Nagarbhavi Club (r) v. The State of Karnataka

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
6 October 2026
Judge
Justice Suraj Govindaraj
Case number
WP No. 15518 of 2026
Result
DISMISSED
Subject
Service, Tax & GST

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

-1HC-KAR

®

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ WRIT PETITION NO. 15518 OF 2026 (GM-KSR) BETWEEN NAGARBHAVI CLUB (R) C.A.NO.6/7, 10TH DIVISION, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BENGALURU - 560072, REPT. BY ITS PRESIDENT SRI. V. PRAKASH S/O LATE VENKATARAMAIAH, AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS ... PETITIONER (BY SRI. D.R. RAVISHANKAR., SR. COUNSEL FOR SRI. SARAVANA S., ADVOCATE) AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, CO-OPERATION DEPARTMENT, 6TH FLOOR, MULTI-STOREY, DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI, BENGALURU 560001. 2. REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, NO. 1, ALI ASKAR ROAD, BENGALURU - 560052. REPT.BY ITS SECRETARY. 3. DEPUTY REGISTRAR OF SOCIETIES, 1ST ZONE, BENGALURU URBAN DISTRICT, SAHAKARA SOUDHA, NO.1461, 1ST FLOOR, 3RD MAIN ROAD, MARGOSA ROAD MALLESWARAM, 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

-2HC-KAR

BENGALURU-560003. 4. ASSISTANT REGISTRAR OF SOCIETIES, 1ST ZONE, SAHAKARA SOUDHA NO.1461, 1ST FLOOR, 3RD MAIN ROAD, MARGOSA ROAD, MALLESWARAM BENGALURU-560003. 5. SHRI VENKATESH N., JOINT REGISTRAR (ICDP) OFFICE OF THE REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, BENGALURU, PRESENTLY APPOINTED AS ADMINISTRATOR OF NAGARABHAVI CLUB (REGISTERED), BENGALURU NO. 6/7, 10TH DIVISION, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BENGALURU-560072. …RESPONDENTS 6. DR. K C YATISH KUMAR S/O K. A. CHINNAPPA, AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS, R/AT: NO.39, 2ND CROSS, 10TH BLOCK, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1560. 7. LT. CDR. MADHAV T VITTAL (RETD) S/O GAYATHRI VITTAL. AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS R/AT: NO.330, 7TH CROSS, NGEF LAYOUT, NRUPATUNGA NAGAR, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1546. 8. SRI. K N PRASANNAKUMAR. S/O NINGAPPA AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS R/AT: 42-43, 13TH CROSS, PP. SBI BANK, MALAGALA, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BENGALURU-560091. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 680. 9. SRI. BHASKAR BANGALORE SRINIVAS. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

-3HC-KAR

C/O M SRINIVASA AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS R/AT: NO.82/1, PRADYOTHA, 13TH CROSS, JAYALAKSHMAMMA LAYOUT, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, PAPAREDDY PALYA, BENGALURU-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1295. 10.SRI. P KRISHNAMURTHY. S/O PARVATHAIAH. AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS R/AT: NO.35, CHETHAN KUTTER, OPP. BHAGAVAN LAW HOSTEL, KOTTEGE PALYA, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560091. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 446. 11.SRI. M B MAHESH AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS. R/AT: NO. 832, 5TH CROSS, 11TH BLOCK, NEAR TERIGE BHAVAN, NAGARBHAVI, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1308. 12.SRI. GOPI KRISHNA K S. S/O LATE. SANJEEVAIAH. AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS. R/AT: NO.227, 8TH MAIN ROAD, 9TH BLOCK, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1206. 13.SRI. H R ARVIND. S/O HN RANGARAJAN. AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS R/AT: NO.88, 9TH BLOCK, 12TH MAIN, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 250. 14.SRI. RAJANNA Y R S/O RANGASHAMAIAH AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS R/AT: NO.27, 2ND CROSS, 2ND MAIN, 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

-4HC-KAR

13TH BLOCK, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BENGALURU-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1632 15. SRI. B R SUSHIL KUMAR NAIDU C/O RAJGOPAL AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS R/AT: NO.195, 2ND G MAIN, 11TH BLOCK, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1378 16. SRI H M RAMESH S/O N MADEGOWDA AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS R/AT: NO.9 BELUKU, 2ND CROSS, 13TH BLOCK, APPROVA LAYOUT, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 860 17. SRI. CHANDRASHEKAR G S/O B.V GOPAL AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS R/AT NO.886, 9TH MAIN, 13TH CROSS, 13TH BLOCK, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 900 18. SRI. DHANANJAYA HS S/O H K SIDAPPA GOWDA AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS R/AT: NO.794, SAMRDHI, 11TH MAIN ROAD, 12TH CROSS, VINAYAKA LAYOUT, NAGARBHAVI, BANGALORE-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 605 19. SRI. MAHESH BALAIAH ASWATHAIYA S/O ASWATHAIYA BALAIAH AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS R/AT: 506, 9TH MAIN ROAD, ITI LAYOUT, 80 FEET ROAD, MALLATHAHALLI, BENGALURU-560056. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

-5HC-KAR

MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 801 20. SRI. SANTOSH NAGASUNDARAN SHROFF. S/O NAGASUNDARAN SV AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS R/AT: NO. 761, 3RD CROSS, 11TH BLOCK, NAGARBHAVI 2ND STAGE, BENGALURU-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 910 21. SRI. MURTHY NLN S/O G NANJAPPA AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS R/AT: NO.199, 2ND STAGE, 1ST BLOCK, NEAR BDA COMPLEX, NAGARBHAVI BENGALURU-560072. MEMBERSHIP NO. LM 1606. …. IMPLEADING RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. PRATHIMA HONNAPURA., AAG FOR R1 TO R5; SRI. C.M. DHANANJAYA., ADVOCATE FOR IMPLEADING R6 & R7; SRI. K.M. PRAKASH ADVOCATE FOR IMPLEADING RESPONDENT ON I.A.2/26) THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT, ORDER, OR DIRECTION, QUASHING AND SETTING ASIDE INQUIRY REPORT DATED 10.03.2026 IN NO.ARB-44/ KALAM-25-CR-2/2025-26 AS PER ANNEXURE-D, SUBMITTED BY THE INQUIRY OFFICER (ASSISTANT REGISTRAR OF COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES, 1ST ZONE). THE PROPOSAL/RECOMMENDATION DATED.23.03.2026 IN NO.DRB1/A.NE./101/2025-26 AND 27.03.2026/09.04.2026 IN NO. JUM.NI(ICDP)/SUM.SUM 02/31/2023-24, AS PER ANNEXURE-E AND E1, MADE BY RESPONDENT NO.2 AND 3 FOR APPOINTMENT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR. THE SHOW CAUSE NOTICE DATED 09.04.2026 VIDE NO. CO 82 CSR 2026, AS PER ANNEXURE-F ISSUED BY RESPONDENT NO.1 AND ETC.

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

-6HC-KAR

THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS AND HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 14.08.2026, THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ

CAV ORDER 1.

The Petitioner-Nagarbhavi Club is before this Court seeking for the following reliefs:

A. Issue a Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order, or direction, quashing and setting aside Inquiry Report dated. 10.03.2026 in No.ARB-44/ KALAM-25-CR-2/2025-26 as per Annexure-D, submitted by the Inquiry Officer (Assistant Registrar of Cooperative Societies, 1st Zone). The proposal/recommendation in dated. 23.03.2026 27.03.2026/09.04.2026 No.DRB1/A.Ne./101/2025-26 in No. and JUM.NI(ICDP)/SUM.SUM 02/31/2023-24, as per Annexure-E & E1, made by Respondent No.2 & 3 for appointment of an Administrator. The Show Cause Notice dated 09.04.2026 Vide No. CO 82 CSR 2026, as per Annexure-F, issued by Respondent No.1; A(i). Issue a Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction, quashing and setting aside the order dated 14.05.2026 passed by the 1st Respondent in No.C.O.82 CSR 2026[Ba.1] appointing 5TH Respondent as Administrator of the Petitioner-club as per Annexure-H; and

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

-7HC-KAR

B. Pass such other or further order(s) as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.

2.

The

Petitioner-Nagarbhavi

Club

is

a

Society

registered under the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’ for brevity) with over 2000 members. The said Club is stated to be in the advanced stages of completing its new club building, having mobilised funds through membership fees, donations, mortgage loans from Veerashaiva Co-operative Bank, and contributions from members. 3.

On 17.11.2025 and 10.01.2026, complaints were filed by two members of the club, namely Sri. K. Puttaswamy Gowda and Sri Hanumantharayappa, alleging certain irregularities in the functioning of the Club.

4.

By proceedings dated 09.12.2025, Respondent No. 3, Deputy Registrar of Societies, appointed Respondent No. 4, Assistant Registrar of Societies, as an Enquiry Officer under Section 25 of the Act to enquire into the allegations. The Enquiry Officer was directed to examine 30 specific allegations. In furtherance of this,

an

enquiry

report

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

was

submitted

on

-8HC-KAR

10.03.2026,

proposing

Administrator. The

appointment

of

an

State Government issued a

show cause notice on 09.04.2026 to the Petitioner. The

Petitioner

18.04.2026

submitted

rebutting

an

explanation

allegations.

It

on is

challenging the enquiry report, the recommendation for appointment of an Administrator and the issuance of a show cause notice that the Petitioner is before this Court. 5.

Sri.

D. R. Ravishankar, learned Senior Counsel

appearing for the Petitioner, would submit that: 5.1. The

complaints

had

been

filed

by

Sri.K.Puttaswamy Gowda, who is the President of the Congress Party Labour Wing and a BDA Member.

His

submission

is

that

said

complaints are politically motivated. He had harboured a personal vendetta against the Club because

he

had

failed

to

pay

full

membership fee of Rs.5,94,000/- and had paid only a sum of Rs.1,22,000/-. He alleges that Sri. K. Puttaswamy Gowda demanded a bribe from the Club to issue a Completion Certificate (CC) and Occupation Certificate (OC) from the BDA for the club building, which the Executive 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

-9HC-KAR

Committee refused. He had also demanded bribe money for the allotment of a second CA site to the Club. 5.2. In furtherance of which, the Club had initiated disciplinary action on 21.11.2025. It is known that the Club is going to initiate disciplinary proceedings;

he

had

filed

aforesaid

complaint on 17.11.2025 as a pre-emptive strike

to

shield

himself

from

disciplinary

proceedings. 5.3. His submission is that the Annual General Meeting held on 01.02.2026 was disrupted by non-members

and

politically

motivated

elements who forcibly occupied the stage, abused

office

bearers

and

prevented

meeting from proceeding as per the agenda. 5.4. The entire basis of the allegation is only to try and coerce the Club into making payment of bribe money. Since the Executive Committee of the Club had refused to make payment of the same, he has made use of his contacts in the official machinery for the Registrar to take up the matter under Section 25 of the Act. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 10 HC-KAR

5.5. His submission is that the allegations which have been made are as regards the regular internal functioning of the club. The accounts of the club are audited by auditors. The audit reports have been accepted by the Goods and Services Tax Department as well as the Income Tax Department. Those accounts having been accepted by those departments, the allegations are only to force and coerce, as well as harass, the administration of the Club. 5.6. He submits that on receipt of the enquiry notice,

hearings

held

on

20.01.2026,

04.02.2026, 18.02.2026 and 04.03.2026, the Petitioner had submitted explanations along with documents, which were not accepted by the Enquiry Officer. The Enquiry Officer has acted

contrary

to

procedure

and

has

conducted the enquiry in a grossly unfair, biased and prejudicial manner, resulting in the submission of a report which is perverse and unsustainable. 5.7. He submits that on 04.02.2026, the President, Vice-President, Secretary, Joint Secretary and Executive Committee Members appeared before 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 11 HC-KAR

the Enquiry Officer and submitted a detailed 11-page explanation along with approximately 400 pages of supporting documents, which was refused to be accepted by the Enquiry Officer without

assigning

any

reason.

These

documents, not having been accepted and taken on record, have been deliberately omitted in the enquiry report. 5.8. His submission is that if these documents had been accepted, the question of the enquiry report being submitted as it was done would not arise. 5.9. On 04.03.2026, the Secretary and Treasurer appeared and submitted written replies to the allegations with approximately 1350 pages of documents, which were also not accepted by the Enquiry Officer. Those documents not being accepted were also not part of the enquiry report. During the course of the enquiry, not only the enquiry officer but also several other persons who were present were neither officers of the concerned Department nor members of

Club.

The

enquiry

proceedings

were

conducted in an atmosphere of intimidation and 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 12 HC-KAR

coercion, including a fear of physical violence against the office bearers of the Club. 5.10. His submission is that these entire proceedings have been recorded through CCTV, as well as photographs taken, which would establish that the persons who were present during the enquiry had no business to be present for such an

enquiry.

The

enquiry officer

had

been

instructed to enquire into 30 specific allegations as raised by the aforesaid person. The enquiry officer has acted as a mouthpiece of the complainants, refusing to consider any defence material and has proceeded to record a onesided, predetermined conclusion. He reiterates that the entire proceedings of the enquiry were illegal, arbitrary, mala fide and violative of the principle of natural justice. 5.11. His submission is that more than 1700 pages of material, including the first-time run of 400 pages and the second-time run of 1350 pages, were not considered by the Enquiry Officer. The Enquiry Officer has acted under the influence of the complainants. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 13 HC-KAR

5.12. The

other

complainant,

Mr

Hanumantharayappa, is a retired Additional Registrar of Societies who has used his good offices during the course of the enquiry to get a biased report submitted against the Club. 5.13. He submits that during the pendency of the above writ petition, Respondent No.1, vide order dated 14.05.2026, has appointed the Joint Registrar as an Administrator for a period of six months. Relying on the enquiry report and the proposals which are under challenge in this writ petition, his submission is that the State

ought

not

to

have

appointed

an

Administrator when this Court was seized of the earlier proceedings. 5.14. The State, vide its order dated 14.05.2026, has held that the AGM for the year 2024-25 was not conducted legally, audit approval for the year 2025-26

was

not

obtained

and

that

Petitioner-Club has failed to address or rebut the 30 charges framed. 5.15. His submission is that, having been called on 01.02.2026, the meeting was disrupted by the complainants and their men, who are not even 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 14 HC-KAR

members of the club. Hence, the contention that the Petitioner-Club did not conduct a proper meeting is negated by the documents on record. 5.16. Insofar as the audit reports are concerned, he submits that they have been regularly filed with the statutory Authorities, including the Income Tax Department and the GST Department, which the State has not considered. The order of the State dated 14.05.2026 is a nonspeaking order, a cryptic order, mechanically reproducing

enquiry

report

without

application of mind. As such, he submits that the same is contrary to Section 27-A(1)(c) of the KSR Act. He refers to Section 27 -A of the KSR Act, which is reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 27A. Appointment of Administrator.Notwithstanding anything in this Act,— (1)(a) where any society on account of the pendency of litigation or otherwise has not held or is unable to hold the annual general meeting; or (b) where the term of office of the members of the governing body of a society has expired and a new 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 15 HC-KAR

governing body has not for any reason been constituted; or (c) where on a report made by the Registrar or otherwise, on enquiry, the State Government considers it necessary in public interest so to do, the State Government may, by order published in the official Gazette, appoint an Administrator for such society for such period, not exceeding six months, as may be specified in the order, to manage the affairs of the society: Provided that for reasons to be recorded in writing, the State Government may, by like order, extend either prospectively or retrospectively, the said period by any further periods not exceeding six months at a time, so however subject to the provisions of clause (5), the aggregate period shall not extend beyond four years; (2) the expenditure incurred by the State Government towards the salary and allowances of the Administrator shall be paid to the State Government from out of the funds of the society; (3) on the appointment of the Administrator under clause (1) and during the period of such appointment the governing body of the society shall cease to exercise any powers and perform and discharge any functions or duties conferred or imposed on it by this Act, or its memorandum of association or the rules and regulations or any other law and subject to any directions which the State Government, may from time to time issue, all such functions or duties shall be performed or discharged by the Administrator; (4) the Administrator shall, before the expiry of the period of his appointment take necessary action to convene the general body meeting of the society and hold elections for the constitution of the governing body;

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 16 HC-KAR

(5) if the Administrator is not, for reasons beyond his control, able to convene the general body meeting or inspite of such meeting being convened, the general body fails to elect the governing body, the Administrator shall forthwith send a report to the State Government, who may pass such orders as are considered necessary, either extending the period of appointment of the Administrator for a further period or if satisfied that public interest so requires, for the dissolution of the society; (5A) the State Government may, if it thinks fit, appoint an Advisory Council to advise and assist the administrator appointed under sub-Section (1) in the exercise of the powers and performance and discharge of the duties and functions conferred or imposed on him under this Act. The members of the Advisory Council shall hold office during the pleasure of the State Government. (6) where an order of dissolution is passed under subSection (5) the assets of the society shall vest in and the liabilities shall devolve on the State Government.

5.17. By relying on Section 27-A of the KSR Act, he submits that Section 27 confers a specific statutory power upon the State Government to appoint an Administrator and that such power can be exercised only when one or more of the contingencies

expressly

contemplated

under

sub-Section (1)(a), (b) or (c) is satisfied. The Registrar

or

Enquiry

Officer

does

not

possess an independent power to appoint an Administrator under Section 27-A. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 17 HC-KAR

5.18. He submits that the three clauses contained in Section

27-A(1)

contemplate

different

circumstances in which the State Government may

intervene

in

management

of

a

registered Society. Clause (a) relates to a situation where the Society has not held, or is unable to hold, its Annual General Meeting on account of pending litigation or otherwise; Clause (b) relates to expiry of the term of office of the governing body without constitution of a new governing body; and Clause (c) relates to a situation where, on a report made by the Registrar or otherwise, and upon enquiry, the State Government considers it necessary in the public interest to appoint an Administrator. 5.19. His submission is that the requirement of an enquiry is not confined only to Clause (c) of Section 27-A(1), but extends to all three contingencies contemplated under Clauses (a), (b) and (c). According to him, the expression “on enquiry” occurring in Section 27-A(1) has to

be

understood

in

context

of

substantive power conferred upon the State Government to appoint an Administrator and the serious consequences flowing from such 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 18 HC-KAR

appointment. The State Government, being the authority

empowered

to

displace

duly

constituted governing body and vest its powers and

functions

in

an

Administrator,

cannot

exercise such power mechanically or merely upon the assertion that one or the other circumstance contemplated under the provision exists. 5.20. He submits that although Clauses (a), (b) and (c) identify different circumstances in which appointment of an Administrator may become necessary,

satisfaction

of

State

Government regarding the existence of the relevant circumstances must necessarily be based upon an appropriate enquiry into the facts. In his submission, the distinction between the three clauses relates to the nature of the circumstances which may warrant intervention, and not to the requirement that the State Government

must

satisfy

itself,

upon

an

enquiry, that intervention by appointment of an Administrator is warranted in the circumstances of the case. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 19 HC-KAR

5.21. According

to

him,

Clause

(a)

concerns

a

situation where the Society has not held, or is unable to hold, its Annual General Meeting due to litigation or otherwise; Clause (b) concerns a situation where the term of the governing body has expired and a new governing body has not been constituted; and Clause (c) concerns a situation where, on the basis of a report of the Registrar or otherwise, the State Government, upon

enquiry,

considers

such

appointment

necessary in public interest. His submission is that, notwithstanding the difference in the factual circumstances contemplated under the three clauses, the State Government must first ascertain whether the foundational facts exist and

whether

Administrator

is

appointment

actually

of

warranted

an

before

exercising the power under Section 27-A. 5.22. He submits that the requirement of enquiry assumes

greater

significance

because

appointment of an Administrator under Section 27-A has the effect of bringing the functioning of the elected governing body to an end. Under Section

27-A(3),

upon

appointment

of

an

Administrator, the governing body ceases to 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 20 HC-KAR

exercise its powers and functions and the Administrator

assumes

those

powers

and

functions, subject to the directions of the State Government.

Thus,

according

to

him,

statutory power is not merely administrative or ministerial in character, but directly affects the constitution and functioning of the Society and the rights of its elected governing body. 5.23. His submission is that the State Government cannot, therefore, proceed on the basis of a mere

allegation,

assumption

or

unverified

assertion regarding the existence of any of the circumstances under Section 27-A(1). It must examine the relevant records and material, ascertain

factual

position,

afford

concerned Society a reasonable opportunity to place its case, consider the explanation and material produced by it, and thereafter arrive at an independent satisfaction as to whether the statutory conditions for appointment of an Administrator stand established. 5.24. His submission is further that, where the State Government proposes to act under Clause (a), he submits that the State Government must 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 21 HC-KAR

ascertain whether the Society had in fact failed to hold its Annual General Meeting or was unable to hold the same and, more importantly, whether the circumstances relied upon fell within

statutory

expression

“due

to

litigation or otherwise.” According to him, the existence of a dispute or difficulty by itself cannot result in automatic appointment of an Administrator without the State Government examining

factual

circumstances

and

satisfying itself that the statutory contingency contemplated by Clause (a) is made out. 5.25. Likewise, in relation to the ground in Clause (b) that the term of the governing body has expired and a new governing body has not been constituted, it must ascertain whether the governing body's term had in fact expired, whether a new governing body had actually not been constituted,

and

whether

factual

circumstances relied upon for invoking Clause (b)

existed

on

relevant

date.

In

his

submission, these facts cannot be presumed and must be determined upon an appropriate enquiry into the records and circumstances of the Society. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 22 HC-KAR

5.26. He further submits that, where the proposed appointment is founded upon a report of the Registrar or an Enquiry Officer in terms of Clause (c), such report cannot be treated as conclusive

or

as

automatically

resulting

in

appointment of an Administrator. The report, according to him, constitutes only material before

Government

State is

Government.

required

to

The

State

independently

examine the report, the material upon which it is founded, the objections or explanation of the Society and the circumstances emerging from the record, and thereafter take its own decision under Section 27-A. 5.27. He submits that this requirement cannot be diluted merely because the Registrar or an authorised person has already conducted an enquiry under Section 25 of the Act. According to him, an enquiry under Section 25 and the exercise of power by the State Government under Section 27-A operate at different stages and serve different purposes. The former is an enquiry into

constitution,

working and

financial condition of the Society, whereas the latter involves the exercise of the statutory 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 23 HC-KAR

power

of

appointing

an

Administrator.

Consequently, the State Government cannot abdicate its statutory responsibility by merely adopting the findings or recommendation of the Registrar or the Enquiry Officer. 5.28. He submits that the requirement of an enquiry is also consistent with the scheme of Section 27-A as a whole. The provision contemplates appointment of an Administrator only for a specified and limited period, requires reasons to be recorded in writing, and casts an obligation upon the Administrator to convene the general body and conduct elections before expiry of the period of administration. According to him, these

safeguards

demonstrate

that

administration by an Administrator is intended to be an exceptional and temporary measure and not a substitute for the elected governing body. 5.29. He

therefore

submits

that,

irrespective

of

whether the State Government invokes Clause (a),

Clause

(b)

or

Clause

(c),

it

must

independently ascertain the existence of the circumstances relied upon and apply its mind to 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 24 HC-KAR

the necessity of appointing an Administrator. Where the proposed action is based upon allegations

of

irregularities

mismanagement,

or

other

financial

adverse

findings

emerging from a Section 25 enquiry, such consideration

must

necessarily

include

furnishing the relevant material to the Society, considering its explanation and objections, and arriving at an independent satisfaction on the material available. 5.30. His specific grievance, therefore, is that the impugned action cannot be sustained if the State Government has merely acted upon the report

or

recommendation

of

Registrar/Enquiry Officer without undertaking the requisite enquiry and without independently satisfying

itself

Administrator

that

was

appointment

warranted

of

an

under

particular clause of Section 27-A(1) invoked in the impugned order. According to him, the statutory power under Section 27-A is vested in the State Government alone, and that power must be exercised upon due application of mind to the statutory conditions and the material placed before it. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 25 HC-KAR

5.31. His submission, however, is that the expression “on enquiry” occurring in Clause (c) cannot be read in isolation from the opening words of Section 27-A(1) or from the scheme of the provision as a whole. According to him, before the State Government exercises the power of appointing an Administrator, it is required to ascertain warrant

whether such

statutory

intervention

and,

conditions where

appointment is founded upon allegations of irregularity

or

mismanagement,

Government

must

undertake

State

requisite

enquiry and arrive at the necessary satisfaction regarding the public interest involved in all three circumstances. 5.32. He submits that the powers under Section 27-A can be exercised by the government only if it is satisfied

that

in

public

interest

it

is

necessary or expedient that an administrator is appointed,

that

such

administrator

be

appointed. His submission is not the interest of members inter se who are governed by the byelaws of the Society, which is a contractual arrangement. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 26 HC-KAR

5.33. If at all the complainants had any issue as regards the functioning of the Society, it was for the complainant to approach the Civil Court of competent

jurisdiction

remedies,

not

to

seeking

involve

suitable

official

Respondents in the matter. The complainants had involved the official Respondents because the official Respondents were to assist the complainants,

which

has

been

filed.

