Mrs Sunanda Madtha v. Mr K Vasantha Shetty
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 30 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice K. V. Aravind
- Case number
- WP No. 27558 of 2026
- Result
- ALLOWED
- Acts & sections
- Article 227 Constitution
- Subject
- Civil
Full judgment
-1HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND WRIT PETITION NO. 27558 OF 2026 (GM-CPC) BETWEEN: 1.
MRS SUNANDA MADTHA W/O. PRABHAKAR RONI MENON AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS.
2.
MRS. POORNIMA JYOTHI D/O. PRABHAKAR RONI MENON, AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS.
3.
Digitally signed by VINUTHA B S Location: High Court of Karnataka
DIANA SAVITHA D/O. PRABHAKAR RONI MENON, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS, ALL ARE R/AT DOOR NO.6-18-730, MENON COMPOUND, NEAR SANGANIKETHANA MANNAGUDDA, MANGALURU - 575003(DK) ALL ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR G.P.A. HOLDER MR.ALWYN JAYAKAR MENON S/O. LATE. MR.DEVAPALAN MENON AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, R/AT MENON COMPOUND, NEAR SANGANIKETHANA MANNAGUDDA, MANGALURU - 575 003(DK). …PETITIONERS (BY SRI. M SUDHAKAR PAI., ADVOCATE) AND:
1.
MR K VASANTHA SHETTY S/O. RAMA SHETTY, AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS, R/AT RAMA KRIPA DOOR NO.6-18-725, NEAR SANGANIKETHANA
-2HC-KAR
MANNAGUDDA, MANGALURU - 575 003(DK). …RESPONDENT (BY SRI. K RAVISHANKAR., ADVOCATE) THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI, TO QUASH THE ORDER DTD-25.04.2026 ON I.A.NO.XIII IN O.S.NO.694/2021 ON THE FILE OF V ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC AT MANGALURU, D.K. VIDE ANNEXURE-H HEREIN AND ALSO ORDER DTD 21.07.2026 ON I.A.NO.XIV IN O.S.NO.694/2021 ON THE FILE OF V ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC AT MANGALURU, D.K. VIDE ANNEXURE-M HEREINB) ISSUE ANY OTHER WRIT, ORDER OR DIRECTION, AS THIS COURT DEEMS FIT TO GRANT, UNDER THE FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES OF THIS CASE, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY AND ETC. THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND
ORAL ORDER The
present
petition
impugns
order
dated
25.04.2026 rejecting the application filed in I.A. No. 13 under Order XXVI Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the order dated 21.07.2026 rejecting the application filed in I.A. No. 14 under Order XVIII Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, seeking recall of DW1 for further crossexamination.
-3HC-KAR
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that the suit is for a declaration that the defendant has encroached upon an extent of 0.32 cents, described as the Suit
Schedule-C
property.
It
is
contended
that
defendants have denied the alleged encroachment and that
appointment
of
a
Court
Commissioner
is
necessary to ascertain whether any encroachment has occurred and, if so, its extent.
3.
Learned counsel further submits that the application
seeking recall of DW1 for further cross-examination was filed in view of two documents sought to be confronted to
witness,
one
of
which
is
Exhibit
P33
in
O.S.No.660/2021, a certified copy of which was issued at the time of the examination of DW1.
4.
It is submitted that the Trial Court rejected the
application on hyper-technical grounds.
5.
Per
contra,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent submits that the Trial Court was justified in
-4HC-KAR
rejecting the application for appointment of a Court Commissioner, as such appointment would amount to collecting
evidence
on
behalf
of
plaintiff.
It
is
contended that, where encroachment is pleaded, the burden lies on the plaintiff to prove the same and that appointment of a Court Commissioner to establish the plaintiff’s case is impermissible.
6.
Learned counsel further submits that, on the date the
application seeking recall of DW1 was filed, the document sought to be confronted was already available with the petitioner and the suit was still at the stage of crossexamination of DW1.
7.
It is submitted that the application has been filed to
delay the proceedings and would cause hardship to the respondent.
8.
Considered the submissions made by learned counsel
for the parties and perused the impugned order.
-5HC-KAR
9.
The suit is instituted seeking a declaration that the
defendants
have
encroached
upon
'C'
Schedule
Property. The alleged encroachment is disputed by the defendants.
10.
The
Co-ordinate
Bench
of
this
Court,
in
W.P.No.201274/2022 dated 24.01.2023, has held that the appointment of a Court Commissioner is desirable where the dispute relates to boundary encroachment. It has further held that a Court Commissioner may be appointed even
during
Commissioner's
course
report
may
of
trial
assist
and
that
plaintiff
in
establishing the case.
11.
In view of the aforesaid legal position, the Trial Court
committed
an
error
in
rejecting
application
for
appointment of a Court Commissioner merely on the ground that such appointment would amount to collecting evidence.
-6HC-KAR
12.
The petitioner filed an application seeking recall of
DW1 for further cross-examination to mark the document at
Annexure-J,
which is
marked as
Exhibit
P33
in
O.S.No.660/2021. The said application was rejected on the ground that the petitioner had ample opportunity to mark the document, as it had been issued by the Court well before the closure of the cross-examination of DW1.
13.
A perusal of the dates on which the copy of the
document was issued and the cross-examination of DW1 was closed reveals that the interval between the two dates was
very
short.
No
doubt,
petitioner
had
an
opportunity to mark the document; however, having regard to the short interval, the bona fides of the application cannot be doubted. The petitioner's failure to mark the document ought not to result in undue hardship to the respondent.
-7HC-KAR
14.
However, in the present case, any hardship caused to
respondent
can
be
adequately
compensated
by
imposing costs. In view of the above, the following order:
ORDER i.
Writ Petition is allowed.
ii.
The order dated 25.04.2026 on I.A. No. 13 is hereby
set aside.
iii.
Application in I.A. No. 13 made under Order XXVI
Rule 9 is hereby allowed.
iv.
The Trial Court is directed to appoint a Court
Commissioner.
v.
Both the parties shall file their memoranda of
instructions accordingly before the trial Court.
vi.
Order dated 21.07.2026 on I.A. No. 14 is hereby set
aside.
-8HC-KAR
vii.
Application made under Order XVIII Rule 17 is
hereby allowed.
viii. DW1
is
hereby
recalled,
for
further
cross-
examination. The cross-examination shall be completed on the day when the date is fixed by the Trial Court, subject to payment of costs of Rs.10,000/- to DW1.
Sd/(K. V. ARAVIND) JUDGE
TIN List No.: 1 Sl No.: 19