MR. Keviletuo Yiese and 61 Ors v. The State of Nagaland and 7 Ors

Court
Gauhati High Court
Date of judgment
2 November 2026
Bench
Justice Susmita Phukan Khaund, Justice Yarenjungla Longkumer
Case number
Review.Pet. No. 4 of 2026
Result
Disposed Of
Acts & sections
Article 215 Constitution
Subject
Property & land

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

Page No.# 1/20 GAHC020006782026

2026:GAU-NL:596-DB

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) KOHIMA BENCH Case No. :

Review.Pet./4/2026

MR. KEVILETUO YIESE AND 61 ORS S/O LATE SATUO YIESE R/O SEIKHAZUO COLONY D KHEL NAGALAND. 2: MR. T. ZELUOLIE KIRE S/O DUOLIE KIRE R/O SEIKHAZOU D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 3: MR. KEZEVITUO KERETSU S/O LATE THEPFULE-U D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 4: MR. RUOKUOSATO KERETSU S/O KONHE KERETSU D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 5: MR. KHRIESAKUOLIE KIRE S/O LATE ZELHOULIE KIRE D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND

Page No.# 2/20 6: MR. NEILAZETUO KIRE S/O LATE KELUOKIELIE KIRE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 7: MR KENEILETUO KIRE S/O LATE NEILASAKUOLIE KIRE R/O LOWER SEIKHAZOU COLONY D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 8: MR. LHOULABEITUO KHEZHIE S/O LATE ZELHOULIE KHEZHIE D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 9: MR. MESEKHRIETUO KHEZHIE S/O LATE AVIU KHEZHIE D KHEL NAGALAND 10: MR. VIBEIZOTUO KEDITSU S/O VITSU KEDITSU D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 11: MR. PEKRUVOTSO KIRE S/O LATE VILHOUTSO KIRE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 12: MR. KEDUONEIU SACHU S/O LATE B.KHRIEZOTUO SACHU D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 13: MR DIETHOSELHOU SACHU S/O LATED SACHU

Page No.# 3/20 D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 14: ER. V NEIBA PIENYU S/O LATE KETSEIU PEINYU D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 15: MR RUOKUOVI KEDITSU S/O LATE NEILASAKUOLIE KIRE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 16: MR KENEILHOULIE KEDITSU S/O LATE NEINGULIE KEDITSU D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 17: MR. KO-O KEDITSU S/O LATE RHICHA R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 18: MR METSEI PIENYU S/O LATE KEMIERHU PIENYU R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 19: PIENYU CLAN REPRESENTED BY MR. METSEI PIENYU S/O KEMIERHU R/O D KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 20: DR. LHOUTSOULIE KUOTSU S/O LATE KUOLHOU R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D KHEL

Page No.# 4/20 NAGALAND 21: MR VITHALIETUO KIRE S/O LATE VILHOUTSO KIRE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 22: MR. RUOKUOSAZO SACHU R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 23: MR KIKRULHOULIE KHEZHIE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 24: MR. KEVINGUZHU KIRE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 25: MR KEDIINGULIE KERETSU R/O LIRIE COLONY KOHIMA NAGALAND 26: MR. MEDOKIETUO KERTSU R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 27: MR KERNEICHA PIENYU D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 28: MR. KELUONGUZO KERETSU D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND

Page No.# 5/20 29: MR. CHUPFULHOU KIRE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 30: MS NEITSEITUNUO KERETSU R/O BASAZOU D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 31: MR R.BEILIE SORHIE R/O KITSUBOZOU KOHIMA NAGALAND 32: MR KEKHRIENGULIE KHEZHIE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 33: MR. METHANEILIE SUOKHRIE R/O L-KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND NAGALAND KOHIMA 34: MR. NEISEVOTUO SORHIE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 35: DR. KEHOUSETUO KUOTSU R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 36: MR. RHEIZEZOLIE PIENYU R/O LOWER CHANDMARI COLONY KOHIMA NAGALAND 37: MR. THEJASETU KERETSU R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 38: MR. MIAZIEZOLIE KERETSU R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND

Page No.# 6/20

39: MR NEIKUOZO KIRE R/O NPHIECHA D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 40: MS NEIKETUOZONUO KHEZHIE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 41: MR VIZOVOTUO KEDITSU R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 42: MR RUOKUOVIU KIRE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 43: KITSUOWHELIE KHEZHIE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 44: MR. ZAKIEVOU SACHU R/O KOHIMA VILLAGE KOHIMA NAGALAND 45: MR. VISANYU KIRE R/O MISSION COMPOUND KOHIMA NAGALAND 46: MR SIETUO KIRE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 47: MR ALBERT KIRE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 48: MR NEISAKUOLIE KIRE R/O D. KHEL

