Mohd Mustafa (died Per Lrs) v. Kakatiya University
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 27 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Tangirala Madhavi Devi
- Case number
- WP No. 15065 of 2021
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Section 420 IPC, Section 151 CPC
- Subject
- Criminal, Service, Property & land
Full judgment
13219 | HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF DECEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW FOUR
PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI WRIT PETIT ION NO: 15065 oF 2021
Between: 1. Mohd Mustafa (Died oer LR'9),.S/o Nas:eeruddin. Aged 70 years, Senior Assistarit. uniirersitlr Ctirr"g" oi-li;. "s;6"4;;, w;reft;i Occ. Retd VE,.u';;:i District, T.S.
2. Sahera Banu, Wo: MoM Mustafa, Aged 50 years, Occ: Housewife Subedari, Warangal District. (As per court order dt: 04.03.2024 vide t.A. 1t24 inWp
1SO6Sj2OZ1 |
...PETITIONER AND frXlSt [1,'d,X8Ery+. S:oto
o' its Res stra r' vid va ra n va p u ri, wa ra nsa t, i
...RESPONOENTS
Petition under Articre 226 of the constitution of rndia praying circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High pleased to issue any writ, order or direction more particurarry
that in the
court may be
one in the nature of
writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondent in rejecting petitioner's representation date 2gro6t2o20 submitted
the
as per the directions of this
Hon'bre court in w.p. No. 12996 0f 200g dated 22to6/2020 by way
of proceedings
No. 02IA3/KU/N21 dated or.o1 .2021 though the petitioner is not
found guirty in
c.c.No.35 of 2012 for the offences u/ss 409,420 ,468,471of rpc and
accordingry
acquitted uls 248 of cr.p.c as illegal , arbitrary , discriminative and
violative of
Articles 14 and 21 of the constitution of rndia and consequenfly
direct the
respondents to set aide the proceedings No. 02iA3lKUt2o21
dated l.o1 .2021, which passed in response to the order in wp No. 12996 of 2oo9 by this Hon,bre court and direct the respondents to regurarise'his services with a[ service and monitory benefits and other applicable benefits.
Prayer is amended as per C'0 dt' 18/08/2023
in lA 01/2023
lA NO: 1 oF 2021 that in the circumstances stated in Petition under Section 151 CPC praying petition' the High Court may be pleased to direct the affidavit filed in support of the No' 02/A3/KUl2O21 dated07lO112021 the respondent to suspend the proceedings his service with all service and monitory and direct the respondents to regularise
benefitssuchasRevisedPayScaleswithincrements,Pension,gratuity' and other applicable benefits on par with Commutation, earned Leaves, GPF otheremployees,pendingdisposalofthemainwritpetitionintheinterestofjustice per C'O dl' 18l1gl2123 in lA 01/2023 and to pass Prayer is amended as Gounsel for the Petitioners: SRI RAMESH
CHILLA
PRAXASH Counsel for the Respondents: SRI P' BHANU uNlvERSlw, wARANGAL) KAKATIYA ;oR
iil
The Court made the following: ORDER
THE HONO{JRABLE SMT. JUSTICE T. MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETITION NO.15065 oB 2021
ORD ER In this Writ Petition, the petitioner is seeking a Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondent University in rejecting his representation dt.29.06.2020 submitted as per the directions of this
Court in W.P.No,l2996 of 2009 dt.22.06.2020, by way of proceedings
No.02lA3lKU/2021 dt.07.01.2021, though the petitioner is acquined in the criminal case in C.C.No.35 of 2012, as illegal and arbitrary and
consequently to set aside the proceedings of the respondent dt.07.01.2021 and to direct the respondent to regularize the services of the petitioner with all service and monetary benefits and other applicable
benefits and to pass such other order or orders.
2.
After hling of this Writ Petition, the petitioner died and his wife
was impleaded as-@ kgal representative as petitioner No.2 as per the orders of this Court dt.04.03 .2024 inI.A.No.l of 2024.
3.
Brief facts leading to the filing of the present Writ Petition are
that petitioner No. I was appointed and was working as a Telephone
W.P.Nc.l5065 of202l
Operator under the control of the Registrar of Kakatiya University. Subsequently, he was promoted as Senior Assistant in the year 1999, but
he continued 1.o work as Telephone Operator till February, 2004. On 25.11.2004, the respondent University issued a show-cause notice alleging that petitioner No.l herein embezzled funds of the University.
