Sanjay Vitthalrao Shinde v. District Co-Operative Election Officer, Pune, and Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-Op. Soc., Pune DIV.

Court
Bombay High Court
Date of judgment
16 November 2026
Case number
WP No. 5976 of 2026
Result
Disposed Off

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

2026:BHC-KOL:11124

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIRCUIT BENCH AT KOLHAPUR CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 5976 OF 2026 Sanjay Vitthalrao Shinde, Age : 58 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Post Nimgaon (T.), Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005.

2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

Ranjit Babanrao Shinde, at Post Nimgaon (T.), Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

5.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, at Post Nimgaon (T.), Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

6.

Ganpatrao Dhanajirao Sathe, Mitraprem, Mangalwar Peth, Madha, Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

7.

Bharat Haribhau Shinde, at and post Aran, Taluka Madha,

8.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

9.

The State of Maharashtra, Through the Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textiles Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5971 OF 2026 Ranjitsinh Vijaysinh Mohite-Patil, Age : 54 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Patil Wada, Akluj, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur.

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005.

2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

5.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

6.

Sachin Panchappa Kalyanshetti, Residing at Hunnar, Taluka Akkalkot,

7.

Vishweshwar Tukappa Nagur, Residing at Hunnar, Taluka Akkalkot,

8.

Sanjiv Sidramappa Patil, Residing at Kumathe, Post Kasegaon, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur.

9.

Ranveer Rajendra Raut, Residing at Ashok Nagar, Barshi, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur.

10.

Rajendra Vitthal Raut, Residing at Ashok Nagar, Barshi, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur.

11.

Shambhuraje Jaywantrao Jagtap, Residing at Satbai Farmhouse, Nagar-Tembhurni Bypass Road, Karmala, Taluka Karmala,

12.

Subhash Jagannath Gulve, Residing at Takali, Taluka Karmala,

13.

Subhash Dinkarrao Nimbalkar, Residing at Malinagar, Taluka Malshiras,

14.

Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil, Residing at Shankar Nagar, Taluka Malshiras,

15.

Shahajirao Mudhojirao Deshmukh, Residing at Natepute, Taluka Malshiras,

16.

Sangramsinh Ajitsinh Jahagirdar, Ro. Piliv, Taluka Malshiras,

17.

Dnyanraj Sanjay Patil, Residing at Natepute, Taluka Malshiras,

18.

Ranjit Babanrao Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

19.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

20.

Ganpatrao Dhanaji Sathe, Residing at Mangalwar Peth, Madha, Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

21.

Bharat Haribhau Shinde, Residing at Aran, Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

22.

Sushil Babanrao Awatade Residing at Nagne Wadi, Taluka Mangalwedha,

23.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade, Residing at Hivargaon, Post Dongargaon, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

24.

Vikrant Rajan Patil, Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol,

25.

Kalyan Vasantrao Kale, Residing at Wadi Kuroli, Taluka Pandharpur,

26.

Umesh Prabhakar Paricharak, Residing at Vijapur Galli, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

27.

Pranav Mukund Paricharak, Residing at Vijapur Galli, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

28.

Popat Ramchandra Gadade, Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

29.

Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate, Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola,

30.

Subhash Krushnadev Patil, Residing at Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

31.

Maruti Namdev Dhale, Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola,

32.

Gajendra Jagannath Kolekar, Residing at Kidebisari, Nagaj, Taluka Sangola,

33.

Babasaheb Annasaheb Deshmukh, Residing at Station Road, Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

34.

Chetansinh Tatyasaheb Kedar Sawant, R/o. Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

35.

Vilas Narayan Patil, Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola,

36.

Siddheshwar Mhallappa Metkari, Residing at Gherdi, Taluka Sangola,

37.

Sanjay Ganapati Ingole, Residing at Ekhatpur, Taluka Sangola,

38.

Atul Pawar, R/o. Methawade, Taluka Sangola,

39.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Residing at Sumitra Niwas, Plot No. 7, Gangadhar Housing Society, Hotgi, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur.

40.

Dhananjay Adnyanrao Bhosale, Residing at Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur,

41.

Babasaheb Kisanrao Patil, Residing at Mardi, Taluka North Solapur,

42.

Shridip Suresh Hasapure, Residing at Saiful, Taluka South Solapur,

43.

Bharati Rajshekhar Shivdare, Residing near Dayanand College, Solapur, Taluka North Solapur,

44.

Radha Rajendra Suravase, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

45.

Asmita Suresh Gaikwad, Residing at Ramakant Karnik Nagar, Solapur.

46.

Mandakini Popat Gadade, Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

47.

Shrushti Mahesh Tikke, Residing at Salgar, Taluka Mangalwedha,

48.

Nilabai Balaso Katkar Residing at Waki, Taluka Sangola,

49.

Sindhu Suresh Patil, Residing at Varawade, Taluka Madha,

50.

Rohini Ramchandra Tadwalkar, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Ajoba Ganapati, Solapur.

51.

Shobha Shrishail Banshetti, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Dudh Galli, Solapur.

52.

Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate, Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola,

53.

Nita Devanand Gund, Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol,

54.

Priyanka Umakant Bhagat, Residing at Narotewadi, Taluka North Solapur,

55.

Rupmati Dipak Salunkhe, Residing at Jawala, Taluka Sangola,

56.

Shamal Digambarrao Bagal, Residing at Mangi, Taluka Karmala,

57.

Vanita Subhash Gulve, Residing at Takali, Taluka Sangola,

58.

Ashwini Sujit Bagal, Residing at Mangi, Taluka Karmala,

59.

Vanita Maruti Lawate, Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola,

60.

Puja Santosh Chougule, Residing at Wadegaon, Taluka Sangola,

61.

Sindhu Pratap Patil, Residing at Sakat, Pananga, Taluka Barshi,

62.

Suvarna Sushilkumar Dalave, Residing at Ambegaon, Jawalgaon, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur.

63.

Nandabai Haridas Kevare, Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala,

64.

Rukmini Vitthal Randive, Residing at Lotewad Martand Wada, Tungat, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

65.

Vaishali Bhagwan Chougule, Residing at Bhalwani, Taluka Pandharpur,

66.

Archana Dilip Ghadge, Residing at Suste, Taluka Pandharpur,

67.

Minal Ganpatrao Sathe, Residing at Madha, Taluka Madha,

68.

Chhayadevi Sopan Naranavar, Residing at Umbare, Taluka Malshiras,

69.

Triveni Sham Akale, Residing at Hajapur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

70.

Kavita Dattatray Khadtare, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

71.

Shankar Bhagwat Gaikwad, Residing at Haldahiwade, Taluka Sangola,

72.

Vishnu Ambadas Waghmare, Residing at Hiraj, Taluka North Solapur,

73.

Jayant Tanaji Sale, Residing at Hunnur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

74.

Arvind Anna Bhosale, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

75.

Mahadev Murlidhar Sabale, Residing at Khandali, Taluka Malshiras,

76.

Nanasaheb Pandharinath Naiknavare, Residing at Tondale, Taluka Malshiras,

77.

Arvind Anna Bhosale, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

78.

Mahadev Kisan Kamble, Residing at Upalai, Taluka Barshi,

79.

Malhari Bapu Dhobale, Residing at Fondshiras, Taluka Malshiras,

80.

Kisan Nivrutti Satpute, Residing at Piliv, Taluka Malshiras,

81.

Ram Vitthal Satpute, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

82.

Dattatray Tatya Khadtare, Residing at Sarkari Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

83.

Kavita Dattatray Khadtare, Residing at Sarkari Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

84.

Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil, Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol,

85.

