Mohd. Moid Mohd. Rakeeb Khan v. The Deputy Commissioner of Police and Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 13 October 2026
- Case number
- WP No. 1408 of 2026
- Result
- Disposed Off
- Acts & sections
- Section 189 BNS, Article 227 Constitution
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.1408 OF 2026
Mohd. Moid Mohd. Rakeeb Khan Versus The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
…Petitioner …Respondents
WITH CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.984 OF 2026 Mohd. Saeed Mohd. Rakeeb Khan Versus The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
…Petitioner …Respondents
Mr. M. B. Shirsat a/w. Ms. Fehmida Ahmed, Ms. Swati Pandey i/b. Mr. M. A. Khan, for the Petitioners. Ms. S. D. Shinde, APP, for the Respondent-State in WP/1408/2026. Mrs. Savita M. Yadav, APP, for the Respondent-State in WP/984/2026. Mr. Ganpat Ganeshkar, PSI, Chunabhatti Police Station, Mumbai, present.
CORAM: DATED :
MADHAV J. JAMDAR, J. 13th OCTOBER 2026
PC:-
1.
Heard Mr. Shirsat, learned Counsel appearing for the
Petitioners, Ms. Shinde and Mrs. Yadav, learned APPs appearing for the Respondent-State.
2.
By these Writ Petitions filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, the challenge is to the legality and validity of the impugned order dated 25th July 2025 passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Zone-6, Chembur, Mumbai, in Externment Case No.57 of 2025 as also the orders dated 6th February 2026 passed by the Divisional Commissioner, Konkan Division, Mumbai, in Appeal No.112 of 2025 and 113 of 2025 filed under the provisions of Section 60 of the Maharashtra Police Act, 1951.
3.
It is the submission of Mr. Shirsat, learned Counsel
appearing for the Petitioners that the impugned order dated 25 th July 2025 has been passed against eight persons. He submits that out of those eight persons, the said order has been set aside as far as six persons are concerned. To substantiate the said contention, he relies on the order dated 13th March 2026 passed by a learned Single Judge in Criminal Writ Petition No.1011 of 2026 and the order dated 30th April 2026 passed by a learned Single Judge in Criminal Writ Petition No.1930 of 2026. He submits that for the same reasons, the impugned orders be quashed and set aside.
4.
On the other hand, learned APPs strongly oppose the Writ
Petitions and supported the impugned order.
5.
Perusal of the record shows that as far as the Petitioner in
Writ Petition No.984 of 2026 is concerned, the offences which are taken into consideration are set out in paragraph No.1.3 of the impugned order dated 25th July 2025 and as far as Petitioner in Writ Petition No.1408 of 2026 are concerned, they are set out in paragraph 1.4. The said paragraphs are set out herein below for ready reference:
1-3 VksGh ize[ q k eksgEen lbZn eksgEen jdhc [kku mQZ xCcj ;kps fo:/n nk[ky xqUgsv- iks- Bk.ks xq-j-Ødye o dk;nk nk[ky fnukad DksVZ dsl Øuacj 1 usg:uxj 145@08 143] 144] 147] 148] 149] 19@04@2008 107@ihMCyw 324] 504] 506¼2½ 34 Hkknfo @09 2 pqukHkV~Vh 05@20 353] 341] 323] 506] 504 10@01@2020 766@ls’ku Hkknfo dsl@21 fn 02@02@ 2021 3 pqukHkV~Vh 93@21 326] 323] 504] 506] 34 03@04@2021 2641@ihMC Hkknfo yw@22 fn 17@10@22 4 pqukHkV~Vh 100@25 189¼3½] 191¼2½] 190] 132 Hkk 16@02@2025 1557@ihMC U;k la yw@25
ln;fLFkrh funksZ”keqDr nks”keqDr
nks”keqDr
U;k;izfo”B
1-4 VksGhrhy lnL; eks- eksbZn ekssgEen jdhc [kku ;kps fo:/n nk[ky xqUgs v- iks- Bk.ks xq-j-Ødye o dk;nk nk[ky fnukad DksVZ dsl ln;fLFkrh Øuacj 61@201 143] 149] 341] 448] 506¼2½] 26@03@2017 214@ihMCyw U;k;izfo”B 120¼c½ Hkknfo lg 37¼1½ eiksdk @18 fn17@01@18 93@202 326] 323] 504] 506] 34 03@04@2021 2641@ihMC nks”keqDr pqukHkV~Vh 1 Hkknfo y@22 fn17@10@ 2022 ------ek l= 521@20 354] 509] 506¼2½] 504] 05@12@2023 323] 336] 34 Hkknfo lg U;k;ky;kus 37¼1½] 135 eiksdk lnjpk xqUgk jn~n dsyy s k vkgs4 100@25 189¼3½] 191¼2½] 190] 132 Hkk 16@02@2025 1557@ihMC U;k;izfo”B U;k la yw@25
6.
The above paragraphs 1.3 and 1.4 of the impugned order
clearly shows that except the offence registered in the year 2025 i.e. C.R. No.100 of 2025 registered with Chunabhatti Police Station, Mumbai, there is no live-link between other offences and action of externment. As far as said C.R. No.100 of 2025 is concerned, a learned Single Judge by order dated 13 th March 2026 passed in Criminal Writ Petition No.1011 of 2026 has observed in paragraphs 14 and 15 as under:
“14. On the aforesaid touchstone, reverting to the facts of the case, evidently, the petitioners are not arraigned in any of the crimes registered against Mohameed Sayeed, the alleged gang leader, or other members of the gang. The petitioners seem
to have been roped in on the basis of registration of CR No.100/2025 for the offences punishable under Sections 189(3), 191(2), 190 and 132 of the BNS, 2023 only. A perusal of the final report filed in the said crime indicates that on 15th February, 2025, the police party found that two groups of persons were involved in a fight. When the police party tried to intervene, the gang leader and his nephew Zaid, pushed the police party aside and fled away. A report was, thus, came to be lodged with the allegations that the members of the said two groups, which were engaged in the fight, including Mohammad Sayeed, the alleged gang leader, and Zaid, a member of the alleged gang, formed an unlawful assembly and committed rioting, and used criminal force to a public servant with intent to deter the said public servant from discharging his duty as such public servant. The petitioners have been arraigned as the members of the said unlawful assembly. 15. Even if the allegations in the said FIR are taken at par, it does not appear that the petitioners were involved in the offences as the members of the gang allegedly led by Mohammad Sayeed. On the contrary, it appears that two groups of persons were involved in a fight and thereby they formed an unlawful assembly and used criminal force to the public servants, when the later tried to intervene. There is no clarity as to whether the petitioners were in fact the members of the alleged gang led by Mohammad Sayeed. At best, the offences arrayed against the petitioners are individualistic in nature rather than a part of a concerted action by a group or gang. In substance, the acts attributed to the petitioners lack the element of gang or group based criminal conduct. Thus, the externment order suffers from a fundamental error. ”
7.
Thus, the above reasons are squarely applicable to the
present case.
8.
Accordingly, in the facts and circumstances, case is made out
for interference in the impugned orders. The Writ Petitions are disposed of by passing the following order:
ORDER
(a)
The impugned order dated 25th July 2025 passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Zone-6, Chembur, Mumbai, in Externment Case No.57 of 2025 as also the orders dated 6th February 2026 passed by the Divisional Commissioner, Konkan Division, Mumbai, in Appeal No.112 of 2025 and 113 of 2025 are quashed and set aside.
[MADHAV J. JAMDAR, J.] Digitally signed by SONALI SONALI MILIND MILIND PATIL PATIL Date: 2026.10.14 10:57:34 +0530