on which they could talk to them. Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi said that Zarar had fed their numbers in the mobiles and that on punching the green button twice the phone would be connected to them and they would be able to report to them about the work. 68. He then gave some (telephone) numbers to Ismail and asked him to note down those numbers in his diary. Ismail noted down the numbers in the diary which he always kept with him. Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi also gave the names of some areas of Bombay, like Colaba, WTC etc., which names, too, Ismail noted down in his diary. During the training, Abu Hamza had given them some codes so that no one would suspect while they communicated on the phone. Ismail had those codes and the details of "tul" and "chou rai" also noted in his diary. Thereafter, Zaki-ur-Rehman gave a satellite phone to Ismail and left. 69. Ismail then distributed the weapons and the explosives. He gave a large sack to all the "Mujahedeens". He also gave each of them one (1) 'Kalashan', eight (8) magazines, two hundred and forty (240) rounds, eight (8) hand grenades, one bayonet (Kasab called it "Sangeen'), one (1) pistol with three (3) magazines, twenty-one (21) rounds, one (1) water bottle, one (1) Kg raisins, one (1) headphone and three (3) nine (9) volt batteries along with a charger. He also gave each of them an ROX bomb of eight (8) Kg that was kept in a tiffin box in a small sack. He also gave each 'buddy' a GPS system and a small pouch to everyone to tie around the waist. 70. All of them took th.eir goods and cleaned and serviced

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A the "Kalashan" and the pistol; put thirty (30) rounds in each magazine of their "Ka/ashan" and seven (7) in those of the pistol. As trained, they joined two (2) magazines together with tape so as to easily replace the magazine being emptied while firing from "Kalashan". They then packed all the "aslaha", the B other goods and their new clothes in the large sack. Everyone's sack, containing the bombs and the goods, was kept for the night in the Lashkar-e-Toiba's car. Ismail asked all of them to keep their ID cards with Hindustani names in their pockets, and they did as instructed.

c

71. At night, Abu Hamza and Kata told Ismail to note down the "tul" and "chourai" while on their way to Bombay so that they could reach Bombay with the help of GPS without difficulty. Ismail made the notes in his diary, as instructed by them, in Kasab's presence. The Journey to Mumbai by Sea:

72. On November 22, they woke at six (6) in the morning and offered Namaz. Then they left for Karachi, along with Kata and Abu Hamza, to make the "Fidayeen" attack on Bombay. After walking for about thirty (30) minutes they reached a creek. Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi was present there. He told them that the "Aaqa" (master) Hafiz Sayeed and all of them had worked very hard for that mission. Their efforts must bear fruit. They had been trained fully in every skill. They must not be let down. That was their responsibility. Zaki-ur-Rehman further told them to switch on the mobile phones on reaching Bombay. He said that the "buddiyas" targeting Nariman House, Taj Hotel and Oberoi Hotel would communicate with the media. They (Zaki-urRehman and the other conspirators) would tell them afterwards what to say to them. They (Zaki-ur-Rehman and the other conspirators) would also send e-mail to the media and challenge the Hindustani government. Zaki-ur-Rehman then handed over to each 'buddy' the maps sent by Sabauddin and Fahim. Ismail kept the map that showed the way to reach VTS and Malabar Hill. Zaki-ur-Rehman instructed them to tear up the

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 375 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J] maps after reaching their destinations. Thereafter, Zaki-urRehman prayed for them saying that he put them under the protection of Allah and Allah would protect them. He further prayed that Allah might let them complete the desired work fully. He then gave instruction to Ismail to take out the sea valve before leaving the Hindustani boat s6 that it would sink into the sea. Zaki-ur-Rehman then took Ismail aside and talked to him privately. 73. At around seven (7:00 AM) in the morning a small wooden boat arrived to take them. After sailing in that boat for an hour and a half, they were transferred to a bigger boat and the small boat went back. Hakim Saab and his three colleagues were also there in the big boat. At about 9:00 PM they boarded an even bigger vessel, Al-Hussaini, while Hakim Saab and his three colleagues returned in the second boat. There were seven (7) persons on the Al-Hussaini from before, of whom three were called Murshad (wanted accused No. 16), Aaquib (wanted accused No. 17) and Usman (wanted accused No. 19). They were all members of Lashkar-e-Toiba. Murshad gave them the sacks containing the bombs, and the "Kalashan" that were packed in the Karachi house. Murshad also gave Ismail a rubber speed boat, a pump to fill air in the rubber boat, life jackets, blankets, rice, flour, oil, pickle, milk powder, match boxes, detergent powder, tissue papers, bottles of Mountain Dew cold drink, dental cream, spray paint, towels, shaving kits, tooth brushes, etc.

s

C

They spent that night on Al-Hussaini. 74. [At this point the court time was over but Kasab's statement was incomplete. The magistrate, therefore, sent him back to judicial custody. He was again produced before her on the following day, February 21, 2009, at 10.40 AM. The magistrate once again satisfied herself that he had been insulated from any external influence and would make the statement completely voluntarily. She then resumed taking down his statement].

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

75. Continuing the narrative where he stopped on the previous day, Kasab said that on November 23, at about 12.00 PM they had traveled by Al-Hussaini for about half an hour (sic) when they saw a boat coming towards them. Usman waved a broken engine belt, indicating to the people on that boat that they were in need of help and, on the pretext of seeking their help in changing the broken belt, they approached that boat and captured it. The name of the Hindustani boat was "Kuber". Four persons on that boat were taken hostage by Hakim Saab and Usman and were brought aboard the Al-Hussaini. They also brought from the Kuber TV set and VCR and some other articles lying on it to the Al-Hussaini. Then all ten (10) "Fidayeens" along with all their belongings boarded the Kuber. The "Nakhva" (navigator) of "Kuber" was also put in their custody. Then, on Hakim Saab's instructions, Ismail checked the amount of diesel on Kuber. The "Nakhva" told him that there were seven hundred (700) liters of diesel in its tank and another four (4) drums filled with diesel on board. Ismail asked him whether that would be sufficient to take them to Bombay to which he replied that that may not be sufficient to carry them to Bombay. Hakim Saab told Ismail that there might arise the need for more diesel, and asked his three colleagues to transfer the iron drums and plastic cans filled with diesel from Al-Hussaini to Kuber.

76. Thereafter, according to plan, they sailed for Bombay, F with the help of GPS and the "tu/" and "chourai" that were given to them, and with the assistance of Amarchand Solanki, the Nakhva of Kuber. 77. On Kuber, lmran Babar was assigned the work of G cooking and the other nine (9) men were divided by Ismail in groups of three each for guard duty. Kasab was in the group with Ismail Khan and Nasir. Each group was given guard duty for two hours on rotation basis. Ismail also noted down in his diary the hours assigned to each group, mentioning the members of each group by the names given to them by Hafiz

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 377 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] Sayeed. 78. After sailing tor some distance, they tied :he "Nakhva's" hands, blindfolded him and made him sit near the engine. The three groups guarded the Kuber against any unfriendly intrusion round the clock and they also kept a watch on Amarchand, the "Nakhva". Ismail and Javed were sailing the boat with the help of the "Nakhva". During the voyage they were talking to Abu Hamza on the satellite phone. And Ismail was verifying with the aid of GPS that they were sailing in the right direction. They were also feeding the "Nakhva". They filled diesel in the engine of the Kuber thrice on the journey to Bombay, with help from the "Nakhva". 79. On November 26, at 11.00 AM, according to plan, they tied red-yellow coloured threads around their wrists. Around 4.00 PM on that day they neared Bombay and its tall buildings came within into sight.

C

o

Kasab shames the Butcher: 80. According to plan, Kasab called Abu Hamza on the satellite phone. He told him that they had reached Bombay and asked what was to be done with the "Nakhva". Abu Hamza laughed and said he should do whatever he wanted. Kasab then told Ismail that it would be better to kill the "Nakhva". Ismail agreed with him. Kasab then asked Soheb and Nasir to hold the "Nakhva" by the legs in the engine room. He himself yanked him by the hair and pulling his head down cut his neck. He then hid his body in the engine room. 81. Meanwhile, Ismail, Fahadullah, Jayed and Nazir Ahmed began inflating the rubber speed-boat with the pump. After half an hour, when the boat was filled with air, it was lowered into the sea. They wore the new clothes purchased from the market in Karachi. Kasab put on a red T-shirt and, over it, a blue T-shirt with a cap attached to it and green cargo pants.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012)? S.C.R.

Like him, the others also put on the new clothes purchased from the market in Karachi. They all put on red life jackets and yellow waterproof trousers. They left behind the clothes they had travelled in on the Kuber. Kasab left a white shalwar and a white shirt that he had been wearing earlier. All of them offered B namaz and then, according to plan, they all took out their mobile phones from the bags and switched them on. But there was no network on the sea. They unloaded all the articles for the attack on to the speed- boat. While they were engaged in moving from the Kuber to the speed-boat, they saw a boat approaching. C They thought it was a 'navy' boat. Alarmed, they quickly got into the speed-boat and set sail. In his haste, Ismail forgot to take out the sea valve of the Kuber. He also forgot his satellite phone on the Kuber.

82. They left the Kuber at a distance of about four (4) D nautical miles from Bombay and sailed for Bombay on the speed-boat. Ismail was sailing the speed-boat The speed-boat had the engine of Yamaha Company. Nazir Ahmed, with the aid of GPS, was showing the way to Bombay. On the way, Ismail said that first he and Kasab would leave for VTS by taxi, E then Soheb and Nazir Ahmad would go to Leopold Hotel by taxi, and then Javed and Hafiz Arshad would go to the Taj Hotel by taxi. Im ran Babar and Nasir would walk to Nariman House. Last of all, Fahadullah and Abdul Rehman (Chhota) would go to Oberoi Hotel in the speed-boat. Ismail asked Kasab, Soheb F and Javed to place ROX bombs, according to plan, under their taxi drivers' seats. He told the others to place their bombs near the targets.

