Mr Venkatesh Kannappan v. The State of Karnataka

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
12 November 2026
Judge
Justice Suraj Govindaraj
Case number
CRL.P No. 11838 of 2025
Result
DISMISSED
Acts & sections
Section 318 BNS, Section 420 IPC
Subject
Criminal

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

-1HC-KAR

®

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 11838 OF 2025 (482(Cr.PC) / 528(BNSS)-) BETWEEN MR VENKATESH KANNAPPAN S/O SRI. KANNAPPAN RAMASAMI, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, RESIDING AT A-11, APPLE BLOCK, APPASWAMY ORCHIDS, 85-87, ARCOT ROAD, OPPOSITE TO AVM STUDIO, VADAPALANI, CHENNAI 600 026 ...PETITIONER (BY SRI: A. RAMESH., SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI. ATUL MADHAVAN., ADVOCATE) AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY PARAPPANA AGRAHARA P.S. REPRESENTED BY SPP, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT BUILDING, BENGALURU-560001. 2. MR. K. VENKATESH CHELLAM, S/O. MR. V.C. KRISHNA MURTHY, AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS, RESIDING AT NO.20, 2ND CROSS, PARAPPANNA AGRAHARA, BENGALURU-560 010 …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. RANJITH KUMAR N., HCGP FOR R1; SRI. ARUNA SHYAM., SR. COUNSEL FOR SRI. S. RAJU., ADVOCATE FOR R2)

-2HC-KAR

THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED U/S.482(FILED U/S.528 BNSS) CR.P.C BY PRAYING TO QUASH THE FIR (ANNEXURE-A) IN CR.NO.146/2025 IX ADDL. CHIEF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE, BENGALURU REGISTERED BY RESPONDENT NO.1 PARAPANNA AGRAHARA POLICE, FOR THE OFFENCES U/S.S 318(4),319(2),322,351(2),351(3) OF THE BNS, 2023 AND CONSEQUENTLY THE COMPLAINT (ANNEXURE-B) FILED BY RESPONDENT NO.2 AND ETC. THIS CRIMINAL PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS AND HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 13.10.2026, THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ

CAV ORDER

1.

The Petitioner is before this Court seeking for the following reliefs:

2.

i.

Quash the FIR (Annexure-A) in Cr.No.146/2025 IX Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate, bengaluru registered by Respondent no.1 Parapanna Agrahara Police, for the o/p/s 318(4), 319(2), 322, 351(2), 351(3) of the BNS, 2023 and consequently the complaint (Annexure-B) filed by Respondent no.2.

ii.

Pass any such other and further orders as this Hon’ble Court deems fit to grant under the facts and circumstances of the case, in the interest of justice and equity.

On a complaint being filed by Respondent No.2 on 12.05.2025, an FIR in Crime No.146 of 2025 came to be registered by the Parappana Agrahara Police Station on 15.05.2025 for offences under Sections

-3HC-KAR

318(4), 319(2), 322, 351(2) and 351(3) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Challenging the same, the Petitioner is before this Court seeking for the aforesaid reliefs. 3.

The submission of Sri.A.Ramesh., learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner is that: 3.1. The complaint has been filed only to give a criminal colour to a civil dispute to require this Court to intercede. 3.2. He submits that, according to the complaint, Respondent No.2 claims to be the absolute owner

and

property

in

peaceful

bearing

possession

No.584,

A-Block,

of

AECS

Layout, Kudlu Village, Sarjapura Hobli, Anekal Taluk, Bengaluru, measuring 2,400 sq. ft., which was purchased under a sale deed dated 28.03.2022 executed by Smt. Usha in his favour. 3.3. It is alleged that, as Respondent No.2 was required to travel frequently, he executed a General Power of Attorney (GPA) in favour of the Petitioner on 07.12.2022 to look after the property in his absence. Respondent No.2 is

-4HC-KAR

stated

to

have

cancelled

GPA

on

15.04.2025, caused a publication in two local newspapers on 22.04.2025 and informed the Petitioner of the cancellation on 23.04.2025. Despite

such

intimation,

Petitioner

is

alleged to have sold the property under a sale deed. Respondent No.2 claims to have learnt of the sale on 05.05.2025 and thereafter to have received threatening calls. 3.4. Learned Senior Counsel submits that, even if the allegations in the complaint are accepted as true, they concern the transfer of immovable property and arise out of a civil dispute. According

to

him,

allegations

do

not

disclose the ingredients of the offences alleged against the Petitioner. 3.5. He disputes the complainant's version and submits that it was, in fact, the Petitioner who funded

purchase

of

property.

