Ranjit Singh Thakur v. Honourable High Court of Hp

Court
High Court of Himachal Pradesh
Date of judgment
3 November 2026
Bench
Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Justice Yogesh Jaswal
Case number
CWP No. 11397 of 2025
Result
Disposed Off
Subject
Service

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

2026:HHC:49215

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA C.W.P No.11397 of 2025 Date of Decision: 03.11.2026 ____________________________________________________________ Ranjit Singh Thakur

...Petitioner Versus

Hon’ble High Court of H.P & others Coram

....Respondents

Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge Whether approved for reporting? Yes ________________________________________________________________ For the petitioner:

Mr.Vishal Sharma, Advocate (through V.C) and Mr. Karan Sharma, Advocate, for petitioner.

For the respondents:

Mr. Shriyek Sharda, Advocate, for respondent No.1

Mr. P.S. Goverdhan, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Rakesh Thakur, Advocate, for respondents No.2 to 5. _____________________________________________________________ Ajay Mohan Goel, J.(Oral) By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has, inter alia, prayed for the following reliefs: “(i)For quashing the order dated 18.10.2024 by

District

&

Sessions

Judge

Solan

(Annexure P-1) and also quashing the order

2. 2026:HHC:49215

dated 08.05.2025 (Annexure P-3) passed as non-speaking considering

non

reasoned

order

representation

dated

15.01.2025 (Annexure P-2) in the interest of justice

and

to

stop

back

door

entry

mechanism done to give benefit to certain class of people against the settle Himachal Pradesh

District

Judiciary

Staff

Recruitment, Promotion, control, conduct, discipline and other condition of service Rules,

2022

amendment

done

on

16.10.2024 (Annexure P-4) in the interest of justice by using inherent powers of this Hon’ble Court

which are there to prevent

sheer abuse of process of law and secure ends

of

justice

to

all

without

any

discrimination conferred to them under 226. (ii) And till the pendency of the present writ as a interim relief the implementation of office order dated 18.12.2024 (Annexure P1) to the extent of promotion on the post of chief administrative officer should be kept vacant by imposing stay on the said office order in the interest of justice fairness and equity otherwise there will be irreparable loss to the petitioner.” 2.

According to the petitioner, there is a post of Chief

Administrative Officer. As per him, in terms of Annexure P-4,

3. 2026:HHC:49215

appended with the petition i.e. Notification dated 16.10.2024, the Himachal Pradesh District Judiciary Staff (Recruitment, Promotion, Control, Conduct, Discipline and other conditions of service), Rules 2022 (herein after referred to as the “2022 Rules”) stood amended inter alia to the effect that the post of Senior Shrestedhar

in the Court of District Judge Forest,

CBI Courts, Family Courts and Additional District Judges Court, wherever post is sanctioned, is to be filled by placement from amongst the senior most Senior Sheristedars working in the Division and the post of Senior Sheristedar in the Court of Senior Civil Judge is to be filled by promotion from amongst the Sheristedars of the Courts of Civil Judges and Reader Grade-II working in Division, having

minimum

educational qualification of 10+2 and qualifying service of 2 years in the feeder category, in terms of option. Further, according to the petitioner, in terms of the said amendment, the post of Chief Administrative Officer was to be filled by way of promotion, by selection from amongst first six eligible officers in the cadre of Senior Shirastedars and Reader GradeI working in the concerned Civil and Sessions Division. 3.

According to the petitioner in terms of Annexure

P-1, i.e office order dated 18.12.2024, the private respondent-

4. 2026:HHC:49215

Devi Singh was

placed as Senior Sheristedar, which office

order was liable to be quashed and set aside, on the ground that as on the date when said office order was issued, said respondent was ineligible to be considered for promotion against the post of Senior Sheristedar, as possessing

he was not

the minimum educational qualification of 10+2.

On this premise, other reliefs have also been prayed for by the petitioner, including the relief that the post of Chief Administrative Officer be kept vacant during the pendency of the present petition. 4.

This writ petition was filed

on 15.07.2025 and

before filing of the same, the private respondent infact stood promoted against the post of Chief Administrative Officer vide Notification

dated 08.05.2025, Annexure R-2/5, appended

with the reply filed by the private respondents. In other words, before

the petitioner had filed the present writ petition,

Notification dated 08.05.2025 stood issued, which has not been assailed by the petitioner incidentally till date. 5.

Learned counsel of the petitioner submitted that

as Shri Devi Singh was not possessing the qualification of 10+2, which was the minimum educational qualification as per Annexure P-4 for promotion to the post of Senior

5. 2026:HHC:49215

Sheristedar

from

amongst

Sheristedars,

therefore,

his

promotion

to the post of Chief Administrative Officer (which

though is not under challenge) was bad in law, because as per him, same was contrary to Annexure P-4,

in terms

whereof, the post of Chief Administrative Officer was to be filled by way of promotion by selection from amongst first six eligible officials in the cadre of Senior Sheristedars and Reader Grade-II working in the concerned Civil and Sessions Division. As per the learned counsel as respondent Devi Singh was not eligible for promotion to the post of Sheristedar, this rendered

Senior

his promotion to the post of

Senior Sheristedar and also to the post of Chief Administrative Officer bad in law. This was the only argument, addressed before us by the learned counsel for the petitioner. 6.

