Praveen Narayan v. State of U.P. and 8 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
- Date of judgment
- 22 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Anish Kumar Gupta
- Case number
- WRIA No. 20213 of 2023
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD WRIT - A No. - 20213 of 2023
Praveen Narayan .....Petitioner(s) Versus
State Of U.P. And 8 Others .....Respondent(s) Counsel for Petitioner(s) Counsel for Respondent(s)
: Amar Jeet Singh, Praveen Narayan : C.S.C.
Court No. - 34 Sl. No. 50
HON'BLE ANISH KUMAR GUPTA, J.
1. Heard Praveen Narayan the petitioner in person and Sri Raj Kumar Tiwari, learned standing counsel for the State. 2. The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner with the following prayers: "I. Issue a writ order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents authorities to sanction the first promotional time pay scale from the date on which it was admissible to the petitioner w.e.f. 1.6.1998 payable to the petitioner in pursuance of the section 2(2)(c) GO No. 761/Karmik-1/1993 dated 30.6.1993 ignoring the adverse entry of year 1994-95 and the so called adverse entry of 1998-99 due to non communication to the petitioner. II. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing to the respondent authorities to pay the petitioner's arrear of salary along with interest up to date. III. Issue nature a writ, order or direction in the of mandamus directing to the respondent authorities to fix the second selection grade of time pay scale w.e.f. 01.06.2003 in place of 02.06.2004. IV. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing to the respondent authorities to fix the Second ACP w.e.f. 01.12.2008 in place of 01.12.2009. V. a Issue writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing to the respondent authorities to fix the time Third ACP w.e.f. 01.06.2010 in
place of 01.06.2011. VI. Issue writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing to the respondent authorities to fix the amount of pension of the petitioner after sanctioning the promotional pay scales from the admissible date and accordingly to pay the arrears of pension along with up to date interest. "
3. It is an admitted position that there was an adverse entry in the year 1994-95 against the petitioner which was duly communicated to the petitioner and against which the petitioner has also represented. However subsequent thereto there was another adverse entry in the year 1998-99 against the petitioner. The claim of the petitioner is that the said adverse entry of the year 1998-99 was never communicated to the petitioner. In this regard the aforesaid fact has also been admitted in para 10 of the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents and the letter dated 14.11.2008 has been annexed as Annexure CA-2 to the counter affidavit wherein it has been categorically admitted that after examination of the old documents it could not be established that the adverse entry of the year 1998-99 was ever communicated to the petitioner. Learned counsel for the petitioner relying upon the UP Government Servant Disposal of Representation Against Adverse Annual Confidential Reports and Allied Matters Rules 1995 submits that in terms of the Rule 4 of the aforesaid Rules, 1995 the adverse entry is required to be communicated to the government servant within a period of 45 days and if the said adverse entry is not communicated within 45 days, the same cannot be treated as an adverse entry in terms of Rule 5 thereof. 4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has further relied upon the Government Order dated 30.06.1993. Clause 2 (2) (c) of the said G.O. provides for determination of the satisfactory service for the purpose of promotion and other increments to be granted. If in the period of consideration of the satisfactory service if any adverse entry is existing and thereafter for the next 5 years there is no adverse entry then the said adverse entry shall be ignored for the purpose of determination of the satisfactory work. Thus learned counsel for the petitioner submits though there was an adverse entry in the year 1994-95 against the petitioner and thereafter for next 5 years there was no adverse entries against the petitioner except the adverse entry of 1998-1999 which was never