Page No.# 7/20 KOHIMA NAGALAND 49: MR KETOUNEI KIRE R/O KIREPFURO CHIENUO D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 50: MR MEDOLEZO KIRE R/O FOREST COLONY NAGALAND KOHIMA 51: MR. VILASIELIE PIENYU R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 52: MR. SECHALIE KHEZHIE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 53: MR NEIKEYIE KHEZHIE R/O A.G. COLONY NAGALAND KOHIMA 54: MR ZHAVITO RHUTSO R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 55: MR. SAVITUO KHEZHIE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 56: MR RUOKUOBEIZO KIRE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 57: MS VIKEZELIE KHEZHIE R/O SEIKHAZOU COLONY D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND

Page No.# 8/20 58: MS KEVIRHEINUO KHEZHIE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 59: MS ZENEISEI-U KIRE R/O KITSUBOZOU COLONY NAGALAND KOHIMA 60: MR. VIPHRELIE KERETSU R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 61: MR KIKRUKHRIELIE KIRE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND 62: MR KEKHRIESETUO KIRE R/O D. KHEL KOHIMA NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 7 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY GOVT. OF NAGALAND 2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY/SECRETARY DEPT. OF LAND REVENUE AND RECORDS GOVT. OF NAGALAND KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY/SECRETARY (W AND H) DEPT. OF WORKS AND HOUSING GOVT. OF NAGALAND KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE CHIEF ENGINEER PWD (NATIONAL HIGHWAYS) GOVT. OF NAGALAND KOHIMA NAGALAND 5:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER KOHIMA NAGALAND

Page No.# 9/20 6:THE UNION OF INDIA THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS GOVT. OF INDIA TRANSPORT BHAWAN 1 PARLIAMENT STREET NEW DELHI-110001 7:THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (P) NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED R/O KOHIMA PWD REST HOUSE PWD COLONY NAGALAND 8:THE NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD. MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS GOVT. OF INDIA 3RD FLOOR PTI BUILDING 4 PARLIAMENT STREET NEW DELHI-110001 REPRESENTED BY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (P). THE NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD. RO KOHIMA PWD COLONY KOHIMA NAGALAND -----------Advocate for : A. ZHIMOMI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 7 ORS

Linked Case : Review.Pet./3/2026 MR. MEDOSELHOU KERETSU AND 30 ORS S/O LATE SIEVI KERETSU D KHEL NAGALAND 2: MR. T ABAO KIRE S/O DR. N.K. ANGAMI D KHEL DISTRICT

Page No.# 10/20 NAGALAND. 3: MR. RAZOUPFHELIE KIRE S/O LATE NEIHELHOU KIRE D KHEL NAGALAND 4: MR. VILASELIE KERETSU S/O LATE HELIE KERETSU D KHEL NAGALAND 5: MR. ZAYIEKIETUO S/O LATE WEZHU KIRE D KHEL NAGALAND 6: MR. POTHITA PHESAP S/O LATE VAMUZO D KHEL NAGALAND 7: MR. SELIEHU KIRE S/O LATE THEYIEKUOLIE KIRE D KHEL NAGALAND. 8: MR. KETOUNEI KIRE S/O LATE NEIHIE-O KIRE D KHEL NAGALAND 9: MR. THEYIESITUO S/O LATE ZNUOVILIE KUOTSU D KHEL

Page No.# 11/20 NAGALAND 10: DR. VIKETUOLIE PIENYU S/O MR. K. PIENYU R/O P. KHEL NAGALAND 11: MR. RUOKUOTUOLIE SORHIE S/O LATE VIYELHOU SORHIE R/O BAYAVU HILL NAGALAND 12: MR. RHEIZEZOLIE PIENYU S/O MR. K. PIENYU R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 13: MR. KHRIEKUOLIE SACHU S/O LATE TSOCHALIE SACHU R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 14: MR. ADIBOU SACHU S/O MR. KHRIEKUOLIE SACHU R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 15: MRS. ZENEISEIU KIRE S/O LATE ZAKIETUO KIRE R/O KITSUBOZOU NAGALAND 16: DR. KIKRUKUOLIE KIRE S/O LATE TSEILHOUZHU KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND

Page No.# 12/20 17: MR. MOSELIE KUOTSU S/O LATE LHOULETUO KUOTSU R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 18: MR. KHRIEKHETUO KIRE S/O LATE NEILAZOTUO KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 19: MR. KENEILETUO KIRE S/O LATE NEILASAKUOLIE KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 20: MR. SIETUO KIRE S/O LATE LALHOULIE KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 21: MR. ZETSEILIE KIRE (DECEASED) REPRESENTED BY HIS SON KEVISEDE KIRE R/O DAKLANE NAGALAND 22: MR. THEPFULAKUO SACHU S/O LATE KHRIEZOTUO SACHU R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 23: MR. KHRIEZOTUO SACHU (DECEASED) REPRESENTED BY HIS SON THEPFULAKUO SACHU R/O D KHEL NAGALAND

