Principal Commissioner of Customs Acc Import New Delhi v. Ms Micromax Informatics Limited
- Court
- High Court of Delhi
- Date of judgment
- 27 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice Avneesh Jhingan, Justice Shail Jain
- Case number
- CUSAA No. 38 of 2024
Full judgment
$~6 to 10 *
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 27.10.2026
# +
CNR No. DLHC010208572024 CUSAA 34/2024
# +
CNR No. DLHC010213652024 CUSAA 36/2024
# +
CNR No. DLHC010221782024 CUSAA 38/2024
# +
CNR No. DLHC010246872024 CUSAA 41/2024
# +
CNR No. DLHC010246882024 CUSAA 42/2024 PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS ACC IMPORT NEW DELHI .....Appellant Through:
Mr. Aditya Singla, SSC
versus MS MICROMAX INFORMATICS LIMITED Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Balbir Singh, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Pranav Sarthi, Mr. Ayush Raj, Ms. Disha, Mr. Vedant Kohli, Mr. Vinayak, Ms. Prachi Dhingra, Mr. Utkarsh Vatsa & Mr Udit Bajpai, Advs.
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN AVNEESH JHINGAN, J. (ORAL) 1.
The issues involved in all the appeals are similar. For the sake
of convenience, the period involved and the relevant dates are tabulated below: HC Appeal (Against Sanctioned Refund)
Period
CUSAA No. 36/2024
June 2014 to March 2015 Export Commissio nerate
CUSAA No. 34/2024
September 2014 Import Commissio nerate
Refund and Interest amount
Sanctioned Refund Rs. 28,48,22,600/- + Interest Rs. 2,13,57,289/-
Sanctioned Refund Rs. 22,48,35,292/- + Interest Rs. 1,53,75,038/- + Rejected Claim Rs. 14,08,263/-
OIA dt. 09.03.2022
CESTAT Order dt. 26.09.2023(Against Sanctioned Refund)
Sanctioned refund amounts to be paid to Micromax + Interest for delayed payment of refund to be paid as per law to Micromax.
Upheld OIA dated 09.03.2022
Sanctioned refund amounts to be paid to Micromax + Interest not dealt with as already decided in previous OIA
Upheld OIA dated 09.03.2022
CUSAA No. 41/2024
October 2014 Import Commissio nerate
CUSAA No. 38/2024
November 2014 to January 2015 Import Commissio nerate
CUSAA No. 42/2024
February 2015 and March 2015 Import Commissio nerate
2.
Sanctioned Refund Rs. 33,91,47,955/- + Interest Rs. 2,14,63,884/-
Sanctioned Refund Rs. 68,11,45,947/- + Interest Rs. 4,15,40,572/- + Rejected Claim Rs. 25,46,390/-
Sanctioned Refund Rs. 50,15,32,437/- + Interest Rs. 2,95,14,840/- + Rejected Claim Rs. 10,10,708/-
Sanctioned refund amounts to be paid to Micromax + Interest not dealt with as already decided in previous OIA
Upheld OIA dated 09.03.2022
Sanctioned refund amounts to be paid to Micromax + Interest not dealt with as already decided in previous OIA
Upheld OIA dated 09.03.2022
Sanctioned refund amounts to be paid to Micromax + Interest not dealt with as already decided in previous OIA
Upheld OIA dated 09.03.2022
The respondent imported Cellular Phones and mobile parts
during the relevant period. Self-assessed Bills of Entry for home consumption were filed classifying the imported goods to be chargeable @ 0% Basic Customs Duty and @ 6% Countervailing Duty (for short ‘CVD’). 2.1
Notification No. 12/2012-CE dated 17.03.2012 was issued
granting exemption from excise duty. The notification was amended
by Notification No. 4/2014-CE dated 17.02.2014. By Notification No. 12/2015-CE dated 01.03.2015, the exemption granted was made subject to fulfilment of Condition No. 16. The condition is reproduced below: “If no credit under rule 3 or rule 13 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 has been taken in respect of the inputs or capital goods used in the manufacture of these goods.” 2.2
The issue as to whether CVD was leviable on the goods
imported by the respondent was decided by the Supreme Court in SRF Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs, Chennai, (2015) 14 SCC 596. It was held that CVD was not payable on the goods imported during the period in issue. 2.3
The respondent on basis of the decision in SRF Ltd. (supra)
applied for a refund of the CVD. The application was ultimately decided by the Commissioner of Customs (Imports) (hereinafter ‘AA’). It was ordered that the refund claimed by the respondent along with interest be credited to the Consumer Welfare Fund (for brevity ‘CWF’) in terms of Section 27(2) of the Customs Act, 1962 (for short ‘the Act’). 2.4
Aggrieved by the Order-in-Original (for short O-I-O), the
respondent preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of Customs (Appeals)/First Appellate Authority (for short ‘FAA’) and succeeded. The FAA held that the adjudicating authority had ignored the certificate issued by the independent chartered accountant (for short ‘CA’), the certification by the statutory auditor of the balance sheet for
the financial year 2014-15 and 2015-16 and erred in concluding that the CVD paid was made part of the cost of the mobile phones thereby implying that the burden was passed on to the buyers. 2.5
The appeal filed by the appellant was dismissed by the
Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter ‘tribunal’) on 26.09.2023. Hence, the present appeal. 3.