On

assessment, they ought to have arrived at a conclusion that the disputes are a private lis between the parties in which the optional machinery cannot be put into motion under Section 25 of the KSR Act, which is reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 25. Enquiry by the Registrar, etc.(1) The Registrar may on his own motion and shall on the application of the majority of the members of the governing body or of not less than one-third of the members of the society, hold an enquiry or direct some person authorised by him by order in writing in accordance with the rules made in this behalf to hold an enquiry into the constitution, working and financial condition of a registered society.

(2) The Registrar or the person authorised by him under subSection (1) shall have the following powers, namely,— (a) he shall, at all reasonable times, have free access to the books, accounts, documents, securities, cash and other 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 27 HC-KAR

properties belonging to or in the custody of the society and may summon any person in possession or responsible for the custody of any such books, accounts, documents securities, cash or other properties to produce the same at any place at the headquarters of the society or any branch thereof; (b) he may summon any person who, he has reason to believe, has knowledge of any of the affairs of the society to appear before him at any place at the headquarters of the society or any branch thereof and may examine such person on oath; (c) (i) he may, notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any rule or regulation prescribing the period of notice for a general meeting of the society, require the governing body of the society to call a general meeting at such time and place at the headquarters of the society or any branch thereof and to determine such matters as may be directed by him. If the governing body of the society refuses or fails to call a meeting, he shall have power to call it himself; (ii) any meeting called under sub-clause (i) shall have all the powers of a general meeting called under the rules or regulations of the society and its proceedings shall be regulated by such rules or regulations; (iii) when an enquiry is made under this Section, the Registrar shall communicate the result of the enquiry to the society concerned.

5.34. By referring to Section 25 he submits that it contemplates a structured statutory enquiry into the constitution, working and financial condition of a registered Society. The Registrar may conduct such enquiry himself or, by an order in writing, authorise another person to conduct the enquiry in accordance with the 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 28 HC-KAR

Rules. The enquiry, therefore, is not an informal fact-finding exercise, but a statutory proceeding governed by the Act and the Rules. 5.35. He submits that the expression “constitution, working and financial condition” occurring in Section 25(1) is only restricted to the manner in

which

Society

is

constituted

and

governed, the functioning of its governing body, compliance with its bye-laws, maintenance and utilisation of its funds of the Society. 5.36. He further submits that Section 25(2) confers significant statutory powers upon the Registrar or the person authorised by him for the effective conduct of the enquiry. These include access to the books, accounts and documents of the Society, power to summon persons having custody of such records and power to summon

and

examine

persons

having

knowledge of the affairs of the Society. 5.37. According to him, the conferment of such extensive powers necessarily carries with it a corresponding obligation to conduct the enquiry fairly and in accordance with the procedure prescribed

under

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

Act

and

Rules.

The

- 29 HC-KAR

enquiry cannot be reduced to a unilateral collection without

of

material

affording

against

Society

Society

an

effective

opportunity to explain the material relied upon against it. 5.38. He submits that this requirement is further reinforced

by

Section

25(2)(c)(iii),

which

expressly provides that, when an enquiry is made under Section 25, the Registrar shall communicate the result of the enquiry to the Society concerned. The statutory requirement of communication is intended to ensure that the Society is made aware of the findings reached in the enquiry and is not kept unaware of the conclusions drawn against it. 5.39. His submission is that the requirement to communicate the result of the enquiry cannot be treated as an empty or ministerial formality, particularly

where

enquiry

report

is

subsequently proposed to be relied upon for taking consequential action against the Society or its governing body. Communication of the result enables the Society to know the findings recorded against it and to avail itself of such 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 30 HC-KAR

remedies or opportunities as may be available to it in law. 5.40. His submission is that the person authorised by the Registrar under Section 25(1) does not acquire an independent statutory power beyond the authority delegated to him. He conducts the enquiry on behalf of the Registrar and in accordance with the Act and Rules. The findings emerging

from

such

enquiry

therefore

constitute the result of a statutory enquiry and cannot,

merely

because

they

have

been

recorded by an authorised Enquiry Officer, be treated as the final decision of the competent authority. 5.41. He

further

submits

that

statutory

requirement under Section 25(2)(c)(iii) is cast in mandatory terms, namely that the Registrar “shall communicate the result of the enquiry to

society

expression

concerned.” “shall”,

The

according

use

of

to

him,

demonstrates that communication of the result is not discretionary. 5.42. His submission is that where the enquiry report contains

adverse

findings

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

which

are

- 31 HC-KAR

subsequently relied upon for recommending or appointing an Administrator, the communication of the result must be meaningful and effective. The Society should be made aware of the findings and conclusions which are proposed to be acted upon, so that it is not deprived of an opportunity to contest the factual basis of the proposed consequential action. 5.43. He submits that the requirement under Section 25(2)(c)(iii) is independent of the opportunity that may have been afforded to the Society during the course of the enquiry. Participation in the enquiry and communication of the result of

completed

enquiry

serve

different

purposes. The former enables the Society to participate in the fact-finding process, whereas the latter enables it to know the ultimate findings

recorded

upon

completion of that

process. 5.44. He further submits that the requirement of communication becomes particularly material where the Enquiry Officer records findings adverse to the Society despite the explanation or documents placed by it. Unless the result of 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 32 HC-KAR

the enquiry is communicated, the Society would have no effective means of knowing whether its explanation was accepted, rejected or ignored and on what basis the adverse findings were arrived at. 5.45. The

fact

that

opportunity

during

Society

was

enquiry

given

an

before

Registrar does not dispense with the obligation of the State Government, while exercising the power under Section 27-A(1)(c), to afford the Society

an

opportunity

before

taking

consequential decision. 5.46. In the present case, therefore, his submission is that the Court is required to examine whether the statutory procedure under Section 25 was duly followed; whether the Petitioner-Club was afforded an effective opportunity during the enquiry; whether the material and documents produced by it were received and considered; whether the findings of the Enquiry Officer were duly

recorded;

whether

result

of

enquiry was communicated to the Club as required

under

thereafter,

Section

whether

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

25(2)(c)(iii); State

and,

Government

- 33 HC-KAR

independently considered the matter before exercising its power under Section 27-A. 5.47. He submits that if the enquiry report was not communicated to the Petitioner-Club, the Club was deprived of an opportunity to know the findings recorded against it and to effectively challenge

same

before

competent

authority. Such non-communication, particularly where the report constitutes the basis for appointment

of

an

Administrator,

would

constitute a violation of the statutory procedure prescribed under Section 25. 5.48. He

accordingly

submits

that

statutory

scheme does not permit the authorities to proceed directly from an enquiry report to appointment complying

of

an

Administrator

with

intervening

without

safeguards

prescribed by law. The Registrar's enquiry, communication of its result and the State Government's independent consideration are distinct

stages,

each

having

submits

that,

a

separate

statutory purpose. 5.49. He

therefore

where

appointment of an Administrator is founded 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 34 HC-KAR

upon the report of an enquiry under Section 25 and the requirements relating to conduct and communication of the enquiry result have not been complied with, the consequential order under Section 27-A cannot be sustained. The defect goes to the legality of the process by which the material forming the foundation of the appointment was generated and acted upon. 5.50. He accordingly submits that, in the facts of the present case, the failure to communicate the result of the enquiry, coupled with the failure to afford

opportunity

Petitioner-Club before

State

requisite

Government,

vitiates the consequential appointment of the Administrator and warrants setting aside the impugned order. 5.51. His submission is that there is no necessity or expediency

for

appointment

of

an

administrator from the order or from the facts of the case. There is no independent application by the State at the time of appointment of the Administrator

inasmuch

as

there

is

no

independent satisfaction of the government 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 35 HC-KAR

which had been established in the said order, his submission is that such an order appointing an administrator has to be based on cogent, credible and unimpeachable material and not on the basis of considering the enquiry report which had been impugned in these proceedings. 5.52. He submits that the club is a private members' club, not a public body or a Co-operative Society dealing with public funds. The funds are contributed by members voluntarily. Apart from the aforesaid two complainants, there are no complaints which have been raised by any other member

and

these

complaints

were

also

motivated for the reasons as indicated supra. 5.53. His submission is that by way of appointment of an Administrator, the democratically elected Executive Committee has been put out of office and a person appointed by the executive is running the administration of the Society which is not permissible. Such an Administrator could not have been appointed to supersede the elected bodies, is the submission of the learned Senior Counsel. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 36 HC-KAR

5.54. He relies upon the decision of this Court in Karnataka Roller Skating Association (R) Vs. State of Karnataka,1 more particularly paras 4 and 6 thereof, which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: “4. His submission is that Respondent No.2 has only extracted the various charges and the finding of the enquiry officer and has gone on to appoint an Administrator. There being a violation of Section 25(2)(C)(iii) of the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960, he submits that the reliefs sought are required to be granted.

6. This aspect has been dealt with by this Court vide its order dated 29.07.2025 in W.P.No.104203/2025 in the decision of Gousemohammad and another Vs. The District Registrar of Societies (WP.No.104203/2025), more particularly, paras 7.6, 7.7 and 7.8 thereof which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference:

“7.6. The fact that the Registrar can appoint any other person authorised by him in writing to conduct the enquiry does not mean that the enquiry made by such a person is automatically accepted by the Registrar. The person conducting the enquiry is only a delegate of the Registrar and does not substitute the Registrar himself. 7.7. Once, an enquiry has been made, it would be for the Registrar to apply his independent mind to the enquiry report and either accept or reject the said report, and if the report is rejected, a reenquiry could also be ordered by the Registrar.

W.P.No.11661/2026 dated 23.06.2026 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 37 HC-KAR

7.8. In that view of the matter, I answer the above point raised by holding that the Registrar of Societies in pursuance of an enquiry held by his delegate, appointed by him under subSection (1) of Section 25, cannot as a postman forward the enquiry report as received to the society, the registrar has to apply his mind, accept the report and then forward it to the society in terms of clause (3) in Section 25(2)(C)(iii).”

5.55. By

relying

on

Karnataka

Roller

Skating

Association, he submits that in the said decision, while considering the validity of the action taken by the Registrar consequent upon an enquiry, this Court referred to and relied upon its earlier decision in Gousemohammad and another Vs. The District Registrar of Societies

[W.P.No.104203/2025,

particularly

paragraphs 7.6, 7.7 and 7.8], wherein the scope and effect of an enquiry conducted by a person authorised under Section 25(1) of the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960 were considered. 5.56. He submits that the principle emerging from the aforesaid decisions is that the enquiry conducted

by

an

officer

authorised

under

Section 25(1) is only a fact-finding exercise undertaken on behalf of the Registrar. The 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 38 HC-KAR

Enquiry Officer does not exercise or exhaust the statutory

power

vested

in

Registrar.

Consequently, the enquiry report does not, by its mere submission, become the decision of the Registrar, nor can the findings recorded therein be treated as having been mechanically adopted by the Registrar. 5.57. The

statutory

obligation

of

Registrar,

therefore, does not end with receipt of the enquiry report. The Registrar is required to independently consider the report, the material forming its basis and the conclusions recorded therein, apply his own mind and thereafter take a decision whether the report is liable to be accepted or rejected. It is only upon such independent consideration and acceptance of

report

consequence

that

further

contemplated

under

statutory Section

25(2)(c)(iii) can follow. 5.58. It is in this context that the observation that the Registrar cannot act merely as a “postman” assumes

significance.

The

requirement

of

independent application of mind is not an empty procedural formality. It is a substantive 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 39 HC-KAR

safeguard intended to ensure that the statutory decision is that of the Registrar, who alone is vested with the power under Section 25, and not that of the Enquiry Officer acting as his delegate. 5.59. He submits that the same principle would apply with greater force where the consequential action proposed or taken is the appointment of an

Administrator.

The

appointment

of

an

Administrator is not an automatic consequence flowing merely from the findings recorded by

Enquiry

Officer.

Before

taking

such

consequential action, the Registrar is required to independently consider the enquiry report and the material on record and arrive at his own satisfaction regarding the existence of the circumstances which warrant exercise of the statutory power. 5.60. He

therefore

submits

that

mere

reproduction or extraction of the charges, the evidence considered by the Enquiry Officer and the findings recorded in the enquiry report cannot, by itself, constitute an independent decision by the Registrar. What is required is an 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 40 HC-KAR

independent consideration of the report and a conscious decision

by the

Registrar as to

whether the findings deserve acceptance and, if accepted, whether they justify the particular statutory consequence proposed to be imposed. 5.61. According to him, the decision in Karnataka Roller

Skating

Association

is

directly

relevant to the present controversy. In that case also, the challenge was to the action taken by the authorities consequent upon an enquiry, and this Court, while considering the validity of such action, reiterated the principle laid down in Gousemohammad that the Registrar must apply his independent mind to the enquiry report. The ratio is, therefore, not confined merely to the forwarding of the enquiry report to the society; it goes to the very foundation of

subsequent

whether

independently

statutory competent

considered

action,

namely,

authority and

adopted

has

findings before exercising the consequential power. 5.62. In the present case, therefore, the question is not merely whether an enquiry was conducted 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 41 HC-KAR

or whether an enquiry report was submitted. The material question is whether, after receipt of the enquiry report, the Registrar himself independently considered the report and the material on which it was founded, recorded his satisfaction regarding the findings therein and thereafter exercised the power vested in him under Section 25. The impugned order merely reproduces and summarises the charges and the findings of the Enquiry Officer, without demonstrating an independent consideration and

acceptance

of

those

findings

by

Registrar, the same prima facie disclose nonapplication of mind and failure to comply with

statutory

requirement

under

Section

25(2)(c)(iii). 5.63. The

submission,

therefore,

is

that

distinction between an enquiry report and the Registrar's decision upon the enquiry report is fundamental. The former is the product of a delegated fact-finding exercise; the latter is the exercise of the statutory jurisdiction vested in the Registrar. The latter cannot be dispensed with, substituted by or inferred merely from the existence of the former. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 42 HC-KAR

5.64. His submission is that the Registrar is required to pass a reasoned order accepting or rejecting

report.

In

this

case,

no

such

order,

reasoned or otherwise, has been passed by the Registrar accepting the enquiry report, nor was the result of the enquiry communicated to the petitioner-Club, and as such, he submits that there is complete non-application of mind by the Registrar. 5.65. He relies upon the decision of the Division Bench

of

this

Court

in

Sri

Beereswara

Devastana Seva Samiti, Madlere Vs The State of Karnataka, Rep. by its Principal Secretary and others,2 more particularly para 15 and 16 thereof, which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference. “15. A reading of the above portion of the order sheet would not record nor disclose hearing provided to the Petitioner upon receiving the documents. It is also not clear from the above order sheet whether the proceedings are concluded or whether the proceedings are posted for orders or submitting report. A careful perusal of the order sheet gives an impression that the enquiry is abruptly adjourned without showing the next date or stage of the proceedings. When Rule 8[4] of the Rules requires the Enquiry Officer to provide oral hearing, it is absolutely necessary for the Enquiry Officer to record hearing provided to the society or the

W.A.No.100143/2022 C/w CCC.No.100144/2022 dated 09.09.2022 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 43 HC-KAR

aggrieved person. Whether the society or the aggrieved person submits explanation or not, Rule 8 of the Rules mandates oral hearing during Section 25 Enquiry. Since the order sheet or the records of the enquiry would not disclose providing oral hearing to the Petitioner, we are of the view that the report submitted by the second Respondent under Section 25 of the Act is in violation of Rule 8[4] of the Rules and also violative of principles of natural justice.”

5.66. By relying on Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti, his submission is that the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court, while considering an enquiry conducted under Section 25 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960, held that Rule 8(4) of the Karnataka Societies Registration Rules, 1961 mandates that the Enquiry Officer provide an oral hearing to the Society or the aggrieved person. The Division Bench further held that the enquiry records must disclose that such hearing was in fact afforded and that failure to do so would render the enquiry report violative of Rule 8(4) and the principles of natural justice. 5.67. The

submission,

contemplated

under

is

that

Section

enquiry

cannot

be

treated as a mere administrative or fact-finding exercise in which the Society is only required to 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 44 HC-KAR

submit

a

written

explanation.

Rule

8(4)

expressly contemplates an oral hearing before the Enquiry Officer, and compliance with the requirement

of

such

hearing

must

be

demonstrable from the order sheet or the enquiry record. Thus, the validity of the enquiry report depends not merely upon the existence of a notice and a written reply, but also upon compliance with the prescribed procedure and the principles of natural justice, including the opportunity of oral hearing. 5.68. He further submits that the requirement of compliance with natural justice does not end with the conclusion of the enquiry. Once the enquiry report is placed before the Registrar and notice is issued to the Society under Section 25(2)(c)(iii) or Section 27-A, as the case may be, the Registrar is required to consider the explanation/reply submitted by the Society

before

Such

consideration

meaningful

and

taking

consequential must

not

merely

be

real

and

a

matter

of

recording that a reply has been received. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

action.

- 45 HC-KAR

5.69. In this regard, he submits that the requirement before the Enquiry Officer and the requirement before the Registrar operate at two distinct stages. At the first stage, the Enquiry Officer is required to conduct the enquiry in accordance with Rule 8, including affording the Society an oral hearing. At the second stage, the Registrar, being the statutory authority competent to take consequential

action,

is

required

to

independently apply his mind to the enquiry report as well as the objections/explanation submitted by the Society and thereafter arrive at his own decision. 5.70. He submits that the written reply submitted by the Society cannot be treated as an empty formality. Where the reply specifically disputes the findings in the enquiry report, places material objections

before

Registrar,

or

raises

going

to

legality,

factual

correctness or evidentiary basis of the findings, the Registrar is required to consider such submissions while arriving at his decision. If the Registrar proposes to accept the enquiry report notwithstanding the objections raised by the Society, the order must disclose the reasons 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 46 HC-KAR

which demonstrate that the objections have been considered and rejected. 5.71. He therefore submits that, in the present case, there are two independent infirmities in the decision-making

process. First, the

enquiry

itself is conducted without the oral hearing mandated by Rule 8(4), thereby affecting the validity of the enquiry report. Secondly, even assuming that the enquiry report is otherwise available for consideration, the Registrar was required to independently consider the reply submitted by the Society and apply his mind to the objections raised therein before accepting

findings

and

proceeding

to

take

consequential action. 5.72. His submission is that the latter requirement assumes particular significance in view of the decision

in

subsequently

Gousemohammad, noticed

and

followed

as in

Karnataka Roller Skating Association. The Registrar

cannot

mechanically

adopt

findings of the Enquiry Officer. The Registrar must independently consider the enquiry report and the response of the Society and thereafter 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 47 HC-KAR

take a reasoned decision. Thus, compliance with natural justice at the enquiry stage and independent

application

of

mind

at

Registrar's stage are cumulative safeguards and compliance with one cannot dispense with compliance with the other. 5.73. He accordingly submits that where the enquiry record does not establish that the oral hearing contemplated by Rule 8(4) was afforded, the enquiry report itself is vitiated in terms of the law laid down in Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti. Further, where the Registrar, notwithstanding the objections/reply submitted by the Society, proceeds to accept the enquiry report

without

submissions recording

dealing

raised

reasons

with

material

therein

and

without

for

rejecting

them,

consequential order would independently suffer from violation of natural justice and nonapplication of mind. 5.74. The submission, therefore, is that the impugned action

cannot

be

sustained

merely

by

demonstrating that notice was issued to the Society and a written reply was received. The 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 48 HC-KAR

Court would be required to examine whether (i) the Enquiry Officer complied with Rule 8(4) by affording

and

recording

requisite

oral

hearing; (ii) the enquiry report was prepared upon consideration of the material placed by the Society; (iii) the Society was afforded an effective opportunity to respond to the enquiry report at the subsequent statutory stage; and (iv) the Registrar independently considered such response and the enquiry report before arriving at his decision. Failure at any of these stages would have to be considered in the context

of

prejudice

caused

and

statutory scheme governing the exercise of power under Section 25. 5.75. He relies upon the decision of a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in BHEL Employees Welfare

Association

Vs.

State

of

Karnataka,3 more particularly para 7, which is reproduced hereunder for easy reference: “7. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties. From the perusal of the records, it is evident that the District RegistrarRespondent No.2 while submitting the report dated 21.04.2018 has not considered the objections preferred

W.P.No.24288/2018 dated 06.03.2019 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 49 HC-KAR

by the Petitioner and no finding has been recorded with regard to the contents of the documents filed by the Petitioner on 14.07.2017. The Registrar has also not recorded any satisfaction whether or not the evidence is recorded as provided under Rule 8(4) of the Rules. Therefore, it is evident that the impugned order has been passed in violation of Rule 8(4) of the Rules. Therefore, the same cannot be sustained in the eye of law. It is accordingly quashed. The matter is remitted to Respondent No.2 who is directed to conclude the enquiry as contemplated under Rule 8 of the Rules within a period of four months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. It is needless to state that the Petitioner as well as Respondents No.3 and 4 shall co-operate with the Registrar-Respondent No.2 and shall not seek any un-necessary adjournments in order to enable the second Respondent to conclude the enquiry within a period of four months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. In the result, writ petition is disposed of.”

5.76. By

relying

on

BHEL

Employees

Welfare

Association, his submission is that in that case this Court found from the records that the District Registrar, while submitting the report, had failed to consider the objections raised by the Petitioner and had not recorded any finding with regard to the documents produced by the Petitioner. The Court further noticed that the Registrar had not recorded any satisfaction as to whether the evidence had been recorded in accordance with Rule 8(4) of the Karnataka Societies Registration Rules. On those grounds, 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 50 HC-KAR

the impugned order was held to be in violation of Rule 8(4) and was consequently quashed, with the matter being remitted to the Registrar for conclusion of the enquiry in accordance with Rule 8. 5.77. By relying upon BHEL Employees Welfare Association, he submits that compliance with the procedure prescribed under Rule 5.78. 8 of the Rules is an essential component of an enquiry under Section 25 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960. The Registrar, before acting upon the enquiry and submitting or accepting the report, is required to ensure that the procedure prescribed under Rule 8 has been duly followed, including compliance with

requirements

relating

to

recording

of

evidence under Rule 8(4). 5.79. He further submits that BHEL Employees Welfare Association makes it clear that the objections

raised

by

Society

and

documents produced in support thereof cannot be disregarded. The competent authority is required

to

consider

such

objections

and

material and record its satisfaction regarding 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 51 HC-KAR

the manner in which the evidence has been recorded. A report which does not demonstrate such

consideration

or

satisfaction

cannot

constitute a valid foundation for further action under Section 25. 5.80. His submission is that the requirement of compliance with Rule 8 is not merely procedural in the narrow sense. The safeguards contained in the Rule are intended to ensure that the enquiry is conducted fairly, that the Society is afforded an effective opportunity to place its case and material before the Enquiry Officer, and that the conclusions ultimately acted upon by the Registrar are founded upon an enquiry conducted in accordance with the prescribed procedure. 5.81. He submits that, consequently, before accepting or acting upon the enquiry report, the Registrar is required to examine whether the enquiry has been conducted in accordance with Rule 8, whether the material and objections placed by the Society have been considered, and whether

requirements

relating

to

recording

of

evidence and hearing have been complied with. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 52 HC-KAR

If the enquiry report has been prepared or submitted

without

following

procedure

prescribed

under

mandatory

Rule

8,

Registrar could not mechanically accept or act upon such report. 5.82. Read with the principles laid down in Sri Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti and Gousemohammad,

he

submits

that

statutory scheme requires procedural fairness at the enquiry stage as well as independent application of mind at the decision-making stage. Thus, the Registrar is required not only to ensure that the enquiry conforms to Rule 8, but also to independently consider the enquiry report and the objections/material placed by the Society before taking any consequential action. 5.83. He accordingly submits that, in the present case, the validity of the action taken by the Registrar would have to be examined with reference to whether the mandatory safeguards under Rule 8 were complied with, whether the Society's

objections

and

documents

were

considered, whether the evidence was recorded 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 53 HC-KAR

in the manner prescribed by Rule 8(4), and whether the Registrar recorded his satisfaction regarding such compliance before acting upon the enquiry report. In the absence of such compliance and independent consideration, the enquiry report could not validly form the basis for the consequential action taken against the Society. 5.84. Rule 8 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Rules, 1975, is reproduced hereunder for easy reference: “Rule - 8. Enquiry by the Registrar. (1) Where the Registrar proposed to hold an enquiry under Section 25, either on his own motion or on an application, he or the person authorised by him under the said Section to hold an enquiry shall issue notice to the society concerned in this behalf.