On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for

respondent No.1 and learned Senior Counsel appearing for the private respondents drew the attention of the Court to the documents appended with the petition and have apprised the Court that respondent Devi Singh was promoted against the post of Senior Sheristedar vide office order dated 03.11.2017 Annexure R-2/1 and not vide office order dated 18.12.2024. They further apprised the Court that as on the date when the

6. 2026:HHC:49215

said promotion order was issued, the relevant Recruitment and Promotion Rules, which were in vogue,

relating to the

post of Senior Sheristedar, which stand appended with the reply

filed by the private respondents as Annexure RA,

provided that

the eligibility criteria for promotion against the

post of Senior Sheristedar was minimum qualification of Matric and qualifying service of two years in the feeder cadre. They submitted that as respondent Devi-Singh was fulfilling the eligibility criteria for promotion, as it was existing as on the date, when he was promoted against the post of Senior Sheristedar,

present

writ

petition

is

completely

misconceived. 7.

Learned Senior Counsel for the private respondents

further argued that

as

respondent-Devi Singh

stood

promoted against the post of Chief Administrative Officer even before the filing of the writ petition and as till date, there is no challenge to the said appointment, this petition is liable to be dismissed on this ground. 8.

In rebuttal, learned counsel for the petitioner

submitted that dehors

the fact whether Devi Singh stood

promoted against the post of Senior Sheristedar vide office order dated 03.11.2017 and

what was the requirement of

7. 2026:HHC:49215

Recruitment and Promotion Rules at because subsequently, this Rule was

the relevant

time,

amended in terms of

Annexure P-4 and as Devi Singh was not fulfilling the eligibility criteria for promotion to the post of Senior Sheristedar as per Annexure P-4, his promotion to the post of Senior Sheristedar was liable to be set aside and so also his promotion to the post of Chief Administrative Officer and he was liable to be demoted to the post of Sheristedar. 9.

We have heard learned counsel for the parties and

have also gone through the pleadings as well as documents appended with the petition. 10.

It is a matter of record that respondent Devi Singh

was promoted against the post of Senior Sheristedar vide office order dated 03.11.2017 (Annexure R-2/A). A perusal of this office order demonstrates that he was promoted as such by the order passed by the learned District & Sessions Judge, Solan, H.P. It is not in dispute that when

respondent-Devi

Singh was promoted as Senior Shirastedar on 03.11.2017, he was fulfilling the eligibility criteria, as was existing on the said date for promotion to the post of Senior Shirastedar. 11.

In light of the fact that as the private respondent

stood promoted to the post of Senior Sheristedar as on

8. 2026:HHC:49215

03.11.2017 and said promotion order is not under challenge, the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the said promotion of the private respondent has to be set aside

on account of the Notification issued on 16.10.2024,

deserves to be

negated. This is for the reason that service

jurisprudence does not provide that if a person already stands promoted to a particular post as per the prevailing Rules and subsequently, the R & P Rules qua the said post are amended and certain qualifications are added, which are not possessed by a person, who is already holding the promotional post, then post amendment in the R & P Rules, the promotion of that person to the post in issue as per the Rules existing at the time when the promotion was made, becomes bad in law and such an incumbent then has to be demoted. Therefore, in light of the said observations, the contention of the petitioner that because on 16.10.2024, the minimum educational qualification for promotion to the post of Senior Sheristedar from amongst the Sheristedars working in the Courts of Civil Judges and the Reader Grade-II stood amended, the private respondent should be demoted from the post of Senior Sheristedar as his promotion becomes bad in law, is rejected.

9. 2026:HHC:49215

12.

Further,

demonstrates that

a

perusal

of

vide office order

Annexure

P-1

dated 16.12.2024,

respondent Devi Singh, Superintendent Grade-II in the office of District and Sessions Judge, Solan, H.P, who stood designated as Senior Sheristedar, was placed as such in the same office. Meaning thereby, that as on the date when this office order was issued, the private respondent was serving in the office of Additional District & Sessions Judge, Solan and therefore also, the minimum educational qualification, which otherwise was relevant for Sheristedar,

promotion to the post of Senior

has no relevance as far as the facts of this case

are concerned. This is

for the reason that this minimum

qualification has to be read only vis-a-vis the promotion of a Sheristedar in the Courts of Civil Judges and Reader Grade-II to the post of Senior Sheristedar in the Court of Civil Judges. Besides this, Annexure P-4, which was a Notification issued on 16.10.2024, obviously has to be applied prospectively, meaning thereby that after said amendment was incorporated in the 2022 Rules, thereafter, a Senior Sheristedar was to be appointed by way of promotion in terms of this particular Rule. In light of the fact that Devi Singh was already serving as a Senior Sheristedar when this amendment was brought

10. 2026:HHC:49215

into force, he was eligible for promotion by selection to the post of Chief Administrative Officer, because his eligibility for promotion to the said post was not to be judged from the perspective of the amendment which was carried out vide Annexure

P-4

qua

promotions

to

post

of

Senior

Sheristedar. 13.

Therefore, in

light of the above discussions, we

have no hesitation in holding that the present writ petition is completely misconceived. In light of the fact that the private respondent stood promoted to the post of Senior Sheristedar as far back as in the year 2017 and as at the relevant time, he was fulfilling the eligibility criteria provided in the R & P Rules, which governed

promotion to the post of Senior

Sheristedar at that time, the prayer of the petitioner of quashing Annexure P-1 is hereby rejected

and so are the

subsequent prayers of the petitioner. Petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. (Ajay Mohan Goel) Judge

November 03, 2026 (meera)

(Yogesh Jaswal) Judge

Related judgments

More Himachal Pradesh High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.