Ram Narain Popli v. Central Bureau of Investigation

Court
Supreme Court of India
Date of judgment
14 January 2003
Judge
Justice M.B. Shah
Neutral citation
2003 INSC 10
Reported in
[2003] 1 S.C.R. 119
Result
Disposed off
Acts & sections
Section 409 IPC, Section 467 IPC, Section 468 IPC, Section 13 PC Act, Section 120A IPC, Section 405 IPC, Section 420 IPC, Section 403 IPC
Subject
Criminal

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

RAM NARAIN POPLI v. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

JANUARY 14, 2003 [M.B. SHAH, B.N. AGRAWAL AND ARIJIT PASAYAT, JJ.]

Penal Code, 1860; Sections 120B rlw Ss. 403, 409, 420, 467 and 4711 Special Court (Trial of Offences relating to Transactions in Securities) Act, 1992.

c

Financial transactions between Govt. Company, banks and brokersIrregularities therein-CB/filed cases against/we accused under the provisions of Special Court Act-Misappropriation ofpublic funds, charges of cheating, criminal breach of trust, criminal conspiracy and abuse of public officesSpecial Court convicted all except one of the accused -On appeal-Held, D Agreement to commit crime is essential ingredient and overt act not necessary-Criminal conspiracy-Direct evidence is rarely available, circumstantial evidence proves complicity of accused in the crime-In the facts and circumstances ofthe case, accused Bank employees intended to hide informaJion about involvement of accused-broker in the financial transactions ta provide benefit to him, which goes to prove conspiracy amongst the accused-Economic E Offences. Criminal breach of trust-Entrustment ofproperty, conversion to one's own use or use in violation of law with dishonest intention-Necessary ingredients established by the acts and =onduct of some of the accusedHence, they are rightly convicted for offence of criminal breach of trust.

Forgery-Some of the accused found involved in making false Bank Receipts and other documents with the intention to cause injury to Government Company -Hence committed forgery. Cheating-Some ofthe accused by their conduct impliedly inferredfrom the nature of transactions acted fraudulently and dishonestly to induce Govt. company/banks in delivering valuable security/property-Hence committed the offence of cheating.

Market practices-Approval of-Held, a wrong practice even though

SUPReME COURT REPORTS

[2003] I S.C.R.

A prevailing, cannot be treated as approved practice-Since no public interest is involved, such a p>"(!ictice cannot be a substitute for Statutory & Regulatory prescriptiott:S.

c

Prevention of Corruption Act, 1986; Ss. 13(J)(c) r/w S. 13(2): Public Servant-Acts of Corruption-Involvement-Held, some of the accused-public servants, in jurtl#!r'ance of criminal conspiracy, abused their position by causing!alif>wing the funds ofGovernment Company to be utilizedfor wrongful gain of accused-broker-Hence provisions of Sections 13(1)(c) and 13(2) attracted Words and Phmses: 'Entru.stment' and 'Market practices'-Meaning of

Central Bureau of Investigation filed a case before the Special Court under the provisions of Special (Trial of Offences relating to Transactions in Securities), Act, 1992 against accused Nos. 1 to S. Al and A2 were officers of Maruti Udyog Ltd., a Govt. Company; A3 and A4 were bank Officers and AS was a financial broker. According to the prosecution AS in connivance with Al, A2, A3 and A4 involved in irregularities committed in five financial transactions involving sale and purchase of securities (Units of Units Trust oflndia) and reversal thereof. Several enquiries were made in relation to said security scam. Reserve Bank of India appointed the Jankiraman Committee; Besides, a joint Parliamentary Committee was also appointed to enquire into the financial irregularities. Reports of both the Committees were placed before the Trial Court. The main allegation was that accused No.S hatched a criminal

F conspiracy with other accused and in collusion with accused nos.3 & 4 got

deposited surplus funds of MUL into Banks and finally transferred the same in his favour. It was also alleged that Al & A2, without lawful authority, dealt with AS and indulged in illegal financial transaction intentionally to provide benefits to AS. All the five accused appellants were charged under Sections 409, 420, 467, 471 IPC and Sections 13(l)(c) r/w Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Special Court convicted all the accused except accused no. 2 for committing various offences under Indian Penal Code. Hence these appeals by Al, A3, A4 and AS. CBI filed appeal against acquittal of A2. During the pendency of appeals, AS expired and on the petition filed by widow of AS, appeal was ordered to be continued.

J....

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l.

lt was contemled for the appellants that the investment/loan involved A

)(

in live transactions was for a slmrt period and at a higher rate of interest. The amount was paid ba~k 11n due dates; that AS did not commit any offence or offe11ces but the prosecution was a piece of political revenge against AS fllr di•closing certain facts to the Press against the political leaders; that the transactions were loan transactions because rate of interest and period was settled before exchange of money in lieu of B Government securities; that delay in lodging of FIR indicates that investigation was Intentionally kept alive by the CBI for undisclosed motive; that cheques were drawn in favour of one of the Bank for expeditious transmission of amount to AS to prevent monetory loss to him; that there was no conspiracy to siphon off the surplus funds of MUL as C the amount was lent on security and repaid with interest in time; that the prosecution had tried to prove the theory of absurd conspiracy by the sole evidence of approver PW23 without corroborating his evidence; that crossexamination of PW16 was not allowed to corroborate the evidence of PW23; that there was no evidence to establish that Bank Receipts were issued without Units being available with the Bank; that by allowing the D proceeds to be credited to the account of the c.ustomer, i.e A-5, the Bank was neither g~Uty of negligence nor of any criminality, thus no officer of

the Bank could be held liable for the same; that PW23's insistence that A2 was present In the alleged meeting between accused leads to the irresistible inference that deposition about the alleged meeting was totally E concoct!'d; llrnt the charge of conspiracy was cooked up to cover first three transaction• wMeh were prior to issuance of the RBI Circular for stopping illegal praetices; that the alleged link between the accused and in furtherance of conspiracy doing of overt act that by involvement in alleged irregularities in financial transactions, was broken by the fact that 13 other transactio11s tool; place during the same period between AS and MUL; F that the pardon granted to approver PW23 becomes inadmissible; that the evidence of PW23 did not disclose any conspiracy; that the conviction cannQt be based on sole evidence of approver; that there was no evidence against ,.\2 and no material evidence was provided justifying any interference in acquittal appeal; that the prosecution has failed to establish G Al misrepresenting to MUL regarding transfer of funds to one of the Bank at the instrqctions of the other Bank; that the charge of conspiracy was fabricated one, there was no mens rea for alleged criminal breach of trust on the part or Al; that charges under the provision of Section 13(l)(c) of Prevention or Corruption Act and Section 409 IPC were without any foundation; that PW7 and PW14, Officials of a Bank, could not H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003] l S.C.R.

A differentiate whether Bank Receipts and letters pertain to the alleged " transactions involving accused Bank officers and accused client broker; that and prosecution has failed to examine material witnesses; that there was no evidence to prove that A4 handled the cheque of one of the Banks though PW16 accepted the cheque and forwarded it for encashment in favour of accused AS; that A4 was not in any way party to any fraud; B that the prosecution witnesses themselves deposed that cheques were deposited in the account of the Bank and not in the account of AS; that the RBI Circular nowhere prohibits the Banks to act on behalf of their clients; that sine there was no illegality on the part of A3 in the transfer of funds of MUL to AS and there was no evidence of any actual loss caused C to anybody or of intention of causing loss to anybody; that A3 was not connected with the 5th transaction as at the relevant time he was transferred to another branch; that A3 was erroneously charged for forging the Bank Receipts on the wrong assumption that the Bank did not hold the units for which the BRs were issued.

F.

It was submitted for the respondent that these transactions were a facade for a wrong transaction which could not be entered into by MUL in favour of AS; that in view of the guidelines issued by RBI, MUL could not give loan to AS for diverting the funds to MUL; that Al got issued cheques for payment by one Bank in favour of another Bank which in turn transferred to the account of AS; that since the cheques for payment had not been delivered to the representative of UCO Bank, the transaction was not between MUL and UCO Bank; that since cheques were issued in favour of Grindlays Bank for transferring the amount to UCO Bank, it was not loan transaction between MUL and AS; that A3 was having no authority to sell or purchase units with the Bank; and that since A3 was having no authority to issue BRs/documents, he forged these documents to provide benefits to AS.

Disposing of the appeals, the Court HELD (By the Court):

(1) Criminal Appeal filed by the State against A2 is dismissed. (2) Crimimtl Appeal filed by A4 is allowed and he is acquitted of all the offences alleged against him.

(3) Criminal Appeal filed by Al, A3 and deceased AS are partly allowed. Conviction of Al, A3 and AS by the Special Court

-r-·

_.)...

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I.

is confirmed. Sentence of Al and A3 is reduced to the period A already undergone. Per Pasaya!, J. (for himself and Agrawal, J.) :

~

1.1. From the statement of account of UCO Bank, Bombay it is clear that there was no debit entry showing that the UCO Bank, Bombay has B charged any commission for the transaction of certain units of UTI and there is also nothing to show that UCO Bank had charged any commission from A-5. From internal vouchers, it is clear that though names of Bank of America and UCO Bank have been indicated, there was no involvement of UCO Bank either in passing or receivlni: funds in its own account. On the contrary, evidence shows that in tlie Orsi instance money was paid by A-5 through its bankers to MUL. There was nothing to show that the · payment was made to MUL through Bank of America under the instructions of UCO Bank, Bombay. Similarly, at the stage of reversal, the amount paid by MUL directly came to be credited in the account of A-5 first in the Grindlays Bank, Delhi, then in the Grindlays Bank, D Bombay and finally in the UCO Bank, Bombay. In all these three stages, the amount went directly to the account of A-5. There was no involvement of UCO Bank in financial aspects of the transaction, if the Bank, as claimed by A-5, at all acted for him as routing Bank in the transaction. There is nothing to show that such payment was made under the instructions of UCO Bank, Bombay. (286-C, D, E, F]

c

_._

-

'"'

1.2. In the 2nd transaction, the BR authorised and signed by A3 and Issued by UCO Bank recites that UCO Bank having receiyed from MUL the concerned sum, being the cost of certain units of UTI, the security will be delivered when ready in exchange "by this receipt" is duly discharged. F It clearly indicates that UCO Bank had undertaken to MUL to deliver security as and when the Units were ready in exchange for the BR. There is also endorsement made in the BR reading as "discharged" with a rubber stamp of MUL which is proved to be made by accused No. l as proved by PW-3, an officer of MUL. This endorsement shows UCO Bank having discharged its obligations to MUL under the said BR. Credit advice issued G by UCO Bank Is in the handwriting of A-3. Although, In the narration of credit voucher it was mentioned that certain units related to MUL, there is no written record in that regard. Exbt. 128, which is the advice of Grindlays Bank, does not justify the narration as appearing in the credit voucher. The material on record clearly justifies a conclusion that the H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

amount involved came from the account of A-5 and was paid to MUL. There was no involvement whatsoever of UCO Bank though the stand of MUL is that the transaction was between it and UCO Bank. As is the case with the first transaction, the situation is somewhat similar so far as transaction no. 3 is concerned. 1287-F, G, H; 288-A, B, C, DJ

1.3. In the fourth transaction MUL was dealing with UCO Bank and there was no question of A-5 dealing with MUL on principal-to-principal basis. In the minutes of Sub-Committee of MUL for the investment, the committee had earlier approved the proposals as contained in the Agenda Note, where the investment in the security in question was to be made with Grindlays Bank. But later on, the same was changed and it was resolved to be made with UCO Bank, Bombay as proposed by A-1. Significantly, there was no written proposal either from UCO Bank or Grindlays Bank which has been received and placed before the Committee of MUL. The Committee had given its approval to the proposal for investment with UCO Bank. In respect of the other transaction, there was no direct involvement of UCO Bank and it was A-5 creating a facade to give a picture to MUL as if the transaction was between it and UCO Bank. 1288-G, H; 289-A)

C

f.-

)- -

1.4. In transaction No.S, there was no letter issued by UCO Bank, Bombay and proposal to MUL was similar to earlier transactions. The most significant aspect is that there was also no Bank Receipt (BR) issued by UCO Bank, Bombay favouring MUL in respect of this transaction. Notwithstanding these, the security was put through, the MUL parted with money which went into the account of A-S in the same manner as in the case of trans~tions 2 to 4. Another important aspect is that the monies/ funds were in fact credited eventually in the account of A-S with UCO Bank, Bombay. The debit and credit vouchers of the Bank amply prove this. 1289-C, F] 2.1. A-1 concealed the receipt signed by PW-23 on the letterhead of A-S cancelling the receipt of certain units from MUL. It is hard to believe that A-1 did not know that the ultimate beneficiary was A-S. A-1 delivered pay order for the second transaction to PW-16. It has to be noted that for the first time in this Court A-5 has taken the stand that the relevant transactions were iii the nature of loan transaction between A-S and MUL. A-1 used to place the proposal before the Board and obtained approvals for the investments in question. A decision was taken by MUL for investing its funds with PSU. That clearly indicates that investments could only be

_,.L_

R.N. POPL! v. C.8.1.

in PSU's bonds. [289-F, G]

,.

'

~

.

..,_

2.2. The plea that there was instruction by UCO Bank to issue pay order in favour of Grindlays Bank is clearly untenable because if the UCO Bank intended that in its transaction the pay orders were to be issued to Grindlays Bank, the same could not have been without any direction from UCO Bank. In respect of fourth and fifth transactions, pay orders B continued to be issued to Grindlays Bank even though admittedly there was no instruction from UCO Bank. In the fifth transaction, Al released funds of MUL even in the absence of an authority letter or a security in the form of Bank Receipt from UCO Bank. Payments made at the stage of reversal by MUL were directly made to A-5. There was no authorization C to purchase any securities from any brokers. There was no mention about the intention that monies will be given on loan to any broker. Each transaction, as reflected, was considered to be a placement of funds with PSUs and there was no scope of any placement of surplus funds with private person. It is unbelievable that A-1 did not know about the involvement of A-5 when the receipt in respect of certain units was kept D in the records of MUL. (291-A, B, C, DJ 2.3. In all the transactions the role of A-3 is very significant. Investment of the first transaction indicates that the same was written on the letterhead of UCO Bank and was signed by A-3 with reference to certain units. So far as reverse entries are concerned, a letter was E addressed by the UCO Bank, Bombay to MUL requesting MUL to remit funds through ANZ Grindlays Bank. Transaction No.2-BR is in the handwriting of A-3 and is signed by him. Carbon copy of credit voucher of UCO Bank is in the handwriting of A-3 and also bears his signature. It indicates that the amount was intended for A-5 being the amount of F security, namely, units sold to MUL. Similarly Exbt. 151(1) shows that A-3 signed on the debit voucher in the name of A-5 for certain amount. ]291-E, F, G] 2.4. One significant factor as deposed by PW-7 is that none of the UCO Bank Managers were authorized to deal with securities. If there was any genuine transaction.for sale of security, the deal could have been concluded by the Head Office of the Bank. Accused No.3 wrote letters and made a representation that he has entered into transactions for the Bank. A-3 was not authorized to write a letter unless he is permitted to do so from the Head Office. A-3, therefore, did not have the authority to deal with the Bank or to any arrangement. PWs. 14 and 21 deposed that only

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003] I S.C.R.

the Head Office can instruct on behalf of the Bank. A-3 fraudulently signed documents showing different designations to misrepresent something which in reality was not there. In reality he was the Assistant Manager. These are clearly conducts of deceit and dishonest intention. On the basis of the letters and BRs. MUL parted with its funds which went to the account of A-5. [292-D, F, GJ 2.5. Grindlays and UCO Bank never received money in their own· right. They only collected the cheque for A-5, although the cheque in each case was non-negotiable payee cheque in favour of Grindlays Bank without any instructions from MUL. UCO Bank did not sell or agree to sell, as A-3 had no authority either to sell or commit UCO Bank to any sale of security on behalf of the Bank, even if it is accepted that the Bank had purchased the security, it had become the property of Bank, and the securities dealt with as an agent is not to be reflected in the books of the Bank yet such recording is appropriate. In the instant case, the sale or repurchase has not been passed through the Bank's books. The stand that Bank had received a commission is inconsistent with the stand that there was a sale and repurchase involved in the transaction. In such a transaction, the difference in price is the profit and not a commission. For the 5th transaction neither there was a letter from the UCO Bank nor a BR which amply demonstrate that no security was delivered. Though in respect of transactions 2, 3 and 4 certain securities were placed with A-3 by A-5, that really is of no assistance to A-5. If any security is received, the Bank ought to have made some payment and if the Bank has not paid to retain the security, it would have been required to deliver the securities based on the BR and/or its letters. The Banker's cheque issued by Canara Bank on MUL's account was received by Grindlay's Bank and credited to the account of A-5, and remitted to the Bombay Branch of Grindlay's Bank. There was an instruction from Grindlays Bank to credit the amount in the account of A-5 in respect of Banker's cheques of UCO Bank. Thus, UCO Bank did not receive any money in the transaction. (293-A, B, C, D, E, F) 2.7. For the first time before this Court A-5 took a stand that there was a transaction between him and the UCO Bank. Hence A-5 was the recipient of the money and he had derived benefit of it. (293-G) 2.8. Pay Orders of Canara Bank were collected by PW 16. These were deposited as though he was the payee. It is clear from the descriptions in the pay-in slips, letters written by his agent/employees to Grindlays

-+;I; (

-

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I.

Bank giving clear instructions to remit the proceedings of Pay Orders to A bis account. Receipts given by A-S in respect of the first transaction of certain units of UTI were in the records of MUL. It is clear from the resolutions and the minutes of discussion that MUL had not approved the role or involvement of AS and it was not known to the Board that the transactions were in reality with AS. The subterfuge adopted was to conceal actual state of affairs and to present a totally distorted picture. B (293-H; 294-A-BJ

.•

2.9. A Bank cannot act as a broker under the Banking Act. It is not one of tbe permitted acts. There is also not a question of paying of any commission on purchase/sale of transactions. Hence, the transactions are C not transparent. (294-HJ 2.10. MUL does not appear to have noticed about the role of the brokers. The decisions in question did not refer to A-5, but to UCO Bank, however, the beneficiary is A-S. The pay-in slips were filled up by PW-16 which indicate that the payment was made to A-S and in fact there was authorization from MUL in this regard. In Exhibit 38, A-3 has signed as "Accountant". The document uses the expression "cost". Though the receipt was from A-S, it was indicated as if it was from MUL. All the relevant vouchers show as if the sale of units was to Grindlays' Bank. Transactions show that payment was made to Grindlays Bank and not to UCO Bank and there was no question of MUL issuing the cheque to Grindlays Bank. It would have been to UCO Bank, Grindlays Bank made the payment and UCO Bank had nothing to do with MUL. The draft was in the name of UCO Bank. In essence, UCO Bank has not received any money from MUL. There was direction given by Grindlays Bank, New Delhi. All the vouchers that have been produced show that same are put through Grindlays Bank. The vouchers of MUL clearly show as if the transaction was between MUL and UCO Bank. (29S-A, B, C, DJ

-, _ J_

2.11. The evidence on record clearly shows that PW 23 was not only known to MUL but represented accused No.S and in particular to accused No.I. Exbt. 58 is the letter of the UCO Bank, Bombay wherein MUL had been instructed to deliver certain units to PW 3 whose specimen signature was attested by accused No. 3. Delivery of the said securities was effected to PW 23 by MUL and the receipt was passed by PW 23. The acknowledgment is on the printed stationery i.e. letter head of A-S. In respect of each of the transactions 2 to S, the pay orders issued by MUL through its Bankers, Canara Bank towards the consideration of the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] I S.C.R.

A security was handed over to PW 16 under instructions· of A-l or A-2. This

C

amply establishes that PW 23 was not a total stranger or unknown to accused 1 and 2 as claimed. His association with accused S also Is clearly borne out. It is unbelievable that to a stranger, PW 23, valuable securities of crores of rupees and pay orders were delivered by MUL for which receipts were issued on the letterhead of A-5. The evidence also shows that letters and the BRs issues by the UCO Bank, Bombay in the transactions addressed to MUL were first received in the office of A-S and were then passed on to MUL. (295-E, F, G, H; 296-A, DJ An attempt was made to as if there was no broker involved. Accounts were to be presented in such a manner that the role of A-5 would remain hidden.

2.12. So far as the Sth transaction is concerned, there is no letter or the BR. Though accused No.5 was the mastermind in reality, it reflects the involvement of several persons to present legitimacy while in reality D that was not so. Letters authored by A-3 made a clear representation to MUL as if it was transacting with UCO Bank. [296-EJ

>-- -

3.1. The essence of criminal conspiracy is an agreement to do an illegal act and such an agreement can be proved either by direct evidence or by circumstantial evidence or by both, and it is a matter of common experience that direct evidence to prove conspiracy is rarely available. Therefore, the circumstances proved before, during and after the occurrence have to be considered to decide about the complicity of the accused. [299-C)

....

Halsbury's Laws of England (4th Ed. Vol.11, page 44, page 58), referred to.

3.2. It is not always possible to give affirmative evidence about the date of the formation of the criminal conspiracy, about the persons who took part in it, about the object, which the objectors set before themselves and about the manner in which the object of conspiracy is to be carried G out, all this is necessarily a matter of inference. [301-C, DJ 3.3. The provisions of Section 120A and 120B IPC have brought the law of conspiracy in India in line with the English Law by making the overt act unessential when the conspiracy is to commit any punishable offence. [301-E)

Regina v. Murphy, (1837) 173 ER S02, referred to.

..L

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I.

Russell on Crime (12th Ed. Vol. /, P.202) and "Criminal law" by Glanville Williams (Second Ed P. 382), referred jo.

-" • ,.L

- -<

.. . .-"-

..__

__ J.

3.4. Where the conspiracy alleged is with regard to commission of a serious crime of the nature as contemplated in Section 1208 read with the proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 120A IPC, then in that event mere proof of an agreement between the accused for commission of such a crime B alone is enough to bring about a conviction under Section 1208 and the proof of any overt act by the accused or by any one of them would not be necessary. Sections 120-A and 120-8 IPC have brought the law of conspiracy in India in line with English law by making an overt act inessential when the conspiracy is to commit any punishable offence. In a C case where criminal conspiracy is alleged, the Court must inquire whether the two persons are independently pursuing the same end or they have come together to pursue the unlawful object. The former does not render them conspirators but the latter does. For the offence of conspiracy some kind of physical manifestation of agreement is required to be established. The express agreement need not be proved. The evidence as to the D transmission of thoughts sharing the unlawful act is not sufficient. A conspiracy is a continuing offence which continues to subsist till it is executed or rescinded or frustrated by choice of necessity. During its subsistence whenever any one of the conspirators does an act or series of acts, he would be held guilty under Section 120-8 of the Indian Penal Code. E [302-F, G, HJ S.C. Bahri v. State ofBihar, AIR (1994) SC 2420; E.K. Chandrasenan, v. State of Kera/a, AIR (1995) SC 1066; Kehar Singh and Ors. v. The State (Delhi Administration), AIR (1988) SC (1883), P. (1954); Ajay Agarwal v. Union of India & Ors. JT (1993) 3 SC 203; Yash Pal Mittalv. State ofPunjab, [1977) 4 SCC 540 and State of Maharashtra v. Som Nath Thapa, [1996) 4 sec 659, relied on.

3.5. It would be extremely difficult to find direct evidence in case of criminal conspiracy. The circumstances and surrounding factors have to be taken note of. In the instant case, the accused 1, 2 and 5 have submitted G that the role of PW-5 as described is that he did not want to be directly shown in the picture. In fact, A-1 wanted that MUL did not want to involve brokers and did not want to deal with them. This itself a fatal blow to the stand taken by the accused that there was no prohibition of acting through brokers and the intention was that dealing would be directly with the Bank and not through any broker or intermediary. Use of the expression H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] I S.C.R.

A "through" is indicative of the fact that emphasis was on securities being . ·'

c

not purchased in the open market, but "through" named PSU. These PSUs were admittedly not brokers. They were either Banks or financial institutions. Evidence clearly shows that A-S wanted that he will not directly come to the picture, and would not appear in the books of accounts of MUL; but he would stand to gain by way of commission and brokerage from the Bank. The statement of A-1 that he would look into any good proposals if A-S does not come to the picture shows that the actual state of affairs was intended to be hidden from the MUL authorities and a totally distorted picture was sought to be given. These are factors which clearly proves conspiracy. (306-E, G, H; 307-A)

4.2. To constitute an offence of criminal breach of trust, there must

E be an entrustment, there must be misappropriation or conversion to one's own use, or use in violation of a legal direction or of any legal contract; and the misappropriation or conversion or disposal must be with a dishonest intention, when a person allows others to misappropriate the money entrusted to him that amounts to a criminal appropriation of trust as defined by Section 405. The Section relatable to property is in a positive part and a negative part. The positive part deals with criminal misappropriation or conversion of the property and the negative part consists of dishonestly using or disposing of the property in violation of any direction and of law or any contract touching the discharge of trust. (307-G, HJ

...

-kh I

State of Kera/a v. P. Sugathan & Anr., [2000) 8 SCC 203, relied on.

4.1. Repayment itself is not an indication of lack of dishonest intention. It so happens that with a view to create confidence the repayments are made so that for the future transactions the money can D be dishonestly misappropriated. This is a part of the scheme and the factum of repayment cannot be considered in isolation. The repayment can be a factor to be considered while awarding sentence, but cannot be a ground for proving innocence of the accused. (307-B)

>r

4.3. The term 'entrustment' is not necessarily a term of law. It may have different implication in different context. In its most general signification all it imports is the handing over possession for some purpose which may not imply the conferring of any proprietary right at all. When a person misappropriates to his own use the property that does not belong to him, the misappropriation is dishonest even though there was an

)-

-

... --l...

... )..

J..._

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I.

intention to restore it at some future point of time. [309-C, DI

•

Jaswantrai Manila/ Akhaney v. The State of Bombay, AIR (1956) SC 575 and Jaikrishnadas Manohardas Desai and Anr. v. State ofBombay, AIR

(1960) SC 889, relied on.