Learned counsel for the appellant contends that the production
of the certificate issued by the CA in itself is not evidence that the burden of CVD was not passed on to the consumer. It is submitted that the respondent had not shown the amount of refund due as an amount receivable in the balance sheets as on 31.03.2015 and 31.03.2016, fortifying the case of the department that the burden of CVD paid was passed on. It is canvassed that uniformity in prices before and after the change in the CVD payment scenario does not establish that the burden was not passed on to the customers. 4.
Learned senior counsel for the respondent submits that no
substantial question of law arises. It is contended that the factual findings recorded by the FAA were upheld by the tribunal holding that the case was not of unjust enrichment. It is submitted that the invoices as directed by the department were produced to substantiate that there was no change in prices during the relevant period and thereafter. 4.1
The submission is that the statutory audit reports, balance sheets
as on 31.03.2015 and 31.03.2016 and the notes appended thereto established that the burden of CVD was not passed on and the amount of CVD paid was recorded as an asset. The argument is that the
certificate issued by the CA supports the claim of the respondent for refund. Reliance is placed on the decision of this Court in Principal Commissioner of Customs (ACC Imports) v. Nokia India Sales Pvt. Ltd., 2025:DHC:5400-DB to buttress the submission that in similar circumstances the certificate issued by an independent CA was held to be a valid document for discharging the burden, to claim a refund under Section 27(2) of the Act. 5.
The undisputed facts are that no CVD was payable on the goods
imported by the respondent during the relevant period, consequently a refund was due. The only issue was whether the burden of CVD paid by the respondent was passed on or not. Another aspect was whether the respondent had successfully rebutted the presumption under Section 28D of the Act that the burden of duty was passed on to the consumers. 6.
The respondent before the AA produced invoices, a complete
set of balance sheets for the relevant financial years and a certificate issued by the CA certifying that the burden of CVD paid was not passed on to the customers. The tribunal considered the legal position that the onus of rebutting the presumption under Section 28D of the Act was on the respondent. The FAA concluded that the burden of CVD was not passed on to the customers. A factual finding was recorded that the invoices produced showed that CVD was neither recovered from the buyers nor reflected in the invoices. The nonclaiming of expenditure vis-à-vis the CVD paid was held not to be fatal to the claim of the respondent for refund of CVD paid, as it was
not proof of the burden having been passed on. 7.
The rejection of the CA certificate by the AA was contrary to
Board Circular No. 18/2010 dated 07.08.2010. The reliance placed by the FAA on the CA certificate stating that the incidence of CVD was not passed on, was upheld by the tribunal being in consonance with the circular. 8.
The decision in Nokia India Sales Pvt. Ltd. (supra) relied upon
by the respondent supports the contention that the certificate of the CA cannot be ignored more so, when supported by other documents such as the books of account. The conclusion of the tribunal upholding the findings of fact recorded by the FAA suffers from no legal or factual error much less perversity. There is no question of law involved much less a substantial question of law. 9.
The appeals are dismissed. Pending applications, if any, are also
disposed of.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
SHAIL JAIN, J OCTOBER 27, 2026 ‘JK’ Reportable:- Yes