Basavaraj Ramgonda Patil, Residing at Maroli, Shiranandani, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

86.

Shrishail Devansiddh Banshetti, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur.

87.

Shridip Suresh Hasapure, Residing near Suresh Ganapati, Saiful, Solapur.

88.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur.

89.

Chidanand Virbhadra Swami, Residing at Wani Chinchale, Taluka Sangola,

90.

Nagnath Devram Shinde, Residing at Upalai, Taluka Barshi,

91.

Vishal Haridas Kevare, Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala,

92.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

93.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

94.

Sham Tukaram Akale, Residing at Hajapur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

95.

Hanmant Tatabo Masal, Residing at Hivargaon, Taluka Mangalwedha,

96.

Popat Ramchandra Gadade Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

97.

Rahul Baba Ghutukade Residing at Manewadi, Taluka Mangalwedha,

98.

Vilas Bhiva Lengare Residing at Murari Peth, Solapur.

99.

Sanjay Tukaram Rathod Residing at Tinhe Tanda, Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur.

100. Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola, 101. Prathamesh Vasantrao Patil, Residing at Bhandarkavathe, Taluka South Solapur, District Solapur. 102. Aniket Chandrakant Deshmukh Residing at Sangola, Taluka Mangalwedha,

103. Shivaji Abadas Kamble Residing at Aran, Taluka Madha, 104. Maruti Bhimrao Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola, 105. Rahul Bajirao Waghmode Residing at Chakore, Taluka Malshiras, 106. Birmal Bhimrao Koli Residing at Dahitane Tulshidas, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur. 107. Rajendra Dhulappa Bandichhode Residing at Saphale, Taluka Akkalkot, 108. Shridhar Upendram Kondale Residing at Hyderabad Road, Solapur. 109. Tanaji Maruti Waghmode Residing at Tisangi, Taluka Pandharpur, 110. Vilas Narayan Patil Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola, 111. Dnyanraj Sanjay Patil Residing at Natepute, Taluka Sangola, 112. Mahendra Manohar Khatke Residing at Narotewadi, Taluka North Solapur, 113. Hanmant Devba Sul Residing at Marochi, Taluka Malshiras,

114. Sushil Babanrao Awatade Residing at Khandoba Galli, Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 115. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 116. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 117. Baburao Ramchandra Gaikwad Residing at Sangola, Taluka Sangola, 118. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at Jalave, Taluka Sangola, 119. Ramesh Pandurang Jadhav Patil Residing at Shivajinagar, Sangola, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur. 120. Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 121. Vijay Narayan Tate Residing at Sangam Narasingpur, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 122. Dhairyashil Rajsinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Yashwantnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 123. Sangramsinh Ajitsinh Jahagirdar Residing at Piliv, Taluka Malshiras, 124. Milan Malappa Kalyanshetti Residing at Solapur Road, Akkalkot, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur.

125. Nagaraj Irappa Kumbhar Residing at Mahadev Nagar, Akkalkot, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 126. Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 127. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 128. Abhijit Dhananjay Patil Residing at Degaon, Taluka Pandharpur, 129. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 130. Malhari Bhausaheb Gaikwad Residing at Pare, Taluka Sangola, 131. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at Jalave, Taluka Sangola, 132. Dhairyashil Rajsinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Yashwantnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 133. Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Taluka Malshiras, 134. Maruti Bhimrao Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola, 135. Vanita Maruti Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola,

136. Puja Santosh Chougule Residing at Wadegaon, Taluka Sangola, 137. Shivaji Balbhim Patil Residing at Chandaj, Adegaon, Taluka Sangola, 138. Balasaheb Mahadev Mali Residing at Shevate, Taluka Pandharpur, 139. Abhijit Dilip Ghadge Residing at Suste, Taluka Pandharpur, 140. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 141. Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur. 142. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 143. Manish Subhash Deshmukh Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur. 144. Subhash Sureshchandra Deshmukh Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur. 145. Prakash Shamrao Patil Residing at Paniv, Taluka Malshiras, 146. Asmita Suresh Gaikwad Residing at Ramakant Karnik Nagar, Solapur.

147. Kalyan Vasantrao Kale Residing at Wadi Kuroli, Taluka Pandharpur, 148. Bhimashankar Nagappa Jamadar Residing at Musti, Taluka South Solapur, 149. Siddharam Baburao Chakote Residing at Jodbhavi Peth, Mangalwar Bazar, Solapur. 150. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 151. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 152. Amol Balasaheb Shinde Residing at Uttar Kasba Choupad, Solapur. 153. Rohini Ramchandra Tadwalkar Residing at Near Ajoba Ganapati, Solapur. 154. Shahaji Gulchand Pawar Residing at Mardi, Taluka North Solapur, 155. Rajendra Shivaraya Gangade Residing at Hotgi, Taluka South Solapur, 156. Kanhatyalal Girdhardas Devi Residing at Karmala, Taluka Karmala, 157. Shrishail Revansiddh Banshetti Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur.

158. Shobha Shrishail Banshetti Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur. 159. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at J alave, Taluka Sangola, 160. Devanand Raosaheb Gund Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol, 161. Nita Devanand Gund Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol, 162. Arvind Shrimant Kalel Residing at Somewadi, Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur. 163. Chandrashekhar Jaynarayan Kondambheri Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 164. Subhash Jagannath Gulve Residing at Takali, Taluka Karmala, 165. Bharat Haribhau Jadhav Residing at Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur, 166. Shankar Mallikarjun Patil Residing at Vajreshwari. Nagar, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur. 167. Balaso Nivrutti Katkar Residing at Waki Shivane, Taluka Sangola, 168. Shridhar Upendram Kondale Residing at Bidi Gharkul, Hyderabad Road, Solapur.

169. Vishal Haridas Kevare Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala, 170. Pranav Mukund Paricharak Residing at Pradakshina Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, 171. Rajkumar Baburao Hanchate Residing at Akkalkot Road, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 172. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5972 OF 2026 Ranjitsinh Vijaysinh Mohite-Patil, Age : 54 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Patil Wada, Akluj, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur.

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005.

2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

5.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

6.

Sachin Panchappa Kalyanshetti, Residing at Hunnar, Taluka Akkalkot,

7.

Vishweshwar Tukappa Nagur, Residing at Hunnar, Taluka Akkalkot,

8.

Sanjiv Sidramappa Patil, Residing at Kumathe, Post Kasegaon, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur.

9.

Ranveer Rajendra Raut, Residing at Ashok Nagar, Barshi, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur.

10.

Rajendra Vitthal Raut, Residing at Ashok Nagar, Barshi, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur.

11.

Shambhuraje Jaywantrao Jagtap, Residing at Satbai Farmhouse, Nagar-Tembhurni Bypass Road, Karmala, Taluka Karmala,

12.

Subhash Jagannath Gulve, Residing at Takali, Taluka Karmala,

13.

Subhash Dinkarrao Nimbalkar, Residing at Malinagar, Taluka Malshiras,

14.

Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil, Residing at Shankar Nagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur.

15.

Shahajirao Mudhojirao Deshmukh, Residing at Natepute, Taluka Malshiras,

16.

Sangramsinh Ajitsinh Jahagirdar, Ro. Piliv, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur.

17.

Dnyanraj Sanjay Patil, Residing at Natepute, Taluka Malshiras,

18.

Ranjit Babanrao Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

19.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

20.

Ganpatrao Dhanaji Sathe, Residing at Mangalwar Peth, Madha, Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

21.

Bharat Haribhau Shinde, Residing at Aran, Taluka Madha,

22.

Sushil Babanrao Awatade Residing at Nagne Wadi, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

23.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade, Residing at Hivargaon, Post Dongargaon, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

24.

