Ramavatar v. State of Bihar and ORS.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 7 April 1997
- Bench
- Justice K. Ramaswamy, Justice D.P. Wadhwa
- Neutral citation
- 1997 INSC 381
- Reported in
- [1997] 3 S.C.R. 683
- Result
- Dismissed
- Advocates
- Civil Appeal Nos, Pramod Swarup, Pravir Chaudhry, Manoj Saxena, Irshad Ahmad, K.N. Rai, B.B. Singh, Madhya Pradesh, Patna, Admittedly, Late Tulsi Sah, Late Mahabir Sah, Ram Avatar, Kaushalya, Laxmi Narayan
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
l
'
)
l.
RAMAVATAR
A
v. STATE OF BIHAR AND ORS. APRIL 7, 1997 [K. RAMASWAMY AND D.P. WADHWA, .IJ.) Scheduled Tribe-Status certificate-Ge11ui11eness of-Appel/a/It's claim for promotion on the basis of Scheduled Tribe status-Rejection of-None of appellant's forefather granted status certificate-Family histo1y indicated that his claim was higlily doubtful-Appellant held not eligible for status as Scheduled Tribe. CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 2951-52 of 1997. From the Judgment and Order dated 15.4.96 of the Patna High Court in L.P.A. No. 130of1996 and 165of1996.
C ..,
D
Pramod Swarup for the Appellant. Pravir Chaudhry, Manoj Saxena and Irshad Ahmad for the Respondents. K.N. Rai and B.B. Singh for the Respondent No. 7.
E
The following Order of the Court was delivered : Leave granted. The appellant claims for promotion as Engineer-in-Chief on the basis of a Scheduled Tribe Status. In the judgment in Major Yogendra Narain F Yadav v. State of Bihar & Ors., the right of the person has been determined. In this case, the question arises is: whether the appellant really belongs to Scheduled Tribe? With a view to find the genuineness of the status as Scheduled Tribes, we had directed the petitioner to file genealogy table of his family history. It is now admitted in his affidavit that the family of the appellant hails from Bilaspur, Madhya Pradesh. He claims that his G forefathers had migrated to Bihar and that the appellant had _done his education there and had obtained the certificate also from the District Magistrate, Patna. Admittedly, none of his forefathers had been granted any such certificate. The family history, as stated in the affidavit indicates as under: H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
(1997) 3 S.C.R.
"GENEOLOGY Late Chilbili Sah Late Chintaman Sah Late Hira Sah
c
Late Tulsi Sah
Late J anki Sah
Late Mahabir Sah
Ram Avatar (Son)
Kaushalya (Widow) (Daughter)
Laxmi Narayan (Son)
I Married with Yashoda Devi Ara District Old Shahabad District.
D
Married with late Ganga Pd., Patna
Rashmi Bala Daughter
Married to Bagaha District Bettiah, Old District Motihari
Ushmi Bala Daughter
Abhijit Son
E ..... All are married ..... Shashi Nishi Bala Rishi Bala Bala
F
Daughter Daughter married
to O.P. Gond,
G
H
Patna City Patna
Pa wan Suman Sandhya Pragati Raman Kumar Kumar Gond Kumar
Daughter Good Son unn1arrn1arried son Raghunath to Unn1arr- ied Manjhi Lasia Birendra ied P.S.E. Sah Kurrudcg in Jarsuguda Semdega in in the Ranchi Sabalpur District now District Presently Gum la JharsuDistrict guda (Orissa)
n1arried to
Daughter Daughter Son married n1arried unto to Ajay n1arried Chapra Kr., District Patna presently Gopalganj District
/
RAMAVTAR.v. STATE
A reading of this family history indicates that his claim as Scheduled Tribe is not only highly doubtful but beyond comprehension to believe that he is eligible for the same. Under the circumstances, we do not find any substance to interfere with the order of the High Court. However, it would be open for the appellant to be entitled to compete as a general candidate.
A.
The appeals are accordingly dismissed but without any order as to
costs. T.N.A.
Appeals dismissed.