83. After sailing for about an hour and a half or two hours they reached the Bombay shore. According to plan, Abu Ali G jumped out and anchored the boat to the shore. First, Ismail and Kasab alighted from the speed-boat. They took their bags. Both Ismail and Kasab removed their life jackets and waterproof trousers and threw them into the sea. After getting

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 379 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] off the boat, Kasab put on his shoes. Following Kasab and A Ismail, the others also got off the speed boat. At that time it was about 9.00 PM and according to the plan they were late by about an hour and a half. 84. On getting down from the boat they came across two persons. They asked them who they were and from where had they come. Kasab told them that they were students. Ismail had an altercation with them. The Attack:

c

85. Ismail and Kasab took their bags and walked up to the road. They took a taxi. Ismail sat in the front and Kasab sat in the back seat. Ismail asked the driver to take them to VTS. He started talking to the driver. Meanwhile Kasab fixed two nine (9) volt batteries to the wire of the. timer in the bomb in the bag. D He placed this bag, containing the bomb, under the driver's seat. He had set the time of explosion for after an hour and fifteen minutes. 86. They reached VTS within fifteen to twenty minutes and were annoyed to find the crowd at the station far less than what E they had seen on the CD. Ismail tried to communicate with Abu Hamza on his mobile but the mobile did not show any network. Ismail then tried to make the call from Kasab's mobile but his mobile, too, did not work. Ismail kept Kasab's mobile with him and both of them entered and came inside the passage. They F saw the stairs going upwards. The people there had come with large bags and from that they gathered that this platform was for long-distance trains. There was a toilet nearby. Kasab gave his bag to Ismail and went to the toilet. When he came back, Ismail went to the toilet carrying the !!mall bag containing the G bomb with him. Inside, according to plan, he fixed the batteries in the bomb and came out with the bag containing the bomb. Ismail put the bag containing the bomb among the passengers' luggage. They then signaled to each other and decided to open fire. Kasab took out the 'Kalashan' from his bag and Ismail took H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

out a hand grenade from his bag. He removed its clip and threw it at the people. At the same time both Kasab and Ismail started firing on the people present there. After a while, Ismail threw another grenade at the people. They continued firing from their 'Kalashans'. As a result of the firing, many people were B killed on the station. The people at the station were frightened and started running in all directions. Within a short time, the entire station was empty. Meanwhile the police had started firing on them. Both of them fired back at the police, giving cover to each other.

c

87. The police continued to fire at them and tried to stop them. Ismail and Kasab shot the policemen dead and came out of VT station through the stairs. (He refers to the footoverbridge on the side of platform No.1 of the local lines). Kasab said that he fired almost six magazines at the station.

88. After coming down from the overbridge they looked for a taxi in the lane (Badruddin Tayabji Marg). But they found none. They tried to open the cars parked in the lane but were unable to open any car. They moved ahead in the lane. They both fired E in that lane. At that time heavy police firing started and they decided to enter the opposite building (which happened to be Gama Hospital), climb to its terrace and kill the policemen by firing and throwing grenades at them from this higher position. 89. They jumped over a closed gate, entered the building F and climbed up its floors. The police followed them into the building. They fired at the police and the people and also threw hand grenades at them. At that time the police was also firing at them. They shot the policemen dead. Then, as the firing stopped, they came down. They were in that building for almost G an hour. Then they came to know that the building was a hospital. They could hear the screams of women and cries of children coming from the rooms of the building. They decided to enter every room of the building and to kill the women and children there. They tried to open the doors of the rooms but H all the doors were closed from inside and the iron-grill doors

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 381 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] outside were also closed. They were unable to open any of the doors. They decided to get out from that building and go to their last target. They came down from the building and moved ahead, taking cover of a wall. After moving ahead, they jumped over lhe wall and came out on the road. 90. They moved ahead on the road, keeping on the right side, taking cover of the wall. They saw a policeman coming. Kasab pointed his 'Kalashan' at him and fired, killing the policeman on the spot. At that time they were fired at from the opposite direction. They fired in retaliation and entered a lane. They saw a white car with a red beacon light in the lane moving backwards. Kasab fired at the car. The car moved for a little distance and stopped. Ismail threw a hand grenade at the car and Kasab again fired at it with a view to make the car move away from there. But when they reached near the car and tried to open its door they found all the window glasses raised and the doors locked and the driver lying dead inside the car. They tried to open the door of the car but were unable to open it. 91. Then they saw a car with a yellow light coming towards them from the opposite direction. Seeing that car, both of them hid in the bushes, taking the cover of the wall behind them. As soon as that car came near them, they fired at it; at the same time shots were fired from the car, hitting Kasab on both his hands. When the firing from the car stopped they looked at the car and found that the persons inside the car were policemen and all of them were dead. They tried to open the car's rear door but it did not open. Kasab was injured and he stood leaning on the vehicle, shaking his hands, while Ismail fired a round of 'brush fire' on the road behind the car. Ismail then went near the car and pulled out the dead bodies of the driver and the policeman sitting behind the driver. Kasab pulled out the dead body of the policeman sitting next to the driver and threw it on the ground. There were no rounds left in lsmail's 'Kalashan' and, therefore, he picked up the policeman's 'Kalashan' from the car. He started the car and drove at full speed. He told

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A Kasab that bullets had hit him on the legs and in the armpits. 92. After some time they reached the chowk and found a large crowd comprising both policemen and the public. Ismail fired at the policemen and the public while continuing to drive B the car. After some time it appeared that the back right tyre of their car was punctured. Ismail was, nevertheless, driving the car at a very high speed. Then, on seeing a white car approaching from the opposite direction, Ismail stopped their car. Kasab fired from his 'Kalashan' in the air and both of them got out of the car. He went towards the white car and, pointing C the 'Kalashan' at the driver, asked him to stop the car. The driver immediately stopped the car. Ismail pulled him out. At the same time the person sitting next to the driver and the woman sitting on the back seat also got out. All this while, Kasab was giving cover to Ismail. Having thus snatched the car, D Ismail sat on the driver's seat and Kasab quickly sat next to him and they left. At this point Kasab asked Ismail where they had to go. Ismail said they had to go to Malabar Hill. Kasab further asked where exactly in Malabar Hill. Ismail said he would tell him on reaching Malabar Hill.

93. After going for some distance, Kasab saw that they were traveling on a road going along the sea and then he realized that this road was shown in the map by Sabauddin and Fahim as going towards Malabar Hill. While they were driving F at full speed, going in the direction of Malabar Hill, they saw the barricade on the road and policemen standing around the barricade. The policemen had seen their car moving at great speed from a long distance and were asking them to stop by raising their hands and blowing their whistles. Realizing that it G was impossible to cross the barricade by smashing against it, Kasab asked Ismail to stop the car at some distance from the barricade and to keep the headlights on so that the policemen would not be able to see either them or the number of their car. Ismail stopped the car at some distance from the barricade and kept the headlights on. The policemen were shouting at them H and were asking them to switch off the headlights.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 383 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] 94. Looking around, Kasab saw that the road divider on A his right was very low and thought they could cross it by driving the car at very high speed. He advised Ismail accordingly. Ismail immediately switched on the water spray on the wind screen and started the wiper. He took the car a little ahead and turned it to the right in the direction of the road divider. He drove at B full speed but the car did not go over the divider and stopped there. At the same time the policemen charged at them from both sides. Realizing the gravity of the situation they both raised their hands. But the policemen kept coming at them. Seeing this Ismail tried to pick up the 'Kalashan' but it was kept below c and he couldn't take it out. He then picked up his pistol, which was kept on the seat, and fired at the policemen. At the same time, Kasab saw a policeman coming towards him; he 6pened the door of the car and got hold of his 'Kalashan'. The police had started firing. A policeman tried to snatch the 'Kalashan' D from him. In the struggle, Kasab fell down but he had his finger on the trigger and he pressed it. The bullets hit a policeman holding a rifle and he collapsed on the ground. The other policemen beat him with lathis and snatched the 'Kalashan' from his hands. Ismail was injured in the police firing and he too was E overpowered. 95. Kasab said that he and Ismail were then brought to the hospital in an ambulance. In the hospital he learnt that Ismail died by police bullets. He gave his and lsmail's names to the police and the doctors and also told them that they were Pakistanis. 96. He concluded his statement before the magistrate by saying that the doctors in the hospital cleaned and bandaged his wounds and got him admitted in the hospital. There the doctors took away his blood-smeared clothes and gave him hospital clothes to wear. When the police asked him about his colleagues and how they reached Bombay he told them everything. 97. This is the appellant's account, as told by him to the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

magistrate. We now propose to take a brief look at the violent crimes committed by the. appellant and his group of terrorists in Mumbai through Indian eyes. And for that we shall follow the bloody trails of the appellant and those of the other members of the terrorist group.