Page No.# 13/20

24: MR. LHOUKHRIETUO KHEZHIE S/O LATE KUOTHIE KHEZIE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 25: MR. KEKHRIELEZO KIRE S/O LATE KELHOUKHELIE KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 26: MR. VATSUMVU KIREKHA S/O LATE ZETSOVI KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 27: MR. ZIEBOU KIRE S/O LATE DR. N.K. ANGAMI R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 28: MR. KHRIEZOTUOLIE KIRE S/O LATE DZIESEVITUO KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 29: MR. KESOSIELIE SACHU S/O LATE ZIEKRO-O SACHU R/O D KHEL NAGALAND 30: MR. THEPFUNGUNYU YIESE S/O MR. NEILAKUOLIE YIESE R/O D KHEL

Page No.# 14/20 NAGALAND 31: MR. DZIESETUONYU KIRE S/O LATE VINGUTUO KIRE R/O D KHEL NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 6 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY GOVT. OF NAGALAND NAGALAND 2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY/ SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF LAND REVENUE AND RECORDS GOVT. OF NAGALAND NAGALAND 3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (NATIONAL HIGHWAYS) GOVT. OF NAGALAND NAGALAND 4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS GOVT. OF INDIA TRANSPORT BHAVAN 1 PARLIAMENT STREET NEW DELHI - 110001 6:THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (P) NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED R/O KOHIMA PWD REST HOUSE PWD COLONY NAGALAND.

Page No.# 15/20

7:THE CHAIRMAN DAPFHUTSUMIA COUNCIL KOHIMA VILLAGE NAGALAND REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN -----------Advocate for : A. ZHIMOMI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 6 ORS

BEFORE HON’BLE MRS. SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER Advocate for the Petitioner

: Mr. A. Zhimomi Ms. Esther Ms. Lhousino

Advocate for the Respondents

: Ms. V. Suokhrie Addl. AG Mr. A. Chusi.

Date on which judgment is reserved

: 15.10.2026

Date of pronouncement of judgment

: 03.11.2026

Whether the pronouncement is of the Operative part of the judgment ? Whether full judgment has been pronounced ?

: No : Yes

JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV) (Y.Longkumer,J)

By filing the instant Review Petition, the petitioners are praying for a limited review of the common judgment and order dated 05.06.2026 passed in W.A No. 7/2025 and W.A.No. 6/2025.

Page No.# 16/20

2.

Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner Mr. A. Zhimomi Also

heard Ms. V. Suokhrie, learned Addl. A.G. appearing for the State respondents and Mr. A. Chusi, learned counsel for the respondent number 5 and 6. 3.

The applicants herein as the writ petitioners had filed WP(C)

216/2021 and W.P.(C) 50/2022 claiming compensation for the acquisition of their land by the respondents. 4.

By a common judgment and order dated 29.11.2024, the learned

Single Judge had held that the petitioners/applicants are entitled to just and fair compensation for the acquisition of their lands in terms of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act of 2013 (herein after referred to as the Act of 2013). 5.

Aggrieved by the decision of the learned Single Judge, the State

respondents had filed W.A No. 7/2025 and W.A.No. 6/2025. By judgment and order dated 05.05.2026, this court had disposed of both the writ appeals, upholding the decision of the learned Single Judge that the applicants are entitled to just and fair compensation in terms of the Act of 2013. 6.

While disposing of the said appeals, this court discussed the

submission of the parties and made certain observations. It is the submission of the learned counsel for the applicant that the State respondents are construing the said observations to mean that the Nagaland Land Requisition and Acquisition Act 1965 (herein after referred to as the Act of 1965) applies in the State of Nagaland and not the Act of 2013.

Page No.# 17/20

7.

The learned counsel submits that in view of the observations of this

court in paragraphs 59, 60, and 64 of the judgment, the applicants herein are praying for review of the said judgment and order dated 05.06.2026. The learned counsel submits that at paragraph 59 of the judgment, this court had agreed with the judgment and order dated 29.11.2023 passed in WPC 236/2017, Repasosang Ao vr. State of Nagaland which was a judgment per incuriam. 8.

It is submitted that at paragraph 60 of the judgment also it was held

that there is no doubt that the Act of 2013 and the National Highways Act of 1956 has not been adopted by the State of Nagaland. The learned counsel submits that it was argued by the applicants before the Court that there is no need to adopt the National Highways Act 1956 and the Act of 2013 as by virtue of section 26 of the State of Nagaland Act of 1962, there was no necessity to adopt the same as they are already in force. However, this submission was not considered. 9.