communicated, therefore the impact of the adverse entry of the year 199899 cannot be read against the petitioner. Thus after 1994-95 till 2007 there was no adverse entry against the petitioner therefore when the claim of the petitioner for the purpose of fixation of time scale/ACP was considered, the said adverse entry of 94-95 was required to be ignored in terms of clause 2 (2) (c) of the Government Order dated 30.06.1993. Consequently the benefit of ACP could not have been denied to the petitioner. 5. Thus learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner was entitled for the grant of ACP/time scale ignoring the aforesaid adverse entries against the petitioner which has wrongly not been accorded to the petitioner. Government order dated 30.6.1993 provides that if there is only one adverse entry and thereafter for the next 5 years there is no adverse entry then that previous adverse entry shall be ignored. Further in terms of the Rules, 1995 if any adverse entry is not communicated to the concerned government employee that cannot be said to be an adverse entry against him and that also cannot be read as an adverse entry. Therefore the entry of the year 1998-99 cannot be read as an adverse entry against the petitioner due to want of communication and so far as the entry of the year 1994-95 is concerned the same is required to be ignored in terms of Clause 2 (2) (c) of the Government Order dated 30.6.1993. 6. The Rule 4 and 5 of Rules, 1995 read as unde: "4. Communication of adverse report and procedure for disposal of representation.-(1) Where a report in respect of a Government Servant is adverse or critical, wholly or in part, hereinafter referred to as adverse report, the whole of the report shall be communicated in writing to the Government Servant concerned by the accepting authority or by an officer not below the rank of reporting authority nominated in this behalf by the accepting authority, within a period of 45 days from the date of recording the report and a certificate to this effect shall be recorded in the report. (2) A Government Servant may, within a period of 45 days from the date
of communication of adverse report under sub-rule (1), represent in writing directly and also through proper channel to the authority one rank above the accepting authority, hereinafter referred to as the competent authority, and if there is no competent authority, to the accepting authority itself, against the adverse report so communicated: Provided that if the competent authority or the accepting authority, as the case may be, is satisfied that the Government Servant concerned had sufficient cause for not submitting the representation within the said period,he may allow a further period of 45 days for submission of such representation. (3) The competent authority or accepting authority as the case may be, shall, within a period not exceeding one week from the date of receipt of the representation under sub-rule (2), transmit the representation to the appropriate authority, who has recorded the adverse report, for his comments, who shall, within a period not exceeding 45 days from the date of receipt of the representation, furnish his comments to the competent authority or the accepting authority as the case may be : Provided that no such comments shall be required if the appropriate authority has ceased to be in, or has retired from, the service or is under suspension before sending his comments. (4) The competent authority or the accepting authority, as the case may be, shall, within a period of 120 days from the date of expiry of 45 days specified in sub-rule (3), consider the representation along with the comments of the appropriate authority, and if no comments have been received without waiting for the comments, and pass speaking orders(a) rejecting the representation; or (b) expunging the adverse report wholly or partly as he considers proper. (5) Where the competent authority due to any administrative reasons, is unable to dispose of the representation within the period specified in subrule (4), he shall report in this regard to his higher authority, who shall pass such orders as he considers proper for ensuring disposal of the