Vikrant Rajan Patil, Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol,

25.

Kalyan Vasantrao Kale, Residing at Wadi Kuroli, Taluka Pandharpur,

26.

Umesh Prabhakar Paricharak, Residing at Vijapur Galli, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

27.

Pranav Mukund Paricharak, Residing at Vijapur Galli, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

28.

Popat Ramchandra Gadade, Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

29.

Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate, Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola,

30.

Subhash Krushnadev Patil, Residing at Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

31.

Maruti Namdev Dhale, Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola,

32.

Gajendra Jagannath Kolekar, Residing at Kidebisari, Nagaj, Taluka Sangola,

33.

Babasaheb Annasaheb Deshmukh, Residing at Station Road, Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

34.

Chetansinh Tatyasaheb Kedar Sawant, R/o. Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

35.

Vilas Narayan Patil, Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola,

36.

Siddheshwar Mhallappa Metkari, Residing at Gherdi, Taluka Sangola,

37.

Sanjay Ganapati Ingole, Residing at Ekhatpur, Taluka Sangola,

38.

Atul Pawar, R/o. Methawade, Taluka Sangola,

39.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Residing at Sumitra Niwas, Plot No. 7, Gangadhar Housing Society, Hotgi, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur.

40.

Dhananjay Adnyanrao Bhosale, Residing at Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur,

41.

Babasaheb Kisanrao Patil, Residing at Mardi, Taluka North Solapur,

42.

Shridip Suresh Hasapure, Residing at Saiful, Taluka South Solapur,

43.

Bharati Rajshekhar Shivdare, Residing near Dayanand College, Solapur, Taluka North Solapur,

44.

Radha Rajendra Suravase, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

45.

Asmita Suresh Gaikwad, Residing at Ramakant Karnik Nagar, Solapur.

46.

Mandakini Popat Gadade, Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

47.

Shrushti Mahesh Tikke, Residing at Salgar, Taluka Mangalwedha,

48.

Nilabai Balaso Katkar Residing at Waki, Taluka Sangola,

49.

Sindhu Suresh Patil, Residing at Varawade, Taluka Madha,

50.

Rohini Ramchandra Tadwalkar, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Ajoba Ganapati, Solapur.

51.

Shobha Shrishail Banshetti, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Dudh Galli, Solapur.

52.

Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate, Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola,

53.

Nita Devanand Gund, Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol,

54.

Priyanka Umakant Bhagat, Residing at Narotewadi, Taluka North Solapur,

55.

Rupmati Dipak Salunkhe, Residing at Jawala, Taluka Sangola,

56.

Shamal Digambarrao Bagal, Residing at Mangi, Taluka Karmala,

57.

Vanita Subhash Gulve, Residing at Takali, Taluka Sangola,

58.

Ashwini Sujit Bagal, Residing at Mangi, Taluka Karmala,

59.

Vanita Maruti Lawate, Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola,

60.

Puja Santosh Chougule, Residing at Wadegaon, Taluka Sangola,

61.

Sindhu Pratap Patil, Residing at Sakat, Pananga, Taluka Barshi,

62.

Suvarna Sushilkumar Dalave, Residing at Ambegaon, Jawalgaon, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur.

63.

Nandabai Haridas Kevare, Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala,

64.

Rukmini Vitthal Randive, Residing at Lotewad Martand Wada, Tungat, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

65.

Vaishali Bhagwan Chougule, Residing at Bhalwani, Taluka Pandharpur,

66.

Archana Dilip Ghadge, Residing at Suste, Taluka Pandharpur,

67.

Minal Ganpatrao Sathe, Residing at Madha, Taluka Madha,

68.

Chhayadevi Sopan Naranavar, Residing at Umbare, Taluka Malshiras,

69.

Triveni Sham Akale, Residing at Hajapur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

70.

Kavita Dattatray Khadtare, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

71.

Shankar Bhagwat Gaikwad, Residing at Haldahiwade, Taluka Sangola,

72.

Vishnu Ambadas Waghmare, Residing at Hiraj, Taluka North Solapur,

73.

Jayant Tanaji Sale, Residing at Hunnur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

74.

Arvind Anna Bhosale, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

75.

Mahadev Murlidhar Sabale, Residing at Khandali, Taluka Malshiras,

76.

Nanasaheb Pandharinath Naiknavare, Residing at Tondale, Taluka Malshiras,

77.

Arvind Anna Bhosale, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

78.

Mahadev Kisan Kamble, Residing at Upalai, Taluka Barshi,

79.

Malhari Bapu Dhobale, Residing at Fondshiras, Taluka Malshiras,

80.

Kisan Nivrutti Satpute, Residing at Piliv, Taluka Malshiras,

81.

Ram Vitthal Satpute, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

82.

Dattatray Tatya Khadtare, Residing at Sarkari Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

83.

Kavita Dattatray Khadtare, Residing at Sarkari Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

84.

Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil, Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol,

85.

Basavaraj Ramgonda Patil, Residing at Maroli, Shiranandani, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

86.

Shrishail Devansiddh Banshetti, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur.

87.

Shridip Suresh Hasapure, Residing near Suresh Ganapati, Saiful, Solapur.

88.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur.

89.

Chidanand Virbhadra Swami, Residing at Wani Chinchale, Taluka Sangola,

90.

Nagnath Devram Shinde, Residing at Upalai, Taluka Barshi,

91.

Vishal Haridas Kevare, Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala,

92.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

93.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

94.

Sham Tukaram Akale, Residing at Hajapur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

95.

Hanmant Tatabo Masal, Residing at Hivargaon, Taluka Mangalwedha,

96.

Popat Ramchandra Gadade Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

97.

Rahul Baba Ghutukade Residing at Manewadi, Taluka Mangalwedha,

98.

Vilas Bhiva Lengare Residing at Murari Peth, Solapur.

99.

Sanjay Tukaram Rathod Residing at Tinhe Tanda, Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur.

100. Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola, 101. Prathamesh Vasantrao Patil, Residing at Bhandarkavathe, Taluka South Solapur, District Solapur.

102. Aniket Chandrakant Deshmukh Residing at Sangola, Taluka Mangalwedha, 103. Shivaji Abadas Kamble Residing at Aran, Taluka Madha, 104. Maruti Bhimrao Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola, 105. Rahul Bajirao Waghmode Residing at Chakore, Taluka Malshiras, 106. Birmal Bhimrao Koli Residing at Dahitane Tulshidas, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur. 107. Rajendra Dhulappa Bandichhode Residing at Saphale, Taluka Akkalkot, 108. Shridhar Upendram Kondale Residing at Hyderabad Road, Solapur. 109. Tanaji Maruti Waghmode Residing at Tisangi, Taluka Pandharpur, 110. Vilas Narayan Patil Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola, 111. Dnyanraj Sanjay Patil Residing at Natepute, Taluka Sangola, 112. Mahendra Manohar Khatke Residing at Narotewadi, Taluka North Solapur,

113. Hanmant Devba Sul Residing at Marochi, Taluka Malshiras, 114. Sushil Babanrao Awatade Residing at Khandoba Galli, Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 115. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 116. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 117. Baburao Ramchandra Gaikwad Residing at Sangola, Taluka Sangola, 118. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at Jalave, Taluka Sangola, 119. Ramesh Pandurang Jadhav Patil Residing at Shivajinagar, Sangola, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur. 120. Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 121. Vijay Narayan Tate Residing at Sangam Narasingpur, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 122. Dhairyashil Rajsinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Yashwantnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 123. Sangramsinh Ajitsinh Jahagirdar Residing at Piliv, Taluka Malshiras,