,,,, • _!..

--<

.,

c

4.5. The accused persons have tried to take shelter behind what they have described as "market practices". Such practices even if existing, cannot take the place of statutory and regulatory function. There is no public interest involved in such practices and they cannot be a substitute for compliance with the regulatory or statutory prescriptions. An attempt was made to show that there was subsequent disapproval of the market practices; at the point of time when the transactions took place there was

-.. ,J,

"-·

..

4.4. In order to constitute an offence of forgery the documents must be made dishonestly or fraudulently. But dishonest or fraudulent are not tautological. Fraudulent does not imply the deprivation of property or an element of injury. In order to be fraudulent, there must be some advantage on the one side with a corresponding loss on the other, Every forgery postulates a false document either in whole or in part, however, small. [310-A, Bl

no embargo. Nothing plausible was found in these explanations. A practice even if was prevailing, if wrong, is not to be approved. The subsequent clarifications do not in any way put seal the approval of the practices E adopted on the past on the other band it contemns it. 1310-D-E-FI 4.6. When the factual background highlighted is considered in the light of the various provisions, it is clear that the offences under the Indian Penal Code alleged, have been established against the accused persons. The Special Judge was justified in convicting Al, A3 and AS, [310-GI

5, In view of the finding by the trial Court that A-1 in furtherance of criminal conspiracy, in his capacity as public servant abused his position by causing and/or allowing MUL's funds to be utilized for the wrongful gain of A-5, provisions of Section 13(l)(c) read with Section 13(2) are clearly applicable. Similar is the position vis-a-vis A-3. [310-HI

6. The offences in these cases were not of the conventional or traditional type. The ultimate objective was to use public money in a carefully planned manner for personal use with no right to do it Funds of the public bodies were utilized as if they were private funds. There was no legitimacy in the transactions. Huge funds running into hundreds of crores H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

A of MUL, a Government Company, were diverted and all the concerned

c

accused persons A-1, A-3 and A-5 played dubious roles in these illegitimate transactions. Their acts had serious repercussions on the economic system of the country, and the magnitude of financial impact involved in the present appeal is only tip of the iceberg. There were several connected cases and some of the prosecution witnesses in the present case are stated to be accused in those cases. That itself explains the thread of self-perservance running through their testimony. Therefore, the need to pierce the facadial smoke screen to unravel the truth to lift the veil so that the apparent, which is not real, can be avoided. The proverbial red herrings are to be ignored, to find out the guilt of the accused. [311-A-B-C-D] State ofGujarat v. Mohan/al Jitamalji Porwal & Anr., AIR (1987) 1321,

relied on.

7. Cases involving offences which corrode the economic stability are to be dealt with sternly. U is, however, noticed that A-5 has died during the pendency of the appeal, A-1 and A-3 were small flies who appear to have been caught in the web of A-S's machinations. Apparent reason for their involvement is greed and avarice. There may be substance in the plea that higher ups of MUL and Banks can not certainly be unaware of the goings on, and have not been proceeded with and given clean chit. Though this is certainly a matter of concern, yet that cannot be a ground for taking a sympathetic view of A-1 and A-3's conduct. Considering the fact that the occurrence took place a decade back, and the trial has spread over a few years, and the death of A-5, custodial sentence for the period already undergone would meet the ends of the justice. While fixing the quantum of sentence, the fact that the amounts have been paid back was duly considered. [311-H; 312-A, B, CJ

Per Shah, J. (Partly dissenting): 1.1. The SCAM Act was promulgated with a view to recover public monies lost by certain banks and financial institutions in securities where such losses arose as a result of such transactions. On the eontrary where G there were no losses at all, the institution of the Special Court was wholly unnecessary and the Special Court was not to try such transactions even if they amounted to·some technical offences. If these two propositions are correct, then there is simply no justification for the instant prosecution. [155-D]

1.2. The MUL resolution for investment of surplus funds inter a/ia

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I.

provides that it was open to MUL to invest the surplus funds in the units of Unit Trust of India through scheduled banks or directly to fetch higher . rate of interest than what is available on loaning of funds to PSUs without invoking any risk as to return of the principal and/or yield. It is also provided that Board has permitted the sub-committee which comprises of Chairman-cum-Managing Director and Director (Finance) to invest surplus funds of the Company in the purchase of units of UTI either through scheduled banks or directly. All the five transactions took place ..l. after the sub-committee passed appropriate resolutions. In one of the resolutions, it has been specifically mentioned that MUL may place funds 'with UCO Bank' in units for a period of five days as per the request from UCO Bank. The change of wording in the last resolution clearly indicates that funds were placed with UCO Bank for investment in units for a period of five days in anticipation of higher yield. In previous three cases, if in --; reality the funds were placed with UCO Bank then the phrase 'through UCO Bank' would not have been used. This change of phrase reveals that the nature of transactions was known to the Directors and that units were to be purchased for a limited period through UCO Bank. (220-G, H; 221-A-B; 228-F, G, H; 229-A]

""

.

'--

...

A.

•·

l_

1.4. The various resolutions issued by. MUL (Maruti Udyog Ltd.) reveal that proposals for investment of funds in units through UCO Bank for a specified period with the expected yield were received and it was resolved that MUL may place funds in units "through UCO Bank" as per the proposal. In the resolutions, the period of as well as expected yield was also mentioned which would indicate that as a matter of fact nature of such transaction was nothing but loan. Purpose of having UTI units was to secure repayment of loan. (228-E; 229-B( 1.5. During the last week of December, 1990 and in the month of January, 1991, the receipt of payments by MUL was relatively less and it was required either to borrow funds or withdraw money from PSUs. However, in the documentation, the borrowings were required to be shown as sale of investments. This would indicate that whatever may be the documentation of purchase or sale of UTI units, the same would not reflect the true and real nature of transaction. (229-C, E] 1.6. There is nothing on record to indicate that Chairman-cumManaging Director and Director (Finance), MUL who have passed the resolutions for investment of funds, did not know that disputed investment of the funds were meant for A-5 but they were not examined by the

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] I S.C.R.

A prosecution for reasons best known to them. [229-G, HI

1.7. It is difficult to imagine that Superintendent of Police, CBI would not be aware of the li:vidence Act which stipulates that he cannot depose on behalf of two responsible persons of MUL i.e. the Chairman and Managing Director of MUL and Director (Finance) of MUL. Whether they were aware of the fact that investment of the MUL funds to A-5 through UCO Bank tould have been deposed only by them and not by Investigating Officer. [230-CI

+

2..1. The Report of Joint Parliamentary Committee clearly

C established that Al or A2 were not having any dominion over the MUL funds. The assertions by the MUL before the JPC would certainly me~n that Al or A2 have not done anything dishonestly with the intention of causing wrongful gain to AS or wrongful loss to MUL or that Chairman and Managing Director or the Director (Finance) were not knowing about such transactions through UCO Bank. (235-D, E]

2.2. On the basis of evidence, it is also established that (1)

Resolutions used the phrase "through UCO Bank" whenever necessary. It also used the words 'with UCO Bank' or' '.with Bank' whichever is the Bank as per the nature of the transaction.

...il -

(2) Documents maintained by MUL do not reveal true state of affairs. (3) It is totally misconceived to hold that Al or A2 were having

any dominion over MUL funds/property. funds were to be invested as per the decision of the Sub-Committee consisting of Chairman-cum-Managing Director and the Director (Finance). (4) Resolutions passed by the Sub-Committee were approved by

the Board.

(5) MUL has clarified that the funds were invested as a commercial transaction for getting optimum yield and MUL has not suffered any loss in the said transactions. (6) Pending CBI inquiry, MUL considered that Al or A2 have

not committed any wrong and they were promoted subsequently.

_,,i.

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. (7) ~

As per suggestion of UCO Bank, cheques were issued by A Canara Bank in favour of Grindlays Bank. This was a commercial practice adopted by many Banks for tra11smitting the funds at the earliest. This practice rightly or wrongly was developed with the PSUs and financial institutions.

(8) PW4 admits that MUL used to invest in certain securities ~

,L

through brokers and the name of the broker did not figure or reflect on the record of MUL.

(9) That Al_ or A2 had not acted dishonestly in issuing cheques

in favour of Grindlays Bank for transmitting the funds of MUL to UCO Bank, Bombay.

-~

c

(10) Internal or statutory audit did not raise objection despite the fact that Comptroller and Auditor General had also audited the accounts. For these reasons neither Al nor A2 can be convicted for the alleged offences. No doubt A2 is already acquitted by the D Special Court. (23S-F, G, H; 236-A, B, C, D, E, F]

\. ~-

3.1. In view of the evidence, it can also be stated that all the five pay orders in connection with these transactions were sent for inter bank clearance by the Grindlays Bank. The amount was credited by "account payee" and "non-transferable" pay orders in the account of Grindlays E Bank. Under the circumstances, it is not necessary to discuss the relevant provisions of Negotiable Instruments Act that 'account payee' 'nontransferable' cheques cannot be credited in anybody else's account. As such, the entire prosecution against A4 was based on an erroneous assumption that A4 got the amount of 'account payee' cheque bearing stamp 'non-transferable' credited straightway in the account of AS. There F is nothing on record to establish who directed that the said amount should be credited in the account of AS. IO did not verify at whose instance the amount in question was specifically credited in the account of AS. Besides the evidence of PW12 also reveals that there was a practice of crediting the proceeds of the banker's cheques into the account of third party in G case of high-networth customers. (241-G, H; 242-A, B, C( 3.2. While convicting the accused, the trial Court has not been able to segregate the fact that even assuming that what was done by Grindlays Bank was irregular that does not necessarily mean that it was done by the appellant A-4. None of the witnesses of the bank have been able to

I

'll ,,-...._

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] I S.C.R.

A clearly point out as to when? the app-ellant was posted during the relevant period nor his initials were identified and nothing has been brought on record that he ~redited the cheques in the account of AS or he was concerned with the credit ()f the amount in question in favour of AS. In the absence of .ih.y such evidence, the charge under Section 120B and B substantivt offences under Section 409 are not proved against A4. 4.1. It emerges from the evidence that RBI Circular/guidelines came to be issued after the five transactions were over. The Circular specifically requests the banks to evolve investment policy to ensure that operations in securities are conducted in accordance with sound and acceptable C business practices. Prosecution has not brought on record the policy evolved by UCO Bank after issuance of this Circular. The guidelines would indicate that till the date of issue of guidelines banks were issuing BRs on behalf of their broker clients. There is no other prohibition under any law or guidelines debarring the banks from issuing any BRs particularly when the BRs were backed by necessary securities. (251-H; 252-B, E; 253-A, CJ

4.2. It is for the prosecution to establish that BRs were issued by A3 without being backed by UTI units. Admittedly, there is no such evidence. On the contrary, there is sufficient evidence on record that for the first transaction, MUL gave certain units for taking loan. As soon as the amount was refunded on due date, the said units were also received from MUL E by A-5. For the remaining three transactions admittedly BRs were received and this is also 'stated in the reply given by MUL to JPC. For the 5th transaction, as the BRs were not received by MUL, transaction was over within five days, but there is no evidence that UCO Bank was not holding the units for the said transaction. From the evidence on record it cannot be held that A3 had issued BRs without being backed by sufficient number F of securities i.e UTI Units. No witness from the Bank has stated that A3 was required to maintain the account for such transactions. On the contrary, if has come on record that practice of maintaining register was dispensed with because of inc.rease of workload with the Bank. The evidence on record clearly establishes that for the 5th transaction A3 G cannot be held responsible, because at the relevant time he was transferred from that Branch of UCO Bank. (253-D, E, G; 254-A, BJ 4.3. Resolutions passed by MUL also reveal that MUL was placing funds through UCO Bank in units. This phraseology used in the resolution does not reveal true colour of the transactions that MUL was not H ·purchasing and selling the Units from UCO Bank nor UCO Bank was

./

R.N. POPLl v. C.B.l.

...,..

'

selling or purchasing the units from MUL, It only meant that the A transactions were through UCO Bank. Seller or purchaser was a third person. In this set of circumstances, to say that A3 prepared forged documents that UCO Bank was selling or purchasing the units is totally misconceived and is against the documentary record maintained by MUL. (257-E, F(

•

.>-

4.4. Evidence on record estallllshes beyond any doubt that A3 was authorized to deal on behalf of the broker clients and if the broker client had instructed that amount be sent through Grindlays Bank, writing of such letter would not mean that he has committed any fraud. (260-B-CJ

c

·-<

... - jit_ -

4.5. A3 has been charged with forging the BRs on the ground that UCO Bank did not hold the units for which the BRs were issued. All the transactions are based upon the documents, which stand proved by the evidence of various witnesses of MUL, who signed the documents. The transactions were through UCO Bank. There is nothing on record to show that UCO Bank either purchased or sold the units to MUL. The charges D proceed on an incorrect assumption that the BRs were issued on behalf of UCO Bank. CBI has undertaken no investigation to discover whether the BRs were backed up by securities belunging to AS. Once it is held that the UCO Bank, Bombay was entitled to deal on behalf of their clients, then it would be difficult to hold that issuance of the said BRs by A3 was in any way forgery punishable under the Indian Penal Code. Issuance of BRs E on behalf of broker clients was part of commercial transaction. Routing facility was being given by the Bank to its customer prior to issuance of RBI Circular. Even RBI Circular does not prohibit issuance of BRs if properly backed by the security. The evidence on record nowhere establishes that the Bank was not holding adequate securities before F issuance of BRs. With regard to the allegedly forged typing of letters outside the office of UCO Bank, evidence of PW6 shows that in 1991 there was only one typewriter in the said Branch of UCO Bank to do heavy work in the office. Under the circumstances, document was typed out side the Bank. Hence, it would be difficult to infer that A3 did anything dishonestly, fraudulently or to defraud. (260-D, E, F, G, H; 263-E] Dr. Vim/av. Delhi Administration, (1963] Supp. 2 SCR 585, relied on.

J.....

5.1. There cannot be any doubt that those who are found guilty should be punished but the conviction must be on the basis of established criminal jurisprudence and not on moral or equitable ground or H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] I S.C.R.

impression created or gathered by the prosecuting agency. In the instant case, dealing in public funds was to a large extent, but that would not itself be a sufficient ground for drawing any inference in favour of the prosecution particularly when there is no evidence on record that MUL or UCO Bank suffered any loss or any of accused Nos. 1 to 4 gained anything. On the contrary, there is evidence on record that UCO Bank got commission from the said transactions. (265-G-H; 266-AI State (Delhi Admn.) v. Laxman Kumar, (1985) 4 SCC 476 at 505, relied

on.

C

-l_ .. I

5.2. Allegations in this case are that firstly, accused appropriated cheques issued by Canara Bank in favour of Grindlays Bank to himself. Secondly, that appropriation was misappropriation and, thirdly, it was dishonest. Under Section 405 IPC, essential ingredient which is required to be established would be 'dishonest misappropriation or use'. Primafacie, there is no law prohibiting the transaction as in the instant case nor it can be held to be an offence under any law. In such a transaction, there is no question of dishonest misappropriation. The Investigating Officer PW25 in his cross-examination, has stated that according to him, after the placement of funds with UCO Bank, the Bank would not be acting illegally if it places those very funds with a third party. (270-E, ff; 271-A, G)

j

Manakkal Narayan lttiravi Nambudiri v. State of Tranvancore, Cochin AIR (1953) SC 478, relied on.

5.3. MUL has passed a resolution to invest its funds with the PSUs or Banks or through PSUs or Banks. The word 'through' would certainly mean that it is not with the Banks because of the resolutions passed by the MUL, it cannot be held that there was any prohibition for the MUL to invest its funds through the Banks by giving loan to an individual. If Bank intervenes as the broker taking its responsibility on behalf of its client then it cannot be said that the transactions are illegal or fraudulent. Managing Director and Director (Finance) of MUL would have stated that they were or were not aware that loan amount was for AS. It is admitted that they were examined by the Investigating Officer who exercised his discretion and arrived at the conclusion that they were not required to be examined. In criminal prosecution, in such a situation, if any reasonable doubt arises, benefit would be in favour of accused. Adverse inference could have been drawn against AS if the amount was received by him without pledging any units with the Bank. It is the contention on behalf

.

,..L

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I.

-+ .,.

of A5 that UTI units were handed over to the Bank and on that basis BRs were issued by A3. However, prosecution has failed to establish that BRs were issued without being backed by the units. (274-B, C, D, E, F)

5,5. As 11er prosecution evidence the transfer of monies in favour of

AS from Canara Bank to UCO Bank at Bombay Branch via Grindlays Bank, such irregular unjustifiable liractlces had developed with certain Banks and even SDI had give11 Sl1Ch facility to AS (as per JPC Report). Under the circumstances, it cannot be held beyond reasonable doubt that A5 committed any offence punishable under Section 403 or abetted offence punishable under Section 405 IPC or has abetted any commission of offence punishable under Section 468 r/w Section 464 IPC. For the cheque issued by the Canara Bank in favour of Grindlays Bank, there is nothing on record that monies were meant for Grindlays Bank. (274-G, H; 275-A) ---< )

. ~

C

6.1. Transaction nos. 1, 2 and 3 had taken place prior to cut-off date prescribed under Section 3(2) of the SCAM Act Besides, prosecution has failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that accused have committed any offence. D Hence Special Court has no jurisdiction to deal these cases. (275-E, F] 6.2. There is no loss to MUL or to the Bank but as the loan amount is given to A5 by MUL through UCO Bank and as the loan is re-paid by AS, it cannot be held that AS committed the offence of mis-appropriation. (275-G]

6.3. In the instant case, it is very important to determine who is the controlling agent behind the act of the Company (MUL). If the Board of the MUL or the Management of the Bank were fully aware of such transactions, subordinates who carry out the transactions could not be held guilty as for the offences for which the accused are charged, mens rea must F be proved. Therefore, those who are responsible for taking such decision, could be prosecuted, but not those who are only carrying out directions on the basis that it is a commercial policy of the Company (MUL) or the Bank. As stated before JPC, it was an effort to maximise the yield or surplus funds of MUL and there was no need for the company to take any action against the officers. Prosecution has failed to prove its case G against the accused. (280-F, G, HJ CRIMINAL APPELLATE WRISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 1097 of 1999.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] 1 S.C.R.

From the Judgment and Order dated 27128.9.99 of the Special Court, Trial of Offences relating to Transactions in Securities Act, 1992, Mumbai in S.C. No. 6 of 1994.

+.

WITH Crl. A. Nos. 1117, 1141, 1150/99 and 521 of 2000.

C

Barish N.Salve, Solicitor General (NP), Ram Jethmalani, Rak'esh Dwivedi (NP); R.K. Jain, <;,.A. Sundram, Ms. Rani Jethmalani (NP), Ms. Gouri Kamna Das, Ms. Gitanjali Malviya (NP) Saurabha Avasthi (NP), PaIVez A Siddiqui, Ms'. Geetanjali Mohan, Barish Gulati, Mahesh Jethamalani (NP), Ms. Kamini Jaiswal, Mrs. Shomila Bakshi, Ms. Bipakkhi Brothakur, Ms. Aishwarya Rao (NP), Ajay Bhalla, P.K. Jain, Aron K. Sinha, R.S. Mhamane, A Subba Rao, P. Parmeswaran, Tara Chandra Sharma, Ms. Aparajita Singh, Ms. Sushma Suri (NP), Ms. Mennakshi Sakhardande, V. Madhukar, Adv. (NP), Ms. Gayatri Goswami (NP), Sidharth Chaudhary (NP) and Amar Jyoti Sharma for the appearing parties.

(

The Judgments/Order of the Court were delivered SHAH, J. The entire prosecution version is around the following five transactions entered into by Maruti Udyog Limited (hereinafter referred to as 'MUL'), through United Commercial Bank (hereinafter referred to as 'liCO Bank') wherein Barshad S. Mehta A-5 is payee or recipient of the amount, which are mentioned hereunder:Trans. A-5 Dates Days Rate of Amt. Rs. Interest Amount To % Rs. Repaid (Rs)

No. From

01. Lent 24.01.91 25.02.91 32 12.75 4,99,45,000 5,58,250 5,05,03,250 to

F MUL

Remarks-MUL delivered 35 lacs Units of UT! to A5. 02. Borrow-13.03.91 25.03.9112 16.75 10,11,50,000 5,56,995 10,17,06,200

-ed

Remarks-UCO gave BR to MUL for 70 lacs Units. 03. Borrow- 18.03.91 22.03.91521.0010,83,75,000 3,11,775 10,86,86,775 -ed

Remarks-UCO gave BR to MUL for 75 lacs Units.

../ -·"'· -

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

04. Borrow- 24.04.91 26.04.91 2 26.25 7,62,45,000 1,09,650 7,63,54,650

-ed

Remarks-UCO gave BR to MUL[or 51 lacs Units. ·05. Borrow- 02.05.91 07.05.91 5 25.00 10,39,50,000 2,99,090 10,42,49,090 -ed

Remarks-Number of Units not known but only value stated in chargehseet. Undisputedly, (a) the receipt and the payment of amount was for a fixed period; (b) interest rate was fixed and was received or paid as agreed; C (c) for the first transaction, before receiving the money, MUL gave UTI units as a security; for 2nd, 3rd and 4th transactions UCO bank issued Banks Receipts (BRs); (d) the transactions are squared-up on fixed date i.e. the amount is repaid on date fixed; (e) commission/brokerage is received and credited by the UCO Bank for which there are credit entries in the account D books; (f) there is no loss to the MUL and the UCO Bank; (g) accounts of UCO Bank are audited, no objection is raised by internal or external auditors; and (h) accounts of MUL are also audited and there is no objection raised by the internal or external auditors to such transactions; (i) no suggestion that any accused gained by such transactions except that A-5 got loan.

On the basis of the aforesaid special features of the prosecution story, the Special Court, Bombay under Special Court (Trial of Offences Relating to Transactions In Securities) Act, 1992, (hereinafter referred to as the "SCAM Act") in Special Case No.6of1994 [RC.2(A)/93-ACU-VIJ] tried five accused for the offences of cheating, criminal breach of trust, forgery by using forged documents, abuse of public offices and dishonest misappropriation of the F public funds under Section 120B read with Sections 420, 409, 467 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code (!PC) and Section 13(I)(c) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as "the PC Act"). A-I Pramod Kumar Pritarn Lal Manocha, A-2 Ambuj Sushi! Kumar Jain and A-3 Vinayak Narayan Deosthali were separately charged under G Section 13(l)(c) read with Section 13(2) of the PC Act as also under Section 409 of !PC. For being a Bank employee, A-4 Ram Narayan Popli was also charged under Section 409 of IPC. A-3 in addition was charged for the offence punishable under Section 420 IPC for cheating MUL and was also charged under Section 471 read with Sections 467 and 468 of !PC for fradulently and dishonestly using letter-heads and BRs of UCO Bank, Harnam H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

c

[2003] I S.C.R.

Street Branch, Bombay knowing the same to be false and forged documents as also forging certain documents to be used as valuable securities. A-5 Harshad Shantilal Mehta was also charged for the offence punishable under Section 403 of IPC. By judgment and order dated 27th/28th September, 1999, the learned Special Judge acquitted accused No.2 and convicted accused Nos. l, 3, 4 and 5 as under:1. "A-1 Pramod Kumar Pritam Lal Manocha, A-3 Vinayak Narayan Deosthali, A-4 Ram Narayan Popli and A-5 Harshad Shantilal Mehta are convicted being the parties to criminal conspiracy alongwith Mr. Mohan D. Khandelwal (PW23) between the period of April - May, 1989 to May, 1991 in Bombay and Delhi, the object of which was to divert the surplus funds of MUL lying with its account in Canara Bank, Sansad Marg, New Delhi branch to the account of A-5 HSM with ANZ Grindlays Bank, Sansad Marg, New Delhi branch and thereby committing offences of criminal breach of trust fraudulently using forged documents, abuse of public offices, dishonest appropriation of the amount of Rs.38,97,20,000 punishable under Section 120-B r/w Sections 409, 467, 468 and 471 of IPC and Section 13(l)(c) read with Section 13(2) of the P.C. Act, 1988.

2.

ACCUSED NO.I Pramod Kumar Pritamlal Manocha-

(i)

A- I is convicted for furtherance of criminal conspiracy in' his capacity as a public servant viz. being Deputy Manager (Finance) ofMUL at the relevant time, for causing and/or allowing MUL's fund wrongfully to be gained by A-5 HSM, being an offence punishable under Section 13(l)(c) read with 13(2) of the PC Act, 1988;

(ii) A-1 is convicted for offence punishable under Section 409 of IPC for committing criminal breach of trust in respect of property of Maruti Udyog Limited, Delhi, then Government company of 35 lakhs Units of UTI, valued at Rs.4,99,45,000 by dishonestly and in violation of specific directions of the Board of Directors of MUL, delivering the same to Mr. Mohan D. K.handelwal (PW23) in knowing that Mr. Khandelwal was an Attorney of accused no.5 Harshad S. Mehta;

(iii) A-1 is convicted for offence under Section 409 of IPC for

+

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

committing criminal breach of trust in respect ofMUL's property viz. Canara bank's bankers cheque no.645585 dated 13.3.1999 (Ex.13) for a sum of Rs. I 0, 11,50,000 drawn in favour of Grindlays Bank and made payees Ale only, by dishonestly delivering the same to Mr. Anuj Kalia (PW16) knowing that the said Mr. Anuj Kalia was an employee of accused no.5-HSM;

-+

(iv) A-I is convicted for offence under Section 409 of IPC for committing criminal breach of trust in respect ofMUL's property viz. Canara Bank's Bankers Cheque No.863260 dated 2.5.1991 (Ex.36) for a sum of Rs. I 0,39,50,000 drawn in favour of Grindlays Bank and made payees Ale only by dishonestly delivering the same to Mr. Anuj Kalia (PW-16) knowing that the said Mr. Anuj Katia was an employee of accused no.5 HSM; ---<

,._

3.

