P.b.prakirth v. The Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner(l)

Court
High Court of Kerala
Date of judgment
5 November 2026
Judge
Justice Harisankar V. Menon
Case number
RP No. 701 of 2017
Result
DISMISSED

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.UBAID FRIDAY, THE 05TH DAY OF APRIL 2019 / 15TH CHAITHRA, 1941 RP.No. 515 of 2017 IN CO.ADJ.APPEAL. 15/2014 REVIEW PETITIONERS/NOT PARTIES IN THE ABOVE COMPANY ADJUDICATION APPEAL:

SASEENDRAN.A, ETTAMMAL HOUSE, ERINAV P.O, CHERUKUNNU VIA, KACHIERITHARA.

VIJAYAN.CK, POURNAMI, MOWANCHERRY P.O, MACHERI, KANNUR

RAJAN.T, THACHOTH HOUSE, THILANNUR, KAPPAD P.O, KANNUR 670 006

SURESH BABU.M.C MANDEN HOUSE, PAYYAMBALAM, KANNUR 670 001. BY ADVS. SRI.THOMAS ABRAHAM SMT.MERCIAMMA MATHEW SRI.ASWIN.P.JOHN

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANT AND RESPONDENT: THE ASSISTANT PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER (L) EMPLOYEES PROVIDENT FUND ORGANISATION, SUB REGIONAL OFFICE, V.K.COMPLEX, FORT ROAD, KANNUR - 670 001.

OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM BY ADVS. SRI.K.MONI SRI.ASHOK B.SHENOY, SC, ANERT

THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 05.04.2019, ALONG WITH RP.318/2018, RP.337/2018, RP.390/2018, RP.701/2017, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.UBAID FRIDAY, THE 05TH DAY OF APRIL 2019 / 15TH CHAITHRA, 1941 RP.No. 318 of 2018 IN CO.ADJ.APPEAL. 2/2016 REVIEW PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS 2 TO 5:

SASEENDRAN A, ETTAMMAL HOUSE, ERINAV P.O, CHERUKUNNU VIA, KACHERITHARA.

VIJAYAN.C.K, POURNAMI, MOWANCHERRY P.O, MACHERI, KANNUR

RAJAN.T, THACHOTH HOUSE, THILANNUR, KAPPAD P.O, KANNUR 670 006

SURESH BABU.M.C MANDEN HOUSE, PAYYAMBALAM, KANNUR 670 001. BY ADVS. SRI.THOMAS ABRAHAM SMT.MERCIAMMA MATHEW SRI.ASWIN.P.JOHN

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANT AND RESPONDENT:

SATHEESH BABU.M, S/O.KRISHNAN, KAKKATTUCHALIL HOUSE, THOTTADA P.O, KANNUR 670 007

OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM 682 031 BY ADV. SRI.K.MONI

THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 05.04.2019, ALONG WITH RP.390/2018, RP.337/2018, RP.701/2017, RP.515/2017, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.UBAID FRIDAY, THE 05TH DAY OF APRIL 2019 / 15TH CHAITHRA, 1941 RP.No. 337 of 2018 IN CO.ADJ.APPEAL. 4/2017 REVIEW PETITIONERS/APPELLANTS:

SASEENDRAN.A, TTAMMAL HOUSE, ERINAV P.O, CHERUKUNNU VIA,KACHERITHARA

VIJAYAN.C.K, POURNAMI,MOWANCHERRY P.O, MACHERI,KANNUR

RAJAN.T, THACHOTH HOUSE, THILANNUR, KAPPAD P.O, KANNUR 670 006

SURESH BABU.M.C MANDEN HOUSE, PAYYAMBALAM, KANNUR 670 001. BY ADV. SRI.THOMAS ABRAHAM

RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENT:

OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR HIGH COURT OF KERALA,ERNAKULAM

DINESHAN.A, S/O.POCKKAN,C.H.HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI P.O, EACHUR,KANNUR 670 591 BY ADV. SRI.K.MONI

THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 05.04.2019, ALONG WITH RP.390/2018, RP.318/2018, RP.701/2017, RP.515/2017, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.UBAID FRIDAY, THE 05TH DAY OF APRIL 2019 / 15TH CHAITHRA, 1941 RP.No. 390 of 2018 IN MCA. 16/2017 REVIEW PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS 1 TO 4:

SASEENDRAN.A, ETTAMMAL HOUSE, ERINAV P.O, CHERUKUNNU VIA, KACHERITHARA

VIJAYAN.C.K, POURNAMI,MOWANCHERRY P.O, MACHERI, KANNUR

RAJAN.T, THACHOTH HOUSE, THILANNUR, KAPPAD.P.O, KANNUR 670 006

SURESH BABU.M.C MANDEN HOUSE, PAYYAMBALAM, KANNUR 670 001. BY ADVS. SRI.THOMAS ABRAHAM SMT.MERCIAMMA MATHEW SRI.ASWIN.P.JOHN

RESPONDENT/APPLICANT: OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR HIGH COURT OF KERALA,ERNAKULAM BY ADV. SRI.K.MONI THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 05.04.2019, ALONG WITH RP.337/2018, RP.318/2018, RP.701/2017, RP.515/2017, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.UBAID FRIDAY, THE 05TH DAY OF APRIL 2019 / 15TH CHAITHRA, 1941 RP.No. 701 of 2017 IN CO.ADJ.APPEAL. 15/2014 REVIEW PETITIONERS/NOT PARTIES IN THE ABOVE COMPANY ADJUDICATION APPEAL:

P.B.PRAKIRTH S/O.M.K.BALAKRISHNAN,PADMINI NIVAS, PO PALLIKKUNNU,KANNUR DISTRICT,PIN 670 004.

JOY.D, C/O.VINCENT DICRUZE, HOUSE NO.51/4,BARNASSERY P.O, KANNUR 670 013.

K.SANAD, AGED 57 YEARS S/O.BHASKARAN,KUTHIRODAN HOUSE, AZHIKODE SOUTH, KANNUR

SASEENDRAN.P.V, S/O.NARAYANAN, CHARANAKANDY HOUSE, P.O.CHOWVA, KANNUR

S.MURUGAN, AGED 49 YEARS S/O.A.SUBAYA, HOUSE NO.107,B4, BARNASSERI, KANNUR 670 013.

P.B.ABDUL SHUKKOOR, AGED 59 YEARS S/O.V.K.MAMMU,”SUMAYYA”, P.O.PAPPINISSERI WEST, KANNUR 670 565

M.ANILKUMAR, AGED 49 YEARS S/O.M.KUMARAN(LATE), REVATHY NIVAS, THILANORE ROAD, CHOWVA, KANNUR-18.

E.K.MOHANAN, AGED 49 YEARS S/O.KUNHIRAMAN,ELLATHANKANDI HOUSE, P.O.KADACHIRA, ADOOR, KANNUR

P.M.PAVITHRAN, AGED 50 YEARS S/O.KANNAN NAMBIAR, CHANDROTH HOUSE, P.O.MUNDALLUR, PERALASSERY,VADAKKUMPAD, KANANUR 670 741

P.SUNDARAN, AGED 43 YEARS S/O.P.P.SIDHARTHAN,32 ROOMS, NO.3 BAZAR, KANNUR 670 001

M.SATHEESH BABU, AGED 43 YEARS S/O.KRISHNAN,KAKKATIYALIL HOUSE, P.O.THOTTADA, KANNUR

A.REGHUTHAMAN, AGED 59 YEARS S/O.MANNAN,ALINKEEZHIL HOUSE, AZHIKODE SOUTH P.O, KANNUR 670 001.

M.SUDHAKARAN, AGED 53 YEARS S/O.KARUNAKARAN,MULLANKANDI HOUSE, CHALAD, KANNUR

C.RAJENDRAN, AGED 51 YEARS S/O.C.KUNHI KELU,CHELORAKANDY HOUSE, ELAYAOOR P.O, MUNDAYAD,KANNUR

A.ARAVINDAN, AGED 56 YEARS S/O.KUNHIRAMAN,PUTHIYAPPARAMBATH HOUSE, P.O.ALAVI,PALLIYANMALA,KANNUR

M.BALAKRISHNAN, AGED 53 YEARS S/O.U.K.KUNHAMBU,VADAKKEPARAMBU HOUSE, P.O.MUNDAYAD, KANNUR 670 594.

