Raffles Residency Private Limited v. The State of Karnataka
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 6 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Suraj Govindaraj
- Case number
- WP No. 3640 of 2023
- Result
- DISMISSED
Full judgment
-1HC-KAR
®
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ WRIT PETITION NO. 3640 OF 2023 (LB-RES) BETWEEN RAFFLES RESIDENCY PRIVATE LIMITED RAFFLES PARK, SOUKYA ROAD, SAMETHANAHALLI VILLAGE, ANUGONDANAHALLI HOBLI, HOSKOTE TALUK, BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT-560067 MR. HUSSAIN SOMJEE ... PETITIONER (BY SRI. JOSHUA HUDSON SAMUEL., ADVOCATE) AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA DEPARTMENT OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT AND PANCHAYAT RAJ, VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGALORE-560001 REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY 2. SAMETHANAHALLI GRAM PANCHAYAT SAMETHANAHALLI VILLAGE, ANUGONDANAHALLI HOBLI, HOSKOTE TALUK, BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT-560067 REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT 3. THE PANCHAYAT DEVELOPMENT OFFICER SAMETHANAHALLI GRAM PANCHAYAT, SAMETHANAHALLI VILLAGE, ANUGONDANAHALLI HOBLI, HOSKOTE TALUK, BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT-560067 4. THE HOSKOTE TOWN PLANNING AUTORITY 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
-2HC-KAR
NO. 2221, SRI. JAYACHAMARAJENDRA CIRCLE, K.R. ROAD, HOSKOTE-562114 (R4 CAUSE TITLE AMENDED AS PER COURT ORDER DATED 16.02.2023) 5. THE SATELLITE TOWN RING ROAD PLANNING AUTHORITY, BMRDA OFFICE, NO.01, ALI ASKER ROAD, VASANTHA NAGAR, BENGALURU-560052 (R5 CAUSE TITLE AMENDED AS PER COURT ORDER DATED 12.10.2023)
6. MR. KOSHY KURUVILLA S/O LATE PETER KURUVILLA AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS R/AT VILLA NO.8, RAFFLES PARK, SOUKYA ROAD, SAMETHANAHALLI, BANGALORE-560067. (IMPLEADING APPLICANT 1)
7. MR. ANAND KRISHNAMOORTHI, S/O LATE A.N. KRISHNAMURTHY, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, R/AT VILLA NO.8, RAFFLES PARK, SOUKYA ROAD, SAMETHANAHALLI, BANGALORE-560067. (IMPLEADING APPLICATION 2) 8. THE GREATER BANGALORE AUTHORITY, EAST CITY CORPORATION, N.R. SQUARE, BENGALURU-560002 REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF COMMISSIONER.
9. THE GREATER BANGALORE AUTHORITY EAST ZONE OFFICE-MAHADEVAPURA GROUND FLOOR, CORPORATION BUILDING, OPPOSITE PHOENIX MALL, ITPL MAIN ROAD, 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
-3HC-KAR
MAHADEVAPURA, BANGALORE-560018 REP BY THE JOINT COMMISSIONER. …. RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. BOPPANNA BELLIAYAPPA., AGA FOR R1; SRI. M.S. DEVRAJU., ADVOCATE FOR R2 & R3; SRI. A.V. GANGADHARAPPA., ADVOCATE FOR R4; SRI. YOGESH D. NAIK., ADVOCATE FOR R5; SRI. SURAJ SAMPATH ON IA 2/24 IMPLEADING APPLICANT) THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OR ORDER IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI AND QUASH THE IMPUGNED NOTICE/ORDER NO. PDO/SGR/ / 2022-23 DATED 10.01.2023 VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND ETC. THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS AND HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 13.07.2026, THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ
ORAL ORDER
1.
Petitioner is before this court seeking for the following reliefs: 1. Issue a Writ or Order in the nature of Certiorari and quash the impugned Notice / Order No. PDO/SGR/ / 2022-23 dated 10.01.2023 vide ANNEXURE:A; and ii. Issue a Writ / Order / Direction in the nature of a Mandamus directing the Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 to grant sufficient opportunity to the Petitioner before taking any action with regard to withdrawal of the Occupancy Certificate. 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
-4HC-KAR
iii. Pass any other order or direction as this Hon'ble Court deems fit under the facts and circumstances of the case.
2.
The above matter had been disposed of vide order dated 11.12.2023 quashing the impugned order dated
10.1.2023
and
restoring
Occupancy
Certificates issued from 19.09.2016 to 05.05.2017, more particularly on 19.09.2016 for Villa Nos. 42 and 45, on 14.12.2016 for Villa Nos. 55, on 15.03.2017 for Villa Nos. 51, on 10.04.2017 for Villa Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18 and 19, on 05.05.2017 for Villa Nos. 24, 26, 32, 40, 46, 48, 49, 50, 52, 54, 56, 58, 59, 60 and 61 subject to the premises being put back in a fit condition for occupancy within three months. If the same were not to be done by 15.03.2024, Respondents No.2 and 3 were at liberty to issue fresh notice to show cause as to why the Occupancy Certificate could not be cancelled after hearing the petitioner and passing necessary orders. The due taxes were also directed to be cleared within a period of 90 days from the date of receipt of a copy of the order. 3.
Post the disposal, application IA-1/2024 was filed by two persons, claiming to be purchasers of the villas in
project
of
petitioner,
09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
to
implead
-5HC-KAR
themselves as party respondents. IA-2/2024 was filed by them, seeking recall of the order dated 11.12.2023 and restoration of the matter for fresh hearing. IA-1/2024 4.
The present application has been filed by two persons claiming to be victims of the fraud allegedly perpetrated by the petitioner in collusion with the official respondents. It is contended that the project is yet to be completed and that the petitioner, in concert with respondents No.2 to 5, has misled this Court. According to the impleading applicants, no proper verification or inspection was undertaken before the earlier Occupancy Certificates came to be issued to ascertain whether the construction had been
completed
in
all
respects.
It
is
further
contended that none of the villas had been occupied at the relevant point in time. Though it is now asserted by the petitioner that the doors and windows have subsequently been removed, the specific allegation of the impleading applicants is that such doors and windows were, in fact, never installed in the first instance. 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
-6HC-KAR
5.
It is, therefore, contended that the Occupancy Certificates
issued
on
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
19.09.2016, and
14.12.2016,
05.05.2017
were
procured by practising fraud upon the authorities and were issued at the behest of the petitioner solely with a view to prevent the project from being treated as an "ongoing project" within the meaning of the provisions
of
Real
Estate
(Regulation
and
Development) Act, 2016 (for short, "RERA"). 6.
The impleading applicants further submit that they, along with several other purchasers, have already instituted
proceedings
before
Real
Estate
Regulatory Authority (RERA), which are presently pending consideration. According to them, relying upon the order passed by this Court, the petitioner has taken a specific stand before the RERA that, since Occupancy Certificates had been issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016, 15.03.2017, 10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 the project falls outside the purview of
an
"ongoing
project"
under
RERA
and,
consequently, the Authority lacks jurisdiction to entertain the complaints. 7.
It is submitted that the observations made in the order passed by this Court are being relied upon by 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
-7HC-KAR
the petitioner to the prejudice of the impleading applicants in the proceedings pending before the RERA. Since the outcome of the present proceedings is likely to have a direct bearing upon their rights and remedies, the impleading applicants contend that they are necessary and proper parties to the present proceedings and therefore seek to be impleaded. IA-2/2024 8.
By way of I.A. No.2/2024, the proposed respondents seek recall of the order dated 11.12.2023. The application substantially reiterates the allegations made in the impleading application. In addition thereto, it is contended that the sale deed in respect of Villa No.38 was executed only on 19.09.2018 and possession thereof was delivered on 08.11.2018. According to the applicants, these facts belie the petitioner's assertion that Occupancy Certificates had been issued as early as between September 2016 and
May
2017
14.12.2016, 05.05.2017.
It
specifically
on
19.09.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
is
that,
submitted
had
and a
valid
Occupancy Certificates been issued during the said period, there would have been no occasion for the petitioner to defer the execution of the sale deed and 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
-8HC-KAR
delivery
of
possession
for
more
than
a
year
thereafter. The delay in execution of the sale deed and
handing
over
possession,
it
is
contended,
unmistakably demonstrates that neither the project nor the villas were complete and fit for occupation at the relevant point of time. 9.
The impleading applicants further contend that even the requisite electricity connections had not been obtained, thereby reinforcing their contention that the construction was incomplete. It is alleged that the petitioner approached this Court by suppressing these material facts and succeeded in obtaining the order dated 11.12.2023. According to them, the petitioner is now relying upon the said order before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) to contend that the project stood completed in the year 2017 by virtue of the issuance of the Occupancy Certificates on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016, 15.03.2017, 10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 consequently, does not fall within the ambit of an "ongoing project" under the section 3 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. It is therefore submitted that this Court, in exercise of its inherent and extraordinary jurisdiction, ought to recall the order dated 11.12.2023 so as to prevent its process from 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
-9HC-KAR
being abused and to ensure that no party derives an advantage from an order allegedly obtained by suppression of material facts. Objections to IA 1 and 2/2024 10.
The petitioner has filed a common statement of objections opposing both the applications. It is contended that neither application is maintainable either in law or on facts and that the proposed respondents have no locus standi to seek either impleadment or recall of the order dated 11.12.2023. It is submitted that the notices impugned in the writ petition pertain only to 33 residential villas, namely Villa Nos.1 to 6, 10, 12, 14 to 19, 24, 26, 32, 40, 42, 45, 46, 48 to 52, 54 to 56 and 58 to 61.
11.
The proposed respondents admittedly claim rights only in respect of Villa Nos.8 and 53, which do not form part of the subject matter of the impugned notices or the proceedings culminating in the order dated 11.12.2023. Hence, it is contended that the proposed respondents are complete strangers to the subject matter of the writ petition and have no legal right or interest which would entitle them to seek impleadment or recall of the order passed by this Court. 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 10 HC-KAR
12.
It is further contended that the allegation of fraud is wholly unfounded and devoid of material particulars. The petitioner denies having committed any fraud, either independently or in collusion with the official respondents,
and
submits
that
burden
of
establishing such serious allegations squarely rests upon the applicants. It is further submitted that valid Occupancy Certificates have been issued in respect of Villa Nos.8 and 53. Since those Occupancy Certificates continue to remain valid and subsisting and
have
never
been
challenged
before
any
competent forum, the applicants cannot contend that their rights have been adversely affected by the order passed in the present writ petition. On these grounds, the petitioner prays for dismissal of both the applications. 13.
The petitioner has also filed an application seeking extension of the time granted by this Court under its order dated 12.03.2023. By the subsequent order dated 11.12.2023, this Court extended the time for restoring the villas to a condition fit for occupation by directing the petitioner to complete the restoration of 15 villas within three months and the remaining 18 villas within a further period of three months, besides 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 11 HC-KAR
directing payment of all property taxes from the date of issuance of the Occupancy Certificate. 14.
In support of the application for extension, it is contended that, insofar as the villas already sold are concerned,
petitioner
had
discharged
property tax liability until the respective dates of sale, whereafter the liability was borne by the purchasers. In respect of the unsold villas, though the petitioner remained liable to pay the taxes, it could not do so owing to financial constraints occasioned by the villas remaining unsold and the intervening COVID-19 pandemic. It is on these grounds that extension of time was sought even for payment of the outstanding taxes. 15.
The petitioner further submits that Villa Nos.4, 26, 32 and 59 have either already been sold or are under agreements of sale. Since the prospective purchasers are residing abroad and executed
interior
have
works
not finalised or
according
to
their
individual preferences, those villas could not be restored to a condition fit for occupation within the time stipulated by this Court. 16.
It is further submitted that Villa Nos.1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 10, 12, 14 to 19, 24, 40, 42, 45, 46, 48 to 52, 54, 56, 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 12 HC-KAR
58, 60 and 61 continue to remain unsold. According to the petitioner, the interior works and finishing of these
villas
are
intentionally
deferred
until
a
prospective purchaser is identified, so that the interiors may be customised in accordance with the individual preferences of the purchaser. It is also submitted that the glass facades and window panels had to be removed on account of cracks that developed due to temperature variations and that certain
doors
were
removed
to
facilitate
such
customisation. 17.
The petitioner further states that a substantial quantity of the materials required for completion of the interior and finishing works forms the subject matter of Commercial Appeal No.1021/2021 and, therefore, could not be utilised pending adjudication of the said proceedings. It is also submitted that enquiries
are
continuously
being
received
from
prospective purchasers and that the petitioner is making
earnest
inventory
in
efforts
order
to
to
liquidate
reduce
unsold
substantial
maintenance costs being incurred. The petitioner is stated to be in constant communication with its financial creditor for obtaining the necessary No Objection Certificates to effect such sales, a process 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 13 HC-KAR
that has taken considerable time. It is in these circumstances that the petitioner undertook, by way of the affidavit dated 12.03.2024, to restore all the unsold villas which form the subject matter of the writ petition to a condition fit for occupation within a period of six months from the date of the affidavit, irrespective of whether they are sold during the said period. 18.
The petitioner has also addressed the issue regarding the competency of the authority which issued the Occupancy Certificate. Referring to the contention of the respondents that respondent Nos.2 and 3 lacked the authority to issue the Occupancy Certificate, it is submitted that the said contention is misconceived. According to the petitioner, under the provisions of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayat, Taluka Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control for Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015 (for short, "the 2015 Bye-laws"), the expression "Authority" has been specifically defined to mean the authority authorised by the Gram Panchayat to grant licences and discharge the functions of the Authority under the Bye-laws. It is, therefore, contended that respondent Nos.2 and 3 were fully competent to 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 14 HC-KAR
issue
Occupancy
Certificate
and
that
challenge to their authority is legally untenable. 19.
Hence, this Court recorded the same on 16.04.2024 as under: ORDER
1. The submission made by the counsel for the petitioner is that in terms of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Grama Panchayat Control Over erection of buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015, the authority is defined as an authority authorized by Grama Panchayat to grant licenses and perform the function of the authority under the Bye-laws.
2. A perusal of the said model Bye-laws indicates that the building license is sanctioned by the authority, the applications for erection, re-erection, material alteration and demolition of building have to be made to the authority. The applications for construction of commercial and business buildings, education, religious, charitable as also industrial buildings would have to be made to the authority. The authority could cancel the license and it is the authority which has to issue the Completion Certificate as also the Occupancy Certificate. The above would only indicate that anyone authorized by Grama Panchayat would be an authority.
3. It is not clear from these Bye-laws whether the Bye-laws would apply even to the Town Planning Authority having jurisdiction over that particular area or would this apply only as regards Panchayat coming outside the jurisdiction of the Town Planning Authority. It is also not clear as to what are the competencies available with the Grama Panchayat including the human qualifications as also the infrastructural requirements to carry out the above activities and sanction/issue permissions. In the event of Panchayat not having any human resource or infrastructure resource to carry out the above activity which are available with the Planning Authority which remains to be explained by the Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department as to how the Grama Panchayat would have jurisdiction to issue the Occupancy Certificate, plan sanction etc., as regards the area which falls within the jurisdiction of Planning Authority 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 15 HC-KAR
formulated for that purpose, since the model Bye-laws have been issued under the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 as also be the Principal Secretary, Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department to file its affidavit in this regard.
4. Affidavit to be filed on or before 22.04.2024. 5. Re-list on 23.04.2024.
20.
On 24.04.2024, an affidavit of the Under Secretary of the Government Urban Development Department dated 22.04.2024 was filed, which reads as under: AFFIDAVIT I, Rajesh Sulikeri, S/o Sangappa Sulikeri, aged about 46 years, working as Under Secretary to Government, Urban Development Department (BDA & B-1), Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru-560 001, do hereby solemnly affirm and state on oath as follows:1. I state that I am working as Under Secretary to Government, Urban Development Department(BDA & B-1), Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru and I am aware of the facts of the case as borne out from the records. Hence, I am swearing to this Affidavit. 2. This Hon'ble High Court, vide its daily order dated 16.04.2024 has directed as below:. "It is not clear from these Bye-laws whether the Bye-laws would apply even to the Town Planning Authority having jurisdiction over that particular area or would this apply only as regards Panchayat coming outside the jurisdiction of the Town Planning Authority. It is also not clear as to what are the competencies available with the Grama Panchayat including the human qualifications as also the infrastructural requirements to carry out the above activities and sanction/issue permissions. In the event of Panchayat not having any human resource or infrastructure resource to carry out the above activity which are available with the Planning Authority which remains to be explained by the Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department as to how the Grama Panchayat would have jurisdiction to issue the Occupancy Certificate, plan sanction etc., as regards the area which falls within the jurisdiction of 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 16 HC-KAR
Planning Authority formulated for that purpose, since the model Bye-laws have been issued under the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 as also be the Principal Secretary, Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department to file its affidavit in this regard". 3. I state that Local Planning areas are declared under section 4-A of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act and Planning Authorities are constituted for such areas and the Planning Authority carries out the functions specified in the Act which includes the preparation and implementation of the Master Plans approved by the Government along with the Zonal regulations for the Local Planning Area. 4. I state that Under section-15 of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 the Planning authority is to issue permission for development of buildings in the commencement certificate prescribed in the Karnataka Planning Authorities Rules, 1965. That with respect to Urban Local Bodies in the State powers to issue commencement certificates for development of buildings is delegated to the Urban Local Bodies under section 81 of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act. However, in the Gram Panchayat limits within the Local Planning Areas, the Commencement certificates are issued by the Planning Authorities for permission for development of buildings in accordance with master plan; layout plan approved under section 17 of the KTCP Act, 1961 and the provisions in the applicable Zonal regulations. The copy of commencement certificate is produced herewith. as ANNEXURE-R1. 5. I state that Provisions with regards to permission for building development in The Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat raj Act, 1993 is enumerated as under: Section-64:Regulation of the erection of the building. (1) Subject to such rules as may be prescribed, no person shall erect any building or alter or add to any existing building or erect advertisement hoarding or set up mobile towers atop or alongside or in any vacant space within the premises or reconstruct any building without the written permission of the Grama Panchayat. The permission may be granted on payment of such fees as may be specified by bye-laws. (2) If the Grama Panchayat does not, within sixty days from the receipt of the application determine whether such permission should be given or not and communicate its 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 17 HC-KAR
decision to the applicant, such permission shall be deemed to have been given and the applicant may proceed to execute the work, but not so Pas to contravene any of the provisions of this Act or any rules or bye-laws made under this Act. (5A) Gram Panchayats shall strictly comply with the provisions of the Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 in the matter of issue of building license or approvals of housing or residential layouts. Any approval in violation of any of the provisions of the town and country planning Act, 1961 shall be construed as "misconduct" for which the concerned officer or official shall be liable for disciplinary action. (ii) That RDPR has issued notification No. RDP 788 GPA 2014 dated: 08.05.2015 as the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Grama Panchayat Control over erection of Buildings) Model Byelaws, 2015. The provisions in the Bye-laws to the extent that is not specified in the Zonal Regulations of the approved Master plan under section 13(3) of the KTCP Act, 1961 is applicable in the Jurisdiction of the Gram Panchayat within the limits of the Local Planning Authority. The building license is to be considered under section 64 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat raj Act, 1993 to be read with clause-9 of the notified Model Byelaws-2015 and completion certificate from the qualified Architect/ Qualified empanelled engineer/supervisor (Civil Diplomaholder) regarding completion of work under clause-12 and permission to occupy the building is to be issued by the Gram Panchayat under clause-13 of the said Byelaws. 6. I respectfully submit that with respect to the provisions related to open space, area, height limitations, parking spaces, exemption to open spaces there are overlapping provisions in the approved Zonal Regulations and Model Building byelaws. However as specified under sub section (5A) of Section 64 of The Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat raj Act, 1993 the provisions Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 in the matter of issue of building license is applicable and hence the provisions in the Zonal Regulations are applicable mutatis-mutandis in the Gram Panchayat limits within the Local Planning Areas. 7. I respectfully submit that as explained above it is to be noted that within the Gram panchayat limits in the Local Planning Areas the gram Panchayat has to obtain the Commencement certificate issued under section-15 of the 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 18 HC-KAR
KTCP Act, 1961 from the concerned Planning Authority and subsequently grant the permission for erection of building under section-64 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat raj Act, 1993 read with clause-9 of the Notified model byelaws-2015. There is no provision in the KTCP Act, 1961 to issue Occupancy Certificates and hence the Planning Authorities do not issue Occupancy Certificates. On completion of construction of the building, the completion certificate regarding completion of the construction of building is submitted by the applicant through the qualified Architect/Qualified empanelled engineer/supervisor (Civil Diploma holder) to the gram panchayat in Form-V specified _ in the Notified model Byelaws-2015. Thereafter permission to occupy the building is issued by the Gram Panchayat under clause-13 in Form-VI specified in the notified model Byelaws-2015. 8. I respectfully submit that in areas other than Local Planning Areas Building license and Occupancy certificates are to be issued under the provisions of The Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat raj Act, 1993 and the notified byelaws-2015. The copy of the Model Bye-laws is produced herewith as ANNEXURE-R2. Provisions in Bengaluru Metropolitan Region: 9. I respectfully submit that in case of areas within the Bengaluru Metropolitan Region the Government has notified the Bengaluru Metropolitan Region Development Authorities Rules, 2022 vide Notification No: UDD 234 BMR 2020(e) dated: 20.11.2023, in sub rule-(5) of the Rule 18 the following provision is made: "18. Power to inspect and Review.- (5) The Metropolitan Commissioner shall call for his prior concurrence to any proposals and activities including Single Site Approvals, Provisional/ Final Layout Approvals, Orders of Release of Sites, Approval of Development Plans, Allowing developments in Agriculture Zone within specified distance from the Gramatana during land conversion and Development Plan approval, Proposals of Technical Opinion before issuing building plans, Commencement Certificate and Occupancy Certificate for Multistorey Projects by Local bodies/ Planning Authorities/ Urban Development Authorities and any other Authority executing Town and Country Planning functions in the Local Planning Areas within Bengaluru Metropolitan 10. I respectfully submit that in accordance with the provisions made in the Rule above in case of Multistoried 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 19 HC-KAR
buildings the Commencement Certificate and Occupancy Certificate for Multistorey Projects by Local bodies shall be issued in concurrence with the Metropolitan Commissioner of BMRDA. The copy of the Notification is produced herewith as ANNEXURE-R3. WHEREFORE, I respectfully pray that this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to accept the Affidavit, in the interest of justice and equity.
21.
A perusal of the affidavit filed by the Under Secretary of the Government Urban Development Department indicates that reliance has been placed upon the provisions of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayat, Taluka Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control for Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015. It is contended that rule 2(b) of the said Byelaws defines the expression "Authority" to mean the authority authorised by the Gram Panchayat to grant licences and discharge the functions of the Authority under the Bye-laws. Reference is also made to Rule 5, which provides that, while the building plan is required to be signed by a qualified architect, engineer or supervisor, it is the Gram Panchayat, being the competent authority, that examines the proposal and accords approval to the building plan in accordance with the provisions of the model Byelaws. 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 20 HC-KAR
22.
The petitioner further relies upon Rules 9 and 10 of the Bye-laws read with Section 111(1) and (2) of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, to contend that every Gram Panchayat is required to have a full-time Panchayat Development Officer (PDO) and a Secretary, who are Government officers, besides such other officers as may be appointed. On the strength of these provisions, it is contended that the Panchayat Development Officer is the competent authority to exercise powers under the Bye-laws, including the power to cancel a licence and to issue the requisite clearance or Occupancy Certificate. Consequently, it is submitted that the Occupancy
Certificate
issued
by
Panchayat
Development Officer is by a competent authority and cannot
be
faulted
on
ground
of
lack
of
jurisdiction. 23.
By relying on Rule 13, it was contended that the Gram Panchayat is the authority to issue Occupancy Certificates. It is in that background, the following order was passed on 24.04.2024:
ORDER 1. An affidavit of the Under Secretary to the Government, Urban Development Department has been 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 21 HC-KAR
filed. Much arguments have been advanced by all the counsel on the said affidavit. Despite the said affidavit having been filed and the arguments being advanced, there is no clarity as to whether the Model Bye-laws would apply to an area where the Town Planning Authority has jurisdiction i.e., could both the Gram Panchayath and the Town Planning Authority have the jurisdiction in the same area and if so, to what extent. If not, who will have the jurisdiction whether it is the Gram Panchayath or the Town Planning Authority 2.The learned counsel for respondents No.2 and 3 is also directed to place on record if the Model Bye-laws have been adopted/drafted by respondent No.2 3.Re-list on 25.04.2024 at 2.30 p.m.
24.
On 25.04.2024 no categorical submission having been made as regards who is the authority, the following order was passed: ORDER 1. Though the matter was taken up today once again for determining who is the authority who could issue the Occupancy Certificate, the affidavit which has been filed by the Under Secretary, Urban Development Department and Under Secretary, Panchayath Raj Department, have not stated categorically as to who has got authority to issue plan sanction, commencement certificate and Occupancy Certificate. The model bye-laws indicate as if it is the Panchayath who has to grant Occupancy Certificate. 2. However, the Panchayath Development Officer who is present before this Court submits that the model bye-laws have not been adopted by Respondent No.2. In such a situation, it would be required for the Urban Development Department, Panchayath Raj Department as also the Director, Town and Country Planning Department to categorically state as to who is the authority he has to approach for grant of Occupancy 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 22 HC-KAR
Certificate. The consequence of not adopting the model bye-laws also to be made clear. 3. Re-list on 03.06.2023 at 2.30 p.m.
25.
Pursuant to the directions issued by this Court, an affidavit came to be filed by the Under Secretary to Government, Urban Development Department. In the said affidavit, it is stated that Local Planning Areas are declared under Section 4A of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 (for short, "the KTCP Act"), and Planning Authorities are constituted for such areas. It is further stated that the Planning Authorities discharge the functions entrusted to them under the KTCP Act, including the preparation, approval and implementation of the Master Plan and the regulation of planned development within their respective jurisdictions.
26.