THE LANt>ING:

98. The inflatable rubber dinghy on which the terrorists came to Mumbai landed at a place called Badhwar Park. The dinghy's arrival at that particular place could not possibly be by C accident or by chance. Badhwar Park was evidently selected as the landing site for the terrorists with great care and with consideration of its immense strategic potential for the attack on their chosen targets. It is also clear that the selection of Badhwar Park as their landing place was not made by the D attackers themselves but by someone else among the conspirators. Th& selection of the landing place for the dinghy was clearly based on a good deal of reconnaissance and survey work; and whoever selected the spot for landing had undoubtedly made himself fully familiar not only with the Mumbai E shore line but also the city. 99. Badhwar Park is a settlement of fishermen and at that place the sea comes more deeply into the land mass, forming a kind of a vesicle. Hence, the water is calm and, this being a fishermen's colony, a group of young people arriving from the F sea is not likely to arouse any suspicion or even attract much attention. Further, the place abutts a main road. A sandy slope from the water, not more than ten (10) metres in length, takes one to the road where taxis are readily available. The CST railway station is at distance of 3.5 kms from Badhwar Park G and by a taxi it takes fifteen to twenty (15-20) minutes to reach there. The Taj Hotel is at distance of 1 km and Leopold Cafe nine hundred (900) metres. Nariman House, to which the two (2) terrorist went walking, is at a distance of 0.5 km. Nariman Point, where the last pair took the dinghy by sea after the other

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 385 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] eight had alighted at Badhwar Park, is 0.55 nautical miles (1 A km) from there; and from the point where the last pair got off the dinghy, Oberoi Hotel and Trident Hotel are at a distance of three hundred (300) metres. The last pair walked to these ; hotels. 100. Kasab had said to the magistrate that on getting down from the boat they had come across two persons. They had enquired about them and even while Abu Ismail tried to rebuff them Kasab told them that they were students. One of these two men that Kasab met was Bharat Dattatray Tamore (PW-28). He lived in the Fisherman Colony, Cuffe Parade. He C was a permanent employee of Hotel Taj Mahal, Colaba, where he worked as Mukhadam. He lived in Chawl no.2 which was situated very close to the sea shore at about fifteen (15) minutes walking distance from the Taj Hotel. He deposed before the court that since his Chawl was very close to the shore, for going D anywhere he had to go along the shore quite close to the water. On November 26, 2008, he left his house at about 9.15 PM for the hotel, where his duties commenced at 10.00 PM and ended the following morning at 7.00 AM. On the way to the hotel he saw an inflatable boat on the shore. In the boat there were ten E (10) people who were in the age group of twenty to twenty five (20-25) years. He saw eight out of them alighting from the boat. Each of them was carrying a sack and a hand-bag. Two of them proceeded towards the main road ahead of the others. They appeared strangers to the place and he asked them where F they came from. One of them said they were students while the other responded by roughly asking in reply as to how he was concerned about them. He added that the two persons who had not alighted took the boat towards Nariman Point. He returned to his home next morning at about seven (7:00 AM). On way G he came across four (4) policemen near the Badhwar Park Railway Officers' Colony who were talking about the inflatable boat. He then told them what he had witnessed the previous evening. He later identified the appellant in the test identification parade held on December 28, 2008. He also identified the H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

dead body of the other person at the mortuary of J.J. Hospital. He also identified the appellant while deposing in court, as one of the persons who had alighted from the boat. 101. There is another person called Prashant Hemnath Dhanu (PW-29) who lived in the fishermen's colony. He was

twenty-four (24) years old and a fisherman by profession. He stated before the court that he had a fishing boat and on November 26, 2008, at about 9.15 PM he, along with a few relatives, had gone out to sea on his boat to fish. On nearing Nariman Point around 9.45 PM they saw a seemingly C abandoned rubber boat. There were some life jackets in the boat and it was fitted with a Yamaha engine. Buffeted by the sea waves, it was bouncing against the tetrapod. Lest the owner of the boat might suffer its loss they towed it to their fishing trawler and brought it to the jetty near the fishermen's colony at D Badhwar Park (that is, to the point where it had first landed!). He informed the coast guard about the abandoned boat found by him. He further said that the police had arrived there and they took charge of the boat under a Panchnama. We shall deal with the seizure of the boat by the police and the articles found E in it in due course. Suffice here to note that the rubber boat (Article 156) was shown to the witness in court and he duly identified it as the one that he had found abandoned at Nariman Point and had towed back to the Fishermen's Colony, Badhwar Park. He also indicated the yellow strip of paint on the black F body of the boat, on the basis of which he was able to identify it. 102. From Badhwar Park the appellant, Kasab, and his accomplice, Abu Ismail, took a taxi and proceeded to CST. G Kasab told the magistrate that he occupied the back seat of the taxi and, on the way to CST, had put the ROX bomb under the driver's seat, setting the time of blast for after an hour and fifteen minutes. We shall see the fate of the taxi, its driver and the passenger, who occupied it after Kasab and Abu Ismail,. H presently under the marginal heading "The Vile Parle Blast".

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 387 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.]

But, for the present, the appellant and his 'buddy' are on a spree of mass killings at CST.

Slaughter at CST: Fifty two (52) dead and One hundred and nine (109) injured:

103. In regard to the CST episode, like all other parts of the case, the prosecution has gathered a very large amount of evidence: ocular, forensic and of other kinds, e.g., CCTV recordings 4 • They have documented practically every action and movement of the two killers from the point when Abu Ismail threw the first hand grenade5 at the passengers on the platform till they went out of CST through the foot-overbridge on the side of platform no.1 of the local lines (and thereafter. ... ). On the basis of the ocular evidence alone (not taking into account for the moment the other evidences) the prosecution has presented before the court a vivid and photogrc;phic (figuratively and actually) account of the CST events. Here we propose to examine in slightly greater detail four witnesses whose evidence, in one way or another, has some special features, and then to take an overview of some more witnesses to

c

4.

5.

To reconstruct the events at the CST the prosecution has examined fiftythree (53) witnesses. Leaving aside the forensic experts and other witnesses of a formal nature such as panch witness, the number of eyewitnesses who gave ocular accounts of the events is not less than twentyfive (25). Out of these, ten (10) are policemen and members of Railway Protection Force (RPF) and Home Guard; among them three (3) are injured witnesses. Of the remaining fifteen(15), nine (9) are passengers, of whom eight (8) are injured witnesses. Of the remaining six (6), four (4) are railway employees, of whom two (2) are injured. The remaining two (2) are photographers from the Times of India, one of the prime English dailies of the Country. According to the appellant's confessional statement before the magistrate, before lobbing the hand grand at the crowd of passengers, Abu Ismail had placed the bag containing the ROX bomb, with the timer set for blast, among the passengers' luggage. Fortunately, however, the bomb failed to explode. The bomb along with the bag was later seized after it was diffused by the bomb disposal squad, but that forms part of the forensic evidence to which we will advert in due course.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A construct a broad picture ot tne massacre at CST. 104. Before proceeding to examine the witnesses it may be appropriate to say a word about the way most of the witnesses identified the appellant. The appellant, Kasab, and his accomplice, Abu Ismail, seemed to make an odd pair in that Abu Ismail was quite tall, about six (6) feet in height, and Kasab is barely over five (5) feet. The difference in their height appears to have struck almost anyone who saw them together. Although different witnesses described them by their complexion C (both Abu Ismail and Kasab are described as fair), age (Abu Ismail is said to be between 22 and 25 years and Kasab between 22 and 24 years), built of body (Abu Ismail as medium built, Kasab as strongly built), their apparel and the bags they were carrying, almost everyone referred to their heights, calling Abu Ismail as "the taller" and Kasab as "the shorter'' one. Many D witnesses called them "lamboo" (tall) and "butka" or "tingu" (short). 105. Now the witnesses:

Bharat Ramchandra Bhosale (PW-49) is the Informant in E connection with the offences committed at CST. At the time of the assault on CST he was an Assistant Inspector of Police attached to the CST Railway Police Station. The police station is situated within the premises of CST in the passage between the main hall of local lines and the main hall of main lines. On F the night of November 26 and 27, he was on duty at the police station and he reported for duty at 20.30 hours. At about 21.50 hours, while he was coming out of the PS, he heard the sound of firing from the main hall of the main line railway station. The main hall is at a distance of about fifty to sixty (50 - 60) feet G from the PS. He proceeded to the main hall from the side of the taxi stand (north). Police Inspector Shashank Shinde (one of the policemen killed in the attack), who was also on duty at that time, proceeded to the hall from the side of the SBI ATM (south). On coming to the main hall he saw the two terrorists H indiscriminately firing from AK-47 rifles at the passengers sitting

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 389 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J ] in the main hall. Many people were lying injured in pools of blood; many of them were crying. Those who were still on their legs were trying to flee the main hall. Bhosale said that he first saw the two terrorists when they were firing from a spot near the public toilet. He described the location of the public toilet and went on to say that when he first saw the two terrorists they were in the main hall at a distance of about forty (40) feet. There was sufficient light in the main hall for him to see them. 106. Bhosa/e then proceeded to give a description of the two terrorists. He said that one of them was short, aged about twenty-two to twenty-four (22-24) years with long hair that came down to his neck; he had a fair complexion and was strongly built. He was wearing a blue T-shirt and was carrying a rexine bag. He was holding an AK-47 rifle. The other terrorist was taller than the first one. He was also fair and of medium built. He was aged about twenty-two t<? twenty-five (22-25) years. He was wearing a black T-shirt and he too was carrying a rexine bag. He was also carrying an AK-47 rifle. 107. At this point, the witness paused in his narration to identify the appellant as one of the two terrorists who was described by him as short, strong built and who was wearing a blue T-shirt. 108. The witness was then shown the identity card recovered from Abu Ismail (Article 61 )6 • He identified the photograph as that of the other terrorist, the accomplice of the appellant. 109. The witness proceeded with his narration and said that he rushed back to the police station to ask for additional force. As he came near the entrance door of the police station he was fired at by the terrorists. One of the bullets pierced through his right upper arm and struck the wall near the table 6.

The fake identity card with Hindu name given to each member of the group of terrrorists by Abu Kala before leaving for Mumbai.

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

of the police station's House Officer. He intimated the railway police helpline about the assault by the terrorists and asked for additional force 7 . He also intimated the Commissioner of Police, Railways, on his walkie-talkie.

110. He then came back to the main hall accompanied by Police Constable Nalawade who had a carbine with him. He saw Police Inspector Shinde lying injured near the SBI, ATM. Also lying injured in the main hall were about one hundred to one hundred and twenty-five (100-125) passengers.

C

111. By the time he came back to the main hall of the main lines, the two terrorists had moved in the direction of the main hall of the local railway station. Constable Nalawade fired three rounds towards them from his carbine. Constable Nardele (PW-58) also fired eight rounds at them from the main hall of D the main lines while the terrorists were in the main hall of the local lines. The appellant and his associate were, however, not hit and they continued to proceed towards platform No. 1 of the local lines. By then, the additional police force had come and the public had also come to their help. The injured persons were E being taken to hospitals. The witness himself was admitted to St. George's Hospital for treatment of the firearm injury in his right upper arm.

112. He later came to learn that Police Inspector Shinde and MN Chaudhary of the RPF were also among those who were killed as a result of the firing by the two terrorists. He also learnt that the appellant and his associate had also used handgrenades at the railway station.