M.P.YADYANATH, AGED 57 YEARS S/O.M.P.VASUDEVAN,POURNAMI,NEAR JOHN MILL, P.O.CIVIL STATION, KANNUR-2.

T.C.RATHNAKARAN, AGED 52 YEARS S/O.CHATHU NAMBIAR, P.O.KIZHUNNA, KANNUR

A.DINESHAN, AGED 49 YEARS S/O.C.H.POCKAN,C.H.HOUSE,KOTANICHIERRY,P.O, EACHUR,KANUR

SATHEESHAN.P.P, AGED 46 YEARS S/O.P.P.BALAKRISHNAN,PADINJAREPURAYIL HOUSE, KARIKKANKULAM P.O, PAPPINIEESRY WEST, KANNUR

P.K.ANEESHKUMAR, AGED 46 YEARS S/O.DAMODHARAN,SREELAKSHMI NIVAS, ELAMBILANPARA P.O, ALAVIL, KANNUR 670 008

M.VISHALAKSHAN, AGED 51 YEARS S/O.NARAYANAN,MANDOTHAN HOUSE, NEAR KILASI LANE, AYIKKARA P.O, H.G.HOSPITAL, KANNUR

PREMAN.T, AGED 56 YEARS S/O.KUNHIRAMAN,KAKKATUCHALIL HOUSE, P.O.THOTTADA, KANNUR

K.BALAKRISHNAN, AGED 56 YEARS S/O.KUNHIRMAN,JYOTHIS,CHIRAKKUTHAZHE, P.O,KIZHUNNA, KANNUR

V.K.PRABHANANDAN, AGED 50 YEARS S/O.DAMODHARAN,NANDANAM,KOTTAPPALAM, PAPPINESSERY WEST, KANNUR

PRAKASHAN.P.K, KUNDIL VALAPIL HOUSE, THALANNUR, P.O.ATTADAPPA, KANNUR

K.RAGHAVA MARAR, S/O.KANNAN MARAR, MAVILAKANDY HOUSE, DURGA ROAD, P.O.PALLIKUNNU, KANNUR

M.V.PREMAN, S/O.M.V.BALAN, MEETHALE VEETIL, P.O.PAPPINISSERY WEST, KANNUR

P.P.HAREESH, S/O.P.V.KRISHNAN,PUTHAN VEEDU, SATHRAM ROAD, THILANNUR, THAZHE CHOUVA P.O, KANNUR 670 018.

C.MANOHARAN, AGED 52 YEARS S/O.GOPALAN,CHENIYARAKKAL HOUSE, CHEMBILODE P.O, MOWANCHERY,KANNUR

P.PADMANABHAN S/O.A.KARUNAKARAN, MOTTAMMAL HOUSE, SOUTH BAZAR P.O, CIVIL STATION, KANNUR

TERENCE PETRIC S/O.IVAN LAZZAR, HOUSE NO.113E,BURNCHERRY,KANNUR 670 013.

K.M.PRASANNAKUMAR S/O.AMBUKUTTY, PRASANNAM, NEAR FISH MARKET, PALLIKUNNU, KANNUR

BALASUBRAMANIYAM.K.M LAKSHMISADANAM, THULICHERI P.O, KAKKAD, KANNUR 670 005.

NARAYANAN.C, S/O.KORAN, NAGATHANKOTTAYIL HOUSE, EDAKKAD P.O, KANNUR

DHARMESH.C.T, S/O.NARAYANAN, CHIMMINIYAN HOUSE, THAVAKKARA, KANNUR-2 BY ADV. SMT.M.R.JAYALATHA

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANT AND RESPONDENT:

THE ASSISTANT PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER(L) EMPLOYEES PROVICENT FUND ORGANIZATION, SUB REGIONAL OFFICE, V.K.COMPLEX, FORT ROAD, KANNUR 670 001.

THE OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM BY ADVS. SRI.K.MONI SMT.T.N.GIRIJA SRI.ASHOK B.SHENOY, SC, ANERT

THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 05.04.2019, ALONG WITH RP.390/2018, RP.337/2018, RP.318/2018, RP.515/2017, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

R.P. Nos. 515 & 701 of 2017 and 318, 337 & 390 of 2018 O R D E R The petitioners are common in these five review petitions.