Respondent No.2 had allegedly approached the Petitioner for financial assistance, representing that he was a contractor and would develop the property, thereby securing good returns for the Petitioner.

-5HC-KAR

3.6. Learned Senior Counsel submits that the emails and other correspondence placed on record demonstrate

that

Respondent

No.2

acknowledged that the funds for purchasing the property

were

provided

by

Petitioner.

Though Respondent No.2 paid the registration charges and stamp duty, those amounts were also reimbursed by the Petitioner. He further relies upon WhatsApp conversations between the parties which, according to him, establish Respondent

No.2's

acknowledgment

of

Petitioner's financial contribution. 3.7. He submits that the explanation that the GPA was executed merely to look after the property during Respondent No.2's travel is improbable. The property is situated in Bengaluru, whereas the Petitioner resides in Chennai. According to learned Senior Counsel, the GPA, which also conferred the power to sell, was executed to secure

property

Petitioner's

and

not

investment

merely

to

in

enable

Petitioner to look after it in Respondent No.2's absence.

-6HC-KAR

3.8. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that Respondent

No.2

failed

to

hand

over

developed project despite repeatedly assuring the Petitioner that he would do so. Instead, Respondent No.2 unilaterally cancelled the GPA, thereby jeopardising the Petitioner's interests. The Petitioner thereafter executed sale deeds in respect of the property and the development thereon at a lesser cost, which, according to him, also resulted in financial loss to the Petitioner. 3.9. On these facts, learned Senior Counsel submits that the execution of the sale deeds was an attempt to protect the Petitioner's investment and would not constitute an offence under Section 318 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS). He contends that the offence of cheating

requires

deception

and

dishonest

intention from the inception of the transaction. In the present case, the dealings between the parties commenced in 2022, with the Petitioner providing

funds

for

property,

construction

purchase

and

other

of

expenses.

Respondent No.2, on the other hand, did not pay any amount to the Petitioner. It is the

-7HC-KAR

Petitioner's case that Respondent No.2 has retained the benefit of the investment while cancelling the GPA and denying the Petitioner the benefit of the transaction. 3.10. He,

therefore,

submits

that

essential

ingredients of cheating, particularly dishonest intention at the inception of the transaction, are absent. The dispute concerning the cancellation of the GPA and the subsequent execution of the sale deeds cannot, in the circumstances, be converted into an offence under Section 318(4) of the BNS. 3.11. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the Petitioner had lodged a complaint against Respondent No.2, which was registered as Crime

No.96

of

2025.

Respondent

No.2

challenged the registration of the said criminal proceedings before the Madras High Court in Crl.O.P. No.18787 of 2025. The petition came to be dismissed. The challenge to that order before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP (Crl.) No.3004 of 2026 was also dismissed. 3.12. He points out that the Petitioner's complaint was

lodged

on

30.04.2025,

whereas

-8HC-KAR

complaint filed by Respondent No.2 was lodged subsequently, on 12.05.2025. He relies upon this sequence of events in support of his submission

that

complaint

filed

by

Respondent No.2 is a counterblast to the proceedings initiated by the Petitioner. 3.13. Learned

Senior

Counsel

also

submits

that

Respondent No.2 has filed O.S. No.620 of 2026 before the Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Anekal, Bengaluru Rural, seeking cancellation of the sale deeds executed by the Petitioner in favour of various persons, a declaration that the sale deeds are void ab initio, recovery of possession of the ten flats constructed on the property, mesne profits and permanent injunction. 3.14. In view of the Petitioner's complaint being under investigation and the civil suit filed by Respondent No.2 being pending, learned Senior Counsel submits that the dispute is essentially civil in nature and that the criminal complaint has been instituted only to give it a criminal colour. 3.15. On

aforesaid

grounds,

learned

Senior

Counsel submits that the criminal proceedings

-9HC-KAR

against the Petitioner are an abuse of the process of Court and that the petition is liable to be allowed. 4.