ACCUSED N0.3 Vinayak Narayan Deosthali-

(i)

A-3 is convicted for an offence under Section 13(l)(c) read with Sect'ion 13(2) of PC Act in furtherance of criminal ' io his capacity as a public servant viz. being Asst!. conspiracy, Manager of U~ Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay which is the Govern ent of India undertaking being a nationalised bank for abusing his position as a public servant and allowing use of funds of MUL to be wrongfully gained by A-5;

c

(ii) A-3 is convicted under Section 467 of JPC in furtherance of

criminal conspiracy, he on or about 23.1.1991 at Bombay having forged a letter dated 23.1.1991 (Ex.58) with the dishonest intent of authorizing remittance of MUL's funds of Rs.4,99,45,000 to Bank of America, New Delhi by accused No.5 to MUL, Delhi and further dishonestly authorizing the delivery of valuable securities of 35 lacs of units of UTI belonging to MUL to Mr. Mohan D. Khandelwal, an attorney of A-5;

(iii) A-3 is convicted under Section 468 IPC for having forged letter dated 23.1.1991 of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay intending that the same could be used for cheating;

(iv) A-3 is convicted under section 471 rlw section 467 and 468 of IPC for having forged a letter dated 23.1.199 I (Ex.58) of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay knowing it to be a false and forged document;

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

(v) A-3 is convicted under Section 467 off PC for having forged on or about 13. l.1991 the document to be a valuable security with the banker receipt No.1121 dated 13.3.1991 (Ex.38) for Rs.IO,l l,50,000 with intent to make MUL believe the UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay was holding 70 lacs units of UTI for the face value of 7 crores and which UCO Bank was to deliver to MUL;

C.

(vi) A-3 is convicted under Section 468 of IPC for forging valuable security with Bankers Receipt No.1121 dated 13.3.1991 (Ex.38) of UCO Bank for the sum of Rs. I 0, 1.1,50,000 in the name of MUL with the intent that the said document should be used for cheating; (vii) A-3 is convicted under Section 471 r/w sections 467 and 468 of IPC for dishonestly using forged bankers receipt No.1121 for the sum of Rs.I0,11,50,000 (Ex.38) as genuine;

(viii) A-3 is convicted under Section 467 of IPC for having forged at Bombay the letter dated 13.3.1991 (Ex.60) on the letter head of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay with the intent to dishonestly authorize remittance of funds of MUL amounting to Rs. I 0, 11,50,000 to Grindlays Bank knowing that the said remittance was meant to cause wrongful gain to A-5; (ix) A-3 is convicted under Section 468 of IPC for having forged the letter dated 13.3.1991 (Ex.60) intending that it should be used for cheating;

(x) A-3 is convicted under Section 471 r/w Sections 467 and 468 of IPC for having fraudulently and dishonestly used the letter dated 13.3.1991 (Ex.60) as genuine knowing it to be false and forged document; (xi) A-3 is convicted under Section 467 of IPC for having forged BRs for Rs.I0,83,75,000 (Ex.39) with the intent to make MUL believe that UCO Bank was holding 75 lacs units ofUTI of the face value of Rs.7,50,00,000 which UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay was to deliver to MUL; (xii) A-3 is convicted under Section 468 of IPC for having forged valuable security viz. BR No. l 132 dated 18.3.1991 for Rs.10,83,75,000 (Ex.39) of UCO Bank intending that it should

l R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH. J.)

be used for cheating;

-+

(xiii) A·3 is convicted under Section 471 r/w Sections 467 and 468 of IPC for dishonestly using the BR No.1132 dated 18.3.1991 for Rs.10,83,75,000 (Ex.39) as genuine; (xiv)A-3 is convicted under Section 467 of IPC for having forged valuable security of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay viz. BR No.166 dated 24.4.1991 for Rs.7,62,45,000 (Ex.41) with the intent to make MUL believe that UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch Bombay was holding 51 lacs units of UTI of face value of Rs.5, I 0,00,000 with UCO Bank to be delivered to MUL;

(xv) A-3 is convicted under Section 468 of IPC for having forged valuable security being BR No.166 dated 24.4.1991 for Rs.7,62,45,000 (Ex.41) with the intent to make MUL believe that it should be used for cheating;

C

(xvi)A-3 is convicted under Section 471 r/w Sections 467 and 468 of !PC for having fraudulently and dishonestly used the said BR dated 24.4.1991 (Ex.41) as genuine knowing it to be a false and forged document; 4.

ACCUSED N0.4 Ram Narayan Popli-

.. '<

(i) A-4 is convicted under Section 409 IPC for having dishonestly credited banker's cheques No.645532 dated 25.2.1991 for sum of Rs.5,05,03,250 (Ex.28), 646402 dated 18.3.1991 for Rs.10,83, 75,000 (Ex.32) and 863237 dated 24.4.1991 for Rs.7,62,45,000 favouring Grindlays Bank into the account of accused no.5 HSM ~ith Grindlays Bank, New Delhi instead of crediting the said Cheque into the account of Grindlays Bank, New Delhi;

S. ACCUSED NO.S Harshad Shantilal Mehta(i)

A-5 is convicted under Section 403 oflPC for having dishonestly misappropriated four bankers' cheques to wit:(a)

Cheque No.645585 dated 13.3.1991 for Rs.10,11,50,000, (ii) cheque no.646402 dated 18.3.1991 for Rs.10,83, 75,000, (iii) cheque no.863237 dated 24.4.1991 for Rs.7,62,45,000, (iv) Cheque no.863260 dated 2.5.1991 for Rs.10,39,50,000 [Exs. 30, 32, 34 and 36] aggregating to Rs.38,97,20,000 drawn by MUL on its bankers viz.

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) 1 S.C.R.

Canara Bank, Sansad Marg Branch, New Delhi in favour of Grind lays Banks.' Against the said judgment anq order, A-1 Pramod Kumar Pritam Lal Manocha has filed Criminal Appeal No.1117 of 1999, A-3 Vinayak Narayan Deosthali has filed Criminal Appeal No. I 141 of 1999, A-4 Ram Narayan Popli has filed Criminal Appeal No. -1097 of 1999 and A-5 Harshad Shantilal Mehta has filed Criminal Appeal No. 1150 of 1999. Against the acquittal order of A-2 Ambuj Sushi! Kumar Jain, Central Bureau of Investigation has filed Criminal Appeal No.521 of 2000. It is to be stated that pending hearing and disposal of these appeals A5 expired on 31.12.2001. Normally, appeal would have abated against him. However, his wife filed Criminal Misc. Petition No.574 of2002 on 16.1.2002 for continuing the said appeal. By order dated 24.1.2002, we granted such permission and appeal is heard on merits.

The prosecution version is that A-1 Pramod Kumar Pritam Lal Manocha was an employee (Dy. Manager) of MUL-a government Company as provided under Section 6(l)(vii) of the Companies Act; A-2 Ambuj Sushilkumar Jain was also an employee (Senior Executive) of MUL, who joined MUL on 19.4.1989; A-3 Vinayak Narayan Deosthali was an employee (Assistant Manager) of UCO Bank at Hamam Street Branch, Mumbai; A-4 E Ram Narayan Popli was an employee (Officer attached to the Remittance/ Clearance Section) of ANZ Grindlays Bank, Delhi Branch; and A-5 Harshad Shantilal Mehta was a financial broker operating in money market and securities. In short, it is the prosecution version that A- l to A-5 entered into a criminal conspiracy to siphon off the funds of MUL in favour of A-5 for F which afore-quoted five transactions took place, even though there was prohibition on granting loan by MUL to individuals. It is stated that A-1 and A-2 were working closely and they had dominion over the property of MUL. A-1 used to place the proposal before the Board and obtain approval for the investments. A-1 and A-2 used to give instructions on the basis of which letters addressed to banks were prepared. It is alleged that they misappropriated G the property in violation of the law as well as their duty (express and implied) by making it available for use of A-5. This is on account of the fact that they were authorised to invest the money in the defined securities in a transaction with Public Sector Undertakings only. They, however, knowingly entered into a series of transactions, which had the result of making the funds of MUL available to A-5.

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

It is also the prosecution version that they [A I, A2 and A3] being public servants during the material time, abused their position and thereby conferred a pecuniary advantage upon A-5 and in any event while holding office as a public servant obtained a pecuniary advantage for A-5 against public interest. Thus, they were charged with an offence u/s 13(1)(c) of the PC Act.

It is further stated by the prosecution that A-1 alongwith A-3, A-4 and A-5 conspired to obtain funds from MUL under the pretence that the funds were being drawn for purchasing securities from UCO Bank but diverted these funds to the accounts of A-5 for which A-I and A-2 played the role of misrepresenting to MUL and withdrawing the funds. A-3 forged documents which helped A-1 to secure the release of monies from MUL. A-1 conspired alongwith A-3 and A-4 for making money available to A-5, who became the prime beneficiary of the money. The bankers' cheques were handed over, on the instructions of A-1 and A-2, to Anuj Kalia an employee of A-5.

C

SUBMISSIONS -

Learned senior counsel Mr. Ram Jethmalani appearing for A-5 at the outset submitted that from the aforesaid five transactions, it is apparent that the investment/loan was for a short period. Yield - interest is at a higher rate. According to him, the amount is received and paid on due dates. There is no loss to MUL or to the UCO Bank and the Bank has received commission for the said commercial transactions. First transaction is loan taken by the MUL through UCO Bank from A-5 on the basis of 35 lacs of UTI units given by MUL to A5 through UCO Bank. It is his submission that in view of these facts it is apparent that prosecution is motivated and the conviction of the accused requires to be set aside.

For the prosecution, it is the contention of the learned Solicitor General Mr. Harish N. Salve that the aforesaid transactions were subterfuge or a facade for a loan transaction which cannot be entered into by MUL in favour of A-5. It is his contention that in the background of the resolutions passed by the Board of Directors of MUL and on the basis of the guidelines issued G by the RBI, MUL could not giv~ loan to A-5 and, therefore, there was a conspiracy between A-I and A-5 for diverting the funds of MUL by having subterfuge of sale or purchase of units of UTI by the UCO Bank to MUL. In furtherance of the said conspiracy, for 2nd to 5th transactions, A-I got issued cheques by the Canara Bank in favour of Grindlays Bank which in tum transferred the said amount in account of A-5, first at Delhi and thereafter H

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

at Bombay. ANZ Grindlays Bank's Bombay Branch issued cheque to UCO Bank at Hamam Street and from there the amount was paid to A-5. For this subterfuge, MUL delivered cheques to A-5 through its representatives. If the transaction was between MUL and UCO Bank, the cheque would have been delivered to the representative of UCO Bank either at Delhi or at Bombay. If there was a loan transaction between the MUL and A-5 then there was no necessity of issuing cheque in favour of Grindlays Bank at New Delhi and transferring the said amount to UCO Bank. It is the prosecution version that as the transactions were not genuine and as loan could not be given to A-5 in his individual capacity, it was given to A-5 by creating forged documents. He pointed out that after receiving the cheques issued by Canara Bank on behalf of MUL in favour of Grindlays Bank, the same were immediately encashed on the same day and thereafter Grindlays Bank, New Delhi again transferred the same to its Bombay branch in favour of A-5. Thereafter, A5 gave cheques to UCO bank. This itself indicates that as the transactions were not genuine, irregular and illegal procedure was adopted for encashing the cheques. Therefore, this is a case of misappropriation and forgery. Further, if there was genuine sale of units by UCO Bank to MUL, the transactions would have been straight forward between UCO Bank and MUL. It is the prosecution version that brokering by bank is not allowed and, therefore, to contend that commission was paid to UCO Bank is not a just ground for holding that there was no misappropriation or forgery. If there was a genuine transaction then the cheques would not have been issued in favour of Grind lays Bank for so-called expeditious movement of funds. If a person acts in a manner which is sinister or contrary to law then it cannot be said that the transaction was as per the commercial practice. It is a case of forgery because certain sets of documents are created where there is no real or genuine transaction. It is also contended that A-3 was not having any authority to purchase or sell units on behalf of the Bank. Secondly, he got letters. Exs.58, 60 and 6 I typed outside the office and nobody knows wherefrom the said letters were got typed and this would not be in normal course of business. This would be a most relevant factor for judging whether his act was dishonest or not. A-3 wrote a document, which he had no authority to write, with a specific motive to enable the transaction to be completed and money pulled out of MUL and he issued Bank Receipts (hereinafter referred to as 'BRs') without having security, namely, having UTI units. The learned counsel admits that there is no direct evidence on record to establish that BRs were issued

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. (M.B. SHAH, J.]

-j.

without possessing the units but inference can be drawn that the same were issued without holding units as A-3 has not maintained any record for this purpose. Contra, Mr. Jethmalani, learned senior counsel submitted that despite the voluminous record consisting of 40 massive volumes, the case remains a simple one. Admittedly, five transactions took place between MUL and A5 during the period from end of January to beginning of May, 1991. As per the first transaction, A-5 lent money to MUL. Loan period was for a period of 32 days and the interest rate was 12.75%. MUL returned the loan amount on due date with agreed interest. This was secured loan as MUL transferred and delivered 35 lac units of UT! to A-5. Though, formally it was an out and out sale by MUL to A-5, it was understood that this was only to secure repayment of the loan on due date. It is the case of A-5 that except for first transaction he borrowed money from the MUL because MUL had surplus funds which MUL were to invest and make substantial profits out of investment. A-5 returned the borrowed amount on due date with interest in each transaction. All the said four transactions were backed by BRs as collateral security and the BRs were backed by requisite number of units. Loan was for a short period e.g. 2nd transaction was for 12 days, 3rd was for five days, 4th was for two days and 5th for five days. Interest rate was also high i.e. 16.75%, 21%, 26.25% and 25% respectively. It is his submission that it is absurd to suggest that A-5 committed any offence or offences, but the prosecution is a piece of political revenge against A-5 for disclosing certain facts to the press against the political leaders. He conter.ds that transactions were loan transactions because in all these transactions the rate of interest and number ~f days for which the loan was being advanced was settled before the money and the units changed hands. This is consistent only with the transaction being a loan transaction. He also submitted that mainly the prosecution case in the FIR dated 15.4.1993 which was lodged after preliminary enquiry which started from 15.9.1992 as well as in the charge-sheet submitted by the CBI on 15.12.1994 was that MUL gave loan to A-5 at a lower rate of interest and suffered loss.

The learned senior counsel submitted that FIR was lodged after investigation for seven months and charge-sheet was submitted after more than one year and eight months, which itself indicates that CBI knew that there was no case to be put up before a Court and the investigation was kept

C

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

alive for sordid and dishonest motive. He pointed out that-{ I) the CBI itself understood that the FIR was based upon the one single allegation that MUL should have received more interest than it actually received. The chargesheet nowhere states that at the time of the FIR the nature of these five transactions was misunderstood or that they changed their mind after investigation; (2) paragraph 4 of the charge-sheet expressly confirms that the first transaction was loan transaction inasmuch as it is averred that MUL borrowed the amount at a higher rate of interest at 12.75% per annum for 32 days against physical delivery of 35 lacs Units of the UTI; (3) paragraph 5 of the charge-sheet refers to the transaction of· I3th March, 1991 which describes it as an investment of I 0 crores and odd from MUL for a period of 12 days at the interest rate of 16.75% per annum. This is nothing but a loan to Harshad S Mehta; (4) paragraphs 6, 7 and 8 contain similar descriptions of the remaining transactions:-

+·"

~

~

He further submitted that cheques were drawn in favour of Grindlays bank for expeditious transmission of amounts to A-5, the loan transactions D were only for a few days and if couple of days are lost in realising the amounts through normal banking pr~ctice, the accused was to lose lacs of rupees. For this, he relied on evidence of prosecution witnesses that such facilities were available only in foreign banks.

He contended that there is no evidence on record that Grindlays bank or the Canara bank had any objection to this course of dealing. He further contends that there is no question of conspiracy to siphon off the surplus funds of MUL as the amount was lent on security and repaid with interest on due dates. He contends that prosecution has tried to prove the theory of socalled absurd conspiracy by the sole evidence of approver PW23 and has failed to prove the same miserably. He pointed out that before taking loan, units of UTI were deposited or were with the UCO Bank and there is no evidence on record to establish that units were not with the UCO bank at the time when the BRs were issued. It is his submission that in a criminal prosecution it is absurd to suggest that defence has to prove that BRs were obtained without sufficient security. The prosecution witnesses of the UCO Bank have admitted that necessary record was not maintained by the bank because of heavy pressure of work.

>-.

,-4

.J__

It is also submitted that for similar transactions RC.8(BSC)/94/Bom. was lodged and a report was submitted before the Court stating that there was no case against the accused. After investigation, it was discovered that the

., ·C

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.)

BRs were indeed backed up by the securities, hence the CBI filed closure report dated 11.11.1994 Ex.A-5-116 before the High Court and the said report was accepted on 17.3 .1997. That order was upheld by this Court. However, the CBI proceeded with this prosecution for an oblique motive. In written submissions filed on behalf of A-5, it has been further stated that the charge against A-5 reads as under: "That you accused no.5 in furtherance of ihe aforesaid conspiracy did ·dishonestly misappropriate 4 banker's cheques to wit. Cheque No.645585 dated 13.3.1991, cheque no.646402 dated 18.3.1991, cheque no.863237 dated 24.4.1991 and cheque no.863260, dated 2.5.1991 aggregating to Rs.38,97,20,000 drawn by MUL on its bank to wit the Canara Bank, Connaught Place Branch in favour of the ANZ Grindlays Bank and you thereby committed an offence under Section 403 of the IPC." It is contended that the point of determination is - whether this charge is legally sustainable. In other words whether borrowing money on four occasions and returning it on the due date with interest is an offence under Section 403 of the !PC? The answer to this point is - a resounding No. The learned senior counsel further submitted that following are the ingredients of the offence charged above: (i)

C

that the accused appropriated the cheques to himself;

(ii) that the appropriation was a misappropriation; (iii) that it was dishonest. He submits that the first ingredient is satisfied-A-5 appropriated the cheques or their proceeds to himself. A person misappropriates only when he appropriates property to himself which in fact belongs to somebody else and he does so without that person's consent. Grindlays bank had not negotiated the loan for itself. Cheques were being issued for the purpose of lending money by MUL to AS. The cheques and their proceeds were meant for the accused and it was the accused who was receiving it by a pay order in the name of Grindlays Bank. It is not the prosecution case that the amount was in fact meant for Grindlays bank but it is the prosecution case that the amount was meant only for A-5. It is argued that when in the four transaction the loan was advanced by

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) 1 S.C.R. ·

MUL to A-5, it was done every time by a pay order. Under that pay order issued by the Canara Bank, it was to pay a sum of money to Grindlays bank. Grindlays bank acknowledged the receipt. This pay order had been given by the Canara Bank to an employee of A-5. The very fact that this was so handed over shows that Canara Bank must have received instructions from their own customer that the cheque be handed over not to an employee of Grindlays bank but to some other person. Further, it is submitted that the contention of the prosecution that the Grindlays bank should have first credited the amount to itself and then after some interval paid to its customer A-5, is without any substance as what has been do\le was only to expedite the payment so that the large amount of interest which was to be paid by A-5 may not go waste. What the Grindlays bank did was to provide a laudable legitimate banking service. In any event, every trifling departure from practice does not make the transaction illegal. At worst it is unusual, but not irregular. For this, it is submitted that PW12 Ashok Monga, Asstt. Manager, ANZ Grindlays Bank has fully supported the existence and propriety of this practice. The kind of pay order like Ex.30 has never been held to be a cheque. To hold it to be a cheque would lead to some absurdity. Section 128 of the Negotiable Instruments Act lays down that when a cheque is crossed, the banker on whom it is drawn shall not pay it otherwise than to banker. It is obvious that if the payee is itself a banker he cannot be expected to present it to another banker for collection. Grindlays Bank cannot open an account with some other bank and cash its Pay orders in that account. Even paying a crossed cheque otherwise than through a bank only renders the bank liable for negligence if somebody suffers a loss. If the banker is certain who the beneficiary of the cheque is, it may well pay out in the certain belief that no loss will occur. It is a manifestly untenable proposition that a criminal breach of trust or misappropriation thereby takes place. Even if it is assumed that the cheque was property of Grindlays bank, the bank cannot be said to have committed any offence by passing on its property to anybody it likes. By allowing the proceeds to be credited to the account of its true customer, the Bank is neither guilty of negligence nor of any criminality. Similarly, no oCicer of the bank could be held liable for the same and there is no question of any liability for A-5. There is no evidence that Grindlays bank or the Canara bank had any objection to this course of dealings. Certainly there was no intention to cause wrongful loss to anybody because no loss has been caused and no unlawful means were used. Learned senior counsel referred to the decision in Dr. Vim/av. Delhi

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

Administration, [1963] Suppl. 2 SCR 585 and submitted that unlike the above A case, every thing in the present case is above board, there is no deceit, there is no falsehood· and suppression of truth. It is contended that an approver's evidence cannot be accepted without corroboration and certainly not when it is in conflict with the unchallenged testimony of another prosecution witness. There was no justification for the Court to come to the conclusion that it is accused no.5 who is responsible for these pay orders being credited directly in his account. Of course, it is without prejudice to the arguments that the amount is not directly put into his account. It is contended that even though it was necessary to recall PW16 for the cross-examination on the new falsehoods which were introduced through the examination-in-chief and cross-examination of PW23, but the learned Judge dismissed the application filed on behalf of A-5 and it has caused incalculable damage. The illegality is of such vital importance that it vitiates the entire trial and judgment. The charge of conspiracy against A-5 is legally and factually absurd, false and frivolous. The alleged conspiracy is supposed to have originated in April/May, 1989. The sole prosecution witness who deposed about the alleged meeting of April/May, 1989 is approver PW23. The evidence discloses that PW23 had stated a willful falsehood in deposing about the said meeting. His own sworn testimony unambiguously establishes that the meeting alleged by him to have taken place could not and did not take place. According to him, the alleged meeting took place either in April or May, 1989 at the office premises of MUL, K.G. Marg, New Delhi. He is categorical that A-5 visited New Delhi once in April or May, 1989. In his cross examination on behalf of A I and A-2, he states that: "I cannot say about the frequency of visits of A-5, but I recollect he having visited Delhi once sometime in April, May, 1989."

C

PW23 makes passing reference to A-2's presence at the alleged meeting so that it could be said that it was a condonable lapso of memory on his part. On appreciation of his evidence, it cannot be said that he had an understandably G vague memory regarding A-2's presence; on the contrary, his deposition evidences vivid details about the role and participation of A-2 at the said meeting. Since A-2 could not even be present at the meeting as he was not employed with MUL on that date, it is abundantly clear that PW23 has deposed falsely about the meeting. If A-2 could not have been present at the meeting, PW23's insistence that A-2 was so present, leads to the irresistible H

) SUPREME COURT REPORTS

C

[2003) I S.C.R.

inference that his deposition regarding the alleged meeting is totally concocted. It has come on record that PW23 disclosed regarding the alleged meeting. only on I 0.8.1994. Indeed, the very suggestion by PW23 that a police officer who interrogated him would not question him about the circumstances of five transactions is absurd and incredible. The said meeting being a crucial aspect of the instant prosecution ought to have been referred to in the very first statement of PW23. The fact that it was not so referred to conclusively established that the meeting never took place and reference to it in PW23 's later statement of I 0.8.1994 and in his judicial confession recorded u/s 164 CrPC was at the instance of the CBI to whose suggestions he readily acceded in view of an agreement to make him an approver. It is further contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that in fact no such meeting ever.took place and consequently. the conspiracy charge insofar as it is alleged to have commenced from April/May, 1989 is unsubstantiated by any evidence and in fact falsified by it as(a) the veracity of PW23 has been destroyed in cross examination. He denied his taped conversation and feigned ignorance of police statement. He suppressed truth from the JPC. (b) Para 160 at page 294 of the impugned judgment, contains a legal error. The learned Judge treats as corroborative evidence what in law and common sense is not corroborative evidence at all. Learned Judge has held that evidence of Khandelwal is corroborated from what followed thereafter in the form of various transactions between MUL and A-5. It is contended that the conspiracy of 1989 cannot be corroborated by transaction in 1991. (c)

In charge no. I. one of the objects of the conspiracy is alleged to be 'dishonest misappropriation'. This has obviously reference to the 34th charge against A-5. On the facts this charge cannot be established. For the same reason the charge u/s 409 IPC against A-5 cannot stand. The other section mentioned is 420. The learned Judge has recorded no conviction under this charge and all the accused against whom this charge was framed are deemed to be acquitted of this charge.

The charge of conspiracy is cooked up to cover first three transactions which were prior to 1st April, 1991. Further, the RBI's Circular dated 09.9.1992 Ex.148 recognizes that there was a practice followed even by the Scheduled

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

-j

~

banks. When banks follow a particular practice they do so at least in the bonajide belief that the practice did not violate any law. If a practice is illegal, it may not convert that which is illegal into legal but it certainly provides for bonafides and absence of dishonesty. From this circular, it is clear that the scheduled banks were being advised against a practice which might put them in difficulty. They were running the risk of being responsible for unauthorized payments.

·"

.._

· .l._

MOTIVATION BEHIND THE INSTANT CASE: There are several salient features of the instant prosecution which clearly show that the entire investigation has been dishonest.