representation within the specified period. (6) An order passed under sub-rule (4) shall be communicated in writing to the Government Servant concerned. (7) Where an order expunging the adverse report is passed under subrule (4), the competent authority or the accepting authority as the case may be shall omit the report so expunged. (8) The order passed under sub-rule (4) shall be final. (9) Where any matter for(i) communication of an adverse report; (ii) representation against an adverse report; (iii) transmission of representation to the appropriate authority for his comments; (iv) comments of the appropriate authority; or (v) disposal of representation against an adverse report; is pending on the date of the commencement of these rules, such matters shall be dealt with and disposed of within the period prescribed therefor under this rule. Explanation. In computing the period prescribed under this rule for any matters specified in this sub-rule the period already expired on the date of the commencement of these rules shall not be taken into account. Rule 5. Report not to be treated adverse. - Except as provided in Rule 56 of the Uttar Pradesh Fundamental Rules contained in Financial Handbook Volume II, Parts II to IV. Where an adverse report is not communicated or a representation against an adverse report has not been disposed of in accordance with Rule 4, such report shall not be treated adverse for the purposes of promotion, crossing of Efficiency Bar and other service matters of the Government Servant concerned.".
7. Clause 2 (2)(c) Government Order dated 30.06.1993 reads as under: "शासनादेश सं
: 761/ का क-1/1993
नांक : 30 जून, 1993 षय : स
षजनक सेवा का
रण।
महोदय, शासन के सं न (यथा
यह त
लाया गया है
सेवा स
करण
यीकरण, द ता रोक पार कराने, समयमान वेतनमान
ये जाने,
सी० एस० आर० के अनु द 470 (बी) के तहत शन से कटौती
ये जाने
आ
माम )
स
रण हेतु कोई
त सरका त मानक
सेव
"स
त न होने के कारण
स म
का
रा
वेक से अलग-अलग
फल
प इस बात
स
वना बनी रहती है
सेवा ले
के आधार पर सेवा
के सेवा ले
के होते ए भी
षजनक सेवा के
को स
पर य
ये जाते ,
सी मामले
न
षजनक माना गया हो, उसी
सी सरे मामले
र
सेवा
को संतोशजनक
षय
ता
का उ
अ
न माना जाये। स
2.य कृ
का
जाने
प
षजनक सेवा के
रण का
षय है और सभी संगत सेवा ले के प पे रा इस षय
स त
स म
का
स म
का
सहायता हेतु शासन रा स क् चारोपात इस षय
त सामा
मा द क
(1)
यीकरण के स
प वी
काल और जहां
समु त
य तय
या जा सकता है, तथा ये गये है-
य लेने के
ये केवल
यमानुसार प वी
काल को
अव
के सेवा ले
जाये
प वी
सेवा स
षजनक रही या न ।
काल स त स
को ही आधार बताकर यह काल
स
त सरका
(2) द तासेक पार कराने, समयमान वेतनमान
य
या
सेवक
कृत करने
तथा सी० एस० आर० के अनु द 470 (बी) के तहत शन
र्मि
पि
लि
प्र
की
ति
प्र
न्धी कि स्त
रों
की
जि र्ण की स्वी
पें दि
में
न्तो
यों
में
ष्टि
दृ
शों
र्ण
नि
में
क्टि
ब्जे लि क्षा
म्पू
हि र्ण
नि री
लि
रि क्षा न्धि
म्ब
में
हीं च्छे
वि र्दे
नि
कि वि
कि वि
वि
पि
श्चा
खि
न्त लि
भि
न्हें
नि
ओं
स्त
में
हैं
न्न
न्तो
भि लि
र्ण कि में वि लि कि
म्य
र्ण
ध्य
खों
र्धा
नि न्त
द्धा
र्ण
नि
में
रि
नि
न्ध
सि
द्वा
चि
में
भि
नि
दू
न्तो
कि
नि
वि
की
कों रि
र्धा
री
पें
दि
म्ब
र्धा
नि
कि
न्तो
थ्य
में क्ष न्धि
में
लों
म्ब
नि
श्चि
र्धा
नि
वि
स्व
द्वा
यों
रि
धि
क्ष
प्रा
की
स्व
रू
ओं
भि
खों
कि
हु
भि
खों
न्तो
पि
द्य तिः
प्र
वि
क्ष्य
यों
ति
स्थि
रि
की
रि
में
वि
द्वा
री
धि
क्ष
प्रा
यों
रि
धि
प्रा
क्ष
की
र्श
र्ग
न्य
लि
म्न
नि
खि
म्ब
स्था रि
क्षा
ढ़ा
ढ़ा
खों
भि
धि
रि
कि
क्षा
हैं
न्तो
यें क्ष
दि
न्य
की
न्य म्न
नि
र्धा
नि
में
म्भा
नि
दि
च्छे
स्था
ज्ञा
वि
दि
ख्या
अनुम ता आ
ओं
ये
गहनता से अ यन करने के प त् ही
ब या गया हो वहां ब ये गये प वी
न्तो
व
अ
का
रण करने हेतु
(अ) स
षजनक सेवा
सभी
ष
त के
स को
षय
षजनक सेवा रखा जाये:
य लेने के
नांक
के पू
स समय तक के अ ले
सरका सेवक को स अनुम चु
के आधार पर स
त
षजनक सेवा के आधार पर कोई लाभ
कराया जा चुका हो अथवा उसे पदो हो अथवा उ उसका
यीकरण
दान
जा
या जा चुका हो
अथवा उसे द ता रोक अनुम
कराय जा चुका हो, । उन
सेवा ले
नं
को पुनः
प त् के सेवा ले का
रण
चार
या जाये, वरन् उसके
के आधार पर ही स
षजनक सेवा
या जाये।
(ब) य
उस अव
उसके सेवा ले
उपरो
चार
आते .
सी व
स
मा त न
गयी हो पर
अनुव
सम
( स
सं
कम 5 अव
हो)
स
व
(स) य
को अस
जाती
अ मा त स
के
पांच व
.
सके सेवा लेख उपरो
नुसार
आते . कोई
मान हो और उस
से स
त घटना
के बाद
अगले
अव
कोई अ
कूलता (यथा
कूल
, द स
षजनक न माना जाये।