It is further stated that, under Section 15 of the KTCP Act, the Planning Authority is the competent authority to grant permission for development and to issue the commencement certificate in accordance with
provisions
of
Karnataka
Planning
Authority Rules, 1965. Referring to Section 64 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, it is stated that the Model Bye-laws framed 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 23 HC-KAR
thereunder would apply to areas falling within the jurisdiction of a Gram Panchayat only to the extent the subject matter is not governed by the Zonal Regulations forming part of the approved Master Plan. 27.
It is therefore stated that an application for grant of a building licence is required to be considered under Section 64 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, read with Rule 9 of the notified Model Bye-laws, and that the permission to erect a building is to be granted by the Gram Panchayat. However, where the property is situated within a notified Local Planning Area, the provisions of the KTCP Act and the applicable Zonal Regulations would also govern the development. In such cases, before granting permission for erection of a building under Section 64 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, the Gram Panchayat is required to obtain or ensure the existence of a commencement
certificate
issued
by
jurisdictional Planning Authority under Section 15 of the KTCP Act. 28.
The affidavit further clarifies that the KTCP Act does not contain any provision empowering the Planning 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 24 HC-KAR
Authority to issue an Occupancy Certificate upon completion of the construction. Consequently, the Planning
Authorities
do
not
issue
Occupancy
Certificates. Upon completion of the building, it is the Gram Panchayat which is competent to issue the Occupancy Certificate in Form VI prescribed under the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control of Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015. 29.
Insofar
as
developments
situated
within
Bengaluru Metropolitan Region are concerned, it is stated that the matter is governed by sub-rule (5) of Rule
of
Development
Bengaluru
Authority
Metropolitan
Rules,
2022,
Region which
specifically regulates the issuance of occupancyrelated
permissions
falling
within
in
respect
jurisdiction
of of
developments
Bengaluru
Metropolitan Region Development Authority. 30.
It is in that background that this court passed the order dated 3.06.2024 as under:
ORDER 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 25 HC-KAR
1. An affidavit of Sri Rajesh S. Sulikeri, the Under Secretary to Government, Urban Development Department has been filed. The same is taken on record.
2. A memo has been filed on behalf of respondents No.2 and 3 enclosing the Model Bye-laws. The same is taken on record.
3. Since the learned Advocate General was present before this Court, the issue in the above matter was brought to the notice of the learned Advocate General requesting him to look into the matter and make a submission on behalf of all the departments concerned to bring a quietus to the issue as also a transparency for owners, developers, purchasers, etc., to be clear on which is the concerned authority for grant of development plan, plan sanction, building licence, commencement certificate, Occupancy Certificate, etc., in relation to a property which falls within the jurisdiction of a Planning Authority as also a Gram Panchayath.
4. Re-list on 20.06.2024 at 02:30 p.m.
31.
On 6.08.2024, a submission was made that out of 61 villas, taxes were paid in respect of 46 villas and the clubhouse and in respect of two villas, the taxes are yet to be paid.
32.
In the meanwhile, a committee had been constituted comprising representatives of various departments. A memo was filed on 28.08.2024 enclosing a Circular dated
5.08.2024
issued
by
both
Urban
Development Department and Rural Development Department. The said Circular reads as under: 09/10/2026, 12:06, Bengaluru
- 26 HC-KAR
ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ಸ ಾ ರ ಸಂ ೆ :NAE 136 BMR 2024 ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ಸ ಾ ರದ ಸ
ಾಲಯ
ಬಹುಮಹ ಕಟ ಡ ೆಂಗಳ ರು,
ಾಂಕ:05-08-2024 ಸು ೊ!ೕ#ೆ
$ಷಯ: : &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ ಾ ,!ಯ-.ನ ಕಟ ಡಗಳ 01ಾ ಣಗ3&ೆ 4ಾ56ೕನ ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ' (Occupancy Certificate) $ತರ8ೆ 1ಾಡುವ ಬ&ೆ:. ಉ#ೆ.ೕಖ: 1. ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? ಆಯು ಾ!ಲಯದ ಸು ೊ!ೕ#ೆ ಸಂ ೆ : ಕಪಂ>ಾ / ಅBವೃ D/131/2024
ಾಂಕ: 12.03.2024.
2. ಸ ಾ ರದ ಅ6ಸೂಚ ೆ ಸಂ ೆ : &ಾ'ಅಪ 788 &ಾ'ಪಂಅ 2014 :08.05.2015. 3.
ಾಂಕ 24.06.2024 ರಂದು ಸ ಾ ರದ ಅಪರ ಮುಖ ಾಯ ದF ,
ನಗ>ಾBವೃ D ಇ#ಾ ೆ ರವರ ಅಧ I ೆಯ-. ನJೆದ ಸKೆಯ ನಡವ3. 1ಾನ ಉಚL
ಾ MಾಲಯವN OP ಅQ
ಸಂ ೆ :26194/2023 ರ-. 0ೕ ರುವ
0Rೇ ಶನದನ5ಯ ಉ#ೆ.ೕಖ(2) ರ-. Tೊರ ಸ#ಾUರುವ ಸು ೊ!ೕ#ೆಯ-.ನ ಅಂಶಗಳನುV ಪNನರುಚWOX ಮುಂದುವ>ೆಸು ಾ!, >ಾಜ ದ ಎ#ಾ. &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ 0[ ಸ#ಾಗುವ
ಕಟ ಡಗ3&ೆ
ಅಥ ಾ
ಅX!ತ5ದ-.ನ
ಕಟ ಡಗಳ
ಾ ,!ಗಳ-.
ಬದ#ಾವ8ೆಗ3&ೆ
ಸಂಬಂ6Xದಂ ೆ ಕ ಾ ಟಕ &ಾ'ಮ ಸ5>ಾ? ಮತು! ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? ಅ60ಯಮ, 1993 ರ ಪ'ಕರಣ 64 ರನ5ಯ ಅನುಮ+ ಪJೆಯುವNದು ಕJಾ]ಯ ಾUದು^ ಇದನುV
ಉಲ.ಂ_Xದ-. ಅ60ಯಮದ ಪ'ಕರಣ 298 ರನ5ಯ ಕ'ಮ ವ`ಸಲು ಸೂ ಸ#ಾUರುತ!Rೆ. ಕ ಾ ಟಕ &ಾ'ಮ ಸ5>ಾ? ಮತು! ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? (ಕಟ ಡಗಳ 01ಾ ಣದ aೕ#ೆ Q#ಾ. ಪಂ)ಾಯ=ಗಳ,
ಾಲೂ.ಕು ಪಂ)ಾಯ=ಗಳ ಮತು! &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾಯ=ಗಳ
0ಯಂತ'ಣ) 1ಾದO ಉಪ$6ಗಳb, 2015 ರ 13 ೇ ಉಪ$6ಯ-. ಅ6KೋಗRಾO ೆ ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ' $ತರ8ೆಯ ಬ&ೆ: +3ಸ#ಾUದು^ ಉಪ$6ಗಳನುV ಉಲ.ಂ_ಸುವ ಸಂಬಂಧ 14 ರ ಉಪ$6ಯ-. ಕ'ಮವ`ಸುವ ಬ&ೆ: +3ಸ#ಾUರುತ!Rೆ.
ಕ ಾ ಟಕ &ಾ'ಮ ಸc>ಾ? ಮತು! ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? ಅ60ಯಮ, 1993 ರ ಪ'ಕರಣ 64 (5-ಎ) ರ-. &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾಯ=ಗಳb ಕಟ ಡದ #ೈ4ೆef 0ೕಡುವ $ಷಯದ-. ನಗರ
ಮತು! &ಾ'1ಾಂತರ gೕಜ ೆ ಅ60ಯಮ, 1961 ರ ಉಪಬಂಧಗಳನುV ಕJಾ]ಯ ಾU 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 27 HC-KAR
hಾ-ಸತಕiದು^. ಸದO ಉಪಬಂಧಗಳ ಉಲ.ಂಘ ೆಯನುV 'ದುನ ಡ ೆ" kಂದು ಅlೈ X ಸಂಬಂಧಪಟ ಅ6 ಾO ಅಥ ಾ Xಬmಂ ಯನುV Fಸು! ಕ'ಮ ೆi Tೊ8ೆ&ಾರ>ಾಗುವ ಬ&ೆ: +3ಸ#ಾUರುತ!Rೆ. &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ಗಳb, gೕಜ ಾ ಪ'Rೇಶದ
ಾ ,!gಳ&ೆ ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ನಗರ ಮತು!
&ಾ'1ಾಂತರ gೕಜ ಾ ಅ60ಯಮ, 1961 ರ ಪ'ಕರಣ 15 (1) ರಂ ೆ gೕಜ ಾ hಾ'6 ಾರಗ3ಂದ ಕಟ ಡಗಳ 01ಾ ಣ ೆi hಾ'ರಂBಕ ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ'ವನುV ಕJಾ]ಯ ಾU ಪJೆಯತಕiದು^ ಸದO ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ' ಪJೆಯದ MಾವNRೇ ಾಮ&ಾOಯನುV 1ಾ ದ>ೆ ಅಥ ಾ ಅದರ MಾವNRೇ ಬಳ ೆಯನುV 1ಾ ದ>ೆ ೆ&ೆದು ೊಳn ೇ ಾದ ಕ'ಮಗಳ ಬ&ೆ:. +3ಸ#ಾUರುತ!Rೆ.
ಕಟ ಡ 01ಾ ಣ ಪoಣ &ೊಂಡ ನಂತರ ಅQ Rಾರರು ಒಂದು +ಂಗqೆ ಳ&ೆ ಕಟ ಮೂಲಕ 4ಾ56ೕನ/ ಅ6KೋಗRಾO ೆ ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ' (Occupancy Certificate) ವನುV &ಾ'ಮ ಪoಣ &ೊಂಡ ಬ&ೆ: 0ಗ ತ ನಮೂ ೆಯ-. &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+&ೆ ಅQ ಯನುV ಸ-.ಸುವ ಪಂ)ಾ*+*ಂದ ಪJೆಯ ೇrರುತ!Rೆ. ಆದ^Oಂದ aೕಲiಂಡ ಾk^ಗಳb ಮತು! ಉಪ $6ಗಳ ಅನ5ಯ >ಾಜ ದ ಎ#ಾ. &ಾಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ ಾ ,!ಗಳ-. 0[ ಸ#ಾಗುವ ಕಟ ಡಗ3&ೆ ಅಥ ಾ ಅXsತ5ದ-.ನ ಕಟ ಡಗಳ ಬದ#ಾವ8ೆಗ3&ೆ ಸಂಬಂ6Xದಂ ೆ ಾಮ&ಾOಯು ಪoಣ &ೊಂಡ ನಂತರ hಾ'6 ಾರ ೆi ಅಹ ಾದ ಾಸುF-t /ಪu ಯ-.ನ (Empanelled) ಇಂQ0ಯv/ aೕ- )ಾರಕOಂದ ಕಟ ಡ ಪoಣ &ೊಂಡ ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ'ವನುV ಪJೆದ ನಂತರ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ ಅBವೃ D ಅ6 ಾOಯು 4ಾ56ೕನ/ಅ6KೋಗRಾO ೆ
ಪ'1ಾಣ
ಪತ'
$ತರ8ೆ&ೆ
ಪoವ ದ-.
hಾ'ರಂBಕ ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ' ಮತು! &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+*ಂದ $ತರ8ೆ 1ಾಡ#ಾದ #ೈ4ೆef, ಅನುwೕ ಸ#ಾದ ಕಟ ನxೆ Tಾಗೂ ಅಂRಾಜು ಪu ಗಳಂ ೆ ಕಟಡ 01ಾ ಣ ಾUರುವ ಬ&ೆ: ಸಂಬಂ6Xದ hಾ'6 ಾರಗqೆ ಂ &ೆ ಜಂuMಾU ಪOFೕ-X, ಸಂಬಂ6Xದ
gೕಜ ಾ
hಾ'6 ಾರ ಂದ
ಅನುwೕ ತ
ಾಮ&ಾO/ಕಟ ಡ ಪoಣ ಾUರುವ ಬ&ೆ:, ಕJಾ]ಯ ಾU
ನxೆಯನು4ಾರ
ಾಂ+'ಕ ಅBhಾ'ಯವನುV
ಪJೆದು, ಸದO 01ಾ ಣವN ಕ ಾ ಟಕ &ಾ'ಮ ಸ5>ಾ? ಮತು! ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? (ಕಟ ಡಗಳ 01ಾ ಣದ aೕ#ೆ Q#ಾ. ಪಂ)ಾಯ=ಗಳ, ಾಲೂ.ಕು ಪಂ)ಾಯ=ಗಳ ಮತು!
&ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾಯ=ಗಳ 0ಯಂತ'ಣ) 1ಾದO ಉಪ $6ಗಳb, 2015 Tಾಗೂ ಕ ಾ ಟಕ &ಾ'ಮ ಸ5>ಾ? ಮತು! ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? ಅ60ಯಮ, 1993 ರ ಪ'ಕರಣ 64 (5-ಎ) ರ-.ನ ಷರತು!ಗಳನVಯ ದೃyೕಕOX ೊಂಡ ನಂತರವzೆ ೕ 4ಾ56ೕನ/ಅ6KೋಗRಾOಕ 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 28 HC-KAR
ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ'ವನುV 0ಗ ತ ನಮೂ ೆಯ-. ಪoಣ
$ವರಗqೆ ಂ &ೆ ಸಂಬಂ6Xದ
ಅ6KೋಗRಾO0&ೆ $ತOಸಲು ಕ'ಮವ`ಸತಕiದು^. aೕಲiಂಡ ಸು ೊ!ೕ#ೆಯ-.ನ 0Rೇ ಶನಗಳನುV ಉಲ.ಂ_X &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ಗಳb 4ಾ56ೕನ/ ಾಸgೕಗ /ಅ6KೋಗRಾO ೆ
ಪ'1ಾಣ
ಪತ'
$ತರ8ೆ
1ಾ ದ^-.
ಸಂಬಂ6Xದವರ $ರುದD 0ಯ1ಾನು4ಾರ ಕ'ಮ ೈ&ೊಳn#ಾಗುವNRೆಂದು ಸಹ +3XRೆ. Sd/- Sd/(ಎ{.ಆv. ಉ1ಾಶಂಕv) ( ಅಂಜು| ಪ ೇ ?)
ಸ ಾ ರದ ಅಪರ ಮುಖ ಾಯ ದF ಸ ಾ ರದ ಅಪರ ಮುಖ ಾಯ ದF (ಪಂ.>ಾ?) ನಗ>ಾBವೃ D ಇ#ಾ ೆ. &ಾ'[ೕ8ಾBವೃ D ಮತು! ಪಂ. >ಾ? ಇ#ಾ ೆ,
33.
Learned HCGP submitted that it is the procedure prescribed
under
this
Circular
which
would
be
applicable. In that background, the following order was passed on 28.08.2024 as under: Order 1. Learned HCGP has filed a memo dated 28.08.2024 enclosing a circular dated 05.08.2024 issued by both, the Urban Development and the Rural Development Departments. 2. She further submits that, it is this procedure which would be applicable in respect of any action to be taken under the Karnataka Gram Samraj and Panchayat Raj (Control of Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Gram Panchayats on constructions of building), 2015. By placing reliance on the same, she submits that, it is for the Gram Panchayts to get mandatory technical opinion about the completion of the work from the planning authority and thereafter take necessary action. 3. In this regard, I am of the considered opinion that the technical wing attached to the Zilla Panchayats comprising of the Executive Engineer, the Assistant Executive Engineer at the Taluka Panchayat level and the Assistant 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 29 HC-KAR
Engineer or the Junior Engineer at the Gram Panchayat level, could be included to conduct periodical inspections, take measurements, ascertain if the same is in compliance or there is any deviation, submit necessary reports and thereafter obtain technical opinion in association with the planning authority. 4. It is stated that, the circular has been circulated to all the concerned authorities for implementation as also web hosted on the respective websites. Her submission is taken on record. 5. Sri. Suraj Sampath, learned counsel appearing for the proposed respondents, submits that the Occupancy Certificate was issued in 2016 without the inspection of the petitioner's property. 6. Sri. Joshua Hudson Samuel, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would however submit that, there was an inspection conducted and the inspection report is considered by the Panchayat before issuing of Occupancy Certificate. 7. Sri. M.S.Devaraju, learned counsel appearing for the Gram Panchayats, is directed to verify and make his submissions as to whether the inspection was carried out and if an inspection has been carried out to place the inspection report on record in the present proceedings. 8. If inspection has not been carried out, he is directed to offer an explanation as to how without inspection an Occupancy Certificate has been issued. 9. Sri.M.S.Devaraju, learned counsel for the respondent Nos.2 and 3 submits that, notices have ben issued to the petitioner. In reply, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, no notices have been issued. Hence, Sri. M.S.Devaraju, learned counsel is directed to place the notices issued with due acknowledgement, on record. 10. Re-list on 18.09.2024 at 2.30 p.m.
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 30 HC-KAR
34.
Since a specific contention had been urged that certain Occupancy Certificates were issued in 2016, this Court directed the learned counsel appearing for the Gram Panchayat to obtain instructions and make a specific submission as to whether any inspection had in fact been carried out prior to issuance of the Occupancy Certificate. It was further directed that, if any
such
inspection
had
been
conducted,
inspection report and all connected records be placed before the Court. 35.
On 23.10.2024, learned counsel appearing for the Gram Panchayat submitted that a site inspection had been conducted and that an inspection report dated 20.08.2016 had been submitted. The said report was produced along with a memo dated 13.09.2024. A perusal of the inspection report, however, revealed that it merely contained the numbers of the villas and the extent of construction in each of them. The report did not disclose the nature or scope of the inspection undertaken, nor did it indicate whether the inspecting authority had verified the structural completion of the villas, the availability of civic and other mandatory amenities, or compliance with the sanctioned
plan
and
applicable
statutory
requirements. There was also no material to indicate 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 31 HC-KAR
that any inspection had been carried out in respect of the project as a whole before issuance of the Occupancy Certificate. 36.
In view thereof, the learned counsel for the Gram Panchayat was directed to verify and clarify whether the Occupancy Certificate had been issued in respect of the entire project or only in respect of individual villas. Simultaneously, the learned counsel appearing for the Planning Authority was directed to place on record
Authority
procedure while
adopted
inspecting
a
by
Planning
development
for
considering grant of an Occupancy Certificate or any analogous permission. He was also directed to produce
Standard
Operating
Procedure,
inspection protocol, checklist or any other guidelines governing such inspections, if available. 37.
On 27.11.2024, it was submitted that a Standard Operating Procedure had been prepared in relation to inspections under Section 17 of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961, and the same was directed to be placed on record. Upon consideration of the material produced, this Court, by order dated 02.12.2024, observed that while the approval of the layout plan is granted by the jurisdictional Planning 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 32 HC-KAR
Authority under the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961, after the coming into force of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control of Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015, the power to issue Occupancy
Certificates
developments
had
in
been
respect
vested
in
of
such
Gram
Panchayats. 38.
The Court also noticed that the Gram Panchayat had no role in sanctioning the layout or development plan and that there existed no comprehensive statutory guidelines,
Standard
Operating
Procedure
or
inspection protocol governing the manner in which Occupancy Certificates were to be issued by the Gram Panchayats. It was further noticed that several Gram
Panchayats
did
not
even
have
qualified
engineers on their establishment to technically verify whether a building or project satisfied the statutory requirements
before
issuance
of
an
Occupancy
Certificate. The absence of any uniform mechanism for inspection and certification gave rise to serious concerns regarding the manner in which Occupancy Certificates were being issued. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 33 HC-KAR
39.
It was in the aforesaid background, and having regard to the larger ramifications of the issues arising for consideration extending beyond the facts of the present case, that the learned Advocate General sought permission to assist the Court. Permission was accordingly granted.
40.
The learned Advocate General submitted that the deficiencies and lacunae noticed by the Court in the existing regulatory framework had been taken note of by the State Government and that appropriate corrective measures were under consideration. It was further submitted that amendments to the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control of Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015 were proposed with a view to streamlining the procedure governing the issuance of Occupancy Certificates and removing the ambiguities that presently existed.
41.
It was also brought to the notice of the Court that the Model Bye-laws had not yet been adopted by several Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Gram Panchayats across the State, resulting in a lack of uniformity
in
regulatory
regime
governing
building permissions and Occupancy Certificates. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 34 HC-KAR
42.
The learned Advocate General further pointed out that several proceedings relating to the very same project
were
pending
before
Real
Estate
Regulatory Authority (RERA). This Court clarified that the scope of the present proceedings was confined to examining
legal
framework
governing
issuance of Occupancy Certificates and the procedure required to be followed by the competent authorities. All issues arising in the proceedings pending before the RERA, including the rights and liabilities of the parties
under
Real
Estate
(Regulation
and
Development) Act, 2016, were left open to be adjudicated independently by the Authority on their own merits and in accordance with law. 43.
During the course of the proceedings, a memo was also filed placing on record the communication dated 26.09.2024 issued by the Director, Panchayat Raj Department, as well as a Circular issued by the Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department. The said documents were taken on record and considered for the purpose of examining the existing statutory and administrative framework governing the issuance of Occupancy Certificates. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 35 HC-KAR
44.
The same were recorded vide order dated 4.03.2025 which reads as under:
1.
ORAL ORDER Learned AGA has placed on record a memo enclosing the letter dated 26.9.2024 issued by the Director, Karnataka Panchayat Raj, Bengaluru. The same reads as under: ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ಸ ಾ ರ ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? ಆಯು ಾ!ಲಯ ಾ3Rಾಸ ರ4ೆ!, &ಾಂ6ನಗರ ೆಂಗಳ ರು - 560 009. ಸಂ ೆ . ಕಪಂ>ಾಅ/ಅBವೃ D/575/2024
ಾಂಕ:: 26.09.2024
ರವO&ೆ. ಮುಖ ಾಯ 0 ಾ ಹಕ ಅ6 ಾO, Q#ಾ. ಪಂ)ಾ*+, ೆಂಗಳ ರು &ಾ'1ಾಂತರ. 1ಾನ >ೆ, $ಷಯ: ಪoಣ &ೊಳnದ $#ಾ.ಗ3&ೆ ಾಸgೕಗ ಪ'1ಾಣ ಪತ'ಗಳನುV $ತರ8ೆ 1ಾ ರುವ ಬ&ೆ:. ಉ#ೆ.ೕಖ: 1. ಘನ ಉಚL ಾ Mಾಲಯದ ಪ'ಕರಣ ಸಂ ೆ : WP No. 3640/2023 2. ಅವರ ಮುಖ ಾಯ ದF , ನಗ>ಾBವೃ D ಇ#ಾ ೆ
ರವರ ಅಧ I ೆಯ-. ಾಂಕ: 24.06.2024 ರ ಸKಾ ನJಾವ3 3. ಾಯ 0 ಾ ಹಕ ಅ6 ಾO, ಾಲೂ.ಕು ಪಂ)ಾ*+,
Tೊಸ ೋ}ೆ. Tಾಗೂ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ ಅBವೃ6 ಅ6 ಾO, ಸaೕತನಹ3n &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+, Tೊಸ ೋ}ೆ 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 36 HC-KAR
ಾಲೂ.ಕು ರವರ ವರ :
ಾಂಕ :27.06.2024,
$ಷಯ ಸಂಬಂ6Xದಂ ೆ. ಉ#ೆ.ೕಖ-1 ರ ಪತ'ದ-. ಘನ ಉಚL ಾ Mಾಲಯದ ೆಂಗಳ ರು &ಾ'1ಾಂತರ Q#ೆ., Tೊಸ ೋ}ೆ
ಪ'ಕರಣದ-.
ಾಲೂ.ಕು,
ಸaೕತನಹ3n &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+*ಂದ &ಾ'ಮ ಪಂ)ಾ*+ ಾ ,!ಯ-. ಮ. >ಾ~ೆ•f
>ೆXJೆ0f
ಪoಣ &ೊಂಡ
hೆ€ ೇP
Tಾಗೂ
-[}ೆ•
4ಾ56ೕನ
ಪoಣ &ೊಳnದ
ಪತ'ವನುV
$#ಾ.ಗ3&ೆ
0ೕ ರುವ
ಬ&ೆ:
ಉ#ೆ.ೕ‚ಸ#ಾUರುತ!Rೆ. ಇದರ ಸಂಬಂಧ ಉ#ೆ.ೕಖ-2 ರ ಸKೆಯ-. ಸದO ಪ'ಕರಣದ ಬ&ೆ:, ಪOFೕ-ಸಲು ಸೂ ಸ#ಾUದು^, ಉ#ೆ.ೕಖ-3ರ ವರ ಗಳನVಯ a. >ಾ~ೆ•f >ೆXJೆ0f hೆ€ ೇP -[}ೆ• ಪoಣ &ೊಳnದ $#ಾ.ಗ3&ೆ ಪoಣ &ೊಂಡ Tಾಗೂ 4ಾ56ೕನಪತ'ವನುV 0ಯಮ ಾ`ರ ಾU $ತರ8ೆ 1ಾ ರುವ ಬ&ೆ:, ಊ#ೆ.ೕ‚X ಈ ಾMಾ ಲಯ ೆi ವರ ಸ-.Xರು ಾ!>ೆ. ಆದ^Oಂದ, ಉ#ೆ.ೕ‚ತ ಪತ'ಗಳ-. ಉ#ೆ.ೕ‚Xರುವಂ ೆ ಮತು! ಪoಣ &ೊಳnದ $#ಾ.ಗ3&ೆ ಪoಣ &ೊಂಡ Tಾಗೂ 4ಾ56ೕನಪತ'ವನುV 0ೕ ರುವ ಸಂಬಂಧ ತ0 ೆ
ನJೆX
0ಯ1ಾನು4ಾರ
ಸೂಕ!
ಕ'ಮವ`X
ಾ Mಾಲಯದ
$ಷಯ ಾUರುವNದOಂದ ಕ'ಮವ`Xದ ಬ&ೆ: ತು ಾ U ಈ ಕ…ೇO&ೆ ವರ ಸ-.ಸಲು Tಾಗೂ ಘನ ಉಚL ಾ Mಾಲಯದ-.ನ ಪ'ಕರಣದ ಬ&ೆ:
ೈಯುr!ಕ
ಗಮನ ಹOಸಲು ೋORೆ. (ಆಯುಕ!ರು, ಕ.ಪಂ.>ಾ.ಆಯು ಾ!ಲಯ. ರವOಂದ ಅನುwೕ XRೆ)
ತಮc $†ಾ5X, Sd/-
0Rೇ ಶಕರು (ಅBವೃ .) ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ಪಂ)ಾಯ= >ಾ? ಆಯು ಾ!ಲಯ, ೆಂಗಳ ರು.