113. His statement was recorded at the hospital and on G that basis a formal FIR was drawn up in regard to the CST episode. He identified his statement (Ext. no. 219) and the formal FIR (Ext. no. 220). 114. He further told the court that he had earlier identified H 7. Independently established through mobile phone call records.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 391 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] the appellant in the test identification parade held at Arthur Road Prison on December 28, 2008. 115. In reply to a court question, Bhosa/e said that though he was carrying a 9mm pistol, loaded with nine rounds, he did not fire at the terrorists because there was a strong risk of the passengers getting killed or injured by his firing. 116. Vishnu Dattaram Zende (PW-65) is the railway announcer. His job is to make announcements of the arrival and departure of trains on a public address system. For that purpose he sits with his colleagues in a cabin on the mezzanine floor, almost at the centre of the main hall of the local lines, facing the full expanse of the main hall and beyond it up to platforms 1 to 7 of the local lines. Perched in his office Zende had a completely unobstructed view through the glass screen of his cabin and he was able to see all that happening down below in the main hall and the local lines' platforms on the fateful evening of November 26, 2008. Here it must also be noted that showing great devotion to duty and remarkable presence of mind Zende saved countless people from death or injury by constantly announcing on the public address system that the railway station was under terrorist assault and by advising passengers alighting from local trains that continued to arrive at the station while the attack was underway to not go towards the main hall but to exit through the rear side of the local lines' platforms. 117. Deposing before the court, he began with a succinct description of CST from inside. He then proceeded to tell the court that on November 26, 2008, he was on duty from 3.00 PM to 11.00 PM. At about 9.55 PM he heard a big explosion. He guessed that it was a bomb and looked outside the window of his cabin. He saw passengers from the main line hall running towards the local lines. Among them some were bleeding. Some were trying to rescue others who were unable to flee or move on account of injuries.

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

118. He further stated before the court that he saw two terrorists coming from the direction of platform no. 7. He could see one. of them from a distance of 15 to 20 feet as he came near the entry gate of platform no. 4. The other was following him. Both were firing. At that point he suspended his B announcements because the terrorists, from where they were at that time, could see him and fire at him. He then saw the shorter of the two terrorists sit down on the floor of the main hall, load his gun with a magazine, throw his bag in the hall and resume firing.

c

119. Zende added that, to avoid being shot at by the terrorists, he and his colleagues sat down on the floor of their cabin. Nonetheless, shots were fired in the direction of their cabin and one of the bullets smashed the glass pane and went right through, piercing the plywood partition at the back of the D cabin. They continued sitting on the floor for about an hour and a half. All the while they were in contact with their officers on the telephone.

120. He then gave a description of the two terrorists and E identified Kasab as the person who loaded his rifle sitting down on the floor of the main hall and who threw away his bag. He was then shown the identity card, Article 61. He identified the photograph as that of the taller terrorist who was accompanying the appellant. He was shown a black haversack, Article 219. F He identified it as the bag that the appellant had thrown away in the main hall of the local lines. 121. While dealing with the CST episode we must take note of two other witnesses. Their evidence is extraordinary in that they did not only witness the incidents but also made a G visual record of the events by taking pictures of the two killers in action and also of their victims. The pictures taken by these two witnesses, without anything else, are sufficient to conclude the issue of identification of Kasab and Abu Ismail (deceased accused no.1) as the killers of CST. Both the witnesses are H professional photographers working with the Times of India

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 393 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] group. Both of them, caring little for their own safety and A displaying exemplary professionalism, followed the killers practically at their heels. Their ocular testimony together with the photographs taken by them provides a graphic picture of the carnage at CST. 122. Sabastian Barna/ D'Souza (PW-61) is one of the two photographer witnesses. He stated before the court that on the evening of November 26, 2008, he was in his office on the fourth floor of the Times of India Building, which stands opposite the CST railway station. The main gate of the Times of India Building faces platform no.1 of the local railway station and one gate of CST railway station opens in front of the Times of India Building. At about 9.50 PM he came to know from one of his colleagues that a gunman had entered Taj Hotel and was firing there randomly. On this information, two photographers immediately proceeded to the Taj Hotel. D'Souza and his colleague also came out of the office. As they came out of the main gate of the building, they heard the sound of firing at CST railway station. D'Souza jumped over the road divider and entered platform no.1 of the local railway station, carrying a Nikon digital camera. The railway station was deserted and there were no passengers on the platforms. A local train was standing on platform no.1. He crossed through the train and reached platform no.2. There were no trains on platforms no. 2 and 3. He proceeded to the main hall of the local railway station and walked up to the exit of platform no.6 in the main hall. There he found one policeman in uniform and another person accompanying him in plain clothes. They were looking towards the passage between the main line and the local line. It was at this point that he saw, at a distance of about one hundred (100) feet, in the passage between the main lines and the local lines, two persons who were firing from guns held by them. They were near the booking window of local railway line in front of CST police station while he himself was at the exit of platform no.6 of the local line. At this juncture, one of the policemen 8 fired at 8.

As we shall see presently this was Assistant Sub-Inspector Sudama Aba Pandarkar (PW-62)

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

the two gunmen. 123. At a nearby book-stall, the owner started to pull down the shutter and, as he was doing so, he was hit by a bullet and fell down. D'Souza took a picture of the fallen book-stall owner.

124. D'Souza then described the two gunmen and the way they were dressed. He identified the appellant in the dock as the shorter of the two gunmen. He added that both were carrying guns.

c

125. He further said to the court that he wanted to take photographs of the gunmen and, therefore, he entered one of the compartments of the train standing on platform no.6. The policeman in uniform and the other person accompanying him in plain clothes were still there. He thought the man in plain clothes was also a policeman. He saw the plainclothesman 9 taking the gun from the policeman in uniform and taking position to fire at the appellant and his companion. He took pictures of the policeman in uniform and the plainclothesman. He asked the two policemen to enter the train compartment because he thought they had taken a position that was quite dangerous.

126. He further said that since the gunmen were coming towards the local lines, he went to platform no.4. He told the court that during the course of the incident he took over one hundred (100) photographs but most of them were blurred. He was not using the flash-gun and the light was not good for taking photographs. In course of the deposition he was shown the photographs taken by him and he identified those photographs.

127. The photograph showing the book-stall owner felled G by a bullet was marked Ext. no. 238. A set of three photographs showing the policeman in uniform and the plainclothesman taking aim with the rifle was marked collectively as Ext. no. 239. A set of three photographs of the appellant taken by D'Souza 9.

As well shall see presently this was Police Constable Ambadas Pawar (one of the policemen failing down to the terrorists bullets).

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 395 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] from behind a pillar was collectively marked Ext. no. 240 10 • A set of four photographs in which Kasab is shown with the other gunman Abu Ismail (deceased accused no.1) was marked collectively as Ext. no. 241. A photograph showing two persons lying dead or injured was marked Ext. no. 242 11 . A set of 10 photographs taken by him after the gunmen had gone over to platform no.1 of the local lines, showing dead or wounded passengers lying in the main hall of the main lines, was collectively marked as Ext. no. 243. 128. He told the court that pictures taken by him were saved in the memory card of his camera. He had prepared a CD of the photographs from the memory card, to produce in court. The print-outs were taken from the CD. He produced the memory card before the court (which the court, after it was marked as Article 216, directed to be returned to the witness for safe custody until further orders).

C

129. He said that the CD was produced by him before the police on January 7, 2009, in presence of panch witnesses and then it was sealed. The CD was taken out of a sealed packet (bearing no. 204) and was marked by the court as Article 217.

130. Significantly, he also said before the court that while at the station he heard the announcement on the public address system warning passengers of incoming local trains not to alight from the train and, in case they had to go out, not to come to the main hall but to exit through the rear gate.

10. All the three pictures clearly show Kasab, carrying a haversack on his back and an AK-47 in his hands. In the first picture he is shown moving forward, with the left hand raised and the right had holding the Ak-47 with the barrel pointing downwards. In the second picture he is raising the gun with the right hand and the left hand in coming down towards the gun for providing support. In the third picture he is stepping forward with both hands holding AK-47 at waist level in firing position. 11. As we shall see presently these two were Police Inspector Shashank Shinde and Police Constable Ambadas Pawar (who fell down to the terrorists' bullets).

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

131. Sriram Ramakant Vernekar (PW-102), the other photographer witness, works as a press photographer with the Times of India. He stated before the court that on November 26, 2008, he-was in the office at the Times of India Building, opposite CST railway station. At about 10.00 PM, on hearing B the sound of firing, he picked up his camera and rushed towards CST station. He approached the station from the subway gate. He saw two persons firing in the directions of the railway office and booking office. He took pictures of the two gunmen from near the entrance to the main hall from the subway porch. As c they were moving in his direction, he got out of the station and, crossing the road divider, came on the side of the Times of India Building. 132. He told the court that he had seen the two gunmen in front of platform no.6 when he took their first photograph. He D produced before the court four enlarged print-outs of the photographs taken by him which were collectively marked, for the purpose of identification only, as Ext. no. 410. 133. He also produced the original memory card of his E Nikon 0200 camera containing more than ten (10) pictures taken by him with that camera. The memory card was marked, for the purpose of identification, as Ext. no. 411. The witness explained that the three photographs bearing Ext. no. 410-A. Ext. no. 410-B and Ext. no. 41 O-C 12 were the first photographs F of the two gunmen taken by him. He further stated before the court that one of them lobbed a hand grenade while they were proceeding irom the main hall