(2) The said notice shall specify a date on which, place in which and the time at which, as also the matters in respect of which the enquiry will be held. The notice shall also call upon the society to furnish its explanation in respect of matters referred to therein before the elate specified in the notice.

(3) The society shall furnish its explanation to the Registrar or the authorised person before such date.

(4) On the date fixed for the enquiry, or on such other date or dates to which the enquiry might be adjourned, 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 54 HC-KAR

the Registrar or the authorised person shall give the society a oral hearing. He may also examine such persons as may be considered necessary. He may receive any relevant document. If the society fails to furnish its explanation as required under sub-rule (3) or to attend the enquiry on the date fixed or the adjourned date, the Registrar or the authorised person may proceed with the enquiry ex parte.

(5) On the completion of the enquiry, the Registrar or the authorised person shall record his findings and communicate the same to the society concerned.”

5.85. By referring to Rule 8 he submits that the Rule prescribes a complete and sequential procedure governing the conduct and conclusion of an enquiry

under

Section

25.

The

procedure

commences with a notice specifying the matters proposed to be enquired into, the date, time and place of enquiry and requiring the Society to

furnish

its

explanation;

proceeds

to

consideration of the explanation, oral hearing, examination of persons and receipt of relevant documents; and culminates in recording of findings and communication thereof to the Society. 5.86. He submits that the expression “shall” occurring in Rule 8(4), in the context of the requirement that the Registrar or the authorised person 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 55 HC-KAR

“shall give the society an oral hearing”, makes the requirement mandatory. The Rule does not contemplate that the Society may be deprived of an oral hearing merely because it has submitted a written explanation. The written explanation under sub-rule (3) and the oral hearing

contemplated

under

sub-rule

(4)

constitute distinct procedural safeguards. 5.87. He further submits that Rule 8 deliberately uses the expression “Registrar or the authorised person” in sub-rules (3) and (4). Therefore, where the enquiry is entrusted to an authorised person

under

Section

25,

such

authorised

person is required to conduct the enquiry in accordance with all the procedural safeguards contained in Rule 8, including granting an oral hearing,

receiving

relevant

documents

and

recording findings. 5.88. At

same

time,

sub-rule

(5)

assumes

significance in determining the nature and effect of the enquiry. The Rule contemplates that, on completion of the enquiry, findings are to be recorded and communicated to the Society. Where the enquiry is conducted by an 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 56 HC-KAR

authorised person, the findings so recorded constitute the outcome of the delegated enquiry and cannot, merely by reason of their being recorded by the authorised person, be equated with an independent decision of the Registrar exercising the statutory power vested in him under Section 25. 5.89. He submits that Rule 8 must therefore be read harmoniously with Section 25. The authorised person may conduct the enquiry on behalf of the Registrar and record findings in accordance with Rule 8; however, the statutory power of the Registrar is not thereby transferred or exhausted. The Registrar remains required to consider

enquiry

report/findings

in

accordance with the statutory scheme and, before

taking

consequential

action,

to

independently apply his mind to the material placed before him. 5.90. He further submits that the requirement of recording

findings

necessarily

implies

under that

sub-rule

(5)

findings

must

emerge from the procedure prescribed in subrules (1) to (4). A finding cannot be treated as 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 57 HC-KAR

a valid finding under Rule 8 if it has been arrived at without furnishing the Society the notice

contemplated

under

sub-rule

(2),

without considering its explanation under subrule (3), or without affording the oral hearing mandated under sub-rule (4). 5.91. Thus, according to him, compliance with Rule 8 is not a matter of mere formality. The Rule embodies the minimum procedural safeguards intended

to

ensure

that

enquiry

is

conducted fairly and that the findings are reached after the Society has been afforded a meaningful opportunity to meet the allegations against it. 5.92. He

therefore

submits

that,

on

a

conjoint

reading of Section 25 and Rule 8, the enquiry process cannot be regarded as valid merely because a report or set of findings has been prepared. The Court is required to examine whether the statutorily prescribed procedure preceding the findings was actually followed and whether the Society was afforded the procedural safeguards expressly contemplated by Rule 8. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 58 HC-KAR

5.93. It is accordingly submitted that the following aspects assume significance while examining the validity of the enquiry in the present case: 5.93.1.

Whether a notice complying with Rule 8(1) and (2) was issued specifying the matters proposed to be enquired into;

5.93.2.

Whether the Society was afforded an effective

opportunity

to

furnish

its

explanation under Rule 8(3); 5.93.3.

Whether the Registrar or the authorised person conducting the enquiry actually afforded the Society the oral hearing mandated under Rule 8(4);

5.93.4.

Whether

relevant

documents

produced by the Society were received and considered and, where necessary, whether

relevant

persons

were

examined; 5.93.5.

Whether the findings recorded under Rule 8(5) are

demonstrably founded

upon the material and procedure forming part of the enquiry; and 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 59 HC-KAR

5.93.6.

Where the enquiry was conducted by an authorised person, whether the Registrar thereafter independently considered the findings/report and the objections or explanation

of

Society

before

exercising the statutory power vested in him. 5.94. His submission, therefore, is that there are two distinct stages which cannot be conflated: first, a procedurally valid enquiry resulting in findings under Rule 8; and second, the independent exercise

of

statutory

jurisdiction

by

Registrar upon consideration of those findings and the response of the Society. Compliance with the first stage does not dispense with the second,

and

conversely,

independent

consideration by the Registrar cannot cure an enquiry which is itself fundamentally vitiated by failure

to

comply

with

mandatory

safeguards under Rule 8. 5.95. He relies upon the decision of this Court in KEB Scheduled

Caste

and

Scheduled

Tribes

Welfare Association and Another Vs. The State of Karnataka, Department of CoDigitally Signed By: 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 60 HC-KAR

operation,4 more particularly para 3 thereof, which

is

reproduced

hereunder

for

easy

reference: “3. Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that no enquiry as envisaged under Section 27-A(c) of the Act was held and no opportunity of hearing was afforded to the Petitioner. It is further submitted that the Special Officer has passed the impugned order and the same has not been published in the gazette as required under the Act. Therefore, the impugned order is liable to be quashed. In support of his submissions, reference has been placed on a decision of the Supreme Court in ‘RAJENDRA AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY VS. ASHOK KUMAR PRASAD AND OTHERS’, (2010) 1 SCC 730 and order dated 19.02.2019 passed by this Court in W.P.No.22487/2017 and connected matters. On the other hand, learned Additional Advocate General has submitted that the term of the office bearers of the Society will expire tomorrow i.e., on 18.06.2019 and the Administrator has already taken charge on 16.03.2019. It is also urged that there has been compliance of Section 27-A(3) & (4) of the Act and the Administrator be directed to hold the elections of the Society. In support of aforesaid submissions, reference has been made to a decision of this court in the case of ‘B.BALAJI VS. THE HEBBAR SRI VAISHNAVA SABHA (REGD) AND OTHERS’, W.P.NO.50154/2017. Learned counsel for the impleading applicant submitted that the Petitioners did not hold the Annual General Meeting for a period of two years and did not get the account audited. It is further submitted that a Gazette Notification was issued on 11.04.2019.”

W.P.No.12882-83/2019 dated 17.06.2019 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 61 HC-KAR

5.96. By relying on KEB Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes Welfare Association, his submission is that the said decision arose in the context of proceedings under Section 27-A of KSR Act, where a challenge was raised, inter alia,

on

ground

that

no

enquiry

as

contemplated under Section 27-A had been held and that no opportunity of hearing had been

afforded

to

Society

before

consequential action was taken. 5.97. He submits that the exercise of power under Section

27-A

mechanically

cannot

upon

receipt

be of

undertaken a

report

or

material emanating from the Registrar. Where Section 27-A contemplates an enquiry and consequential action affecting the management of

a

Society,

statutory

requirements

governing such enquiry and the opportunity of hearing to the Society must be complied with before the consequential order is passed. 5.98. He submits that the requirement of hearing assumes particular significance because the action contemplated under Section 27-A may result

in

displacement

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

of

existing

- 62 HC-KAR

management

and

appointment

of

an

Administrator/Special Officer. Such action has serious civil consequences and, therefore, the Society

must

opportunity

to

be

afforded

place

its

an

case

effective

before

competent authority before the decision is taken. 5.99. His submission is that the enquiry or report prepared at an earlier stage cannot, by itself, dispense

with

subsequent

statutory

requirement of hearing where Section 27-A requires the competent authority to undertake an enquiry or consider the matter before taking consequential action. The authority exercising power under Section 27-A must consider the material placed before it and the explanation of the Society and thereafter arrive at its own decision in accordance with law. 5.100. He

further

submits

that

expression

“enquiry” occurring in Section 27-A must be given meaningful content. It cannot be reduced to a mere receipt of the report of the Registrar or

an

administrative

endorsement

of

conclusions already reached. Where the statute 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 63 HC-KAR

contemplates an enquiry preceding the exercise of

power,

competent

authority

must

undertake the requisite consideration and afford the affected Society an opportunity of hearing. 5.101. He submits that this requirement must also be considered in conjunction with the principles emerging

from

decisions

in

Sri

Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti, BHEL Employees

Welfare

Gousemohammad.

Association

The

statutory

and

scheme

contemplates procedural fairness at the stage of enquiry and independent application of mind by

authority

competent

to

take

consequential decision. The fact that an earlier authority

has

conducted

an

enquiry

or

submitted a report does not, by itself, satisfy

requirement

of

a

hearing

before

authority which ultimately exercises the power resulting in civil consequences. 5.102. He accordingly submits that, if the impugned action under Section 27-A has been taken merely on the basis of the Registrar's report, without

State

Government/competent

authority itself conducting or undertaking the 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 64 HC-KAR

enquiry contemplated by the provision and without

affording

Society

an

effective

opportunity of hearing, such action would be contrary to the statutory scheme and the principles of natural justice. 5.103. He therefore submits that the validity of the impugned action would require examination of whether, after receipt of the Registrar's report, the competent authority: 5.103.1. Undertook

enquiry

contemplated

under Section 27-A; 5.103.2. furnished the Society with an effective opportunity to submit its explanation and objections; 5.103.3. afforded an opportunity of hearing where required by the statutory provision and principles of natural justice; 5.103.4. considered the report of the Registrar along with the explanation, objections and material produced by the Society; and 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 65 HC-KAR

5.103.5. thereafter independently arrived at the satisfaction necessary for exercising the power under Section 27-A. 5.104. His submission, therefore, is that the report of

Registrar

may

constitute

material

for

consideration by the authority competent to act under Section 27-A, but it cannot be treated as a substitute for the statutory decision-making process contemplated under Section 27-A. The ultimate order, particularly an order resulting in displacement

of

elected/existing

management

and

appointment

of

an

Administrator, must be preceded by compliance with the prescribed procedure, observance of natural justice and an independent application of mind by the authority vested with the power to take such action. 5.105. In the present case, though the PetitionerSociety submitted a reply to the show-cause notice, it is submitted that the same has neither

been

duly

considered

by

District/Joint Registrar nor have the objections and material placed by the Society been dealt with in the decision-making process. More 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 66 HC-KAR

importantly, upon receipt of the report/material from the Registrar, no notice has been issued by the State Government/competent authority to the Society, nor has the Society been afforded an opportunity of hearing before the consequential action under Section 27-A was taken. His submission is that the requirement of enquiry

and

hearing

contemplated

under

Section 27-A(c) of the Act is therefore not satisfied. 5.106. He submits that the opportunity afforded at the earlier stage before the District/Joint Registrar cannot, by itself, be treated as compliance with the requirement of hearing before the authority competent to exercise the power under Section 27-A.

The

State

Government/competent

authority, before taking a decision which has the effect of displacing the elected Executive Committee and office bearers and appointing an Administrator, is required to consider the material placed by the Society and afford it an effective opportunity to meet the case against it. In the absence of such consideration and hearing, the consequential appointment of the Administrator is vitiated for failure to comply 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 67 HC-KAR

with the statutory procedure and principles of natural justice. 5.107. His submission is also that, apart from the aforesaid procedural infirmity, the appointment of an Administrator under Section 27-A is required to be given effect to only in the manner prescribed by the Act, including the requirement

of

publication

in

Official

Gazette. Gazette publication is not, according to him,

a

mere

statutory

ministerial

requirement

formality,

governing

but

a

legal

no

such

place.

He

efficacy of the appointment. 5.108. In

Gazette

present

case,

publication

admittedly,

has

taken

therefore submits that the alleged appointment has

not

acquired

legal

efficacy

contemplated under Section 27-A and that, in

absence

of

prescribed

Gazette

notification, the person purporting to act as Administrator cannot assume control over the affairs of the Society. 5.109. He further submits that the consequence of recognising

a

person

as

Administrator

is

substantial, as it results in the displacement of 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 68 HC-KAR

the democratically elected Executive Committee and office bearers of the Society and confers upon the Administrator the authority to manage and administer the affairs of the Society. Such displacement of the elected body can take place only upon strict compliance with the statutory conditions governing the appointment. 5.110. He accordingly submits that, in the absence of compliance with the hearing requirement under Section

27-A

and,

independently,

in

absence of the requisite Gazette publication, there

is

no

valid

and

legally

efficacious

appointment of an Administrator. Consequently, the person purporting to act as Administrator cannot take over the management of the Society,

displace

Committee

or

elected

exercise

Executive

powers

and

functions of the office bearers. 5.111. He therefore submits that the impugned action is liable to be set aside on two independent grounds:

first, failure

to

comply

with

statutory requirement of enquiry/hearing and failure to consider the Society's reply and objections

before

09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

State

- 69 HC-KAR

Government/competent

authority

took

consequential action; and secondly, failure to comply

with

statutory

requirement

of

Gazette publication necessary to give legal efficacy

to

appointment

of

Administrator. 6.

Smt.

Prathima

Honnapura,

learned

Additional

Advocate General appearing for the RespondentState would submit that: 6.1.

Sri.

K.

Puttaswamy

Hanumantharayappa dated

Gowda

Sri.

submitted

complaints

and

10.01.2026,

17.11.2025

respectively,

and

alleging

irregularities

in

management and utilisation of the funds of the Petitioner-Club.

On

basis

of

said

complaints, the Registrar initiated a Suo motu enquiry under Section 25 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960 and appointed Respondent No.4 as the Enquiry Officer. It is submitted that the enquiry was not initiated arbitrarily or without any foundational material, but pursuant to specific complaints alleging financial and administrative irregularities in the affairs of the Club. 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 70 HC-KAR

6.2.

Her submission is that the Petitioner-Club was put on notice of the allegations and participated in

enquiry

proceedings

conducted

Respondent No.4. The Club and

by

its office

bearers were given repeated opportunities to appear,

explain

allegations,

produce

documents and place their defence on record. The contention that the enquiry was conducted behind the back of the Club or without affording an opportunity of hearing is therefore incorrect. 6.3.

The Enquiry Officer initially fixed the matter for hearing on 20.01.2026. On the said date, the President, Treasurer and Vice-President of the Club were present, while the Secretary was absent. The President and Treasurer sought 45 days'

time

to

submit

their

reply

to

allegations, stating that the documents relating to

Club

were

in

custody

of

Secretary, who was stated to be on leave on account

of

ill

health.

The

request

for

adjournment was considered and the matter was adjourned. 6.4.

The

matter

was

thereafter

taken

up

on

04.02.2026. On that date, the President and 09/10/2026, 12:09, Bengaluru

- 71 HC-KAR

Treasurer were again present. It was then represented that the documents relating to the Club

were

in

custody

of

Sri.

B.

M.

Ravishankar, who had served as Treasurer of the Club during the period from 2017 to 2021 and as a Director of the Executive Committee during the period from 2022 to 2025. It was stated

that

documents

had

not

been

returned to the Club and, on that basis, three months' time was sought to produce the same. 6.5.

Sri. B. M. Ravishankar, however, addressed a communication to the Enquiry Officer stating that

he

had

resigned

as

Treasurer

on

16.10.2020 and as Director on 25.11.2025 and that he was not in possession of any documents pertaining to the Club, which, according to him, were available with the Club itself. The matter was thereafter adjourned to 18.02.2026. Even on the subsequent date, no substantive written explanation

rebutting

allegations

was

furnished by the Petitioner-Club. The matter was therefore adjourned to 04.03.2026. 6.6.

On 04.03.2026, the President was absent, while the Secretary and Treasurer were present. The 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 72 HC-KAR

Secretary stated that, from 1997 onwards, the transactions in question had been undertaken by the President and that the documents relating to those transactions were in the custody of the President. The Treasurer, on the other hand, stated that he had merely signed cheques at the direction of the President and had no other role in the functioning of the Club. Thus, even at that stage, the office bearers took

inconsistent

positions

regarding

custody and availability of the documents, but did not place before the Enquiry Officer a comprehensive explanation supported by the relevant records. 6.7.

Her submission is that the aforesaid chronology itself demonstrates that the Petitioner-Club was afforded more than one opportunity to answer the allegations. On the first occasion, time was sought on the ground that the documents were with

Secretary;

thereafter,

it

was

represented that the documents were with the former Treasurer; and subsequently, it was stated that the documents were with the President. Despite such repeated opportunities, 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 73 HC-KAR

the Club did not place the relevant documents or a substantive explanation on record. 6.8.

It is therefore submitted that the Petitioner cannot, after having participated in the enquiry proceedings,

sought

repeated

adjournments

and failed to produce the material on which it proposed to rely, contend that there was denial of natural justice. The principle of natural justice requires a reasonable opportunity to meet

indefeasible

case;

it

does

not

to

seek

right

confer

an

repeated

adjournments or to keep the enquiry pending indefinitely. 6.9.

Her submission is further that the proceedings conducted by the Enquiry Officer were duly recorded in the order sheet. The order sheet records the appearances, requests for time, submissions made by the office bearers and the reasons furnished by them for not producing the documents or filing their explanation. The President of the Club signed the order sheet and did not record any objection or dissent to the proceedings recorded therein. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 74 HC-KAR

6.10. Her submission, therefore, is that the Petitioner cannot now selectively dispute the proceedings recorded in the order sheet when its authorised office

bearer

had

participated

in

proceedings and signed the record without protest.

The

order

sheet

constitutes

contemporaneous evidence of the manner in which the enquiry proceeded and demonstrates that the Petitioner was aware of the allegations and was repeatedly given an opportunity to respond. 6.11. As regards the contention that the mandatory procedure under Rule 8 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Rules, 1975 was not followed, her submission is that the record demonstrates compliance with the essential requirements of Rule 8. Notice was issued to the Club; the Club was called upon to furnish its explanation; its office bearers appeared before the Enquiry Officer; oral submissions were made on their behalf; time was granted on their request; and the matter was adjourned on several occasions to enable them to place their explanation and documents on record. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 75 HC-KAR

6.12. She submits that Rule 8(4) contemplates an opportunity of oral hearing before the Registrar or the person authorised by him. In the present case, the Petitioner-Club and its office bearers were in fact heard on several dates. The fact that the Petitioner did not ultimately submit a written reply or produce the documents which it claimed were necessary for its defence cannot be converted into a contention that no hearing was afforded. 6.13. Her submission is that the requirement of oral hearing is intended to provide the Society an effective opportunity to explain the allegations and place its defence before the Enquiry Officer. That

requirement

stood

substantially

and

effectively complied with in the present case, since the President, Secretary, Treasurer and other office bearers appeared on different dates and made oral submissions on the allegations and on the availability of the documents. 6.14. She

submits

that

Petitioner

cannot

simultaneously contend that it was denied an opportunity of hearing and, on the other hand, rely upon the various oral submissions made by 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 76 HC-KAR

its office bearers before the Enquiry Officer. The very nature of those submissions demonstrates that the Club was heard and was aware of the allegations against it. 6.15. As

regards

reliance

placed

upon

decision in Sri Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti, she submits that the said decision has to be understood in the factual context in which the Court found that the records did not disclose that an oral hearing had been given. The present case stands on a different footing, since the order sheets disclose the repeated appearance of the office bearers and the oral submissions made by them before the Enquiry Officer. 6.16. Her submission is that the present case is therefore not one where the record is silent as to

hearing.

On

contemporaneous

contrary,

proceedings

record

appearances and submissions made by the office bearers. The requirement under Rule 8 cannot be construed to mean that an enquiry must

remain

pending

indefinitely

merely

because the Society chooses not to file the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 77 HC-KAR

explanation sought from it despite repeated opportunities. 6.17. As regards the allegation that the Enquiry Officer refused to receive documents produced by the Petitioner-Club, her submission is that no specific document has been identified which was tendered before the Enquiry Officer and was refused or rejected. The Petitioner has not demonstrated from the order sheet or the enquiry record that any particular document was

produced

and

that

Respondent

No.4

declined to receive the same. 6.18. On the contrary, the consistent position taken by the office bearers was that the relevant documents were in the custody of different persons. Initially, the documents were stated to be with the Secretary; subsequently, with the former Treasurer; and thereafter, with the President. When the former Treasurer was approached,

he

denied

possession

of

documents and stated that the same were available with the Club. Thus, the inability of the Petitioner to produce documents cannot be 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 78 HC-KAR

attributed to any refusal on the part of the Enquiry Officer to receive them. 6.19. She submits that the burden cannot be shifted to the Enquiry Officer when the Petitioner itself failed to identify, produce and tender the documents upon which it intended to rely. In the absence of any material demonstrating actual

refusal

to

receive

documents,

allegation is merely an assertion and cannot invalidate the enquiry. 6.20. As regards the contention that the Enquiry Officer

could

appointment

not of

have

an

recommended

Administrator,

her

submission is that Respondent No.4 did not purport to exercise the statutory power vested in the State Government under Section 27-A. The

Enquiry

findings

Officer

emerging

recommended competent

merely

from

consequential

authority.

The

recorded

enquiry

and

action

to

recommendation

contained in the report cannot be equated with an order appointing an Administrator. 6.21. She submits that the statutory scheme itself contemplates an enquiry and a report being 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 79 HC-KAR

placed before the competent authority. The Enquiry Officer was appointed by the Registrar for the purpose of conducting the enquiry and recording

findings.

The

report

was

thereafter submitted to Respondent No.3 and forwarded

to

State

Government.