~+

It is almost trite to suggest that the SCAM Act was promulgated with a view to recover public monies Jost by certain banks and financial institutions in securities where such losses arose as a result of such transactions. It is equally trite to state the contrary proposition that where there were no losses at all, the institution of the Special Court was wholly unnecessary and the Special Court was not to try such transactions even if they amounted lo some technical offences. If the aforesaid two propositions are correct, then, there is simply no justification for the instant prosecution. The Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) succinctly set out the dimensions of the scam in its report. The Committee highlighted various irregularities and fraudulent transactions undertaken by the Banks and Financial Institutions etc. in the six reports submitted by it. Yet, inspite of all the above mentioned features peculiar to the instant case, the charge sheet in the present case was one of the earliest to be filed against A-5. In view of the palpable lack of nexus between the instant prosecution and legislative intent in enacting the SCAM Act the question can arise as to why the CBI chose to investigate and prosecute the instant case. This question has a clear answer that the CBI chose to pursue the instant case and other cases in which PW23 had acted on behalf of A-5 in New Delhi in transactions with public sector undertaking to intimidate and blackmail PW23 for not supporting A-5's public declaration from June, 1993 onwards that he had paid the sum of Rs. 1 crore to the then Prime Minister at his residence in Delhi. In simple words, if PW23-a vital witness in A-5's allegation against the then PM-supported the allegation of A-5, then he would be prosecuted along with accused no.5 in the instant case and other cases. If he cooperated and did not support A-5, he would be granted a pardon in the said

c

) SUPREME COURT REPORTS

c

cases. The forum in which the cooperation of PW23 was sought for was in proceedings before the JPC which inter alia was to inquire into A-S's allegation against Slui Narsimharao, the then Prime Minister. Following consequences of events conclusively establish the quid pro quo referred to between the CBI and PW23. (a)

In June, 1992, PW23 met the then Director CBI. This is admitted by PW23. The Director told him that if he wanted to disclose something, he should meet Mr. PC Sharma, the then DIG Special Investigation Wing.

(b)

PW23 met Mr. Sharma on a number of occasions thereafter.

(c)

JPC was informed by Mr. Sharma that PW23 was sent to him as a 'source'. What was the source disclosed to Mr. Sharma has not been revealed by the latter to the JPC as he did not wartt to betray his source.

t-

.... ~

~-

(d) Notwithstanding the fact tl1at PW23 first met the CBI as a source, a preliminary enquiry was registered in the instant case on 15.9.1992. (e)

13 members of the JPC in a separate note have described this change in status of PW23.

(f)

On 17th February, 1993, A-5's advocate addressed a letter to CBI about 4 cash withdrawals from banks in Bombay and Dellri between 2nd and 4th November, 1991 which according to him were politically sensitive in the extreme and stated that details of these would be revealed if A-5 was given assurance of complete protection from political harassment or persecution.

(g)

Although the CBI replied A-S's letter on 2S.2.1993 to the effect that it was beyond their power to grant such protection, they continued to make efforts in March, 1993 to obtain A-S's narration on the said cash withdrawals. It is only after they failed to obtain such a narration that the FIR in tlle instant case was filed on 15.4.1993.

(h)

(2003) I S.C.R.

The FIR of dated 15.4.1993 did not cite PW23 as an accused, despite the fact that PW16 was cited as an accused in the FIR. IO PW25 says that decision to name PW16 in the FIR was that of the Superintendent of Police V.D. Maheshwari and the investigating agency and that he had to agree with that decision.

x.

.A

_,l._

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

Further, they decided not to cite PW23 as an accused in the FIR.

-;

(i)

:+

The evidence of VD Maheshwari as a court witness completely corroborates the fact that the FIR was registered not because the investigating agency had applied its mind and such application had revealed to it that the case prima facie disclosed offences which deserved to be investigated but was to extort PW23's support in connection with the conditional disclosures that A-5 offered to make. Thus in his cross-examination on behalf of A5, he does not even remember the following(i)

whether he questioned A-5 before the FIR was registered;

(ii) whether he interrogated any of the other accused in the instant case before the FIR was registered;

c

(iii) whether he interrogated PW23;

(iv) whether he discussed the matter with the IO;

(v) whether the IO submitted any written report on the outcome of the preliminary enquiry; (vi) whether at the time of registration of the FIR he had determined the role of PWl6;

(vii) why PW23 was not named as an accused in the FIR which came to be registered; (viii) whether he personally referred to any documents before deciding to register the FIR.

All the above circumstances reveal the non- application of mind which the investigating agency displayed in filing the FIR. The only circumstance that Maheshwari recalls is that the decision to lodge the FIR was a unanimous one. (j)

The investigation concluded on 4.11.93 when the IO PW25 recommended the prosecution of all the accused including PW23. Although the investigation had ostensibly concluded, no charge sheet was filed. Obviously, the CBI was awaiting the outcome of the event.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(k) The JPC prepared its report in December 1993. In January 1994, the said report was made public. The report disclosed that PW23 fulfilled his part of the bargain with the CBI refusing to support A-S's public claim that the cash withdrawals made by him in November 91 were utilized for paying a sum of Rs.I crore to the PM, which claim became public by virtue of a press conference held on 16.6.1993. (I)

c

;f

(2003) I S.C.R.

In the very next month after the publication of JPC report, a charge-sheet was filed in a case dealing with the funds of Power Finance Corporation in which A-5 and PW23 were cited as accused.

(m) On 26.5.1994 PW23 made an application u/s 306 read with S.164 Cr.P.C. that his judicial confession be recorded and that he be made an approver in the instant case before the Ld. Special Judge, New Delhi who was seized of the charge-sheet in the PFC case. That application was rejected.

J

-f·.>

*

Thereafter, on second attempt, after his arrest on 10.8.1994, his confessional statement was recorded by another Magistrate and not by the Special Judge who rejected the application for pardon in PFC case. (n) Ld. CMM assigned the case for recording of confession to PW20 Dr. Ramkrishna Yadav, M.M., New Delhi who ultimately recorded ·the judicial confession (Ex. I 39) of PW23 on 21.10.1994.

).<,

Ultimately, the application for grant of pardon was accepted by the same Magistrate. Very soon, after the said pardon was granted, the charge sheet was filed on 6.12.1994 i.e. within a period of six weeks from the pardon being granted.

,..,

+--

(o) The absence of any loss to MUL in the instant case, the absence of proof whether A-5 made any gain in the instant case; the fact that the transactions took place at a time in which three of them were beyond the time period for which the Special Court exercises jurisdiction; the fact that all five transactions were prior to the RBI circular of 26.7.1991; the allegation of A-5 against the then PM; the abdication by the IO of the powers and

J_

~

_,k

l

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

discretion vested in him by the CrPC to his superiors in the CBI in the matter of proceeding with this case; the total nonapplication of mind of those superiors in lodging the FIR on 15.4.1993; the untenability of the charges both in law and in fact against all the accused, the manifest incompetence and negligence in investigation on the part of the CBI and the attempt to wilfully suppress material and politically sensitive documents in the case all indicate that the present case far from sub-serving the objects for which the Special Court was established, is a colossal waste of public time and money, a travesty of justice and an unfortunate reminder of how individuals subvert our criminal justice system by causing institutions like the CBI to file cases which are only vehicles to subserve their own private interests.

"'I

Lastly, the learned senior counsel for A-5 submitted that not only AS and others charged alongwith him be acquitted of all charges, but strictures against the investigating agency for bringing the system of criminal justice administration into disrepute be passed.

C

Before dealing with the contentions raised by the learned counsel for A-5 and CBI and before narrating submissions made by the counsel for rest of the accused, we would first refer to: -

A.

A.

Allegations in the FIR and charge-sheet

B.

Relevant Part of the Report of the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC).

ALLEGATIONS IN THE FIR AND CHARGE-SHEET.

The FIR was recorded on 15.4.1993 by the CBI after Preliminary inquiry which started on 15.9.1992, wherein it is inter a/ia stated as under:-

(i)

During Jan., 1991 to May, 1991 Shri Pramod Kumar was functioning as Dy. Manager (Finance) and Shri Ambhuj Jain was functioning as Sr. Executive in the Corporate Finance Cell at the Corporate- Office of MUL, New Delhi, and they were having control and dominion over the surplus funds of MUL which they were handling for investments with various agencies. These investments were being made in each case with the specific approval of a Sub Committee for investments consisting of Shri

)

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003] I S.C.R.

R.C. Bhargava then CMD MUL and S. Natrajan, then Director . (Finance) MUL. During this period MUL was a public sector undertaking and these officials were public servants. (ii) S/Shri Promod Kumar and Ambhuj Jain entered into a criminal conspiracy during the period from January 1991 to May 1991 at Delhi and Bombay with V.N. Deosthali an officer of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay, R.N. Popli of ANZ Grindlays Bank, Delhi and Sh. Harshad S. Mehta a broker, his employee Anuj Kalia and certain other unknown persons with the object to misappropriate the said surplus funds of MUL and to provide pecuniary advantage to Sh. Harshad S. Mehta out of the funds to be invested by MUL by abusing their official position as public servants.

'r--

-f .-

(iii) In pursuance to the said criminal conspiracy, Shri V.N. Deosthali

wrote a letter on 24.1.91 to MUL to effect physical delivery of 35 lacs units of UTI to Sh. Mohan Khandelwal, the attorney ~f Sh. Harshad S. Mehta and an amount of Rs.4,99,45,000 was credited to the account of MUL in Bank of America at Delhi out of the account of Sh. Harshad S. Mehta. This amount was borrowed by MUL at higher interest rate of 12.75% per annum for 32 days against physical delivery of 3 5 lac units of UTI. The physical delivery of 35 lac units was taken by Sh. Anuj Kalia on the basis of receipt given by Sh. Mohan Khandelwal on the letter head of Sh. Harshad S. Mehta. After expiry of 32 days the principal amount together with interest totalling to Rs.5,05,03,250 was refunded by MUL on 2.5.91 for this refund Sh. Ambhuj Jain obtained banker's cheque in favour of ANZ Grindlays Bank out of the account of MUL in Canara Bank, Sansad Marg, New Delhi and the cheque was delivered to Sh. Anuj Kalia, an employee of Sh. Harshad S. Mehta. Although the said cheque was in the name of ANZ Grindlays Bank, Shri R.N. Popli, officer of ANZ Grindlays Bank, Sansad Marg, New Delhi with oblique motive credited the same into the account of Shri Harshad S. Mehta and then transferred it to his account in Bombay. (iv) The transactions of 13th March, 18th March, 1991 and 24th April, 1991 are referred to in para 5. The said paragraph itself recites the number of days and the rate of interest.

,,+-

')<,

)

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.)

For these investments, Banker's cheques were obtained by S/ Shri Pramod Kumar and Ambhuj Jain from the account of MUL in Canara Bank, Sansad Marg, New Delhi in the name of ANZ Grindlays Bank and the same were collected by Shri Anuj Kalia who deposited the same into the account of Shri Harshad S. Mehta in ANZ Grindlays Bank, Sansad Marg, New Delhi. As these Banker's cheques were in the name of .ANZ Grindlays Bank, they should have been credited into the account of the bank but Shri R.N. Popli in connivance with his co-conspirators, credited the same into the account of Shri Harshad S. Mehta unauthorisedly. On reversal of these investments the amounts were credited in the account of MUL from the account of Shri Harshad S. Mehta. -+.

C

For the above investments, Shri V.N. Deosthali issued bogus bank receipts unauthorisedly in pursuance of the said conspiracy. With regard to the 5th transaction dated 2.5.1991, similar averments are made in paragraph 7. (v) The enquiry into the said PE disclosed that MUL, Delhi during the said period had invested its huge surplus amounts with other banks and public sector undertakings on higher rate of interest. Similarly, during the same period other public sector undertakings had invested their funds at much higher rates then the rate of interest on which MUL had made aforesaid four investments.

..

(vi) S/Shri Pramod Kumar and Ambhuj Jain in pursuance of said conspiracy misappropriated funds of MUL by abusing their official position as public servants in as much as they invested the funds of MUL at lower rate of interest and thereby caused pecuniary advantage to the co-conspirators and corresponding loss to the MUL. In the charge-sheet submitted on 15.12.1994, similar allegations are reiterated. Learned senior counsel Mr. Jethmalani pointed out that-( 1) Paragraph 4 of the charge-sheet expressly confirms that the first transaction was loan transaction inasmuch as it is averred that MUL borrowed the amount at a higher rate of interest i.e. at 12.75% per aonum for 32 days against physical delivery of 35 lacs Units of the UTI; (2) paragraph 5 of the chargesheet referring to the transaction of 13th March, 1991 describes it as an investment of 10 crores aod odd from MUL for a period of 12 days at the

)

C

[2003] I S.C.R.

interest rate of 16.75% per annum. (3) paragraphs 6, 7 and 8 contain similar descriptions of the remaining transactions. (4) Para 3 of the FIR is the basis for conspiracy during the period from January 1991 to May 1991. From the contents of the FIR it appears that A-1 and A-2 were investing surplus funds of MUL with various agencies. These investments were made in each case with the specific approval of Sub-committee for Investment consisting of Mr. RC Bhargava, the then Chairman and Managing Director (CMD), MUL and S. Natrajan then Director (Finance), MUL. Allegation in the FIR is that for the first transaction MUL borrowed the amount at higher rate of interest of 12. 75%. With regard to the remaining transactions it is alleged that MUL gave funds to A-5 at a lower rate of interest and thereby pecuniary advantage accrued to the borrowers and MUL suffered corresponding loss. Same is the position in the charge-sheet. Further, there cannot be any dispute that the FIR and the charge-sheet is the basis in a warrant triable case. Charges were also framed on the basis oi" FIR as well as other material produced by the investigating agency. The CBI itself understood that MUL should have received more interest than it ac.tually received. The charge-sheet nowhere states that at the time of lodging of the FIR the nature of these five transactions was misunderstood. Further, in the FIR as well as in the charge-sheet it is stated that conspiracy between the accused for the alleged transaction took place during the period from January 1991 to May 1991.

B.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

RELEVANT PART OF THE REPORT OF JOINT PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE (JPC).

JPC noticed the findings of Janakiraman Committee's Report submitted in May 1992 that unscrupulous brokers in collusion with certain bank officials had manipulated securities transactions of banks and financial institutions for their own purpose in a variety of ways and in clear violation of the established rules, guidelines and prudent business practices. Parliamentary Committee also noticed (i) number of irregularities including extensive use of BRs for ready forward transactions, (ii) issuance of number of. BRs on the basis of one outstanding BR and issue of BRs having no backing of securities, (iii) facilitating the brokers to take temporary position in Government securities without involvement of their funds by putting the transactions through brokers account and issuing BRs on behalf of brokers.

~

R.N. POPLI v. C.BJ. [M.B. SHAH, J.)

For the BRs, the Committee observed as under:

4.6 "The three instruments widely misused in the irregular transactions were (I) Bank Receipts (BRs); (2) Subsidiary General Ledger (SGL) transfer forms; and (3) Bankers cheques. BR is a non-transferable unstamped trust receipt issued by a bank selling securities when it is not able to effect physical · B delivery of the securities sold even after the receipt of the purchase consideration for reasons such as the securities are lying at another centre. In terms of the B.R., the seller bank undertakes to hold the security on trust for the purchaser for the short period till delivery and it is generally considered valid for C 90 days or till delivery is effected whichever is earlier. In the inter bank market, a large number of transactions in securities were being concluded by means of BR deliveries (instead of physical delivery of securities sold); however, there was no uniformity in the format of the BR and there were also not set guidelines for its usage. B.R. does not find a place in the Banking D Regulation Act, 1949. It was only on the 6th May, 1991 that IBA issued a circular prescribing a format and laying down certain broad guidelines and recommending its adoption by member banks and other financial institutions like IOBl/IFCI/ ICCl/NABARD etc. The RBI for the first time inter a/ia issued instructions to banks in this regard in their Circular of 26. 7.1991 E (Appendix-IX). A similar receipt issued by a non-banking financial company is termed 'Security Receipt' (SR) and such receipts also came to be freely used in security transactions.

>-·

4.32 The Committee is led to the conclusion that the BR system has been considerably misused. Every step should, therefore, be taken to prevent recurrence of such things in future. There is need for reforms of the BR system, for example, by way of reduction in the period of its validity and imposing of severe penalties for its

misuse. MANIPULATIONS TO FAVOUR BROKERS

.....

CREDITING OF CHEQUES TO BROKERS' ACCOUNTS 12.14 The scrutiny of securities transactions in a number of banks revealed that some banks were even handing over Account payee

•

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

c

cheques drawn in favour of other banks to the brokers who got them credited to their account ostensibly to assist the latter in transferring funds quickly to meet their obligations. As per informal understanding and in the name of market practice, the payee-bank used to credit the proceeds to the accounts of the broker constituents who brought the cheque to it for collection. These practices were in gross violation of the instruction that the accounts of banks with RBI, should be utilised only for genuine inter bank transactions and not for transfer of funds to their clients. The total amount diverted to the brokers accounts and the ultimate disposal of funds has not been determined. Some instances are however given below.

12.15 In respect of investment transactions between PFC and UCO Bank during the period.July, 1990 to May, 1991, 16 bankers cheques totalling Rs.394.23 crores were unauthorisedly issued in favour of ANZ Grindlays which were irregularly credited to the account of HSM.

ROUTING OF TRANSACTIONS

12.24 Many brokers e.g. HSM, HPD, ADN, Excel & Co., NKA etc. used some of the banks as 'routing' banks which carried iarge volume of securities transactions for them. Thus Andhra Bank, UCO Bank, BOK, Bank of Madura and ABFSL carried transactions of the value of over Rs.77,000 crores for brokers and others during April, 1991 to May, 1992. These banks, thus, provided special privilege to a select few brokers by lending their names to the transactions of these brokers totally disproportionate to the income derived and exposed themselves to great risk by irregularly issuing their own BR or SGL transfer forms against BR received or to be received in their favour.

SINGLE POINT CLEARANCE

G.

12.28 In the case of SBI, it was noticed that HSM had been unauthorisedly given the facility of collection and credit of the bankers cheques by SBI as per his instructions. The Bombay Main Branch of SBI acting as the agent of SBI Caps had debited SBI Caps account and unauthorisedly credited funds to the .account of HSM instead of making payments to named banks/

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH. J.]

institutions. Cheques drawn on UCO Bank had been credited to the current account of the same broker.

·+

.k

12.29 The Committee noticed in this connection that HSM had requested the Bombay Main Branch twice by his letter dated 19.8.91 and 10.01.92 for acceptance of bankers cheques from banks/organisations brought by him or his representative and issuance of bankers cheques there against. In fact, the broker wanted that the facility of 'single point clearance' whereby the activities of issuance and acceptance of bankers cheques in their account may be conducted through the Securities Division of the SBI Main Branch Bombay instead of the Personal Banking Division in the same branch where he had the account. This facility had enabled HSM to put through the transactions through the Securities Division itself and also to get bankers cheques in favour of SBI credited to his account and issue of cheques against the credits. The SB! in a note furnished to the Committee stated that the letter dated 19.8.91 was not traceable but the letter dated 10.01.92 did make a reference of the same. The Committee, however, obtained a copy of the letter dated 19.8.91 from HSM. In this letter, HSM while requesting for the facility of obtaining bankers cheques against presentation of bankers cheques in bank's favour argued that there would be no outlay of any funds by the bank. On the contrary, a good amount of sum will be left in current account for the bank to enjoy the float.

C

12.30 In his letter dated I 0.01.92, ti1e broker repeated his request and stated: "to facilitate a single point clearance, we have to request you to let the activities of issuance and acceptance of Banker's Cheques be conducted by the Securities Division. This will facilitate us to meet the deadlines of inter-bank

clearing timings." 14.21 The Committee note that the PSUs were the single largest source of surplus investible funds around Rs.36,000 crores between April 1990 and December 1992 only. In the investment of these funds guidelines and instructions were routinely flouted and no norms were observed Neither DPE nor the Ministries concerned took any steps to ensure the compliance of their guidelines. Even the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas

G .

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] 1 S.C.R.

which had made a review of investment of surplus funds by the PSUs under its administrative control in May 1990 closed its eyes knowing fully well that PSUs were investing with the foreign banks despite the guidelines of OPE that PSUs could have normal banking transactions only with nationalised banks.

B PLACEMENT OF FUNDS FOR SHORT PERIODSThe PSUs have placed funds with banks and finance companies for very short periods, sometimes for only a few days and even for one day implying supply offunds for speculative purposes to earn higher return. These banks/finance companies

14.98

c

issued BRs for the amount received. The PS Us after the maturity of investments returned the BRs and got their moneys along with the yield which was agreed to at the time of placement of funds. Thus these transactions were in the nature of ready forward deals instead of genuine investment transactions which was in contravention of RBI guidelines issued on 11.4.1988 which stated that sale and purchase of securities with the same party and for identical or similar amounts were construed as tacit arrangements which was in contravention of the instructions prohibiting buy back arrangements with non-bank clients.

DIVERSION OF FUNDS TO BROKERS14.114 While most of the PSUs/Organisations denied before the Committee about utilising the services of brokers, the Committee found

that in some cases inquiries/investigations by CBI/internal auditors clearly established nexus between brokers, officers of PSUsl banks resulting in syphoning offunds of PS Us to brokers. It is reported that 22 PSUs had placed funds to the extent of over Rs. 12,000 crores through Harshad S. Mehta which were syphoned of to him and his groups of Companies. Some instances are given below: -

(i)

(ii) In the case of Maruti Udyog Limited, it was found, that funds ofMUL meant for purchase of units from UCO bank were credited into the individual accounts of HSM. There is a financial involvement of Rs. 33.63 crores. (iii)

+·,

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.j

(iv) 17.48 On 16th June, 1993 Shri Harshad Mehta held a press conference in which he issued a copy of an affidavit of 24th February, 1993 and briefed the press of the details of the 4 specific withdrawals of 2nd and 4th November, 1991 and its subsequent disbursement. In a press conference held on the same day he released a copy of an affidavit dated 24th February, 1993 alleging that these were in connection with payment of Rs. I crore to the P.M. on 4.11.1991.

-+

18.5 HSM was summoned by the Committee again on 30.6.1993. During evidence when his attention was drawn to the inherent contradictions between what he had deposed before the Committee earlier and that given in the press conference he stated that he had been 'discrete' about the information given by him to the Committee. From the aforesaid part of the report, it is apparent that(a)

C

Some banks were even handing over account payee cheques drawn in favour of other banks to the brokers who got them credited to their account ostensibly to as,ist the latter in transferring funds quickly to meet their obligations. As per

informal understanding and in the name of market practice, the payee bank used to credit the proceeds to the accounts of the broker constituents who brought the cheque to it for collection. (b)

Routing of transactions facility was given to many brokers including A-5.

(c)

Single Point Clearance claimed by A-5 and given by SB!.

(d)

PSUs were investing the funds against the guidelines and

instructions. (c)

PSUs were investing funds for short periods for few days and even for one day implying supply of funds for speculative

purposes to earn higher return. (f)

In the investment of these funds guidelines and instructions were routinely flouted and no norms were observed. Neither OPE nor the Ministries concerned took any steps to ensure the compliance of their guidelines.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003] l S.C.R.

A RELEVANT PART OF EVIDENCE-

C

In the present case, the evidence runs into more than 40 volumes. However, at the time of hearing of this matter, on behalf of A-5, five transactions in question are admitted. Hence, it is not necessary to refer to or consider the evidence pertaining to the transactions in question. If the prosecution and defence had concentrated on the real issues for determination before the Special Court, it would have saved the Court's time in recordin~ evidence at such a length. Unfortunately, a practice is developed in criminal/ civil cases not to admit any document and thereby to prolong the litigation with impunity. For the purpose of deciding these appeals, it is necessary to only refer to relevant part of evidence which learned counsel for the parties have relied upon. For this purpose, we would divide the evidence and submissions as under:- [On behalf of] -

-r--

+-

(a) MUL;

(b) UCO Bank; (c)

(d) other relevant witnesses, such as, PW16 Anuj Kalia, PW23 Mohan D. Khandelwal (Approver) and PW25 1.0. etc.

(a)

ANZ Grindlays Bank;

WITNESSES FROM MUL [PWI, PW3 and PW4)

PWl Brijendra Singh Bhargava stated that he was Legal Advisor of MUL and at the relevant time Company Secretary and also internal legal advisor for the Company. It is his say that during May, 1989 to May, 1991 Mr. R.C. Bhargava was the Managing Director and Shri S. Natrajan was the Director (Finance). During the said period, MUL had several bankers, such as, Canara Bank, Bank of America and Bank of Tokyo. At that time, A-1 Pritam Lal Manocha was Deputy Manager, Corporate Finance and one of his duties was deployment of funds of MUL. He had power and authority to sign cheques on behalf of MUL and to operate its account. Mr. S. Natrajan was superior officer to A-1. A-2 was also an employee ofMUL since 1989. It is his say that surplus funds available with MUL used to be invested with the publ!c .sector undertakings and the Board of Directors had delegated the poWefs of

-~

+

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH, l.]

·1

deployment of funds to the sub-committee constituted by it. Such subcommittee comprised of Managing Director and Director (Finance), which would have final say in the deployment of funds, but there was a practice reporting the same to the Board of Directors in its meeting. The Corporate Finance department used to put up proposal for fund deployment before subcommittee. The sub-committee would then take decision one way or the other. He has produced relevant documents and the resolutions passed by the Board as well as the sub-committee. It is his say that he was broadly aware of the activities of Funds Investment Committee for the placement of funds. His office was also a section of Corporate Finance, which was located in a big open hall and they all were sitting adjoining to each other. Only the Director (Finance) was having closed cabin in the said hall, which has transparent glasses. It is his further say that the fact that MUL was having surplus funds was well known in the finance market and the large amount used to remain idle in the bank. Company felt that there was need of optimum utilization of surplus funds to get best possible returns. It is his say that four transactions of investment were approved by the sub-committee consisting of Mr. R.C. Bhargava and Mr. S. Natrajan and there was also discussion with him in respect of dis-investment of units of UT! on 24th January, 1991. It is his say that the investment and dis-investment transactions were placed before Board of Directors for information and Board had not raised any objection. In cross-examination, when he was asked whether he was aware that the representatives of the brokers representing the counter parties used to contact officials of the Corporate Finance Department, he stated, "according to him, the Director of Finance might be knowing about the same.''

,_

He also admitted that there was a system of internal audit and a statutory audit and aforesaid transactions would be covered by the same. Comptroller and Auditor General of India had also audited the account of MUL for the period in question arid they had made their comments as 'nil', which means they made no comments in respect of said five transactions.