Petitioner No. I therefore requested the respondenl. to issue him the documents for making such allegation. However, the same were not
fumished to him and therefore, petitioner No.l filecl W.P.No.14410 of
2007 before this Court and the same was disposed of vde orders dt.06.07.2007 directing the respondent to fumish all relevant documents
to the petitioner within a period of two weeks from the date of the order
and further directed the disciplinary authority to look jnto those documents for the purpose of conducting enquinz into the matter. Flowever, the respondent, without conducting any enquiry, issued final show-cause notice and aggrieved by the same, petitioner No.l filed a
Writ Petition in W.P.No. I 6l 74 of 2008 to direct the respondent to give him proper opportunity of hearing. The said Writ Petition was disposed
of on 10.1 .2008 directing petitioner No. I herein to submit his
explanation within 30 days before the respondent. The petitioner No.l
submitted his explanation, but not sarisfied with the same, the
I
W.P.No.l5O65 of202l
respondent has passed the
order dt.Z6.tl.z}Ogremoving petitioner
herein from service. Simultaneously, criminal case against petitioner No.l Class Magistrate, Warangal under
No.l
the respondent had also filed
before vII Additionar Judicial
a
First
Sections 420,409,46g and 471 of
IPC and a charge sheet was filed
and the case was registered as
c'C'No'4 l g of 2012' ultimately, the
trial court has acquitted petitioner
No.l by judgmenr dt.26.l,l.2}l3 holding not guilty. Thereafter, peritioner
that petitioner No.l herein is
No.l has filed W.p.No. 12996 of 2009
questioning the action of the respondent
dt'26'r2'2009 dismissing peritioner recovery of Rs.4,25,l gg/_ from him
without giving opportunity to him.
for issuing the proceedings
No.l from service and also for
without conducting any enquiry and This court has disposed of the said
writ Petition by directing the authorities
to review the order of dismissal
by duly raking nore of the acquittal of
petitioner No.l from the criminal
case. Thereafter, petitioner No. I
claims to have submitted his
explanation dt.22.06.2020 and when thereon, petitioner No. I filed a
no orders have been passed
Contempt Case in C.C.No.9g6 of 20920
for non-compliance of the directions of pending disposal' Thereafter, the
Registrar of the respondent University
retired from service and the Executive
\
this Court and the same was
council has passed a resolution
W.P.No.l5065 of 2021
of petitioner No' dt.OT.Ol.2[zlrejecting the application
the present the same, petitioner No'l has hled
1' Aggrieved by
Writ Petition' The
Council has passed the impugned
petitioners submit that the Executive
petitioner thus violating the Court
order deciding the issue against the
orders and only to deny the petitioner retirement benefits and other benefits
No'l his pensionary and
to which petitioner No' I is entitled
of the impugned order' to and therefore, he sought setting aside to the respondent to pay him the dt.O7.Ol.2O2l and a direction pensionary benefits.
4.
Leamed counsel for the petitioners'
while reiterating the above
submitted submissions made in the writ aflidavit' departmental proceedings as well
that the charges'in the
as in the police complaint are
the same and he has filed a synopsis
one and
to substantiate the said submissions
andsubmittedthatwhenboththeproceedingsarebasedonidenticalset
offactsandevidence,thisisafitcasetosetasidetlrepenaltyirnposed judgments of the Hon'ble by the departmental enquiry as per the Supreme Court in the case of G'M'Tank
othersl which has reaffirmed the Supreme Court in the case of
' (ibool s scc ++o
Vs' State of Gujarat and
principles laid down by the Hon'ble
R'P'Kapur Vs' Union of tndia- ald / /
W.P.No. t 5065 of 2O2l
atrothef. He also placed reliance Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of Ram Lal Vs. State
and otherss ln support ofthe said
5.
upon the recent judgment of the
contentions
Leamed counsel for the respondent,
upon the averments made in the petitioner No. I had worked as
pointed out certain anomalies telephone bills and requested to
counter af,fidavit and submitted that
regarding the payment of University constitute a committee for verification
officer appointed to enquire into the
pointing out that there is prima
of embezzlement of University funds and inflating bills by petitioner No.