The

ultimate power to appoint the Administrator was exercised by the State Government and not by the Enquiry Officer. 6.22. Her submission is therefore that there is no merit in the contention that Respondent No.4 usurped the power of the State Government. The Enquiry Officer only performed the function for which he had been authorised, namely, conducting the enquiry, recording the findings and making a recommendation on the basis of the material available. 6.23. She

further

submits

that

decision

in

Karnataka Roller Skating Association and the decision in Gousemohammad, relied upon by the Petitioner, do not assist the Petitioner in the present case. Those decisions recognise the distinction between an enquiry report and the decision to be taken by the statutory authority. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 80 HC-KAR

In the present case also, the report of the Enquiry Officer was only placed before the competent authority and the ultimate decision under Section 27-A was taken by the State Government. 6.24. Her submission is that the mere fact that the State

Government

considered

findings

recorded in the enquiry report does not amount to mechanical acceptance of the report. The State Government was entitled to rely upon the material gathered during the statutory enquiry, provided it independently considered the same before exercising the power vested in it. 6.25. As

regards

contention

that

Government

was

required

to

State

conduct

an

entirely fresh enquiry after receipt of the report of the Registrar, her submission is that the statutory scheme does not require duplication of

enquiry

already

conducted

merely

because the report has been placed before the State Government. The purpose of the enquiry report is to place the relevant facts and findings before

authority

consequential action. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

competent

to

take

- 81 HC-KAR

6.26. She submits that what is required of the State Government is that it should independently consider the material before it, afford the Society an opportunity to explain why the proposed action should not be taken and thereafter arrive at the requisite satisfaction under Section 27-A. It is not necessary that the State Government should mechanically repeat each

and

every

undertaken

procedural

during

step

enquiry

already by

authorised Enquiry Officer. 6.27. Her submission is that the decision in Bharata Ratna

Mokshgundam

Viswaswaraiah

Education Society Vs. District Registrar, (Deputy

Commissioner),

Kolar

is

distinguishable from the present case only to the extent that the said decision emphasises the independent statutory role of the State Government. The present case satisfies that requirement

because,

after

receipt

of

enquiry report, the State Government itself issued a show-cause notice to the PetitionerClub before proceeding with the appointment.

1984 SCC OnLine Kar 122 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 82 HC-KAR

6.28. She submits that the State Government did not treat the report of the Enquiry Officer as an automatic order of appointment. The report was considered as the material forming the basis for the proposed action, and the Petitioner-Club was thereafter specifically called upon to show cause as to why an Administrator should not be appointed. 6.29. Thus, according to her, there are two distinct stages:

first, the

enquiry

report;

and

secondly,

report

and

other

resulting

in

consideration

of

material

by

State

Government before exercising the statutory power under Section 27-A. Both stages were complied with in the present case. 6.30. She submits that, contrary to the contention of the Petitioner, the State Government did afford a separate opportunity to the Petitioner-Club after

receipt

of

enquiry

report.

On

09.04.2026

(Annexure

R9),

State

Government

issued

show-cause

notice

a

specifically calling upon the Club to explain why an Administrator should not be appointed in 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 83 HC-KAR

view of the irregularities and findings recorded in the enquiry report. 6.31. The said notice was therefore not a mere formality. It put the Petitioner-Club on specific notice of the proposed consequential action and afforded it an opportunity to place its objections and material before the State Government. The Petitioner was thus given an opportunity at the stage when the competent authority itself was considering exercise of the power under Section 27-A. 6.32. She submits that the Petitioner did not submit any reply to the said show-cause notice. Having consciously chosen not to respond to the notice issued by the State Government, the Petitioner cannot

thereafter

contend

that

State

Government proceeded without affording an opportunity of hearing. 6.33. Her

submission

hearing

does

is not

that

an

opportunity

necessarily

require

of

authority to await a response indefinitely. Once a reasonable opportunity is granted and the Society fails to avail itself of that opportunity, 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 84 HC-KAR

the competent authority is entitled to proceed on the material available on record. 6.34. She further submits that there is no material to demonstrate that the Petitioner

sought an

extension of time from the State Government, sought

a

personal

hearing,

or

requested

permission to produce additional documents in response to the notice dated 09.04.2026. In the absence of any such request, the allegation that the State Government denied a hearing is without basis. 6.35. As

regards

contention

that

reply

submitted by the Club before the District/Joint Registrar was not considered, her submission is that the said reply formed part of the enquiry record and was available to the authorities while considering the matter. The Petitioner cannot contend that every contention raised in the reply must necessarily find separate and elaborate discussion in the final order. 6.36. What is required is consideration of the material relevant to the decision. In the present case, the enquiry proceedings, the submissions of the office bearers, the material gathered during 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 85 HC-KAR

enquiry, the findings of the Enquiry Officer and the subsequent proceedings before the State Government constituted the material on the basis of which the statutory decision was taken. 6.37. She submits that, in any event, when the State Government issued a fresh show-cause notice dated 09.04.2026, the Petitioner had a further opportunity to place before the competent authority all its objections, explanations and documents. The Petitioner did not avail itself of that opportunity. Therefore, it cannot now contend that it was prevented from placing its defence before the authority competent to appoint the Administrator. 6.38. Her submission is that the enquiry report was not founded upon vague or general allegations. The Enquiry Officer recorded specific findings concerning the manner in which membership subscriptions were collected and accounted for and the manner in which the financial affairs of the Club were being maintained. 6.39. It was found that membership subscriptions had, on several occasions, been collected in cash without corresponding entries being duly 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 86 HC-KAR

reflected in the books of the Club and without receipts being issued for such collections. These circumstances

raised

serious

questions

regarding the transparency and accountability of the financial management of the Club. 6.40. She further submits that membership funds were

collected

purposes,

from

including

members

for

stated

construction-related

purposes, but the utilisation of such funds was not

demonstrated

by

proper

records.

The

financial affairs of the Club were therefore found to suffer from serious irregularities. 6.41. Her submission is that the Enquiry Officer was entitled accounts,

to

examine

books,

records,

resolutions

and

other

material

pertaining to the Club and to record findings on the basis thereof. The Petitioner, having failed to produce the material which it claimed would rebut those findings, cannot challenge the report merely by making a general allegation that the findings are incorrect. 6.42. With regard to the Annual General Meeting stated to have been held on 01.02.2026, she submits that the conduct of the meeting was 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 87 HC-KAR

also examined in the context of the bye-laws governing the Club. Ordinarily, consideration and

approval

of

audited

financial

statements and the budget constitute important matters for consideration by the general body. 6.43. However, neither acceptance of the audited financial statements nor approval of the budget formed part of the agenda of the said meeting. Her submission is that the manner in which the Annual General Meeting was conducted was inconsistent with the requirements of the byelaws and constituted a further circumstance relevant

to

overall

administration

and

financial management of the Club. 6.44. Her submission is that the power under Section 27-A is not confined to cases of individual misconduct

or

personal

disputes

between

members of a Society. Where the affairs of a Society

disclose

serious

financial

or

administrative irregularities affecting the proper management of the Society and the interests of its members, the same may legitimately give rise

to

considerations

of

public

contemplated under the provision. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

interest

- 88 HC-KAR

6.45. The Petitioner-Club manages funds contributed by its members and is required to maintain proper accounts and conduct its affairs in accordance with its bye-laws and the governing statute.

Failure

accounts,

to

maintain

non-accounting

of

transparent membership

collections and irregular utilisation or nonutilisation

of

funds

purposes

have

a

interests of the

collected

direct

for

bearing

members and

specified upon

the proper

administration of the Club. 6.46. She

submits

that

reference

to

public

interest in Section 27-A cannot be construed narrowly so as to require proof of an interest of the entire population at large. The proper administration of a registered Society, the protection of its funds and the interests of its members are themselves matters which may legitimately be taken into consideration while determining whether statutory intervention is warranted. 6.47. Her submission is that appointment of an Administrator was not made merely because an enquiry report contained adverse observations. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 89 HC-KAR

The State Government considered the material placed before it, the nature of the irregularities recorded in the enquiry report and the absence of any effective rebuttal from the PetitionerClub, and thereafter exercised the statutory power vested in it under Section 27-A. 6.48. She

submits

that

Petitioner

has

not

demonstrated any jurisdictional error in the exercise of that power. The State Government was the competent authority under Section 27A and exercised the power only after the statutory process had been initiated and the Petitioner had been given an opportunity to explain its position. 6.49. The fact that appointment of an Administrator results in the elected Executive Committee and office bearers ceasing to administer the affairs of the Club does not, by itself, invalidate the appointment.

Such

displacement

is

statutory consequence of a valid appointment under Section 27-A and cannot be relied upon as a ground to defeat the exercise of the statutory power itself. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 90 HC-KAR

6.50. Her submission is that the right of an elected Executive Committee to continue in office is subject to the provisions of the governing statute and the power conferred upon the competent

authority

thereunder.

Once

statutory

conditions

for

intervention

are

satisfied, the mere fact that the existing office bearers

were

elected

cannot

confer

an

immunity against statutory action. 6.51. The

learned

submits

Additional

that

Advocate

order

General

appointing

Administrator has also been published in the Official

Gazette

requirement

on

relating

20.05.2026.

Thus,

to

publication

Gazette

under the Act has been duly complied with. 6.52. She submits that, even assuming the Petitioner contends that Gazette publication is a condition governing the legal efficacy of the appointment, the said requirement now stands satisfied by publication dated 20.05.2026. Consequently, the Petitioner cannot seek to invalidate the appointment on the ground that the order had not been published in the Gazette. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 91 HC-KAR

6.53. She

further

submits

that

Gazette

publication confirms that the appointment was made by the competent statutory authority and that

Administrator

was

appointed

in

accordance with the statutory scheme. The contention

that

Administrator

had

no

authority whatsoever to assume office therefore does not survive in view of the subsequent publication. 6.54. The

learned

submits

Additional

that

Administrator

Advocate

contention

cannot

General

that

displace

democratically elected Executive Committee is equally without merit. The appointment under Section 27-A is itself a statutory intervention which

necessarily

carries

with

it

consequence of the Administrator assuming management of the Society in accordance with the terms and period of appointment. 6.55. The

learned

Additional

Advocate

General

therefore submits that the challenge raised by

Petitioner

proceeds

assumption

that

constituted

decision

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

on

enquiry to

an

erroneous

report

itself

appoint

an

- 92 HC-KAR

Administrator. The report was only the outcome of the enquiry conducted by the authorised Enquiry Officer. The ultimate statutory decision was taken by the State Government, which was the competent authority under Section 27-A. 6.56. She submits that the record establishes the following

sequence:

complaints

were

received; the Registrar initiated the enquiry; the Petitioner-Club was put on notice; the Club and

its

office

proceedings;

bearers

participated

repeated

opportunities

in

were

granted to furnish explanations and documents; oral submissions were made on behalf of the Club; the Enquiry Officer recorded his findings; the report was placed before the competent authorities; the State Government thereafter issued a separate show-cause notice dated 09.04.2026; the Petitioner did not submit any reply thereto; the State Government considered the material available on record and proceeded to

appoint

Administrator;

and

appointment was subsequently published in the Official Gazette on 20.05.2026. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 93 HC-KAR

6.57. Her submission is therefore that the principal objections raised by the Petitioner, namely, absence of notice, denial of oral hearing, noncompliance with Rule 8, refusal to receive documents, failure to consider the Petitioner's defence, lack of independent consideration by the State Government, absence of a further enquiry under Section 27-A, want of jurisdiction on the part of the Enquiry Officer, and absence of Gazette publication, are all factually and legally unsustainable. 6.58. She accordingly submits that the Petitioner was afforded adequate and effective opportunity at both stages of the proceedings, namely, during

enquiry

Enquiry

conducted

Officer

and

by

before

authorised

State

Government prior to exercise of the power under Section 27-A. The State Government, being the competent authority, independently exercised

statutory

power

upon

consideration of the material available before it. There

being

procedure

or

no

violation

principles

of of

statutory

natural

justice

warranting interference under Article 226 of the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 94 HC-KAR

Constitution, the writ petition is liable to be dismissed. 7.

Sri.

K.M.

Prakash,

learned

counsel,

filed

I.A.

No.6/2026 seeking impleadment of the applicants in the present proceedings on the ground that they are members of the Petitioner-Society. This Court, by order

dated

counsel

to

24.07.2026, assist

permitted

Court

as

an

learned

intervener;

however, the application for impleadment was not allowed. Accordingly, the applicants have not been impleaded as parties to the proceedings, and the learned counsel has been heard in the limited capacity of an intervener assisting the Court. 7.1. He relied upon the decision of this Court in K.Shivanna

and

Others

Karnataka

by

its

Vs.

State

Secretary,6

of

more

particularly paras 12.2, 12.3, 12.4, 12.5 and 13.1, which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: “12.2 He relies on the second portion of Clause (c) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 27A of KSRA, 1960, to contend that on enquiry the State Government, if it considers it necessary in public interest to do so, would include an enquiry under Section 25 of the KSRA, 1960 and as such, notice has to be issued to the governing

W.P.No.33814/2025 C/w W.P.No.33855/2025 dated 28.11.2025 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 95 HC-KAR

body/ existing Committee, to be heard before an order of appointment of an Administrator is passed. 12.3 I am unable to agree with this submission also inasmuch as that enquiry is related to the circumstances covered under Clause (c) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 27A of KSRA, 1960, and not to that covered under Clause (b) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 27A of KSRA, 1960, inasmuch as there is no further enquiry to be made when the term of the governing body of a Society has expired and a new governing body has not for any reason been constituted. Inasmuch as, admittedly, the term expired on 12.10.2025 (actually 11.10.2025), by which date no elections were held and no new governing body/Management Committee had taken charge. 12.4 The explanation which has been offered by the existing Committee that there will be disruption of work and/or handover cannot be made properly is only an excuse on part of the Committee to extend its term inasmuch as the Committee was always aware that the term would expire on 11.10.2025 and it ought to have made necessary arrangements for audit, for completion of work or the like. Be that as it may, even if there are works which are pending, the new Committee could continue and complete those works, which cannot be a ground for extending the term of the existing Committee. 12.5 Hence, I answer point No.2 by holding that while exercising powers under Clause (b) of SubSection (1) of Section 27A of KSRA, 1960, the principles of natural Justice are not required to be followed, the existing Committee is not required to be heard, if the term of the existing Committee has come to an end and a new Committee has not taken charge in terms of Clause (b) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 27A of KSRA, 1960, an Administrator would have to be appointed, the only formality being an order to be passed by the state government, which is required to be published in the official Gazette. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 96 HC-KAR

13.1 Having answered point No.2 above, the principles of natural Justice are not required to be followed. Hence, the question of enquiry under Section 25, is also not required since I have already rejected the contention of Sri.M.R.Rajagopal, learned Counsel that on enquiry, the State Government, must consider it necessary in public interest to do so, would not apply to Clause (a) and (b), but it is only integral and restricted to Clause (c) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 27A of KSRA, 1960.”

7.2. By relying on K.Shivanna, his submission is that the nature and extent of the procedure to be followed by the State Government while exercising the power under Section 27-A(1) depends upon the particular clause under which the Administrator is proposed to be appointed. The requirement of an enquiry culminating in the State Government satisfying itself that appointment of an Administrator is necessary in the public interest is specifically attracted to the circumstances

falling

under

Clause

(c)

of

Section 27-A(1), and cannot be mechanically imported into cases falling under Clause (b). 7.3. He submits that Clause (b) operates in a materially different factual situation, namely, where the term of the governing body of the Society has expired and, for whatever reason, a 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 97 HC-KAR

new governing body has not been constituted. In such a case, the expiry of the tenure is an objective and ascertainable fact. Once the term of the existing governing body has expired and the newly constituted governing body has not taken charge, the outgoing Committee has no continuing

statutory

tenure

which

can

be

extended merely on the ground that certain administrative

or

other

matters

remain

incomplete. 7.4. His submission is that, in such circumstances, the appointment of an Administrator under Clause (b) is not founded upon an allegation of misconduct,

financial

irregularity

or

other

wrongdoing

requiring

adjudication.

It

is

a

statutory consequence flowing from the expiry of the term of the governing body and the absence of a newly constituted governing body. Consequently, the considerations applicable to an appointment under Clause (c), including an enquiry

into

circumstances

warranting

intervention in the public interest, cannot be imported into an appointment under Clause (b). 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 98 HC-KAR

7.5. He submits that the decision in K. Shivanna makes it clear that, while exercising the power under Clause (b), the State Government is not required to issue a notice to the outgoing Committee hearing

or

afford

merely

it

an

before

opportunity

of

appointing

an

Administrator. The principles of natural justice do not have to be separately complied with in such a case because there is no disputed allegation

requiring

an

adjudicatory

determination against the existing Committee. 7.6. He further submits that the fact that the outgoing Committee may have certain pending works,

administrative

matters,

accounts

or

other matters to be completed cannot confer upon it a right to continue beyond the statutory tenure. The Committee is expected to make necessary arrangements before expiry of its term so as to facilitate an orderly transition. The pendency of work or the apprehension of disruption in handing over charge cannot, by itself, constitute a ground for continuation of the expired Committee. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 99 HC-KAR

7.7. Relying particularly upon paragraph 13.1 of K. Shivanna, he submits that the requirement of an enquiry under Section 25 is not an invariable or universal precondition for every exercise of power

under

Section

27-A.

The

said

requirement is integral to and confined to the circumstances contemplated under Clause (c). It does not extend to the cases covered by Clauses (a) and (b), where the statutory basis for intervention is different. 7.8. He

therefore

submits

that

Petitioner's

contention that, in every case where the State Government

proposes

to

appoint

an

Administrator, it must first conduct an enquiry under Section 25, afford an opportunity of hearing

and

record

a

satisfaction

that

appointment is necessary in the public interest, is contrary to the express distinction drawn in Section 27-A(1) and the interpretation placed upon

provision

by

this

Court

in

K.

Shivanna. 7.9. His submission is that the authorities relied upon

by

requirement

of

Petitioner

concerning

enquiry,

hearing

and

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 100 HC-KAR

independent

satisfaction

of

State

Government have to be understood in the context of Clause (c) of Section 27-A(1), where the appointment of an Administrator is founded upon circumstances requiring such an enquiry. Those

decisions

cannot

be

applied

indiscriminately to a case falling under Clause (b), where the statutory trigger is the expiry of the term of the governing body coupled with the failure to constitute or bring into office a new governing body. 7.10. He accordingly submits that the first question for

consideration

is

precise

statutory

provision under which the State Government has

exercised

power

to

appoint

Administrator. If the appointment is referable to Clause (b) of Section 27-A(1), the requirement of a further enquiry under Section 25 and a separate opportunity of hearing to the outgoing Committee, as contemplated in cases falling under Clause (c), would not arise. The only statutory

requirement,

according

to

decision in K. Shivanna, is that the State Government

pass

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

requisite

order

of

- 101 HC-KAR

appointment and publish the same in the Official Gazette. 7.11. He further submits that the Petitioner's reliance upon the fact that its office bearers were democratically

elected

cannot,

in

circumstances contemplated by Clause (b), extend

tenure

beyond

that

of the

prescribed

by

governing

body

Society's

governing framework. The democratic character of the Committee does not confer a right to continue in office after expiry of its lawful tenure. 7.12. He therefore submits that, if the material on record establishes that the term of the existing governing body had expired and that no newly constituted governing body had taken charge,

State

Government

was

competent

to

appoint an Administrator under Clause (b) without undertaking a further enquiry into the alleged irregularities or recording a separate finding regarding public interest. The challenge based solely upon non-compliance with the procedure

applicable

to

consequently be misplaced. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

Clause

(c)

would

- 102 HC-KAR

7.13. He submits that the subsequent publication of the order of appointment in the Official Gazette would further satisfy the statutory requirement recognised in paragraph 12.5 of K. Shivanna. Consequently, once the appointment is shown to have been made under the appropriate clause of Section 27-A(1) and the order has been duly gazetted, the challenge based upon absence of a prior enquiry or prior hearing cannot be sustained if the case falls within Clause (b). 7.14. His submission, therefore, is that K. Shivanna establishes an important distinction in the statutory

scheme:

an

appointment

under

Clause (b), founded upon expiry of the tenure of the governing body and absence of a new governing body, does not require the enquiry and natural justice safeguards applicable to Clause (c); whereas an appointment under Clause (c), being founded upon circumstances warranting intervention in the public interest, attracts the requirement of enquiry and the corresponding opportunity contemplated by the provision. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 103 HC-KAR

7.15. He accordingly submits that the Petitioner's challenge must first be tested with reference to the particular clause of Section 27-A(1) under which the Administrator has been appointed. The Petitioner cannot rely upon the procedural safeguards applicable to Clause (c) to invalidate an appointment validly made under Clause (b). On that basis, he submits that the challenge to the appointment on the ground of absence of a further enquiry and absence of an opportunity of hearing is liable to be rejected. 7.16. He refers to the decision in Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha and the State of Karnataka by its Principal Secretary,7 more particularly, para 12, 50 and 51 thereof which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: “12. During pendency of the present writ petitions, an application was filed by the impleading applicants seeking permission to implead themselves and to come on record as Respondent Nos.4 to 9. After earing the parties, this Court by the order dated 28.11.2018 allowed the application and permitted the proposed impleading applicants to come on record as Respondent Nos.4 to 9, who have also filed their written submission reiterating the objections filed by the State Government contending that, the Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha has committed several mismanagement, misfeasance and misuse of funds, against the interest of the Sangha while admitting the students to the Medical

W.P.No.36772/2018 and other connected matters dated 08.01.2019 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 104 HC-KAR

College run by the Sangha for the First Year MBBS Course and there has been host complaints lodged by the students and their parents regarding the gross misconduct and corruption by the Executive Committee Members. The Office bearers of the Sangha and its Executive Committee Members have collected entire admission fees fixed by the Government from the MBBS students and inspite of collecting entire admission fees from students for the respective academic year, they have not deposited the entire amount to the account of the Sangha. They have remitted only a part of the amount and retained the balance amount with themselves with an undertaking that they will remit the same at a later stage. But till now, they have not remitted the same. Hence, the Sangha-Institution has suffered huge loss of money. In those context, some of the students, who have been admitted in excess than the quota fixed by the Government for Medical Courses by misleading them for extraneous consideration and when their admissions were not approved by the MCI/University, had also approached this Court and this Court had passed strictures on the Management of the Institution by imposing penalty of Rs. Three Crores which shows that the Managing Committee is not protecting the interest of the Institution/Sangha and there are criminal cases registered against some of the Office Bearers or Directors. Therefore, sought to dismiss the writ petitions.

50. Though Respondent Nos.4 to 9 filed the written statement and brought to the notice of the Court that several irregularities have been committed by the Office Bearers of the Sangha including criminal cases, this Court cannot take into consideration to supply new material to the impugned order. As it is well settled by the catena of decisions of this Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Respondents cannot supplement to the impugned order by way of additional documents or the statement of objections in support of the impugned order. The State Government, who has passed the impugned order is justified in appointing the Administrator under the provisions of Section 27-A(1)(a) of the Act in view of the admitted facts and violation of the provisions of Sections 11, 12 and 13 of 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 105 HC-KAR

the Act and the Bye-laws of the Sangha, as stated in the pleadings of the writ petitions.

51. It is high time for the members of the Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha or any other Sanghas or Societies to maintain honesty and integrity while electing the Office Bearers of the respective Societies in the interest of Community and Society at large. It is to be remembered that "there is no wealth greater than good reputation and, bad reputation is death itself". The persons who contest the elections to the Societies or particular Sangha as Members should adopt and practice three principles of life: "Daiva Preethi, Papa Bheethi, Sanga Neethi i.e., Love for God, Fear of sin, Morality in Society". If there is no Morality to a person to contest the election for the Society or on behalf of any Sangha, it is his death itself.”