2.
She also relies upon the Circular dated 5.8.2024 issued by the Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department and Principal Secretary, Rural Development and Panchayath Raj Department, which reads as under:KARNATAKA GOVERNMENT
No. Na.Aa.E 136 BMR 2024 Karnataka Government Secretariat, Vikas Soudha, 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 37 HC-KAR
Bengaluru, dated: 05.08.2024. CIRCULAR Sub:Regarding issuance of Occupancy Certificate for the construction of buildings in Gram Panchayat limits. Ref:1. Circular No. Ka.pam.ra.aa/ Development/131/2024. Dated: 12.03.2024 issued by the Commissionerate of Karnataka Panchayat Raj. 2. Government Notification No: Gra.Aa.Pa 788 Gra. Pam. Aa 2014, Dated: 08.05.2015. 3. Proceedings of the meeting held on 24.06.2024 under the chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Urban Development Department. Pursuant to the direction given by the Hon'ble High Court in Writ Petition No:26194/2023, in continuation of the points contained in the circular issued under reference (2) is reiterated and further directed that as per Section 64 of the Karnataka Grama Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, it is mandatory to obtain the approval for the buildings to be constructed or with regard to the alterations to the existing buildings in all Gram Panchayat areas of the State. if it is violated, instructions are given to take action under Section 298 of the Act. As per the Model Bye-laws, 2015 of the Karnataka Gram Samraj and Panchayat Raj (Control of Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Gram Panchayats on constructions of buildings), in subsection 13 stipulates regarding issuance of Occupancy Certificate and action in respect of violation of sub-section 14. The Gram Panchayats should mandatorily comply with the provisions of the Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 in the matter of grant of building licences as per Section 64(5-A) of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993. It is informed that the violation of the said provisions is construed to be "misconduct" making the officer or staff concerned liable to disciplinary action. The Gram Panchayats within the limits of the planning area, shall obtain compulsorily Commencement Certificate for construction of buildings from Planning Authorities as per Section 15(1) of Karnataka Town and Rural Planning Act, 1961. The actions to be taken if any work is done without obtaining the said certificate or any use is made has been informed. The applicant should obtain an Occupancy Certificate from the Gram Panchayat by submitting an application to the Gram Panchayat in the prescribed form regarding the completion of the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 38 HC-KAR
building within one month after the construction of the building is completed. Therefore, with regard to the buildings to be constructed or alterations to existing buildings in all Gram Panchayat areas of the State in accordance with the above Acts and sub-rules, the Panchayat Development Officer shall, after obtaining the Building Completion Certificate from Architect/Empanelled Engineer/Superintendent qualified by the Authority, before issuing the Possession/Occupancy Certificate, jointly verify with the concerned authorities about the construction of the building as per the approved building plan and estimates, Commencement Certificate and license issued by the Gram Panchayat and get mandatory technical opinion about the completion of the work/building as per the approved map from the concerned Planning Authority, and take action for issue of Possession/ Occupancy Certificate to the concerned occupier with full particulars in the prescribed form only after it is confirmed that the said construction is in accordance with the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj (Regulation of Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Gram Panchayats on Construction of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015 and as per the conditions of section 64 (5A) of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993. It is also informed that action will be taken as per rules against those concerned if Gram Panchayats issue Possession/ Occupancy/ Occupancy Certificate in violation of the directions in the above circular.
Sd/(S.R. UMASHANKAR) Additional Chief Secretary to Government Urban Development Urban Development
3.
Sd/(ANJUM PARVEZ) Additional Chief Secretary to Government Department. (Panchayath Raj) Department
She submits that insofar as Panchayaths who have adopted the Karnataka Panchayath Raj (Zilla panchayaths, Taluka Panchayaths and Grama Panchayaths control over Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-Laws 2015, there will be a joint inspection, measurement and certification done by the Panchayath along with the Planning Authority and thereafter, necessary certificate, Occupancy Certificate and/or any other certificate required to be issued by the concerned Panchayath and Planning Authority.
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 39 HC-KAR
45.
4.
In the present case, Panchayath has not adopted the Model Byelaws of 2015. On enquiry, as to what could be the situation insofar as respondents No.2 and 3 are concerned, she seeks for and is granted a weeks’ time to obtain instructions and make her submission. She also seeks for a week’s time to comply with Para 3 of the order dated 9.1.2025 to place on record the list of Taluks Panchayaths and Zilla Panchayaths, who have adopted the Model Byelaws or not.
5.
Further more, learned AGA would have to make the stand of the State clear as regards the status of the matters prior to the circular being issued since the present matter falls within that grey area where there was no such circular in force.
6.
Re-list on 17.3.2025 at 2.30 p.m.
These circulars and orders being applicable post the issuance thereof, learned AGA was directed to make a submission as regards the projects taken up prior to the issuance of the circular, and it was further noticed that there being 5950 Gram Panchayats, 239 Taluk
Panchayats
and 31
Zilla
Panchayats, the
methodology of verification of the adoption of the model Bye-laws was not available. In furtherance of this, an
affidavit
Government,
of
Principal Secretary
Department
of
Personnel
to and
Administrative Reforms, e-Governance, was filed, which is taken on record. It was considered vide order dated 4.04.2025, which reads as under:
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 40 HC-KAR
SGRJ: 4.04.2025 ORAL ORDER
1.
Learned AGA has filed the affidavit of the Principal Secretary to Government, Department of Personal Administrative Reforms (e-Governance). The same reads as under: AFFIDAVIT I. Pankaj Kumar Pandey S/o. Deo Mani Pandey, aged about 48 years, working as Principal Secretary to Government, Department of Personal Administrative Reforms (e-Governance), Bengaluru do hereby solemnly affirm and state on oath as follows:1. I submit that I am swearing this Affidavit on behalf of me in the above writ petition as directed by the Hon'ble High Court on 21.03.2025 the same is reproduced as under:"1. Learned AGA submits that the order dated 4.3.2025 has not been uploaded. The further submission made by counsel for the petitioner is that after the order of 9.1.2025, no order has been uploaded. 2. Registry is directed to look into the same and upload all the orders. 3. Learned AGA seeks for and is granted two weeks time to make a submission as regards the order dated 4.3.2025. 4. An affidavit of the Desk Officers, Department of Rural Development has been filed. On the basis of the said affidavit, it is submitted by the learned AGA that it was the duty on part of the grama panchayats to have adopted the model by laws. The adoption or otherwise was not kept track of, since it was presumed that the panchayats would have adopted the model by laws. There have been 5,950 ground panchayats, Taluk panchayat and 31 Zilla Panchayat in the State 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 41 HC-KAR
of Karnataka. It is stated that there is no particular system in place to verify the adoption of the model by laws by the said panchayats. 5. In that view of the matter, I am of the considered opinion that there would have to be a system at least now implemented to keep track of these kind of issues as regards the adoptions of model by laws, dissemination of circulars, notifications, etc. 6. The Principal Secretary of e-governance Department is directed to look into this matter and come up with a viable solution. He is also directed to onboard all the grama panchayats, Taluk panchayats and Zilla panchayats onto the Court Case Monitoring System (CCMS), so that at least the dissemination could be made using the CCMS of any Circular, Notification or the like. 7 .An affidavit of the Principal Secretary, egovernance Department to be filed on or before 4.4.2025. 8. Re list on 4.4.2025." 2. I submit that, the State Government of Karnataka is Implementing a Unified Land Management System (ULMS), which will provide a single platform for use across departments that participate in transactions related to land and property. One of the key modules in ULMS is SITE (LAYOUT) and BUILDING PLAN APPROVAL SYSTEM. Under ULMS, the Site & Building Plan Approval System (SBPAS) in accordance to the provision of the Byelaws for the Urban Areas has been developed and rolled out for the Urban Areas is under Pilot Mode. DPAR (e-Governance) in consultation with RDPR will deliberate the usage of the ULMS SBPAS system for adoption of model bylaws by the Grama Panchayats in rural areas. 3. I submit that, the Court Case Monitoring System (CCMS) is a comprehensive, web-based, end-toend solution to monitor Government litigations where Government Departments are petitioners or respondents. Its primary objective is to ensure timely action and strict compliance with court 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 42 HC-KAR
orders. Cases handled by the Advocate scanned by the CCMS Cell within the AG Office and subsequently forwarded to relevant Government Departments for necessary action. Currently, 48 Government Departments and their affiliated Offices along with 79 Boards and Corporations have been successfully on boarded on to the CCMS Platform. The Rural Development and Panchayath Raj Department (RDPR) has already been onboarded into CCMS platform. As of now, 44 Admin logins and 183 user logins have been created at the Zilla Panchayat, Taluk Panchayath levels. As of now, within RDPR Department 31 Zilla Panchayaths and 8 Taluk Panchayats are already onboarded into CCMS. Necessary steps will be taken to onboard all the remaining Taluk Panchayaths and Gram Panchayaths in coordination with RDPR Department. (Annexure 1 & 2). 4. I submit that, the Centre for e-Governance manages the websites of all the State Government Departments. As part of the web portal facility has been provided to the Department nodal officer(s) for uploading Acts/ Rule/ Circular/Notifications/Government Orders. As per the Government Policy dissemination of the Circulars/Notifications are done through the websites of respective Departments/Boards/Corporations for making available to both the officials and the general public. In this regard, Govt. orders and Circulars have been already issued by DPAR (e-Governance) laying down the process for content preparation by the Department (Annexure-3 to 6). WHEREFORE, I most respectfully pray that this Hon'ble Court may kindly pleased to accept this Affidavit in the Writ Petition, in compliance with the directions issued by this Court in the interest of the justice and equity.
2.
Based on the above affidavit, she submits that the Government of Karnataka is implementing a Unified Land Management System (ULMS), which will provide a single platform for use across all departments that participate in transactions relating to land and property, including plan approval, the plan 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 43 HC-KAR
sanction, commencement Occupancy Certificate, etc.
certificate,
3.
The ULMS being a software which has been set up by the e-Governance Department, it will be required for all the concerned departments to be onboarded. She submits that 31 Zilla Panchayats and 8 Taluk Panchayats have been onboarded on application being made by them. Insofar as the other Taluka Panchayats and Gram Panchayats, it would be for the Principal Secretary of Rural Development and Panchayat Raj to issue necessary instruction for their onboarding on to the ULMS. Once the same is done, the monitoring as regards adoption of model byelaws, implementation of various rules could be monitored. In that view of the matter, the Principal Secretary of Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department is directed to coordinate with the Principal Secretary, eGovernance Department and issue necessary directions, guidelines and Standard Operating Procedure to enable all the Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Gram Panchayats to be onboarded on to the ULMS with clear direction as to what actions are to be taken by each Zilla Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat and Gram Panchayat.
4.
She submits that the Court Case Monitoring System has also been implemented for monitoring government litigations including litigation of these kinds. 48 Government Departments along with 79 Boards and Corporations have been successfully onboarded on to the CCMS.
5.
Insofar as the Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department is concerned, she submits that 44 admin logins and 183 user logins have been created. If the details of the other users at the Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Gram Panchayats are provided 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 44 HC-KAR
to the e-Governance Department, necessary logins would be created to onboard them. Hence, the Principal Secretary of Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department is directed to get prepared and furnish a list of all users who need to be onboarded on to the CCMS at the Zilla Panchayats, Taluk Panchayats and Gram Panchayats level to the Principal Secretary, e-Governance Department within a period of 15 days from today. 6.
Lastly, she submits that the Centre for eGovernance has set up a website for all State Government Departments where a facility has been provided to the Department Nodal Officer for uploading the Acts, Rules, Circulars, Notification, Government Orders, etc. User logins have been created. It would be for the Nodal Officer to upload all these on to the respective website of concerned departments. Her submission is that the website having been set up, the e-Governance Department does not take care of the uploading of the concerned Acts, Rules, Circulars, Notification, Government Orders, etc. It is for each department to do so. Hence, the concerned departments would have to upload it on their respective website.
7.
There being numerous departments who would have to upload the Act, Rules, Circulars, Notification, Government Orders, etc., the Chief Secretary, Government of Karnataka is directed to issue necessary instructions and or directions to all the departments to upload their respective Act, Rules, Circulars, Notification, Government Orders (i.e., all primary, sub-ordinate, delegate and executive legislation) on to their respective website. The same would also have to be directed to be uploaded on India Code maintained by the NIC, so that there is a single repository available for all concerned instead of going to different websites. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 45 HC-KAR
8.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner has filed a memo with certain documents. His submission is that all the requirements of development plan and building plans have been complied with by the Petitioner and as such the Occupancy Certificate ought to be issued in their favour. He submits that it is the Gram Panchayat who had issued the Occupancy Certificate earlier and believing the Gram Panchayat to be the concerned and authorised entity, the Petitioner had approached the Gram Panchayat, which was so done pursuant to the refusal of the Planning Authority to issue Occupancy Certificate.
9.
Learned counsel for impleading applicant has also filed certain documents enclosing certain photographs and submits that the works have not been carried out, many of the buildings are incomplete and the development works were not as per the development plan approved by the Planning Authority.
10.
On the earlier occasion, Learned AGA was called upon to make a submission as to which authority would now be the concerned authority to inspect, verify and certify the works carried out by the Petitioner as regard the development plan sanctioned by the Planning Authority.
11.
Today, she submits that the joint circular issued by the Principal Secretary of Urban Development Department, Principal Secretary, Rural Development Panchayat Raj Department dated 5-8-2024, though being prospective, taking into consideration the peculiar fact situation in the present matter, both the representative of the Gram Panchayat and the representative of the Planning Authority will cause a joint inspection of the subject project of the Petitioner, verify if all the works have been carried out in accordance with the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 46 HC-KAR
development plan and building plan sanctions and submit a joint report. 12.
The same is acceptable to the Petitioner and the impleading applicant, so long as they are part of the inspection and survey to be carried out. In that view of the matter, the representative of respondent No.2 -Panchayat and the representative of respondent No.5, shall carry out an inspection of the subject property on 21.4.2025, commencing from 10.30 am, to ascertain if the project has been completed in all respects as per the development plan and the building plan. Photographs of each of the villas, as also the clubhouse and any other common facilities as indicated in the development plan and the building plan sanction would have to be taken. The cost of the same is for now quantified at Rs.20,000, which would be required to be paid by the petitioner. If the inspection is not completed on 21.4.2025, the same would continue on the next day and thereafter till completion. The report to be filed by 9.5.2025. Relist on 4.6.2025.
46.
At this stage, learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the Petitioner, being under the belief that the Gram Panchayat had adopted the model Bye-laws, had made an application for issuance of an Occupancy Certificate to the Gram Panchayat, which had issued the Occupancy Certificate. This was done since the planning authority had refused to issue the Occupancy Certificate. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 47 HC-KAR
47.
It was then stated by the Learned AGA that a joint inspection of the subject project would be carried out to verify if the works had been carried out in accordance with the development plan and building plan sanction and a joint report would be submitted. A brief report was filed, along with memo dated 4.06.2025, which was recorded in the order sheet, dated 4.06.2025 as under: SGRJ: 4.06.2025 ORAL ORDER 1. Memo dated 04.06.2025 has been filed enclosing note bearing No.RDPR/10/GPA/2024 dated 03.06.2025. 2. Learned AGA submits that along with the said note, a list of Town Panchayaths and Grama Panchayaths which are yet to be onboarded is eventual. On instructions she submits that necessary correspondence with the e-Governance Department to onboard the Grama Panchayaths and Town Panchayaths has been taken up and the process would be completed given two weeks time. 3. Her submission is placed on record. 4. Memo dated 04.06.2025 has been filed enclosing a brief report as regards uploading of primary, sub-ordinate, delegated and executive legislation, the same reads as under: In its orders dated: 04.04.2025, in W.P. 3640/2023, the Hon'ble High Court has instructed the Chief Secretary, Government of Karnataka, as,Digitally Signed By: 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 48 HC-KAR
"6........ the centre for e-Governance has set up websites for all the State Government Departments for uploading Acts, Rules, Circulars, Notifications, Govt. Orders etc., User logins have been created. It would be for the Nodal officer to upload all these on to the respective websites of concerned departments. Hence, concerned departments would have to upload it on their respective website. There being numerous departments who would have to upload the Act, Rules, Circulars, Notification, Government Orders etc., the Chief Secretary, Government of Karnataka is directed to issue necessary instructions and or directions to all the departments to upload their respective Act, Rules, Circulars, Notifications, Government Orders (i.e. all primary, sub-ordinate, delegate and executive legislation) on their respective website. The same would also have to be directed to be uploaded on India Code maintained by the NIC, so that there is a single repository available for all concerned instead of going to different websites." In view of the above orders, it is submitted that with regard to uploading of Act, Rules, Circulars, Notifications, Government Orders (i.e. all primary, sub-ordinate, delegate and executive legislation) on their respective websites, the departments have already filed affidavits with respect to their updated websites, as per the orders of the Hon'ble High Court in the W.P. 22941/2023 and directions of the Chief Secretary. The updation of website is an ongoing process, as it has to be updated as and when any new Act, Rule, Circular etc., is notified. Hence, all the departments were instructed to maintain their websites up to date. As per Karnataka Government (Transaction of Business) Rules, 1977, the allocation of work of issuing statutory Rules, Notifications or Orders etc. is with the respective administrative department. The department of parliamentary affairs and 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 49 HC-KAR
Legislation is only having the duty of vetting and to give opinion and revise the drafts sent by the administrative departments. Therefore, as per the above referred Rules framing of the Rules, Regulations, By-laws or issuing Notifications in respect of State Laws or Central Laws is in the absolute domain of the respective administrative department and the department of parliamentary affairs and Legislation is not having any control in the process of framing or publishing of Rules, Regulations, By-laws, Notifications etc. Currently, the department of Parliamentary affairs and Legislation is updating all the Codified Acts in the department website and India Code portal, in both English and Kannada languages. But, with respect to the sub-ordinate legislation i.e. Rules, regulations, Circulars, notifications etc., Nodal officers of the respective departments, who are incharge of the departmental websites, have to upload the same on the India Code Portal, which is maintained by NIC. Hence, directions may be issued to the departments to upload all the sub-ordinate legislations to the India Code Portal and keep it updated whenever they update their respective websites.''
5. Learned AGA is directed to secure instructions and place on record the total number of primary, secondary delegated, subordinate at executive legislation department wise. The respective departments are directed to furnish the same to Secretary, Department of Parliamentary affairs within 15 days from today. The concerned nodal officer of each of the departments are directed to upload all the primary, sub-ordinate, delegated and executive legislation on India Code. The National Informatics Centre is directed to create necessary login for each of the Departments in the State of Karnataka to enable them to upload the above on to India Code. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 50 HC-KAR
6. Learned counsel for respondents 2 and 3 has filed inspection report along with photographs. Same is taken on record. Copy thereof is furnished to the learned counsel for petitioner and the impleading applicant who seek for and are granted a week's time to make their submissions. 7. Re-list on 10.06.2025 at 2.30 P.M.
48.
The inspection report was filed and taken on record. Along with the inspection report, assessment orders in respect of each of the villas were also produced. A perusal of the assessment report indicated that the photographs of each of the assessed villas had been uploaded in the software of the panchayat. However, the said photographs indicated that they are as available in the brochure issued by the Petitioner and not as per the actual site conditions. It is on that basis that the inquiry was made as regards the manner of uploading the photographs. As regards which, it was submitted that a draft user manual for online generation of Form-9 had been prepared and it is the procedure under the said draft user manual that is required to be followed. There being several inadequacies
in
uploading,
same
were
recorded in order dated 7.07.2025, which reads as under: 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 51 HC-KAR
ORDER 1. Learned counsel for respondents No.2 and 3 has filed memo enclosing the resolution uploading the issuance of Khata to the petitioner as also the Draft User Manual for online generation of the Form No.9 under letter dated 05.07.2025 addressed by the Panchayat Development Officer to learned counsel for respondents No.2 and 3 indicated the manner in which the Khata had been issued as regards the properties of the petitioner. 2. A perusal of the Draft User Manual indicates that the SDA (Second Division Assistant) has to identify the property that has been entered into the system in the existing register for further reference. The SDAA should scan and keep all the documents required in a folder which he would be asked to upload during the data entry, may be the sketch received from the Tahsildar, layout conversion copy, layout approval order, layout plan, release order of the sites, etc., 3. In the present case, his submission by reference to the letter dated 05.07.2022 is that then PDO Sri.C.Muniraju had on 18.11.2015 received the applications and data entry was made by him and sent to the Secretary Sri.S.Prasad for approval, which was so approved by the Secretary and thereafter placed before the Panchayat for approval which was so approved by way of the aforesaid resolution dated 18.11.2015. 4. A perusal of the said documents clearly indicates the manner in which action has been taken in as much as the application has been submitted on 18.11.2015, everything has been processed on the same date and the resolution has also been passed by the panchayat on 18.11.2015. 5. The perusal of the photographs which have been furnished on the last occasion would indicate that these photographs are of typical villas and not the actual photograph of each and every villa indicating the nature of construction and the state of construction. In fact, all the photographs are identical to each other depending on the type of 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 52 HC-KAR
villa and as seen there are six types of villas, which has also been confirmed by the counsel for the petitioner. 6. If that be so, it is clear that the PDO concerned namely Sri.C.Muniraju had never visited the property, never verified the status of construction and without doing so caused an entry into the software by uploading photographs which are not the actual photographs at site. 7. In that view of the matter, I am of the considered opinion that necessary action would have to be taken against the said PDO by the Principal Secretary, Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department under whose Administrative Supervision the PDO comes under. Hence, the Principal Secretary, Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department is directed to initiate such action as may be necessary in accordance with law. 8. If the Principal Secretary were to be of the opinion that issuance of Khata in respect of the present property has been improperly done and the procedure has not been followed properly, the Principal Secretary would be entitled to get the same redone by issuing proper direction as to the manner in which it is to be done, in accordance with appropriate law. 9. A details Standard Operating Procedure is directed to be circulated to all concerned in all Gram Panchayats to enable the said procedure to be followed, especially as regards on-site inspection and uploading on actual on-site photography. 10. For arguments on merits, re-list on 23.7.2025 at 2.30 p.m. 11. The synopsis of dates and events filed by learned counsel for impleading applicants is taken on record. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 53 HC-KAR
12. All the counsels are directed to exchange their respective synopsis of dates and events, list of authorities and authorities by next date of hearing.
49.
In the meanwhile, it was indicated that the property came within the jurisdiction of Greater Bengaluru Authority and the Greater Bengaluru Authority was brought on record as a party respondent. Learned counsel who appeared for the Greater Bangalore Authority submitted that this particular property comes under the jurisdiction of Samethanahalli Gram Panchayat, which is not within the jurisdiction of Greater Bangalore Authority. As such, it was the said Gram Panchayat that was the concerned authority. It is in that background that the above matter was taken up for arguments.
50.
In
view
of
Circulars,
Standard
Operating
Procedure and various communications issued by the State Government during the pendency of these proceedings, brought
considerable
about
with
clarity
regard
to
has
now
been
procedure
governing the issuance of Occupancy Certificates. What, however, remains to be considered is the legal position governing projects in respect of which the building plans had been sanctioned prior to the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 54 HC-KAR
issuance of the said Circulars, Standard Operating Procedure and other executive instructions. 51.
The questions that therefore arise for consideration are: (i) what is the legal regime applicable to such projects; (ii) which authority was competent in law to issue the Occupancy
Certificate
in
respect
of
such
developments; (iii) whether, in the facts of the present case, the Gram Panchayat was the competent authority to issue the Occupancy Certificate; (iv) if so, whether the Gram Panchayat complied with the applicable statutory provisions and followed the prescribed procedure before issuing the Occupancy Certificate; and (v) whether the subsequent cancellation of the Occupancy Certificate was in accordance with law. 52.
Sri. Suraj Sampath, learned counsel appearing for the impleading applicants 6 & 7, submits as under: 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 55 HC-KAR
52.1. There is no verification which has been made by the concerned authorities regarding the issuance of the Occupancy Certificates. The status of the villas would clearly establish that the said villas have not been occupied. The doors and windows of many of the villas have been removed. The finishing works have not been completed. No maintenance of the villas has been done by the developer. Though the petitioner had on 11.12.2023 indicated that the doors and windows would be put back and maintenance activities would be taken up given three months' time as recorded in the final order
on 11.12.2023, the said
doors and
windows are yet to be put back. The petitioner has subsequently sought an extension of time. Despite the period for which extension was sought for has elapsed, none of the above activities
have
been
performed
by
petitioner. He negates the submission of the counsel for the petitioner that it is due to the non-occupation of the villas that maintenance has not been done resulting in deterioration of the villas. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 56 HC-KAR
52.2. His submission is that the villas were never completed in the first place. Certificate issued by the architect is a false certificate, which is borne out by the inspection which has been carried out as per the directions of this Court. Though the petitioner claims that 31 villas have been sold and all are occupied, his submission is that only 7 villas, namely V07, V08, V09, V11, V38, V53 and V62 are occupied. 12 villas namely V3, 21, 22, 24, 26, 27, 30, 34, 39, 46, 55, 59 still do not have BESCOM connection and 4 villas namely V24, V46, V55, V59, as regard which, Occupancy Certificate had been received by the petitioner has been withdrawn. 52.3. His submission is that the first sale deed for any villa
in the
project
was executed by
petitioner on 19.09.2018 i.e. Villa No.38 and was handed over on 08.11.2018, which is more than 18 months after the recent of the alleged Occupancy
Certificates
were
obtained
on
05.05.2017 and more than 28 months after the promised delivery date of 26.02.2016. His submission
in
this
regard
is
that
if
Occupancy Certificate was a valid one, obtained on 05.05.2017 after the completion of the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 57 HC-KAR
construction, then the petitioner would have handed over possession on that date or year about, as also executed necessary sale deeds, the fact that no such sale deeds having been executed
negates
contention
of
petitioner that the villas were ready on which basis the Occupancy certificate was issued. 52.4. His submission in this regard is that the Occupancy Certificates issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017 were fraudulently obtained, so as to evade the registration required under Section
of
Real
Estate
(Regulation
and
Development) Act, 2016 (Hereinafter referred to
as
‘RERA’),
which
came
into
force on
01.05.2017. He relies on the letter of the petitioner
addressed
to
BESCOM
on
12.05.2017, which was sent after the receipt of the fraudulent certificates, stating that the works in respect of 41 villas were incomplete and requesting the respondent not to grant permission for connection of electricity to those villas, viz., on Exhibit-R39. The contents are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 58 HC-KAR
RPK/AFE/LTR-49/17-18 To The Assistant Executive Engineer (Ele), Hosakote Sub division, BESCOM, Bangalore. Dear Sir, Sub: Servicing of villas project for Raffles Residency Pvt Ltd, Sy.No. 250, 251, 252, 264/4, 264/5, 264/6, 264/7, 264/8 & 264/9, Soukya road, Samethanahally village, Anugondanahally Hobli, Hosakote taluk Reg: Partial villas servicing. Ref: 1) BESCOM work order no. 23 dated 14/06/2016 2) Deputy chief electrical inspector approval Of electrical installation letter no. ACEI/BN/DCEI/DCW/252-56/2017-18 dated 10/04/2017 We refer to the above service connections to 61 villas + common area with sanction load of 799.2KW. In this connection we request you to grant permission to install 20 nos villas Kwh meters with RR nos + common area load (67.2KW) instead of total 61 villas + common area. The delay in completing the remaining 41 villas is taking time, due to market bad conditions & the balance Kwh meters will be connected in due course. We request you to grant permissions for partial villas servicing. With regards, For RAFFLES RESIDENCY PVT. LTD.