As far as paragraph 64 of the judgment is concerned, the learned

counsel for the applicants submits that this court had relied on the case of Naeem Bano @ Gaindo vs Mohammad Rahfes & Anr in SLP(C) No.16460 of 2023 and therefore this Court ought to have held that by the principle of implied repeal, the Act of 1965 has been replaced by the Act of 2013. 10.

The learned counsel further submits that in view of the observations

made in paragraphs 59, 60, and 64 which are errors of law apparent on the face of records, the said judgment and order dated 05.06.2026 in WA No. 6/2025 and WA No. 7/2025 may be reviewed and it may be declared that the Act of 2013 is applicable in the State of Nagaland and the State

Page No.# 18/20

respondents may be directed to acquire the land of the applicants in accordance with the procedure prescribed by the Act of 2013. 11.

The learned Addl. A.G Ms. V. Suokhrie appearing for the State

respondents submits that the applicants have not been able to make out a case for review in the instant case in as much as the grounds for review of a judgment are very narrow and limited, and a review cannot be an appeal in disguise. She submits that a party may seek review of a judgment only on the ground of: (i) discovery of new and important matters which, despite the exercise of due diligence, was not within the applicant's knowledge or could not be produced when the judgment was passed, (ii) mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or (iii) any other sufficient reason. 12.

The learned Addl A.G. submits that the review jurisdiction is

corrective and not appellate. A judgment cannot be reviewed merely because another view on the facts or law is possible. The learned Addl. A.G therefore submits that there is no cause shown by the applicants in the instant review application for reviewing the judgment dated 05.06.2026, passed in WA No. 6/2025 and WA No. 7/2025. 13.

We have carefully considered the submissions of the learned counsel

for the review applicants and examined the pleadings as well as the judgment sought to be reviewed. 14.

This Court certainly has the power to review its judgments under

Article 226 read with Article 215 of the Constitution. The principles governing review are substantially similar to those applicable under Order 47 Rule 1 of the CPC.

Page No.# 19/20

15.

The Supreme Court has clarified in a catena of judgments that the

error apparent on the face of records must be self-evident and not one that requires a long drawn process of reasoning. The instances that may justify review depending on the circumstances may include: (i) An arithmetical or clerical mistake (ii) A patent error in applying a statutory provision (iii) An inadvertent omission to consider a material provision of law or a binding precedent where the omission results in a manifest error or (iv) A finding based on a clear factual mistake apparent from the record itself. 16.

Not every legal error, omission, or failure to discuss an argument

qualifies for review. The error must satisfy the restrictive test governing review jurisdiction. 17.

In the case of Kamlesh Verma v. Mayawati, reported in

(2013) 8 SCC 320, the Supreme Court held that a review is not maintainable on the following grounds: (i) Repetition of arguments already considered and rejected. (ii) A request to re-appreciate evidence or reassess the merits. (iii) The possibility of taking another view on the same facts or law and; (iv) An alleged erroneous decision that requires appellate reconsideration or a plea that the judgment ought to have been more elaborate or should have discussed every argument.

The Supreme Court emphasized that

review cannot be used to substitute one judicial view for another. 18.

Having considered the grounds on which the applicant is seeking

review of the judgment dated 05.06.2026, passed in WA No. 6/2025 and WA No. 7/2025, we are of the considered opinion that the grounds do not fulfill the requirements for a review. Only some clarification would be

Page No.# 20/20

required in the instant case, affirming the findings already arrived at by this Court in the said judgment sought to be reviewed. 19.

We hereby reiterate that the principle of implied repeal does not

necessarily render the entire earlier act inapplicable. The doctrine of harmonious construction may still be applied to permit the old act and the new act to coexist where there is no repugnancy. 20.

We therefore clarify that the Act of 1965 has not been replaced by

the Act of 2013 in the State of Nagaland. However, by applying the doctrine of harmonious construction, it is stated that this Court has made an endeavor to give effect to both the enactments without concluding that the earlier law has been repealed by implication. We hereby clarify that the acquisition process may be done in terms of the Act of 1965. However, just and fair compensation has to be made as per rates and quantification as provided under the Act of 2013 as it will be more beneficial to the landowners. 21.

In terms of the above clarification, the review applications are

disposed of.

JUDGE

JUDGE

Comparing Assistant

MEININGLUNGLIU GONMEI

Digitally signed by MEININGLUNGLIU GONMEI Date: 2026.11.03 15:42:34 +05'30'

Related judgments

More Gauhati High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.