C

He admitted that MUL has not lodged any complaint/FIR with the CBI nor made any complaint to anyone about the said transactions and according to him no loss was caused to the MUL in the said five transactions. He admitted that after CBI enquiry, the management of MUL did not

C

p

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

take any action against A 1 and A2 as it felt that A-I and A-2 were not guilty. The performance of A-1 was appreciated and he was subsequently promoted to the next level. He was also granted one additional increment. For that purpose, the relevant letters written by Mr. R.C. Bhargava, Chairman-cumManaging Director of MUL are produced on record. He has also admitted that A-2 Ambuj Sushilkumar Jain was also promoted by the management on considering his perfonnance and merits. He further admitted that Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) was constituted by the Parliament for the purpose of inquiring into various securities transactions and MUL was required by the JPC to clarify certain queries in respect of its securities transactions including those transactions which are subject matter of this case. It is his say that he was associated along with Director (Finance) Mr. A.R. Halasyam and Mr. RC Bhargava, ChairmanCum-Managing Director for the preparation of the reply to be given to the JPC. Besides, some officials from Corporate Finance were also associated in the process of preparation of replies. Reply was based on the information and record furnished and made available by Corporate Finance. It is his say that Mr. R.C. Bhargava was summoned by JPC. Next witness from MUL-PWJ Mr. Agharam Ramakrishnan Halasyam was the General Manager (Finance) since 1985 till the end of I 989; in 1991 he was promoted as Chief General Manager (Finance) and thereafter was promoted as Director (Finance) from Ist June, I 991. According to him, in 1991 MUL used to have surplus funds, which were invested in UTI and PSU bonds. It also disinvested the same when funds were required. This was done by the Corporate Finance Cell. For this purpose, Corporate Finance Cell used to get quotations from different banks for different kinds of securities and Finance Cell used to evaluate quotations received from the banks in terms of yields. After such evaluation, Director (Finance) used to be apprised and then a decision would be taken depending upon the best yield possible. Thereafter, an agenda used to be put up to the Director (Finance) for a final decision and that A-1 used to convey such offers to Director (Finance) orally. A-1 also used to put-up a written note about the proposals of investments before the Director (Finance). It is his say that such deals were directly discussed with the counter party and such investment deals were not put through any individual by MUL on principal to principal basis. He stated that in respect of five transactions being the subject matter of this case, he was not having any personal information. However, when he took over as a Director (Finance), the same policy about the placement of funds continued. It is also his say that

-+-

).__

J

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH. J.]

i71

BR held by MUL is discharged when the duration of investment gets over. He admitted that looking at the BR of UCO Bank (Ex.41 dated 24.4.1991) for identification) no suspicion would arise on the face of it. With regard to all five transactions, he stated the same thing. In further cross-examination, he admitted that issuance of BR necessarily indicates that the bank issuing it would be holding the security covered under the said BR. The BR would also acknowledge the receipt of monies from MUL for the purchase of security. He further agreed that in respect of three transactions dated 13th March, 1991, 18th March; 1991 and 24th April, 1991, the payments made from MUL were for buying securities and securities were received and the subsequent delivery of the securities involved receipts of payment by MUL. For these transactions, MUL had also received the payments with agreed yield. Jn the last transaction of May, 1991, MUL made payment for the purchase of securities. In the said transaction, MUL had received money with agreed yield. In respect of disinvestment transaction dated 24.1.1991 MUL delivered the securities against the payment and on reversal received the securities and made the payment.

)-

He further admitted that MUL had not suffered any monetary loss in any of the five transactions. In the five transactions there was optimum yield and utilization from the point of investment by MUL. MUL used to have large amount of surplus funds for investment. Every day there used to be such investment transactions for and on behalf of MUL on short term basis. This fact was well known in the financial market. He also admitted that afrer he took over as Director (Finance), he heard about some of the brokers on behalf of some financial institutions/banks making offers to MUL. Such services included delivery of securities, delivery of offers and other connected documents including delivery of BRs. He further stated that essentially most of the offers in respect of placement of funds which MUL used to receive were on telephone. In case of investment for a short period i.e. for couple of days (for two or three weeks) there might not be written proposal and he had heard this while discussing with A-1 and A-2. He also admits that with regard to the JPC, he was concerned with the queries received by the MUL and their response. One Mr. Surender Singh was then the concerned Secretary. He was a Director of MUL representing Government of India. He himself and the Managing Director had occasion to discuss with him about the queries received as also the response that MUL was to make. Response which MUL gave was with the approval of Mr. Singh. This witness has proved the agenda notes and resolutions passed by the

C

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) l S.C.R.

Sub-Committee of MUL. Prosecution has also examined PW4 Rajan Ramgopal, Executive, who at the relevant time was posted as Accountant and working in Corporate Finance Cell under A- I and A-2. In examination-in-chief, the witness has stated that MUL through its Finance Cell used to deploy its surplus funds in Inter Corporate Deposit with Public Sector Undertakings and al~o invest in securities through Banks and also through brokers quoting on behalf of the banks. For this purpose, the office was receiving telephone calls directly from the banks as also from brokers acting on behalf of the banks. Similarly, MUL also used to make calls for the enquiries to the banks as also the brokers. It is his say that in case of incoming calls, the calling party would disclose its identity and would inquire about A-1 or A-2. In case both being busy then he used to take down the particulars furnished by the calling party and then pass on to A-1 or A-2. The calling party would ask whether MUL has any surplus funds for deployment in securities. They used to pass on the said message to A-1 or A-2 and inform what the other party had offered.

He also states that the name of broker did not figure or reflect on the record of MUL in the event of transaction of investment being through the Broker. It is his further say that PW2 Mr. Meda Sai Swaroop, who was the concerned Manager of the Canara Bank after preparing bankers' cheque as E per their instructions would hand over the same to him and he in turn used to hand over the cheque to the representative of the said bank or brokers' represel?tative. It is his say that because of pressure of work, they were not going to the respective banks and instead handing over the bankers cheque to the representative of the bank or to the broker under the instructions of either A-1 or A-2. In cross-examination, he admits that during the relevant F period foreign banks used to effect transfer of monies from one city to another much faster than the national banks and they were able to do so during the banking hours of the same day. He came across transactions where SBI Capital Market Services had done transactions both of receiving monies and paying it to them on the date of maturity which payments were made or reused through Bank of America. He further states that the brokers who used G to contact them on behalf of their bank clients and financial institutions during the relevant period were:-DSP Financial Services, Hemdev & Sons, B.D. Agarwal & Co. and one Mr. Asit Mehta. Finally, he admits that writing contained on all the vouchers and its language was his and he used expression as either 'through UCO bank' or 'through ANZ Grindlays bank' because H transactions in question were between MUL and the concerned banks. He

-~.

/

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

failed to give any explanation as to why he did not use the expression 'with bank' instead of 'through bank" (b)

-+

......

•

WITNESSES FROM UCO BANK [PW7, PW14, PW21 and DW.A-3(2) AND PW2 FROM CANARA BANK[.

PW7 Mr. Pradip Anant Karkhanis is a dismissed employee of UCO B Bank. He is one of the accused in a security scam related case being case no.5 of 1996 pending on the file of Sessions Court, Greater Bombay. He had worked in the Hamam Street Branch during the period July 1976 to September 1980 and September 1990 to April 1992. During his second posting, he worked as Sr. Manager and was over all in-charge of the said branch. It is C his say that he was not familiar in detail with the working of the security department of the said branch. The security department used to attend the security transactions on behalf of the head office as also on behalf of the clients which also included brokers. The branch was not concluding deals in the security transactions, in case where such transactions were on behalf of their bank and the same used to be concluded by the Head Office. The D transactions in securities included both sale of such securities by UCO Bank as also purchase. It was only the Head Office which was concluding deals of sale of the securities, inviting the proposals etc. As per instructions of the head office, Hamam Street branch used to receive the sale proceeds and deliver the securities to the purchasing bank. The branch used to receive E instructions in respect of such concluded deals from the head office over telephone. During the relevant period there were no hard and fast rules and any officer including the witness used to receive such telephonic instructions from the head office in respect of security transactions. The securities sold by their bank were not delivered in a physical form and their branch used to issue mostly SGL Forms. In case of some of the financial institutions, the F delivery used to be in a physical form of security. During his tenure in Hamam Street Branch in one or two cases BRs were issued. As per format of a BR at least two authorized officers were required to sign the BR. There were three types of head office accounts with their branch i.e. Director Head Office (DHO), Inter Branch Transaction and Block Account. It was not G permissible to use the said accounts for any individual. While working in Hamam Street Branch, sometimes he came across few brokers including Harshad S. Mehta whom he met once in his office along with Mr. S.V. Ramnathan, the then Divisional Manager of the bank. He never came across transactions known as buy back or ready forward. He came across transactions known as switch transactions, wherein security is received from one bank H

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003] 1 S.C.R.

and delivered to the other bank. During the relevant time, a doubt was entertained in respect of switch transactions, the Zonal Manager and Divisional Manager took the decision to stop the said practice. After one week, the Divisional Manager phoned Hamam Street Branch and asked them to resume such transactions. Accused no.3 was not authorized to conclude transactions in security on his own on behalf of the bank. On seeing the Jetter dated 23rd January, 1991 addressed to MUL, containing signature of A-3, it is his say that it was not within the authority of A-3 to address such letters. He agreed

-

that Switch transactions were the transactions conducted by the UCO Bank for buying and selling the securities on behalf of its clients including brokers. The negotiations in respect ofsuch transactions were conducted by the clients directly with the counter party. UCO Bank used to act as a routing bank in such transactions. The said transactions were done through the brokers' accounts and were not treated as transactions of UCO Bank. He did not know whether such transactions were ever undertaken by their head office. The Hamam street branch used to conduct its transactions on the instructions of the head office and under the instructions of its clients on their behalf.

D UCO Bank used to undertake such transactions on behalf of its clients on charging its commission and that the bank had made substantial profit by undertaking such transactions. In 1990, he noticed that the bank has conducted

such transactions for about 9 brokers. In January, 1990, Mr. Barve who was also one of the Managers in Hamam Street Branch informed the Divisional Manager and Zonal Manager the names of 18 such brokers for whom UCO Bank was doing switch over transactions. Because of increase in deposits, Hamam Street Branch of UCO Bank was upgraded from medium to large branch. He has further stated that the bank was charging the commission for routing such switch over transactions but did not agree that it was so doing for lending its name as suggested. According to him, routing transaction means-UCO bank used to receive bank receipts from one bank and against it the bank used to issue BRs to other bank. It is also his say that in some cases their bank received bankers cheques from one bank and UCO bank issued its bankers' cheques to another bank. Whenever switch over transactions

used to take place under the instructions of the brokers, the brokers'

G instructions to receive or deliver securities were sent to the counter party along with the cost memos and BRs. The BRs and cost memos used to be of UCO bank. The brokers instructions used to be on the letter head of the broker. The purpose of sending brokers instructions along with various documents to the counter party was to put it on a proper notice.

It is his further say that although he was overall in charge of Hamam

...

R.N. POPLJ v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

-

•

Street branch of UCO bank all the debit and credit vouchers of that branch A were not being received by hin1 every day. He was fa1niliar with what is meant by 'day book' which was kept and maintained by the bank. All the debit and credit vouchers would be reflected in the said 'day book' on particular day including in subsidiary book. Such 'day books' used to come to him every day. He knew that securities transactions on behalf of brokers were taking place but he had no detailed particulars thereof. By going through the B debit and credit vouchers it was not possible to get such details or particulars of such transactions. Credit voucher in a security transaction would contain the particulars such as a nomenclature of security, face value, rate etc. The name of the counter party may not necessarily be reflected in such vouchers. He might have seen some credit vouchers but he did not remember. He did C not remember whether the names of the counter party were mentioned in those vouchers which he might have seen. It is his further say that there used to be 30 to 40 switch over transactions every day. The strength of the staff available in the said department was adequate enough to handle the volume of work in such transactions. Such transactions were to be completed on the very same day during the banking hours. There used to be auditing of the D Hamam street branch. This auditing used to be done by internal auditors, external auditors and also by the statutory auditors. Between September, 1990 to April, 1992 during his tenure one internal inspection and one statutory audit took place in respect of Hamam Street branch. He had gone through both these audit reports and no adverse comments were made over the switch E transactions.

PWl4 Prem Shanker Joshi, who was Assistant Chief Officer in Merchant Banking Division, situated at YWCA Building, Madam Cama Road, Bombay, stated that in the year I 992, he was transferred as Manager in Security Section of Hamam Street Branch of UCO Bank and thereafter he F was promoted as Sr. Manager in the year 1993. To a que;tion-What was the nature of the business conducted by the security cell?, -he replied- as far as Hamam Street Branch was concerned, the said branch used to conduct the security transactions on behalf of their head office as well as on behalf of clients. Mr. Harshad S. Mehta was one such client. In case of sale transactions G on behalf of their clients, they used to get written instructions from their clients, having necessarily their accounts with the bank. Such written instructions would be addressed to the Branch Manager. The instructions being for the sale of the security, they were ascertaining from their clients about the availability of the security with the bank or the time of delivering of security to the bank. On receipt of the security, they were preparing a cost H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

memo as per instructions of their client as contained in his instructions letter. The officers working in the security department were authorised to sign the cost memos and such authorised officer used to sign the same. Their bank was receiving payment in accordance with the cost memo from the counter party and on receipt of such payment they were delivering the security in B question to the counter party. Without security in the hands of the bank, they were not preparing the cost memo and sending it to the counter party. He admitted that UCO Bank, Hamam Street branch can issue a BR while dealing on behalf of its client in the security transactions provided there is a back up security of the client. He further stated that BR should not be issued on behalf of the client in absence of security or back up security. In case of security C transaction on behalf of the client, they credit the sale proceed receipt into the account of client. They were preserving and keeping the original letters so .received from the client and instructions received from the head office by telex or fax messages. In respect of security transactions executed for and on behalf of head office, Hamam street branch used to debit and/or credit direct D head office account (shortly known as 'DHO account'). It is his further say that the officer working in Hamam Street branch could not enter into any purchase transaction in security on behalf of head office without instructions from head office. Similarly, on behalf of the client, the officer working in Hamam Street branch could not enter into a purchase transaction in security without instruction of a client. He admitted that Hamam Street branch of E UCO, Bank was not maintaining security account, either security wise or otherwise, of the clients. However, the record in respect of security transactions put through head office was maintained in the Hamam Street Branch in a Security Register. On. perusing the BRs Exs.38, 39 and 41(1), he admits that the said BRs were issued in respect of Security Transaction put through on behalf of the Head Office or the client.

~

It is his further say that for head office transactions they used to give expressions such as HID i.e. Head Office Instructions to Deliver and HIR i.e. Head Office Instructions to receive. For clients transactions they were using expression of ID i.e. instruction to deliver i.e. sale and IR instructions to receive i.e. purchase on behalf of clients. On seeing Ex.34, he stated that there is an inscription at the left hand top comer reading as 'Payees Account only' and that being so, the said instrument has to be deposited in the account of Payee named in the said instrument i.e. UCO Bank. Such instrument like the pay order shown to him cannot be deposited in the account of any third party. Payer bank has to give covering letter instructing them to deposit the said pay order into the third party account, if so required. Such instruction

•

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

letter containing instructions of the payer bank are preserved along with other related records such as vouchers in their office. On seeing the delivery order Ex.A-3(2), he stated that the said letter is the letter of instruction received from A-5 Harshad S. Mehta addressed to UCO Bank without the name of its branch. By reading the said letter, it is noticed that the same contains. instructions to UCO Bank.

-+

PW21 Mr. Makarand Vasant Shidhayajoined UCO Bank on 8.5.1972. He has stated that he was named as one of the accused in five Security related scam cases along with the other accused which are on the file of Special Court. On 1.10.1982 he was promoted as an officer. During January, 1991 to May, 1991, he worked as an officer in Hamam Street Branch in security department. During the said period, V.N. Deosthali, A-3 also worked in the said branch as an officer. He himself and A-3 were empowered and authorized to sign BRs, bankers cheques and all other related vouchers for and on behalf of their bank. The head office used to conclude its deals in Securities, and Hamam Street Branch used to execute the security deals of their head office as per advice received from zonal office, MBD Department and Division Office. No officer or an employee working in Hamam Street Branch was authorized to conclude any security deal on behalf of their head office. Officers working in Hamam Street branch were not dealers and their job was only to execute the security transactions of the head office as per their instructions. One Harshad S. Mehta (A-5) had his current account with their branch and he was knowing him. He came across a person by name Mr. Pankaj Shah working with Harshad S. Mehta, who sometimes used to come to Hamam street branch in connection with brokers security transactions. It is his further say that no record in a form of security ledger or security register broker wise was kept and maintained in respect ofsecurity transactions of their broker clients. Initially, there used to be such record but because of increase in the transactions in security on behalf of their broker clients in large numbers, the practice of maintaining of such record was discontinued. There were no guidelines formulated or received in this regard in their branch. On seeing Ex.106, xerox copy of the delivery order dated 25.2.1991 on the letter head of A-5 Harshad S. Mehta, it is his say that the same is delivery order of Harshad S. Mehta addressed to UCO Bank containing instructions to deliver 35 lakhs units of UT/ to MUL. The question put to the witness was-whether the above document (Ex. I 06) is the sale of the security by the broker client or the purchase? To that, he replied-by the said delivery order Harshad S. Mehta has instructed UCO Bank to deliver 35 lakhs units to MUL. He was unable to say whether the said delivery order represents sale

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] 1 S.C.R.

A of the security by Harshad Mehta to MUL. On seeing the carbon copy of credit voucher of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch dated 13 .1.1991, he stated that the same is in the handwriting of Mr. V.N. Deosthali (A-3) and also bears his signature under the caption of Asstt. Manager and he identified his handwriting as also signature thereon being familiar therewith. The same B also bears initials of Mr. H.l. Naik, the cashier of the branch.. He further identified the signature of A-3 Deosthali on a debit voucher dated 13.3.1991 of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, being the commission from various securities. He was further shown BRs of UCO Bank and he stated that the same were issued by the UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch and have been signed by him in the caption of accountant and he signed the said BRs after C he found the contents thereof to be true. With regard to the BR dt.29.4.1991 contain.ing signature on its reverse, it is his say that the signature on the reverse of BR signifies reversal of the BR meaning thereby that the counter party had received the security and obligation of UCO Bank, who had issl'f'' the said BR stood discharged.

DW-A3(2) Mr. Sekharipuram Vasudevan Ramnathan-Chief Officer, UCO Bank stated that he joined services of UCO Bank at c;alcutta in the year 1969 as Probationary Officer. In June, 1990 he was brought to Bombay Office as Divisional Manager in its Nariman Point Office and he worked at the said office till October, 1992. Thereafter, he was transferred to Bhuvaneshwar, Orissa. Since February, 1993 he has been under suspension. On seeing the letter dated 8.1.1991 written by Divisional Manager to Senior Manager, Hamam Street Branch, he stated that the letter bears his signature as being writer of the said letter and he identified the same. He also identified the initials of Karkhanis on the same and stated that he- was working as Senior Manger in the said UCO Bank's branch at Hamam Street. On seeing letter dated 17.3.1992 written by D.M. to Zonal Manager, Zonal Office, General Admn. Department, Bombay, he stated that he was the a•Jthor of the said letter and the same bears his signatures. He has further stated that he is one of the accused in Special Case No. I of 1993 on the file of the Special Court. In connection with the said case Mr. Bhaskar Raichoudhary the then Zonal Manager in the rank of DGM was arrested in Special Case No. I of 1993 who later on was turned to be an approver. There is no departmental proceeding or inquiry instituted against him either by UCO Bank or Central Vigilance Commission in that matter. A question was put to him-What was pre-condition to use BRs in the security transactions and how transactions in securities by means of BRs used to be

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

put through at the relevant time.

His answer to the above query was that-the bank would issue its BR only against back up of another BR i.e. the BR issued by other banks in favour of UCO Bank stating therein that the said issuing Bank held the securities in question with it. BRs could be issued on bank's own behalf as also on behalf of its customers. When UCO Bank is selling its security on its

own, it would issue its BR favouring the counter party bank. In case of

· I-

purchase by UCO Bank the process would be vice a versa i.e. other counter party bank would issue its BR favouring UCO Bank. When UCO Bank would act for a customer while issuing its BR, same position would exist as far as back up of the security except that it would debit or credit, as the case C may be in the customers account. No bank can issue its BRs in the name of any party other than banks and financial institutions.

On seeing letter dated 8.1.1991, he stated that UCO Bank had stopped the routing transactions facility to all the brokers and its customers earlier to t/;e said letter. The brokers represented that their certain security transactions were in the pipelines to be routed through UCO Bank and hence

this letter was written. Since there were no definite guidelines, they had certain apprehensions i.e. when pay orders for purchase and sale did not ,A··

come in time, they might not be able to send them in time and the clearing may go against them. Therefore, routing facility of the brokers/customers was stopped by the UCO Bank. He further stated that no officer of UCO

Bank working in Ha1nam Street Branch was authorised to lend or borrow

monies on behalf of UCO Bank.

-

He explained the routing facility as-routing transactions is the transaction in which purchase and sale of the securities was done by the bank as an agent of its customer for a commission. The Routing facility was offered to many brokers including A-5 in the year 1991 and such brokers availed ofthe said facility. Such routing facility was already in practice even before he joined as Divisional Manager in June 1990. Some banks were offering such facilities. He was an accused in two special cases before the Special Court and the said cases did not relate to the security transactions concerning routing facility. He further stated that a bank can issue its BR against physical security and SGLs held by it in addition to the BRs which it may hold. He was aware about a meeting between the officers of RBI and the officials of all the banks about reconciliation of outstanding banks receipts. To his knowledge, there were no outstanding BRs against UCO Bank. One

-t

/

\

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

A Mr. R. Venkatakrishnan, the then GM, Treasury and Investment Management Department attended the said meeting on behalf of UCO Bank.

~

Letter dated 8.1.1991 (Ex.231) written by the Divisional Manager, UCO Bank, Divisional Office, Bombay to the Senior Manager, Hamam Street Branch for switch transactions reads thus-

"Re: Switch Transactions. We refer to your letter No.BR:002:91 dated l.l.1991 on the subject matter.

c

After stoppage of the switch transactions by us, all the Brokers called on us as well as Zonal Manager and Zonal Manager had also discussion in this regard with Mr. Venkatakrishnan, General Manager, subsequently, based on the discussions Deputy General Manager and the undersigned had with all the brokers and based on tL~ understanding that Branch will never run into a difficulty and day on account of switch transactions and because the brokers have already entered into contracts with various banks to route the transactions through UCO bank on various dates up to end of March, 1991, it was decided to resume the switch transactions on the following terms: (1)

The resumption is temporary and that bank after having detailed discussion further with individual brokers and after discussion with various bankers who are dealing in switch transactions and who are not dealing in switch transactions may discontinue routing this transaction through UCO Bank depending upon our findings.

(2) The brokers will give us an advance list of transactions they are going to put through. (3) They will deliver the pay orders well in time to the Branch so that this can be sent in clearing in time. If there is a delay in receiving the pay orders, bank will be perfectly in order to refuse to accept the same and allow the transaction. In case on account of any brokers delay, bank is put into difficulty the concerned broker will be paying interest to the bank at call money market rate for one day on the amount transacted on his behalf.

(4) Bank may at its discretion increase the commission ·which is

-+·

+-' :-

...., ~

~

__,...

R.N. POPL! v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

only Rs.300 per crore at present.

(5) Special case should be taken that clearing particularly on Saturdays does not go against us on account of switch transactions. In fact, it will be better to avoid switch transactions on Saturday. (6) Only straight forward transaction either on SGL or BR should be routed through Bank and the brokers will have to give an undertaking to this effect.

In the meantime, the undersigned is contacting the brokers separately and is having discussions with them. Two such brokers have already had discussions C with the undersigned. Shortly the matter will be discussed with a couple of other brokers also. You are advised to contact other banks through whom such transactions are routed and have detailed discussions with them regarding their experience, the commission they charge, the modus operandi and their opinion why other banks are not entering the field. You are also advised to contact other banks who are not having such transactions and have discussion D with them with a view to find out why inspite of profitability in this area they are not entertaining this and give at your report at an early date." PW2 Meda Sai Swaroop, who was the Manager in the Parliament Street branch of Canara Bank at New Delhi, stated that after preparing the bankers' cheque, the same would be handed over as per instructions contained in the instructions letter or to the bearer of that letter. He has identified the signatures of Anuj Kalia, to whom the bankers' cheque was handed over. It is his say that in all the cheques in question there were cross lines on the left hand top comer of the said pay order which indicate that the amount of the said pay order was to be credited into the account of payee only as named therein i.e. Grindlays Bank. On the right hand top corner of the said pay order, 'not transferable' was also printed. This would show that it was only the payee of the said pay order which was entitled to receive the credit of the

said pay order. In the cross-examination, he has stated that he was sure that

payee banker i.e. Grindlays Bank had received the credit under the said pay order and that Canara bank was not concerned as to what Grindlays bank did with the proceeds of the said pay order. (c)

WITNESSES FROM ANZ GRINDLAYS BANK (PW9, PWl l, PWI2 and PW15 AND also PW22 Ex. RBI Officer] PW9 Ravi Saluja, was an employee of ANZ Grindlays Bank. During

SUPREME COURT REPORtS

(2003) 1 S.C.R.