52.5. On that basis he submits that the petitioner has misled
this
court
that
construction
is
completed and the withdrawal of the Occupancy 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 59 HC-KAR
Certificates by the authorities is not proper and on that basis obtained an order for restoration of the Occupancy Certificates on the condition that the entire finishing works will be completed in three months’ time and the due taxes will be paid within 90 days. 52.6. His submission is that none of the works were carried out by the petitioner. The petitioner has abandoned the project and left it incomplete years ago. Even the application for extension in IA-3/2024 filed on 5.03.2024 was not pressed by the petitioner. Even otherwise, he submits that the time period of extension sought for in
said
application
has
also
lapsed.
His
submission is that in terms of clause (2) of the operative portion of the final order dated 11.12.2023, the second and third respondents have not cancelled the Occupancy Certificates, even though the petitioner has not completed the project and the petitioner has sought an extension.
It
is
only
on
account
of
fraudulent Occupancy Certificates issued on 19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 being produced before the RERA on 20.12.2023 to evade the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 60 HC-KAR
liability of the petitioner that the proposed respondents came to know of the fraud played by the petitioner on this court, and it is in that background that the impugned applications were filed. 52.7. His submission is also that the third respondent never visited the property, never verified the status of construction and without doing so, entries were made in the software by uploading photographs from the brochure in pursuance of which e-Khata were issued on 18.11.2015, which indicates not only fraud on the part of the petitioner,
but
a
collusion
between
petitioner and respondent No.3. The claim that the villas had been completed is negated by the spot inspection report submitted on 20.08.2016 which discloses certain pending works, which would necessarily indicate that no Occupancy Certificates could have been issued to the petitioner for 23 villas. He submits that if the recent of the Occupancy Certificates had been issued on 05.05.2017, when the project was complete, there was no need for the petitioner to have obtained a loan of Rs. 100 crores from M/s. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd., as per the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 61 HC-KAR
sanction
letter
20.03.2018,
produced
at
Annexure-R3 to IA-2/2024. The contents of the sanction
letter
dated
20.03.2018
are
reproduced hereunder for easy reference:
Indiabulls HOUSING FINANCE Sanction Letter
Date: March 20, 2018 To Raffles Residency Private Limited No:54, The Planet', 11 Floor, Whitefield Main Road, Opp: HUL Research Centre, Bangalore-560 066 Dear Sir/Madam, Subject: Sanction of loan With reference to your application for the loan and the subsequent discussions, we are pleased to advise that we have sanctioned you a loan of Rs. 100,00,00,000/(Rupees One Hundred Crores only). The detailed terms and conditions of the sanction are as under: Borrower(s)
Raffles Residency Private Limited (RRPL)
Co-Borrower
NA
Personal Guarantee
Joint and Several Personal Guarantee of: a) Mr. Iqbal Jumabhoy b) Mr Hussain Somjee Counter Indemnity of: a) Mr. Asad Jumabhoy b) Mrs. Naseem Jumabhoy
Mortgagor(s)
RRPL and any other Landowners/Proposed 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 62 HC-KAR
security owners as per Title Search Report Amount Sanction
of
Tenor Rate Interest
of
Upto Rs 100,00,00,000 (Rs. One Hundred Crore Only) Not exceeding 60 months from the date of first of disbursement Variable and linked to IHFL ICLR as plus 500 bps (IHFL ICLR is currently 12% p.a. and the current applicable Interest Rate shall be 17.00% p.a.p.m.)
Interest rate reduction milestones; A)Reduction by 50 bps Upon sale of additional 25,000 34 ft (currently the area sold being approx. 2.10 lacs sq. 11 (31 villas) out of total salable area of 4.15 lacs sq. ft) and minimum collection milestone to be maintained at 20 er B)Reduction by additional 50 bps -Upon cumulative sale of 50,000 sq. ft. and minimum collection milestone in be maintained at Rs. 40 Cr C) Reduction by additional 100 bps upon cumulative sale of 1,50,000 sqft Processing Fees
Repayment Terms
Rs 500,000/- (Rupees Five Lacs only) plus applicable taxes payable upfront and nonrefundable
•
Interest on outstanding principal to be paid monthly throughout the loan tenor
•
Principal Moratorium of 12 months from the date of first disbursement
•
Principal Repayment to be done in 16 quarterly Installments as per the repayment schedule as below
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 63 HC-KAR
End of
Security
Quarter 1
Amount (Rs. In Crs) -
Quarter 2
-
Quarter 3
-
Quarter 4
-
Quarter 5
15 Cr
Quarter 6
15 Cr
Quarter 7
15 Cr
Quarter 8
15 Cr
Quarter 9
15 Cr
Quarter 10
15 Cr
Quarter 11
1 Cr
Quarter 12
1 Cr
Quarter 13
1 Cr
Quarter 14
1 Cr
Quarter 15
1 Cr
Quarter 16
1 Cr
Quarter 17
1 Cr
Quarter 18
1 Cr
Quarter 19
1 Cr
Quarter 20
1 Cr
Total
100 Cr
Registered Equitable Mortgage of Contiguous/Accessible Non-Agricultural land 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 64 HC-KAR
admeasuring 14 Acres 06 guntas along with any present and future construction thereon for the Project "Raffles Park of Villas with total saleable area of approx. 4.15 lakh sq ft and Club House and common area/ amenities, at Survey Nos 250, 251, 252 etc Soukya Road, Samthenahalli, Anugondanahalli (Hobli), Hoskote Taluk, Bangalore District. the satisfaction of the lender g) Sales/Leasing Step-in rights for the projects mortgaged to the Lender shall be assigned to the Lender h) Construction step-in rights for the projects mortgaged to the Lender shall be assigned to the Lender i) All the collections to be routed through the escrow account and the funds shall be first utilised towards due /overdue interest/principal/ pre-payment of facility or any other charges of the lender thereafter to be released for construction activities to the satisfaction of the lender. The same to be monitored on monthly basis. j) Any equity brought by the promoters in any form (Equity/Unsecured loans including SBLC from DBS) shall not be taken out of the company during the tenor of the facility k) The borrower should sell minimum 6 units (villas) in a block of 9 months each. The 1" block of 9 months to start from the date of 1" disbursement and next blocks thereafter. In case the same is not achieved it shall be treated as event of default and penal interest of 2% per month payable monthly shall be charged till the same is regularised Insurance l) Insurance of all Mortgaged mortgaged/charged in favour of, the Lender against loss Properties, or damage for risks 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 65 HC-KAR
and contingencies as the Lender deems fit, with an insurer acceptable to the Lender, for not less than the full replaceable value of the Mortgaged Properties (mortgaged/charged in favour of the Lender)/Contractors All risk policy/Project Insurance. m) Life/Critical Illness/Accident/Disability /policies (to be taken from insurer acceptable to the Insurance lender) for the Promoter(s) with cumulative sum assured equal to at least 2 years of interest payable on the outstanding principal of all the loans sanctioned by the Lender or its affiliates (including the interest payable on the sanctioned facility) All the insurance policies shall be assigned to the Lender within 15 days of the sanctioned facility Predisbursement Conditions
Letter from current lenders State Bank of India stating outstanding facility amount, additionally also committing to hand over original documents and charge of existing mortgaged property to the proposed new Lender (in the format of the lender) Submit Engineer's/ Architect's Certificate certifying that all requisite permissions/approvals from the competent authorities to successfully undertake the Project have been obtained including opinion on sufficiency of the same Hypothecation of receivables from soid and unsold area tooth present and future) from sale/lease/transfer of mortgaged properties and escrow of such receivables with POA in favor of the lender Hypothecation of receivables from service/sale/roceipt of any additional interior/ customised work done on behalf of the customer and escrow of such receivables with POA in favor of the lender Any other security as acceptable to the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 66 HC-KAR
Lender Pledge Share
Other Conditions
of
Pledge of shares of the following shareholders of the borrower (100%):
Name of the shareholder
% share
No. shares
Mr. Iqbal Jumabhoy
33.33%
130,089
Mrs. Nassem Somjee Jumabhoy
33.33%
130,089
Mr. Asad Jumabhoy
33.33%
130,089
Total
100%
390.267
of
a) The Borrower/Obligor undertake to obtain a written No Objection Certificate ("NOC") from the Lender prior to, inter alia, any agreement(s)/contract(s) for/of sale, transfer, allotment, lease and/or assignment of the Security (or any part thereof). Indicative minimum price per sq. feet for any sale for the Project "Raffles Residency" as mentioned above shall be Rs. 8,000/- per sq. ft. (of saleable area) b) The Borrower shall maintain a Debt Service Reserve (DSR) of Rs. 5 crores with Lender throughout the tenor of the loan by way of undisbursed amount from the total sanctioned amount. The amount in the DSR would be utilized only in case of a shortfall in cash flows for meeting debt service requirement from time to time. However, if any amount from the DSR is utilized to meet such a shortfall, then the DSR will be replenished by the Borrower to the extent of the utilized amount within 15 working days. c) First Disbursement shall be up to the takeover of all the facilities of the existing lender SBI 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 67 HC-KAR
d) Disbursement shall be construction linked and directly to the vendors or to the satisfaction of the lenders e) Undertaking that within 15 days from the date of 1st disbursement, or prior to such date(s) as specified/agreed by the Lender, the Obligor(s) shall create or shall cause to be created and perfected adequate security as required by the Lender f) Balance disbursement shall be done upon perfection of security, filing of form CHG 1 and other conditions to loan/facility offered by IHFL to the Borrower(s) and/or CoBorrower(s)/Guarantor(s)
e) the legal/technical report on the property or any other verification report on the borrower co-applicant/guarantor is not to the satisfaction of HFL in its sole & absolute discretion f) if IHFL in its sole & absolute discretion considers that the Loan should be revoked for whatever reason it may so deem fit and proper. 24. The loan and interest shall be paid as stated above. However, IHFL may in its sole discretion alter the rate of interest suitably and prospectively if unforeseen or extraordinary changes in the money market conditions take place. 25. IHFL is entitled to add to, delete or modify all or any of the aforesaid terms and conditions. 26. IHFL reserves the right, in its sole discretion and on such terms as to pre-payment charges, etc., as it may prescribe permit prepayment / acceleration in payment of installments at the request of the Borrower. 27. Further, kindly note that the Lender reserves its right to appropriate the amounts received from you towards payment/repayment of the amounts due under the Loan Documents in the following order of priority a. Firstly, towards costs and expenses, if any, incurred to be incurred by the Lender, 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 68 HC-KAR
a. Secondly, towards additional interest, default interest, interest and/or other amounts (other than outstanding Loan Amount) payable by you under the Loan Documents; and c. Thirdly, towards the outstanding Loan Amount payable by you under the Loan Documents. 28. This sanction letter is valid for 30 days for acceptance from the date of its issuance. Please sign the duplicate copy of this sanction letter as a token of your acceptance of the terms and conditions mentioned, duly signed by all the Borrower's and Co- Borrower /s. For M/s. Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited Sd/Authorized Signatory We accept the Sanction of Loan Facility of Rs. 100,00,00,000/(Rupees One Hundred Crores only) on the terms and conditions as prescribed above. Borrower For M/s. Raffles Residency Private Limited Sd/Authorized Signatory
52.8. By
referring
to
above
letter
of
M/s.
Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd., his submission is that the disbursal of the monies was linked to the construction, which would establish that even as on that date, that is 20.03.2018, large amount of construction was pending, requiring an investment of Rs. 100 crores. The petitioner had also written to the proposed respondent on 26.04.2018, indicating that the loan had been 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 69 HC-KAR
obtained and the works would be completed which has been produced at Annexure-R4 to IA2/2024. On that basis, he submits that even on 26.04.2018 the petitioner had communicated to the proposed respondents that the construction was not complete and would be taken up in terms of the loan sanctioned by M/s. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. His submission is that the nefarious activities of the petitioner did not cease and continued. The amounts advanced were misused by the petitioner. The petitioner defaulted in repayment of the loan amount, resulting
in
proceedings
under
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act,
2002
(‘SARFAESI’)
being
initiated
culminating in an e-auction sale notice dated 24.08.2023 in respect of 23 villas, including to be constructed villas in the project. The notice categorically indicated that the outstanding loan amount was Rs. 222,08,88,390/- and has been produced at Annexure-R5 to IA-2/2024. 52.9.
The e-Auction having been held, 23 villas were sold for around Rs. 3 crores per villa to another builder, whereas the petitioner sold the villas in 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 70 HC-KAR
the project to unsuspecting persons like the proposed respondents between Rs. 6.00 to Rs. 7.20 crore during the years 2014 to 2017. His submission is that the fact that the villas were sold for Rs. 3 crores in e-auction indicate that the construction was not completed, several works were remaining. He submits that the action
taken
by
respondent
No.2
and
respondent No.3 is in pursuance of the email issued
by
proposed
respondent
on
12.12.2022, bringing to their notice that the villas are not complete, which came to be challenged by the petitioner in the present petition. His submission is also that later on, the proposed respondents came to know that respondents No.2 and 3 did not have any power to
issue
Occupancy
19.09.2016, 10.04.2017
Certificates
14.12.2016, and
05.05.2017
dated
15.03.2017, and
very
Occupancy Certificates are non est and, when non est, could not have been restored at the request of the petitioner. The second and third respondents issued a notice dated 26.12.2022 to the petitioner and architect of the project. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 71 HC-KAR
The
contents
of
which
are
reproduced
hereunder for easy reference: SAMETHANAHALLI GRAMA PANCHAYAT OFFICE Samethyanahalli Village, Anugondanahalli Hobli, Hosakote taluk, Bengaluru Rural Dist SL.No. PDO/SGP/08/2072-23 Date: 26-12-2022
Notice Sub-Completion Certificates issued by you for villas at Raffles Park, situated at survey Nos. 250, 251, 252 & 264(P), Soukya Road, Samethanahalli Village, Hoskote Taluk, Bangalore Rural District. Upon conducting our site inspection on 22-12-2022 we have established that several villas are incomplete even today as follows and as per photographs attached: 1. No electricity connection service given for 41 villas. 2. No main doors and windows for several villas. 3. No plumbing works completed for several villas. 4. No electrical works completed for several villas, 5. No flooring completed for several villas. 6. Several other works Incomplete. Therefore these villas are not fit for Occupancy You are instructed to visit the site within 7 days of this Notice and report for a Joint Inspection with the undersigned. Falling which, you will be held responsible for the consequences of further action that we will take against you, Raffles Residency Pvt. Ltd., and the promoters of the project. You have issued Completion Certificates on several dates for several villas when they were still incomplete and not fit for 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 72 HC-KAR
Occupancy. You and the promoter of the project will be held liable for this Offence.
Sd/Samethanahalli Grama Panchayat, Hoskote Taluk
To Karan Grover & Associates Kirti Tower, Tilak Road, Vadodara 390 001
52.10. He submitted that for 41 villas, there were no main
doors,
windows,
plumbing
works,
electrical works, flooring, etc., which were completed,
rendering
said
villas
uninhabitable. This, he submits, is borne out by photographs taken during inspection ordered by this court. Though in terms of notice dated 26.12.2022, the petitioner and the architect were called upon to visit the project site within 7 days and report for joint inspection, the petitioner and the architect failed to comply with the notice and in that background, the Occupancy Certificates issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017 were withdrawn on 10.01.2023. 52.11. His
submission
approached
is
that
respondent
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
petitioner
No.4-
Town
- 73 HC-KAR
Planning Authority for sanction of a group housing development plan in terms of Sections 15 and 17 of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961, which was so approved by the planning authority, subsequently, the same came to be modified on 11.02.2015 in terms of which at Sl. No.3, there is an obligation for completion of the construction work and to obtain occupancy/completion certificate from the respondent No.4. Subsequently, a modified commencement
order/
sanction
for
development dated 2.03.2015 was issued by the Planning Authority in respect of the Club House, which also required to obtain completion certificate from the respondent No.4. 52.12. The respondent relies upon the decision of the Hon’ble
High
Court
of
Madras
in
P.
Anandasundaresan -v- Akshaya Pvt. Ltd.1 more particularly paragraphs 6 ,7(a), 7(b), 8 & 9, which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 6. Perusal of records would reveal that the learned Adjudicating officer, TNRERA, Chennai, vide order dated 30.03.2021 has directed the respondent/ Promoter to deposit a sum of Rs.7,90,000/- to the credit of Appeal
LAWS (MAD) 2025(1) 59 (DB) 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 74 HC-KAR
No.103 of 2021 on the file of Tamil Nadu Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, Chennai. When this matter was taken up for hearing, this Court had granted an interim order of Status Quo, dated 15.06.2022, in C.M.P.No.9256 of 2022 with an observation that the respondent/ Promoter shall not withdraw the aforesaid amount which was earlier deposited to the credit of Appeal No.103 of 2021 on the file of Tamil Nadu Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, Chennai till the disposal of this Appeal and framed the following substantial questions of law. (i) Whether a letter issued by President of Panchayat will be equivalent to a Completion Certificate as contemplated under Sec.2(h)(ii) of TN RERA Act? (ii) Whether a certificate issued by an incompetent person other than CMDA will amount to a completion certificate as defined under Sec.2(h)(ii) of TNRERA Act? (iii) Whether the Tribunal is correct in holding that the TNRERA Act is not applicable to the appellant's case, when the building and the amenities of the gated community were not completed by the builder, even after TNRERA Act came into force and therefore the Act was applicable? (iv) Whether the statutory mandate of getting completion certificate be waived by the issuance of a mere letter by Panchayat, especially when the actual project completion was delayed by more than 4 years after 2014 and the entire gated community with amenities were not handed over by the Builder until 2018 as per the project plan? (v) Whether the Appellate Tribunal, in the absence of material evidence hold that an ongoing project as completed and thereby take way a builder from the purview of the RERA Act, which is applicable to ongoing projects on the date of the introduction of the Act and also deprive the compensation to an affected buyer for the delayed handover? 7(a) First and foremost, it can be inferred that the completion certificate obtained by the respondent/ Promoter from Thaiyur Panchayat on 26.02.2014 cannot be considered as a valid completion certificate, since at that point of time, the construction of the subject building was not completed and the respondent/ Promoter himself has requested the buyers through an email, dated 26.10.2015 stating that they would regret 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 75 HC-KAR
for the inconvenience caused to the buyers with regard to the delay incurred in completing the Project and has rescheduled the dates of completion and also vide the same email, has revised the compensation amount for 1 BHK, 2BHK & 3BHK as Rs.5,000/-, Rs.7,500/- & Rs/10,000/- per month post the revised timeline. 7(b) Obviously, this would suffice answering the issues in favour of the appellant, since the handing over of the building was made only on 24.02.2018 and handing over of the amenities mentioned by the respondent/Promoter was made only on 26.01.2021 with a long delay of nearly 4 years and 7 years respectively from 30.04.2014, which is the actual date of handing over as stated by the respondent/ Promoter. 8. Question no.(iv): When Section 2(h) (ii) of the TN RERA Act is read in consonance with Section 11 (4)(b) of the RERA Act, which states that it is the duty of the promoter to obtain the completion certificate or the Occupancy Certificate, or both, as applicable, from the relevant competent authority as per local laws or other laws for the time being in force and to make it available to the allottees individually or to the association of allottees, as the case may be. In the present case on hand, as obtaining completion certificate is not a discretionary but a mandatory one as per the provisions mandated under the TNRERA Act, the same cannot be waived by any other similar letter issued by the Panchayat under the guise of alleged completion. Hence, Question (iv) is answered in favour of the appellant. 9. Question no.(v): From the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing on either side as well as the perusal of the material evidences submitted before this Court, this Court is of the considered opinion that the project 'January' of the respondent/ promoter is an ongoing project and it definitely falls under the provisions of the TN RERA Act. Therefore, the respondent/ Promoter cannot evade from paying compensation to the appellant for delayed handover as ordered by the learned Adjudicating Officer,TNRERA, Chennai vide order dated 30.03.2020 passed in CCP No.30 of 2020. Accordingly, the Question no.(v) is also answered in favour of the appellant. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 76 HC-KAR
52.13. By relying
on
P. Anandasundaresan, he
submitted
that
certificate
or
mere
issuance
communication
by
a
of
a
Gram
Panchayat cannot, by itself, establish that a project stood completed in accordance with law. It is contended that the nomenclature of the document is not determinative; what is relevant is whether the certificate has been issued by the competent authority after due verification of
completion
conformity
with
of
project
statutory
and
in
requirements
governing the grant of an Occupancy Certificate or Completion Certificate. 52.14. It is further submitted that the High Court of Madras, while interpreting the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, held that a completion or Occupancy Certificate cannot be treated as conclusive merely because such a document has been issued, if the factual position demonstrates that
construction
remained
incomplete,
possession had not been handed over, or the promised amenities had not been provided. The Court emphasised that the requirement of obtaining a valid completion or Occupancy 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 77 HC-KAR
Certificate from the competent authority is mandatory and cannot be diluted or substituted by
any
other
communication
or
certificate
issued without complying with the statutory requirements. 52.15. Learned counsel submits that the ratio of the said decision squarely applies to the facts of the present
case.
According
notwithstanding
issued
19.09.2016,
on
to
Occupancy
15.03.2017, 10.04.2017 and
him,
Certificates 14.12.2016,
05.05.2017, the
material placed on record would indicate that the project was not complete in all respects, several villas were not fit for occupation, basic amenities
had
not
been
provided
and
possession had not been delivered to the purchasers.
These
circumstances,
it
is
contended, clearly demonstrate that the project continued
to
remain
an
ongoing
project
notwithstanding the issuance of the Occupancy Certificate. 52.16. It is therefore submitted that the petitioner cannot
rely
solely
upon
Occupancy
Certificate to contend that the project stood 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 78 HC-KAR
completed or that it falls outside the ambit of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. According to the respondents, the actual state of completion of the project, the availability of the requisite infrastructure and amenities, and compliance with the applicable statutory requirements are the determinative factors, and not the mere existence of an Occupancy Certificate. On this basis, it is contended that the impugned action cannot be faulted. 52.17. The respondent relies upon the decision of Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in Paramount Prop. Build. Pvt. Ltd-v-State of U.P. and Ors.2, more particularly paragraphs 6, 8, 18, 19 & 20 which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 6. Briefly stated facts of the present case are that the petitioner is promoter of 'Paramount Golf Foreste' project for construction of apartments. The respondent nos. 4 to 50 booked the apartments with the petitioner. The petitioner issued allotment letters dated 10.08.2011 to them. However, the petitioner could not complete the project within the given time and could not handover possession of the apartments to the allottees. Consequently, the respondent allottees filed complaint before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Gautam Budh Nagar alleging that the completion of project is delayed by more than four years and they
Writ Civil No.12574/2020 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 79 HC-KAR
claimed interest and possession of the apartments. Before the authority, the petitioner raised objection as to the jurisdiction on the ground that the project in question does not fall within the definition of 'ongoing project' as defined in Rule 2 (h) of the Uttar Pradesh Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2016 (in short 'the Rules, 2016). The authority considered the evidence on record and also the facts noticed in the inspection made by the technical team on 24.07.2019 and recorded a finding of fact that the project is still incomplete and some No Objection Certificates (for short 'NOC') including NOC of fire fighting etc. relating to some technical work had not been obtained. The authority recorded findings of fact and passed the impugned orders dated 18.10.2019. 8. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the project of the petitioner is not 'ongoing project' inasmuch as the petitioner had applied for completion certificate with the Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation on 13.10.2016 and therefore in terms of the provisions of Rule 2 (h) of the Rules, 2016, the project in question is not 'ongoing project' and consequently, the project was not required to be registered under Section 3 (1) of the Act, 2016, and the RERA Authority did not have the jurisdiction to look into the complaint made by the allottees. 18. It therefore follows that in the case of a project where all development works have not been completed, the mere filing of an application with the competent authority for issuance of completion certificate would not bring it out from the purview of an 'ongoing project', as defined under Rule 2 (h) of the Rules, 2016. Such projects would accordingly be held to be 'ongoing projects' and in terms of the proviso to Section 3 (1) of the Act, 2016, the promoter would be liable to make an application to the authority for registration of the said project within the stipulated time period. 19. In the instant case, the findings recorded by the RERA Authority which are based on a consideration of the material evidence on record are to the effect that the development works in respect of the project were not completed. Accordingly, the project cannot be said to be excluded under Rule 2 (h). The project has therefore rightly been held to be an 'ongoing project' within the meaning of Rule 2 (h) and it would require 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 80 HC-KAR
registration under the proviso to Section 3 (1) of the Act, 2016. Accordingly the matters pertaining thereto would fall within the jurisdiction of the RERA Authority. 20. The impugned orders passed by the RERA Authority, therefore, cannot be held to be without jurisdiction.
