R. Swarnalatha v. Bhasker Kareri
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice P.sam Koshy, Justice Laxmi Narayana Alishetty
- Case number
- CC No. 474 of 2025
- Result
- DISMISSED
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
[ 3304 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY CONTEMPT GASE NO: 474OF 202s
Contempt Case under Sections 10 to 12 of Contempt of Courts Act 1971 to punish the respondent herein for their willful and deliberate disobedience of the order
dt.23-09-2024 in W.A.No. 702 ot 2024. Between:
R. Swarnalatha, D/o Late R. Venkat Narayana aged about 37 years, Unemployed No 1-4-24914, Balaji Nagar, Suryapet, Suryapet District. ...PETITIONER AND
1. Bhasker kareri, Chief General Manager (HRD) TGSPDCL Corporate Office 2nd floor, Mint Compound, Hyderabad 2. Musharraf Ali Faruqui, Chairman and [Vlanaging Director The Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Mint Compound, Hyderabad
...Respondents Counsel for the Petitioner : Sri M.V. Rama Rao Counsel for the Respondents : Sri G. Vidya Sagar, Senior Counsel representing Ms. K. Uday Sri The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDEABAD THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY CONTEMPT CASE No.474 of 2o25 CNR No.HBHCO LOO42442O25
DATE: L4.tO.20.26 Reserved ou 20.08.2026
Pronounced on Lf .LO.2O26 Uploaded on: L8.10.2026
Between R.Swat nalatha
...Petitioner AND
Bhaskt:r Karer-i and another.
,..Respondents
ORDEE: - lper Hon'ble Sn Juslzce l,oxmi Nqrogatla AlishettA)
This contempt case is liled to punish the respondents under Sections 10 to 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 197 1,
lor rvilllul and deliberate (lisobedience of the Order dated 23.O9.2()2,1 , passed by this Court in W.A. No.702 of 2021.
2.
I {earr1
Sri M.V.Rama Rao, learned Counsel for the
petitioner and Sri G.Vidya Sagar, learned Senior Counsel representing Ms.K.Uday Sri, learned Standing Counsel for responclt'nts.
3.
Lerrnred Counsel for the petitioner submittecl that
petitione,''s lather worked as Lineman in Telangana State
Solrlhern l)ower Distribution Company Limited (for short
LNA,,)
C.(-.No.171 of 202 5
TGSPDCL') and he expired on 13.05.2013 leaving behind
petitioner and her sister; that since the petitioner and her husband are unemployed, petitioner submitted a representation d,ated 12.07 .20 13 to TGSPDCL for appointment in a suitable post on compassionate grounds as she was solely dependent on
her father, but the same was rejected bv the respondents; that petitioner filed a writ petition uide W.P.No.14118 of 2OI4 and a learned Single Judge of this Court uide Order dated 08.O9.2022 ' disposed of the same with a direction to TGSPDCL to reconsider
the case of the petitioner for compassionate appointment; that the case of the petitioner was again rejected by TGSPDCL ufuJe
Order dated 28.10 .2022 on the ground that petitioner was neither deserted by her husband nor her husband died. 3. 1
. He further submitted that petitioner {iled one more writ
petition zde W.P.No.9593 of 2023 and the same was dismissed uide Order dated 23.02.2024. Aggrieved by the same, petitioner preferred W.A.No.702 of 2O24 and the same was disposed of bv
this Court uide Order dated 23.09 .2024 , with a direction to respondents to reconsicler the case of petitioner herein by examining whether petitioner was totally dependent and "vas living with her deceased father at the time of his death and pass
appropriate orders preferably within a period of two months from the date of receipt of Order.
"r/
LNA,J C C.No.17t of 2025
3.2. Hr: furrher submitteci that respondents once rejected r_he case of the petjti oner 18.12 2A2l
again
uid_e proceedings dated
on rhc same grounds, on vl,hich earlier
reprt_,st--n LeLticrns r,vcre rejectccl,
t,,ithout tollowing the directions
issued bv this Courr in proper perspective
and in true spirit. He
further subrnitred that respondents have
recalled the rejection
Order dared 18.12.2024 uide proceeclings
dared 26.O3.2025 and,
issued fresh rejection Order dated 2a.OS.2O2S. submittecl that reasons assigned
by the respondents in the
eariier rejer:tion ordcrs that petirioner nor descrted br.hc,r husband vyas
He further
was married and she was
faulted q,ith bv this Court and
directed lhe respondents Lo reconsider the request of the
petttioner for
compassionate appointment, however,
respondenis orce again rejectecl
the case of petitioner by merely
referring tc) Lhe' Government Memo
dated 0g.10.2003. He further
submitted thal the grounds on u.hich. u"as rejecteci *ere ilregal and
the case of the petirioner
contrary to the directions issred
b1' this Court. Br con tcnding
rhus, praved to punish the
respondcn Ls.
4.