A the period 1990 tit! May, 1991 he was posted at Karol Bagh branch of the said bank as an officer. It is his say that ANZ Grindlays bank has a department known as clearing department and he is acquainted with the procedure of clearing department. He has stated about the procedure how the clearing aspect is processed. According to him, the account holder of the bank is required to deposit the cheque meant for clearance by filling in slip known B as pay-in-slip or deposit slip mentioning particulars such as the date of the deposit, name of the account holder, the nature of account, the account number, the amount of the deposited cheque, the name of the bank, its branch and number of the cheque to be deposited. The cheques so received for clearance were then sent to the clearing department for further processing. The said C department would verify and tally the particulars as appearing in the pay-inslip and the related cheque. The centralized branch then would make the consolidated statement and arrange to send the cheques received for cleara.nce to the clearing house of RBI. There is also category of cheque known as bankers' cheque, that is to say, a particular bank issues its cheques in favour of another bank. In such a case, the issuing bank can use the format of pay D order also. If such bankers cheques are made payees account only then the same are not transferable. On seeing Ex.28, he stated that it is inter bank cheque in favour of Grindlays bank issued by Canara bank bearing stamp 'Payee A/c only' and 'not transferable' .. There is a rubber stamp of Grindlays bank on its reverse indicating that the said banker's cheque is cleared. It is E his say that Grindlays bank would dispose offthe proceeds of tile said cheque as per the covering letter. It is his further say that without instructions of Canara Bank, Grindlays bank could not credit the amount of the pay orders Ex.28 and Ex.30 to any thirdparty's account. He identified A-4 R.N. Popli, an employee of Grindlays bank, but stated that he was not aware about his posting during the relevant period i.e. from the year 1990 to 31.5.1991.

PW/I Suraj Amarnath Tandon, Assistant Manager of ANZ Grindlays Bank, stated that from March, 1990 to March, 1992 he worked as Second Officer, Front Office in Sansad Marg branch. It is his say that on the receipt of the instruction letter of the customer, their bank used to put its rubber stamp in token of receipt of such letter indicating date and time of its receipt. On seeing the letter, Ex.73, dated 26.4.1991 of Harshad S. Mehta addressed to the Manager Grindlays Bank, he has stated that by that letter Harshad S. Mehta (their account holder) instructed them to issue a bankers cheque for a sum of Rs.7,63,54,650 favouring Canara bank for the benefit of MUL. As per the sa_id letter, they issued bankers' cheque on the date itself for the amount ~ mentioned above and handed over the same to the bearer of the

+-

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

>

said letter, Mr. Anuj Kalia, who has received and acknowledged the receipt A of the said pay order by signing the same at the right hand bottom comer ·of th.e said letter. A debit voucher in respect of issuance of the said pay order was prepared with one original and one carbon copy. The original was sent to Mr. Harshad S. Mehta and carbon copy thereof was retained in their office.

PWl2 Ashok Kumar Anant Ram Mo·nga, Asstt. Manager, Grindlays Bank stated that during the year 1991 he was posted in Sansad Marg branch. He identified A-4 R.N. Popli as the person who also worked in the said branch along with him as officer in charge; clearing department. He was overall in-charge of the said branch along with the Manager and in that C capacity, he used to have supervision over the working of the concerned clearing department. He was shown bankers cheque Ex.28 favouring Grindlays bank, having rubber stamp in the left hand top comer reading as 'Payee Account only' and on the right hand side top corner reading as 'Not transferable'. The witness stated that since the Canara Bank is the drawer of the said cheque and the Grindlays bank who is the payee in respect of the D cheque bearing endorsement 'not transferable' and 'payees account only', therefore, cheque irrespective of whoever may have deposited, Grindlays bank would not credit the amount of the said cheque into the account of any third party other than in its own account. It is his further say that the entry in respect of the amount as reflected in Ex. 71 (3) in statement of account and E in the said. pay in slip will have to be authorised by the officer in charge of the clearing department who was at the relevant time A-4 as the amount involved was more than a lakh of rupees. He could not identifY the initials appearing on the said pay in slip, who authorised the said entry. He stated that in these types of transactions, two authorizations were required, the first authorization related to giving credit to the third party which is generally F given by Branch Manager marketing department who are known as Relationships Manager or Account Manager and lastly the Funds Manager. Only after the first authorization has been received the officer in-charge would proceed to indicate his second authorization by authorising transactions for posting on computer system i.e. the pay in slip is authorised to be used G as authorised voucher for posting on computer system. During the period when the transactions covered by Ex.28, took place there was a market practice followed by various banks to present bankers cheques through a Special Clearance settlement which is known as inter bank settlement. The objective of drawing the bankers cheque was to provide speediest or fastest clearance of such instruments which was not possible through other clearing 'settlements H

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003] I S.C.R.

available to the customers, namely, MICR. If the instrument is cleared through MICR cleafl\ilce, the customer gets funds only on third day. The other settlement introduced by RBI in the year 1985 in response to the needs of the business community as a mode of faster settlement or cheques, also took minimum two days to provide clearance of cheques. He was shown entry Ex.71(4) dated 13.3.1991 into the accounts of Harshad S. Mehta. He stated that the then officer in charge of clearing department had authorized the said entry to be made in the statement of account. He could not recall the name of the said officer who was in charge of clearing department. He agreed that in 1991-92 there was a practice of crediting the proceeds of the bankers' cheques i»to the account of third party other than its payee. However, it was e:Jctended to only certain high networth customers like British Airways, Classic Financial Nizhewan travels and Harshad Mehta Group, which list is not exhaustive and he came across the instances in case of the said parties where their bank had allowed such credits. He further agreed that RBI had never takefi any action against the Grindlays bank in respect of five pay orders shown to him earlier. He was aware that RBI possessed the power to take action against any errant bank. The Grindlays bank had not received any complaint from MUL for crediting the amounts of said five pay orders to the account of third party. When the instrument like pay order is drawn favouring Grindlays bank then the same has necessarily to be deposited in Grindlays bank account with RBI. He was asked about the category of customers regarded as High Networth customers. He replied-such classification is generally given by the concerned manager of the bank having regard to the deposits maintained by the customer or other business potentials. Any officer working in the branch of their bank having any doubt was certainly approaching the Branch Manager for clarification and ifhe could not answer then it was being taken to the Area Manager. The services to be extended to the customers like high networth customers would be decided by the branch manager. Such decision could not be taken by the concerned officer who attended such customers. In the cross-examination, it is his say that all the five pay orders which were shown to him being Ex.28, 30, 32, 34 and 36 were sent for inter Bank Clearance by the Grind lays bank. The amount of these pay orders was debited into the account of the issuing bank and credited into the account of Grindlays bank. The account of the issuing bank and payee are with the RBI. He admitted that it is only after credit of the proceeds of the said five pay orders in to the Grindlays bank account that the proceeds thereof in turn were credited into the account of A-5. PW15 Mr. Kanwal Krishan Kuda, Bank Officer, ANZ Grindlays

--<

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH, l.j

Bank stated that in the month of March, J991 he was posted in Sansad Marg Branch, New Delhi as Officer Jn-charge Remittance Department. He identified A-4 R.N. Popli as the person working in the same branch in different department of the pank. It ia his further say that he is also one of the accused in a case w)]jQh has been Instituted by the CBI in the Court of Special Judge at Delhi being CBI Case No.RC-2A/92 ACU-(1) which is still pending. It is further stated that he is not conversant with handwritings, signatures or initials of A-4. The activities which they carried out in the Remittance Department were Remittance of funds from one branch to another branch or another bank, cheque collection, cheque purchases, standing orders etc. During the course of his work, he came across Payees Account Cheque, Pay-in-Slip, debit vouchers and credit vouchers. With regard to the credit voucher dt.26.4.1991 into the account of Harshad S. Mehta, it is his say that the same was approved by him and it bears his initials. The entry appearing therein is correct and the same was prepared on the basis of credit advice received from the RBI. It is his further say that Grindlays Bank did not receive any instructions from RBI for crediting the amount of the two vouchers shown to him earlier into the account of Harshad S. Mehta, The cheques being the subject matter of the two credit vouchers shown to him were not deposited in the department where he was working. The same were deposited in the treasury department in the same branch. It was the treasury department to which they used to send the said cheques for clearance. He could not recollect who was or who were the concerned officers of the treasury department who would be giving such instructions as there were many such officers. The instructions were conveyed to him orally and he considered the same to be in proper order. PW22 V. Rangarajan is an ex-employee of RBI. He joined R.B.l. in 1961 as a Junior Officer and retired in 1997. It is his say that in December, 1990 he was elevated to the position of Additional Chief Officer and was posted in Department of Banking Operations and Developments (DBOD). It is his say that the commercial banks have their account with RBI. Individual persons are not eligible and entitled to open their account in any form with the R.B.I. The bankers cheque/pay order issued by one bank favouring other bank are negotiated as under:-

C

"The payee bank would deposit the cheque for clearance in clearing house and RBI would settle the payment thereof by giving credit into the account of payee with RBI." The witness was further questioned-Is it permissible to deposit an

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

A account payee bankers' cheque favouring another bank in the account of unnamed persons as per the clearing house rules? The witness replied Clearing House rules relate to the settlement of cheque issued by one bank in favour of another bank and therefore the accounts of both the banks are involved in this transaction.

c

-"<

For hig~lighting the submission made by the learned counsel for the accused, we would refer to the relevant questions and answers given by this witness"Q. The practice of crediting proceeds of the Bankers cheques to third parties is not prohibited by any Banking law or any guideline, rule or circular of the RBI.

A. (Witness refers to portion of the circular Ex.148 in para 2 reading as under in answer to the said question;

'If any bank credits the account of a constituent who is not the payee named in the cheque without proper mandate of the drawer, it does so at its own risk and will be responsible for the unauthorised payment' ..

Q. (Witness is referred to portion of his depositfon in para 18 on page 495 in question and answer form (witness is questioned). Whether the practice of crediting the proceeds of Bankers cheques to unnamed beneficiaries was not violative of any specific banking law or any RBI circular or guideline on the subject?

A. The same would not violate any Banking law as I understand. As I am not aware of issuance of any prior circular on the subject I cannot say of !,ts violation.

Q.

The circular Ex.148 was issued w~~,ih~_approval of the then Governor of RBI who was Mr. Venkataramana 'at the relevant till_le.

~-

(Witness is again referred to portion of Circular Ex.148 in the second para reading as:

'If an bank credL .......... for the unauthorised payment'. -.y·

Q.

Does the use of the word 'Unauthorised' referred to the fact that the issuing bank may not have· authorised the payee bank to credit the amount into the account of third party?

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

A.

Yes. The said aspect has been further clarified in the said circular (Witness refers to the following portion of the said circular) reading as:'ln the case of 'account payee' cheques wherein a bank is a payee, the payee bank should always ensure that there are clear instructions for disposal of proceeds thereof from the drawer of the instrument'.

The Circular dated 09.9.1992 Ex.148 issued by the Reserve Bank of India reads thus:'September 9, 1992.

c

Bhadra 18, 1914 (Saka) The Chairman/Chief Executives of Scheduled Commercial Banks (excluding RRBs) Dear Sir,

Payment of cheques/pay orders It has come to our notice that banks have undertaken large value transactions with third parties on a significant scale by means of cheques drawn on their accounts maintained with Deposit Accounts Department of Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in the names of other banks maintaining accounts with the RBI. As banks are aware, the facility of maintaining accounts with RBI has been granted mainly to enable banks to fulfil their statutory obligations, settlement of transactions with RBI/Government, settlement of inter-bank transactions or adverse clearing balances. It is reiterated that the accounts maintained with RBI should be utilised only for these purposes and not for facilitating credit to accounts of third parties. 2. It has also been revealed during investigations that banks have credited cheques drawn in their favour by other banks marked 'Account Payee' to the accounts of constituents even when they are not named in the cheques as the beneficiaries. In the case of cheques not having been drawn in the names of constituents nor containing 'any' direction to pay to the constituents the proceeds thereof, or having any 'other independent direction to that effect, the amount cannot be paid to the constituent. If any bank credits the account of a constitue!lt who is

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

c

[2003) I S.C.R.

not the payee, in the c~eque without proper mandate of the drawer, it does so at its own risk and will be responsible for the unauthorised payment. Payment systems require that the legal requirements laid down in the various relevant laws are fully observed. In the case of 'Account Payee' cheques wherein a bank is a payee, the payee bank should always ensure that there are clear instructions for disposal of proceeds thereof from the drawer of the instrument. If there are no such instructions, the cheque should be returned to the sender. RBI reiterates the position that crediting of proceeds of such cheques to parties otherwise than in pursuance of clearly delineated instructions of issuer of such cheques is unauthorised and should not be done under any circumstances. Banks cannot and also should not invoke market practice in justifrcation of doing that, which is not supported by law or recognised banking practice. These instructions should be carefully noted. Banks which indulge· in any deviation from these instructions would invite severe penal action. Kindly acknowledge receipt of this letter. Yours faithfully, Sd/-

(V. Rangarajan) Addi. Chief Officer' (d) OTHER RELEVANT WITNESSES INCLUDING EVIDENCE AGAINST A-5:

[PW23, PW25, PW16, CWl and DW5(8)

Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of A-5 stated that the evidence led by the prosecution for establishing the five transactions is not required to be dealt with as he admits on behalf of A-5 that in 'four transactions the amount was taken by A-5 and in first transaction he gave loan to MUL but as loan was given, he has not committed any illegality in taking loan from MUL through UCO Bank. In this view of the matter, it is not nece_ssary to discuss the evidence with regard to_ the receipt of the money by A-5 through UCO Bank. l-lowever, we would refer to the evidence of PW23, PW25, PWI6, CWI and DW5(8) pertaining to A-5 and other accused.

PW23 Mohan Das Khandelwal, a Share broker, who is approver in

( --,....

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

this case stated that after doing B.Sc., MBA, he worked with Delhi Cloth & A General Mills Co. Ltd. and State Bank of India upto the year 1986. Thereafter, in 1990 he got membership of Delhi Stock Exchange. It is his say that through a common acquaintance, he came across one Ashwin Mehta in the year 1988 and then with Harshad S. Mehta (A-5). Ashwin Mehta is the younger brother of A-5. It is his further say that Ashwin Mehta was looking for a qualified person who could assist him in research activities in the share B market and he called him to come to Bombay to meet Harshad Mehta and accordingly he went to Bombay somewhere in December, 1988 {when for the first time he met A-5). The purpose was to enable him to have a set up in Delhi. He met A-5 at his residence and office. In the meeting, they decided to associate with each other for the purpose of carrying out research in-share C market and companies in Delhi. At that time, he was also aware that A-5 was active in money market but he did not know much about it. A-5 wanted to set up his business in Delhi and for that purpose wanted to find out suitable place for his office and also establish the office in Delhi. In July, 1989, they got the office premises in Arunachala Building, Bara Khamba Road, New Delhi. The said premises was purchased by one of the holding companies of D Harshad S. Mehta. During his visit to Bombay, he came to know the company as Mis Growmore Research & Assets Mangement Ltd., which was an umbrella company to give the corporate identity and the office to be set up in Delhi. The said office premises were acquired with the full knowledge of A-5 who provided money for the same.

-,

It is his further say that he came across a person Anuj Kalia. He was recruited as Executive in the said company somewhere in June or July, 1990. Initially, when he met Mehtas in the year 1989, the business activities which were thought over were research activities on Delhi based companies as well as little bit of operations of Delhi Stock Exchange. The business activities F were undertaken in the individual name of Harshad Mehta. Share market operations were undertaken in the name of Harshad S. Mehta which was his proprietary concern, he being a member of Bombay Stock Exchange. After it was decided to set up office in Delhi as stated earlier, A-5 made another trip to Delhi somewhere in April or May, 1989. In this trip, A-5 spoke about G the activities in money market. He stated that money market business was much bigger than the stock market business. He also told him that there were many P.S.U. Companies in Delhi; these PSUs had large investable surplus funds with them and that such large funds of PSUs in Delhi could be invested in banks at Bombay. A-5 wanted him to keep liaison with certain PSUs. He also wanted him to convey on his behalf money market trends, quotations H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003] I S.C.R.

A etc. to such PSUs. He was supposed to convey the same to the functionaries of the PSUs who were concerned in the investment of the funds. It was AS who used to inform him about the money market trend, rates of interest etc. which he wanted him to convey to the functionaries of the PSUs. A-5 was mostly in Bombay and he used to convey him the same over telephone.

C

It is his say that a number of accounts with various banks were opened in Delhi in the name of Harshad Mehta, in the name of his company and other concerns including the account in the name of Ashwin S. Mehta. He was one of the authorized signatories, being a Power of Attorney holder, to operate the said accounts except one of the accounts which was opened in Citibank. He received the authority for the operation of some accounts which were in the name of Harshad S. Mehta. Usually Mr. Anuj Kalia used to attend to the bank's work.

During his visit to Delhi in April/May, 1989, A-5 made reference to MUL and told that MUL had surplus investable funds as a PSU and they were very active. in money market. On his request, he fixed an appointment of A-5 with accused no. I, who was the concerned functionary in the investment of funds. He was not knowing the exact date and time but it was during A5' s visit to Delhi in April/May, 1989. A-1 and A-2 were present in the meeting which took place in the office of MUL. It is his further say that he saw and heard Harshad Mehta introducing himself in the said meeting as a Member of Bombay Stock Exchange who was very active in money market and that he wanted to deal with MUL. He also informed that he had lot of contacts with the banks in Bombay and he could offer to MUL excellent deals in the money market. Question was put to the witness-Did he (Mehta) indicate the method by which he could work out the said offers between MUL and the banks in Bombay? Witness replied-A- I at that time stated that the MUL could not deal or involve the brokers. A-5 stated that the deals would be between MUL and banks, structured and suggested by him and his name would not appear in the books of accounts of MUL and that is what he stated. It is his further say that A-5 stated that he would stand to gain by way of commission and/or brokerage from the banks and that MUL would benefit by getting better deals. A-1 stated that he would look into any good proposals if A-5 did not come. into picture. The said meeting lasted for half an hour.

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

He agreed that in connection with the said meeting transactions took place between MUL and any banks at the behest of A-5.

)I

-~

~

. ,..!..

).-

• ·-.--

The first transaction was in January 1991. At that time, Harshad Mehta was in Bombay and he was in Delhi. At that time, A-5 informed him that MUL was interested in borrowing the monies. He told him that the securities which MUL would offer were units of UTI, the bank lending the money would be UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay and that offer in that respect would come from the said bank who would be showing it as an offeror. It is further say of the witness that he came across a person named V.N. Deosthali (A-3). He was an officer working in UCO Bank in its Hamam Street Branch at Bombay. He learnt about the same from A-5. At subsequent stage, he had occasion to meet Deosthali (A-3). He heard the name ofDeosthali in the year 1990, it may be even early in the year 1989 in connection with some other transactions with some other PSUs. He never came across the name. of Deosthali before joining Harshad Mehta's company. In the year 1989 or 1990, he heard the name of Deosthali from Harshad Mehta. He identified A-3 sitting in the Court. In January 1991 he received the letter Ex.58 of UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay, dated 23rd January, 1991. As per the said letter, he was to collect 35 lacs units of UT! from MUL. He contacted A-1 for the purpose of complying with the instructions as contained in the said letter. Anuj Katia was deputed by him to collect the said security. Instructions for transferring the proceeds of the pay orders of Canara Bank favouring Grindlays Bank into the account of Harshad S. Mehta in his account in Bombay were given by him but he did so as per instructions which he received from Harshad Mehta. He gave instructions in his official capacity being in charge of Delhi office and also as per instructions ofHarshad S. Mehta. He had no knowledge as to whether the Canara Bank, Parliament Street Branch issued any instructions to the ANZ Grindlays Bank to credit the proceeds of the said pay order Ex.36 and the said proceeds of which were credited into the account of Harshad S. Mehta with Grindlays Bank. As per his knowledge, the amount involved in four transactions referred to by him earlier, which were credited into the account of Harshad S. Mehta were

c

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

reversed at later stages. He further stat.ed that he knew a person by name Ram Narayan Popli, A-4, and he identified him. In the year 1991, A-4 was working with ANZ Grindlays Bank, Parliament Street Branch, New Delhi. He had occasions to meet him during the year 1990-91 in the Parliament Street Branch of Grindlays Bank. The purpose of meeting was in connection with the operation of the accounts of Harshad S. Mehta with the banks. He was not aware what was his official designation at that time, but to his knowledge he was working in the Remittance Department of the said bank in its Parliament Street Branch office. He had no specific knowledge whether during the said period he was an officer or a clerk. Whenever, he used to meet A-4, he used to have talk in connection with remittances which were to be received from Bombay or remittances which were to be made from Delhi to Bombay branch and he requested him to expedite the process of the said work. A-4 appeared to be very cooperative. On seeing Ex.203, which is a letter written by the witness expressing his desire to make confessional statement, he stated that he was taken to the Court of Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Delhi. Mr. Bhatnagar was also present at that time. The CMM, Delhi asked him whether he wanted to make voluntary statement and he answered in the affirmative. The CMM assigned the matter to other Metropolitan Magistrate Mr. Yadav. ln further cross-examination, he stated that the visit which he stated earlier accompanied by A-5 in MUL was in its office at Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi. The meeting took place in a hall type premises. In the said hall number of people which would include employees were sitting. He further stated that their meeting was with A-1 and A-2 who were sitting in the said hall. He was not known to the other employees of MUL who were silting in the said hall. He .and A-5 were sitting across the table and in front of them A-1 and A-2 were also sitting there and the said meeting was among four of them. He was arrested by the CB[ in this case. It was in the month of August 1994 but he does not recollect the exact date. As far as he remembered, it was on I 0th of August 1994. He presumes that CBI officer recorded his statement on I 0th of August, 1994, which was read over to him and he found the same having been correctly recorded.

R.N. POPLI v. C.ll.l. (M,B. SHAH, J.]

Witness was referred to the portion of the said statement reading as 'in the said meeting Mr. Harshad S. Mehta, accused no. I and accused no.2 were present'.~The witness stated that his statement before the Court is correct. If in his statement recorded by CBI, he has not mentioned about the presence of accused no.2 in the said meeting then it may be that he had not stated about the same.

He agreed that Harshad S. Mehta elaborated to A-1 and A-2 about excellent deals in the money market. A-1 showed interest in the deployment of funds of MUL in the money market in the said excellent deals as stated by A-5. At that time, A· I stated that MUL could not pay any brokerage to the brokers. He furthet stated that .A-5 did not specifically state that he C wanted to act as a broker between MUL and the banks. It is correct that A5 stated in the said meeting that he would get his brokerage from the concerned banks. A- I stated that he did not want to mention the name of Harshad Mehta as broker in the books of MUL. A-2 was absolutely quiet during the said meeting. A I said that he would be open to any good suggestions and offers or proposals in the money market. Witness was shown Pay Order Ex.34 dated 24.4.1991 and was questioned-on what basis ANZ Grindlays Bank credited the proceeds of the said pay order in the account of Harshad S. Mehta with them? The witness replied-ANZ Grindlays bank usually used to credit the amount on the basis of covering letter of Harshad Mehta issued by Delhi Office. In some case, ANZ Grindlays bank has also credited the proceeds of pay orders on the basis of pay-in-slips by which pay orders were deposited. The covering letters which used to be normally given to ANZ Grindlays bank were given to Anuj Kalia which were pre-signed but he cannot say whether Anuj Kalia delivered such letters along with the said pay order to the said bank. He did not inform A- I and A-2 or any other personnel of MUL that proceeds of the said pay order were credited into the account of Harshad S. Mehta in ANZ Grindlays Bank. A suggestion was put to the witness that because officials of MUL knew that the transactions were with Harshad Mehta and not with UCO Bank, the MUL's officials contacted him and not UCO Bank. The witness denied the suggestion and stated that since all letters, bank receipts and securities involved in the transactions were received from Bombay

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

A office of Harshad S. Mehta through the Delhi Office, the officials of MUL contacted him. He stated that he cannot say whether the officials of MUL contacted ·UCO Bank, Bombay.

He denied the suggestion that he deliberately chose to forget the transactions of 1990 to connect the transactions of 1991 in this case with the alleged meeting of 1989. He was further questioned about recording of his statement by CBI prior to l 0.8.1994. He replied that CBI officials had called him earlier on number of

C occasions and questioned him and he gave them answers to such questions. He· could not recollect whether CBI officials recorded his statement/s or not. He again stated that on 10.8.1994 he was arrested. H~ was summoned by CBI on two occasions in'June, 1993 for interrogation in this case. He was D first called on l.6.1993 and then again on 15.6.1993. Mr. B.C. Bhatnagar called him on both the occasions. On 1.6.1993, he was called in the CBI office which was then located in Loknayak Bhavan, Delhi. He had received written summons at that time. The summons mentioned about the MUL's case. He could not recollect the exact time when the process of recording of his interrogation commenced and ended but it was during the office hours E between l 0 am to 5 pm. The process of interrogation continued on when the officer Mr. Bhatnagar questioned him and he gave answers to his questions. He could not recollect whether Mr. Bhatnagar at that time went Gn recording his statements. On being shown para 32 of his deposition recorded by Mr. Bhatnagar under Section 161 CrPC, he stated that by reading the statement, he can say that he had not mentioned specifically the said fact in his statement F before the CBI. He was further referred to his statement recorded on 15.6.1993 wherein he stated that 'earlier on arriv~I to office.on 4.ll.1991 (FN) Shri Harshad S. Mehta had told him that he had to attend a meeting with PM on ·that day'. The witness denied having made such ·statement before the CBI.