52.18. By relying on Paramount Prop. Build. Pvt. Ltd-v-State of U.P. and Ors. he submits that the decisive factor in determining whether a project is an "ongoing project" under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 is not the mere filing of an application for issuance
of
a
Completion
Certificate
or
Occupancy Certificate, nor the existence of such a certificate in isolation, but the actual factual completion of the development in accordance with the sanctioned plan and the applicable statutory requirements. 52.19. It is submitted that the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court has categorically held that where the development
works
remain
mandatory
approvals
and
incomplete, No
Objection
Certificates have not been obtained, or the project is otherwise not complete in all material respects, the project would continue to remain 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 81 HC-KAR
an
"ongoing
project"
notwithstanding
any
application made for grant of a Completion Certificate.
In
such
circumstances,
promoter continues to be under an obligation to register the project under the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, and the jurisdiction of the Real Estate Regulatory Authority to entertain complaints relating to such project remains unaffected. 52.20. Learned counsel submits that the principle emerging from the said judgment is that the question whether a project is complete is essentially one of fact, to be determined on the basis of the actual status of the project and not merely on the basis of documents relied upon by
promoter.
Where
competent
authority, upon consideration of the material on record, arrives at a finding that the project remains incomplete, such finding cannot be displaced merely because the promoter relies upon an application or a certificate said to have been issued. 52.21. Applying the aforesaid principle to the present case, it is submitted that the respondents have 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 82 HC-KAR
consistently contended that the project was not complete in all respects, several villas were not fit
for
occupation,
and
necessary
infrastructure and amenities had not been completed. According to the respondents, the mere issuance of an Occupancy Certificate by the Gram Panchayat would not, by itself, take the project outside the ambit of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, if, in fact,
project
continued
to
remain
incomplete. It is therefore submitted that the question whether the project constitutes an "ongoing project" is one which falls squarely within
jurisdiction
of
Real
Estate
Regulatory Authority to examine on the basis of the evidence placed before it, and the petitioner cannot
rely
solely
upon
Occupancy
Certificate to contend otherwise. 52.22. The respondent relies upon the decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Madras in M/s Sare Shelters Project Pvt. Ltd-v-Sare Squires3 more particularly paragraphs 24, 27, 28, 32, 33,
34,
&
which
hereunder for easy reference:
CMSA No.27/2020 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
are
reproduced
- 83 HC-KAR
24. The question arise, whether the completion certificate contemplated under Section 3(2)(b) of the RERA Act can be construed as a valid completion certificate within the meaning of the provisions of the RERA Act. Undoubtedly, Executive Officer/Thiruporur Town Panchayat in the present case issued a completion certificate within the meaning of Town and Country Planning Act. Thus, such a completion certificate issued without fulfilling the requirements and conditions stipulated in the Town and Country Planning Act cannot be considered as a valid completion certificate for the purpose of grant of exclusion for registration under Section 3(ii) of the RERA Act. The question arise, whether the completion certificate issued in the year 2014 admittedly can be a completion certificate for the purpose of granting exclusion. 27. Let us now consider the orders passed by the competent authority under the RERA Act. The Regulatory Authority has simply relied upon Section 3(2)(b) of the RERA Act and held that the building completion certificate was already issued by the Executive Officer, Thiruporur Town Panchayat. Therefore, the registration is not required under the provisions of the Act. Thus, the application submitted by the apartment owner's Association is not maintainable. The Regulatory Authority has not considered the scope of the Act. The constructive interpretation of the Act has not been dealt with by the Regulatory Authority. The purpose and object of the Act, which is a welfare legislation has not been discussed at all. The very idea of the legislation to protect the interest of the purchasers by flats and villas etc., has not gone into by the Regulatory Authority. 28. As far as the welfare legislations are concerned, the Courts are bound to adopt pragmatic approach and ensure that the purpose and object of the Act is dealt with in its real spirit so as to extend the fruits and benefits of the legislation in favour of the public in general and in consonance with the constitutional requirements. The very legislation is to be read in consonance with the constitutional philosophy and ethos. It is not as if the language employed alone would be sufficient to decide the issues. The language is meant to reflect the purpose and object and it is not as if the word should be defined with a dictionary meaning. The words “employed” in such welfare 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 84 HC-KAR
legislations are required to be interpreted by adopting the principles of “progressive interpretation”, which is mandatory. In view of the fact that our great nation is able to sustain the Constitution for more than 70 years, only in view of such progressive interpretations. Even pre-independence legislations are in-force even now in our great nation, because the Constitutional Courts are adopting progressive and constructive interpretations despite the change of circumstances and the social changes and developments in the Society. Inspite of fast developmental activities, such pre-independence statutes are able to sustain because of such progressive interpretations. Therefore, a blanket reading of the words “employed” in the legislation would not serve its statement of purpose and object and the heart and the soul of the statutes are to be culled out for the purpose of implementation of such legislations. 32. The Appellate Tribunal further considered that many owners have taken their respective apartments and few more flats are vacant and with the possession of appellants/builders. This apart, appellant/builder is continuing their construction work in the project for the purpose of construction of villas. The appellants/builders are utilizing the amenities already provided in the project for the purpose of their construction activities and the disputed approach road is also being used, which is insufficient to meet out the number of villas, flats constructed in the project. The project is being developed in 112 acres as per the Project plan of the appellant/promoter. Thus, their presence is very much available in the project even as of now. Therefore, the project cannot be said to be a completed project. It is an on-going project. The project completion means that it must be completed in all respects and the entire project was handed. Therefore, the builder cannot enter thereafter into the project premises as they lost their legal rights except with the permission of the owners or with reference to the agreement, if any, between the parties. Thus, the completion indicates in all respects, and in entirety and, the various definitions provided under the RERA Act also indicates that the duties and responsibilities of the builders to ensure that all the common amenities and facilities are provided in accordance with the agreement and the laws in-force. Thus, the word “completion” cannot be read in isolation and it must be in connection with the definitions enumerated in various provisions under the RERA Act. Thus, the completion certificate 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 85 HC-KAR
issued by the Executive Officer, Thiruporur Town Panchayat cannot be construed as a valid completion certificate for granting exclusion under the provisions of the RERA Act. This apart, there is no evidence to establish that such a completion certificate was issued by the Executive Officer, Town Panchayat only after conducting full-fledged inspection in the project. Every public authority is expected to issue completion certificate only after conducting an inspection with reference to the provision of the Statues. Any certificate issued by the public authority, which is not in consonance with the provisions of the statute is to be construed as invalid or improper certificate. The invalid certificate indicates that the certificate was not in consonance with the provisions of law. The improper certificate indicates that the certificate issued was without conducting proper inspection. Thus, an improper certificate or an invalid certificate, both cannot be accepted for the purpose of justifying the completion certificate issued by the competent authority. In the present case, though the completion certificate was issued by the competent authority under the provision of the Town and Country Planning Act or under the regulations, certainly such certificate is an improper one, which is to be construed as irregular as no full-fledged inspection or enquiry was conducted nor the completion certificate issued contains any of the particulars. Thus, such certificate would not confer any right on the parties to claim exoneration from the provision of the RERA Act, more specifically, under Section 3(2)(b) of the Act. 33. The Act being comprehensive, remedial mechanism are provided in the Act. Undoubtedly, the provisions of the Act excludes the completed project. The question arises, what is the completed project. Completed project in common parlance is that a project, which is completed in its entirety in all respects and by complying with the specifications, norms prescribed in the building plan approval and by providing all amenities, facilities as agreed between the parties. The completion indicates that the builders/developer constructed the project as a whole and handed over the entire project as well as maintenance to the owners association as far as the apartments are concerned, including the title documents. Thus, it is made clear that a project, which is completed means or within the provisions of the RERA Act is that a project, which was completed in all respects by complying with the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 86 HC-KAR
covenants, terms and conditions in the agreement between the parties including handing over of all original title documents and all other documents etc. Thereafter, the rights of the builder to enter into the premises are restricted in accordance with the agreements, if any, between the parties. Thus, mere completion of structural building is insufficient to arrive a conclusion that it is a 'completion' within the meaning of the provisions of the RERA Act or under the Town and Country Planning Act. In such circumstances, a builder/developer may make an attempt to exploit or cheat the bona fide purchasers, who are all innocent purchasers. This exactly the legislators thought fit to enact the RERA Act. Large number of exploitations and cheatings are noticed in our great nations in real estate activities. Many crimes are registered in the subject of Real Estate business. Taking note of the prevailing situation in the real estate, the parliament thought fit and enacted the law in order to regulate the activities of the builders/developer. Therefore, in all respects, the Act should be applied in its real spirit so as to protect the rights of the innocent bona fide purchasers from the developer/builders. This apart, the developer of the ongoing project cannot be allowed to escape from the clutches of the Act. It is not as if the Act grants exclusion for an on-going project or incompleted project. Therefore, the completion must be with reference to the provisions of the Act and not based on the certificate of completion issued by the Executive Officer, Town Panchayat who issued such certificates mostly on extraneous considerations. Thus, this Court is of the considered opinion that the certificates are not issued after inspection but obtained. This Court is conscious regarding the prevailing situation in the real estate business. For each and every thing, corrupt activities are dominating the field and the competent authorities are not initiating appropriate action to control the menace of corruption in the real estate activities. Thus, every protection ensured under the statute must be adequate and proper so as to protect the interest of public in general and more specifically, the bona fide purchasers of the apartments or villas from the developers/promoters. Court cannot close its eyes with reference to the corrupt activities in public offices. Thus, any certificate issued by such Executive Officer, Town Panchayat cannot be taken as a conclusive factor. If a literal meaning is adopted with reference to Section 3(2)(b) of the RERA Act, then many number of builders/developers, who are all in the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 87 HC-KAR
process of construction will escape from the clutches of law and that is not the intention of the legislation and certainly, not the intention of the parliament. That is the reason why terms are carefully defined. What are all the amenities, facilities are also well defined. Even Section 3(2)(b) of the Act states that, where the promoter has received a completion certificate for real estate project prior to the commencement of the Act. Undoubtedly, in the present case, the certificate was obtained prior to the commencement of the Act. However, such certificate obtained is improper and illegal as the certificate was not issued within the parameters stipulated even under the Town and Country Planning Act and more specifically, by not conducting any proper inspection or enquiry with reference to the actual completion of the project as defined under the provisions of the statutes and in accordance with the plan approval. Thus, this Court has no hesitation in arriving a conclusion that the completion certificate issued by the Executive Officer, Town Panchayat cannot be trusted upon nor be accepted so as to arrive a conclusion that the said certificate was issued in compliance with the building plan approval or the Statute. Thus, with reference to the RERA Act, such completion certificate cannot be considered for grant of exclusion. Thus, the completion certificate is of no avail to the appellant and the reliance placed upon by the Regulatory Authority is improper and not in consonance with the statement of the objects and reasons as well as the provisions under the Act. 34. The State Government in this regard has to issue appropriate orders to the Head of the Department to initiate action against all erring officials, who are all issuing such certificate without even conducting any proper inspection under the provisions of the Town and Country Planning Act prior to the commencement of the Act and not in consonance with approved building plan as well as specifications. No doubt, in the present case, the completion certificate was issued prior to the commencement of the RERA Act. Thus, the Executive Officer had no occasion to conduct any inspection in accordance with RERA Act. However, the Executive Officer would have conducted inspection or enquiry with reference to the provision of the Town and Country Planning Act and more specifically, with reference to the building plan approval sanctioned by the Director of the Town and Country Planning . Thus, even 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 88 HC-KAR
considering the ground raised by the appellant that the completion certificate was issued prior to the commencement of the RERA Act, this Court is of the considered opinion that the certificate was not issued in accordance with the provisions of the Town and Country Planning Act as well as the building plan approval sanctioned by the Director of Town and Country Planning. It is relevant to note that even in common parlance, the word “completion” defines the “substantial completion” in accordance with contract. Thus, even in the absence of any statute, specifically, a completion certificate is to be issued by any Competent Authority, once if the project is completed. Substantial completion indicates providing of approach road, water facilities, including drainage etc. These are all the basic amenities to be provided, if at all the builder/promoter claims that the building is completed. If water facilitates and drainage facilities, approach roads are not provided adequately and the project is completed, then it will undoubtedly against the provisions of the Statutes. Therefore, the completion must be in all respects and in accordance with the contract between the parties. The covenants in the contract are the essential parameters, which must be the deciding factor regarding the actual completion and not mere completion of structure in the project. This being the object to be sought for, even in the absence of the RERA Act, the completion certificate issued by the Executive Officer, Town Panchayat is improper and not in consonance with the established principle for issuing a completion certificate even in a common parlance and under the Town and Country Planning Act. 35. The only question of law raised in the present second appeal is that whether the complaint/application filed by the respondent before the Regulatory Authority is maintainable or not. In view of the fact that the completion certificate issued by the Executive Officer, Town Panchayat is not in consonance either with the provisions of the Town and Country Planning Act as well as the building plan approval sanctioned by the Director of Town and Country Planning or in accordance with the provision of the RERA Act, the same cannot be construed as a valid certificate for the purpose of grant of exclusion under Section 3(2)(b) of the RERA Act. The certificate is to be construed as insignificant and irrelevant as far as the RERA Act is concerned and for all purposes, the building is to be treated as on-going project. Therefore, the appellants/builders are bound to 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 89 HC-KAR
comply with the terms and conditions in the project as well as comply with the provisions of various laws governing real estate affairs. Accordingly, this Court has no hesitation in arriving a conclusion that the application/complaint filed by respondents/apartment owners association is maintainable under the provisions of the RERA Act, 2016 and accordingly, the order passed by the Appellate Tribunal stands confirmed and consequently, Civil Miscellaneous Second Appeal stands dismissed. No costs. 36. The Regulatory Authority is directed to entertain application/complaint filed by respondents/apartment owners association and adjudicate the issues on merits and in accordance with law by affording opportunity to all the parties concerned and accordingly, pass speaking final orders within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
52.23. By relying on M/s Sare Shelters Project Pvt. Ltd’s case he submits that the expression "completion certificate" occurring in Section 3(2)(b) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 cannot be understood in a purely literal or mechanical manner. It is contended that the certificate relied upon by a promoter must be a valid certificate issued by the competent authority after satisfying itself that
project
has
accordance
with
applicable
statutory
been
completed
in
sanctioned
plan,
requirements
and
obligations undertaken by the promoter. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 90 HC-KAR
52.24. Learned counsel submits that the Hon’ble High Court of Madras
has held that
issuance
completion
of
a
the mere
certificate
or
Occupancy Certificate by a local authority would not, by itself, entitle a promoter to claim exclusion from the provisions of the RERA Act. If the certificate has been issued without a proper
inspection,
without
verification
of
compliance with the sanctioned plan, or without ensuring that the project has been completed in all material respects, such a certificate cannot be regarded as a valid completion certificate for the purposes of Section 3(2)(b) of the Act. 52.25. It is further submitted that the said judgment recognises that the question whether a project is complete is one of substance and not of form. A project cannot be regarded as complete merely because the structural work has been completed or because a certificate has been issued
by
a
local
authority.
Completion
necessarily postulates that the entire project has been completed in accordance with the sanctioned plans, that all common amenities and infrastructure have been provided, that the contractual
obligations
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
undertaken
by
- 91 HC-KAR
promoter have been fulfilled, and that the project has been rendered fit for occupation in all respects. 52.26. Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
Hon'ble Madras High Court has emphasised that the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 is a beneficial legislation enacted for the protection of homebuyers and, therefore, its provisions must receive a purposive and progressive
interpretation.
The
statutory
exclusion under Section 3(2)(b) cannot be interpreted in a manner that enables promoters of incomplete projects to evade the regulatory framework of the Act merely by relying upon certificates obtained without due compliance with the statutory requirements. 52.27. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, learned counsel submits that
Occupancy
19.09.2016,
Certificates 14.12.2016,
issued
on
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 relied upon by the petitioner cannot be treated as conclusive proof of completion of the project. According to him, the material placed on record discloses that no 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 92 HC-KAR
comprehensive inspection of the project was undertaken before issuance of the Occupancy Certificates, that several villas were incomplete, that all common amenities and infrastructure had not been provided, and that the project itself had not been completed in its entirety. In such circumstances, the respondents contend that
Occupancy
Certificate
cannot
be
treated as a valid certificate for claiming that the project stood completed or for excluding the project from the ambit of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. 52.28. It is therefore submitted that the issue whether the project is an "ongoing project" and whether the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 are attracted must necessarily be determined on the basis of the actual factual status of the project and not merely on the existence of an Occupancy Certificate.
Consequently,
proceedings
before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority are maintainable and are required to be adjudicated on their own merits in accordance with law. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 93 HC-KAR
52.29. The respondent relies upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court Badami (Deceased) by her LR-v-Bhali4 more particularly paragraphs 19, 20, 21, 22, 23 24 & 25 which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 19. Presently, we shall refer as to how this Court has dealt with concept of fraud. In S. B. Noronah v. Prem Kumari Khanna[12] while dealing with the concept of estoppel and fraud a two-Judge Bench has stated that it is an old maxim that estoppels are odious, although considerable inroad into this maxim has been made by modern law. Even so, “a judgment obtained by fraud or collusion, even, it seems a judgment of the House of Lords, may be treated as a nullity”. (See Halsbury’s Laws of England, Vol. 16 Fourth Edition para 1553). The point is that the sanction granted under Section 21, if it has been procured by fraud or collusion, cannot withstand invalidity because, otherwise, high public policy will be given as hostage to successful collusion. 20. In S. P. Chengalvaraya Naidu (dead) by L.Rs. v. Jagannath (dead) by L.Rs. and others[13] this court commenced the verdict with the following words:““Fraud-avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or temporal” observed Chief Justice Edward Coke of England about three centuries ago. It is the settled proposition of law that a judgment or decree obtained by playing fraud on the court is a nullity and non est in the eyes of law. Such a judgment/decree - by the first court or by the highest court - has to be treated as a nullity by every court, whether superior or inferior. It can be challenged in any court even in collateral proceedings.” 21. In the said case it was clearly stated that the courts of law are meant for imparting justice between the parties and one who comes to the court, must come with clean hands. A person whose case is based on falsehood has no right to approach the Court. A
(2012) 11 SCC 574 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 94 HC-KAR
litigant who approaches the court, is bound to produce all the documents executed by him which are relevant to the litigation. If a vital document is withheld in order to gain advantage on the other side he would be guilty of playing fraud on court as well as on the opposite party. 22. In Smt. Shrist Dhawan v. M/s. Shaw Brothers[14] it has been opined that fraud and collusion vitiate even the most solemn proceedings in any civilised system of jurisprudence. It has been defined as an act of trickery or deceit. The aforesaid principle has been reiterated in Roshan Deen v. Preeti Lal[15], Ram Preeti Yadav v. U. P. Board of High School and Intermediate Education and other[16] and Ram Chandra Singh v. Savitri Devi and others[17]. 23. In State of Andhra Pradesh and another v. T. Suryachandra Rao[18] after referring to the earlier decision this court observed as follows:“In Lazaurs Estate Ltd. v. Beasley[19] Lord Denning observed at pages 712 & 713, “No judgment of a Court, no order of a Minister can be allowed to stand if it has been obtained by fraud. Fraud unravels everything.” In the same judgment Lord Parker LJ observed that fraud vitiates all transactions known to the law of however high a degree of solemnity. ” 24. Yet in another decision Hamza Haji v. State of Kerala & Anr.[20] it has been held that no court will allow itself to be used as an instrument of fraud and no court, by way of rule of evidence and procedure, can allow its eyes to be closed to the fact it is being used as an instrument of fraud. The basic principle is that a party who secures the judgment by taking recourse to fraud should not be enabled to enjoy the fruits thereof. 25. It would not be an exaggeration but on the contrary an understatement if it is said that all facets of fraud get attracted to the case at hand. A rustic and illiterate woman is taken to court by a relation on the plea of creation of a lease deed and magically in a hurried manner the plaint is presented, written statement is drafted and filed, statement is recorded and a decree is passed within three days. On a perusal of the decree it is manifest that there is no reference of any kind of family arrangement and there is total non-application of mind. It only mentions there is 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 95 HC-KAR
consent in the written statement and hence, suit has to be decreed. Be it noted, it was a suit for permanent injunction. There was an allegation that the respondent was interfering with the possession of the plaintiff. What could have transpired that the defendant would go with the plaintiff and accede to all the reliefs. It not only gives rise to a doubt but on a first look one can feel that there is some kind of foul play. However, the learned trial Judge who decreed the first suit on 27.11.1973 did not look at these aspects. When the second suit was filed in 1984 for title and the third suit was filed for possession thereafter, the courts below had routinely followed the principles relating to consent decree and did not dwell deep to find out how the fraud was manifestly writ large. It was too obvious to ignore. The courts below have gone by the concept that there was no adequate material to establish that there was fraud, though it was telltale. That apart, the foundation was the family arrangement. We have already held that it was not bona fide, but, unfortunately the courts below as well as the High Court have held that it is a common phenomenon that the people in certain areas give their property to their close relations. We have already indicated that by giving the entire property and putting him in possession she would have been absolutely landless and would have been in penury. It is unimaginable that a person would divest herself of one’s own property in entirety in lieu of nothing. No iota of evidence has been brought on record that Bhali, the respondent herein, had given anything to Badami in the arrangement. It is easily perceivable that the rustic woman was also not old. Though the decree was passed in 1973 wherein it was alleged that the defendant was already in possession, she lived up to 1992 and expired after 19 years. It is a matter of record that the possession was not taken over and inference has been drawn that possibly there was an implied agreement that the decree would be given effect to after her death. All these reasonings are absolutely non-plausible and common sense does not even remotely give consent to them. It is fraudulent all the way. The whole thing was buttressed on the edifice of fraud and it needs no special emphasis to state that what is pyramided on fraud is bound to decay. In this regard we may profitably quote a statement by a great thinker: 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 96 HC-KAR
“Fraud generally lights a candle for justice to get a look at it; and rogue’s pen indites the warrant for his own arrest.”
52.30. By relying on Badami’s case, he submits that fraud vitiates every solemn act and every judicial
or
administrative
proceeding.
