Rakshi Bhoi v. State of Odisha
- Court
- Orissa High Court
- Date of judgment
- 13 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice Sashikanta Mishra
- Case number
- WP(C) No. 26298 of 2026
- Result
- Disposed Off
- Advocates
- P.K.Mohanty, P. Mohanty, G. Mohanty
- Subject
- Civil
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK W.P.(C) No.26295 of 2026 ODHC010630902026 W.P.(C) No.35198 of 2026 ODHC010885532025 W.P.(C) No. 26136 of 2026 ODHC010619902026 W.P.(C) No. 26296 of 2026 ODHC010631032026 W.P.(C) No. 26298 of 2026 ODHC010630932026 W.P.(C) No.26313 of 2026 ODHC010630982026 W.P.(C) No.26566 of 2026 ODHC010622732026 W.P.(C) No.26572 of 2026 ODHC010622782026 W.P.(C) No.26745 of 2026 ODHC010641202026 W.P.(C) No.27742 of 2026 ODHC010662232026 W.P.(C) No.27744 of 2026 ODHC010661872026 W.P.(C) No.28541 of 2026 ODHC010668952026 W.P.(C) No.28574 of 2026 ODHC010668962026 W.P.(C) No.28580 of 2026 ODHC010672682026 W.P.(C) No.28831 of 2026 ODHC010677292026 W.P.(C) No.29133 of 2026 ODHC010690282026 W.P.(C) No.29136 of 2026 ODHC010690332026 (Applications under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India)
W.P.(C) No.26295 of 2026 Radha Mirdha & Ors.
…
Petitioners
…
Opposite Parties
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
W.P.(C) No.35198 of 2026 …
Sanju Meher
Petitioner
-versus…
State of Odisha & Ors.
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No. 26136 of 2026 Rushi Kumar Bhoi … Petitioner -versus…
State of Odisha & Ors.
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No. 26296 of 2026 Dharmu Munda
…
Petitioner
…
Opposite Parties
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 26298 of 2026 …
Petitioner
…
Opposite Parties
Rakshi Bhoi -versusState of Odisha & Ors.
W.P.(C) No.26313 of 2026 …
Manish Kumar Behera
Petitioner
-versus…
State of Odisha & Ors.
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No.26566 of 2026 …
Apurba Bagartti
Petitioner
-versusThe Registering Officer-Cum-Sub-Registrar, Maneswar & Ors. … Opposite Parties W.P.(C) No.26572 of 2026 …
Tulasi Dip
Petitioner
-versusThe Registering Officer Cum Sub Registrar, Sambalpur & Ors. … Opposite Parties W.P.(C) No.26745 of 2026 …
Bijay Kumar Naik
Petitioner
-versus…
State of Odisha & Ors.
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No.27742 of 2026 …
Raju Minz
Petitioner
-versusW.P.(C) No.26295 of 2026 & Batch
…
State of Odisha & Ors.
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No.27744 of 2026 Artatrana Suresh
…
Petitioner
…
Opposite Parties
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
W.P.(C) No.28541 of 2026 Suryamani Bhoi
…
Petitioner
…
Opposite Parties
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
W.P.(C) Nos.28574 & 28580 of 2026 Dhanamali Mirdha
…
Petitioner
…
Opposite Parties
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
W.P.(C) No.28831 of 2026 Baikuntha Naik
…
Petitioner
…
Opposite Parties
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
W.P.(C) No.29133 of 2026 …
Pravasini Sohela
Petitioner
-versusW.P.(C) No.26295 of 2026 & Batch
State of Odisha & Ors.
…
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No.29136 of 2026 Biswajit Kumbhar
…
Petitioner
…
Opposite Parties
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
Advocates appeared in the case through hybrid mode: For Petitioners
:
Mr. P.K.Mohanty, Sr. Advocate. Mr. P. Mohanty, Advocate
For Opposite Parties
:
Mr. G. Mohanty, S.C.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------CORAM: JUSTICE SASHIKANTA MISHRA JUDGMENT 13.11.2026. Sashikanta Mishra,J. Since the facts and questions of law involved in all these writ applications are substantially similar and the matters have been heard analogously, they are being disposed of by this common judgment. For the sake of brevity and convenience, however, the facts of W.P.(C) No.26295 of 2026 shall be considered and referred to.
2.
The petitioners have filed this Writ Petition seeking to
challenge the refusal of the Sub-Registrar, Sambalpur to accept the sale deed presented by them for registration. The petitioners claim to be the recorded tenants of the suit land. For legal necessity they decided to sell the property to the Opposite Party No.4. Accordingly, a sale deed was prepared
and
presented
before
the
Sub-Registrar,
Sambalpur but he refused to accept the same. Such refusal was on the ground that though the petitioners belong to the Scheduled Tribe and the Opposite Party No.4 is a nonScheduled Tribe person, no permission under Section 22 of the OLR Act was obtained by them for such transfer. The petitioners contend that the land being situated within the urban area i.e., Sambalpur Municipal Corporation, the provisions of OLR Act are not attracted as per Section 73(c) of the Act. 3.