12. Ext. nos. 410-A, 410-B and 410-C are pictures taken when Kasab and Abu Ismail were at CST. All the three pictures appear to be taken from the front. In the picutres they appear behind what appears to be the frames of a set of two metal detectors. In Ext. No. 410-A Kasab and Abu Ismail are standing about three ft. apart peering ahead; in Ext. No. 410-B they appear standing close together in the frame of the metal detector looking ahead. In Ext. No. 410-A. C Abu Ismail is hidden behind a pillar but Kasab is clearly shown carrying a haversack on his back and an AK-47 in both hands.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 397 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] to platform no.1. The hand grenade was thrown on ON Road A in front of MCGM building. He went on to say that he saw the two gunmen going from platform no.1 to the foot-overbridge. Both of them were carrying bags on their shoulders. He was in front of the Times of India Building at that time. Both of them were firing towards the Times of India Building from the foot- B overbridge. They were Jobbing hand grenades also. He wanted to take their photographs and, therefore, he went to the second floor of the Times of India Building from where the foot-over bridge is clearly visible. He took about three to four (3-4) photographs from there. Since the quality of photographs was not satisfactory, he took another photograph by using flash. As a result, the shorter man, who was moving in front, got alerted and he fired three to four (3-4) rounds at the Times of India Building. The witness identified the fourth photograph (Ext. no. 410-0 13 ) as the photograph taken by him by using flash. He further said that the photograph was taken when the shorter fellow was getting down from the overbridge towards Badruddin Tayabji Road.

c

134. Vernekar then identified the appellant as "the shorter fellow". He also identified the appellant's partner from the photograph in the Identity Card Article 61. 135. Among the rest of the CST witnesses we shall take a brief look first at some of the policemen and then at some of the passenger witnesses. 136. Jilu Baddu Yadav (PW-54 ), Mammath Motiral Nardele (PW-58), Harshad Punju Patil (PW-59), Geetanjali Krishnarao Gurav (PW-60), Sudama Aba Pandarkar (PW-62), Pandurang Subrao Patil (PW-63) and Sandeep Tanaji Khiratkar (PW-66) are policemen or members of the Railway Protection Force. At the time of occurrence, they were on duty 13. Ext. no. 410-D clearly shows Kasab coming down from the foot-over-bridge The picture was taken with a flash and, therefore, it shows Kasab both startled and angry with the haversack hanging from the shoulde and the AK-47 held in both hands read" io fire.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

at different places in the vast premises of CST. On hearing the explosion and the gun shots and on seeing the passengers fleeing for their lives, they realized that a terrorist attack was underway at the railway station and proceeded from their respective stations towards the spot where the assault was B launched. On the way, some of them came across each other. A few were lucky to escape unharmed and some survived even after receiving grave injuries to tell the story before the court; some others laid down their lives while trying to tackle the assailants either completely unarmed or carrying antiquated c weapons that failed them at the most crucial moment.

137. Harshad Punju Patil (PW-59) was a police constable and on that date he was on patrolling duty in the ladies' compartment in the local trains. He was carrying a .303 rifle and ten (10) rounds. When the terrorists' attack took place, he was waiting for the train on which he was on duty near the Police Help Center in the main hall of the local lines, in front of platform no.3. Soon after the firing started, Police Inspector Shashank Shinde of the CST Railway Police Station came there and told them that two terrorists were firing in the main hall of the main station. Police constables Nardele and Gavit were also there. Both of them were carrying carbines. Shashank Shinde proceeded towards the main line station accompanied by Nardele and Gavit. Patil started loading the ten (10) rounds in his rifle. He then saw the two terrorists coming towards the local railway station from the main lines' side. Taking cover of the Police Help Centre he fired one round at them. But the shot misfired because the cartridge was defective; the bolt was jammed and he was unable to open it. By that time, the terrorists had come in front of platform no.3 of the local lines. At that point, Jil/u Baddu Yadav (PW-54), a head constable of the RPF, also arrived there, proceeding from his place of duty at the General Manager Gate of the CST Railway Station. He himself was unarmed but he saw Patil carrying a rifle with him. He saw one of the assailants sitting down on the floor of the main hall of the local station and loading his rifle with a

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 399 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] magazine. Yadav asked Patil to fire at the terrorist. He did not know that Patif's rifle bolt had jammed and it would not open. Thinking that Patil was trying to avoid firing at the terrorist, Yadav took the rifle from him and tried to fire at the terrorist who was sitting down on the station floor, loading the magazine into the rifle, but the rifle did not fire as it had locked. Meanwhile, the other terrorist also arrived at the spot and they fired in the direction of Yadav and Patil. He and Patil then took cover behind a pillar from where he threw one plastic chair towards the two terrorists. In retaliation they again fired back towards them while proceeding in the direction of platform no.1 of the local railway station. 138. Patil identified the appellant as the one whom he had described as the shorter of the two terrorists. He identified Abu Ismail (deceased accused no. 1) from his photograph on the fake identity card, Article 61. He said before the court that he had earlier identified the appellant in the test identification parade held on January 14, 2009, at Arthur Road Prison. Yadav identified the appellant as the person who was firing at him from his AK-47 rifle and at whom he had thrown the plastic chair. Yadav also identified Abu Ismail from Article 61. 139. Mammath Motiral Nardele (PW-58) was a police constable and on that date he was on anti-sabotage duty on the foot-overbridge at platform no.1, opposite the Times of India building. He was carrying a carbine with ten (10) rounds. At about 9.45 PM, leaving his two other colleagues on duty, he came to take his meal at the Police Help Centre situated in front of platform no.3 of the local railway station. No sooner had he reached there that he heard the noise of a bomb explosion and gun shots from the direction of the main hall of the main lines and saw passengers running away from there. Shashank Shinde came there and alerted him saying that terrorists were firing in the main hall of the main line. Shinde asked Nardele to accompany him. Nardele started loading the ten (10) rounds in his carbine but Shinde proceeded towards the main line

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

without waiting for him. Nardele saw Shinde proceeding in the direction of the main hall of the main line accompanied by ASI Pandarkar14 , a police constable 15 and a photographer16 • He went after them and heard the sound of firing on platform no. 7. He entered a compartment of a local train on platform no.6 and 8 from there he saw two terrorists, each carrying an AK-47 rifle and a hand-bag on their shoulders, proceeding towards the local railway station. He fired eight (8) rounds from his carbine (but the shots did not hit them). They retaliated but he was safe inside the rail compartment. He again tried to fire, but in the C meanwhile his carbine was locked. He could not fire from it any longer. He then went to the armory, got his carbine unlocked and loaded it with more rounds. But by the time he came back to the main hall of the local lines, the terrorists had already left the local railway station.

140. Nardele identified the appellant in court as the shorter of the two terrorists. He also identified the clothes worn by the two assailants. He also identified Abu Ismail (deceased accused no.1) from Article 61. He further told the court that he had earlier identified the appellant in the test identification E parade held on December 28, 2008, at Arthur Road Prison, Mumbai. He had also identified the dead body of the deceased accused no.1 at the mortuary of JJ Hospital on January 6, 2009.

141. Sudama Aba Pandarkar (PW-62) was an Assistant F Sub-Inspector of police and on November 26, 2008, he was on patrolling duty on the local trains. He was carrying a .303 rifle and ten (10) rounds. The train on which he was on duty arrived at CST on platforms no. 4 or 5 at 9.45 PM. He went to the Police Help Center and made the entry concerning his patrolling duty. Within a few minutes the explosion took place G followed by firing, and he saw many passengers running wildly. 14. PW-62, Injured: shown in photograph Ext. No. 245. 15. Ambadas Pawar, killed; shown lying down the with Shashank Shinde in photograph Ext. No. 242.

H 16. PW-61, D'souza.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 401 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] In the meantime, Shashank Shinde came to the Police Help A Center. He told them that the railway station was under attack by terrorists. Shinde asked Pandarkar to load his .303 rifle. Pandarkar accompanied Shinde towards the main line. He saw a terrorist who was about 6 feet in height coming from the side of the taxi stand and firing towards the railway police B station. At that time he was standing in front of the railway police station. He fired two rounds at him from his .303 rifle but the shots did not hit him. At this point, Police Constable Ambadas Pawar, who was also accompanying Shinde, took the rifle from Pandarkar and fired one round at the terrorist. At the same time C Pandarkar saw the other terrorist (the appellant) coming towards them from the side of platform no.8 (main line). He was shorter in height than the other terrorist. He was firing from his AK-47 rifle. Pandarkar, Constable Ambadas Pawar and Pl Shinde went towards platform no.7 through platform no.6 and D came near the ATM of Indian Bank. Both the terrorists started firing at them from AK-47 rifles. One of the bullets pierced through Pandarkar's left chest and exited from the back. He fell down as a result of the bullet injury. Shashank Shinde and Ambadas Pawar too were hit by the terrorists' shots and E unfortunately they were not as lucky as Pandarkar. They succumbed to their injuries. 142. In the course of his deposition Pandarkarwas shown the three (3) photographs collectively marked Ext. no. 239. He identified himself and the slain Constable Ambadas Pawar in those photographs. In the photograph Ext. no. 242, he identified Shashank Shinde and Ambadas Pawar lying prone after being shot by the terrorists. In one of the photographs from Ext. no. 243 (collectively) he identified himself and Lau Kharat (PW-57), who worked at the railway station, who is holding him by the arm after he was shot and helping him to be taken to St. George's Hospital. This particular photograph from Ext. no. 243 (collectively) was separately marked Ext. no. 245. 143. Pandarkar identified the appellant as the shorter of

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A the two terrorists. He identified Abu Ismail from his photograph on Article 61. He had earlier identified the appellant in the test identification parade held on January 14, 2009. 144. Sandeep Tanaji Khiratkar (PW-66) was an Inspector B in the Railway Protection Force. At the time of the occurrence he was at his residence and was informed about the attack by Jadhav (PW-54) by telephone. He rushed to the police station on his motor-cycle and arrived there in five to seven (5-7) minutes. He went to the RPF armory on the ground floor of the C General Manager Office building and took out a .303 rifle and twenty (20) rounds from the armory. He came out of the station from the GM Porch abutting DN Road. SI Bhosale (PW-68) and Inspector Kshirsagar were with him. They took position in the GM Porch. At that time they saw two terrorists coming towards the porch situated near the subway. Both the terrorists fired at D them. They also retaliated and fired back at the terrorists. The firing by Khiratkar and his men forced the terrorists to re-enter the railway station and move in the opposite direction towards platform no. 1 from where they went out of the railway station through the foot-overbridge. When Khiratkar and his men E reached near the gate of the foot-overbridge they were informed that the terrorists had already left the railway station. Khiratkar then went to the control room of the CCTV cameras in the RPF office. There he found that on that date the CCTV cameras of the main lines were shut down for maintenance but F the movements of Kasab and Abu Ismail were recorded by the CCTV cameras in the main hall and platform no.1 of the local lines. At about 11.30 PM on the same day, he was informed by Constable Jadhav that the movements of the terrorists had been recorded on the Data Visual Recorder. Immediately G thereafter he prepared from the DVR a CD of the visuals captured by CCTV cameras of the main hall and other places wherever the movements of the terrorists had been seen. The CD was sealed by him immediately and it was later handed over to an officer of DCB CID, Mumbai. He further stated H before the court that the recording on the DVR is stored for a

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 403 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.) period of seven days. At the end of the seventh day the first day's recording would get deleted to make space for the recording of the eighth day. 145. Khiratkar identified the appellant as the shorter of the two terrorists. He identified Abu Ismail (deceased accused no.1) from his photograph on Article 61. He had earlier identified the appellant in the test identification parade held on December 28, 2008, at Arthur Road prison, Mumbai.