It
is
contended that it is a well-settled principle of law that an order or judgment obtained by practising fraud upon a Court or a statutory authority is a nullity in the eye of law and can neither
confer
any right
upon the person
obtaining it nor be permitted to stand merely because it has attained finality. 52.31. Learned
counsel
submits
that
Hon'ble
Supreme Court has repeatedly held that every litigant approaching a Court is under a solemn obligation to make a full, fair and truthful disclosure of all material facts. Suppression of material
facts,
concealment
of
relevant
documents, or obtaining an order by misleading the Court amounts to practising fraud upon the Court and disentitles such a litigant from claiming any equitable or discretionary relief. It is further submitted that no Court would permit its process to be used as an instrument to 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 97 HC-KAR
perpetuate fraud or to enable a party to enjoy the fruits of an order obtained by deception. 52.32. Applying the aforesaid principles to the present case,
learned
petitioner
counsel
deliberately
submits
that
suppressed
true
factual status of the project while approaching this Court. According to him, the petitioner projected the project as one that had been completed
and
in
respect
of
which
valid
Occupancy Certificates had been issued, while concealing
fact
that
incomplete,
several
villas
rendered
fit
for
amenities
had
project
was
not
been
had
occupation,
not
provided
been
requisite and
possession had not been handed over to the purchasers. It is submitted that these facts were material to the adjudication of the writ petition and ought to have been candidly disclosed. 52.33. It is further contended that the petitioner has not only obtained favourable orders from this Court
by
relying
upon
Occupancy
Certificates issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016, 15.03.2017, 10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 but is 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 98 HC-KAR
also seeking to utilise those orders before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority to contend that the project is not an "ongoing project" within
meaning
of
Real
Estate
(Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 and, consequently,
that
Authority
lacks
jurisdiction to entertain the complaints of the allottees. According to the respondents, this constitutes a continuing attempt to derive an advantage from an order allegedly obtained by suppression of material facts. 52.34. Learned counsel therefore submits that, if this Court
comes
to
conclusion
that
Occupancy Certificates issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017 were obtained or relied upon by suppressing material facts or that the earlier order of this Court was procured by misleading the Court regarding the true status of the project, the principles laid down in Badami would squarely apply. In such an event, this Court would not only be empowered but would be duty-bound to prevent abuse of its process by recalling or modifying its earlier order, since no litigant can be permitted to retain or enjoy 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 99 HC-KAR
the benefit of an order obtained by fraud or misrepresentation. 52.35. The respondent relies upon the decision in Meghmala and Others vs G. Narasimha Reddy and Others5 more particularly paras 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 & 28 which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 20. It is settled proposition of law that where an applicant gets an order/office by making misrepresentation or playing fraud upon the competent authority, such order cannot be sustained in the eye of the law. “Fraud avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or temporal.” (Vide S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath [(1994) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1994 SC 853] .) In Lazarus Estates Ltd. v. Beasley [(1956) 1 QB 702 : (1956) 2 WLR 502 : (1956) 1 All ER 341 (CA)] the Court observed without equivocation that : (QB p. 712) “No judgment of a court, no order of a Minister, can be allowed to stand if it has been obtained by fraud. Fraud unravels everything.” 21. In A.P. State Financial Corpn. v. GAR Re-Rolling Mills [(1994) 2 SCC 647 : AIR 1994 SC 2151] and State of Maharashtra v. Prabhu [(1994) 2 SCC 481 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 676 : (1994) 27 ATC 116] this Court observed that a writ court, while exercising its equitable jurisdiction, should not act as to prevent perpetration of a legal fraud as the courts are obliged to do justice by promotion of good faith. “Equity is always known to defend the law from crafty evasions and new subtleties invented to evade law.” 22. In Shrisht Dhawan v. Shaw Bros. [(1992) 1 SCC 534 : AIR 1992 SC 1555] it has been held as under : (SCC p. 553, para 20)
(2010) 8 SCC 383 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 100 HC-KAR
“20. Fraud and collusion vitiate even the most solemn proceedings in any civilised system of jurisprudence. It is a concept descriptive of human conduct.” 23. In United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Rajendra Singh [(2000) 3 SCC 581 : 2000 SCC (Cri) 726 : AIR 2000 SC 1165] this Court observed that “Fraud and justice never dwell together” (fraus et jus nunquam cohabitant) and it is a pristine maxim which has never lost its temper over all these centuries. 24. The ratio laid down by this Court in various cases is that dishonesty should not be permitted to bear the fruit and benefit to the persons who played fraud or made misrepresentation and in such circumstances the Court should not perpetuate the fraud. (See Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi [(1990) 3 SCC 655 : 1990 SCC (L&S) 520 : (1990) 14 ATC 766] , Union of India v. M. Bhaskaran [1995 Supp (4) SCC 100 : 1996 SCC (L&S) 162 : (1996) 32 ATC 94] , Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan v. Girdharilal Yadav [(2004) 6 SCC 325 : 2005 SCC (L&S) 785] , State of Maharashtra v. Ravi Prakash Babulalsing Parmar [(2007) 1 SCC 80 : (2007) 1 SCC (L&S) 5] , Himadri Chemicals Industries Ltd. v. Coal Tar Refining Co. [(2007) 8 SCC 110 : AIR 2007 SC 2798] and Mohd. Ibrahim v. State of Bihar [(2009) 8 SCC 751 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 929] .) 25. Fraud is an intrinsic, collateral act, and fraud of an egregious nature would vitiate the most solemn proceedings of courts of justice. Fraud is an act of deliberate deception with a design to secure something, which is otherwise not due. The expression “fraud” involves two elements, deceit and injury to the person deceived. It is a cheating intended to get an advantage. [Vide Vimla (Dr.) v. Delhi Admn. [AIR 1963 SC 1572 : (1963) 2 Cri LJ 434] , Indian Bank v. Satyam Fibres (India) (P) Ltd. [(1996) 5 SCC 550] , State of A.P. v. T. Suryachandra Rao [(2005) 6 SCC 149 : AIR 2005 SC 3110] , K.D. Sharma v. SAIL [(2008) 12 SCC 481] and Central Bank of India v. Madhulika Guruprasad Dahir [(2008) 13 SCC 170 : (2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 272] .] 26. An act of fraud on court is always viewed seriously. A collusion or conspiracy with a view to deprive the rights of the others in relation to a property would render the transaction void ab initio. Fraud and deception are synonymous. Although in a given case a 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 101 HC-KAR
deception may not amount to fraud, fraud is anathema to all equitable principles and any affair tainted with fraud cannot be perpetuated or saved by the application of any equitable doctrine including res judicata. Fraud is proved when it is shown that a false representation has been made (i) knowingly, or (ii) without belief in its truth, or (iii) recklessly, careless whether it be true or false. Suppression of a material document would also amount to a fraud on the court. (Vide S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu [(1994) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1994 SC 853] , Gowrishankar v. Joshi Amba Shankar Family Trust [(1996) 3 SCC 310 : AIR 1996 SC 2202] , Ram Chandra Singh v. Savitri Devi [(2003) 8 SCC 319] , Roshan Deen v. Preeti Lal [(2002) 1 SCC 100 : 2002 SCC (L&S) 97 : AIR 2002 SC 33] , Ram Preeti Yadav v. U.P. Board of High School & Intermediate Education [(2003) 8 SCC 311 : AIR 2003 SC 4268] and Ashok Leyland Ltd. v. State of T.N. [(2004) 3 SCC 1 : AIR 2004 SC 2836] ) 27. In Kinch v. Walcott [1929 AC 482 : 1929 All ER Rep 720 (PC)] it has been held that: “… mere constructive fraud is not, at all events after long delay, sufficient but such a judgment will not be set aside upon mere proof that the judgment was obtained by perjury”. Thus, detection/discovery of constructive fraud at a much belated stage may not be sufficient to set aside the judgment procured by perjury. 28. From the above, it is evident that even in judicial proceedings, once a fraud is proved, all advantages gained by playing fraud can be taken away. In such an eventuality the questions of non-executing of the statutory remedies or statutory bars like doctrine of res judicata are not attracted. Suppression of any material fact/document amounts to a fraud on the court. Every court has an inherent power to recall its own order obtained by fraud as the order so obtained is non est.
52.36. By relying on Meghmala’s case he submits that it is a settled principle of law that any order obtained by practising fraud or by making material misrepresentations before a Court or a 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 102 HC-KAR
statutory authority is a nullity and cannot be permitted to subsist. It is contended that fraud vitiates
every
judicial,
quasi-judicial
and
administrative act and that no litigant can be permitted to derive any advantage from an order obtained by deception, concealment or suppression of material facts. 52.37. Learned
counsel
submits
Supreme
Court
has
that
consistently
Hon'ble
held
that
suppression of material documents or material facts which have a bearing on the adjudication of the dispute amounts to fraud upon the Court. Such conduct disentitles a party from invoking the equitable and discretionary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is further submitted that where fraud is established, every Court possesses the inherent jurisdiction to recall or set aside its own order, notwithstanding the availability or exhaustion of any statutory remedy, since an order obtained by fraud is non est in the eye of law. 52.38. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, learned counsel submits that 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 103 HC-KAR
the petitioner obtained the earlier order of this Court by projecting that the project had been completed
in
all
respects
and
that
valid
Occupancy Certificates had been issued by the competent
authority
on
19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017, while allegedly suppressing the true factual position that the project remained incomplete, several villas were not fit for occupation, common amenities had not been provided and possession had not been delivered to the allottees. According to the respondents, these facts were material to the adjudication of the writ petition and their non-disclosure has resulted in the Court being misled. 52.39. It is further submitted that the petitioner is now seeking to rely upon the order passed by this Court
before
Real
Estate
Regulatory
Authority to contend that the project is not an "ongoing project" and that the Authority lacks jurisdiction
to
entertain
complaints
preferred by the allottees. According to the respondents,
permitting
petitioner
to
continue to rely upon the said order would amount to allowing the petitioner to reap the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 104 HC-KAR
benefit
of
an order
allegedly
obtained by
suppression of material facts. 52.40. Learned counsel therefore submits that if, upon appreciation of the material placed on record, this Court arrives at the conclusion that the earlier
order
concealment
was or
procured
deliberate
by
fraud,
suppression
of
material facts, this Court would be fully justified in exercising its inherent jurisdiction to recall the said order. It is submitted that no principle of finality, acquiescence or any other procedural doctrine can be invoked to perpetuate an order tainted by fraud, as fraud unravels every judicial
act
and
every
advantage
obtained
thereby must necessarily be taken away. 52.41. The respondent relies upon the decision of this Court in Raffles Residency Private Limited v ANS
Connectors
particularly
paras
Private
Limited6
to
which
more are
reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 12. A perusal of the legal notices which have been issued by the petitioners would indicate that the petitioner had called upon the respondents to come forward, make payment of the dues and execute a sale deed and construction agreement. The claim made by
CMP No. 504 of 2021 C/W CMP No. 494 of 2021 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 105 HC-KAR
the respondents before the RERA is also regarding execution of a sale deed, but of course the respondents have claimed certain other reliefs including compliance with the terms and conditions of the agreement of sale, as also claim for damages, compensation, etc., which is required to be adjudicated by the Authority. 13. Be that as it may, the claim of the petitioner in the legal notice being already pending before the RERA and RERA being a special authority created under the RERA Act of 2016, and a separate Adjudicatory mechanization having been provided under the said Act in terms of Section 89 thereof having over riding effect over any other law in force notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith, I am of the considered opinion that RERA Act of 2016 will have a effect irrespective of the contents of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. As such the proceedings now pending before the RERA Authority, it would be required for the said Authority to decide the disputes. 14. The submission of Sri.Christopher, learned counsel for the petitioner is that insofar as the disputes between the petitioner and respondents is concerned, the RERA would not have jurisdiction. If that be so, it is for the petitioner to make submissions regarding the same before the said Authority. In the event of the said Authority holding in favour of the petitioner, liberty would have to be reserved to the petitioner to revive the above petition.
52.42. By relying on Raffles Residency Private Limited’s case, he submits that where disputes fall
within
ambit
of
Real
Estate
(Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, the Real
Estate
specialised
Regulatory
statutory
Authority
forum
is
constituted
by
Parliament for adjudication of such disputes. It is contended that the RERA Act is a special enactment
providing
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
a
comprehensive
- 106 HC-KAR
regulatory and disputes
arising
adjudicatory mechanism for between
promoters
and
allottees, and by virtue of Section 89 of the Act, its provisions have overriding effect over any inconsistent law. 52.43. Learned counsel submits that the aforesaid decision recognises that once proceedings are pending before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority in respect of the subject matter, it is for the Authority to examine all questions arising under the Act, including issues relating to the maintainability of the proceedings and the extent of its own jurisdiction. If a promoter disputes the jurisdiction of the Authority on the ground that the project does not fall within the scope of the Act, such objection is required to be urged before the Authority itself, which is competent
to
adjudicate
same
in
accordance with law. 52.44. Applying the aforesaid principle to the facts of the present case, learned counsel submits that several complaints instituted by the allottees are admittedly pending before the Real Estate Regulatory
Authority.
One
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
of
principal
- 107 HC-KAR
issues
arising
for
consideration
therein
is
whether the project is an "ongoing project" attracting the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation
and
Development)
Act,
2016.
According to the respondents, that question falls squarely within the jurisdiction of the Authority and is required to be decided by it upon appreciation of the evidence placed before it. 52.45. It is therefore submitted that this Court ought not to render any finding which would either foreclose or prejudice the adjudication of the said
issue
by
Real
Estate
Regulatory
Authority. The petitioner is at liberty to urge before the Authority all such contentions as are available in law, including the contention that the project falls outside the purview of the Act by reason of the Occupancy Certificates having been issued prior to the commencement of the Act. Equally, it is open to the allottees to contend that the project continued to remain an "ongoing project" notwithstanding the issuance of the Occupancy Certificates. It is for the Real Estate Regulatory Authority to adjudicate those rival
contentions
on
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
their
own
merits
in
- 108 HC-KAR
accordance with the provisions of the Act and the evidence placed before it. 52.46. The respondent relies upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sakiri Vasu vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors7 more particularly paras 18, 19, 20, 21 & 22 which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 18. It is well settled that when a power is given to an authority to do something it includes such incidental or implied powers which would ensure the proper doing of that thing. In other words, when any power is expressly granted by the statute, there is impliedly included in the grant, even without special mention, every power and every control the denial of which would render the grant itself ineffective. Thus where an Act confers jurisdiction it impliedly also grants the power of doing all such acts or employ such means as are essentially necessary for its execution. 19. The reason for the rule (doctrine of implied power) is quite apparent. Many matters of minor details are omitted from legislation. As Crawford observes in his Statutory Construction (3rd Edn., p. 267): “… If these details could not be inserted by implication, the drafting of legislation would be an interminable process and the legislative intent would likely be defeated by a most insignificant omission.” 20. In ascertaining a necessary implication, the court simply determines the legislative will and makes it effective. 21. An express grant of statutory powers carries with it by necessary implication the authority to use all reasonable means to make such grant effective. Thus in ITO v. M.K. Mohammad Kunhi [AIR 1969 SC 430] this Court held that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
(2008) 2 SCC 409 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 109 HC-KAR
has implied powers to grant stay, although no such power has been expressly granted to it by the Income Tax Act. 22. Similar examples where this Court has affirmed the doctrine of implied powers are Union of India v. Paras Laminates (P) Ltd. [(1990) 4 SCC 453 : 1991 SCC (L&S) 208 : (1990) 14 ATC 798 : AIR 1991 SC 696] , RBI v. Peerless General Finance and Investment Co. Ltd. [(1996) 1 SCC 642 : AIR 1996 SC 646] (AIR at p. 656), CEO & Vice-Chairman, Gujarat Maritime Board v. Haji Daud Haji Harun Abu [(1996) 11 SCC 23] , J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. CCE [(1996) 6 SCC 92 : AIR 1996 SC 3527] , State of Karnataka v. Vishwabharathi House Building Coop. Society [(2003) 2 SCC 412] (SCC at p. 432), etc.
52.47. By relying on Sakiri Vasu’s case, he submits that
it
is
a
settled
principle
of
statutory
interpretation that where a statute confers a power
upon
an
authority
to
discharge
a
particular function, it also confers, by necessary implication, all such ancillary and incidental powers
as
are
reasonably
necessary
to
effectively discharge that function. Such implied powers are inherent in the statutory grant and need not be expressly provided for in the enactment. 52.48. Learned
counsel
submits
that
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
has
that
an
express
held
conferment of jurisdiction necessarily carries with it the authority to adopt all reasonable measures required to render the exercise of 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 110 HC-KAR
such jurisdiction effective. The absence of an express
provision
conferring
a
particular
ancillary power does not denude the statutory authority of the power to take such measures as are indispensable for the effective discharge of its statutory duties. 52.49. Applying the aforesaid principle to the present case, learned counsel submits that the Real Estate Regulatory Authority, being a specialised statutory authority constituted under the Real Estate
(Regulation
and
Development)
Act,
2016, is entrusted with the duty of determining, inter alia, whether a project falls within the ambit of the Act, whether it constitutes an "ongoing project", and whether the promoter has complied with the obligations cast upon him under the Act. According to the respondents, the conferment of such jurisdiction necessarily carries with it the incidental and implied power to examine the validity, legality and evidentiary value
of
documents
relied
upon
by
promoter, including an Occupancy Certificate or Completion
Certificate,
to
extent
such
examination is necessary for deciding the issues arising under the Act. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 111 HC-KAR
52.50. It is therefore submitted that the Real Estate Regulatory Authority is not precluded from examining whether the Occupancy Certificates relied upon by the petitioner was validly issued, whether it was issued after due inspection and compliance
with
applicable
statutory
requirements, and whether the mere issuance of such certificate is sufficient to take the project outside the purview of the Real Estate (Regulation
and
Development)
Act,
2016.
According to the respondents, such an enquiry is merely incidental to, and inseparable from,
Authority's
statutory
obligation
to
determine whether the project is an "ongoing project" and whether it is amenable to its jurisdiction. 52.51. On the aforesaid basis, learned counsel submits that the contention of the petitioner that the Real Estate Regulatory Authority is bound to accept the Occupancy Certificate at face value and is precluded from examining its validity or legal effect is untenable. Such a restricted interpretation would defeat the object of the Act and render the statutory powers conferred upon the Authority ineffective, contrary to the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 112 HC-KAR
doctrine of implied powers recognised by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sakiri Vasu case. 52.52. As regard to Model Bye-laws dated 08.05.2015, his submission is that those Model Bye-laws are required to be adopted by respondent No.2 in terms of sub-section (2) of section 316 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayath Raj Act, 1993. Said Section 316(2) is reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 316. Power of Government to make model regulations and bye-laws and adoption of such regulations and bye-laws by the Panchayats.… (2) A Grama Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat or Zilla Panchayat may by resolution adopt the model byelaws or regulations, as the case may be, made under sub-section (1), and such bye-laws and regulations shall come into force within the jurisdiction of the Grama Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat or Zilla Panchayat from such date as the Grama Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat or Zilla Panchayat, as the case may be, may specify in a notice published in the prescribed manner….
52.53. By relying on Section 316(2), his submission is that if there is no adoption made of the Model Bye-laws by respondents No.2 and 3, the Model Bye-laws would not apply to them, requiring the Planning Authority to issue the Occupancy 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 113 HC-KAR
Certificates that are required. It is only if the Model
Bye-laws
had
been
adopted
by
respondent No. 2 and 3, the question of Occupancy
Certificates
being
issued
by
respondents No.2 and 3 would arise. That means that the said Model Bye-laws would not apply to the present case. 52.54. He submits that even the Joint Circular issued by the Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department
and
Principal
Panchayathraj
and
Department
05.08.2024
on
Rural
Secretary, Development
would
not
be
applicable to the current project since that is prospective in nature. It is a law as on the date on which the Occupancy Certificate was sought for that would have been considered which in this case requires the petitioner to have applied to
planning
authority
irrespective
of
whether the planning authority has rejected the application,
petitioner
could
not
have
approached respondents No.2 and 3 for grant of Occupancy Certificate. If the actions of the planning authority were contrary to law, it was for the petitioner to have challenged it before the appropriate court, seeking for appropriate 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 114 HC-KAR
relief. Instead of doing so, the petitioner has sought
to
confer
power
and
authority
on
respondent No.2 and respondent No.3, which they never had. 52.55. He also makes certain submissions as regard the monies paid by the proposed respondent to the petitioner, the delay which is being caused, the compensation which is required to be paid by the petitioner to the proposed respondent, etc. All the same are not subject matter of the present writ petition and as such, are not adverted to. 52.56. Even
after
receipt
of
fraudulent
Occupancy Certificates, the petitioner has sent multiple emails to the proposed respondent on 11.08.2017, 03.03.2018,
23.10.2017, 26.06.2018,
08.02.2018,
04.07.2018
and
14.02.2019, whereunder the petitioner always indicated that the construction of the project was still ongoing and would be completed. This conduct on the part of the petitioner in the various emails sent would again establish that the construction was not completed and the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 115 HC-KAR
question of issuance of Occupancy Certificates would not arise. 52.57. Referring to the report as regard to joint inspection
conducted
on
26.02.2024,
he
submits that the said inspection was carried out on the basis of a direction issued by a coordinate
Bench
26591/2023,
of
this
which
court
in
indicates
W.P.
No.
that
construction was not completed. As regards the report
dated
13.11.2024,
issued
by
Assistant Executive Engineer, Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority, the project was incomplete as on 12.11.2024. The report dated 31.01.2025 submitted by the Executive Officer, Taluk Panchayat, Hoskote, indicates that the villas
were
incomplete.
The
report
dated
25.04.2025 jointly submitted by respondents No. 2 and 5 also indicates that the project has not been completed, report having been filed on 04.06.2025. 52.58. He relies on the decision on the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Debashis Sinha and others v M/s R.N.R. Enterprise8, more particularly
Civil Appeal No. 3343 of 2020 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 116 HC-KAR
para 11 and 12. which is reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 11. The conduct of the respondents, the NCDRC recorded in the impugned order, was far too casual and on the face of it, the respondents are guilty of “unfair trade practice” within the meaning of section 2(1)(r) of the C.P. Act. After so recording, the NCDRC held that this does little to rescue the complainants. The reason assigned therefor defies logic. We have failed to comprehend as to what the NCDRC meant when it observed that the appellants “ought to have known what they were purchasing”. More often than not, the jurisdiction of the consumer fora under the C.P. Act is invoked post- purchase. If complaints were to be spurned on the specious ground that the consumers knew what they were purchasing, the object and purpose of the enactment would be defeated. Any deficiency detected post-purchase opens up an avenue for the aggrieved consumer to seek relief before the consumer fora. The reasoning of the NCDRC is, thus, indefensible. Indeed, the appellants had purchased their respective flats on payment of consideration amounts as per market rate and there was due execution and registration of the deeds of conveyance preceded by agreements for sale and these instruments did indicate, inter alia, what formed part of the common facilities/amenities; however, the matter obviously could not have ended there. Whether the appellants had been provided what the respondents had promised did survive for consideration, which does not get reflected in the impugned order. 12. NCDRC, in our opinion, might have missed to appreciate the present day realities of life. Now-a-days, flat owners seldom purchase flats with liquid cash. Flats are purchased on the basis of finances being advanced by banks and other financial institutions. Once a flat is booked and the prospective flat owner enters into an agreement for loan, instalments fall due to be paid to clear the debt irrespective of whether the flat is ready for being delivered possession. The usual delays that are associated with construction activities result in undue anxiety, stress, and harassment for which many a prospective flat owner, it is common knowledge, even without the project/flat being wholly complete is left with no other option but to take possession. Whether, upon taking possession, a flat owner forfeits his/her right to claim such services which had been promised but are not provided resulting in deficiency in services is a question that the NCDRC ought to have adverted to. Once 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 117 HC-KAR
the NCDRC arrived at a finding that the respondents were casual in their approach and had even resorted to unfair trade practice, it was its obligation to consider the appellants’ grievance objectively and upon application of mind and thereafter give its reasoned decision. If at all, the appellants had not forfeited any right by registration of the sale deeds and if indeed the respondents were remiss in providing any of facilities/amenities as promised in brochure/advertisement, it was the duty of the NCDRC to set things right.
52.59. By relying on Debashis Sinha, his submission is that having no option but to take possession on account of the long lapse of time, they took possession of the villa and completed the balance work of the villa. However, the common areas
and
common
issues
are
still
not
learned
counsel
for
Panchayat
completed. 53.
Sri.M.S.Devaraj, submits that:
53.1. The Gram Panchayat acted entirely on the basis of the representations made by the petitioner. It
is
contended
that
petitioner
had
represented that all the 61 villas together with the clubhouse had been fully completed and were fit for occupation. In support thereof, the petitioner had produced a completion certificate issued by the project architects, namely, M/s. Karan Grover and Associates. Acting upon the 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 118 HC-KAR
said
representation
and
architect's
certification, the Gram Panchayat, in its General Body Meeting, resolved to permit the entry of
villas
in
e-Swathu
software
in
accordance with the sanctioned plan approved by the jurisdictional Planning Authority and further resolved to issue e-Swathu records in respect of the villas and the clubhouse as requested by the petitioner. 53.2. Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
respondent Nos.2 and 3 had thereafter caused a
physical
inspection
of
villas
to
be
conducted and, based on the material then available, Occupancy Certificates came to be issued. Subsequently, however, upon a further inspection
conducted
on
26.02.2024,
authorities found that the project had not, in fact, been completed
in all respects. The
inspection report dated 26.02.2024 has been placed on record. Placing reliance thereon, learned
counsel
submits
that
all
structures, namely 61 villas and the clubhouse, were not complete and several deficiencies continued to exist. According to him, the Occupancy
Certificates
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
came
to
be
issued
- 119 HC-KAR
primarily on the strength of the completion certificates furnished by the project architects, though, in reality, the construction had not attained completion in accordance with the sanctioned plan and the applicable statutory requirements. 53.3. It
is
further
submitted
that
Occupancy
Certificates in respect of 33 villas issued on 19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
10.04.2017,
05.05.2017
15.03.2017,
together
with
clubhouse were initially issued by following the procedure contemplated under the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control of Erection of Buildings) upon
Model
Bye-laws,
subsequently
2015. However,
noticing
that
construction had not been completed and that the villas were not fit for occupation, the Gram Panchayat
cancelled
Certificates. The
order
said
Occupancy
of cancellation
was
challenged by the petitioner in the writ petition, wherein this Court, by order dated 11.12.2023, allowed
restoration
of
writ
petition
and
Occupancy
directed
Certificates,
subject to the petitioner restoring 15 villas to a 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 120 HC-KAR
condition fit for occupation within three months, the remaining 18 villas within a further period of three months, and further directed payment of all outstanding property taxes within ninety days. Learned counsel submits that none of these directions have been complied with by the petitioner. 53.4. Learned counsel submits that the petitioner had,
as
early
as
16.08.2016,
represented
before the Gram Panchayat that 61 villas and one clubhouse had been completed and sought issuance of Occupancy Certificates. However,
subsequent
material
placed
on
record
completely belies the said representation. In particular, reference is made to the objections filed by the petitioner on 10.06.2025 to the inspection report, wherein the petitioner has admitted that only 20 villas have electricity connections and that the remaining villas do not have electricity supply. It is also admitted therein that 23 villas have been mortgaged to M/s. Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited and certain other villas have been mortgaged to Punjab National Bank. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 121 HC-KAR
53.5. Learned counsel further submits that, out of the 61 villas, property taxes have been paid only in respect of 25 villas, whereas taxes remain unpaid in respect of the remaining 36 villas. According to him, the existence of mortgages does not absolve the petitioner of its statutory obligation to pay property taxes. It is therefore contended that the petitioner has failed to comply with the conditions imposed by this Court
in
its
order
dated
11.12.2023.
Consequently, notices dated 08.08.2024 and 16.08.2024 were issued by the Gram Panchayat calling
upon
petitioner
to
pay
outstanding property taxes and produce all relevant documents justifying the issuance of the Occupancy Certificates, failing which the Occupancy Certificates would be cancelled. 53.6. Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
representatives of the Samethanahalli Gram Panchayat, along with officials of the Town and Country Planning Department and the Satellite Town Ring Road Regional Planning Authority (STRR Planning Authority), conducted a joint inspection of the project. During the course of the inspection, it was found that the petitioner 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 122 HC-KAR
had failed to restore the villas to a condition fit for
occupation,
furnished
before
despite this
Court.
undertaking It
is
further
submitted that the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner obstructed and interfered with the inspection proceedings conducted by the officials. 53.7. Referring to the inspection report, learned counsel
submits
that
several
deficiencies,
deviations and violations were noticed. It is contended that there are substantial deviations from
sanctioned
building
plan
in
common areas; electricity connections have not been provided to 41 villas; the internal roads and pathways have not been fully developed or maintained; the Sewage Treatment Plant has been constructed by encroaching upon the Government Rajakaluve and in deviation from the sanctioned plan; the clubhouse, though constructed, has not been properly maintained; and the diesel generator installed for the project has also not been maintained. 53.8. It is further submitted that only six villa owners are presently residing in the project and that 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 123 HC-KAR
they are themselves bearing the expenses towards security personnel and maintenance staff, which, according to the learned counsel, ought to have been borne by the petitioner. It is also submitted that two villas mortgaged to Punjab National Bank have become the subject matter of proceedings under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act, pursuant to which possession has been taken by the Bank. Insofar as the remaining
villas
Indiabulls
Housing
mortgaged Finance
to
M/s.
Limited
are
concerned, it is submitted that the petitioner has
defaulted
in
repayment
of
loan,
whereupon the secured assets have been taken over
by
Asset
Enterprise
Care
Limited
and
(ACRE).