124. Milan Malappa Kalyanshetti Residing at Solapur Road, Akkalkot, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 125. Nagaraj Irappa Kumbhar Residing at Mahadev Nagar, Akkalkot, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 126. Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 127. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 128. Abhijit Dhananjay Patil Residing at Degaon, Taluka Pandharpur, 129. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 130. Malhari Bhausaheb Gaikwad Residing at Pare, Taluka Sangola, 131. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at Jalave, Taluka Sangola, 132. Dhairyashil Rajsinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Yashwantnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 133. Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Taluka Malshiras, 134. Maruti Bhimrao Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola,

135. Vanita Maruti Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola, 136. Puja Santosh Chougule Residing at Wadegaon, Taluka Sangola, 137. Shivaji Balbhim Patil Residing at Chandaj, Adegaon, Taluka Sangola, 138. Balasaheb Mahadev Mali Residing at Shevate, Taluka Pandharpur, 139. Abhijit Dilip Ghadge Residing at Suste, Taluka Pandharpur, 140. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 141. Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur. 142. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 143. Manish Subhash Deshmukh Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur. 144. Subhash Sureshchandra Deshmukh Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur. 145. Prakash Shamrao Patil Residing at Paniv, Taluka Malshiras,

146. Asmita Suresh Gaikwad Residing at Ramakant Karnik Nagar, Solapur. 147. Kalyan Vasantrao Kale Residing at Wadi Kuroli, Taluka Pandharpur, 148. Bhimashankar Nagappa Jamadar Residing at Musti, Taluka South Solapur, 149. Siddharam Baburao Chakote Residing at Jodbhavi Peth, Mangalwar Bazar, Solapur. 150. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 151. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 152. Amol Balasaheb Shinde Residing at Uttar Kasba Choupad, Solapur. 153. Rohini Ramchandra Tadwalkar Residing at Near Ajoba Ganapati, Solapur. 154. Shahaji Gulchand Pawar Residing at Mardi, Taluka North Solapur, 155. Rajendra Shivaraya Gangade Residing at Hotgi, Taluka South Solapur, 156. Kanhatyalal Girdhardas Devi Residing at Karmala, Taluka Karmala,

157. Shrishail Revansiddh Banshetti Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur. 158. Shobha Shrishail Banshetti Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur. 159. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at J alave, Taluka Sangola, 160. Devanand Raosaheb Gund Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol, 161. Nita Devanand Gund Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol, 162. Arvind Shrimant Kalel Residing at Somewadi, Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur. 163. Chandrashekhar Jaynarayan Kondambheri Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 164. Subhash Jagannath Gulve Residing at Takali, Taluka Karmala, 165. Bharat Haribhau Jadhav Residing at Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur, 166. Shankar Mallikarjun Patil Residing at Vajreshwari. Nagar, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur. 167. Balaso Nivrutti Katkar Residing at Waki Shivane, Taluka Sangola,

168. Shridhar Upendram Kondale Residing at Bidi Gharkul, Hyderabad Road, Solapur. 169. Vishal Haridas Kevare Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala, 170. Pranav Mukund Paricharak Residing at Pradakshina Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, 171. Rajkumar Baburao Hanchate Residing at Akkalkot Road, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 172. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Manganese, Taluka Mangalwedha,

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5973 OF 2026 Dilip Brahmadev Mane, Age : 62 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Sumitra Niwas, Plot No.7, Gangadhar Housing Society, Hotgi Road, Solapur.

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005.

2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor,

Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur. 3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Goldfinch Peth, Solapur Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

Dhananjay Dnyanrao Bhosale, Age: Adult, Occupation: Agricultural Residing at Bhosale Vasti, At post Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur,

5.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Age: Adult, Occupation: Agricultural Residing at: Sumitra Niwas, Plot No. 7, Gangadhar Housing Society, Hotgi Road, Solapur.

6.

Babasaheb Kisanrao Patil, Age: Adult, Occupation : Agricultural, Residing at Post Mardi, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur.

7.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

8.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5974 OF 2026 Suresh Siddappa Hassapure, Age : 58 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Post Nimbargi, Taluka South Solapur, Solapur.

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar,

Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005. 2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Goldfinch Peth, Solapur Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

Ajinkyarao Rajan Patil, At and post Anagar, Taluka Mohol,

5.

Basavaraj Ramgonda Patil, at Maroli, post Shrinandgi, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

6.

Shrishailya Revansiddha Banshetti, 731, Shukrawar Peth, Dudh Galli, Solapur.

7.

Shobha Shrishailya Banshetti, 731, Shukrawar Peth, Dudh Galli, Solapur.

8.

Shrideep Suresh Hassapure, Near Ganapati Temple, 38, Swami Vivekanand Nagar, Saiful, Taluka South Solapur,

9.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Sumitra Niwas, Plot No. 7, Gangadhar Housing Society, Hotgi Road, Solapur.

10.

Chidanand Veerabhadra Swami,

at and Post Wani Chinchale, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur. 11.

Nagnath Devrao Shinde, At and Post Upale, Taluka Barshi, Dist. Solapur.

12.

Vishal Haridas Kevare, At and Post Aljapur, Taluka Karmala, Dist. Solapur.

13.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, At and Post Nimgaon (T.), Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

14.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Autade, Khandoba Galli, Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

15.

Sham Tukaram Akale, At and post Hajapur, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

16.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune, Through its Secretary

17.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5975 OF 2026 Ranjitsinh Vijaysinh Mohite-Patil, Age : 54 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Patil Wada, Akluj, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur.

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar,

Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005. 2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

5.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

6.

Sachin Panchappa Kalyanshetti, Residing at Hunnar, Taluka Akkalkot,

7.

Vishweshwar Tukappa Nagur, Residing at Hunnar, Taluka Akkalkot,

8.

Sanjiv Sidramappa Patil, Residing at Kumathe, Post Kasegaon, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur.

9.

Ranveer Rajendra Raut, Residing at Ashok Nagar, Barshi, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur.

10.

Rajendra Vitthal Raut, Residing at Ashok Nagar, Barshi, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur.

11.

Shambhuraje Jaywantrao Jagtap, Residing at Satbai Farmhouse, Nagar-Tembhurni Bypass Road, Karmala, Taluka Karmala,

12.

Subhash Jagannath Gulve, Residing at Takali, Taluka Karmala,

13.

Subhash Dinkarrao Nimbalkar, Residing at Malinagar, Taluka Malshiras,

14.

Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil, Residing at Shankar Nagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur.

15.

Shahajirao Mudhojirao Deshmukh, Residing at Natepute, Taluka Malshiras,

16.

Sangramsinh Ajitsinh Jahagirdar, Ro. Piliv, Taluka Malshiras,

17.

Dnyanraj Sanjay Patil, Residing at Natepute, Taluka Malshiras,

18.

Ranjit Babanrao Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

19.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

20.

Ganpatrao Dhanaji Sathe, Residing at Mangalwar Peth, Madha, Taluka Madha, District Solapur.

21.

Bharat Haribhau Shinde, Residing at Aran, Taluka Madha,

22.

Sushil Babanrao Awatade Residing at Nagne Wadi, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

23.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade, Residing at Hivargaon, Post Dongargaon, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

24.

Vikrant Rajan Patil, Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol,

25.

Kalyan Vasantrao Kale, Residing at Wadi Kuroli, Taluka Pandharpur,

26.

Umesh Prabhakar Paricharak, Residing at Vijapur Galli, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

27.

Pranav Mukund Paricharak, Residing at Vijapur Galli, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

28.