146. Pandurang Subrao Patil (PW-63) was an Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police on duty carrying a lathi. He told the court C that he was fired at by the shorter terrorist (i.e., the appellant). The bullet hit his left thigh and, passing through it, pierced his right thigh and exited from the exterior portion of his right thigh. He simply collapsed on to the floor. He further said that he had seen the two terrorists from a distance of twenty-two to twenty- D five (22 to 25) feet. 147. Patil identified the appellant as the shorter of the two terrorists. He also identified Abu Ismail, (deceased accused no.1) from his photograph on Article 61.

148. Geetanjali Krishnarao Gurav (PW-60) was on duty at the CST local railway station near main gate no. 3. On hearing the explosion and the gun shots she along with Shinde (killed), API Bhosa/e (PW-49), PSI Khandale and other policemen went towards the main hall of the main lines. She F saw two terrorists in the main hall and she saw the taller of the two throwing a hand grenade at a crowd of passengers. The grenade exploded, causing injuries to a large number of passengers. Both terrorists were continuously firing from AK47 rifles. She and Bhosale, therefore, proceeded towards the G railway police station to call for additional force. While on way to the police station, Bhosale was hit by a bullet in his left upper arm and he fell down. She tied a handkerchief to his wound and helped him )n getting back on his feet. At that time, she saw both the terrorists proceeding in the direction of the local railway H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

station. More than hundred (100) passengers lay badly injured in the main hall of the main lines. 149. Geetanjali Gurav identified the appellant as the shorter of the two terrorists. She also identified Abu Ismail (deceased accused no.1) from his photograph on Article 61. 150. Now, some of the passengers:

Natwarlal Gigaji Rotawan (PW-50) and his daughter Devika Natwarlal Rotawan, aged about ten (10) years, (PWC 51 }; 17 Farooqi Nasiruddin Khaliluddin (PW-52); Nafisa Shadab Qureshi (PW-53); Sangeeta Niranjan Sardar(PW-86) and her husband Niranjan Sadashiv Sardar (PW-87); and Ansar Alabaksha Mohd. Hanif Saudagar (PW-88), are some of the passenger witnesses. They were in the main hall of the 0 main lines waiting for their respective trains. They were jolted out of whatever they might be doing or thinking at that moment by the explosion of the first grenade thrown by Abu Ismail (deceased accused no.1) and from that moment they watched, in abject horror, the appellant and his companion firing E indiscriminately at the group of passengers in the main hall; Abu Ismail throwing the second grenade and then the two moving around on the platforms in different directions until the spray of bullets and the shrapnel from the exploding grenades hit them or one of their group.

151. Natwarial Rotawan (PW-50) was lucky to escape unhurt but his daughter, Devika Rotawan (PW-51), was hit by a bullet on her right leg. She was treated as an indoor patient in the hospital for about a month and a half and thereafter

17. Though Devika was not examined by the police earlier and she was only a child aged 1O years, on an application made by prosecution the trial court by order dated June 10, 2009 allowed her to be examined as one of the prosecution witnesses under oath after being satisfied that she was capable of understanding the meaning of oath. We feel that the trial court was quite justified in examining Devika as one of the witnesses of the occurrence.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 405 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J] remained bedridden for four to six (4-6) months. When she came to depose in court after about 6 months of the occurrence, she was still unable to walk properly. 152. Natwarlal identified the appellant as the "shorter one" and said that his companion was not present in court. Devika identified the appellant as the person who was firing at the VT railway station.

153. Farooqi Nasiruddin Khaliluddin (PW-52) was at the station with his son. Both of them were injured, the son far more badly than the father, by the splinters from the second grenade thrown by Abu Ismail (deceased accused no. 1). Khaliluddin told the court that the firing by the terrorists continued for about fifteen to twenty (15-20) minutes. He further said that the taller man had paused in the firing as he took out'a bomb from his bag and threw it in their direction but that the other man (that D is, the appellant) continued with the firing and he appeared to be in a "joyous mood" on seeing the lethal effect of his firing. Identifying the appellant in court, he once again said that he was the same person whom he had seen in "joyous mood".

c

154. Nafisa Qureshi (PW-53), who worked as a maidservant, lost her six (6) ~ar old daughter Afrin to the terrorists' bullets. She was hit by a bullet on the back and died at the spot. Nafisa herself sustained a bullet injury on her left leg.

155. She identified the appellant as one of the two persons who were firing at CST in all directions. The appellant was the person whom she had, earlier in her deposition, referred to as the "shorter one".

156. Sangeeta Sardar(PW-86) and her husband Niranjan Sadashiv Sardar (PW-87) also sustained injuries as a result G of the firing and throwing of grenades. Sangeeta was hit by steel balls (from the hand grenade) that pierced her body, and some of which were still lodged inside her body as she deposed. Her husband, Niranjan, sustained two (2) bullet injuries, one on the right side of the head and the other below H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

the right ear. Both of them remained indoor patients in the hospital for weeks.

157. Sangeeta identified the appellant as the "butka" who was firing at the CST railway station. She identified the "lamboo B fellow" from his photograph on the identity card Article 61. 158. Ansar Alabaksha Mohd. Hanif Saudagar (PW-88) was hit by a bullet on his right leg, below the knee joint. In court, Saudagarwas asked to identify the appellant from among the three (3) accused in the dock. He identified the appellant as C the "butka" firing at the passengers at the CST railway station. He also identified the person who was accompanying the appellant from the photograph on Article 61. Cama ln 18 : Seven (7) dead and ten (10) injured 19

159. Kasab and Abu Ismail were seen exiting CST via the foot-overbridge and coming down the bridge in the evidence of Vemekar (PW-102) and in the photograph of Kasab (Ext. no. 410-D) taken by him. On descending from the footoverbridge, they came to Badruddin Tayabji Marg, which is a E long, meandering road, a part of which runs along the premises of Cama Hospital. Cama Hospital has large premises, on which there are a number of buildings including a six-storey structure called the New Hospital Building. The entry to Cama Hospital is from Mahapalika Road on its western side, and F Badruddin Tayabji Marg runs along the back of its premises. The prosecution, with the aid of eleven (11) eye-witnesses, has

18. For this part of the case the prosecution examined thiry-two (32) witnesses. Leaving aside the doctors, forensic experts and other witnesses of a formal nature, such as panch witnesses, the number of eye witnesses who gave an ocular accout of the events is not less than eleven (11). Of the eleven (11), two are policemen both of whom received injuries at the hands of Kasab and Abu Ismail, five (5) are from the public of whom one (1) is injured, and four (4) are hospital staff of whom two (2) are injured. 19. The number relates to the persons Killed a~d injured by Kasab and Abu Ismail both in the before they entered Cama hospital and inside the hospital.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 407 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] traced practically every step taken by Kasab and Abu Ismail from the moment they came out of CST, entered Cama hospital and eventually left the hospital. We, however, propose to examine only some of these steps, to get a broad idea of how the two were moving around killing people, completely mindlessly. 160. Bharat Budhabhai Waghela (PW-103) worked as a Safai Kamgar with Valtas. He lived in a hut off Badruddin Tayabji Marg. At about 9.30 PM on November 26, 2008, he was sitting near the back gate of Cama Hospital on Badruddin Tayabji Marg engaged in small talk with his friends Sandeep Waghe/a (PW-105), who lived on the premises of Cama Hospital, and Bhagan Shinde, who lived in the same hutments as Waghela. Gupta bhel-vendor was also near the gate selling snacks of bhel-puri. At about 10.30 PM they saw two persons coming on to Badruddin Tayabji Road from the direction of the Times of India Building. One of them was 'lamboo' (tall) and the other was 'butka' (short). Both were carrying bags on their shoulders. Suddenly, they started firing. The butka man fired straight at them, and he shot Gupta bhelwala in full view of Waghela. Waghela was frightened and ran towards his hut. His friends also ran away from the spot. Back in his hut, Waghela told his mother about the incident. He shut the doors of his hut and peeped out from the little gap between the frame of the door and the panels. He saw the butka fellow standing near his brother's shanty, adjoining Waghela's own hut, and firing at it. He heard his brother cry out. He saw the /amboo fellow firing in the lane. After some time, he saw both of them going towards the gate of Cama Hospital. 161. After a while, Waghela went to his brother, Thakur Waghela's shanty. He found his brother lying in a pool of blood. His five (5) year old son was also there but his wife was not present. Waghela took his brother to the GT Hospital where he was declared dead by the doctors. Five minutes later,

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

A Bhagan Shinde was brought to the hospital. He was also declared dead.

c

162. Waghela identified the appellant as the gunman who had shot Gupta bhelwala and fired at his brother's shanty. He said before the court that he had identified the accused in the test identification parade on December 27, 2008. He had also identified the dead body of the "lamboo" when it was placed among six (6) other dead bodies at the mortuary of JJ Hospital. He then identified him from the photograph on the identity card, Article 61.