facie act
by way of fabricating, duplicating
l during the period between 2000
and 2O04 and therefore, a show-cause
notice was issued and the
of Rs.4,26,lgg/_ were also sought to be
recovered. It is submitted that when
petitioner No.l sought for supply of
documents on the basis of which University had informed him that the on any working day, but petitioner ' etR t96q sc zsz ' 2023 SCC Onl_ine SC I6 t8
2004
Fund Audit, Kakatiya University had
of telephone bills and the enquiry
embezzled funds to the tune
on the other hand, relied
a Telephone Operator till February,
and in the year 2004, the Local
same has submitted his report
of Rajasthan
the allegations were made, the
original documents can be perused
No. I did not respond and verifr the
W.P.No.l5065 of 2021
original documents. It is submitted that
the enquiry iniriated pursuant
the directions of this Court in W'P'No'14410 completed within the directed period cooperation from the 1't petitioner's
of 2007 could not be
of six months due to non-
end and after the time was extended
as by this Court, the enquiry was conducted
per the existing rules and
followed therefore, the required procedure was submitted that as per the decision of
its
show-cause notice dt'05'07'2008
was issued to petitioner No'l to submit should not be removed from service
by the respondent' It is
the Executi"" (6unci[ taken at
78ft meeting held on 30'06'2008' ltnal
his explanation as to why he
of the University besides recovery
of misappropriated funds and instead of submitting of 2008' petitioner No.1 has filed W'P'No'1 6174 Hon'ble High Court has therefore directed submit his explanation and it is only
his explanation'
It is submitted that the
petitioner No' I herein to
after considering his explanation
that that petitioner No' l was dismissed dt.22.l2.2OO8.It is submitted that
to
from service virle proceedings
there was nothing iltegat arrd irregular
about the order. As regards the acquittat case and whether it should be considered
of petitioner No l in criminal lor reconsideration of his case
for reinstatement, it is submitted that the independent of the disciplinary action
acquittal in criminal case is
which is civit in nature and is
a
W.P.No.l5065 of 2O2 t
based on principlos of substantive
€rs per the directions of this
evidence. Further, it is submitted that
Court in W.p.No.l2996 of 2009
dt.22.06.2020, petitioner No.l has submitted 29.06.2020 for awarding of revised pay
his representation on
scales, five increments including
ad hoc 8 years service completed, pensionary
benefits and other benefits
and that the same was placed before
the Executive council and in its
133'd meeting held on O5.Ol.ZO2l,
it was considered but rejected.
Therefore, according to him, there is
no reason for any interference by
this Court.
6.
At the time of hearing, the leamed counsel for the
taken an additional ground that petitioner No.
I was appointed by thg
orders of the Registrar of Kakatiya University Executive Council could not have passed
petitioners has
and therefore, the
the order of dismissal from
service and as per the Service Regulations
of the University, it is the
Registrar who can pass the order o[ dismissal
and not the Executive
Council. He placed reliance upon the powers
of the Registrar under
Chapter III of the Act - Officers of the
7.
University for this purpose.
Leamed Standing Counsel for the respondent
other hand, has fired a copy of the
University, on the
resorution of the Executive council,
wherein the Council had put up the resolution
before the Registrar who
w P.No.t5065 of 2021 E
has agreed with the proposal for the order of
removal from service and
Counsel' it was the
therefore, according to the leamed Standing Registrar who has passed the order and not the
Executive Council and
the Executive Council has only proposed the punishment'
8.
On merits, the Ieamed counsel for petitioner No'l
submitted that as part of the enquiry into the
has further
embezzlement of funds by
claiming false telephone bills, the Registrar has addressed BSNL to furnish the details of the phone numbers payment and authenticity ofduplicate bills issued
a letter to
covered under each
by their office and has
also enclosed the reply from BSNL dt'23'08'2004
stating that they are
fumishing the details of the phone numbers and
bills against which
payment was made in the enclosed statement and
that the information is
taken from their computer system and there are
differences between the
cheque amounts mentioned in the letter and this
could be for the reason
that the cheque numbers would have been wrongly and that no record of the lists received from the
fed in some cases
University end is readily
available and it is diffrcult to reconcile the differences
at the relevant
point of time. lt is submitted that even without seeking
and waiting for
the appropriate reply from the BSNL, the respondent
has taken action to
remove petitioner No.l from service on 26'12'20081'
He further relied
W.P.No.l5065 of202l
upon the powers and duties of university to submit that it is the
the Vice Chancellor of Kakatiya
Vice chanceror who sha, have power
to appoint, punistr, suspend or dismiss holding posts berow the rank of
an Administrative and Accounts
and when he exercises such powers, shall be entitled to prefer an
employees of the University
officer
the person punished or dismissed
appeal to the Syndicate within
90 days from
the date of serving the orders.