7.17. By referring to Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha, his submission is that the office bearers of a registered Society are under an obligation to discharge their functions in accordance with the provisions of the Act, the Rules and the byelaws of the Society and in a manner that protects the interests of the Society and its members. The elected status of the office bearers immunity

does

not

from

confer

upon

statutory

them

any

scrutiny

or

intervention where the affairs of the Society are found to have been conducted contrary to the governing statutory provisions or the bye-laws. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 106 HC-KAR

7.18. He submits that, in the present case, the enquiry report records specific irregularities in the functioning and financial administration of the Petitioner-Club. The findings are not based upon a mere difference of opinion between the members of the Club, but upon the material collected during the course of the enquiry, including

accounting

manner

of

maintenance

of

membership of

financial

collection

and

subscriptions, records

and

compliance with the bye-laws governing the affairs of the Club. 7.19. His submission is that the material placed before

competent

authority

disclosed

circumstances warranting statutory intervention in the affairs of the Club. The Enquiry Officer, upon consideration of the material available during the enquiry, recorded findings regarding the irregularities and recommended appropriate consequential action. The report was thereafter placed before the competent authority and the State Government, upon consideration of the material,

proceeded

Administrator. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

to

appoint

an

- 107 HC-KAR

7.20. He

submits

that

decision

in

Rajya

Vokkaligara Sangha also makes it clear that

validity

of

action

of

State

Government has to be tested with reference to the material and reasons which formed the basis of the impugned order. The Respondents cannot seek to cure any deficiency in the order by subsequently introducing fresh grounds, documents

or

explanations

through

their

statement of objections. 7.21. His submission, therefore, is that the State Government is not seeking to supplement the impugned order by relying upon material which was unavailable or not considered at the time of passing the order. The appointment of the Administrator is founded upon the enquiry report and the material which was placed before the competent authority during the statutory

proceedings.

The

subsequent

reference to such material in the statement of objections is only explanatory of the basis on which the impugned action was taken and does not constitute an attempt to introduce a new ground for the appointment. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 108 HC-KAR

7.22. He further submits that the Petitioner has not demonstrated that the findings recorded in the enquiry report are wholly unsupported by the material available on record. On the contrary,

enquiry

proceedings

disclose

repeated

opportunities having been afforded to the Club and its office bearers to produce the relevant records

and

explain

allegations.

The

Petitioner having failed to place the requisite material before the Enquiry Officer cannot now seek to invalidate the proceedings merely by disputing the conclusions reached therein. 7.23. His

submission

is

that

financial

and

administrative irregularities recorded in the enquiry

report

are

material

circumstances

which the competent authority was entitled to take

into

whether

consideration statutory

while

intervention

determining in

management of the Club was warranted. The proper maintenance of the funds and records of a registered Society and adherence to its byelaws are matters directly connected with the lawful administration of the Society. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 109 HC-KAR

7.24. He

submits

that

decision

in

Rajya

Vokkaligara Sangha demonstrates that where there

are

admitted

demonstrating

facts

violation

of

or

material

governing

statutory provisions and bye-laws, the State Government is entitled to exercise the power conferred upon it under Section 27-A. The power is intended to ensure that the affairs of a registered Society are conducted in accordance with law and that the interests of the Society are not prejudiced by the acts or omissions of its governing body. 7.25. He accordingly submits that the fact that the Petitioner-Club is managed by a democratically elected Executive Committee cannot, by itself, defeat

statutory

power

of

State

Government. The right of an elected governing body to continue in management is subject to the Act, the Rules and the bye-laws, as well as the statutory powers conferred upon the State Government where the conditions prescribed under Section 27-A are satisfied. 7.26. He further submits that the conduct of the office bearers, as disclosed from the enquiry 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 110 HC-KAR

proceedings, is relevant to the consideration of whether the existing management is capable of properly administering the affairs of the Club. The repeated failure to produce the relevant financial and administrative records, coupled with the findings recorded in the enquiry report regarding the manner in which membership funds

were

collected

and

accounted

for,

constitutes sufficient material for the competent authority to consider intervention. 7.27. His submission is that the Petitioner cannot seek

to

compartmentalise

individual

irregularities identified in the enquiry report and contend

that

each

irregularity,

viewed

in

isolation, is insufficient to warrant appointment of an Administrator. The competent authority was entitled to consider the cumulative effect of the financial, administrative and procedural irregularities

while

determining

whether

continuation of the existing management was consistent with the interests of the Club and its members. 7.28. He submits that the enquiry report, read as a whole,

discloses

a

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

pattern

of

irregular

- 111 HC-KAR

administration technical

rather

infraction.

than The

an

isolated

findings

or

regarding

collection of membership subscriptions, nonaccounting of cash collections, non-issuance of receipts, inadequate maintenance of financial records and irregularities in the conduct of the affairs of the Club were circumstances which

competent

authority

was

entitled

to

that,

once

consider cumulatively. 7.29. He

accordingly

submits

competent authority was satisfied on the basis of

material

before

it

that

statutory

intervention was warranted, the appointment of an Administrator cannot be interfered with merely because the Petitioner seeks to place a different

interpretation

disputes

upon

conclusions

facts

or

recorded

in

enquiry report. 7.30. He submits that the observations in paragraph 51 of Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha, though expressed in strong terms, emphasise the broader principle that persons entrusted with the management of registered Societies are required to act with honesty, integrity and in 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 112 HC-KAR

the interests of the Society and its members. The elected office bearers hold a position of trust

and

are

required

to

ensure

proper

administration and financial accountability. 7.31. He therefore submits that the present case is not one where the State Government has interfered with the elected management merely on

basis

of

a

private

dispute

or

unsubstantiated allegations. The appointment has followed an enquiry pursuant to complaints, consideration of the material relating to the affairs of the Club, recording of findings by the Enquiry Officer and consideration of the matter by the competent authority. 7.32. He accordingly submits that no fault can be found with the action of the State Government in

appointing

an

Administrator,

particularly

when the material on record demonstrates irregularities in the administration and financial affairs of the Club and the Petitioner has failed to

effectively

rebut

same

despite

opportunities having been afforded to it. 7.33. He submits that, to the extent the appointment is founded upon Clause (b) of Section 27-A(1), 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 113 HC-KAR

the additional requirement of an enquiry and satisfaction

in

public

interest

contemplated

under Clause (c) would not arise, in view of the law laid down in K. Shivanna. The State Government was therefore entitled to proceed in accordance with the statutory consequence contemplated under Clause (b), subject to compliance with the requirements applicable to that provision. 7.34. He therefore submits that the reliance placed by the Petitioner upon decisions concerning the procedural

requirements

applicable

to

appointments under Clause (c) is misplaced if, on a proper construction of the impugned order and the statutory basis for the appointment, the action is referable to Clause (b). The challenge must be examined with reference to the precise statutory clause invoked and the reasons recorded by the State Government in support of its action. 7.35. He accordingly submits that the decision in Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha, read with K. Shivanna, supports the validity of the action taken by the State Government, provided the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 114 HC-KAR

impugned order itself discloses the statutory basis and material upon which the power under Section 27-A was exercised. The Petitioner has not

established

any

ground

warranting

interference with the impugned order and the writ petition is therefore liable to be dismissed. 8.

Sri D R Ravishankar, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, in reply would submit that 8.1. He relies upon the decision in Bharata Ratna Mokshgundam Society

Vs.

Viswaswaraiah

District

Registrar,

Education (Deputy

Commissioner), Kolar, more particularly para 6 thereof, which is reproduced hereunder for easy reference. “6. The grounds mentioned in the aforesaid clauses (a) and (b) of sub-sec. (1) of S. 27A of the Act are not exhaustive. The report made by the Registrar under sub-cl. (c) thereof may be on the other grounds other than the grounds mentioned in clauses (a) and (b) thereof. The State Government under S. 27A(1) of the Act is empowered to appoint an Administrator for a Society registered under the Act either on a report made by the Registrar or otherwise, but on enquiry the State Government has to be satisfied that it is necessary in the public interest to appoint an Administrator. No doubt, the Registrar has no power under S. 27A(1) of the Act to appoint an Administrator for a Scoiety registered 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 115 HC-KAR

under the Act; but he is entitled to make a report to the State Government for appointing an Administrator to the Society. If for the purpose of making such a report, the Registrar gives a notice to the Society and calls upon it to show cause as to why an action under S. 27A(1) of the Act should not be taken, such an act cannot be held beyond the competence of the Registrar. Show cause notice issued by the Registrar is only for the purpose of making a report to the State Government under S. 27A(1)(c) of the Act and not for appointing an Administrator by himself. Therefore, it is not possible to hold that the notice issued by the Registrar is illegal and is opposed to the provisions of S. 27A(1) of the Act. Even though the report is made by the Registrar after affording an opportunity to the Society, the State Government on receipt of such a report is still required to afford an opportunity to the society, and it has to be satisfied on holding an enquiry that it is necessary in public interest to appoint an Administrator for the soeciety for a specified period as per the provisions contained in clause (c) of sub-sec. (1) of S. 27A of the Act, as the power to appoint an Administrator is vested in the State Government. The fact that the Registrar has given notice before making a report under clause (c) of sub-Section (1) of S. 27A of the Act does not dispense with the enquiry to be held and an opportunity to be afforded to the Society by the State Government before it decides to appoint an Administrator to the Society. Therefore, point No. 3 is answered against the Petitioner.”

8.2. By relying on Bharata Ratna Mokshgundam Viswaswaraiah

Education

Society,

his

submission is that the statutory scheme under Section 27-A(1) of the Act draws a clear 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 116 HC-KAR

distinction between the role of the Registrar and

that

of

State

Government.

The

Registrar is competent to conduct the enquiry necessary for the purpose of making a report under Section 27-A(1)(c) and to submit such report to the State Government; however, the power to appoint an Administrator is vested exclusively with the State Government. The Registrar, therefore, cannot, either expressly or by

implication,

assume

power

of

appointment vested in the State Government. 8.3. He submits that the report of the Registrar is only

material

upon

which

State

Government may proceed under Section 27A(1)(c) and does not conclude the matter. Upon receipt of such report, the State Government is required to independently consider whether the statutory conditions for appointment of an Administrator are satisfied. In particular, it is required to afford an opportunity to the Society and, upon holding the enquiry contemplated under

satisfaction

provision, that

arrive

at

its

own

appointment

of

an

Administrator is necessary in the public interest for a specified period. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 117 HC-KAR

8.4. His submission, therefore, is that the enquiry conducted by the Registrar for the purpose of submitting a report cannot be treated as a substitute

for

enquiry

required

to

be

undertaken by the State Government before exercising its statutory power of appointment. The fact that the Society may have been afforded an opportunity by the Registrar before submission of the report does not, by itself, dispense with the independent obligation of the State Government to afford an opportunity to the Society and to consider the matter before taking the consequential decision. 8.5. He

accordingly

submits

that

State

Government cannot mechanically act upon, or merely accept, the report submitted by the Registrar

and

proceed

to

appoint

an

Administrator. It must independently apply its mind to the report, the objections/explanation of the Society and the other material available on

record, and

must

satisfaction

that

Administrator

is

record the requisite

appointment necessary

interest. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

in

of

an public

- 118 HC-KAR

8.6. In the present case, his submission is that no such independent enquiry has been undertaken by the State Government and no separate opportunity of hearing has been afforded to the Society after receipt of the Registrar's report. Consequently, the statutory preconditions for exercise of the power under Section 27-A(1)(c) have not been fulfilled. The appointment of the Administrator, compliance

having

with

been

made

mandatory

without statutory

procedure, is therefore liable to be set aside. 8.7. He

further

submits

Government

that

proceeds

where to

State

appoint

an

Administrator without undertaking the enquiry contemplated under Section 27-A(1)(c), and without affording the Society the opportunity expressly contemplated by the provision, the resulting appointment is without jurisdiction and cannot be sustained in law. He accordingly submits that the impugned appointment ought to be set aside. 8.8. He relies upon the decision in K.N.Rudrappa and Others Vs. The State of Karnataka, Rep. by its Principal Secretary Revenue 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 119 HC-KAR

Department,8 more particularly paras 10, 11 and

thereof,

which

are

reproduced

hereunder for easy reference: “10. In view of the contention put forth on behalf of Respondent No. 1 that the present action has been initiated on the report of the Registrar, obviously the power is sought to be exercised as contemplated under Section 27A(1)(c) of the Act. When that is the position, even before adverting to the issue as to whether such situation on the instant facts had arisen, it is necessary to notice as to whether the procedure contemplated in law had been followed. Though the learned counsel for the Respondents had relied on the decision in the case of the very same society noticed supra, it would not apply to the present situation since nothing has been brought on record with regard to the notice having been issued by the Government before passing the order under Section 27A of the Act. It is no doubt true that the Enquiry Officer had issued a notice dated 25.05.2012 and the society had replied to the same on 26.06.2012. Subsequent thereto, the Registrar had issued the notice dated 18.01.2013 wherein it is informed to the society that since an enquiry is to be conducted with regard to the report submitted relating to the election conducted to elect the office bearers, the society is required to appear with all the documents. The society has made a detailed reply dated 06.02.2013. Thereafter neither a detailed enquiry has been held nor the report been sent to the society. However, the impugned order dated 05.07.2013 refers to two reports of the Registrar - one dated 09.11.2012 and the other dated 14.03.2013 which are both subsequent to the date of the elections to the post of the office bearers which were scheduled on 21.03 2012. The details of the said report has not been relied upon in these petitions to come to a conclusion as to whether the Registrar was justified in his conclusion in the background of the

2014 SCC Online Kar 2040 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 120 HC-KAR

contention put forth by the Respondents that the election had been held by nominating persons who were not entitled to and excluding persons who were entitled to. 11. Even otherwise, if there were certain reports adverse to the society and even if a situation for exercise of power under Section 27A of the Act had arisen, the Government was required to notify the society and should have provided an opportunity as held by this Court in the case of People's Education Society (supra). In fact this aspect has been amplified further by a subsequent decision of this Court and as such, it will be useful to refer to the case of Bharataratna Mokshagundam Vishweshwaraiah Education Society v. The District Registrar (Deputy Commissioner), Kolar (AIR 1985 Kar 163) wherein it is held as hereunder: 5B. Even though the report is made by the Registrar after affording an opportunity to the Society, the State Government on receipt of such a report is still required to afford an opportunity to the society and it has to be satisfied on holding an enquiry that it is necessary in public interest to appoint an Administrator for the society for a specified period as per the provisions contained in clause (c) of sub-sec (1) of S. 27A of the Act, as the power to appoint an Administrator is vested in the State Government. The fact that the Registrar has given notice before making a report under clause (c) of sub-Section (1) of S. 27A of the Act does not dispense with the enquiry to be held and an opportunity to be afforded to the Society by the State Government before it decides to appoint an Administrator to the Society. Therefore, point No. 3 is answered against the Petitioner. 12. In addition, it would also be useful to take note of the decision of this Court in the case of V. Narayanaswamy v. The State of Karnataka (2004 (1) KCCR 504) wherein the decision of the Registrar was the recommendation for appointment of Administrator. In such situation, it was held that it is mandatory for the Registrar to communicate the result of enquiry to 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 121 HC-KAR

the Society concerned, so that the Society should have the opportunity to defend such action. Since no copy was furnished and further since no enquiry was held as mandatorily required under Section 27-A(1)(c) of the Act, the order appointing the Administrator was found fault with and the samBy relying on K.N.Rudrappa, his submission is that this Court in K.N.Rudrappa’s case has come to a conclusion that if the State were not to conduct an enquiry by issuance of notice under Section 27-A(1)(c), then any order passed by the government without such an enquiry is illegal. Apart from the Registrar notifying the Society about the enquiry report, it was also required for the government to notify the Society about its intention to appoint an Administrator for the Society. Clause-C of Sub-Section 1 of Section 27-A does not dispense with the enquiry to be held and an opportunity to be afforded to the Society by the State Government before it appoints an Administrator to the Society. In the present case, the State Government not having issued any notice, the State Government could not have appointed an Administrator.”

8.9. By relying on K.N.Rudrappa, his submission is that where the power under Section 27-A(1)(c) of the Act is sought to be exercised on the basis of a report submitted by the Registrar, the statutory procedure does not come to an end with the enquiry conducted by the Enquiry Officer or the Registrar. The report of the Registrar is only a step preceding the exercise of

statutory

power

by

State

Government, which is the competent authority to appoint an Administrator. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 122 HC-KAR

8.10. He submits that the decision in K.N. Rudrappa makes it clear that even where the Enquiry Officer or the Registrar has issued notice to the Society and afforded it an opportunity during the enquiry, such opportunity cannot be treated as a substitute for the opportunity required to be afforded by the State Government before exercising the power under Section 27-A(1)(c). 8.11. His submission is that the State Government, upon receipt of the report of the Registrar, is required to independently notify the Society of the proposed action and afford it an effective opportunity to meet the allegations and findings contained in the report. The State Government is thereafter required to consider the material available on record and satisfy itself that the statutory conditions for appointment of an Administrator under Clause (c) are fulfilled. 8.12. He submits that the requirement of an enquiry under Section 27-A(1)(c) cannot be treated as a mere formality. The provision contemplates an independent consideration by the State Government as to whether, in the facts and circumstances of the case, appointment of an 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 123 HC-KAR

Administrator

is

necessary

in

public

interest. The report submitted by the Registrar may constitute the basis for such consideration, but it does not itself constitute the decision of the State Government. 8.13. He further submits that the distinction between the enquiry conducted by the Registrar/Enquiry Officer and the consideration required by the State Government is fundamental. The former results in a report or recommendation; the latter involves exercise of the statutory power to appoint an Administrator. Since the power of appointment

is

vested

in

State

Government, the State Government must itself comply with the procedural safeguards attached to that power. 8.14. Relying upon paragraph 11 of K.N. Rudrappa, he submits that even if an adverse report has been submitted by the Registrar and even if circumstances exist which may warrant exercise of power under Section 27-A, the Government is still required to notify the Society and afford it an opportunity before passing the order of appointment. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 124 HC-KAR

8.15. He submits that the opportunity afforded before the Enquiry Officer or the Registrar cannot be treated

as

sufficient

compliance

with

requirement applicable at the stage of decisionmaking by the State Government. The Society must have an opportunity to meet the case which is ultimately placed before the State Government and the proposed consequential action of appointment of an Administrator. 8.16. He further relies upon the principle referred to in paragraph 12 of K.N. Rudrappa, arising from V. Narayanaswamy [2004 (1) KCCR 504],

that

where

Registrar's

decision

constitutes a recommendation for appointment of an Administrator, the result of the enquiry is required to be communicated to the Society so as to enable it to defend itself against the proposed action. The communication of the report is therefore an important component of the procedural safeguards available to the Society. 8.17. His

submission

is

that

failure

to

communicate the enquiry report, coupled with the failure of the State Government to issue 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 125 HC-KAR

notice to the Society before appointing an Administrator,

deprives

Society

of

an

effective opportunity to challenge the factual and legal basis for the proposed appointment. Such a procedure, according to him, is contrary to the express statutory scheme and the law laid down by this Court. 8.18. He submits that the State Government cannot rely merely upon the fact that the Society had participated in

proceedings

Enquiry

Officer.

The

relevant

whether

Society

was

opportunity

at

stage

before

question

is

afforded

an

when

State

Government itself proposed to exercise the power

under

Section

27-A(1)(c).

The

opportunity

at

earlier

stage

opportunity

at

stage

of

and

consequential

decision-making operate at distinct stages and serve different purposes. 8.19. In the present case, his submission is that, though the Petitioner-Club participated in the enquiry conducted by Respondent No.4, the enquiry report was thereafter acted upon by the authorities

without

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

State

Government

- 126 HC-KAR

undertaking

contemplated

under

independent Section

enquiry 27-A(1)(c).

According to him, the Petitioner was not issued an appropriate notice by the State Government setting out the proposed action on the basis of the enquiry report and was not afforded an effective opportunity to demonstrate why an Administrator should not be appointed. 8.20. He submits that the subsequent issuance of a show-cause notice dated 09.04.2026, relied upon by the State, would have to be examined to

determine

statutory

whether

opportunity

it

constitutes

contemplated

under

Section 27-A(1)(c), whether the enquiry report and material relied upon were made available to the Petitioner, and whether the Petitioner was

afforded

a

meaningful

opportunity

to

respond before the final decision was taken. 8.21. He further submits that merely issuing a showcause

notice

cannot,

by

itself,

establish

compliance with the statutory requirement. The State Government was required to consider the response, if any, and the material placed by the Society

and

thereafter

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

arrive

at

its

own

- 127 HC-KAR

satisfaction

regarding

necessity

of

appointment of an Administrator in the public interest. The requirement is therefore one of meaningful

consideration

and

not

merely

issuance of notice as a procedural formality. 8.22. He

submits

that

subsequent

order

appointing the Administrator must therefore disclose

that

independently

State

considered

Government material

and

arrived at the requisite satisfaction. If the order merely reproduces or adopts the findings of the Enquiry

Officer

without

independent

consideration, the requirement recognised in K.N. Rudrappa, according to him, would not stand satisfied. 8.23. He accordingly submits that, in a case falling under Section 27-A(1)(c), the following stages are required to be distinguished: (i) initiation and conduct of the enquiry; (ii) recording of findings and submission of the report by the Enquiry Officer/Registrar; (iii) communication of the relevant findings/report to the Society; (iv) notice

by

State

Government

of

proposed appointment; (v) opportunity to the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 128 HC-KAR

Society to place its defence before the State Government;

and

(vi)

independent

consideration and satisfaction by the State Government

that

Administrator

is

appointment

necessary

in

of

an public

interest. 8.24. His submission is that the omission of any of these

essential

independent

safeguards,

particularly

opportunity

before

and

consideration by the State Government, vitiates the exercise of power under Section 27-A(1)(c). The enquiry conducted by the Enquiry Officer cannot cure the subsequent failure of the State Government

to

comply

with

statutory

requirements governing its own exercise of the power. 8.25. He therefore submits that the decision in K.N. Rudrappa,

read

with

Mokshagundam

Bharataratna

Vishweshwaraiah

Education Society and V. Narayanaswamy, makes it clear that the Registrar's report is not conclusive and that the State Government must independently

undertake

process

contemplated by Section 27-A(1)(c), including 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 129 HC-KAR

affording an opportunity to the Society before deciding to appoint an Administrator. 8.26. He accordingly submits that, in the present case,

if

State

Government

did

not

undertake such independent consideration and enquiry after receipt of the Registrar's report,

appointment

of

Administrator

is

contrary to the mandatory requirements of Section 27-A(1)(c) and is liable to be set aside. 8.27. On all the above grounds, learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner submits that all the reliefs which have been sought for by the Petitioner are required to be granted. 9.

Heard Sri. D.R.Ravishankar, learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, Smt.Prathima Honnapura, Learned Additional Advocate General for Respondents No.1 to 5, Sri.K. M. Prakash, learned counsel who is the intervener

in

I.A.No.6/2026

and

Sri.C.M.

Dhananjaya, learned counsel, who is the intervener in I.A.No.5/2026. Perused papers. 10.

The points that would arise for consideration are: (i)

Whether the Section 25 enquiry enquiry report dated 10.03.2026 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

and are

- 130 HC-KAR

vitiated for non-compliance with Section 25 and Rule 8, including denial of oral hearing and failure to receive/consider the Petitioner's material? (ii)

Whether, after receipt of the report of the authorised Enquiry Officer, the Registrar was required to independently apply his mind to the enquiry report and the material on record before acting upon or forwarding the same; and, where the Registrar recommended appointment of an Administrator and Government thereafter issued a separate show-cause notice proposing such appointment and furnished the enquiry report to the Petitioner, whether the result of the enquiry was nevertheless required to be separately communicated to the Petitioner under Section 25(2)(c)(iii), or whether furnishing the enquiry report along with Government's show-cause notice constituted sufficient compliance with the said provision?

(iii) Under which clause of Section 27-A(1), Clauses (a), (b) or (c), was the State Government's power exercised, and what are the statutory requirements applicable to such exercise? (iv) Whether, as contended by the Petitioner, an enquiry and independent satisfaction by the State Government are required in all three contingencies under Section 27A(1), or whether the requirement of enquiry and public-interest satisfaction is 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 131 HC-KAR

confined to Clause (c), having regard, inter alia, to the decision in K. Shivanna? (v)

If the appointment is referable to Clause (c), whether the State Government, after receipt of the Registrar's/Enquiry Officer's report, independently considered material, afforded the Petitioner an effective opportunity, considered its response and arrived at the requisite satisfaction that appointment of an Administrator was necessary in public interest?