163. Anjali Vijay Kulathe (PW-101) worked as a staff nurse at Cama Hospital. On November 26, 2008, she arrived for duty at 8.00 PM. She was on duty on the first floor of the New Building. At about 10.30 PM she heard the sound of firing D from the back of the hospital. She looked out from the back window of the ante-natal care unit and saw two persons climbing over the steel gate at the back of the hospital. One of them was 'lamboo' (tall) and the other was 'butka' (short). She could see them clearly in the light from the street lights. She E further said that the gate was at the distance of ten to fifteen (10-15) feet from the window from where she saw the intruders. 164. The two men jumped inside the Cama Hospital premises. The tall man fired towards the window from where she was looking at them. One of the bullets hit the right wrist of F a hospital servant, Hira Jadhav. She was immediately removed to the casualty ward on the ground floor of the hospital. Ku/athe further said that she informed the CMO on duty, Dr. Archana, that two terrorists had entered the hospital building. She then rushed back to her ward and closed all the doors from inside. G She also locked the ward's collapsible (iron grill) gate. Moreover, since the ward had windows on all sides, all twenty (20) patients who were in the ANC ward at that time were moved to the pantry for their safety.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 409 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] 165. She further stated before the court that the noise of firing and explosions went on for about two hours. She and all the patients were frightened due to the continuous noise of explosions and firing. She and the patients stayed inside the pantry till 4.00 AM the following morning, when senior officers came and took them out. 166. She then identified the appellant as the butka man who, along with his tall partner, had entered the Cama Hospital premises by jumping over its back gate. She identified the tall partner of the appellant from the photograph on the identity card, Article 61. She further told the court that she had identified the appellant in the test identification parade on December 27, 2008, held by "judge" (sic) Sharad Vichare. She further said that, on being identified by her, the appellant had said that he was in fact Ajmal Kasab and she had correctly identified

h~.

167. Raosaheb Changdev Funde (PW-107) is an exserviceman and he worked as an unarmed security guard at Cama Hospital. On November 26, 2008, his shift ended at 10.00 PM but he learnt that some incidents had taken place at CST and, therefore, decided not to go home but to stay back for the night at the hospital. He stated before the court that, on learning about the CST incidents, he returned to Cama Hospital's main (front) gate, near the collapsible gate. Another security guard, Baban Ugade, was also there. As Funde was standing with Ugade near the collapsible gate, he saw the appellant and one other person coming towards them. The appellant fired a shot at Ugade from his rifle. The shot hit Ugade in the abdomen and he fell down. Funde was scared and ran up the stairs to the fifth floor, where he took shelter in a ward, hiding behind a stand which is used for drying clothes. The appellant, however, followed him there and, putting the barrel of his rifle on his head, ordered him, "Utho" (get-up). The appellant then asked Funde to proceed towards the bathroom. Funde saw one person lying in a pool of blood in front of the

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

bathroom with a tall man standing near him. The appellant made him enter the bathroom where three (3) persons were already confined 20 . The bathroom was then bolted from outside. After two to three (2 or 3) hours, the police arrived there and opened the bathroom. Funde narrated the incident to the police.

c

168. Funde then identified the appellant's partner from the photograph on the identity card, Article 61. He further told the court the he had identified the appellant at the test identification parade on December 27, 2008. He had also identified the dead body of the appellant's partner on January 7, 2009, at JJ Hospital.

169. Harishchandra Sonu Shrivardhankar (PW-106) was the person whom Funde had seen lying in a pool of blood near the door of the bathroom. His encounter with the two terrorists D has something uncanny about it. Fate seemed to force his every step towards meeting the terrorists and when he actually stood face-to-face with them, quite certain of death, he did not go down without fighting. Tough, two and a half times the age of his opponents, completely unarmed and untrained in any kind E of fighting, he put up a fight nonetheless. Unfortunately, his attempt could not succeed against an armed and trained killer. He was stabbed and shot and left behind by the terrorist in the belief that he was dead or would soon die. Shrivardhankar, however, survived to tell the story and to identify his assailant. 170. Shrivardhankar worked as a Senior Clerk at the Mantralaya at the time. Apparently a devotee of Hazrat Sayyed Shah Baba (a Muslim saint), after leaving his office at 6.00 PM on November 26, 2008, Shrivardhankarwent to the Urs at the G saint's Durgah (shrine), situated behind Metro Cinema. He left the Durgah at 10.30 PM and proceeded to CST via the Metro

20. They were I. Timesh Narsing Chinnekar (PW-123) whose wife Gracy was admitted in the hospital on November 22, 2008, for deliver; 2. Thomas Sidhappa Uledhar (PW-108), borther-in-law of Chinnekar; and 3 Soman, a friend of Uledhar.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 411 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] subway and St. Xavier's College to catch a train home. On approaching the gate of Cama Hospital at Mahapalika Road, Shrivardhankar saw many people running in panic and learnt about the incident of firings at CST. To avoid getting caught in the firing, he sought refuge in Cama Hospital. On entering the gate of the hospital he saw a dead body (Ugade) lying in front of the entrance to the main building. On seeing the dead body he was scared and, suspecting that some incident must have taken place on the premises of the hospital, he entered the main building through the collapsible gate. There was complete silence in the building and he found all the doors closed. He went up to the fourth floor; all the floors appeared to be deserted and the doors of all the wards were closed.

c

171. As soon as he reached the fifth floor, the luckless man found himself standing in front of a man holding a gun and a knife, and carrying a bag on his shoulder. He was about five D feet six inches (5' 6") tall and had short hair. He was wearing a jacket. He put his knife on Shrivardhankar's neck. Shrivardhankar realised that the man would kill him in any case and, therefore, decided to fight. He tried to hit the man in the groin with his knee and also attempted to hit him with his bag. E The bag, however, slipped out of Shrivardhankar's hand and the killer struck him two (2) times on the neck with his knife, causing bleeding. The killer caught hold of Shrivardhankar's collar and pushed him down. He inflicted a third knife blow on his back and also shot a bullet in his back. By that time, F Shrivardhankar had lost any strength to resist and fell unconscious. He regained consciousness after three to four (34) days at JJ Hospital and was treated as an indoor patient for about three (3) months 21 • 21. The only issue on which the two judges hearing the case were unable to agree completely was what would be the witnesses' feelings towards the saint. The author of these lines felt that he would never again go to shrine holding him responsible for getting nearly killed on November 26. The other judge, on the other hand, maintained that the occurence would have greatly enhance his devotion for the saint, whom the witness would see as his savior.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

172. Shrivardhankar vividly recounted his encounter with one of the terrorists. He also told the court that in the fight with the killer his spectacles had fallen down. At that time he was wearing brown slippers (footwear). Shrivardhankar told the court that his footwear and spectacles were lost and he did not find them on regaining consciousness at JJ Hospital.

C

173. He then identified his assailant at Cama Hospital from the photograph on the identity card, Article 61. He also identified the assailant in the photographs Ext. no. 410-A & Ext. no. 410-B (part of Ext. no. 410 collectively).

174. He also identified his spectacles, Article 310 (recovered and seized from Cama Hospital and produced in court as one of the case articles) but said that the slippers shown to him as Article 309 did not belong to him.

175. Chandrakant Dnyandev Tikhe (PW-109) was the lift operator at Cama Hospital. On November 26, 2008, he was on duty as Generator Operator from 10.00 PM in the evening till 7:00 AM the following morning. The generator room is E situated on the terrace of the building. At about 10:00 PM, when he was on the terrace, Tikhe heard the sound of firing from the ground floor. On hearing the gunshots he immediately went inside the enclosure where the solar system is installed and locked its collapsible gate. He was still inside the enclosure when, around 11 :00 PM, the two terrorists arrived on the F terrace. He saw them clearly in the light of the electric bulb of 200 watts that was lit on the terrace. One of them was taller and the other was shorter. The "butka" (short) fellow pointed his rifle towards Tikhe and asked him to come out or else he would blow him to bits ("Aage aao warna uda dunga'J. Therefore, G Tikhe opened the gate and came out of the enclosure. The tall man was also holding a gun. Tikhe then identified the appellant as the short man who had pointed his gun at him. 176. When Tikhe came out of the enclosure, the appellant H asked him the way out from the hospital. Tikhe told them that

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 413 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] there was only one staircase that alone could be used to exit the hospital. The tall fellow, who was keeping a watch, suddenly shouted "Police!" and started firing towards the stairs. The appellant held his gun against Tikhe's back and pushed him towards the stairs. The appellant and his tall partner brought Tikhe to the landing between the sixth floor and the terrace. From there, Tikhe saw three to four (3-4) policemen in front of the lift on the sixth floor. Tikhe raised his hands apprehending that he might be killed by the police if they suspected him of being a terrorist. A staff member of Cama Hospital, namely Kai/ash (PW-111 ), was also with the policemen and he identified Tikhe to the police as one of the hospital staff. The police fired at the appellant and his tall partner forcing them to retreat to the terrace. In that time, Tikhe escaped and came down to the sixth floor landing. He told the police that there were two terrorists. 177. The appellant then started firing at them from above. He also threw a hand grenade on to the sixth floor. The splinters from the hand grenade hit Tikhe on his neck and he sustained a bleeding injury. Some policemen were also injured from the explosion of the hand grenade. The appellant and his tall partner kept firing at the policemen. Tikhe saw a police officer and another policeman getting shot and falling down in front of the lift. After some time, the terrorists again threw down a hand ·grenade and fired indiscriminately in the direction of the lift. The other policemen a1 ,d the officers were also injured by the second explosion and the firing. 178. At this point, Tikhe came down to the second floor. He was accompanied by two policemen and by Kai/ash. One of these policemen went further down but the other stayed with them. After being given first aid they were shifted to GT Hospital. From there, Tikhe was taken to KEM Hospital for treatment as hand grenade splinters were lodged in his neck. He was treated as an indoor patient for seven (7) days. 179. He also told the court that he had identified the

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

appellant in the test identification parade on December 27, 2008.