9'
Having regard to the rivar contentions
this court finds that the initial
jurisdiction of the Executive
objection of petitioner No.l is about
the
Council to pass the impugned order
of
removal from service, this Court
finds that under Kakatiya University
Act, 1976, the Vice Chancellor of conferred with the power of
Kakatiya University has been
appointment, punishment, suspension
dismissal of the employees of the
Telephone Operator, who was Assistan! but continued to work
or
University holding posts below the
rank of Administrative and Accounts
Officer. petitioner No. I is a
subsequently promoted as Senior
as Telephone Operator till 2004.
chapterlll of the Kakatiya university the Registrar of the University
and the materiar on record,
As per
Act, l976and section l2 thereof,
shall be a whore-time paid officer
University appointed by the Executive
of the
Council on such terms as may be I
W.P.No.l5065 of 202I
prescribed by the Statutes and shall
have the power to exercise such
other powers and discharge such other
duties as may be prescribed by
thestatutes.UnderSectionl5(2)tirereof,theRegistrarshallactasthe Secretary of the Executive Council
and Academic Senate and he shall
exercise such powers and perform such From the proceedings dt'28'01'1988
duties as may be prescribed'
and 15'03'1988 and the resolutions
passed in the meeting held on 01'02'1988'
Executive Councit are to be communicated
the decisions taken by the
by the Registrar on behalf of
the University. Therefore, this Court does
not find any illegality or
inegularity in passing of the orders by
the Executive Counci[ of
appointment or removal which are communicated Chancellor. The said objection of
by the Registrar/Vice
petitioner No'1 is therefore rejected'
10. However, as regards the merits of this case' this the fact-finding authority has found certain generated and paid by Kakatiya University was working as Telephone Operator during had sought information from BSNL'
Court finds that
discrepancies in the bills
and since petitioner No'l
the yeats 2002 to 2004' they
However' as rightly pointed out by
the leamed counsel fbr the petitioners, appropriate response from BSNL' but
they did not wilit ior the
have come to the conclusion that
petitioner No.l is responsible for the said
discrepancies and passed the
tt order of dismissal from service
from him. This Court also
and also sought to recover
finds that for the very same
criminal case has been fired
and after contested triar,
that the charges against petitioner petitioner No.l has been
ll.
set of facts, the
the triar court herd
honorably acquitted.
Vs. State of Gujarat and
of facts' criminal proceedings the acquittal in the criminal
reiterated by
in the case of Ram Lal Vs. State
Rajasthan and others (3 supra),
disciplinary proceedings as
Court in the case of G.M.Tank
others (l supra) which has been
the Hon'ble Supreme Court
identical set
and disciplinary proceedings
are initiated,
case would have to be considered
in the
well. For the purpose of ready reference,
reproduced as under:
if we examine the criminar
following factual posilion emerges. The very
wilnesses, who were examined etom i ned i n r he crimi nat
PL{/3, PW6, pI[/9 ond pWl3
; ;:::: ;:;; ^*:;::::'' Karan Sharma were examined pW2,
from them, eight other witnes oJ the charge i,
same
in tho ,t,,---,-^.-. -,
;::' ;#,r
Shravan Lal, Raj Singh ond
as
respectively at the criminal
triat. Apart
were also examined' The gravamen
m, "ri*) j jo,;;:;::,,:::,,-:;:::,,:;,,::::;:",:: tu^,*o,i)w, he, by making alteration in
of
when on the very same or
'23' Mth this above background, proceedings the
the amount
No.l have not been proved and
As herd by the Hon,ble Supreme
re.levant paragraphs are
W.P.No.15065 of 2O2l
his dare of birth tn rejlect the
some as
the
'W.P.No.15065 of 202 I
t2 to the
1974' dnd obtained recruitment appellant thc Trial Court convicted the
24.04.1972 in place of 21'04 post of Constable Though
under Section 420 of IPC' the
Appellate Court recorded
crucial findings while acquitting
the appcllant:
"MainLy the presenl case
was based on th e documents
this e.ffect whether the date
2104.1972 or 2l'04 1974 Mar ks heet ,lnw hic h. the date s
the following
to
of birth of accused is iso rtelnaL Exh. been
ofb irth of
hot ,n as 2l 04.197 2an ds
hos also been
be the v itnesses examt ned on
bv utton.
of
produced before the ll'ht ttcver the documents have been of 21'04'1974 are either Courr regarding the date of birth are Duplicate T'C' or
the letters of Principal or tr[arksheets. Neither the such origirtal docttments
prosecution has produced ary'' in the Subordinate Court to thi::
efftcr thttt when the admission form
of accused was fillecl'
by the accused in it' u,hal dare of birth was mentioned Register of School' what v,hat v'as the date of birth in Roll
dttte o.[ birth was mentioned by
accused in the
l:\a tmation Form of Secondary' and nor
afier bringin'q
concerned lt)itnesses' same thr: ,triginal records from the circumstance's' \r.ru gol proved in the evidence' In these date of birth of accused tltis fctcr becomes doubtful that to receive i{s uas 21.0'!.t974, arul accused is entitled
btnc./it. In the considered opinion
of this Court' the
ctvtt'iction made by the Ld Subordinate
Court merely on
rhe hosis oJ oral evidences and letters documenls' is not iusl and proper' llrc acctrsed
or duplicate
It is justiJiable to dcquil
I
r-
W.P.No. 15O65 of202l
Resultantly, on the basis of $oresaid consideratio4 the present appeal Jiled by the Appellant/Accused is liable to be allowed."