They seek review of the interim

order passed by this Court on 19.03.2018 directing the Official Liquidator to make payment of 50% of the amount granted by him on adjudication to the Badali workers. When the official liquidator failed to

comply

brought

with

two

applications

the

contempt are

order,

the

Badali

applications,

pending.

The

workers

and

grievance

those of

the

review petitioners is that the order passed by the court

requires

clarification

as

to

50%

of

what

amount will have to be paid to the Badali workers. On

the

first

adjudication

made

by

the

Official

Liquidator, nothing substantial was granted to the Badali workers. Their right and status was also

disputed by the permanent workers and the company people.

But that issue, as to whether they are

entitled for benefits, was considered by this Court in

an

earlier

dated

proceeding,

05.03.2013,

this

and

as

Court

has

per

the

order

clarified

in

paragraph 4 of the order that, though the Badali workers

are

called

Badali

workers,

they

are

actually, and in effect, the employees receiving not

only

a

regular

salary,

but

also

various

benefits including House Rent Allowance. This order was not challenged in appeal by anybody.

Thus,

this

Badali

Court

has

once

workers,

they

are

besides

salary,

found

that

though

entitled

for

the

because

they

are

benefits, practically

permanent employees of the company. At the first round,

the

Official

Liquidator

adjudicated

their

claims, and some nominal amount was granted. That order was challenged before this Court, and a re-

adjudication

was

ordered.

After

re-adjudication,

the official Liquidator heard all the parties in detail,

considered

all

relevant

documents

and

registers, and passed a fresh order of adjudication granting

some

additional

benefits

to

the

Badali

workers. This adjudication order is under challenge by the permanent workers in Co.Appln. No. 331 of 2014.

Thus, it is a matter to be decided by this

Court

finally

whether

the

Badali

workers

are

entitled for huge benefits as found by the Official Liquidator

on

re-adjudication.

Of

course,

as

regards their right to get reliefs or benefits as employees of the company, there cannot be a doubt or dispute in view of the order of this Court dated 05.03.2013.

The only scope of enquiry must be as

regards the exact amount they are entitled to get. 2.

In

the

explanation

submitted

by

the

Official Liquidator in the contempt proceeding, his

explanation is that it is not certain whether the 50%

ordered

amount.

by

the

court

is

50%

of

the

entire

I do not find any legal reason to review

the order as such, because the right of the Badali workers to get benefits cannot be disputed, though the extent and measure of the said right will have to be adjudicated in appeal. 3. including

On the

a

perusal

review

of

petitions,

the

materials

and

also

the

explanation given by the Official Liquidator in the contempt applications, I find that practically the grievance of everybody is as regards the amount payable to the Badali workers. It appears that on re-adjudication,

the

Official

Liquidator

has

granted huge benefits to the Badali workers.

This

is under challenge by the review petitioners and also the permanent workers.

When there cannot be

any doubt or dispute regarding the right of the

Badali workers also to get benefits under the law, the

order

as

such

cannot

be

reviewed,

and

the

benefits cannot be denied to the Badali workers. I feel that a clarification and modification of the earlier orders will suffice, and a review as such is not necessary.

There is no situation to review

the order, and decide the issue afresh. review

petitioners

require

only

a

When the

clarification,

and the Official Liquidator also requires such a clarification disbursed,

as

the

to

how

the

amount

shall

be

Court

can

very

well

clarify

and

modify the order, without in fact reviewing the order as such . 4.

On the finding that a review as such

is not required in the present circumstances, the order

dated

19.03.2018

will

stand

clarified

and

modified that instead of the 50% ordered by the court earlier, 1/3rd of the amount will suffice, and

it shall be 1/3rd of the amount additionally awarded by the Official Liquidator on adjudication.

It is

once more clarified that only the additional amount awarded by the Official Liquidator at the second round of re-adjudication shall be considered, and only

25%

of

that

amount

shall

be

paid

to

each

Badali worker by the Official Liquidator. With clarification,

the the

above review

modification petitions

are

and

closed.

Payment shall be made by the Official Liquidator within a month from this date. Sd/-

P.UBAID Ds 08.04.2019

JUDGE

Related judgments

More Kerala High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.