180. Sadanand Vasant Date (PW-118) is an IPS Officer and, at the material time, he was posted as Additional Commissioner of Police, Central Region, Mumbai. On November 26, 2008, at about 10.00 PM, he was at his residence when the assault at CST took place. CST did not come within his jurisdiction but, on the request of his colleague Dr. Vankatesham whose jurisdiction included CST, Date came C out like any dutiful police officer. He first went to the Malabar Hill Police Station, which was close to his residence, and collected one carbine and twenty (20) rounds. On the way to CST he got information about the movements of the terrorists and, in light of this information, he and his team reached Cama Hospital a little after 11.00 PM. Date came to learn that the D terrorists had gone up to the terrace of Cama Hospital building and, therefore, he took the lift to the sixth floor landing, from where stairs led up to the terrace22 . There, he had an encounter with the two terrorists who were at that time on the terrace of the building, holding Tikhe there.

181. On reaching the sixth floor, instead of rushing to the terrace, Date picked up an iron object lying there and threw it towards the door of the terrace, to check the position of the terrorists. In response, a burst of firing from an automatic F weapon came from the terrace door. Shortly thereafter, Date saw a bulky person (Tikhe) coming down to the landing on the stairs between the terrace and the 6th floor. Date challenged the bulky person but Kai/ash (PW-111) identified him as a member of the hospital staff. The bulky person indicated that there was somebody behind him. Date asked him to bend down G and then fired over his head towards the terrace. That forced the terrorists to go back to the terrace. Taking advantage of the

22. The New Hospital building of Cama Hospital had two lifts, apart from the stairs, for going to the upper floors. The lifts could take one up to the sixth floor but the stairs would go beyond, right up to terrace of the building.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 415 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] situation, Tikhe came down to the sixth floor landing. In the meantime, a grenade was thrown from the terrace. It exploded on the sixth floor in front of the lift causing injuries to some police officers, including Date, and also to Tikhe. 182. Date's team comprised seven (7) police officers and policemen. All of them were armed with firearms. Date's operator Tilekar and police constable Khandelkar had one carbine each. Date himself was wearing a bullet-proof jacket and he had a carbine with twenty (20) rounds. But all this did not prove sufficient to take out Kasab and Abu Ismail or even to stop them. The two terrorists were able to overcome the police and to escape from the tight spot in which they had landed - the terrace that had only one (1) exit by the stairs. This was because, besides having superior fire power, they had the great advantage of hand grenades. Grenades exploding in the very small landing area badly injured the policemen who had no cover or shelter there. 183. Date stated before the court that, after the first hand grenade exploded, his officers continued to fire towards the terrace. But shortly afterwards, another hand grenade was thrown, which caused injuries to almost all officers who were present there, including Date. The injured police officers, policemen and staff members of Gama Hospital were asked to go down. More (killed) could not go down because he was badly injured and unconscious. Police constable Khandekar (killed) also could not go down as he, too, was badly injured. Date said before the court that he continued to fire towards the terrace in retaliation of the firing from there. The exchange of fire went on for about forty (40) minutes during which he had taken cover behind a wall situated in front of the right side lift. After some time he sensed some movement and, as he came out from behind the wall which he was using for cover, he found that two persons had already gone down towards the fifth floor. He fired two shots towards the two persons going away but was unable to say whether or not they were hit. He was unable to pursue them because of his leg injury.

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012] 8 S.C.R.

184. He said it would be 11.50 PM at that time. 185. Accordingly, Date informed his superiors that two persons had gone down from the sixth floor of the building and that they had automatic weapons and hand grenades.

186. Date further said that the help came at about 00.45 AM and he was shifted to KEM Hospital, where he was admitted for three (3) days. Apart from several minor injuries he had sustained injuries from splinters and fragments of the hand grenade in his right eye and on the left side of chest just C below armpit, and in his throat, right knee and left ankle.

Cama Out23: Nine (9) dead, seven (7) injured 24 187. Date on the sixth floor landing was unable to stop Kasab and Abu Ismail and, while he took shelter against the D hail of bullets and shrapnel from the grenades behind a wall, the two managed to sneak down the stairs. 188. Suresh Shantaram Kadam (PW-138) and Yashwant Shankar Thorawade (PW-128) 25 next saw Kasab and Abu

23. For this part of the case the prosecution exaimned eighteen (18) witnesses. Leaving aside the doctor, forensic expert and other witnesses for a formal nature, such as panch witnesses, the number of eye witnesses who gave an ocular account of the events is not less than seven (7). Out of the seven (7), six (6) are policemen one (1) of whom received injuries at the hands of Kasab and Abu Ismail and One (1} is the driver of a car who received gunshot injuries when his car was fired upon by the terrorists. 24. The number relates to the person killed and injured by Kasab and Abu Ismail from the point they came out of Gama hospital and until they snatched the Skoda car.

25. Thorawade (PW-128) was earlier examined on July 14, 2009, before Kadam (PW-138) who was examined on July 27, 2009. But on July 14, 2009 he only stated before the cout that, from November 28, 2008 he was handing the investigation of Crime No. 245-08 till it was taken over by DCB, CID on December 2, 2008. Later, Kadam, in his deposition before the court, stated that Thorawade was also among the policemen stationed in front of the entrance to Gama Hospital when Kasab and Abu Ismail came out of the Hospital, and he too had witnessed the whole incident. Thereupon, the cour recalled Thorawade and he was re-examined by the court on November 23, 2009.

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 417 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.]

Ismail coming out of Gama Hospital from its front side on Mahapalika Road and immediately gunning down a police officer.

189. Thorawade was a Police Inspector and, on the evening of November 26, 2008, in the absence of the senior B police inspector, he was holding charge of Azad Maidan police station. Kadam was a constable attached to the same Police Station. As Azad Maidan police station received information that terrorists had entered CST and were firing there, the policemen proceeded to the railway station in two police C vehicles. On the way, they learnt that the terrorists had left the railway station and were seen going in the direction of Metro Cinema. Accordingly, they came to Metro junction where they came across Additional Police Commissioner Date (PW-118). Date asked them to go back and collect bullet-proof jackets and arms and ammunition from Azad Maidan police station as D ' had reached information had arrived by then that the terrorists the terrace of Gama Hospital building and were firing from there. As directed by Date, Kadam, Shelke (PW-141) and some others went back to Azad Maidan police station where they collected two bullet-proof jackets and some fire-arms and E ammunition. 190. Returning to the scene of firing, they decided to go to the front gate of Gama Hospital (instead of going to the back side), expecting the terrorists to exit the hospital from its main gate. Kadam stated that he was accompanied by Pl Thorawade (PW-128), PSI Shelke (PW-141), and police constables Utekar and Rathore. Constable Gawade was driving the Bolero vehicle (called Peter-1 26 Azad Maidan) in which they came there. The vehicle was parked on the left side of the road facing Metro junction and they took position by the side of the vehicle. 26. Peter Mobile is the name given to a vehicle fitted with a wireless system. One such Peter Mobile is proided to each police station under the direct control of the Sr. Pl in charge of the police station.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2012) 8 S.C.R.

191. At about 11 :45 PM, the policemen saw two persons coming out of Cama Hospital. Kadam first saw them on the footpath of Cama Hospital and Thorawade when they were near the gate of St. Xavier's College adjoining the hospital. Kadam said that one of them was 'lamboo' (tall) and the other was B 'butka' (short). In the meantime, they saw a motor-cycle driving on Mahapalika Road from Metro junction towards CST. It was driven by a police constable and a police officer was on its pillion. The officer got down near the gate of St. Xavier's College and, according to Kadam, the motor-cycle went c ahead. (According to Thorwade, the constable made a u-turn and went back towards Metro). The officer who got down from the motor-cycle started directing people coming from the direction of CST to return. He seemed to have asked the lamboo and the butka also not to proceed further but to go back. But they continued moving towards him and fired at him from a distance of about fifteen to twenty (15-20) feet. The officer collapsed to the ground. This confirmed to Thorawade and Kadam that the two persons who had come out from Cama Hospital were the terrorists whom they had been watching for. Thorawade started firing at them from his service pistol. Kadam E also fired one round from his pistol and then he stopped because Thorawade was firing at the terrorists. The terrorists fired back in retaliation. 192. Thorawade told the court that he tried sending F messages to South Control from the wireless installed in his Bolero police vehicle but, due to heavy traffic on the network, he was unable to send the message. Therefore, Thorawade went to the Metro junction where two to three (2-3) police vehicles were available. The message was sent from the G wireless set of one of those vehicles.

193. There were many people at the metro junction. After a short while, one police vehicle (Qualis) appeared from Badruddin Tayabji Road and took right turn on Mahapalika Road towards Metro junction. Thorawade saw the two terrorists

MOHAMMED AJMAL MOHAMMAD AMIR KASAB @ABU 419 MUJAHID v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [AFTAB ALAM, J.] in that vehicle. The person who was sitting on the right side was firing at the large crowd assembled at Metro junction. One policeman ard another person were injured due to firing from that vehicle 27 •

194. In the meanwhile, Kadam had remained in front of B Cama Hospital. He went on to state before the court that he saw a white car with a red beacon approaching Mahapalika Road from Badruddin Tayabji Road but, immediately thereafter, he saw the car going backwards on Badruddin Tayabji Road. The /amboo and the butka fired at that car. One of them also C threw a hand-grenade towards the white car. Thereafter, both of them proceeded towards Rang Bhavan Lane on (BT Road). The officer who was shot near the gate of St. Xavier's College was later identified from the name plate on his uniform as Durgude. Kadam then identified Kasab in the dock as the butka who had fired at Durgude and who was accompanying D the /amboo. Kadam further stated that he had earlier identified the appellant in the identification parade on December 27, 2008, and had also identified the dead body of the lamboo on January 6, 2009, at the JJ Hospital mortuary. 195. Maruti Madhavrao Phad (PW-139) was the driver of the "white car with red beacon" which Kadam had seen coming from Badruddin Tayabji Road towards Mahapalika Road and then going in the reverse direction. It was actually a white Honda City car, a government vehicle allotted to one Bhushan F Gagrani, IAS, Secretary Medical Education and Drugs Department (PW-140). Phad was the dr

Related judgments

More Supreme Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.