Counter affidavit has been filed by the Sub-Registrar
in W.P.(C) No.35198/2025 and adopted in all cases of the batch, including the present case. It is stated that though the land is recorded as Gharabari and situated in urban
area
within
Sambalpur
Municipal
Corporation,
still
permission under Section 22 of the OLR Act is necessary for transfer of the land as the petitioners belong to the Scheduled Tribe. Mere inclusion in the urban area cannot exempt the applicability of the mandatory provisions of the OLR Act. The document was therefore, rightly not accepted for registration. 4.
Heard Mr. B. Bhuyan, learned Senior counsel, leading
arguments on behalf of the petitioners and Mr. G. Mohanty, learned Standing Counsel for the State. 5.
Before proceeding further, this Court deems it proper
to mention here that several cases involving identical facts have been disposed of by issuing directions similar to those issued by a coordinate Bench in the judgment rendered in the
case
of
represented
Hemanta through
Naik its
v.
State
Secretary,
of
Odisha,
Revenue
and
Disaster Management Department and Another & batch1. When the present cases came up for hearing, the State filed a counter affidavit and attempted to take a
1 W.P.(C) No.27920 of 2023 & Batch
different stand by contending that directions similar to those issued in Hemanta Naik (Supra), being contrary to law, should not be issued. The matter was heard at length on this point 6.
Since the objection was raised by the State, it would
be proper to refer to the contentions advanced by the State counsel at the outset. 7.
Mr. G. Mohanty learned Standing Counsel for the
State, makes a two-fold argument. Firstly, having itself held that mere inclusion of the land in an urban area would not exclude the applicability of the provisions of Section 22 of the OLR Act, the Co-ordinate Bench directed the revenue authority to make a fact-finding inquiry in each case regarding usability of the land in question for purposes other than agriculture. Secondly, the judgment of the Coordinate Bench was passed contrary to the ratio decided by the Supreme Court in the case of Om Prakash Agrawal and others v. Batara Behera2 and, hence, cannot be treated as a precedent being per incuriam. On such basis, it
2 1999 (3) SCC 231
is contended that the judgment in Hemanta Naik (supra) can be ignored. Mr. Mohanty has relied upon several judgments in support of his contentions, but in view of the order proposed to be passed, this Court does not deem it necessary to refer to the same. 8.
Mr. Bhuyan, learned Senior counsel, on the other
hand, would argue that it is nobody’s case that only because the land is included in the urban area, the provisions of Section 22 of the OLR Act shall not apply. It is rather the specific case of the petitioners that the land is not being used for agricultural purposes, having been recorded as homestead (Gharbari Kisam). It is the usability of the land which is material. Mr. Bhuyan further argues that the Co-ordinate Bench took due note of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case Om Prakash Agrawal (Supra) and therefore, it cannot be treated as having been rendered per incuriam. 9.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties at length,
this Court is firstly of the view that the judgment passed by the Co-ordinate Bench in Hemanta Naik (Supra) was
never challenged by the State nor sought to be reviewed. The State also did not challenge the orders passed by this Court in the light of the directions issued in Hemanta Naik (Supra). In fact, as stated at the Bar, some of such directions have already been complied with. Therefore, this Court is of the view that it is no longer open to the State to raise the point at this belated stage. 10. Coming to the other contention that the judgment in Hemanta Naik (Supra) was rendered per incuriam and can be ignored for being contrary to the ratio decided in Om Prakash Agrawal (Supra), the same principle would apply to the effect that this is also a matter for challenge by the State before the higher forum, which it has not done so far. Nevertheless, this Court finds that the Coordinate Bench has referred to the judgment in Om Prakash Agrawal (Supra) and taking note of the specific observations therein that the OLR Act applies to all lands which are used or capable of being used for agricultural purposes irrespective of where such lands are situated, found it necessary to direct a fact-finding inquiry regarding the usability of each
parcel
of
land.
It
goes
without
saying
that
the
determination regarding usability of the land can only be a question of fact to be decided independently in each case. Therefore, this Court, on the same facts, has felt persuaded to pass identical orders. 11. This Court is in respectful agreement with the reasoning adopted by the Co-ordinate Bench in Hemanta Naik (Supra) and is therefore, not inclined to take a different view. The contention that Hemanta Naik (Supra) being decided per incuriam can be ignored, is not accepted. 12. For the foregoing reasons therefore, this Court finds no merit in the contentions raised by the State and therefore, issues the following directions in disposal of this batch of writ petitions. 13. Liberty is granted to each Petitioner to approach the competent Revenue Authority, i.e. concerned Tahasildar to give his opinion on the usability of the land and in such event, the concerned Tahasildar shall submit his opinion in respect of the specific lands regarding its usability for agricultural purpose in the present scenario, within a
period of 60 days from the date of application by the petitioners. Depending upon the opinion of the Revenue Authority, the Petitioners are at liberty to approach the Sub-Collector/Registering Officer again. 14. The Writ Petitions are disposed of accordingly.
……..……….……………. Sashikanta Mishra, Judge
Ashok Kumar Behera
Signature Not Verified Digitally Signed Signed by: ASHOK KUMAR BEHERA Reason: Authentication Location: Orissa High Court of Cuttack Date: 13-Nov-2026 17:53:27