Learned Sen ior Counscl lor the
[o Counter sub;nitted that in
passed bt
respondents by referring
terms of Order dated 23.Og.2024,
rhjs Court, the case of the petitioner
reconsiclerecl atrd the
was
same was relected ulde Order dated
LNA,J C C No J7l of2025
18.12.2024; that the said Order d.ated, 26.03.2025 and fresh
was recailed uide proceedings
rejection Order dated 28'05'2025'
was passed by recording detailed
reasons He further submitted
that the case of the petitioner was examined
thoroughly and as
hercasedoesnotfallwithintheparametersandguidelinesfor compassionate appointment' the 4. I
same was rejected'
. He further submitted that the contention
of the petitioner
same ground on which earlier that her case was rejected on the submitted were rejected is incorrect He further
representations
that this Cottrl uide Order dated 23
father and whether she was
living with her father at the tlme
of his death. He further
submitted that accordinglY, resPondents case of the petitioner in accordance
have examined the
with the directions issued
by this Court and have passed a
reasoned order dated
is aggrieved 28.05.2025, and if the petitioner has to challenge the rejection
' directed the
whether the petitioner was
respondents to examine the aspect solely dependent on her deceased
Og '2024
by the same' she
order dated 28 05 2025 He finally
of submitted that legaiity and correctness
an order passed in
this Court cannot be bY issued directions of compliance examined in contemPt and that
no further or suPPlementary
orders can be passed in the contempt, is liable to be dismissed
therefore, contempt CaSe
LNA,J C.C No 174 of 2a25
5.
This Court has considered the submissions advanced on
behalf of both the, parties and perused the record.
6.
In the present case, by order datecl 23.O9.2024 passed in
W.A.No.70.2 rf 2021, rhrs Court directed the respondents to
reconsider thc case of the petitioner by examining whether the
petitioner was totally dependent on her father and she was living ri ith aer- deceased father at the time of his death and pass
appropriate orders thereon in accordance with law, within a period of tw() months from the date of receipt of Order. The
dircction iss:ted br. thrs CoLlrt \t.as to reconsider the representaLion of Lhc petitroner ancl to pass appropriate orders
q,ithin a srr:criied period and it ri,as not a direc[ion
to grant the
relief sough L for bv the petitioner.
7.
The material placed on record discloses that in
compliancr: ol- O rcler passed by this Court, respondents have
passed Order dated 18.t2.2O24, rejecting the case of the pe[rtioner anC tl'rr' same v",as recalled uide proceedings
dated
26.O3.2O2a; a;..d tl-esh rejecrion Order darcd 2g.05.2025
r,,",as
passed. In thr: rejection Order <jated 2g OS.2O2S, detailecl reasons lor r-ejcction have been recorded bv the respondents
b1,
referring to Gc,vernment Memo dated 0g.10.2003 (adopted
by
ihe corporarion on 20.03.2004) clarifying the policy
of the
Government to pror.ide compassionate appointment to
L,YA,J C C.No 171 ol 2025
dependents of deceased Government employees to help the family in distress. [n the Government Memo dated 08 10.2003,
it is clarified that once a marriage is performed, a daughter is not dependent even if she is an unemployee or her husband is an unemployee and a married daughter is said to be dependent on her parents when her husband deserts her or disappears for years together or dies. It was also clarified that the spouse of the deceased employee, pre-deceased her husband, therefore, the
choice of one of the married daughters does not arise for consideration of the married daughter for employment on compassionate grounds. In the rejection Order it
is also
observed that mere living of thc married daughter with the deceased employee at the time of death alone is not the criteria
for consideration of employment on compassionate grounds'
8.
It is pertinent to note that the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of Lalith Mathur Vs' L.Maheswara Raol, held that when
the direction of the Court was to consider the employee's representation, and thc said drrcction r'r'as complicd with, be it, rejection of the same on merils, lhe employee has to assaii the rejection order in a fresh Writ Petition; that Contempt Petition
hled before the High Court is not maintainable and the High
i "/ ' (zooo) to scc 285
LNA,,) (-..('.No.171 of 202 5
Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the same and give relief on meD ts
9.
It is settled principle of lar,r. that contempt jurisdiction
cannol be invoked for deciding the correctness or Iegality of an order pztssed in purported compliance with the directions of the
Court. OrLce an order has been passed pursuant to the directions issued by the Court, the remed-y of the aggrieved
party li('s elsewhere and not in contempt proceedings. If the petition(.r is aggricved by the order dated 2g.05.2025 passed
by
the responrlents, it is always open for her to chaltenge the same before the:Lppropriate forum in accordance with law.
10. Havirrg regard to the facts and circumstarces of the case, in consicier,:d opinion of this Court, the petitioner has failed to establish any rvillful, deliberatc or intentional disobeclience o[
the order riared 23.09.2024 passed in W.A.No.702 ot 2021. Therelo|c, no case is made out for initiating punitive action
against the respondents uncler the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.
1. Accorrlingly, the contempt case is dismissed. There shall
be no orclr:r i1s to costs.
LNA.,I
Miscel.laneous petitions closed.
('.(-.Mt.tzJ tf
)0lj
Pending, if any, shall stand
SD/. A.V.S. PRASAD DEPUTY REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY//
To
SECTION OFFICER
1. One CC to Sri M.V. Rama Rao, CC to Sri G. Vidya Sagar,
I 9r" CC to Ms.
? 9r" 4. Two CD Copies Mvj/GNK
9mq.
Advocate (OPUC)
Advocate IOeUCJ' K. Uday Sri, Advocate (OPUC) '
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2811012026
B
\o
ORDER '<.
GG.No. 474 of 2025
J o t)
0tNo\l m
t D €SPATC.Hj0_t
CLOSING THE CC
(@*. 3t Vol>j'
i Il
t