(vi) Whether the order dated 14.05.2026 appointing the Administrator is otherwise sustainable in law, and consequently whether the Petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought? (vii) What Order?

11.

This Court answers the above points as follows:

12.

Answer to Point No. (i): Whether the Section 25 enquiry and enquiry report dated 10.03.2026 are vitiated for non-compliance with Section 25 and Rule 8, including denial of oral hearing and failure to receive/consider the Petitioner's material? 12.1. Sri D.R. Ravishankar, learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, submitted that the enquiry conducted by Respondent No.4, the Assistant 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 132 HC-KAR

Registrar of Societies acting as Enquiry Officer, was vitiated from the very outset. His first plank

was

President,

factual.

According

Vice-President,

to

him,

Secretary,

Joint

Secretary and Executive Committee members of the Club appeared before the Enquiry Officer on

04.02.2026.

They

tendered

a

detailed

explanation running to about eleven pages, supported by roughly four hundred pages of documents. This material, he said, was not accepted, and no reason was assigned for the refusal.

A

second

set

of

written

replies,

supported by close to thirteen hundred and fifty pages

of

documents,

was

tendered

on

04.03.2026 by the Secretary and the Treasurer, and this too, according to the Petitioner, met the same fate. Taken together, his submission was that upward of seventeen hundred pages of material placed by the Club before the Enquiry Officer never found their way into the enquiry report, because they were never taken on record in the first place. 12.2. His second ground concerned the atmosphere in which the enquiry was held. He submitted that persons who were neither officers of the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 133 HC-KAR

Department nor members of the Club were present

during

proceedings.

The

proceedings, he said, were conducted in an atmosphere

of

intimidation

and

coercion,

including apprehension of physical harm to office bearers, and this could be shown through CCTV footage and photographs taken at the time. On this basis, he described the enquiry as having

proceeded

in

a

manner

that

was

arbitrary, mala fide and contrary to natural justice, with the Enquiry Officer effectively acting

as

a

mouthpiece

for

two

complainants, Sri K. Puttaswamy Gowda and Sri Hanumantharayappa, rather than as an independent statutory functionary. 12.3. Learned Senior Counsel then referred to the statutory scheme. He first referred to Section 25 of the KSR Act and submitted that the provision contemplates an enquiry into the constitution, working and financial condition of a registered society. Such enquiry may be conducted by the Registrar himself or by a person authorised by him in accordance with the Rules. He then referred to Rule 8 of the KSR Rules and submitted that it lays down a 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 134 HC-KAR

specific procedure to be followed in the enquiry. The

procedure

includes

issuance

of

notice

setting out the matters to be enquired into, an opportunity to the society to submit its written explanation and, separately, an oral hearing on the date fixed for the enquiry. 12.4. He submitted that the use of the word "shall" in Rule 8(4) makes the oral hearing mandatory. A written explanation under Rule 8(3), according to him, cannot take the place of the oral hearing required under Rule 8(4). Therefore, an oral hearing was not given and that the same was not recorded, the enquiry report would be contrary to Rule 8(4). 12.5. In support of this submission, he relied upon the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Sri Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti, Madlere

Vs.

particularly submitted

The

State

paragraphs that,

in

that

of

Karnataka,

and

case,

16.

He

Hon’ble

Division Bench noticed that the order sheet did not show that an oral hearing had been given and, on that basis, held that the enquiry report 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 135 HC-KAR

was in violation of Rule 8(4) and the principles of natural justice. 12.6. Learned Senior Counsel also relied upon the decision of a co-ordinate bench of this Court in BHEL Employees Welfare Association Vs. State of Karnataka, particularly paragraph 7. His submission was that an enquiry or order cannot be sustained where the objections of the society are not considered, the documents produced by it are not dealt with and there is no satisfaction recorded as to whether the evidence was recorded in the manner required under Rule 8(4). According to him, the same defect is present in the present case. He submitted

that

about

1,700

pages

of

documents were produced by the Club, but the enquiry

report

does

not

deal

with

those

documents or explain why they were not considered. 12.7. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the validity of the enquiry has to be examined with reference to the following aspects: 12.7.1.

whether notice as required under Rule 8(1) and (2) was issued; 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 136 HC-KAR

12.7.2.

whether the Club was given a proper opportunity

to

submit

its

written

explanation under Rule 8(3); 12.7.3.

whether an oral hearing, as required under Rule 8(4), was actually given;

12.7.4.

whether

documents

and

other

material produced by the Club were received and considered; 12.7.5.

whether the findings recorded under Rule 8(5) are supported by the material and by the procedure followed during the enquiry; and

12.7.6.

where the enquiry was conducted by an authorised person, whether the Registrar thereafter independently considered the enquiry report and the material before taking any further action.

12.8. He submitted that the enquiry suffers from more than one of these defects. His further submission

was

that

report

dated

10.03.2026, therefore, cannot form the basis for the subsequent action taken against the Club. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 137 HC-KAR

12.9. Smt. Prathima Honnapura, learned Additional Advocate General appearing for Respondent Nos.1 to 5, responded to this contention by referring to the proceedings recorded in the order sheet of the enquiry. She submitted that the Enquiry Officer first fixed the matter for hearing on 20.01.2026. On that date, the President and the Treasurer appeared in the absence of the Secretary and sought forty-five days' time to submit their reply, stating that the relevant records were with the Secretary, who was stated to be unwell. The matter was accordingly adjourned. 12.10. She submitted that, on 04.02.2026, the Club represented that the documents were with Sri B.M. Ravishankar, a former office bearer, and sought a further three months' time. Sri B.M. Ravishankar, however, informed the Enquiry Officer that he had resigned earlier and did not have any documents of the Club. The matter was thereafter adjourned to 18.02.2026. As no substantive reply was filed on that date, the matter was again adjourned to 04.03.2026. On 04.03.2026, the Secretary and the Treasurer appeared, while the President was absent. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 138 HC-KAR

According to the learned Additional Advocate General, the statements made on that date disclosed different versions as to who was in possession

of

relevant

records.

The

Secretary referred to the President, while the Treasurer stated that his role was confined to signing

cheques

at

instance

of

President. 12.11. Learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the above chronology shows that the Club was given repeated opportunities to participate in the enquiry and to place its explanation and documents before the Enquiry Officer. She submitted

that,

despite

opportunities

granted and the adjournments sought by the Club, no substantive explanation or specific documents, which the Club now claims were refused by the Enquiry Officer, were placed before the Enquiry Officer. 12.12. She further submitted that the order sheet records the participation of the office bearers and was signed by the President on the respective occasions without any protest being recorded. Her submission was that a party 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 139 HC-KAR

which participates in the proceedings, seeks and obtains repeated adjournments and signs

proceedings

without

recording

any

objection cannot subsequently contend, without identifying the particular instance, that it was denied an opportunity of hearing. 12.13. As regards the allegation that the Enquiry Officer refused to receive documents, learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the Petitioner has not identified any particular document which was actually tendered before the Enquiry Officer and refused to be received. According to her, the record instead shows that the Club itself gave different versions as to the person

in

possession

of

relevant

documents. She therefore submitted that the grievance is not one of refusal by the Enquiry Officer, but of the Club having failed to produce the documents despite being given sufficient opportunity to do so. 12.14. With regard to the decision in Sri Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti, learned Additional Advocate

General

submitted

that

said

decision turned on the facts of that case. She 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 140 HC-KAR

pointed out that, there, the order sheet did not disclose that an oral hearing had been given. In the present case, according to her, the order sheet records the appearance of the President, Secretary and Treasurer on different dates and also records the submissions made by them. 12.15. She therefore submitted that the record in the present case demonstrates that the Club was given an opportunity of oral hearing and that the requirement under Rule 8(4) was complied with. On that basis, she submitted that the enquiry

and

report

dated

10.03.2026

cannot be held to be vitiated for want of oral hearing. 12.16. This Point involves two separate issues. The first is whether the requirement of oral hearing under Rule 8(4) of the Karnataka Societies Registration Rules was complied with. The second is whether the documents said to have been tendered by the Petitioner-Club were refused or ignored by the Enquiry Officer. The two issues have to be considered separately, keeping in view the provisions of Section 25 of the Act and Rule 8 of the Rules. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 141 HC-KAR

12.17. Section 25 (1) of the Act, insofar as relevant, reads as follows: "25. Enquiry by the Registrar, etc.- (1) The Registrar may on his own motion and shall on the application of the majority of the members of the governing body or of not less than onethird of the members of the society, hold an enquiry or direct some person authorised by him by order in writing in accordance with the rules made in this behalf to hold an enquiry into the constitution, working and financial condition of a registered society."

12.18. Sub-Section (2), insofar as relevant, provides: "(2) The Registrar or the person authorised by him under subSection (1) shall have the following powers, namely,(a) he shall, at all reasonable times, have free access to the books, accounts, documents, securities, cash and other properties belonging to or in the custody of the society...; (b) he may summon any person who, he has reason to believe, has knowledge of any of the affairs of the society to appear before him...and may examine such person on oath; (c)(i) he may...require the governing body of the society to call a general meeting...; (ii) any meeting called under subclause (i) shall have all the powers of a general meeting...; (iii) when an enquiry is made under this Section, the Registrar shall communicate the result of the enquiry to the society concerned."

12.19. Section 25 (1) thus permits the Registrar either to conduct the enquiry himself or to authorise another person to conduct it. The Registrar or the authorised person is given power to access 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 142 HC-KAR

the records of the society and to examine persons having knowledge of its affairs. The provision also specifically requires the Registrar to communicate the result of the enquiry to the society. Section 25 does not set out the detailed procedure to be followed during the enquiry. That procedure is prescribed by Rule 8 of the Rules. 12.20. Rule 8 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Rules, as referred to during the hearing, reads as follows: “8. Enquiry by the Registrar.- (1) Where the Registrar proposed to hold an enquiry under Section 25, either on his own motion or on an application, he or the person authorised by him under the said Section to hold an enquiry shall issue notice to the society concerned in this behalf. (2) The said notice shall specify a date on which, place in which and the time at which, as also the matters in respect of which the enquiry will be held. The notice shall also call upon the society to furnish its explanation in respect of matters referred to therein before the date specified in the notice. (3) The society shall furnish its explanation to the Registrar or the authorised person before such date." (4) On the date fixed for the enquiry, or on such other date or dates to which the enquiry might be adjourned, the Registrar or the authorised person shall give the society a oral hearing. He may also examine such persons as may be considered necessary. He may receive any relevant document. If the society fails to furnish its explanation as required under subrule (3) or to attend the enquiry on the date fixed or the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 143 HC-KAR

adjourned date, the Registrar or the authorised person may proceed with the enquiry ex parte. (5) On the completion of the enquiry, the Registrar or the authorised person shall record his findings and communicate the same to the society concerned."

12.21. Rule 8, read as a whole, sets out the procedure to be followed in the enquiry. It begins with notice, followed by an opportunity to submit a written

explanation,

an

oral

hearing

and,

thereafter, recording of findings. Rule 8(4) uses the word "shall" in relation to the oral hearing. The requirement of oral hearing, therefore, cannot be treated as optional. The filing of a written explanation does not dispense with the requirement of oral hearing. The two serve different

purposes.

A

written

explanation

enables the society to place its case in writing, while an oral hearing gives it an opportunity to explain its case before the Enquiry Officer and answer any questions that may arise. To this extent,

submission

of

learned

Senior

Counsel is well founded. 12.22. The decision of the Division Bench in Sri Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti, also supports this position. In paragraph 15, the Hon'ble Division Bench observed that where 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 144 HC-KAR

Rule 8(4) requires the Enquiry Officer to give an oral hearing, it is necessary for the Enquiry Officer to record that such hearing was given to the society or the aggrieved person. In that case, since the order sheet did not disclose that an oral hearing had been given, the enquiry report was held to be in violation of Rule 8(4). The principle emerging from the decision is that the oral hearing required by Rule 8(4) must actually be given and the record of the enquiry should show that it was given. 12.23. The

question,

therefore,

is

whether

this

requirement was complied with in the present case. On this aspect, the facts are different from those in Sri Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti. The chronology placed before this

Court

by

Smt.

Prathima

Honnapura,

learned Additional Advocate General, and the dates of hearing are not in dispute. The order sheet shows that the office bearers of the Club appeared

before

20.01.2026,

Enquiry

04.02.2026,

Officer

18.02.2026

on and

04.03.2026. On these dates, the President, Secretary and Treasurer appeared on different occasions

and

made

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

submissions.

The

- 145 HC-KAR

submissions were mainly in relation to the availability and custody of the Club's records, and the matter was adjourned on more than one occasion. The Petitioner does not dispute that these proceedings took place. Its grievance is that the documents which it claims to have produced were not received or considered. 12.24. On the material before this Court, it cannot be held

that

there

was

no

oral

hearing

as

contemplated by Rule 8(4). In Sri Beereswara Devastana Seva Samiti, the record did not show that any oral hearing had been given. The position here is different. The order sheet records the appearance of the Club's office bearers on four different dates and also records the submissions made by them. The requests for

further

time

were

considered

and

adjournments were granted. Thus, the record shows that the Club was given an opportunity to appear before the Enquiry Officer and make its submissions, which it did not. 12.25. Rule 8(4)

requires an opportunity of oral

hearing. It does not mean that the enquiry must be adjourned repeatedly until the society 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 146 HC-KAR

is ready with all its records. In the present case, the Club was given more than one opportunity

to

appear

and

make

its

submissions, despite which neither documents were submitted nor oral submissions made. 12.26. There is, however, one aspect which requires consideration. The proceedings on the four dates show that the Club and its office bearers were not refusing to participate in the enquiry. Their consistent request was for time to submit their

explanation

on

ground

that

relevant records and papers were not available with them. In an enquiry which concerns, among other things, the financial transactions of the Club, an explanation without access to the relevant accounts, records and supporting documents

would

have

had

little

practical

value. The request for time was therefore considered by the Enquiry Officer and the matter was adjourned on more than one occasion. 12.27. The record, however, also shows that the Club and its office bearers did not make use of the time granted to place their explanation on 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 147 HC-KAR

record. On each occasion, the question of custody of the records was raised and a further adjournment was sought. If the Club was ready to address the allegations, it could have placed before the Enquiry Officer whatever records were available with it and made its submissions on

that

basis.

Instead,

proceedings

continued to be postponed on the ground that the records were with some other person. No substantive reply dealing with the allegations was placed before the Enquiry Officer during this period. 12.28. This conduct is relevant when the present allegation

of

denial

considered.

The

Club

of was

oral

hearing

given

is

repeated

opportunities to appear before the Enquiry Officer. It sought time to enable it to obtain the records which, according to it, were necessary for giving its explanation, and those requests were granted. Having itself sought time on the ground that the records were not available, the Club cannot now, without explaining this earlier stand, contend that it was denied an oral hearing because the records were not available. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 148 HC-KAR

12.29. There is also an apparent inconsistency in the stand

now

taken

by

Petitioner.

The

contemporaneous record shows that time was sought on the ground that the relevant papers were with the Secretary, and later with a former office bearer. The present contention is that the documents were produced before the Enquiry Officer but were not received. These two versions cannot readily stand together. If the documents had already been tendered before the Enquiry Officer, there would have been no reason to repeatedly seek time on the ground that the documents were not available. Conversely,

if

Club

was

seeking

time

because the records were not available, the present allegation that the same records had already

been

tendered

and

were

refused

requires specific proof. 12.30. Rule 8(4) certainly requires an oral hearing, and that requirement cannot be diluted. But the rule does not require the Enquiry Officer to adjourn the proceedings indefinitely when the society repeatedly seeks time without placing its explanation on record. The record in the present case shows that the Club was heard, 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 149 HC-KAR

that its requests for time were considered and that the adjournments

sought

by it were

granted. The subsequent claim that the Club was denied an oral hearing, therefore, cannot be accepted merely because it chose to seek further

time

instead

of

addressing

allegations on the dates fixed for the enquiry. 12.31. The grievance that about 1,700 pages of documents

were

tendered

but

were

not

received by the Enquiry Officer would have to be considered in detail. The decision in BHEL Employees Welfare Association is relevant to this issue. In paragraph 7 of that decision, this Court found that the District Registrar had not considered the objections of the Petitioner and had not recorded any finding with regard to the documents filed by it. The Court also noticed

absence

of

satisfaction

as

to

whether the evidence had been recorded in accordance with Rule 8(4). On that basis, the enquiry was quashed and the matter was remitted. 12.32. The principle of that decision is that material properly placed

before the Enquiry Officer

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 150 HC-KAR

cannot simply be ignored. If documents or objections are received as part of the enquiry, the record should show that they have been considered. 12.33. The question in the present case is whether the material relied upon by the Petitioner was in fact tendered and received during the enquiry. For this purpose, the actual record has to be examined rather than the number of pages alone. 12.34. The

sequence

of

events

shows

that

on

04.02.2026 the Club sought time on the ground that

relevant

papers

were

with

Secretary. It was thereafter stated that the documents were with Sri B.M. Ravishankar, a former office bearer. Sri B.M. Ravishankar, however, informed the Enquiry Officer that he had resigned earlier and did not have the Club's documents.

On

04.03.2026,

Secretary

stated that the President was handling the relevant

transactions,

while

Treasurer

stated that his role was limited to signing cheques on the instructions of the President. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 151 HC-KAR

12.35. Thus, the record shows different versions from the office bearers themselves as to the custody of the Club's records. This is different from a case where documents are admittedly tendered before the Enquiry Officer and are thereafter refused or ignored. The decision in BHEL Employees

Welfare

Association

applies

where material has been placed on record and there is no consideration of that material. It cannot be applied in the same manner where the very fact that the documents were tendered and refused is disputed. 12.36. It is also relevant that the Petitioner has not identified any particular document which was tendered on a particular date and refused by the Enquiry Officer. The Petitioner relies mainly on the figure of about 1,700 pages, stated to comprise

explanation

and

documents

produced on 04.02.2026 and 04.03.2026. 12.37. The mere assertion that a large volume of documents was ready to be tendered is not sufficient to establish that the documents were actually produced before the Enquiry Officer and

were

refused.

Whether

09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

a

particular

- 152 HC-KAR

document was tendered and, if so, whether it was

refused

or

was

not

produced,

would

require consideration of the competing versions of the parties. If necessary, such an issue may also require evidence. 12.38. This Court, exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, is not required to determine disputed questions of fact which cannot be decided on the basis of the existing record. The Court is concerned with examining the legality of the decision on the material before it. It would not be appropriate, in these proceedings, to conduct a factual enquiry into whether

each

of

comprise

1,700

documents

said

pages

actually

was

to

tendered and refused. More so, when they are not even placed before this Court. 12.39. The order sheet is also relevant in this regard. It bears the signature of the President of the Club on more than one occasion, and no objection is recorded regarding the manner in which

proceedings

were

conducted.

A

contemporaneous record of the proceedings carries considerable weight, particularly when it 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 153 HC-KAR

has been signed by the person representing the Club without recording any protest. 12.40. The Petitioner has now alleged that documents were refused and that the proceedings were conducted in an atmosphere of intimidation. Such allegations cannot, however, be accepted merely

on

contemporaneous

assertion

when

record

not

support

does

them and no specific instance of refusal has been identified. 12.41. The Petitioner has also contended that persons who were not office bearers or members were present during the proceedings and that the atmosphere was intimidating. It is submitted that this can be established from CCTV footage and photographs. 12.42. These are allegations of fact. The material said to support them has not been placed before this Court in a manner which would permit their examination. This Court cannot, in a writ proceeding, undertake a fresh examination of disputed

factual

allegations

by

weighing

evidence. The allegations are therefore noticed, 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 154 HC-KAR

but no finding can be recorded on them in the absence of material sufficient to establish them. 12.43. It is necessary to make clear the scope of the finding on this issue. This Court finds that the record shows that the Club was given an oral hearing on four dates and that the requirement of Rule 8(4), in that regard, was substantially complied with. This Court also finds that the allegation that about 1,700 pages of documents were tendered and wrongly refused has not been established with sufficient particulars. To

extent

that

this

allegation

involves

a

disputed question of fact, it cannot be decided in the present writ proceedings. 12.44. As regards the six aspects placed by learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, this Court finds that: 12.44.1. the issuance of notice is not disputed. 12.44.2. The Club was given opportunities to submit its explanation and appeared before the Enquiry Officer on several dates. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 155 HC-KAR

12.44.3. The order sheet also records the oral submissions made by its office bearers. 12.44.4. The specific allegation that documents were tendered and refused has not been established on the material placed before this Court. 12.44.5. As regards the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer, the question whether the findings are supported by the material available in the enquiry will have to be considered while examining the report and the subsequent action based on it. 12.44.6. The sixth aspect raised by learned Senior Counsel, namely, whether the Registrar independently applied his mind after receiving Officer,

report

a

separate

is

of

issue.

Enquiry It

will

therefore be considered while examining Point No.(ii). 12.45. For the above reasons, Point No.(i) is answered against the Petitioner. The Section 25 enquiry and the report dated 10.03.2026 are not shown to be vitiated for want of an oral hearing under 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 156 HC-KAR

Rule 8(4). The Club was given an opportunity of oral hearing on more than one occasion. The allegation that the documents relied upon by

Petitioner

were

tendered

but

wrongly

refused has also not been established on the material before this Court. 13.

Answer to Point No. (ii): Whether, after receipt of the report of the authorised Enquiry Officer, the Registrar was required to independently apply his mind to the enquiry report and the material on record before acting upon or forwarding the same; and, where the Registrar recommended appointment of an Administrator and the Government thereafter issued a separate show-cause notice proposing such appointment and furnished the enquiry report to the Petitioner, whether the result of the enquiry was nevertheless required to be separately communicated to the Petitioner under Section 25(2)(c)(iii), or whether furnishing the enquiry report along with the Government's show-cause notice constituted sufficient compliance with the said provision? 13.1. Sri. D.R. Ravi Shankar, learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, submitted that a person authorised by the Registrar under Section 25(1) is only a delegate and does not exercise the statutory power vested in the Registrar. Relying on the decision of this Court in Karnataka Roller Skating Association (R) Vs. State of 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 157 HC-KAR

Karnataka, particularly paragraphs 4 and 6, he submitted that the Registrar cannot simply reproduce

charges

and

findings

recorded by the Enquiry Officer and proceed on that basis without independently considering the report. 13.2. He referred to paragraph 6 of the said decision, which considers the earlier decision of this Court in Gousemohammad and another Vs. The District Registrar of Societies. Learned Senior Counsel placed particular reliance on paragraphs

7.6,

7.7

and

7.8

Gousemohammad.

He

submitted

of that

Gousemohammad makes it clear that the person authorised to conduct the enquiry acts only

as a

delegate of

the Registrar. The

Registrar is required to independently consider the enquiry report and the material before him. He may accept the report or reject it and, if necessary, order a fresh enquiry. The Registrar, he

submitted,

cannot

act

merely

as

a

"postman" by forwarding the enquiry report to the society without first applying his own mind to it. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 158 HC-KAR

13.3. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the enquiry report and the decision of the Registrar upon that report are two different stages. The enquiry report is the result of the fact-finding exercise conducted by the authorised person. The Registrar, on receiving that report, is required to consider it independently and take the decision which the statute requires him to take. According to him, the existence of an enquiry report by itself does not establish that the Registrar has independently applied his mind. 13.4. He

submitted

that,

in

present

case,

although the record refers to an acceptance of the enquiry report, no reasons are recorded for such acceptance. His submission is that merely stating that the report is accepted, without indicating that the Registrar considered the report and the material independently, does not show application of mind. 13.5. Learned

Senior

Counsel

also

relied

upon

Section 25(2)(c)(iii), which provides that, when an enquiry is made under Section 25, the Registrar "shall communicate the result of the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 159 HC-KAR

enquiry

to

society

concerned".

He

submitted that the use of the word "shall" makes

communication

of

result

a

mandatory requirement. 13.6. According to him, this requirement is separate from the opportunity given to the society during

enquiry.