उस अव
चार
कम से
लगातार मा त
रही हो तो केवल उस एक व आधार सेवा
नुसार
आ ) न हो तो उस
षजनक सेवा के मू
कन हेतु
को
चार
नं
या जा
अ त उसे नजर ज कर या जाये। (द) य
स
त अव
सुझावा कः न
षजनक सेवा के मू
कन हेतु
त अव
से
कोई
या वृहद
या गया हो अथवा एक से
या जा ।
(य) य , स अ
सेवक को
या चोतावनी दी गयी हो तो सुझावा क
/ चेतावनी को स चार
सी सरका
लघु द
अ क बार पांच व के अ राल से कम अव दी गयी हो, तो स स
त अव
ले
के आधार पर
सावधानीपू क
चार कर स म
का
रा
समु त
या जाये।
(र) य स
त अव
एक से अ क व
पांच व के अ राल से कम अव हो तो सामा तया उ
न्धि
म्ब
खों
भि
जि
की
प्र
ति कि
न्न
न्तो
स्था
ओं
न्तो
लि
न्य में
वि
खों
खों
भि
श्चा
क्ता
की
णि की
ष्ठा
नि
त्य
णि
ख्या
प्र
खों ष्ठा
नि की णि
प्र
प्र
जि
त्य
भि
कि
क्ता
भि
ति ष्टि
वि
यें
लि
प्र
प्र
की
द्य
वि
ष्टि थि
ति ति
न्दा
नि वि
में री
त्म ल्या
न्न
भि
ष्टि
वि
प्र
न्दा
नि
में
धि ल्यां
वि
स्व
भि
खों
द्वा
री
ष्ठा
त्य
की न्तो
धि
र्षों णि
प्र ओं
नि
र्धा
नि
धि
दि
में
की
कि
हैं
में
त्र
क्षे
वि
र्ष
र्षों
र्ती
न्तु
स्त
ष्ठा
त्य
की
श्य
नि
की
र्ष ओं
न्तो में
धि
दि
जि
वि
प्र
न्दो
नि
में
त्र
क्षे
वि
हों
की
म्ब
ष्टि
वि
प्र
न्दा
नि
न्धि
न्य
में
धि
र्ष
की
दि
ण्ड
ष्टि
प्र
वि
ल्यां
न्तो
न्दा
र्था
दि
कि
में
धि
म्ब
दि
न्धि ष्टि
वि
प्र
त्म
न्तो
ष्टि
प्र
वि
लि
में
वि
यें
न्दा
नि
धि
न्चि
म्ब
दि
में
दि
ष्ण्ड
दृ
न्य
ण्ड
न्त
र्ष
धि ष्टि
वि
प्र
न्तो
त्रा
धि
न्धि
स्त
धि
प्रा
क्ष
र्व र्ण
नि
चि
वि
में
धि
न्धि
म्ब
दि
लि
में
न्त
र्ष
धि की
धि
क्त
म्ब
प्र
भि
क्ष
की
न्य
री
र्व
समझा जाये।
न्य
कन हेतु
से
य
के सम
षजनक सेवा के मू
अव
वेक से स
अ मा त कर दी गयी सेवा
को अस
षजनक
(3) अनुरोध है कृपया इस
षय पर
य लेते समय उपरो
भलीभां
त क
तथा इ
अपने अधीन
भी ला , ता
उनके
र पर भी उपरो
अनुपालन सु
का
के सं न
का अनुपालन सु
त
मा द क
है। ये
षय पर इस स
और न ही इस स सरका सेवक को
स म
या जा सके।
(4) उपरो सी
का
स म
केवल स म
का
के पथ द ना
लागू
य
को अव
त न करते
का
के वेका कार के
सी
सी कार का कोई अ कार दान करते । भवदीय, ओ० पी० आ स व ।"
8. Thus from the aforesaid Rules it is apparent that any adverse entry made against a government servant is required to be communicated to him within a period of 45 days and if the said adverse entry is not communicated within 45 days then that cannot be read against the employee as adverse entry. The aforesaid Government Order dated 30.6.1993 categorically provides that if after an adverse entry is made and for the next 5 years there is no adverse entry against a government servant the said adverse entry shall be ignored for the purpose of determination of the satisfactory work of such government servant. 9. In view of the aforesaid provisions of Rules, 1995 as well as the Government Order dated 30.6.1995, in the considered view of this court the petitioner has been wrongly denied the benefit of ACP/time scale reading the entry of the year 1998-99 as an adverse entry against the petitioner as the same was never communicated to him and this fact has been admitted in the letter dated 14.11. 2008. Thus the adverse entry of the year 1998-99 could not be read against the petitioner and the adverse entry of the year 1994-95 ought to have been ignored in terms of the Government Order dated 30.06.1993 for the determination of the satisfactory work of the petitioner for the purposes of granting the time scale/ACP to the petitioner.
न्तों
सि
क्त
र्ण
नि
द्धा
क्ष
स्थ
न्तों
द्धा
सि
क्त
न्हें
श्चि
नि
रें
स्त
कि
में
र्थ हैं
प्र
र्श कि
द्ध
रु
हीं
यों
रि
र्य चि
धि
प्रा
मि
मों
क्र
वि
वि
धि
हैं
प्र
ज्ञा
यों
रि
धि
दें
क्ष नि
में
यों
धि
रि
धि
श्चि
नि
कि
न्त
द्धा
सि
र्श
क्त
र्ग
म्ब
वि
कि
न्ध प्रा
में
न्ध
म्ब
क्ष प्र
कि
री
प्रा
ति
वि
10. In such view of the matter the instant writ petition is allowed. Since the petitioner has already been superannuated, the respondents are
directed to calculate the benefits of the ACP/time scale whichever may be available to the petitioner at the relevant point of time ignoring the aforesaid adverse entry of the year 1998-99 in terms of Rule 5 of Rules, 1995 and ignoring the adverse entry of the year 1994-95 in terms of the Clause 2 (2) (c) of the Government Order dated 30.06.1993. All consequential benefits shall be paid to the petitioner within period of 8 weeks from the date of communication of certified copy of this order. October 23, 2026 o.k.
(Anish Kumar Gupta,J.)
Digitally signed by :OM KRISHNA CHOUDHARY High Court of Judicature at Allahabad