Nirmala Devi v. State of Hp
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
- Date of judgment
- 26 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Ranjan Sharma
- Case number
- CWPOA No. 1752 of 2019
- Result
- Disposed Off
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
2020:HHC:7732
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA CWPOA No. 1752 of 2019 Date of decision: 26.10.2026. Nirmla Devi
...Petitioner. Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & others
...Respondents.
Coram: The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge. Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner For the respondents
:
Ms. Ranjana Pathania, Advocate vice Ms. Archna Dutt, Advocate. :
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with Mr. Sumit Sharma, Deputy Advocate General.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge: Petitioner being the widow of deceased Kuldeep Singh had filed a Civil Writ Petition No. 1308 of 2013 and upon establishment of the State Administrative Tribunal, the matter
was
transferred
to
Tribunal;
and
after
its
abolition, the same has been re-transferred to this Court as CWPOA 1752 of 2019, seeking the following relief: “That
respondent
department
may
kindly be directed to grant the work charge status/regularization to the late husband of the petitioner w.e.f. the year due date
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
-2instead
year
2007
with
all
consequential benefits as per the verdict of Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
Mool
Raj
Upadhayaya’s case in the interest of justice and fair play.” FACTUAL MATRIX:
2.
Case as set up is that husband of the petitioner
namely Sh. Kuldeep Singh
was engaged as daily wager in
Forest Division Bilaspur in 1988 and he had rendered continuous service under the Respondents and based on such service his services were regularized in the year 2007. It is averred that though the husband of the petitioner Late Sh. Kuldeep Singh had expired on 29.09.2009, yet, he was to be granted the work-charge status from the date of completion of ten years of continuous daily wage service. Petitioner has relied upon a judgment dated 16.06.2010 passed in CWP No. 4161 of 2009, whereby, the daily wagers who had rendered continuous service were granted the work-charge status in terms of the judgment in the case of Mool Raj Upadhyaya passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Petitioner is seeking the similar treatment as given to other daily wagers in the State with all consequential benefits. STAND OF AFFIDAVIT:
STATE
AUTHORITIES
IN
REPLY-
-33.
Upon
issuance
notice
on
28.03.2013,
Respondents have filed the Reply-Affidavit dated 25.07.2013 of Conservator of Forests, Bilaspur Forest Circle, Himachal Pradesh. 3 (i).
Perusal of the Reply-Affidavit and the Man-Days
chart [Annexure R-2] indicates that the husband of the petitioner joined as a daily wager in 1996 and has rendered continuous service with 240 days till 2006. Reply- Affidavit indicates that the services of the husband of the petitioner were regularized as Forest Worker on 19.09.2007. It is averred that regarding discrepancy in man-days as contended by the petitioner vis-à-vis the stand spelt out in Para 3 of the ReplyAffidavit,
State
Authorities
has
initiated
disciplinary
proceedings vide Annexure R-III against the officials who had furnished incorrect Mandays to the petitioner’s husband. NO REBUTTAL BY PETITIONER:
4.
Petitioner has chosen not to file any rejoinder
so as to controvert the stand taken in the Reply-Affidavit. 5.
Be that as it may. STATEMENT OF LEARNED COUNSEL BASED ON SUBSEQUENT EVENTS:
6.
At this stage, Learned Counsel for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner shall be satisfied, in case, the
-4Respondents are directed to consider the case of the petitioner’s husband for conferment of work-charge status from the date of completion of eight years of continuous daily waged service in terms of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Surajmani and others [Civil Appeal No. 1595 of 2025, decided on 06.02.2025], with all consequential benefits. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that similar benefit of work charge status has been granted in CWPOA No. 1489 of 2020, titled as, Lekh Ram vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & others, decided on 09.10.2026. [Statement Taken on Record]. ANALYSIS:
7.
Issue involved in the instant case is no longer
res-integra in view of the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Surajmani and others, Civil Appeal No. 1595 of 2025, decided on 06.02.2025, reads as under: “8.
However,
in
order
to
allay
apprehension of the State as expressed thereunder and to safeguard the interest of
State
which
otherwise
would
have
burdened the exchequer with extra benefits being conferred on the employees who had not been regularly appointed, this Court has, as a succor to the State, restricted the
-5claim or, in other words, modified the order of the Tribunal as affirmed by the High Court by arriving at a conclusion that the petitioners/appellants
therein
would
be
entitled to the notional benefits of the order passed by the Tribunal and accordingly disposed of the said appeal. 9.