Sri.Aruna Shyam., learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent No.2 would submit that: 4.1. The property in question stands in the name of Respondent No.2 under a registered sale deed. The Petitioner's contention that he had funded the purchase of the property is disputed and is a matter requiring investigation. According to him, even assuming that the Petitioner had provided

funds

towards

purchase

or

development of the property, such financial contribution

would

not,

by

itself,

confer

ownership of the property upon the Petitioner or authorise him to deal with it contrary to the terms of the authority granted to him. 4.2. Learned

Senior

Counsel

submits

that

Respondent No.2 had executed a General Power of Attorney in favour of the Petitioner on 07.12.2022.

The

said

GPA

was,

however,

cancelled on 15.04.2025, and a registered deed of revocation was also executed on that date. Thereafter,

a

public

notice

notifying

- 10 HC-KAR

cancellation

was

published

in

two

local

newspapers on 22.04.2025. The Petitioner was also specifically informed of the cancellation on 23.04.2025. Thus, according to learned Senior Counsel, there can be no dispute, at least at this stage, that the Petitioner had notice of the revocation of the GPA before the subsequent sale transactions. 4.3. He further submits that, notwithstanding the cancellation of the GPA and the intimation thereof, the Petitioner proceeded on 05.05.2025 to execute sale deeds in favour of various purchasers

in

respect

of

ten

flats

constructed on the property, together with the corresponding ten car parking areas. The sale transactions were thus undertaken after the authority under which the Petitioner claims to have acted had been revoked and after such revocation had been communicated to him. Learned Senior Counsel contends that this circumstance is central to the complaint and cannot

be

disagreement

brushed

aside

concerning

investment between the parties.

as

a

accounts

mere or

- 11 HC-KAR

4.4. According

to

learned

Senior

Counsel,

Petitioner's assertion that he had funded the purchase and development of the property does not answer the specific allegation that he proceeded to execute the sale deeds after the revocation of the GPA. Whether the Petitioner actually provided the funds, the nature and extent of such funding, the purpose for which the GPA was executed, the rights conferred thereunder and the circumstances in which the Petitioner proceeded to execute the sale deeds are

all matters

during

which

investigation.

require

The

examination

Petitioner

cannot,

merely by relying upon the alleged financial contribution, claim an unrestricted right to deal with the property after the authority granted to him had been revoked. 4.5. Learned

Senior

Counsel

submits

that

allegations require the Investigating Officer to examine the registered sale deed under which Respondent No.2 acquired the property, the GPA executed in favour of the Petitioner, the registered deed of revocation, the public notice and the subsequent sale deeds executed by the Petitioner. The circumstances in which the sale

- 12 HC-KAR

deeds came to be executed, the purchasers in whose

favour

they

were

executed,

consideration received, the manner in which the sale

proceeds

were

dealt

with

and

Petitioner's knowledge of the revocation are all relevant aspects. These matters cannot be conclusively determined on the basis of the Petitioner's

interpretation

of

correspondence

and

transactions

financial

between the parties. 4.6. On these facts, learned Senior Counsel submits that

conduct

complaint discloses allegations of going

beyond

a

mere

breach

of

contractual or civil obligations. The allegation is not confined to a failure to account for the money allegedly invested by the Petitioner or to a disagreement regarding the development of the property. The specific allegation is that, after the revocation of the GPA had been communicated to him, the Petitioner proceeded to execute sale deeds in respect of the flats and car parking areas in favour of third parties. Whether this conduct attracts the offences alleged is a matter to be examined on the basis of the material collected during investigation. It

- 13 HC-KAR

would, therefore, be premature for this Court to accept

Petitioner's

explanation

and

terminate the investigation at its threshold. 4.7. Learned Senior Counsel also questions the Petitioner's contention that the dispute is purely civil in nature. He submits that the mere availability of civil remedies does not exclude the possibility of criminal liability where the allegations

independently

disclose

ingredients of an offence. 4.8. Respondent No.2 has instituted O.S. No.620 of 2026 seeking, among other reliefs, cancellation of the sale deeds executed by the Petitioner, a declaration that they are void ab initio, recovery of possession of the ten flats, mesne profits and permanent injunction. The pendency of the civil suit does not, according to him, prevent the jurisdictional

police

from

investigating

allegations concerning the Petitioner's conduct after the revocation of the GPA. 4.9. He

further

submits

that

contention

is

internally

Petitioner

has

himself

complaint

against

inconsistent. lodged

Respondent

Petitioner's

a

The

criminal

No.2,

which

- 14 HC-KAR

came to be registered as Crime No.96 of 2025, arising out of the very

same

transaction.