[Emphasis suppliedJ
24.
What is important to notice is that the Appellate Judge has
clearly recorded that in the document Exh. p_3 _ original marlcsheet
of
the 8th standard, the date of birth was clearly shown as 21.04.1972
and the other documents produced by the prosecution were either letters or a duplicate marksheet. No doubt, the Appellate Judge
says
that it becomes doubtfut whether the date of birth was 21.04. 1974
and that the accused was entitled to receive its benefit. However, whqt we
are supposed to see is the substance of the judgment. A reading
of the entire judgment clearly indicates that the appellant was acquitted after full considerdtion of the prosecution evidence and afier
that the prosecution has miserably
noticing
failed ro prove the charge [See S.
Samuthiram
25.
Expressions like ,,benefit of doubt,, and ,,honorably
acquitted", used in judgments are not to be underslood as magic incantations. A court of law will not be carried away by the
mere use
of such terminolog. In the present case, the Appellate Judge has recorded. that Exh. P-3, the original marksheet carries the
date of birth as 21.04.1972 and the same has also been provetl by the witnesses examined on behalf of the prosecution. The conclusion the acquittal in the criminal proceeding was after
that
full consideration of
the prosecution evidence and that the prosecution miserably
faited to prove the charge can only be affived at after a reading of the judgment in its entirely. The court in judicial review
is obliged to examine the substance of the judgment and not go by the __,, Jorm of nxpression used.
t4
26.
W.P.No.l 5065 of 2021
lfie are satisJied that the frndings of the appellate iudge in the
criminal case clearly indicate lhat the charge against the appellant was nol ju.tt, "not proved" - in fact the charge even stood "disproved"
by the very prosecution evidence. As held by this Court, a fact is said
to be "disproved" when, after considering the matters before it, the courl either believes that it does not exist or considers its fionexistence so probable that a prudent man ought, under the circumslances of the particular case, to act upon the supPosition that
it does not exist. A fact is said lo be "not proved" when it is neither "proved" nor "disproved" [See Wjayee Singh and Otlrcn w Stale of u.P. (1990) 3 SCC t90l
27.
We are atklirionally satisf ed that in the teeth of the finding of
the sppellate Judge, the disciplinary proceedings and the orders passed thereon cannot be allowed to stand. The charges were not iust
similar but itlenncal and the evidence, witnesses and circumstances were all lhe sume This is a case where in exercise oJ our discretion, we quash lhe orders of the disciplinory authority and the appellate
aurhoriry as allov,ing them to stand will be unjust, unfair and oppressive. This case is very similar to the situatio'1 that arose in G.M. Tank (supra).
12. In view thereof and in view of the acquittal of the petitioner from the criminal case, the order of dismissal from service dt'07 '01'2021 against petitioner No. I is ser aside and petitioners are entitled for consequential benefits
13. The Writ Petition is accordingly allowed. No order as to costs' -t""
a.
W.P.No.l5065 of 2021
l5 I
14.
i
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, in this
I
Writ petition shall
stand closed. I
i
Mondav' the Thirtieth Witness THE HON'BLE CHIEF JUSTICE ALOK ARADHE' Day of December two Thousand and Twenty Four
ASS //TRUE COPY// To,
SD/.T.JAYASREE NT REGISTRAR S CTION OFFICER
. The Registrar, Kakatiya University, Vidyaranyapuri' Warangal' Warangal District. T.S.
3:
Si:3i ls .'f#E[ni Bi]l?.ft$"4':'l?':"Y,tl Universitv, waransa,) toPUcl
TJ
4 . Two CD CoPies
BSK
q
k
/
HIGH COURT
DATED:3011212024
-2:a
/.,4.':-. {\.' /tl\'
ORDER
I
i,
r:
if- S l.\ {. -.
(
11 Frtil
2025
WP.No.15065 ot 2021 {1 IJ
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
f+ 1\
.v 2->
6 cPt'">
'.-r,.l c H r-O
*
.L\