The

opportunity

to

participate in the enquiry enables the society to place its explanation and material before the Enquiry Officer. Communication of the result serves a different purpose: it informs the society of the outcome of the statutory process. The

two

safeguards,

therefore,

cannot

be

treated as interchangeable. 13.7. His submission was that the Club was entitled to know what conclusion had ultimately been reached on the material placed before the Enquiry Officer. Unless the result of the enquiry was communicated to it, the Club would not know whether its explanation and material had been considered and accepted, rejected or otherwise dealt with. 13.8. Lastly, he submits that on communication, the Club ought to have been given an opportunity 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 160 HC-KAR

to make its submission on the enquiry report, before acceptance by the Registrar. 13.9. Learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that failure to comply with Section 25(2)(c)(iii), coupled with the absence of any recorded independent consideration by the Registrar, vitiates the further action founded upon the enquiry report. 13.10. Smt. Prathima Honnapura, learned Additional Advocate General, submitted that the Petitioner is proceeding on the assumption that the Registrar was required to pass a separate and elaborate order accepting the report of the Enquiry Officer. She did not dispute that no such separately reasoned order of acceptance has

been

placed

before

this

Court.

Her

submission, however, was that the report was not treated as the final decision. It was placed before Respondent No.1 through Respondent Nos.2 and 3 for consideration by the State Government. 13.11. She submitted that it was Respondent No.1, the State Government, which thereafter took the matter forward. The State Government issued a 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 161 HC-KAR

show-cause notice dated 09.04.2026 referring to the irregularities and findings recorded in the enquiry report and called upon the PetitionerClub to explain why further action should not be taken. According to her, the Club was thus made aware of the substance of the findings before the final decision was taken. She pointed out that the Club did, in fact, submit its explanation dated 18.04.2026 in response to the notice and dealt with the allegations made against it. 13.12. Learned Additional Advocate General submitted that

decisions

in

Karnataka

Roller

Skating Association and Gousemohammad do not assist the Petitioner in the facts of the present case. According to her, those decisions dealt with cases where the report of the Enquiry Officer was treated as final and acted upon without any further consideration by the competent authority. 13.13. She submitted that the present case stands on a different footing. The enquiry report was followed by its consideration at the level of the concerned authorities and, more importantly, 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 162 HC-KAR

by an independent show-cause notice issued by the State Government. The State Government thereafter considered the Club's explanation before

passing

impugned

order.

Her

submission, therefore, was that the process cannot be said to have ended with the report of the Enquiry Officer and that the Petitioner cannot contend that the State Government mechanically acted upon that report without giving the Club an opportunity to respond. 13.14. The Petitioner raises two objections. First, it is contended

that

independently

consider

Registrar

report

did

not

of

Enquiry Officer. Secondly, it is contended that, after receiving the enquiry report, the Registrar was required to give the Petitioner another opportunity of hearing before recommending appointment of an Administrator to the State Government. 13.15. The first objection is not supported by the record. The material shows that the report of the Enquiry Officer was placed before the Registrar, that the proposal for appointment of an Administrator was considered by him and 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 163 HC-KAR

that he thereafter made a recommendation to the State Government. The Registrar therefore did not merely forward the report without consideration. 13.16. This is also consistent with the principle laid down

in

Karnataka

Roller

Skating

Association v. State of Karnataka, namely, that the Registrar must apply his own mind to the report of the authorised Enquiry Officer. The Registrar

cannot

mechanically

adopt

findings of the Enquiry Officer. In the present case, however, the record shows consideration by the Registrar before the recommendation was made. 13.17. The second objection requires the scheme of Sections 25 and 27A to be considered in sequence. 13.18. Section 25 provides for an enquiry into the constitution, working and financial condition of a registered society. The enquiry may be conducted by the Registrar himself or by a person authorised by him. Rule 8 prescribes the procedure to be followed in such enquiry. The society is given notice, an opportunity to 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 164 HC-KAR

furnish its explanation and an opportunity of hearing. The Enquiry Officer thereafter records his findings and submits his report. 13.19. The important point is that a Section 25 enquiry

does

not

necessarily

lead

to

appointment of an Administrator. The enquiry may

find

that

allegations

established.

It

may

disclose

irregularities

requiring

are

only

correction.

not minor

It

may

disclose misapplication of funds, misfeasance or breach of trust, in which case proceedings under Section 26 may become relevant. In an appropriate case, the findings may be such that appointment

of

an

Administrator

requires

consideration under Section 27A. 13.20. Thus, appointment of an Administrator is only one possible consequence of a Section 25 enquiry. The Section 25 enquiry is not itself a proceeding for appointment of an Administrator. Its purpose is to ascertain the constitution, working and financial condition of the society and to place the findings before the Registrar. 13.21. After

enquiry

report

is

received,

Registrar has to consider it. If the material does 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 165 HC-KAR

not call for further action, the matter may end there. If it discloses matters attracting another statutory provision, appropriate proceedings may follow. If, however, the Registrar considers that the circumstances warrant appointment of an Administrator, he may recommend such action to the State Government. 13.22. This is the point at which Section 27A becomes relevant. The Registrar's recommendation does not itself appoint an Administrator. The power to appoint an Administrator is vested in the State Government. The Government has to consider whether appointment is necessary in

public

interest.

recommendation

or,

It after

may

accept

considering

material and the explanation of the society, decide that an Administrator need not be appointed. 13.23. Therefore, the Registrar's recommendation and the Government's decision are not the same thing.

The

Registrar

forms

a

view,

on

consideration of the enquiry material, that the matter requires consideration under Section 27A. The Government thereafter has to make 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 166 HC-KAR

its own decision whether the statutory power should be exercised. 13.24. This explains the purpose of the show-cause notice issued by the State Government. The notice is not issued because the appointment of an Administrator has already been decided. It is issued precisely because the Government has to decide whether such appointment should be made. The society is therefore called upon to show cause against the proposed action. 13.25. In the present case, after the Registrar made his recommendation, the State Government issued

show-cause

notice

dated

09.04.2026. The enquiry report was furnished to the Petitioner and the Petitioner was called upon to explain why action should not be taken under Section 27A. The Petitioner submitted its explanation dated 18.04.2026. 13.26. The Petitioner was thus given the enquiry report

and

an

opportunity

to

answer

material on which the proposed action under Section 27A was based. This opportunity was before the authority which had the statutory power to appoint an Administrator. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 167 HC-KAR

13.27. The question, therefore, is whether, in addition to the hearing which the society had during the Section

enquiry

and

opportunity

subsequently given by the State Government under Section 27A, the Registrar was required to

conduct

enquiry

another report

hearing

on

same

before

making

his

recommendation. 13.28. Section 25(2)(c)(iii) provides that the Registrar shall communicate the result of the enquiry to the society. This requirement has to be given effect to. The question, however, is what is the purpose

of

such

communication

and

what

consequence follows where the report is not separately furnished by the Registrar before making

his

subsequently

recommendation, furnished

by

but

is State

Government along with the notice issued under Section 27A. 13.29. The purpose of communicating the result of the enquiry is to ensure that the society is made aware of the findings on the basis of which further action may be proposed and is given an opportunity to meet those findings before the 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 168 HC-KAR

competent authority takes the final decision. If that is the object of the requirement, there is no denial of that opportunity in the present case. The State Government furnished the enquiry report to the Petitioner along with the show-cause notice under Section 27A and called upon it to explain why an Administrator should not be appointed. 13.30. The

Petitioner

thus

knew,

before

Government took the final decision, the findings recorded in the enquiry and the material on which

Registrar's

recommendation

was

based. It was given an opportunity to answer

same

and,

in

fact,

submitted

its

explanation. The report was therefore not acted upon behind the back of the Petitioner. 13.31. In this context, the question cannot be decided merely by asking whether the report was furnished by the Registrar before he made his recommendation. The more material question is whether the Petitioner was denied an effective opportunity to know the findings and meet the material before the power under Section 27A was exercised. Where the report is furnished 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 169 HC-KAR

along with the Section 27A notice and the society is given an opportunity to respond before the Government takes the final decision,

purpose

of

disclosure

is

substantially

achieved. 13.32. The facts of the present case bear this out. After the Registrar made his recommendation, the State Government issued the show-cause notice dated 09.04.2026 and furnished the enquiry report to the Petitioner. The Petitioner was thereby made aware of the findings on which the proposed action was based. It was given an opportunity to submit its explanation and submitted its response dated 18.04.2026. 13.33. The position would have been different if the Government had proceeded under Section 27A without furnishing the enquiry report, relied upon the report without disclosing its contents to the society and thereafter taken a decision without giving the society an opportunity to meet the material. In such a case, the purpose of communicating the report would plainly have been defeated. That is not the position here. 09/10/2026, 12:10, Bengaluru

- 170 HC-KAR

13.34. The Petitioner's contention therefore involves two separate questions. The first is whether the result of the enquiry was required to be communicated. The answer to that question is plainly in the affirmative by reason of Section 25(2)(c)(iii). 13.35. The second is whether the fact that the Registrar did not separately communicate the report

before

necessarily

making

his

invalidates

recommendation

subsequent

proceedings under Section 27A. That does not follow merely from the first proposition. 13.36. The second question has to be considered in the light of the purpose of the requirement and

opportunity

actually

available

to

Petitioner. In the present case, the report was furnished at the commencement of the Section 27A proceedings. The Petitioner was called upon to show cause against the proposed appointment and was given an opportunity to place its case before the authority competent to take the final decision. It cannot therefore be said

that

Petitioner

09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

was

denied

an

- 171 HC-KAR

opportunity to know or answer the findings of the enquiry. 13.37. The fact that the report was furnished by the State Government rather than by the Registrar cannot, by itself, establish prejudice. What is material is that the report was disclosed to the Petitioner before the Government exercised its power

under

Section

27A

and

that

Petitioner was given an opportunity to respond to it. 13.38. This also answers the Petitioner's contention that the Registrar was required to give another hearing before making his recommendation. Communication of the result of the enquiry is not the same thing as a second adjudicatory hearing

before

25(2)(c)(iii)

requires

Registrar.

result

Section to

be

communicated; it does not expressly require the Registrar, after completion of the enquiry, to commence another round of proceedings in which the society is heard afresh on the report before a recommendation can be made under Section 27A. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 172 HC-KAR

13.39. The

distinction

Registrar

does

is

important

not

decide

because

whether

an

Administrator is to be appointed. He considers

enquiry

report

and,

where

circumstances so warrant, recommends that

matter

be

considered

by

State

Government. The final decision under Section 27A rests with the Government. 13.40. The Government, in turn, is not bound by the Registrar's recommendation. It must consider the material for itself and decide whether appointment of an Administrator is necessary in the public interest. The show-cause notice issued under Section 27A is therefore not a notice preceding an inevitable appointment. It is the opportunity given to the society to persuade the Government that an Administrator should not be appointed. 13.41. If, therefore, the Petitioner's case is that the report

had

Government

to

be

furnished

proceeded

to

before

consider

appointment of an Administrator, that purpose was achieved when the Government furnished the report along with the Section 27A showDigitally Signed By: 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 173 HC-KAR

cause

notice.

The

Petitioner

was

then

in

possession of the very material on which the Registrar's recommendation was based and had an

opportunity

to

answer

it

before

Government took the final decision. 13.42. Requiring a further hearing before the Registrar would serve no separate purpose in such circumstances. The Registrar would hear the society on the enquiry report, consider its objections and make his recommendation. The Government would thereafter have to furnish the same report and hear the society again before

deciding

whether

an

Administrator

should be appointed. This would create two successive hearings on substantially the same material, although the final power is vested only in the State Government. 13.43. The statutory scheme does not warrant such duplication. The Section 25 enquiry is a factfinding exercise concerning the constitution, working and financial condition of the society. The Registrar considers the result of that enquiry and, where appropriate, recommends further action. Section 27A then requires the 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 174 HC-KAR

State

Government

to

decide

whether

appointment of an Administrator is necessary in the public interest. 13.44. The

fact

that

consideration

Registrar

recommends

of

appointment

of

an

Administrator does not alter this position. A Section 25 adverse

enquiry

action.

may end

It

may

without any

result

in

minor

corrective measures. It may disclose matters attracting

Section

26.

It

appropriate

case

that

is

only

in

Registrar

an may

consider that the circumstances warrant a recommendation under Section 27A. Even then, the recommendation does not itself result in appointment. 13.45. This is also why the exigency under Section 27A

has

exigency

to

be

does

properly not

understood.

arise

because

The an

Administrator must necessarily be appointed. The Government may, after considering the society's explanation, decide that appointment is not warranted. The exigency arises because, once the Registrar has recommended that the question of appointment requires consideration, 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 175 HC-KAR

the Government must consider that question without avoidable delay. 13.46. Such prompt consideration may be necessary where

circumstances

disclosed

in

enquiry concern the functioning, administration or

financial

affairs

of

society.

Those

circumstances may continue or worsen while the matter remains pending. The need for prompt consideration is therefore part of the practical operation of Section 27A. 13.47. This does not mean that urgency permits the Government to dispense with notice or hearing. It does not. The society must be informed of the material relied upon and must be given a meaningful opportunity to respond. That is precisely what was done here when the enquiry report

was

furnished

with the show-cause

notice and the Petitioner's explanation was obtained. 13.48. The

statutory

scheme

therefore

does

not

require a choice between urgency and natural justice. Both are preserved by requiring the Government to furnish the report, issue notice and hear the society before taking the final 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 176 HC-KAR

decision. What is unnecessary is to introduce an additional hearing before the Registrar which would precede the Government's consideration and

substantially

duplicate

opportunity

which the society is thereafter given before the competent authority. 13.49. The present case is consequently different from a case in which the society is never supplied with the enquiry report or is required to face an order under Section 27A without knowing the material against it. Here, the Petitioner received the report, knew the findings on which the proposed

action

was

based,

submitted

its

explanation and was heard before the authority competent to make the final decision. 13.50. The conclusion, therefore, is a limited one. Section 25(2)(c)(iii) requires the result of the enquiry to be communicated to the society. But that requirement cannot, without more, be converted into a requirement of a second hearing before the Registrar. Where the report is furnished by the State Government along with the Section 27A notice and the society is given an opportunity to respond before the 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 177 HC-KAR

Government takes the final decision, the object of ensuring disclosure of the report and an opportunity to meet its findings has been achieved. 13.51. This Court answers Point No. (ii) by holding that the Registrar independently considered the enquiry

report

before

making

his

recommendation. A Section 25 enquiry does not

invariably

lead

to

appointment

of

an

Administrator; it may result in no further action, corrective

measures

or

proceedings

under Section 26. Only in an appropriate case does the matter proceed to consideration under Section 27A. The Registrar's recommendation does not itself appoint an Administrator. The State Government must independently decide whether such appointment is necessary in the public

interest.

In

present

case,

Government furnished the enquiry report along with the show-cause notice under Section 27A and gave the Petitioner an opportunity to submit its explanation before taking the final decision. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 178 HC-KAR

13.52. If the purpose of communicating the report is to ensure that the society knows the findings and

is

able

to

meet

them

before

Government decides whether an Administrator should

be

appointed,

that

purpose

was

achieved in the present case. The fact that the report was furnished by the Government at the Section 27A stage, rather than separately by

Registrar

before

making

his

recommendation, does not, by itself, establish prejudice or require a second hearing before the Registrar. 13.53. Requiring an additional hearing would result in duplication and could delay the Government's consideration

of

whether

intervention

was

necessary. The exigency under Section 27A is therefore

not

an

urgency

to

appoint

an

Administrator without hearing the society; it is the need to decide promptly, after hearing the society,

whether

Administrator

is

appointment necessary

in

of

an public

interest. 14.

Answer to Point No. (iii): Under which clause of Section 27-A(1), Clauses (a), (b) or (c), was the State Government's power exercised, and 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 179 HC-KAR

what are the statutory requirements applicable to such exercise? 14.1. Sri. D.R. Ravi Shankar, learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, took the Court through Section 27-A(1) of the Act. He submitted that

provision

deals

with

three

separate

situations in which the State Government may appoint an Administrator. 14.2. According to him, Clause (a) applies where the society has not held, or is unable to hold, its annual general meeting because of pending litigation or otherwise. Clause (b) applies where the term of the governing body has expired and a

new

governing

body

has

not

been

constituted. Clause (c) applies where, on a report of the Registrar or otherwise, and on enquiry, the State Government considers it necessary in the public interest to appoint an Administrator. 14.3. His

broader

submission,

which

will

be

considered under Point No.(iv), was that an enquiry and an independent satisfaction of the State Government are required under all three clauses. For the present Point, however, his 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 180 HC-KAR

submission was that the facts of the present case bring it within Clause (c). 14.4. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that there is no case that the Club failed to hold its annual general meeting. He pointed out that an annual general

meeting

was

in

fact

held

on

01.02.2026, though the Petitioner contends that

meeting

was

disrupted.

He

also

submitted that there is no case that the term of the Executive Committee had expired. 14.5. According to him, the sequence of events itself shows the provision under which the State Government proceeded. There was a complaint, followed by an enquiry under Section 25, an enquiry

report

and

a

recommendation

for

appointment of an Administrator based on the findings in that report. His submission was that this is a case falling within Section 27-A(1)(c). 14.6. Smt. Prathima Honnapura, learned Additional Advocate General, did not dispute that the proceedings

commenced

with

complaints,

followed by an enquiry under Section 25 and submission of an enquiry report recommending appointment of an Administrator. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 181 HC-KAR

14.7. Her submission was that the State Government had before it the Section 25 enquiry report, considered the material contained in the report, issued a show-cause notice to the Petitioner referring to the irregularities found during the enquiry and thereafter passed the impugned order. 14.8. She did not contend that the appointment was made because the Club had failed to hold an annual general meeting. She also did not contend that the term of the governing body had

expired.

Thus,

on

this

aspect,

submission of the State proceeds on the same basis as that of the Petitioner, namely, that the action

was

taken

with

reference

to

circumstances contemplated under Section 27A(1)(c). 14.9. Sri. K.M. Prakash, learned counsel appearing as intervener, relied upon the decision of this Court in K. Shivanna and Others Vs. State of Karnataka by its Secretary, particularly paragraphs 12.2 to 12.5 and 13.1. 14.10. His submission was that the requirement of an enquiry and satisfaction as to public interest, 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 182 HC-KAR

arising from the words "on enquiry" in Section 27-A(1), is applicable to Clause (c). According to him, the same requirement does not apply to Clause (b), where the term of the governing body has expired and a new governing body has not been constituted. 14.11. Learned

counsel

submitted

that

first

question, therefore, is to identify the clause under which the impugned order was made, since

statutory

depending

upon

submission

on

requirements

this

clause aspect

differ

invoked. was,

His

however,

confined to the legal position. He did not place any material before the Court to show that the term of the Club's governing body had expired or that the Club had failed to hold its annual general meeting. 14.12. Thus, on the material and submissions placed before this Court, neither the Petitioner nor the State Government has placed the impugned action on Clause (a) on the ground that the Club had failed to hold its annual general meeting, or on Clause (b) on the ground that the term of its governing body had expired. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 183 HC-KAR

14.13. The

proceedings

were

initiated

following

complaints, an enquiry under Section 25 was conducted, an enquiry report was submitted and

proceeded

State to

Government

consider

thereafter

appointment

of

an

Administrator. The case of both the Petitioner and the State Government, on this limited question, therefore, proceeds on the basis that the power exercised is referable to Section 27A(1)(c). 14.14. The question as to what follows from the invocation

of

Clause

(c),

including

requirement of enquiry, the opportunity to the society and the independent satisfaction to be recorded

by

State

Government,

is

considered under Point No.(iv). 14.15. Section 27-A(1) of the Act, in the portion material to this Point, reads as follows: "27A. Appointment of Administrator.- Notwithstanding anything in this Act,(1)(a) where any society on account of the pendency of litigation or otherwise has not held or is unable to hold the annual general meeting; or (b) where the term of office of the members of the governing body of a society has expired and a new governing body has not for any reason been constituted; or 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 184 HC-KAR

(c) where on a report made by the Registrar or otherwise, on enquiry, the State Government considers it necessary in public interest so to do, the State Government may, by order published in the official Gazette, appoint an Administrator for such society for such period, not exceeding six months, as may be specified in the order, to manage the affairs of the society."

14.16. Section

27-A(1)

provides

three

distinct

situations in which the State Government may appoint an Administrator. Clause (a) applies where the society has not held, or is unable to hold, its annual general meeting. Clause (b) applies where the term of the governing body has expired and a new governing body has not been constituted. Clause (c) applies where, on a report made by the Registrar or otherwise, and

on

enquiry,

State

Government

considers it necessary in the public interest to appoint an Administrator. 14.17. The facts of the present case make it clear that the impugned order does not proceed on Clause (a) or Clause (b). The Club did hold an annual general meeting on 01.02.2026. The dispute as to that meeting concerns the manner in which it was conducted and not the failure to hold it. There is also no case that the term of the 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 185 HC-KAR

elected Executive Committee had expired and that a new governing body had not been constituted. 14.18. On

other

commenced

hand,

with

complaints

proceedings regarding

affairs of the Club, followed by an enquiry under Section 25 of the Act. The Enquiry Officer submitted

a

recommending

report

dated

10.03.2026

appointment

of

an

Administrator. The matter thereafter proceeded through proposals and a show-cause notice issued by the State Government, culminating in the impugned order dated 14.05.2026. 14.19. The State Government has also not contended that the impugned order was passed because the Club had failed to hold its annual general meeting or because the term of its governing body had expired. Its case, as placed before this Court, is founded on the findings recorded in the Section 25 enquiry and the material placed before the Government thereafter. The proceedings therefore fall within Clause (c) of Section 27-A(1). 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 186 HC-KAR

14.20. The use of the expression "or otherwise" in Clause (c) makes it clear that the State Government may

act on a report of the

Registrar or on other material. That, however, does

not

dispense

with

remaining

requirements of Clause (c). Where that clause is invoked, the State Government must act on enquiry

and

must

consider

whether

appointment of an Administrator is necessary in the public interest. 14.21. This

distinction

is

important

because

appointment of an Administrator has a direct effect on the elected governing body. Under Section

27-A(3),

appointed,

once

an

governing

Administrator

is

body

to

ceases

exercise its powers and functions during the period of such appointment. The Administrator is also required to take steps for convening the general body and holding elections. The power is

therefore

not

a

routine

administrative

measure. 14.22. The decision in K. Shivanna relied upon by Sri K.M. Prakash has to be considered in this statutory context. That decision dealt with 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 187 HC-KAR

Clause (b), where the term of the governing body had expired and no new governing body had been constituted. The Court held that the enquiry

and

public-interest

requirement

contained in Clause (c) could not be imported into a case falling under Clause (b). The present case, however, is not a Clause (b) case. 14.23. On

material

before

this

Court,

foundation of the impugned order is the Section 25 enquiry and the report arising therefrom. There is no factual basis to treat the case as one falling under Clause (a) or Clause (b). The impugned order is therefore referable to Clause (c) of Section 27-A(1). 14.24. This Court answers point No. (iii) by holding that

power

exercised

by

State

Government in the present case was under Section

27-A(1)(c).

The

requirements

governing exercise of that power, including the scope of the enquiry, the consideration to be undertaken by the State Government and the requirement of satisfaction in public interest, are considered under Point No. (iv). 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 188 HC-KAR

15.