Respondent No.2 challenged the registration of those proceedings before the Madras High Court in Crl.O.P. No.18787 of 2025, and the petition was dismissed. The challenge to that order before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP (Crl.) No.3004 of 2026 was also dismissed. Having invoked the criminal process against Respondent No.2 in relation to the transaction, the Petitioner cannot, merely for the purpose of resisting the present complaint, contend that the dispute is exclusively civil in nature and that

no

criminal

investigation

can

be

undertaken against him. 4.10. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the fact that the Petitioner's complaint was lodged on 30.04.2025, before Respondent No.2 lodged the present complaint on 12.05.2025, does

not

by

itself

render

latter

a

counterblast. The sequence of complaints is only one circumstance and cannot, without examining

allegations

and

events

preceding them, determine the bona fides or otherwise of the complaint filed by Respondent

- 15 HC-KAR

No.2. The latter complaint specifically concerns the execution of the sale deeds after the cancellation of the GPA and the communication of such cancellation to the Petitioner. 4.11. Learned

Senior

Counsel

submits

that

Petitioner is seeking, at this stage, to rely upon his own version of the financial arrangements between the parties and to invite this Court to accept

that

sale

transactions

were

undertaken only to protect his investment. Such a defence involves disputed questions concerning

source

of

funds,

understanding between the parties, the scope of the GPA, the effect of its revocation and the circumstances surrounding the execution of the subsequent sale deeds. These questions require investigation and cannot be resolved merely by accepting the Petitioner's interpretation of the correspondence,

emails

and

WhatsApp

exchanges relied upon by him. 4.12. He, therefore, submits that the allegations in the complaint, particularly the execution of the sale deeds after the registered revocation of the GPA and after the Petitioner had been informed

- 16 HC-KAR

of such revocation, warrant investigation by the jurisdictional

police.

The

pendency

of

Petitioner's complaint, the civil suit filed by Respondent No.2 and the Petitioner's claim of having

funded

themselves,

property

do

not,

by

justify

quashing

present

proceedings. The investigation ought not to be interdicted at this stage. 4.13. On

aforesaid

Counsel

submits

grounds, that

learned

Senior

contention

that

Respondent No.2 has given a criminal colour to a civil dispute is untenable. He submits that the complaint

discloses

allegations

requiring

investigation and that the petition is liable to be dismissed.

5.

Heard Sri.A.Ramesh., learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner, and Sri.Aruna Shyam., learned Senior Counsel for Respondent No.2. Perused the papers.

6.

Though there are several decisions which have been relied upon by Sri.A.Ramesh., learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, they are not being adverted to, since most of the said citations relate to general

- 17 HC-KAR

principles, which would not be applicable to the peculiar facts and circumstances of this matter. 7.

The peculiar facts of the present case are that the Petitioner is stated to

be residing in Chennai.

Respondent

allegedly

No.2

had

approached

Petitioner at Chennai with an investment proposal. The Petitioner claims to have invested several crores of rupees towards the purchase of the property in Bengaluru in the name of Respondent No.2 and the subsequent construction of ten flats on the said property. 8.

The dispute appears to have arisen at the stage when the flats were to be handed over. The Petitioner contends that, upon cancellation of the General Power of Attorney, he proceeded to transfer the flats to third parties to safeguard his investment.

9.

Respondent No.2, on the other hand, claims that the property belongs to him, that the Petitioner was merely his power of attorney holder and that the Petitioner, despite being informed of the cancellation of the GPA, proceeded to sell the flats to third parties. On this basis, Respondent No.2 alleges commission of the offences referred to above.

- 18 HC-KAR

10.

It is also necessary to notice that the Petitioner lodged a criminal complaint on 30.04.2025. Though the complaint was lodged on that date, it came to be registered only on 28.05.2025 as Crime No.96 of 2025 for an offence under Section 420 of the IPC, corresponding to Section 318(4) of the BNS, 2023. Respondent No.2 lodged a complaint on 12.05.2025, which came to be registered on 15.05.2025 as Crime No.146 of 2025.

11.

Thus, both the Petitioner and Respondent No.2 have set the criminal law in motion against each other in respect of the very same transaction. It is relevant that Respondent No.2 challenged the registration of Crime No.96 of 2025 before the Madras High Court in Crl.O.P. No.18787 of 2025. The said petition was dismissed

on

07.10.2025,

permitting

investigation to proceed. The challenge to that order before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP (Crl.) No.3004 of 2026 was also dismissed on 23.02.2026, with

Hon'ble

Supreme

Court

declining

to

interfere. Consequently, investigation in Crime No.96 of 2025 is proceeding before the Chennai CCB, whereas further proceedings in Crime No.146 of 2025 have been stayed by this Court in the present petition.