Reconstruction It
is
further
submitted that ACRE has proceeded to alienate the said villas. 53.9. On the basis of the aforesaid facts, learned counsel
submits
that
petitioner
has
consistently misrepresented the factual status of the project before the Gram Panchayat and other authorities. It is therefore contended that the decision of the Gram Panchayat cancelling the Occupancy Certificates is fully justified, 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 124 HC-KAR
legal and in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions and
does
not
warrant
Learned
Counsel
interference by this Court. 54.
Sri.
Joshua
Hudson
Samuel,
appearing for the Petitioner, would submit that: 54.1. The impleading application as well as the application seeking recall of the order dated 11.12.2023 are wholly misconceived, devoid of merit and not maintainable either in law or on facts. According to him, the applicants neither have the requisite locus standi nor have they established any legal basis for seeking recall of a judicial order passed after hearing the parties to the writ petition. He therefore submits that both applications are liable to be dismissed. 54.2. Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
petitioner developed the project after obtaining all
requisite
statutory
approvals
and
permissions from the competent authorities. Upon
completion
of
construction,
project architects, namely M/s. Karan Grover and Associates, certified that the construction had been completed in accordance with the sanctioned
plans.
Armed
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
with
said
- 125 HC-KAR
completion certificates, the petitioner initially approached the Hoskote Planning Authority seeking issuance of Occupancy Certificates. It is submitted that the Planning Authority orally informed the petitioner that it was not the authority competent to issue an Occupancy Certificate
and
advised
petitioner
to
approach the jurisdictional Gram Panchayat. It was in those circumstances that the petitioner approached
respondent
Nos.2
and
for
issuance of the Occupancy Certificates. 54.3. Learned
counsel
submits
that,
upon
consideration of the petitioner's application, the Gram Panchayat issued Occupancy Certificates on
19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 in respect of 35 Villas
.
Subsequent
thereto,
Electrical
Inspectorate granted approval for installation and energisation of the electrical transformers, and the Karnataka State Pollution Control Board also inspected the Sewage Treatment Plant and granted
establishment
requisite and
consent
operation.
It
for is
its
further
submitted that, acting upon the Occupancy 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 126 HC-KAR
Certificates, nine purchasers are presently in possession and residing therein. 54.4. It is only thereafter, nearly six years after issuance of the Occupancy Certificates, that the Gram Panchayat issued a show cause notice dated 26.12.2022 proposing cancellation of 33 Occupancy Certificates. The said notice was challenged before this Court in the present writ petition, which came to be disposed of by order dated 11.12.2023. 54.5. Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
present impleading applicants claim rights only in respect of Villa Nos.8 and 53. Admittedly, neither of these villas forms part of the thirtythree villas covered by the impugned show cause notice or the consequential proceedings initiated by the Gram Panchayat. Consequently, the applicants have no direct or legal interest in the subject matter of the present writ petition and cannot be regarded either as necessary or proper parties to these proceedings. 54.6. It is further submitted that separate building licences
had
been
issued
by
Gram
Panchayat in respect of each of the 61 villas 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 127 HC-KAR
and
that
construction
was
completed
substantially in accordance with the sanctioned building plans. According to learned counsel, only certain minor interior and finishing works remained to be carried out, which would not detract from the fact that the
villas had
attained substantial completion. It is submitted that the completion certificate issued by the project architects was accepted by the Gram Panchayat after due consideration, whereupon the Occupancy Certificates were issued on 19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and
05.05.2017. Learned counsel
therefore contends that the validity of the Occupancy
Certificates
cannot
now
be
questioned after the lapse of several years. It is his
further
submission
that,
once
Occupancy Certificates had been issued prior to the commencement of section 3 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 on 01.05.2017, the project ceased to be an "ongoing
project"
and
consequently
falls
outside the purview of the provisions of the RERA Act. According to him, the Occupancy Certificates,
having
been
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
issued
by
- 128 HC-KAR
competent authority, carry a presumption of validity and are required to be accepted unless they are set aside in accordance with law. 54.7. With regard to the transactions entered into by M/s. Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited and Asset
Care
and
Reconstruction
Enterprise
Limited (ACRE), learned counsel submits that
petitioner
had
no
knowledge
of
alienations effected by the secured creditors. Upon
becoming
petitioner
has
aware already
of
initiated
same,
appropriate
proceedings before the National Company Law Tribunal,
Bengaluru,
where
presently
pending
consideration.
matter
is
Learned
counsel submits that, as on date, 20 villas have been
sold
Limited,
by
Indiabulls
villas
are
Housing
stated
to
be
Finance under
agreements of sale executed by Indiabulls, four villas have been sold directly by the petitioner, 3 villas continue to remain mortgaged with Punjab National Bank, and only 1 villa remains in the ownership of the petitioner. 54.8. Insofar
as
impugned
notices
villas are
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
covered
concerned,
by
learned
- 129 HC-KAR
counsel submits that the inspection relied upon by the respondents has not been conducted in compliance with the directions issued by this Court.
It
is
contended
that,
during
inspection, the petitioner specifically requested
inspection
team
to
photograph
electricity meter board chamber and the area behind it, which would have disclosed the underground
sewerage
lines,
water
pipelines,
electrical
cabling,
supply
generator
connections, earthing arrangements and other concealed infrastructure demonstrating that the villas were fully serviced. According to him, despite such deliberately portions.
request, the
inspection
team
to
photograph
those
petitioner
has
omitted The
therefore
independently placed the relevant photographs on record. 54.9. It is further submitted that the inspection report relied upon by the respondents is not an independent inspection undertaken pursuant to the directions of this Court, but is a report prepared in connection with another proceeding and has merely been pressed into service in the present
matter.
Learned
09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
counsel
therefore
- 130 HC-KAR
contends that no reliance can be placed upon the said report for the purpose of determining the validity of the Occupancy Certificates issued on
19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017. 54.10. Learned counsel lastly submits that respondent Nos.2 and 3 possess no statutory power to revoke or cancel an Occupancy Certificate once validly
issued,
except
in
exceptional
circumstances expressly recognised in law, such as where the certificate has been obtained by practising
fraud
or
where
its
issuance
is
demonstrably contrary to the provisions of the governing statute. According to him, no such circumstances exist in the present case. Hence, the impugned action cancelling the Occupancy Certificates is wholly without jurisdiction and liable to be set aside. 54.11. He
relies
particularly
on
Rule
model
Bye-laws,
thereof,
more
which
reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 12. Completion Certificate. Every person erecting, reerecting, making material alteration, demolition a building shall, within one month after completion of such building shall give written notice to the Authority through the qualified Architect/ qualified empanelled engineer / 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
is
- 131 HC-KAR
supervisors (Civil Diploma holder) regarding completion of work prescribed in the license in the prescribed form given in Schedule V.
54.12. By relying on Rule 12, he submits that Rule 12 itself prescribes the procedure to be followed upon completion of a building. According to him, once the construction is completed, the obligation cast upon the owner or developer is to intimate the competent authority regarding such completion through a qualified architect, empanelled
engineer
or
supervisor
in
prescribed form. The Rule does not contemplate any further technical certification by any other authority before the Gram Panchayat proceeds to consider the request for issuance of an Occupancy Certificate. 54.13. It is his submission that, in the present case, the petitioner had strictly complied with the requirements of Rule 12 by furnishing the completion certificate issued by the project architects,
namely
M/s.
Karan
Grover
and
Associates, certifying that the construction had been
completed
in
accordance
with
sanctioned plans. Upon receipt of the said completion certificate and after causing such 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 132 HC-KAR
verification as it considered appropriate, the Gram
Panchayat
consciously
issued
Occupancy Certificates. Having exercised its statutory jurisdiction and issued the Occupancy Certificates
on
19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017, 10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 , it is not now open to the Gram Panchayat to contend that the procedure prescribed under the Model Bye-laws had not been followed or that
certificates
were
issued
without
compliance with Rule 12. 54.14. Learned counsel further submits that Rule 12 does not envisage a detailed or elaborate enquiry of the nature now sought to be insisted upon by the respondents. If the Rule-making authority intended such a procedure, the same would have been expressly incorporated in the Model Bye-laws. In the absence of any such statutory
requirement,
validity
of
Occupancy Certificates cannot be questioned by importing procedural requirements which were not in existence at the relevant point of time. It is therefore submitted that the Occupancy Certificates were issued strictly in accordance with the statutory framework then prevailing 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 133 HC-KAR
and cannot be retrospectively invalidated on the basis
of
subsequent
circulars,
standard
operating procedures or executive instructions issued by the Government. 54.15. In pursuance of this, action under Rule 13 is required to be taken. Rule 13 is reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 13. Occupancy Certificate. Within a period of one month after receipt of the notice of completion the Authority shall communicate in the form given in Schedule VI the requisite permission to occupy any such building or to use any building or part thereof effected by any such work.
54.16. By relying on Rule 13 he submits that Rule 13 casts a statutory obligation upon the competent authority to consider the notice of completion submitted under Rule 12 and, within one month thereof, communicate its decision regarding grant of permission to occupy the building in the prescribed form. According to him, the Rule contemplates a sequential statutory process, namely,
certificate
submission
under
Rule
of
a
completion
followed
by
consideration of the same by the competent authority
and
issuance
Certificate under Rule 13. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
of
an
Occupancy
- 134 HC-KAR
54.17. Learned counsel submits that the petitioner had duly complied with the requirements of Rule 12 by
submitting
through
Panchayat,
completion
project
architects.
The
Gram
considering
said
after
certificate
application, exercised its statutory jurisdiction and issued the Occupancy Certificates in terms of Rule 13. The issuance of the Occupancy Certificates was thus a conscious administrative decision taken by the competent authority and not a ministerial or mechanical act. Once such statutory
power
had
been
exercised,
validity of the Occupancy Certificates could not subsequently be questioned merely because a different opinion had been formed regarding the state of completion of the project. 54.18. It is further submitted that Rule 13 does not confer any express power upon the Gram Panchayat to review, revoke or cancel an Occupancy Certificate once validly issued. In
absence
of
any
statutory
provision
conferring such power, the authority which granted the Occupancy Certificate becomes functus officio after its issuance and cannot subsequently reopen or annul its own decision. 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 135 HC-KAR
According to learned counsel, if the legislature intended to confer a power of cancellation, review
or
recall,
it
would
have
expressly
provided for the same in the Model Bye-laws. 54.19. Learned counsel therefore submits that the Occupancy Certificates having been issued in exercise of statutory powers under Rule 13, they continue to remain valid and operative unless set aside by a competent judicial forum or by an authority specifically empowered under the governing statute. The subsequent show cause notices and the orders cancelling the Occupancy Certificates are therefore wholly without jurisdiction, being unsupported by any statutory source of power, and are liable to be quashed on that ground alone. 54.20. Learned counsel submits that Rules 12 and 13 of the Model Bye-laws constitute a complete statutory scheme governing the issuance of an Occupancy Certificate. According to him, once a completion certificate is submitted by the owner through a qualified architect in accordance with Rule 12 and is accepted by the competent authority, the authority is required to proceed 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 136 HC-KAR
in terms of Rule 13 by issuing the Occupancy Certificate. It is submitted that the issuance of the Occupancy Certificate necessarily implies that the competent authority was satisfied about the completion of the construction in accordance with the sanctioned plan and the applicable statutory requirements. 54.21. Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
completion certificate issued by the project architects,
which
has
been
produced
as
Annexure-A to the writ petition, has been criticised by the respondents as being vague. According to him, such a contention is wholly misconceived. The certificate issued by the architects is in the format contemplated under the Model Bye-laws and certifies completion of the construction. Once the competent authority accepted the said certificate and acted upon it by issuing the Occupancy Certificates, it is not open
to
respondents
to
subsequently
contend that the certificate did not contain sufficient
particulars.
considered
If
particulars
authority
furnished
to
be
inadequate, it ought to have sought clarification or additional information at the relevant point 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 137 HC-KAR
of
time
before
issuing
Occupancy
Certificates. Having accepted the completion certificate and exercised its statutory powers under Rule 13, the respondents cannot now be permitted to question the sufficiency of the particulars contained therein. 54.22. With regard to the deficiencies pointed out by the Gram Panchayat in its inspection report, learned counsel submits that the said report is vague,
general
and
unsupported
by
any
particulars. According to him, the allegations contained therein do not identify the specific villas in respect of which any deficiency is alleged to exist. It is submitted that although
respondents
contend
that
electricity
connections have not been provided to several villas, all the villas have in fact been provided with electricity infrastructure and the requisite electrical connections. Likewise, the allegation that the villas do not have main doors and windows is wholly unsupported by particulars, inasmuch as the inspection report does not specify the villa numbers in respect of which such deficiencies are alleged. The same is the position with regard to the allegations relating 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 138 HC-KAR
to incomplete plumbing works and electrical installations. According to learned counsel, the inspection report merely contains broad and omnibus observations without identifying the nature,
extent
deficiencies
or
or
location
of
alleged
how
such
demonstrating
deficiencies render any particular villa unfit for occupation. 54.23. It is therefore submitted that the report relied upon by the Gram Panchayat does not satisfy
minimum
standards
expected
of
an
inspection report and cannot constitute the basis for cancellation of Occupancy Certificates which had remained in force for several years. Learned counsel reiterates that the villas had been substantially completed in accordance with the sanctioned plans, that the Occupancy Certificates
were
validly
issued
after
due
consideration by the competent authority, and that the subsequent inspection report is legally unsustainable. 54.24. On these grounds, it is submitted that I.A. No.1/2024
seeking
impleadment
and
I.A.
No.2/2024 seeking recall of the order dated 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 139 HC-KAR
11.12.2023 are liable to be dismissed and that no case is made out for recalling or otherwise interfering with the order dated 11.12.2023 passed by this Court. 54.25. In this regard, the Learned counsel for the petitioner relies upon the decision of Hon’ble Bombay
High
Court
in
M/s
Satra
Plaza
Premises Co-op.Soc., Ltd. -v- Navi Mumbai Municipal
Corporation9
more
particularly
paras 28, 29 & 30, which are reproduced hereunder for easy reference: 28. At the outset, it needs to be stated that on facts, there is no dispute that Satra Properties was allotted the plots in question and that Satra Properties had undertaken the construction in question. The construction was undertaken as per the plans which were approved. The construction was never categorized to be an illegal construction and was in fact, granted an Occupancy Certificate on 09 February, 2012. The consequence of a building receiving Occupancy Certificate needs no elaboration, suffice it to observe that the building in question was permitted to be legally occupied as also tenements in the building could be purchased and sold by the members of the petitioner to third parties. Thus, the consequence of Occupancy Certificate being granted not only is a consequence relevant to the cooperative society like the petitioner, in which such tenements are situated, but also relevant in so far as the members of the petitioner who have purchased the tenements and who are entitled in law to occupy the same on the assumption, that their occupation by
WP No. 1374 of 2017 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 140 HC-KAR
virtue of the Occupancy Certificate granted by the municipal corporation is legal and valid. 29. The power of revocation of an Occupancy Certificate is governed by Section 51 of the MRTP Act. As the impugned order passed by the Municipal Commissioner is in exercise of such powers, such provision is required to be noted which reads thus:"51. Power of revocation permission to development:-
and
modification
of
(1) If it appears to a Planning Authority that it is expedient, having regard to the Development plan prepared or under preparation that any permission to develop land granted 1 [or deemed to be granted] under this Act or any other law, should be revoked or modified, the Planning Authority may, after giving the person concerned an opportunity of being heard against such revocation or modification, by order, revoke or modify the permission to such extent as appears to it to be necessary: Provided that- (a) where the development relates to the carrying out of any building or other operation, no such order shall affect such of the operations as have been previously carried out; or shall be passed after these operations have substantially progressed or have been completed; (b) where the development relates to a change of use of land, no such order shall be passed at any time after change has taken place. (2) Where permission is revoked or modified by an order made under sub-section (1) and any owner claims within the time and in the manner prescribed, compensation for the expenditure incurred in carrying out the development in accordance with such permission which has been rendered abortive by the revocation or modification, the Planning Authority shall, after giving the owner reasonable opportunity of being heard by the Town Planning Officer, and after considering his report, assess and offer, subject to the provisions of section 19, such compensation to the owner as it thinks fit. (3) If the owner does not accept the compensation and gives notice, within such time as may be 09/10/2026, 12:07, Bengaluru
- 141 HC-KAR
prescribed, of his refusal to accept, the Planning Authority shall refer the matter for the adjudication of the Court, and the decision of the Court shall be final and be binding on the owner and Planning Authority." 30. A bare reading of Section 51 of the MRTP Act makes it explicit that the planning authority is required to be satisfied on the following requirements to invoke the powers under Section 51 to revoke the Occupancy Certificate:i. If it appears to the Planning Authority that it is expedient, having regard to the "Development Plan" prepared or under preparation that any permission to develop land granted [or deemed to be granted] under the MRTP Act is required to be revoked or modified, ii. Necessarily such a decision of the Planning Authority is required to be taken in the context of an existing development plan prepared or under preparation, that such a permission to develop is likely to affect such development plans. iii. A Planning Authority in taking such action is under an obligation to grant an opportunity of being heard to the person concerned against such revocation or modification, before an order is passed to revoke or modify the permission.
54.26. By relying on Satra Plaza Premises Coop.Soc., Ltd. he submits that the issuance of an
Occupancy
inconsequential
Certificate
is
administrative
statutory
determination
authority
that
by
not
act
building
an
but
a
competent has
been
constructed in accordance with the sanctioned plans
and
is
fit
for
occupation.
Once
an
Occupancy Certificate is issued, valuable rights accrue not only in favour of the developer but 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 142 HC-KAR
also in favour of the purchasers, occupants, financial institutions and all other persons who have acted upon the representation made by
statutory
authority.
The
Occupancy
Certificate enables lawful occupation of the premises and facilitates conveyance, transfer and
enjoyment
of
property
by
further
submits
that
purchasers. 54.27. Learned
counsel
Hon’ble Bombay High Court has recognised that the power to revoke or cancel an Occupancy Certificate is not an inherent administrative power but one that must trace its source to an express statutory provision. Such power, where available,
has
to
be
exercised
strictly
in
accordance with the conditions prescribed by the governing statute. It is therefore contended that, in the absence of an express provision under
Karnataka
Gram
Swaraj
and
Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 or the Karnataka Panchayat Raj (Zilla Panchayat, Taluk Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control of Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015 conferring a power upon the Gram Panchayat to revoke or cancel an Occupancy Certificate once issued, 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 143 HC-KAR
respondent Nos.2 and 3 lacked the jurisdiction to
issue
impugned
notices
proposing
cancellation of the Occupancy Certificates. 54.28. It is further submitted that even assuming, without admitting, that such a power exists, the same
can
be
exercised
only
upon
strict
compliance with the principles of natural justice and
only
upon
recording
cogent
reasons
demonstrating that the statutory conditions for exercise of such power exist. According to learned counsel, no such jurisdictional facts have been established in the present case. The impugned notices merely proceed on vague allegations regarding incomplete construction without
identifying
warranting
any
cancellation
statutory of
violation Occupancy
Certificates. 54.29. Learned counsel therefore submits that, the Occupancy Certificates issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017 having remained in force since and several third-party rights having crystallised on the basis thereof, the respondents cannot seek to reopen or cancel the same merely on the 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 144 HC-KAR
basis
of
a
subsequent
change
of
opinion
regarding the condition of the villas. Such action, apart from being unsupported by any statutory
provision,
would
unsettle
vested
rights that have accrued to purchasers and other stakeholders who have acted upon the Occupancy Certificates issued by the competent authority. It is therefore submitted that the impugned
notices
and
proceedings
seeking
Occupancy
Certificates
consequential
cancellation
of
are
without
wholly
jurisdiction and liable to be quashed. 55.
Heard Sri. Joshua Hudson Samuel., Advocate for Petitioner. Sri. Boppanna Belliyappa., AGA for R1, Sri. M.S. Devaraju., advocate for R2 and R3, Sri. A.V. Gangadharappa., advocate for R4, Sri. Yogesh D. Naik., Advocate for R5, Sri. Suraj Sampath, Advocate for the impleading applicants.
56.
The Points that would arise for consideration are: (i)
Whether I.A. No.1/2024 seeking impleadment is maintainable and whether the applicants are necessary or proper parties?
(ii)
Whether I.A. No.2/2024 seeking recall of order dated 11.12.2023 is 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 145 HC-KAR
maintainable and whether sufficient grounds for recall, including fraud or suppression of material facts, have been established? (iii)
What is the statutory regime governing issuance of Occupancy Certificates for buildings situated within Gram Panchayat limits but falling within a notified Local Planning Area/Planning Authority?
(iv)
Which authority was competent in law to issue the Occupancy Certificate in respect of the subject project/villas?
(v)
Whether respondent Nos.2 and 3/Gram Panchayat were competent to issue the Occupancy Certificate in the facts of the present case, notwithstanding jurisdiction of the Planning Authority?
(vi)
Whether the Occupancy Certificates were issued after compliance with the statutory requirements, including inspection, verification of construction against the sanctioned plan, and obtaining requisite technical opinion?
(vii)
Whether the subject villas/project were in fact complete and fit for occupation on the date of issuance of the Occupancy Certificate?
material on record (viii) Whether establishes that the Occupancy Certificates were procured or issued on the basis of misrepresentation, suppression of material facts, or failure of the authorities to undertake the required verification? 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 146 HC-KAR
(ix)
Whether subsequent cancellation/withdrawal of the Occupancy Certificate was within the jurisdiction of competent authority and was otherwise in accordance with law and the principles of natural justice?
(x)
What is the effect, if any, of the Occupancy Certificate and the present proceedings upon the applicability of RERA, and whether such question is required to be determined in the present proceedings?
(xi)
What relief, if any, is the petitioner entitled to in the writ petition and what relief, if any, are the impleading applicants entitled to?
(xii)
What consequential directions are required to secure compliance with the applicable planning, building and occupancy requirements, while preserving the rights of purchasers and issues pending before RERA?
(xiii) What Order
57.
This Court answers the above points as follows:
58.
Answer to Point No.(i): Whether I.A. No.1/2024 seeking impleadment is maintainable and whether the applicants are necessary or proper parties? 58.1. Sri. Suraj Sampath, learned counsel appearing for the proposed respondents (the impleading 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 147 HC-KAR
applicants),
submitted
that
his
clients
are
purchasers of villas in the very same project and are, along with several other purchasers, before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority in proceedings that are presently pending. His submission was that the petitioner is relying on
order
dated
11.12.2023
before
Authority to contend that the project ceased to be an “ongoing project” once the Occupancy Certificates
were
issued
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
on
19.09.2016,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017, and that this contention, if it succeeds, will defeat the very claims that his clients and other similarly placed purchasers have carried to the Authority. 58.2. Learned counsel submitted that his clients did not seek to be impleaded out of any interest in the thirty-three villas named in the notice as such, but because the observations recorded by this
Court
while
passing
order
dated
11.12.2023 touch the Occupancy Certificates issued for other villas , comprising in total sixty-one villas and the clubhouse , and the finding on its validity, which the petitioner now seeks to use against every purchaser before the 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 148 HC-KAR
Authority, including his clients. He submitted that a person need not hold a direct stake in the specific relief claimed in a writ petition to be a proper party; it is enough that the order likely to be passed will have a direct and prejudicial bearing on rights that are the subject of another pending proceeding to which the order will be cited. 58.3. It
was
further
submitted
that
no
proper
verification had, according to the applicants, preceded
Certificates
issuance
on
of
19.09.2016,
Occupancy 14.12.2016,
15.03.2017, 10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017, and that this was a matter going to the propriety of the process followed by the official respondents, a matter in which every purchaser in the project, and not merely the owners of the thirty-three named villas, has a legitimate concern. Learned counsel accordingly submitted that his clients are, at the least, proper parties whose presence would assist the Court in arriving at a complete and correct adjudication of the questions raised. 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 149 HC-KAR
58.4. Sri. Joshua Hudson Samuel, learned counsel for the petitioner, opposed I.A. No.1/2024 on the short ground that the applicants are complete strangers to the subject matter of the writ petition. His submission was that the notice impugned in this petition, and the proceedings that culminated in the order dated 11.12.2023, concerned only thirty-three residential villas, being Villa Nos.1 to 6, 10, 12, 14 to 19, 24, 26, 32, 40, 42, 45, 46, 48 to 52, 54 to 56 and 58 to 61. 58.5. Learned counsel pointed out that the proposed respondents claim rights only in Villa Nos.8 and 53, and it is not in dispute that neither of these two villas figures anywhere in the list of thirtythree villas set out above. On this footing, he submitted that the applicants have no legal right or interest of any kind in the notice under challenge or in the order dated 11.12.2023, and are consequently neither necessary nor proper parties within the meaning of that expression. 58.6. It was further submitted that valid Occupancy Certificates subsist in respect of Villa Nos.8 and 53, that these certificates have never been 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 150 HC-KAR
questioned before any authority or court, and that the applicants therefore suffer no prejudice of any kind on account of the order impugned or sought to be reopened. According to learned counsel,
a
certificate
person is
whose
untouched
own
and
occupancy
unchallenged
cannot claim a right to be impleaded merely because the litigation concerns other villas forming part of the same layout. 58.7. A
writ
court
is
not
bound
by
strict
conception of a “necessary party” applicable to an ordinary civil suit. While the distinction between a necessary party and a proper party remains
relevant,
Court
exercising
jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution possesses a wider discretion to determine whether the presence of a person would
facilitate
a
complete
and
effective
adjudication of the controversy before it. 58.8. A person may, therefore, be impleaded as a proper party where, though his presence is not indispensable for the grant of the relief sought in the writ petition, his participation would assist the Court in effectively adjudicating an 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 151 HC-KAR
issue arising in the proceedings and in ensuring that its determination does not operate to his prejudice
without
an
opportunity
of
being
heard. 58.9. In the present case, the applicants' villas are admittedly not amongst the thirty-three villas covered by the impugned notice. Ordinarily, that circumstance would weigh substantially against
their
impleadment.