PW25 Mr. B.C. Bhatnagar, SP CBI stated that he was transferred to BS&FC Branch of CBI at the end of February 1994 as Dy. S.P. At that time, he was working in Delhi. Case No.RC.2(A)/93~ACU.VII was entrusted to him soon after the registration of FIR of this case in 1993 itself. The FIR of this case was registered by Shri V.D. Maheshwari, who was the SP, CBI and Incharge of ACU (VII) Unit. Mr. Maheshwari had entrusted this case to him for investigation. During the investigation conducted by him Shrl Maheshwari

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

... •

being his superior remained in touch with this case as a supervisory authority A of investigation till November, 1993. Inspector O.P. Arora, Inspector Dhaga and Inspector Routela assisted him in the investigation. Pursuant to the orders from the headquarter of CBI, the papers were handed over by him to Dy. S.P. Mr. Panwar. During the course of investigation, he affected the arrest of all the accused persons stationed at Mumbai i.e. Harshad Mehta and V.N. B Deosthali. He also enquired about the status of MUL. The requisite information was received by him from Mr. BS Bhargava, the Company Secretary of MUL vide document Ex.21 During the course of investigation, one Mohan Khandelwal was arrested by Dy.S.P. Shri Panwar. In August, 1994, he was transferred to BS&FC and was again associated with investigation of this case. Mr. Verma, the then SP, Mr. JN Prasad, working as SP and Mr. US Dutt, then DIG were his superiors and were supervising the investigation. On or about 3 lst August, 1994, Mr. Mohan Khandelwal gave him a letter Ex.203, which was discussed by him with his superiors. It was decided that in case Mr. Khandelwal discloses the full facts he may be taken as an approver and his statement may be got recorded. He further stated that he did not take possession of the visitors register of MUL during investigation. He also did not ascertain that MUL at all maintained such a register or not. He had ascertained the date of joining of A-2 with MUL as 19.4.1989 and that during the month of May, 1989 A-2 was on an orientation programme at the factory at Gurgaon. Except the statement of Mohan Khandelwal, he was not aware when A-5 visited Delhi during the month of April-May, 1989. He secured the statement of Mohan Khandelwal with regard to the presence of A-1 and A-2 and about.the fact of the meeting in April-May, 1989. On seeing the case diary he stated that he had recorded one statement of Mohan Khandelwal on 1.6.1993. Prior to 15.6.1993, he had not recorded any statement of Anuj Kalia. Between 15.4.1993 to 15.6.1993 he had not interrogated Anuj Kalia.

C

In cross-examination, the witness stated that he does not remember if during the course of investigation, he had checked up the various records of Grindlays Bank, Sansad Marg Branch where A-4 was working and particularly between February 1991 to May 1991. He also does not remember if he had made any application/request for production of documents to the said bank H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

A during the said period and that he had conducted any search and seizure .from

C

the said bank with regard to the documents like attendance register, duty roster or any other similar document showing the presence of particular officer at particular time. He agreed that he neither saw nor took into possession any such record dated 25.2.1991, 13.3.1991, 18.3.1991, 24.4.1991 and 2.5.1991 with regard to the presence of A-4 in the concerned bank on these dates. He further stated that it is wrong to say that due to the five transactions in question no pecuniary loss has been caused to MUL. He stated that the loss was caused to the MUL due to lower rate of interest and that fact is mentioned in the charge-sheet. In further cross-examination, the witness stated that during the course of investigation MUL never complained of any pecuniary loss to it. MUL also did not disclose if it had filed any case of recovery against ANZ Grindlays Bank, Sansad Marg Branch, New Delhi, for any loss. During the course of investigation, he had not visited any other bank except the Grindlays bank to ascertain the procedure of inter banking clearance. He had examined the transactions of high value inter banking clearance prior to February 1991. These transactions pertained to the high network customers of the bank. He had also checked the high value transactions of inter banking clearance pertaining to high network customers of the bank between February, 1991 to May, 1991. After May 1991 he had not examined such kind of transactions of the bank. He could not remember as to how many transactions of the kind of nature referred to above were examined by him prior to February, 1991. He agreed that he did not check up the record and the procedure of inter banking clearance of the cheques of high value of the high networth customers of Bank of America, Hong Kong and Shenghai Banking Corp., Standard Chartered Bank or any other foreign bank. He denied that he had deliberately not checked the said procedure with other banks as it would have shown that the Grindlays Bank was also adopting the same procedure as followed by other banks during the relevant period for inter banking clearances of high value cheques. He also denied the suggestion that he had deliberately not checked up with Grindlays bank with regard to the attendance and posting etc. of A-4 with the obvious purpose that such records would have falsified the case of the prosecution in relation to A-4. He also denied the suggestion that on 31.8.1994 Mohan Khandelwal was under tremendous pressure due to rejection of his application by the

,,.......

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

Special Judge and the fact was in his knowledge and that the accused had no A other choice except to toe the line of CBI and to become an approver. He was not aware of Mohan Khandelwal being involved in fi\·e or six other cases of scams at the relevant time.

y

He also stated that it was one of the significant factors in the investigation that loss had been caused to MUL. During the course of preliminary enquiry B he had collected information which indicated pecuniary loss to MUL. Out of the five transactions in question, the first one was a borrowing by MUL whereas the remaining four were lending by MUL. The loss was caused to MUL because MUL paid higher rate of interest in comparison to the rate of interest paid by other PSUs on borrowings. He does not remember as to what rate of interest was paid by MUL but it is mentioned in the charge-sheet. He had seen the charge sheet. It does not carry any mention of other PSUs. There is also no list showing the rate of borrowing by other PSUs. He admitted that the rate of interest in the market fluctuates from day to day and hour to hour. He investigated on the aspect as to on what rate of interest other PSUs borrowed on 23.1.1991. He had not recorded the statements of any person D from those PSUs. But he collected the data showing the borrowing rate !If interest. He had collected such data from GAIL, Indian OIL and ONGC etc. but it has not been made part of the charge-sheet, the reason being oversight. He stated that it was wrong to suggest that the said data was deliberately suppressed because it would not indicate any loss to MUL. At that time, he E did not consider it necessary to record the statement of the concerned officials · of the PSUs.

......

c

.......:i..

...

_,,.1-. . '

He could not remember if he had recorded the statement of any officials of MUL on the point of loss. He does not recollect if MUL had other borrowings on that day and if so at what rate. He agreed that MUL had not lodged any FIR with regard to any of the five transactions in question .

•:i.-

He had recorded the statement of R.C. Bhargav and Natrajan during investigation to ascertain if any other higher authority of MUL was also involved in the case. On that basis his conclusion was that A-I and A-2 were liable for their acts as mentioned in the charge-sheet. So far as Mr. Bhargav and Mr. Natrajan were concerned, they were found not involved directly. They were involved not criminally but for approving the proposal put by Al and A-2. The proposal put by A-1 and A-2 was a criminal act. Mr. Bhargav and Mr. Natrajan were not aware that the investment in fact has been made '·' with A-5 through UCO Bank. Mr. Bhargav and Mr. Natrajan had bonafidely H

'

[2003) I S.C.R.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

A accepted the proposal put up by A-1 and A-2. A-1 and A-2 were the person who were responsible for investing the amount with the banks for the benefits of MUL. The approval by Mr. Bhargav and Mr. Natrajan was with the application of mind.

Following Question was put to the witness(Q.) Do you now understand the distinction between 'advancing to' and 'advancing through'? (A) Yes, when the advance is made to a person directly it is 'advance to' and when there is a mediator then it is 'advance through'.

c

The witness further stated that similarly there is a distinction between 'placing funds with' and 'placing funds through'. On seeing Ex:23, wherein the placing of funds through UCO Bank is mentioned, he stated that so far as this document is concerned the funds were placed through UCO Bank and not to UCO Bank. Similarly, in Ex.24 the word used 'through'. In these two documents even after the use of the word 'through', his conclusion was that the placement of funds by MUL was with UCO Bank and not with a third person. The witness further clarified that the placement of funds was with UCO Bank which offered the sale of units available with them and the contents of the resolutions in Ex.23 and Ex.24 should be read with the Agenda Note and the letter of offer by UCO Bank. According to him, after 'the placement of funds with UCO Bank, the Bank would not be acting illegally if it places those very funds with a tl1ird party. He admitted that in-Ex.24 MUL had adopted a resolution on the same day placing the funds with Mis Can Bank Financial Services for investment in bonds/units/government securities. He denied that he and the Investigating Agency have protected Mr. Bhargav and Mr. Natrajan. He could not remember if he had recommended the prosecution of Mr. Bhargav and Mr. Natrajan or tllat the Investigating Agency rejected that recommendation for extraneous reasons.

is

The decision to name Anuj Katia in the FIR was of Mr. Malieshwari and the Investigating Agency and he had agreed. The decision to drop him from the list of accused was his and that of investigating agency. After recording statement of M. Khandelwal under Section 164 Cr.P.C. it was decided to drop him from the list of accused. Till that time, he was an accused. It was the decision of Mr. Maheshwari and the Investigating Agency not to cite M. Khandelwal as an accused at the time of FIR. He does not know as to who was the particular person in the hierarchy of CBI whose

.

~ '

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.J

decision was not to cite M. Khandelwal as an accused in the FIR. As an IO, he was at the bottom of the hierarchy i.e. SP and then his DIG, Joint Director, Additional Director, Special Director and the Director. He had in fact not made any conclusion as to whom should be made the accused. He had only given his findings of the preliminary enquiry. During the course of preliminary enquiry, he had learnt that Anuj Kalia was the person who took the cheques of these five transactions to and fro, the bank and delivered them in Delhi. He had mentioned the role of Anuj Kalia in the report submitted to his SP. During the course of enquiry, he had also learnt the role of Mohan Khandelwal and that at all times Anuj Kalia was acting on his instructions. He had mentioned the fact in his report that Anuj Katia was working under Mohan Khandelwal.

L

In further cross-examination, he stated that A-3 was implicated on account of the overt acts done by him as mentioned in the charge-sheet. One of the overt acts of A-3 was issuing irregularly the bank receipts. Although the issuance of bank receipts was an usual and common practice being followed by UCO Bank under instructions from Head Office and on behalf of their clients, A-3 issued Bank Receipts single handedly. He did not remember if A-3 was not in the branch of UCO Bank when the last two transactions took place or that between 15.4.1991 to 15.5.1991 he had been transferred to Hingna branch in Maharashtra. He agreed that he had not implicated the officer who played the role of A-3 during last two transactions. He did not remember if the said officer was Mr. Shidey who performed the role of A3 after his transfer. On seeing the bank receipts Ex.A-5 (17) to Ex.A-5 (29), he stated that he had not seen the same during the course of investigation of this case. Those documents were not seized in this case. He agreed to the suggestion that the statement dated 15.6.1993 of Mohan Khandelwal was not a statement connected with this case. He did not remember if the statement dated 15.6.1993 came to be recorded only because a day earlier i.e. on 14.6.1993 Harshad Mehta happened to convene a press conference in which he leveled the allegations of having paid Rs.One crore to Narsimha Rao, the then Prime Minister and in which Mohan Khandelwal was a vital witness. He did not know if the said statement dated 15.6.1993 had been brought to the notice of Mr. Narasimha Rao and his advisors.

PW/6 Anuj Kalia stated that he was working as Management Trainee with Mis Growmore Research and Assets Management Ltd. at New Delhi. While working in the said company and in connection with the work of that

C

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

company, he came across a person by name Harshad S. Mehta. It is stated that the said company namely M/s Growmore Research and Assets Management Ltd. was a family concern of A-5. During 1990 and 1991, A5 used to visit the said office at Delhi 011ce in a few months or so. During the said period, A-5 was stationed in Mumbai. It is further say of this witness that he got himself appraised of the nature of the business of the said company which was to conduct the research in Stock Market and to make investments in stock market and similar services of broker. The witness further stated that during his visits to Grindlays bank in connection with the work of their company, he came across an officer by name R.N. Popli, (A-4) working with the said branch ofGrindlays Bank. and that A-4 was attached to Remittances Department. Sometimes, he also worked in other department. The witness also stated that in connection with the office work, he had occasion to visit the office of MUL situated at Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi on ft:w occasions. On seeing the letter Ex.58 issued by the UCO Bank on 23.1.1991.addressed to MUL, New Delhi, he stated that he had an occasion to handle the said letter. The said letter was given to him by Mohan Khandelwal. At that time, he was also given one more letter by Mr. Khandelwal (witness was shown Ex.A-5(1) being receipt dated 24.l.1991 on the letter · head of Harshad S. Mehta). Along with the said letter shown to him, Mr. Khandelwal gave him this document also. He was instructed by Mr. Khandelwal to go along with both these documents to the office of MUL and collect the envelope containing units of UTI from that office.

The witness stated that he had an occasion to collect bank pay order from the office of MUL while working in the said company. He did so under the instructions of Mr. Mohan Khandelwal. He was instructed by .Mr. Khandelwal to go to the office of MUL and meet either A-1 or 2 and collect the banker's cheque and then deposit the same into the account of .Harshad S. Mehta with Grindlays bank, Sansad Marg Branch. He was not appraised and he was also not aware in respect of what transaction the said payment was made· for as he was simply told to collect the cheque.

On seeing the pay-in-slip dated 25.2.1991 [X-18 (Ex.100)) of ANZ Grindlays bank, the witness stated that the same is pay in slip on the printed format of ANZ Grindlays Bank. The same is written in his handwriting and he identified the same. Tiie initials therein appear to be of A-4 but he was not sure about the same. He filled in the said pay-in-slip for depositing the

p

;

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.l. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

bankers' cheque issued by Canara Bank, Parliament Street Branch as per instructions of Mr. Khandelwal. The said pay-in-slip is the detached part from its counter foil which remains in the book. The rubber stamp of the Grindlays Bank dated 25.2.1991 appearing therein was put by the said bank when the cheque was deposited. Such rubber stamp was also put by the said bank on the counter foil of the said pay-in-slip.

On seeing Ex.26-MUL' s instruction letter dated 25.2.1991-the witness

stated that it is the letter on the strength of which he collected the pay order Ex.28. The same bears his signature at two places marked as Ex.27( I) and 27(2) in the said letter. Handwritten portion thereon reading as "Mr. Sai Swaroop Please deliver the cheque to Mr. Anuj Kalia" is the handwriting of A-2 and he identified the same being familiar therewith. He identified the signature thereon marked as Ex.26 (2) as that of A-2 Ambuj Jain. Further, on seeing Ex.IOI-covering letter dated 25.2.1991 on letter head of Harshad S. Mehta addressed to the Manager, Grindlays Bank, New Delhi-the witness stated that the hand written part of the said letter was written by him in his own handwriting and he identified the same. The same has been signed by Mr. Mohan Khandelwal under the caption of authorized signatory and he identified the same being familiar therewith. He wrote the said letter under the instructions of Mr. Mohan Khandelwal. The said letter was written for depositing the bankers' cheque of Canara Bank mentioned therein into the account of A-5 as such letters used to be written for depositing bankers cheques into the said account.

C

On seeing Ex.102-detached part of pay-in-slip of Grindlays bank dated 13.3.1991-the witness stated that the same was in his handwriting and he prepared the same for depositing bankers' cheque of Canara Bank, Parliament Street Branch, as per its number and amount mentioned therein into the account of A-5.

On seeing Ex. 76, the witness stated that he wrote the said letter under instruction of Mohan Khandelwal. He handed over the letter Ex.76 along with pay-in-slip Ex. I02 and Ex.30 to A-4 in Grindlays Bank. He handed over the instruction letter and pay order to A-4 because A-4 was handling the said work and he was also instructed by Mr. Khandelwal to do so.

On seeing Ex.32, 78 and 103 being Canara Bank's pay order dated 18.3.1991 favouring Grindlays Bank, Pay-in-slip dated 18.3.1991 and instruction letter dated 18.3.1991, the witness stated that the said documents

··

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

A co-relate to each other and he handed over the same to A-4 as he was the

C

concerned officer handling the said work and he was also instructed by Mr. Khandelwal to do so. It is his further say that x~ 18 pay-in-slip dated 24.4.1991 of ANZ Grindlays Bank was filled in by him and it relates to the deposit of bankers' cheque of Canara Bank, .Sansad Marg Branch of the number and amount mentioned therein into the account of A-5. ·He deposited the said cheque by the. said slip under the instruction of Mr. Khandelwal. On seeing Ex.26, which is an instruction letter dated 25 .2.1991 of MUL to Canara Bank, Parliament Street Branch, the witness stated that he read the name of Mr. Sai Swaroop in the said letter in a portion which has been marked as Ex.26(3). Mr. Sai Swaroop was the Manager of Canara Bank attached to Parliament Street Branch at that time. He had occasions to meet the said officer few times. He further stated that for collecting the letter Ex.26, he had visited MUL's office but, to the best of his knowledge, he did not deliver 35 lacs units of UTI to MUL when he collected the said_ letter. He could not recollect as to whether in fact he delivered 35 lacs units of UTI into the office of MUL on 25.2.1991. ln the cross-examination, the witness stated that he was questioned by the CBI Officers in Scam related cases. He does not recollect exactly but somewhere in Juty·or August, 1992 he first time came to be questioned. He had received a process at that time from the CBI Officer. He does not remember the name of the officer who questioned him. He denied the suggestion that in the CBI Office he was told to implicate A-4 in this case and that he would not be implicated in this case. To the question that-during February and May, 1991 A-4 was not working in Remittance Department in Grindlays Bank in its branch at Sansad Marg,~he replied that he was not knowing about his department but he knew where he used to sit in the said branch.

CW1 Mr. Vishnu Deo Maheshwari, SP CBI stated that during the years 1991, 1992 and 1993 he was supervising investigation of cases relating to anti corruption offences. In the year 1992-93 Mr. Amod Kanth, the then DIG was his superior. Mr. B.C. Bhatnagar, the then Dy. ~.P. was amongst the subordinate officers working under him during th~ said,period. He was asked to explain about his precise role in the process of supervision/investigation of the MUL's case. He stated that he discussed.the evidence collected. by Mr. Bhatnagar who was the 1.0. of the case as also with senior officials;

.-y'

4...

1'.

--../..

,, R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.)

--/.

examination or interrogation of witnesses and to assess the documents collected A as also the statements of witnesses and to discuss with 1.0. as well as senior officers. Besides supervision of the investigation of the case, the then DIG Mr. Amod Kanth ordered to examine one Mr. Mohan Khandelwal with the assitance of IO about the MUL's .security transactions as well as cash withdrawals during 1991-92 from the accounts of A-5, Accordingly, he B recorded the statement of Mr. Khandelwal on 15.6.1993 in presence of IO at Delhi. He stated that FIR was registered on 15th April, 1993. It is his say that to ascertain whether any departmental irregularity was committed or any criminal offences were committed, the CBI instituted the preliminary enquiry. He admitted that there is no statutory provision which permits or allows the investigating agency like CBI to institute and conduct preliminary enquiry as C has been done in this case prior to the registration of crime. He did not know why the said statement dated 15.6.1993 of Mr. Khandelwal was not furnished and or included along with the papers accompanying the charge sheet submitted before the Court. He did not instruct the investigating officer of this case not to include the said statement along with the charge sheet. So long as he D handled the case, the said ·statement dated 15.6.1993 formed part of the record of this case. He further stated that the source information did not disclose commission ofany offence. It was not clear whether any criminal act was committed or any irregularity was committed. He did not remember any other role of Mr. Khandelwal that was discovered during the said period but the fact that he was the constituted Attorney was discovered. He further did E not remember as to why Mr. Khandelwal was not named as accused in the FIR. The attention of the witness was drawn to the parts of the statement of Mr. Khandelwal recorded on 15.6.1993 by him, which are as under:(i)

For withdrawal of 25 lacs the self cheque signed by him was given to Shri Anuj Kalia who brought the cash to the office and delivered to him when Shri Harshad S. Mehta was also present in the office.

(ii) The VIP suit case containing the said cash brought by Shri Anuj Kalia was handed over to Shri Harshad S. Mehta who took it in the Honda Car of Shri Sunil Mittal and took away the ·money to some place not known to him.

:.,..

(iii) Visited at ANZ Grindlays Bank along with Shri Anuj Kalia. (iv) The cheque was encashed and cash was brought to the office but the suitcase containing cash remained in the office NE 118.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

(v) At about 3-4 p.m. Shri Harshad S. Mehta came to office in the car of Shri Sunil Mittal and the suitcase containing cash lying in NE 118 car was shifted to the car of Shri Sunil Mittal. (vi) He, Sunil Mittal and Harshad S. Mehta went to residence of Shri Sitaram Kesari, party Treasurer.

c

(vii) There he remained along with them in the front room. (viii)Later Shri Harshad S. Mehta and Sunil Mittal went inside the connected room and the suitcase containing the cash was picked up by somebody from the Bungalow (Residence of Shri Sitaram Kesari) and taken inside that room. (ix) While returning from that room Shri Kesari asked Harshad S. Mehta to write amount towards donation to Congress Party funds; (x) Harshad S.Mehta initialed in the note book produced by Shri Ke sari.

(xi) Then all three of them returned to office from where he remained in the office and Shri Harshad S. Mehta along with Sunil Mittal proceeded to Hotel; (xii) Similar heavy cash withdrawal was also done on 4.5.1992 when Rs.20 lacs were withdrawn from the same bank.' The witness was questioned-whether the said evidence of Mr. Khandelwal denying the recording of his said statement was true? The witness replied 'No'. He had recorded the said statements. He said that Mr. Khandelwal in his said statement recorded by him on 15.6.1993 had made the statement as above at SI. Nos.(i) to (xii).

On the basis of the aforesaid statement, question was asked to the

witness that-whether he realised that the said statement disclosed the material requiring or warranting separate and independent enquiry in certain aspects which were not covered or directly related to the evidence of the case which he has registered as per the. FIR? To this question, he replied that he did realise so and thereafter DIG Mr. Amod Kanth conducted some enquiry with Mr. Sitaram Kesari who revealed that he did not recollect about the donation to the party. DWS(S) Atul Manubhai Parekh stated that he is dealing with

H pharmaceuticals and chemicals since about last two years. Prior thereto, he

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.J. [M.B. SHAH, J.)

was in the employment of A-5 from June 1990 till June 1992. He was Asstt. Vice President and looking after settlement of money market transactions of A-5. He used to sit at Nariman Point Office, Bombay of A-5. He then stated that deals in money market transaction in security transactions used to take place during the day for and on behalf of A-5. His duty was to confirm about the delivery of the securities both delivery on behalf of A-5 as also receipt on behalf of other parties. Regarding the procedure of settlement of the deals and about his role, the witness stated that after feeding the computer, the contract notes and delivery orders were generated from the computer and handed over to him. On receipt thereof, he used to depute the delivery boys to the concerned banks for the purpose of collecting or receiving the deliveries of the securities. After collecting the securities, the same used to be sent to UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay. The delivery boys would deliver the securities and then collect the bankers cheques from UCO Bank and deliver again the said bankers -cheques to the banks from where they had earlier collected the , securities in question.

C

UCO bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay was giving routing facility for money market transactions to various brokers which included his master A-5. He used to do daily reconciliation with UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay in respect of the security position in the account of A-5 on telephone. After confirming the position of the balance of the securities in a form of BRs held by UCO Bank in the account of A-5, he would pass on the same to the dealers of A-5. Without holding the securities by way of BRs, UCO Bank would not issue BRs for and on behalf of A-5. Apart from BRs the securities in the physical form of A-5 would also lie with UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay. Whatever securities received either by BRs, SGLs or physical for and on behalf of A-5, the same used to remain with UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay. There used to be generally surplus balance of securities in the account of A-5 with UCO bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay.

He agreed to the suggestion that UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay issued its BR in respect of 70 lacs units of UT! on 13.3.1991 in respect of the second transaction favouring MUL.

---<

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) 1 S.C.R.

He was in Bombay when A-5 was arrested. He was also arrested by CBI in RC Case No.S(A)/92. He was aware that A-5 was kept in the CBI · custody for well over 90 days. He was not knowing whether A-5 was under CBI custodial interrogation. ALLEGED CONSPIRACY

C

In this case, conspiracy is the basis for convicting the accused. Special Court has mainly relied upon the evidence of PW23 for holding that prosecution has established conspiracy on the basis of so-called meeting between A-1, A-i, A-5 and PW23 Mohan Khandelwal in the month of April/ Mar, 1989. For conspiracy, it is the prosecution version that Al to A5 entered into a criminal conspiracy to siphon-off the funds of MUL in favour of A5 and afore-quoted five transactions took place, even though there was a specific bar of granting loan by MUL to individuals. Mr. Mahesh Jethmalani who appeared as amicus curiae for A-3,

D submitted that the conspiracy charge is not tenable for the following reasons:;

....

(a) It is absurd to suggest that the conspiracy took place in 1989 and the first overt act in pursuance of that conspiracy took place in March, 1991. The link between the conspiracy of 1989 the first overt act of March, 1991 is further broken by the fact that 13 other transactions took place in the year 1990 between A-5 and MlJL. All these tfansa~iions have been brought out in crossexamination of PW23 and the relevant documents have been proved by the defence through their defence witnesses.

and

.

'

(b) Th~re can n9t be a ~on~piracy to siphon-off surplus funds when the overt acts show that nothing of that kind happened even once; monies were lent on security· and repaid with interest on the due date. (c) .There was effort made to prove this absurd conspiracy based on the sole evidence of the approver PW23. Now in this very case it has been held by the previous Bench that the pardon granted to the approver by the Magistrate was invalid. Where the pardon granted is without jurisdiction the use of the evidence may not affect the validity of the entire proceedings by reasqn of the curative provisions ofCr.P.C. but.certainly the evidence becomes inadmissible. It is significant that the Solicitor General during his long arguments never once relied upon the evidence of the

I

~

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. (M.B. SHAH, l.]

approver. (d) The veracity of PW23 has been destroyed in cross-examination. He denied his taped conversation and feigned ignorance of one police statement. He suppressed truth from the JPC. Even if the evidence of PW23 is taken at its face value, it does not disclose any conspiracy viz. an agreement to commit an illegal act. (e)

It is well-settled that an approver is not worthy of credit and his evidence must be corroborated in all material particulars through independent evidence. The conviction cannot be based on sole evidence of an approver. It is submitted that in the instant case there is no corroboration of the so-called conspiracy through any independent evidence; in fact the evidence of approver himself does not disclose any conspiracy as alleged in the charge.