- 19 HC-KAR

12.

The legal position concerning counter-complaints is well settled. A complaint by the opposite party setting out a rival version of the same transaction is not barred merely because an earlier FIR has already been registered. Where there are rival versions of the same

occurrence,

separate

complaints

may

be

registered and investigated. The two complaints in the present case are, on the face of the record, rival versions put forward by the parties to the same underlying transaction. The mere fact that the Petitioner's complaint was lodged earlier does not render

complaint

of

Respondent

No.2

impermissible. 13.

What requires consideration is the manner in which the two complaints are to be investigated. The allegations in both complaints are interlinked and concern the same investment arrangement, the purchase and development of the property, the execution and cancellation of the GPA, and the subsequent sale of the flats. The alleged dealings and financial arrangements extend between Chennai and Bengaluru.

Since

Chennai

CCB

is

already

investigating Crime No.96 of 2025, it would be appropriate for the connected allegations made by Respondent No.2 in Crime No.146 of 2025 also to be

- 20 HC-KAR

examined

in

police

Karnataka.

in

coordination with This

would

jurisdictional facilitate

a

comprehensive investigation of both versions and avoid inconsistent or uncoordinated investigations. 14.

The complaint lodged by Respondent No.2 has already resulted in the registration of Crime No.146 of 2025 in Karnataka. It is, therefore, not a case for registering a fresh FIR at Chennai. The competent police authorities of Karnataka and Tamil Nadu shall work out the necessary arrangements, in accordance with law, for the connected investigation to be undertaken by the Chennai CCB, with the assistance of the jurisdictional police in Karnataka wherever required. The two complaints shall nevertheless be examined as separate rival versions, and the merits of each shall be independently assessed.

15.

In the facts and circumstances of the present case, the complaint lodged by Respondent No.2 cannot be quashed merely on the ground that it gives a criminal colour to a civil dispute. The Petitioner himself has invoked the criminal process in respect of the very same transaction, and the challenge to the proceedings arising from his complaint has been rejected by the Madras High Court and the Hon'ble

- 21 HC-KAR

Supreme Court has declined to interfere with that order. The pendency of a civil suit concerning the property does not, by itself, exclude the possibility of criminal offences having been committed. Whether the allegations ultimately establish the ingredients of the offences alleged is a matter for investigation. At this stage, the complaint of Respondent No.2 cannot be interdicted on the grounds urged by the Petitioner. 16.

In that view of the matter, taking into account the peculiarity

of the facts, this

Court

passes the

following: ORDER

(i)

The Criminal Petition is dismissed.

(ii)

The interim order staying further proceedings in Crime No.146 of 2025, registered by Parappana Agrahara Police Station, Bengaluru, is hereby vacated.

(iii)

Having regard to the interconnection between the allegations in Crime No.96 of 2025, being investigated by the Chennai CCB, and Crime No.146 of 2025, registered in Karnataka, the Director General of Police, Karnataka, shall coordinate with the Director General of Police, Tamil Nadu, to facilitate an effective and coordinated investigation of both complaints, in accordance with law. 13/11/2026, 14:20, Bengaluru

- 22 HC-KAR

(iv)

The investigating agency in Crime No.146 of 2025 shall coordinate with the Chennai CCB, obtain relevant materials collected in Crime No.96 of 2025 and examine the allegations of Respondent No.2 in the light of the material available in both cases. The Chennai CCB shall extend necessary assistance and cooperation to the jurisdictional investigating agency in Karnataka.

(v)

Both complaints shall be treated as separate rival versions of the underlying transaction. The investigation in each case shall be conducted independently and impartially, without being influenced by the observations made in this order or by the mere fact that one complaint was lodged earlier than the other.

(vi)

All contentions of the parties on the merits of the allegations are kept open. Nothing stated in this order shall be construed as an expression of opinion on the guilt or innocence of either party.

(vii)

The investigation shall be conducted expeditiously and in accordance with law

This Court has been assisted by Ms. Harshada R.B., Law Clerk, in reviewing this judgement. 13/11/2026, 14:20, Bengaluru

(SURAJ GOVINDARAJ) JUDGE SR, List No.: 1 Sl No.: 62

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.