Popat Ramchandra Gadade, Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

29.

Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate, Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola,

30.

Subhash Krushnadev Patil, Residing at Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

31.

Maruti Namdev Dhale, Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola,

32.

Gajendra Jagannath Kolekar, Residing at Kidebisari, Nagaj, Taluka Sangola,

33.

Babasaheb Annasaheb Deshmukh, Residing at Station Road, Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

34.

Chetansinh Tatyasaheb Kedar Sawant, R/o. Sangola, Taluka Sangola,

35.

Vilas Narayan Patil, Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola,

36.

Siddheshwar Mhallappa Metkari, Residing at Gherdi, Taluka Sangola,

37.

Sanjay Ganapati Ingole, Residing at Ekhatpur, Taluka Sangola,

38.

Atul Pawar, R/o. Methawade, Taluka Sangola,

39.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Residing at Sumitra Niwas, Plot No. 7, Gangadhar Housing Society, Hotgi, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur.

40.

Dhananjay Adnyanrao Bhosale, Residing at Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur,

41.

Babasaheb Kisanrao Patil, Residing at Mardi, Taluka North Solapur,

42.

Shridip Suresh Hasapure, Residing at Saiful, Taluka South Solapur,

43.

Bharati Rajshekhar Shivdare, Residing near Dayanand College, Solapur, Taluka North Solapur,

44.

Radha Rajendra Suravase, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

45.

Asmita Suresh Gaikwad, Residing at Ramakant Karnik Nagar, Solapur.

46.

Mandakini Popat Gadade, Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

47.

Shrushti Mahesh Tikke, Residing at Salgar, Taluka Mangalwedha,

48.

Nilabai Balaso Katkar Residing at Waki, Taluka Sangola,

49.

Sindhu Suresh Patil, Residing at Varawade, Taluka Madha,

50.

Rohini Ramchandra Tadwalkar, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Ajoba Ganapati, Solapur.

51.

Shobha Shrishail Banshetti, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Dudh Galli, Solapur.

52.

Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate, Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola,

53.

Nita Devanand Gund, Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol,

54.

Priyanka Umakant Bhagat, Residing at Narotewadi, Taluka North Solapur,

55.

Rupmati Dipak Salunkhe, Residing at Jawala, Taluka Sangola,

56.

Shamal Digambarrao Bagal, Residing at Mangi, Taluka Karmala,

57.

Vanita Subhash Gulve, Residing at Takali, Taluka Sangola,

58.

Ashwini Sujit Bagal, Residing at Mangi, Taluka Karmala,

59.

Vanita Maruti Lawate, Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola,

60.

Puja Santosh Chougule, Residing at Wadegaon, Taluka Sangola,

61.

Sindhu Pratap Patil, Residing at Sakat, Pananga, Taluka Barshi,

62.

Suvarna Sushilkumar Dalave, Residing at Ambegaon, Jawalgaon, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur.

63.

Nandabai Haridas Kevare, Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala,

64.

Rukmini Vitthal Randive, Residing at Lotewad Martand Wada, Tungat, Taluka Pandharpur, District Solapur.

65.

Vaishali Bhagwan Chougule, Residing at Bhalwani, Taluka Pandharpur,

66.

Archana Dilip Ghadge, Residing at Suste, Taluka Pandharpur,

67.

Minal Ganpatrao Sathe, Residing at Madha, Taluka Madha,

68.

Chhayadevi Sopan Naranavar, Residing at Umbare, Taluka Malshiras,

69.

Triveni Sham Akale, Residing at Hajapur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

70.

Kavita Dattatray Khadtare, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

71.

Shankar Bhagwat Gaikwad, Residing at Haldahiwade, Taluka Sangola,

72.

Vishnu Ambadas Waghmare, Residing at Hiraj, Taluka North Solapur,

73.

Jayant Tanaji Sale, Residing at Hunnur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

74.

Arvind Anna Bhosale, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

75.

Mahadev Murlidhar Sabale, Residing at Khandali, Taluka Malshiras,

76.

Nanasaheb Pandharinath Naiknavare, Residing at Tondale, Taluka Malshiras,

77.

Arvind Anna Bhosale, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

78.

Mahadev Kisan Kamble, Residing at Upalai, Taluka Barshi,

79.

Malhari Bapu Dhobale, Residing at Fondshiras, Taluka Malshiras,

80.

Kisan Nivrutti Satpute, Residing at Piliv, Taluka Malshiras,

81.

Ram Vitthal Satpute, Residing at Mandave, Taluka Malshiras,

82.

Dattatray Tatya Khadtare, Residing at Sarkari Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

83.

Kavita Dattatray Khadtare, Residing at Sarkari Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

84.

Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil, Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol,

85.

Basavaraj Ramgonda Patil, Residing at Maroli, Shiranandani, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

86.

Shrishail Devansiddh Banshetti, Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur.

87.

Shridip Suresh Hasapure, Residing near Suresh Ganapati, Saiful, Solapur.

88.

Prithviraj Dilip Mane, Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur.

89.

Chidanand Virbhadra Swami, Residing at Wani Chinchale, Taluka Sangola,

90.

Nagnath Devram Shinde, Residing at Upalai, Taluka Barshi,

91.

Vishal Haridas Kevare, Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala,

92.

Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde, Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha,

93.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade, Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

94.

Sham Tukaram Akale, Residing at Hajapur, Taluka Mangalwedha,

95.

Hanmant Tatabo Masal, Residing at Hivargaon, Taluka Mangalwedha,

96.

Popat Ramchandra Gadade Residing at Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola,

97.

Rahul Baba Ghutukade Residing at Manewadi, Taluka Mangalwedha,

98.

Vilas Bhiva Lengare Residing at Murari Peth, Solapur.

99.

Sanjay Tukaram Rathod Residing at Tinhe Tanda, Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur.

100. Rupali Dadasaheb Lawate Residing at Lotewadi, Taluka Sangola, 101. Prathamesh Vasantrao Patil, Residing at Bhandarkavathe, Taluka South Solapur, District Solapur. 102. Aniket Chandrakant Deshmukh Residing at Sangola, Taluka Mangalwedha, 103. Shivaji Abadas Kamble Residing at Aran, Taluka Madha, 104. Maruti Bhimrao Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola, 105. Rahul Bajirao Waghmode Residing at Chakore, Taluka Malshiras, 106. Birmal Bhimrao Koli Residing at Dahitane Tulshidas, Taluka Barshi, District Solapur. 107. Rajendra Dhulappa Bandichhode Residing at Saphale, Taluka Akkalkot, 108. Shridhar Upendram Kondale Residing at Hyderabad Road, Solapur.

109. Tanaji Maruti Waghmode Residing at Tisangi, Taluka Pandharpur, 110. Vilas Narayan Patil Residing at Mahud, Taluka Sangola, 111. Dnyanraj Sanjay Patil Residing at Natepute, Taluka Sangola, 112. Mahendra Manohar Khatke Residing at Narotewadi, Taluka North Solapur, 113. Hanmant Devba Sul Residing at Marochi, Taluka Malshiras, 114. Sushil Babanrao Awatade Residing at Khandoba Galli, Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 115. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 116. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 117. Baburao Ramchandra Gaikwad Residing at Sangola, Taluka Sangola, 118. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at Jalave, Taluka Sangola, 119. Ramesh Pandurang Jadhav Patil Residing at Shivajinagar, Sangola, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur.

120. Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 121. Vijay Narayan Tate Residing at Sangam Narasingpur, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 122. Dhairyashil Rajsinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Yashwantnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 123. Sangramsinh Ajitsinh Jahagirdar Residing at Piliv, Taluka Malshiras, 124. Milan Malappa Kalyanshetti Residing at Solapur Road, Akkalkot, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 125. Nagaraj Irappa Kumbhar Residing at Mahadev Nagar, Akkalkot, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 126. Yashwant Sanjaymama Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 127. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 128. Abhijit Dhananjay Patil Residing at Degaon, Taluka Pandharpur, 129. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 130. Malhari Bhausaheb Gaikwad Residing at Pare, Taluka Sangola,

131. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at Jalave, Taluka Sangola, 132. Dhairyashil Rajsinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Yashwantnagar, Taluka Malshiras, District Solapur. 133. Arjunsinh Madansinh Mohite-Patil Residing at Shankarnagar, Taluka Malshiras, 134. Maruti Bhimrao Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola, 135. Vanita Maruti Lawate Residing at Kadlas, Taluka Sangola, 136. Puja Santosh Chougule Residing at Wadegaon, Taluka Sangola, 137. Shivaji Balbhim Patil Residing at Chandaj, Adegaon, Taluka Sangola, 138. Balasaheb Mahadev Mali Residing at Shevate, Taluka Pandharpur, 139. Abhijit Dilip Ghadge Residing at Suste, Taluka Pandharpur, 140. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, 141. Siddheshwar Babanrao Awatade Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha, District Solapur.

142. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 143. Manish Subhash Deshmukh Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur. 144. Subhash Sureshchandra Deshmukh Residing at Hotgi Road, Solapur. 145. Prakash Shamrao Patil Residing at Paniv, Taluka Malshiras, 146. Asmita Suresh Gaikwad Residing at Ramakant Karnik Nagar, Solapur. 147. Kalyan Vasantrao Kale Residing at Wadi Kuroli, Taluka Pandharpur, 148. Bhimashankar Nagappa Jamadar Residing at Musti, Taluka South Solapur, 149. Siddharam Baburao Chakote Residing at Jodbhavi Peth, Mangalwar Bazar, Solapur. 150. Ajinkyarana Rajan Patil Residing at Anagar, Taluka Mohol, 151. Ranjit Babanrao Shinde Residing at Nimgaon, Taluka Madha, 152. Amol Balasaheb Shinde Residing at Uttar Kasba Choupad, Solapur.

153. Rohini Ramchandra Tadwalkar Residing at Near Ajoba Ganapati, Solapur. 154. Shahaji Gulchand Pawar Residing at Mardi, Taluka North Solapur, 155. Rajendra Shivaraya Gangade Residing at Hotgi, Taluka South Solapur, 156. Kanhatyalal Girdhardas Devi Residing at Karmala, Taluka Karmala, 157. Shrishail Revansiddh Banshetti Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur. 158. Shobha Shrishail Banshetti Residing at Shukrawar Peth, Solapur. 159. Suryaditya Dipakrao Salunkhe Residing at J alave, Taluka Sangola, 160. Devanand Raosaheb Gund Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol, 161. Nita Devanand Gund Residing at Ashti, Taluka Mohol, 162. Arvind Shrimant Kalel Residing at Somewadi, Gaudwadi, Taluka Sangola, District Solapur. 163. Chandrashekhar Jaynarayan Kondambheri Residing at Mangalwedha, Taluka Mangalwedha,

164. Subhash Jagannath Gulve Residing at Takali, Taluka Karmala, 165. Bharat Haribhau Jadhav Residing at Tinhe, Taluka North Solapur, 166. Shankar Mallikarjun Patil Residing at Vajreshwari. Nagar, Taluka North Solapur, District Solapur. 167. Balaso Nivrutti Katkar Residing at Waki Shivane, Taluka Sangola, 168. Shridhar Upendram Kondale Residing at Bidi Gharkul, Hyderabad Road, Solapur. 169. Vishal Haridas Kevare Residing at Aljapur, Taluka Karmala, 170. Pranav Mukund Paricharak Residing at Pradakshina Road, Pandharpur, Taluka Pandharpur, 171. Rajkumar Baburao Hanchate Residing at Akkalkot Road, Taluka Akkalkot, District Solapur. 172. Samadhan Mahadev Awatade Residing at Manganese, Taluka Mangalwedha,

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5977 OF 2026 Suresh Siddappa Hassapure, Age : 58 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Post Nimbargi,

Taluka South Solapur, Solapur.

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005.

2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Goldfinch Peth, Solapur Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

Shrideep Suresh Hassapure, Near Ganapati Temple, 38, Swami Vivekanand Nagar, Saiful, Taluka South Solapur,

5.

Bharati Rajshekhar Shivdare, Residing near Dayanand College, Solapur, Taluka North Solapur,

6.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

7.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5978 OF 2026

Jaywantrao Namdevrao Jagtap, Age : 68 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Satbai Farm House, Nagar-Tembhurni Bypass Road, Karmala, Taluka Karmala,

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005.

2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The District Co-operative Election Officer, Solapur.

4.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Goldfinch Peth, Solapur Through its Chief Executive Officer.

5.

Shambhuraje Jaywantrao Jagtap, Residing at Satbai Farm House, Nagar-Tembhurni Bypass Road, Karmala, Taluka Karmala,

6.

Subhash Jagannath Gulve, At and post Takali (Ra.), Taluka Karmala, District Solapur.

7.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

8.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.

...RESPONDENTS

AND WRIT PETITION NO. 5979 OF 2026 Baban Baburao Autade Age : 60 Years, occu : Agriculturist, Residing at Mallewadi, Post and Taluka Mangalwedha,

...PETITIONER

VERSUS 1.

The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, Sakhar Sankul, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005.

2.

The Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Central Administrative Building, E Block, First Floor, Old Collector’s Office Compound, Solapur.

3.

The Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur. Goldfinch Peth, Solapur Through its Chief Executive Officer.

4.

Sushil Babanrao Autade, Residing at : Mallewadi, Post and Taluka Mangalwedha,

5.

Siddheshwar Babanrao Autade, Residing at : Mallewadi, Post and Taluka Mangalwedha,

6.

The State Co-operative Election Authority, Maharashtra State, Pune. Through its Secretary.

7.

The State of Maharashtra, Through its Principal Secretary, Co-operation, Marketing and Textile Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai. ...RESPONDENTS ***  Mr. Girish Godbole, Senior Counsel h/f Mr. Abhijit Dilip Kulkarni a/w Mr. Abhay Jadhavar (Through V.C.), Advocate for the Petitioner in WP/5976/2026.  Mr. Abhijit Dilip Kulkarni a/w Mr. Abhay Jadhavar (Through V.C.), Advocate for the Petitioners in WP/5971/2026, WP/5972/2026, WP/5973/2026, WP/5974/2026, WP/5975/2026, WP/5977/2026, WP/5978/2026 and WP/5979/2026.  Ms. Tejas J. Kapre (Through V.C.), AGP for Respondent – State in all WP  Mr. Ruturaj P. Pawar, Advocate for Respondent No.2 in all Writ Petitions.  Mr. Bhushan Walimbe (Through V.C.), Advocate for Respondent No.3  Mr. Shailesh D. Chavan a/w Mr. Ajinkya Sangittrao a/w Ms. Swarrali B. Chougule (Through V.C.), Advocate for Resp. Nos.4 and 5 in WP/5973/2026.  Mr. Ajinkya Sangittrao (Through V.C.), Advocate for Resp. No.4 in WP/5974/2026.  Mr. Ajinkya Sangittrao (Through V.C.), Advocate for Resp. Nos.4, 5 and 6 in WP/5976/2026.  Mr. Ajinkya Sangittrao (Through V.C.), Advocate for Resp. No.8 in WP/5977/2026.  Mr. Shailesh D. Chavan a/w Mr. Ajinkya Sangittrao a/w Ms. Swarrali B. Chougule (Through V.C.), Advocate for Resp. Nos.4 and 5 in WP/5979/2026. *** CORAM DATE

: ABHAY J. MANTRI, J. (VACATION COURT) (THROUGH V.C.) : NOVEMBER 16, 2026

ORAL JUDGMENT : 1.

Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith. With the consent of

learned counsel for the parties, heard finally.

2.

All these group of Writ Petitions arise out of the order dated 06 th

November 2026 passed by Respondent No.1 – the Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Pune, (for short, “Respondent No.1” ) dismissing the respective Appeals filed by the Petitioner/s thereby confirming the order dated 03rd November 2026 passed by Respondent No. 2 – Returning Officer, election to the Board of Directors of the Solapur District Central Cooperative Bank Ltd., Solapur, (for short, “Respondent No.2” ) whereby the nomination forms of the Petitioner/s herein were rejected. Aggrieved by the said orders, the Petitioner/s have preferred these separate Writ Petitions. 3.

The issue involved in all these bunch of Writ Petitions is

identical and arises out of the orders passed by Respondent Nos.1 and 2 herein. Therefore, all these Writ Petitions are taken together for hearing and final disposal by common order. 4.

Heard Mr. Godbole, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the

Petitioner in Writ Petition No.5976 of 2026, and Mr. Kulkarni, learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner/s in the remaining Writ Petitions. Mr. Ruturaj Pawar, learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.2; Mr. Walimbe, learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.3; Mr. Shailesh D. Chavan and Mr. Ajinkya Sangittrao, learned counsel appearing for Respondent Nos.4, 5 and 6; and Ms. Kapre, learned AGP for the RespondentShrikant Malani

State. 5.

The facts in a nutshell are as under:(a)

The Petitioner/s is/are a former director/chairman/member of the

Respondent No.3 – the Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solapur (for short, “the Bank/Respondent No.3”). Who resigned their Membership before the order dated 28th May 2018 passed by the Commissioner for Co-operation and Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Maharashtra State, Pune (for short, “the Commissioner”). They submitted Nomination Form No.4 for their respective Constituency, under the approved programme for the Bank’s Board election for 2026-2027 to 2031-32. (b)

The Respondent No. 2, the Returning Officer, Election to the

Board of Directors of the Bank (for short, “the Returning Officer/Respondent No. 2”) scrutinised the Form, and by Order dated 03rd November 2026

rejected the Nomination on the ground that the finding recorded under Section 88 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (for short, “the MCS Act”), held him/them responsible for being conducted in a manner

detrimental to the interest of the depositors and for securing the proper management of the Bank and as such they are disqualified under Section 73CA of the MCS Act. (c)

The Petitioner/s has/have challenged the said order/s before the

Respondent No.1, who after hearing them dismissed the Appeal on 06 th November 2026 and confirmed the rejection order passed by Respondent No.2. Aggrieved by the said orders, the Petitioner/s has/have preferred these Petitions. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS.

6.

The thrust of the arguments of Mr. Godbole, learned Senior

Counsel appearing for the Petitioner in Writ Petition No.5976 of 2026, was that the Petitioner had tendered his resignation on 15 th May 2018, before the conclusion of the enquiry, before the Competent Authority. Therefore, the order passed by the Commissioner superseding the Board of Directors of Respondent No.3 – Bank and appointing an Administrator could not be attracted against the Petitioner in his capacity as a member of the superseded Board, as he had resigned before the conclusion of the enquiry. During the course of arguments, he took me through the order passed by this Court in Writ Petition No. 2347 of 2025 and submitted that in paragraph Nos.7 and 8 thereof, this Court had directed the Appellate Authority to decide either the Appeal or the Application for stay preferred by the Petitioners expeditiously, preferably within a period of two months from the date of the said order, i.e. 06th March 2025, and that till then, the concerned Authorities were directed not to take any coercive action pursuant to the order dated 08 th October 2024. The purposive interpretation of the said order is that the consequences arising

out of the order passed under Section 88 of the MCS Act would not come in the way of the Petitioner while contesting the election. Alternatively, he submitted that despite the said order, the Appellate Authority failed to comply with the same within the stipulated period and, therefore, the Petitioner ought not to suffer on account of such failure on the part of the Appellate Authority. Hence, he submitted that the Petitioner be permitted to amend the Petition to mould the relief by directing the Appellate Authority to decide the Appeal within two days. (a)

Upon a query, he fairly submitted that the Commissioner, by an

order dated 28th May 2018, had superseded the Board of Directors of Respondent No.3 – Bank and appointed an Administrator. The said order is sub judice before the Appellate Authority. (b)

During the course of arguments, he has taken me through

paragraph Nos.6 and 22 of the Writ Petition to substantiate his contentions regarding the purposive interpretation of the order dated 06th March 2025. 7.

Mr. Kulkarni, learned counsel appearing for the Petitioners in

the connected Writ Petitions, adopted the arguments advanced by Mr. Godbole, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Petitioner, and further propounded that the Petitioner/s had resigned before the conclusion of the enquiry. Therefore, they cannot be held responsible for the alleged scam or held liable based on the said report which is sub judice before the Appellate

Authority. 8.

Mr. Godbole, learned Senior Counsel, and Mr. Kulkarni, learned

counsel appearing for the respective Petitioners, in support of their respective submissions, have relied upon the following judgments of this Court and the Hon’ble Apex Court: Prakash Mahadeo Khot and Others Vs. Maruti Dadu Khot and Others1, (ii) Dilip Abhaykumar Phade and Another Vs. Deputy Registrar, Cooperative Societies and Others2, (iii) Mool Chand Yadav and Another Vs. Raza Buland Sugar Company Limited, Rampur and Others3; and (iv) Kalabharati Advertising Vs. Hemant Vimalnath Narichania and Others4. (i)

9.

They drew my attention to paragraph No. 4 of the judgment in

Mool Chand Yadav’s case (supra) and paragraph Nos.3 to 6 of the judgment in Kalabharati’s case (supra) and submitted that the authorities cannot flout the

order passed by this Court. They further submitted that when the orders are challenged, and Appeals are pending, the concerned Authority or Court ought to pass an order staying or suspending the operation of the impugned order. The Authority cannot permit a swinging pendulum to continue during the pendency of the Appeal by failing to pass any order. 10.

They further canvassed that the pendency of the Appeal and

failure of the Appellate Authority to pass an order either on the Appeal or on

2005 (2) ALL MR 775 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 11092 (1982) 3 SCC 484 (2010) 9 SCC 437

the Application for stay, despite the hearing having concluded in August 2026, led to an inference that the matter was kept pending for an ulterior purpose. Therefore, according to them, such pendency would not disqualify the Petitioner/s from tendering their nomination forms. Hence, they urged for setting aside the impugned orders.

Per contra, Mr. Walimbe, learned counsel appearing for

11.