The
present
proceedings, however, did not remain confined to the validity of the notice insofar as those thirty-three villas were concerned. 58.10. During the course of the proceedings, the Court is required to examine, inter alia, the statutory framework
governing
issuance
of
Occupancy Certificates by Gram Panchayats in areas falling within the jurisdiction of Planning Authorities, the competence of the concerned authority to issue such certificates, and the procedure required to be followed before an Occupancy Certificates could be issued. This Court
is
also
circumstances
required in
which
to
examine
Occupancy
Certificates in respect of the project had been 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 152 HC-KAR
issued and the adequacy of the inspection and verification said to have preceded its issuance. 58.11. The applicants' case is that their rights and remedies in proceedings pending before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority are going to be adversely affected by the findings in the present proceedings, particularly because the Occupancy Certificates issued in respect of the project is relied upon in those proceedings. This aspect
cannot
be
regarded
as
wholly
speculative. It is not in dispute that proceedings relating to the very same project are pending before the RERA Authority and that the Court had expressly clarified that the rights and liabilities of the parties under RERA were left open for independent determination by that Authority. 58.12. The
objection
of
petitioner
that
Occupancy Certificates pertaining to Villa Nos.8 and
have
independently
neither
been
challenged
is
cancelled
nor
undoubtedly
relevant. The applicants, however, do not seek, by their impleadment, any adjudication of the validity of the certificates pertaining to their 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 153 HC-KAR
individual
villas,
nor
do
they
seek
any
substantive relief concerning those villas in the present writ petition. Their grievance is that findings made in these proceedings, particularly those
concerning
circumstances
under
which the Occupancy Certificates were issued, may be relied upon in proceedings in which they are directly interested. 58.13. In these circumstances, this Court is of the view that the applicants have demonstrated an interest to justify their presence as proper parties, though not as necessary parties. Their presence would enable the Court, within the permissible scope of the present proceedings, to hear the persons who assert that the findings sought
to
be
relied
upon
against
them
elsewhere have a bearing upon their rights and remedies. 58.14. This conclusion must, however, be confined within proper limits. The applicants are not necessary parties in the sense that no effective order in the writ petition could have been passed in their absence. Their impleadment does not enlarge the subject matter of the writ 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 154 HC-KAR
petition so as to bring Villa Nos.8 and 53 within the scope of the impugned notice, nor does it confer upon the applicants any independent right to seek adjudication of the validity of the Occupancy Certificates pertaining to those villas in the present proceedings. 58.15. For the aforesaid reasons, this Court answers point no.(i) by holding that I.A. No.1/2024 is maintainable and is allowed. The applicants are impleaded as proper parties; counsel for the Petitioner to carry out necessary amendments and file amended cause title within 14 days of the receipt of a certified copy of this Order. 59.
Answer to Point No.(ii): Whether I.A. No.2/2024 seeking recall of the order dated 11.12.2023 is maintainable and whether sufficient grounds for recall, including fraud or suppression of material facts, have been established? 59.1. Sri. Suraj Sampath, learned counsel for the impleading applicants, submitted that the villas had not in fact been completed when the Occupancy 14.12.2016,
Certificates 15.03.2017,
dated
19.09.2016,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017 are stated to have been issued; that the completion certificate furnished by the 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 155 HC-KAR
project architect was consequently incorrect; and that the order dated 11.12.2023 was obtained on the basis of a representation of completion
which,
contradicted
by
according
to
him,
petitioner's
is own
contemporaneous conduct and correspondence. 59.2. Learned counsel first drew attention to the chronology. According to him, the first sale deed in respect of any villa in the project was executed only on 19.09.2018, with possession being delivered on 08.11.2018. He submitted that this was substantially after the Occupancy Certificates is stated to have been obtained on 19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.4.2017 and 05.05.2017 and also well after the promised date of delivery of 26.02.2016. His submission was that, if the certificates genuinely reflected completion and fitness for occupation of the project as represented, the substantial interval before execution of even the first sale deed and delivery of possession called for explanation. 59.3. Learned counsel then placed emphasis on the date 05.05.2017. He pointed out that section 3 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 156 HC-KAR
of
Real
Estate
(Regulation
and
Development) Act, 2016 came into force on 01.05.2017,
only
four
days
earlier.
His
submission was that the proximity of the two dates
was
significant
and
warranted
examination as to whether the Occupancy Certificates had been procured at that stage with a view to taking the project outside the statutory concept of an “ongoing project” under the said Act. 59.4. In support of this submission, learned counsel relied
upon
12.05.2017 Executive
petitioner's
addressed Engineer
to
letter
dated
Assistant
(Electrical),
BESCOM,
Hoskote Sub Division, produced as Exhibit R39. He pointed out that, in this letter, written one week after the date of the recent of the Occupancy Certificates is stated to have been obtained
on
05.05.2017,
informed
BESCOM
that
petitioner
servicing
of
remaining forty-one villas was delayed and sought permission for servicing only twenty villas
along
with
common
petitioner, in the said letter, stated: 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
area.
The
- 157 HC-KAR
“The delay in completing the remaining 41 villas is taking time, due to market bad conditions & the balance Kwh meters will be connected in due course.”
59.5. Learned counsel submitted that this was not an assertion emanating from a third party, but a contemporaneous
statement
made
by
petitioner itself to a public utility in the ordinary course
of
its
unconnected
affairs
with the
and
for
present
a
purpose
proceedings.
According to him, the statement was significant because it indicated that forty-one out of the sixty-one villas remained incomplete as on 12.05.2017, i.e., one week after the date on which the petitioner claims that the Gram Panchayat
had
already
issued
Occupancy
Certificates in respect of certain villas on 05.05.2017 in respect of the project. 59.6. Learned counsel next relied upon the sanction letter
dated
20.03.2018
issued
by
M/s.
Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited, produced at Annexure-R3 to I.A. No.2/2024, by which a loan of Rs.100,00,00,000/- was sanctioned to the petitioner. He submitted that the facility was structured with disbursement linked to construction progress and operated through an 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 158 HC-KAR
escrow mechanism. According
to
him, the
procurement of a construction-linked facility of such magnitude nearly a year after the recent of the alleged Occupancy Certificates were issued on 05.05.2017 indicating
that
was
a circumstance
substantial
construction
remained to be completed. 59.7. He further referred to the petitioner's letter dated 26.04.2018 addressed to the proposed respondents, produced at Annexure-R4, which, according to him, recorded that the loan had been obtained and that the works would be completed utilising those funds. He also relied upon the communications dated 11.08.2017, 23.10.2017,
08.02.2018,
03.03.2018,
26.06.2018, 04.07.2018 and 14.02.2019, in which,
according
to
learned
counsel,
petitioner repeatedly indicated that construction activities were still continuing. 59.8. Learned
counsel
also
referred
to
subsequent SARFAESI proceedings, culminating in the e-auction notice dated 24.08.2023 in respect of twenty-three villas at a reserve price of
approximately
Rs.3
09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
crore
per
villa.
He
- 159 HC-KAR
compared
this
with
original
sale
considerations stated to have been in the range of Rs.6 crore to Rs.7.2 crore during the period 2014
to
2017
and
submitted
that
substantial decline in the realisable value was consistent with the project having remained incomplete. 59.9. Learned
counsel
thereafter
manner in which the issued
on
questioned
Occupancy Certificates
19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017, 10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 came to be entered in the Panchayat records. Relying upon
Draft
User
Manual
for
online
generation of Form No.9 and the letter dated 05.07.2025
of
Panchayat
Development
Officer, he submitted that the photographs uploaded
at
time
of
data
entry
on
18.11.2015 were stock photographs taken from the petitioner's sales brochure and were not photographs depicting the actual villas. He further submitted that the then Panchayat Development Officer, Sri. C. Muniraju, had not personally visited the site or verified the state of construction before the entries were made. 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 160 HC-KAR
59.10. Learned
counsel
contended
that
this
circumstance, when considered along with the spot inspection report dated 20.08.2016, which according to him recorded pending works, raised a serious question as to whether any genuine verification of the state of completion had preceded the issuance of the Occupancy Certificates subsequently relied upon by the petitioner. 59.11. On
legal
consequence
of
suppression,
learned counsel relied upon the decisions of the Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
Badami
(Deceased) by her LRs. v. Bhali [(2012) 11 SCC
574]
(paragraphs
to
25)
and
Meghmala and Others v. G. Narasimha Reddy and Others, [(2010) 8 SCC 383] (paragraphs 20 to 28). 59.12. Learned counsel submits that these decisions establish the principle that an order obtained by practising
fraud
upon
Court,
or
by
suppression of a material fact or document, cannot be
permitted to
stand;
that fraud
vitiates judicial proceedings; and that the Court 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 161 HC-KAR
possesses the power to recall an order obtained by such fraud. 59.13. From paragraph 20 of Meghmala, learned counsel relied upon the proposition that “Fraud avoids
all
judicial
acts,
ecclesiastical
or
temporal.” He also relied upon paragraph 26, where the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that suppression of a material document would amount to fraud on the Court. 59.14. From paragraph 20 of Badami, learned counsel relied upon the observation that a judgment or decree obtained by playing fraud on the Court is a nullity and non est in the eyes of law. He also relied upon the observations that a litigant approaching the Court must come with clean hands and is required to place before the Court relevant documents within his knowledge and custody, and that suppression of such material may amount to fraud upon the Court as well as upon the opposite party. 59.15. Applying
aforesaid
principles,
learned
counsel submitted that the petitioner's letter dated 12.05.2017 addressed to BESCOM, as well as the subsequent loan documentation and 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 162 HC-KAR
correspondence relied upon by the applicants, were material documents bearing directly upon the state of completion of the project and, consequently, upon the question whether the premises
were
fit
for
occupation.
His
submission was that these documents were within the petitioner's own knowledge and custody and had not been disclosed when the matter came to be considered on 11.12.2023. According
to
learned
counsel,
their
non-
disclosure, coupled with the petitioner's reliance upon the Occupancy Certificates issued on 19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 as evidence of completion, constituted suppression of material facts and documents of a nature sufficient to warrant recall of the order dated 11.12.2023. 59.16. Sri. Joshua Hudson Samuel, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that the allegation of fraud
is
wholly
unfounded
and
devoid
of
material particulars. He submitted that the petitioner
had
practised
no
fraud,
either
independently or in collusion with the official respondents,
and
that
establishing
such
serious
09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
burden
allegation
of
rested
- 163 HC-KAR
squarely upon the applicants, which burden, according to him, had not been discharged. 59.17. Learned counsel's principal submission on the facts
was
that
project
had time
issued
on
substantially
completed
by
Occupancy
Certificates
were
19.09.2016,
14.12.2016,
been
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017 and that whatever residual work remained, particularly interior finishing
in
respect
of
unsold
villas,
was
deliberately deferred so that the villas could thereafter be finished in accordance with the individual requirements and preferences of the eventual
purchasers.
According
to
learned
counsel, such a practice was neither unusual nor impermissible in the context of the sale of high-value villas. 59.18. He further submitted that the glass facades and window
panels
in
certain
villas
had
subsequently been removed on account of cracks caused by temperature variation and that doors had similarly been removed to facilitate customisation. His submission was that
these
circumstances
09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
related
to
- 164 HC-KAR
subsequent condition of the villas and could not, without more, establish that the villas were incomplete when the Occupancy Certificates were issued. 59.19. Learned counsel took the Court through the sequence in which respondent Nos.2 and 3 had, according to him, consciously exercised their statutory power under Rules 12 and 13 of the Model
Bye-laws
Certificates
in
19.09.2016,
in
issuing
2016-2017,
Occupancy
specifically
14.12.2016,
on
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017 and 05.05.2017, after accepting the completion certificate furnished by the project
architects,
M/s.
Karan
Grover
and
Associates. 59.20. He submitted that the Occupancy Certificates were thus the result of an exercise of statutory power
by
competent
authority
upon
consideration of the material placed before it and that the Gram Panchayat could not, years thereafter, reopen or invalidate that exercise except in accordance with law. The precise scope of the statutory power, the manner in which it was exercised, and the authority and 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 165 HC-KAR
jurisdiction, if any, to subsequently cancel or withdraw matters
Occupancy
considered
Certificates
separately
are
under
Point
counsel
for
No.(ix). 59.21. Sri.
M.S.
Devaraju,
learned
respondent Nos.2 and 3, submitted that the Gram
Panchayat
had
acted
upon
representation made by the petitioner and the completion certificate furnished by the project architects, and that, at the relevant time, the Gram Panchayat had no reason to doubt the material placed before it. He submitted that it was only
26.02.2024,
subsequent conducted
inspection
pursuant
to
dated
directions of this Court, that brought to light the extent to which the project remained incomplete. 59.22. Learned
counsel
drew
attention
to
petitioner's own admission in its objections dated 10.06.2025 to the inspection report, that only twenty out of the sixty-one villas had electricity connections. He further pointed out that property tax remained unpaid in respect of thirty-six
out
of
09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
sixty-one
villas,
- 166 HC-KAR
notwithstanding the specific direction contained in the order dated 11.12.2023 requiring the petitioner to clear all outstanding dues within ninety days. 59.23. According
to
learned
counsel,
these
circumstances demonstrated that the position presented to the Gram Panchayat at the time of issuance of the Occupancy Certificates could not be equated with the actual state of the project subsequently found on inspection, and also
showed
that
petitioner
had
not
complied fully with the conditions imposed by this Court in its order dated 11.12.2023. 59.24. Before considering the allegation of suppression on merits, the objection to the maintainability of I.A. No.2/2024 requires consideration. It is contended that the applicants were not parties to the writ petition when the order dated 11.12.2023 was passed and, therefore, cannot seek recall of that order. 59.25. The objection cannot be accepted. Under Point No.(i), the applicants have already been held to be proper parties for the limited purpose of these proceedings. Their case is not merely that 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 167 HC-KAR
they are dissatisfied with the order. They contend that the order was obtained without placing before the Court material facts and documents concerning the state of completion of the project and that the order is being relied upon to their prejudice before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority. 59.26. The principles in Meghmala and Badami make it clear that an order obtained by suppression of material facts cannot be allowed to stand merely because the suppression is brought to the Court's notice subsequently. 59.27. I.A. No.2/2024 is, therefore, maintainable. 59.28. On merits, the material relied upon by the applicants falls broadly into two categories. The first consists of disputed questions concerning
physical
condition
of
individual
villas,
including allegations regarding doors, windows, finishing,
amenities
construction.
The
and
other
parties
aspects
have
of
placed
conflicting versions before the Court on these matters.
This
Court
cannot,
in
these
proceedings, undertake a detailed trial of such disputed questions. To the extent they relate to 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 168 HC-KAR
rights and remedies under RERA, they may be considered by the competent statutory forum. 59.29. The
second
category
comprises
contemporaneous documents, particularly the petitioner's letter dated 12.05.2017 addressed to BESCOM, the loan sanction letter dated 20.03.2018, and the sale deed for Villa No. 38 dated 19.09.2018, followed by the delivery of possession on 08.11.2018. These documents require separate consideration because their existence and contents are not dependent on the disputed inspection material. 59.30. The
letter
dated
12.05.2017
is
most
significant of these documents. The petitioner referred to the project as comprising “61 villas + common area”, sought permission to install meters for only twenty villas and stated: “The delay in completing the remaining 41 villas is taking time, due to market bad conditions & the balance Kwh meters will be connected in due course.”
59.31. This
was
a
communication
made
by
petitioner itself to BESCOM in the ordinary course of its affairs. It expressly records that the remaining forty-one villas were yet to be 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 169 HC-KAR
completed. The petitioner may contend that the statement referred only to electrical servicing or had some other explanation. That does not, however, alter the fact that the petitioner itself had disclosed a state of affairs materially different from an unqualified assertion that all sixty-one villas had been completed. 59.32. The subsequent financing arrangement further supports this position. On 20.03.2018, the petitioner accepted a loan facility of Rs.100 crore from M/s. Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited. The material placed before the Court indicates that the facility was connected with project and sales milestones. The subsequent communication dated 26.04.2018 also refers to completion of the works using the loan facility. 59.33. This Court does not treat the sanction of Rs.100 crore, by itself, as proof that construction was incomplete.
Financing
may
be
raised
for
different purposes. However, in the context of a project
comprising
clubhouse,
sixty-one
substantial
villas
and
a
construction-linked
financing obtained after the date on which the project is said to have been completed is a 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 170 HC-KAR
circumstance of considerable weight. Read with the petitioner's own BESCOM communication, it supports the conclusion that substantial project requirements continued after the asserted date of completion. 59.34. The chronology concerning Villa No.38 provides further
corroboration.
The
sale
deed
was
executed on 19.09.2018, and possession was delivered on 08.11.2018. This circumstance, by itself, does not establish that the project was incomplete.
However,
when
read
with
petitioner's 12.05.2017 communication and the subsequent financing arrangement, it assumes significance
and
is
inconsistent
with
an
unqualified assertion that the entire project had already attained completion and fitness for occupation. 59.35. The issue is therefore whether these facts were material to the order dated 11.12.2023 and whether
their
non-disclosure
amounts
to
suppression. 59.36. The answer is in the affirmative. The order dated
11.12.2023
restored
Occupancy
Certificates issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2016, 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 171 HC-KAR
15.03.2017,
10.04.2017
and
05.05.2017,
subject to the premises being put into a condition
fit
for
occupation.
The
state
of
completion and fitness for occupation was thus central to the relief granted. The petitioner approached
this
Court
relying
upon
Occupancy
Certificates,
while
its
own
communication dated 12.05.2017 stated that forty-one of the sixty-one villas remained to be completed. This was a material fact directly relevant to the controversy. It ought to have been disclosed. 59.37. The Court is conscious that the loan sanction and the sale deed, considered separately, do not conclusively establish non-completion. Their significance lies in the circumstances in which they occurred. The BESCOM communication, followed
by
substantial
construction-linked
financing and subsequent completion-related correspondence, presents a consistent picture of continuing project work. 59.38. This
Court
is
therefore
not
required
to
determine the exact extent of construction remaining on any particular date or to decide 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 172 HC-KAR
the condition of each villa individually. The material placed before the Court is sufficient to establish that the factual position concerning completion was not fully disclosed. 59.39. The
suppression
is
material
because
documents were within the petitioner's own knowledge and custody. The petitioner was the author
of,
or
party
to,
relevant
communications and could not reasonably have been unaware of their contents. This Court accordingly finds that the petitioner did not merely omit a collateral circumstance. Material facts
bearing
directly
upon
state
of
completion and fitness for occupation were withheld. The representation made before the Court was therefore not a full and truthful disclosure of the position reflected in the petitioner's own records. 59.40. This
Court
has
reached
this
conclusion
principally on the basis of the petitioner's own letter
dated
12.05.2017,
and
not
on
disputed allegations concerning individual villas. The Rs.100 crore financing arrangement and 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 173 HC-KAR
the chronology relating to Villa No.38 provide additional support to that conclusion. 59.41. The case is therefore not one where the applicants merely seek reconsideration because another view of the evidence is possible. The complaint
is
documentary
of
non-disclosure
evidence
which
of
had
material a
direct
bearing upon the factual basis on which relief was granted. 59.42. The principles in Meghmala and Badami are consequently attracted. An order obtained by suppression
of
material
facts
cannot
be
permitted to operate to the advantage of the party responsible for such suppression. 59.43. In the circumstances, this court answers point no (ii) by holding that sufficient grounds are made
out
11.12.2023.
for I.A.
recall
of
No.2/2024
order is
dated
accordingly
allowed and the order dated 11.12.2023 is recalled. 60.
Answer to Point No.(iii): What is the statutory regime governing issuance of Occupancy Certificates for buildings situated within Gram 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 174 HC-KAR
Panchayat limits but falling within a notified Local Planning Area/Planning Authority? 60.1. Sri. Joshua Hudson Samuel, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that under the Model Bye-laws, the expression “Authority” means the authority authorised by the Gram Panchayat to grant
licences
and
perform
functions
assigned to it under the Bye-laws. 60.2. He submitted that Rule 9 makes the Gram Panchayat
responsible
for
examining
and
approving building plans, though the plans are required to be signed by a qualified architect, engineer or supervisor. He further relied upon Rule
read
with
Section
111(2)
of
Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, to contend that every Gram Panchayat is required
to
have
a
full-time
Panchayat
Development Officer and that the Panchayat Development Officer is competent to exercise
powers
conferred
by
Bye-laws,
including the power to issue an Occupancy Certificate under Rule 13. 60.3. On this basis, learned counsel contended that respondent Nos.2 and 3 had the statutory 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 175 HC-KAR
authority to issue the Occupancy Certificate. According to him, the fact that the Planning Authority had jurisdiction over the layout and development plan of the project did not take away the power of the Gram Panchayat to issue the Occupancy Certificate. This contention is considered under Points No.(iv) and (v). 60.4. The statutory position was explained principally by respondent No.1-State of Karnataka through affidavits filed pursuant to the directions of this Court.
The
learned
Advocate
General also
assisted the Court after it became clear that the issues raised involved questions concerning the statutory
framework
applicable
beyond
parties to the writ petition. Since respondent No.1 is a party to the writ petition, its affidavits are treated as its submissions on the statutory position. 60.5. In the affidavit dated 22.04.2024 of Sri. Rajesh S. Sulikeri, Under Secretary to Government, Urban Development Department, it was stated that Local Planning Areas are declared under Section 4-A of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961, and that the Planning 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 176 HC-KAR
Authorities constituted for such areas prepare and implement the Master Plan and Zonal Regulations. 60.6. The affidavit further states that, under Section 15 of the said Act, the Planning Authority grants permission for development of buildings by issuing a Commencement Certificate in the manner prescribed by the Karnataka Planning Authority Rules, 1965. It is specifically stated that, where Gram Panchayat limits fall within a Local
Planning
Area,
Commencement
Certificate is issued by the Planning Authority and not by the Gram Panchayat. 60.7. The affidavit also placed on record Section 64 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj and Panchayat Raj Act, 1993. Sub-section (1) requires prior written permission of the Gram Panchayat for erection,
alteration
or
reconstruction
of
a
building. Sub-section (2) provides for deemed permission where the Gram Panchayat does not communicate its decision within sixty days. 60.8. Of particular relevance is sub-section (5A) of Section 64, which requires Gram Panchayats to comply with the provisions of the Karnataka 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 177 HC-KAR
Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 while issuing building licences or approving housing or residential layouts. An approval contrary to that Act is treated as misconduct for which the concerned officer or official may be proceeded against. 60.9. The State further relied upon the Karnataka Panchayat
Raj
(Zilla
Panchayat,
Taluk
Panchayat and Gram Panchayat Control of Erection of Buildings) Model Bye-laws, 2015, notified
on
affidavit,
08.05.2015.
these
Bye-laws
According apply
to
to
Gram
Panchayat areas falling within a Local Planning Area, subject to the Zonal Regulations framed under
Karnataka
Town
and
Country
Planning Act, 1961. 60.10. The affidavit states that a building licence is considered under Section 64 of the Act read with
Rule
Completion qualified
of
Certificate
architect
or
Bye-laws; is
a
required
empanelled
Building from
a
engineer
under Rule 12; and permission to occupy is issued by the Gram Panchayat under Rule 13. 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 178 HC-KAR
60.11. The State also clarified that the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 does not contain a provision authorising
a Planning
Authority to issue an Occupancy Certificate. According to the State, that function rests with the Gram Panchayat. 60.12. In
relation
to
Bengaluru
Metropolitan
Region, the State also referred to Rule 18(5) of
Bengaluru
Development
Metropolitan
Authority
Rules,
Region 2022.
The
provision requires the prior concurrence of the Metropolitan
Commissioner
for
specified
proposals and activities, including proposals relating to technical opinion before issuance of building plans, Commencement Certificates and Occupancy Certificates for multistorey projects by local bodies, Planning Authorities and other authorities
performing
town
and
country
planning functions within Local Planning Areas in the Bengaluru Metropolitan Region. 60.13. This
Court's
order
dated
16.04.2024
had
already identified the principal issue: whether and to what extent the Model Bye-laws operate within the jurisdiction of a Planning Authority 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 179 HC-KAR
and
whether
a
Gram
Panchayat
has
necessary statutory and technical capacity to perform functions of this nature. 60.14. The learned Advocate General was accordingly requested to assist the Court. The matter was considered over several hearings between June and
August
2024.
In
that
process,
Additional Chief Secretary, Urban Development Department,
and
Additional
Chief
Secretary, Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department, issued a joint Circular dated 05.08.2024. 60.15. The Circular requires Gram Panchayats situated within
a
Planning
Commencement construction
from
Area
to
Certificate
obtain
for
building
concerned
Planning
Authority under Section 15(1) of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961. 60.16. It further provides that, after completion of the building and upon production of the Building Completion
Certificate
architect,
empanelled
from
engineer
qualified or
other
qualified person, the Panchayat Development Officer
shall,
before
09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
issuing
- 180 HC-KAR
Possession/Occupancy Certificate, jointly verify the construction with the concerned authorities. The verification is to cover, among other things, compliance with the approved building plan
and
estimates,
Commencement
Certificate and the licence issued by the Gram Panchayat. The Panchayat Development Officer is also required to obtain the technical opinion of the concerned Planning Authority regarding completion in accordance with the approved plan. 60.17. The
Circular
directs
that
Occupancy
Certificate is to be issued only after such compliance is established. 60.18. Thus, according to the State's own submission, the statutory scheme operates at two stages. 60.18.1. First, where a Gram Panchayat falls within
a
Local
Planning
Area,
Planning Authority controls development through the Commencement Certificate and the applicable planning framework. The Gram Panchayat thereafter exercises the power to grant the building licence and, upon completion, the power to 09/10/2026, 12:08, Bengaluru
- 181 HC-KAR
issue the Occupancy Certificate under the Model Bye-laws. 60.18.2. Second, the exercise of the latter power is
not
independent
framework. verification
The
of
planning
Circular
requires
of
compliance
with
Commencement
Certificate,
approved
plan and other applicable requirements, together with technical opinion from the concerned Planning Authority, before the Occupancy Certificate is issued. 60.19. The learned AGA, appearing on 28.08.2024, confirmed that the State considered this to be the procedure applicable. 60.20. Sri. Suraj Sampath, learned counsel for the impleading applicants, while not disputing the content of this Circular, submitted that it postdates the events in question by several years and is, by its own terms, prospective. His submission was that it is the law as it stood in 2016-2017, when the Occupancy Certificates in the present case were issued on 19.09.2016, 14.12.2