Answer to Point No. (iv): Whether, as contended by the Petitioner, an enquiry and independent satisfaction by State Government are required in all three contingencies under Section 27-A(1), or whether the requirement of enquiry and publicinterest satisfaction is confined to Clause (c), having regard, inter alia, to the decision in K. Shivanna? 15.1. Shri D.R Ravi Shankar, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, submitted that the words “on enquiry” in Section 27-A(1) should not be confined to Clause (c). According to him, the provision has to be read as a whole, having regard to the opening words of sub-Section (1) and the nature of the power conferred on the State Government. 15.2. His submission was that Clauses (a), (b) and (c) prescribe different factual situations in which an Administrator may be appointed, but the State Government must, in every case, first ascertain whether the conditions prescribed in the relevant clause are in fact satisfied. Thus, even in a case under Clause (a) or (b), the State Government must verify whether the term of the governing body has expired and 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 189 HC-KAR

whether a new governing body has not been constituted. 15.3. Learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that, irrespective of the clause invoked, the State Government must examine the relevant facts, afford an opportunity to the society and arrive at an independent satisfaction before appointing an Administrator. 15.4. Smt. Prathima Honnapura, learned Additional Advocate General, did not advance a separate submission on this question. Her case is that the present proceedings fall under Clause (c), and that the requirements of enquiry and independent

satisfaction

applicable

to

that

clause were complied with. Her submissions on that aspect are considered under Point No. (v) and need not be repeated here. 15.5. Sri K.M. Prakash, learned counsel appearing as intervener, relied upon the decision of this Court in K. Shivanna and Others v. State of Karnataka

by

paragraphs

12.2

its

Secretary,

to

12.5

and

particularly 13.1.

He

submitted that the decision makes a distinction between Clauses (b) and (c) of Section 27Digitally Signed By: 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 190 HC-KAR

A(1). According to him, the expression “on enquiry” and the requirement that the State Government be satisfied that appointment of an Administrator is necessary in the public interest are requirements of Clause (c). 15.6. He submitted that, in a case falling under Clause (b), the relevant facts are whether the term of the governing body has expired and whether a new governing body has not been constituted. Once those facts are established,

additional

requirements

applicable

to

Clause (c) cannot be imported into Clause (b). He therefore submitted that the enquiry and hearing contemplated in relation to Clause (c) cannot be treated as conditions precedent for an appointment under Clause (b). 15.7. The submission of the Petitioner that an enquiry is required in all three contingencies cannot be accepted.

The

question

has

already

been

considered in K. Shivanna, where the scope of Section 27-A(1) was examined with reference to the language of Clauses (a), (b) and (c). 15.8. The scheme of Section 27-A(1) makes a clear distinction between the three clauses. Clause 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 191 HC-KAR

(a) operates where the annual general meeting has not been held or cannot be held. Clause (b) operates where the term of the governing body has expired and a new governing body has not been constituted. Clause (c), on the other hand,

deals

with

a

different

situation.

It

requires the State Government, on an enquiry, to

consider

that

Administrator

is

appointment

necessary

in

of

an

public

interest. 15.9. The words “on enquiry” occur specifically in Clause

(c),

in

context

of

State

Government considering whether appointment of an Administrator is necessary in the public interest. They do not occur in Clauses (a) or (b). The distinction is deliberate. Clauses (a) and

(b)

are

founded

on

circumstances.

Clause

(c)

specific

factual

involves

an

assessment by the State Government as to whether, having regard to the material before it, intervention is necessary in the public interest. 15.10. This

was

distinction

recognised

in

K.

Shivanna. The decision holds that the enquiry 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 192 HC-KAR

contemplated by Section 27-A(1) is “integral and restricted to Clause (c)”. In a case under Clause (b), where the term of the governing body has expired and a new governing body has

not

been

requirement

to

constituted,

there

is

no

undertake

enquiry

contemplated by Clause (c) before appointing an Administrator. 15.11. The

Petitioner's

Government

submission that

must

nevertheless

State

conduct

an

enquiry in every case cannot, therefore, be accepted. Doing so would add to Clauses (a) and (b) a requirement which the Legislature has expressly incorporated only for Clause (c). 15.12. This does not mean that the State Government can act without ascertaining the facts necessary to

invoke

Clause

(a)

or

Clause

(b).

The

statutory condition contained in the relevant clause must necessarily exist. Thus, in a case under Clause (b), the State Government must be satisfied that the term of the governing body has expired and that a new governing body has not been constituted. What is not required is the separate enquiry contemplated by Clause 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 193 HC-KAR

(c),

including

an

enquiry

into

whether

appointment of an Administrator is necessary in the public interest. 15.13. The distinction is important in the present case. As already held under Point No. (iii), the impugned action is referable to Clause (c). The question, therefore, is not whether an enquiry was necessary. In a Clause (c) case, that requirement is part of the statute. The question is

whether

State

Government

in

fact

undertook the requisite enquiry, considered the material

independently

and

arrived

at

necessary satisfaction in public interest. 15.14. The decision in Rajya Vokkaligara relied upon by Sri K.M. Prakash, does not

require a

different conclusion on this question. That decision

concerned

an

appointment

under

Clause (a) and did not decide the question now under consideration as to whether the enquiry contemplated by Clause (c) extends to Clauses (a) and (b). 15.15. This Court answers Point No. (iv) by holding that the requirement of “on enquiry” and the consequent

satisfaction

09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

of

State

- 194 HC-KAR

Government

that

appointment

of

an

Administrator is necessary in the public interest are requirements of Clause (c) and are not conditions applicable uniformly to Clauses (a), (b) and (c). The State Government must, of course, ascertain that the factual conditions of the particular clause invoked are satisfied. Since the present case falls under Clause (c), the requirement of enquiry and independent satisfaction applies to the impugned action. Whether

that

requirement

was

actually

complied with is considered under Point No. (v). 16.

Answer to Point No. (v): If the appointment is referable to Clause (c), whether the State Government, after receipt of Registrar's/Enquiry Officer's report, independently considered material, afforded the Petitioner an effective opportunity, considered its response and arrived at the requisite satisfaction that appointment of an Administrator was necessary in public interest? 16.1. Shri D R Ravi Shankar, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the report of the Registrar or the Enquiry Officer is only material placed before the State Government and does not conclude the exercise required 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 195 HC-KAR

under

Section

27-A(1)(c).

He

relied

upon

paragraph 6 of the decision in Bharata Ratna Mokshgundam

Viswaswaraiah

Education

Society, where this Court held that even if an opportunity had been given to the society before the Registrar submitted his report, the State Government was still required to afford an opportunity to the society and satisfy itself, on

enquiry,

Administrator

that was

appointment necessary

in

of

an

public

interest. 16.2. Learned Senior Counsel also relied upon K.N. Rudrappa, particularly paragraphs 10 to 12. He submitted that the opportunity afforded during the Section 25 enquiry cannot substitute the opportunity required to be afforded by the State Government before exercising the power under Section 27-A(1)(c). 16.3. On the facts of the present case, he submitted that the show-cause notice dated 09.04.2026, by itself, does not establish compliance with Section 27-A(1)(c). According to him, the State Government

was

required

to

consider

Petitioner's response and the material placed by 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 196 HC-KAR

it and thereafter arrive at its own satisfaction as

to

necessity

of

appointing

an

Administrator. 16.4. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that there is no material to demonstrate such independent consideration or satisfaction. He contended that the impugned order proceeds substantially on the findings in the enquiry report, which are themselves disputed by the Petitioner. He submitted that the appointment of an Administrator, resulting in displacement of an elected Executive Committee, could not have been made without the State Government independently examining the allegations and the material relied upon against the Petitioner. 16.5. Smt. Prathima Honnapura, learned Additional Advocate General, submitted that the decisions relied

upon

by

Petitioner

are

distinguishable. According to her, the State Government

in

present

case

did

not

proceed directly from the Registrar's report to the appointment of an Administrator. After considering the material placed before it, the State Government issued a separate showDigitally Signed By: 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 197 HC-KAR

cause notice dated 09.04.2026 calling upon the Petitioner to explain why an Administrator should not be appointed having regard to the findings recorded in the enquiry report. 16.6. Learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the Petitioner did not submit any reply to the said notice. There is also no material to show that the Petitioner sought further time, requested

a

personal

hearing

or

sought

permission to place additional documents in response to the notice. She therefore submitted that a reasonable opportunity having been given, the State Government was entitled to proceed on the material available before it. 16.7. As

regards

independent

satisfaction,

she

submitted that the impugned order contains reasons relating to the manner in which the annual general meeting for the year 2024-25 was conducted, the non-obtaining of approval of the audited financial statements for 2025-26, and the failure of the Petitioner to address the charges framed against it. According to her, these reasons show that the State Government considered the material before passing the 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 198 HC-KAR

order and did not mechanically adopt the Enquiry Officer's recommendation. 16.8. Learned Additional Advocate General submitted that

Bharata

Viswaswaraiah

Ratna Education

Mokshgundam Society

only

emphasises the independent role of the State Government after receipt of the Registrar's report. According to her, that requirement was satisfied in the present case since the State Government itself issued the show-cause notice before passing the impugned order. 16.9. She further submitted that the expression “public interest” in Section 27-A(1)(c) is not confined to the interest of the public at large. In her submission, proper administration of a registered society, protection of its funds and safeguarding the interests of its members are also matters of public interest, particularly where the enquiry disclosed allegations of collection of membership subscriptions in cash without corresponding entries or receipts and absence of proper records regarding utilisation of amounts collected for construction purposes. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 199 HC-KAR

16.10. It is now necessary to examine whether the requirements of Clause (c) of Section 27-A(1) were complied with in the present case. The State Government was required to consider the material before it, afford the Petitioner an opportunity to meet the proposed action and thereafter arrive at its own satisfaction that appointment of an Administrator was necessary in the public interest. 16.11. The

decision

Mokshgundam

in

Bharata

Viswaswaraiah

Ratna Education

Society, particularly paragraph 6, makes the position clear. The Registrar has no power to appoint an Administrator. He may only submit a report to the State Government. Even where the society has been given an opportunity before the Registrar, the State Government is required, on receipt of the report, to afford an opportunity to the society and satisfy itself, on enquiry, that appointment of an Administrator is

necessary

in

public

interest.

The

opportunity given by the Registrar does not take the place of the opportunity to be given by the State Government. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 200 HC-KAR

16.12. The

same

principle

was

applied

in

K.N.

Rudrappa. In that case, although the Enquiry Officer had issued notice and the society had participated in the proceedings, there was no material to show that the State Government had itself issued notice before appointing the Administrator.

This

Court

held

that

Government was required to notify the society and provide an opportunity before exercising the power under Section 27-A. 16.13. These decisions therefore require two distinct stages to be kept in view. The enquiry before the Registrar or the Enquiry Officer does not conclude the exercise under Section 27-A(1)(c). After

receiving

report,

State

Government must itself consider the proposed action, give the society an opportunity to respond and take that response into account before deciding whether appointment of an Administrator

is

necessary

in

public

interest. 16.14. On the present facts, however, the position is different

from

Mokshgundam

that

in

Bharata

Viswaswaraiah

09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

Ratna

Education

- 201 HC-KAR

Society and, in particular, K.N. Rudrappa. In those cases, the defect was the absence of any notice

or

Government

opportunity

from

before

Administrator

State was

appointed. Here, Respondent No.1 - State Government

issued

a

separate

show-cause

notice dated 09.04.2026. The notice referred to the irregularities and findings in the enquiry report and called upon the Petitioner to show cause why an Administrator should not be appointed. 16.15. The Petitioner does not dispute the issuance of the notice dated 09.04.2026. The Petitioner availed itself of the opportunity by submitting its explanation dated 18.04.2026. The question is therefore whether the response so submitted was duly considered before the impugned order was passed. 16.16. An opportunity of hearing does not mean that the authority must keep the proceedings open indefinitely. The Petitioner, having availed itself of

opportunity

and

submitted

its

explanation dated 18.04.2026, the question is whether such explanation was considered by 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 202 HC-KAR

State

Government

before

passing

impugned order. There is also no contention that the period granted under the notice dated 09.04.2026 was insufficient. The objection is essentially that issuance of the notice alone did not satisfy the requirement of Section 27A(1)(c). That contention has to be considered separately from the question whether the State Government thereafter applied its mind to the material. 16.17. On that aspect, the impugned order dated 14.05.2026 has to be examined. The omission identified at the Registrar's stage under Point No.

(ii),

namely

absence

of

material

demonstrating communication of the result of the enquiry to the Petitioner-Club, does not by itself establish that the State Government failed to

apply

its

own

mind.

The

statutory

satisfaction under Clause (c) is that of the State Government, and it is therefore the order of Respondent No.1 which must be examined for this purpose. 16.18. The impugned order records, among other things, that the annual general meeting for 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 203 HC-KAR

2024-25 was not conducted in accordance with law, that approval of the audited financial statements for 2025-26 had not been obtained, and that the Petitioner had failed to address or rebut the charges framed against it. These are matters

which

State

Government

has

referred to in support of its decision. The order therefore

cannot

be

said

to

be

a

mere

reproduction of the Enquiry Officer's report. It records consideration of the material before Respondent

No.1

and

explanation

submitted by the Petitioner in response to the proposed action. 16.19. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the material relied upon was neither cogent nor unimpeachable and that the enquiry report itself was under challenge. That submission cannot, at this stage, be examined as though this Court were sitting in appeal over the merits of the decision. The scope of judicial review under Article 226 is to examine whether the decision is supported by relevant material, whether the authority has applied its mind and whether the decision is vitiated by perversity, illegality or other recognised grounds of judicial 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 204 HC-KAR

review. This Court is not required to substitute its own view merely because another view may also be possible. 16.20. Tested on that basis, the material placed before this Court does not establish that Respondent No.1 acted mechanically on the enquiry report. The State Government issued its own notice, the Petitioner was given an opportunity to respond,

and

reasons

in

impugned

support

of

order

records

decision.

The

requirement of an independent consideration by the State Government is therefore satisfied. 16.21. Learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the Petitioner is a private members' club and that

funds

involved are

contributed by

its

members. Therefore, according to him, the matter could not be treated as one involving public

interest

submission

also

under

Clause

(c).

This

cannot

be

accepted.

The

expression “public interest” in Section 27A(1)(c) cannot be restricted to cases involving government funds or funds belonging to the public at large. The proper administration of a registered society and the protection of the 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 205 HC-KAR

funds and interests of its members are matters which may, depending on the facts, constitute public interest for the purpose of the provision. 16.22. The

material

relied

upon

by

State

Government includes the alleged collection of membership corresponding

subscriptions entries

or

in

cash

receipts

without and

alleged absence of proper records regarding the utilisation of amounts collected for construction. These allegations concern the administration and financial management of the registered society and were matters which the State Government consideration

was

entitled

while

to

examining

take

into

whether

intervention was necessary. This is not a matter where inter se membership rights are in issue or where the allegations relate to violation of individual members’ rights and obligations. 16.23. The fact that the Executive Committee was elected also does not, by itself, prevent the exercise of power under Section 27-A. The statutory power can operate against an elected governing body when the requirements of the provision are satisfied. The elected character of 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 206 HC-KAR

the Committee is, however, a circumstance which underscores the need for the statutory requirements to be strictly complied with before such a body is displaced. 16.24. For the above reasons, this Court holds that the requirement under Section 27-A(1)(c) that the State Government itself consider the matter, afford the Petitioner an opportunity and arrive at the requisite satisfaction was complied with. The defect found at the Registrar's stage under Point No.(ii) does not, on the material available, establish a corresponding failure on the part of

State

Government

under

Section

A(1)(c). 16.25. This Court answers Point No. (v) in favour of

Respondents,

by

holding

that

appointment is referable to Clause (c) and that the State Government, after receipt of the Registrar's/Enquiry

Officer's

report,

has

independently considered the material, afforded

Petitioner

an

effective

opportunity,

considered its response and arrived at the requisite satisfaction that appointment of an Administrator was necessary in public interest. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 207 HC-KAR

17.

Answer to Point No. (vi): Whether the order dated 14.05.2026 appointing the Administrator is otherwise sustainable in law, and consequently whether the Petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought? 17.1. Sri D R Ravishankar, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, raised two further objections to the order dated 14.05.2026. First, he submitted that the order had not been published in the official Gazette when the writ petition was argued. According to him, publication under Section 27-A(1) is a statutory requirement and not a mere formality. Until such publication, the Administrator could not assume charge of the Club

or

displace

elected

Executive

Committee. 17.2. Learned Senior Counsel next submitted that the findings relied upon by the State Government regarding the annual general meeting held on 01.02.2026 were factually incorrect. According to him, the meeting was disrupted by persons who were not members of the Club and who had entered the meeting with political motives. He submitted that the manner in which the 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 208 HC-KAR

meeting proceeded could not, therefore, be attributed to the Petitioner or its Executive Committee. 17.3. He further submitted that the Club's audit reports had been accepted by the Income Tax Department and the Goods and Services Tax Department and that this circumstance was inconsistent with the allegation of financial irregularities.

He

also

submitted

that

proceedings had originated from complaints made by persons having personal grievances against the Club and that the circumstances in which the complaints were made ought to be taken

into

account

while

assessing

reliability of the allegations. 17.4. Smt. Prathima Honnapura, learned Additional Advocate General, submitted that the order dated 14.05.2026 was subsequently published in the official Gazette on 20.05.2026. She therefore

submitted

that

statutory

requirement of publication had been complied with.

According

to

her,

subsequent

publication does not affect the validity of the appointment. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 209 HC-KAR

17.5. On the merits, learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the failure to place the audited financial statements and the budget before the general body for approval was, in itself, a violation of the Club's byelaws. This issue, she submitted, was separate from the question

whether

accounts

had

been

accepted by the Income Tax Department or the Goods and Services Tax Department. 17.6. She submitted that even assuming that the annual general meeting was disrupted, that circumstance would not explain or cure the other irregularities found during the enquiry. She

reiterated

that

enquiry

disclosed

collection of membership subscriptions in cash without corresponding entries or receipts and inadequate

records

regarding

utilisation

of

funds collected for construction. According to her, these matters, taken together, justified the State Government's decision to appoint an Administrator. 17.7. Sri K.M. Prakash, learned counsel appearing as intervener, relied upon the decision in Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha, particularly paragraphs 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 210 HC-KAR

12, 50 and 51. He submitted that the fact that the governing body was elected does not, by itself, protect it from statutory intervention where the requirements of Section 27-A are otherwise satisfied. 17.8. He further submitted that the validity of the impugned

order

must

be

examined

with

reference to the reasons stated in the order itself. The Respondents cannot improve or supplement

those

statement

of

reasons

objections

through or

their

subsequent

pleadings. According to him, when examined on that

basis,

impugned

order

contains

sufficient reasons arising from the material gathered during the Section 25 enquiry. 17.9. Three matters arise for consideration under this Point: first, the effect of publication of the order in the official Gazette on 20.05.2026; second, the Petitioner's objections regarding the annual general meeting and the audit; and third, whether the order dated 14.05.2026, when considered in the light of the findings on Points No.(i) to (v), can be sustained. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 211 HC-KAR

17.10. Section 27-A(1) requires an order appointing an Administrator to be published in the official Gazette. The requirement is statutory and cannot be treated as a mere formality. The appointment results in the elected governing body

ceasing

functions.

to

exercise

Publication

its

powers

and

therefore

serves

purpose of making the appointment known to the society and its members. 17.11. In

present

14.05.2026

was

case,

published

in

order

dated

official

Gazette on 20.05.2026. The Petitioner has not contended that the notification so published differs from the order dated 14.05.2026 in any material respect. Nor has any specific prejudice caused by the six-day interval between the order and its publication been demonstrated. The requirement of publication having been subsequently complied with, and there being no material to show any intervening action causing prejudice to the Petitioner, the delay of six days by itself cannot be a ground to invalidate the appointment. The objection based on nonpublication

therefore

does

not

interference with the impugned order. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

warrant

- 212 HC-KAR

17.12. The Petitioner has also questioned the finding regarding the annual general meeting held on 01.02.2026. According to the Petitioner, the meeting was disrupted by persons who were not members of the Club and who were acting for political reasons. The State, on the other hand, relies upon the finding that the audited financial statements and the budget were not placed before the general body for approval. 17.13. Whether the meeting was disrupted in the manner alleged by the Petitioner is a disputed question

of

jurisdiction

fact.

This

Court,

under

Article

226,

exercising would

not

ordinarily undertake an examination of such competing factual versions, particularly where their determination may require evidence. It is therefore not necessary to record a finding on the alleged disruption. 17.14. The relevant fact for the present purpose is that the audited financial statements and the budget were not placed before the general body for approval,

nor

have

audited

financial

statements and the budget been placed before this Court along with the Writ Petition, or 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 213 HC-KAR

during

course

of

hearing.

Government

was

entitled

to

circumstance

into

account

while

The

State

take

this

examining

whether the affairs of the Club were being conducted in accordance with its byelaws. The allegation of disruption, even if accepted, would not by itself answer this separate issue. 17.15. The submission that the Club's accounts had been accepted by the Income Tax Department and the Goods and Services Tax Department also does not alter the position. Compliance with requirements under the tax laws is distinct from compliance with the Club's own byelaws. The fact that a taxing authority has accepted the accounts for the purposes of the tax statutes does not establish that the accounts and budget were placed before and approved by

general

body

as

required

by

byelaws. More so when the allegations concern cash transactions, which would not form part of the returns. 17.16. The

Petitioner

has

also

questioned

complaints which led to the commencement of

proceedings,

contending

09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

that

- 214 HC-KAR

complainants had personal grievances against the Club. It is not necessary for this Court to determine the motive of the complainants. The fact that a complaint may have arisen from a dispute between members does not, by itself, invalidate

enquiry.

authority

receives

Once

information

statutory disclosing

matters requiring examination, the validity of

subsequent

action

depends

upon

material considered and the manner in which the statutory power is exercised. 17.17. The decision in Rajya Vokkaligara Sangha, relied upon by Sri K.M. Prakash, is relevant to the extent that it requires the validity of an order to be tested on the reasons and material forming its basis. The Respondents cannot improve the impugned order by supplying new reasons through their statement of objections or during arguments. This Court has applied that principle while considering Point No. (v). The question, therefore, is whether the reasons contained in the order dated 14.05.2026 are sufficient to sustain the decision. 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 215 HC-KAR

17.18. The findings already recorded may now be considered together. The Section 25 enquiry has not been shown to be vitiated for want of oral hearing, though the allegation regarding refusal to receive documents could not be conclusively determined in these proceedings. Annexure-E1

shows

considered

that

proposal/enquiry

Registrar report,

accepted the recommendation for appointment of an Administrator and forwarded the matter to

State

Government.

material on record

does

However,

disclose

any

not

separate communication by the Registrar to the Petitioner-Club of the result of the enquiry after consideration and acceptance of the enquiry report, as required under Section 25(2)(c)(iii). The State Government thereafter independently considered

matter

under

Section

A(1)(c), issued the show-cause notice dated 09.04.2026 and proceeded to pass the order dated 14.05.2026. 17.19. The

present

case

falls

under

Section

A(1)(c). The requirement of an enquiry and satisfaction

of

State

Government

that

appointment of an Administrator is necessary in 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 216 HC-KAR

public

interest

therefore

applied.

That

requirement has been found to have been complied

with

under

Point

No.

(v).

The

subsequent publication of the order in the official Gazette also satisfies the statutory requirement of publication. 17.20. The

remaining

objections

raised

by

Petitioner either involve disputed questions of fact which cannot appropriately be determined in these proceedings or relate to matters which do not displace the findings recorded by the State Government. The fact that the Executive Committee was elected does not by itself prevent the State Government from exercising

power

under

Section

27-A

when

statutory requirements are otherwise satisfied. 17.21. For these reasons, the order dated 14.05.2026 appointing the Administrator does not warrant interference

under

Article

of

Constitution. 17.22. This Court answers Point No. (vi) by holding that the order dated 14.05.2026 appointing the Administrator is proper and sustainable in law, having been passed in accordance with due 09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

- 217 HC-KAR

procedure, and consequently the Petitioner is not entitled to the reliefs sought. 18.

Answer to Point No. (vii): What Order? 18.1. In view of the findings recorded above, this Court passes the following order: (i)

Writ Petition No.15518 of 2026 (GM-KSR) is dismissed.

This Court has been assisted by Ms. Harshada RB, Law Clerk, in the formulation of this judgment.

09/10/2026, 12:11, Bengaluru

(SURAJ GOVINDARAJ) JUDGE

KTY/List No.: 3 Sl No.: 4

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.