C

Learned senior counsel Mr. Jethmalani also referred to a note recorded by 13 Members of JPC, wherein it is stated as under: -

-

'\

" ....... The CBl's treatment of Shri Mohan Khandelwal, first as a 'source' and thereafter as an accused is mystifying, to say the least. No satisfactory explanation about this was ever forthcoming'. It is submitted that from the aforesaid note inference is obvious - the registering of preliminary enquiry in this case and other cases was an attempt to threaten PW23 for not disclosing to the public what he had informed to Shri Sharma, DIG Special Investigation Wing privately. The registering of the cases had the desired effect-PW23 did not reveal his knowledge to anybody because the agency to whom he had revealed it from June, 1992 onwards, had chosen not to use the information but to investigate cases in which he could be roped in. Obviously, the filing of cases against PW23 intimidated him sufficiently not to divulge the information he was aware of. He submitted that this is crystal clear from the evidence of CWl Mr. V.D. Maheshwari wherein he has stated that Mr. Khandelwal in his statement dated I 5.6.1993 disclosed that after withdrawing large amount from the bank, A-5 along with Sunil Mittal went at the residence of Mr. Sitaram Kesari, Congress Party Treasurer and handed over the said arnoimt to him. To suppress this, Mr. Khandelwal was made approver. The learned counsel for all the accused contended that prosecution story of conspiracy between A I to A~ is absurd, subsequently developed and cooked up. It is contended that one of the purposes for developing the story

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

of conspiracy hatched in the year 1989 might be for seeing that the offences are tried by the Special Court. It is contended that under Section 3(2), the offence which took place between first day of April, 1991 and on or before 6th June, 1992 could only be tried by the Special Court. The transactions of giving loan by A-5 on 24.1.1991 to MUL and borrowing by A-5 on 13.3.1991 which was repaid on 25.3.1991 and third transaction for which amount was received on 18.3.1991 and repaid on 22.3.1991, would not be covered by sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the SCAM Act. Hence, it is submitted that the allegation of conspiracy between the accused since 1989, apart from being unreliable, is cooked up. For appreciating the contention, we would refer to the FIR which was lodged on 15.4.1993. In the FIR, (in para 3) it has been mentioned that'S/Shri Pramod Kumar and Anibhuj Jain entered into a criminal conspiracy during the period from January, 1991 to May, 1991 at Delhi and Bombay with V.N. Deovasthali an officer of UCO Bank, . Hamam Street Branch, Bombay, R.N. Popli ofANZ Grindlays Bank, Delhi and Shri Harshad S. Mehta, a broker, his employee Anuj Katia and certain other unknown persons with the object to misappropriate the said surplus funds of MUL and to provide pecuniary advantage to Shri Harshad S. Mehta out of the funds to be invested by MUL by abusing their official position as public servants.' Similar allegations were made in the charge-sheet, which was filed on 15.12.1994 which reads as under:-.

'The investigation has further revealed that Pramod Kumar (A-I) and Ambhuj Jain (A-2) entered into a criminal conspiracy and were member of the same during the period from January, 91 to May, 91 at Delhi and Bombay with V.N. Deosthali (A-3), then Asstt. Manager UCO Bank, Hamam Street Branch, Bombay, R.N. Popli (A-4) of ANZ Grindlays Bank, New Delhi, Harshad S. Mehta (A-5) a broker and Mohan Khandelwal an attorney of Harshad S. Mehta, with the . object to misappropriate the surplus funds of MUL and to provide pecuniary advantage to Harshad S. Mehta (A-5) by abusing their official position as public servants.' In respect of the aforesaid prosecution story that accused entered into criminal conspiracy during the period-January, 1991 to May, 1991 - the prosecution has not. led'any~idence and it appears that it has given up the

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) l S.C.R.

sure when A-5 visited New Delhi, but he visited New Delhi once in April or May, 1989 and the meeting took place in the office of MUL at New Delhi. The atte11tion of the witness was also drawn to the hand written entry in the visitors' register of the ONGC, New Delhi for the period 25.2.1989 till 4.11.1989, which reveals that A-5 was present in Delhi on 10.4.1989 and even assuming that A-5 stayed there for one week, as stated by the witness, his stay would be up to 17.4 .1989. . ·On the basis of the aforesaid evidence, it has also been rightly contended that the story developed by the prosecution that A-2 was present during the said meeting is, on the face of it, absurd. For this purpose, it has been pointed out that by an office order dated 4-4:1989 Ex.At and Ex.A2 (5), A-2 was appointed and thereafter he joined the MUL on 19.4.1989 as Junior Officer on probation. He was sent for refresher course from 1st May. In this set of circumstances, it would be difficult to believe that a raw junior officer who was on probation would take part in alleged meeting and be a party to conspiracy of dealing in MUL funds illegally or irregularly.

Further, PW23 has developed a story after his arrest on 10.8. t 994 that A-2 was present ~n the meeting. PW23 has admitted in cross-examination that he wa5 first summoned by CBI in June, 1993 for interrogation on two occasions, i.e. on l.6.1993 and 15.6.1993. In further cross~examination, he .... E admitted that neither he could recollect the exact date and time of the meeting which took place in the premises of MUL nor remember the month of the meeting. The witness has also stated that if in the statement recorded by the CBI, he has not mentioned about the presence of A-2 in the said meeting, then it may be, he has not stated about the same. The public prosecutor admitted that it was an omission in the statement recorded by the CBI with F · regard to the presence of A-2. From the aforesaid admission in the crossexamination, it is apparent that A-2 was not present during the meeting and that the prosecµtion story with regard to the alleged meeting appears to be doubtful. In any case, approver PW23 does not assign any role to A2 in the said meeting.

~

·.: ..

It is also to be noted that the alleged rn,eeting took place in an open hall where other employees of MUL were sitting in close proximity of A-l and A-2 and one of the employees was PW-4 Rajan Ramgopal who joined the Corporate Finance Cell of MUL sometime in the year 1986 as deposed by him. He stated that he used to work directly under A- I and that he himself, A-I, A-2 and Jagdish Kumar used to sit in a common hall; A-I had his table

·•...... ,.

•

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

-

with chairs meant for visitors and by the side of it and in front of him, there was a common table where A-2 used to sit; he (PW4) used to sit opposite to A-2; to the side of A-2, Mr. Jagdish Kumar used to sit and one Mr. Shrinivasan used to sit next to him. Thereafter, he states that while working with Corporate Finanee Cell of MUL, he had not heard the name of Harshad Mehta and that he had never seen the said Mr. Mohan Khandelwal. Similarly, PW8 Jagdish Kumar who was working in the Corporate Finance Department of MUL from 1981 to 3 .5 .1991 has not at all deposed about the alleged meeting. The other employee who was also working in the said room is not examined by the prosecution, therefore, it is submitted that PW23 has uttered a blatant falsehood when he deposed before the court that alleged meeting took place in the premises of MUL in the month of April or May, 1989. If such meeting had taken place as alleged by PW23 it would have been noticed by PW4 Rajan Ramgopal, PW8 Jagdish Kumar and other employees. From the aforesaid discussion, it is apparent that approvers' statement for establishing conspiracy does not inspire any confidence. Further, the evidence' led by the prosecution itself destroys the socalled conspiracy hatched in April/May 1989 because the reply of A I as stated by PW23 in the meeting was limited to the extent that MUL could not deal with or involve the brokers and that he would look into any gooo proposals if AS does not come into the picture. From this statement, no inference can be drawn that there was any conspiracy to misappropriate MUL funds or commit fraud or to commit any illegal act. Further, for the prosecution version that Al and A2 entered into a criminal conspiracy with other accused between January 1991 to May 1991 as stated in the FIR (which was recorded after preliminary inquiry) and in the charge-sheet (virtually filed after more than two years of the preliminary inquiry), no attempt is made to prove the same. Subsequently developed prosecution version that conspiracy was hatched in April/May, 1989 on the basis of approver's evidence appears to be unreliable and baseless. Next question would be (even though not argued) - Can we draw an inference from the transactions in question that there was any such conspiracy fi'om January, 1991 to May,1991 between accused? · There is no circumstance on record for establishing any conspiracy between A-1 and A-3 who was Assistant Manager of UCO Bank. There is nothing on record to show that A-1 or A-2 had any talk with A-3 or A-4 with

C

'E

•

c

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

i·

regard to the alleged conspiracy and that they were party to it. However, let us consider that five transactions mentioned above took place and as MUL could not lend money to A-5 directly, the transactions took place under the name of and through UCO Bank and in four transactions UCO Bank in tum gave the said amount to A-5. It is pointed out that as there was conspiracy, A I and/or A-2 gave Account Payee cheques issued by Canara Bank on behalf of MUL payable to Grindlays Bank to Anuj Katia representative of A-5. Grindlays Bank deposited the said amount in the account of A-5 at Delhi and thereafter transferred the same to the account of A-5 at Bombay. Subsequently on the same day, it was transferred to UCO Bank and UCO Bank gave cheque to A-5.

)-

*

-

~

From the nature of aforesaid transactions, whether conspiracy can be inferred? It is true that apparently transactions are not simple. It casts serious doubt with regard to functioning of Banks and MUL. But as against this, the evidence which is brought on record by the prosecution establishes that these were routing/switch transactions. PWl4 Assistant Chief Officer, UCO Bank has stated that in case of security transactions on behalf of the client, they credit the sale proceeds receipt into the account of the client. PW-7 Karkhanis has specifically stated that Hamam Street branch on each day used to have 30-40 such transactions and such transactions were to be completed witl1in the banking hours. DW-A3(2) Mr. Ramnathan, who was the Divisional Manager of UCO Bank at Bombay Office has produced on record the letter dated 08.1.1991 Ex.231 written by him indicating resumption of switch transactions and that letter was written after discussing the subject with various authorities including brokers, Zonal Manager and also with General Manager and Dy. General Manager of UCO Bank.

-.:,; ...

-...,I.._

~

It appears that such irregular and unjustified banking practice had

developed. But in view of the evidence for such routing/switch transaction developed by the banks/brokers, it cannot be inferred that there was any conspiracy between A I, A2 and A3 or A4 and AS. As stated above, this irregular practice is also discussed by JPC. The JPC had arrived at the conclusion that scrutiny of securities transactions in a number of banks revealed that some banks were even handing over account payee cheques drawn in favour of other banks to the brokers who got them credited to their account ostensibly to assist the latter in transferring the funds quickly to meet their obligations. This was done as per infonnal understanding and in the name of market practice. The payee bank used to credit the proceeds to the accounts

~.

-

--"

I'

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.)

of the broker constituents who brought the cheque to it for collection. The JPC also observed that routing of transactions of many brokers including A5 had been carried out by banks. The banks were lending their names to the transactions of these brokers and exposed themselves to great risk by irregularly issuing their own BRs. Therefore, if this commercial practice was rightly or wrongly developed in various banks or the PSUs, it cannot be inferred that there was any conspiracy between the banks and PSUs or that there Y(3S consi>iracy between A-1, A-2, A-3, A-4 and A-5. Further, in the present case, .there is no evidence on record that BRs were issued by the UCO Bank without being backed by the security namely UT! Units.

c

In this set of circumstances, it would be difficult to hold that prosecution has proved the charge of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B of IPC against the accused. I would also state that it is not properly understood by the prosecuting agency that by introducing or adding a new story in a criminal prosecution, in most of the cases, it adversely affects or destroys the prosecution case. Not only it creates doubts with regard to that part of the prosecution version but on occasions casts doubt about the motive. Result is-under our criminal jurisprudence, benefit of doubt may go to the accused.

Once we arrive at the conclusion that the prosecution has failed to prove the criminal conspiracy, the conviction of the accused under Section 120-B of IPC requires to be set aside. JURISDICTION OF THE SPECIAL COURT UNDER THE SCAM ACT. At the outset, it is to be stated that accused were tried under the SCAM Act which was preceded by an Ordinance promulgated on 6th June, 1992. In the year 1992, it was noticed that there was a scam in the stock exchange as there was sudden rise or fall of prices in the stock market and large number of persons who were trading in stock exchange were losing their money. Some of them were experienced gamblers at the stock exchange and most of them were laymen. As per the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Act, large scale irregularities and malpractices were noticed by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in relation to transactions in both the Government and other securities indulged in by some brokers in collusion with the banks and financial

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

A initltutions. The irregularities and mal-practices noticed by the RBI were

C

with regard to diversion of funds from banks and financial institutions to · individual account'S of certain brokers. Hence, the SCAM Act was enacted which provid~s for establishment of a Special Court for tJt~ trial of offences relating to transactions in securities and for matters conhected therewith or incidental thereto. The object of the Act is to deal with situation mentioned above and in particular to ensure speedy rec!overy of huge amount involved, to punish the guilty and moore ttlhfldence in and maintain the basic integrity and credibility t>fthe bittlt<s and financial institutions. Under Section 5 of the SCAM Ad; Specilll Court is to be established and one or more sitting Judges of the Hi;h Court would have jurisdiction in respect of any offence referred t<> in sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the SCAM Act. Section 3(2) reads thus:-

'3. Appointment and functions of Custodian.(1)

D.

(2) The Custodian may, on being satisfied on infonnation received that any person has been involved in any offence relating to transactions in securities after the /st day of April, 1991 and on and before 6th June, 1992, notify the name of such person in the Official Gazette.' Hence, under the Act, jurisdiction of the Special Court is limited for offences relating to transactions in securities after the 1st April, 1991 and on or before 6.6.1992 and the Court is required to follow the procedure prescribed by the Code of Criminal Procedure for the trial of warrant cases before a Magistrate. Sections 6 and 7 inter alia provide that the Special Court would have exclusive jurisdiction to take cognizance of or to try such cases as are instituted before it or transferred to it as provided. Further, it is to be clearly understood that the Act does not create any new offence nor brings about any change in the procedure or raises any presumption pertaining to an offence punishable under the IPC or P.C. Act, which is to be tried under the Act. Therefore, the offences pertaining to misappropriation, criminal breach of trust or fraud and forgery are required to be established by the prosecution on the touchstone of ingredients laid down under the relevant provisions of Indian Penal Code and by following the Evidence .Act. Hence, for conviction under Section 403 arid/or Section 405 IPC the prosecution is required to establish the ingredients of said sections beyond reasonable doubt.

R.N. POPLI v. C.8.1. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

Therefore, as the prosecution has failed to establish the conspiracy, the jurisdiction of the Special Court would be limited only for the transactions which took place after Isl April, 1991. In the present case, only two transactions, i.e., dated 24.4.1991 and 2.5.1991 would be covered.

CASE AGAINST A-1 AND A-2

In this case, as the prosecution has failed to establish criminal conspiracy, we are required to consider the prosecution case against each accused for the acts committed by them and to find out whether they have committed any offences. The case of the prosecution against A-1 and A-2 is as follows:(a) A-1 and A-2 misappropriated the property in violation of the law as well as their duty (express and implied) by making it available for use of A-S. This is on account of the fact that they were authorised to invest the money in defined securities in a transaction with Public Sector Undertakings only. They, however, knowingly entered into a series of transactions, which had the result of making the funds of MUL available to AS . . (b) A-I and A-2 were also admittedly public servants during the material time. They abused their position and thereby conferred a pecuniary advantage upon A-S and in any event while holding office as a public servant obtained a pecuniary advantage for AS against public interest. Thus, they were charged with an offence u/s 13(1)(c) of the PC Act. It is also pointed out that the evidence given by the prosecution witnesses of the MUL inter a/ia establishes the following-

C

(a) A-1 was the Deputy Manager and A-2 was senior exe~utive working closely with him.

(b) 'F/iat MUL had taken a decision to invest its funds with PSUs. In fa't:t it was clarified that investment would only be in PSU bonds.

(c) A-I used to place the proposals before the Board and obtain approvals for the investments in question. ( d) MUL did not engage services of brokers for its transactions. (e) A-I and A-2 used to give instructions on the basis of which

SUPREME COURt R~PORTS

letters addressed to ba\\ks were prepared.

',A (f)

[2003) t S.C.R.

The Banket;s cheques were handed over on the instructions of A·l 'Ot A-2 to Anuj Kalia - an employee of A-5.

(g) The vouchers prepared in MUL clearly suggest that transaction Was between MUL and UCO Bank. This has also been stated by PW4 in his cross-examination. In the circumstances, it is submitted that it is very clear that the transaction, which was authorised, was ~a transaction in securities directly with UCO Bank.

y--

(h) The fact that the pay order was being given to Grindlays Bank in a transaction with UCO Bank was brought to the notice of AI by PW4 to which A-l's reply was that it was the problem of UCO Bank.

c (i)

The contention that A- I was instructed by UCO b.ank to issue the pay order in favour of Grindlays Bank is unacceptable for the simple reason that in the fourth and the fifth transaction pay order continued to be issued to Grindlays Bank without any direction from UCO bank.

G)

In any event, there was no authorisation to purchase any securities from any brokers. There was no mention of the monies being given on loan to any broker. It bears emphasis that surplus funds were many times invested in securities in buy back transaction, in that the arrangement would be to purchase a security and then resell it within a stipulated time after the identified period at a price which would include the cost of purchase plus the stipulated interest. This ~ransaction was considered as placement of funds with PSUs. The witnesses have clearly stated that the only authorisation for placement of surplus funds was PSUs and not private person.

+-

-.I,._

,:(

CHARGES AGAINST A-2

(a)

He was present in the meeting held in April/May, 1989.

(b) He signed letter dated 25.2.1991 for issuing a pay order in the name of ANZ Grindlays bank and also wrote in his own handwriting to Canara Bank that the pay order might be handed over to one Mr. Anuj Kalia (PW16) [Ex.26-first transaction).

(c) He signed letter dated 18.3.1991 for issuing pay order in the

. _,../

,' R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, J.]

name of ANZ Grindlays Bank (Ex.31-third transaction)

(d) He signet! letter dated 24.4.1991 for issuing a pay order in the name of ANZ Grindlays bank (Ex.33--4th transaction). (e) He discharged a bank receipt after the money was received by MUL on 26.4.1991 (Ex.41--4th transaction).

The learned senior counsel Mr. Jain appearing on behalf of A-2 submitted thus:For Charge (a)The prosecution lias miserably failed to establish conspiracy sought to be proved by examining PW23 Mr. Khandelwal. This submission requires to be accepted as discussed above.

C

For Charge (b)A2 signed the letter dated 25.2.1991 (Ex.26) in routine manner and the same was put up by PW4 under the instructions of Al, who confinns the same in his statement under Section 313 CrPC.

For Charge (c)-

)L

The letter dated 18.3.1991 was written by PW8 after the decision with regard to investment had been taken by the sub-Committee and conveyed to A· I. In his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., A· l admitted that MUL got issued banker's cheque dated 18.3.1991 favouring ANZ Grindlays Bank as per written instructions of UCO Bank. A2 signed the said letter being authorised signatory. PW8 in his entire deposition has nowhere mentioned that the letter was written under instructions of A2. The said document can not be said to have been signed by A2 with any criminal intent and as such this circumstance cannot be used against A2 for implicating him in the offences alleged. For Charge (d)-

Letter dated 24.4.1991 was also written by PW8 after the decision for

< investment had been taken by sub-Committee and conveyed to Al and Al confirmed that MUL got banker's cheque dated 24.4.1991 issued in the name of ANZ Grindlays bank in respect of transaction between MUL and UCO Bank. A2 signed the letter being authorised signatory.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2003) I S.C.R.

For Charge (e)-

No charge has been framed against A2 in respect of any BR. Since the prosecution had cited document Ex.41 during arguments before this Court, the same is being replied to by A-2 as under:-

c

"A2 saw this BR at the ti!lle of discharge as authorised signatory after MUL had got the money back and the transaction had got reversed. When PW4 who was the custodian of all records of every transaction and was maintaining BRs, put up the said BR for discharge before A2 for signing after MUL had got the money back, he signed the same in a routine manner." Under the circumstances, it is submitted that no criminality can be imputed against A2 for signing this BR as an authorised signatory after the reversal of the transaction. Hence, it is submitted that this circumstance also cannot be held against A2.

+

Learned senior counsel further submitted that as there is no evidence against A-2, the Special Court had rightly acquitted him and in the appeal also learned Solicitor General appearing on behalf of CBI has not pointed out any material evidence to hold that the judgment and order passed by the Special Court calls for any interference in acquittal appeal.

He referred to Ex.26 and submitted that the said document is signed by him but as deposed by PW4 the said document was authored by PW4 and approved by A-1 and, therefore, it cannot be held that he did anything wrong in mentioning in the said letter that cheque may be handed over to Anuj Katia. It is his submission that even handing over of cheque to a person· who had brought 35 lacs of units for being delivered to MUL cannot be termed in any way as dereliction of duty. Learned senior counsel Mr.Sundaram on behalf of A- I has given detailed written submissions and has inter alia submitted that the prosecution has failed to establish that(a) A-1 mis-represented to the sub-committee of the MUL regarding transfer of funds to UCO Bank on UCO Bank's instructions through Grindlays Bank;

.-(

(b) A-1 mis-represented to the sub-committee by not putting to their

..-'.

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH,),)

knowledge the resolution (If tho ftll8rd dated 4th May, I 989;

(c) The charge of conspiracy Is fabricated one; (d) There was no mens rea for the alleged criminal breach of trust on the part of A-I;

-~

(e) In any case, it would be totally unjustified to hold that Al was having any dominion over MUL's properties. There is no misrepresentation nor any loss to the MUL, There is no evidence on record suggesting that A-I WM knowing that the funds were disposed of by UCO a.ml< in favour of A-5. MUL has given funds to the UCO Bftnk and it ls not the function of MUL to verify from UCO Bank as to how the said funds are utilised;

(t) ·~

c

Th@ @h~rges under the provisions of Section 13(1Xc) of PC Act and Section 409 of IPC are without any foundation;

(g) The evidence of PW7 and PWl4, both officials from UCO Bank have deposed that they could not differentiate whether BRs and letters pertaining to the relevant transactions shown to them pertain to a transaction conducted on behalf of their bank or on behalf of the client broker; and _,>...

(h) Prosecution has failed to examine material witnesses, i.e., Mr. R.C. Bhargava, Chairman-cum-Managing Director and Mr. S. Natrajan, Director (Finance), even though they were available all-throughout and who were examined by the JPC and IO.

FINDINGS:

)l

I would first refer to the resolution dated 4th May, 1989 of the MUL for investment of surplus fund' and also the resolutions for investment for the five transactions in question, which are proved and produced on record. ln that resolution, the Board of MUL laid down guidelines for investment of surplus funds by MUL, which read thus:"Resolutlon d11ted 4.5.1989 (Ex.9) l!OARI) AGENDA ITEM N0.17 INVESTMENT OF SURPLUS FUNDS BY MUL

1.0 In terms of the existing guidelines from the Board, MUL has been loaning its surplus funds to Central Public Sector Undertllkings consistent with the terms and conditions of the approval" accorded by the Central Government u/s 3 70 of · H

fl

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2003) I S.C.R.

Companies Act, 1956. 2.0 A Sub-Committee comprising the Managing Director and Director (Finance) has been delegated the authority by the Board to facilitate taking faster decision in this regard. The details of investment made are placed in the Board meeting for information.

c

3.0 Of late, the number of PSUs, who have surplus funds wanting to loan funds to PSUs has increased. Some PSUs, who were earlier requiring temporary accommodation are now in a position to give funds. As a result of this, there is an increasing competition between PSUs affecting the yield on such loaning of funds.

4.0 In an effort to maximise yield on surplus funds, it is proposed to invest funds in the units of UTI, Central Govt. securities, public sector bonds either through scheduled banks or directly. These investments, at times, are expected to fetch a higher rate of return than what is available on loaning of funds to PSUs without involving any risk as to the return of the principal and/or yield.

5.0 It is, therefore, proposed that the Board may permit the SubCommittee formed by it for the purpose to invest surplus funds of the company from time to time in the purchase of units of . UTI, Central Government and State Govt. Securities, public sector bonds either through scheduled banks or directly.

6.0 In March, 1989, MUL invested surplus funds in PSU Bonds, Units of UTI and Central Govt. Securities as contained in the Annexure. The Board may kindly accord ex post facto approval for such investments made to utilise the opportunity of high yield during such periods. 7.0 The Board may kindly approve proposals in paras 5.0 and 6.0 above."

\

Much has been contended that the Board resolution dated 4.5.1989 (Ex.9) passed by the Board of Directors of MUL prohibits granting of loan in favour of individuals and, therefore, transactions by A-5 with MUL are illegal and against the policy of MUL and, therefore, A-5 misappropriated, even though temporariiy, the amount of MUL. The afore-quoted resolution inter alia provides that it was open to the MUL to invest the surplus funds in the UTI units through scheduled banks or directly. The reason being, these investments were expected to fetch higher rate of interest than what is available

~

-y-·

-+

-./.....

.J(

~.

R.N. POPLI v. C.B.I. [M.B. SHAH, l.]

..+·

· on loaning of funds to PSUs without invoking any risk as to return of the A principal and/or yield. It is also provided that Board has pennitted the subcommittee to invest surplus funds of the Company in the purchase of units ofUTI either through scheduled banks or directly. It is admitted position that on the basis of the resolution, sub-committee was constituted consisting of Chainnan-cum-Managing Director and Director (Finance) for the purpose of B investment. It is also proved that all the five transactions took place after the subcommittee passed appropriate resolutions.

c

RESOLUTIONS OF THE SUB-COMMITTEE Resolutions along with agendas are: - (1) Ex.22 dated 01.2.1991, (2) Ex.23 dated 13.3.1991, (3) Ex.24 dated 18.3.1991, (4) Ex.40 dated 24.4.1991 and (5) Ex.42 dated 02.5.1991. Relevant part of resolutions is reproduced hereunder:-

(1) Ex.22 dated 01.2.1991

"MARUTI UDYOG LIMITED (CORPORATE FINANCE) No.MULIFIN./CF/91. 1st February, 91.

Sub:- Funds Management 1.0 In November and December Maruti has placed lot of money in Government Securities/Units and PSU Bonds through Banks. These investments have been made for a period of 3 months to 6 months on assured yield ranging from 16.25% to 22% per annum.

•

2.0 During the last week of December and in January, the receipt of payments were relatively less. Maruti was required to borrow funds or withdraw money from PSU's. One of the options G available for borrowing was to sell our investments to other banks with a understanding to buy back these investments after a gap of 30 days or so. This amounts to borrowing of funds at low rates, as Maruti will continue to get advantage of the high assured yield. The bank with whom we have earlier invested the funds H

and the bank from whom we borrow the funds need not necessarily be the same

Related judgments

More Supreme Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.