It would not be out of context to refer
at this juncture itself that the State, in its wisdom, having felt that the subsequent schemes
having
been
formulated
and
implemented, would alter the situation and, therefore, order dated 12.04.1994 passed in Mool Raj Upadhyaya’s (Supra) case has to be modified, had approached this Court by filing an Interlocutory Application being IA No. 3 in the year 2005 in the aforesaid Mool Raj Upadhyaya’s case, i.e., Writ Petition (Civil) No. 787 of 1987. A perusal of the said application
and
averments
made
thereunder would clearly indicate that the very
same
contentions
urged,
pleas
advanced and arguments put forth today before
us
were
ones
which
were
urged/raised in the said application. Though Mr. Vivek Tankha, learned senior counsel appearing for the State would fairly submit that the said application was withdrawn on the ground of subsequent schemes having been formulated and implemented by the State of Himachal Pradesh, but we are unable
to
accept
said
proposition
-6howsoever attractive it may be, for the simple reason that the said application was dismissed simpliciter as withdrawn. Yet another factor which sways our mind to reject the contention raised by the learned senior counsel appearing for the State would be the fact that the State having accepted the judgment of Ashwani Kumar (Supra), has implemented the same and it is in this background,
High
Court
in
impugned order has observed that the State cannot adopt pick and choose policy. 10.
For
cumulative
reasons
aforestated, we are of the considered view that the dicta laid down by this Court vide order dated 22.07.2019 in Ashwani Kumar’s (Supra) case which is based on the judgment of Mool Raj Upadhyaya (Supra) holds the field and would also be applicable to the Respondents herein who had approached the Tribunal or the High Court seeking similar relief. As such, the Respondents shall be entitled for grant of ‘work-charged’ status from the date of completion of 8 years of service. However, we hold that the relief in the present appeals will be limited to notional benefits as explained in paragraph 3 and 4 of Ashwani Kumar’s (Supra) case in Civil Appeal No(s). 5753 of 2019 and the present
appeals
stand
disposed
accordingly with no order as to costs.
-711.
We also make it explicitly clear that
the State in its endeavour of implementing the orders of the Tribunal, High Court or this Court, if having paid the amounts in excess, would be at liberty to take such steps as it deems fit without insisting for one time recovery. 12. It is further underscored that this judgment would necessarily be a judgment in rem and the State shall hence forth not take recourse to employing personnel as daily wagers but shall make appointments only in accordance with law, as enumerated in the case of Secretary, State of Karnataka Vs. Uma Devi [(2006) 4 SCC 1].”
8.
Per contra, Learned State Counsel submits that
the mandate of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of Surajmani (supra) is not in dispute. He further submits that so far as the prayer for consequential benefits is concerned, the same cannot be accorded to the petitioner, as the Hon'ble Supreme Court has limited the relief to “notional benefits only.” 9.
Faced with above situation, since the claim for work
charged status in terms of the judgment in case of Surajmani (supra) has been raised for first time, during the course of hearing today, therefore, no mandate can be issued to grant
-8work charge status, but in view of the declaration of law of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Surajmani (supra), which is a judgment in rem and has retrospective applicability, this
Court
can
certainly
direct
Respondents-State
Authorities to examine/consider the case of the husband of the petitioner for conferment of work-charge status from the date of completion of eight years of continuous daily wage service [with effect from 01.01.2003 in instant case] even though notionally from due date, but without any past arrears, in the light of the judgment in the case of Surajmani (supra). DIRECTIONS:
10.
In view of the above discussion and for reasons
recorded hereinafter, instant petition, is disposed of, in the following terms: (i)
State
Authorities
shall
consider
/examine the case of the husband of the petitioner namely Sh. Kuldeep Singh for conferment of work-charge status as Forest Worker Class-IV in applicable time scale from the date
completion
eight
years
continuous daily wage service with effect
from
01.01.2004,
but
with
notional benefits, in terms of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
-9Court
in
case
Surajmani
(supra); (ii)
Needless to say, that the petitioner shall not be entitled for any past arrears, except the notional benefits, as mentioned above;
(iii)
Upon
consideration,
in
case,
petitioner’s husband Late Sh. Kuldeep Singh is granted work charge status then, the petitioner being the widow, shall
be
granted
retiral
benefits,
including revised family pension from the date of passing of the judgment in the case of Surajmani (supra) with effect from 06.02.2025 and thereafter; (iv)
State Authorities shall complete the entire
action,
not
later
than
15.12.2026; (v)
Parties to bear respective costs.
In aforesaid terms, instant petition and the pending applications, if any, shall accordingly stand disposed of.
(Ranjan Sharma) Judge 26th October, 2026. (kck)