Respondent No.3 – Bank, strenuously opposed these Petitions. He canvassed that the nomination forms were rejected on two grounds. The first ground was that the Petitioner/s had been held responsible in the enquiry conducted under Section 88 of the MCS Act and, therefore, as per Section 73CA(1)(f) (iii), they were held disqualified. The second ground was that, by the order dated 28th May 2018, the Commissioner had passed an order under Section 110-A(1)(iii) of the MCS Act, thereby superseding the Board of Directors of Respondent No. 3 – Bank and appointing the Administrator. At the time of the enquiry, the Petitioner/s were Members of the Board of Directors of Respondent No.3 – Bank and, therefore, stood disqualified under Section 73CA(3A) of the MCS Act. Hence, the orders passed by the Authorities are just and legal. On the contrary, the Petitioner/s have failed to demonstrate that the impugned orders are illegal or bad in law. Therefore, no interference is warranted. (a)

He further pointed out paragraph Nos.4 and 9 of the order dated

06th March 2025 passed by this Court in Writ Petition No.2347 of 2025 and submitted that this Court had clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the matter. Therefore, he submitted that the observations in paragraph No.8, that no coercive action shall be taken pursuant to the order dated 08th October 2024, would not help the Petitioner/s support their contentions. Hence, he urged for dismissal of the Petitions. 12.

Ms. Kapre, learned AGP, strongly opposed the Petitions and

argued that a purposive interpretation of paragraph No.8 of the order dated 06th March 2025 supports the Respondent-Authority rather than the Petitioners. As per the observations in paragraph No. 8, the order dated 08 th October 2024 means that no coercive action shall be taken in respect of the recovery proceedings. The said order cannot be equated with the disqualification of the Petitioner/s under Section 73CA of the MCS Act. She further submitted that the Competent Authority, after conducting the preliminary enquiry under Section 83 of the MCS Act, commenced the enquiry under Section 88 of the MCS Act in April 2018 and, after conducting a detailed enquiry, the Commissioner passed the order dated 28 th May 2018 superseding the Board of Directors and appointing an Administrator. Therefore, it cannot be said that the enquiry was formal in nature. She further submitted that 34 persons were exonerated in the said enquiry. The enquiry revealed a scam involving ₹ 238 Crores, involving a huge financial stake.

Therefore, the Respondent-Authority had rightly rejected the nomination forms. 13.

Mr. Chavan and Mr. Sangittrao, learned counsel appearing for

Respondent Nos.4 to 6, submitted that the mere pendency of the Appeal would not absolve the Petitioner/s of their liability. They further submitted that an alternative remedy in the form of an Election Petition is available under Section 77A of the MCS Act. Therefore, they urged for dismissal of the Petitions. 14.

Having heard the rival contentions of the parties and having

gone through the record, at the outset, it appears that the Petitioner/s were Members/Directors/Chairman of the Board of Directors from 2009 to 2014 and from 2014 until their respective resignations in 2018. On 03 rd February 2018, the preliminary enquiry report under Section 83 of the MCS Act was submitted and, pursuant to the said enquiry report, Respondent No.1 initiated proceedings under Section 88 of the MCS Act and Rule 72 of the MCS Rules vide his order dated 18th April 2018. The said enquiry was concluded, and by an order dated 28th May 2018, the Commissioner passed an order under Section 110-A(1)(iii) of the MCS Act, thereby superseding the Board of Directors of Respondent No.3 – Bank and appointing an Administrator. The said order is under challenge in the Appeal before the Appellate Authority.

The Appellate Authority has neither granted any stay of the order dated 28 th May 2018 nor decided the said Appeal. 15.

It is the contention of the learned Senior Counsel appearing for

the Petitioner/s that, before the passing of the order by the Commissioner, they had tendered their resignations to the Chairman. However, on a query, they failed to show that the Competent Authority accepted their resignations or that, when the enquiry was initiated, they were not members of the Board of Directors. It is undisputed that, at the time the enquiry was initiated, and throughout its pendency, the Petitioner/s continued to be Members of the Board of Directors from 2009 to 2014 and from 2014 until their respective resignations in 2018. 16.

Upon perusal of the impugned order, it is revealed that

Respondent No.2 – Returning Officer, in his order dated 03 rd November 2026, has categorically observed that, as per Section 73CA(2)(a) and (iii) of the MCS Act, a person who has been held responsible under Section 88 of the MCS Act is not eligible to become a Member of the Committee. Secondly, he held that, under Section 73CA(3) and (3A) of the MCS Act and Rule 32.3 of the Bank’s bye-laws, the Petitioners are not eligible to become Members of the Committee as they were superseded by order dated 28 th May 2018. He further observed that the Appeal against the order passed under

Section 88 of the MCS Act is sub judice before the Appellate Authority and, therefore, the Petitioners were/are not qualified to become Members. Hence, he rejected their nomination forms. 17.

The said order was challenged before Respondent No.1. After

considering the material placed before him, Respondent No.1, by an order dated 06th November 2026, confirmed the order passed by Respondent No.2 and dismissed the Appeal. 18.

While dealing with the controversy that arises herein, it would

be appropriate to reproduce Section 73CA(1)(f)(iii) and Section 73CA(3A) of the MCS Act, for kind perusal, which read thus: “73CA(1)(f)(iii) has been held responsible under section 79 or 88 or has been held responsible for payment of costs of inquiry under section 85; or 73CA(3A) In case of an insured Co-operative Bank, if an order for supersession of its Committee, as per the requisition of the Reserve Bank of India, is made under Section 110A, then no member of such Committee shall be eligible for being re-appointed, re-nominated, reelected or re-co-opted on the Committee of such bank or, for being a member, or for being appointed, nominated, elected or co-opted, as a member of Committee of such bank or any other bank, for a period of two terms of the Committee from the date of order of supersession of the Committee.”

19.

A bare perusal of Section 73CA of the MCS Act indicates that a

member who has been held responsible under Section 88 or has been held

responsible for payment of the costs of an enquiry under Section 85 of the MCS Act is disqualified from becoming a Member of the Bank’s Committee. Similarly, as per Section 73CA(3A) of the MCS Act, if an order for supersession of the Committee of the Bank is made under Section 110-A of the MCS Act, then no Member of such Committee shall be eligible for being re-appointed, re-nominated, re-elected or re-co-opted on the Committee of such Bank. 20.

Undisputedly, in the case at hand, the Petitioners were the

Members of the Committee from 2009 to 2018, during which period the enquiry under Section 88 of the MCS Act was initiated. Similarly, by the order dated 28th May 2018, the Commissioner superseded the Board of Directors of Respondent No. 3 – Bank, and the Petitioner/s were Members of the Board of Directors when the enquiry was commenced. The said order is under challenge. The Appellate Authority has neither granted any stay of the said order nor decided the said Appeal till date. Therefore, in view of Section 73CA(1)(f)(iii) and Section 73CA(3A) of the MCS Act, Respondent Nos.1 and 2 have rightly passed the impugned orders. I do not find any illegality or perversity in the impugned orders warranting interference in the exercise of writ jurisdiction. 21.

That being so, and considering the facts of the case, I do not find

any substance in the arguments advanced by Mr. Godbole, learned Senior Counsel, and Mr. Kulkarni, learned counsel appearing for the Petitioners, that the mere pendency of the Appeals wherein arguments was concluded in August 2026 would not come in the way of the Petitioner/s or as per the mandate laid down in the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mool Chand Yadav (supra) and Kalabharati (supra), a purposive interpretation of

paragraph Nos.7 and 8 of the order dated 06 th March 2025, would lead to the conclusion that the consequences of the order passed under Section 88 of the MCS Act would not come in the way of the Petitioners. Nor is it necessary to direct the Appellate Authority once again to decide the Appeal within a timebound period. 22.

Having gone through the judgments relied upon by the

Petitioners, I find that the facts of the present case are distinct from those in the said judgments. Therefore, the law laid down in the said judgments is hardly of any assistance to the Petitioners in support of their contentions. 23.

In the light of the above discussion, I do not find any merit in

the Petitions. Hence, the Petitions stand dismissed. No order as to costs. 24.

The Rule is discharged.

(ABHAY J. MANTRI, J.)

Related judgments

More Bombay High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.